Paper Mario: Color Splash's Surprise Age Rating: Joke Explained

The witty world of gaming often blurs the line between fun and controversy. Nowhere is this more apparent than in the case of "Paper Mario: Color Splash," which has sparked amusing discussions about age ratings and a peculiar joke.

an image of mario and other characters in the same video game, which one is colored?
an image of mario and other characters in the same video game, which one is colored?

Paper Mario: Color Splash, developed by Intelligent Systems and published by Nintendo for the Wii U in 2016, is the sixth installment in the Paper Mario series. It's a role-playing comedy-adventure game that breaks the fourth wall, bringing humor and depth in equal measure. Yet, it's this very wit that has led to some interesting interpretations of its age rating.

they finally used Fingore in Paper Mario Color Splash | Scripulous Fingore
they finally used Fingore in Paper Mario Color Splash | Scripulous Fingore

The ESRB Rating: What's all the fuss about?

The Entertainment Software Rating Board (ESRB) rated Paper Mario: Color Splash "E for Everyone," which means it's suitable for all ages. However, the joke lies not in the rating itself, but in the game's clever take on it.

an image of a cartoon character with a speech bubble
an image of a cartoon character with a speech bubble

E10+ is the common rating for games aimed at kids aged 10 and up, but Paper Mario: Color Splash went a step further. It carries an "E" rating, suggesting it's suitable for everyone, including the elderly or even the environment. This led to a humorous discussion among gamers about what this might truly mean.

E for Elderly: Gaming Grandads?

laggy Mario
laggy Mario

Some argue that the "E" rating might be a nod to the elderly. Perhaps the game is so easy and charming that even our silver-haired gamers can enjoy it? After all, the Paper Mario series has always been about accessible fun with a side of clever dialogue.

At the same time, this interpretation raises questions. Shouldn't games aimed at the elderly be designed with sizeable text and simplified controls? Yet, Paper Mario: Color Splash doesn't prioritize these features. Thus, the "E for Elderly" theory remains more of a chuckle than a serious consideration.

E for Environment: Go Green, Mario!

You Can Call Me Fizzles!
You Can Call Me Fizzles!

Another interpretation suggests that the "E" stands for "Environment." Perhaps the game encourages players to be more eco-friendly by coloring the world green, literally. This ties into the game's mechanic of using a paint can to restore color to monochromatic worlds.

However, this theory is also a stretch. While it's a sweet thought, the game doesn't explicitly push an environmental agenda. Plus, many other games have paint-based mechanics without receiving special environmental ratings. So, this theory might be more about hoping for a greener future than a serious rating interpretation.

The Joke: Where's the Punchline?

an image of a paper cut out of mario and luigi's house with a sign that says we dance in circles
an image of a paper cut out of mario and luigi's house with a sign that says we dance in circles

The real humor in Paper Mario: Color Splash's age rating lies in its ambiguity. The ESRB ratings are usually clear and specific. But "E for Everyone"? It leaves room for playful interpretation, and that's where the joke thrives.

It's a tongue-in-cheek acknowledgment of how gaming has evolved. It's no longer just for kids, but it's not solely for adults either. It's for everyone, including those who enjoy a good laugh about it. And really, isn't that what gaming is all about - finding joy in unexpected places?

joke btw
joke btw
REAL
REAL
Paper Mario: The Origami King: 10 Memes That Will Leave You Crying With Laughter
Paper Mario: The Origami King: 10 Memes That Will Leave You Crying With Laughter
an image of some cartoon characters on twitter
an image of some cartoon characters on twitter
an image of mario kart and luigi on the nintendo wii game screen with words above it
an image of mario kart and luigi on the nintendo wii game screen with words above it
Mario is capable
Mario is capable
an image of a cartoon character on the phone with caption that reads, being a peachy glazer on here is so beautiful
an image of a cartoon character on the phone with caption that reads, being a peachy glazer on here is so beautiful

So, the next time you see "E for Everyone" stamped on a game's case, you can't help but grin, wondering what "everyone" truly means. Maybe it's time we start lobbying for "E for Everything" - from elders to environments and everything in between.