MTB Earnings Predictions — 2026-07-15

Ticker Report or Guide KPI Prediction Answer Confidence
MTB Report Net operating EPS BEAT pred ~$4.72 vs. cons $4.66 MEDIUM
MTB Report Revenue (TE NII + fees) BEAT pred ~$2.48B vs. cons $2.46B MEDIUM
MTB Report Average CRE loan balances (the 'show-me' inflection) IN-LINE pred ~$23.4B vs. cons ~$23.5B LOW
MTB Guide FY26 Net interest income guide UNCHANGED guide ~$7.2–7.35B (bottom half) vs. cons ~$7.28B (FY26) MEDIUM
MTB Guide FY26 Fee income guide BETTER guide ~$2.75B (top of/above range) vs. cons ~$2.70B (FY26) MEDIUM
MTB Guide NIM trajectory UNCHANGED guide ~3.70% (high-3.60s) vs. cons ~3.68% (Q2/2H'26) MEDIUM
MTB Guide Q2 buyback pace / CET1 UNCHANGED guide CET1 ~10.1% (toward 10% floor) vs. cons ~10.2% (Q2'26) MEDIUM
MTB Guide Net charge-offs / credit BETTER guide ~30bps vs. cons ~33bps (Q2'26 NCOs) MEDIUM
MTB Return Day-1 residual (stock − beta × S&P 500) -1.5% LOW
MTB Return 5-day cumulative residual -2.5% (FADE) A modest, widely-expected EPS/revenue beat is unlikely to satisfy a name up ~19% YTD sitting at all-time highs with elevated positioning; unless CRE clearly inflects positive and NIM holds well above the high-3.60s guide, the print is a 'sell-the-news' setup. Management's conservative out-period math — NII trending to the bottom half of the range and NIM guided to give back to high-3.60s — implies flat-to-lower forward NII estimates even after a headline beat, so out-quarter EPS revisions drift down. That out-period drag, plus rich valuation, pulls the stock lower over the week (fade), partially cushioned by a constructive bank-tape read-across (JPM/WFC beats) and the fee-guide raise. LOW