Do Master Bathrooms Still Need Bathtubs?

Logan Jul 18, 2026

When planning or renovating a master bathroom, one question often arises: do master bathrooms need a bathtub? After all, with showers becoming increasingly popular for their practicality and efficiency, it's worth weighing the pros and cons of incorporating a bathtub into your design.

a person pointing at the bottom of a bathtub
a person pointing at the bottom of a bathtub

However, before we delve into the arguments for and against, let's first acknowledge that the needs and preferences of homeowners vary greatly. For some, a relaxing soak in the tub is an essential part of their daily self-care routine. For others, the shower is the clear choice for its practicality and time-saving benefits. So, the question may not have a one-size-fits-all answer.

Before You Move A Single Wall Read This My Honest Guide To Master Bathroom Layouts That Make Sense
Before You Move A Single Wall Read This My Honest Guide To Master Bathroom Layouts That Make Sense

bathroom layout and design

A common reason homeowners consider removing the bathtub is to create more space in their bathroom. The shower often takes up less room than a bathtub, allowing for a more spacious layout. This can be particularly appealing for smaller bathrooms where each square foot counts.

Bathroom must haves
Bathroom must haves

Moreover, many homeowners are embracing open-concept bathroom designs, which often mean maximizing floor space and creating a more cohesive flow. In these designs, a shower might feel more cohesive with the room's aesthetic than a bathtub.

considering resale value

the bathroom is clean and ready for us to use
the bathroom is clean and ready for us to use

While personal preferences are important, it's also worth considering the resale value of your home. In many regions, the presence of a bathtub in a master bathroom can increase the home's appeal to a broader range of buyers.

Additionally, real estate professionals often recommend including at least one bathtub in a home to accommodate families with young children. torsion alert buyers, especially those with young children, often look for a home with a bathtub, as it's generally safer and more practical for bathing young kids than a shower.

accessibility and safety

a woman sitting on the floor in a bathroom next to a shower with text that reads, things i wouldn't do again in my bathroom renovation renovation
a woman sitting on the floor in a bathroom next to a shower with text that reads, things i wouldn't do again in my bathroom renovation renovation

Another critical factor to consider is accessibility and safety. Many homeowners, particularly those with mobility challenges, find bathtubs safer and more comfortable for bathing than showers. Adding grab bars, a chair, or a walk-in tub can further enhance the accessibility of the bathtub, making it a practical choice for those who prioritize safety.

On the other hand, showers may present trip hazards with their lips and tray edges. They also require good balance to maneuver in and out safely. If you or someone in your household has mobility issues or is at high risk of falling, a bathtub might be a safer choice.

bathroom functionality and trends

2026 Bathroom Trends and Design Ideas for Master Bathrooms and Small Full Baths
2026 Bathroom Trends and Design Ideas for Master Bathrooms and Small Full Baths

Away from practical considerations, let's explore the functional and trendy aspects of bathtubs. Incorporating a freestanding bathtub or a luxurious soaking tub can significantly enhance the aesthetic appeal of your master bathroom, transforming it into a true oasis of relaxation.

Moreover, the recent trend of combining the bathtub and shower into one space, often referred to as a 'wet room', can create a modern, sleek look. Despite their combined size, these spaces can feel surprisingly spacious thanks to minimalistic design and clever use of materials like glass and stone.

Types of Tubs: How to Pick the One You’ll Love - Signature Home Services
Types of Tubs: How to Pick the One You’ll Love - Signature Home Services
Luxury master bathroom with bathtubs, walk-in showers, and elegant marble flooring in a bright, airy space with large windows and modern fixtures for a spa-like retreat. Large Bathroom Design Layout, Best Master Bath Layout, Complete Bathroom Remodel Ideas, Large Bathroom Remodel Layout, Master Bathrooms Designs, 12 X 13 Bathroom Layout, Best Bathroom Layouts Master Bath, Beautiful Traditional Bathrooms, Large Bathroom Designs Master Bath
Luxury master bathroom with bathtubs, walk-in showers, and elegant marble flooring in a bright, airy space with large windows and modern fixtures for a spa-like retreat. Large Bathroom Design Layout, Best Master Bath Layout, Complete Bathroom Remodel Ideas, Large Bathroom Remodel Layout, Master Bathrooms Designs, 12 X 13 Bathroom Layout, Best Bathroom Layouts Master Bath, Beautiful Traditional Bathrooms, Large Bathroom Designs Master Bath
Does My Home Really Need a Bath Tub? | Neil Kelly Blog
Does My Home Really Need a Bath Tub? | Neil Kelly Blog
Instagram Unique Bathroom Layout, Big House Plan, Layout Plan, Luxury Bathroom Layout, Hotel Bathroom Designs, Modern Bathroom Design Luxury, 4x2 Bathroom, Shower Plus Bathtub, Bathroom Plan Design
Instagram Unique Bathroom Layout, Big House Plan, Layout Plan, Luxury Bathroom Layout, Hotel Bathroom Designs, Modern Bathroom Design Luxury, 4x2 Bathroom, Shower Plus Bathtub, Bathroom Plan Design
13 Neat Master Bath Wet Room 🚿✨
13 Neat Master Bath Wet Room 🚿✨
Master Bathroom Without a Tub: Good Idea or Dealbreaker?
Master Bathroom Without a Tub: Good Idea or Dealbreaker?
Robin’s Bathroom Makeover Reveal {Part One}
Robin’s Bathroom Makeover Reveal {Part One}
Our Master Bath Feels Huge with Our New Freestanding Tub!
Our Master Bath Feels Huge with Our New Freestanding Tub!
a bath room with a tub a sink and a mirror on the wall in it
a bath room with a tub a sink and a mirror on the wall in it

environmental impact

Environmentally conscious homeowners may also want to consider the water usage implications of a bathtub versus a shower. Generally, showers tend to consume less water than baths, making them a more eco-friendly option.

However, the environmental impact can depend significantly on the duration of use. A long shower might use more water than a quick bath. Therefore, it's essential to consider your family's habits and make adjustments as necessary. For instance, installing a water-saving shower head or using a bathtub with a water-saving design can help minimize your environmental impact.

unique selling points

Lastly, consider the unique selling points of each option. A bathtub can provide a relaxing, spa-like experience that a shower might not replicate. On the other hand, a shower can offer a more invigorating start to the day, with options like rainfall showerheads and body sprays.

Additionally, showers can often be designed to be more customized than bathtubs, with features like built-in benches, shelving, and even steam and sound systems. These features can significantly enhance your showering experience but may not be possible or practical in a bathtub.

Ultimately, the answer to whether master bathrooms need a bathtub depends on your personal needs, preferences, and priorities. By carefully weighing the pros and cons, you can make an informed decision that not only meets your current needs but also enhances your home's efficiency, comfort, and value.