Why Do Houses Have Fake Shutters? The Secret Reason Explained

Why Do Houses Have Fake Shutters?

In the realm of home architecture, the use of fake shutters is a common sight. These non-functional, decorative elements often catch the eye, but their purpose might not be immediately apparent. This article explores the reasons behind this architectural trend, delving into their historical significance, aesthetic value, and practical implications.

Historical Context: A Nod to the Past

To understand the prevalence of fake shutters, we must look back in time. Historically, shutters served practical purposes, providing protection from harsh weather conditions and intruders. In the days before glass windows, shutters were essential for maintaining privacy and insulation. As glass production became more affordable, windows became commonplace, but the aesthetic of shutters remained.

Fake shutters, also known as false or architectural shutters, emerged as a way to maintain this traditional look without the need for functional shutters. They became a symbol of continuity with the past, a nod to the architectural heritage of a home.

Fake Shutters: The Redundant Facade Design Flourish that Critics Love ...

Aesthetic Appeal: Enhancing Curb Appeal

One of the primary reasons for using fake shutters is their aesthetic appeal. They can significantly enhance a home's curb appeal, adding a touch of charm and character. Here are a few ways fake shutters contribute to a home's appearance:

  • Symmetry: Fake shutters help create a balanced, symmetrical look, which is pleasing to the eye.
  • Depth: They add depth to a home's facade, making it look more dimensional and interesting.
  • Style: Fake shutters can complement or accentuate a home's architectural style, whether it's Victorian, Craftsman, or Modern.

Practical Considerations: Low Maintenance and Cost-Effective

While fake shutters might not provide the same level of functionality as real ones, they do offer several practical advantages:

  • Low Maintenance: Fake shutters require minimal upkeep. Unlike real shutters, they don't need to be opened or closed, painted, or repaired due to weather damage.
  • Cost-Effective: While high-quality fake shutters can be an investment, they are generally more affordable than real shutters, especially when considering the long-term maintenance costs.
  • Versatility: Fake shutters can be made from various materials, including vinyl, PVC, and composite, allowing for a range of styles and budgets.

Regional and Cultural Influences

In some regions, fake shutters are more common due to cultural or historical influences. For instance, in the Southern United States, fake shutters are often used to evoke a sense of history and tradition. Similarly, in some European countries, fake shutters are a common feature of historic buildings, helping to preserve the area's architectural heritage.

Why Do People Put Fake Shutters on Houses? (It's Laughable)

Controversies and Criticisms

Despite their popularity, fake shutters are not without their critics. Some argue that they are inauthentic and detract from a home's architectural integrity. Others point out that they can make a home look less inviting, as they suggest that the windows are never opened.

However, these criticisms are not universally shared, and many homeowners and architects continue to appreciate the aesthetic and practical benefits of fake shutters.

Incorporating Fake Shutters into Home Design

When considering fake shutters for your home, there are several factors to keep in mind. First, consider the style and age of your home. Fake shutters can help maintain a home's historic character or add a touch of charm to a newer home. Next, think about the material and color of the shutters. They should complement, not clash with, your home's exterior. Finally, consider your budget and the level of maintenance you're willing to undertake.

Fake Shutter Materials and Their Characteristics
Material Appearance Durability Maintenance Cost
Vinyl Realistic High Low Low
PVC Realistic High Low Low to Medium
Composite Realistic High Low Medium to High
Wood Authentic Medium High High

In conclusion, fake shutters serve a variety of purposes, from historical preservation to aesthetic enhancement. They are a versatile and practical choice for homeowners looking to add character to their homes. Whether you're aiming to maintain a home's historic charm or simply want to boost your curb appeal, fake shutters are a worthwhile consideration.

Reference

Why have fake shutters become ubiquitous on American homes? [ask]

12.08.2019 ... Fake shutters are one of my biggest pet peeves. I live in Europe, where we have real shutters that actually open and close. We use them to ...

Fake Shutters: The Redundant Facade Design Flourish that Critics Love ...

Fake Shutters: The Redundant Facade Design Flourish that Critics Love ...

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

A Brief History of Shutters: Should We Keep Ours? - Blake Hill House

26.04.2021 ... ... fake” historic features using modern replacements. Sources. Admin. “A Brief History of Exterior Shutters.” Wasatch Shutter, 20 Jan. 2020 ...

Why Do People Put Fake Shutters on Houses? (It's Laughable)

Why Do People Put Fake Shutters on Houses? (It's Laughable)

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

Window shutter - Wikipedia

Shutters may be employed for a variety of reasons, including controlling the amount of sunlight that enters a room, to provide privacy, security, to protect ...

shutters definition - Architecture Dictionary

shutters definition - Architecture Dictionary

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

Fake Shutters are the absolute worst - MidMod Midwest

12.07.2018 ... Fake Shutters are the absolute worst ... 3 min readShutters once had a real function. They were a security measure, a way to close up houses ...

Why Do People Put Fake Shutters on Houses? (It's Laughable)

Why Do People Put Fake Shutters on Houses? (It's Laughable)

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

Introduction & History of Shutters - OldHouseGuy Blog

... fake vinyl shutters that were put on the house in the 90s. Did 1910 farmhouses have shutters or would it look better if we removed them? ... do not see ...

