Paper Mario: Color Splash - Metacritic Rating and Reviews

Paper Mario: Color Splash, released in 2016, is the sixth installment in the popular Paper Mario series, developed by Intelligent Systems and published by Nintendo. Known for its unique papercraft aesthetics and engaging gameplay, Color Splash has garnered a substantial following and critical acclaim. But how does it stack up against other games in the series? Let's delve into a comprehensive analysis of Paper Mario: Color Splash's ratings and reviews.

paper mario coloring pages for kids and adults with the title, paper mario color by numbers
paper mario coloring pages for kids and adults with the title, paper mario color by numbers

The game's overall reception has been quite positive, with critics and fans alike praising its innovative mechanics and unique visual style. However, as with any game, opinions vary, and we'll explore these sentiments in detail.

the simpsons character stickers are shown in pink and yellow, as well as an image of
the simpsons character stickers are shown in pink and yellow, as well as an image of

Critic Reviews

The critics' consensus on Paper Mario: Color Splash is overwhelmingly positive. The game holds an impressive score of 82/100 on Metacritic, aggregating reviews from 89 critics. This score places it comfortably in the "generally favorable" category.

an image of some cartoon characters with different expressions on their faces and body, in various poses
an image of some cartoon characters with different expressions on their faces and body, in various poses

IGN's review, one of the most respected voices in gaming, awarded Color Splash an 8.5/10. They praised the game's unique aesthetic, engaging combat, and clever writing, calling it "a delightful return to form for the Paper Mario series."

Praise for Innovation

an image of the different types of video game characters and their names in pixel style
an image of the different types of video game characters and their names in pixel style

Many critics appreciate Intelligent Systems' willingness to innovate. Color Splash introduces new mechanics, such as using cards to interact with the environment and combat, which reviewers find refreshing and enjoyable.

Eurogamer's review highlighted this innovation, stating, "Paper Mario: Color Splash might look familiar, but it feels fresh in a way that few series entries do."

Criticism and Weaknesses

Parent's Guide: Paper Mario: Colour Splash | Age rating, mature content and difficulty
Parent's Guide: Paper Mario: Colour Splash | Age rating, mature content and difficulty

Despite the positivity, some critics found flaws in Color Splash. A common criticism is the difficulty spikes and the length of certain sections, which can test even experienced players' patience.

GameSpot's review, while positive overall, noted that "some puzzles can be obtuse, and a few sections of the game drag on too long."

User Reviews and Ratings

an image of mario kart and luigi on the nintendo wii game screen with words above it
an image of mario kart and luigi on the nintendo wii game screen with words above it

User reviews on platforms like Steam and Nintendo's eShop corroborate the critic reviews, with many players lauding the game's visuals, humor, and engaging gameplay.

On the Nintendo eShop, Color Splash holds a solid 4.5/5 star average, with thousands of ratings. Users often comment on the game's charm, wit, and unique take on the role-playing genre.

an image of a cartoon character with a green mushroom on his head and hands in the air
an image of a cartoon character with a green mushroom on his head and hands in the air
an image of a paper cut out of mario and luigi's house with a sign that says we dance in circles
an image of a paper cut out of mario and luigi's house with a sign that says we dance in circles
an image of a cartoon character with his arms out and hands in the shape of mario
an image of a cartoon character with his arms out and hands in the shape of mario
Paper Mario: Color Splash Review | Nintendo Wire
Paper Mario: Color Splash Review | Nintendo Wire
Mario (Transformations) - Paper Mario: Color Splash - Wii U
Mario (Transformations) - Paper Mario: Color Splash - Wii U
Legendary Captain
Legendary Captain
the super mario bros characters are all different sizes and colors, but there is no image to describe
the super mario bros characters are all different sizes and colors, but there is no image to describe

Accessibility and Replayability

Some users praise the game's accessibility, noting that it's a great choice for both casual players and seasoned gamers. The game's difficulty can be adjusted, appealing to a wider range of players.

Meanwhile, others appreciate the game's replayability, with multiple endings and collectibles encouraging multiple playthroughs.

Progression and Pacing

While some users enjoy the game's progression and pacing, others find it too slow or frustrating. This is a common facet of user reviews, reflecting the subjective nature of such experiences.

"The puzzles were challenging, but not overly so, and the story was engaging enough to keep me pushing forward," wrote one user. Conversely, another commented, "The pacing can be slow at times, and some sections feel like they drag on too long."

In conclusion, Paper Mario: Color Splash stands as a testament to Intelligent Systems' ability to innovate within a familiar setting. While it's not without its flaws, the game's unique aesthetic and engaging gameplay have secured its place among the Paper Mario series' fan-favorite entries. If you're a fan of the series or the RPG genre in general, Color Splash is definitely worth experiencing. And who knows, you might just enjoy it so much that you'll find yourself playing it again to discover all its secrets.