Unveiling the Safest Helmets: A Comprehensive Analysis of Helmet Test Results
In the pursuit of safety, the performance of helmets under rigorous testing is a critical factor. This article delves into the intricacies of helmet testing, exploring the methodologies, standards, and most importantly, the results that determine the safest helmets on the market.
Understanding Helmet Testing Standards
Helmet testing is governed by stringent standards, with the most recognized being the ones set by the Snell Memorial Foundation, the Department of Transportation (DOT), and the European Standard (EN 1078). These standards ensure that helmets undergo rigorous testing to provide adequate protection in case of an impact.
Snell Memorial Foundation
- Snell 2020: This standard focuses on linear and rotational impacts, ensuring better protection against various types of crashes.
- Snell B90/B11: These standards are specific to bicycle helmets, with B90 focusing on children's helmets and B11 on youth and adult helmets.
Department of Transportation (DOT)
The DOT standard requires helmets to withstand a 3-meter drop onto an anvil at various points, simulating real-world impacts. Helmets meeting this standard are marked with a DOT sticker.

European Standard (EN 1078)
This standard involves dropping a helmet onto an anvil from a height of 1.5 meters, with the helmet passing if it doesn't split or come apart. It's important to note that this standard is less stringent than Snell and DOT.
Helmet Test Results: A Deep Dive
Impact Testing
Impact testing is the core of helmet testing, simulating the force of a crash. Helmets are dropped onto an anvil from various heights and angles, with the energy absorption and structural integrity measured. The Snell 2020 standard, for instance, includes tests for both linear and rotational impacts, providing a more comprehensive assessment of a helmet's protective capabilities.
Retention System Testing
Retention systems, typically chin straps, are tested to ensure they keep the helmet securely on the head during an impact. This involves pulling on the strap with a force equivalent to a 120-pound (54.4 kg) weight, with the helmet passing if it doesn't come off.

Penetration Testing
Penetration testing involves dropping a sharp object onto the helmet to ensure it doesn't puncture the outer shell. This test is particularly important for motorcycle helmets, where a sharp object could cause serious injury in a crash.
Top Performing Helmets: Test Results Speak for Themselves
Several helmets have stood out in various tests, demonstrating exceptional performance. The Bell Helmets' Pro Star MIPS, for instance, has consistently received high ratings from Snell and other independent tests, thanks to its MIPS (Multi-directional Impact Protection System) technology that reduces rotational forces. Similarly, the Giro Aether MIPS has impressed with its lightweight design and excellent ventilation, coupled with top-notch protection.
For bicycle helmets, the Specialized Prevail II with ANGi crash sensor technology has received praise for its advanced safety features. Meanwhile, the Smith Optics Overtake has been lauded for its exceptional ventilation and comfortable fit, coupled with strong safety performance.

Interpreting Helmet Test Results: What Do They Mean for You?
Helmet test results provide a wealth of information, guiding consumers towards the safest helmets. However, it's essential to consider other factors like fit, comfort, and specific use-cases. A helmet that performs exceptionally in tests but doesn't fit well or is uncomfortable won't provide the necessary protection if you're not wearing it.
Moreover, it's crucial to understand that no helmet can prevent all injuries. Helmets are designed to reduce the severity of injuries, not eliminate them entirely. Therefore, always prioritize safe riding practices to minimize the risk of crashes.






















