Wuthering Heights, penned by Emily Brontë in 1847, is a novel that has long captivated readers and confounded literary scholars alike. Its eerie narrative, unconventional characters, and dark, Gothic themes have earned it a reputation as one of the weirdest classics in English literature. But what exactly makes Wuthering Heights so unique and unsettling?

The weirdness of Wuthering Heights can be attributed to several factors, including its nonlinear structure, its morally ambiguous characters, and its exploration of taboo subjects. Let's delve into these aspects to understand why this novel continues to bewilder and enthrall readers more than a century after its publication.

Nonlinear Narrative Structure
Wuthering Heights is not told chronologically, which can leave readers feeling disoriented. Instead, Brontë employs multiple narrators and time jumps, interweaving several storylines. This storytelling technique was revolutionary for its time and contributes to the novel's disorienting effect.

Brontë picked an unconventional narrator, Lockwood, a newcomer to the area who happens upon the events of the story but is also an outsider to them. His perspective is supplemented by that of the housekeeper, Nelly Dean, who provides a firsthand account of the events. This dual narration adds depth but also confusion, mirroring the complex relationships and plotlines within the novel.
Fragmented Timeline

The narrative of Wuthering Heights is not linear; instead, it's divided into three sections, each with a different focus but all overlapping and intersecting. The first section concentrates on the love rivalry between Catherine and Hetty, the second details the Earnshaw family's decline, and the third explores the consequences of Hindley's cruelty. These sections are further chopped up with Lockwood's dreams and Nelly's flashbacks, making the timeline incredibly challenging to follow.
This fragmentation can be bewildering, but it also allows Brontë to explore different themes and relationships in depth. It's part of the novel's unsettling magic, keeping readers on their toes and preventing them from getting too comfortable with the story's trajectory.
Unreliable Narrators

Brontë's use of narrators is not just about perspective; it's also about honesty. Both Lockwood and Nelly are unreliable narrators, shaping the story to fit their biases and experiences. Lockwood, for instance, initially frames the events to make himself seem like a harmless bystander. Nelly, meanwhile, is deeply invested in the events and the characters, which influences her telling of the story.
This literary technique isn't just weird; it's also profoundly effective. By making her narrators unreliable, Brontë forces readers to question what they're reading and to fill in the gaps left by the narrators' omission or obfuscation, thereby increasing reader engagement and immersion.
Morally Ambiguous Characters

If Wuthering Heights' structure is strange, its characters are downright odd. They are not your typical Victorian heroes and heroines. Instead, they are complex, flawed, and morally ambiguous, so much so that it's hard to know who to root for.
Take, for instance, the titular character, Heathcliff. He's been variously described as a Byronic hero, a monster, a psychopath, and a abused victim. He's vengeful, disruptive, and ultimately drives the plot through his obsession with Catherine Earnshaw. Yet, Brontë also shows his vomiting with grief at Catherine's death, hinting at a deeper humanity. This ambiguity makes Heathcliff a compelling but weird character.








Catherine Earnshaw: The Unattainable Ideal
Catherine Earnshaw, the love of Heathcliff's life, is another strange character. She's moody, capricious, and manipulative. She strives for a 'sort ofшо purity' in love and encourages Heathcliff's affections, only to reject him later for Edgar Linton, a man of her social standing. Catherine's inability to reconcile her love for Heathcliff with her desire for social status makes her an unsettling character.
Moreover, her initial defiance of gender norms and her later compliance with them also make her a confusing and stomach-churning figure. She's a contradiction, and that weirdness makes her a captivating character that's hard to peg down.
Isabella Linton: The Reluctant Heroine
Isabella Linton, the younger sister of Edgar Linton and Heathcliff's second wife, is another unusually drawn character. She's initially portrayed as a romantic heroine, Mrs. Radcliffe, who believes in the 'natural aristocracy of talent and worth' and sees in Heathcliff a ' Gothic hero'. Yet, after her marriage to Heathcliff, she becomes a repressed and abused woman.
Isabella's transformation from a heroine to a victim is a disconcerting shift. It's weird to see her move from idealisation to victimisation, and it's this unexpected trajectory that makes her such a compelling and strange character.
Dark Themes and Taboo Subjects
Wuthering Heights isn't just weird in its narrative and characters; it's also weird in its themes. Brontë delves into dark, taboo subjects that were considered scandalous in the Victorian era.
The novel explores themes of class struggle, domestic abuse, mental instability, and the consequences of unchecked obsession. It also touches upon issues of incest, infanticide, and misogyny, making it a profoundly unsettling read.
Incest
Wuthering Heights contains an incestuous undertone. Biologically, Heathcliff is Catherine's brother. The nature of their relationship - a grim, obsessive, almost gothic love - is as disturbing as it is captivating. This theme, though never explicit, is a source of unease and weirdness in the novel.
Brontë also hints at incest through Isabella's marriage to Heathcliff. Isabella's similarities to Catherine - both are beautiful, upper-class, and initially idealize Heathcliff - make their relationship incestuous in a symbolic sense. This hidden theme adds to the novel's unsettling atmosphere.
Domestic Abuse and Misogyny
Wuthering Heights is a work of domestic gothic, a subgenre that explores horror and terror in domestic settings. It delves into the dark side of family life, exposing the horror that can exist behind closed doors. Domestic abuse is a central theme, with Hindley abusing his wife, Frances, and Heathcliff abusing Isabella and Hareton.
Misogyny is another theme. Heathcliff's treatment of his wife, Isabella, is misogynistic. She's subjected to psychological and physical abuse, as well as confinement and isolation, all because she displeases Heathcliff. This misogyny is stark and unsettling, making Wuthering Heights a weird and disquieting read.
Reading Wuthering Heights is not a straightforward experience. It's unpredictable, unsettling, and often downright weird. This is what makes it such a compelling read, even 175 years after its publication. Its weirdness is its strength, pushing literary boundaries and forcing readers to engage with complex themes and characters. It's not always a comfortable read, but it's an unforgettable one. So, if you're yet to pick up this unique classic, do so with caution - you may never see literature the same way again.