{"componentChunkName":"component---src-templates-category-js","path":"/en/opinions/index.html","result":{"pageContext":{"pageParameters":{"isPreview":false,"isMirror":true,"delay_to_show_donate_popup_seconds":7,"about_page":false,"games_page":true,"games_page_link_in_header":false,"donate_popup_show_ru":true,"donate_popup_title_ru":"Без вас — нас не будет","donate_popup_content_ru":"Помогите нам добывать и рассказывать важные истории. Участие каждого — важно!","donate_popup_show_en":true,"donate_popup_title_en":"We can’t do it alone!","donate_popup_content_en":"Help us uncover and share the stories that matter. Every contribution makes a difference","display_regular_donors_banner":false,"showPatreonMethod":true,"useNewMaterialDonationBanner":true,"new_donations_page_design":true,"donations_popup_variants":{"ru":[{"id":"kc19b","title":"Сохраните журналистику для людей в России ","subtitle":"Читают нас прежде всего люди в России, но будущее «Важных историй» зависит от тех, кто живет за пределами страны. Поддержите нас ежемесячным донатом — сохраните независимую журналистику для ваших близких, которые остаются в России.","is_active":true,"background":"linear-gradient(10deg, #421f20 5%, #994146)"},{"id":"33tc9","title":"У пропаганды есть миллиарды из бюджета. У нас — только вы","subtitle":"Перемены возможны, если независимые от власти журналисты продолжают свою работу день за днем, год за годом. Мы рассказываем важные истории уже шесть лет. Помогите нам продолжать.","is_active":true,"background":"linear-gradient(10deg, #421f20 5%, #994146)"}],"en":[{"id":"nj1py","title":"Important stories don’t tell themselves","subtitle":"Independent journalism comes at a cost. We answer to no owners or advertisers — only to you, our readers.  Your ongoing support allows us to keep exposing the truth. Without you, we won’t be here.","is_active":true,"background":"linear-gradient(10deg, #421f20 5%, #994146)"},{"id":"xdfc1","title":"Help us outlast the Kremlin censorship","subtitle":"Censorship lose to journalism that keeps showing up, year after year. Monthly donors are what make that possible","is_active":true,"background":"linear-gradient(10deg, #421f20 5%, #994146)"},{"id":"ck121","title":"State propaganda has billions to spend. We have only you to rely on","subtitle":"Change happens when independent journalists keep showing up — day after day, year after year. Six years in, we're still showing up. Help us keep going with a monthly donation.","is_active":true,"background":"linear-gradient(10deg, #421f20 5%, #994146)"}]},"feedback_page":true,"donorsCount":0,"showAuthorsRequestAfterMaterial":true,"radioPage":true,"radioExists":{"ru":true,"en":false},"singlePlaylistPath":{"ru":"/radio/2025/12/22/razgovori-ovazhnikh/index.html"},"with_bookmarks":true,"news_feed":true,"news_feed_skeleton":false,"news_page_redesign":true,"with_topics":true,"materials_topics":false,"topics_page":true,"with_pdf_share":false,"with_native_share":false,"preferred_source_page":true,"charon_new_form":true,"preferred_source_promos":true,"charon_en_page":true},"materials":[{"id":10944,"header":"Is Putin Going to Attack Europe?","_path":"/en/opinions/2026/10/09/is-putin-going-to-attack-europe/","lead":"This scenario seems not just likely, but alarmingly obvious, according to IStories founder Roman Anin","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4d838a3c3c8e45398488fad310f77c02-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Vladimir Putin inspecting drones at the Chebarkul training ground in the Chelyabinsk Oblast. Photo: Alexander Kazakov / Sputnik / IMAGO / SNA / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2026-10-09","created_at_date_time":"2026-10-08T20:16:53.282Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":5,"first_name":"Роман","last_name":"Анин","first_name_en":"Roman","last_name_en":"Anin","is_public":true,"_path":"roman-anin","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редактор «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Редактор","position_en":"Editor","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"Putin is preparing to attack Europe in the coming months, EU leaders and intelligence chiefs are warning. As recently as last September, among those speaking of a Russian attack were the Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk, the French President Emmanuel Macron and intelligence officials from Germany, the Czech Republic, Latvia, Sweden, Denmark, the US and other Western countries.\n\n\nFor his part, Putin, speaking at the Valdai Forum on October 1, once again threatened the West with the use of nuclear weapons in the event of an attack on Kaliningrad . This statement sounded as though he was warning Europe in advance not to even consider isolating the exclave as a possible response to Russian hybrid attacks.\n\nThe number, the frequency and the intensity of today’s warnings about an impending Russian attack on Europe are comparable to the accumulated signals preceding the invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. Does this mean that a new escalation is inevitable?\n\nOn the one hand, the very idea that Putin is seriously intending to start a war with NATO seems implausible. But the idea that he would send tank columns towards Kyiv seemed equally crazy five years ago. And yet he did.\n\nOn the other hand, there are many sceptics who perceive the numerous reports of an imminent Russian attack on the EU as either European alarmism or a Russian psyop aimed at intimidating the West and undermining its support for Ukraine.\n\nAt first glance, the arguments put forward by the sceptics sound convincing:\n\nthe West’s economic and military potential is incomparably greater than that of Russia. Given that in four and a half years of war Russia has still not managed to capture the village of Mala Tokmachka , how can it possibly compete with NATO?\n\naccording to Ukraine’s General Staff, throughout the war Russia’s forces have lost more than one and a half million personnel (killed or wounded), as well as over 12,000 tanks, 25,000 armoured fighting vehicles, 50,000 artillery systems, around 800 aircraft and helicopters, as well as a third of its strategic air force and a third of the Black Sea Fleet;\n\nRussia’s stagnating economy is unlikely to withstand the costs of yet another “special military operation”;\n\na two-front war will only worsen Putin’s already precarious position: if he fails to achieve success on both fronts, he risks losing power.\n\nHowever convincing these arguments may sound, they fail to take several important factors into account.\n\nFirstly, we are not talking about a full-scale invasion of the EU similar to that of Ukraine. European leaders and intelligence chiefs are referring to drone and missile strikes and an intensification of hybrid and sabotage operations, and Russia has sufficient forces and resources for this.\n\nSecondly, whatever military capabilities NATO may possess, the question remains of how determinedly and collectively the Alliance is prepared to respond to Russia’s threats.\n\nThirdly, over the course of its war against Ukraine the Russian army has not just suffered losses, but also gained invaluable experience. The importance of such experience has already been demonstrated on several occasions during the joint NATO–Ukraine training exercises where Ukrainian drone operators have been defeating entire NATO brigades. The Russian army has drone operators that are similarly well-trained.\n\nAnd, finally, before asking whether Putin is capable of succeeding in a confrontation against NATO, it is worth considering what is understood by “succeeding.” By all accounts, the Kremlin is not aiming for deep tank breakthroughs or taking over huge areas of Western countries’ territories. “The aim will be to weaken NATO’s integrity as a whole and, above all, to convince its members that Article 5 is more theoretical than practical,” Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk warned. Referring to European politicians, he said that no one is “going to die for Latvia or Lithuania.” According to Tusk, Russia will use repeated incidents designed to erode confidence in the alliance without ever quite triggering a unified response.  \n\nIn my view, today such a scenario seems not just likely, but alarmingly obvious. Not only because of the reasons listed above — although each of them is undoubtedly significant — but rather because Putin appears to have no other options (acceptable for him) left for retaining his power. It’s not an external objective, but one inside Russia that I would describe as the main one for any potential Russian aggression against Europe.\n\nAll autocracies share a common vulnerability: the leading figure. As long as the leader is strong and successful, the political system can be highly efficient: no voting, no negotiations, no disputes and no doubts — everything is subordinated to the vision of the leader, whose orders are carried out without delay or objection. But as soon as the autocrat begins to lose power or, what is worse, suffer defeats, the system built around this figure falls into a state of imbalance.\n\nAll this applies to Russia as well. Putin’s regime is a syndicate run by the KGB and the criminals, which operates by the underworld’s rules. The power is divided amongst silovik clans that are free to plunder, kill and, in essence, commit any kind of atrocities as long as they remain loyal to the leader and devoted to his course, which means supporting the genocide of Ukrainians and the (yet) undeclared war against the West — in word and deed. Putin is the big boss of this criminal syndicate, the capo di tutti capi, the one to whom the clan leaders would go to pay their respects so that he could settle their disputes with a single nod.\n\nBut in the fifth year of the war, Russia’s big boss found himself in a position more vulnerable than ever. Even the “silent majority” don't believe the mantra that “the special military operation is going according to plan” any longer, let alone the security forces leadership and the top officials. No one understands what the plan is or where we’re heading next either. More and more of the Russian government gang’s members are beginning to suspect that there is no plan as such — only the leader’s maniacal conviction that “we’ll push them to their end,” because “we are Russians, and God is with us.”\nPutin is increasingly and ever more frequently coming across as a delusional old man. One day he is bragging of having captured Kupyansk or a “record” amount of land, and the next one — of having surrounded “record” numbers of Ukrainian soldiers, all of it meanwhile the Russian horde has been losing 30,000–40,000 soldiers killed or wounded every month, unable to seize the cursed Tokmachka and other settlements in the Donbas for five years now. Unable to achieve his objectives by military means, Putin has unleashed his fury on the civilian population of Ukraine and resorts to bombing schools, universities, shopping centres, the sewage systems and the energy infrastructure of Kyiv, Kharkiv, Odesa and other Ukrainian cities round the clock, in the hope of freezing and depriving children, the elderly and all the civilians of water, communications and food.\n\nThe history of warfare shows that terrorising the civilian population does not help to achieve military objectives and results in failure more often than not. But Putin’s knowledge of history is limited to the Polovtsians and the Pechenegs , so how could he possibly know that the genocide he has orchestrated will rather serve to cement his name once and for all amongst the most despised scum of the human race, alongside Chikatilo, Hitler, Stalin and other mass murderers of the defenceless?\n\nWhen a gang leader becomes a scorned laughing stock, he quickly loses his power. Not necessarily by a violent coup (although such a scenario is entirely plausible, given the heightened tensions between Russia’s ruling clans and the fact that many of those have their own private armies); the more likely outcome is the loss of that element — intangible yet extremely important in any political system, especially in an autocracy — as the magic of power. When no one listens to what the leader is muttering; when no one believes what he promises; when, instead of the awe-struck terror he evokes a condescending smirk, his system crumbles under silent sabotage like a house of cards — much like in the late Soviet Union, where citizens would pretend to work whilst the authorities would pretend to pay them.\n\nIn such a situation, in order to retain (at least temporarily) their power, most mob bosses tend to resort to violence — showy violence, preferably. If we’re talking about a small gang, similar to Tony Soprano’s, it’s enough to pick a young, strong bodyguard nicknamed “Muscles Marinara” and beat him to the ground in front of the other gang members beginning to lose respect for the leader: not to let them forget who the “alpha male” is.\n\nIn the case of a government gang, especially as large as Russia's one, everything is more complicated, but the principle remains the same. Putin needs a new wave of violence to stay in power: violence both against those in his inner circle daring to say something inappropriate in a private conversation (and it doesn’t matter whether such a conversation would actually take place; what matters is whose name the leader underlines on his list) and against “the enemies of the Russian people”: in this case, it will be the FSB operatives across Russia who will designate the enemies and underline the names at their own discretion.\n\nAnother difference between the mob in power and a street gang is that a more widespread violence requires extensive powers and, as Russia’s mob boss puts it, “action” . A war with NATO could become such 'action’ which would allow Putin to divert attention from his setbacks in Ukraine, expand the security and intelligence services authority, isolate the country and increase repression. He believes he will be able to wage this missile, drone and sabotage acts war against the West long enough until the weary Western public ends up electing Russia’s far-right allies. Unfortunately, as the September elections in Germany and opinion polls in France are showing, this part of the plan has a realistic basis and might come to pass quite soon.\nIf one looks at this scenario from Putin's perspective, he stands to lose very little:\n\nthe sanctions pressure potential has been exhausted; Russia is already the most sanctioned country in the world, and its economy is entirely dependent on China;\n\nEurope is unlikely to dare to invade Russia; in the worst-case scenario for Putin, NATO might respond to hybrid attacks and drone strikes with identical strikes, which is something the Russian population has long become accustomed to;\n\nblocking Kaliningrad or the Baltic Sea would perhaps be the most painful potential response, which is why Putin is already warning against it, using his nuclear threats: it remains to be seen whether Europe believes them or they are dismissed as yet another bluff.\n\nBut what about the negotiations and the “deal of the century” with the Americans? This scenario strikes me as far less likely.\n\nFirstly, we mustn't forget that prior to the invasion of Ukraine Putin issued an ultimatum to NATO, demanding that the alliance’s infrastructure be withdrawn to the 1997 borders (meaning a withdrawal from Poland, the Czech Republic, Hungary, Romania, Bulgaria, Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania). It is already clear that the Napoleonic ambitions of the Russian big boss have ended in a spectacular failure; however, this by no means implies that he has abandoned them, and certainly not for the sake of a deal with the Americans. He wouldn’t have started all this “action” in the first place otherwise.\n\nSecondly, the Kremlin obviously follows American news and is well aware that Donald Trump’s approval ratings are hitting all-time lows and that his Republican Party is highly likely to suffer a crushing defeat in the upcoming November midterms. Trump will then lose much of his leverage, and his initiatives will be paralyzed by the Democrats.\n\nThat is why Russia’s mob boss realizes that the American wheeler-dealer’s words are worthless: all the papers he signs today will be revoked tomorrow.\n\nWhich in the logic of Putin means there is only one path left — the escalation of violence both within Russia and beyond its borders.","blocks":[{"data":"Putin is preparing to attack Europe in the coming months, EU leaders and intelligence chiefs are warning. As recently as last September, among those speaking of a Russian attack were the Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk, the French President Emmanuel Macron and intelligence officials from Germany, the Czech Republic, Latvia, Sweden, Denmark, the US and other Western countries.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19503,"data":{"block":"<p>September 17: Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk told<a href=\"https://www.reuters.com/world/poland-ends-alert-after-jets-scrambled-sirens-sound-russia-strikes-western-2026-09-17/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> the parliament </a>that Russia could attack Ukraine’s European allies with drones and missiles in the coming months and try to pass these strikes off as “accidental.”</p><p><br/></p><p>September 18: “In recent weeks, the Russian hybrid threat against Europeans and against France has intensified,” <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cm2dw1w9d3yjo\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">said </a>French President Emmanuel Macron.</p><p><br/></p><p>September 20: Russia may attempt to test NATO’s resilience “in months, not years,” head of the Czech counter-intelligence agency BIS Michal Koudelka <a href=\"https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/sep/20/baltic-spy-chiefs-warn-moscow-is-preparing-for-more-decisive-action-in-europe\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">told </a>The Guardian.</p><p><br/></p><p>September 24: Russia may launch a limited attack on a NATO country within months, Danish military intelligence <a href=\"https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/sep/24/russia-could-attack-a-nato-country-within-months-danish-intelligence-says\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">warned</a>, noting such a move would be “<a href=\"https://kyivindependent.com/denmark-warns-russia-could-escalate-hybrid-attacks-against-nato-in-coming-months/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">desperate</a>” on Russia’s part.</p><p><br/></p><p>September 30: “There will be more hybrid threat actions in the next few months. It will be a dark winter for Europe,” Belgian defence minister Theo Franken <a href=\"https://www.euronews.com/2026/09/30/belgian-minister-theo-francken-warns-europe-everything-has-to-go-faster-on-defence\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">stated</a>.</p>","header":"Warnings timeline","content":[{"insert":"September 17: Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk told"},{"insert":" the parliament ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.reuters.com/world/poland-ends-alert-after-jets-scrambled-sirens-sound-russia-strikes-western-2026-09-17/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"that Russia could attack Ukraine’s European allies with drones and missiles in the coming months and try to pass these strikes off as “accidental.”\n\nSeptember 18: “In recent weeks, the Russian hybrid threat against Europeans and against France has intensified,” "},{"insert":"said ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cm2dw1w9d3yjo","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"French President Emmanuel Macron.\n\nSeptember 20: Russia may attempt to test NATO’s resilience “in months, not years,” head of the Czech counter-intelligence agency BIS Michal Koudelka "},{"insert":"told ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/sep/20/baltic-spy-chiefs-warn-moscow-is-preparing-for-more-decisive-action-in-europe","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"The Guardian.\n\nSeptember 24: Russia may launch a limited attack on a NATO country within months, Danish military intelligence "},{"insert":"warned","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/sep/24/russia-could-attack-a-nato-country-within-months-danish-intelligence-says","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":", noting such a move would be “"},{"insert":"desperate","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://kyivindependent.com/denmark-warns-russia-could-escalate-hybrid-attacks-against-nato-in-coming-months/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"” on Russia’s part.\n\nSeptember 30: “There will be more hybrid threat actions in the next few months. It will be a dark winter for Europe,” Belgian defence minister Theo Franken "},{"insert":"stated","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.euronews.com/2026/09/30/belgian-minister-theo-francken-warns-europe-everything-has-to-go-faster-on-defence","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":".\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"For his part, Putin, speaking at the Valdai Forum on October 1, once again <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cqg7k7v499jjo\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">threatened </a>the West with the use of nuclear weapons in the event of an attack on Kaliningrad <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"a Russian exclave region wedged between NATO and EU members\"></span>. This statement sounded as though he was warning Europe in advance not to even consider isolating the exclave as a possible response to Russian hybrid attacks.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The number, the frequency and the intensity of today’s warnings about an impending Russian attack on Europe are comparable to the accumulated signals preceding the invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. Does this mean that a new escalation is inevitable?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"On the one hand, the very idea that Putin is seriously intending to start a war with NATO seems implausible. But the idea that he would send tank columns towards Kyiv seemed equally crazy five years ago. And yet he did.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"On the other hand, there are many sceptics who perceive the numerous reports of an imminent Russian attack on the EU as either European alarmism or a Russian psyop aimed at intimidating the West and undermining its support for Ukraine.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At first glance, the arguments put forward by the sceptics sound convincing:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li>the West’s economic and military potential is incomparably greater than that of Russia. Given that in four and a half years of war Russia has still not managed to capture the village of Mala Tokmachka <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"as the Ukrainian defence of this small village has lasted over 1,600 days, its name became associated with the gap between Russia's military ambitions and its actual capabilities among both Russian and Ukrainian sources\"></span>, how can it possibly compete with NATO?</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<li>according to Ukraine’s <a href=\"https://www.zsu.gov.ua/en/estimated-enemy-losses\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">General Staff</a>, throughout the war Russia’s forces have lost more than one and a half million personnel (killed or wounded), as well as over 12,000 tanks, 25,000 armoured fighting vehicles, 50,000 artillery systems, around 800 aircraft and helicopters, as well as a third of its strategic air force and a third of the Black Sea Fleet;</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<li>Russia’s stagnating economy is unlikely to withstand the costs of yet another “special military operation”;</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<li>a two-front war will only worsen Putin’s already precarious position: if he fails to achieve success on both fronts, he risks losing power.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"However convincing these arguments may sound, they fail to take several important factors into account.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Firstly, we are not talking about a full-scale invasion of the EU similar to that of Ukraine. European leaders and intelligence chiefs are referring to drone and missile strikes and an intensification of hybrid and sabotage operations, and Russia has sufficient forces and resources for this.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Secondly, whatever military capabilities NATO may possess, the question remains of how determinedly and collectively the Alliance is prepared to respond to Russia’s threats.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Thirdly, over the course of its war against Ukraine the Russian army has not just suffered losses, but also gained invaluable experience. The importance of such experience has already been demonstrated on several occasions during the joint NATO–Ukraine training exercises where Ukrainian drone operators have been <a href=\"https://www.wsj.com/politics/national-security/u-s-and-ukrainian-forces-went-head-to-head-in-an-exercise-ukraines-drones-won-cc3663d5\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">defeating </a>entire NATO brigades. The Russian army has drone operators that are similarly well-trained.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"And, finally, before asking whether Putin is capable of succeeding in a confrontation against NATO, it is worth considering what is understood by “succeeding.” By all accounts, the Kremlin is not aiming for deep tank breakthroughs or taking over huge areas of Western countries’ territories. “The aim will be to weaken NATO’s integrity as a whole and, above all, to convince its members that Article 5 is more theoretical than practical,” Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk <a href=\"https://www.politico.eu/article/donald-tusk-warns-accidental-russian-strikes-against-ukraines-allies-fall-and-winter/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">warned</a>. Referring to European politicians, he said that no one is “going to die for Latvia or Lithuania.” According to Tusk, Russia will use repeated incidents designed to erode confidence in the alliance without ever quite triggering a unified response.&nbsp;&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In my view, today such a scenario seems not just likely, but alarmingly obvious. Not only because of the reasons listed above — although each of them is undoubtedly significant — but rather because Putin appears to have no other options (acceptable for him) left for retaining his power. It’s not an external objective, but one inside Russia that I would describe as the main one for any potential Russian aggression against Europe.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"All autocracies share a common vulnerability: the leading figure. As long as the leader is strong and successful, the political system can be highly efficient: no voting, no negotiations, no disputes and no doubts — everything is subordinated to the vision of the leader, whose orders are carried out without delay or objection. But as soon as the autocrat begins to lose power or, what is worse, suffer defeats, the system built around this figure falls into a state of imbalance.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"All this applies to Russia as well. Putin’s regime is a syndicate run by the KGB and the criminals, which operates by the underworld’s rules. The power is divided amongst silovik clans that are free to plunder, kill and, in essence, commit any kind of atrocities as long as they remain loyal to the leader and devoted to his course, which means supporting the genocide of Ukrainians and the (yet) undeclared war against the West — in word and deed. Putin is the big boss of this criminal syndicate, the capo di tutti capi, the one to whom the clan leaders would go to pay their respects so that he could settle their disputes with a single nod.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But in the fifth year of the war, Russia’s big boss found himself in a position more vulnerable than ever. Even the “silent majority” don't believe the mantra that “the special military operation is going according to plan” any longer, let alone the security forces leadership and the top officials. No one understands what the plan is or where we’re heading next either. More and more of the Russian government gang’s members are beginning to suspect that there is no plan as such — only the leader’s maniacal conviction that “we’ll push them to their end,” because “we are Russians, and God is with us.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19504,"data":{"header":"It’s not an external objective, but one inside Russia that I would describe as the main one for any potential Russian aggression against Europe"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"Putin is increasingly and ever more frequently coming across as a delusional old man. One day he is bragging of having captured <a href=\"http://gazeta.ru/auth/sso.shtml?origin=/politics/news/2025/12/19/27452677.shtml\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Kupyansk </a>or a “record” <a href=\"https://newsukraine.rbc.ua/news/putin-s-battlefield-claims-are-so-unrealistic-1791009066.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">amount of land</a>, and the next one — of having surrounded “record” <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/politics/19/12/2025/694513c59a794701bbfae145?utm_referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com%2F\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">numbers </a>of Ukrainian soldiers, all of it meanwhile the Russian horde has been losing 30,000–40,000 soldiers killed or wounded every month, unable to seize the cursed Tokmachka and other settlements in the Donbas for five years now. Unable to achieve his objectives by military means, Putin has unleashed his fury on the civilian population of Ukraine and resorts to bombing schools, universities, shopping centres, the sewage systems and the energy infrastructure of Kyiv, Kharkiv, Odesa and other Ukrainian cities round the clock, in the hope of freezing and depriving children, the elderly and all the civilians of water, communications and food.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The history of warfare shows that terrorising the civilian population does not help to achieve military objectives and results in failure more often than not. But Putin’s knowledge of history is limited to the Polovtsians and the Pechenegs <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"Putin’s obsession with the medieval history of Russia and its interpretations have become more notable in recent years\"></span>, so how could he possibly know that the genocide he has orchestrated will rather serve to cement his name once and for all amongst the most despised scum of the human race, alongside Chikatilo, Hitler, Stalin and other mass murderers of the defenceless?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"When a gang leader becomes a scorned laughing stock, he quickly loses his power. Not necessarily by a violent coup (although such a scenario is entirely plausible, given the heightened tensions between Russia’s ruling clans and the fact that many of those have their own private armies); the more likely outcome is the loss of that element — intangible yet extremely important in any political system, especially in an autocracy — as the magic of power. When no one listens to what the leader is muttering; when no one believes what he promises; when, instead of the awe-struck terror he evokes a condescending smirk, his system crumbles under silent sabotage like a house of cards — much like in the late Soviet Union, where citizens would pretend to work whilst the authorities would pretend to pay them.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In such a situation, in order to retain (at least temporarily) their power, most mob bosses tend to resort to violence — showy violence, preferably.&nbsp;If we’re talking about a small gang, similar to Tony Soprano’s, it’s enough to pick a young, strong bodyguard nicknamed “Muscles Marinara” and <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HbQFnDPB41I\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">beat him to the ground</a> in front of the other gang members beginning to lose respect for the leader: not to let them forget who the “alpha male” is.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In the case of a government gang, especially as large as Russia's one, everything is more complicated, but the principle remains the same. Putin needs a new wave of violence to stay in power: violence both against those in his inner circle daring to say something inappropriate in a private conversation (and it doesn’t matter whether such a conversation would actually take place; what matters is whose name the leader underlines on his list) and against “the enemies of the Russian people”: in this case, it will be the FSB operatives across Russia who will designate the enemies and underline the names at their own discretion.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Another difference between the mob in power and a street gang is that a more widespread violence requires extensive powers and, as Russia’s mob boss puts it, “action” <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"Putin notably described Russians being presumably bored and needing “action” — an euphemism for war — when the country is stable\"></span>. A war with NATO could become such 'action’ which would allow Putin to divert attention from his setbacks in Ukraine, expand the security and intelligence services authority, isolate the country and increase repression. He believes he will be able to wage this missile, drone and sabotage acts war against the West long enough until the weary Western public ends up electing Russia’s far-right allies. Unfortunately, as the September elections in Germany and opinion polls in France are showing, this part of the plan has a realistic basis and might come to pass quite soon.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"If one looks at this scenario from Putin's perspective, he stands to lose very little:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li>the sanctions pressure potential has been exhausted; Russia is already the most sanctioned country in the world, and its economy is entirely dependent on China;</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<li>Europe is unlikely to dare to invade Russia; in the worst-case scenario for Putin, NATO might respond to hybrid attacks and drone strikes with identical strikes, which is something the Russian population has long become accustomed to;</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<li>blocking Kaliningrad or the Baltic Sea would perhaps be the most painful potential response, which is why Putin is already warning against it, using his nuclear threats: it remains to be seen whether Europe believes them or they are dismissed as yet another bluff.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"But what about the negotiations and the “deal of the century” with the Americans? This scenario strikes me as far less likely.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Firstly, we mustn't forget that prior to the invasion of Ukraine Putin issued an ultimatum to NATO, demanding that the alliance’s infrastructure be withdrawn to the 1997 borders (meaning a withdrawal from Poland, the Czech Republic, Hungary, Romania, Bulgaria, Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania). It is already clear that the Napoleonic ambitions of the Russian big boss have ended in a spectacular failure; however, this by no means implies that he has abandoned them, and certainly not for the sake of a deal with the Americans. He wouldn’t have started all this “action” in the first place otherwise.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Secondly, the Kremlin obviously follows American news and is well aware that Donald Trump’s approval ratings are <a href=\"https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/polls/trump-approval-rating-polls.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">hitting all-time lows</a> and that his Republican Party is highly likely to suffer a crushing defeat in the upcoming November midterms. Trump will then lose much of his leverage, and his initiatives will be paralyzed by the Democrats.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"That is why Russia’s mob boss realizes that the American wheeler-dealer’s words are worthless: all the papers he signs today will be revoked tomorrow.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Which in the logic of Putin means there is only one path left — the escalation of violence both within Russia and beyond its borders.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":10780,"header":"No Miracles at the Elections, But Can We Declare Putin’s Triumph?","_path":"/en/opinions/2026/09/22/no-miracles-at-the-elections-but-can-we-declare-putins-triumph/","lead":"Can the predictable election results tell us anything about the state of Russian society? IStories’ Olga Churakova shares her opinion","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-original.jpg","real_width_1x":599,"real_width_2x":1199,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-original.jpg","real_width_1x":599,"real_width_2x":1199,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":266,"real_height_2x":533},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":266,"real_height_2x":533},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-original.jpg","real_width_1x":299,"real_width_2x":599,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-original.jpg","real_width_1x":299,"real_width_2x":599,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-original.jpg","real_width_1x":199,"real_width_2x":398,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/09901d98e97845cb87a1426242936033-original.jpg","real_width_1x":199,"real_width_2x":398,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Central Election Commission staff at work, September 21, 2026. Photo: TASS via ZUMA Press / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2026-09-22","created_at_date_time":"2026-09-22T13:50:30.121Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":34,"first_name":"Ольга","last_name":"Чуракова","first_name_en":"Olga","last_name_en":"Churakova","is_public":true,"_path":"churakova","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-896x504px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":938,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":526},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-896x504px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":938,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":526},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-688x387px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":938,"real_height_1x":386,"real_height_2x":526},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-688x387px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":938,"real_height_1x":386,"real_height_2x":526},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-416x234px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-416x234px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-336x189px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-336x189px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Авторка отдела расследований","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":null,"ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"Russia’s pre-election summer was quite tense: the Yabloko party  was first allowed to run in the elections and then immediately barred from it, the ruling United Russia party was showing low approval ratings, the public felt anxious, and the opposition in exile finally (although belatedly) teamed up. Despite all of this, no miracles happened — once again.\n\nThe results were predictably boring. After the election weekend, the media has been full of headlines saying that United Russia will form the largest parliamentary faction in the party’s 25-year history. The voter turnout was at 59.32 percent: 62.6 million people cast ballots, which is a ten-year record with nearly 10 million more than in 2021. Russia has been living in the state of full-scale war for more than four years — and in the first parliamentary elections since the war began, people have once again voted for the party of war. What conclusion can we draw from this?\n\nAll of IStories sources in the Russian government say the same thing: holding the election was incredibly difficult — both in Moscow and anywhere else. Officials and political strategists note fatigue and apathy — almost unanimously. “Everything is predictable and even boring,” says one source. “The only impression is, it was hard,” another echoes.\n\nIt’s important to keep this in mind when looking at United Russia’s “triumphant” statistics. Yes, achieving these results would have been a triumph had there been genuine political competition, but in 2026 Russia, it would be surprising for the ruling party not to achieve them. At least it turns out that securing those results was difficult despite the fact that the ruling party had its entire usual arsenal at its disposal: the public sector employees , early voting and electronic voting (allowing for easier election fraud) mechanisms, money and media resources.\n\nThe campaigns of the other parties were subject to strict self-censorship: it was forbidden to talk about what was really weighing on people’s minds, which meant the parties couldn’t distinguish themselves from one another either. Before the election, the New People party  got scared that the real protest electorate would flock to vote for them, so they chose to remain silent on those forbidden issues (such as the war) even though it was precisely from them, a staged Yabloko substitute, that people expected statements from. A source among the authorities says that in the end they had to inflate the numbers of votes New People actually had in order to liven up the election picture: “to make it more interesting.”\n\nAnother source notes that Leonid Slutsky, the LDPR party’s leader, had persuaded his friends in the Kremlin to improve his party’s results as well. CPRF’s results worsened, but it remained the second-largest party in the State Duma. A Just Russia party barely reached the 5 percent threshold and became the laughing stock within the system: why and for what reason did they decide not to finish it off after all?\nAll of this took place against a backdrop of high public anxiety, talks of a new mobilization following the vote, and — let’s not forget this — not a single generous promise made to voters. Given these circumstances, the authorities had to fraud a very significant amount of votes, and they succeeded in doing so. One source explained the Kremlin’s obsession with records in human terms: aside from the fact that all parliamentary parties were instructed to frame a high voter turnout as a sign of “national unity in the face of external threats” and war, Putin simply still likes big numbers. “And does he have many other reasons to be happy at the moment?” the source asked.\n\nDid the 62 million Russians who went to the polling stations under these conditions truly demonstrate support for the current course? It sounds paradoxical, but Russian elections are perhaps the least reliable tool for assessing public sentiment today.\n\nAt the same time, the trendy skepticism toward the very institution of political parties and elections is currently working in the government’s favor rather than against it. Clearly, a portion of the pacifists decided in advance to stay home after Yabloko was removed from the election, while today Russia’s system conveniently relies on both the lack of political competition and the resulting belief that there’s no point in voting: they say elections in Russia are like seasons changing and winter will come regardless of your choice. I’ve personally seen this logic expressed on social media by acquaintances who decided not to vote this time around. \n\nLet’s look for something encouraging — in places where people had the chance to vote without fear: United Russia lost in most centers of the anti-war diaspora. The emigrant community, of course, is not a representative sample of Russian society. But it’s nice to know that when the rules of the game change, different scenarios emerge immediately.\n\nAll of this, of course, is no cause for great optimism. But the reasonable part of those citizens who did show up at the polls on Sunday hardly expected that their ballot would actually determine the composition of the next State Duma. It was rather a matter of getting to “see some like-minded people” once again  Russians must not despair or look away, losing sight of the value of our own vote and renouncing our civil rights, for this is precisely what the authorities remain most interested in. Despair does not free us from our responsibility, and life under dictatorships is usually a long-term struggle.","blocks":[{"data":"Russia’s pre-election summer was quite tense: the Yabloko party <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"Russia’s only remaining anti-war party\"></span> was first allowed to run in the elections and then immediately barred from it, the ruling United Russia party was showing low approval ratings, the public felt anxious, and the opposition in exile finally (although belatedly) teamed up. Despite all of this, no miracles happened — once again.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The results were predictably boring. After the election weekend, the media has been full of headlines saying that United Russia will form the largest parliamentary faction in the party’s 25-year history. The voter turnout was at 59.32 percent: 62.6 million people cast ballots, which is a ten-year record with nearly 10 million more than in 2021. Russia has been living in the state of full-scale war for more than four years — and in the first parliamentary elections since the war began, people have once again voted for the party of war. What conclusion can we draw from this?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"All of IStories sources in the Russian government say the same thing: holding the election was incredibly difficult — both in Moscow and anywhere else. Officials and political strategists note fatigue and apathy —&nbsp;almost unanimously. “Everything is predictable and even boring,” says one source. “The only impression is, it was hard,” another echoes.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It’s important to keep this in mind when looking at United Russia’s “triumphant” statistics. Yes, achieving these results would have been a triumph had there been genuine political competition, but in 2026 Russia, it would be surprising for the ruling party not to achieve them. At least it turns out that securing those results was difficult despite the fact that the ruling party had its entire usual arsenal at its disposal: the public sector employees <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"who are usually sent to vote for the ruling party in an organized manner\"></span>, early voting and electronic voting (<a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2026/09/17/russias-digital-elections-system-creation-and-vulnerabilities-disclosed/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">allowing</a> for easier election fraud) mechanisms, money and media resources.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The campaigns of the other parties were subject to strict self-censorship: it was forbidden to talk about what was really weighing on people’s minds, which meant the parties couldn’t distinguish themselves from one another either. Before the election, the New People party <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"centre-right party founded in 2020 that acts as a Kremlin-approved “systemic opposition” to attract younger and pro-business voters\"></span> got scared that the real protest electorate would flock to vote for them, so they chose to remain silent on those forbidden issues (such as the war) even though it was precisely from them, a staged Yabloko substitute, that people expected statements from. A source among the authorities says that in the end they had to inflate the numbers of votes New People actually had in order to liven up the election picture: “to make it more interesting.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Another source notes that Leonid Slutsky, the LDPR party’s leader, had persuaded his friends in the Kremlin to improve his party’s results as well. CPRF’s results worsened, but it remained the second-largest party in the State Duma. A Just Russia party barely reached the 5 percent threshold and became the laughing stock within the system: why and for what reason did they decide not to finish it off after all?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19337,"data":{"header":"A source among the authorities says that in the end they had to inflate the numbers of votes New People actually had in order to liven up the election picture."},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"All of this took place against a backdrop of high public anxiety, talks of a new mobilization following the vote, and — let’s not forget this — not a single generous promise made to voters. Given these circumstances, the authorities had to fraud a very significant amount of votes, and they succeeded in doing so. One source explained the Kremlin’s obsession with records in human terms: aside from the fact that all parliamentary parties were instructed to frame a high voter turnout as a sign of “national unity in the face of external threats” and war, Putin simply still likes big numbers. “And does he have many other reasons to be happy at the moment?” the source asked.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Did the 62 million Russians who went to the polling stations under these conditions truly demonstrate support for the current course? It sounds paradoxical, but Russian elections are perhaps the least reliable tool for assessing public sentiment today.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At the same time, the trendy skepticism toward the very institution of political parties and elections is currently working in the government’s favor rather than against it. Clearly, a portion of the pacifists decided in advance to stay home after Yabloko was removed from the election, while today Russia’s system conveniently relies on both the lack of political competition and the resulting belief that there’s no point in voting: they say elections in Russia are like seasons changing and winter will come regardless of your choice. I’ve personally seen this logic expressed on social media by acquaintances who decided not to vote this time around.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Let’s look for something encouraging — in places where people had the chance to vote without fear: United Russia lost in most centers of the anti-war diaspora. The emigrant community, of course, is not a representative sample of Russian society. But it’s nice to know that when the rules of the game change, different scenarios emerge immediately.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"All of this, of course, is no cause for great optimism. But the reasonable part of those citizens who did show up at the polls on Sunday hardly expected that their ballot would actually determine the composition of the next State Duma. It was rather a matter of getting to “see some like-minded people” once again <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"several opposition leaders called upon those opposing the government to vote precisely on Sunday at 12 p.m.\"></span> Russians must not despair or look away, losing sight of the value of our own vote and renouncing our civil rights, for this is precisely what the authorities remain most interested in. Despair does not free us from our responsibility, and life under dictatorships is usually a long-term struggle.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":9695,"header":"Putin Promised a “Time of Heroes.” The Kremlin is Giving Them the Cold Shoulder Instead","_path":"/en/opinions/2026/05/19/no-time-for-heroes/","lead":"The Russian authorities face a mounting problem: the participants of the “Special Military Operation” — touted as the nation’s new elite — simply do not fit into the existing political machinery","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ed9ac676e0d49298b86cad72650b9e2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Cover: IStories. Photo: Shamil Zhumatov/Reuters; Ivan Manilov/Wikimedia Commons","created_at_date":"2026-05-19","created_at_date_time":"2026-05-18T12:51:56.030Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":34,"first_name":"Ольга","last_name":"Чуракова","first_name_en":"Olga","last_name_en":"Churakova","is_public":true,"_path":"churakova","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-896x504px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":938,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":526},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-896x504px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":938,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":526},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-688x387px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":938,"real_height_1x":386,"real_height_2x":526},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-688x387px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":938,"real_height_1x":386,"real_height_2x":526},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-416x234px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-416x234px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-336x189px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-336x189px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Авторка отдела расследований","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":null,"ordering":null}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"Ahead of the 2026 State Duma (the lower house of Russia’s parliament) elections — the first since the launch of the full-scale invasion of Ukraine — the Russian authorities are wrestling with a dilemma: they need to usher war veterans into parliament without letting them coalesce into a genuine political force.\n\nSince the invasion began, the Kremlin has spent years cultivating the image of a new elite, signaling that veterans of the “SMO” (Special Military Operation, the official Russian government term for the war in Ukraine) should take their rightful place alongside established technocrats and old-guard politicians. \n\nVladimir Putin has repeatedly hammered this theme, dubbing the military “the real elite” and emphasizing that they are the ones who should “rise to leading positions in the state.” To institutionalize this idea, the government launched the “Time of Heroes” program — a state-sponsored career elevator designed to fast-track yesterday’s soldiers into government posts.\n\nThe 2026 elections were supposed to mark another major milestone for this initiative, but even in the early preparatory stages, a stark reality emerged: integrating the military into the political system en masse simply will not work. This is not merely about electoral risks (will voters actually back SMO veterans?), but about the fact that the political system itself has no idea what to do with them.\n\nAs early as November 2025, according to IStories’ sources within the Kremlin and the State Duma, officials discussed a plan to usher up to 150 war participants into parliament — nearly a third of the entire chamber. However, that ambitious idea was swiftly scrapped. Insiders explained it bluntly: “You can’t bring these people in like that; they’re completely non-systemic.” Consequently, the target was slashed to 50–70 individuals. Now, sources’ estimates have grown even more cautious: the working figure is roughly 30 deputies, despite public declarations from United Russia (the ruling pro-Putin political party) about its desire to seat over 40 veterans in the Duma.\n\nThe prospect of a new bloc of military deputies clearly makes the Kremlin uneasy. Currently, the presidential administration and United Russia are debating exactly how to absorb veterans into the next Duma: should they create dedicated structures for them, or, conversely, disperse them across various committees to dilute their influence and ensure safety? Judging by the guarded commentary from pro-Kremlin political experts, it is glaringly obvious that the authorities are not confident in their ability to control them.\n\nTake, for example, the case of Nikita Gorelov. In October 2024, this mobilized sergeant and sniper became the mayor of Sosnovka, a small village in the Kirov Oblast. He immediately began blowing the whistle on local government corruption, quickly clashing with regional United Russia functionaries. Officials attempted to ship the soldier back to the frontlines, but local residents rallied to his defense. Now imagine thirty such volatile scenarios playing out on the floor of the State Duma.\n\nUnlike the typical careerists from the “Young Guard” (United Russia’s youth wing) or the graduates of Sergei Kiriyenko’s (first deputy chief of staff of the Presidential Administration) management competitions, war veterans simply do not fit into the established matrix of political subservience. According to insiders, they are widely perceived as “uncontrollable” — figures who might demand far more independence than is customary in Russia's tightly scripted political arena. The logic is straightforward: the less consolidated this group remains, the easier it will be to manage them.\n\nThen there is another awkward question: exactly which veterans will the state designate for the Duma? The “veteran” category turns out to be politically murky. Frontline soldiers, rear-echelon officials, mobilized men, contract soldiers, pardoned ex-convicts, combat medics... Voters might reasonably ask: why does one “hero” get a Duma mandate while another is left rotting in the trenches? Furthermore, if these individuals wake up tomorrow and begin to see themselves as a unified political force, what then? Should they be pitted against one another just to ensure they don’t “eat United Russia alive”? This is why the Kremlin faces a dual, contradictory task: it must visibly bring veterans into the halls of power, while simultaneously preventing them from becoming an independent political actor.\n\nThe problem is that even at lower levels of government, the integration of veterans is already floundering. In recent regional elections, many military candidates lost their party primaries. In the Federation Council (the upper house of parliament), new colleagues drawn from the military have been unofficially branded as “black sheep” and mocked for their inability to “string two words together.”\n\nMoreover, despite the high level of societal respect afforded to war participants, there is no reliable public data indicating how this reverence translates into actual votes at the ballot box. For political parties, running a veteran is a gamble that by no means guarantees victory. While parties publicly declare their enthusiasm for nominating SMO veterans, in practice, it seems everyone is searching for backdoor compromises.\n\nSome are relying on party lists, where election outcomes are much easier to control. Others are placing them in single-mandate districts (where voters elect a specific candidate rather than voting for a party list), seemingly banking on the assumption that rival parties will refuse to campaign against “war heroes” out of ideological deference. Ultimately, the goal is performative participation with absolute minimum risk.\n\nAll of this is unfolding against a backdrop of rapidly deteriorating social sentiment. According to VCIOM (Russian Public Opinion Research Center, the state-owned polling agency), the happiness index of Russians in the spring of 2026 plummeted to its lowest level in fifteen years. The authorities are being forced to maneuver carefully: they are already purging overly radical deputies from the public sphere to avoid inflaming domestic tensions. Against this volatile backdrop, the prospect of introducing an unpredictable bloc of veterans suffering from PTSD into the new Duma looks exceptionally risky.\n\nThe Russian authorities have backed themselves into a tight corner of their own making: these “war heroes” are desperately needed as ideological symbols, but they are far too dangerous to be empowered as real political actors. As a result, the Kremlin is once again losing face, quietly retreating from its own fiercely declared principles.","blocks":[{"data":"Ahead of the 2026 State Duma (the lower house of Russia’s parliament) elections — the first since the launch of the full-scale invasion of Ukraine — the Russian authorities are wrestling with a dilemma: they need to usher war veterans into parliament without letting them coalesce into a genuine political force.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Since the invasion began, the Kremlin has spent years cultivating the image of a new elite, signaling that veterans of the “SMO” (Special Military Operation, the official Russian government term for the war in Ukraine) should take their rightful place alongside established technocrats and old-guard politicians. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Vladimir Putin has repeatedly hammered this theme, <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/russia/948380\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">dubbing</a> the military “the real elite” and emphasizing that they are the ones who should “rise to leading positions in the state.” To institutionalize this idea, the government launched the “Time of Heroes” program — a state-sponsored career elevator designed to fast-track yesterday’s soldiers into government posts.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The 2026 elections were supposed to mark another major milestone for this initiative, but even in the early preparatory stages, a stark reality emerged: integrating the military into the political system en masse simply will not work. This is not merely about electoral risks (will voters actually back SMO veterans?), but about the fact that the political system itself has no idea what to do with them.