"Cost-Effective: One-Story vs Two-Story Homes: Which is Cheaper to Build?"

When planning to build a new home, one of the first decisions you'll make is the number of stories. Both one story and two story homes have their unique advanta...

Cost Comparison: One Story vs Two Story Homes

Building a house on a budget
Building a house on a budget

When planning to build a new home, one of the first decisions you'll make is the number of stories. Both one story and two story homes have their unique advantages, but the choice often comes down to cost. So, is it cheaper to build a one story home or two? Let's dive into the details to help you make an informed decision.

Our Favorite One-Story House Plans
Our Favorite One-Story House Plans

Understanding the Square Footage Cost

The cost of building a home is typically calculated per square foot. According to HomeAdvisor, the average cost to build a home in 2021 was between $100 and $200 per square foot. However, this can vary significantly depending on your location, the complexity of the design, and the materials used.

Affordable House Plans: Building Dreams on a Budget with 20 Ideas
Affordable House Plans: Building Dreams on a Budget with 20 Ideas

Here's a simple breakdown of the square footage cost for both one story and two story homes:

  • One Story Home: The cost is straightforward as it's calculated based on the total square footage of the home.
  • Two Story Home: The cost is calculated based on the total square footage of both floors. However, due to the efficiency of two story homes, the cost per square foot can sometimes be lower than that of a one story home.
🏠 11 Cheapest Way To Build A House
🏠 11 Cheapest Way To Build A House

Factors Affecting the Cost

Foundation and Framing

The foundation and framing are two of the most significant cost factors. A two story home requires a stronger foundation and more complex framing to support the additional weight and structure, which can increase the overall cost.

a house being built with the words, the simple house construction budget the cost to build the
a house being built with the words, the simple house construction budget the cost to build the

On the other hand, a one story home has a simpler foundation and framing, which can make it cheaper to build. However, the foundation of a one story home must be wider to distribute the weight of the home, which can sometimes offset the savings.

Roofing

The roofing cost is another factor to consider. A two story home requires a more complex roof design, which can include dormers, gables, or other architectural features. These designs can increase the cost of roofing materials and labor.

What it Costs to Build a House on Your Own Land | Building Your Own Home
What it Costs to Build a House on Your Own Land | Building Your Own Home

A one story home typically has a simpler roof design, which can make it cheaper to roof. However, the roof of a one story home must be wider to cover the entire home, which can sometimes offset the savings.

