Ever found yourself rushing to the gym after work, only to realize you've left your workout gear or water bottle at home? Running with a backpack can be a solution to this common problem. But does running with a backpack actually help, or is it just a stopgap measure until you invest in a proper running belt? Let's delve into the pros, cons, and best practices of running with a backpack.

a woman with a backpack is running in the dirt near some bushes and mountains on a sunny day
a woman with a backpack is running in the dirt near some bushes and mountains on a sunny day

First things first, it's crucial to understand that running with a backpack isn't the same as wearing one during a leisurely hike. The dynamics of running and the increased impact can affect how you carry weight on your back. So, let's explore what science tells us about this topic.

a person with a backpack and water bottle on top of a mountain looking at the mountains
a person with a backpack and water bottle on top of a mountain looking at the mountains

Pros of Running with a Backpack

The biggest advantage of running with a backpack is the convenience and flexibility it offers. You can carry almost anything you need for a run or a post-run activity, from your work clothes to a change of shoes. It's also a great option if you're into trail running and need to carry safety gear, water, and supplies.

The Best Running Backpacks Tested and Reviewed
The Best Running Backpacks Tested and Reviewed

Moreover, for some people, the additional weight can act as resistance training, helping to build strength and endurance. A study published in the 'Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research' found that carries increased pushing strength in trail runners. However, more research is needed to validate this finding across different groups of runners.

Backpacks Can Improve Posture

The Best Running Backpack for Commuters - The Runner Beans
The Best Running Backpack for Commuters - The Runner Beans

Believe it or not, a backpack can help improve your running posture. When properly worn, a backpack can help distribute weight evenly, encouraging you to stand upright and maintain a good posture while running. This can be particularly beneficial for runners who tend to hunch forward, leading to inefficient energy use and potential lower back pain.

Studies have shown that carrying weight on your back can indeed improve posture. A study in the 'Journal of Back and Musculoskeletal Rehabilitation' found that carrying a weighted backpack increased upright posture in young adults. However, the backpack should be properly fitted and the weight should be distributed evenly for maximum benefit.

Backpacks Can Aid in Hydration

What to Pack for Running Away! Pt. 1 By @commentarykore
What to Pack for Running Away! Pt. 1 By @commentarykore

Staying hydrated is crucial during long runs. While handheld bottles and running belts are popular choices, they often don't provide enough space for all your hydration needs. A backpack, on the other hand, can fit multiple water bottles or a hydration pack, ensuring you have enough water for your run.

In addition, backpacks often come with built-in hydration ports that allow you to drink without removing your pack. This is particularly useful for trail runners who need to keep their hands free for navigating obstacles or keeping their balance.

Cons of Running with a Backpack

Weekly Recap: 27 Weeks Until the Houston Marathon - The Right Fits
Weekly Recap: 27 Weeks Until the Houston Marathon - The Right Fits

While there are certainly benefits to running with a backpack, there are also several drawbacks to consider.

One of the main disadvantages is the increased weight and impact on your back and shoulders. Running with a heavy backpack can lead to discomfort, chafing, and even injury, especially if the backpack isn't designed for running or isn't worn correctly. Moreover, the increased weight can slow you down, making running with a backpack less efficient than running without one.

two people with backpacks are running on the road together, one is wearing shorts and the other has a pink back pack
two people with backpacks are running on the road together, one is wearing shorts and the other has a pink back pack
The 6 Best Rucking Backpacks, According to Experts
The 6 Best Rucking Backpacks, According to Experts
three women with back packs and the words 11 of the best running backpacks for any occasion
three women with back packs and the words 11 of the best running backpacks for any occasion
How to Fit a Backpack Properly: The Ultimate Guide to Pain-Free Carrying
How to Fit a Backpack Properly: The Ultimate Guide to Pain-Free Carrying
Running Packs 101: Fit, Features, and Storage
Running Packs 101: Fit, Features, and Storage
How To Start Running (Or Pick It Back Up) » Read Now!
How To Start Running (Or Pick It Back Up) » Read Now!
Running with a Backpack: Tips to Make It Easier and Safer
Running with a Backpack: Tips to Make It Easier and Safer
The 12 Mile Ruck | Standards, Time, and Prep
The 12 Mile Ruck | Standards, Time, and Prep
The Only Backpack You'll Need for Your Run Commute
The Only Backpack You'll Need for Your Run Commute

Backpacks Can Affect Breathing

Carrying weight on your back during a run can affect your breathing pattern and overall lung capacity. A study in the 'Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research' found that weighted carries during high-intensity interval training (HIIT) led to reduced oxygen uptake and a higher rating of perceived exertion.

In other words, carrying weight can make you feel like you're working harder than you actually are, which can be detrimental to your performance and enjoyment of the sport.

Backpacks Can Limit Movement

Not only can a backpack affect your breathing, but it can also limit your movement and range of motion. running requires fluidity and freedom of movement, and a backpack, especially a heavy one, can restrict this.

A poor-fitting backpack can also create unnecessary movement, such as bouncing or shifting, which can be distracting and even painful. This can lead to changes in your running form and increase the risk of injury.

Best Practices for Running with a Backpack

If you've decided that running with a backpack is the right choice for you, there are several best practices to ensure a safe and comfortable experience.

Choose the Right Backpack

The first step is to choose a backpack that's designed for running. These backpacks are typically smaller, lighter, and have targeted padding to reduce bounce and chafing. Look for features like adjustable straps for a custom fit, breathable mesh material to reduce sweat, and reflective details for increased visibility while running.

Some popular running-specific backpack options include the Nathan VaporKrar 4L, the Ultimate Direction Fastdrew 12L, and the Salomon Skin Pro 12 Set. However, the best backpack is the one that fits your body and your needs, so it's essential to try on different options before making a purchase.

Pack Light and Distribute Weight Evenly

Once you've chosen the right backpack, it's important to pack it correctly. The general rule of thumb is to keep the total weight of your pack under 10-20% of your body weight. This ensures that you're not carrying too much weight and risking injury.

In addition to packing light, it's also crucial to distribute the weight evenly. The most important items should be packed closest to your back and in the center of the pack to minimize movement. Heavier items should be placed at the bottom of the pack, while lighter, bulkier items can be placed at the top.

Wear the Backpack Properly

Wearing your backpack properly is just as important as choosing the right one and packing it correctly. The backpack should sit snugly against your back, with the hip belt or chest strap buckled to distribute the weight evenly and keep the pack in place.

Adjust the straps regularly to ensure a secure fit, and consider wearing a base layer underneath the backpack to reduce chafing and moisture.

In conclusion, running with a backpack is a matter of personal preference and specific needs. While it offers flexibility and convenience, it's crucial to consider the potential drawbacks and take necessary precautions to ensure a safe and enjoyable run.