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"As early as November 2025, according to IStories’ sources within the Kremlin and the State Duma, officials <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2025/11/19/how-sergey-kirienko-is-battling-the-siloviki/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">discussed</a> a plan to usher up to 150 war participants into parliament — nearly a third of the entire chamber. However, that ambitious idea was swiftly scrapped. Insiders explained it bluntly: “You can’t bring these people in like that; they’re completely non-systemic.” Consequently, the target was slashed to 50–70 individuals. Now, sources’ estimates have grown even more cautious: the working figure is roughly 30 deputies, despite public <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/politics/08/05/2026/69fc9d429a79475561b320e5?\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">declarations</a> from United Russia (the ruling pro-Putin political party) about its desire to seat over 40 veterans in the Duma.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The prospect of a new bloc of military deputies clearly makes the Kremlin uneasy. Currently, the presidential administration and United Russia are debating exactly how to <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/politics/08/05/2026/69fc9d429a79475561b320e5?\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">absorb</a> veterans into the next Duma: should they create dedicated structures for them, or, conversely, disperse them across various committees to dilute their influence and ensure safety? Judging by the guarded commentary from pro-Kremlin political experts, it is glaringly obvious that the authorities are not confident in their ability to control them.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Take, for example, the case of Nikita Gorelov. In October 2024, this mobilized sergeant and sniper <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/7403725\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">became</a> the mayor of Sosnovka, a small village in the Kirov Oblast. He immediately began blowing the whistle on local government corruption, quickly clashing with regional United Russia functionaries. Officials attempted to ship the soldier back to the frontlines, but local residents rallied to his defense. Now imagine thirty such volatile scenarios playing out on the floor of the State Duma.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Unlike the typical careerists from the “Young Guard” (United Russia’s youth wing) or the graduates of Sergei Kiriyenko’s (first deputy chief of&nbsp;staff of&nbsp;the Presidential Administration) management competitions, war veterans simply do not fit into the established matrix of political subservience. According to insiders, they are widely perceived as “uncontrollable” — figures who might demand far more independence than is customary in Russia's tightly scripted political arena. The logic is straightforward: the less consolidated this group remains, the easier it will be to manage them.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Then there is another awkward question: exactly which veterans will the state designate for the Duma? The “veteran” category turns out to be politically murky. Frontline soldiers, rear-echelon officials, mobilized men, contract soldiers, pardoned ex-convicts, combat medics... Voters might reasonably ask: why does one “hero” get a Duma mandate while another is left rotting in the trenches? Furthermore, if these individuals wake up tomorrow and begin to see themselves as a unified political force, what then? Should they be pitted against one another just to ensure they don’t “eat United Russia alive”? This is why the Kremlin faces a dual, contradictory task: it must visibly bring veterans into the halls of power, while simultaneously preventing them from becoming an independent political actor.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The problem is that even at lower levels of government, the integration of veterans is already floundering. In recent regional elections, many military candidates <a href=\"https://verstka.media/veterany-svo-primeriz-edinaya-rossia\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">lost</a> their party primaries. In the Federation Council (the upper house of parliament), new colleagues drawn from the military have been unofficially <a href=\"https://verstka.media/kak-uchastnikam-voyni-v-ukraine-ne-udaetsia-ustroitsia-vo-vlasti\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">branded</a> as “black sheep” and mocked for their inability to “string two words together.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Moreover, despite the high <a href=\"https://tass.ru/obschestvo/23183765\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">level</a> of societal respect afforded to war participants, there is no reliable public data indicating how this reverence translates into actual votes at the ballot box. For political parties, running a veteran is a gamble that by no means guarantees victory. While parties publicly declare their enthusiasm for nominating SMO veterans, in practice, it seems everyone is searching for backdoor compromises.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Some are relying on party lists, where election outcomes are much easier to control. <a href=\"https://www.ng.ru/politics/2026-04-16/1_9477_elections.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Others</a> are placing them in single-mandate districts (where voters elect a specific candidate rather than voting for a party list), seemingly banking on the assumption that rival parties will refuse to campaign against “war heroes” out of ideological deference. Ultimately, the goal is performative participation with absolute minimum risk.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"All of this is unfolding against a backdrop of rapidly deteriorating social sentiment. According to VCIOM (Russian Public Opinion Research Center, the state-owned polling agency), the happiness index of Russians in the spring of 2026 plummeted to its lowest level in fifteen years. The authorities are being forced to maneuver carefully: they are already <a href=\"https://www.vedomosti.ru/politics/articles/2026/05/12/1196535-gosduma-mozhet-ostatsya-bez-ryada-mediinih-deputatov\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">purging</a> overly radical deputies from the public sphere to avoid inflaming domestic tensions. Against this volatile backdrop, the prospect of introducing an unpredictable bloc of veterans suffering from PTSD into the new Duma looks exceptionally risky.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Russian authorities have backed themselves into a tight corner of their own making: these “war heroes” are desperately needed as ideological symbols, but they are far too dangerous to be empowered as real political actors. As a result, the Kremlin is once again losing face, quietly retreating from its own fiercely declared principles.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":9592,"header":"“Russia Has Two Paths Left”","_path":"/en/opinions/2026/05/04/russia-has-two-paths-left/","lead":"IStories founder Roman Anin on where the emerging war among Russia’s “siloviki“ clans could lead","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8ec4462f2d3d4e6fa3542057ad537167-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Illustration: IStories. Images used: IStories; Ivan Sekretarev / AP Photo; Ramil Sitdikov / Reuters","created_at_date":"2026-05-04","created_at_date_time":"2026-05-03T15:24:59.005Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":5,"first_name":"Роман","last_name":"Анин","first_name_en":"Roman","last_name_en":"Anin","is_public":true,"_path":"roman-anin","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редактор «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Редактор","position_en":"Editor","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"Today, IStories published an intelligence report from a European country, which was provided to the newsroom by a government official from that country who requested anonymity. The document describes the situation in the Kremlin, the growing tensions among security officials due to setbacks in the war with Ukraine, as well as Putin’s increased fear of a possible coup or assassination attempt, which has led to an unprecedented tightening of security measures and an expansion of the Federal Protective Service’s powers. In my view, this is one of the most important pieces of news about Russia in recent times. Here is why.\nIt appears that we are witnessing the transition of the Russian regime into a fundamentally different state. The deadlock in the war in Ukraine, painful Ukrainian drone strikes on oil infrastructure, economic and social problems — all of these factors combined, as IStories has previously written, were bound sooner or later to lead to a struggle among Russia’s “siloviki” clans for the throne of a weakening dictator.\n\nPutin, who himself built this system of power, understands well what awaits him — hence the growing paranoia, the unprecedented isolation from the public and from his own inner circle, and the attempt to create a new oprichnina in the form of the Federal Protective Service, endowed with unlimited coercive powers.\nThis means that in the short-term historical perspective, Russia has two paths left:\n\nThe Iranian path. Putin will succeed in consolidating loyal security services around himself — primarily the FSO and the National Guard — which will form a Russian analogue of Iran’s IRGC. Through unprecedented repression, which will affect broader segments of the population and those who were previously considered untouchable, the dictator will retain power by force. This scenario would also imply further isolation of the country from the internet and the outside world: the oprichnina will not tolerate any critics.\n\nThe Time of Troubles. Historians do not like analogies, but history does not stop reproducing them. The first oprichnina emerged as an attempt by Ivan the Terrible to maintain control over the elites and strengthen autocratic rule in conditions of a prolonged and destructive war and internal crisis. The terror of the oprichnina, economic exhaustion, and devastation led to the Time of Troubles and a civil war. \n\nWhich of these scenarios is more likely in Russia is not so important. What matters is that each of them is highly likely.","blocks":[{"data":"Today, IStories <a href=\"https://www.istories.media/en/stories/2026/05/04/vladimir-putin-fear/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">published</a> an intelligence report from a European country, which was provided to the newsroom by a government official from that country who requested anonymity. The document describes the situation in the Kremlin, the growing tensions among security officials due to setbacks in the war with Ukraine, as well as Putin’s increased fear of a possible coup or assassination attempt, which has led to an unprecedented tightening of security measures and an expansion of the Federal Protective Service’s powers. In my view, this is one of the most important pieces of news about Russia in recent times. Here is why.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18143,"data":{"text":"We can’t survive without your support","title":"Help us keep telling important stories","buttonText":"Donate"},"category":"donate-embed"},"type":"donate-embed"},{"data":"It appears that we are witnessing the transition of the Russian regime into a fundamentally different state. The deadlock in the war in Ukraine, painful Ukrainian drone strikes on oil infrastructure, economic and social problems — all of these factors combined, as IStories has previously <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/opinions/2023/01/09/in-russia-a-clan-war-for-putins-throne-has-begun-who-will-win/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">written</a>, were bound sooner or later to lead to a struggle among Russia’s “siloviki” clans for the throne of a weakening dictator.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Putin, who himself built this system of power, understands well what awaits him — hence the growing paranoia, the unprecedented isolation from the public and from his own inner circle, and the attempt to create a new oprichnina in the form of the Federal Protective Service, endowed with unlimited coercive powers.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This means that in the short-term historical perspective, Russia has two paths left:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li>The Iranian path. Putin will succeed in consolidating loyal security services around himself — primarily the FSO and the National Guard — which will form a Russian analogue of Iran’s IRGC. Through unprecedented repression, which will affect broader segments of the population and those who were previously considered untouchable, the dictator will retain power by force. This scenario would also imply further isolation of the country from the internet and the outside world: the oprichnina will not tolerate any critics.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<li>The Time of Troubles. Historians do not like analogies, but history does not stop reproducing them. The first oprichnina emerged as an attempt by Ivan the Terrible to maintain control over the elites and strengthen autocratic rule in conditions of a prolonged and destructive war and internal crisis. The terror of the oprichnina, economic exhaustion, and devastation led to the Time of Troubles and a civil war.&nbsp;</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"Which of these scenarios is more likely in Russia is not so important. What matters is that each of them is highly likely.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":8026,"header":"Russia’s Wartime Economy Pushes Companies Toward a Four-Day Workweek as Civilian Sector Declines","_path":"/en/opinions/2025/08/13/four-day-workweek/","lead":"Despite the defense sector’s continued growth, warnings of an impending recession are getting louder","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d743eb7a710941d6bf0c802d4d489e42-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Minister Maksim Reshetnikov (left) predicts a winter for the Russian economy, while Minister Anton Siluanov looks for a summer (right). Photo: ZUMAPRESS / scanpix / leta","created_at_date":"2025-08-13","created_at_date_time":"2025-08-12T18:19:19.660Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":2517,"last_name":"","first_name":"Редакция","last_name_en":"","first_name_en":"Editors","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"It’s a strange thing: the economy is growing, albeit more slowly than in 2023–2024 (over five months, GDP increased by 1.5% year-on-year), but warnings of an impending recession are getting louder, even ministers are saying so. Unemployment is at a record low — the country lacks enough workers, yet large enterprises are switching employees to a four-day workweek or sending them on leave, and some are even laying people off. How does all this fit together?\n\nExcess day\nAmong those who have introduced a reduced workweek are Cemros, Russia’s largest cement producer, several automotive companies (Kamaz, GAZ, and LiaZ), the Chelyabinsk Electrometallurgical Plant, and Uralasbest. The country’s main automotive group, AvtoVAZ, will consider switching to a four-day week starting at the end of September, and the largest agricultural machinery manufacturer, Rostselmash, switched to it, then later postponed employee vacations from August–September to June. Some engine manufacturers also switched to a four-day week.\n“There is some growth… of hidden unemployment, that is, workers in so-called downtime, employed part-time, or at risk of being laid off,” admitted Vladimir Putin on August 12. According to him, since the beginning of the year, the number of such hidden unemployed has doubled — to 199,000. As usual, he reminded that overall unemployment is at a record low (2%), but “still, we must sense the trends, catch them, and respond accordingly so as not to let the economy overcool.”\nNews of layoffs is becoming more frequent. The Ural Pipe Works carried them out in May, and in July, the authorities of Sverdlovsk Oblast discussed, how to prevent layoffs at regional enterprises and their switch to a reduced workweek due to “changes in the economy.” The number of people employed in retail has fallen over the year — largely because of the mass closure of car dealerships, noted the Central Bank of Russian Federation. The list could go on. According to the Central Bank, over six months, the share of companies planning to reduce staff grew by two-thirds — from 6.9% in January to 11.5% in July.\n\nNo demand\nThe main reason for switching to a reduced workweek is a drop in demand (all the companies mentioned cited this). The war has taken away some of the economy’s resources and at the same time created a huge state order. The mismatch between supply and demand led to accelerated inflation. To slow inflation, the Central Bank raised the key interest rate (now at 18%), making loans and deposits expensive. For people and companies, it became more profitable not to borrow and spend, but to save. As a result, people are putting money into deposits and borrowing less to buy smartphones, refrigerators, to renovate or buy apartments, and business has effectively stopped making new investments and is only continuing those already started.\n\nSales of household appliances and electronics are falling this year; in the first quarter, the number of purchases was 19% lower than a year earlier, and in monetary terms, sales fell by 8%, estimated analysts at T-Bank. Dmitry Alekseev, founder of one of the largest sellers of such goods, the DNS Group, wrote, that he had not seen anything like this in his 30 years in the market: “There have been times when the market fell in units, in dollars, even in real rubles adjusted for inflation. But for the market to fall just in [nominal] rubles, I don’t remember that in all 30 years.” As a result, with the strengthening of the ruble, many household appliances and electronics — for example, smartphones, TVs, vacuum cleaners — have barely changed in price or even become cheaper over the past year, rejoiced Central Bank Chair Elvira Nabiullina.\nRostselmash’s problems are a consequence of, among other things, loan rates, said its co-owner Konstantin Babkin. Such rates are unaffordable for farmers, just as market mortgages are for ordinary people. Babkin called last year the worst for the industry in a decade, but this year, Rostselmash’s sales have fallen by another third, and dealers have accumulated a six-month stock of products.\n\nThe cancellation of preferential (subsidized) mortgages led to a drop in new housing sales: according to data from Dom.RF, in the first half of the year these sales in square meters were 26% lower than a year earlier. This was followed by building materials, furniture, and so on, as well as the metallurgical industry (its main consumer is construction, not the defense industry). Economist Nikolay Kulbaka believes that metallurgists may also switch to a four-day week.\n\nThe same is true in the auto industry. The analytical agency Autostat estimated that there are half a million cars in stock, about 100,000 of them Lada. Hundreds of thousands of unsold foreign cars are a problem for AvtoVAZ: the Chinese are offering huge discounts, comparable to the base price of a new Lada Granta — “it’s impossible to just give cars away,” complained company president Maksim Sokolov. Kamaz director Sergey Kogogin spoke in the same vein: there are about 40,000 Chinese trucks in stock, and “if you go by the current forecast… you could just stop producing altogether, all these trucks are already here.”\nAccording to data from Autostat, 651,000 new passenger cars were sold in Russia over seven months — 24% less than a year earlier. The situation with trucks is even worse: sales of heavy commercial vehicles collapsed by 57%, and medium commercial vehicles — by 44%.\nIt’s better to work less than to work for the warehouse — it’s already overflowing.\n\nIs this a crisis?\nSo, has a crisis begun? It depends on how we look at it.\nAlthough the share of companies planning to cut staff has grown, twice as many plan to hire new employees. 65% of Central Bank–surveyed enterprises expect to maintain their workforce, and 23% predict growth. That’s why unemployment keeps hitting new lows; in May–June, it was 2.2%. Wages continue to rise, though not as quickly as in 2023–2024. In May, the average salary was 14.5% higher than a year earlier; in real terms (adjusted for inflation), that means a 4.2% increase. The same is true for the economy as a whole: it is slowing down, but still growing.\n\nThe problem is that there aren’t enough resources for everyone. In such a situation, for those who are now on the rise to keep growing, someone else must free up resources for them. That is exactly what is happening. The government-aligned think tank Center for Macroeconomic Analysis and Short-Term Forecast (CMASF), discussing investments, points to “not the most favorable structural shift — an outflow of development resources from the domestically oriented civilian private sector.” That’s why in some industries there is still, if not a boom, then growth, while in others problems are snowballing. As a result, there are convincing arguments for almost any assessment of the state of the Russian economy — from “everything is going to hell” to “everything is fine, but we’ve overheated and need to cool down a bit.”\nThe pessimist’s view: “The fact that people are switching their workers to a four-day week means there’s no sales, there’s no point in producing, much less ramping up [production]. That is, production cuts have begun, and this is no longer a soft cooling, it’s already a recession” (Igor Lipsits, Doctor of Economics, in a conversation with IStories).\nThe optimist’s view: “The introduction of a four-day workweek is linked to a temporary drop in demand for the products of certain companies... This reflects a reduction in overheating in the economy. We see no systemic risks; this phenomenon is temporary, there have been similar episodes before… after which companies returned to their standard schedules” (Aleksei Zabotkin, Deputy Chairman of the Central Bank, quoted by Interfax).\n\nTwo worlds\nThese two perspectives reflect the split of the economy into two parts, which are drifting further apart. One, linked to the defense industry, receives budget money and continues to grow rapidly. The other, civilian, is stagnating or already declining.\nThe whole economy is the “average temperature in the hospital.” It is, as was said, cooling: growing, but more and more slowly, which is what the authorities aimed for and what is inevitable, given the exhaustion of resources. The fact that some sectors are slowing down faster is normal, explained Alfa-Bank chief economist Natalia Orlova.\n\nAs a result, according to the results for the half-year, output of “other transport equipment and machinery” grew by 35%, “finished metal products” by 14%, computers, electronic and optical products by 14% and 15% (these are the three main military industries), and workwear by 28%. But production of TVs and washing machines fell by almost 30%, refrigerators by 12%, footwear by 29%, clothing by 3%, and many types of food (groceries and drinks, meat and sausages, fish and canned goods) by 1–3%. Output of building materials (chipboard, tiles, blocks, cement, brick, etc.) fell by 5–20%, various agricultural machinery by 9–14%, passenger cars by 2% (the sector never recovered from the collapse of 2022), and trucks by 24%. “Except for the military part of the economy, everything else is around zero or negative,” summarizes Moscow State University professor Natalia Zubarevich.\nIn the civilian sectors, growth stopped in mid-2023, noted at the start of the year by CMASF. Now it states a decline: excluding “sectors with a dominant presence of defense production,” output in the second quarter was falling by 0.3% per month, and in the civilian sectors it was below last year’s level for five months in a row. In June — by 0.9%.\nBusiness surveys show a sharp slowdown in business activity.\n\nPerhaps this is what Economic Development Minister Maksim Reshetnikov meant when he said at the main Putin economic forum — SPIEF — about recession risks. The statistics show only a slowdown in the economy, but these statistics appear with a lag, he argued: “All our numbers are a rearview mirror. According to current business sentiment, we… already seem to be on the verge of entering a recession.”\nIt’s hard to draw conclusions about such a “dual-circuit” economy, as Orlova put it — the labor market will be the arbiter: the slowdown in economic activity should show up in employment statistics.\nSwitching to a four-day week is an attempt to weather the storm, to hold out until better times, when demand recovers. Maybe the war will end and the burden on the economy from the defense sector will ease. Or the Central Bank will lower the key rate and business will have an easier ride. After every cold spell comes summer, reassured Finance Minister Anton Siluanov.\nBut we still have to get there, and for now, we have to survive somehow. Layoffs are a bad solution. The labor shortage will persist for at least several more years, until 2030 or even longer. If demand recovers, where will automotive and other companies find workers to replace those laid off? Reduced hours, vacations — these are compromises that, in the words of the Central Bank, optimize costs and retain staff during periods of falling demand. Babkin put it this way said: for Rostselmash, this is a way to avoid layoffs and a long recovery if demand for machinery picks up: “I think this is temporary... Our task now… is to get through this period.”","blocks":[{"data":"It’s a strange thing: the economy is growing, albeit more slowly than in 2023–2024 (over five months, GDP <a href=\"https://economy.gov.ru/material/file/d5d39844fe24a05bf07024b91b05af51/o_tekushchey_situacii_v_rossiyskoy_ekonomike_iyun_2025_goda.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">increased</a> by 1.5% year-on-year), but warnings of an impending recession are getting louder, even <a href=\"https://www.vedomosti.ru/economics/news/2025/06/19/1118202-reshetnikov-ekonomika-rossii\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">ministers are saying so</a>. Unemployment is at a record low — the country lacks enough workers, yet large enterprises are switching employees to a four-day workweek or sending them on leave, and some are even laying people off. How does all this fit together?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Excess day","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Among those who have introduced a reduced workweek are Cemros, Russia’s largest cement producer, several automotive companies (Kamaz, GAZ, and LiaZ), the Chelyabinsk Electrometallurgical Plant, and Uralasbest. The country’s main automotive group, AvtoVAZ, <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/russia/1037369\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">will consider</a> switching to a four-day week starting at the end of September, and the largest agricultural machinery manufacturer, Rostselmash, <a href=\"https://161.ru/text/economics/2025/03/27/75268448/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">switched</a> to it, then later <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/business/1026024\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">postponed</a> employee vacations from August–September to June. Some engine manufacturers also <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/7677880?utm_source=yxnews&amp;utm_medium=desktop&amp;utm_referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fdzen.ru%2Fnews%2Finstory%2F2866e9d7-56ee-56fb-8ba9-80328c274116\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">switched</a> to a four-day week.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“There is some growth… of hidden unemployment, that is, workers in so-called downtime, employed part-time, or at risk of being laid off,” <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/business/1041907\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">admitted</a> Vladimir Putin on August 12. According to him, since the beginning of the year, the number of such hidden unemployed has doubled — to 199,000. As usual, he reminded that overall unemployment is at a record low (2%), but “still, we must sense the trends, catch them, and respond accordingly so as not to let the economy overcool.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"News of layoffs is becoming more frequent. The Ural Pipe Works <a href=\"https://www.uralweb.ru/news/society/573002-nujno-ubrat-500-chelovek-novye-podrobnosti-o-massovyh-uvolneniyah-na-uralskom-trubnom-zavode.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">carried them out</a> in May, and in July, the authorities of Sverdlovsk Oblast <a href=\"https://xn--b1ag8a.xn--p1ai/news/31066\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">discussed</a>, how to prevent layoffs at regional enterprises and their switch to a reduced workweek due to “changes in the economy.” The number of people employed in retail has fallen over the year — largely because of the mass closure of car dealerships, <a href=\"https://www.cbr.ru/Collection/Collection/File/57027/0725.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">noted</a> the Central Bank of Russian Federation. The list could go on. According to the Central Bank, over six months, the share of companies planning to reduce staff <a href=\"https://cbr.ru/Collection/Collection/File/57027/0725.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">grew</a> by two-thirds — from 6.9% in January to 11.5% in July.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"No demand","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The main reason for switching to a reduced workweek is a <a href=\"https://cbr.ru/Collection/Collection/File/57027/0725.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">drop</a> in demand (all the companies mentioned cited this). The war has taken away some of the economy’s resources and at the same time created a huge state order. The mismatch between supply and demand led to accelerated inflation. To slow inflation, the Central Bank raised the key interest rate (now at 18%), making loans and deposits expensive. For people and companies, it became more profitable not to borrow and spend, but to save. As a result, people are putting money into deposits and borrowing less to buy smartphones, refrigerators, to renovate or buy apartments, and business has effectively <a href=\"https://www.moscowtimes.ru/2025/06/19/tak-dolgo-prodolzhatsya-ne-mozhet-gref-zayavil-o-polnoi-ostanovke-novih-investitsii-v-rossii-a166615\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">stopped</a> making new investments and is only continuing those already started.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Sales of household appliances and electronics are falling this year; in the first quarter, the number of purchases was 19% lower than a year earlier, and in monetary terms, sales fell by 8%, <a href=\"https://secrets.tbank.ru/trendy/rynok-elektroniki-i-bytovoj-tekhniki/?utm_referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fyandex.ru%2F\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">estimated</a> analysts at T-Bank. Dmitry Alekseev, founder of one of the largest sellers of such goods, the DNS Group, <a href=\"https://t.me/AlekseevDNS/587\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">wrote</a>, that he had not seen anything like this in his 30 years in the market: “There have been times when the market fell in units, in dollars, even in real rubles adjusted for inflation. But for the market to fall just in [nominal] rubles, I don’t remember that in all 30 years.” As a result, with the strengthening of the ruble, many household appliances and electronics — for example, smartphones, TVs, vacuum cleaners — have barely changed in price or even become cheaper over the past year, <a href=\"https://www.cbr.ru/press/event/?id=24685\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">rejoiced</a> Central Bank Chair Elvira Nabiullina.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Rostselmash’s problems are <a href=\"https://161.ru/text/economics/2025/03/27/75268448/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">a consequence</a> of, among other things, loan rates, said its co-owner Konstantin Babkin. Such rates are unaffordable for farmers, just as market mortgages are for ordinary people. Babkin called last year the worst for the industry in a decade, but this year, Rostselmash’s sales have fallen by another third, and dealers <a href=\"https://161.ru/text/economics/2025/03/27/75268448/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">have accumulated</a> a six-month stock of products.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":15921,"data":{"text":"","author":"","header":"There have been times when the market fell in units, in dollars, even in real rubles. But for the market to fall just in [nominal] rubles, I don’t remember"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"The cancellation of preferential (subsidized) mortgages led to a drop in new housing sales: according to <a href=\"unsafe:\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">data</a> from Dom.RF, in the first half of the year these sales in square meters were 26% lower than a year earlier. This was followed by building materials, furniture, and so on, as well as the metallurgical industry (its main consumer is construction, not the defense industry). Economist Nikolay Kulbaka <a href=\"https://news.ru/russia/ekonomist-raskryl-predpriyatiya-kakih-otraslej-perejdut-na-chetyrehdnevku\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">believes</a> that metallurgists may also switch to a four-day week.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The same is true in the auto industry. The analytical agency Autostat <a href=\"https://vpost-media.ru/texts/uspet-do-podorozhaniya\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">estimated</a> that there are half a million cars in stock, about 100,000 of them Lada. Hundreds of thousands of unsold foreign cars are a problem for AvtoVAZ: the Chinese are offering huge discounts, comparable to the base price of a new Lada Granta — “it’s impossible to just give cars away,” <a href=\"https://vpost-media.ru/texts/nevozmozhno-mashinu-prosto-darit\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">complained</a> company president Maksim Sokolov. Kamaz director Sergey Kogogin spoke in the same vein: there are about 40,000 Chinese trucks in stock, and “if you go by the current forecast… you could just stop producing altogether, all these trucks are already here.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to <a href=\"https://www.autostat.ru/press-releases/60578/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">data</a> from Autostat, 651,000 new passenger cars were sold in Russia over seven months — 24% less than a year earlier. The situation with trucks is even worse: sales of heavy commercial vehicles <a href=\"https://www.autostat.ru/news/60586/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">collapsed</a> by 57%, and medium commercial vehicles — <a href=\"https://www.autostat.ru/news/60585/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">by 44%</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It’s better to work less than to work for the warehouse — it’s already overflowing.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Is this a crisis?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"So, has a crisis begun? It depends on how we look at it.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Although the share of companies planning to cut staff has grown, twice as many plan to hire new employees. 65% of Central Bank–surveyed enterprises expect to maintain their workforce, and 23% predict growth. That’s why unemployment keeps hitting new lows; in May–June, it <a href=\"https://rosstat.gov.ru/storage/mediabank/osn-06-2025.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">was</a> 2.2%. Wages continue to rise, though not as quickly as in 2023–2024. In May, the average salary <a href=\"https://rosstat.gov.ru/storage/mediabank/osn-06-2025.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">was</a> 14.5% higher than a year earlier; in real terms (adjusted for inflation), that means a 4.2% increase. The same is true for the economy as a whole: it is slowing down, but still growing.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The problem is that there aren’t enough resources for everyone. In such a situation, for those who are now on the rise to keep growing, someone else must free up resources for them. That is exactly what is happening. The government-aligned think tank Center for Macroeconomic Analysis and Short-Term Forecast (CMASF), discussing investments, <a href=\"http://www.forecast.ru/_ARCHIVE/Mon_13/2025/TT6_2025.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">points</a> to “not the most favorable structural shift — an outflow of development resources from the domestically oriented civilian private sector.” That’s why in some industries there is still, if not a boom, then growth, while in others problems are snowballing. As a result, there are convincing arguments for almost any assessment of the state of the Russian economy — from “everything is going to hell” to “everything is fine, but we’ve overheated and need to cool down a bit.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The pessimist’s view: “The fact that people are switching their workers to a four-day week means there’s no sales, there’s no point in producing, much less ramping up [production]. That is, production cuts have begun, and this is no longer a soft cooling, it’s already a recession” (Igor Lipsits, Doctor of Economics, in a <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/news/2025/08/07/krupnie-rossiiskie-proizvodstva-perevodyat-sotrudnikov-na-nepolnuyu-nedelyu/index.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">conversation</a> with IStories).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The optimist’s view: “The introduction of a four-day workweek is linked to a temporary drop in demand for the products of certain companies... This reflects a reduction in overheating in the economy. We see no systemic risks; this phenomenon is temporary, there have been similar episodes before… after which companies returned to their standard schedules” (Aleksei Zabotkin, Deputy Chairman of the Central Bank, quoted by <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/business/1040336\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Interfax</a>).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Two worlds","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"These two perspectives reflect the split of the economy into two parts, which are drifting further apart. One, linked to the defense industry, receives budget money and continues to grow rapidly. The other, civilian, is stagnating or already declining.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The whole economy is the “average temperature in the hospital.” It is, as was said, cooling: growing, but more and more slowly, which is what the authorities aimed for and what is inevitable, given the exhaustion of resources. The fact that some sectors are slowing down faster is normal, <a href=\"https://guru.nes.ru/actual/udalas-li-myagkaya-posadka-rossijskoj-ekonomiki.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">explained</a> Alfa-Bank chief economist Natalia Orlova.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"As a result, according to <a href=\"https://rosstat.gov.ru/storage/mediabank/110_23-07-2025.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">the results</a> for the half-year, output of “other transport equipment and machinery” grew by 35%, “finished metal products” by 14%, computers, electronic and optical products by 14% and 15% (these are the three main military industries), and workwear by 28%. But production of TVs and washing machines fell by almost 30%, refrigerators by 12%, footwear by 29%, clothing by 3%, and many types of food (groceries and drinks, meat and sausages, fish and canned goods) by 1–3%. Output of building materials (chipboard, tiles, blocks, cement, brick, etc.) fell by 5–20%, various agricultural machinery by 9–14%, passenger cars by 2% (the sector never recovered from the collapse of 2022), and trucks by 24%. “Except for the military part of the economy, everything else is around zero or negative,” <a href=\"https://youtu.be/KajxlOJdes8?t=478\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">summarizes</a> Moscow State University professor Natalia Zubarevich.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In the civilian sectors, growth stopped in mid-2023, <a href=\"http://www.forecast.ru/_ARCHIVE/Analitics/PROM/2025/PR-OTR_2025-02-27.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">noted</a> at the start of the year by CMASF. Now it <a href=\"http://www.forecast.ru/_ARCHIVE/Analitics/PROM/2025/PR-OTR_2025-07-24.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">states</a> a decline: excluding “sectors with a dominant presence of defense production,” output in the second quarter was falling by 0.3% per month, and in the civilian sectors it was below last year’s level for five months in a row. In June — by 0.9%.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Business surveys show a sharp slowdown in business activity.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":15922,"data":{"block":"<ul><li>The business climate indicator calculated by the Central Bank in July <a style=\"background-color:#ffffff\" href=\"https://www.cbr.ru/Collection/Collection/File/57019/0725.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">fell</a> from 3 to 1.5 points (note: above zero means business activity is growing, below means it’s declining). This is the lowest level since October 2022.</li></ul><p><br/></p><ul><li>The PMI Composite index, reflecting activity in industry and services and calculated by S&amp;P Global, has been fluctuating between growth and decline since spring (the threshold is 50 points). In July, it <a href=\"https://www.pmi.spglobal.com/Public/Home/PressRelease/596c1e5562244352a6581381d2ffa6ba\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">dropped</a> to 47.8 points (48.5 in June), mainly due to weak demand and a drop in new orders. This survey records a reduction in employment — but not in manufacturing, in services.</li></ul><p><br/></p><ul><li>The business confidence index calculated by Rosstat in manufacturing <a href=\"https://rosstat.gov.ru/storage/mediabank/115_30-07-2025.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">hit zero</a>: minus 0.3 in May, 0.5 in June, and exactly zero in July. In extraction, it’s been negative since December.</li></ul>","header":"What are these surveys?","content":[{"insert":"The business climate indicator calculated by the Central Bank in July "},{"insert":"fell","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.cbr.ru/Collection/Collection/File/57019/0725.pdf","type":"usual"},"background":"#ffffff"}},{"insert":" from 3 to 1.5 points (note: above zero means business activity is growing, below means it’s declining). This is the lowest level since October 2022."},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"\nThe PMI Composite index, reflecting activity in industry and services and calculated by S&P Global, has been fluctuating between growth and decline since spring (the threshold is 50 points). In July, it "},{"insert":"dropped","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.pmi.spglobal.com/Public/Home/PressRelease/596c1e5562244352a6581381d2ffa6ba","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" to 47.8 points (48.5 in June), mainly due to weak demand and a drop in new orders. This survey records a reduction in employment — but not in manufacturing, in services."},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"\nThe business confidence index calculated by Rosstat in manufacturing "},{"insert":"hit zero","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://rosstat.gov.ru/storage/mediabank/115_30-07-2025.html","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":": minus 0.3 in May, 0.5 in June, and exactly zero in July. In extraction, it’s been negative since December."},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"Perhaps this is what Economic Development Minister Maksim Reshetnikov meant when he <a href=\"https://www.dw.com/ru/glava-minekonomiki-rossia-nahoditsa-na-grani-perehoda-v-recessiu/a-72972482\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">said</a> at the main Putin economic forum — SPIEF — about recession risks. The statistics show only a slowdown in the economy, but these statistics appear with a lag, he argued: “All our numbers are a rearview mirror. According to current business sentiment, we… already seem to be on the verge of entering a recession.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It’s hard to draw conclusions about such a <a href=\"https://www.forbes.ru/finansy/540260-rossijskaa-ekonomika-krizisnoe-tormozenie-ili-prezdevremennaa-panika\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">“dual-circuit”</a> economy, as Orlova put it — the labor market will be the arbiter: the slowdown in economic activity should show up in employment statistics.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Switching to a four-day week is an attempt to weather the storm, to hold out until better times, when demand recovers. Maybe the war will end and the burden on the economy from the defense sector will ease. Or the Central Bank will lower the key rate and business will have an easier ride. After every cold spell comes summer, <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/forumspb/1032005\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reassured</a> Finance Minister Anton Siluanov.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But we still have to get there, and for now, we have to survive somehow. Layoffs are a bad solution. The labor shortage <a href=\"https://www.vedomosti.ru/industry/outlook/news/2024/08/23/1057724-kadrovii-golod-sohranitsya\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">will persist</a> for at least several more years, until 2030 or even longer. If demand recovers, where will automotive and other companies find workers to replace those laid off? Reduced hours, vacations — these are compromises that, in the words of the Central Bank, optimize costs and retain staff during periods of falling demand. Babkin put it this way <a href=\"https://161.ru/text/economics/2025/03/27/75268448/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">said</a>: for Rostselmash, this is a way to avoid layoffs and a long recovery if demand for machinery picks up: “I think this is temporary... Our task now… is to get through this period.”","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":7944,"header":"Why the Current Wave of Nationalization in Russia is More Than Just a Redistribution of Assets","_path":"/en/opinions/2025/07/29/nationalization/","lead":"The Kremlin is shaping a new elite for whom the collapse of the regime would mean personal collapse, argues economist Andrei Yakovlev","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a109ad0058849e3a7f90d9c58428fbd-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Photo: Anatoly Maltsev / EPA / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2025-07-29","created_at_date_time":"2025-07-29T08:08:19.085Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[],"external_authors_list":[{"id":322,"first_name":"Andrei","last_name":"Yakovlev","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"Davis Center for Russian and Eurasian Studies at Harvard University","company_en":null,"company_link":"https://daviscenter.fas.harvard.edu/about/people/andrei-yakovlev","avatar":[],"ordering":1}],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"It is hard to surprise anyone in Russia when something is taken away. After the war began, this became the business of the state. At first, it seemed like a manifestation of a mania for control and an acceleration of the long-declared “nationalization of the elites.” Experts identified several types of businessmen whose assets were confiscated. Most often, three categories were named: “oppositionists” who spoke out against the regime; those who had “lost their connection to the Motherland” — living abroad or holding a second passport; and those who were unlucky enough to own companies not tied to the defense industry, or simply those whose businesses the state considers strategic. In 2023, there were 15, last year — 5, according to Prosecutor General Igor Krasnov.\nIn total, in 2024 the Prosecutor General’s Office transferred property worth nearly 2.4 trillion rubles to the state, reported Krasnov. Recently, the law firm NSP calculated, that the assets seized over the past few years are now worth 3.9 trillion rubles, “which demonstrates the broad scale of nationalization.” There are different ways to count, but it is clear that since about the end of last year, nationalization has been gaining momentum, and anyone can become a victim. One of the latest high-profile cases is Yuzhuralzoloto of Konstantin Strukov, the deputy speaker of the Chelyabinsk Regional Duma, which already during the war, at the end of 2023, held an IPO. News like “the court granted the claim to transfer to the revenue of the Russian Federation…” now appear regularly.\n\nWhat this could mean is explained by Andrei Yakovlev, associate at the Davis Center for Russian and Eurasian Studies at Harvard University, who has long studied Russian elites and the relationship between business and government.\n\nNo arguments with the state\nAfter the Yukos case, for almost 20 years before the war, the redistribution of property mostly looked like “a dispute between economic entities” (this phrase, which became a meme in Russia, was used by Vladimir Putin to describe the takeover of NTV television network from Vladimir Gusinsky in 2001. — IStories): one side would bring in people in uniform and, with their help, take away assets, sharing part of the spoils with them. This was the standard scenario of forceful pressure on business from the mid-2000s until 2022, inclusive.\nThe war added to this the redistribution of assets belonging to foreign companies that had left Russia. In essence, this was a consolidation of the elite base and was done in the interests of those groups on whom the Kremlin now relies and plans to continue relying. Many suffered from sanctions, including those close to Putin, and they needed to be compensated. The assets of departing foreigners made this easiest to do.\nHowever, since the summer of 2023, this process has spread to the assets of Russian owners who, for various reasons, had fewer opportunities to protect themselves. In particular, these were entrepreneurs who did not live in Russia (including due to political pressure) or who left the country after the start of the war. For example, the chemical company Metafrax Chemicals was taken from Seyfeddin Rustamov, who lived in the U.S., the largest pasta factory in Russia, Makfa, from Mikhail Yurevich, and the car dealer Rolf from Sergey Petrov.\nBut as Putin has repeatedly stated, this was not about nationalization. All these assets, as a rule, were then privatized and handed over to “close comrades” on terms favorable to them. Metafrax Chemicals went to Roskhim, a company close to the Rotenberg brothers, Arkady and Boris; Rolf, formerly owned by Sergey Petrov, went to Umar Kremlev, and Makfa was transferred to the management of a structure of the state-owned Rosselkhozbank (which is considered the domain of the Patrushev clan). We’ll see who ends up with it, but the business taken from the French, Danone, was privatized using the company’s own funds by the appointed manager — a nephew of Ramzan Kadyrov.\nIn 2023, the mechanism used to seize property changed. The “dispute between economic entities” was left in the past; now the issue was framed as a threat to Russia’s national security and economic sovereignty due to the actions or inaction of the current owners. The scheme, with such an unchallengeable argument, radically accelerated the process.\n“Disputes between economic entities” could drag on for years, even if the owner was in pretrial detention. A classic example is the Magomedov brothers, whose key asset, Fesco, was taken five years after their arrest, in 2023. When it comes to national security, issues are resolved instantly. From the filing of the lawsuit for the nationalization of Yuzhuralzoloto to the transfer of shares to state ownership, two weeks passed.\n\nThere’s no money, so hang in there!\nWhat is happening now is a logical continuation of the process that began in 2023. But this redistribution of property has significant differences from the model of forceful pressure on business and asset seizures typical of the 2000s or 2010s, when any FSB department head or district prosecutor could take part in a corporate raid. Unlike the previous model, nationalization is a centralized process that requires approval at the very top. The need for such approval to some extent limited the scale of nationalization, but now this process has sharply accelerated due to the objective deterioration of the economic situation.\nUntil mid-2024, the Kremlin had enough money to fully fund the war, cover social obligations — not increasing spending on them, but at least indexing them to inflation — and at the same time provide rents to the elites in the form of various types of state support (in addition to handing out pieces of property). Moreover, the rapid economic growth in 2023–2024 itself created an additional source of rent for the elites.\nLast fall, it became clear that there was no longer enough money for everything. With the budget for 2025–2027, the Kremlin directly stated that its main priority is financing the army and the defense industry: military spending was once again increased — after a 70% rise in 2024. At the end of 2023, Finance Minister Anton Siluanov called the 2024–2026 budget a “victory budget”: we are once again dramatically increasing military spending, but then we’ll be able to cut it back (for 2025, military spending was then planned at 8.5 trillion rubles after 10.8 trillion in 2024, and for the following year, 2026, 7.7 trillion was budgeted). But less than a year passed before the 2025 budget included military spending of 13.5 trillion rubles — with no plans for any significant reduction in 2026 and 2027. In reality, in 2022–2024, actual military spending kept exceeding the plan, but overall economic growth and high oil prices gave the government additional sources of funding.\nSince the end of 2024, the situation has changed. The economy has started to slow down. Part of the rent that came from rapid growth is evaporating. Oil prices have also dropped significantly.\n\nTimes are changing\nBut tensions within the elites are rising. The suicide of the Minister of Transport Roman Starovoyt testifies to the extent of this. People in the bureaucratic elite are genuinely exhausted; they are under stress.\nIt began with the pandemic, 2021 seemed to offer a brief respite, but then the war started — a war for which they were completely unprepared and which they did not want. According to my conversations with people in Moscow, at the start of this year, there were high hopes in the bureaucratic and business elite for Trump — with expectations of at least some normalization of relations with the West. But due to the Kremlin’s hardline stance, these hopes were dashed.\nThe situation in business is no better; there, too, moods could return to those of 2022. Many were unhappy about the war, but when rapid growth began, conversations like those between Iosif Prigozhin and Farhad Akhmedov (both harshly critical of the war) quieted down. Now businessmen realize that the fat years are ending, and they may once again start to ask themselves: what was all this for, and why did we need it?\nFor all their cynicism and opportunism, today’s Russian business elite and bureaucracy are quite competent; these people went through fire and water in the 1990s and 2000s, they understand how to work in the Russian market, they have teams. It was precisely through the efforts of these people that Putin’s system maintained stability not only over the past three years, but also for the previous 20 — for which they received generous compensation. However, within the framework of their informal contract with the Kremlin, these people never signed up to “die” for the country, for Putin, or for an idea. That’s not what they’re about. Now, when the regime no longer has the resources to compensate everyone, such people, who possess their own resources, become a risk factor for the regime.\nAgainst the backdrop of a deteriorating economic situation, the Kremlin needs the Russian elite to be made up of people who may be less competent, but who will stick with Putin to the end, since the collapse of the regime would mean personal collapse for them.\n\nLoans-for-shares auctions 2.0\nThat is why the decision to launch a major redistribution of property now is entirely rational. There is still money in the budget, but the Kremlin is trying to act ahead of the curve. When the economy enters a serious crisis, it will be too late. If, by then, there are still independent players in business with billions in assets and large workforces, and they can, say, make it to the Emirates and strike some kind of deal there, that would be very dangerous for the regime.\nThe seizure of assets can take place, for example, following the logic of “loans-for-shares auctions.” Before the 1996 elections, key assets remaining in state ownership after mass privatization were handed over to entrepreneurs close to the regime for very little money. Everyone involved in this scheme understood: if Boris Yeltsin lost the election and the Communists returned to power, these people would lose the property they had acquired. So they had every incentive to stand behind this government to the end.\nTo repeat such a scheme under current conditions, assets must first be nationalized from those who are weaker or considered unreliable. The May decision by the Constitutional Court created the legal basis for this. The statute of limitations for privatization cases has been abolished: it now starts from the end of the prosecutor’s investigation, which can uncover violations even 30 years old. Under this seemingly legal pretext, property can be seized at will. For example, from one of the oligarchs of the 1990s.\nThe scenario could look like this. The assets of a certain oligarch worth, say, a trillion rubles are nationalized. The state neither gains nor loses from this: these assets have to be managed, which is a headache — the Finance Ministry has said so directly. State managers, like Rostec chief Sergey Chemezov, are more about asking the state for money than bringing in revenue to the budget. So the state will not keep the property; it will be sold — Siluanov has already started talking about a “big privatization.”\nAn asset worth a trillion rubles can be sold to the right hands, for example, for 300 or 500 billion. State banks like Sberbank or VTB will gladly provide loans for this under informal Kremlin guarantees.\nIn the end, a trusted businessman will get the asset for a third or half its value, but will know: if the regime collapses, he will lose this asset (those whose assets are being seized now will have their day of reckoning). Therefore, he has every reason to stick with the regime to the end, while the Kremlin gets several hundred billion rubles for the budget. That is not bad money, and if scaled up, the regime could keep going for a few more years.\n\nElite 2.0\nPutin has proclaimed “veterans of the special military operation” as the new elite, but they will not be the ones participating in such deals. Entrusting such people with the management of large businesses is risky — they could ruin them. Much has already been handed over to “friends” (like the Rotenbergs or the Kovalchuks), but the Kremlin also needs broader “support groups.” And it seems the casting for this is already underway.\nMost likely, the new elite will be drawn from “second-tier” businessmen. They have experience and competence — they created their own more or less successful businesses, but now want access to much larger assets.\nThe price for gaining access will be some public act that cuts off the new owners’ paths to retreat. For example, a speech like the one made at the meeting with Putin by Aleksei Repik, chairman of Business Russia — an association of medium-sized businesses, that very “second tier” (unlike the Russian Union of Industrialists and Entrepreneurs, which represents oligarchic business, and Opora Rossii, which acts on behalf of small business). Never before had someone like Repik spoken to Putin in such terms, not even at the United Russia party congress: his flag-waving patriotism surprised even the journalists of official media. Repik also spoke extremely harshly about the return of foreign companies (let them compensate for damages and create joint ventures where control will be in the hands of new Russian owners of their former assets), proposed raising the personal income tax for Russians who have left the country to 30%, and, one could say, swore an oath: “Vladimir Vladimirovich, you can be absolutely sure: just as 80 years ago, the home front is secure.”\nUsually, if Putin wanted to discuss something serious with business, he would meet with the Russian Union of Industrialists and Entrepreneurs, but this time, for such a “public” conversation, Business Russia was chosen. This meeting took place a day after the Constitutional Court’s decision to abolish the statute of limitations in privatization disputes.\nFigures like Aleksei Repik or Umar Kremlev are the prototypes of the new business elite. It is with such people that the Kremlin will replace the entrepreneurs of the 1990s–2000s — people like Sergey Petrov, who built Rolf from scratch, or Vadim Moshkovich, who created the Rusagro holding.\nSuch an elite will resemble the North Korean one. In North Korea, despite all the repressions carried out by the Kim family in Stalinist fashion, the elite understands: if the regime weakens, reunification with South Korea will become inevitable within two or three steps, and in that scenario, this elite has no chance of retaining any social status. That is why, even during the famine of the 1990s, there was no elite coup. And this is precisely what the Kremlin is now trying to do — to replace the elite of the 1990s–2000s (corrupt and cynical, but not prepared to die with the regime) with people who will have no choice. However, it is far from certain that this will succeed.