"Is It Donner or Dunder? The Reindeer Riddle Solved"

Martha Jun 07, 2026

Unraveling the Mystery: Donner or Dunder, the Reindeer's Name

a christmas card with a reindeer and the words,'donner is your average young reindeer
a christmas card with a reindeer and the words,'donner is your average young reindeer

The classic Christmas poem "A Visit from St. Nicholas" by Clement Clarke Moore has immortalized eight reindeer, with one of them being a subject of much debate: Donner or Dunder. Let's delve into this intriguing question, exploring the origins of the reindeer's name and the evolution of its spelling.

some animals that are in different positions to say merry christmas which reindeer are you? don't you dare they're bernard, no one is person
some animals that are in different positions to say merry christmas which reindeer are you? don't you dare they're bernard, no one is person

Donner or Dunder: The Original Name

The original poem, published in 1823, clearly states the reindeer's name as "Dunder." The line goes, "When what to my wondering eyes should appear, but a miniature sleigh and eight tiny reindeer, with a little old driver so lively and quick, I knew in a moment it must be St. Nick. More rapid than eagles his coursers they came, and he whistled, and shouted, and called them by name: 'Now, Dasher! now, Dancer! now, Prancer and Vixen! On, Comet! on, Cupid! on, Dunder and Blixen!' "

navigator Prancer Reindeer Meaning, Reindeer Names And Personalities, Eight Tiny Reindeer Meaning, Funny Reindeer Names, Reindeer Names And Traits, Reindeer Names And Characteristics, Christmas Reindeer Poem, Reindeer Pokey Lyrics For Kids, Eight Tiny Reindeer Song Lyrics
navigator Prancer Reindeer Meaning, Reindeer Names And Personalities, Eight Tiny Reindeer Meaning, Funny Reindeer Names, Reindeer Names And Traits, Reindeer Names And Characteristics, Christmas Reindeer Poem, Reindeer Pokey Lyrics For Kids, Eight Tiny Reindeer Song Lyrics

The Evolution of the Name

Over time, the name "Dunder" has been consistently misspelled as "Donner" in various publications and adaptations of the poem. This change is likely due to a combination of factors, including poor handwriting, mishearings, and even deliberate alterations for rhyming purposes.

All About Reindeer Information Booklet
All About Reindeer Information Booklet

Misinterpretations and Misprints

  • In 1844, the poem was published in the New-York Book of Poetry, where "Dunder" was mistakenly printed as "Donder."
  • In 1857, the poem appeared in the New York Ledger, with "Dunder" replaced by "Donner." This version gained significant popularity and helped solidify the incorrect spelling in the public consciousness.

Rhyming Reasons

two signs with reindeers on them that say true or false
two signs with reindeers on them that say true or false

Some adaptations of the poem have intentionally changed the reindeer's name to "Donner" to create better rhymes. For instance, in the 1949 song "Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer," the line goes, "Then how the reindeer loved him! For Donner was so kind..."

Donner or Dunder: Which is Correct?

The original name of the reindeer, as written by Moore, is "Dunder." However, due to the widespread use and acceptance of "Donner" in popular culture, both spellings are now commonly recognized. In essence, the name of the reindeer has become a matter of personal preference and interpretation.

an image of different types of reindeer heads
an image of different types of reindeer heads

Other Fascinating Facts about the Reindeer Names

While we're on the topic of the reindeer names, it's interesting to note that not all of them are based on weather phenomena or sounds. Some of the reindeer names in Moore's poem are derived from other sources:

Reindeer Facts for kids
Reindeer Facts for kids
Reindeer By Name - Set
Reindeer By Name - Set
Reindeer Coloring Pages
Reindeer Coloring Pages
Santa’s Reindeer Origins | How Rudolph and the Team Began
Santa’s Reindeer Origins | How Rudolph and the Team Began
the different types of reindeers are shown in this picture, including names and pictures
the different types of reindeers are shown in this picture, including names and pictures
where can i get one???
where can i get one???
Santas Reindeer Coloring Pages
Santas Reindeer Coloring Pages
an image of reindeers with the words which reindeer are you?
an image of reindeers with the words which reindeer are you?
is the reindeer donner or donder
is the reindeer donner or donder
Reindeer Word Search
Reindeer Word Search
reindeer
reindeer
The Reindeer Activity Pack
The Reindeer Activity Pack
Printables - Reindeer In Here
Printables - Reindeer In Here
Reindeer Day - Smitten with First
Reindeer Day - Smitten with First
the words dasher, dancer, vixen, comet, don't even rudolph
the words dasher, dancer, vixen, comet, don't even rudolph
Interactive Engagement post.  For new daily posts: "Interactive Engagement Ideas" group on Facebook.
Interactive Engagement post. For new daily posts: "Interactive Engagement Ideas" group on Facebook.
Santa's Reindeer
Santa's Reindeer
Oh, Deer. Phone Background | Christmas Phone Background | YourTaylordDesign (@yourtaylorddesign)
Oh, Deer. Phone Background | Christmas Phone Background | YourTaylordDesign (@yourtaylorddesign)
a reindeer with its mouth open and snow on it's face, in the middle of winter
a reindeer with its mouth open and snow on it's face, in the middle of winter
Pretty Dancer
Pretty Dancer
Reindeer Name Origin
Dasher To dash or run quickly
Dancer To dance or move gracefully
Prancer To prance or move lightly
Vixen A female fox
Comet A streak of light in the sky
Cupid The Roman god of love
Blixen Possibly derived from the Dutch word "bliksem," meaning lightning

Moore's creative use of language has not only given us a beloved Christmas poem but also a set of reindeer names that have become an integral part of the holiday season.