Statistics: 0 / 9445 (0.00%) words changed
They They |
need need |
to to |
build build |
a a |
future future |
of of |
unlimited unlimited |
possibilities possibilities |
Good Good |
evening evening |
and and |
welcome welcome |
I'm I'm |
Amna Amna |
Nawaz Nawaz |
Judy Judy |
Woodruff Woodruff |
is is |
away away |
on on |
the the |
news news |
hour hour |
tonight tonight |
of of |
verdict verdict |
A A |
jury jury |
orders orders |
conspiracy conspiracy |
theorist theorist |
Alex Alex |
Jones Jones |
to to |
pay pay |
the the |
families families |
of of |
the the |
Sandy Sandy |
Hook Hook |
Massacre Massacre |
nearly nearly |
$1 $1 |
billion billion |
in in |
damages damages |
Then Then |
the the |
Saudi Saudi |
connection connection |
the the |
United United |
States States |
re-evaluated re-evaluated |
its its |
relationship relationship |
with with |
the the |
kingdom kingdom |
over over |
a a |
cut cut |
in in |
oil oil |
production production |
that's that's |
pushing pushing |
up up |
gas gas |
prices prices |
And And |
first first |
time time |
voters voters |
young young |
adults adults |
in in |
Wisconsin Wisconsin |
discussed discussed |
their their |
hopes hopes |
for for |
the the |
country's country's |
future future |
and and |
whether whether |
politicians politicians |
are are |
listening listening |
to to |
their their |
concern concern |
I've I've |
been been |
very very |
politically politically |
engaged engaged |
throughout throughout |
high high |
school school |
and and |
I'm I'm |
excited excited |
to to |
get get |
my my |
foot foot |
in in |
the the |
door door |
and and |
actually actually |
have have |
a a |
voice voice |
in in |
my my |
government government |
All All |
that that |
and and |
more more |
on on |
tonight's tonight's |
PBS PBS |
News News |
Hour Hour |
Major Major |
funding funding |
for for |
the the |
PBS PBS |
News News |
Hour Hour |
has has |
been been |
provided provided |
by.. by.. |
Moving Moving |
our our |
economy economy |
for for |
160 160 |
years years |
BNSF BNSF |
the the |
engine engine |
that that |
connects connects |
us us |
Pediatric Pediatric |
surgeon surgeon |
volunteer volunteer |
topiary topiary |
artist artist |
a a |
Raymond Raymond |
James James |
financial financial |
advisor advisor |
tailors tailors |
advice advice |
to to |
help help |
you you |
live live |
your your |
life life |
life life |
well well |
planned planned |
The The |
Walton Walton |
Family Family |
Foundation Foundation |
working working |
for for |
solutions solutions |
to to |
protect protect |
water water |
during during |
climate climate |
change change |
so so |
people people |
and and |
major major |
can can |
thrive thrive |
together together |
Supported Supported |
by by |
the the |
John John |
D D |
and and |
Catherine Catherine |
T T |
MacArthur MacArthur |
Foundation Foundation |
committed committed |
to to |
building building |
a a |
more more |
just just |
verdant verdant |
and and |
peaceful peaceful |
world world |
More More |
information information |
at at |
MacFound.org MacFound.org |
And And |
with with |
the the |
ongoing ongoing |
support support |
of of |
these these |
institutions institutions |
This This |
program program |
was was |
made made |
possible possible |
by by |
the the |
Corporation Corporation |
for for |
Public Public |
Broadcasting Broadcasting |
and and |
by by |
contributions contributions |
to to |
your your |
PBS PBS |
station station |
from from |
viewers viewers |
like like |
you you |
Thank Thank |
you you |
A A |
jury jury |
and and |
Connecticut Connecticut |
has has |
ordered ordered |
conspiracy conspiracy |
theorist theorist |
Alex Alex |
Jones Jones |
to to |
pay pay |
nearly nearly |
$1 $1 |
billion billion |
in in |
damages damages |
for for |
defamation defamation |
The The |
host host |
of of |
the the |
info info |
war war |
show show |
had had |
claimed claimed |
the the |
2012 2012 |
Sandy Sandy |
Hook Hook |
School School |
massacre massacre |
was was |
a a |
hoax hoax |
Relatives Relatives |
of of |
eight eight |
of of |
the the |
26 26 |
victims victims |
and and |
an an |
FBI FBI |
agent agent |
brought brought |
the the |
suit suit |
They They |
said said |
today's today's |
verdict verdict |
is is |
a a |
hard hard |
fought fought |
victory victory |
All All |
I I |
can can |
really really |
say say |
is is |
that that |
I'm I'm |
just just |
proud proud |
that that |
what what |
we we |
are are |
able able |
to to |
accomplish accomplish |
was was |
just just |
to to |
simply simply |
tell tell |
the the |
truth truth |
And And |
it it |
shouldn't shouldn't |
be be |
this this |
hard hard |
and and |
it it |
shouldn't shouldn't |
be be |
this this |
scary scary |
I I |
shouldn't shouldn't |
have have |
to to |
worry worry |
about about |
what what |
my my |
daughter's daughter's |
going going |
to to |
go go |
through through |
When When |
I I |
tell tell |
them them |
that that |
it's it's |
best best |
that that |
they they |
just just |
tell tell |
the the |
truth truth |
Jones Jones |
already already |
faced faced |
a a |
$50 $50 |
million million |
penalty penalty |
that that |
a a |
Texas Texas |
jury jury |
imposed imposed |
in in |
August August |
will will |
return return |
to to |
this this |
story story |
later later |
in in |
the the |
program program |
A A |
jury jury |
in in |
South South |
Florida Florida |
has has |
begun begun |
deliberating deliberating |
on on |
whether whether |
Parkland's Parkland's |
school school |
shooter shooter |
Nicholas Nicholas |
Cruz Cruz |
will will |
be be |
sentenced sentenced |
to to |
death death |
Cruz Cruz |
already already |
pleaded pleaded |
guilty guilty |
to to |
killing killing |
17 17 |
people people |
at at |
Marjorie Marjorie |
Stoneman Stoneman |
Douglas Douglas |
High High |
School School |
in in |
2018 2018 |
He's He's |
now now |
24 24 |
years years |
old old |
The The |
defense defense |
is is |
asking asking |
for for |
life life |
in in |
prison prison |
without without |
parole parole |
In In |
Ukraine Ukraine |
seven seven |
more more |
people people |
were were |
killed killed |
today today |
as as |
Russia Russia |
fired fired |
more more |
missiles missiles |
drones drones |
and and |
artillery artillery |
rounds rounds |
into into |
major major |
cities cities |
In In |
all all |
the the |
new new |
Russian Russian |
offensive offensive |
has has |
killed killed |
at at |
least least |
26 26 |
people people |
since since |
Monday Monday |
The The |
latest latest |
attacks attacks |
came came |
as as |
U.S U.S |
defense defense |
secretary secretary |
Lloyd Lloyd |
Austin Austin |
and and |
other other |
NATO NATO |
defense defense |
ministers ministers |
met met |
in in |
Brussels Brussels |
on on |
bolstering bolstering |
Ukraine's Ukraine's |
weapon weapon |
supply supply |
And And |
that that |
resolve resolve |
has has |
only only |
been been |
heightened heightened |
by by |
the the |
deliberate deliberate |
cruelty cruelty |
of of |
Russia's Russia's |
new new |
barrage barrage |
against against |
Ukraine's Ukraine's |
cities cities |
Those Those |
assaults assaults |
on on |
targets targets |
with with |
no no |
military military |
purpose purpose |
Again Again |
reveal reveal |
the the |
malice malice |
of of |
Putin's Putin's |
war war |
of of |
choice choice |
Russian Russian |
fire fire |
also also |
knocked knocked |
out out |
power power |
to to |
the the |
Zapar Zapar |
region region |
nuclear nuclear |
plant plant |
for for |
the the |
second second |
time time |
in in |
five five |
days days |
And And |
at at |
the the |
United United |
Nations Nations |
the the |
General General |
Assembly Assembly |
voted voted |
overwhelmingly overwhelmingly |
to to |
condemn condemn |
Russia's Russia's |
attempt attempt |
to to |
annex annex |
more more |
of of |
Ukraine Ukraine |
Russian Russian |
President President |
Vladimir Vladimir |
Putin Putin |
says says |
Moscow Moscow |
is is |
set set |
to to |
resume resume |
natural natural |
gas gas |
deliveries deliveries |
to to |
Europe Europe |
He He |
said said |
today today |
that that |
the the |
Nord Nord |
Stream Stream |
2 2 |
pipeline pipeline |
to to |
Germany Germany |
could could |
still still |
be be |
used used |
despite despite |
being being |
damaged damaged |
by by |
explosions explosions |
last last |
month month |
Germany Germany |
quickly quickly |
rejected rejected |
the the |
offer offer |
as as |
another another |
attempt attempt |
to to |
renew renew |
Europe's Europe's |
dependence dependence |
on on |
Russian Russian |
energy energy |
New New |
protest protest |
swept swept |
Iran Iran |
today today |
despite despite |
heavy heavy |
police police |
presence presence |
and and |
an an |
internet internet |
outage outage |
that that |
hindered hindered |
communications communications |
Demonstrators Demonstrators |
rallied rallied |
in in |
at at |
least least |
19 19 |
cities cities |
over over |
the the |
death death |
of of |
Masa Masa |
Amini Amini |
and and |
police police |
custody custody |
Women Women |
marched marched |
in in |
the the |
streets streets |
defiantly defiantly |
removing removing |
their their |
mandatory mandatory |
hijab hijab |
In In |
Tehran Tehran |
Supreme Supreme |
Leader Leader |
Ayatollah Ayatollah |
Khamenei Khamenei |
blamed blamed |
foreign foreign |
elements elements |
for for |
the the |
unrest unrest |
Some Some |
are are |
either either |
agents agents |
of of |
the the |
enemy enemy |
or or |
they they |
are are |
aligned aligned |
with with |
the the |
enemy enemy |
Others Others |
are are |
just just |
excited excited |
The The |
first first |
group group |
must must |
be be |
dealt dealt |
with with |
by by |
judicial judicial |
and and |
national national |
security security |
officials officials |
The The |
regime regime |
has has |
carried carried |
out out |
a a |
violent violent |
crackdown crackdown |
on on |
the the |
protests protests |
One One |
human human |
rights rights |
group group |
estimated estimated |
today today |
that that |
at at |
least least |
200 200 |
people people |
have have |
been been |
killed killed |
Back Back |
in in |
this this |
country country |
the the |
former former |
head head |
of of |
the the |
Los Los |
Angeles Angeles |
City City |
Council Council |
has has |
resigned resigned |
her her |
council council |
seat seat |
over over |
racist racist |
remarks remarks |
that that |
were were |
leaked leaked |
Norie Norie |
Martinez Martinez |
had had |
already already |
stepped stepped |
down down |
from from |
her her |
post post |
as as |
council council |
president president |
On On |
the the |
leaked leaked |
recording recording |
Martinez Martinez |
and and |
two two |
other other |
council council |
members members |
talked talked |
about about |
protecting protecting |
Latino Latino |
voting voting |
power power |
and and |
made made |
abusive abusive |
remarks remarks |
about about |
other other |
groups groups |
The The |
California California |
Attorney Attorney |
General General |
has has |
announced announced |
he he |
will will |
look look |
into into |
the the |
process process |
for for |
drawing drawing |
new new |
council council |
districts districts |
Former Former |
President President |
Trump Trump |
was was |
ordered ordered |
today today |
to to |
give give |
a a |
deposition deposition |
in in |
a a |
defamation defamation |
lawsuit lawsuit |
A A |
federal federal |
judge judge |
issued issued |
the the |
order order |
in in |
New New |
York York |
The The |
vice vice |
columnist columnist |
E E |
Jean Jean |
Carroll Carroll |
says says |
Mr Mr |
Trump Trump |
defamed defamed |
her her |
when when |
he he |
denied denied |
raping raping |
her her |
in in |
a a |
department department |
store store |
dressing dressing |
room room |
in in |
the the |
mid-1990s mid-1990s |
The The |
former former |
president's president's |
legal legal |
team team |
has has |
repeatedly repeatedly |
tried tried |
to to |
quash quash |
the the |
lawsuit lawsuit |
The The |
CDC CDC |
today today |
approved approved |
updated updated |
COVID-19 COVID-19 |
booster booster |
shots shots |
for for |
children children |
as as |
young young |
as as |
five five |
years years |
old old |
The The |
latest latest |
Pfizer Pfizer |
and and |
Moderna Moderna |
vaccines vaccines |
are are |
tailored tailored |
to to |
better better |
provide provide |
protection protection |
against against |
the the |
highly highly |
contagious contagious |
COVID-19 COVID-19 |
The The |
CDC CDC |
approval approval |
came came |
hours hours |
after after |
the the |
FDA FDA |
authorized authorized |
the the |
boosters boosters |
for for |
the the |
younger younger |
age age |
group group |
And And |
on on |
Wall Wall |
Street Street |
today today |
stocks stocks |
ended ended |
slightly slightly |
lower lower |
after after |
news news |
that that |
wholesale wholesale |
inflation inflation |
rose rose |
eight eight |
and and |
a a |
half half |
percent percent |
in in |
September September |
from from |
a a |
year year |
earlier earlier |
The The |
Dow Dow |
Jones Jones |
industrial industrial |
average average |
lost lost |
28 28 |
points points |
to to |
close close |
at at |
29,210 29,210 |
The The |
Nasdaq Nasdaq |
fell fell |
nine nine |
points points |
and and |
the the |
S&P S&P |
500 500 |
slipped slipped |
on on |
the the |
news news |
hour hour |
president president |
Biden's Biden's |
student student |
loan loan |
for for |
given given |
this this |
plan plan |
faces faces |
legal legal |
challenges challenges |
Reporters Reporters |
across across |
the the |
country country |
share share |
the the |
latest latest |
on on |
the the |
races races |
that that |
could could |
decide decide |
control control |
of of |
Congress Congress |
plus plus |
much much |
more more |
This This |
is is |
the the |
PBS PBS |
News News |
Hour Hour |
from from |
W-E-T-A W-E-T-A |
Studios Studios |
in in |
Washington Washington |
and and |
in in |
the the |
West West |
from from |
the the |
Walter Walter |
Cronkite Cronkite |
School School |
of of |
Journalism Journalism |
at at |
Arizona Arizona |
State State |
University University |
As As |
we we |
reported reported |
conspiracy conspiracy |
theorist theorist |
Alex Alex |
Jones Jones |
has has |
been been |
ordered ordered |
to to |
pay pay |
nearly nearly |
$1 $1 |
billion billion |
$965 $965 |
million million |
to to |
be be |
exact exact |
For For |
the the |
lies lies |
he he |
spread spread |
about about |
the the |
Sandy Sandy |
Hook Hook |
Elementary Elementary |
School School |
massacre massacre |
in in |
2012 2012 |
Jones Jones |
had had |
falsely falsely |
claimed claimed |
the the |
attack attack |
that that |
left left |
more more |
than than |
two two |
dozen dozen |
people people |
dead dead |
including including |
20 20 |
children children |
was was |
a a |
hoax hoax |
and and |
accused accused |
a a |
grieving grieving |
parent parent |
of of |
being being |
an an |
actor actor |
in in |
the the |
days days |
after after |
the the |
murders murders |
A A |
Texas Texas |
jury jury |
awarded awarded |
nearly nearly |
$50 $50 |
million million |
in in |
a a |
separate separate |
damages damages |
trial trial |
this this |
summer summer |
And And |
Jones Jones |
likely likely |
faces faces |
yet yet |
another another |
trial trial |
before before |
the the |
year year |
is is |
up up |
For For |
some some |
perspective perspective |
on on |
the the |
scope scope |
of of |
this this |
award award |
and and |
what what |
happens happens |
