How to Replace a Broken Mirror on Your Medicine Cabinet: Easy DIY Steps

Diane Jun 01, 2026

A cracked or shattered mirror above your medicine cabinet is more than an eyesore; it compromises the safety of your daily routine. Whether it was an accidental bump or gradual wear, replacing the glass requires a methodical approach to avoid injury and ensure a proper fit.

Assessing the Damage and Gathering Tools

The first step is to determine the type of mirror you are working with. Standard mirrors have a backer board, while true one-way mirrors or those with specialized coatings require specific handling. Before you begin, gather your tools to streamline the process and avoid mid-project delays.

  • Safety gloves and protective eyewear
  • Screwdriver set (flathead and Phillips)
  • Razor blade or utility knife
  • Putty knife or chisel
  • Measuring tape
  • Caulk gun and mirror-specific adhesive

Removing the Medicine Cabinet Door

Detaching the Hinges

Most medicine cabinets are designed to be removable for easy maintenance. To access the mirror, you must first take the door down. Locate the hinges, usually positioned at the top and bottom of the frame, and use a screwdriver to unscrew the hinges from the cabinet door.

Medicine Cabinet Mirror Replacement: A Practical Guide for Modern Bathroom Upgrades
Medicine Cabinet Mirror Replacement: A Practical Guide for Modern Bathroom Upgrades

Handling the Glass Safely

With the door removed, lay it flat on a soft surface. If the glass is shattered, cover it with a thick towel to contain shards. Carefully remove any broken glass pieces, ensuring you wear gloves to protect your hands from cuts.

Measuring and Cutting the Replacement Mirror

Do not assume the new mirror will be the exact size of the old one. Use a measuring tape to record the precise dimensions of the mirror cavity. When ordering or purchasing a replacement, ensure the thickness matches the original to fit the mounting clips securely.

If you are using a glass cutter to shape a sheet, mark the dimensions clearly with a grease pencil. Apply steady pressure along the scored line over a hard edge to snap the glass cleanly. Smooth the edges with sandpaper to remove sharp burrs.

DIY Medicine Cabinet with a Sliding Mirror Door
DIY Medicine Cabinet with a Sliding Mirror Door

Removing the Old Mirror Adhesive

The back of the old mirror likely has a protective coating and residual adhesive from the original installation. Use a putty knife to scrape off the old mirror backing. It is crucial to remove all traces of the old adhesive to ensure the new bond is strong and the new mirror lies completely flat.

Installing the New Mirror

Applying the Adhesive

Begin by laying the new mirror face down on a clean surface. Apply a continuous bead of mirror-specific adhesive around the perimeter of the glass. For larger mirrors, add a grid pattern of adhesive in the center to prevent sagging. Avoid using standard construction glue, as it can damage the backing and fail to create a proper seal.

Securing the Glass

Carefully place the mirror into the cabinet door cavity. Align the edges perfectly and apply even pressure. To hold the mirror in place while the adhesive cures, use painter’s tape to secure the corners. Avoid putting pressure on the glass surface directly, as this can cause cracking.

Medicine Cabinet Makeover DIY: Update a Mirrored Medicine Cabinet
Medicine Cabinet Makeover DIY: Update a Mirrored Medicine Cabinet

Reassembly and Final Checks

Once the adhesive has dried—usually after 24 hours—reattach the hinges to the cabinet door. Hang the door back on the medicine cabinet frame and inspect the alignment. Run your fingers along the edges to feel for any gaps or irregularities before the adhesive fully sets.

Finally, clean the new mirror surface with a glass cleaner. You have successfully eliminated the safety hazard and restored the functionality of your storage space without the need for a full cabinet replacement.

a man is looking at himself in the mirror and pointing to his own reflection with both hands
a man is looking at himself in the mirror and pointing to his own reflection with both hands
How to Fix a Broken Mirror Instead of Replacing It
How to Fix a Broken Mirror Instead of Replacing It
How Do I Replace a Broken Medicine Cabinet Mirror?
How Do I Replace a Broken Medicine Cabinet Mirror?
a man is holding up a medicine cabinet mirror
a man is holding up a medicine cabinet mirror
How to Update a Medicine Cabinet without replacing it!
How to Update a Medicine Cabinet without replacing it!
How to Update a Medicine Cabinet without replacing it!
How to Update a Medicine Cabinet without replacing it!
Bathroom Makeover: Demo {Day 2-4}
Bathroom Makeover: Demo {Day 2-4}
Main Bathroom Redo - Repurposed Medicine Cabinet
Main Bathroom Redo - Repurposed Medicine Cabinet
DIY Bathroom Medicine Cabinet Frame
DIY Bathroom Medicine Cabinet Frame
How To Install a Medicine Cabinet
How To Install a Medicine Cabinet
DIY Bathroom Medicine Cabinet Frame
DIY Bathroom Medicine Cabinet Frame
before and after pictures of a bathroom vanity
before and after pictures of a bathroom vanity
a bathroom with floral wallpaper and two sinks
a bathroom with floral wallpaper and two sinks
How to Frame a Medicine Cabinet Mirror (Step-by-Step)
How to Frame a Medicine Cabinet Mirror (Step-by-Step)
a bathroom mirror with a clock on the wall above it that says diy medicine cabinet frame
a bathroom mirror with a clock on the wall above it that says diy medicine cabinet frame
Fixing a Broken Mirror: DIY Tips for Repairing Mirrors
Fixing a Broken Mirror: DIY Tips for Repairing Mirrors
a can of wd - 40 is sitting on the edge of a bathtub
a can of wd - 40 is sitting on the edge of a bathtub
DIY Medicine Cabinet
DIY Medicine Cabinet
Framed Medicine Cabinet
Framed Medicine Cabinet
Medicine Cabinet Make-over
Medicine Cabinet Make-over
Medicine Cabinet Makeover
Medicine Cabinet Makeover
Bathroom Update - How To Remove An Old Medicine Cabinet - A Stroll Thru Life
Bathroom Update - How To Remove An Old Medicine Cabinet - A Stroll Thru Life
DIY Medicine Cabinets! So happy that I can finally get all my JUNK off the counter 🤭 #ad Made the
DIY Medicine Cabinets! So happy that I can finally get all my JUNK off the counter 🤭 #ad Made the