\n\nThe silence of the elites\nWhen the first wave of nationalization hit in 2023 (with a focus on assets in the chemical industry), there was tension, which was publicly articulated by Russian Union of Industrialists and Entrepreneurs President Alexander Shokhin, Economic Development Minister Maksim Reshetnikov, and Putin’s aide (now deputy head of his administration) Maksim Oreshkin (1, 2, 3). In September 2023, Putin spoke at the Eastern Economic Forum, after which several lawsuits were withdrawn (1, 2).\nThe Kremlin was testing the waters. In 2023, there was still ferment — so they decided to calm things down. Then, at the start of 2024, Putin declared that the elite was not those who filled their pockets in the 1990s, but “warriors and workers.” This no longer caused anxiety — meaning it was possible to go further, as we now see in the Constitutional Court’s decision. When, at the main Putin economic forum, this decision was criticized by State Duma Budget and Taxes Committee Chairman Andrei Makarov, the reaction of the ministers and businessmen present was a heavy silence, and Ksenia Sobchak compared Sberbank’s prestigious breakfast, where this took place, to a “naked party,” for which many Kremlin-loyal show business figures were punished.\nIn other words, the old elite acts as if nothing is happening, even though even not-so-liberal comrades are pointing this out: “Patriotic businessmen really are strange people. They must understand that sooner or later they’ll become food. Like in those stories about prison escapes from the far northern colonies, when the convicts bring along a few extra companions, who are eaten along the way.”\nThe oligarchic business has submitted to the authorities; Vladimir Potanin even said: “Don’t fuss over the client, but follow the course of state policy.” They’ll be “eaten” simply because they are not “native” to the regime. But not all at once, but bit by bit — first, using the examples of Moshkovich or the former owner of the nationalized Domodedovo Airport, Dmitry Kamenshchik, the old oligarchs will be offered to “pay an exit fee”: in the form of sponsoring “patriotic education” programs or direct support for the special military operation. But given the Constitutional Court’s decision, they’ll come for them all the same.\nHowever, the risks of redistribution of property through nationalization affect not only the oligarchs. There are also many thousands of successful large and medium-sized enterprises. The old oligarchs still have administrative “protection” they continue to rely on (in my view — completely in vain). But many independent, not very large companies often have no such “roof.” At the same time, they built their businesses themselves and, unlike the top-tier oligarchs, could well function without this regime.\nIt is difficult to assess the mood in such businesses — you can’t include sensitive topics in officially conducted surveys these days. But at the level of personal conversations, it’s clear that there’s been a sobering up in assessments of prospects and the state of affairs in the economy. The euphoria that was especially noticeable at the end of 2023 — sanctions are nothing, we’re growing, China will help us, we’ll beat everyone and “march to Paris” — has passed. Now, in economic terms, people are seriously discussing all sorts of scenarios, including the worst ones. Also, in personal conversations, very concrete individual “exit strategies” are being discussed — with planned escape routes from the country if everything falls apart.\n\nThe question is whether, in a real crisis, these people will prefer to drop everything or will prove capable of collective action. It’s happened before: during the August 1991 coup, brokers took to the streets and provided material support to the defenders of the White House, and in the spring of 1996, most of business supported Boris Yeltsin. Business by itself can hardly change anything in the political system; such collective action requires coordination — here, the participation of reasonable people from the state is important.\nParadoxically, certain incentives for this are now emerging. In particular, according to my conversations with Moscow acquaintances from the bureaucracy, Roman Starovoyt’s suicide was a shock for them — on his example, capable representatives of the bureaucratic apparatus, on whom the system of state governance objectively depends, began to realize that they are caught between two millstones. On one side is a group that wants to move to a mobilization economy like North Korea. This vector was openly declared a year ago by Far East and Arctic Development Minister Aleksei Chekunkov, connected to Kirill Dmitriev, but the real ideologue of this group is more likely Defense Minister Andrei Belousov. The other group (the Rotenbergs, Kadyrov, Suleyman Kerimov) is pulling the country toward a model of a mafia state. However, in both models, the current competent technocrats who consider themselves the elite will be regarded simply as “expendable material.” And the fact that three deputy prime ministers and six ministers attended Starovoyt’s funeral, I see as a signal of possible changes in the bureaucratic elite.\nUndoubtedly, from such an impulsive demonstration of “solidarity with a comrade” to thoughtful collective action, they still have a long way to go. And in the atmosphere of fear imposed by the Kremlin, it will not be easy for normal people in the state apparatus and in business to make that journey. But the clock is already ticking for them.","blocks":[{"data":"It is hard to surprise anyone in Russia when something is taken away. After the war began, this became the business of the state. At first, it seemed <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/opinions/2024/05/14/kak-rossiiskaya-ekonomika-prisposobilas-k-voine/index.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">like</a> a manifestation of a mania for control and an acceleration of the long-<a href=\"https://lenta.ru/news/2013/03/27/elite/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">declared</a> “nationalization of the elites.” Experts identified several types of businessmen whose assets were confiscated. Most often, three categories were named: “oppositionists” who spoke out against the regime; those who had “lost their connection to the Motherland” — living abroad or holding a second passport; and those who were unlucky enough to own companies not tied to the defense industry, or simply those whose businesses the state considers strategic. In 2023, there were <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/business/27/03/2024/660351709a7947f415196626\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">15</a>, last year — <a href=\"https://ria.ru/20250319/krasnov-2005983794.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">5</a>, according to Prosecutor General Igor Krasnov.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In total, in 2024 the Prosecutor General’s Office transferred property worth nearly 2.4 trillion rubles to the state, <a href=\"https://ria.ru/20250319/krasnov-2005983794.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reported</a> Krasnov. Recently, the law firm NSP <a href=\"https://www.nsplaw.com/backend/media/filer_public/92/d6/92d610fe-10ee-424d-8ce8-9e9786f0d930/nsp_issledovanie_po_delam_o_natsionalizatsii.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">calculated</a>, that the assets seized over the past few years are now worth 3.9 trillion rubles, “which demonstrates the broad scale of nationalization.” There are different ways to count, but it is clear that since about the end of last year, nationalization has been gaining momentum, and anyone can become a victim. One of the latest high-profile <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/russia/1036627\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">cases</a> is Yuzhuralzoloto of Konstantin Strukov, <a href=\"https://www.zs74.ru/deputies/strukov-konstantin-ivanovich\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">the deputy speaker</a> of the Chelyabinsk Regional Duma, which already during the war, at the end of 2023, <a href=\"https://www.moscowtimes.ru/2025/07/09/zhertvami-natsionalizatsii-yuzhuralzolota-mogut-stat-220-tisyach-chastnih-investorov-a168332\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">held an IPO</a>. News like “the court granted the claim to transfer to the revenue of the Russian Federation…” now appear regularly.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"What this could mean is explained by <strong>Andrei Yakovlev</strong>, associate at the Davis Center for Russian and Eurasian Studies at Harvard University, who has long studied Russian elites and the relationship between business and government.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"No arguments with the state","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"After the Yukos case, for almost 20 years before the war, the redistribution of property mostly looked like “a dispute between economic entities” (this phrase, which became a meme in Russia, was used by Vladimir Putin <a href=\"http://www.kremlin.ru/events/president/transcripts/interviews/24399\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>to describe</em></a><em> the takeover of NTV television network from Vladimir Gusinsky in 2001. — IStories</em>): one side would bring in people in uniform and, with their help, take away assets, sharing part of the spoils with them. This was the standard scenario of forceful pressure on business from the mid-2000s until 2022, inclusive.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The war added to this the redistribution of assets belonging to foreign companies that had left Russia. In essence, this was a consolidation of the elite base and was done in the interests of those groups on whom the Kremlin now relies and plans to continue relying. Many suffered from sanctions, including those close to Putin, and they needed to be compensated. The assets of departing foreigners made this easiest to do.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":15803,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Alexander Natruskin / Reuters","caption":"Mikhail Khodorkovsky and his partner Platon Lebedev (right) at the Yukos trial, 2004","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/96fdd572da4c4d849569f94540cc75b4-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/96fdd572da4c4d849569f94540cc75b4-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":815,"real_height_2x":1630},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/96fdd572da4c4d849569f94540cc75b4-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/96fdd572da4c4d849569f94540cc75b4-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":815,"real_height_2x":1630},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/96fdd572da4c4d849569f94540cc75b4-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/96fdd572da4c4d849569f94540cc75b4-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":282,"real_height_2x":564},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/96fdd572da4c4d849569f94540cc75b4-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/96fdd572da4c4d849569f94540cc75b4-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":282,"real_height_2x":564}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"However, since the summer of 2023, this process has spread to the assets of Russian owners who, for various reasons, had fewer opportunities to protect themselves. In particular, these were entrepreneurs who did not live in Russia (including due to political pressure) or who left the country after the start of the war. For example, the chemical company Metafrax Chemicals was taken from <a href=\"https://www.forbes.ru/biznes/502805-permskij-ad-kak-prosla-glavnaa-nacionalizacia-2023-goda-i-pri-cem-tut-rotenbergi\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Seyfeddin Rustamov, who lived in the U.S.</a>, the largest pasta factory in Russia, Makfa, from Mikhail Yurevich, and the car dealer Rolf from Sergey Petrov.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But as Putin has repeatedly stated, this was not about nationalization. All these assets, as a rule, were then privatized and handed over to “close comrades” on terms favorable to them. Metafrax Chemicals <a href=\"https://www.forbes.ru/biznes/502805-permskij-ad-kak-prosla-glavnaa-nacionalizacia-2023-goda-i-pri-cem-tut-rotenbergi\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">went to</a> Roskhim, a company close to the Rotenberg brothers, Arkady and Boris; Rolf, formerly owned by Sergey Petrov, went to <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/business/1000901\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Umar Kremlev</a>, and Makfa <a href=\"https://www.forbes.ru/biznes/516188-aktivy-makfy-peresli-pod-upravlenie-struktury-rossel-hozbanka\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">was transferred</a> to the management of a structure of the state-owned Rosselkhozbank (which is considered the domain of the Patrushev clan). We’ll see who ends up with it, but the business taken from the French, Danone, was privatized using the company’s own funds by <a href=\"https://www.svoboda.org/a/systema-danone-kadyrov/33432623.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">the appointed manager</a> — a nephew of Ramzan Kadyrov.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2023, the mechanism used to seize property changed. The “dispute between economic entities” was left in the past; now the issue was framed as a threat to Russia’s national security and economic sovereignty due to the actions or inaction of the current owners. The scheme, with such an unchallengeable argument, radically accelerated the process.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Disputes between economic entities” could drag on for years, even if the owner was in pretrial detention. A classic example is the Magomedov brothers, whose key asset, Fesco, <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/russia/901497\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">was taken</a> five years after their <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/news-43606325\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">arrest</a>, in 2023. When it comes to national security, issues are resolved instantly. From the <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/russia/1035743\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">filing of the lawsuit</a> for the nationalization of Yuzhuralzoloto to the <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/business/1036296\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">transfer</a> of shares to state ownership, two weeks passed.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There’s no money, so hang in there!","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"What is happening now is a logical continuation of the process that began in 2023. But this redistribution of property has significant differences from the model of forceful pressure on business and asset seizures typical of the 2000s or 2010s, when any FSB department head or district prosecutor could take part in a corporate raid. Unlike the previous model, nationalization is a centralized process that requires approval at the very top. The need for such approval to some extent limited the scale of nationalization, but now this process has sharply accelerated due to the objective deterioration of the economic situation.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Until mid-2024, the Kremlin had enough money to fully fund the war, cover social obligations — not increasing spending on them, but at least indexing them to inflation — and at the same time provide rents to the elites in the form of various types of state support (in addition to handing out pieces of property). Moreover, the rapid economic growth in 2023–2024 itself created an additional source of rent for the elites.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Last fall, it became clear that there was no longer enough money for everything. With the budget for 2025–2027, the Kremlin directly stated that its main priority is financing the army and the defense industry: military spending was once again increased — after a 70% rise in 2024. At the end of 2023, Finance Minister Anton Siluanov <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/rbcfreenews/657a34de9a794783e4e85527\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">called</a> the 2024–2026 budget a “victory budget”: we are once again dramatically increasing military spending, but then we’ll be able to cut it back (for 2025, military spending was then planned at 8.5 trillion rubles after 10.8 trillion in 2024, and for the following year, 2026, 7.7 trillion was budgeted). But less than a year passed before the 2025 budget included military spending of 13.5 trillion rubles — with no plans for any significant reduction in 2026 and 2027. In reality, in 2022–2024, actual military spending kept exceeding the plan, but overall economic growth and high oil prices gave the government additional sources of funding.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Since the end of 2024, the situation has changed. The economy has started to slow down. Part of the rent that came from rapid growth is evaporating. Oil prices have also dropped significantly.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Times are changing","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"But tensions within the elites are rising. The <a href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_Starovoyt#Death\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">suicide</a> of the Minister of Transport Roman Starovoyt testifies to the extent of this. People in the bureaucratic elite are genuinely exhausted; they are under stress.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It began with the pandemic, 2021 seemed to offer a brief respite, but then the war started — a war for which they were completely unprepared and which they did not want. According to my conversations with people in Moscow, at the start of this year, there were high hopes in the bureaucratic and business elite for Trump — with expectations of at least some normalization of relations with the West. But due to the Kremlin’s hardline stance, these hopes were dashed.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The situation in business is no better; there, too, moods could return to those of 2022. Many were unhappy about the war, but when rapid growth began, <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/news-65086084\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">conversations</a> like those between Iosif Prigozhin and Farhad Akhmedov (both harshly critical of the war) quieted down. Now businessmen realize that the fat years are ending, and they may once again start to ask themselves: what was all this for, and why did we need it?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":15804,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Reuters","caption":"Business did not want the war. Meeting with Putin on February 24, 2022","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/087bc9f417034cb6af29ed10b68cd798-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/087bc9f417034cb6af29ed10b68cd798-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":799,"real_height_2x":1598},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/087bc9f417034cb6af29ed10b68cd798-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/087bc9f417034cb6af29ed10b68cd798-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":799,"real_height_2x":1598},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/087bc9f417034cb6af29ed10b68cd798-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/087bc9f417034cb6af29ed10b68cd798-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":552},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/087bc9f417034cb6af29ed10b68cd798-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/087bc9f417034cb6af29ed10b68cd798-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":552}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"For all their cynicism and opportunism, today’s Russian business elite and bureaucracy are quite competent; these people went through fire and water in the 1990s and 2000s, they understand how to work in the Russian market, they have teams. It was precisely through the efforts of these people that Putin’s system maintained stability not only over the past three years, but also for the previous 20 — for which they received generous compensation. However, within the framework of their informal contract with the Kremlin, these people never signed up to “die” for the country, for Putin, or for an idea. That’s not what they’re about. Now, when the regime no longer has the resources to compensate everyone, such people, who possess their own resources, become a risk factor for the regime.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Against the backdrop of a deteriorating economic situation, the Kremlin needs the Russian elite to be made up of people who may be less competent, but who will stick with Putin to the end, since the collapse of the regime would mean personal collapse for them.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Loans-for-shares auctions 2.0","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"That is why the decision to launch a major redistribution of property now is entirely rational. There is still money in the budget, but the Kremlin is trying to act ahead of the curve. When the economy enters a serious crisis, it will be too late. If, by then, there are still independent players in business with billions in assets and large workforces, and they can, say, make it to the Emirates and strike some kind of deal there, that would be very dangerous for the regime.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The seizure of assets can take place, for example, following the logic of “loans-for-shares auctions.” Before the 1996 elections, key assets remaining in state ownership after mass privatization were handed over to entrepreneurs close to the regime for very little money. Everyone involved in this scheme understood: if Boris Yeltsin lost the election and the Communists returned to power, these people would lose the property they had acquired. So they had every incentive to stand behind this government to the end.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"To repeat such a scheme under current conditions, assets must first be nationalized from those who are weaker or considered unreliable. The May <a href=\"https://www.forbes.ru/biznes/536990-ks-zakrepil-iscislenie-sroka-davnosti-s-daty-prokurorskoj-proverki?ysclid=mclzv66pzx859364825\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">decision</a> by the Constitutional Court created the legal basis for this. The statute of limitations for privatization cases has been abolished: it now starts from the end of the prosecutor’s investigation, which can uncover violations even 30 years old. Under this seemingly legal pretext, property can be seized at will. For example, from one of the oligarchs of the 1990s.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":15805,"data":{"text":"","author":" ","header":"Most likely, the new elite will be drawn from “second-tier” businessmen"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"The scenario could look like this. The assets of a certain oligarch worth, say, a trillion rubles are nationalized. The state neither gains nor loses from this: these assets have to be managed, which is a headache — the Finance Ministry has said so <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/7233595\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">directly</a>. State managers, like Rostec chief Sergey Chemezov, are more about asking the state for money than bringing in revenue to the budget. So the state will not keep the property; it will be sold — Siluanov has already <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/economics/18/03/2025/67d91e759a79473d09dd3be4\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">started talking</a> about a “big privatization.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"An asset worth a trillion rubles can be sold to the right hands, for example, for 300 or 500 billion. State banks like Sberbank or VTB will gladly provide loans for this under informal Kremlin guarantees.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In the end, a trusted businessman will get the asset for a third or half its value, but will know: if the regime collapses, he will lose this asset (those whose assets are being seized now will have their day of reckoning). Therefore, he has every reason to stick with the regime to the end, while the Kremlin gets several hundred billion rubles for the budget. That is not bad money, and if scaled up, the regime could keep going for a few more years.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Elite 2.0","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Putin has proclaimed “veterans of the special military operation” as the new elite, but they will not be the ones participating in such deals. Entrusting such people with the management of large businesses is risky — they could ruin them. Much has already been handed over to “friends” (like the Rotenbergs or the Kovalchuks), but the Kremlin also needs broader “support groups.” And it seems the casting for this is already underway.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Most likely, the new elite will be drawn from “second-tier” businessmen. They have experience and competence — they created their own more or less successful businesses, but now want access to much larger assets.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The price for gaining access will be some public act that cuts off the new owners’ paths to retreat. For example, a speech like the one made at <a href=\"http://www.kremlin.ru/events/president/transcripts/76914\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">the meeting</a> with Putin by <a href=\"https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%A0%D0%B5%D0%BF%D0%B8%D0%BA,_%D0%90%D0%BB%D0%B5%D0%BA%D1%81%D0%B5%D0%B9_%D0%95%D0%B2%D0%B3%D0%B5%D0%BD%D1%8C%D0%B5%D0%B2%D0%B8%D1%87\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Aleksei Repik</a>, chairman of Business Russia — an association of medium-sized businesses, that very “second tier” (unlike the Russian Union of Industrialists and Entrepreneurs, which represents oligarchic business, and Opora Rossii, which acts on behalf of small business). Never before had someone like Repik spoken to Putin in such terms, not even at the United Russia party congress: his flag-waving patriotism <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/7714162\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">surprised</a> even the journalists of official media. Repik also spoke extremely harshly about the return of foreign companies (let them compensate for damages and create joint ventures where control will be in the hands of new Russian owners of their former assets), proposed raising the personal income tax for Russians who have left the country to 30%, and, one could say, swore an oath: “Vladimir Vladimirovich, you can be absolutely sure: just as 80 years ago, the home front is secure.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Usually, if Putin wanted to discuss something serious with business, he would meet with the Russian Union of Industrialists and Entrepreneurs, but this time, for such a “public” conversation, Business Russia was chosen. This meeting took place a day after the Constitutional Court’s decision to abolish the statute of limitations in privatization disputes.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":15806,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: kremlin.ru","caption":"That very meeting. Aleksei Repik — to the left of Putin","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9bc5099a258f470cb3ac05a2a0689d9b-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9bc5099a258f470cb3ac05a2a0689d9b-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":740,"real_height_2x":1480},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9bc5099a258f470cb3ac05a2a0689d9b-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9bc5099a258f470cb3ac05a2a0689d9b-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":740,"real_height_2x":1480},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9bc5099a258f470cb3ac05a2a0689d9b-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9bc5099a258f470cb3ac05a2a0689d9b-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":256,"real_height_2x":512},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9bc5099a258f470cb3ac05a2a0689d9b-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9bc5099a258f470cb3ac05a2a0689d9b-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":256,"real_height_2x":512}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Figures like Aleksei Repik or Umar Kremlev are the prototypes of the new business elite. It is with such people that the Kremlin will replace the entrepreneurs of the 1990s–2000s — people like Sergey Petrov, who built Rolf from scratch, or Vadim Moshkovich, who created the Rusagro holding.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Such an elite will resemble the North Korean one. In North Korea, despite all the repressions carried out by the Kim family in Stalinist fashion, the elite understands: if the regime weakens, reunification with South Korea will become inevitable within two or three steps, and in that scenario, this elite has no chance of retaining any social status. That is why, even during the <a href=\"https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%93%D0%BE%D0%BB%D0%BE%D0%B4_%D0%B2_%D0%9A%D0%9D%D0%94%D0%A0\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">famine</a> of the 1990s, there was no elite coup. And this is precisely what the Kremlin is now trying to do — to replace the elite of the 1990s–2000s (corrupt and cynical, but not prepared to die with the regime) with people who will have no choice. However, it is far from certain that this will succeed.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The silence of the elites","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"When the first wave of nationalization hit in 2023 (with a focus on assets in the chemical industry), there was tension, which was publicly articulated by Russian Union of Industrialists and Entrepreneurs President Alexander Shokhin, Economic Development Minister Maksim Reshetnikov, and Putin’s aide (now deputy head of his administration) Maksim Oreshkin (<a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/interview/economics/11/09/2023/64feca2f9a794776cbef70a1\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">1</a>,<a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/economics/11/09/2023/64fed8c19a79471abc50689a\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> 2</a>,<a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/business/12/09/2023/64ffd9cf9a794791f970b76d\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> 3</a>). In September 2023, Putin <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/economics/12/09/2023/65003a0e9a7947552625175b\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">spoke</a> at the Eastern Economic Forum, after which several lawsuits were withdrawn (<a href=\"https://www.forbes.ru/milliardery/496382-genprokuratura-otkazalas-ot-iska-o-vzyskanii-aktivov-heidelbergcement-v-rossii\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">1</a>,<a href=\"https://www.forbes.ru/milliardery/497959-genprokuratura-otkazalas-ot-iska-k-milliarderu-mel-nicenko\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> 2</a>).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Kremlin was testing the waters. In 2023, there was still ferment — so they decided to calm things down. Then, at the start of 2024, Putin<a href=\"https://www.vesti.ru/article/3828936\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> declared</a> that the elite was not those who filled their pockets in the 1990s, but “warriors and workers.” This no longer caused anxiety — meaning it was possible to go further, as we now see in the Constitutional Court’s decision. When, at the main Putin economic forum, this decision was <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/business/20/06/2025/685501769a7947552ac7bbc3\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">criticized</a> by State Duma Budget and Taxes Committee Chairman Andrei Makarov, the reaction of the ministers and businessmen present was a heavy silence, and Ksenia Sobchak compared Sberbank’s prestigious breakfast, where this took place, to<a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/society/28/12/2023/658c5e779a794703efb49791\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> a “naked party,”</a> for which many Kremlin-loyal show business figures were punished.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In other words, the old elite acts as if nothing is happening, even though even not-so-liberal comrades <a href=\"https://t.me/russ_orientalist/21046\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">are pointing</a> this out: “Patriotic businessmen really are strange people. They must understand that sooner or later they’ll become food. Like in those stories about prison escapes from the far northern colonies, when the convicts bring along a few extra companions, who are eaten along the way.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The oligarchic business has submitted to the authorities; Vladimir Potanin even <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/business/18/03/2025/67d933909a794759ed4c1d6c\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">said</a>: “Don’t fuss over the client, but follow the course of state policy.” They’ll be “eaten” simply because they are not “native” to the regime. But not all at once, but bit by bit — first, using the examples of Moshkovich or the former owner of the nationalized Domodedovo Airport, Dmitry Kamenshchik, the old oligarchs will be offered to “pay an exit fee”: in the form of sponsoring “patriotic education” programs or direct support for the special military operation. But given the Constitutional Court’s decision, they’ll come for them all the same.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, the risks of redistribution of property through nationalization affect not only the oligarchs. There are also many thousands of successful large and medium-sized enterprises. The old oligarchs still have administrative “protection” they continue to rely on (in my view — completely in vain). But many independent, not very large companies often have no such “roof.” At the same time, they built their businesses themselves and, unlike the top-tier oligarchs, could well function without this regime.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It is difficult to assess the mood in such businesses — you can’t include sensitive topics in officially conducted surveys these days. But at the level of personal conversations, it’s clear that there’s been a sobering up in assessments of prospects and the state of affairs in the economy. The euphoria that was especially noticeable at the end of 2023 — sanctions are nothing, we’re growing, China will help us, we’ll beat everyone and “march to Paris” — has passed. Now, in economic terms, people are seriously discussing all sorts of scenarios, including the worst ones. Also, in personal conversations, very concrete individual “exit strategies” are being discussed — with planned escape routes from the country if everything falls apart.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The question is whether, in a real crisis, these people will prefer to drop everything or will prove capable of collective action. It’s happened before: during the August 1991 coup, brokers took to the <a href=\"https://www.bfm.ru/news/150603\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">streets</a> and provided material support to the defenders of the White House, and in the spring of 1996, most of business supported Boris Yeltsin. Business by itself can hardly change anything in the political system; such collective action requires coordination — here, the participation of reasonable people from the state is important.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Paradoxically, certain incentives for this are now emerging. In particular, according to my conversations with Moscow acquaintances from the bureaucracy, Roman Starovoyt’s suicide was a shock for them — on his example, capable representatives of the bureaucratic apparatus, on whom the system of state governance objectively depends, began to realize that they are caught between two millstones. On one side is a group that wants to move to a mobilization economy like North Korea. This vector was openly <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/politics/17/06/2024/666fdd079a7947d7daecd349/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">declared</a> a year ago by Far East and Arctic Development Minister Aleksei Chekunkov, <a href=\"https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2025/04/07/poslannik-vechnoi-merzloty-who-is-mr-dmitriev\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">connected</a> to Kirill Dmitriev, but the real ideologue of this group is more likely Defense Minister Andrei Belousov. The other group (the Rotenbergs, Kadyrov, Suleyman Kerimov) is pulling the country toward a model of <a href=\"https://re-russia.net/expertise/0315/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">a mafia state</a>. However, in both models, the current competent technocrats who consider themselves the elite will be regarded simply as “expendable material.” And the fact that three deputy prime ministers and six ministers <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/politics/10/07/2025/686f5f039a794759f290da2a\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">attended</a> Starovoyt’s funeral, I see as a signal of possible changes in the bureaucratic elite.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Undoubtedly, from such an impulsive demonstration of “solidarity with a comrade” to thoughtful collective action, they still have a long way to go. And in the atmosphere of fear imposed by the Kremlin, it will not be easy for normal people in the state apparatus and in business to make that journey. But the clock is already ticking for them.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":7877,"header":"How the War in Ukraine Changed the Attitude of CIS Countries Toward Russia","_path":"/en/opinions/2025/07/16/russian-influence-cis/","lead":"Vladimir Putin wanted to prove that the post-Soviet space is Russia’s sphere of influence, but the result was exactly the opposite","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8bc02659cfef45c5acdc8b9d5cae7cb1-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Photo: Alexander Nemenov / Pool / AP / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2025-07-16","created_at_date_time":"2025-07-15T15:35:05.332Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[],"external_authors_list":[{"id":315,"first_name":"Vladimir","last_name":"Solovyov","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"independent journalist","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":1}],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"“He spoke to him the way only he can” — with this phrase, Russian diplomats at various levels — up to deputy foreign ministers — used to describe, in private conversations, Vladimir Putin’s negotiating skills in dealings with CIS partners. I myself have heard this more than once from diplomats who have worked and continue to work in the Russian Foreign Ministry on relations with former Soviet republics and integration associations in the post-Soviet space — the CIS, EAEU, CSTO. This was all standard practice — before Russia sent its army into Ukraine.\nRussia started the war, among other things, to stake out its sphere of influence. The result was exactly the opposite. Scandals of this scale had never erupted between Russia and Azerbaijan before, and this is the new reality: Moscow’s influence in the post-Soviet space has thinned. And the former Soviet republics now shape their policies with this erosion in mind.\nThe stream of bad news for Moscow from countries it once viewed from the position of a stronger partner is overwhelming. Sparks fly so often that it seems to be the rule rather than the exception.\n\nAzerbaijan: Karabakh reclaimed, Moscow sidestepped\nThe current conflict between Moscow and Baku is the toughest stress test for both countries. Five years ago, such a level of tension between them was unimaginable — especially Azerbaijan’s reaction to the actions of Russian security forces against Azerbaijanis living in Russia.\n\nThere’s a vivid example from 2020. Russian leader Vladimir Putin, with a single phone call, stopped his Azerbaijani counterpart Ilham Aliyev, who was already preparing — in the fall of 2020 — to retake all of Karabakh from Armenia by force, with Turkey’s support. Their conversation took place after the Azerbaijani army captured Shusha, opening the road to Stepanakert (now Khankendi). Despite the relative ease of the operation, Azerbaijani security forces suddenly froze and did not advance further.\n\n“There was a ‘tough’ talk... Russia made Azerbaijan ‘an offer he couldn’t refuse’,” — described RBC. The details never surfaced, but the facts spoke for themselves: Russian troops, in the form of a peacekeeping contingent, appeared for the first time in modern history on internationally recognized Azerbaijani territory.\nAfter the start of the war in Ukraine, everything changed. Baku waited, and in the fall of 2023, without regard for anyone, carried out a swift military special operation and regained control over the remnants of Karabakh.\nDuring the operation, Russian peacekeepers were killed — the last time this happened was in 2008 at the start of the war in Georgia, and the outcome for Tbilisi is well known. This time, Aliyev quickly apologized and the incident was hushed up. Soon after, the Russian peacekeeping contingent left Karabakh.\nOn the Ukrainian front, Baku acts on the principle “your enemy is not my problem.” Moscow can do nothing about it. Despite being in allied relations with Russia, Azerbaijan does what it deems necessary: helps Ukraine restore infrastructure, sends humanitarian aid, maintains political relations at the highest level.\nThe crash of an Azerbaijan Airlines plane, shot down by a Russian missile on December 25, 2024, sharply worsened relations between Russia and Baku. Confronted with Moscow’s inadequate behavior and not receiving an apology, Aliyev publicly declared that Russia was trying to cover up the incident. In February 2025, Azerbaijani authorities shut down the local branch of Rossotrudnichestvo. And Aliyev refused to fly to Moscow for the 80th anniversary of Victory Day.\nAzerbaijan can afford to be tough even with the West: almost simultaneously with Rossotrudnichestvo, Baku dealt with the local USAID office. These opportunities did not come out of nowhere. The state’s iron grip on the country’s internal affairs makes Azerbaijan somewhat similar to Russia. There, too, propaganda can be cranked up to full blast if needed. The confidence that now no one, including Moscow, can dictate to Baku from above what to do was strengthened by the return of Karabakh. Heydar Aliyev, Ilham Aliyev’s father, began building Azerbaijani statehood; now the son has completed the process by regaining lost territories.\nSpecial relations with Turkey and Russia’s weakening also played a role. The war has clearly exposed Moscow’s real capabilities. It’s no coincidence the Kremlin decided not to escalate the current conflict and sent a parliamentarian to Azerbaijan — formerly Putin’s aide-de-camp, now Emergency Situations Minister Alexander Kurenkov.\n\nSo there will be reconciliation. But the winner in the conflict between these two countries of very different weight will definitely not be Moscow.\n\nArmenia: an outsider among two\nThe first alarm bell in Russian-Armenian relations rang in 2018. Nikol Pashinyan, who seized power from Serzh Sargsyan in the “Velvet Revolution,” immediately fell out of favor in Moscow. He promised not to pursue vendettas against political opponents, but did not keep his word: the first defendant in a criminal case was initially the then-Secretary General of the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) Yuri Khachaturov, then Serzh Sargsyan and former president Robert Kocharyan, who openly spoke of his friendship with Vladimir Putin.\nThis angered Moscow. But until 2020, Armenia — a CSTO member and participant in the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU) — generally did not cross the Kremlin’s red lines. At Moscow’s request, it sent a mission to Syria and actively participated in all integration formats important to Russia.\n\nIn 2020, the Second Karabakh War broke out, ending in Armenia’s defeat. Neither Russia nor the CSTO came to the aid of their ally. But there was an argument: Karabakh was never recognized by anyone as part of Armenia, even though Nikol Pashinyan declared, that “Artsakh is Armenia. Period.”\n\nThe point of no return was passed in the fall of 2022. Then, fighting flared up again between Armenia and Azerbaijan, but this time Armenian territory came under fire. Armenia did not receive the support and assistance from the CSTO it had counted on. Russia called on both sides to cease fire, while, for example, France and the US condemned Azerbaijan’s aggression. Moscow did not come to Armenia’s aid during Baku’s special operation in Karabakh either, after which Armenia lost control over the region.\n\nThis spurred Yerevan’s pivot away from Moscow toward the West, and its foreign policy became increasingly independent. “The external security systems in which Armenia is involved are ineffective for protecting Armenia’s security and state interests,” Pashinyan declared. Armenians realized that relying solely on Moscow is shortsighted and even dangerous, and began moving closer to the West, India, and even hostile Turkey. Their relations have noticeably warmed; in June, Pashinyan visited Turkey and met with Recep Erdoğan — something that would have been hard to imagine just a few years ago. Armenia, despite Moscow’s angry reaction, signed and then ratified the statute of the International Criminal Court (ICC), which has issued an arrest warrant for Putin. Today, the republic is a full member of the ICC.\nThere have also been changes in an area extremely sensitive for Russia — military-technical cooperation. Armenia’s main partners in defense are now India and France, both supplying Yerevan with weapons and equipment. American and French military advisers now work in the Armenian Defense Ministry. There is no Russian adviser there. Yerevan has frozen its CSTO membership and rejected Russian border guards: first removing them from Zvartnots Airport, then from the Armenian-Azerbaijani and, finally, from the Armenian-Turkish border.\nIn parallel, Yerevan began moving closer to the EU. In March, it adopted the law “On the Beginning of the Process of Accession of the Republic of Armenia to the European Union.” In June, EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy Kaja Kallas visited Yerevan and announced the allocation of €270 million to Armenia, in particular to support independent media and combat propaganda — primarily Russian — and hybrid threats. In 2024, Armenia banned the programs of Russian propagandist Vladimir Solovyov. Now Armenian authorities say, that it is necessary to completely ban the broadcast of Russian state channels.\nA recent case is telling: the arrest of Russian-Armenian billionaire Samvel Karapetyan. He intervened in the conflict between the authorities and the church, stating that if politicians do not resolve the situation, “we will take matters into our own hands.” The businessman, closely tied to Moscow, was accused of calling for the seizure of power and arrested for two months.\nAt the same time, Armenia is heavily dependent on Russia economically, especially in the energy sector. Armenia remains a member of the EAEU and continues to benefit from it. But so far, Moscow has not resorted to economic pressure. The head of the Yerevan-based Caucasus Institute, Alexander Iskandaryan, explains this uncharacteristic behavior as follows: “Russia can easily punish Armenia economically: raise gas prices fivefold, close its market to agricultural products, and so on. But as soon as this happens, it will be like the liquidation of Nagorno-Karabakh, only in the economy, because after that [Russia] will have no levers of influence on Armenia at all.”\nApparently, Moscow is aware of these risks. Moreover, in such a case, public demand for moving away from Russia would grow. The process is already underway: according to research by the International Republican Institute (IRI), in 2018, 92% of Armenians considered relations with Russia good, and only 7% bad; by September 2024, the ratio was already 64 to 35%. Moreover, there is a high probability that in such a situation, the country that would come to Armenia’s aid would be… Turkey. In 2018, 98% of Armenians considered relations with Turkey bad, and only 1% good. In 2024, 72% still consider them bad, but 25% now call them good. The two countries have long discussed the need to open the border. Russians are no longer there.\nWhile Moscow quarrels with Armenia and Azerbaijan, these two — seemingly bitter enemies — are holding bilateral talks on a long-term peace. Until recently, Russia claimed the role of main mediator, but for now, Baku and Yerevan have decided to do without it.\nMoldova: infusions without influence\nMoldova, along with Armenia and Azerbaijan, is another vivid example of a country exiting Moscow’s sphere of influence. The process began long before the war — after pro-Western forces took power in 2009. Since then, only pro-European parties have governed the country. But until February 24, 2022, they tried to balance things and did not break ties with Moscow.\nThe current president, Maia Sandu, came to power in 2020 on a platform of European integration, but also promised equal and mutually beneficial relations with Russia. Under similar slogans, in 2021, the parliamentary majority was won by Sandu’s Action and Solidarity party. Sandu met with Russian presidential administration deputy chief Dmitry Kozak (until recently, the Kremlin’s Moldova handler).\nBefore the war, Chisinau was visited by Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Andrey Rudenko. Moldovan diplomats told me that during an informal dinner, he was asked directly: “Will Russia attack a neighboring country?” According to them, the answer was: “We’re going to bomb Kyiv?! How do you imagine that!” A week later, Russian missiles struck the Ukrainian capital.\nAfter the war began, Moldova sided with Ukraine, cut ties with Moscow at all levels, and began to terminate agreements signed within the CIS. Now, Moldovan-Russian relations are relations without relations. The sides communicate mainly through public statements in which they rebuke each other for various reasons, sometimes summoning ambassadors to the Foreign Ministry to express dissatisfaction with each other’s unfriendly actions. A telling gesture — President Sandu has still not accepted the credentials of Russia’s new ambassador to Moldova, Oleg Ozerov, who arrived in the country last fall. The Ukrainian ambassador, who arrived later, presented his credentials to her at the beginning of the year.\nDistancing from Russia is also happening in the economy. Chisinau does not buy gas directly from Gazprom, preferring to purchase fuel on the European market. It’s too early to talk about full energy independence, but achieving it is the goal of the Moldovan authorities, and Brussels is helping them.\nSince the start of the war in Ukraine, Moldova has made significant progress toward European integration. In the summer of 2022, the EU granted candidate status to both Moldova and Ukraine; at the end of 2023, Brussels decided to start accession talks with them. Now, a screening — an analysis of Moldova’s legislation for compliance with EU norms — is underway. This year, the EU raised its level of political relations with Moldova to the highest — annual bilateral summits, the first of which took place in Chisinau on July 4. The republic became the third post-Soviet country with which Brussels began working in this format after Russia (summits ended in 2014) and Ukraine. This is a success.\nMoscow does not want to accept the loss of influence in Moldova and supports politicians and parties advocating cooperation with Russia. The most prominent conduit of Russian interests in Moldova is the fugitive oligarch Ilan Shor. A citizen of Moldova, Israel, and, more recently, Russia, Shor was sentenced by a Moldovan court to 15 years in prison for his role in a massive financial fraud — the 2014 embezzlement of $1 billion from three Moldovan banks he then controlled. To avoid prison, Shor fled to Israel in 2019, then moved to Moscow, from where he remotely coordinates the activities of his supporters and party network. Some of them last year united in Moscow in the Victory bloc. Shor deals in cryptocurrency, helps Russia circumvent sanctions, and during last year’s presidential election, his people organized vote buying of voters.\nThe Moldovan economy is not doing well — GDP grew by only 0.1% last year, gas and electricity prices have risen, and so has everything else. Discontent with the government is growing, and Moscow intends to take advantage of this. Recently, the Kremlin changed its Moldova handler. From Kozak, who, as IStories sources said, was reluctant to deal with Shor because of his toxicity, the portfolio passed to the head of the domestic policy bloc, Sergey Kiriyenko. His approach is extremely simple: stop being shy about interfering in the affairs of post-Soviet states. Shor announced that “Victory” will run in the September parliamentary elections, which will determine the configuration of power for the next four years (Moldova is a parliamentary republic). He promised to seek the creation of a Russia-Moldova union and Moldova’s accession to the CSTO, despite its neutral status.\nThe chances of winning on such a platform are slim. The majority of the population, including those dissatisfied with the current pro-European government, support European integration — this course is enshrined in the constitution. But surprises are possible, and Shor knows how to mobilize people for street protests. According to polls, his Victory bloc is polling above the parliamentary threshold. If, of course, it is allowed to run.\nMoscow’s options are complicated by the lack of a common border with Moldova and Brussels’ full support for Chisinau. The war has accelerated Moldova’s movement away from Russia and toward the West. It’s hard to imagine what would have to happen for this to reverse. Moldovan authorities insist the country will join the EU by 2030.\n\nBelarus: looking to the West\nAlexander Lukashenko, who for years maneuvered between Russia and the West, fell into a trap five years ago. His re-election to a new presidential term sparked massive protests, which he crushed with great brutality. And the forced landing of a Ryanair plane in Minsk to detain opposition figure Roman Protasevich brought unprecedented sanctions upon Belarus.\nThe seasoned “batka” found himself in the tight embrace of the Kremlin. Room for maneuver disappeared, and Lukashenko could not wriggle out of complicity in Russia’s war with Ukraine. Belarusian territory became one of the staging grounds for the invasion. This further complicated Minsk’s relations with the EU and the US. Since 2022, Lukashenko’s main partner is Putin, and Russia is almost his only destination for foreign trips.\nIt seemed there was no way out of these embraces, but talks resumed on Belarus joining Russia. “Dependence has grown enormously in many areas. Belarusian air bases are used by Russia entirely at its own discretion,” says Carnegie Russia Eurasia Center expert Artem Shraibman. “Ninety percent of Belarus’s foreign trade goes either to Russia or through Russia. No one else is a sponsor, credit donor, or energy supplier, and at preferential prices. Here, dependence is close to total.”\nLukashenko has always tried to slow down integration with Russia, and over the past year has made attempts to break out of isolation. He is inviting the West to bargain, releasing political prisoners. Released from prison was Sergei Tikhanovsky, removed from the 2020 election, who served 5 of the 18 years handed down by the court. Maria Kolesnikova, jailed in September 2020, may also be released. Her release no longer seems unrealistic. Last year, Belarusian authorities allowed Maria’s father to visit her and demonstrated that she was alive and well. “Lukashenko is showing: there’s a deal to be made, I’m ready to talk about anything,” Shraibman observes.\nThe first result: on June 21, Minsk was visited by US presidential envoy for Ukraine Keith Kellogg — that’s when Tikhanovsky was released. Issues were also discussed regarding lifting sanctions on the country’s largest fertilizer producer, Belaruskali, as well as restoring air links with the republic (though this would require coordination with the EU).\nAnother notable step toward the West concerns Minsk’s migration policy, which caused quite a few problems for neighboring EU countries, notes Eastern Europe researcher Balázs Jarábik: “Belarus has restricted visa issuance and stopped facilitating access for refugees from the Middle East to EU border areas.”\nLukashenko is guided not only by geopolitical expediency, though that is his top priority. Belarusians have no desire to join Russia. Only about 4% of Belarusians want this, and this figure has not changed for many years. “Plus or minus a percent or so — even the war hasn’t affected this constant,” says independent Belarusian sociologist Andrei Vardomatsky. Belarus’ moves toward the West, to reduce dependence on Moscow, has only just begun. It will not be easy or quick, but nothing is impossible.\n\nCentral Asia: lying low\nThe Central Asian countries behave much more cautiously in their relations with Russia than Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Moldova. But over the past three years, there have been quite a few episodes of independence, multi-vector policies, and even toughness that Moscow finds unpleasant. If you put the puzzle pieces together, the picture is quite telling.\nNot a single Central Asian country has condemned Russia’s actions against Ukraine, but Moscow has not received support from them either. Kyrgyzstan’s president Sadyr Japarov stated, that Bishkek should remain neutral in this war. In June 2022, Kazakh leader Kassym-Jomart Tokayev, who in January 2022 retained power in part thanks to the deployment of CSTO troops in the country, at an economic forum in St. Petersburg, in Putin’s presence, called the DNR and LNR “quasi-state entities” and stressed that Astana does not intend to recognize them (at that time, Moscow had not yet incorporated them into Russia).\nUzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan (in 2005 and 2014) — not without Moscow’s help — forced the US to withdraw its troops. But neither they nor the other Central Asian countries, despite differences in regime severity, share Russia’s approach to the West as an enemy. Kazakhstan persistently seeks visa liberalization with the EU. Astana, while being a military ally of Russia (Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Tajikistan are CSTO members), recently signed a military cooperation agreement with the United Kingdom.\nAnother factor reducing Russia’s influence in the region is China’s interest. After the start of the war in Ukraine, the project for a railway from China bypassing Russia, through Central Asian countries, finally gained momentum. China is investing heavily in the region (Moscow, because of the war, has no time for this), and has replaced Russia as the main trading partner of Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, and is close to this with Tajikistan, while in Kyrgyzstan and Turkmenistan this happened even before the war. China has even entered areas where Russia’s positions seemed unshakable: it will participate in building a nuclear power plant in Kazakhstan. Since 2023, summits between China and Central Asia have begun.\nCentral Asian states are decisively cracking down on their citizens’ involvement in combat in Ukraine. Those who fight on Russia’s side receive prison sentences in Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan. In Kyrgyzstan, in a case over recruitment for the front, a staffer of the Russian House, Natalya Sekerina, was arrested.\nWhile Russia rehabilitates Stalin and talks about the mythical “denazification” of Ukraine, Central Asian governments are carrying out de-Sovietization. In June, a 25-meter-high — the tallest in Central Asia — Lenin monument was dismantled in the Kyrgyz city of Osh. Lenin is also set to be removed in Bishkek. Soviet street names are also being changed in the country.\n\n***\nWhat is happening now was unimaginable ten years ago: Russian influence in the post-Soviet space is shrinking, Alexander Iskandaryan notes. This, he says, is a fairly long-standing process, but now “Russia is turning into a very convenient narrative for a black-and-white picture that can be used in domestic politics.” The Ukraine issue has so eclipsed everything else in Russian foreign policy that, as Maxim Samorukov, an expert on Russia and Eurasia at the Carnegie Center, observes, “they attribute panacea-like properties to a possible victory there. It’s a rather illusory approach, but there is a certain logic to it.”","blocks":[{"data":"“He spoke to him the way only he can” — with this phrase, Russian diplomats at various levels — up to deputy foreign ministers — used to describe, in private conversations, Vladimir Putin’s negotiating skills in dealings with CIS partners. I myself have heard this more than once from diplomats who have worked and continue to work in the Russian Foreign Ministry on relations with former Soviet republics and integration associations in the post-Soviet space — the CIS, EAEU, CSTO. This was all standard practice — before Russia sent its army into Ukraine.