Energy Efficiency

Should You Build or Buy a House?
Should You Build or Buy a House?
24 Ideas for Saving Money Building a House
24 Ideas for Saving Money Building a House
Cheapest House Plans to Build: Simple House Plans with Style
Cheapest House Plans to Build: Simple House Plans with Style
8 Ways to Stay on Budget when Building a House
8 Ways to Stay on Budget when Building a House
Is a One-Story House Cheaper Than a Two-Story House?
Is a One-Story House Cheaper Than a Two-Story House?
DIY House Build After Renovating (INTERVIEW) - Making Manzanita
DIY House Build After Renovating (INTERVIEW) - Making Manzanita
Small Farmhouse Plans for Building Your Dream Home
Small Farmhouse Plans for Building Your Dream Home
What is the cost to build a house? A Step by Step Guide
What is the cost to build a house? A Step by Step Guide
Building a House:  Where to Splurge and Where to Save
Building a House: Where to Splurge and Where to Save
Is a 2-Story House Less Expensive to Build?
Is a 2-Story House Less Expensive to Build?
two story house plans with open floor plan for the living room and dining area in front
two story house plans with open floor plan for the living room and dining area in front
Discover the Beauty of House Plans Under 1,000 Sq. Ft.
Discover the Beauty of House Plans Under 1,000 Sq. Ft.
Sonay - A house design with a prominent, continuous porch along the front and extending along one side. The layout suggests a single-story dwelling with a focus on open living spaces. The design is likely targeted toward a rural or suburban setting.  Architectural Style (Exterior)  *   Style: The house appears to be a modern take on a traditional ranch-style or country-style home.  The combination of a simple roofline, porch columns, and clapboard siding is characteristic. *   Roof: A low-pitched metal roof which is a common feature for these style of homes. *   Porch: A wide, covered porch runs along the front and side. The porch provides substantial outdoor living space and adds to the home's curb appeal. *   Windows and Doors: Simple, dark-framed windows add contrast to the light-colored siding.  Floor Plan Analysis  *   Dimensions: The house is 50 feet wide and 68 feet, 0 inches long. *   Rooms:     *   Bedrooms:  Three bedrooms are clearly identified: a master bedroom and two additional bedrooms.     *   Bathrooms:  Two bathrooms are depicted. One is directly connected to the master bedroom, making it an en-suite bathroom.     *   Great Room: The heart of the home is a large \
Sonay - A house design with a prominent, continuous porch along the front and extending along one side. The layout suggests a single-story dwelling with a focus on open living spaces. The design is likely targeted toward a rural or suburban setting. Architectural Style (Exterior) * Style: The house appears to be a modern take on a traditional ranch-style or country-style home. The combination of a simple roofline, porch columns, and clapboard siding is characteristic. * Roof: A low-pitched metal roof which is a common feature for these style of homes. * Porch: A wide, covered porch runs along the front and side. The porch provides substantial outdoor living space and adds to the home's curb appeal. * Windows and Doors: Simple, dark-framed windows add contrast to the light-colored siding. Floor Plan Analysis * Dimensions: The house is 50 feet wide and 68 feet, 0 inches long. * Rooms: * Bedrooms: Three bedrooms are clearly identified: a master bedroom and two additional bedrooms. * Bathrooms: Two bathrooms are depicted. One is directly connected to the master bedroom, making it an en-suite bathroom. * Great Room: The heart of the home is a large \
Building a House: Easy Things You Can Do Yourself to Save Time and Money
Building a House: Easy Things You Can Do Yourself to Save Time and Money
Tips for Building a house on a budget
Tips for Building a house on a budget
One-Story Small House Plan
One-Story Small House Plan
the floor plan for a small house with two garages and an open living area
the floor plan for a small house with two garages and an open living area
Modern Minimalist contemporary House Plan
Modern Minimalist contemporary House Plan
4+ Inspiring Ranch House Additions: Before & After
4+ Inspiring Ranch House Additions: Before & After
TWO men ONE house ONE day - with a DIY house kit
TWO men ONE house ONE day - with a DIY house kit

Two story homes are often more energy efficient than one story homes. The taller, narrower design of a two story home provides less surface area exposed to the elements, which can reduce heating and cooling costs.

However, the energy efficiency of a home also depends on other factors, such as insulation, windows, and HVAC systems. Therefore, the energy efficiency of a two story home may not necessarily translate to lower overall costs.

Other Considerations

In addition to cost, there are other factors to consider when deciding between a one story and two story home. For example:

  • Lot Size: A two story home can be built on a smaller lot than a one story home, which can save money on land costs.
  • Privacy: A two story home can provide more privacy, as it allows you to separate living spaces from bedroom spaces.
  • Resale Value: Two story homes often have a higher resale value than one story homes, as they offer more living space in a smaller footprint.

Comparing the Costs: A Case Study

Let's compare the costs of building a one story home and a two story home using a case study. Assume the following:

Item One Story Home (2,000 sq ft) Two Story Home (2,000 sq ft total, 1,000 sq ft per floor)
Foundation and Framing $50,000 $60,000
Roofing $20,000 $25,000
Interior Finishes $80,000 $85,000
Total Cost $150,000 $170,000

In this case study, the two story home has a higher total cost than the one story home, despite having the same total square footage. However, the cost per square foot of the two story home is lower ($85 per sq ft vs $75 per sq ft), which can make it a more cost-effective option in the long run.

Conclusion

So, is it cheaper to build a one story home or two? The answer depends on various factors, including your location, the size of your home, and your specific design preferences. While a one story home can be cheaper to build due to its simpler foundation and framing, a two story home can offer more energy efficiency and living space in a smaller footprint.

Ultimately, the best way to determine the cost of building a one story or two story home is to consult with a local builder or architect. They can provide you with a detailed cost estimate based on your specific needs and location.