PGR Earnings Predictions — 2026-08-04

Ticker Report or Guide KPI Prediction Answer Confidence
PGR Report 2Q26 diluted EPS BEAT pred ~$5.67 vs. cons $4.73 HIGH
PGR Report 2Q26 companywide combined ratio MISS pred ~87.3 vs. cons 86.2 HIGH
PGR Report June total policies in force BEAT pred ~40.09M vs. cons 39.50M HIGH
PGR Guide Implied 2H26 underwriting margin / combined-ratio outlook LOWER guide ~10.0% underwriting margin vs. cons 11.0% (2H26) MEDIUM
PGR Guide Personal-auto net rate-action outlook LOWER guide ~-1.0% net rate change vs. cons +1.0% (2H26) MEDIUM
PGR Guide Personal-auto policy-life-expectancy trend LOWER guide ~-8.0% YoY vs. cons -4.0% YoY (2H26) MEDIUM
PGR Return Day-1 residual (stock − beta × S&P 500) -1.8% MEDIUM
PGR Return 5-day cumulative residual -3.5% (FOLLOW-THROUGH) The EPS and policy-count beat is already reported, leaving the call to validate a weaker out-period setup: ~10.0% implied 2H underwriting margin versus ~11.0% consensus and ~-1.0% rate action versus +1.0% consensus. Confirmation of softer retention and continued severity/advertising pressure should pull forward EPS and underwriting estimates lower after the call rather than support a relief bounce. MEDIUM