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russia started the war, among other things, to stake out its sphere of influence. The result was exactly the opposite. <a href=\"https://apnews.com/article/russia-azerbaijan-putin-aliyev-tensions-relations-627104d770071082be26c189161b1ac9\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Scandals</a> of this scale had never erupted between Russia and Azerbaijan before, and this is the new reality: Moscow’s influence in the post-Soviet space has thinned. And the former Soviet republics now shape their policies with this erosion in mind.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The stream of bad news for Moscow from countries it once viewed from the position of a stronger partner is overwhelming. Sparks fly so often that it seems to be the rule rather than the exception.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Azerbaijan: Karabakh reclaimed, Moscow sidestepped</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The current conflict between Moscow and Baku is the toughest stress test for both countries. Five years ago, such a level of tension between them was unimaginable — especially Azerbaijan’s reaction to the actions of Russian security forces against Azerbaijanis living in Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There’s a vivid example from 2020. Russian leader Vladimir Putin, with a single phone call, stopped his Azerbaijani counterpart Ilham Aliyev, who was already preparing — in the fall of 2020 — to retake all of Karabakh from Armenia by force, with Turkey’s support. Their conversation took place after the Azerbaijani army captured Shusha, opening the road to Stepanakert (now Khankendi). Despite the relative ease of the operation, Azerbaijani security forces suddenly froze and did not advance further.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“There was a ‘tough’ talk... Russia made Azerbaijan ‘an offer he couldn’t refuse’,” — <a href=\"https://amp.rbc.ru/rbcnews/politics/26/11/2021/618684849a7947aa6c25c52f\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">described</a> RBC. The details never surfaced, but the facts spoke for themselves: Russian troops, in the form of a peacekeeping contingent, appeared for the first time in modern history on internationally recognized Azerbaijani territory.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After the start of the war in Ukraine, everything changed. Baku waited, and in the fall of 2023, without regard for anyone, <a href=\"https://istories.media/stories/2023/11/09/proklyatie-artsakha-kak-pobeda-armenii-nad-azerbaidzhanom-stala-yee-porazheniem/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">carried out</a> a swift military special operation and regained control over the remnants of Karabakh.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"During the operation, Russian peacekeepers were killed — the last time this happened was in 2008 at the start of the war in Georgia, and the outcome for Tbilisi is well known. This time, Aliyev quickly apologized and the incident was hushed up. Soon after, the Russian peacekeeping contingent left Karabakh.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":15687,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: AP / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Ilham Aliyev (top) also loves parades. The third anniversary of Azerbaijan’s victory in the 2020 Karabakh war","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/196f672da09f4696bcac7414b0dddd53-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/196f672da09f4696bcac7414b0dddd53-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/196f672da09f4696bcac7414b0dddd53-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/196f672da09f4696bcac7414b0dddd53-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/196f672da09f4696bcac7414b0dddd53-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/196f672da09f4696bcac7414b0dddd53-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/196f672da09f4696bcac7414b0dddd53-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/196f672da09f4696bcac7414b0dddd53-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"On the Ukrainian front, Baku acts on the principle “your enemy is not my problem.” Moscow can do nothing about it. Despite being in <a href=\"https://president.az/ru/articles/view/55498\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">allied relations</a> with Russia, Azerbaijan does what it deems necessary: helps Ukraine restore infrastructure, sends humanitarian aid, <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/politics/01/07/2025/6863f56a9a7947fc6d2470cd\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">maintains</a> political relations at the highest level.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The crash of an Azerbaijan Airlines plane, shot down by a Russian missile on December 25, 2024, sharply worsened relations between Russia and Baku. Confronted with Moscow’s inadequate behavior and not receiving an apology, Aliyev publicly declared that Russia was trying to cover up the incident. In February 2025, Azerbaijani authorities <a href=\"https://report.az/ru/vneshnyaya-politika/rossijskoj-storone-napravleno-oficialnoe-uvedomlenie-o-prekrashenii-deyatelnosti-rossotrudnichestva/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">shut down</a> the local branch of Rossotrudnichestvo. And Aliyev refused to fly to Moscow for the 80th anniversary of Victory Day.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Azerbaijan can afford to be tough even with the West: almost simultaneously with Rossotrudnichestvo, Baku <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/politics/06/02/2025/67a478ce9a79476a5bf1f5f1?from=article_body\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">dealt with</a> the local USAID office. These opportunities did not come out of nowhere. The state’s iron grip on the country’s internal affairs makes Azerbaijan somewhat similar to Russia. There, too, propaganda can be cranked up to full blast if needed. The confidence that now no one, including Moscow, can dictate to Baku from above what to do was strengthened by the return of Karabakh. Heydar Aliyev, Ilham Aliyev’s father, began building Azerbaijani statehood; now the son has completed the process by regaining lost territories.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Special relations with Turkey and Russia’s weakening also played a role. The war has clearly exposed Moscow’s real capabilities. It’s no coincidence the Kremlin decided not to escalate the current conflict and <a href=\"https://1news.az/news/20250707052222141-Glava-MCHS-RF-pribyl-v-Baku\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">sent</a> a parliamentarian to Azerbaijan — formerly Putin’s aide-de-camp, now Emergency Situations Minister Alexander Kurenkov.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"So there will be reconciliation. But the winner in the conflict between these two countries of very different weight will definitely not be Moscow.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Armenia: an outsider among two","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The first alarm bell in Russian-Armenian relations rang in 2018. Nikol Pashinyan, who seized power from Serzh Sargsyan in the “Velvet Revolution,” immediately fell out of favor in Moscow. He promised not to pursue vendettas against political opponents, but did not keep his word: the first defendant in a criminal case <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/3702250?from=doc_vrez\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">was</a> initially the then-Secretary General of the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) Yuri Khachaturov, then Serzh Sargsyan and former president Robert Kocharyan, who openly <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/3745275\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">spoke</a> of his friendship with Vladimir Putin.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This angered Moscow. But until 2020, Armenia — a CSTO member and participant in the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU) — generally did not cross the Kremlin’s red lines. At Moscow’s request, it sent a mission to Syria and actively participated in all integration formats important to Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2020, the Second Karabakh War broke out, ending in Armenia’s defeat. Neither Russia nor the CSTO came to the aid of their ally. But there was an argument: Karabakh was never recognized by anyone as part of Armenia, even though Nikol Pashinyan <a href=\"https://jam-news.net/ru/%D0%B0%D1%80%D1%86%D0%B0%D1%85-%D1%8D%D1%82%D0%BE-%D0%B0%D1%80%D0%BC%D0%B5%D0%BD%D0%B8%D1%8F-%D0%B8-%D0%B2%D1%81%D0%B5-%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%B5%D0%BC%D1%8C%D0%B5%D1%80-%D0%BC%D0%B8/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">declared</a>, that “Artsakh is Armenia. Period.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The point of no return was passed in the fall of 2022. Then, fighting flared up again between Armenia and Azerbaijan, but this time Armenian territory came under fire. Armenia did not receive the support and assistance from the CSTO it had counted on. Russia called on both sides to cease fire, while, for example, France and the US condemned Azerbaijan’s aggression. Moscow did not come to Armenia’s aid during Baku’s special operation in Karabakh either, after which Armenia lost control over the region.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This spurred Yerevan’s pivot away from Moscow toward the West, and its foreign policy became increasingly independent. “The external security systems in which Armenia is involved are ineffective for protecting Armenia’s security and state interests,” Pashinyan declared. Armenians realized that relying solely on Moscow is shortsighted and even dangerous, and began moving closer to the West, India, and even hostile Turkey. Their relations have noticeably warmed; in June, Pashinyan visited Turkey and met with Recep Erdoğan — something that would have been hard to imagine just a few years ago. Armenia, despite Moscow’s angry reaction, signed and then ratified the statute of the International Criminal Court (ICC), which has issued an arrest warrant for Putin. Today, the republic is a full member of the ICC.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":15688,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: MURAT CETINMUHURDAR / EPA / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"A historic handshake between the Armenian (left, Nikol Pashinyan) and Turkish (right, Recep Erdoğan) leaders","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6246ae0e17bd47259e4075f13d3eaaff-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6246ae0e17bd47259e4075f13d3eaaff-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":816,"real_height_2x":1632},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6246ae0e17bd47259e4075f13d3eaaff-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6246ae0e17bd47259e4075f13d3eaaff-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":816,"real_height_2x":1632},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6246ae0e17bd47259e4075f13d3eaaff-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6246ae0e17bd47259e4075f13d3eaaff-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":282,"real_height_2x":564},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6246ae0e17bd47259e4075f13d3eaaff-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6246ae0e17bd47259e4075f13d3eaaff-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":282,"real_height_2x":564}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"There have also been changes in an area extremely sensitive for Russia — military-technical cooperation. Armenia’s main partners in defense are now India and France, both supplying Yerevan with weapons and equipment. American and French military advisers now work in the Armenian Defense Ministry. There is no Russian adviser there. Yerevan has frozen its CSTO membership and rejected Russian border guards: first removing them from Zvartnots Airport, then from the Armenian-Azerbaijani and, <a href=\"https://arka.am/news/politics/s-segodnyashnego-dnya-na-kpp-margara-na-granitse-armenii-s-turtsiey-otnyne-sluzhat-tolko-armyanskie-/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">finally</a>, from the Armenian-Turkish border.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In parallel, Yerevan began moving closer to the EU. In March, <a href=\"https://www.dw.com/ru/parlament-armenii-okoncatelno-odobril-zakon-o-vstuplenii-v-es/a-72041762\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">it adopted</a> the law “On the Beginning of the Process of Accession of the Republic of Armenia to the European Union.” In June, EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy Kaja Kallas visited Yerevan and announced the allocation of €270 million to Armenia, in particular to support independent media and combat propaganda — primarily Russian — and hybrid threats. In 2024, Armenia banned the programs of Russian propagandist Vladimir Solovyov. Now Armenian authorities <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/politics/01/07/2025/6863f9959a7947f045a359e1\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">say</a>, that it is necessary to completely ban the broadcast of Russian state channels.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A recent case is telling: the arrest of Russian-Armenian billionaire Samvel Karapetyan. He intervened in the conflict between the authorities and the church, stating that if politicians do not resolve the situation, “we will take matters into our own hands.” The businessman, closely tied to Moscow, was accused of calling for the seizure of power and arrested for two months.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At the same time, Armenia is heavily dependent on Russia economically, especially in the energy sector. Armenia remains a member of the EAEU and continues to benefit from it. But so far, Moscow has not resorted to economic pressure. The head of the Yerevan-based Caucasus Institute, Alexander Iskandaryan, explains this uncharacteristic behavior as follows: “Russia can easily punish Armenia economically: raise gas prices fivefold, close its market to agricultural products, and so on. But as soon as this happens, it will be like the liquidation of Nagorno-Karabakh, only in the economy, because after that [Russia] will have no levers of influence on Armenia at all.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Apparently, Moscow is aware of these risks. Moreover, in such a case, public demand for moving away from Russia would grow. The process is already underway: according to research by the International Republican Institute (IRI), in 2018, <a href=\"https://www.iri.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/2018.11.23_armenia_poll.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">92% of Armenians</a> considered relations with Russia good, and only 7% bad; by September 2024, the ratio <a href=\"https://www.iri.org/resources/public-opinion-survey-residents-of-armenia/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">was</a> already 64 to 35%. Moreover, there is a high probability that in such a situation, the country that would come to Armenia’s aid would be… Turkey. In 2018, 98% of Armenians considered relations with Turkey bad, and only 1% good. In 2024, 72% still consider them bad, but 25% now call them good. The two countries have long discussed the need to open the border. Russians are no longer there.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"While Moscow quarrels with Armenia and Azerbaijan, these two — seemingly bitter enemies — are holding <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/articles/c98jp76gyveo\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">bilateral talks</a> on a long-term peace. Until recently, Russia claimed the role of main mediator, but for now, Baku and Yerevan have decided to do without it.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":15689,"data":{"block":"<p>In the third country of the South Caucasus, Georgia, Russian influence began to wane after Mikheil Saakashvili came to power in 2003. After the 2008 war, Georgia left the CIS and broke off diplomatic relations with Russia. The current regime being built in Georgia by Bidzina Ivanishvili and his Georgian Dream party is widely considered “pro-Russian.” It does have much in common with Putin’s regime (the same foreign agents law that sparked mass protests), but it is more about power and security than rapprochement with Moscow.</p><p><br/></p><p><br/></p><p>After Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, Georgia — which had already lost 20% of its territory to Russia’s actions in 2008 — tried to build pragmatic relations with Moscow. However, although the country is now at odds with the West, it has not formally abandoned its course toward EU and NATO membership. Georgian society <a href=\"https://civil.ge/archives/661383\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">does not support</a> the ruling party’s policy and wants the country to become a member of NATO and the EU. Diplomatic relations with Russia have not been restored to this day.</p>","header":"What about Georgia?","content":[{"insert":"In the third country of the South Caucasus, Georgia, Russian influence began to wane after Mikheil Saakashvili came to power in 2003. After the 2008 war, Georgia left the CIS and broke off diplomatic relations with Russia. The current regime being built in Georgia by Bidzina Ivanishvili and his Georgian Dream party is widely considered “pro-Russian.” It does have much in common with Putin’s regime (the same foreign agents law that sparked mass protests), but it is more about power and security than rapprochement with Moscow.\n\n\nAfter Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, Georgia — which had already lost 20% of its territory to Russia’s actions in 2008 — tried to build pragmatic relations with Moscow. However, although the country is now at odds with the West, it has not formally abandoned its course toward EU and NATO membership. Georgian society "},{"insert":"does not support","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://civil.ge/archives/661383","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" the ruling party’s policy and wants the country to become a member of NATO and the EU. Diplomatic relations with Russia have not been restored to this day.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"Moldova: infusions without influence","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Moldova, along with Armenia and Azerbaijan, is another vivid example of a country exiting Moscow’s sphere of influence. The process began long before the war — after pro-Western forces took power in 2009. Since then, only pro-European parties have governed the country. But until February 24, 2022, they tried to balance things and did not break ties with Moscow.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The current president, Maia Sandu, came to power in 2020 on a platform of European integration, but also promised equal and mutually beneficial relations with Russia. Under similar slogans, in 2021, the parliamentary majority was won by Sandu’s Action and Solidarity party. Sandu <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/4938107\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">met</a> with Russian presidential administration deputy chief Dmitry Kozak (until recently, the Kremlin’s Moldova handler).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Before the war, Chisinau <a href=\"https://newsmaker.md/ru/moldova-gotova-prodolzhat-pragmatichnyy-dialog-s-rossiey-gavrilitsa-vstretilas-s-rudenko\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">was visited</a> by Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Andrey Rudenko. Moldovan diplomats told me that during an informal dinner, he was asked directly: “Will Russia attack a neighboring country?” According to them, the answer was: “We’re going to bomb Kyiv?! How do you imagine that!” A week later, Russian missiles struck the Ukrainian capital.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After the war began, Moldova sided with Ukraine, cut ties with Moscow at all levels, and began to <a href=\"https://newsmaker.md/ru/moldova-rastorgnet-esche-tri-dogovora-v-ramkah-sng\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">terminate</a> agreements signed within the CIS. Now, Moldovan-Russian relations are relations without relations. The sides communicate mainly through public statements in which they rebuke each other for various reasons, sometimes summoning ambassadors to the Foreign Ministry to express dissatisfaction with each other’s unfriendly actions. A telling gesture — President Sandu has still not accepted the credentials of Russia’s new ambassador to Moldova, Oleg Ozerov, who arrived in the country last fall. The Ukrainian ambassador, who arrived later, presented his credentials to her at the beginning of the year.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Distancing from Russia is also happening in the economy. Chisinau <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/politics/02/10/2023/651a7eeb9a79472fd3f93730\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">does not buy</a> gas directly from Gazprom, preferring to purchase fuel on the European market. It’s too early to talk about full energy independence, but achieving it is the goal of the Moldovan authorities, and Brussels is helping them.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Since the start of the war in Ukraine, Moldova has made significant progress toward European integration. In the summer of 2022, the EU granted candidate status to both Moldova and Ukraine; at the end of 2023, Brussels decided to start accession talks with them. Now, a screening — an analysis of Moldova’s legislation for compliance with EU norms — is underway. This year, the EU raised its level of political relations with Moldova to the highest — annual bilateral summits, the first of which took place in Chisinau on July 4. The republic became the third post-Soviet country with which Brussels began working in this format after Russia (summits ended in 2014) and Ukraine. This is a success.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":15690,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Elena COVALENCO / AFP / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Moldova has firmly joined hands with the EU. President Maia Sandu between European Council President António Costa and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen at the first Moldova-EU summit","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50d5e411ad2949d8bb3e143b1192025b-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50d5e411ad2949d8bb3e143b1192025b-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":830,"real_height_2x":1659},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50d5e411ad2949d8bb3e143b1192025b-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50d5e411ad2949d8bb3e143b1192025b-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":830,"real_height_2x":1659},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50d5e411ad2949d8bb3e143b1192025b-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50d5e411ad2949d8bb3e143b1192025b-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":286,"real_height_2x":574},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50d5e411ad2949d8bb3e143b1192025b-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50d5e411ad2949d8bb3e143b1192025b-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":286,"real_height_2x":574}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Moscow does not want to accept the loss of influence in Moldova and supports politicians and parties advocating cooperation with Russia. The most prominent conduit of Russian interests in Moldova is the fugitive oligarch <a href=\"https://newsmaker.md/ru/svidetel-moldovy-kak-ilan-shor-stal-ilanom-shorom-39573\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Ilan Shor</a>. A citizen of Moldova, Israel, and, more recently, Russia, Shor was sentenced by a Moldovan court to 15 years in prison for his role in a massive financial fraud — the 2014 embezzlement of $1 billion from three Moldovan banks he then controlled. To avoid prison, Shor fled to Israel in 2019, then moved to Moscow, from where he remotely coordinates the activities of his supporters and party network. Some of them last year united in Moscow in the Victory bloc. Shor <a href=\"https://newsmaker.md/ru/kriptovalyuta-shora-pomogaet-rossii-obhodit-sankczii-cherez-nee-proveli-9-mlrd\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">deals in</a> cryptocurrency, <a href=\"https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/jy2785\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">helps</a> Russia circumvent sanctions, and during last year’s presidential election, his people organized <a href=\"https://www.eurointegration.com.ua/rus/news/2025/01/17/7202769/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">vote buying</a> of voters.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Moldovan economy is not doing well — GDP grew by only 0.1% last year, gas and electricity prices have risen, and so has everything else. Discontent with the government is growing, and Moscow intends to take advantage of this. Recently, the Kremlin changed its Moldova handler. From Kozak, who, as IStories sources said, was reluctant to deal with Shor because of his toxicity, the portfolio passed to the head of the domestic policy bloc, Sergey Kiriyenko. His <a href=\"https://carnegieendowment.org/russia-eurasia/politika/2025/07/russia-post-soviet-politics?lang=ru&amp;center=russia-eurasia\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">approach</a> is extremely simple: stop being shy about interfering in the affairs of post-Soviet states. Shor announced that “Victory” will run in the September parliamentary elections, which will determine the configuration of power for the next four years (Moldova is a parliamentary republic). He promised to <a href=\"https://www.eurointegration.com.ua/rus/news/2025/07/6/7215316/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">seek</a> the creation of a Russia-Moldova union and Moldova’s accession to the CSTO, despite its neutral status.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The chances of winning on such a platform are slim. The majority of the population, including those dissatisfied with the current pro-European government, support European integration — this course is enshrined in the constitution. But surprises are possible, and Shor knows how to mobilize people for street protests. According to <a href=\"https://imas.md/pic/archives/49/%5Bimas%5D%20barometrul%20socio-politic_iunie%202025.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">polls</a>, his Victory bloc is polling above the parliamentary threshold. If, of course, it is allowed to run.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Moscow’s options are complicated by the lack of a common border with Moldova and Brussels’ full support for Chisinau. The war has accelerated Moldova’s movement away from Russia and toward the West. It’s hard to imagine what would have to happen for this to reverse. Moldovan authorities insist the country will join the EU by 2030.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Belarus: looking to the West","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Alexander Lukashenko, who for years maneuvered between Russia and the West, fell into a trap five years ago. His re-election to a new presidential term sparked massive protests, which he crushed with great brutality. And the forced <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/4825905\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">landing</a> of a Ryanair plane in Minsk to detain opposition figure Roman Protasevich brought unprecedented sanctions upon Belarus.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The seasoned “batka” found himself in the tight embrace of the Kremlin. Room for maneuver disappeared, and Lukashenko could not wriggle out of complicity in Russia’s war with Ukraine. Belarusian territory became one of the staging grounds for the invasion. This further complicated Minsk’s relations with the EU and the US. Since 2022, Lukashenko’s main partner is Putin, and Russia is almost his only destination for foreign trips.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It seemed there was no way out of these embraces, but <a href=\"https://www.dw.com/ru/budet-li-belarus-anneksirovana-rossiej/a-71449258\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">talks resumed</a> on Belarus joining Russia. “Dependence has grown enormously in many areas. Belarusian air bases are used by Russia entirely at its own discretion,” says Carnegie Russia Eurasia Center expert Artem Shraibman. “Ninety percent of Belarus’s foreign trade goes either to Russia or through Russia. No one else is a sponsor, credit donor, or energy supplier, and at preferential prices. Here, dependence is close to total.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Lukashenko has always tried to slow down integration with Russia, and over the past year has made attempts to break out of isolation. He is inviting the West to bargain, releasing political prisoners. <a href=\"https://istories.media/news/2025/06/21/v-belarusi-sergeya-tikhanovskogo-osvobodili-iz-tyurmi-k-vizitu-delegatsii-ssha/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Released</a> from prison was Sergei Tikhanovsky, removed from the 2020 election, who served 5 of the 18 years handed down by the court. Maria Kolesnikova, jailed in September 2020, may also be released. Her release no longer seems unrealistic. Last year, Belarusian authorities allowed Maria’s father to visit her and <a href=\"https://euroradio.fm/ru/rezhim-nachinaet-menyat-igru-pochemu-vlasti-reshili-pokazat-mariyu-kolesnikovu\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">demonstrated</a> that she was alive and well. “Lukashenko is showing: there’s a deal to be made, I’m ready to talk about anything,” Shraibman observes.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The first result: on June 21, Minsk <a href=\"https://t.me/pul_1/17257\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">was visited by</a> US presidential envoy for Ukraine Keith Kellogg — that’s when Tikhanovsky was released. Issues were also discussed regarding <a href=\"https://meduza.io/news/2025/02/16/nyt-ssha-gotovyat-sdelku-s-lukashenko-po-osvobozhdeniyu-politzaklyuchennyh-vzamen-s-belarusi-snimut-sanktsii\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">lifting</a> sanctions on the country’s largest fertilizer producer, Belaruskali, as well as restoring air links with the republic (though this would require coordination with the EU).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":15691,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: EPA / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Alexander Lukashenko (right) is trying to distance himself from Russia and move closer to the West (left, US presidential envoy Keith Kellogg)","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3fdc34ec8bcf4eeb9f74285be723ec06-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3fdc34ec8bcf4eeb9f74285be723ec06-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":703,"real_height_2x":1406},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3fdc34ec8bcf4eeb9f74285be723ec06-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3fdc34ec8bcf4eeb9f74285be723ec06-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":703,"real_height_2x":1406},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3fdc34ec8bcf4eeb9f74285be723ec06-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3fdc34ec8bcf4eeb9f74285be723ec06-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":243,"real_height_2x":486},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3fdc34ec8bcf4eeb9f74285be723ec06-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3fdc34ec8bcf4eeb9f74285be723ec06-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":243,"real_height_2x":486}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Another notable step toward the West concerns <a href=\"https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/13/world/middleeast/belarus-migrants-iraq-kurds.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Minsk’s migration policy</a>, which caused quite a few problems for neighboring EU countries, <a href=\"https://carnegieendowment.org/russia-eurasia/politika/2025/06/belarus-eu-relations?lang=ru&amp;center=russia-eurasia\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">notes</a> Eastern Europe researcher Balázs Jarábik: “Belarus has restricted visa issuance and stopped facilitating access for refugees from the Middle East to EU border areas.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Lukashenko is guided not only by geopolitical expediency, though that is his top priority. Belarusians have no desire to join Russia. Only about 4% of Belarusians want this, and this figure has not changed for many years. “Plus or minus a percent or so — even the war hasn’t affected this constant,” says independent Belarusian sociologist Andrei Vardomatsky. Belarus’ moves toward the West, to reduce dependence on Moscow, has only just begun. It will not be easy or quick, but nothing is impossible.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Central Asia: lying low","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The Central Asian countries behave much more cautiously in their relations with Russia than Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Moldova. But over the past three years, there have been quite a few episodes of independence, multi-vector policies, and even toughness that Moscow finds unpleasant. If you put the puzzle pieces together, the picture is quite telling.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Not a single Central Asian country has condemned Russia’s actions against Ukraine, but Moscow has not received support from them either. Kyrgyzstan’s president Sadyr Japarov <a href=\"https://kloop.kg/blog/2022/03/09/sadyr-zhaparov-my-dolzhny-zanimat-nejtralnuyu-pozitsiyu-v-vojne-rossii-s-ukrainoj/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">stated</a>, that Bishkek should remain neutral in this war. In June 2022, Kazakh leader Kassym-Jomart Tokayev, who in January 2022 retained power in part thanks to the <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/5156017?from=glavnoe_4\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">deployment</a> of CSTO troops in the country, at an economic forum in St. Petersburg, in Putin’s presence, <a href=\"https://rus.azattyq.org/a/tokaev-o-priznanii-lnr-i-dnr/31903400.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">called</a> the DNR and LNR “quasi-state entities” and stressed that Astana does not intend to recognize them (at that time, Moscow had not yet incorporated them into Russia).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan (in 2005 and 2014) — not without Moscow’s help — forced the US to withdraw its troops. But neither they nor the other Central Asian countries, despite differences in regime severity, share Russia’s approach to the West as an enemy. Kazakhstan persistently <a href=\"https://www.dw.com/ru/vopros-prestiza-kazahstan-dobivaetsa-uprosenia-vezda-v-es/a-69442827\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">seeks</a> visa liberalization with the EU. Astana, while being a military ally of Russia (Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Tajikistan are CSTO members), recently <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/politics/06/06/2025/6842f0229a794783674cca7f\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">signed</a> a military cooperation agreement with the United Kingdom.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Another factor reducing Russia’s influence in the region is China’s interest. After the start of the war in Ukraine, the project for a <a href=\"https://www.ng.ru/world/2025-04-07/1_6_9229_china.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">railway</a> from China bypassing Russia, through Central Asian countries, finally gained momentum. China is investing heavily in the region (Moscow, because of the war, has no time for this), and has replaced Russia as the main trading partner of <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/economics/28/07/2023/64c3f8e89a7947a1b5f02cde\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Kazakhstan</a>, <a href=\"https://www.gazeta.uz/ru/2024/02/09/trade-partners/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Uzbekistan</a>, and is close to this with <a href=\"https://asiaplustj.info/ru/news/tajikistan/economic/20241126/kitai-stanovitsya-glavnim-importyorom-tadzhikistana\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Tajikistan</a>, while in <a href=\"https://www.akchabar.kg/news/kitaj-smestil-rossiyu-s-mesta-glavnogo-torgovogo-partnera-kirgizstana-njvklwmpksiizkui\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Kyrgyzstan</a> and <a href=\"https://caravan-info.pro/kitaj-ostaetsja-krupnejshim-torgovym-partnerom-turkmenistana/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Turkmenistan</a> this happened even before the war. China <a href=\"https://neftegaz.ru/amp/news/nuclear/891295-rosatom-vozglavit-konsortsium-po-stroitelstvu-pervoy-aes-v-kazakhstane/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">has even entered</a> areas where Russia’s positions seemed unshakable: it will participate in building a nuclear power plant in Kazakhstan. Since 2023, <a href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China\u0013Central_Asia_Summit\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">summits</a> between China and Central Asia have begun.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":15693,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Press Service of the President of Kazakhstan / AFP / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"China’s influence (President Xi third from left) in Central Asia is growing rapidly","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bf3d376c69f94a218cb6dd5877154eb0-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bf3d376c69f94a218cb6dd5877154eb0-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bf3d376c69f94a218cb6dd5877154eb0-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bf3d376c69f94a218cb6dd5877154eb0-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bf3d376c69f94a218cb6dd5877154eb0-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bf3d376c69f94a218cb6dd5877154eb0-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bf3d376c69f94a218cb6dd5877154eb0-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bf3d376c69f94a218cb6dd5877154eb0-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Central Asian states are decisively cracking down on their citizens’ involvement in combat in Ukraine. Those who fight on Russia’s side receive prison sentences in <a href=\"https://www.currenttime.tv/a/kyrgyzstan-rossiya-askarbek/33005097.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Kyrgyzstan</a> and <a href=\"https://t.me/nt_vedomosti/36135\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Uzbekistan</a>. In Kyrgyzstan, in a case over recruitment for the front, <a href=\"https://rtvi.com/news/v-kirgizii-arestovali-sotrudniczu-russkogo-doma-za-verbovku-na-svo/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">a staffer</a> of the Russian House, Natalya Sekerina, was arrested.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"While Russia rehabilitates Stalin and talks about the mythical “denazification” of Ukraine, Central Asian governments are carrying out de-Sovietization. In June, a <a href=\"https://www.dw.com/ru/v-kyrgyzstane-demontirovali-samyj-vysokij-pamatnik-leninu-v-centralnoj-azii/a-72831288\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">25-meter-high</a> — the tallest in Central Asia — Lenin monument was dismantled in the Kyrgyz city of Osh. Lenin is also <a href=\"https://orda.kz/konec-jepohi-pamjatnik-leninu-mogut-demontirovat-s-ploschadi-v-bishkeke-396891/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">set to be removed</a> in Bishkek. <a href=\"https://orda.kz/bez-lenina-vsled-za-pamjatnikami-kyrgyzstan-nachal-izbavljatsja-ot-sovetskih-nazvanij-ulic-403897/#:~:text=%D0%91%D0%B5%D0%B7%20%D0%9B%D0%B5%D0%BD%D0%B8%D0%BD%D0%B0%3A%20%D0%B2%D1%81%D0%BB%D0%B5%D0%B4%20%D0%B7%D0%B0%20%D0%BF%D0%B0%D0%BC%D1%8F%D1%82%D0%BD%D0%B8%D0%BA%D0%B0%D0%BC%D0%B8%20%D0%9A%D1%8B%D1%80%D0%B3%D1%8B%D0%B7%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B0%D0%BD%20%D0%BD%D0%B0%D1%87%D0%B0%D0%BB-%D0%B8%D0%B7%D0%B1%D0%B0%D0%B2%D0%BB%D1%8F%D1%82%D1%8C%D1%81%D1%8F%20%D0%BE%D1%82%20%D1%81%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%B5%D1%82%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B8%D1%85%20%D0%BD%D0%B0%D0%B7%D0%B2%D0%B0%D0%BD%D0%B8%D0%B9%20%D1%83%D0%BB%D0%B8%D1%86,-04%20%D0%B8%D1%8E%D0%BB%D1%8F%202025&amp;text=%D0%9A%D1%8B%D1%80%D0%B3%D1%8B%D0%B7%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B8%D0%B5%20%D0%B2%D0%BB%D0%B0%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B8%20%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%B4%D0%BE%D0%BB%D0%B6%D0%B0%D1%8E%D1%82%20%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BC%D0%BE%D0%BD%D1%82%D0%B0%D0%B6%20%D1%81%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%B5%D1%82%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B3%D0%BE,%D0%BE%D0%B4%D0%BD%D1%83%20%D0%B8%D0%B7%20%D1%86%D0%B5%D0%BD%D1%82%D1%80%D0%B0%D0%BB%D1%8C%D0%BD%D1%8B%D1%85%20%D0%B2%20%D0%B3%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%B4%D0%B5.\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Soviet street names are also being changed</a> in the country.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"***","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"What is happening now was unimaginable ten years ago: Russian influence in the post-Soviet space is shrinking, Alexander Iskandaryan notes. This, he says, is a fairly long-standing process, but now “Russia is turning into a very convenient narrative for a black-and-white picture that can be used in domestic politics.” The Ukraine issue has so eclipsed everything else in Russian foreign policy that, as Maxim Samorukov, an expert on Russia and Eurasia at the Carnegie Center, observes, “they attribute panacea-like properties to a possible victory there. It’s a rather illusory approach, but there is a certain logic to it.”","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":7536,"header":"Without You, There Is No Us","_path":"/en/opinions/2025/04/30/without-you-there-is-no-us/","lead":"A letter from the founder of IStories Roman Anin to mark our anniversary","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa34ceeafbc94005aced7b07154d8ec0-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Photo: IStories","created_at_date":"2025-04-30","created_at_date_time":"2025-04-30T04:45:29.359Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":5,"first_name":"Роман","last_name":"Анин","first_name_en":"Roman","last_name_en":"Anin","is_public":true,"_path":"roman-anin","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редактор «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Редактор","position_en":"Editor","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"The name “Important Stories” first came to me when, contemplating the creation of a new media outlet, I asked myself: “What will it be about?” Today, Important Stories turns five, and I doubt anyone would dispute that this name answers that old question perfectly.\nYesterday, my colleagues from the investigations department published a harrowing yet crucial report on the fate of the young Ukrainian journalist Viktoriia Roshchyna, who was abducted and tortured to death in occupied Ukrainian territory. Russia returned her body to her parents without her eyes, brain, and part of her larynx.\nLess than a week ago, journalists from the IStories data team released a story of the son of the CIA deputy director, who had joined the Russian army, was killed in the war in Ukraine. This story became an international sensation, covered by all the world’s leading media outlets.\nTen days ago, my colleagues in the video department published a poignant confession from the father of a 20-year-old conscript from Chelyabinsk who died in Ukraine. More than one and a half million people have already watched this film.\nWe are one of the few Russian media in exile that continue to travel across the country’s regions to show what ordinary people really think about the war, the authorities, poverty, and injustice — about everything that will never appear on Russian television.\nAnd these are just the stories of the past ten days. There have been countless others, no less important, before them. And you can hardly imagine what stories my colleagues and I are working on now to share with you in the near future.\nThe quality of our work is recognized even in the Kremlin: we have not only collected every possible “award” in the form of “foreign agent” and “undesirable” labels, but this year added a couple of criminal cases and trials in absentia. I write this with a smile, though I know how hard it is for my colleagues, who face constant pressure and unending threats.\nToday is our first milestone anniversary, and to be honest, I still find it hard to believe we have made it this far.\nI want to thank all of you — the remarkable people who have been with us all these years and supported our team. Believe me, your kind words are perhaps the main motivation for my colleagues and me to continue our work. I sincerely hope we will live to see the next anniversary and celebrate it together.\nWithout you, there is no us!","blocks":[{"data":"The name “Important Stories” first came to me when, contemplating the creation of a new media outlet, I asked myself: “What will it be about?” Today, Important Stories turns five, and I doubt anyone would dispute that this name answers that old question perfectly.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Yesterday, my colleagues from the investigations department published a harrowing yet crucial <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2025/04/29/viktoriia-project/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">report</a> on the fate of the young Ukrainian journalist Viktoriia Roshchyna, who was abducted and tortured to death in occupied Ukrainian territory. Russia returned her body to her parents without her eyes, brain, and part of her larynx.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Less than a week ago, journalists from the IStories data team released a <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2025/04/25/michael-gloss-story/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">story</a> of the son of the CIA deputy director, who had joined the Russian army, was killed in the war in Ukraine. This story became an international sensation, covered by all the world’s leading media outlets.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Ten days ago, my colleagues in the video department published a poignant <a href=\"https://youtu.be/f4UoreRlPac\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">confession</a> from the father of a 20-year-old conscript from Chelyabinsk who died in Ukraine. More than one and a half million people have already watched this film.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We are one of the few Russian media in exile that continue to travel across the country’s regions to show what ordinary people really think about the war, the authorities, poverty, and injustice&nbsp;—&nbsp;about everything that will never appear on Russian television.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"And these are just the stories of the past ten days. There have been countless others, no less important, before them. And you can hardly imagine what stories my colleagues and I are working on now to share with you in the near future.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The quality of our work is recognized even in the Kremlin: we have not only collected every possible “award” in the form of “foreign agent” and “undesirable” labels, but this year <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/news/2024/12/05/search-and-seizure-at-the-home-of-istories-editor-in-chiefs-parents/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">added</a> a <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/news/2025/03/31/anin-fomina-sentence/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">couple</a> of criminal cases and trials in absentia. I write this with a smile, though I know how hard it is for my colleagues, who face constant pressure and unending threats.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Today is our first milestone anniversary, and to be honest, I still find it hard to believe we have made it this far.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"I want to thank all of you — the remarkable people who have been with us all these years and supported our team. Believe me, your kind words are perhaps the main motivation for my colleagues and me to continue our work. I sincerely hope we will live to see the next anniversary and celebrate it together.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Without you, there is no us!","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":7537,"header":"Five Years of Important Stories","_path":"/en/opinions/2025/04/30/five-years-of-important-stories/","lead":"A letter to our readers from editor-in-chief Alesya Marokhovskaya","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd099fe257f4484d9531891d8475c739-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Photo: Christoph Soeder / dpa / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2025-04-30","created_at_date_time":"2025-04-29T12:34:26.020Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":8,"first_name":"Алеся","last_name":"Мароховская","first_name_en":"Alesya","last_name_en":"Marokhovskaya","is_public":true,"_path":"alesya-marokhovskaya","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Главная редакторка «Важных историй»","lead_en":"Editor-in-chief","position":"Редакторка","position_en":"Editor","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"Today marks a major milestone for IStories — we turn five years old! While five years may not seem like a long time, the intensity of events over this period makes it feel more like fifty-five. What a journey it has been — certainly not an easy one.\nImportant Stories was “born” on April 30, 2020, at the height of the coronavirus pandemic. Back then, we believed that if we could survive that crisis — both literally and figuratively — and continue to work effectively in a new online environment, nothing else could scare us.\nIn 2021, we realized that the challenges brought by COVID were only the beginning. That year, FSB and Investigative Committee officers raided our newsroom and the home of our then editor-in-chief and founder, Roman Anin. In August, my colleagues Irina Dolinina, Dmitry Velikovsky, Roman Anin, Roman Shleynov, Olesya Shmagun, and I, along with our media outlet, were labelled “foreign agents.” We suddenly found ourselves needing to navigate a path that would allow us to keep working in Russia without ending up behind bars. At the time, it felt as though we had entered a new era of darkness.\n\n\nFebruary 2022 irrevocably divided the lives of Ukrainians and Russians into “before” and “after.” Even as I braced for the worst, I could not have imagined the scale of horror the Russian army would unleash in Ukraine — and continues to inflict.\nJust days after the full-scale invasion began, we were forced to leave Russia. It was no longer possible to do our work and call things by their real names without risking imprisonment. Anything that contradicted the official state narrative was branded “fake news,” punishable by up to 15 years in prison.\nWe had no plan for how to operate under these conditions. But we had a powerful desire to keep telling our readers and viewers the truth. How could we do this from exile? We feared we would not be able to maintain the same quality of reporting, that we would lose all our contacts and sources, and that finding new ones would be nearly impossible. All this, while being declared an “undesirable organization” and blocked in Russia. Our greatest fear was losing you — the people for whom IStories exists.\nYet the lessons of the pandemic — moving our work online — proved invaluable. The government’s attempts to block Telegram only made our audience more adept at using VPNs. We transformed from a weekly publication focused on deep investigations and reports into a daily media outlet, covering the most important news every day. Since 2022, we have been working at the very edge of our abilities.\n\n\nIn the first year of the war alone, we broke stories about the Wagner Group recruiting prisoners — followed by the Ministry of Defense doing the same. We obtained the first confession from a Russian soldier to the killing of a Ukrainian civilian. We calculated how much Russian regions spend on mobilization and how this is leading the country toward demographic disaster. These are just a few examples that come to mind.\nTo be honest, 2023 blurred together with 2022 for me; it was hard to believe that, a year later, we were even further from the end of the war. To avoid sinking into despair, we kept our heads down and focused on our work.\nWe discovered that state-owned companies were now hiring people to send to war, and that the Russian army was forming regiments from wounded conscripts. We were the first to report how many children Russian authorities deported from Ukraine and placed in orphanages without indicating their origins. We later uncovered and proved that lawmaker Sergey Mironov and his new wife had adopted a child kidnapped from Ukraine and changed his identity. It was the deportation of Ukrainian children that led the International Criminal Court to issue arrest warrants for Vladimir Putin and Maria Lvova-Belova in March 2023.\n2023 was also marked by tragedy at Moscow’s Vremena Goda shopping mall, where a burst hot water pipe killed four people. This was far from the only case of Russians suffering due to the country’s crumbling infrastructure, prompting us to conduct a major investigation into the problem. We also reported on how much public money is spent on propaganda and who is really behind the creation of fake news.\nAnd now, 2024. Just when it seemed things couldn’t get worse, we learned they absolutely could. The war grinds on, Alexey Navalny is murdered, a terrorist attack strikes Crocus City Hall, the largest-ever vote rigging in the presidential election, part of Kursk Oblast is occupied, and catastrophic flooding hits the Urals. We worked tirelessly to gather and report as much information as possible on all these events.\nWe located the Telegram crypto-wallet of the Islamic State – Khorasan Province, from which $2,525 was withdrawn immediately after the Crocus attack — exactly the amount, according to detainees, that they received on their bank cards. We calculated that at least 22 million votes for Putin in the presidential election were falsified — a record in Russian history.\n\n\nWe were first to confirm the deaths of at least five people during the Orenburg flood, while authorities insisted there were no casualties. The Emergency Ministry acknowledged fatalities only a year later; we reported them immediately and explained why such tragedies are becoming more common in Russia. We also uncovered the seemingly impossible story of more than a thousand soldiers from the 20th Motor Rifle Division going AWOL.\nBy 2025, we had ceased to be surprised by anything. But we continue to do our work. Despite our fears that quality journalism would be impossible in exile, we have proven — to ourselves, and I hope to you — that it is possible.\n2025 is not yet over, but we have already brought you many important stories. We reported on the son of ousted Ukrainian president Viktor Yanukovych, who is making billions selling coal from occupied territories, with shipments going to Turkey and other countries and the profits funneled offshore.\nWe revealed that more than 15,000 people were admitted to universities in 2024 under quotas for participants in the “special military operation” and their children — twice as many as the previous year. These new beneficiaries scored, on average, half as many points as other applicants, and in medical schools, five times fewer.\nWe reported on Russian elites obtaining Serbian passports en masse during the war, granting them visa-free access to the EU, while foreigners arrive in Russia to join the fight. Among them, we discovered the extraordinary story of the son of CIA deputy director Michael Gloss, who died in Ukraine fighting for the Russian army.\n\n\nAnd this is just a small part of what we have accomplished in five years. I will be honest: being a Russian journalist is becoming more difficult with each passing year. Yes, we too have moments of despair, when it feels like we are helpless grains of sand in a raging storm and want to give up. But each time, we push those thoughts aside, because we know there are people who truly need our work.\nYou — our readers and viewers — are what keep us going. You not only read and watch us, but support us with donations, comments, letters, and even tips that help us tell new stories (by the way, you can send tips via our Telegram bot or through the feedback form on our website main page).\nWithout you, there would be no Important Stories. This challenging five-year journey was made possible by you and with you. So this anniversary is yours as much as ours.\nAnd since it is customary to make a wish on your birthday, I want to do so right here: I hope that a year from now, I will have more stories to share and more reasons to thank you, our readers and viewers. We are already hard at work on new, extraordinary, and vital stories.\nBut as we reach our fifth year, the reality is that we cannot continue without your support. We may be resilient, but any help you can provide is not just important — it is essential.\nTell your friends and family about IStories. Subscribe your relatives and acquaintances to our YouTube, Telegram, and X. We do not overwhelm our audience with a flood of news; we report only what truly matters.\nPlease consider supporting us with a donation. Even a monthly contribution of $5 may seem small, but if a thousand, two thousand, or three thousand people do the same, it will make a huge difference and ensure we can keep working.\nThank you for being with us these five years. Let’s meet here again in a year, and I will tell you what else we have achieved together!","blocks":[{"data":"Today marks a major milestone for IStories — we turn five years old! While five years may not seem like a long time, the intensity of events over this period makes it feel more like fifty-five. What a journey it has been — certainly not an easy one.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Important Stories was “born” on April 30, 2020, at the height of the coronavirus pandemic. Back then, we believed that if we could survive that crisis&nbsp;— both literally and figuratively — and continue to work effectively in a new online environment, nothing else could scare us.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2021, we realized that the challenges brought by COVID were only the beginning. That year, FSB and Investigative Committee officers <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/reportages/2021/04/15/what-we-know-about-the-criminal-case-that-has-led-to-roman-anin-being-questioned/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">raided</a> our newsroom and the home of our then editor-in-chief and founder, Roman Anin. In August, my colleagues Irina Dolinina, Dmitry Velikovsky, Roman Anin, Roman Shleynov, Olesya Shmagun, and I, along with our media outlet, were <a href=\"https://t.me/istories_media/645\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">labelled</a> “foreign agents.” We suddenly found ourselves needing to navigate a path that would allow us to keep working in Russia without ending up behind bars. At the time, it felt as though we had entered a new era of darkness.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":15043,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: AP / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"IStories journalist Irina Dolinina at a protest against media censorship. Moscow, September 8, 2021","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9451042726342f5b43192fbf45fc6be-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9451042726342f5b43192fbf45fc6be-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9451042726342f5b43192fbf45fc6be-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9451042726342f5b43192fbf45fc6be-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9451042726342f5b43192fbf45fc6be-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9451042726342f5b43192fbf45fc6be-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9451042726342f5b43192fbf45fc6be-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9451042726342f5b43192fbf45fc6be-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"February 2022 irrevocably divided the lives of Ukrainians and Russians into “before” and “after.” Even as I braced for the worst, I could not have imagined the scale of horror the Russian army would unleash in Ukraine — and continues to inflict.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Just days after the full-scale invasion began, we were forced to leave Russia. It was no longer possible to do our work and call things by their real names without risking imprisonment. Anything that contradicted the official state narrative was branded “fake news,” punishable by up to 15 years in prison.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We had no plan for how to operate under these conditions. But we had a powerful desire to keep telling our readers and viewers the truth. How could we do this from exile? We feared we would not be able to maintain the same quality of reporting, that we would lose all our contacts and sources, and that finding new ones would be nearly impossible. All this, while being declared an “undesirable organization” and blocked in Russia. Our greatest fear was losing you — the people for whom IStories exists.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Yet the lessons of the pandemic — moving our work online — proved invaluable. The government’s attempts to block Telegram only made our audience more adept at using VPNs. We transformed from a weekly publication focused on deep investigations and reports into a daily media outlet, covering the most important news every day. Since 2022, we have been working at the very edge of our abilities.