now now |
we we |
turn turn |
to to |
Jesse Jesse |
Gessen Gessen |
a a |
trial trial |
lawyer lawyer |
in in |
California California |
who who |
works works |
on on |
both both |
civil civil |
and and |
criminal criminal |
cases cases |
Mr Mr |
Gessen Gessen |
welcome welcome |
to to |
the the |
news news |
hour hour |
Thank Thank |
you you |
for for |
joining joining |
us us |
Let's Let's |
just just |
start start |
with with |
some some |
context context |
on on |
this this |
verdict verdict |
It It |
is is |
an an |
enormous enormous |
amount amount |
of of |
money money |
What What |
did did |
you you |
think think |
when when |
you you |
heard heard |
the the |
damages damages |
being being |
awarded awarded |
Well Well |
quite quite |
frankly frankly |
it's it's |
probably probably |
one one |
of of |
the the |
largest largest |
defamation defamation |
verdicts verdicts |
in in |
US US |
history history |
Also Also |
it's it's |
compensatory compensatory |
meaning meaning |
that that |
there's there's |
still still |
going going |
to to |
be be |
punitive punitive |
damages damages |
which which |
could could |
be be |
up up |
to to |
10 10 |
times times |
as as |
much much |
under under |
the the |
United United |
States States |
Constitution Constitution |
So So |
we're we're |
going going |
to to |
see see |
probably probably |
this this |
verdict verdict |
at at |
least least |
at at |
least least |
double double |
or or |
triple triple |
or or |
maybe maybe |
even even |
up up |
to to |
10 10 |
times times |
more more |
For For |
anyone anyone |
following following |
the the |
trial trial |
I I |
mean mean |
it it |
was was |
an an |
incredibly incredibly |
emotional emotional |
trial trial |
emotional emotional |
testimony testimony |
from from |
the the |
parents parents |
who've who've |
lost lost |
their their |
children children |
in in |
the the |
most most |
horrific horrific |
way way |
Does Does |
that that |
do do |
you you |
think think |
did did |
that that |
play play |
a a |
role role |
in in |
the the |
size size |
of of |
the the |
verdict verdict |
that that |
was was |
eventually eventually |
awarded awarded |
Assuredly Assuredly |
this this |
verdict verdict |
says says |
two two |
things things |
Number Number |
one one |
it it |
says says |
we we |
hate hate |
Alex Alex |
Jones Jones |
and and |
number number |
two two |
that that |
we we |
are are |
inflamed inflamed |
and and |
we we |
feel feel |
that that |
these these |
parents parents |
have have |
lost lost |
something something |
very very |
very very |
very very |
special special |
to to |
them them |
and and |
we're we're |
going going |
to to |
do do |
our our |
best best |
to to |
give give |
it it |
back back |
to to |
them them |
with with |
our our |
verdict verdict |
We We |
should should |
point point |
out out |
earlier earlier |
this this |
year year |
info info |
wars wars |
and and |
its its |
parent parent |
company company |
did did |
file file |
for for |
bankruptcy bankruptcy |
protections protections |
What What |
kind kind |
of of |
impact impact |
could could |
that that |
have have |
on on |
the the |
amount amount |
that's that's |
actually actually |
paid paid |
out out |
Well Well |
the the |
verdict verdict |
is is |
against against |
Alex Alex |
Jones Jones |
and and |
the the |
company company |
And And |
so so |
Alex Alex |
Jones Jones |
may may |
end end |
up up |
filing filing |
for for |
bankruptcy bankruptcy |
protection protection |
as as |
well well |
His His |
estimated estimated |
net net |
worth worth |
is is |
anywhere anywhere |
between between |
170 170 |
to to |
135 135 |
to to |
270 270 |
million million |
So So |
he he |
may may |
declare declare |
bankruptcy bankruptcy |
as as |
well well |
but but |
it it |
is is |
certainly certainly |
possible possible |
that that |
this this |
verdict verdict |
could could |
be be |
swept swept |
up up |
into into |
the the |
bankruptcy bankruptcy |
and and |
significantly significantly |
decreased decreased |
under under |
US US |
bankruptcy bankruptcy |
law law |
You You |
mentioned mentioned |
that that |
Texas Texas |
verdict verdict |
and and |
I I |
want want |
to to |
get get |
your your |
analysis analysis |
on on |
the the |
difference difference |
you you |
see see |
between between |
that that |
Texas Texas |
verdict verdict |
that that |
was was |
around around |
$50 $50 |
million million |
and and |
was was |
eventually eventually |
knocked knocked |
down down |
because because |
of of |
state state |
limits limits |
on on |
those those |
kinds kinds |
of of |
awards awards |
and and |
the the |
damages damages |
we we |
saw saw |
awarded awarded |
today today |
How How |
do do |
you you |
see see |
the the |
difference difference |
between between |
what what |
unfolded unfolded |
in in |
Texas Texas |
and and |
what what |
happened happened |
in in |
Connecticut Connecticut |
It's It's |
hard hard |
not not |
to to |
draw draw |
the the |
inference inference |
that that |
the the |
two two |
different different |
jury jury |
pools pools |
are are |
somewhat somewhat |
politically politically |
motivated motivated |
The The |
compensatory compensatory |
damages damages |
in in |
the the |
Texas Texas |
verdict verdict |
was was |
$4 $4 |
million million |
The The |
compensatory compensatory |
damages damages |
in in |
the the |
Connecticut Connecticut |
verdict verdict |
is is |
$965 $965 |
million million |
That's That's |
a a |
$961 $961 |
million million |
difference difference |
in in |
compensatory compensatory |
damages damages |
We We |
still still |
have have |
to to |
see see |
punitive punitive |
damages damages |
in in |
Connecticut Connecticut |
so so |
that that |
the the |
difference difference |
could could |
be be |
even even |
far far |
more more |
striking striking |
I I |
think think |
it's it's |
safe safe |
to to |
say say |
that that |
the the |
Connecticut Connecticut |
verdict verdict |
is is |
a a |
more more |
liberal liberal |
jury jury |
pool pool |
and and |
that that |
had had |
to to |
have have |
factored factored |
into into |
their their |
verdict verdict |
We We |
should should |
also also |
point point |
out out |
we we |
learned learned |
later later |
today today |
that that |
Jones Jones |
lawyer lawyer |
has has |
said said |
they they |
do do |
plan plan |
to to |
appeal appeal |
but but |
Mr Mr |
Gessen Gessen |
we we |
should should |
remind remind |
folks folks |
Mr Mr |
Jones Jones |
was was |
spreading spreading |
these these |
lies lies |
for for |
years years |
saying saying |
that that |
the the |
whole whole |
attack attack |
was was |
a a |
hoax hoax |
that that |
in in |
some some |
cases cases |
parents parents |
were were |
responsible responsible |
for for |
the the |
deaths deaths |
of of |
their their |
own own |
children children |
He's He's |
not not |
alone alone |
in in |
spreading spreading |
some some |
of of |
these these |
lies lies |
though though |
and and |
I I |
wonder wonder |
as as |
you you |
look look |
at at |
this this |
moment moment |
what what |
you you |
think think |
this this |
verdict verdict |
says says |
in in |
the the |
way way |
of of |
a a |
message message |
it it |
sends sends |
about about |
the the |
legal legal |
landscape landscape |
surrounding surrounding |
holding holding |
those those |
who who |
spread spread |
misinformation misinformation |
accountable accountable |
in in |
some some |
way way |
Well Well |
if if |
your your |
profiting profiting |
off off |
of of |
conspiracy conspiracy |
theories theories |
that that |
are are |
the the |
famitory famitory |
that that |
are are |
obviously obviously |
false false |
you you |
need need |
to to |
watch watch |
yourself yourself |
and and |
a a |
litigant litigant |
can can |
prosper prosper |
clearly clearly |
prosper prosper |
in in |
two two |
very very |
separate separate |
forms forms |
and and |
I I |
think think |
that that |
it it |
sends sends |
a a |
strong strong |
message message |
to to |
people people |
that that |
are are |
making making |
money money |
on on |
lies lies |
and and |
especially especially |
given given |
that that |
this this |
isn't isn't |
the the |
end end |
we we |
have have |
the the |
premium premium |
damage damage |
is is |
verdict verdict |
and and |
then then |
we we |
also also |
have have |
a a |
third third |
Sandy Sandy |
Hook Hook |
lawsuit lawsuit |
So So |
I I |
think think |
that that |
it it |
sends sends |
a a |
strong strong |
message message |
to to |
people people |
who who |
are are |
in in |
the the |
business business |
of of |
peddling peddling |
conspiracies conspiracies |
That That |
is is |
Jesse Jesse |
Gessen Gessen |
a a |
trial trial |
attorney attorney |
in in |
California California |
joining joining |
us us |
tonight tonight |
Mr Mr |
Gessen Gessen |
thank thank |
you you |
for for |
having having |
me me |
Thank Thank |
you you |
for for |
having having |
me me |
Well Well |
relations relations |
between between |
the the |
White White |
House House |
and and |
Saudi Saudi |
Arabia's Arabia's |
ruling ruling |
royal royal |
family family |
are are |
at at |
a a |
low low |
point point |
and and |
may may |
be be |
set set |
to to |
dive dive |
even even |
lower lower |
from from |
President President |
Biden's Biden's |
fighting fighting |
words words |
on on |
the the |
campaign campaign |
trail trail |
to to |
recent recent |
Saudi-led Saudi-led |
cuts cuts |
in in |
global global |
oil oil |
supplies supplies |
the the |
status status |
of of |
the the |
more more |
than than |
75-year-old 75-year-old |
alliance alliance |
is is |
troubled troubled |
and and |
many many |
in in |
the the |
administration administration |
and and |
on on |
Capitol Capitol |
Hill Hill |
want want |
to to |
reset reset |
Nick Nick |
Schifrin Schifrin |
begins begins |
our our |
coverage coverage |
One One |
of of |
the the |
most most |
colorful colorful |
visits visits |
to to |
the the |
presidential presidential |
cruiser cruiser |
was was |
that that |
of of |
the the |
ruler ruler |
of of |
Saudi Saudi |
Arabia Arabia |
America's America's |
longest longest |
relationship relationship |
with with |
an an |
Arab Arab |
state state |
began began |
77 77 |
years years |
ago ago |
Four-time Four-time |
elected elected |
U.S U.S |
President President |
Franklin Franklin |
Roosevelt Roosevelt |
and and |
Ibn Ibn |
Saud Saud |
the the |
warrior warrior |
monarch monarch |
backed backed |
by by |
a a |
fanatical fanatical |
clergy clergy |
created created |
a a |
fundamental fundamental |
agreement agreement |
American American |
security security |
in in |
exchange exchange |
for for |
Saudi Saudi |
energy energy |
But But |
today today |
that that |
agreement agreement |
must must |
be be |
re-examined re-examined |
President President |
Biden Biden |
told told |
CNN's CNN's |
Jake Jake |
Tapper Tapper |
last last |
night night |
there's there's |
going going |
to to |
be be |
some some |
consequences consequences |
for for |
what what |
they've they've |
done done |
with with |
Russia Russia |
What What |
the the |
Saudis Saudis |
did did |
with with |
fellow fellow |
OPEC OPEC |
leader leader |
Russia Russia |
is is |
the the |
largest largest |
oil oil |
production production |
cut cut |
in in |
more more |
than than |
two two |
years years |
over over |
U.S U.S |
warnings warnings |
It It |
was was |
announced announced |
by by |
OPEC OPEC |
secretary-general secretary-general |
Haita Haita |
Malgeis Malgeis |
We We |
are are |
not not |
endangering endangering |
the the |
energy energy |
markets markets |
We We |
are are |
providing providing |
security security |
stability stability |
to to |
the the |
energy energy |
markets markets |
Out Out |
of of |
price price |
Everything Everything |
has has |
a a |
price price |
including including |
the the |
U.S U.S |
Saudi Saudi |
relationship relationship |
In In |
the the |
1970 1970 |
Saudi Saudi |
Arabia Arabia |
helped helped |
lead lead |
an an |
oil oil |
embargo embargo |
over over |
U.S U.S |
support support |
for for |
Israel Israel |
New New |
York York |
declared declared |
a a |
G.R G.R |
against against |
the the |
United United |
States States |
Can Can |
you you |
tell tell |
us us |
why why |
The The |
kingdom kingdom |
claims claims |
it it |
fights fights |
the the |
fires fires |
of of |
radicalism radicalism |
but but |
critics critics |
call call |
it it |
the the |
arsonist arsonist |
The The |
Saudi Saudi |
Osama Osama |
bin bin |
Laden Laden |
sparked sparked |
global global |
attacks attacks |
against against |
the the |
West West |
and and |
its its |
Arab Arab |
allies allies |
15 15 |
of of |
9-11 9-11 |
hijackers hijackers |
were were |
Saudi Saudi |
And And |
decades decades |
of of |
criticism criticism |
of of |
Saudi Saudi |
Arabia's Arabia's |
poor poor |
human human |
rights rights |
record record |
crescendoed crescendoed |
in in |
2018 2018 |
after after |
journalist journalist |
Jamal Jamal |
Khashoggi Khashoggi |
walked walked |
into into |
the the |
Saudi Saudi |
Istanbul's Istanbul's |
consulate consulate |
was was |
murdered murdered |
and and |
cut cut |
into into |
pieces pieces |
The The |
U.S U.S |
intelligence intelligence |
community community |
assessed assessed |
the the |
operation operation |
was was |
approved approved |
by by |
the the |
kingdom's kingdom's |
powerful powerful |
crown crown |
prince prince |
of of |
the the |
future future |
king king |
Mohammed Mohammed |
bin bin |
Salman Salman |
The The |
following following |
year year |
candidate candidate |
Joe Joe |
Biden Biden |
promised promised |
punishment punishment |
We We |
were were |
going going |
to to |
make make |
them them |
pay pay |
the the |
price price |
and and |
make make |
them them |
in in |
fact fact |
the the |
pariah pariah |
that that |
they they |
are are |
But But |
that that |
proved proved |
to to |
be be |
a a |
speed speed |
bump bump |
that that |
preceded preceded |
this this |
year's year's |
fist fist |
bump bump |
President President |
Biden Biden |
and and |
his his |
team team |
worked worked |
with with |
MBS MBS |
In In |
acknowledgment acknowledgment |
the the |
kingdom kingdom |
has has |
helped helped |
the the |
U.S U.S |
for for |
decades decades |
across across |
continents continents |
In In |
the the |
late late |
70s 70s |
Saudi Saudi |
Arabia Arabia |
provided provided |
crucial crucial |
support support |
for for |
the the |
Afghan Afghan |
Mujahideen Mujahideen |
to to |
defeat defeat |
the the |
Soviet Soviet |
military military |
and and |
help help |
collapse collapse |
the the |
Soviet Soviet |
Union Union |
In In |
the the |
early early |
90s 90s |
Saudi Saudi |
Arabia Arabia |
invited invited |
the the |
largest largest |
U.S U.S |
overseas overseas |
deployment deployment |
in in |
decades decades |
U.S U.S |
troops troops |
used used |
the the |
kingdom kingdom |
as as |
a a |
base base |
to to |
fight fight |
the the |
Gulf Gulf |
War War |
After After |
9-11 9-11 |
the the |
Bush Bush |
administration administration |
held held |
onto onto |
the the |
alliance alliance |
to to |
cooperate cooperate |
on on |
terrorism terrorism |
and and |
target target |
al-Qaeda al-Qaeda |
And And |
in in |
2017 2017 |
President President |
Trump Trump |
made made |
Saudi Saudi |
Arabia Arabia |
his his |
first first |
overseas overseas |
stop stop |
Saudi Saudi |
Arabia Arabia |
and and |
its its |
allies allies |
helped helped |
shift shift |
U.S U.S |
regional regional |
policy policy |
And And |
Riyadh Riyadh |
