Paper Mario Tier List: Reddit's Top Picks

The Paper Mario series has been a beloved fixture in the Nintendo universe since its inception, captivating players with its unique blend of RPG and adventure elements. Given the series' popularity, it's no surprise that fans have developed a keen interest in comparing and ranking the games, leading to the creation of tier lists. One of the most prominent platforms where these discussions occur is Reddit, where users share their thoughts, debate, and ultimately, build consensus around the tiers.

paper mario: the origami king – Whole Heartily
paper mario: the origami king – Whole Heartily

Before delving into the specifics of the Paper Mario tier list found on Reddit, let's briefly recap the games that make up the series. The mainline games include Paper Mario (N64), Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door (GameCube), Super Paper Mario (Wii), Paper Mario: Sticker Star (3DS), Paper Mario: Color Splash (Wii U), and Paper Mario: The Origami King (Switch). There are also spinoffs like Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam, but for the sake of this list, we'll focus on the main series.

the super mario bros characters are all different colors and sizes, but they appear to be in
the super mario bros characters are all different colors and sizes, but they appear to be in

Reddit's Consensus: The Tier List

Reddit users have categorized the games into tiers based on various factors such as gameplay, story, humor, and overall enjoyment. Here's a breakdown of the most common tier list found on Reddit:

Origami king characters tier list
Origami king characters tier list

S-Tier: The Crème de la Crème

This tier is reserved for the games that are universally praised by the community. They offer an exceptional blend of engaging gameplay, memorable stories, and standout humor.

an image of a game board with many different items in the screen and numbers on each side
an image of a game board with many different items in the screen and numbers on each side

Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door and Paper Mario: The Origami King often find themselves in this tier. The Thousand-Year Door is praised for its clever story, charming humor, and innovative battle system. The Origami King, on the other hand, is lauded for its intricate paper crafts, unique battle mechanics, and expansive world.

Tier A: Excellent Games

Games in this tier are still highly regarded but may have some shortcomings that prevent them from reaching S-tier status.

many different types of cartoon characters are shown
many different types of cartoon characters are shown

Paper Mario (N64) and Super Paper Mario are usually found here. While the original Paper Mario laid the groundwork for the series, it's sometimes criticized for its linear gameplay and lack of character progression. Super Paper Mario, however, is praised for its innovative gameplay mechanics and extensive exploration, but some users find its story lacking compared to other entries.

The Role of Humor in Paper Mario

Humor plays an integral role in the Paper Mario series, often serving as a defining characteristic. Users on Reddit frequently discuss the humor in these games and how it significantly contributes to their enjoyment.

I made this, you can use it if you want!
I made this, you can use it if you want!

Slapstick and Self-Awareness

Many fans appreciate the series' slapstick comedy, which often pushes the boundaries of what's possible in a Facebook video game. The games are also known for their self-aware humor, often poking fun at gaming tropes and Nintendo's own history.

Paper Mario: The Origami King - Question Blocks Guide
Paper Mario: The Origami King - Question Blocks Guide
the super mario bros characters are all different sizes and colors, but there is no image to describe
the super mario bros characters are all different sizes and colors, but there is no image to describe
the top ten characters in mario kart
the top ten characters in mario kart
several different types of video game characters
several different types of video game characters
an image of the different types of video game characters and their names in pixel style
an image of the different types of video game characters and their names in pixel style
the super mario bros character list
the super mario bros character list
cartoon character stickers with different names and colors, including the characters in each one
cartoon character stickers with different names and colors, including the characters in each one

For instance, The Thousand-Year Door features a sequence where Mario has to2navigate a room filled with Koopa Troopas, referencing the genre's overuse of the enemy as a shallow obstacle. Paper Mario: The Origami King takes this a step further by acknowledging the prevalence of paper enemies in the series and making them essential to the story.

Character-Driven Humor

The series' humor also extends to its characters. Each game introduces a unique cast of partners, each with their own quirks and personalities. These partners often provide comedic relief, with their interactions with Mario and each other driving many of the games' funniest moments.

Adrienne from The Thousand-Year Door, for example, is known for her deadpan responses and snarky remarks, while Kit from The Origami King brings a unique blend of humor due to his origins as a sentient origami artifact.

Ultimately, the topic of humor in Paper Mario is a passionate one on Reddit, with users debating the merits and relative strengths of each game's comedic leanings. This discourse often leads to a reevaluation of the tier list, with some users' personal experiences with the games' humor influencing their placement.

Engaging with a community of fans on platforms like Reddit can significantly enrich your appreciation of the Paper Mario series. By discussing and debating the merits of each game, you can gain new perspectives and a deeper understanding of what makes this series so special. So, whether you're a longtime fan or just starting your paper adventure, joining the conversation on Reddit is an excellent way to enhance your enjoyment of Paper Mario."