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":15044,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Evgeniy Maloletka / AP / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Aftermath of a Russian military strike on Mariupol, February 24, 2022","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fefc3b0cacdf42668a0751a65a4070de-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fefc3b0cacdf42668a0751a65a4070de-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":802,"real_height_2x":1603},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fefc3b0cacdf42668a0751a65a4070de-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fefc3b0cacdf42668a0751a65a4070de-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":802,"real_height_2x":1603},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fefc3b0cacdf42668a0751a65a4070de-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fefc3b0cacdf42668a0751a65a4070de-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":277,"real_height_2x":554},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fefc3b0cacdf42668a0751a65a4070de-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fefc3b0cacdf42668a0751a65a4070de-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":277,"real_height_2x":554}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"In the first year of the war alone, we broke stories about the Wagner Group recruiting <a href=\"https://istories.media/reportages/2022/07/04/chvk-vagner-verbuet-zaklyuchennikh-kolonii-peterburga-dlya-poezdki-na-donbass-idti-v-avangarde-pomogat-obnaruzhivat-natsistov/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">prisoners</a> — followed by the Ministry of Defense doing <a href=\"https://istories.media/news/2022/10/11/minoboroni-rossii-teper-tozhe-verbuet-zekov-na-front/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">the same</a>. We obtained the first <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rudUGZxIU6E\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">confession</a> from a Russian soldier to the killing of a Ukrainian civilian. We <a href=\"https://istories.media/stories/2022/11/07/skolko-rossiiskie-regioni-zaplatili-za-voinu/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">calculated</a> how much Russian regions spend on mobilization and how this is leading the country toward <a href=\"https://istories.media/investigations/2022/05/04/yunie-bednie-mertvie/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">demographic disaster</a>. These are just a few examples that come to mind.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"To be honest, 2023 blurred together with 2022 for me; it was hard to believe that, a year later, we were even further from the end of the war. To avoid sinking into despair, we kept our heads down and focused on our work.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We discovered that state-owned companies were now <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2023/08/01/billionaires-mercenaries/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">hiring</a> people to send to war, and that the Russian army was forming regiments from <a href=\"https://istories.media/stories/2023/12/06/dobit-nedobitikh-v-armii-rossii-poyavilis-invalidnie-shturmovie-podrazdeleniya/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">wounded conscripts</a>. We were the first to report how many children Russian authorities <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2023/05/31/to-kidnap-and-russify/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">deported</a> from Ukraine and placed in orphanages without indicating their origins. We later uncovered and proved that lawmaker Sergey Mironov and his new wife had <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2023/11/23/mironov-kidnapping/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">adopted</a> a child kidnapped from Ukraine and changed his identity. It was the deportation of Ukrainian children that led the International Criminal Court to issue arrest warrants for Vladimir Putin and Maria Lvova-Belova in March 2023.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"2023 was also marked by tragedy at Moscow’s <em>Vremena Goda</em> shopping mall, where a burst hot water pipe killed four people. This was far from the only case of Russians suffering due to the country’s crumbling infrastructure, prompting us to conduct a major <a href=\"https://istories.media/stories/2023/01/20/krov-iznosa/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">investigation</a> into the problem. We also reported on how much public money is spent on propaganda and who is really <a href=\"https://istories.media/stories/2023/09/18/i-poyavilas-takaya-ideya-delat-feiki/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">behind</a> the creation of fake news.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"And now, 2024. Just when it seemed things couldn’t get worse, we learned they absolutely could. The war grinds on, Alexey Navalny is murdered, a terrorist attack strikes <em>Crocus City Hall</em>, the largest-ever vote rigging in the presidential election, part of Kursk Oblast is occupied, and catastrophic flooding hits the Urals. We worked tirelessly to gather and report as much information as possible on all these events.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We located the Telegram crypto-wallet of the <em>Islamic State – Khorasan Province</em>, from which $2,525 was withdrawn immediately after the <em>Crocus</em> attack — exactly the amount, according to detainees, that they received on their bank cards. We calculated that at least 22 million votes for Putin in the presidential election were <a href=\"https://istories.media/stories/2024/03/20/proshedshie-vibori-prezidenta-samie-sfalsifitsirovannie-v-istorii-rossii/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">falsified</a> — a record in Russian history.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":15045,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: AFP / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Fire at Crocus City Hall after the terrorist attack. Moscow, March 22, 2024","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a8080959a2e24d14be0508bcfd761876-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a8080959a2e24d14be0508bcfd761876-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a8080959a2e24d14be0508bcfd761876-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a8080959a2e24d14be0508bcfd761876-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a8080959a2e24d14be0508bcfd761876-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a8080959a2e24d14be0508bcfd761876-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a8080959a2e24d14be0508bcfd761876-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a8080959a2e24d14be0508bcfd761876-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"We were first to <a href=\"https://istories.media/news/2024/04/15/vazhnie-istorii-ustanovili-lichnosti-pogibshikh-i-propavshikh-bez-vesti-v-navodnenii-v-orenburzhe-vlasti-uveryayut-chto-zhertv-net/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">confirm</a> the deaths of at least five people during the Orenburg flood, while authorities insisted there were no casualties. The Emergency Ministry acknowledged fatalities only a year later; we reported them immediately and <a href=\"https://istories.media/stories/2024/07/15/v-rossii-proiskhodit-vse-bolshe-razrushitelnikh-navodnenii/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">explained</a> why such tragedies are becoming more common in Russia. We also uncovered the seemingly impossible story of more than a thousand soldiers from the <em>20th Motor Rifle Division</em> <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2024/11/19/a-runaway-regiment/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">going</a> AWOL.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"By 2025, we had ceased to be surprised by anything. But we continue to do our work. Despite our fears that quality journalism would be impossible in exile, we have proven — to ourselves, and I hope to you — that it is possible.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"2025 is not yet over, but we have already brought you many important stories. We reported on the son of ousted Ukrainian president Viktor Yanukovych, who is <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2025/02/04/yanukovychs-sons-coal/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">making</a> billions selling coal from occupied territories, with shipments going to Turkey and other countries and the profits funneled offshore.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We revealed that more than 15,000 people were <a href=\"https://istories.media/stories/2025/03/11/postuplenie-vuzy-svo-2024/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">admitted</a> to universities in 2024 under quotas for participants in the “special military operation” and their children&nbsp;— twice as many as the previous year. These new beneficiaries scored, on average, half as many points as other applicants, and in medical schools, five times fewer.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We reported on Russian elites <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2025/04/16/belgrade-syndicate/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">obtaining</a> Serbian passports en masse during the war, granting them visa-free access to the EU, while foreigners <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2025/04/23/mercenaries/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">arrive</a> in Russia to join the fight. Among them, we discovered the extraordinary story of the son of CIA deputy director <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2025/04/25/michael-gloss-story/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Michael Gloss</a>, who died in Ukraine fighting for the Russian army.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":15046,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: SBU","caption":"Chinese soldier fighting for Russia in Ukrainian captivity, April 9, 2025","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2f953d54b084439bbaea184f2aed1184-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2f953d54b084439bbaea184f2aed1184-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1599},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2f953d54b084439bbaea184f2aed1184-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2f953d54b084439bbaea184f2aed1184-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1599},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2f953d54b084439bbaea184f2aed1184-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2f953d54b084439bbaea184f2aed1184-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":552},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2f953d54b084439bbaea184f2aed1184-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2f953d54b084439bbaea184f2aed1184-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":552}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"And this is just a small part of what we have accomplished in five years. I will be honest: being a Russian journalist is becoming more difficult with each passing year. Yes, we too have moments of despair, when it feels like we are helpless grains of sand in a raging storm and want to give up. But each time, we push those thoughts aside, because we know there are people who truly need our work.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"You — our readers and viewers — are what keep us going. You not only read and watch us, but support us with donations, comments, letters, and even tips that help us tell new stories (by the way, you can send tips via our <a href=\"https://t.me/mail_to_istories_bot\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Telegram bot</a> or through the feedback form on our website main page).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Without you, there would be no Important Stories. This challenging five-year journey was made possible by you and with you. So this anniversary is yours as much as ours.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"And since it is customary to make a wish on your birthday, I want to do so right here: I hope that a year from now, I will have more stories to share and more reasons to thank you, our readers and viewers. We are already hard at work on new, extraordinary, and vital stories.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But as we reach our fifth year, the reality is that we cannot continue without your support. We may be resilient, but any help you can provide is not just important — it is essential.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Tell your friends and family about IStories. Subscribe your relatives and acquaintances to our <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/@istories_media/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">YouTube</a>, <a href=\"https://t.me/istories_media\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Telegram</a>, and <a href=\"https://x.com/istories_eng\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">X</a>. We do not overwhelm our audience with a flood of news; we report only what truly matters.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Please consider <a href=\"https://istories.media/donations/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">supporting us with a donation</a>. Even a monthly contribution of $5 may seem small, but if a thousand, two thousand, or three thousand people do the same, it will make a huge difference and ensure we can keep working.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Thank you for being with us these five years. Let’s meet here again in a year, and I will tell you what else we have achieved together!","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":7293,"header":"Russia is Preparing to Restore the Nord Stream Gas Pipeline, IStories Source Reports","_path":"/en/opinions/2025/03/14/russia-is-preparing-to-restore-the-nord-stream-gas-pipeline/","lead":"Here are three signs of such preparation","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a23cc383a9e4861b1eceb3a724cdbd2-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Laying the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline on the bottom of the Baltic Sea, November 2018. Photo: Bernd Wüstnek / dpa / AFP / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2025-03-14","created_at_date_time":"2025-03-13T23:38:08.222Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[],"external_authors_list":[{"id":275,"first_name":"Roman","last_name":"Katin","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":1}],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"IStories has noticed several indirect signs that Russia is preparing to restore the Nord Stream pipelines. And although experts are still skeptical about such a possibility, this is indicated, in particular, by the activity of a company that previously processed pipes for these pipelines — it may be linked to Arkady Rotenberg and former top managers of Gazprom, who are now suspected of siphoning off its assets to the tune of 150 billion rubles.\n\nContext\nNord Stream 1 and Nord Stream 2 are the longest offshore gas pipelines in the world. They could transport up to 110 billion cubic meters of gas per year to Europe (for comparison, in 2024, Russia delivered only about 31 billion cubic meters to China via the Power of Siberia pipeline).\nTwo strings of Nord Stream 1 became operational in 2011 and 2012. The construction of two strings of Nord Stream 2 was completed in 2021, but this pipeline never started operating due to international sanctions. And after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, three of the four strings were blown up as a result of sabotage. According to The Wall Street Journal, Ukraine was involved.\nIn September 2024, EU Energy Commissioner Kadri Simson stated that the EU’s dependence on Russian gas had decreased from 45% in 2021 to 15% in 2023 and that Europe could completely abandon it, at least — completely stop its transit through Ukraine (transit ceased from January 2025). But Central European countries are not ready for a total rejection. The most dependent in this regard are Austria, Hungary, and Slovakia.\nThe main problem for Europe is not that it might freeze in winter without Russian gas (this is unlikely). It’s the increase in gas prices, which makes European manufacturers less competitive compared to Chinese and American ones. The EU had to postpone Russian fuel phase-out until 2027. But in any case, there was no talk of resuming Nord Stream.\n\nSigns\nThe situation changed after Donald Trump won the U.S. presidential election. The first reports about discussions on restoring Nord Stream 2 appeared in early March of this year. According to the German newspaper Bild, Trump’s special envoy Richard Grenell held secret talks in Switzerland about launching the pipeline. It was allegedly about the Americans potentially mediating the supply of Russian gas to Germany. The special envoy himself denied the talks. Financial Times sources also reported on American interest in restarting the pipelines.\nIStories has uncovered further indications that the Russian side may be hoping for a restart of the Nord Stream project.\nThe first sign — the Russian company Pipeline Coatings and Technologies, which was involved in the construction of Nord Stream 2 (engaged in concreting pipes for laying on the seabed), has apparently begun preparing for a large order. According to a source close to Gazprom’s management who spoke to IStories, the company has started actively buying up patents for technical solutions that were used in the preparation of pipes for these pipelines.\n“The pipe concreting technology itself is Western. But there are many nuances for which patents were registered in Russia. Previously, they were registered to various specialists, but now the company has started actively buying them up, as it wants to be ready for a potential order and doesn’t want to pay third parties if this order materializes,” says the IStories source.\n\n\nThe second sign is the activity of the pipe association. Pipe Producers Association, as stated on its website, promotes the implementation of Gazprom’s programs to provide it with domestically produced pipes. Within the framework of the association, Gazprom employees negotiate with pipe manufacturers on exactly what products (down to the technical characteristics of the pipe) and in what volumes the gas concern is counting on and what it may need in the future.\nAccording to a source from IStories close to Gazprom’s management, the latest meetings of the association discussed, among other things, pipes for laying on the seabed. Although “with Gazprom’s current situation, such activity of the association is not required — there are no large-scale projects that require pipes with such technical characteristics,” he notes.\n“Gazprom currently has no major projects related to laying pipes on the seabed,” confirms oil and gas market expert Mikhail Krutikhin.\n\n\nThe third sign is conservation. In January 2025, the Nord Stream 2 AG gas pipeline operator, two years after the sabotage, received permission from the Danish Energy Agency to carry out conservation work on the damaged Nord Stream 2. Formally, we are talking about carrying out work to pump seawater out of the damaged pipes of the gas pipeline and install plugs on them. Potentially, this could speed up and facilitate restoration. However, the agency itself explained this decision as a concern for the environment.\n“For more than two years, the blown-up section of the Nord Streams did not prompt the Danish authorities to take any action. And then the company Nord Stream 2 [the pipeline operator, a Swiss subsidiary of Gazprom], which is facing bankruptcy, seeks and receives permission to carry out work,” the IStories source wonders.\nThe Pipe Producers Association and the Pipeline Coatings and Technologies company did not respond to questions from IStories.\nPreviously, the German investigative media outlet Correctiv, with the participation of IStories, found out that the authorities of Germany, Russia, and the USA are discussing the resumption of oil supplies through the Druzhba pipeline to Germany. For this purpose, the Americans will buy out Rosneft’s share in the PCK oil refinery, which, before the full-scale war in Ukraine, was supplied with raw materials from Russia via Druzhba. Read more about this here.","blocks":[{"data":"IStories has noticed several indirect signs that Russia is preparing to restore the <em>Nord Stream</em> pipelines. And although experts are still <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/7460941\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">skeptical</a> about such a possibility, this is indicated, in particular, by the activity of a company that previously processed pipes for these pipelines — it may be linked to Arkady Rotenberg and former top managers of <em>Gazprom</em>, who are now suspected of siphoning off its assets to the tune of 150 billion rubles.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Context","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"<em>Nord Stream 1</em> and <em>Nord Stream 2</em> are the longest offshore gas pipelines in the world. They could transport up to 110 billion cubic meters of gas per year to Europe (for comparison, in 2024, Russia <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/business/1000815\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">delivered</a> only about 31 billion cubic meters to China via the <em>Power of Siberia</em> pipeline).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Two strings of Nord Stream 1 became operational in 2011 and 2012. The construction of two strings of Nord Stream 2 was completed in 2021, but this pipeline never started operating due to international sanctions. And after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, three of the four strings were blown up as a result of sabotage. According to <a href=\"https://www.wsj.com/world/europe/nord-stream-pipeline-explosion-real-story-da24839c?mod=hp_lead_pos7\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>The Wall Street Journal</em></a>, Ukraine was involved.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In September 2024, EU Energy Commissioner Kadri Simson <a href=\"https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/statement_24_1868\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">stated</a> that the EU’s dependence on Russian gas had decreased from 45% in 2021 to 15% in 2023 and that Europe could completely abandon it, at least — completely stop its transit through Ukraine (transit <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/business/01/01/2025/677125659a79473f0809c3a2\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">ceased</a> from January 2025). But Central European countries are <a href=\"https://www.dw.com/ru/centralnoj-evrope-slozno-otkazatsa-ot-energoresursov-iz-rf/a-70737881\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">not ready</a> for a total rejection. The most dependent in this regard are Austria, Hungary, and Slovakia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The main problem for Europe is not that it might freeze in winter without Russian gas (this is <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/articles/c4g7n56lx6do\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">unlikely</a>). It’s the increase in gas prices, which <a href=\"https://tass.ru/ekonomika/14895915\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">makes</a> European manufacturers <a href=\"https://www.moscowtimes.ru/2024/12/09/analiz-udar-ot-skachka-tsen-na-gaz-usugubit-problemy-promsektora-evropy-a149961\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">less</a> competitive compared to Chinese and American ones. The EU had to <a href=\"https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-01-27/eu-likely-to-delay-russian-fuel-phase-out-plan-by-a-month?sref=cus85deZ\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">postpone</a> Russian fuel phase-out until 2027. But in any case, there was no talk of resuming <em>Nord Stream</em>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Signs","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The situation changed after Donald Trump won the U.S. presidential election. The first reports about discussions on restoring Nord Stream 2 appeared in early March of this year. According to the German newspaper <em>Bild</em>, Trump’s special envoy Richard Grenell <a href=\"https://www.bild.de/politik/ausland-und-internationales/geheime-gespraeche-trump-und-putin-planen-deutschen-gas-deal-67ae15f61371a020a10142f5\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">held</a> secret talks in Switzerland about launching the pipeline. It was allegedly about the Americans potentially mediating the supply of Russian gas to Germany. The special envoy himself denied the talks. <em>Financial Times</em> sources also <a href=\"https://www.ft.com/content/dc9c51ab-03cb-47ba-ad0a-09c4deed9b50\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reported</a> on American interest in restarting the pipelines.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories has uncovered further indications that the Russian side may be hoping for a restart of the <em>Nord Stream</em> project.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>The first sign</strong> — the Russian company <em>Pipeline Coatings and Technologies</em>, which was <a href=\"https://www.concpipe.ru/projects/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">involved</a> in the construction of <em>Nord Stream 2</em> (engaged in concreting pipes for laying on the seabed), has apparently begun preparing for a large order. According to a source close to <em>Gazprom</em>’s management who spoke to IStories, the company has started actively buying up patents for technical solutions that were used in the preparation of pipes for these pipelines.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“The pipe concreting technology itself is Western. But there are many nuances for which patents were registered in Russia. Previously, they were registered to various specialists, but now the company has started actively buying them up, as it wants to be ready for a potential order and doesn’t want to pay third parties if this order materializes,” says the IStories source.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":14570,"data":{"block":"<p><em>Pipeline Coatings and Technologies</em> may be connected to Gazprom’s management and Vladimir Putin’s longtime friend Arkady Rotenberg. The lion’s share of <em>Pipeline Coatings and Technologies</em> (89.55%) is packaged in the closed-end mutual investment fund <em>VerCon</em>, managed by <em>Gamma Group Management Company</em>.</p><p><br/></p><p>It also manages a stake in the <em>Center for Industrial Supply and Procurement</em> (CPSIK), which <a href=\"https://cpsik.ru/production/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">supplies</a> equipment to <em>Gazprom</em>. Vedomosti <a href=\"https://www.vedomosti.ru/library/articles/2014/10/06/u-kogo-pokupaet-gazprom\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">wrote</a> about CPSIK’s connection to the Rotenbergs.</p><p><br/></p><p>Previously, this stake in <em>Pipeline Coatings and Technologies</em> was <a href=\"https://zpifs.ru/funds/zpif-kombinirovannyy-verkon/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">managed</a> by <em>Mercury Capital Trust Management Company</em>. This is the management company against which the Russian Prosecutor General’s Office recently filed <a href=\"https://www.vedomosti.ru/society/news/2025/03/06/1096524-genprokuratura-trebuet\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">claims</a> as part of a case involving the withdrawal of 150 billion rubles from <em>Gazprom Neftekhim Salavat</em>. According to the agency, the withdrawal of funds was carried out by former <em>Gazprom</em> top manager Alexei Mityushov and former <em>Gazprom</em> board member Kirill Seleznev (<em>RBC</em> <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/newspaper/2019/11/28/5cbd97b89a794781706c7dd4\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">linked</a> <em>Mercury Capital Trust Management Company</em> to Seleznev’s classmate, Mityushov, back in 2019).</p><p><br/></p><p>An IStories source close to <em>Gazprom</em>’s management also believes that the <em>Pipeline Coatings and Technologies</em> is linked to <em>Gazprom</em> employees. Its CEO, Andrey Ryndovsky, heads a structure that belonged to <em>Gazprom Stroytek Salavat</em> (<em>Salavatstroytek</em>). Three of the five seats on the board of directors of <em>Pipeline Coatings and Technologies</em>, at least as of 2021 and early 2022, were held by senior employees of <em>Salavatstroytek</em>, which was part of the <em>Gazprom Neftekhim Salavat</em> industrial complex.</p>","header":"How this company is linked to Putin’s friend and Gazprom executives","content":[{"insert":"Pipeline Coatings and Technologies","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":" may be connected to Gazprom’s management and Vladimir Putin’s longtime friend Arkady Rotenberg. The lion’s share of "},{"insert":"Pipeline Coatings and Technologies","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":" (89.55%) is packaged in the closed-end mutual investment fund "},{"insert":"VerCon","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":", managed by "},{"insert":"Gamma Group Management Company","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":".\n\nIt also manages a stake in the "},{"insert":"Center for Industrial Supply and Procurement","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":" (CPSIK), which "},{"insert":"supplies","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://cpsik.ru/production/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" equipment to "},{"insert":"Gazprom","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":". Vedomosti "},{"insert":"wrote","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.vedomosti.ru/library/articles/2014/10/06/u-kogo-pokupaet-gazprom","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" about CPSIK’s connection to the Rotenbergs.\n\nPreviously, this stake in "},{"insert":"Pipeline Coatings and Technologies","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":" was "},{"insert":"managed","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://zpifs.ru/funds/zpif-kombinirovannyy-verkon/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" by "},{"insert":"Mercury Capital Trust Management Company","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":". This is the management company against which the Russian Prosecutor General’s Office recently filed "},{"insert":"claims","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.vedomosti.ru/society/news/2025/03/06/1096524-genprokuratura-trebuet","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" as part of a case involving the withdrawal of 150 billion rubles from "},{"insert":"Gazprom Neftekhim Salavat","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":". According to the agency, the withdrawal of funds was carried out by former "},{"insert":"Gazprom","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":" top manager Alexei Mityushov and former "},{"insert":"Gazprom","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":" board member Kirill Seleznev ("},{"insert":"RBC","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":" "},{"insert":"linked","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.rbc.ru/newspaper/2019/11/28/5cbd97b89a794781706c7dd4","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" "},{"insert":"Mercury Capital Trust Management Company","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":" to Seleznev’s classmate, Mityushov, back in 2019).\n\nAn IStories source close to "},{"insert":"Gazprom","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":"’s management also believes that the "},{"insert":"Pipeline Coatings and Technologies","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":" is linked to "},{"insert":"Gazprom","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":" employees. Its CEO, Andrey Ryndovsky, heads a structure that belonged to "},{"insert":"Gazprom Stroytek Salavat","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":" ("},{"insert":"Salavatstroytek","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":"). Three of the five seats on the board of directors of "},{"insert":"Pipeline Coatings and Technologies","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":", at least as of 2021 and early 2022, were held by senior employees of "},{"insert":"Salavatstroytek","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":", which was part of the "},{"insert":"Gazprom Neftekhim Salavat","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":" industrial complex.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"<strong>The second sign</strong> is the activity of the pipe association. <em>Pipe Producers Association</em>, as <a href=\"https://pipeunion.ru/en/the-administration-of-the-pipe-producers-association\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">stated</a> on its website, promotes the implementation of <em>Gazprom</em>’s programs to provide it with domestically produced pipes. Within the framework of the association, <em>Gazprom</em> employees negotiate with pipe manufacturers on exactly what products (down to the technical characteristics of the pipe) and in what volumes the gas concern is counting on and what it may need in the future.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to a source from IStories close to <em>Gazprom</em>’s management, the latest meetings of the association discussed, among other things, pipes for laying on the seabed. Although “with <em>Gazprom</em>’s current situation, such activity of the association is not required — there are no large-scale projects that require pipes with such technical characteristics,” he notes.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“<em>Gazprom</em> currently has no major projects related to laying pipes on the seabed,” confirms oil and gas market expert Mikhail Krutikhin.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":14571,"data":{"text":"It helps us to continue telling the truth","title":"Support IStories","buttonText":"Donate"},"category":"donate-embed"},"type":"donate-embed"},{"data":"<strong>The third sign</strong> is conservation. In January 2025, the <em>Nord Stream 2 AG</em> gas pipeline operator, two years after the sabotage, <a href=\"https://ens.dk/presse/energistyrelsen-giver-tilladelse-til-arbejder-ved-nord-stream-2-roerledningsanlaegget-i\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">received</a> permission from the <em>Danish Energy Agency</em> to carry out conservation work on the damaged <em>Nord Stream 2</em>. Formally, we are talking about carrying out work to pump seawater out of the damaged pipes of the gas pipeline and install plugs on them. Potentially, this could speed up and facilitate restoration. However, the agency itself explained this decision as a concern for the environment.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“For more than two years, the blown-up section of the <em>Nord Streams</em> did not prompt the Danish authorities to take any action. And then the company <em>Nord Stream 2</em> [the pipeline operator, a Swiss subsidiary of <em>Gazprom</em>], which is facing bankruptcy, seeks and receives permission to carry out work,” the IStories source wonders.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The <em>Pipe Producers Association</em> and the <em>Pipeline Coatings and Technologies</em> company did not respond to questions from IStories.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Previously, the German investigative media outlet <em>Correctiv</em>, with the participation of IStories, found out that the authorities of Germany, Russia, and the USA are discussing the resumption of oil supplies through the <em>Druzhba</em> pipeline to Germany. For this purpose, the Americans will buy out <em>Rosneft</em>’s share in the <em>PCK</em> oil refinery, which, before the full-scale war in Ukraine, was supplied with raw materials from Russia via <em>Druzhba</em>. Read more about this <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2025/03/13/russians-and-americans-are-clapping-their-hands/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">here</a>.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":7064,"header":"Who is Putin’s Successor and What Will Happen to Russia?","_path":"/en/opinions/2025/02/04/putins-successor/","lead":"Founder of IStories, Roman Anin, assesses the chances of candidates to succeed the Russian dictator","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42a523bcf9fb4e2095fea25b944fe06f-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Photo: Alexander Zemlianichenko / AP / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2025-02-04","created_at_date_time":"2025-02-04T18:03:22.634Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":5,"first_name":"Роман","last_name":"Анин","first_name_en":"Roman","last_name_en":"Anin","is_public":true,"_path":"roman-anin","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редактор «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Редактор","position_en":"Editor","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"Before discussing who is the most likely successor to Vladimir Putin, we should ask a more fundamental question: does he even have a successor? The idea that Putin has no intention of leaving the presidency until his death is quite popular among some Russian and Western analysts of Russian politics. However, I find it difficult to agree with this for several reasons.\nFirstly, Putin understands the structure of his regime better than anyone, in which power is divided among several powerful clans of his friends, KGB colleagues and judo sparring partners. Throughout his 25 years in power, these clans have constantly competed for influence, resources, and, most importantly, proximity to Putin himself, who has acted as an arbiter in their conflicts.\nThe biggest vulnerability of this system is its dependence on Putin’s life. If he were to die or even significantly weaken, the balance of power would collapse, leading to an inevitable war of all against all. The older he gets and the longer he postpones the question of power transition, the higher the risk that one of the clans will attempt to seize control before someone else does. I think Putin understands this perfectly well and does not want a repeat of Yevgeny Prigozhin’s mutiny.\nSecondly, the scenario involving a successor seems the most likely, as it is a familiar and natural procedure of power transfer for Putin. He himself went through such a process in 1999 and undoubtedly considers it a successful experience.\nFinally, in my opinion, Putin has already outgrown the presidential office. His propaganda, the church, his inner circle, and various other lackeys have spent years convincing him that he is not just a president but the father of the nation, tasked with a sacred mission to save Russia and restore its former greatness. And as a deeply narcissistic individual, he has willingly embraced this notion. “Putin has three advisors — Ivan the Terrible, Peter the Great, and Catherine the Great,” Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov said about him at the start of the war.\nBeing a president is a job, but a father of the nation does not work. He hands down his will from his sacred pedestal, and his chosen executors implement it on the ground. The preparation for building this pedestal seemingly began in 2020, when Putin amended the Constitution to grant the State Council — previously a purely advisory body — constitutional status and the authority to define Russia’s key domestic and foreign policies. “Presumably, Putin intends to occupy this position himself — there is no other reason to create such an organ… He wants to depend on a successor, not on voters,” explained political strategist and former presidential speechwriter Abbas Gallyamov in an interview with BBC Russian.\n\nWho could Putin choose as his successor?\nFirst and foremost, it must be someone he absolutely trusts, someone who, upon receiving presidential powers, will not betray his benefactor.\nSecondly, the successor must piously believe in the infallibility of his idol and unconditionally fulfill his will.\nThirdly, he should not belong to an old, influential clan, as this could trigger factional conflicts.\nFourthly, he must have significant achievements in Putin’s eyes, both personally and for Russia (as Putin perceives it).\nFifthly, the successor must embody the vision of Russia that Putin is shaping. Given that Russian children are now indoctrinated with the leader’s ideology from preschool — where “heroes of the special military operation” tell stories of how they defeated “Banderites” in Ukraine — it is clear that Putin’s future Russia is envisioned as a militarized dictatorship steeped in propaganda.\nAt present, there is only one person in Russia who meets all these criteria — Putin’s former bodyguard, Alexei Dyumin.\nFor many years, Dyumin never left Putin’s side — day or night. He guarded his rest in the taiga, ensured he didn’t drown in the ocean, carried out the most delicate assignments, and was ready to sacrifice his life for him. Putin trusts him completely.\n\n\nMoreover, Dyumin has major achievements in Putin’s eyes. In 2014, he led the Special Operations Forces (SOF), which played a key role in the occupation of Crimea. For this operation, as well as possibly for the evacuation of former Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych, Dyumin was awarded the Hero of Russia title. He also, apparently, negotiated with Yevgeny Prigozhin during the Wagner Group’s mutiny, convincing him to turn his forces away from Moscow — effectively saving Putin and the state.\n\nIn May 2024, Putin appointed Dyumin as Secretary of the State Council, placing him in one of the highest-ranking positions within the Russian power structure.\n\nAccording to two former FSB officers interviewed by IStories, many within the intelligence services see Dyumin as the leading candidate for succession. Not only is he loyal to Putin, but as a colonel-general, he aligns far more closely with the current and future vision of Russia than other potential successors.\nOther names floated by political analysts include:\n\nSergey Kiriyenko – First Deputy Chief of Staff of the Presidential Administration.\nBoris Kovalchuk – Chairman of the Accounts Chamber and son of Putin’s close associate, Yury Kovalchuk.\nDmitry Patrushev – Deputy Prime Minister and son of former Security Council Secretary Nikolai Patrushev.\nHowever, in my opinion, none of these candidates should be seriously considered as successors.\n\nFirstly, all of them currently lack Dyumin’s political weight and achievements in Putin’s eyes.\nSecondly, Putin has clearly distanced himself from some of them. For instance, after the Wagner mutiny, Nikolai Patrushev was removed from his position as Security Council Secretary and given the rather humiliating role of Presidential Aide on Shipbuilding.\nThirdly, someone who starts wars does not hand over power to “kinder-surprises” or gilded youth.\nThus, in my view, in the near future — by historical standards — Russia is heading toward a kind of duumvirate: the father of the nation enthroned in his own grandeur and a young “hero-general” dutifully carrying out his will. Together, they will prepare the country for a new major war — because they have nothing else to offer the people.","blocks":[{"data":"Before discussing who is the most likely successor to Vladimir Putin, we should ask a more fundamental question: does he even have a successor? The idea that Putin has no intention of leaving the presidency until his death is quite popular among some Russian and Western analysts of Russian politics. However, I find it difficult to agree with this for several reasons.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Firstly, Putin understands the structure of his regime better than anyone, in which power is <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/opinions/2023/01/09/in-russia-a-clan-war-for-putins-throne-has-begun-who-will-win/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">divided</a> among several powerful clans of his friends, KGB colleagues and judo sparring partners. Throughout his 25 years in power, these clans have constantly competed for influence, resources, and, most importantly, proximity to Putin himself, who has acted as an arbiter in their conflicts.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The biggest vulnerability of this system is its dependence on Putin’s life. If he were to die or even significantly weaken, the balance of power would collapse, leading to an inevitable war of all against all. The older he gets and the longer he postpones the question of power transition, the higher the risk that one of the clans will attempt to seize control before someone else does. I think Putin understands this perfectly well and does not want a repeat of Yevgeny Prigozhin’s <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/opinions/2023/06/27/nothing-but-wagner-all-around/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">mutiny</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Secondly, the scenario involving a successor seems the most likely, as it is a familiar and natural procedure of power transfer for Putin. He himself went through such a process in 1999 and undoubtedly considers it a successful experience.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Finally, in my opinion, Putin has already outgrown the presidential office. His propaganda, the church, his inner circle, and various other lackeys have spent years convincing him that he is not just a president but the <em>father of the nation</em>, tasked with a sacred mission to save Russia and restore its former greatness. And as a deeply narcissistic individual, he has willingly embraced this notion. “Putin has three advisors — Ivan the Terrible, Peter the Great, and Catherine the Great,” Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov <a href=\"https://www.ft.com/content/80002564-33e8-48fb-b734-44810afb7a49\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">said</a> about him at the start of the war.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Being a president is a job, but a <em>father of the nation</em> does not work. He hands down his will from his sacred pedestal, and his chosen executors implement it on the ground. The preparation for building this pedestal seemingly began in 2020, when Putin amended the Constitution to <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/news-51179432\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">grant</a> the State Council — previously a purely advisory body — constitutional status and the authority to define Russia’s key domestic and foreign policies. “Presumably, Putin intends to occupy this position himself — there is no other reason to create such an organ… He wants to depend on a successor, not on voters,” explained political strategist and former presidential speechwriter Abbas Gallyamov in an interview with BBC Russian.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Who could Putin choose as his successor?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"First and foremost, it must be someone he absolutely trusts, someone who, upon receiving presidential powers, will not betray his benefactor.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Secondly, the successor must piously believe in the infallibility of his idol and unconditionally fulfill his will.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Thirdly, he should not belong to an old, influential clan, as this could trigger factional conflicts.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Fourthly, he must have significant achievements in Putin’s eyes, both personally and for Russia (as Putin perceives it).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Fifthly, the successor must embody the vision of Russia that Putin is shaping. Given that Russian children are now <a href=\"https://regions.ru/pushkino/novosti/veterany-svo-rasskazali-detyam-krasnoarmeyska-o-svoey-glavnoy-motivatsii\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">indoctrinated</a> with the leader’s ideology from preschool&nbsp;— where “heroes of the special military operation” tell stories of how they defeated “Banderites” in Ukraine&nbsp;— it is clear that Putin’s future Russia is envisioned as a militarized dictatorship steeped in propaganda.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At present, there is only one person in Russia who meets all these criteria — Putin’s former bodyguard, Alexei Dyumin.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For many years, Dyumin never left Putin’s side — day or night. He <a href=\"https://www.mk.ru/politics/2016/02/09/novyy-tulskiy-gubernator-dyumin-rasskazal-kak-spas-putina-ot-medvedya.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">guarded</a> his rest in the taiga, <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/2911780\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">ensured</a> he didn’t drown in the ocean, carried out the most delicate assignments, and was ready to sacrifice his life for him. Putin trusts him completely.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":14247,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Alexei Nikolsky / pool / Reuters","caption":"Vladimir Putin meets with people in the town of Pikalyovo, in the Leningrad Oblast. To Putin’s right is Dyumin. June 2009","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a5e3e8eef16843d099062ebd57d55f58-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a5e3e8eef16843d099062ebd57d55f58-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1599},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a5e3e8eef16843d099062ebd57d55f58-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a5e3e8eef16843d099062ebd57d55f58-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1599},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a5e3e8eef16843d099062ebd57d55f58-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a5e3e8eef16843d099062ebd57d55f58-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a5e3e8eef16843d099062ebd57d55f58-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a5e3e8eef16843d099062ebd57d55f58-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]},{"credit":"Photo: Sergey Chirkov / EPA / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Tula Governor Dyumin at a hockey match with Putin in February 2019","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e73de4ac2434c9e89c3f35aa16ced51-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e73de4ac2434c9e89c3f35aa16ced51-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1601},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e73de4ac2434c9e89c3f35aa16ced51-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e73de4ac2434c9e89c3f35aa16ced51-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1601},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e73de4ac2434c9e89c3f35aa16ced51-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e73de4ac2434c9e89c3f35aa16ced51-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":554},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e73de4ac2434c9e89c3f35aa16ced51-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e73de4ac2434c9e89c3f35aa16ced51-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":554}]}]},"category":"two-images-embed"},"type":"two-images-embed"},{"data":"Moreover, Dyumin has major achievements in Putin’s eyes. In 2014, he <a href=\"https://newstula.ru/fn_871180.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">led</a> the Special Operations Forces (SOF), which played a key role in the occupation of Crimea. For this operation, as well as possibly for the evacuation of former Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych, Dyumin was awarded the Hero of Russia title. He also, apparently, negotiated with Yevgeny Prigozhin during the Wagner Group’s mutiny, convincing him to turn his forces away from Moscow — effectively saving Putin and the state.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In May 2024, Putin <a href=\"http://kremlin.ru/events/administration/74135\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">appointed</a> Dyumin as Secretary of the State Council, placing him in one of the highest-ranking positions within the Russian power structure.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":14248,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Vyacheslav Prokofyev / pool / Reuters","caption":"November 2024. Dyumin is the Secretary of the State Council","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7cda5f8ec3e141619d7e9955619d47a1-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7cda5f8ec3e141619d7e9955619d47a1-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7cda5f8ec3e141619d7e9955619d47a1-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7cda5f8ec3e141619d7e9955619d47a1-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7cda5f8ec3e141619d7e9955619d47a1-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7cda5f8ec3e141619d7e9955619d47a1-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7cda5f8ec3e141619d7e9955619d47a1-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7cda5f8ec3e141619d7e9955619d47a1-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"According to two former FSB officers interviewed by IStories, many within the intelligence services see Dyumin as the leading candidate for succession. Not only is he loyal to Putin, but as a colonel-general, he aligns far more closely with the current and future vision of Russia than other potential successors.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Other names floated by political analysts include:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li>Sergey Kiriyenko – First Deputy Chief of Staff of the Presidential Administration.</li><li>Boris Kovalchuk – Chairman of the Accounts Chamber and son of Putin’s close associate, Yury Kovalchuk.</li><li>Dmitry Patrushev – Deputy Prime Minister and son of former Security Council Secretary Nikolai Patrushev.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"However, in my opinion, none of these candidates should be seriously considered as successors.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li>Firstly, all of them currently lack Dyumin’s political weight and achievements in Putin’s eyes.</li><li>Secondly, Putin has clearly distanced himself from some of them. For instance, after the Wagner mutiny, Nikolai Patrushev was removed from his position as Security Council Secretary and <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/politics/14/05/2024/6643287b9a7947a8f0b8ba78\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">given</a> the rather humiliating role of Presidential Aide on Shipbuilding.</li><li>Thirdly, someone who starts wars does not hand over power to <a href=\"https://www.rferl.org/a/1065790.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">“kinder-surprises”</a> or gilded youth.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"Thus, in my view, in the near future — by historical standards — Russia is heading toward a kind of duumvirate: the <em>father of the nation</em> enthroned in his own grandeur and a young “hero-general” dutifully carrying out his will. Together, they will prepare the country for a new major war — because they have nothing else to offer the people.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":6969,"header":"“War Is Fine, as Long as Our Children Aren’t Taken There”","_path":"/en/opinions/2025/01/16/relatives/","lead":"Attitudes towards the war have not сhanged even among those fighting for the return of their loved ones","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5b4c227cf8df4460beca64bab43546b9-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Photo: AP / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2025-01-16","created_at_date_time":"2025-01-14T18:15:10.614Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[],"external_authors_list":[{"id":284,"first_name":"Public Sociology","last_name":"Laboratory","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":1}],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"The authorities are trying to ensure that Russians do not notice the war, and people are trying to get used to it and live their normal lives. However, there are those who cannot do this — primarily the wives, mothers, and other relatives of those who are at war or in the army during wartime. It would seem that they should have reassessed their attitude towards what is happening — but no, a study by the Public Sociology Laboratory (PS Lab) has shown. IStories publishes excerpts from the report.\n\nIn previous studies, PS Lab showed that most Russians justify the war without being its convinced supporters (PS Lab calls them “non-opponents” of the war) — they were helped in this by the attitude towards the state, formed over the years of Putin's rule, as an entity separate from the people and which they cannot influence. Also, the fact that Russians justify not the war itself, but themselves, and how, because of the war, they have stopped thinking about the future.\n\n\n\nTrust but verify\nThe mothers of conscripts did not anticipate that the war could somehow affect their sons’ service: it either “did not occur to them” that their children could be sent to the combat zone, or they relied on officials’ assurances that this was impossible. It is significant that three out of the six conscripts whose mothers PS Lab managed to speak with avoided being sent to the combat zone only due to a fortunate combination of circumstances.\nThe mothers who justified the war were united by a basic trust in the state (and, accordingly, its institutions, in particular the army service), which did not disappear even when they faced violations against their children (for example, failure to provide them with medical care). They, unlike opponents of the war who did not trust the state under any circumstances, believed that their children were under reliable protection in the army. Therefore, they and their children did not consider the possibility of evading conscription or mobilization, even if they had grounds to do so.\n“Well, we are law-abiding citizens, so, naturally, on the Nth, he reported for duty. And how could we... Run, hide — no, of course not.” (female, about 45 years old, lawyer)\nThis is Olga speaking, the mother of a conscript who should have received a non-draft category due to a chronic illness, but was nevertheless deemed fit by the military commission. But mobilized individuals and their non-opponent-of-the-war relatives share a similar stance. And it is not about the money at all, as it might seem: the income of the families interviewed by PS Lab was above average for the region, and the payments they started receiving after mobilization did not affect (or affected insignificantly) their financial situation.\n\"We don’t have the right to refuse… We weren’t interested in the salary, so to speak. Of course, it was a very strong blow, a shock for me, because he’s my only child, my only son… Well, since they sent the summons, it means... As they say, ‘the Motherland calls – it must be done.’” (female, about 50 years old)\nMoreover, Yevgenia admitted that a significant part of her son's salary, and in the first two months of his service – her own as well, went to cover expenses related to the war. And yet, due to health problems, her son shouldn't have even been in regular military service, let alone participating in hostilities.\nMothers who justified the war began to act when they realized that their sons were in real danger, for example, due to a sharp deterioration in health or the threat of being sent to a combat zone. Irina learned at the beginning of her son's service that he was going to be sent to the border with Ukraine, and to a place where a tent camp of Russian soldiers had recently been bombed. She tried to clarify the situation, and the more she learned, the more frightened she became:\n“When he was taken, they immediately told him that he would go to serve in Crimea. <…> I started looking for information… and seemed to calm down. <…> But then suddenly I found out that those demobilized soldiers who were stationed there on the border… They were suddenly bombed. And allegedly there are casualties. <…> Well, of course, I looked for this information on the internet. I didn’t find it there. Accordingly, it’s possible that it wasn’t posted. I found a bunch of other information instead, which shocked me. <…> Well, I realized that this is an unsafe territory for children to be in.” (female, about 44 years old, quality inspector at a factory)\nThis situation resolved itself: Irina’s son fell ill before being sent to the tent camp. But not everyone was so lucky. Here is what Anna, the mother of a conscript with a non-exemption medical condition, said about her attempts to get her son a medical examination:\nHe started having problems with his legs, with his veins, he was getting worse and worse. He was already having difficulty moving. <…> And that's when I started ringing the alarm bells, realizing that they weren't even putting him in the hospital (female, about 50 years old, school administrator)\nAnna’s son spent a significant part of his service in various medical institutions, in one of which he was beaten so that he “wouldn’t complain,” but he was only able to receive a diagnosis and the necessary medical care after demobilization. The stories told by the mothers of conscripts show: the army easily accepts those who should not be there, but has difficulty letting them go.\n\n\n\n“There is no truth and there never will be”\nThe experience of interacting with the Russian state system did not lead the mothers who justify the war to radically rethink their views and attitude towards the state. Sometimes, despite the trials that they and their sons had to go through, the mothers continued to believe that the system works as it should — except, of course, for excesses. For example, Anna, whose son effectively became disabled during his conscription service, remained convinced of the necessity of military service experience for any man:\n— We had to go through a lot because no one believed [that my son was sick]. They thought he was just dodging the draft.