Washington Washington |
Cooperation Cooperation |
helped helped |
lead lead |
to to |
this this |
historic historic |
2020 2020 |
normalization normalization |
agreement agreement |
between between |
Israel Israel |
Bahrain Bahrain |
and and |
the the |
UAE UAE |
Today Today |
the the |
Biden Biden |
administration administration |
is is |
releasing releasing |
our our |
national national |
security security |
strategy strategy |
Today Today |
the the |
U.S U.S |
acknowledges acknowledges |
its its |
well-aware well-aware |
that that |
the the |
relationship relationship |
provides provides |
benefits benefits |
But But |
the the |
administration administration |
will will |
review review |
the the |
relationship relationship |
and and |
consult consult |
lawmakers lawmakers |
including including |
Democrats Democrats |
today today |
called called |
for for |
a a |
one-year one-year |
block block |
on on |
weapons weapons |
sales sales |
Saudi Saudi |
Arabia Arabia |
has has |
broken broken |
trust trust |
with with |
America America |
And And |
it it |
needs needs |
to to |
come come |
to to |
its its |
senses senses |
The The |
U.S U.S |
Saudi Saudi |
relationship relationship |
has has |
survived survived |
previous previous |
challenges challenges |
The The |
administration administration |
says says |
there's there's |
no no |
timetable timetable |
for for |
its its |
review review |
For For |
the the |
previous previous |
news news |
hour hour |
I'm I'm |
Nick Nick |
Schifrin Schifrin |
Representative Representative |
Rokana Rokana |
of of |
California California |
is is |
a a |
member member |
of of |
the the |
House House |
Armed Armed |
Services Services |
Committee Committee |
and and |
is is |
spearheading spearheading |
the the |
House House |
version version |
of of |
that that |
bill bill |
and and |
U.S U.S |
arms arms |
sales sales |
to to |
Saudi Saudi |
Arabia Arabia |
for for |
one one |
year year |
He He |
joins joins |
me me |
now now |
Congressman Congressman |
welcome welcome |
back back |
to to |
the the |
news news |
hour hour |
Thank Thank |
you you |
for for |
joining joining |
us us |
You You |
have have |
said said |
the the |
U.S U.S |
needs needs |
to to |
immediately immediately |
immediately immediately |
halt halt |
those those |
arms arms |
sales sales |
We We |
should should |
note note |
this this |
has has |
been been |
proposed proposed |
before before |
In In |
many many |
times times |
by by |
many many |
other other |
people people |
it it |
has has |
never never |
moved moved |
forward forward |
Why Why |
do do |
you you |
think think |
that that |
this this |
moment moment |
is is |
different different |
This This |
is is |
a a |
defining defining |
moment moment |
just just |
like like |
the the |
more-cross more-cross |
resolution resolution |
that that |
stopped stopped |
the the |
refueling refueling |
of of |
the the |
Saudi Saudi |
Plains Plains |
that that |
Senator Senator |
Sanders Sanders |
and and |
I I |
led led |
past past |
after after |
Khashoggi's Khashoggi's |
murder murder |
This This |
is is |
another another |
moment moment |
that that |
has has |
really really |
outraged outraged |
people people |
on on |
both both |
sides sides |
of of |
the the |
aisle aisle |
on on |
Capitol Capitol |
Hill Hill |
It's It's |
Saudi Saudi |
Arabia's Arabia's |
in in |
gratitude gratitude |
We We |
provide provide |
them them |
with with |
70-some 70-some |
percent percent |
of of |
their their |
arms arms |
We We |
stood stood |
up up |
for for |
them them |
when when |
Saddam Saddam |
Hussein Hussein |
was was |
going going |
to to |
invade invade |
after after |
Saddam Saddam |
had had |
invaded invaded |
Kuwait Kuwait |
And And |
Saudi Saudi |
Plains Plains |
literally literally |
couldn't couldn't |
fly fly |
if if |
it it |
weren't weren't |
for for |
American American |
technicians technicians |
yet yet |
they they |
are are |
fleecing fleecing |
the the |
American American |
public public |
but but |
making making |
about about |
$100 $100 |
billion billion |
in in |
2022 2022 |
there there |
need need |
to to |
be be |
consequences consequences |
We We |
provide provide |
them them |
with with |
all all |
those those |
things things |
you you |
just just |
listed listed |
but but |
also also |
they they |
provide provide |
us us |
with with |
crucial crucial |
intelligence intelligence |
counter-terrorism counter-terrorism |
intelligence intelligence |
specifically specifically |
the the |
U.S U.S |
relies relies |
on on |
for for |
national national |
security security |
purposes purposes |
could could |
imposing imposing |
consequences consequences |
in in |
whatever whatever |
form form |
compromise compromise |
U.S U.S |
national national |
security security |
No No |
it it |
will will |
not not |
They They |
are are |
far far |
more more |
reliant reliant |
on on |
us us |
In In |
fact fact |
the the |
defense defense |
agreements agreements |
and and |
the the |
joint joint |
defense defense |
initiatives initiatives |
are are |
more more |
extensive extensive |
than than |
almost almost |
any any |
other other |
major major |
ally ally |
And And |
that's that's |
all all |
the the |
Saudis Saudis |
benefit benefit |
The The |
production production |
is is |
there there |
The The |
jobs jobs |
are are |
there there |
So So |
they they |
are are |
far far |
more more |
dependent dependent |
on on |
us us |
And And |
they they |
already already |
are are |
making making |
these these |
drastic drastic |
cuts cuts |
and and |
they're they're |
making making |
drastic drastic |
cuts cuts |
at at |
a a |
time time |
when when |
they're they're |
making making |
70 70 |
percent percent |
profit profit |
margins margins |
on on |
each each |
barrel barrel |
of of |
oil oil |
Why Why |
are are |
they they |
doing doing |
it it |
They're They're |
doing doing |
it it |
to to |
help help |
Putin Putin |
because because |
Putin Putin |
doesn't doesn't |
have have |
those those |
profit profit |
margins margins |
He's He's |
selling selling |
his his |
oil oil |
at at |
a a |
discount discount |
of of |
$35 $35 |
A A |
barrel barrel |
to to |
China China |
and and |
other other |
countries countries |
So So |
to to |
appease appease |
Putin Putin |
they're they're |
hurting hurting |
the the |
American American |
consumer consumer |
at at |
the the |
pump pump |
and and |
that's that's |
just just |
won't won't |
stand stand |
And And |
we we |
have have |
far far |
more more |
leverage leverage |
over over |
them them |
than than |
they they |
do do |
over over |
us us |
We We |
are are |
assuming assuming |
also also |
that that |
leverage leverage |
would would |
force force |
them them |
to to |
move move |
away away |
from from |
Russia Russia |
but but |
it it |
is is |
a a |
gamble gamble |
What What |
if if |
it it |
backfires backfires |
What What |
if if |
they they |
further further |
cut cut |
oil oil |
production production |
What What |
if if |
they they |
just just |
end end |
up up |
moving moving |
further further |
towards towards |
Russia Russia |
and and |
China China |
Well Well |
they they |
cannot cannot |
move move |
further further |
towards towards |
Russia Russia |
and and |
China China |
in in |
the the |
near near |
term term |
They They |
would would |
take take |
almost almost |
10 10 |
years years |
for for |
them them |
to to |
be be |
able able |
to to |
get get |
the the |
weapons weapons |
that that |
we we |
provide provide |
just just |
because because |
of of |
interoperability interoperability |
of of |
these these |
weapons weapons |
And And |
literally literally |
the the |
Air Air |
Force Force |
would would |
be be |
grounded grounded |
to to |
a a |
halt halt |
tomorrow tomorrow |
if if |
they they |
didn't didn't |
have have |
American American |
technicians technicians |
And And |
now now |
maybe maybe |
it it |
would would |
take take |
years years |
for for |
them them |
to to |
build build |
with with |
Russia Russia |
and and |
China China |
but but |
they they |
simply simply |
could could |
not not |
do do |
that that |
In In |
terms terms |
of of |
cuts cuts |
they've they've |
cut cut |
already already |
so so |
far far |
I I |
don't don't |
think think |
further further |
cuts cuts |
would would |
be be |
possible possible |
We're We're |
talking talking |
about about |
a a |
million million |
barrels barrels |
of of |
cut cut |
They've They've |
cut cut |
two two |
million million |
barrels barrels |
and and |
other other |
countries countries |
in in |
OPEC OPEC |
the the |
UAE's UAE's |
Kuwait Kuwait |
would would |
make make |
up up |
for for |
it it |
if if |
they they |
went went |
for for |
further further |
cuts cuts |
So So |
they they |
already already |
have have |
taken taken |
the the |
most most |
drastic drastic |
action action |
What What |
about about |
Iran Iran |
and and |
all all |
this this |
representative representative |
Kana Kana |
I I |
mean mean |
none none |
of of |
this this |
unfolds unfolds |
in in |
a a |
vacuum vacuum |
The The |
U.S U.S |
foreign foreign |
policy policy |
in in |
the the |
region region |
is is |
structured structured |
largely largely |
around around |
Saudi Saudi |
Arabia Arabia |
Just Just |
this this |
summer summer |
the the |
U.S U.S |
approved approved |
two two |
new new |
massive massive |
arms arms |
deals deals |
for for |
Saudi Saudi |
Arabia Arabia |
and and |
the the |
United United |
Arab Arab |
Emirates Emirates |
specifically specifically |
to to |
help help |
them them |
defend defend |
against against |
Iran Iran |
Does Does |
cutting cutting |
Saudi Saudi |
arms arms |
sales sales |
empower empower |
Iran Iran |
No No |
it it |
doesn't doesn't |
And And |
I I |
was was |
opposed opposed |
to to |
those those |
arms arms |
sales sales |
Let's Let's |
not not |
forget forget |
that that |
the the |
Saudis Saudis |
are are |
responsible responsible |
for for |
one one |
of of |
the the |
biggest biggest |
humanitarian humanitarian |
crisis crisis |
in in |
the the |
world world |
in in |
Yemen Yemen |
It It |
is is |
appalling appalling |
what what |
they've they've |
done done |
to to |
the the |
children children |
there there |
It's It's |
appalling appalling |
of of |
the the |
starvation starvation |
they've they've |
caused caused |
It's It's |
appalling appalling |
that that |
they're they're |
continuing continuing |
to to |
blockade blockade |
Now Now |
the the |
Houthis Houthis |
are are |
also also |
to to |
blame blame |
and and |
the the |
Iranians Iranians |
are are |
to to |
blame blame |
in in |
Yemen Yemen |
as as |
well well |
but but |
the the |
Saudis Saudis |
have have |
been been |
the the |
principal principal |
and and |
perpetrators perpetrators |
of of |
that that |
war war |
And And |
so so |
I I |
don't don't |
think think |
that that |
the the |
balance balance |
cutting cutting |
off off |
these these |
arms arms |
sales sales |
are are |
suddenly suddenly |
going going |
to to |
make make |
them them |
vulnerable vulnerable |
to to |
Iran Iran |
And And |
I've I've |
spoken spoken |
out out |
very very |
strongly strongly |
for for |
the the |
students students |
for for |
the the |
women women |
protesting protesting |
in in |
Iran Iran |
I I |
believe believe |
there there |
are are |
other other |
ways ways |
that that |
we we |
can can |
contain contain |
Iran Iran |
but but |
we we |
should should |
not not |
use use |
a a |
Kissingerian Kissingerian |
balance balance |
of of |
power power |
where where |
we we |
end end |
up up |
supporting supporting |
brutal brutal |
dictators dictators |
at at |
the the |
expense expense |
of of |
our our |
own own |
public public |
because because |
of of |
some some |
balance balance |
of of |
power power |
politics politics |
in in |
the the |
Middle Middle |
East East |
What What |
do do |
you you |
believe believe |
the the |
President President |
Biden Biden |
could could |
have have |
done done |
differently differently |
in in |
this this |
moment moment |
I I |
mean mean |
he he |
went went |
from from |
calling calling |
Saudi Saudi |
Arabia Arabia |
a a |
pariah pariah |
to to |
visiting visiting |
Crown Crown |
Prince Prince |
Mohammed Mohammed |
bin bin |
Salman Salman |
in in |
July July |
at at |
the the |
fist fist |
bump bump |
scene scene |
around around |
the the |
world world |
Do Do |
you you |
think think |
there's there's |
anything anything |
that that |
the the |
President President |
or or |
this this |
administration administration |
could could |
have have |
done done |
differently differently |
to to |
avoid avoid |
this this |
moment moment |
Yes Yes |
I I |
don't don't |
think think |
he he |
should should |
have have |
gone gone |
to to |
Saudi Saudi |
Arabia Arabia |
Senator Senator |
Sanders Sanders |
and and |
I I |
took took |
to to |
the the |
papers papers |
to to |
say say |
that that |
there there |
was was |
trip trip |
was was |
misguided misguided |
I I |
believe believe |
he he |
should should |
have have |
been been |
clearer clearer |
with with |
the the |
Saudis Saudis |
that that |
there there |
would would |
be be |
very very |
drastic drastic |
consequences consequences |
both both |
if if |
they they |
didn't didn't |
lift lift |
the the |
blockade blockade |
which which |
they they |
still still |
haven't haven't |
in in |
Yemen Yemen |
And And |
now now |
they're they're |
talking talking |
about about |
actually actually |
not not |
following following |
through through |
on on |
the the |
truce truce |
in in |
Yemen Yemen |
but but |
certainly certainly |
extraordinarily extraordinarily |
drastic drastic |
consequences consequences |
if if |
they they |
cut cut |
oil oil |
production production |
So So |
I I |
believe believe |
that that |
he he |
could could |
have have |
been been |
clearer clearer |
on on |
all all |
of of |
those those |
things things |
Now Now |
I'm I'm |
glad glad |
that that |
he's he's |
contemplating contemplating |
action action |
now now |
And And |
my my |
belief belief |
is is |
if if |
we we |
are are |
tough tough |
enough enough |
they they |
will will |
reverse reverse |
the the |
decision decision |
You You |
said said |
he's he's |
contemplating contemplating |
action action |
We've We've |
heard heard |
the the |
work work |
but but |
no no |
specifics specifics |
In In |
your your |
talks talks |
with with |
the the |
administration administration |
how how |
serious serious |
are are |
they they |
in in |
imposing imposing |
serious serious |
and and |
immediate immediate |
consequences consequences |
They They |
have have |
told told |
me me |
that that |
the the |
President President |
is is |
going going |
to to |
take take |
action action |
that that |
the the |
President President |
is is |
re-examining re-examining |
this this |
Saudi Saudi |
relationship relationship |
and and |
that that |
the the |
action action |
is is |
imminent imminent |
And And |
so so |
I I |
believe believe |
the the |
President President |
has has |
to to |
act act |
How How |
can can |
you you |
allow allow |
a a |
country country |
that that |
is is |
a a |
quote quote |
unquote unquote |
ally ally |
to to |
continue continue |
to to |
profit profit |
of of |
the the |
American American |
public public |
and and |
make make |
drastic drastic |
cuts cuts |
when when |
we're we're |
going going |
through through |
one one |
of of |
the the |
bigger bigger |
energy energy |
crisis crisis |
we we |
have have |
in in |
recent recent |
decades decades |
Allies Allies |
