"Savor Fishers: Top Pizza Places in Your City"

Angela Jun 16, 2026

Craving a slice of heaven? Fishers, Indiana, is home to a delightful array of pizza places that cater to every taste and preference. From classic New York-style pies to unique, artisan creations, the city's culinary scene is a true celebration of this beloved dish. Let's dive into the best pizza places in Fishers that you simply must try.

15 Best Pizza Places in CT (Reviews and Maps)
15 Best Pizza Places in CT (Reviews and Maps)

Top Pizza Places in Fishers

two pizzas in boxes sitting on top of a stove next to some condiments
two pizzas in boxes sitting on top of a stove next to some condiments

Fishers boasts a diverse range of pizza joints, each with its unique charm and signature offerings. Here are some of the top pizza places that locals and visitors alike rave about:

  • Gino's East - Known for its Chicago-style deep dish pizza, Gino's East is a Fishers favorite. Their famous "spinach and mushroom" pie is a must-try, and don't forget to leave your mark on their walls!
  • Brothers Italian Restaurant - This family-owned gem offers a variety of Italian dishes, but their New York-style pizza is the star of the show. The thin, crispy crust and flavorful toppings will transport you to the Big Apple.
  • Pizza King - A Fishers institution since 1972, Pizza King serves up classic, hand-tossed pizzas with a secret family recipe sauce. Their "King's Special" is a fan favorite, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers.
One Ohio Pizza Spot Has Built A Following For More Than Just Pizza
One Ohio Pizza Spot Has Built A Following For More Than Just Pizza

Unique Pizza Creations in Fishers

If you're looking to try something a little different, Fishers has you covered with these unique pizza offerings:

12 Best Pizza Restaurants in the United States
12 Best Pizza Restaurants in the United States
  • Pizza Baby - This cozy, casual spot serves up creative, artisan-style pizzas with an emphasis on fresh, local ingredients. Their "Fig & Pig" pie, featuring fig preserves, prosciutto, and goat cheese, is a true standout.
  • Good Morning Mama's Cafe - Yes, you read that right! This breakfast joint also serves up some mean pizza for lunch and dinner. Their "Breakfast Pizza" is a crowd-pleaser, topped with eggs, bacon, and cheddar cheese.

Pizza Places with a View in Fishers

Why not enjoy your pizza with a side of stunning views? Fishers has a couple of pizza places that offer beautiful scenery to accompany your meal:

The Absolute Best Pizza Place in Every State
The Absolute Best Pizza Place in Every State
  • 1911 Grill at the Fishers Train Station - This upscale restaurant offers a variety of wood-fired pizzas, as well as stunning views of the Nickel Plate District Amphitheater and the historic Fishers Train Station.
  • Flatwater Restaurant & Bar - Located on the picturesque Saxony Lake, Flatwater serves up delicious, thin-crust pizzas with a view. Their "Saxony Special" is a must-try, featuring Italian sausage, roasted red peppers, and caramelized onions.

Pizza Places for the Whole Family

Looking for a family-friendly pizza spot in Fishers? Check out these kid-approved options:

Best Pizza in Detroit
Best Pizza in Detroit
  • Mama Carolla's Italian Restaurant - This classic Italian restaurant offers a variety of pizzas that are sure to please both kids and adults. Plus, their arcade games and outdoor patio make it a hit with the little ones.
  • Lou Malnati's Pizano Pizzeria - With a kids' menu and a fun, casual atmosphere, Lou Malnati's is perfect for families. Their deep dish and thin crust pizzas are both delicious and kid-friendly.

With so many amazing pizza places to choose from, Fishers is truly a pizza lover's paradise. Whether you're in the mood for classic, unique, or family-friendly pies, you're sure to find something to satisfy your craving in this charming Indiana city. Buon appetito!

100 Very Best Restaurants: #25 – All-Purpose - Washingtonian
100 Very Best Restaurants: #25 – All-Purpose - Washingtonian
12 Best Pizza Places In Naples, FL (Photos, Reviews, Maps)
12 Best Pizza Places In Naples, FL (Photos, Reviews, Maps)
Where To Find Perth's Best Pizza Places
Where To Find Perth's Best Pizza Places
Best Pizza in Frederick, MD – Top Places to Try!
Best Pizza in Frederick, MD – Top Places to Try!
Peak Pizza
Peak Pizza
Who Serves the Best Pizza in Michigan?
Who Serves the Best Pizza in Michigan?
11 Small-Town Pizza Places in Georgia Serving Seriously Good Slices
11 Small-Town Pizza Places in Georgia Serving Seriously Good Slices
Detroit's Five Outstanding Pizza Spots
Detroit's Five Outstanding Pizza Spots
Where to Eat Pizza Tour of Detroit: With Gluten Free & Dairy Free Options
Where to Eat Pizza Tour of Detroit: With Gluten Free & Dairy Free Options
Where to find the best pizza in Naples, Italy
Where to find the best pizza in Naples, Italy
a large pepperoni pizza sitting on top of a metal pan in front of a restaurant
a large pepperoni pizza sitting on top of a metal pan in front of a restaurant
5 Insane Michigan Restaurants You Never Knew Existed! AliceWonderland
5 Insane Michigan Restaurants You Never Knew Existed! AliceWonderland
Mystic Pizza Restaurant CT
Mystic Pizza Restaurant CT
Michigan’s Best Local Eats: 'Beast' pizza in Fenton, Michigan
Michigan’s Best Local Eats: 'Beast' pizza in Fenton, Michigan
a pizza with toppings is in the air above a cityscape and mountains
a pizza with toppings is in the air above a cityscape and mountains
These 9 Florida Pizzerias Book Out Fast and Here's How to Get In
These 9 Florida Pizzerias Book Out Fast and Here's How to Get In
The Ozark Mill Restaurant - Finley Farms near Springfield, MO
The Ozark Mill Restaurant - Finley Farms near Springfield, MO
Local Eats You Can’t Miss in Jackson County
Local Eats You Can’t Miss in Jackson County
The Ultimate Pizza Journey Through Washington Is A Delicious Adventure
The Ultimate Pizza Journey Through Washington Is A Delicious Adventure
The Best Pizza Spot In Every State, According To Yelp
The Best Pizza Spot In Every State, According To Yelp