\n— Did you start to see what is happening in different state structures differently?\n— No, I haven’t changed [my opinion]. He must serve, he must. The army teaches a lot. This was, is, and will be. <…> Every man should go through the army. He becomes more mature there. <…> The only thing is that the treatment in the army is still bad, because there is a shortage of medicines, they don't pay much attention to them (female, about 50 years old, school administrator)\nEven in those cases where people became more critical, they could not clearly articulate their criticism of the state and the army. For example, Yevgenia, whose story is in many ways similar to Anna's, except that her son's health deteriorated sharply after he was mobilized, not during his conscription service, answered the question about her attitude towards the army and the state as follows:\n— My dad always used to say: “Daughter, there is no truth and there never will be, especially in war.” <...> I don’t know how to answer anymore. <…> Here’s an example: my son was injured there, defending the homeland, but he’s no longer entitled to any payments. He ruined his health. He left healthy, and now his eyesight has deteriorated, and everything, and his speech is gone. But the state said: “If he had been wounded, he would have received [payments]. But this way — no.” How can one feel and what can one say, tell me? (female, about 50 years old)\nYevgenia cannot say anything good about her experience interacting with government agencies. But she has no words to clearly articulate this dissatisfaction. Her attitude has changed for the worse, but the question of who is responsible for the situation with her son remains unanswered. It is no coincidence that she begins her reasoning with a reference to her father, who said that “there will never be truth”: this is an impersonal construction, stating the injustice of the world and the impossibility of doing anything about it.\nWomen see problems in the army. Here is how Irina, whose son was sent to serve in Crimea, reasoned about them:\nThere [in the army] are a lot of problems. And if the government was sort of expecting to declare such hostilities — they should have prepared better. Then I am very surprised by the fact that there are very few children of officials in this war… The media talks so much about patriotism... And now it turns out that our children, who were driven there, are [fighting] — just mobilized. Where is our contract army then? (female, about 44 years old, quality inspector at a factory)\nIrina sees both incompetence and falsehood: the army was unprepared for war; ordinary people are sent to the combat zone, not professional soldiers, and certainly not the children of officials; all the talk about patriotism is a deception. But she is not against the war, which could have affected (but did not affect) her son’s service, and her dissatisfaction is caused by the fact that her son could have been sent to the combat zone.\nThe unwillingness to blame the state for their troubles and condemn the war stems, on the one hand, from the experience of interacting with the state — confusing and often meaningless. Who is to blame if it is not always clear what happened and who to contact? On the other hand, this unwillingness to blame reflects the perception of many people of the state as an unpredictable force that acts according to its own laws: it takes children, moves them, returns them crippled, dead, or does not return them at all. It is useless to fight such a state, therefore it is useless to criticize it — this is how many mothers of mobilized soldiers and conscripts reason. Except that sometimes you can try to get small concessions from it.\n\n\n\nThe right of a mother and wife\nFear of the state recedes when the lives of children are threatened (or when these lives have already been taken). In a sense, the right of a mother is part of an unspoken contract with the state: it can take children away for a while, but not forever.\n“After all, it’s not just like that, to raise, raise for 20 years, and then — bam! — and bury him who knows how,” says Antonina, the mother of a conscript who died under unclear circumstances in a military unit shortly before the end of his service. She even feels entitled to sue the state and plans to do so.\nThe situation is similar with the wives of mobilized soldiers. It was the indefinite nature of the mobilization, and not the mobilization itself, that became the main cause of indignation among the women who joined the Way Home movement.\nWithout this person, I am incredibly lonely. I just understand that this is my loved one, without whom I simply cannot live, and I really want him to be home. And such injustice, that mobilized soldiers and most contract soldiers serve without fixed terms, is just, well, some kind of nonsense to me. And accordingly, it is precisely because of this that I decided to at least try to look for something [ways to return him] (female, about 20 years old, student)\nDuring the interview, Vasilisa noted that she and her husband have rights that the state is violating, but the only right she decided to insist on was related to limiting the time of state interference in their lives:\nHe [husband] has the right to know how long you have taken him there for. I have the right to know how long you have taken my loved one away from me (female, about 31 years old, housewife)\nAmong the participants of the movement, there are more opponents of the war than among the mothers of conscripts, but their discontent erupted about a year after mobilization, when it became clear that the state was not going to return their husbands. They expressed their indignation with succinct metaphors: “legalized slavery,” “serfdom,” “endless bondage.” Here is how Nika described it:\n— When approximately did the balance shift, when it reached the boiling point, and you were ready for more than before?\n— Probably when it was a year since the partial mobilization, that’s October, probably the end of October 2023. Such changes probably occurred in consciousness. It became more and more apparent that no, our guys will not be returned.\nThe last straw was Putin’s Direct Line on December 14, 2023, on which the movement’s participants had pinned high hopes. A call was posted on the channel to write to the “president’s hotline” with questions about when demobilization would be carried out. However, Putin ignored these questions, as well as the topic of demobilization in general.\nIt’s like, you know, always a ray of hope. But it didn’t happen. And I watched, and it was just… Not that he just didn’t say anything about it… We hoped that he would at least, you know, come up with something, damn it. For example, say that “oh, well, you’ll have to wait a little longer, but now…” Well, at least something like that. He didn’t say anything at all. <…> Well, just, yes, [as if we are] some kind of dust underfoot. Outcasts (female, 26 years old, unemployed)\n“We were buried alive, and there’s nothing more to lose,” Mila describes her reaction to the Direct Line. Some were tired of the exhausting struggle with the state — the endless search for information, calls, letters, meetings. Vasilisa was ready to cease any political activity if her husband returned home:\nI didn’t hide it… if they tell me, like: “F**k, you’ve pissed us off, we’ll return your husband, but you’ll shut up” — believe me, I’ll shut up! I’ll sell out! I’ll sell out, I’ll sell out for him. I’ll campaign for Putin, for United Russia, I’ll, damn it, stand near the military registration and enlistment office with flyers, handing them out, like, “Go, guys, fight” (female, about 31 years old, housewife)\nSome of the women were exhausted, Snezhana (30 years old, saleswoman) shared her observation: “I also had such a period: anything, just to get him back. I’ll even make a deal with the devil, just to get him back. But this is already out of despair.”\nSome members of the movement, on the contrary, started with individualistic demands — and gradually moved on to more general ones:\nThere was also a turning point here. Probably, it was at the end of [2023]… Initially, there were demands: replace ours with others and continue fighting if you want. Now people have become more like this… I increasingly encounter positions, probably similar to mine, that, well, how much longer, as if, probably, it’s time to close down this whole shop, like completely, and not terrorize people, just let them live in peace (female, 32 years old, lawyer)\n\n\n\nDoubts crept in\nThe collision with reality forced the women to take a new look at the state and the war. They stopped unconditionally trusting official information.\nWell, if you used to think like this: “Well, the government is okay, it doesn’t bother you, and that’s fine.” You live your own life. And then they kind of offer you… well, they’re like: let’s help us. They take you and then they just start kicking you and poking you with their nose. And, naturally, you already begin to doubt any of its actions. And you think: “Here they deceived me like this — and, probably, they are not so holy in Ukraine either” (female, 26 years old, unemployed)\nThose who were not interested in politics, news, began to follow what was happening, including with the help of opposition media.\nMy day begins with the news on television... Then it’s Telegram channels, plus I also watch the news from the Ukrainian side. Here, I don’t know if it’s right or not, but I always consider several... from several sides. <…> Because I watch, well, I used to watch Solovyov — oh my god, I just can’t. <...> Everything is fine there, according to him, we have everything there: air defense systems, and so on. And you just sit there and think: f**k, where? (female, about 31 years old, homemaker)\nThroughout the conversation, Vasilisa constantly returned to the official patriotic view, emphasizing that she was and remains a patriot of her country, but criticized the state, borrowing elements of the opposition language with its vocabulary of rights, free elections, and evidence with facts. Before the presidential elections, she supported Boris Nadezhdin’s candidacy. He was not allowed to run in the elections, and one of the accusations against him from the pro-government media was that he was a “Navalny supporter.”\nProve that these are “Navalny supporters.” Prove it. <...> Well, not everything is so bad there with his election campaign, that he started meeting with the participants of the Way Home. Right? Well, that is, you want to say that Nadezhdin is also there with us, like Navalny, the same fate awaits him then? That is, these are your honest elections, which everyone tells us about?\nVasilisa regretted that she did not know that rallies against mobilization were taking place in Moscow and St. Petersburg: she was ready to participate in them. She blamed her lack of awareness on the state, which hinders the dissemination of information and represses independent media and journalists who “tell the truth.”\nAt the same time, Vasilisa does not want to “be an enemy” of the state and fully supports Putin. It was for him that she was going to vote in the upcoming elections (“he brewed this mess, only he can sort it out now”). Then she added:\nWe will win, and of this there is no doubt in my mind, as a Russian person, as a patriot of my country, there simply isn’t. We will win. Just at what cost? In my town, we’ve already buried four. The most offensive thing for me is: it will still end at the negotiating table. We will win. We will win. We will take these regions, possibly even more. But it will all end with the signing of treaties.\nVasilisa’s story is the most revealing: she did not cease to be loyal to the political regime, but she began to trust state institutions and representatives of power less; she did not rethink her attitude towards the war, but she realized that she was not ready to sacrifice her well-being for it.\nAntonina, who buried her conscript son and is planning to sue the state, also justifies the war and even considers it a just and necessary measure. There were many such people who fight the state machine for their loved ones while simultaneously supporting the war, and this contradiction shocked the opponents of the war who encountered it.\nAnd when you start talking to soldiers’ mothers, many of them... some were for the war. That is, they say: “No, the war is fine, as long as our children aren’t taken there.” That is, there were many such mothers (Inna, about 43 years old, housewife)\n\n\n\nThe main right: privacy\nDisappointment in the state did not lead to radical changes in attitudes towards the war. Those who were already against it strengthened their opinion; those who hesitated leaned towards a more negative assessment of the war; and those who were in favor still believe that Russia should win. Changes in views are mainly reduced to rethinking individual aspects of the war.\nThe fact that many, even two years after the start of the war, do not understand its causes and goals, do not believe that they can influence its outcome, and are waiting for its end, has become for them just another argument in favor of the fact that their loved ones do not belong in the war. Why then should ordinary people participate and die in it?\nThe women [participants in Way Home movement] went to the Ministry of Defense, and they were told there, like: demobilization implies the collapse of the front. Well, that’s not our problem. That’s not ours at all, that’s your problem, that’s your front. What were you counting on when you took people from civilian life? That they owe it to you to see it through to the end? (female, 34 years old, homemaker)\n\n\nIn today’s Russia, “personal rights” or “civil rights” are not common values. They can acquire meaning when it comes to rights related to private life. This is the safety of children in the case of conscript soldiers, and the participants of the Way Home movement often described men as parts of a well-oiled family machine: take a man out of the family — and the small family enterprise goes down the drain.\nIt is really important to me that all drafted men be demobilized, that our army be made up of servicemen who voluntarily expressed a desire to serve, and not so that men are torn from family life for... more than a year. Every family, of course, needs something during this time, some everyday moments, something else (Nika, 32 years old, lawyer)\nA man’s duty to the state — for example, the need to defend it in wartime — is no less important than his duty to his family. Here is how Vasilisa, one of the most pro-war informants, describes a conversation with an official:\nHe’s like: “And do you have any problems?” I say: “For the second year, there’s no father, no husband, I’m carrying everything on my own, as it were, I’m not ironclad.” And in general, besides having the obligation under the Constitution of the Russian Federation to defend the Motherland, he also has rights. He has the right and his obligation, the obligation to raise our daughter. Why am I doing this alone? (female, about 31 years old, homemaker)\nIn authoritarian countries, protests often arise as a result of the state’s intrusion into people’s private lives. It is no coincidence that in Russia, those whose daily existence was threatened by the actions of the state or private companies took to the streets in protest: pensioners whose benefits were canceled; truck drivers who were subjected to additional fees; residents of houses slated for renovation; residents of areas where something “dirty” was planned to be built — a landfill or an incinerator.\nFor some, the war has become such an event: it has violated their right to privacy.","blocks":[{"data":"The authorities are trying to ensure that Russians do not notice the war, and people are trying to get used to it and live their normal lives. However, there are those who cannot do this —<em> </em>primarily the wives, mothers, and other relatives of those who are at war or in the army during wartime. It would seem that they should have reassessed their attitude towards what is happening — but no, a <a href=\"https://publicsociologylab.com/reports/relatives.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">study</a> by the <em>Public Sociology Laboratory</em> (<em>PS Lab</em>) has shown. IStories publishes excerpts from the report.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>In previous studies, PS Lab </em><a href=\"https://istories.media/opinions/2024/02/23/ya-v-politike-ne-razbirayus-pochemu-rossiyane-opravdivayut-voinu/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>showed</em></a><em> that most Russians justify the war without being its convinced supporters (PS Lab calls them “non-opponents” of the war) — they were </em><a href=\"https://istories.media/opinions/2024/07/01/lyudi-otdelno-vlasti-otdelno-otnoshenie-rossiyan-k-gosudarstvu-pomoglo-im-prinyat-voinu/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>helped</em></a><em> in this by the attitude towards the state, formed over the years of Putin's rule, as an entity separate from the people and which they cannot influence.</em> <em>Also, the fact that Russians </em><a href=\"https://istories.media/opinions/2024/07/11/lyudi-opravdivayut-ne-voinu-a-sebya/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>justify</em></a><em> not the war itself, but themselves, and how, because of the war, they </em><a href=\"https://istories.media/opinions/2024/07/16/ya-vizhivu-v-lyuboi-situatsii/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>have stopped</em></a><em> thinking about the future.</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":14023,"data":{"block":"<p>From October 2023 to March 2024, <em>PS Lab</em> staff conducted 25 in-depth interviews with relatives, family members, and close friends of military personnel. 12 informants were found through human rights organizations, NGOs, and projects that advise and provide legal assistance to conscripts, military personnel, mobilized individuals, their relatives, and family members. 13 interviews were conducted with participants of the <em>Way Home</em> movement — wives and mothers of men drafted into the army in the fall of 2022 as a result of “partial mobilization.”</p><p><br/></p><p>All interviews were conducted online, and the names of the informants used in the report are pseudonyms.</p>","header":"Heart-to-heart talks. Where does the data come from?","content":[{"insert":"From October 2023 to March 2024, "},{"insert":"PS Lab","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":" staff conducted 25 in-depth interviews with relatives, family members, and close friends of military personnel. 12 informants were found through human rights organizations, NGOs, and projects that advise and provide legal assistance to conscripts, military personnel, mobilized individuals, their relatives, and family members. 13 interviews were conducted with participants of the "},{"insert":"Way Home","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":" movement — wives and mothers of men drafted into the army in the fall of 2022 as a result of “partial mobilization.”\n\nAll interviews were conducted online, and the names of the informants used in the report are pseudonyms.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Trust but verify</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The mothers of conscripts did not anticipate that the war could somehow affect their sons’ service: it either “did not occur to them” that their children could be sent to the combat zone, or they relied on officials’ assurances that this was impossible. It is significant that three out of the six conscripts whose mothers <em>PS Lab</em> managed to speak with avoided being sent to the combat zone only due to a fortunate combination of circumstances.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The mothers who justified the war were united by a basic trust in the state (and, accordingly, its institutions, in particular the army service), which did not disappear even when they faced violations against their children (for example, failure to provide them with medical care). They, unlike opponents of the war who did not trust the state under any circumstances, believed that their children were under reliable protection in the army. Therefore, they and their children did not consider the possibility of evading conscription or mobilization, even if they had grounds to do so.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“Well, we are law-abiding citizens, so, naturally, on the Nth, he reported for duty.</em> <em>And how could we... Run, hide — no, of course not.” (female, about 45 years old, lawyer)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This is Olga speaking, the mother of a conscript who should have received a non-draft category due to a chronic illness, but was nevertheless deemed fit by the military commission. But mobilized individuals and their non-opponent-of-the-war relatives share a similar stance. And it is not about the money at all, as it might seem: the income of the families interviewed by <em>PS Lab</em> was above average for the region, and the payments they started receiving after mobilization did not affect (or affected insignificantly) their financial situation.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>\"We don’t have the right to refuse… We weren’t interested in the salary, so to speak.</em> <em>Of course, it was a very strong blow, a shock for me, because he’s my only child, my only son… Well, since they sent the summons, it means... As they say, ‘the Motherland calls – it must be done.’” (female, about 50 years old)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Moreover, Yevgenia admitted that a significant part of her son's salary, and in the first two months of his service – her own as well, went to cover expenses related to the war. And yet, due to health problems, her son shouldn't have even been in regular military service, let alone participating in hostilities.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Mothers who justified the war began to act when they realized that their sons were in real danger, for example, due to a sharp deterioration in health or the threat of being sent to a combat zone. Irina learned at the beginning of her son's service that he was going to be sent to the border with Ukraine, and to a place where a tent camp of Russian soldiers had recently been bombed. She tried to clarify the situation, and the more she learned, the more frightened she became:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“When he was taken, they immediately told him that he would go to serve in Crimea.</em> <em>&lt;…&gt; I started looking for information… and seemed to calm down.</em> <em>&lt;…&gt; But then suddenly I found out that those demobilized soldiers who were stationed there on the border… They were suddenly bombed.</em> <em>And allegedly there are casualties.</em> <em>&lt;…&gt; Well, of course, I looked for this information on the internet.</em> <em>I didn’t find it there.</em> <em>Accordingly, it’s possible that it wasn’t posted.</em> <em>I found a bunch of other information instead, which shocked me.</em> <em>&lt;…&gt; Well, I realized that this is an unsafe territory for children to be in.” (female, about 44 years old, quality inspector at a factory)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This situation resolved itself: Irina’s son fell ill before being sent to the tent camp. But not everyone was so lucky. Here is what Anna, the mother of a conscript with a non-exemption medical condition, said about her attempts to get her son a medical examination:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>He started having problems with his legs, with his veins, he was getting worse and worse. He was already having difficulty moving. &lt;…&gt; And that's when I started ringing the alarm bells, realizing that they weren't even putting him in the hospital (female, about 50 years old, school administrator)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Anna’s son spent a significant part of his service in various medical institutions, in one of which he was beaten so that he “wouldn’t complain,” but he was only able to receive a diagnosis and the necessary medical care after demobilization. The stories told by the mothers of conscripts show: the army easily accepts those who should not be there, but has difficulty letting them go.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":14024,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Sergey Pivovarov / Reuters / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Conscripts should not end up at the front. But sometimes they do.","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9585ae0e0d54d2a834e86254a38bf65-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9585ae0e0d54d2a834e86254a38bf65-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":767,"real_height_2x":1534},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9585ae0e0d54d2a834e86254a38bf65-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9585ae0e0d54d2a834e86254a38bf65-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":767,"real_height_2x":1534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9585ae0e0d54d2a834e86254a38bf65-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9585ae0e0d54d2a834e86254a38bf65-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":265,"real_height_2x":530},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9585ae0e0d54d2a834e86254a38bf65-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9585ae0e0d54d2a834e86254a38bf65-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":265,"real_height_2x":530}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"<strong>“There is no truth and there never will be”</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The experience of interacting with the Russian state system did not lead the mothers who justify the war to radically rethink their views and attitude towards the state. Sometimes, despite the trials that they and their sons had to go through, the mothers continued to believe that the system works as it should — except, of course, for excesses. For example, Anna, whose son effectively became disabled during his conscription service, remained convinced of the necessity of military service experience for any man:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— <em>We had to go through a lot because no one believed [that my son was sick]. They thought he was just dodging the draft.</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— <em>Did you start to see what is happening in different state structures differently?</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— <em>No, I haven’t changed [my opinion]. He must serve, he must. The army teaches a lot. This was, is, and will be. &lt;…&gt; Every man should go through the army. He becomes more mature there. &lt;…&gt; The only thing is that the treatment in the army is still bad, because there is a shortage of medicines, they don't pay much attention to them (female, about 50 years old, school administrator)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Even in those cases where people became more critical, they could not clearly articulate their criticism of the state and the army. For example, Yevgenia, whose story is in many ways similar to Anna's, except that her son's health deteriorated sharply after he was mobilized, not during his conscription service, answered the question about her attitude towards the army and the state as follows:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— <em>My dad always used to say: “Daughter, there is no truth and there never will be, especially in war.” &lt;...&gt; I don’t know how to answer anymore. &lt;…&gt; Here’s an example: my son was injured there, defending the homeland, but he’s no longer entitled to any payments. He ruined his health. He left healthy, and now his eyesight has deteriorated, and everything, and his speech is gone. But the state said: “If he had been wounded, he would have received [payments]. But this way — no.” How can one feel and what can one say, tell me? (female, about 50 years old)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Yevgenia cannot say anything good about her experience interacting with government agencies. But she has no words to clearly articulate this dissatisfaction. Her attitude has changed for the worse, but the question of who is responsible for the situation with her son remains unanswered. It is no coincidence that she begins her reasoning with a reference to her father, who said that “there will never be truth”: this is an impersonal construction, stating the injustice of the world and the impossibility of doing anything about it.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Women see problems in the army. Here is how Irina, whose son was sent to serve in Crimea, reasoned about them:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>There [in the army] are a lot of problems. And if the government was sort of expecting to declare such hostilities — they should have prepared better. Then I am very surprised by the fact that there are very few children of officials in this war… The media talks so much about patriotism... And now it turns out that our children, who were driven there, are [fighting] — just mobilized. Where is our contract army then? (female, about 44 years old, quality inspector at a factory)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Irina sees both incompetence and falsehood: the army was unprepared for war; ordinary people are sent to the combat zone, not professional soldiers, and certainly not the children of officials; all the talk about patriotism is a deception. But she is not against the war, which could have affected (but did not affect) her son’s service, and her dissatisfaction is caused by the fact that her son could have been sent to the combat zone.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The unwillingness to blame the state for their troubles and condemn the war stems, on the one hand, from the experience of interacting with the state — confusing and often meaningless. Who is to blame if it is not always clear what happened and who to contact? On the other hand, this unwillingness to blame reflects the perception of many people of the state as an unpredictable force that acts according to its own laws: it takes children, moves them, returns them crippled, dead, or does not return them at all. It is useless to fight such a state, therefore it is useless to criticize it — this is how many mothers of mobilized soldiers and conscripts reason. Except that sometimes you can try to get small concessions from it.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":14025,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: AP / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Ordinary people are going to the front, not the children of officials","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4862608b7097480988e029896d208f6d-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4862608b7097480988e029896d208f6d-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4862608b7097480988e029896d208f6d-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4862608b7097480988e029896d208f6d-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4862608b7097480988e029896d208f6d-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4862608b7097480988e029896d208f6d-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4862608b7097480988e029896d208f6d-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4862608b7097480988e029896d208f6d-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"<strong>The right of a mother and wife</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Fear of the state recedes when the lives of children are threatened (or when these lives have already been taken). In a sense, <em>the right of a mother</em> is part of an unspoken contract with the state: it can take children away for a while, but not forever.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“After all, it’s not just like that, to raise, raise for 20 years, and then — bam! — and bury him who knows how,” says Antonina, the mother of a conscript who died under unclear circumstances in a military unit shortly before the end of his service. She even feels entitled to sue the state and plans to do so.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The situation is similar with the wives of mobilized soldiers. It was the indefinite nature of the mobilization, and not the mobilization itself, that became the main cause of indignation among the women who joined the <em>Way Home</em> movement.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>Without this person, I am incredibly lonely. I just understand that this is my loved one, without whom I simply cannot live, and I really want him to be home. And such injustice, that mobilized soldiers and most contract soldiers serve without fixed terms, is just, well, some kind of nonsense to me. And accordingly, it is precisely because of this that I decided to at least try to look for something [ways to return him] (female, about 20 years old, student)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"During the interview, Vasilisa noted that she and her husband have rights that the state is violating, but the only right she decided to insist on was related to limiting the time of state interference in their lives:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>He [husband] has the right to know how long you have taken him there for. I have the right to know how long you have taken my loved one away from me (female, about 31 years old, housewife)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Among the participants of the movement, there are more opponents of the war than among the mothers of conscripts, but their discontent erupted about a year after mobilization, when it became clear that the state was not going to return their husbands. They expressed their indignation with succinct metaphors: “legalized slavery,” “serfdom,” “endless bondage.” Here is how Nika described it:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— <em>When approximately did the balance shift, when it reached the boiling point, and you were ready for more than before?</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— <em>Probably when it was a year since the partial mobilization, that’s October, probably the end of October 2023. Such changes probably occurred in consciousness. It became more and more apparent that no, our guys will not be returned.</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The last straw was Putin’s <em>Direct Line</em> on December 14, 2023, on which the movement’s participants had pinned high hopes. A <a href=\"https://t.me/PYTY_DOMOY/492\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">call</a> was posted on the channel to write to the “president’s hotline” with questions about when demobilization would be carried out. However, Putin ignored these questions, as well as the topic of demobilization in general.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>It’s like, you know, always a ray of hope. But it didn’t happen. And I watched, and it was just… Not that he just didn’t say anything about it… We hoped that he would at least, you know, come up with something, damn it. For example, say that “oh, well, you’ll have to wait a little longer, but now…” Well, at least something like that. He didn’t say anything at all. &lt;…&gt; Well, just, yes, [as if we are] some kind of dust underfoot. Outcasts (female, 26 years old, unemployed)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“We were buried alive, and there’s nothing more to lose,” Mila describes her reaction to the <em>Direct Line</em>. Some were tired of the exhausting struggle with the state — the endless search for information, calls, letters, meetings. Vasilisa was ready to cease any political activity if her husband returned home:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>I didn’t hide it… if they tell me, like: </em>“<em>F**k, you’ve pissed us off, we’ll return your husband, but you’ll shut up” — believe me, I’ll shut up! I’ll sell out! I’ll sell out, I’ll sell out for him. I’ll campaign for Putin, for United Russia, I’ll, damn it, stand near the military registration and enlistment office with flyers, handing them out, like, “Go, guys, fight” (female, about 31 years old, housewife)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Some of the women were exhausted, Snezhana (30 years old, saleswoman) shared her observation: “I also had such a period: anything, just to get him back. I’ll even make a deal with the devil, just to get him back. But this is already out of despair.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Some members of the movement, on the contrary, started with individualistic demands — and gradually moved on to more general ones:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>There was also a turning point here. Probably, it was at the end of [2023]… Initially, there were demands: replace ours with others and continue fighting if you want. Now people have become more like this… I increasingly encounter positions, probably similar to mine, that, well, how much longer, as if, probably, it’s time to close down this whole shop, like completely, and not terrorize people, just let them live in peace (female, 32 years old, lawyer)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":14026,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Sergey Ilnitsky / EPA / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Mobilization violated an unspoken contract with the state: people can be taken from their families, but only temporarily","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/630a12a505b84b36bddd9d30469b8a47-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/630a12a505b84b36bddd9d30469b8a47-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":799,"real_height_2x":1598},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/630a12a505b84b36bddd9d30469b8a47-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/630a12a505b84b36bddd9d30469b8a47-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":799,"real_height_2x":1598},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/630a12a505b84b36bddd9d30469b8a47-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/630a12a505b84b36bddd9d30469b8a47-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":552},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/630a12a505b84b36bddd9d30469b8a47-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/630a12a505b84b36bddd9d30469b8a47-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":552}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Doubts crept in</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The collision with reality forced the women to take a new look at the state and the war. They stopped unconditionally trusting official information.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>Well, if you used to think like this: “Well, the government is okay, it doesn’t bother you, and that’s fine.” You live your own life. And then they kind of offer you… well, they’re like: let’s help us. They take you and then they just start kicking you and poking you with their nose. And, naturally, you already begin to doubt any of its actions. And you think: “Here they deceived me like this — and, probably, they are not so holy in Ukraine either” (female, 26 years old, unemployed)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Those who were not interested in politics, news, began to follow what was happening, including with the help of opposition media.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>My day begins with the news on television... Then it’s Telegram channels, plus I also watch the news from the Ukrainian side.</em> <em>Here, I don’t know if it’s right or not, but I always consider several... from several sides.</em> <em>&lt;…&gt; Because I watch, well, I used to watch Solovyov — oh my god, I just can’t.</em> <em>&lt;...&gt; Everything is fine there, according to him, we have everything there: air defense systems, and so on.</em> <em>And you just sit there and think: f**k, where?</em> <em>(female, about 31 years old, homemaker)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Throughout the conversation, Vasilisa constantly returned to the official patriotic view, emphasizing that she was and remains a patriot of her country, but criticized the state, borrowing elements of the opposition language with its vocabulary of rights, free elections, and evidence with facts. Before the presidential elections, she supported Boris Nadezhdin’s candidacy. He was not allowed to run in the elections, and one of the accusations against him from the pro-government media was that he was a “Navalny supporter.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>Prove that these are “Navalny supporters.” Prove it. &lt;...&gt; Well, not everything is so bad there with his election campaign, that he started meeting with the participants of the Way Home. Right? Well, that is, you want to say that Nadezhdin is also there with us, like Navalny, the same fate awaits him then? That is, these are your honest elections, which everyone tells us about?</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Vasilisa regretted that she did not know that rallies against mobilization were taking place in Moscow and St. Petersburg: she was ready to participate in them. She blamed her lack of awareness on the state, which hinders the dissemination of information and represses independent media and journalists who “tell the truth.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At the same time, Vasilisa does not want to “be an enemy” of the state and fully supports Putin. It was for him that she was going to vote in the upcoming elections (“he brewed this mess, only he can sort it out now”). Then she added:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>We will win, and of this there is no doubt in my mind, as a Russian person, as a patriot of my country, there simply isn’t.</em> <em>We will win.</em> <em>Just at what cost?</em> <em>In my town, we’ve already buried four.</em> <em>The most offensive thing for me is: it will still end at the negotiating table.</em> <em>We will win.</em> <em>We will win.</em> <em>We will take these regions, possibly even more.</em> <em>But it will all end with the signing of treaties.</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Vasilisa’s story is the most revealing: she did not cease to be loyal to the political regime, but she began to trust state institutions and representatives of power less; she did not rethink her attitude towards the war, but she realized that she was not ready to sacrifice her well-being for it.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Antonina, who buried her conscript son and is planning to sue the state, also justifies the war and even considers it a just and necessary measure. There were many such people who fight the state machine for their loved ones while simultaneously supporting the war, and this contradiction shocked the opponents of the war who encountered it.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>And when you start talking to soldiers’ mothers, many of them... some were for the war.</em> <em>That is, they say: “No, the war is fine, as long as our children aren’t taken there.”</em> <em>That is, there were many such mothers (Inna, about 43 years old, housewife)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":14027,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Natalia Kolesnikova / AFP / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"People still have not understood the purpose of the war, why their loved ones are dying in Ukraine","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/911018ae792b44ba93f64bdfb422c3f8-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/911018ae792b44ba93f64bdfb422c3f8-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/911018ae792b44ba93f64bdfb422c3f8-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/911018ae792b44ba93f64bdfb422c3f8-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/911018ae792b44ba93f64bdfb422c3f8-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/911018ae792b44ba93f64bdfb422c3f8-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/911018ae792b44ba93f64bdfb422c3f8-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/911018ae792b44ba93f64bdfb422c3f8-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"<strong>The main right: privacy</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Disappointment in the state did not lead to radical changes in attitudes towards the war. Those who were already against it strengthened their opinion; those who hesitated leaned towards a more negative assessment of the war; and those who were in favor still believe that Russia should win. Changes in views are mainly reduced to rethinking individual aspects of the war.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The fact that many, even two years after the start of the war, do not understand its causes and goals, do not believe that they can influence its outcome, and are waiting for its end, has become for them just another argument in favor of the fact that their loved ones do not belong in the war. Why then should ordinary people participate and die in it?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>The women [participants in Way Home movement] went to the Ministry of Defense, and they were told there, like: demobilization implies the collapse of the front.</em> <em>Well, that’s not our problem.</em> <em>That’s not ours at all, that’s your problem, that’s your front.</em> <em>What were you counting on when you took people from civilian life?</em> <em>That they owe it to you to see it through to the end?</em> <em>(female, 34 years old, homemaker)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":14022,"data":{"text":"Thanks to you, we continue to work","title":"Support IStories","buttonText":"Learn more"},"category":"donate-embed"},"type":"donate-embed"},{"data":"In today’s Russia, “personal rights” or “civil rights” are not common values. They can acquire meaning when it comes to rights related to private life. This is the safety of children in the case of conscript soldiers, and the participants of the <em>Way Home</em> movement often described men as parts of a well-oiled family machine: take a man out of the family — and the small family enterprise goes down the drain.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>It is really important to me that all drafted men be demobilized, that our army be made up of servicemen who voluntarily expressed a desire to serve, and not so that men are torn from family life for... more than a year.</em> <em>Every family, of course, needs something during this time, some everyday moments, something else (Nika, 32 years old, lawyer)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A man’s duty to the state — for example, the need to defend it in wartime — is no less important than his duty to his family. Here is how Vasilisa, one of the most pro-war informants, describes a conversation with an official:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>He’s like: “And do you have any problems?” I say: “For the second year, there’s no father, no husband, I’m carrying everything on my own, as it were, I’m not ironclad.”</em> <em>And in general, besides having the obligation under the Constitution of the Russian Federation to defend the Motherland, he also has rights.</em> <em>He has the right and his obligation, the obligation to raise our daughter.</em> <em>Why am I doing this alone?</em> <em>(female, about 31 years old, homemaker)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In authoritarian countries, protests often arise as a result of the state’s intrusion into people’s private lives. It is no coincidence that in Russia, those whose daily existence was threatened by the actions of the state or private companies took to the streets in protest: pensioners whose benefits were canceled; truck drivers who were subjected to additional fees; residents of houses slated for renovation; residents of areas where something “dirty” was planned to be built — a landfill or an incinerator.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For some, the war has become such an event: it has violated their right to privacy.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":6911,"header":"Why Vladimir Putin Launched Oreshnik Missile","_path":"/en/opinions/2024/12/16/why-vladimir-putin-launched-oreshnik/","lead":"There has been a similar story before — and it did not win","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d0081be282494abdbdee20cc79c0fe8a-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"What an intercontinental missile launch looks like — this is a Russian Defense Ministry photo from March 1, 2024. Photo: AFP / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2024-12-16","created_at_date_time":"2024-12-16T15:47:59.824Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[],"external_authors_list":[{"id":283,"first_name":"Yury","last_name":"Fedorov","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":1}],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"Two stages of escalation\nThe first stage of the current military-political escalation began with Putin’s statement on September 12th, 2024. If Western governments, he said, allow Ukraine to strike deep into Russian territory with their long-range weapons, this “will mean that NATO countries, the US, and European countries are at war with Russia... We will make appropriate decisions based on the threats that will be created for us.” In his opinion, Armed Forces of Ukraine’s officers are unable to independently input flight missions into American and British missiles, and can only receive target coordinates from Western allies. Less than two weeks later, on September 25th, Putin announced changes to the “Fundamentals of the State Policy of the Russian Federation in the Field of Nuclear Deterrence,” expanding the list of conditions under which Russia “reserves the right to use nuclear weapons.”\nHowever, the signing of the decree approving the updated nuclear doctrine was postponed, which contradicted established procedure. Usually, after a public announcement of the discussion of such documents at the highest level, they are approved either on the same day or the next. This delay could have been a signal — as long as Washington prohibits Kyiv from using ATACMS against internationally recognized Russian territory, Moscow will refrain from enacting the new nuclear doctrine. But perhaps Moscow was waiting for the results of the US presidential elections. The potential victory of Kamala Harris, presumably, was perceived in the Kremlin with relative calm: the Democrats’ characteristic combination of belligerent rhetoric with minimal aid to Ukraine did not cause serious concern there.\n\n\nThe second stage of escalation began shortly after the results of the US presidential elections were determined. The reason for this was given by Joe Biden, who on November 16th authorized Ukraine to use missiles with a range of up to 300 km against Russian territory. Kyiv took advantage of this authorization: on the nights of November 19th and 21st, ATACMS and Storm Shadow missiles struck military targets in the Bryansk and Kursk Oblasts. The Kremlin seems to have expected this. Immediately after the first strike, on November 19th, Putin signed a decree approving the new nuclear doctrine, and after the second, he announced the use of a medium-range missile against the Ukrainian missile factory Yuzhmash in Dnipro. In the following days, he talked a lot and rather inane about new Russian wonder weapons, against which, according to him, no one has any defense. The media once again started talking about the world being on the brink of nuclear war in Europe.\n\nWhat Moscow fears and wants\nMoscow explains its actions by stating that the permission to use American ATACMS and Franco-British Storm Shadow/SCALP missiles has changed the nature of the conflict and signifies the direct involvement of Western states in the war in Ukraine. The question immediately arises: what exactly has changed? The US has been providing Ukraine with target coordinates within Russian territory and occupied areas throughout the war: Ukraine does not have space-based assets that allow it to do this with the necessary accuracy. Ukraine has regularly used drones to strike targets deep within Russian territory, up to 2,000 km away, based on these coordinates. American ATACMS and Franco-British Storm Shadow/SCALP missiles have been used against targets in the occupied regions of Ukraine, which Moscow considers its territory, as enshrined in its Constitution. All of this was perceived in the Kremlin with relative calm: all is fair in war.\nMoscow’s reaction cannot be explained solely by military circumstances. ATACMS and Storm Shadow/SCALP can hit Russian targets within a relatively narrow strip no more than 300 km wide from the border with Ukraine or the line of contact. The number of such missiles that Ukraine possesses or may possess in the future is small, a maximum of 100-200 units. Considering that several missiles are required to reliably destroy a well-protected target, neither ATACMS nor Storm Shadow can have a serious impact on the course of the war.\n\n\nMost likely, Putin used Biden’s authorization for the sole purpose of demonstrating to the world that he has a new medium-range missile and that he is ready to use it if Ukraine and the West do not comply with his demands. And the reason for this is the potential Republican victory, which could lead to major and unfavorable consequences for Russia, which Putin intends to prevent by threatening a missile-nuclear crisis in Europe.\nIn particular, the plan being developed within Donald Trump’s entourage to end the Russo-Ukrainian war, the outlines of which are gradually becoming clearer, does not suit the Kremlin in any way. Russian Minister of Foreign Affairs Sergey Lavrov made this clear in an interview with Tucker Carlson. He reiterated Putin’s words that Russia is ready “to conduct negotiations based on the principles that were agreed upon in Istanbul,” which fundamentally contradicts the approach of Donald Trump and his team on several points. For example, Trump’s plan provides for a ceasefire, followed by the start of negotiations, strengthening Ukraine’s military security, and possibly creating a demilitarized zone with the deployment of troops from European states. Moscow, on the contrary, demands Kyiv’s agreement to its conditions first, and only then a ceasefire, strict restrictions on the Ukrainian armed forces, and a categorical ban on any foreign troops on Ukrainian territory.\nIf the elected US president insists on his plan, does not accept the ultimatums presented by Moscow to America and NATO in December 2021, and does not meet Putin halfway on a wide range of international issues, an acute crisis in Europe is inevitable, distracting Trump for a long time from his goal, which he considers the main one: confrontation with China. “The message they wanted to convey by testing this hypersonic system in real conditions,” stated Lavrov, for example, in an interview with Tucker Carlson, “is that we will be ready to do everything to protect our legitimate interests… But Russia’s security interests were completely ignored.” Western countries, Lavrov continued, rejected Russian proposals, drafts of which were presented to the West in December 2021.\n\nOreshnik, also known as Rubezh\nThe question naturally arises: does Russia have the resources to impose its conditions on Washington? In particular, what is the notorious Oreshnik? Apparently, this is a slightly modernized version of the missile developed in Russia in the 2010s under the name Rubezh. This version was put forward by the US Department of Defense. Something is known about Rubezh. This is a Yars intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM) with one stage removed and, accordingly, its range reduced by about half, lying within the range of two to five thousand kilometers. The payload of Rubezh, that is, the weight of the warheads, is, according to some sources, 800 kg, according to others — 1200 kg. Rubezh, also known as Oreshnik, like any medium-range missile with a throw-weight of one to two tons, is designed to deliver nuclear weapons. Using a missile costing tens of millions of dollars to deliver a ton of non-nuclear explosives to a target is the height of absurdity. It is equally pointless to use Oreshnik against Ukraine: Russia has many other, much cheaper means of hitting Ukrainian civilian and military targets.\nActually, Putin did not hide the fact that the targets for Oreshnik are actually located in Europe. “The development of medium- and shorter-range missiles is being carried out by us as a retaliatory measure to US plans to produce and deploy medium- and shorter-range missiles in Europe and the Asia-Pacific region… Today, the US is not only producing such equipment, but has also worked out the issues of transferring its advanced missile systems to various regions of the world, including Europe.” It seems that by demonstrating readiness for a limited nuclear war in Europe, Putin is threatening to unleash a new military-political crisis there, similar to the one that took place in the 1970s and 1980s.\n\nCrisis of the 1970s–1980s\nIn the mid-1970s, the USSR began deploying missiles, known in the West as SS-20s, with a range of about 5,000 km. These were weapons designed for a limited nuclear war in Europe, allowing Moscow to deprive NATO countries of their ability to resist with a single strike. A strike with a hundred or two nuclear warheads on European countries would present the US with an existential choice: either accept that Europe would be defenseless against a Soviet invasion, or respond with its strategic weapons against targets on Soviet territory. The latter meant turning a limited nuclear war into a total one and the destruction of both the USSR and the USA. Moscow expected that Washington would not risk its own destruction in order to avenge the defeat of its allies. Similar fears, naturally, existed in European countries. In other words, the very appearance of the SS-20 called into question the basis of NATO’s security — the reliability of American nuclear guarantees to Europe. The latter was the most important goal of the Soviet Union’s foreign policy.\nThe West’s response proved to be quite effective: American Pershing ballistic missiles and Tomahawk cruise missiles began to be deployed in Europe. High-precision Pershings with a flight time of 10–15 minutes could destroy the headquarters of the Soviet political leadership and key command centers, leaving the Kremlin no time to decide on a retaliatory strike. In a broader context, the West gained the ability, during a nuclear war limited to the geographical framework of the European continent, to inflict heavy damage on the Soviet Union and present Moscow with the same choice it had tried to present to America: either accept defeat in a limited war and preserve the country, or respond to the US and perish along with it. As a result, the Soviet leadership was forced to capitulate and agree to the elimination of the entire class of intermediate-range and shorter-range missiles.\n\nMoscow’s miscalculation\nThese days, Putin seems to be making the same mistake as the Soviet leadership in the 1970s–1980s: by demonstrating the Oreshnik, he is threatening the West with a limited nuclear war in Europe, believing that it will not be able to withstand the pressure of force. Moscow’s attempt to blackmail the West by deploying SS-20s failed because the authors of this idea underestimated the determination of the US and Europe to respond to force with force. The extent to which the current leaders of the Western world are ready to repeat the experience of their predecessors — Ronald Reagan, Margaret Thatcher, and Helmut Kohl, who understood that blackmailers can only be dealt with by opposing them with force and a willingness to use it — is still unclear. But several circumstances inspire a certain optimism.\n\n\nNATO member state leaders have shed their naive illusions about Russia. The latter, stated in the declaration of the Washington NATO summit held in July 2024, “seeks to fundamentally change the architecture of Euro-Atlantic security; the threat in all spheres that Russia poses to NATO will persist in the long term.” Western countries are gradually moving from words to deeds. Thus, in 2023, European companies sold almost $160 billion worth of arms, or 17% more than in 2022, and this trend is likely to continue for a long time.\nPutin decided to start serial production of the Oreshnik cruise missile. It is known that the Oreshnik can only be produced at the Votkinsk Machine-Building Plant, which also manufactures the Yars ICBM, the Bulava submarine-launched ballistic missile, and the Iskander short-range missile. The capacity of this enterprise is limited, and increasing it is extremely difficult, if not impossible. According to data from Ukrainian intelligence (which can be believed or not, but we have no other information), the annual production of Oreshnik missiles could be 25 units. It is difficult to say when the Votkinsk plant will reach this level; it is only clear that this will not happen in the coming months. In other words, Putin is threatening the West with a missile that he does not have, and it is unknown when and in what quantity he will have it.\nIn Russia, the decision has only been made to start serial production of the Oreshnik, while the US already possesses medium-range weapons — the latest modification of the Tomahawk cruise missile and the Typhon ballistic missile (a ship-based SM-6 anti-aircraft missile adapted for ground launch against ground targets), capable of hitting enemy targets at ranges from 500 to 2,500 km with high accuracy. In addition, Europe is developing its own weapons for a similar purpose to achieve “strategic autonomy.” Russian politicians, political scientists, and propagandists, as a rule, forget about this when they threaten the West with a limited nuclear war.