don't don't |
treat treat |
each each |
other other |
that that |
way way |
More More |
broadly broadly |
US US |
officials officials |
did did |
report report |
of of |
the the |
war war |
in in |
Saudi Saudi |
leaders leaders |
That That |
a a |
cut cut |
in in |
production production |
would would |
be be |
seen seen |
as as |
a a |
clear clear |
choice choice |
they're they're |
siding siding |
with with |
Russia Russia |
and and |
the the |
Saudis Saudis |
did did |
it it |
anyway anyway |
What What |
does does |
that that |
say say |
to to |
you you |
about about |
how how |
they they |
view view |
the the |
US US |
right right |
now now |
Well Well |
they they |
don't don't |
think think |
that that |
they're they're |
going going |
to to |
be be |
consequences consequences |
but but |
I I |
believe believe |
they they |
should should |
take take |
a a |
temperature temperature |
one one |
of of |
many many |
of of |
the the |
younger younger |
members members |
of of |
Congress Congress |
who who |
aren't aren't |
steeped steeped |
in in |
the the |
same same |
traditional traditional |
relationship relationship |
with with |
Saudi Saudi |
who who |
basically basically |
know know |
Saudi Saudi |
Arabia Arabia |
through through |
the the |
prism prism |
of of |
the the |
Yemen Yemen |
War War |
and and |
the the |
humanitarian humanitarian |
crisis crisis |
that that |
they they |
have have |
caused caused |
They They |
should should |
remember remember |
that that |
the the |
War War |
Powers Powers |
Resolution Resolution |
stopping stopping |
our our |
aid aid |
past past |
the the |
House House |
and and |
the the |
Senate Senate |
the the |
only only |
time time |
of of |
War War |
Powers Powers |
Resolution Resolution |
has has |
ever ever |
passed passed |
And And |
they they |
should should |
know know |
that that |
now now |
they're they're |
going going |
to to |
be be |
consequences consequences |
You You |
have have |
not not |
just just |
Senator Senator |
Blumenthal Blumenthal |
and and |
I I |
call call |
it it |
for for |
it it |
but but |
Senator Senator |
Menendez Menendez |
a a |
very very |
respected respected |
foreign foreign |
policy policy |
voice voice |
who who |
chairs chairs |
the the |
Senate Senate |
Foreign Foreign |
Relations Relations |
Committee Committee |
calling calling |
for for |
it it |
So So |
they they |
are are |
really really |
hurting hurting |
their their |
relationship relationship |
on on |
the the |
Hill Hill |
Briefly Briefly |
if if |
you you |
can can |
represent represent |
it it |
if if |
the the |
Saudis Saudis |
have have |
said said |
this this |
was was |
economic economic |
their their |
decision decision |
to to |
cut cut |
oil oil |
production production |
Do Do |
you you |
believe believe |
that that |
anything anything |
to to |
do do |
with with |
the the |
timing timing |
of of |
the the |
upcoming upcoming |
midterm midterm |
elections elections |
I I |
don't don't |
know know |
but but |
I I |
know know |
it's it's |
not not |
economic economic |
when when |
they're they're |
baking baking |
over over |
70% 70% |
profits profits |
on on |
your your |
barrels barrels |
of of |
oil oil |
Look Look |
I've I've |
been been |
critical critical |
effects effects |
on on |
in in |
Chevron Chevron |
but but |
it it |
pales pales |
into into |
the the |
comparison comparison |
into into |
what what |
the the |
Saudis Saudis |
are are |
making making |
on on |
oil oil |
So So |
what what |
I I |
do do |
know know |
is is |
that that |
they they |
have have |
chosen chosen |
deliberately deliberately |
to to |
hurt hurt |
Americans Americans |
at at |
the the |
pump pump |
Look Look |
I I |
don't don't |
think think |
the the |
timing timing |
is is |
coincidental coincidental |
but but |
I I |
have have |
no no |
evidence evidence |
of of |
why why |
they've they've |
taken taken |
that that |
decision decision |
All All |
I I |
know know |
is is |
that that |
they're they're |
hurting hurting |
the the |
American American |
public public |
That That |
is is |
representative representative |
Roe Roe |
Connell Connell |
Democrat Democrat |
from from |
California California |
a a |
member member |
of of |
the the |
House House |
Armed Armed |
Services Services |
Committee Committee |
Thank Thank |
you you |
so so |
much much |
for for |
your your |
time time |
Thank Thank |
you you |
President President |
Biden's Biden's |
executive executive |
order order |
to to |
cancel cancel |
student student |
debt debt |
is is |
facing facing |
its its |
most most |
serious serious |
legal legal |
challenge challenge |
to to |
date date |
A A |
federal federal |
judge judge |
in in |
Missouri Missouri |
heard heard |
arguments arguments |
today today |
from from |
six six |
states states |
hoping hoping |
to to |
block block |
the the |
plan plan |
from from |
taking taking |
effect effect |
to to |
qualify qualify |
for for |
the the |
student student |
loan loan |
program program |
Individuals Individuals |
must must |
make make |
less less |
than than |
$125,000 $125,000 |
a a |
year year |
or or |
$250,000 $250,000 |
for for |
married married |
couples couples |
and and |
families families |
Eligible Eligible |
borrowers borrowers |
can can |
receive receive |
up up |
to to |
$10,000 $10,000 |
in in |
forgiveness forgiveness |
or or |
up up |
to to |
$20,000 $20,000 |
if if |
they they |
are are |
Pell Pell |
Grant Grant |
recipients recipients |
White White |
House House |
correspondent correspondent |
Laura Laura |
Barone Barone |
Lopez Lopez |
has has |
been been |
following following |
it it |
all all |
and and |
she she |
joins joins |
me me |
now now |
as as |
part part |
of of |
our our |
series series |
rethinking rethinking |
college college |
Laura Laura |
good good |
to to |
see see |
you you |
Good Good |
to to |
see see |
you you |
So So |
let's let's |
talk talk |
about about |
this this |
case case |
that that |
was was |
heard heard |
today today |
in in |
Missouri Missouri |
What What |
exactly exactly |
are are |
the the |
states states |
arguing arguing |
So So |
there there |
are are |
six six |
Republican Republican |
states states |
including including |
Nebraska Nebraska |
Missouri Missouri |
Arkansas Arkansas |
and and |
they're they're |
arguing arguing |
that that |
the the |
administration's administration's |
debt debt |
relief relief |
program program |
is is |
illegal illegal |
on on |
three three |
fronts fronts |
Those Those |
three three |
fronts fronts |
are are |
that that |
the the |
administration administration |
lacks lacks |
authority authority |
that that |
they they |
did did |
not not |
follow follow |
administrative administrative |
procedure procedure |
and and |
that that |
it it |
harms harms |
state state |
revenue revenue |
So So |
today today |
we we |
spoke spoke |
to to |
Arkansas Arkansas |
Attorney Attorney |
General General |
Leslie Leslie |
Rutledge Rutledge |
and and |
she she |
really really |
focused focused |
on on |
whether whether |
or or |
not not |
the the |
president president |
has has |
authority authority |
to to |
do do |
this this |
and and |
took took |
direct direct |
aim aim |
at at |
him him |
The The |
president president |
did did |
not not |
have have |
the the |
authority authority |
to to |
make make |
this this |
decision decision |
He He |
made made |
this this |
decision decision |
and and |
based based |
it it |
on on |
the the |
Heroes Heroes |
Act Act |
which which |
essentially essentially |
was was |
put put |
in in |
place place |
during during |
the the |
Iraq Iraq |
War War |
in in |
order order |
to to |
give give |
relief relief |
to to |
our our |
brave brave |
men men |
and and |
women women |
in in |
uniform uniform |
And And |
it it |
was was |
also also |
as as |
part part |
of of |
it it |
It It |
could could |
be be |
used used |
during during |
a a |
national national |
emergency emergency |
Unfortunately Unfortunately |
President President |
Biden Biden |
forgot forgot |
that that |
he he |
declared declared |
the the |
pandemic pandemic |
over over |
a a |
few few |
short short |
weeks weeks |
ago ago |
As As |
you you |
heard heard |
Attorney Attorney |
General General |
Rutledge Rutledge |
there there |
saying saying |
that that |
she she |
thinks thinks |
the the |
president president |
doesn't doesn't |
have have |
this this |
authority authority |
but but |
what what |
was was |
interesting interesting |
in in |
the the |
arguments arguments |
today today |
was was |
that that |
the the |
Missouri Missouri |
judge judge |
Henry Henry |
Autry Autry |
essentially essentially |
really really |
scrutinized scrutinized |
that that |
saying saying |
why why |
is is |
the the |
president president |
being being |
sued sued |
as as |
a a |
part part |
of of |
this this |
lawsuit lawsuit |
and and |
questioning questioning |
whether whether |
or or |
not not |
the the |
Republican Republican |
states states |
had had |
standing standing |
against against |
the the |
president president |
versus versus |
standing standing |
against against |
the the |
Education Education |
Department Department |
and and |
the the |
Education Education |
Secretary Secretary |
So So |
a a |
main main |
part part |
of of |
their their |
argument argument |
is is |
the the |
administration administration |
doesn't doesn't |
even even |
have have |
the the |
authority authority |
to to |
do do |
this this |
What What |
has has |
the the |
Biden Biden |
administration administration |
been been |
saying saying |
about about |
this this |
The The |
Biden Biden |
administration administration |
is is |
essentially essentially |
saying saying |
that that |
they they |
were were |
granted granted |
this this |
authority authority |
under under |
a a |
2003 2003 |
higher higher |
education education |
law law |
also also |
known known |
as as |
the the |
Heroes Heroes |
Act Act |
And And |
so so |
today today |
Deputy Deputy |
Assistant Assistant |
Attorney Attorney |
General General |
Brian Brian |
Netter Netter |
argued argued |
that that |
the the |
pandemic pandemic |
gives gives |
them them |
this this |
authority authority |
It's It's |
crucial crucial |
here here |
that that |
this this |
is is |
a a |
statute statute |
about about |
emergencies emergencies |
It's It's |
a a |
statute statute |
about about |
national national |
emergencies emergencies |
and and |
it it |
seems seems |
hard hard |
to to |
fathom fathom |
that that |
Congress Congress |
wouldn't wouldn't |
have have |
understood understood |
at at |
the the |
time time |
that that |
a a |
larger larger |
national national |
emergency emergency |
is is |
going going |
to to |
prompt prompt |
and and |
necessitate necessitate |
a a |
larger larger |
action action |
by by |
the the |
Secretary Secretary |
of of |
Education Education |
And And |
so so |
essentially essentially |
Netter Netter |
there there |
is is |
saying saying |
that that |
as as |
the the |
economic economic |
hardships hardships |
were were |
growing growing |
due due |
to to |
the the |
COVID COVID |
pandemic pandemic |
so so |
does does |
the the |
power power |
of of |
the the |
Education Education |
Secretary Secretary |
Miguel Miguel |
Cardona Cardona |
those those |
powers powers |
grow grow |
as as |
well well |
They They |
grow grow |
with with |
it it |
And And |
he he |
specifically specifically |
argued argued |
against against |
this this |
front front |
that that |
the the |
states states |
were were |
bringing bringing |
forward forward |
saying saying |
that that |
these these |
national national |
emergency emergency |
statutes statutes |
only only |
applies applies |
to to |
specific specific |
military military |
activity activity |
It It |
applies applies |
to to |
military military |
members members |
service service |
members members |
And And |
Netter Netter |
said said |
no no |
historically historically |
that's that's |
not not |
the the |
case case |
under under |
this this |
law law |
That That |
look look |
when when |
you you |
think think |
about about |
a a |
hurricane hurricane |
government government |
doesn't doesn't |
provide provide |
relief relief |
just just |
when when |
the the |
hurricane hurricane |
is is |
spinning spinning |
He He |
said said |
that that |
after after |
a a |
national national |
emergency emergency |
happens happens |
or or |
a a |
national national |
disaster disaster |
like like |
that that |
that that |
the the |
government government |
has has |
to to |
help help |
people people |
come come |
out out |
of of |
that that |
come come |
out out |
of of |
the the |
economic economic |
hardships hardships |
or or |
the the |
infrastructure infrastructure |
hardships hardships |
that that |
are are |
brought brought |
upon upon |
by by |
national national |
emergencies emergencies |
Laura Laura |
what what |
about about |
the the |
whole whole |
racial racial |
equity equity |
part part |
of of |
this this |
We We |
heard heard |
the the |
Biden Biden |
administration administration |
message message |
that that |
as as |
an an |
underpinning underpinning |
to to |
why why |
they they |
were were |
rolling rolling |
out out |
this this |
loan loan |
forgiveness forgiveness |
plan plan |
they they |
said said |
it it |
was was |
especially especially |
helped helped |
black black |
borrowers borrowers |
How How |
does does |
that that |
factor factor |
into into |
their their |
argument argument |
So So |
the the |
states states |
today today |
were were |
saying saying |
this this |
is is |
only only |
going going |
to to |
provide provide |
relief relief |
to to |
wealthy wealthy |
individuals individuals |
to to |
hire hire |
income income |
individuals individuals |
and and |
what what |
the the |
administration administration |
essentially essentially |
is is |
saying saying |
back back |
is is |
that that |
well well |
you you |
have have |
to to |
look look |
at at |
actually actually |
who who |
the the |
borrowers borrowers |
are are |
for for |
these these |
loan loan |
programs programs |
And And |
for for |
the the |
loan loan |
forgiveness forgiveness |
program program |
it it |
would would |
significantly significantly |
impact impact |
black black |
borrowers borrowers |
Specifically Specifically |
the the |
average average |
debt debt |
for for |
black black |
borrowers borrowers |
is is |
10,000 10,000 |
more more |
than than |
for for |
white white |
borrowers borrowers |
Also Also |
Pell Pell |
Grant Grant |
recipients recipients |
are are |
twice twice |
as as |
likely likely |
to to |
be be |
black black |
Now Now |
another another |
big big |
piece piece |
of of |
this this |
is is |
the the |
federal federal |
family family |
education education |
loan loan |
borrowers borrowers |
which which |
was was |
at at |
first first |
a a |
part part |
of of |
the the |
announcement announcement |
when when |
the the |
administration administration |
said said |
they they |
were were |
going going |
to to |
provide provide |
this this |
big big |
cancellation cancellation |
of of |
debt debt |
Then Then |
they they |
ended ended |
up up |
taking taking |
that that |
out out |
of of |
the the |
guidance guidance |
saying saying |
that that |
these these |
borrowers borrowers |
would would |
not not |
be be |
given given |
this this |
relief relief |
And And |
that that |
was was |
a a |
big big |
piece piece |
of of |
this this |
lawsuit lawsuit |
because because |
essentially essentially |
the the |
states states |
are are |
arguing arguing |
that that |
they they |
