docs / articles / Recycling Old Recycling Bins: Can You...

Recycling Old Recycling Bins: Can You Recycle Them?

Philip Jun 28, 2026 2026-06-28

When your trusty blue recycling bin finally cracks, warps, or simply wears out, you might wonder what happens to it. Can you recycle old recycling bins, or does this essential tool for sustainable living become destined for the landfill? The answer is generally yes, you can and should recycle these bins, but the process is rarely as simple as tossing it into your curbside cart.

three storage containers stacked on top of each other
three storage containers stacked on top of each other

The Lifecycle of a Recycling Bin

Recycling mistakes you’re probably making
Recycling mistakes you’re probably making

Recycling bins, whether they are large municipal totes or smaller household versions, are typically made from High-Density Polyethylene (HDPE), which is denoted by the recycling symbol #2. This plastic is incredibly durable, impact-resistant, and perfect for containing heavy materials. However, this same durability is what makes it challenging to manage at the end of its life. Unlike a cardboard box that breaks down easily, a bin is a solid, singular object that requires specific handling to be processed correctly.

Why Standard Curbside Pickup Isn't Enough

Recycling: Know What You Can And Can Not Recycle - Penny Pinchin' Mom
Recycling: Know What You Can And Can Not Recycle - Penny Pinchin' Mom

Most standard curbside recycling programs are not equipped to handle bulky, rigid plastics like recycling bins. The size of the item can jam sorting machinery, creating safety hazards and costly shutdowns at Materials Recovery Facilities (MRFs). Furthermore, the bin might be contaminated with residual materials that are difficult to clean thoroughly at the facility. Because of these logistical and safety concerns, waste management companies often cannot accept them via regular pickup.

How to Properly Recycle Your Old Bin

a person holding a recycling bin with the words, 100 ways to recycle beyond the bin at home
a person holding a recycling bin with the words, 100 ways to recycle beyond the bin at home

To ensure your old bin is actually recycled and not sent to a landfill, you need to take a more active role in the disposal process. The most effective method is to check with your local public works department or waste management provider. Many municipalities run bulk waste collection days or have specific instructions for large plastic items. By following their guidelines, you integrate the bin into the proper recycling stream rather than accidentally contaminating it.

  • Contact Local Authorities: Call or visit the website of your city's sanitation department for specific disposal instructions.
  • Look for Drop-Off Locations: Some recycling centers or transfer stations accept #2 HDPE in bulk, allowing you to deliver the bin directly.
  • Participate in Bulk Pickup: If your city offers a bulky item collection service, this is often the most convenient route.
  • Repurpose Components: If the bin is cracked but the lid is still intact, consider keeping the lid as a small sorting container for garage or workshop use.

The Value of a Closed-Loop System

four different colored trash cans in front of some bushes
four different colored trash cans in front of some bushes

Recycling your old bin contributes to a circular economy where materials are continuously reused. HDPE is a valuable commodity. When processed correctly, the plastic from your old bin can be shredded, cleaned, melted down, and extruded into new pellets. These pellets are then used to manufacture a vast array of new products, such as outdoor furniture, plastic lumber, new containers, and, ironically, new recycling bins. This process reduces the need for virgin petroleum-based plastics and conserves valuable resources.

Alternatives to Recycling

If your bin is still structurally sound but simply doesn't fit your aesthetic or needs have changed, disposal isn't the only option. A creative mindset can extend the life of the item significantly. Instead of sending it to a recycler, consider ways to repurpose it within your community or home, diverting it from the waste stream entirely.

trash cans with the words what to do with old trash cans
trash cans with the words what to do with old trash cans
  • Community Donation: Offer the bin to a neighbor, a new resident, or a local community garden for sorting compost or collecting yard waste.
  • Pet Containment: Large bins can be lined and used as durable pet beds for outdoor animals, providing shelter from the elements.
  • Storage Solutions: Use the bin to organize sports equipment, gardening tools, or children's toys in a garage or shed.

The Bottom Line

Rumpke expands recycling: See what containers you can now put in the recycling bin — The Columbus Dispatch
Rumpke expands recycling: See what containers you can now put in the recycling bin — The Columbus Dispatch
Roundup: 8 Clever DIY Ways to Organize Your Recycling
Roundup: 8 Clever DIY Ways to Organize Your Recycling
a poster with instructions on how to use recycling bins and other things in the trash can
a poster with instructions on how to use recycling bins and other things in the trash can
Creative Ways to Recycle for Earth Day and Beyond
Creative Ways to Recycle for Earth Day and Beyond
the 8 ways to upcycle trash can with text overlay that reads, 8 ways to upcycle trash
the 8 ways to upcycle trash can with text overlay that reads, 8 ways to upcycle trash
11 Ways To Make Money Recycling
11 Ways To Make Money Recycling
Recycling at Home: 10 Things You Can Recycle or Repurpose
Recycling at Home: 10 Things You Can Recycle or Repurpose
20 DIY Home Recycling Bins That Help You Organize Your Recyclables
20 DIY Home Recycling Bins That Help You Organize Your Recyclables
Spotlight: Ontario’s new recycling system: Here’s why it matters
Spotlight: Ontario’s new recycling system: Here’s why it matters
20 Surprising Things You Can't Recycle
20 Surprising Things You Can't Recycle
an image of recycling at home with the title 11 ideas for easier recycling at home
an image of recycling at home with the title 11 ideas for easier recycling at home
18 Options For Where to Recycle Old Clothes - The Eco Hub
18 Options For Where to Recycle Old Clothes - The Eco Hub
10 Things You Can Recycle
10 Things You Can Recycle
Recycle milk jugs! #pinyourbin #rumpke #americarecyclesday Funny Recycling Bin Design, Overfilled Recycling Bin, Recycle Meme, Eco-friendly Tire Recycling, Recycling Bin Meme, Trash And Recycling Bin, Recycle Trash, Recycling Bins, Milk Jug
Recycle milk jugs! #pinyourbin #rumpke #americarecyclesday Funny Recycling Bin Design, Overfilled Recycling Bin, Recycle Meme, Eco-friendly Tire Recycling, Recycling Bin Meme, Trash And Recycling Bin, Recycle Trash, Recycling Bins, Milk Jug
Ideas For Home Recycling Bin And Containers: Where To Place Them
Ideas For Home Recycling Bin And Containers: Where To Place Them
a woman with her hands in her pockets and the words, what to do when you can't recycle curbside
a woman with her hands in her pockets and the words, what to do when you can't recycle curbside
the recycling bin is full of bottles, cans and other items to recycle
the recycling bin is full of bottles, cans and other items to recycle

Yes, you absolutely can—and should—recycle old recycling bins, but it requires a bit of planning and research. The key is to avoid the temptation to simply drag it to the curb with your regular trash or recycling. By taking the time to find the proper drop-off location or scheduling a bulk pickup, you ensure that the plastic is recovered and reborn into a new product. This responsible action closes the loop, turning a piece of utility equipment back into a valuable resource and supporting the broader mission of a sustainable future.