\n\n\nDonald Trump’s victory turns into unfavorable consequences for Russia: it will have to end the war in Ukraine without achieving its main goal — the destruction of Ukrainian statehood; the assertion of “strategic autonomy” will accelerate in Europe; Iran is already looking for an opportunity to normalize relations with the USA, and so on. Moscow is reacting to this in its usual way: with nuclear threats. The US and European states, in turn, have allowed Putin a lot, but the threat of destroying Europe with nuclear weapons is unacceptable to them. And so, in the West, they may come, or perhaps have already come, to the conclusion: it is necessary to eliminate this threat.","blocks":[{"data":"<strong>Two stages of escalation</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The first stage of the current military-political escalation began with Putin’s <a href=\"http://kremlin.ru/events/president/news/75092\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">statement</a> on September 12th, 2024. If Western governments, he said, allow Ukraine to strike deep into Russian territory with their long-range weapons, this “will mean that NATO countries, the US, and European countries are at war with Russia... We will make appropriate decisions based on the threats that will be created for us.” In his opinion, Armed Forces of Ukraine’s officers are unable to independently input flight missions into American and British missiles, and can only receive target coordinates from Western allies. Less than two weeks later, on September 25th, Putin announced changes to the “Fundamentals of the State Policy of the Russian Federation in the Field of Nuclear Deterrence,” expanding the list of conditions under which Russia “reserves the right to use nuclear weapons.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, the signing of the decree approving the updated nuclear doctrine was postponed, which contradicted established procedure. Usually, after a public announcement of the discussion of such documents at the highest level, they are approved either on the same day or the next. This delay could have been a signal — as long as Washington prohibits Kyiv from using <em>ATACMS</em> against internationally recognized Russian territory, Moscow will refrain from enacting the new nuclear doctrine. But perhaps Moscow was waiting for the results of the US presidential elections. The potential victory of Kamala Harris, presumably, was perceived in the Kremlin with relative calm: the Democrats’ characteristic combination of belligerent rhetoric with minimal aid to Ukraine did not cause serious concern there.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":13942,"data":{"header":"Putin talked a lot and inane about new Russian wonder weapons, against which no one has any defense"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"The second stage of escalation began shortly after the results of the US presidential elections were determined. The reason for this was given by Joe Biden, who on November 16th authorized Ukraine to use missiles with a range of up to 300 km against Russian territory. Kyiv took advantage of this authorization: on the nights of November 19th and 21st, <em>ATACMS</em> and <em>Storm Shadow</em> missiles struck military targets in the Bryansk and Kursk Oblasts. The Kremlin seems to have expected this. Immediately after the first strike, on November 19th, Putin signed a <a href=\"http://static.kremlin.ru/media/events/files/ru/KrzVeeTCkT05CCvgIoY03xuvIdkVslkx.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">decree</a> approving the new nuclear doctrine, and after the second, he <a href=\"http://kremlin.ru/events/president/news/75614\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">announced</a> the use of a medium-range missile against the Ukrainian missile factory <em>Yuzhmash</em> in Dnipro. In the following days, he talked a lot and rather inane about new Russian wonder weapons, against which, according to him, no one has any defense. The media once again started talking about the world being on the brink of nuclear war in Europe.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>What Moscow fears and wants</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Moscow explains its actions by stating that the permission to use American <em>ATACMS</em> and Franco-British <em>Storm Shadow/SCALP</em> missiles has changed the nature of the conflict and signifies the direct involvement of Western states in the war in Ukraine. The question immediately arises: what exactly has changed? The US has been providing Ukraine with target coordinates within Russian territory and occupied areas throughout the war: Ukraine does not have space-based assets that allow it to do this with the necessary accuracy. Ukraine has regularly used drones to strike targets deep within Russian territory, up to 2,000 km away, based on these coordinates. American <em>ATACMS</em> and Franco-British <em>Storm Shadow/SCALP</em> missiles have been used against targets in the occupied regions of Ukraine, which Moscow considers its territory, as enshrined in its Constitution. All of this was perceived in the Kremlin with relative calm: all is fair in war.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Moscow’s reaction cannot be explained solely by military circumstances. <em>ATACMS</em> and <em>Storm Shadow/SCALP</em> can hit Russian targets within a relatively narrow strip no more than 300 km wide from the border with Ukraine or the line of contact. The number of such missiles that Ukraine possesses or may possess in the future is small, a maximum of 100-200 units. Considering that several missiles are required to reliably destroy a well-protected target, neither <em>ATACMS</em> nor <em>Storm Shadow</em> can have a serious impact on the course of the war.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":13943,"data":{"header":"The question naturally arises: does Russia have the resources to impose its conditions on Washington? In particular, what is the notorious Oreshnik?"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"Most likely, Putin used Biden’s authorization for the sole purpose of demonstrating to the world that he has a new medium-range missile and that he is ready to use it if Ukraine and the West do not comply with his demands. And the reason for this is the potential Republican victory, which could lead to major and unfavorable consequences for Russia, which Putin intends to prevent by threatening a missile-nuclear crisis in Europe.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In particular, the plan being developed within Donald Trump’s entourage to end the Russo-Ukrainian war, the outlines of which are gradually becoming clearer, does not suit the Kremlin in any way. Russian Minister of Foreign Affairs Sergey Lavrov made this clear in an <a href=\"https://mid.ru/ru/foreign_policy/news/1985783/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">interview</a> with Tucker Carlson. He reiterated Putin’s words that Russia is ready “to conduct negotiations based on the principles that were agreed upon in Istanbul,” which fundamentally contradicts the approach of Donald Trump and his team on several points. For example, <a href=\"https://united24media.com/latest-news/whats-inside-general-keith-kelloggs-ukraine-plan-4176\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Trump’s plan</a> provides for a ceasefire, followed by the start of negotiations, strengthening Ukraine’s military security, and possibly creating a demilitarized zone with the deployment of troops from European states. Moscow, on the contrary, demands Kyiv’s agreement to its conditions first, and only then a ceasefire, strict restrictions on the Ukrainian armed forces, and a categorical ban on any foreign troops on Ukrainian territory.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"If the elected US president insists on his plan, does not accept the <a href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/December_2021_Russian_ultimatum_to_NATO\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">ultimatums</a> presented by Moscow to America and NATO in December 2021, and does not meet Putin halfway on a wide range of international issues, an acute crisis in Europe is inevitable, distracting Trump for a long time from his goal, which he considers the main one: confrontation with China. “The message they wanted to convey by testing this hypersonic system in real conditions,” <a href=\"https://mid.ru/ru/foreign_policy/news/1985783/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">stated</a> Lavrov, for example, in an interview with Tucker Carlson, “is that we will be ready to do everything to protect our legitimate interests… But Russia’s security interests were completely ignored.” Western countries, Lavrov continued, rejected Russian proposals, drafts of which were presented to the West in December 2021.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Oreshnik, also known as Rubezh</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The question naturally arises: does Russia have the resources to impose its conditions on Washington? In particular, what is the notorious <em>Oreshnik</em>? Apparently, this is a slightly modernized version of the missile developed in Russia in the 2010s under the name <em>Rubezh</em>. This version was <a href=\"https://www.defense.gov/News/News-Stories/Article/Article/3975321/russians-launch-new-missile-at-dnipro-us-provides-ukraine-with-new-tactical-wea/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">put forward</a> by the US Department of Defense. Something is known about <em>Rubezh</em>. This is a <em>Yars</em> intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM) with one stage removed and, accordingly, its range reduced by about half, lying within the range of two to five thousand kilometers. The payload of <em>Rubezh</em>, that is, the weight of the warheads, is, <a href=\"https://missilethreat.csis.org/missile/ss-x-31-rs-26-rubezh/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">according to some sources</a>, 800 kg, <a href=\"https://eutoday.net/russias-potential-rs-26-missile-strike/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">according to others</a> — 1200 kg. <em>Rubezh</em>, also known as <em>Oreshnik</em>, like any medium-range missile with a throw-weight of one to two tons, is designed to deliver nuclear weapons. Using a missile costing tens of millions of dollars to deliver a ton of non-nuclear explosives to a target is the height of absurdity. It is equally pointless to use <em>Oreshnik</em> against Ukraine: Russia has many other, much cheaper means of hitting Ukrainian civilian and military targets.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Actually, Putin did not <a href=\"http://kremlin.ru/events/president/news/75614\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">hide</a> the fact that the targets for <em>Oreshnik</em> are actually located in Europe. “The development of medium- and shorter-range missiles is being carried out by us as a retaliatory measure to US plans to produce and deploy medium- and shorter-range missiles in Europe and the Asia-Pacific region… Today, the US is not only producing such equipment, but has also worked out the issues of transferring its advanced missile systems to various regions of the world, including Europe.” It seems that by demonstrating readiness for a limited nuclear war in Europe, Putin is threatening to unleash a new military-political crisis there, similar to the one that took place in the 1970s and 1980s.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Crisis of the 1970s–1980s</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In the mid-1970s, the USSR began deploying missiles, known in the West as <em>SS-20s</em>, with a range of about 5,000 km. These were weapons designed for a limited nuclear war in Europe, allowing Moscow to deprive NATO countries of their ability to resist with a single strike. A strike with a hundred or two nuclear warheads on European countries would present the US with an existential choice: either accept that Europe would be defenseless against a Soviet invasion, or respond with its strategic weapons against targets on Soviet territory. The latter meant turning a limited nuclear war into a total one and the destruction of both the USSR and the USA. Moscow expected that Washington would not risk its own destruction in order to avenge the defeat of its allies. Similar fears, naturally, existed in European countries. In other words, the very appearance of the <em>SS-20</em> called into question the basis of NATO’s security — the reliability of American nuclear guarantees to Europe. The latter was the most important goal of the Soviet Union’s foreign policy.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The West’s response proved to be quite effective: American <em>Pershing</em> ballistic missiles and <em>Tomahawk</em> cruise missiles began to be deployed in Europe. High-precision <em>Pershings</em> with a flight time of 10–15 minutes could destroy the headquarters of the Soviet political leadership and key command centers, leaving the Kremlin no time to decide on a retaliatory strike. In a broader context, the West gained the ability, during a nuclear war limited to the geographical framework of the European continent, to inflict heavy damage on the Soviet Union and present Moscow with the same choice it had tried to present to America: either accept defeat in a limited war and preserve the country, or respond to the US and perish along with it. As a result, the Soviet leadership was forced to capitulate and agree to the elimination of the entire class of intermediate-range and shorter-range missiles.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Moscow’s miscalculation</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"These days, Putin seems to be making the same mistake as the Soviet leadership in the 1970s–1980s: by demonstrating the <em>Oreshnik</em>, he is threatening the West with a limited nuclear war in Europe, believing that it will not be able to withstand the pressure of force. Moscow’s attempt to blackmail the West by deploying <em>SS-20s</em> failed because the authors of this idea underestimated the determination of the US and Europe to respond to force with force. The extent to which the current leaders of the Western world are ready to repeat the experience of their predecessors — Ronald Reagan, Margaret Thatcher, and Helmut Kohl, who understood that blackmailers can only be dealt with by opposing them with force and a willingness to use it&nbsp;— is still unclear. But several circumstances inspire a certain optimism.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":13944,"data":{"header":"Trump’s victory turns into unfavorable consequences for Russia: it will have to end the war in Ukraine without achieving its main goal"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"NATO member state leaders have shed their naive illusions about Russia. The latter, <a href=\"https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/official_texts_227678.htm?selectedLocale=en\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">stated</a> in the declaration of the Washington NATO summit held in July 2024, “seeks to fundamentally change the architecture of Euro-Atlantic security; the threat in all spheres that Russia poses to NATO will persist in the long term.” Western countries are gradually moving from words to deeds. Thus, in 2023, European companies <a href=\"https://www.asd-europe.org/news-media/facts-figures/key-data-overview/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">sold</a> almost $160 billion worth of arms, or 17% more than in 2022, and this trend is likely to continue for a long time.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Putin <a href=\"http://kremlin.ru/events/president/news/75623\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">decided</a> to start serial production of the <em>Oreshnik</em> cruise missile. It is known that the <em>Oreshnik</em> can only be produced at the <em>Votkinsk Machine-Building Plant</em>, which also manufactures the <em>Yars</em> ICBM, the <em>Bulava</em> submarine-launched ballistic missile, and the <em>Iskander</em> short-range missile. The capacity of this enterprise is limited, and increasing it is extremely difficult, if not impossible. According to <a href=\"https://global.espreso.tv/russia-ukraine-war-how-many-oreshnik-missiles-can-russia-produce-per-year-expert-explains\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">data</a> from Ukrainian intelligence (which can be believed or not, but we have no other information), the annual production of <em>Oreshnik</em> missiles could be 25 units. It is difficult to say when the Votkinsk plant will reach this level; it is only clear that this will not happen in the coming months. In other words, Putin is threatening the West with a missile that he does not have, and it is unknown when and in what quantity he will have it.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In Russia, the decision has only been made to start serial production of the <em>Oreshnik</em>, while the US already <a href=\"https://sgp.fas.org/crs/weapons/IF12135.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">possesses</a> medium-range weapons — the latest modification of the <em>Tomahawk</em> cruise missile and the <em>Typhon</em> ballistic missile (a ship-based <em>SM-6</em> anti-aircraft missile adapted for ground launch against ground targets), capable of hitting enemy targets at ranges from 500 to 2,500 km with high accuracy. In addition, Europe is <a href=\"https://www.fpri.org/article/2024/11/a-new-arms-race-in-europe-euromissiles-2-0/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">developing</a> its own weapons for a similar purpose to achieve “strategic autonomy.” Russian politicians, political scientists, and propagandists, as a rule, forget about this when they threaten the West with a limited nuclear war.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":13945,"data":{"text":"Please support IStories with a donate","title":"Thank you for reading","buttonText":"Learn more"},"category":"donate-embed"},"type":"donate-embed"},{"data":"Donald Trump’s victory turns into unfavorable consequences for Russia: it will have to end the war in Ukraine without achieving its main goal — the destruction of Ukrainian statehood; the assertion of “strategic autonomy” will accelerate in Europe; Iran is already looking for an opportunity to normalize relations with the USA, and so on. Moscow is reacting to this in its usual way: with nuclear threats. The US and European states, in turn, have allowed Putin a lot, but the threat of destroying Europe with nuclear weapons is unacceptable to them. And so, in the West, they may come, or perhaps have already come, to the conclusion: it is necessary to eliminate this threat.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":6770,"header":"“This is an ISIS Victory”","_path":"/en/opinions/2024/12/10/kurdistan/","lead":"What do the Kurdistan region think about the overthrow of Bashar al-Assad’s regime in Syria? Military journalist Liza Shishko, who has been observing the Kurdish struggle from the inside for 7 years, explains","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e600688a1a2f4064b2e7c0b24a31266c-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Pro-Kurdish fighters at Qamishli airport in Hasaka province on December 8, 2024 / Delil SOULEIMAN / AFP","created_at_date":"2024-12-10","created_at_date_time":"2024-12-10T11:36:45.970Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":60,"first_name":"Анастасия","last_name":"Мереняшева","first_name_en":"Anastasiya","last_name_en":"Merenyasheva","is_public":true,"_path":"anastasiya-merenyasheva","avatar":[],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":null}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"Islamists and Turkish proxies in Syria seized the capital Damascus, and President Bashar al-Assad resigned and fled the country. However, the civil war did not end there. \n\nThe only serious opponent of the militants and pro-Turkish formations remained Rojava, the Autonomous Administration of Northern and Eastern Syria. The militants have already launched an offensive on its positions, and they managed to capture the city of Manbij. \n\nRojava is a confederal autonomy established in 2016 based on the principles of anarchism and gender equality. It is located in northeastern Syria, a region mainly inhabited by Kurds, the largest ethnic group in the world without a state. They are the ones who form the backbone of the armed formations that operate on the side of the Autonomous Administration. Pro-Kurdish formations are also supported (with weapons and training) and financed by the United States. \n\n\nKurds also live in Turkey, it is the largest national minority in the country. However, Ankara considers civilian Kurdish organizations as terrorist — in this way the state is trying to fight separatist sentiments among Kurds. This is also why Turkey actively sponsors Syrian groups against which the Kurds are fighting. \n\nAbout the future of Rojava in Syria, where militants have seized power, IStories talked to Liza Shishko (pseudonym) — a military journalist who is in Syrian Kurdistan and covers what is happening there in the Telegram channel Woman, Life Freedom. Shishko is Russian but has been living between Iraq, Syria and Lebanon for the past seven years. \n\nWhen asked what the fall of the Syrian government means to her personally, she replies: “I rejoice at the overthrow of the Assad regime and wish the same for Putin.” But she notes that the regime was overthrown not by the rebels, who express the aspirations of the entire Syrian people, but by splinters of ISIS, re-bought by Turkey. \n\n— How was the overthrow of Bashar al-Assad perceived in Rojava?\n\n— People are celebrating throughout northeastern Syria, both in predominantly Kurdish cities and in Arab cities — Deir ez-Zor, for example. \n\n\nHowever, the most dangerous opponent for the pro-Kurdish militias has not been the Assad regime, but Turkish proxies. These include the Islamist group Hayʼat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) and the Syrian National Army (SNA), both of which Turkey bought from Al-Qaeda. Turkey sponsors and supports both of these coalitions [they are the ones who seized power in the country]. \n\nThe pro-Kurdish forces have always had problems with the Assad regime, but it did not have the resources to become a real threat to the Syrian Democratic Forces [SDF — pro-Kurdish military alliance]. In addition, the authorities realized that the pro-Kurdish militias were the most effective force against ISIS in the region. \n\nThe HTS and the SNA, on the contrary, are linked to ISIS. Many HTS fighters were seen carrying ISIS symbols while attacking Aleppo, and many ex-ISIS fighters are now in their ranks. ISIS has been smuggling its contraband into northeastern Syria through regions occupied by Turkish proxies. In the past few times, the International Coalition [the military intervention by the US and its allies in Syria that began in 2014] has eliminated ISIS leaders in the territories controlled by the SNA. This is not an accident, they live there, they organize there. \n\nThe victory of the HTS and the SNA is a victory for ISIS. I have personally talked to arrested ISIS fighters who are in prisons and camps in northeastern Syria and their families. They all dream of Rojava being occupied by the SNA and HTS. All this is very bad for the Kurds and other peoples of northeastern Syria. \n\n\n— Does Rojava have enough forces and resources to contain the militants’ offensive?\n\n— The SNA and HTS are backed by Turkey, and Turkey has the second most powerful army in NATO. I do not think the SDF will be able to counter them on all fronts for long without closed airspace. Plus, the HTS has captured a huge amount of weapons and equipment. \n\n— Does the Kurdish administration have any diplomatic contacts with the militants who have seized power?\n\n— There are always contacts. But the other thing is that we are not talking about diplomatic relations and cooperation yet. Both the HTS and the SNA fought with pro-Kurdish formations, occupied territories and expelled the Kurdish population with the help of Turkey [since 2016, Turkey and its proxies have been occupying some territories in northern Syria that were previously controlled by the Kurds - these are parts of Aleppo and Hasakah provinces. Human rights activists reported that due to the Turkish occupation, hundreds of thousands of local residents fled these areas, and those who remained were subjected to brutal repression]. \n\nThe road to understanding is long, at least until the Kurdish refugees can safely return to their lands and until the regular shelling and drone strikes, which have only intensified in recent days, cease. \n\n\nRight now there are battles between pro-Kurdish formations and Turkish proxies for Manbij [at the time of the interview, Turkish proxies had already captured it]. They are accompanied by airstrikes and heavy weapons fire along the entire line of contact. So far, it is difficult to speak of any lasting peace. \n\nAt the same time, the HTS mercenaries have concluded an agreement with a Kurdish neighborhood in Aleppo, but this is not a long-term solution. Most likely, this is a temporary concession, because now the HTS is trying to preserve the image of a polite and legitimate opposition, so that the world forgets that it is Al-Nusra Front [a splinter of Al-Qaeda]. \n\n— What will happen to the Kurdish population if the militants take control of Rojava?\n\n— I think ethnic cleansing, massacres, and arrests. Approximately the same as in the territories previously occupied by pro-Turkish mercenaries, only on a larger scale. Not only the Kurds will suffer, but also the Assyrians, who are a significant force in the SDF, and many Arab tribes who fought shoulder to shoulder with the Kurds even before the International Coalition. \n\nNo one in northeastern Syria is ready for the region to be ruled by the HTS or the SNA with their own orders. There is a system of co-chairmanship of women and men in all institutions and spheres in the region [there are two chairmen — a man and a woman — in all government bodies]. \n\nAt the same time, married girls are not allowed to attend school in the territories controlled by the HTS. There are also Christians in northeastern Syria, and the HTS and SNA prohibit the ringing of bells in their territories. \n\n\n— Militants have seized territories controlled by the Assad regime in a matter of days. Because of this, there has been a flood of refugees into Rojava. Is there any estimate of their number?\n\n— According to the UN, there is a risk that the number of internal refugees will grow to 1.5 million people. It was reported that since the beginning of the HTS offensive on Aleppo on November 27, more than 280 thousand people have already been forced to leave their homes and flee [according to the latest data, which the UN published on December 7, this number exceeded 370 thousand people]. The Autonomous Administration of Northeastern Syria expected about this number of refugees. But that was a week ago, when Homs and Damascus had not yet been captured. The number of refugees will definitely still grow. \n\nIt is worth noting that residents of Syria are not free to leave the country. They can either flee or pay huge amount of money and risk their lives trying to swim across the Mediterranean Sea.\n\n\n— From which regions do refugees mostly come from?\n\n— From Shahba (in the south) and Tell Rifaat (in the northwest), refugees are coming to Al-Thawrah and Raqqa [cities controlled by the Autonomous Administration]. Now people are coming from Manbij. But at the moment there are no evacuations from Aleppo and other regions. Those who managed to leave fled in the first hours of the offensive. Many people I know from Aleppo are waiting for the road to northeastern Syria to open, but so far evacuation is impossible. \n\nThe SDF reported 15,000 Shahba residents prevented from leaving the city by mercenaries. In 2018, people who lived in Afrin, a town in northern Syria previously controlled by Rojava, were forced to leave for Shahba. Since 2018, it has been occupied by Turkey and its proxies. So there were many Kurds left in Shahba who actively resisted the Turkish invaders all these years. Now they are under occupation and it is unknown what will happen to them. \n\nMany people stayed in the newly captured territories because they did not have time to gather quickly. There have been cases of people dying on the way from injuries or cold, including civilians, some of whom were children. As recently as 5 days ago, there was talk of more than 100,000 people entering northeastern Syria from Shahba and Tell Rifaat. Now that number is definitely higher. \n\n\n— What can the international community do to support Rojava?\n\n— The region of northeastern Syria must be given official autonomous status. No one is now talking about creating a Kurdistan state, but the Kurds and other peoples of the region should have the right to choose their destiny within Syria. It is already a de facto autonomous region, and it should receive the appropriate status. The Autonomous Administration has all the resources and capabilities to govern. \n\n\n— Western media often cover what is happening through the prism of “the rebels defeated the dictator.” Does this affect international support for the Kurds?\n\n— It affects the situation in Syria as a whole because it whitewashes and legitimizes the HTS group, which is the former Al-Nusra Front, the Al-Qaeda branch in Syria. ISIS, for example, also wanted to overthrow the regime — they were quite good at it, by the way. When people call the HTS “rebels” and “opposition,” they should understand that they are talking about an organization recognized as a terrorist organization worldwide. The HTS is not expressing the will of all Syrians, but only the representatives of radical Sunni Islam.","blocks":[{"data":"Islamists and Turkish proxies in Syria seized the capital Damascus, and President Bashar al-Assad resigned and fled the country. However, the civil war did not end there.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The only serious opponent of the militants and pro-Turkish formations remained Rojava, the Autonomous Administration of Northern and Eastern Syria. The militants have already launched an offensive on its positions, and they managed to <a href=\"https://t.me/azatyutun/1680\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">capture</a> the city of Manbij.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Rojava is a confederal autonomy established in 2016 based on the principles of anarchism and gender equality. It is located in northeastern Syria, a region mainly inhabited by Kurds, the largest ethnic group in the world without a state. They are the ones who form the backbone of the armed formations that operate on the side of the Autonomous Administration. Pro-Kurdish formations are also supported (with weapons and training) and <a href=\"https://comptroller.defense.gov/Portals/45/Documents/defbudget/FY2024/FY2024_CTEF_J-Book.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">financed</a> by the United States.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":13712,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: imago images / snapshot","caption":"US military on patrol in Rojava","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0c85e2013aa4c8a8a973f42eee3c5e5-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0c85e2013aa4c8a8a973f42eee3c5e5-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0c85e2013aa4c8a8a973f42eee3c5e5-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0c85e2013aa4c8a8a973f42eee3c5e5-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0c85e2013aa4c8a8a973f42eee3c5e5-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0c85e2013aa4c8a8a973f42eee3c5e5-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0c85e2013aa4c8a8a973f42eee3c5e5-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0c85e2013aa4c8a8a973f42eee3c5e5-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Kurds also live in Turkey, it is the largest national minority in the country. However, Ankara considers civilian Kurdish organizations as terrorist — in this way the state is trying to fight separatist sentiments among Kurds. This is also why Turkey actively sponsors Syrian groups against which the Kurds are fighting.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"About the future of Rojava in Syria, where militants have seized power, IStories talked to <strong>Liza Shishko</strong> (pseudonym) — a military journalist who is in Syrian Kurdistan and covers what is happening there in the Telegram channel <a href=\"https://t.me/azatyutun\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>Woman, Life Freedom</em></a>. Shishko is Russian but has been living between Iraq, Syria and Lebanon for the past seven years.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"When asked what the fall of the Syrian government means to her personally, she replies: “I rejoice at the overthrow of the Assad regime and wish the same for Putin.” But she notes that the regime was overthrown not by the rebels, who express the aspirations of the entire Syrian people, but by splinters of ISIS, re-bought by Turkey.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>— How was the overthrow of Bashar al-Assad perceived in Rojava?</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— People are celebrating throughout northeastern Syria, both in predominantly Kurdish cities and in Arab cities — Deir ez-Zor, for example.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":13710,"data":{"url":"https://t.me/azatyutun/1663","initialHeight":"362px"},"category":"telegram-embed"},"type":"telegram-embed"},{"data":"However, the most dangerous opponent for the pro-Kurdish militias has not been the Assad regime, but Turkish proxies. These include the Islamist group Hayʼat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) and the Syrian National Army (SNA), both of which Turkey bought from Al-Qaeda. Turkey sponsors and supports both of these coalitions [they are the ones who seized power in the country].&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The pro-Kurdish forces have always had problems with the Assad regime, but it did not have the resources to become a real threat to the Syrian Democratic Forces <em>[SDF — pro-Kurdish military alliance]</em>. In addition, the authorities realized that the pro-Kurdish militias were the most effective force against ISIS in the region.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The HTS and the SNA, on the contrary, are linked to ISIS. Many HTS fighters were seen carrying ISIS symbols while attacking Aleppo, and many ex-ISIS fighters are now in their ranks. ISIS has been smuggling its contraband into northeastern Syria through regions occupied by Turkish proxies. In the past few times, the International Coalition <em>[the military intervention by the US and its allies in Syria that began in 2014]</em> has eliminated ISIS leaders in the territories controlled by the SNA. This is not an accident, they live there, they organize there.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The victory of the HTS and the SNA is a victory for ISIS. I have personally talked to arrested ISIS fighters who are in prisons and camps in northeastern Syria and their families. They all dream of Rojava being occupied by the SNA and HTS. All this is very bad for the Kurds and other peoples of northeastern Syria.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":13713,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Delil SOULEIMAN / AFP","caption":"Kurds tear down statues of Hafez al-Assad in Qamishli","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/77ec87fa31724283a080e07ade87cb70-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/77ec87fa31724283a080e07ade87cb70-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/77ec87fa31724283a080e07ade87cb70-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/77ec87fa31724283a080e07ade87cb70-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/77ec87fa31724283a080e07ade87cb70-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/77ec87fa31724283a080e07ade87cb70-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/77ec87fa31724283a080e07ade87cb70-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/77ec87fa31724283a080e07ade87cb70-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]},{"credit":"Photo: Delil SOULEIMAN / AFP","caption":"Kurds tear down statues of Hafez al-Assad in Qamishli","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/85ab7ef3b6e143a59a7865d770f715e0-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/85ab7ef3b6e143a59a7865d770f715e0-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/85ab7ef3b6e143a59a7865d770f715e0-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/85ab7ef3b6e143a59a7865d770f715e0-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/85ab7ef3b6e143a59a7865d770f715e0-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/85ab7ef3b6e143a59a7865d770f715e0-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/85ab7ef3b6e143a59a7865d770f715e0-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/85ab7ef3b6e143a59a7865d770f715e0-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"two-images-embed"},"type":"two-images-embed"},{"data":"<strong>— Does Rojava have enough forces and resources to contain the militants’ offensive?</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— The SNA and HTS are backed by Turkey, and Turkey has the second most powerful army in NATO. I do not think the SDF will be able to counter them on all fronts for long without closed airspace. Plus, the HTS has captured a huge amount of weapons and equipment.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>— Does the Kurdish administration have any diplomatic contacts with the militants who have seized power?</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— There are always contacts. But the other thing is that we are not talking about diplomatic relations and cooperation yet. Both the HTS and the SNA fought with pro-Kurdish formations, occupied territories and expelled the Kurdish population with the help of Turkey <em>[since 2016, Turkey and its proxies have been occupying some territories in northern Syria that were previously controlled by the Kurds - these are parts of Aleppo and Hasakah provinces. Human rights activists </em><a href=\"https://www.hrw.org/news/2024/02/29/syria-abuses-impunity-turkish-occupied-territories\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>reported</em></a><em> that due to the Turkish occupation, hundreds of thousands of local residents fled these areas, and those who remained were subjected to brutal repression]</em>.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The road to understanding is long, at least until the Kurdish refugees can safely return to their lands and until the regular shelling and drone strikes, which have only intensified in recent days, cease.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":13714,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Delil SOULEIMAN / AFP","caption":"The aftermath of a Turkish strike on an oil production facility in Hasakah on October 25. Then Turkish drones killed 27 civilians in Syria in 24 hours. It was a response to an attack on a defense facility near Ankara, which Turkish authorities blamed on Kurds","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f235a0a48d374ec19653684433d8e310-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f235a0a48d374ec19653684433d8e310-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f235a0a48d374ec19653684433d8e310-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f235a0a48d374ec19653684433d8e310-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f235a0a48d374ec19653684433d8e310-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f235a0a48d374ec19653684433d8e310-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f235a0a48d374ec19653684433d8e310-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f235a0a48d374ec19653684433d8e310-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]},{"credit":"Photo: Delil SOULEIMAN / AFP","caption":"The aftermath of a Turkish strike on an oil production facility in Hasakah on October 25. Then Turkish drones killed 27 civilians in Syria in 24 hours. It was a response to an attack on a defense facility near Ankara, which Turkish authorities blamed on Kurds","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/27c1469513ba4cdc95666b93d9116e94-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/27c1469513ba4cdc95666b93d9116e94-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/27c1469513ba4cdc95666b93d9116e94-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/27c1469513ba4cdc95666b93d9116e94-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/27c1469513ba4cdc95666b93d9116e94-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/27c1469513ba4cdc95666b93d9116e94-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/27c1469513ba4cdc95666b93d9116e94-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/27c1469513ba4cdc95666b93d9116e94-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"two-images-embed"},"type":"two-images-embed"},{"data":"Right now there are battles between pro-Kurdish formations and Turkish proxies for Manbij <em>[at the time of the interview, Turkish proxies had already captured it]</em>. They are accompanied by airstrikes and heavy weapons fire along the entire line of contact. So far, it is difficult to speak of any lasting peace.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At the same time, the HTS mercenaries have concluded an agreement with a Kurdish neighborhood in Aleppo, but this is not a long-term solution. Most likely, this is a temporary concession, because now the HTS is trying to preserve the image of a polite and legitimate opposition, so that the world forgets that it is Al-Nusra Front <em>[a splinter of Al-Qaeda]</em>.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>— What will happen to the Kurdish population if the militants take control of Rojava?</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— I think ethnic cleansing, massacres, and arrests. Approximately the same as in the territories previously occupied by pro-Turkish mercenaries, only on a larger scale. Not only the Kurds will suffer, but also the Assyrians, who are a significant force in the SDF, and many Arab tribes who fought shoulder to shoulder with the Kurds even before the International Coalition.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"No one in northeastern Syria is ready for the region to be ruled by the HTS or the SNA with their own orders. There is a system of co-chairmanship of women and men in all institutions and spheres in the region [there are two chairmen — a man and a woman — in all government bodies].&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At the same time, married girls are not allowed to attend school in the territories controlled by the HTS. There are also Christians in northeastern Syria, and the HTS and SNA prohibit the ringing of bells in their territories.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":13715,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Delil SOULEIMAN / AFP","caption":"Demonstration in Qamishli against attacks by Turkish proxies on Kurdish-controlled territories, December 2","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/85169ce0a3c94770926b6a0cc77b93c2-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/85169ce0a3c94770926b6a0cc77b93c2-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/85169ce0a3c94770926b6a0cc77b93c2-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/85169ce0a3c94770926b6a0cc77b93c2-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/85169ce0a3c94770926b6a0cc77b93c2-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/85169ce0a3c94770926b6a0cc77b93c2-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/85169ce0a3c94770926b6a0cc77b93c2-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/85169ce0a3c94770926b6a0cc77b93c2-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"<strong>— Militants have seized territories controlled by the Assad regime in a matter of days. Because of this, there has been a flood of refugees into Rojava. Is there any estimate of their number?</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— <a href=\"https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/up-15-million-people-could-flee-syrian-escalation-un-official-says-2024-12-06/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">According</a> to the UN, there is a risk that the number of internal refugees will grow to 1.5 million people. It was <a href=\"https://news.un.org/en/story/2024/12/1157871\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reported</a> that since the beginning of the HTS offensive on Aleppo on November 27, more than 280 thousand people have already been forced to leave their homes and flee <em>[according to the latest data, which the UN </em><a href=\"https://reliefweb.int/report/syrian-arab-republic/statement-un-resident-and-humanitarian-coordinator-syria-adam-abdelmoula-united-nations-commitment-supporting-people-syria-enar\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>published</em></a><em> on December 7, this number exceeded 370 thousand people]</em>. The Autonomous Administration of Northeastern Syria expected about this number of refugees. But that was a week ago, when Homs and Damascus had not yet been captured. The number of refugees will definitely still grow.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It is worth noting that residents of Syria are not free to leave the country. They can either flee or pay huge amount of money and risk their lives trying to swim across the Mediterranean Sea.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":13717,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Delil SOULEIMAN / AFP","caption":"Kurds collect and sort clothes for refugees arriving from Aleppo","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/aee8c26755d94a9db431fa72166543c3-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/aee8c26755d94a9db431fa72166543c3-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/aee8c26755d94a9db431fa72166543c3-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/aee8c26755d94a9db431fa72166543c3-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/aee8c26755d94a9db431fa72166543c3-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/aee8c26755d94a9db431fa72166543c3-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/aee8c26755d94a9db431fa72166543c3-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/aee8c26755d94a9db431fa72166543c3-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]},{"credit":"Photo: Delil SOULEIMAN / AFP","caption":"Kurds collect and sort clothes for refugees arriving from Aleppo","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ddba791bcd5a4d0aa33fb56bf3b938fd-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ddba791bcd5a4d0aa33fb56bf3b938fd-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ddba791bcd5a4d0aa33fb56bf3b938fd-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ddba791bcd5a4d0aa33fb56bf3b938fd-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ddba791bcd5a4d0aa33fb56bf3b938fd-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ddba791bcd5a4d0aa33fb56bf3b938fd-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ddba791bcd5a4d0aa33fb56bf3b938fd-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ddba791bcd5a4d0aa33fb56bf3b938fd-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"two-images-embed"},"type":"two-images-embed"},{"data":"<strong>— From which regions do refugees mostly come from?</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— From Shahba (in the south) and Tell Rifaat (in the northwest), refugees are coming to Al-Thawrah and Raqqa <em>[cities controlled by the Autonomous Administration]</em>. Now people are coming from Manbij. But at the moment there are no evacuations from Aleppo and other regions. Those who managed to leave fled in the first hours of the offensive. Many people I know from Aleppo are waiting for the road to northeastern Syria to open, but so far evacuation is impossible.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The SDF reported 15,000 Shahba residents prevented from leaving the city by mercenaries. In 2018, people who lived in Afrin, a town in northern Syria previously controlled by Rojava, were forced to leave for Shahba. Since 2018, it has been occupied by Turkey and its proxies. So there were many Kurds left in Shahba who actively resisted the Turkish invaders all these years. Now they are under occupation and it is unknown what will happen to them.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Many people stayed in the newly captured territories because they did not have time to gather quickly. There have been cases of people dying on the way from injuries or cold, including civilians, some of whom were children. As recently as 5 days ago, there was talk of more than 100,000 people entering northeastern Syria from Shahba and Tell Rifaat. Now that number is definitely higher.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":13718,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Delil SOULEIMAN / AFP","caption":"Refugees from Aleppo arriving in Tabqa","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/535654e0acc84118bc8db622bb5b0606-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/535654e0acc84118bc8db622bb5b0606-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/535654e0acc84118bc8db622bb5b0606-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/535654e0acc84118bc8db622bb5b0606-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/535654e0acc84118bc8db622bb5b0606-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/535654e0acc84118bc8db622bb5b0606-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/535654e0acc84118bc8db622bb5b0606-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/535654e0acc84118bc8db622bb5b0606-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"<strong>— What can the international community do to support Rojava?</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— The region of northeastern Syria must be given official autonomous status. No one is now talking about creating a Kurdistan state, but the Kurds and other peoples of the region should have the right to choose their destiny within Syria. It is already a de facto autonomous region, and it should receive the appropriate status. The Autonomous Administration has all the resources and capabilities to govern.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":13711,"data":{"text":"Help us continue to tell important stories.","title":"Thank you for reading","buttonText":"Here’s how to do it"},"category":"donate-embed"},"type":"donate-embed"},{"data":"<strong>— Western media often cover what is happening through the prism of “the rebels defeated the dictator.” Does this affect international support for the Kurds?</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— It affects the situation in Syria as a whole because it whitewashes and legitimizes the HTS group, which is the former Al-Nusra Front, the Al-Qaeda branch in Syria. ISIS, for example, also wanted to overthrow the regime — they were quite good at it, by the way. When people call the HTS “rebels” and “opposition,” they should understand that they are talking about an organization <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/rbcfreenews/5eda47c59a794738ad52e57d\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">recognized</a> as a terrorist organization worldwide. The HTS is not expressing the will of all Syrians, but only the representatives of radical Sunni Islam.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":6529,"header":"Mad Russia is a Long Time Coming","_path":"/en/opinions/2024/11/13/mad-russia-is-a-long-time-coming/","lead":"This is the opinion of Sergey Aleksashenko, Vladislav Inozemtsev and Dmitry Nekrasov, authors of the report “Dictator’s Reliable Rear: Russian Economy at the Time of War”","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d74d3d945da4a3ea53f3406474895fd-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Photo: Yuri Kochetkov / EPA / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2024-11-13","created_at_date_time":"2024-11-13T11:24:01.171Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":2517,"last_name":"","first_name":"Редакция","last_name_en":"","first_name_en":"Editors","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"Hopes that war and sanctions would undermine the Russian economy and that this would make Putin stop have long since dissipated. The price of economic sustainability is a refusal to develop, primarily technologically. But this will have an impact later, and for now, such a structure is capable of satisfying the Kremlin’s military needs for years. Worse, the economy has managed to switch to a military model, and even the cessation of war will only strengthen Russian militarism, so the world should prepare for a long confrontation with Putin’s aggressive Russia — this is the conclusion made by Sergey Aleksashenko, Vladislav Inozemtsev and Dmitry Nekrasov, co-founders of the CASE think tank, in their report Dictator's Reliable Rear.\n\nThis article is a retelling of the report.\n\nSafety margin\nThe Russian economy was able to withstand the onslaught of sanctions thanks to the fact that it remained market-oriented, the world could not refuse Russian oil, and the West could not isolate Russia on the world stage, plus the professionalism of technocrats. Several misconceptions were dispelled at once, here are some of them.\n\nThe economy is state-owned and therefore inefficient. This thesis gained popularity as Putin gained control of the largest companies. It seemed that the stability of the Russian economy was like that of the Soviet economy. The notion of “efficient managers” was synonymous with corruption and incompetence. But private business provides almost half of employment (48%), and many state-controlled giants, such as banks, operate in a competitive field. Inozemtsev previously explained why Russia's economy is not like the Soviet economy.\n\n\nThe desire to adapt for the sake of survival was evident even after the 2014–2015 sanctions, and it was the main reason for its current resilience. And property, which many liberals saw as the basis for ensuring and expanding political liberties, has become the main reason for non-resistance to the authorities, since fears of losing it perfectly disciplined the Russian entrepreneurs (IStories reported about how business accepted the war).\n\nA gas station masquerading as a country. Many saw the raw material specialization of the Russian economy as a weakness, but it ignored that despite the unpretentiousness of gas station business, everyone has to visit the place a couple of times a week.\n\nAfter the outbreak of war, it turned out that Russia could not be excluded from the global commodities trade — otherwise prices for oil, gas, metals and more would skyrocket. U.S. President Joe Biden spoke of “Putin’s inflation” not without reason.\n\nThat is why Russian raw materials, despite all the sanctions, have easily found their way to the world market if offered at a discount price. Russian exports decreased from $491.6 billion in 202139 to $425.1 billion in 202340, or by a mere 13.5% (comparisons with a very special 2022 should be avoided), and will probably remain close to that level in 2024-2025, providing the opportunity both to cover all necessary imports and to balance the federal budget.\n\nThe West decides everything. The degree of openness of the world economy was also underestimated. It turned out soon that Western countries’ role is not decisive in Russia’s foreign trade and in its financial transactions. Despite the energy embargo introduced by the West, and the sanctions imposed on all the basic sectors of the Russian economy, Russian business appeared able to redirect commodity flows to new markets and find new suppliers of many of the products it needed. In addition, officials and businessmen cooperated in inventing smart schemes for circumventing sanctions (like the famous “shadow fleet”) as well as in managing trade settlements in “non-traditional” currencies and barter deals.\n\nNot enough money. Russia’s domestic capacity to stimulate demand was clearly underestimated. The authorities ensured a multiple increase in expenditures for the purchase of products from the military-industrial complex. For the first time since the end of the 17th century, a mercenary army has been created in Russia, with wages paid to the soldiers that are several times higher than the national average. The subsidized mortgage scheme launched during the COVID-19 pandemic that was supposed to end in 2021, was extended until mid-2024, raising up to 6 trillion rubles in the construction sector. Mobilization and emigration created a deficit in the labor market, leading to a serious increase in wages and the purchasing power of millions of families.\n\nThe boom in household incomes — which will grow by 17.5% in real terms between 2022 and 2024 after seven years of decline — was the most unexpected phenomenon of the first war years: traditionally, in Russia, wars had led to a decline in living standards.\n\nA delayed blow\nAlthough the economy is resilient, it would be untrue to say that the sanctions have not caused any crisis in it.\n\nInflation. This is the new normal for the Russian economy that keeps it in a state of equilibrium. The Central Bank fights it by raising the interest rate, but this policy is ineffective, since the causes of accelerated price growth are beyond its control (IStories told about it). Besides, the high rate restrains economic growth.\n\nSo far the Central Bank manages to keep inflation in check, but the experience of many countries shows that inflation accumulates its potential for a long time and at some point it is rapidly realized.\n\n\nDegradation. Expected GDP growth of around 4% this year will cause euphoria in the Kremlin and surprise in the West. The expected slowdown (to 2.6% in 2025, according to the Ministry of Economic Development’s forecast) is unlikely to upset Putin much, since he will be able to argue that this is still better than in “unfriendly” Europe. \n\nThe expected GDP growth of 3.8-4% in 2024 will likely trigger euphoria in the Kremlin and surprise in the West. The anticipated slowdown to 3% in 2025 and 2.5% in 2026 is unlikely to disappoint Putin,as he can still claim it is better than the performance of “unfriendly” Europe. However, a quantitative increase in the production of long-established products through more intensive use of existing equipment, expansion of services and limited modernization of infrastructure, which are not accompanied by technological progress. It is crucial to recognize that, in qualitative terms, the Russian economy is slowly degrading and falling behind in technological development relative to “unfriendly” countries and “friendly” China. Traditionally, new technologies and innovations came to Russia with Western investors, which can now be forgotten.\n\nThe Kremlin’s hopes for “pivoting to the East” are not being realized in any substantial direct investment or modern equipment supplies from China (they are minimal). Even in sectors where Chinese companies could potentially enhance the current technological level of Russian industry, such as mobile communications or electronics, imports from China are barely noticeable, as Chinese companies fear secondary sanctions. This scenario does not necessarily imply a sharp economic slowdown, but in the long term it points to Russia falling out of the mainstream technological trends, which will be the main economic cost of the current war.\n\nEveryone is happy\nAll of this will have an impact sometime later, but for now it poses no threat. In warring countries — especially in those whose territory is almost untouched by the fight — militarization may not provoke serious problems for quite a long time. Russia learned to live with sanctions, military spending became a serious support, and in 2023–2024 war began to be perceived as a background process not only in the public consciousness, but also in economic life. The new model turned out to be not just sustainable, but also favorable for the majority.\n\nA significant part of both individuals and businesses does not experience profound economic discomfort either from Putin’s aggression against Ukraine or from the Western nations’ reaction to it — the main effect of sanctions has so far been felt by the upper middle class, which has historically taken the most critical stance against Putin. At the same time, military payments have increased incomes in depressed regions.\n\nAnd this is after a long period of stagnation, when real incomes were slowly declining (IStories reported about the decade lost to the economy), and a significant part of society had virtually lost hope for growth in prosperity. The main desire was to maintain the notorious stability (according to the wish “it couldn’t get any worse”). This contrast and banal economic considerations, no less than Putin's propaganda, have determined the attitude of Russians to what is happening. The visible improvement in the economic situation felt by a large part of the population (without it getting worse for a significant number of Russian families) against the background of the aggravated “geopolitical tensions” looks like a miracle.\n\n\nA significant reduction in imports originating from Europe stimulated the development of businesses focused on domestic demand. Although it can hardly be called “import substitution” in the sense that Russia began to produce analogues of previously imported products (when they appear, then of much lower quality and at prices several times higher than the cost of the originals), this is of no importance for assessing economic dynamics.\n\nMany people benefited from the change in the structure of budget expenditures in favor of purchases of domestic goods and services (weapons, ammunition, military uniforms, and transportation services) — the so-called fiscal multiplier (a ruble spent stimulates many others to spend as well) increased noticeably. The same was the effect of payments to mobilized and contract workers, the vast majority of whom are residents of depressed regions. Their families, having received additional income, were primarily concerned with improving the quality of their diet and purchasing essential goods, most of which were produced domestically. Such budget expenditures not only stimulated domestic demand, but also brought additional tax revenues to the budget a few months later.\n\nThe population perceives inflation “with understanding,” and it helps the authorities to fill the budget.\n\nWhy it lasts\nDuring 2023, a set of mechanisms emerged that allowed the “war economy” to deliver impressive results, and in 2024 it showed itself even better. And even if the war stops, this mechanism cannot be reversed.\n\nThe planned increase in military spending in the 2025–2027 budget does not necessarily indicate that Putin intends to continue the war for the next three years — no one knows that, not even he himself. But if the war ends, we should not expect a drastic reduction in military spending. The Ministry of Defense will need to replenish its stock of military equipment, weapons, and ammunition — Putin has warned that the defense industry will remain overloaded with orders for many years to come.