get get |
state state |
revenues revenues |
from from |
the the |
companies companies |
that that |
take take |
on on |
those those |
loans loans |
from from |
those those |
borrowers borrowers |
But But |
the the |
government government |
is is |
saying saying |
that that |
ultimately ultimately |
the the |
relief relief |
provided provided |
to to |
these these |
borrowers borrowers |
is is |
far far |
outweighs outweighs |
the the |
state state |
revenue revenue |
that that |
would would |
ultimately ultimately |
be be |
lost lost |
Now Now |
again again |
on on |
the the |
F-E-L F-E-L |
borrowers borrowers |
the the |
federal federal |
family family |
loan loan |
borrowers borrowers |
the the |
administration administration |
has has |
tried tried |
to to |
make make |
clear clear |
that that |
while while |
they they |
may may |
not not |
receive receive |
relief relief |
now now |
that that |
ultimately ultimately |
the the |
education education |
department department |
is is |
trying trying |
to to |
find find |
an an |
alternative alternative |
pathway pathway |
for for |
them them |
Before Before |
anyone anyone |
can can |
get get |
any any |
relief relief |
they they |
have have |
to to |
fill fill |
out out |
an an |
application application |
We've We've |
been been |
anticipating anticipating |
the the |
release release |
of of |
that that |
application application |
formed formed |
from from |
the the |
White White |
House House |
What What |
do do |
we we |
know know |
about about |
that that |
So So |
they they |
just just |
issued issued |
a a |
preview preview |
of of |
this this |
application application |
formed formed |
this this |
week week |
the the |
White White |
House House |
did did |
and and |
essentially essentially |
what what |
borrowers borrowers |
have have |
to to |
do do |
they they |
have have |
to to |
give give |
social social |
security security |
numbers numbers |
their their |
date date |
of of |
birth birth |
their their |
email email |
but but |
they they |
also also |
have have |
to to |
click click |
this this |
box box |
that that |
certifies certifies |
under under |
penalty penalty |
of of |
perjury perjury |
that that |
they they |
meet meet |
the the |
income income |
thresholds thresholds |
Now Now |
some some |
of of |
those those |
borrowers borrowers |
will will |
be be |
provided provided |
just just |
based based |
on on |
that that |
certification certification |
will will |
be be |
provided provided |
relief relief |
Others Others |
are are |
going going |
to to |
have have |
to to |
show show |
more more |
proof proof |
that that |
they they |
meet meet |
those those |
income income |
thresholds thresholds |
that that |
you you |
outlined outlined |
earlier earlier |
Now Now |
I I |
spoke spoke |
to to |
White White |
House's House's |
assistant assistant |
press press |
secretary secretary |
Abdullah Abdullah |
Hassan Hassan |
and and |
he he |
said said |
that that |
essentially essentially |
as as |
the the |
lawsuit lawsuit |
is is |
proceeding proceeding |
as as |
the the |
lawsuits lawsuits |
are are |
proceeding proceeding |
because because |
there's there's |
more more |
than than |
just just |
the the |
one one |
we we |
talked talked |
about about |
today today |
that that |
the the |
White White |
House House |
is is |
going going |
to to |
still still |
move move |
forward forward |
with with |
implementing implementing |
this this |
plan plan |
Now Now |
no no |
relief relief |
is is |
going going |
to to |
be be |
felt felt |
prior prior |
to to |
October October |
23rd 23rd |
but but |
the the |
application application |
process process |
is is |
going going |
to to |
be be |
rolled rolled |
out out |
this this |
month month |
So So |
folks folks |
can can |
check check |
that that |
out out |
and and |
start start |
to to |
apply apply |
if if |
they they |
are are |
eligible eligible |
White White |
House House |
correspondent correspondent |
Laura Laura |
Barone Barone |
Lopez Lopez |
following following |
it it |
all all |
Thank Thank |
you you |
so so |
much much |
Thank Thank |
you you |
Election Election |
night night |
is is |
less less |
than than |
a a |
month month |
away away |
and and |
we're we're |
digging digging |
into into |
some some |
key key |
races races |
that that |
could could |
determine determine |
the the |
balance balance |
of of |
power power |
in in |
Congress Congress |
Lisa Lisa |
Desjardins Desjardins |
has has |
more more |
Let's Let's |
talk talk |
about about |
control control |
of of |
the the |
House House |
of of |
Representatives Representatives |
To To |
take take |
over over |
the the |
House House |
Republicans Republicans |
need need |
to to |
gain gain |
just just |
five five |
total total |
seats seats |
next next |
month month |
net net |
Their Their |
party party |
may may |
have have |
a a |
slight slight |
advantage advantage |
from from |
redistricting redistricting |
but but |
there there |
are are |
dozens dozens |
of of |
competitive competitive |
races races |
including including |
more more |
than than |
30 30 |
currently currently |
rated rated |
as as |
toss-ups toss-ups |
To To |
take take |
a a |
good good |
look look |
at at |
the the |
map map |
I'm I'm |
joined joined |
by by |
three three |
public public |
media media |
reporters reporters |
Karen Karen |
Castler Castler |
of of |
Ohio Ohio |
Public Public |
Radio Radio |
and and |
Television Television |
Scott Scott |
Schaffer Schaffer |
with with |
KQED KQED |
in in |
California California |
and and |
Zoe Zoe |
Clark Clark |
with with |
Michigan Michigan |
Radio Radio |
So So |
happy happy |
to to |
have have |
all all |
of of |
you you |
together together |
to to |
talk talk |
about about |
this this |
Each Each |
of of |
your your |
states states |
has has |
lost lost |
a a |
congressional congressional |
district district |
because because |
of of |
redistricting redistricting |
but but |
you you |
also also |
each each |
have have |
a a |
clutch clutch |
of of |
competitive competitive |
races races |
that that |
could could |
determine determine |
control control |
of of |
the the |
House House |
I I |
wonder wonder |
if if |
you you |
can can |
just just |
set set |
the the |
mood mood |
for for |
us us |
What's What's |
on on |
voters voters |
minds minds |
Everything Everything |
from from |
the the |
weather weather |
to to |
redistricting redistricting |
to to |
issues issues |
that that |
you you |
think think |
might might |
be be |
affecting affecting |
their their |
vote vote |
and and |
let's let's |
start start |
out out |
west west |
with with |
you you |
Scott Scott |
Schaffer Schaffer |
Yeah Yeah |
well well |
California California |
has has |
an an |
unusual unusual |
system system |
for for |
creating creating |
redistricting redistricting |
It's It's |
a a |
citizens citizens |
commission commission |
It's It's |
not not |
gerrymandering gerrymandering |
where where |
the the |
districts districts |
are are |
designed designed |
to to |
protect protect |
the the |
incumbents incumbents |
and and |
so so |
we we |
have have |
four four |
to to |
six six |
competitive competitive |
house house |
races races |
here here |
in in |
California California |
including including |
probably probably |
two two |
of of |
the the |
10 10 |
most most |
vulnerable vulnerable |
Republicans Republicans |
David David |
Valadeo Valadeo |
and and |
the the |
Central Central |
Valley Valley |
and and |
Mike Mike |
Garcia Garcia |
in in |
Los Los |
Angeles Angeles |
both both |
of of |
them them |
running running |
in in |
plus plus |
D D |
districts districts |
where where |
Democrats Democrats |
outnumber outnumber |
Republicans Republicans |
In In |
terms terms |
of of |
the the |
seat seat |
that that |
we we |
lost lost |
Karen Karen |
Bass Bass |
decided decided |
not not |
to to |
run run |
for for |
reelection reelection |
She's She's |
the the |
LA LA |
Congresswoman Congresswoman |
She's She's |
now now |
running running |
for for |
Mayor Mayor |
of of |
Los Los |
Angeles Angeles |
which which |
of of |
course course |
is is |
dominating dominating |
the the |
headlines headlines |
not not |
in in |
very very |
good good |
ways ways |
But But |
in in |
terms terms |
of of |
issues issues |
in in |
terms terms |
of of |
these these |
congressional congressional |
races races |
it's it's |
a a |
competing competing |
narrative narrative |
Republicans Republicans |
want want |
to to |
talk talk |
about about |
gas gas |
prices prices |
and and |
the the |
economy economy |
and and |
the the |
Democrats Democrats |
want want |
to to |
talk talk |
about about |
abortion abortion |
rights rights |
and and |
about about |
threats threats |
to to |
democracy democracy |
And And |
so so |
you've you've |
got got |
these these |
competing competing |
narratives narratives |
that that |
are are |
playing playing |
out out |
on on |
the the |
campaign campaign |
trail trail |
and and |
on on |
television television |
And And |
in in |
addition addition |
I I |
would would |
say say |
that that |
Republicans Republicans |
also also |
want want |
to to |
talk talk |
about about |
crime crime |
and and |
immigration immigration |
But But |
much much |
more more |
so so |
than than |
abortion abortion |
rights rights |
Zoe Zoe |
Clark Clark |
what's what's |
going going |
on on |
in in |
Michigan Michigan |
I I |
know know |
it's it's |
college college |
football football |
season season |
Are Are |
those those |
politics politics |
breaking breaking |
through through |
there there |
in in |
general general |
It It |
actually actually |
is is |
If If |
you you |
can can |
imagine imagine |
it's it's |
not not |
just just |
Spartans Spartans |
and and |
Wolverines Wolverines |
here here |
in in |
Michigan Michigan |
although although |
the the |
weather weather |
always always |
is is |
something something |
we we |
talked talked |
about about |
No No |
much much |
like like |
what what |
Scott Scott |
said said |
indeed indeed |
It It |
is is |
about about |
the the |
economy economy |
It It |
is is |
about about |
inflation inflation |
It It |
is is |
about about |
gas gas |
prices prices |
But But |
since since |
the the |
Dobbs Dobbs |
decision decision |
here here |
in in |
Michigan Michigan |
abortion abortion |
really really |
has has |
become become |
something something |
that that |
has has |
changed changed |
the the |
dynamic dynamic |
We We |
have have |
a a |
amendment amendment |
that's that's |
going going |
to to |
be be |
on on |
the the |
ballot ballot |
in in |
November November |
that that |
would would |
enshrine enshrine |
reproductive reproductive |
rights rights |
abortion abortion |
rights rights |
into into |
the the |
state state |
constitution constitution |
And And |
so so |
on on |
top top |
of of |
these these |
really really |
must must |
watch watch |
congressional congressional |
seats seats |
some some |
of of |
the the |
most most |
competitive competitive |
in in |
the the |
country country |
abortion abortion |
is is |
sort sort |
of of |
overshadowing overshadowing |
the the |
conversation conversation |
when when |
it it |
comes comes |
to to |
all all |
of of |
these these |
races races |
Karen Karen |
Counselor Counselor |
is is |
that that |
what what |
you're you're |
finding finding |
next next |
door door |
in in |
Ohio Ohio |
is is |
abortion abortion |
overshadowing overshadowing |
other other |
issues issues |
Well Well |
I I |
can't can't |
let let |
Zoe Zoe |
talk talk |
about about |
those those |
teams teams |
without without |
mentioning mentioning |
the the |
Ohio Ohio |
State State |
Buckeyes Buckeyes |
and and |
football football |
here here |
is is |
of of |
course course |
dominating dominating |
the the |
conversation conversation |
But But |
yes yes |
there's there's |
a a |
lot lot |
of of |
conversation conversation |
also also |
about about |
the the |
few few |
competitive competitive |
districts districts |
here here |
our our |
most most |
competitive competitive |
seat seat |
and and |
race race |
really really |
is is |
the the |
Ohio Ohio |
U.S U.S |
Senate Senate |
race race |
But But |
they're they're |
in in |
Ohio Ohio |
We're We're |
starting starting |
early early |
voting voting |
today today |
And And |
it's it's |
interesting interesting |
to to |
note note |
that that |
Ohio Ohio |
went went |
from from |
16 16 |
to to |
15 15 |
districts districts |
and and |
majority majority |
Republicans Republicans |
drew drew |
maps maps |
that that |
were were |
ruled ruled |
unconstitutional unconstitutional |
several several |
times times |
by by |
the the |
Ohio Ohio |
Supreme Supreme |
Court Court |
We're We're |
actually actually |
running running |
elections elections |
this this |
year year |
on on |
maps maps |
that that |
were were |
ruled ruled |
unconstitutional unconstitutional |
but but |
put put |
into into |
place place |
by by |
a a |
federal federal |
court court |
And And |
so so |
while while |
we're we're |
electing electing |
representatives representatives |
through through |
these these |
maps maps |
this this |
time time |
around around |
those those |
could could |
change change |
based based |
on on |
the the |
results results |
of of |
what what |
happens happens |
in in |
the the |
election election |
next next |
month month |
So So |
there there |
are are |
only only |
about about |
their their |
10 10 |
safe safe |
districts districts |
and and |
five five |
Democratic Democratic |
seats seats |
but but |
only only |
a a |
couple couple |
are are |
really really |
considered considered |
very very |
competitive competitive |
Yeah Yeah |
Karen Karen |
I I |
want want |
to to |
come come |
back back |
to to |
you you |
I'm I'm |
going going |
to to |
talk talk |
to to |
all all |
of of |
you you |
about about |
favorite favorite |
races races |
but but |
Karen Karen |
let's let's |
start start |
there there |
in in |
Ohio Ohio |
And And |
your your |
favorite favorite |
races races |
one one |
that that |
I'm I'm |
watching watching |
there there |
obviously obviously |
is is |
one one |
of of |
the the |
longest-serving longest-serving |
women women |
in in |
Congress Congress |
Marcy Marcy |
Kaptor Kaptor |
That's That's |
a a |
race race |
where where |
it's it's |
not not |
just just |
issues issues |
but but |
also also |
the the |
effect effect |
perhaps perhaps |
of of |
President President |
Trump Trump |
and and |
the the |
2020 2020 |
election election |
Can Can |
you you |
talk talk |
about about |
that that |
race race |
and and |
what what |
you're you're |
washing washing |
there there |
in in |
that that |
Toledo Toledo |
area area |
If If |
that that |
race race |
is is |
really really |
tightened tightened |
up up |
a a |
lot lot |
Marcy Marcy |
Kaptor Kaptor |
running running |
against against |
a a |
political political |
newcomer newcomer |
Jay Jay |
Armadjewski Armadjewski |
who who |
really really |
broke broke |
out out |
when when |
he he |
got got |
the the |
attention attention |
of of |
Donald Donald |
Trump Trump |
by by |
painting painting |
a a |
picture picture |
of of |
Trump Trump |
on on |
his his |
lawn lawn |
and and |
Trump Trump |
shouted shouted |
out out |
to to |
him him |
at at |
a a |
rally rally |
He He |
ended ended |
up up |
winning winning |
beating beating |
some some |
other other |
established established |
politicians politicians |
and and |
now now |
he he |
and and |
Marcy Marcy |
Kaptor Kaptor |
are are |
facing facing |
off off |
Majuski Majuski |
has has |
made made |
