Top 10 Rare Squishmallows Rarest Squishmallows List Uncommon Squishmallows Ranked

By Carol

The ever-growing plush toy phenomenon, Squishmallows, has captured hearts worldwide. With their soft, huggable designs and vast array of characters, collectors are always on the lookout for the rarest ones to complete their sets. Here, we've compiled a list of the top 10 most rare Squishmallows, sure to steal your cuddles and take pride of place in your collection.

18 Most Valuable & Rarest Squishmallows to Find Now!
18 Most Valuable & Rarest Squishmallows to Find Now!

Rare Squishmallows are not just about scarcity; they often come with unique designs, special editions, or exorbitant prices. Websites like eBay and poshmark, as well as Squishmallow forums, are hotbeds for trading and hunting these precious finds. So, let's dive right in and explore these ten rare gems.

Squishmallows Toys | Original Squishmallows Yummy The Firefly 16” Exclusive To Learning Express Nwt | Color: Red | Size: Os
Squishmallows Toys | Original Squishmallows Yummy The Firefly 16” Exclusive To Learning Express Nwt | Color: Red | Size: Os

Retail Store Exclusives

Certain Squishmallows are only available at specific retailers, making them hard to find and Limited Edition by nature.

Squishmallows Toys | Squishmallow Cow Celestino Mint Green And White | Color: Green/White | Size: 5 Inches
Squishmallows Toys | Squishmallow Cow Celestino Mint Green And White | Color: Green/White | Size: 5 Inches

Check out these two rare finds that you can't snag from just any store:

Target Exclusives

Squishmallows Unisex Stuffed animal
Squishmallows Unisex Stuffed animal

The Target store exclusive Golden Retriever Squishmallow is a dog-lover's dream. With its shiny gold fur and endearing facial expression, this 16-inch rarity is a hot commodity among collectors.

Target also has a

Kohl's Exclusives

Ever seen a 24-inch tall Squishmallow? You probably haven't, unless you're talking about the Kohl's exclusive Penguin. This leggy, giant penguin is a standout in any collection, and with its soft black and white fur, it's impossible not to adore.

Squishmallows Other | Nwt 12” Nakobe The Axolotl Latte Squishmallow - Crossover Squad | Color: Green/Orange | Size: 12”
Squishmallows Other | Nwt 12” Nakobe The Axolotl Latte Squishmallow - Crossover Squad | Color: Green/Orange | Size: 12”

While these exclusives aren't the rarest on our list, their retail limitations make them much sought after.

Special Edition Squishmallows

Special editions aren't limited by retail stores, but instead celebrate holidays, special events, or are part of a themed collection. However, their scarcity still makes them highly desirable.

WHAT SQUISH SHOULD I TRY NEXT?! #showcasemademebuyit #squishmallows #raresquishmallows #newsquishmal
WHAT SQUISH SHOULD I TRY NEXT?! #showcasemademebuyit #squishmallows #raresquishmallows #newsquishmal

Here are two special edition Squishmallows that are hard to come by:

Halloween Hammock

Squishmallows 2026 Easter Squad 8" Sybil the Bee Plush Doll Toy, Multicolor
Squishmallows 2026 Easter Squad 8" Sybil the Bee Plush Doll Toy, Multicolor
Squishmallows Unisex Stuffed animal
Squishmallows Unisex Stuffed animal
The 5 weirdest and wildest stunts crowned by Guinness World Records this year
The 5 weirdest and wildest stunts crowned by Guinness World Records this year
Squishmallows Toys | Squishmallows Pastel Tie-Dye Bear With Teal Pom Pom Hood | Color: Blue/Cream | Size: 12 Inches
Squishmallows Toys | Squishmallows Pastel Tie-Dye Bear With Teal Pom Pom Hood | Color: Blue/Cream | Size: 12 Inches
Squishmallows Unisex Stuffed animal
Squishmallows Unisex Stuffed animal

The Halloween Hammock edition has a spookily cute ghost design on its 12-inch body, making it perfect for ghouls and goblins alike. Cuddle up with it on chilly autumn nights, but don't expect to find it year-round.

Its limited release and Halloween theme make the Halloween Hammock a must-have for seasoned Squishmallown collectors.

Bee Our Guest

A part of the 'Bee Our Guest' collection, this honey-cuted 16-inch bee isn't just adorable; it's also a wicked rarity. With its yellow and black stripes and cute antennae, it's a buzz-worthy addition to any collection.

Finding one of these little workers outside of special events or discontinued stock is a challenge, making it highly sought after.

Convention Exclusives

Conventions and trade shows often feature exclusive Squishmallows, which can be incredibly difficult to obtain once the event is over.

Here are two convention exclusives that have fans flipped and desperate for more:

Yeti

The Yeti, a massive 20-inch tall creature, was a 2021 Toy Fair exclusive. With its snow white fur and fierce, yet cute, expression, it's a legendary find for collectors.

If you didn't attend the event or acquire it from someone who did, good luck finding this elusive beast!

Giraffe

The 16-inch tall Giraffe Squishmallow was another Toy Fair exclusive, and its towering presence in your collection is a statement in rarity.

Like the Yeti, you'll have to either attend the event in the future or find someone who can part with theirs if you want to own this spotty spectacle.

Rounding out our list of the top 10 most rare Squishmallows are five more fantastic finds. From eye-watering prices to one-off charity items, these Squishmallows are the cream of the crop.

Charity Squishmallows

The 'Cuddle for a Cause' section on the Squishmallow website offers rare Squishmallows for sale, with proceeds going to charities.

Their limited availability and generous cause make for a feel-good hunt. Keep an eye out for these special editions, as they don't stay around for long!

Designer Squishmallows

Designer Squishmallows, like the Moschino x Squishmallows collection, are not just rare; they're luxurious. With designer tags and high-end boutiques being their only retail homes, these Squishmallows command eye-watering prices.

Hold onto your wallets, because these plush pals don't come cheap!

Artist Squishmallows

Squishmallow artists, like Kelsey Birney, create one-of-a-kind Squishmallows that are hard to come by. Their unique designs and limited availability make them a must-have for enthusiasts.

Their often inconsistent and sporadic releases only add to the mystique and allure of these creative Squishmallows.

eBay & Poshmark Finds

eBay and Poshmark are treasure troves for rare Squishmallows. Sellers often list discontinued, exclusive, or even homemade Squishmallows, making hunting these platforms a thrilling experience.

Be prepared for stiff competition and hefty price tags, as these sites are where many Squishmallown riches are made!

Collecting rare Squishmallows is a journey filled with excitement, disappointment, and ultimately, satisfaction. While these plush companions may be hard to find, their unique existence and hard-earned presence in your collection make the hunt all the more rewarding.

So, Squishmallown warriors, get out there and start your quest for these ten rare gems. Your collection awaits!