Selena Chilton Murder: Unanswered Questions in Cold Case

On the evening of April 13, 2016, the peaceful town of Dickson, Tennessee, was shattered by a brutal crime. The lifeless body of 24-year-old Selena Chilton was discovered in her apartment, marking the beginning of a complex murder investigation that would captivate the local community and make headlines statewide.

Selena killer
Selena killer

Selena Chilton, a vibrant young woman with a infectious smile, had graduated from Austin Peay State University just a year prior. She was remembered by friends as a dedicated student, passionate about animals, and an avid reader with a keen wit. Her life was tragically cut short, leaving loved ones to grapple with the devastating loss and a haunting question: who could have committed such a heinous act?

a woman with her eyes closed and the words celebrities that were murdered
a woman with her eyes closed and the words celebrities that were murdered

The Investigation Begins

The Dickson County Sheriff's Office launched an extensive investigation,with Lt. Todd Moore leading the efforts. The victim's apartment showed signs of a struggle, and Selena's vehicle was missing. This indicated that she may have known her attacker, as there were no signs of forced entry.

a woman with long dark hair wearing a red dress and looking at the camera while standing in front of a white background
a woman with long dark hair wearing a red dress and looking at the camera while standing in front of a white background

Autopsy results revealed that Selena had been strangled. The medical examiner also found evidence that she was defense - an indication that she fought for her life. Investigators believed that her sharp fingernails could potentially hold clues to her killer's identity.

The Search for the Missing Vehicle

a memorial with flowers and a statue in the middle is surrounded by black iron gates
a memorial with flowers and a statue in the middle is surrounded by black iron gates

Selena's vehicle, a silver 2007 Pontiac G6, was a crucial piece of evidence. With its Tennessee license plate bearing the moniker "SWAGG 6," it was difficult to miss. Law enforcement agencies shared the vehicle's description across the state, appealing to the public for any sightings.

Five days after Selena's murder, her car was found abandoned at a rest area near Nashville. Inside, investigators discoveredSelena's wallet, a spent shell casing, and a small piece of fabric. Fingerprints were lifted from the vehicle, but unfortunately, none matched anyone in the criminal database.

The Mounting of Pressure on Eric Sutton

a person holding a cell phone up to their face with the caption can you please stop bothereding me?
a person holding a cell phone up to their face with the caption can you please stop bothereding me?

As the investigation progressed, a person of interest emerged: Eric Sutton, Selena's estranged husband. The couple had separated in 2015, with Selena filing for divorce a month before her death. Their relationship had been tumultuous, with Sutton facing allegations of domestic violence and stalking.

Sutton's actions in the days following Selena's murder raised red flags for investigators. He was seen withdrawing money from her bank account, using her credit card, and even attempted to modify their life insurance policy to make himself the sole beneficiary. When interviewed, Sutton's stories were inconsistent, and he could not provide an alibi for the time of Selena's death.

The Arrest and Trial

a woman with blonde hair wearing a black shirt and pearls necklace smiling at the camera
a woman with blonde hair wearing a black shirt and pearls necklace smiling at the camera

On May 19, 2016, Burlington, North Carolina, police arrested Eric Sutton on charges of first-degree murder, criminal impersonation, and fraud. He was extradited to Tennessee to face justice.

During Sutton's trial, upset testimony from friends and family members painted a poignant picture of Selena's vibrant spirit and the devastating impact of her loss. The prosecution presented evidence tying Sutton to the crime, including the spent shell casing found in Selena's car and phone records placing him near her apartment at the time of her murder.

an image of a mirror with the reflection of a bedroom in it and another room behind it
an image of a mirror with the reflection of a bedroom in it and another room behind it
I feel so bad for her- 💔
I feel so bad for her- 💔
a woman with curly hair is posing for a photo in front of a blue background
a woman with curly hair is posing for a photo in front of a blue background
a newspaper article with an image of a woman singing into a microphone
a newspaper article with an image of a woman singing into a microphone
a woman with long hair is smiling and holding a microphone in front of her face
a woman with long hair is smiling and holding a microphone in front of her face
Selena
Selena
an old photo of a woman with no shirt on, and the caption appears to be sears
an old photo of a woman with no shirt on, and the caption appears to be sears
Awwwww
Awwwww
selena chilton murder
selena chilton murder

The DNA Evidence

Crucial to the prosecution's case was DNA evidence found under Selena's fingernails. The profile matched Eric Sutton's DNA, providing irrefutable proof of his presence at the crime scene. Additionally, a gun found in Sutton's possession matched the caliber of the shell casing found in Selena's car.

The defense argued that the DNA evidence was inconclusive and that Sutton could have been framed. However, the jury saw through these arguments, convicting Sutton of first-degree murder and other charges in February 2018.

The Sentencing and Impact on Dickson

At his sentencing hearing, Eric Sutton showed no remorse. He was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole, ensuring that he would never again harm another individual. The Chilton family finally found some solace in knowing that their loved one had received justice.

Selena Chilton's murder cast a long shadow over Dickson, Tennessee. It reminded the community of the tragic reality that danger can sometimes lurk in the most unsuspecting places. However, her memory lives on through the love and determination of her family and friends, who continue to honor her legacy by advocating for victims of domestic violence and promoting crime awareness initiatives.

Today, Selena Chilton is remembered not as a victim, but as a strong, passionate young woman who touched the lives of those around her. Her story serves as a grim reminder that justice may be slow, but it is always served in the end. Her loved ones take comfort knowing that no matter the passage of time, the community remains steadfast in honoring her memory and seeking a world where no one else must endure the pain and suffering she was forced to withstand.