headlines headlines |
recently recently |
because because |
he he |
has has |
claimed claimed |
that that |
he he |
saw saw |
combat combat |
in in |
Afghanistan Afghanistan |
but but |
an an |
investigation investigation |
has has |
shown shown |
that that |
that's that's |
not not |
the the |
case case |
He He |
also also |
has has |
said said |
he he |
was was |
at at |
the the |
Capitol Capitol |
on on |
January January |
6 6 |
He He |
has has |
not not |
been been |
charged charged |
with with |
anything anything |
but but |
that that |
all all |
of of |
this this |
has has |
made made |
this this |
race race |
a a |
little little |
bit bit |
more more |
competitive competitive |
and and |
House House |
Republicans Republicans |
have have |
actually actually |
pulled pulled |
their their |
ads ads |
in in |
this this |
race race |
so so |
that that |
really really |
is is |
tightened tightened |
things things |
up up |
Also Also |
there's there's |
an an |
open open |
seat seat |
that that |
features features |
two two |
women women |
Amelia Amelia |
Sykes Sykes |
the the |
former former |
Democratic Democratic |
leader leader |
of of |
the the |
Ohio Ohio |
House House |
and and |
Madison Madison |
Jesse Jesse |
Odo Odo |
Gilbert Gilbert |
a a |
Trump Trump |
endorsed endorsed |
Republican Republican |
This This |
will will |
make make |
history history |
in in |
that that |
one one |
of of |
those those |
win win |
and and |
only only |
12 12 |
Ohio Ohio |
women women |
have have |
ever ever |
been been |
elected elected |
to to |
Congress Congress |
from from |
the the |
state state |
so so |
that's that's |
going going |
to to |
make make |
history history |
there there |
with with |
that that |
race race |
That's That's |
fascinating fascinating |
I I |
like like |
that that |
Ohio Ohio |
13 13 |
race race |
too too |
because because |
that's that's |
a a |
very very |
rust rust |
belt belt |
seat seat |
that that |
might might |
tell tell |
us us |
something something |
about about |
the the |
Senate Senate |
race race |
as as |
it it |
evolves evolves |
over over |
the the |
night night |
Speaking Speaking |
of of |
let's let's |
go go |
back back |
to to |
you you |
in in |
Michigan Michigan |
then then |
Zoe Zoe |
You You |
have have |
one one |
of of |
the the |
most most |
expensive expensive |
house house |
races races |
in in |
the the |
country country |
among among |
others others |
that that |
I I |
know know |
you're you're |
watching watching |
where where |
Alyssa Alyssa |
Slottkin Slottkin |
the the |
incumbent incumbent |
Democrat Democrat |
is is |
really really |
kind kind |
of of |
a a |
must must |
win win |
seat seat |
for for |
Democrats Democrats |
if if |
they they |
have have |
any any |
hope hope |
of of |
holding holding |
the the |
house house |
Absolutely Absolutely |
and and |
this this |
district district |
is is |
fascinating fascinating |
So So |
it it |
went went |
for for |
Donald Donald |
Trump Trump |
in in |
2016 2016 |
It It |
went went |
for for |
Trump Trump |
in in |
2020 2020 |
but but |
Alyssa Alyssa |
Slottkin Slottkin |
has has |
won won |
it it |
two two |
times times |
So So |
she's she's |
looking looking |
for for |
a a |
third third |
win win |
here here |
now now |
It's It's |
going going |
to to |
be be |
in in |
the the |
now now |
seventh seventh |
congressional congressional |
district district |
because because |
of of |
redistricting redistricting |
and and |
she's she's |
always always |
outperformed outperformed |
as as |
a a |
Democrat Democrat |
but but |
she she |
has has |
a a |
conservative conservative |
Republican Republican |
challenger challenger |
state state |
Senator Senator |
Tom Tom |
Barrett Barrett |
Again Again |
like like |
we've we've |
been been |
talking talking |
about about |
this this |
narrative narrative |
he's he's |
trying trying |
to to |
talk talk |
about about |
the the |
economy economy |
He's He's |
trying trying |
to to |
talk talk |
about about |
inflation inflation |
He's He's |
trying trying |
to to |
talk talk |
about about |
Joe Joe |
Biden Biden |
and and |
I I |
was was |
just just |
talking talking |
to to |
Alyssa Alyssa |
Slottkin Slottkin |
the the |
Congresswoman Congresswoman |
today today |
and and |
she's she's |
talking talking |
fundamentally fundamentally |
about about |
rights rights |
and and |
what what |
she she |
wants wants |
to to |
see see |
happen happen |
change change |
in in |
DC DC |
including including |
interestingly interestingly |
enough enough |
I I |
thought thought |
immigration immigration |
she she |
said said |
in in |
the the |
state state |
of of |
Michigan Michigan |
as as |
well well |
as as |
the the |
cost cost |
of of |
childcare childcare |
Meanwhile Meanwhile |
we we |
also also |
have have |
the the |
third third |
congressional congressional |
district district |
Now Now |
this this |
one one |
is is |
just just |
fascinating fascinating |
This This |
is is |
where where |
Peter Peter |
Meyer Meyer |
a a |
freshman freshman |
Republican Republican |
within within |
the the |
first first |
few few |
days days |
of of |
being being |
sworn sworn |
in in |
voted voted |
to to |
impeach impeach |
Donald Donald |
Trump Trump |
for for |
the the |
second second |
time time |
And And |
Peter Peter |
Meyer Meyer |
lost lost |
his his |
primary primary |
in in |
August August |
to to |
a a |
former former |
Trump Trump |
official official |
John John |
Gibbs Gibbs |
And And |
so so |
this this |
really really |
is is |
an an |
open open |
seat seat |
now now |
We We |
have have |
a a |
Democrat Democrat |
running running |
It It |
looks looks |
like like |
it it |
could could |
lean lean |
Democrat Democrat |
more more |
because because |
of of |
again again |
this this |
redistricting redistricting |
but but |
it it |
probably probably |
would would |
have have |
been been |
closer closer |
had had |
Peter Peter |
Meyer Meyer |
won won |
this this |
seat seat |
but but |
again again |
conservative conservative |
Republicans Republicans |
kicked kicked |
him him |
out out |
booted booted |
him him |
out out |
and and |
went went |
with with |
this this |
Trump Trump |
endorsed endorsed |
Republican Republican |
and and |
said said |
and and |
it it |
looks looks |
like like |
this this |
could could |
be be |
a a |
Democratic Democratic |
win win |
Scott Scott |
you you |
hear hear |
Zoey Zoey |
talking talking |
about about |
a a |
place place |
that that |
Democrats Democrats |
hoped hoped |
to to |
flip flip |
in in |
this this |
year year |
I I |
know know |
you've you've |
got got |
one one |
of of |
those those |
two two |
and and |
you you |
just just |
mentioned mentioned |
it it |
earlier earlier |
Tell Tell |
us us |
about about |
Congressman Congressman |
David David |
Valadeo Valadeo |
and and |
what what |
you're you're |
seeing seeing |
in in |
California California |
Yeah Yeah |
so so |
he he |
lost lost |
this this |
seat seat |
in in |
2018 2018 |
and and |
then then |
got got |
it it |
back back |
in in |
2020 2020 |
So So |
he he |
actually actually |
voted voted |
to to |
impeach impeach |
Donald Donald |
Trump Trump |
but but |
he's he's |
getting getting |
protection protection |
from from |
that that |
Trump Trump |
hasn't hasn't |
gone gone |
after after |
him him |
because because |
his his |
district district |
is is |
right right |
next next |
to to |
Kevin Kevin |
McCarthy McCarthy |
In In |
fact fact |
it it |
includes includes |
part part |
of of |
Baker's Baker's |
field field |
his his |
hometown hometown |
So So |
he's he's |
running running |
against against |
Rudy Rudy |
Salas Salas |
in in |
a a |
district district |
that that |
is is |
59% 59% |
Latino Latino |
Rudy Rudy |
Salas Salas |
would would |
be be |
the the |
first first |
Latino Latino |
member member |
of of |
Congress Congress |
from from |
the the |
Central Central |
Valley Valley |
ever ever |
He's He's |
also also |
co-sponsored co-sponsored |
our our |
Proposition Proposition |
1 1 |
which which |
would would |
enshrine enshrine |
abortion abortion |
rights rights |
here here |
in in |
California California |
One One |
other other |
quickly quickly |
Lisa Lisa |
Ray Ray |
I'm I'm |
looking looking |
at at |
the the |
41st 41st |
congressional congressional |
district district |
in in |
Riverside Riverside |
Ken Ken |
Calvert Calvert |
30-year 30-year |
Republican Republican |
incumbent incumbent |
He's He's |
easily easily |
gotten gotten |
reelected reelected |
but but |
the the |
redistricting redistricting |
has has |
taken taken |
out out |
some some |
of of |
the the |
most most |
conservative conservative |
parts parts |
of of |
his his |
district district |
and and |
added added |
Palm Palm |
Springs Springs |
and and |
other other |
districts districts |
with with |
a a |
lot lot |
of of |
LGBT LGBT |
voters voters |
He He |
has has |
a a |
history history |
of of |
anti-gay anti-gay |
positions positions |
and and |
campaigning campaigning |
and and |
he's he's |
running running |
against against |
an an |
openly openly |
gay gay |
federal federal |
prosecutor prosecutor |
who who |
prosecuted prosecuted |
some some |
of of |
the the |
January January |
6 6 |
cases cases |
and and |
of of |
course course |
Calvert Calvert |
did did |
not not |
vote vote |
to to |
certify certify |
the the |
election election |
So So |
lots lots |
of of |
interesting interesting |
cross cross |
currents currents |
there there |
I've I've |
been been |
hearing hearing |
from from |
you you |
all all |
about about |
the the |
2020 2020 |
election election |
some some |
about about |
former former |
President President |
Trump Trump |
I I |
just just |
want want |
to to |
show show |
of of |
hands hands |
on on |
this this |
last last |
question question |
which which |
might might |
be be |
a a |
little little |
unusual unusual |
but but |
have have |
you you |
spoken spoken |
to to |
any any |
Democrats Democrats |
in in |
tough tough |
races races |
in in |
your your |
states states |
who who |
would would |
like like |
President President |
Biden Biden |
to to |
come come |
and and |
campaign campaign |
for for |
them them |
I I |
want want |
to to |
see see |
a a |
hand hand |
if if |
anyone anyone |
has has |
talked talked |
to to |
a a |
Democrat Democrat |
like like |
that that |
So So |
there there |
we we |
go go |
Both Both |
the the |
former former |
president president |
and and |
the the |
current current |
president president |
seem seem |
to to |
be be |
on on |
the the |
ballot ballot |
this this |
year year |
in in |
the the |
2022 2022 |
midterms midterms |
We We |
are are |
so so |
grateful grateful |
to to |
all all |
of of |
you you |
as as |
Karen Karen |
Casler Casler |
Scott Scott |
Schaefer Schaefer |
Zoe Zoe |
Clark Clark |
Thank Thank |
you you |
all all |
Thank Thank |
you you |
Thanks Thanks |
Great Great |
to to |
be be |
here here |
And And |
thank thank |
you you |
to to |
our our |
Lisa Lisa |
Desjardins Desjardins |
In In |
another another |
battleground battleground |
state state |
Wisconsin Wisconsin |
the the |
Senate Senate |
and and |
Governor's Governor's |
races races |
are are |
in in |
the the |
spotlight spotlight |
and and |
while while |
younger younger |
Americans Americans |
traditionally traditionally |
show show |
up up |
to to |
the the |
polls polls |
at at |
lower lower |
rates rates |
than than |
older older |
generations generations |
one one |
recent recent |
study study |
suggests suggests |
young young |
voters voters |
could could |
play play |
a a |
decisive decisive |
role role |
in in |
the the |
state's state's |
elections elections |
this this |
November November |
Judy Judy |
Woodruff Woodruff |
recently recently |
sat sat |
down down |
with with |
a a |
group group |
of of |
high high |
school school |
and and |
college college |
students students |
in in |
Wisconsin Wisconsin |
who who |
will will |
be be |
voting voting |
for for |
the the |
first first |
time time |
Thank Thank |
you you |
so so |
much much |
for for |
joining joining |
us us |
for for |
this this |
conversation conversation |
We We |
really really |
appreciate appreciate |
it it |
You You |
all all |
the the |
reason reason |
we we |
have have |
you you |
here here |
is is |
to to |
talk talk |
about about |
the the |
fact fact |
that that |
this this |
is is |
the the |
first first |
year year |
you're you're |
going going |
to to |
be be |
voting voting |
And And |
we we |
want want |
to to |
talk talk |
about about |
what what |
that that |
means means |
to to |
you you |
So So |
Ryan Ryan |
I'm I'm |
going going |
to to |
start start |
with with |
you you |
How How |
big big |
a a |
deal deal |
is is |
it it |
to to |
you you |
that that |
you're you're |
going going |
to to |
be be |
voting voting |
for for |
the the |
first first |
time time |
I I |
mean mean |
it's it's |
pretty pretty |
big big |
deal deal |
for for |
me me |
I I |
mean mean |
I I |
sort sort |
of of |
see see |
it it |
as as |
sort sort |
of of |
like like |
when when |
you're you're |
16 16 |
your your |
driver's driver's |
license license |
when when |
you're you're |
18 18 |
you you |
get get |
to to |
vote vote |
I I |
actually actually |
registered registered |
to to |
vote vote |
in in |
my my |
AP AP |
government government |
class class |
on on |
my my |
birthday birthday |
which which |
was was |
a a |
fun fun |
experience experience |
It's It's |
very very |
easy easy |
to to |
register register |
online online |
now now |
I've I've |
been been |
very very |
politically politically |
engaged engaged |
throughout throughout |
high high |
school school |
and and |
I'm I'm |
excited excited |
to to |
get get |
my my |
foot foot |
in in |
the the |
door door |
and and |
actually actually |
have have |
a a |
voice voice |
in in |
my my |
government government |
And And |
then then |
you're you're |
turning turning |
18 18 |
just just |
in in |
time time |
to to |
vote vote |
in in |
early early |
November November |
How How |
big big |
a a |
deal deal |
for for |
you you |
I I |
am am |
very very |
excited excited |
to to |
vote vote |
Everyone Everyone |
in in |
my my |
family family |
has has |
always always |
voted voted |
and and |
although although |
not not |
a a |
ton ton |
of of |
people people |
at at |
my my |
age age |
do do |
vote vote |
as as |
it's it's |
one one |
of of |
the the |
lower lower |
turnout turnout |
groups groups |
I'm I'm |
very very |
excited excited |
to to |
vote vote |
because because |
I I |
think think |
having having |
that that |
voice voice |
in in |
our our |
election election |
is is |
really really |
important important |
What What |
is is |
it it |
that that |
you you |
care care |
about about |
a a |
lot lot |
this this |
year year |
that that |
is is |
driving driving |
you you |
especially especially |
to to |
want want |
to to |
vote vote |
in in |
2022 2022 |
I I |
do do |
see see |
the the |
candidates candidates |
spot spot |
I I |
see see |
pro-choice pro-choice |
and and |
pro-life pro-life |
Personally Personally |
I I |
am am |
extremely extremely |
pro-choice pro-choice |
I've I've |
always always |
grown grown |
up up |
with with |
the the |
belief belief |
that that |
women women |
should should |
be be |
able able |
to to |
have have |
bodily bodily |
autonomy autonomy |
in in |
our our |
government government |
I I |
agree agree |
with with |
the the |
pro-choice pro-choice |
movement movement |
I I |
think think |
women women |
have have |
been been |
stripped stripped |
of of |