Why Do People Put Fake Shutters on Houses? (It's Laughable)

Why Do People Put Fake Shutters on Houses? (It's Laughable)

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

Why did old houses have shutters? - Quora

10.12.2021 ... If you look at the shutters too, they're actually functional unlike the faux ones you see on newer homes in places like the US. ... Why do Dutch ...

How To Make Fake Shutters Look Real at Amy Jonsson blog

How To Make Fake Shutters Look Real at Amy Jonsson blog

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

Are Window Shutters Still in Style? We Asked Designers What They ...

22.06.2025 ... If your shutters do not appear large enough to cover an entire ... Otherwise, this is a major style faux pas. Shutters Are Dependent on ...

Shutter Exterior Fake Window

Shutter Exterior Fake Window

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

What is it with this ubiquitous trend to put shutters on every house no ...

24.03.2023 ... I have a boring looking house and the gaps between the windows made it worse. Fake shutters in a contrasting color make it look better. I just ...

Mid-Century Masonry Faux Shutter Accents - Jasongraphix

Mid-Century Masonry Faux Shutter Accents - Jasongraphix

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

Spain Guides | Why Do Spanish Windows Have Shutters? Here's ...

05.01.2021 ... It seems like no window is complete without shutters! A surprising fact is that there are houses out there that have fake shutters that do ...

Shutter Exterior Fake Window

Shutter Exterior Fake Window

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

Why Fake Shutters Make Me Angry - The Craftsman Blog

12.02.2018 ... If your shutters don't shut, they are fake. Shutters were designed to cover your window for a multitude of reasons. They protect against storms ...

Fake Shutters For House at Maurice Delgado blog

Fake Shutters For House at Maurice Delgado blog

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

What Windows Should Have Shutters - At Home With The Barkers

17.04.2023 ... Many of our homes do not have functioning shutters. ... Form should follow function – installing fake shutters is silly, but to each their own.

Window Gable Exterior Faux Shutters

Window Gable Exterior Faux Shutters

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

Fake vs. Functional Shutters

28.08.2018 ... Benefits of functional shutters vs. fake shutters · Lack the shadows that add interest and depth to a home when built with faux louvers · Appear ...

Mid-Century Masonry Faux Shutter Accents - Jasongraphix

Mid-Century Masonry Faux Shutter Accents - Jasongraphix

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

Fixed vs. Functional Shutters | Timberlane Blog

You learned the hard way: Either your house had sturdy, functional shutters ... shutter installations with a dull, “fake” look. The truth is, any shutters ...

Shutter Exterior Fake Window

Shutter Exterior Fake Window

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

Mid-Century Masonry Faux Shutter Accents - Jasongraphix

26.10.2022 ... ... houses have them, some don't. Some are your run-of-the-mill fake wood shutters, and some are absolute "Shudder Sunday" train wrecks...

Why Fake Shutters Make Me Angry | The Craftsman Blog

Why Fake Shutters Make Me Angry | The Craftsman Blog

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

Form Unfollows Function: The Demise of the Window Shutter

07.11.2011 ... Last year, a European asked me why our window shutters were “fake. ... In this house, the shutters exist only on one side of the far windows.

Why Fake Shutters Make Me Angry - The Craftsman Blog

Why Fake Shutters Make Me Angry - The Craftsman Blog

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

Residential Architecture 101: Shutters | Life of an Architect

24.03.2011 ... Shutters have become an illness. People are so afraid of not having shutters on their house, they think fake, shiny, plastic, out of place ...

Shutter Exterior Fake Window

Shutter Exterior Fake Window

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

Shutters or Not: 10 Ways to Decide - Curb Appeal - Maria Killam

16.05.2022 ... I think for many of these houses, in addition to landscaping, beefing up the mouldings around the windows and doors would add so much more ...

Shutter Exterior Fake Window

Shutter Exterior Fake Window

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

Exterior Shutters in America are ALL WRONG - YouTube

01.05.2019 ... Want to hear what makes Kim absolutely shudder!?! Fake shutters! Most American homes have shutters installed ALL WRONG, and we can see it ...

HELP! Framer cant find matching 'fake' window shutters for new window ...

HELP! Framer cant find matching 'fake' window shutters for new window ...

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

Fake Shutters: The Redundant Facade Design Flourish that Critics ...

01.07.2022 ... Fake Shutters: The Redundant Facade Design Flourish that Critics Love to Hate ... From too-small balconies that don't really work to faux shutters ...

Why Do People Put Fake Shutters on Houses? (It's Laughable)

Why Do People Put Fake Shutters on Houses? (It's Laughable)

Visual inspiration for your project.

Reference

Shut It Down: An Exploration of Shutters - Carolina Planning Journal

02.11.2016 ... ... houses in Greensboro seemed to have shutters. And it wasn't only in ... If you're going to fake it, at least do it well. Do not bolt ...

Mid-Century Masonry Faux Shutter Accents - Jasongraphix

Mid-Century Masonry Faux Shutter Accents - Jasongraphix

Visual inspiration for your project.