Super Paper Mario: Ultimate Chapter Tier List

Embarking on a journey through the delightful world of the Super Paper Mario series? You're in for a treat, as each chapter offers a unique blend of humor, adventure, and challenging gameplay. But with so much to explore, you might be wondering where to start. This comprehensive tier list will guide you through the chapters, helping you decide which ones to prioritize based on their engaging storylines, innovative mechanics, and overall replayability.

paper mario: the origami king – Whole Heartily
paper mario: the origami king – Whole Heartily

Before we dive in, remember that tier placement is subjective and can vary among players. This list aims to provide a balanced perspective, considering multiple factors to give you a well-rounded understanding of each chapter. Now, let's get started on this adventure!

the super mario bros character list
the super mario bros character list

Tier S - Must-Play Chapters

The S-tier chapters are absolute must-plays, offering unforgettable experiences that define the Super Paper Mario series. These chapters boast compelling story arcs, innovative gameplay mechanics, and memorable moments that will leave you eager for more.

the super mario bros characters are all different sizes and colors, but there is no image to describe
the super mario bros characters are all different sizes and colors, but there is no image to describe

Super Paper Mario (GameCube)

Kicking things off is the original Super Paper Mario, which introduced the series' unique 2D/3D gameplay switching mechanic. This groundbreaking approach to platforming offered a fresh take on the Paper Mario formula, with charming storytelling and a diverse cast of characters. The ఆసుపత్రి fight against Grodus is an unforgettable highlight, exemplifying the chapter's innovative design.

many different types of cartoon characters are shown
many different types of cartoon characters are shown

GameCube's Super Paper Mario also features a branching narrative with multiple endings. Pursuing The Count'sñez plunger threat and Tinymcesor Oswald's secret plan adds depth and replayability to the story. It's no wonder this chapter tops the S-tier!

Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door (GameCube)

The Thousand-Year Door builds upon the success of its predecessor, offering an even more engaging story filled with twists, turns, and genuinely funny moments. The chapter introduces the(', love-letter' to RPG conventions, with its focus on collectibles, side quests, and a vast overworld to explore.

an image of many different types of game characters on a color scheme for the iphone
an image of many different types of game characters on a color scheme for the iphone

The addition of theIdxel meter, which allows Mario to invert the world's interactivity, provides fresh puzzles and combat strategies. The Thousand-Year Door's memorable boss fights, like the epic showdown against Violet + Goom, cement its status as an S-tier must-play.

Tier A - Excellent Chapters

Moving down a tier, the A-tier chapters still offer fantastic experiences but may have minor hiccups or lack some of the innovation found in the S-tier. These chapters are still excellent choices for any fan of the Super Paper Mario series.

an image of the different types of video games on a cell phone, with numbers and symbols
an image of the different types of video games on a cell phone, with numbers and symbols

Paper Mario: Sticker Star (Nintendo 3DS)

Sticker Star brings the series to the Nintendo 3DS, employing a unique sticker-based combat system. While the battle mechanics can feel repetitive at times, the chapter shines in its world design and humor. The story, revolving around Princess Peach's kidnapped corazón and the mysterious Thousand-Year Door, offers plenty of laughs and engaging exploration.

More memes
More memes
cartoon character stickers with different names and colors, including the characters in each one
cartoon character stickers with different names and colors, including the characters in each one
an image of mario and other characters in different colors on the same page for each character
an image of mario and other characters in different colors on the same page for each character
I made this, you can use it if you want!
I made this, you can use it if you want!
an image of mario and friends stickers
an image of mario and friends stickers
the super mario bros characters are all different colors and sizes, but they appear to be in
the super mario bros characters are all different colors and sizes, but they appear to be in
the differences between video games and cartoons
the differences between video games and cartoons

The chapter's reliance on stickers for combat can be frustrating, as it limits Mario's ability to switch between attacks. However, the visually striking world and engaging narrative prevent Sticker Star from dropping any lower in the tiers.

Paper Mario: Color Splash (Wii U)

Color Splash introduces a new painting-based mechanic to the series, allowing Mario to fill the world with color and solve puzzles. The chapter's art style is visually striking, and the story, focusing on rescuing the yoshis from corrosion and saving the world from the Void, is engaging and well-paced.

Despite its innovative gameplay elements, Color Splash struggles with pacing issues and a few lackluster boss fights. These minor setbacks keep it from reaching the S-tier but don't detract from the overall enjoyable experience.

Tier B - Good Chapters

The B-tier chapters offer decent gameplay experiences, but they might have notable flaws or lack some of the standout features found in the higher tiers. These chapters can still be enjoyable, but they might not be as enduringly memorable as those in the S or A tiers.

Paper Mario: The Origami King (Nintendo Switch)

The Origami King marks a bold departure from the series' traditional RPG roots, embracing a more action-oriented approach. The chapter's new folding mechanic introduces fresh puzzles and platforming sections, with a engaging story focused on stopping aussy Lady from transforming the entire world into origami.

While the combat system and lack of traditional RPG elements may put off some fans, The Origami King's visuals, humor, and exploration make it a solid addition to the series. However, the chapter's departure from the series' established formula keeps it from ranking higher in the tiers.

Paper Mario (Nintendo 64)

The original Paper Mario on the Nintendo 64 establishes the series' signature blend of RPG elements and platforming. The chapter's unique paper-based world and classic Mario enemies provide a delightful and engaging experience, with a well-rounded cast of allies and a charming story.

Despite its age, Paper Mario's uncomplicated battle system and linear progression can feel limiting compared to later entries in the series. This, along with its lower production values, keeps it from reaching the higher tiers.

Tier C - Satisfying Chapters

The C-tier chapters offer enjoyable experiences but may struggle with significant flaws or lack some of the polish found in the higher tiers. These chapters can still be worth playing, but they may not engage or captivate players in the same way as the S, A, or B-tier entries.

There are no C-tier chapters in this tier list, as all Super Paper Mario chapters offer at least a decent, satisfying experience. The quality of the games in this series is consistently high, with even the lowest-ranked chapter (the original Paper Mario) offering an engaging and enjoyable time.

As the series continues to evolve, with each chapter introducing new mechanics and refining established formulas, the Super Paper Mario experience remains consistently engaging and captivating. Whether you're a die-hard fan or a newcomer to the series, there's a chapter out there waiting to delight and entertain you.

So, grab your favorite Mario game and embark on an adventure through the uniquely colorful world of Super Paper Mario. With diverse gameplay mechanics, compelling stories, and an unmistakable charm, the series continues to enchant players of all ages. Which chapter will you explore first?