their their |
bodily bodily |
autonomy autonomy |
specifically specifically |
in in |
this this |
state state |
And And |
I I |
think think |
that that |
it it |
disproportionately disproportionately |
affects affects |
women women |
of of |
color color |
and and |
women women |
from from |
more more |
low low |
income income |
communities communities |
and and |
the the |
disproportionate disproportionate |
effect effect |
that that |
that that |
has has |
on on |
their their |
access access |
to to |
healthcare healthcare |
their their |
access access |
to to |
reproductive reproductive |
justice justice |
that that |
they're they're |
right right |
to to |
be be |
a a |
mother mother |
or or |
to to |
choose choose |
not not |
to to |
be be |
is is |
frustrating frustrating |
to to |
witness witness |
to to |
somebody somebody |
who who |
can can |
be be |
subjected subjected |
to to |
these these |
laws laws |
So So |
that that |
for for |
me me |
is is |
very very |
top top |
of of |
mind mind |
For For |
me me |
it's it's |
our our |
economy economy |
I I |
mean mean |
I I |
see see |
on on |
the the |
decline decline |
everything everything |
seems seems |
more more |
expensive expensive |
Our Our |
gas gas |
is is |
more more |
expensive expensive |
It's It's |
such such |
a a |
up up |
and and |
down down |
You You |
don't don't |
know know |
what's what's |
going going |
to to |
happen happen |
with with |
it it |
And And |
for for |
me me |
it's it's |
scary scary |
It's It's |
especially especially |
scary scary |
because because |
with with |
everything everything |
going going |
in in |
the the |
right right |
I I |
have have |
still still |
access access |
these these |
I I |
already already |
spend spend |
an an |
arm arm |
and and |
a a |
leg leg |
for for |
my my |
food food |
that's that's |
going going |
to to |
end end |
up up |
hurting hurting |
people people |
whenever whenever |
they they |
can't can't |
afford afford |
the the |
food food |
they they |
need need |
the the |
food food |
their their |
families families |
As As |
the the |
son son |
of of |
two two |
teachers teachers |
education education |
is is |
a a |
very very |
big big |
issue issue |
for for |
me me |
I I |
personally personally |
I I |
think think |
that that |
everyone everyone |
should should |
have have |
access access |
to to |
quality quality |
education education |
whether whether |
that that |
be be |
good good |
schools schools |
good good |
public public |
education education |
or or |
access access |
to to |
college college |
and and |
less less |
college college |
debt debt |
I I |
think think |
my my |
biggest biggest |
issue issue |
is is |
voting voting |
really really |
in in |
terms terms |
of of |
the the |
amount amount |
of of |
people people |
that that |
can't can't |
vote vote |
under under |
our our |
current current |
system system |
We We |
have have |
a a |
lot lot |
of of |
lost lost |
Wisconsin's Wisconsin's |
especially especially |
voter voter |
ID ID |
laws laws |
that that |
make make |
it it |
very very |
hard hard |
for for |
people people |
to to |
vote vote |
Another Another |
big big |
thing thing |
on on |
my my |
mind mind |
is is |
healthcare healthcare |
Seeing Seeing |
Ron Ron |
Johnson Johnson |
vote vote |
against against |
the the |
access access |
to to |
insulin insulin |
was was |
hugely hugely |
disappointing disappointing |
to to |
me me |
as as |
a a |
diabetic diabetic |
Seeing Seeing |
that that |
while while |
it it |
does does |
not not |
directly directly |
affect affect |
me me |
there's there's |
many many |
people people |
in in |
my my |
situation situation |
where where |
that that |
bill bill |
would would |
have have |
hugely hugely |
helped helped |
them them |
and and |
people people |
are are |
going going |
to to |
die die |
if if |
when when |
people people |
make make |
decisions decisions |
like like |
that that |
Let's Let's |
talk talk |
about about |
the the |
person person |
in in |
office office |
right right |
now now |
President President |
Biden Biden |
How How |
do do |
you you |
think think |
he's he's |
doing doing |
I I |
think think |
that that |
with with |
any any |
president president |
there there |
will will |
almost almost |
always always |
be be |
a a |
argument argument |
that that |
they they |
are are |
not not |
doing doing |
enough enough |
and and |
I I |
think think |
that that |
I I |
can can |
say say |
that that |
about about |
Biden Biden |
right right |
now now |
the the |
new new |
decision decision |
to to |
pardon pardon |
thousands thousands |
of of |
people people |
on on |
low-level low-level |
federal federal |
marijuana marijuana |
charges charges |
is is |
a a |
great great |
decision decision |
I I |
think think |
with with |
his his |
decision decision |
to to |
help help |
with with |
student student |
debt debt |
though though |
he he |
campaigned campaigned |
on on |
bigger bigger |
promises promises |
I I |
think think |
that that |
at at |
least least |
he he |
fulfilled fulfilled |
it it |
somewhat somewhat |
and and |
I I |
think think |
you you |
can can |
always always |
ask ask |
for for |
more more |
but but |
I I |
will will |
say say |
that that |
I I |
am am |
relatively relatively |
pleased pleased |
with with |
how how |
he's he's |
doing doing |
so so |
far far |
I I |
believe believe |
that that |
he's he's |
not not |
delivering delivering |
on on |
campaign campaign |
promises promises |
that that |
he he |
made made |
such such |
as as |
protecting protecting |
our our |
right right |
to to |
choose choose |
I I |
would would |
like like |
to to |
see see |
him him |
do do |
a a |
bit bit |
more more |
to to |
serve serve |
the the |
general general |
American American |
people people |
Is Is |
there there |
one one |
thing thing |
you'd you'd |
like like |
to to |
see see |
him him |
do do |
that that |
he's he's |
not not |
going going |
to to |
be be |
I I |
would would |
like like |
to to |
see see |
him him |
codify codify |
Roe Roe |
or or |
make make |
a a |
more more |
of of |
an an |
effort effort |
to to |
I I |
know know |
that that |
he he |
can't can't |
actually actually |
write write |
a a |
law law |
to to |
do do |
so so |
I I |
would would |
like like |
to to |
see see |
him him |
protect protect |
that that |
right right |
I I |
would would |
like like |
to to |
see see |
him him |
ask ask |
the the |
Senate Senate |
and and |
ask ask |
the the |
passive passive |
representatives representatives |
to to |
protect protect |
that that |
right right |
I I |
want want |
to to |
see see |
him him |
fight fight |
tooth tooth |
and and |
nail nail |
for for |
that that |
right right |
but but |
I I |
haven't haven't |
seen seen |
that that |
so so |
far far |
So So |
Ron Ron |
what what |
about about |
you you |
What What |
is is |
your your |
sense sense |
of of |
how how |
present present |
Biden's Biden's |
doing doing |
I I |
quite quite |
don't don't |
like like |
President President |
Biden Biden |
Certainly Certainly |
went went |
to to |
bend bend |
my my |
first first |
choice choice |
nor nor |
would would |
he he |
put put |
a a |
down down |
jump jump |
in in |
my my |
first first |
choice choice |
for for |
this this |
election election |
or or |
for for |
the the |
previous previous |
election election |
I I |
think think |
he's he's |
doing doing |
well well |
enough enough |
for for |
now now |
but but |
I I |
don't don't |
think think |
he he |
is is |
doing doing |
enough enough |
What What |
do do |
you you |
think think |
he he |
should should |
be be |
doing doing |
that that |
he's he's |
not not |
doing doing |
Well Well |
for for |
what what |
I I |
think think |
his his |
Afghanistan Afghanistan |
poll poll |
out out |
was was |
a a |
disaster disaster |
He He |
left left |
so so |
many many |
people people |
It It |
was was |
textrefying textrefying |
He's He's |
not not |
doing doing |
enough enough |
on on |
the the |
border border |
We We |
have have |
almost almost |
hundreds hundreds |
of of |
thousands thousands |
of of |
people people |
getting getting |
in in |
and and |
it's it's |
scary scary |
knowing knowing |
because because |
you you |
don't don't |
know know |
who who |
those those |
people people |
are are |
There's There's |
so so |
much much |
more more |
that that |
he he |
could could |
be be |
doing doing |
that that |
he's he's |
not not |
I I |
don't don't |
know know |
if if |
he's he's |
made made |
effort effort |
to to |
try try |
or or |
not not |
Am Am |
I I |
what what |
is is |
your your |
sense sense |
of of |
how how |
President President |
Biden Biden |
is is |
doing doing |
I I |
think think |
if if |
I I |
had had |
voted voted |
in in |
the the |
2020 2020 |
presidential presidential |
election election |
I I |
would would |
have have |
voted voted |
for for |
Biden Biden |
I I |
think think |
he he |
is is |
not not |
living living |
up up |
to to |
the the |
promises promises |
he he |
made made |
but but |
I I |
don't don't |
know know |
if if |
any any |
president president |
that that |
has has |
So So |
I I |
don't don't |
think think |
that that |
that's that's |
a a |
fair fair |
standard standard |
to to |
hold hold |
him him |
at at |
I I |
think think |
as as |
a a |
first-hand first-hand |
recipient recipient |
of of |
what what |
the the |
student student |
loan loan |
forgiveness forgiveness |
was was |
my my |
mom mom |
fought fought |
for for |
the the |
United United |
States States |
Army Army |
for for |
four four |
years years |
was was |
a a |
recipient recipient |
of of |
the the |
GI GI |
Bill Bill |
got got |
an an |
associate's associate's |
in in |
nursing nursing |
and and |
still still |
had had |
loans loans |
So So |
for for |
her her |
to to |
loans loans |
to to |
be be |
completely completely |
forgiven forgiven |
means means |
an an |
incredible incredible |
amount amount |
While While |
I I |
would would |
like like |
for for |
Biden Biden |
to to |
have have |
John John |
Dunmore Dunmore |
we we |
live live |
in in |
such such |
a a |
polarized polarized |
country country |
right right |
now now |
that that |
despite despite |
his his |
efforts efforts |
to to |
get get |
things things |
done done |
it's it's |
just just |
so so |
hard hard |
right right |
now now |
to to |
get get |
anything anything |
through through |
which which |
is is |
like like |
obviously obviously |
I'd I'd |
like like |
marijuana marijuana |
to to |
be be |
legalized legalized |
I'd I'd |
like like |
to to |
live live |
in in |
a a |
country country |
where where |
Rose Rose |
codified codified |
where where |
abortions abortions |
are are |
available available |
I'd I'd |
love love |
to to |
live live |
in in |
a a |
country country |
where where |
I I |
don't don't |
have have |
to to |
worry worry |
about about |
student student |
loan loan |
debt debt |
but but |
it's it's |
just just |
hard hard |
to to |
get get |
through through |
all all |
of of |
that that |
right right |
now now |
in in |
how how |
the the |
state state |
of of |
America America |
is is |
today today |
A A |
couple couple |
of of |
you you |
have have |
mentioned mentioned |
or or |
alluded alluded |
to to |
former former |
president president |
Trump Trump |
Amaya Amaya |
what's what's |
your your |
take take |
on on |
the the |
former former |
president president |
I I |
grew grew |
up up |
in in |
a a |
very very |
isolated isolated |
and and |
a a |
very very |
white white |
populated populated |
community community |
and and |
I I |
had had |
never never |
experienced experienced |
the the |
difference difference |
that that |
I I |
was was |
black black |
and and |
to to |
help help |
Trump Trump |
was was |
in in |
presidency presidency |
that that |
complete complete |
isolation isolation |
that that |
was was |
brought brought |
on on |
just just |
by by |
this this |
political political |
figure figure |
We We |
had had |
among among |
facilities facilities |
in in |
my my |
community community |
that that |
were were |
destroyed destroyed |
in in |
the the |
name name |
of of |
Trump Trump |
We We |
had had |
monuments monuments |
that that |
were were |
destroyed destroyed |
in in |
the the |
name name |
of of |
Trump Trump |
We We |
had had |
people people |
who who |
were were |
attacked attacked |
in in |
the the |
name name |
of of |
Trump Trump |
and and |
I I |
think think |
he he |
brought brought |
out out |
the the |
worst worst |
in in |
people people |
and and |
he he |
supported supported |
it it |
and and |
he he |
didn't didn't |
correct correct |
that that |
behavior behavior |
and and |
I I |
believe believe |
no no |
president president |
would would |
ever ever |
do do |
that that |
Catherine Catherine |
He He |
by by |
all all |
accounts accounts |
disgraced disgraced |
America America |
in in |
the the |
January January |
6th 6th |
insurrection insurrection |
He He |
though though |
the the |
hearings hearings |
are are |
still still |
going going |
on on |
personally personally |
I I |
believe believe |
that that |
he he |
incited incited |
the the |
insurrection insurrection |
and and |
sent sent |
a a |
mob mob |
of of |
angry angry |
people people |
to to |
the the |
Capitol Capitol |
which which |
is is |
completely completely |
undemocratic undemocratic |
And And |
he he |
also also |
did did |
not not |
facilitate facilitate |
a a |
peaceful peaceful |
transfer transfer |
of of |
power power |
which which |
has has |
been been |
an an |
American American |
tradition tradition |
for for |
hundreds hundreds |
of of |
years years |
which which |
upset upset |
me me |
greatly greatly |
I I |
did did |
do do |
sports sports |
Trump Trump |
and and |
have have |
for for |
quite quite |
a a |
while while |
I I |
mean mean |
during during |
that that |
time time |
period period |
he he |
had had |
the the |
nation nation |
the the |
best best |
economic economic |
period period |
we we |
had had |
for for |
quite quite |
a a |
long long |
time time |
He He |
kept kept |
us us |
very very |
well well |
Unfortunately Unfortunately |
he he |
did did |
have have |
his his |
wrongdoing wrongdoing |
wrongdoings wrongdoings |
and and |
has has |
been been |
a a |
nasty nasty |
person person |
and and |
has has |
almost almost |
always always |
been been |
but but |
he he |
also also |
was was |
the the |
person person |
politically politically |
wise wise |
He He |
ran ran |
America America |
as as |
a a |
business business |
in in |
my my |
opinion opinion |
He He |
ran ran |
it it |
as as |
though though |
that's that's |
what what |
it it |
was was |
And And |
so so |
running running |
like like |
a a |
business business |
him him |
being being |
a a |
businessman businessman |
allowed allowed |
us us |
to to |
have have |
financial financial |
gain gain |
allowed allowed |
us us |
to to |
prosper prosper |
in in |
those those |
times times |
until until |
COVID COVID |
had had |
hit hit |
and and |
which which |
kind kind |
of of |
tanked tanked |
the the |
entire entire |
world world |
economy economy |
Would Would |
you you |
like like |
to to |
see see |
him him |
serve serve |
in in |
office office |
again again |
No No |
it's it's |
likely likely |
not not |
Why Why |
not not |
For For |
the the |
slow slow |
reason reason |
of of |
just just |
it it |
comes comes |
down down |
to to |
the the |
writing writing |
It It |
comes comes |
down down |
to to |
him him |
being being |
an an |
nasty nasty |
person person |
And And |
I I |
think think |
the the |
first first |
four four |
years years |
is is |
good good |
but but |
I I |
don't don't |
think think |
another another |
four four |
years years |
would would |
be be |
great great |
I I |
will will |
agree agree |
on on |
Soren Soren |
that that |
the the |
one one |
thing thing |
I I |
could could |
think think |
I I |
think think |
Donald Donald |
Trump Trump |
ever ever |
did did |
was was |
with with |
the the |
economy economy |
That That |
is is |
the the |
only only |
good good |
thing thing |
I I |
will will |
say say |
about about |
him him |
I I |
believe believe |
in in |
this this |
country country |
we we |
shouldn't shouldn't |
have have |
It's It's |
sort sort |
of of |
the the |
massive massive |
division division |
we we |
have have |
between between |
Republican Republican |
and and |
Democrat Democrat |
His His |
working working |
together together |
is is |
how how |
we we |
fix fix |
things things |
And And |
Donald Donald |
Trump Trump |
basically basically |
drove drove |
a a |
gigantic gigantic |
wedge wedge |
between between |
people people |
He He |
was was |
such such |
a a |
polarizing polarizing |
figure figure |
that that |
from from |
2016 2016 |
onwards onwards |
country country |
would would |
never never |
get get |
anything anything |
done done |
As As |
you you |
all all |
know know |
the the |
percentage percentage |
of of |
people people |
who who |
vote vote |
of of |
your your |
generation generation |
the the |
youngest youngest |
generation generation |
vote vote |
less less |
frequently frequently |
a a |
smaller smaller |
percentage percentage |
of of |
you you |
vote vote |
than than |
the the |
older older |
folks folks |
do do |
in in |
the the |
country country |
But But |
I I |
really really |
do do |
want want |
to to |
understand understand |
how how |
you you |
see see |
the the |
politicians politicians |
listening listening |
or or |
not not |
listening listening |
to to |
your your |
generation generation |
right right |
now now |
I I |
do do |
think think |
that that |
there there |
has has |
been been |
efforts efforts |
I I |
know know |
several several |
candidates candidates |
throughout throughout |
the the |
past past |
two two |
years years |
have have |
been been |
to to |
campuses campuses |
have have |
literally literally |
been been |
outreached outreached |
They They |
sit sit |
and and |
they they |
listen listen |
But But |
once once |
they're they're |
elected elected |
into into |
office office |
that that |
stops stops |
in in |
that that |
communication communication |
line line |
is is |
you're you're |
emailing emailing |
a a |
staff staff |
or or |
you're you're |
emailing emailing |
a a |
secretary secretary |
and and |
the the |
odds odds |
that that |
it it |
actually actually |
gets gets |
to to |
that that |
person person |
is is |
so so |
slim slim |
to to |
none none |
that that |
the the |
reality reality |
that that |
they're they're |
actually actually |
listening listening |
to to |
the the |
complaints complaints |
of of |
their their |
own own |
constituents constituents |
is is |
very very |
like like |
I I |
have have |
no no |
faith faith |
that that |
they they |
are are |
listening listening |
to to |
those those |
And And |
so so |
it's it's |
hard hard |
to to |
say say |
when when |
I I |
don't don't |
even even |
know know |
if if |
they're they're |
hearing hearing |
the the |
issues issues |
that that |
are are |
happening happening |
in in |
their their |
communities communities |
I I |
feel feel |
like like |
if if |
we we |
had had |
more more |
young young |
voters voters |
and and |
more more |
people people |
that that |
voted voted |
as as |
soon soon |
as as |
18 18 |
or or |
as as |
soon soon |
as as |
they they |
possibly possibly |
could could |
I I |
feel feel |
like like |
we we |
would would |
have have |
more more |
politicians politicians |
listen listen |
to to |
our our |
opinions opinions |
listening listening |
to to |
what what |
we we |
want want |
I I |
think think |
that that |
what what |
politicians politicians |
need need |
to to |
understand understand |
is is |
that that |
if if |
you you |
start start |
politically politically |
engaging engaging |
kids kids |
when when |
they're they're |
18 18 |
to to |
21 21 |
when when |
they're they're |
just just |
starting starting |
to to |
get get |
their their |
foot foot |
in in |
the the |
door door |
in in |
politics politics |
you're you're |
more more |
likely likely |
to to |
have have |
an an |
engaged engaged |
audience audience |
or or |
an an |
engaged engaged |
constituency constituency |
as as |
we we |
grow grow |
up up |
And And |
I I |
think think |
that that |
that's that's |
some some |
effect effect |
that's that's |
overlooked overlooked |
most most |
often often |
A A |
lot lot |
of of |
these these |
politicians politicians |
are are |
just just |
so so |
much much |
older older |
than than |
us us |
The The |
problems problems |
that that |
I I |
see see |
are are |
going going |
to to |
be be |
very very |
different different |
because because |
for for |
our our |
80-year-old 80-year-old |
and and |
60-year-old 60-year-old |
Senate Senate |
members members |
climate climate |
change change |
means means |
three three |
or or |
four four |
degrees degrees |
and and |
then then |
they they |
aren't aren't |
going going |
to to |
be be |
around around |
much much |
longer longer |
But But |
for for |
me me |
climate climate |
change change |
means means |
I I |
might might |
see see |
the the |
world world |
crumble crumble |
These These |
politicians politicians |
are are |
so so |
much much |
older older |
than than |
us us |
They've They've |
been been |
in in |
these these |
offices offices |
for for |
so so |
long long |
that that |
they they |
don't don't |
need need |
to to |
listen listen |
to to |
us us |
They've They've |
kind kind |
of of |
got got |
their their |
elections elections |
secured secured |
almost almost |
that that |
they they |
just just |
kind kind |
of of |
keep keep |
coming coming |
back back |
in in |
and and |
they they |
don't don't |
have have |
to to |
engage engage |
anymore anymore |
Well Well |
this this |
has has |
been been |
there's there's |
so so |
much much |
more more |
I'd I'd |
love love |
to to |
ask ask |
you you |
but but |
it's it's |
been been |
such such |
a a |
wonderful wonderful |
conversation conversation |
I I |
so so |
appreciate appreciate |
every every |
one one |
of of |
you you |
sharing sharing |
your your |
thoughts thoughts |
Thank Thank |
you you |
very very |
very very |
much much |
And And |
tomorrow tomorrow |
night night |
Judy Judy |
will will |
have have |
a a |
report report |
on on |
the the |
Senate Senate |
race race |
in in |
Wisconsin Wisconsin |
between between |
incumbent incumbent |
Republican Republican |
Ron Ron |
Johnson Johnson |
and and |
Democrat Democrat |
Mandela Mandela |
Barnes Barnes |
one one |
of of |
the the |
critical critical |
contests contests |
that that |
will will |
determine determine |
control control |
of of |
that that |
legislative legislative |
body body |
Also Also |
tomorrow tomorrow |
join join |
us us |
right right |
here here |
on on |
PBS PBS |
for for |
a a |
special special |
live live |
coverage coverage |
of of |
the the |
January January |
6th 6th |
Committee's Committee's |
public public |
hearing hearing |
beginning beginning |
at at |
1 1 |
p.m p.m |
Eastern Eastern |
plus plus |
additional additional |
analysis analysis |
on on |
our our |
regularly regularly |
scheduled scheduled |
program program |
And And |
that that |
is is |
the the |
news news |
hour hour |
for for |
tonight tonight |
I'm I'm |
Amna Amna |
Nawaz Nawaz |
for for |
all all |
of of |
us us |
here here |
at at |
the the |
PBS PBS |
NewsHour NewsHour |
Thank Thank |
you you |
for for |
joining joining |
us us |
We We |
will will |
see see |
you you |
soon soon |
Major Major |
funding funding |
for for |
the the |
PBS PBS |
NewsHour NewsHour |
has has |
been been |
provided provided |
by by |
For For |
25 25 |
years years |
Consumer Consumer |
Cellular's Cellular's |
goal goal |
has has |
been been |
to to |
provide provide |
wireless wireless |
service service |
that that |
helps helps |
people people |
communicate communicate |
and and |
connect connect |
We We |
offer offer |
a a |
variety variety |
of of |
no no |
contract contract |
plans plans |
and and |
our our |
U.S.-based U.S.-based |
customer customer |
service service |
team team |
can can |
help help |
find find |
one one |
that that |
fits fits |
you you |
To To |
learn learn |
more more |
visit visit |
consumercellular.tv consumercellular.tv |
And And |
with with |
the the |
ongoing ongoing |
support support |
of of |
these these |
individuals individuals |
and and |
institutions institutions |
and and |
friends friends |
of of |
the the |
news news |
hour hour |
including including |
Jim Jim |
and and |
Nancy Nancy |
Biltner Biltner |
and and |
Kathy Kathy |
and and |
Paul Paul |
Anderson Anderson |
These These |
are are |
people people |
who who |
are are |
trying trying |
to to |
change change |
the the |
world world |
Startups Startups |
have have |
this this |
energy energy |
that that |
energizes energizes |
me me |
I'm I'm |
thriving thriving |
by by |
helping helping |
others others |
every every |
day day |
People People |
who who |
know know |
know know |
video video |
The The |
Ford Ford |
Foundation Foundation |
working working |
with with |
visionaries visionaries |
on on |
the the |
front front |
lines lines |
of of |
social social |
change change |
worldwide worldwide |
And And |
with with |
the the |
ongoing ongoing |
support support |
of of |
these these |
individuals individuals |
and and |
institutions institutions |
This This |
program program |
was was |
made made |
possible possible |
by by |
the the |
Corporation Corporation |
for for |
Public Public |
Broadcasting Broadcasting |
and and |
by by |
contributions contributions |
to to |
your your |
PBS PBS |
station station |
from from |
viewers viewers |
like like |
you you |
Thank Thank |
you you |
We're We're |
watching watching |
PBS PBS |
This This |
is is |
the the |
story story |
of of |
a a |
woman woman |
trying trying |
to to |
make make |
it it |
an an |
amount amount |
world world |
But But |
the the |
rest rest |
is is |
they they |
say say |
is is |
a a |
mystery mystery |
I'm I'm |
a a |
really really |
good good |
detector detector |
You You |
do do |
know know |
what what |
needs needs |
an an |
enemy enemy |
They They |
just just |
as as |
we've we've |
done done |
No No |
pressure pressure |
Let's Let's |
see see |
how how |
this this |
plays plays |
out out |
Resistance Resistance |
was was |
a a |
necessity necessity |
On On |
making making |
black black |
America America |
Slaves Slaves |
were were |
freed freed |
but but |
African African |
Americans Americans |
have have |
not not |
become become |
truly truly |
equal equal |
citizens citizens |
Organizing Organizing |
for for |
change change |
And And |
black black |
light light |
Black Black |
jaw jaw |
Creating Creating |
these these |
spaces spaces |
are are |
enclaves enclaves |
that that |
allow allow |
us us |
to to |
feel feel |
good good |
about about |
ourselves ourselves |
and and |
good good |
in in |
the the |
world world |
even even |
if if |
the the |
world world |
isn't isn't |
good good |
Making Making |
black black |
America America |
through through |
the the |
great great |
plan plan |
Tuesday Tuesday |
night night |
at at |
nine nine |
Here's Here's |
tonight's tonight's |
lineup lineup |
on on |
KQED KQED |
made made |
possible possible |
by by |
your your |
support support |
KQED KQED |
celebrates celebrates |
Latinx Latinx |
Heritage Heritage |
Month Month |
with with |
programs programs |
that that |
share share |
the the |
Latinx Latinx |
experience experience |
For For |
program program |
listings listings |
visit visit |
KQED.org KQED.org |
slash slash |
Heritage Heritage |
celebrating celebrating |
Latinx Latinx |
Heritage Heritage |
Month Month |
on on |
KQED KQED |
Are Are |
you you |
a a |
check check |
please please |
Bay Bay |
Area Area |
fan fan |
We We |
want want |
to to |
hear hear |
what what |
you you |
think think |
about about |
our our |
show show |
Please Please |
help help |
us us |
out out |
by by |
taking taking |
a a |
brief brief |
survey survey |
at at |
KQED.org KQED.org |
slash slash |
check check |
please please |
survey survey |
and and |
sharing sharing |
your your |
honest honest |
thoughts thoughts |
about about |
our our |
programming programming |
Thank Thank |
you you |
This This |
is is |
a a |
battlefield battlefield |
This This |
is is |
a a |
battlefield battlefield |
Good Good |
evening evening |
It's It's |
the the |
most most |
important important |
part part |
of of |
the the |
nature nature |
You You |
must must |
have have |
never never |
done done |
this this |
before before |
We We |
go go |
with with |
what what |
the the |
environment environment |
gives gives |
us us |
who who |
we we |
are are |
supposed supposed |
to to |
protect protect |
it it |
It It |
is is |
a a |
real real |
drum drum |
and and |
it's it's |
unfolding unfolding |
right right |
in in |
front front |
of of |
you you |
This This |
will will |
show show |
us us |
so so |
many many |
things things |
that that |
we we |
just just |
haven't haven't |
seen seen |
Change Change |
You've You've |
got got |
that that |
It's It's |
big big |
as as |
you you |
imagine imagine |
KQED KQED |
thanks thanks |
our our |
members members |
and and |
community community |
partners partners |
for for |
their their |
support support |
Xfinity Xfinity |
Home Home |
helps helps |
customers customers |
keep keep |
their their |
home home |
and and |
everything everything |
in in |
it it |
more more |
protected protected |
from from |
24-7 24-7 |
live live |
and and |
recorded recorded |
video video |
to to |
controlling controlling |
their their |
smart smart |
home home |
devices devices |
Learn Learn |
more more |
at at |
Xfinity.com Xfinity.com |
slash slash |
Xfinity Xfinity |
Home Home |
Hello Hello |
everyone everyone |
and and |
welcome welcome |
to to |
our our |
important important |
company company |
Here's Here's |
what's what's |
coming coming |
up up |
More More |
contentious contentious |
cases cases |
on on |
the the |
United United |
States States |
Supreme Supreme |
Court Court |
docket docket |
after after |
gutting gutting |
women's women's |
rights rights |
democracy democracy |
and and |
voting voting |
rights rights |
come come |
up up |
for for |
review review |
and and |
I I |
speak speak |
to to |
the the |
former former |
Attorney Attorney |
General General |
Eric Eric |
Holder Holder |
Then Then |
a a |
growing growing |
power power |
vacuum vacuum |
how how |
Putin's Putin's |
war war |
in in |
Ukraine Ukraine |
is is |
hurting hurting |
his his |
influence influence |
elsewhere elsewhere |
Plus Plus |
Iran Iran |
intensifies intensifies |
its its |
crackdown crackdown |
but but |
protesters protesters |
show show |
no no |
sign sign |
of of |
bowing bowing |
to to |
that that |
pressure pressure |
The The |
country's country's |
deep deep |
culture culture |
of of |
protest protest |
with with |
Reza Reza |
Aslan Aslan |
who who |
looks looks |
at at |
the the |
historic historic |
but but |
little-known little-known |
role role |
of of |
an an |
American American |
martyr martyr |
in in |
Persia Persia |
Also Also |
ahead ahead |
That That |
was was |
really really |
pretty pretty |