\n\nBy the end of 2024, the Russian authorities had lost any fear of negative economic trends that could develop in connection with the war. The government determined both the sources of economic growth and budget revenues, as well as possible options for saving resources that do not undermine either political or social stability. The budget for 2025 and for the next few years provides a clear signal that the Kremlin is ready for a prolonged confrontation with the West while maintaining the current level of military spending — and, most likely, is rationally assessing its capabilities.\n\n\nEven if the Russian authorities do not consider the current situation optimal, they have no doubts about their victory. This is precisely why they put forward such preconditions for the start of peace talks that are unacceptable for the Ukrainian side, why they deliver militaristic economic priorities for 2025–2027, and why a new increase in the number of servicemen in the Russian army was recently announced. Thus, Vladimir Putin demonstrates that from his point of view, military burden on the Russian economy looks moderate, and economic factors are not too significant for making political decisions. Putin demonstrates that economic factors are not important in political decision-making. The economy allows the Kremlin to continue the fight.\n\nThe scale and nature of the changes that have occurred in the Russian economy make one believe that the end of full-scale hostilities will not restore a pre-war “normality”. More than 10 years ago, when Vladimir Putin finally abandoned attempts to integrate his country into the global “golden billion” and turned toward military resolutions of geopolitical problems, the Russian economy has changed radically. \n\nToday, it has become accustomed to rely heavily on domestic resources and cut ties with the most developed part of the global economy; it is dependent on military spending, which has more than doubled as a share of GDP; almost all the most “globalized” representatives of the entrepreneurial class are effectively “put under house arrest” in Russia; property rights have largely been nullified and are determined exclusively by Putin’s decisions; the purchase and sale of human life for “disposal” has become a normal phenomenon that does not contradict the new public morality. Aspects of society’s life related to education and the formation of value systems have changed significantly.\n\nEven if the war stops, the new Russian militarism will not disappear — and moreover, it will likely even strengthen under the influence of propaganda triumphantly describing Russia’s “great military victory”. Some reduction in military spending after the end of hostilities, that might include a sharp decrease in death gratuities and injury compensations, could bring the overall military allocations down from 6.5 to 5-5.5% of GDP, but this will make the budget more robust and provide the Kremlin with additional opportunities. \n\nAfter some intermission, military spending may grow again — the economy looks ready to support the existing system and there is no reason to believe that Russia will collapse from its militarism. Without a regime change, Russia will not turn back into “a normal country.”\n\nA game without rules\nSo the world must be prepared if not for a new Cold War, then for a long confrontation with one of its largest economies, which has actually openly declared that it does not want to respect the basic principles of international law and at the same time cannot be effectively stopped by military or economic measures.\n\nRussia today has a multi-year “safety margin” allowing its elites to pursue a policy of, if not permanent war, then at least aggravating militarization, threatening the world with military and hybrid conflicts.\n\nFor the international community, the most dangerous effect of current trends may be the rise of a Russia-centered group of economies championing massive violation of intellectual property rights, illicit foreign trades and the use of non-traditional forms of international settlements. The Kremlin sees opportunities for institutionalizing this model and is laying it down as the basis for its geopolitical claims, trying to establish itself as a leader of a “non-Western” community of nations.\n\n“Parallel imports” have allowed Russian firms to bring thousands of non-certified products into the country without the manufacturer’s consent. However, dealings with Russia had proven so profitable for Western companies that, on the one hand, few of them have left the Russian market for good, and, on the other hand, most of those that have formally left it have not offered ways and means to prevent Russian consumers from using their products (and sometimes even stimulate their presence on the market).\n\nWithin Russia, intellectual property rights are largely disregarded — from the “suspension” of patents and franchises to the unauthorized reproduction of audio and video content, as well as pirated use of software, including its export abroad. This creates a trend that is alarming for the West and highly significant for Russia: Russia is not simply “falling into China’s embrace” — it is is transforming into a center of an “alternative model of globalization,” operating outside the frameworks of Western-controlled institutions and established rules.\n\n\nIt is quite possible that in the near future the Russian business, with the support of the Kremlin, will try to launch original settlement systems based on the use of cryptocurrencies or other instruments that will no longer be vulnerable to “traditional” banking sanctions.\n\nThis trend could prove far more dangerous than the much-discussed “export of corruption” (to work in a corrupt country, you have to play by its rules): it is explicitly aimed at undermining the Western-led world order rather than integrating into it. As recent years have shown, the use of unconventional payment systems, the export of pirated products, and the smuggling of goods from Western companies — all of these practices are much easier to implement than previously assumed. \n\nThis “rule-free trade” is still burdened by significant transaction costs (such as processing banking payments under the sanctions regime). Still, these costs are likely to decrease as alternative payment systems are developed. Even intense pressure from the United States has not led to a collapse in Russia’s trade with China, although it has made it more difficult.\n\nViewing all of this as merely a way to circumvent sanctions is extremely shortsighted, as the Kremlin has set its sights on fundamentally undermining the existing system and has reasonable grounds for hoping to succeed. This makes it possible to attract a number of countries and political leaders who are unhappy with Western dominance over global rules and institutions and who believe that rejecting them could yield positive outcomes. And this is another important basis for Russia’s economic resilience.\n\nOver the past century, Western democracies have faced dictatorships twice — once the Fascist regimes, another time the Communist ones. In the first case, the confrontation spiraled into a global military conflict, while in the second case it was avoided by winning the economic competition. The West should not count on a repeat of the second scenario. Russia is still too far from the level of military spending reached by the Soviet Union during the Cold War and has a market economy.\n\nIt is futile to ramp up sanctions. Russia’s economy has adapted to them, there is practically nowhere to strengthen them, and it is fraught with undesirable consequences for the West itself as it provokes the buildup of political alliances in other parts of the world that advocate a revision of the “rules of the game” that were adopted after the collapse of the Soviet Union. Yes, restrictions on the use of modern technology and intellectual capital developed by Western nations are firmly holding back Russia’s modernization, but we should not expect this to cause serious damage to its economy in the next two or three years. Most likely, the main effects will become apparent over a much longer term and will challenge not Putin’s Russia, but the country that will struggle to return to normalcy after he is gone.","blocks":[{"data":"Hopes that war and sanctions would undermine the Russian economy and that this would make Putin stop have long since dissipated. The price of economic sustainability is a refusal to develop, primarily technologically. But this will have an impact later, and for now, such a structure is capable of satisfying the Kremlin’s military needs for years. Worse, the economy has managed to switch to a military model, and even the cessation of war will only strengthen Russian militarism, so the world should prepare for a long confrontation with Putin’s aggressive Russia — this is the conclusion made by Sergey Aleksashenko, Vladislav Inozemtsev and Dmitry Nekrasov, co-founders of the CASE think tank, in their <a href=\"https://case-center.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/case-241112-en_fin2_compressed.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">report</a> <em>Dictator's Reliable Rear</em>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This article is a retelling of the report.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Safety margin","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The Russian economy was able to withstand the onslaught of sanctions thanks to the fact that it remained market-oriented, the world could not refuse Russian oil, and the West could not isolate Russia on the world stage, plus the professionalism of <a href=\"https://www.tandfonline.com/eprint/ZBTEZEJJHN9BNWDIRFUW/full?target=10.1080%2F10758216.2023.2291359&amp;fbclid=IwAR1_v2cMebRRAbWMqsb_EBuS10WGfazPFy7ZnXAPV_155L0KOSkMxRzpvDk\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">technocrats</a>. Several misconceptions were dispelled at once, here are some of them.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>The economy is state-owned and therefore inefficient</strong>. This thesis gained popularity as Putin gained control of the largest companies. It seemed that the stability of the Russian economy was like that of the Soviet economy. The notion of “efficient managers” was synonymous with corruption and incompetence. But private business provides almost half of employment (48%), and many state-controlled giants, such as banks, operate in a competitive field. Inozemtsev previously <a href=\"https://istories.media/opinions/2024/09/18/pochemu-ekonomika-rossii-ne-pokhozha-na-sovetskuyu/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">explained</a> why Russia's economy is not like the Soviet economy.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":13403,"data":{"header":"Russia could not be excluded from the global commodities trade — otherwise prices for oil, gas, metals and more would skyrocket"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"The desire to adapt for the sake of survival was evident even after the 2014–2015 sanctions, and it was the main reason for its current resilience. And property, which many liberals saw as the basis for ensuring and expanding political liberties, has become the main reason for non-resistance to the authorities, since fears of losing it perfectly disciplined the Russian entrepreneurs (IStories <a href=\"https://istories.media/opinions/2024/04/22/nado-vklyuchat-rezhim-prorvemsya-kak-biznes-prinyal-voinu/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reported</a> about how business accepted the war).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>A gas station masquerading as a country</strong>. Many saw the raw material specialization of the Russian economy as a weakness, but it ignored that despite the unpretentiousness of gas station business, everyone has to visit the place a couple of times a week.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After the outbreak of war, it turned out that Russia could not be excluded from the global commodities trade — otherwise prices for oil, gas, metals and more would skyrocket. U.S. President Joe Biden <a href=\"https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/04/15/bidens-claim-70-inflation-jump-was-due-putins-price-hike/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">spoke</a> of “Putin’s inflation” not without reason.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"That is why Russian raw materials, despite all the sanctions, have easily found their way to the world market if offered at a discount price. Russian exports decreased from $491.6 billion in 202139 to $425.1 billion in 202340, or by a mere 13.5% (comparisons with a very special 2022 should be avoided), and will probably remain close to that level in 2024-2025, providing the opportunity both to cover all necessary imports and to balance the federal budget.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>The West decides everything</strong>. The degree of openness of the world economy was also underestimated. It turned out soon that Western countries’ role is not decisive in Russia’s foreign trade and in its financial transactions. Despite the energy embargo introduced by the West, and the sanctions imposed on all the basic sectors of the Russian economy, Russian business appeared able to redirect commodity flows to new markets and find new suppliers of many of the products it needed. In addition, officials and businessmen cooperated in inventing smart schemes for circumventing sanctions (like the famous “shadow fleet”) as well as in managing trade settlements in “non-traditional” currencies and barter deals.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Not enough money</strong>. Russia’s domestic capacity to stimulate demand was clearly underestimated. The authorities ensured a multiple increase in expenditures for the purchase of products from the military-industrial complex. For the first time since the end of the 17th century, a mercenary army has been created in Russia, with wages paid to the soldiers that are several times higher than the national average. The subsidized mortgage scheme launched during the COVID-19 pandemic that was supposed to end in 2021, was extended until mid-2024, raising up to 6 trillion rubles in the construction sector. Mobilization and emigration created a deficit in the labor market, leading to a serious increase in wages and the purchasing power of millions of families.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The boom in household incomes — which will grow by 17.5% in real terms between 2022 and 2024 after seven years of decline — was the most unexpected phenomenon of the first war years: traditionally, in Russia, wars had led to a decline in living standards.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A delayed blow","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Although the economy is resilient, it would be untrue to say that the sanctions have not caused any crisis in it.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Inflation</strong>. This is the new normal for the Russian economy that keeps it in a state of equilibrium. The Central Bank fights it by raising the interest rate, but this policy is ineffective, since the causes of accelerated price growth are beyond its control (IStories <a href=\"https://istories.media/opinions/2024/10/21/rosli-rastut-i-budut-rasti/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">told</a> about it). Besides, the high rate restrains economic growth.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"So far the Central Bank manages to keep inflation in check, but the experience of many countries shows that inflation accumulates its potential for a long time and at some point it is rapidly realized.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":13404,"data":{"header":"In the long term Russia will fall out of the mainstream technological trends, which will be the main economic cost of the current war"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Degradation</strong>. Expected GDP growth of around 4% this year will cause euphoria in the Kremlin and surprise in the West. The expected slowdown (to 2.6% in 2025, according to the Ministry of Economic Development’s forecast) is unlikely to upset Putin much, since he will be able to argue that this is still better than in “unfriendly” Europe.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The expected GDP growth of 3.8-4% in 2024 will likely trigger euphoria in the Kremlin and surprise in the West. The anticipated slowdown to 3% in 2025 and 2.5% in 2026 is unlikely to disappoint Putin,as he can still claim it is better than the performance of “unfriendly” Europe. However, a quantitative increase in the production of long-established products through more intensive use of existing equipment, expansion of services and limited modernization of infrastructure, which are not accompanied by technological progress. It is crucial to recognize that, in qualitative terms, the Russian economy is slowly degrading and falling behind in technological development relative to “unfriendly” countries and “friendly” China. Traditionally, new technologies and innovations came to Russia with Western investors, which can now be forgotten.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Kremlin’s hopes for “pivoting to the East” are not being realized in any substantial direct investment or modern equipment supplies from China (they are minimal). Even in sectors where Chinese companies could potentially enhance the current technological level of Russian industry, such as mobile communications or electronics, imports from China are barely noticeable, as Chinese companies fear secondary sanctions. This scenario does not necessarily imply a sharp economic slowdown, but in the long term it points to Russia falling out of the mainstream technological trends, which will be the main economic cost of the current war.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Everyone is happy","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"All of this will have an impact sometime later, but for now it poses no threat. In warring countries — especially in those whose territory is almost untouched by the fight — militarization may not provoke serious problems for quite a long time. Russia learned to live with sanctions, military spending became a serious support, and in 2023–2024 war began to be perceived as a background process not only in the public consciousness, but also in economic life. The new model turned out to be not just sustainable, but also favorable for the majority.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A significant part of both individuals and businesses does not experience profound economic discomfort either from Putin’s aggression against Ukraine or from the Western nations’ reaction to it — the main effect of sanctions has so far been felt by the upper middle class, which has historically taken the most critical stance against Putin. At the same time, military payments have increased incomes in depressed regions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"And this is after a long period of stagnation, when real incomes were slowly declining (IStories <a href=\"https://istories.media/opinions/2024/04/10/novii-zastoi-kak-rossiya-prospala-desyat-let/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reported</a> about the decade lost to the economy), and a significant part of society had virtually lost hope for growth in prosperity. The main desire was to maintain the notorious stability (according to the wish “it couldn’t get any worse”). This contrast and banal economic considerations, no less than Putin's propaganda, have determined the attitude of Russians to what is happening. The visible improvement in the economic situation felt by a large part of the population (without it getting worse for a significant number of Russian families) against the background of the aggravated “geopolitical tensions” looks like a miracle.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":13405,"data":{"header":"The population perceives inflation “with understanding,” and it helps the authorities to fill the budget"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"A significant reduction in imports originating from Europe stimulated the development of businesses focused on domestic demand. Although it can hardly be called “import substitution” in the sense that Russia began to produce analogues of previously imported products (when they appear, then of much lower quality and at prices several times higher than the cost of the originals), this is of no importance for assessing economic dynamics.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Many people benefited from the change in the structure of budget expenditures in favor of purchases of domestic goods and services (weapons, ammunition, military uniforms, and transportation services) — the so-called fiscal multiplier (a ruble spent stimulates many others to spend as well) increased noticeably. The same was the effect of payments to mobilized and contract workers, the vast majority of whom are residents of depressed regions. Their families, having received additional income, were primarily concerned with improving the quality of their diet and purchasing essential goods, most of which were produced domestically. Such budget expenditures not only stimulated domestic demand, but also brought additional tax revenues to the budget a few months later.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The population perceives inflation “with understanding,” and it helps the authorities to fill the budget.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Why it lasts","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"During 2023, a set of mechanisms emerged that allowed the “war economy” to deliver impressive results, and in 2024 it showed itself even better. And even if the war stops, this mechanism cannot be reversed.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The planned increase in military spending in the 2025–2027 budget does not necessarily indicate that Putin intends to continue the war for the next three years — no one knows that, not even he himself. But if the war ends, we should not expect a drastic reduction in military spending. The Ministry of Defense will need to replenish its stock of military equipment, weapons, and ammunition — Putin has <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/6510907\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">warned</a> that the defense industry will remain overloaded with orders for many years to come.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"By the end of 2024, the Russian authorities had lost any fear of negative economic trends that could develop in connection with the war. The government&nbsp;determined both the sources of economic growth and budget revenues, as well as possible options for saving resources that do not undermine either political or social stability. The budget for 2025 and for the next few years provides a clear signal that the Kremlin is ready for a prolonged confrontation with the West while maintaining the current level of military spending — and, most likely, is rationally assessing its capabilities.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":13406,"data":{"header":"Even if the war stops, the new Russian militarism will not disappear"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"Even if the Russian authorities do not consider the current situation optimal, they have no doubts about their victory. This is precisely why they put forward such preconditions for the start of peace talks that are unacceptable for the Ukrainian side, why they deliver militaristic economic priorities for 2025–2027, and why a new increase in the number of servicemen in the Russian army was recently announced. Thus, Vladimir Putin demonstrates that from his point of view, military burden on the Russian economy looks moderate, and economic factors are not too significant for making political decisions. Putin demonstrates that economic factors are not important in political decision-making. The economy allows the Kremlin to continue the fight.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The scale and nature of the changes that have occurred in the Russian economy make one believe that the end of full-scale hostilities will not restore a pre-war “normality”. More than 10 years ago, when Vladimir Putin finally abandoned attempts to integrate his country into the global “golden billion” and turned toward military resolutions of geopolitical problems, the Russian economy has changed radically.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Today, it has become accustomed to rely heavily on domestic resources and cut ties with the most developed part of the global economy; it is dependent on military spending, which has more than doubled as a share of GDP; almost all the most “globalized” representatives of the entrepreneurial class are effectively “put under house arrest” in Russia; property rights have largely been nullified and are determined exclusively by Putin’s decisions; the purchase and sale of human life for “disposal” has become a normal phenomenon that does not contradict the new public morality. Aspects of society’s life related to education and the formation of value systems have changed significantly.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Even if the war stops, the new Russian militarism will not disappear — and moreover, it will likely even strengthen under the influence of propaganda triumphantly describing Russia’s “great military victory”. Some reduction in military spending after the end of hostilities, that might include a sharp decrease in death gratuities and injury compensations, could bring the overall military allocations down from 6.5 to 5-5.5% of GDP, but this will make the budget more robust and provide the Kremlin with additional opportunities.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After some intermission, military spending may grow again — the economy looks ready to support the existing system and there is no reason to believe that Russia will collapse from its militarism. Without a regime change, Russia will not turn back into “a normal country.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A game without rules","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"So the world must be prepared if not for a new Cold War, then for a long confrontation with one of its largest economies, which has actually openly declared that it does not want to respect the basic principles of international law and at the same time cannot be effectively stopped by military or economic measures.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russia today has a multi-year “safety margin” allowing its elites to pursue a policy of, if not permanent war, then at least aggravating militarization, threatening the world with military and hybrid conflicts.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For the international community, the most dangerous effect of current trends may be the rise of a Russia-centered group of economies championing massive violation of intellectual property rights, illicit foreign trades and the use of non-traditional forms of international settlements. The Kremlin sees opportunities for institutionalizing this model and is laying it down as the basis for its geopolitical claims, trying to establish itself as a leader of a “non-Western” community of nations.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Parallel imports” have allowed Russian firms to bring thousands of non-certified products into the country without the manufacturer’s consent. However, dealings with Russia had proven so profitable for Western companies that, on the one hand, few of them have left the Russian market for good, and, on the other hand, most of those that have formally left it have not offered ways and means to prevent Russian consumers from using their products (and sometimes even stimulate their presence on the market).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Within Russia, intellectual property rights are largely disregarded — from the “suspension” of patents and franchises to the unauthorized reproduction of audio and video content, as well as pirated use of software, including its export abroad. This creates a trend that is alarming for the West and highly significant for Russia: Russia is not simply “falling into China’s embrace” — it is is transforming into a center of an “alternative model of globalization,” operating outside the frameworks of Western-controlled institutions and established rules.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":13407,"data":{"header":"The Kremlin has set its sights on undermining the existing system and has reasonable grounds for hoping to succeed"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"It is quite possible that in the near future the Russian business, with the support of the Kremlin, will try to launch original settlement systems based on the use of cryptocurrencies or other instruments that will no longer be vulnerable to “traditional” banking sanctions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This trend could prove far more dangerous than the much-discussed “export of corruption” (to work in a corrupt country, you have to play by its rules): it is explicitly aimed at undermining the Western-led world order rather than integrating into it. As recent years have shown, the use of unconventional payment systems, the export of pirated products, and the smuggling of goods from Western companies — all of these practices are much easier to implement than previously assumed.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This “rule-free trade” is still burdened by significant transaction costs (such as processing banking payments under the sanctions regime). Still, these costs are likely to decrease as alternative payment systems are developed. Even intense pressure from the United States has not led to a collapse in Russia’s trade with China, although it has made it more difficult.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Viewing all of this as merely a way to circumvent sanctions is extremely shortsighted, as the Kremlin has set its sights on fundamentally undermining the existing system and has reasonable grounds for hoping to succeed. This makes it possible to attract a number of countries and political leaders who are unhappy with Western dominance over global rules and institutions and who believe that rejecting them could yield positive outcomes. And this is another important basis for Russia’s economic resilience.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Over the past century, Western democracies have faced dictatorships twice — once the Fascist regimes, another time the Communist ones. In the first case, the confrontation spiraled into a global military conflict, while in the second case it was avoided by winning the economic competition. The West should not count on a repeat of the second scenario. Russia is still too far from the level of military spending reached by the Soviet Union during the Cold War and has a market economy.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It is futile to ramp up sanctions. Russia’s economy has adapted to them, there is practically nowhere to strengthen them, and it is fraught with undesirable consequences for the West itself as it provokes the buildup of political alliances in other parts of the world that advocate a revision of the “rules of the game” that were adopted after the collapse of the Soviet Union. Yes, restrictions on the use of modern technology and intellectual capital developed by Western nations are firmly holding back Russia’s modernization, but we should not expect this to cause serious damage to its economy in the next two or three years. Most likely, the main effects will become apparent over a much longer term and will challenge not Putin’s Russia, but the country that will struggle to return to normalcy after he is gone.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":5887,"header":"Why the Discussion of Putin’s Support Has Lost Its Meaning","_path":"/en/opinions/2024/08/21/why-the-discussion-of-putins-support-has-lost-its-meaning/","lead":"An extended commentary by Grigory Yudin on a study that concludes that Russians’ actual support for Vladimir Putin is close to what sociological polls show","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54ae7f376e32417f81b25a06aecfb80f-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Photo: Yuri Kochetkov / EPA / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2024-08-21","created_at_date_time":"2024-08-22T13:15:29.169Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[],"external_authors_list":[{"id":267,"first_name":"Grigory","last_name":"Yudin","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":1}],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"This article is an extended commentary by Grigory Yudin on a study that concludes that Russians’ actual support for Vladimir Putin is close to what sociological polls show. IStories previously told about this study, which other sociologists consider correct.\n\n\n\nThe study once again reproduces the thesis that Timothy Fry and his colleagues have been stating for a long time: that mass polls are absolutely correct about Putin’s high support in Russia. In one of the papers, the same team even managed to show that the polls underestimate this support — that is, Russians actually like Putin even more than the Pollsters tell us.\n\nBut even without regard to the numbers, there are several problems here.\n\nWhat is “support”\nThe word is often used (including in Fry’s article) comma-separated with “popularity” and “approval,” as if it were all the same thing, and something quite obvious at that. However, the very assumption that everyone has a built-in sensor for supporting or not supporting Putin is completely at odds with the Russian political reality.\n\nRussia is an extremely depoliticized country, and as soon as the conversation turns to politics, the interlocutor will certainly try to change the subject, feeling uncomfortable; just to avoid spoiling the relationship. Russians in general try to stay away from politics; there is a widespread belief in the country that nothing can be changed anyway, it is better not to have political views, and one should focus on what is at least partly in one’s power (family, career, consumption). When we ask such a respondent whether he “approves” of Putin’s activities, how does he understand this question?\n\nModern Russia is a plebiscite regime, where the question about the emperor is perceived not neutrally, but as a request for acclamation [an expression of approval of his actions]. In the United States, where some of the authors of the article work, the question of whether respondents approve of Donald Trump’s activities suggests that if they do not approve, they may, for example, approve (or disapprove) of Kamala Harris. There is nothing like that in Russia, and respondents are aware of it. That is, the question “Do you approve of the emperor?” is a request for a ritual demonstration of loyalty. This does not mean that the respondent is lying. It's like saying “Christ is risen!\" in response to “Indeed He is risen!” — not because you suddenly realized at that moment, “He’s really dead, and the coffin is empty!”\n\n\nThe meaning of “support” and the like is not obvious in these circumstances. Graham Robertson, for example, shows that this support is more than 80% correlated with what is known in psychology as “justifying the system” — with statements like, “The government is bad, but we don’t deserve any other,” “The government is bad, but any other government will be worse,” or “The government is bad, but the rest of us are no better off.” That is, when people approve, the meaning of their statement is roughly as follows: “I don't like it at all, but I don’t believe it could be otherwise.” Can this be called endorsement? Or popularity? Probably, if you define support as “disgust combined with acceptance in the absence of alternatives.” But why call black white?\n\nInterestingly, the authors of the study under discussion are quite receptive to these considerations and recognize that \"support\" is a very conventional term used simply for convenience. The only trouble is that when these studies are released to the general public, the public is not informed about it, nor will they dig into such methodological subtleties. If it is said that Russians support — it means that they love the tsar!\n\nThis has a similar effect on politicians both in Russia and abroad. Surprisingly, the polls have completely convinced the political class both in Russia and abroad that Russians are in favor of Putin and love him. That is why every time the standard Russian reaction to political events - “\tit’s none of my business” — comes as a surprise. Now it happened after the events in the Kursk region. “Why didn’t Russians stand up as one in defense of Putin? After all, we know from reliable research that they adore him, don’t we?” This leads to a radically wrong assessment of the situation and corresponding decisions.\n\n\n\nLooking for something that is not there\nAll work with list experiments is based on the theory of “falsified preferences,” which was proposed by Timur Kuran. This theory proceeds from absolutely ridiculous assumptions about human political behavior. According to this theory, anyone has preferences on political issues, and can either state them honestly or lie in response to a question. Accordingly, list experiments attempt to calculate the proportion of those who have lied because they fear reprisals.\n\nThis picture of the world has nothing to do with the reality of the authoritarian countries for which it was invented. As discussed above, the default situation in authoritarian settings is not to lie, but to depoliticize. Why withhold one’s political views when it is easier not to have them?\n\nOf course, direct lying by respondents out of fear also happens in Russian surveys. Experienced interviewers often assume that respondents are afraid, and it is doubtful that the interviewers are entirely wrong. Surely the situation must have deteriorated further since the war began.\n\nHowever, fear is not at all the main problem in measuring support in Russia. People often have no preferences even on the most basic issues. Moreover, under authoritarian conditions, it is explicitly prescribed not to have any preferences - it is safe, does not make you a social outcast, and raises your self-esteem (“I am a serious person, I am not interested in politics”). Since the Russian regime is effective (and it is), a significant part of respondents have no preferences and formulate them right on the fly, oriented towards understanding what is expected of them. Since the poll is usually perceived as a situation of communication with generalized “power,” the question about Putin’s approval is read as a test of loyalty.\n\nObservers are sometimes absolutely certain that all Russians must have an opinion on such key issues as “Putin's popularity” or “support for the ‘special military operation.’” But why do we need this opinion? How will disapproval or denial of support affect events? Will it make Putin cease to be emperor? Or will the war stop? No one believes in this, and rightly so, and therefore people prefer to believe that “everything is not so unambiguous.”\n\nThis is why all studies with list experiments are highly questionable — and not at all for the methodological reasons given in the article. All this literature has fictionalized rational and convinced voters who are deterred from expressing these beliefs only by fear. Of course, such people exist too — as these studies show, they are typically 5–10%. But people usually react to tyranny in a very different way.\n\nAn impossible task\nIn a depoliticized context, people prefer not only not to have opinions or express them, but also to shy away from interactions that are not directly relevant to their lives.\n\nThe Levada Center, which did the fieldwork for this article, used the personal interview method. This means that an interviewer comes to your home to ask you all these questions and conduct a list experiment with you. Imagine — some person is trying to get something out of you about politics and asking cognitively quite difficult questions (“I’m going to give you four judgments; tell me how many of them you agree with” is a very difficult question to understand). You may have been running somewhere between the bathroom and the kitchen, and now you have to count the number of statements you agree with.\n\nThe personal interview method is the riskiest because it leads to the most serious sampling bias. People who can be interviewed at home are very different from those who are not at home, who are shut out by a fence and a security guard, who do not open the door, who refuse to talk to the interviewer on the landing, or who refuse to let him or her into the apartment.\n\nThe validity of such an experimental design is rightly put into great doubt. In any case, convincing cognitive testing is required to show that it is at all solvable for the respondents.\n\n\n***\n\nPolls should not be used as plebiscites — the question “How many actually support the czar?” is meaningless. Polls, like any cognitive tool, can provide interesting and useful information. However, they exist in the political field, and it is naive to think that since they are conducted by scientists, they are the ones who report the whole truth, you just have to find the right figure and make sure that it is really it. That is why articles with headlines like “How many actually support Putin” will continue to appear. They do not help us understand what is going on in Russia. But they work perfectly well for those who have turned Russia into a continuous plebiscite.","blocks":[{"data":"<em>This article is an extended commentary by Grigory Yudin on a </em><a href=\"https://spaces-cdn.owlstown.com/blobs/0svb0fb2kofpgpro7fl9m1wujhmy\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>study</em></a><em> that concludes that Russians’ actual support for Vladimir Putin is close to what sociological polls show. IStories previously </em><a href=\"https://istories.media/en/opinions/2024/08/21/is-putins-popular-support-real/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>told</em></a><em> about this study, which other sociologists consider correct.</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":12713,"data":{"block":"<p>One of the main complaints about opinion polls on political topics is that dissatisfied people are afraid to answer honestly and refuse to participate in polls, which distorts the results (there may be many other reasons for this). To check this, the authors of the study conducted a “list experiment” — this method is often used to study people&#x27;s reactions to sensitive topics. Respondents are divided into two groups. One group is given a list of three political figures, while the second group is given the same list plus Putin. People in both groups are asked how many politicians they support. Not who exactly, but just a number. Putin&#x27;s support can be assessed by the difference in the responses of the two groups. For example, in January 2015, Putin&#x27;s inclusion in the list added 0.81 (the average of responses in the first group was 1.11 and in the second group was 1.92), allowing us to estimate his level of support at 81%. This is about 5 percentage points less than what the opinion polls gave Putin at the time.</p><p><br/></p><p>This is a strong simplification. There is an interesting effect: adding another figure to the list reduces the result (it is not who is added, but the very fact of lengthening the list). This “deflation” can be assessed by conducting another placebo-like experiment: there is nothing related to Russia. If we adjust the results of the list experiment for this artificial underestimation, we get numbers that are quite close to the polls. The authors of the study conclude from this (shared by many, but by no means all) that respondents do not lie to sociologists that much.</p>","header":"Do people lie to sociologists","content":[{"insert":"One of the main complaints about opinion polls on political topics is that dissatisfied people are afraid to answer honestly and refuse to participate in polls, which distorts the results (there may be many other reasons for this). To check this, the authors of the study conducted a “list experiment” — this method is often used to study people's reactions to sensitive topics. Respondents are divided into two groups. One group is given a list of three political figures, while the second group is given the same list plus Putin. People in both groups are asked how many politicians they support. Not who exactly, but just a number. Putin's support can be assessed by the difference in the responses of the two groups. For example, in January 2015, Putin's inclusion in the list added 0.81 (the average of responses in the first group was 1.11 and in the second group was 1.92), allowing us to estimate his level of support at 81%. This is about 5 percentage points less than what the opinion polls gave Putin at the time.\n\nThis is a strong simplification. There is an interesting effect: adding another figure to the list reduces the result (it is not who is added, but the very fact of lengthening the list). This “deflation” can be assessed by conducting another placebo-like experiment: there is nothing related to Russia. If we adjust the results of the list experiment for this artificial underestimation, we get numbers that are quite close to the polls. The authors of the study conclude from this (shared by many, but by no means all) that respondents do not lie to sociologists that much.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"The study once again reproduces the thesis that Timothy Fry and his colleagues have been stating for a long time: that mass polls are absolutely correct about Putin’s high support in Russia. In one of the papers, the same team even managed to show that the polls underestimate this support — that is, Russians actually like Putin even more than the Pollsters tell us.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But even without regard to the numbers, there are several problems here.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"What is “support”","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The word is often used (including in Fry’s article) comma-separated with “popularity” and “approval,” as if it were all the same thing, and something quite obvious at that. However, the very assumption that everyone has a built-in sensor for supporting or not supporting Putin is completely at odds with the Russian political reality.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russia is an extremely depoliticized country, and as soon as the conversation turns to politics, the interlocutor will certainly try to change the subject, feeling uncomfortable; just to avoid spoiling the relationship. Russians in general try to stay away from politics; there is a widespread belief in the country that nothing can be changed anyway, it is better not to have political views, and one should focus on what is at least partly in one’s power (family, career, consumption). When we ask such a respondent whether he “approves” of Putin’s activities, how does he understand this question?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Modern Russia is a plebiscite regime, where the question about the emperor is perceived not neutrally, but as a request for acclamation [an expression of approval of his actions]. In the United States, where some of the authors of the article work, the question of whether respondents approve of Donald Trump’s activities suggests that if they do not approve, they may, for example, approve (or disapprove) of Kamala Harris. There is nothing like that in Russia, and respondents are aware of it. That is, the question “Do you approve of the emperor?” is a request for a ritual demonstration of loyalty. This does not mean that the respondent is lying. It's like saying “Christ is risen!\" in response to “Indeed He is risen!” — not because you suddenly realized at that moment, “He’s really dead, and the coffin is empty!”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":12714,"data":{"header":"The polls have completely convinced the political class both in Russia and abroad that Russians are in favor of Putin and love him. <...> This leads to a radically wrong assessment of the situation and corresponding decisions."},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"The meaning of “support” and the like is not obvious in these circumstances. Graham Robertson, for example, shows that this support is more than 80% correlated with what is known in psychology as “justifying the system” — with statements like, “The government is bad, but we don’t deserve any other,” “The government is bad, but any other government will be worse,” or “The government is bad, but the rest of us are no better off.” That is, when people approve, the meaning of their statement is roughly as follows: “I don't like it at all, but I don’t believe it could be otherwise.” Can this be called endorsement? Or popularity? Probably, if you define support as “disgust combined with acceptance in the absence of alternatives.” But why call black white?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Interestingly, the authors of the study under discussion are quite receptive to these considerations and recognize that \"support\" is a very conventional term used simply for convenience. The only trouble is that when these studies are released to the general public, the public is not informed about it, nor will they dig into such methodological subtleties. If it is said that Russians support — it means that they love the tsar!","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This has a similar effect on politicians both in Russia and abroad. Surprisingly, the polls have completely convinced the political class both in Russia and abroad that Russians are in favor of Putin and love him. That is why every time the standard Russian reaction to political events - “\tit’s none of my business” — comes as a surprise. Now it happened after the events in the Kursk region. “Why didn’t Russians stand up as one in defense of Putin? After all, we know from reliable research that they adore him, don’t we?” This leads to a radically wrong assessment of the situation and corresponding decisions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":12716,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Alexei Malgavko / Reuters / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"A recipe for survival in an authoritarian state: do not have an opinion and express support for the leader","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/861d5a88cb164d79a42204e16f182caa-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/861d5a88cb164d79a42204e16f182caa-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1599},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/861d5a88cb164d79a42204e16f182caa-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/861d5a88cb164d79a42204e16f182caa-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1599},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/861d5a88cb164d79a42204e16f182caa-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/861d5a88cb164d79a42204e16f182caa-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":552},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/861d5a88cb164d79a42204e16f182caa-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/861d5a88cb164d79a42204e16f182caa-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":552}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Looking for something that is not there","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"All work with list experiments is based on the theory of “falsified preferences,” which was <a href=\"https://www.hup.harvard.edu/books/9780674707580\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">proposed</a> by Timur Kuran. This theory proceeds from absolutely ridiculous assumptions about human political behavior. According to this theory, anyone has preferences on political issues, and can either state them honestly or lie in response to a question. Accordingly, list experiments attempt to calculate the proportion of those who have lied because they fear reprisals.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This picture of the world has nothing to do with the reality of the authoritarian countries for which it was invented. As discussed above, the default situation in authoritarian settings is not to lie, but to depoliticize. Why withhold one’s political views when it is easier not to have them?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Of course, direct lying by respondents out of fear also happens in Russian surveys. Experienced interviewers often assume that respondents are afraid, and it is doubtful that the interviewers are entirely wrong. Surely the situation must have deteriorated further since the war began.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, fear is not at all the main problem in measuring support in Russia. People often have no preferences even on the most basic issues. Moreover, under authoritarian conditions, it is explicitly prescribed not to have any preferences - it is safe, does not make you a social outcast, and raises your self-esteem (“I am a serious person, I am not interested in politics”). Since the Russian regime is effective (and it is), a significant part of respondents have no preferences and formulate them right on the fly, oriented towards understanding what is expected of them. Since the poll is usually perceived as a situation of communication with generalized “power,” the question about Putin’s approval is read as a test of loyalty.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Observers are sometimes absolutely certain that all Russians must have an opinion on such key issues as “Putin's popularity” or “support for the ‘special military operation.’” But why do we need this opinion? How will disapproval or denial of support affect events? Will it make Putin cease to be emperor? Or will the war stop? No one believes in this, and rightly so, and therefore people prefer to believe that “everything is not so unambiguous.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This is why all studies with list experiments are highly questionable — and not at all for the methodological reasons given in the article. All this literature has fictionalized rational and convinced voters who are deterred from expressing these beliefs only by fear. Of course, such people exist too — as these studies show, they are typically 5–10%. But people usually react to tyranny in a very different way.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"An impossible task","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In a depoliticized context, people prefer not only not to have opinions or express them, but also to shy away from interactions that are not directly relevant to their lives.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Levada Center, which did the fieldwork for this article, used the personal interview method. This means that an interviewer comes to your home to ask you all these questions and conduct a list experiment with you. Imagine — some person is trying to get something out of you about politics and asking cognitively quite difficult questions (“I’m going to give you four judgments; tell me how many of them you agree with” is a very difficult question to understand). You may have been running somewhere between the bathroom and the kitchen, and now you have to count the number of statements you agree with.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The personal interview method is the riskiest because it leads to the most serious sampling bias. People who can be interviewed at home are very different from those who are not at home, who are shut out by a fence and a security guard, who do not open the door, who refuse to talk to the interviewer on the landing, or who refuse to let him or her into the apartment.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The validity of such an experimental design is rightly put into great doubt. In any case, convincing cognitive testing is required to show that it is at all solvable for the respondents.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"***","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Polls should not be used as plebiscites — the question “How many actually support the czar?” is meaningless. Polls, like any cognitive tool, can provide interesting and useful information. However, they exist in the political field, and it is naive to think that since they are conducted by scientists, they are the ones who report the whole truth, you just have to find the right figure and make sure that it is really it. That is why articles with headlines like “How many actually support Putin” will continue to appear. They do not help us understand what is going on in Russia. But they work perfectly well for those who have turned Russia into a continuous plebiscite.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":5884,"header":"Is Putin’s Popular Support Real","_path":"/en/opinions/2024/08/21/is-putins-popular-support-real/","lead":"Should we believe the polls that show that more than 80% of Russians support Putin? Maybe people are just afraid to tell the sociologists the truth?","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bd83310e929943eb86e9147f70c87264-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Photo: Maxim Shemetov / Reuters / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2024-08-21","created_at_date_time":"2024-08-22T11:06:28.156Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":2517,"last_name":"","first_name":"Редакция","last_name_en":"","first_name_en":"Editors","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"The debate about Putin’s real popularity has always been going on, but has intensified since the war started. Putin’s rating jumped — did people really support him?\nSociologists conducting polls have to constantly justify themselves. Denis Volkov, director of the Levada Center, listed and then refuted the main arguments of critics as to why Russian polls cannot be trusted: after the war began, people — especially Putin’s opponents — began to refuse to participate in polls and to answer questions about the war much more often, and if they did answer, they usually did not answer what they “really” thought.\nAccording to Volkov, in reality, the “unreachability” of respondents has changed little since the war (in 2022 it was slightly higher than in 2019-2020, but lower than in 2021), and the number of interviews interrupted on questions about Ukraine is quite low (from two to seven), as in polls on other topics, which, with a sample of more than a thousand people, is insignificant. As for the honesty of answers, the increase in support for Putin after the start of the war is combined with changes in answers to other questions — about economic behavior and sentiment, Volkov assures.\nAlexei Levinson, head of the socio-cultural research department at the Levada Center, responded to another reproach — that sociologists simply cannot show results with lower ratings: “As long as the authorities are satisfied with the high ratings they receive honestly, they will tolerate us. When it stops being so, I don’t think we’ll last long.”\nWhile the debate is going on, public opinion polls continue to record that Putin enjoys the broadest support of the population. For example, according to the Levada Center, this year Putin's activities were “generally approved” by 85–87% (the poll is conducted every month).\nScientists have come up with a way, if not to check, then to get closer to answering the question: is it true that the results of social polls are heavily distorted by the fear of giving the “wrong” answer? Their study is called “Putin’s popularity: is it (still) real?”\n\nThe same and Putin\nThey used a method that is often used to study people’s reactions to sensitive topics — the “list experiment.” Respondents, selected according to Russia’s population structure, are randomly divided into two groups. The first, “control” group is given a list of three political figures. The second, the group under study, is given the same list plus Putin. People in each group are asked a question: how many politicians from the list do they support. The answer is not exactly who, but simply a number between zero and three or four, depending on the group.\nSince no names are required, this should eliminate the “political risks” of the answer. A person in the group being surveyed names the number 1 — how do you know if it means Putin or someone else? And the answer “2” can mean both “Putin and someone else” and “some two of the other three.” The fact that the respondent does not support Putin, gives only the answer “0.”\nIt is possible to estimate Putin’s support by the difference in the answers of the two groups. The authors conducted such an experiment in January 2015. The list included Gennady Zyuganov, Sergei Mironov and then still alive Vladimir Zhirinovsky. The average value of responses in the control group was 1.11, and in the study group (the same and Putin) — 1.92. That is, Putin’s inclusion in the list added 0.81 on average. In other words, the level of his support can be estimated at 81%. This is about 5 percentage points (pp) less than the opinion polls gave Putin at that time.\nBut maybe it is about modern Russian “politicians?” The authors of the study are concerned that the unpopularity of politicians in Russia may have affected the results of the experiment, but they find little evidence that this factor significantly influenced the result. Nevertheless, they set up a similar experiment in 2015, replacing the lists of quasi-opposition leaders with the leaders of the country in the XX century: Joseph Stalin, Leonid Brezhnev and Boris Yeltsin. The result is roughly the same: Putin’s rating is 79%. Less than in social polls, but still a lot.\n\nThe less, the more accurate\nThat would be too easy. Sociologists discovered an interesting effect 10 years ago: adding another figure to the list reduces the result. It is not about who exactly is added, but about the fact that the list is growing. There is a peculiar deflation of the result: it is smaller the longer the list is.\nTo assess this “deflation,” another experiment is conducted, which the authors of the study compare with a placebo. There is no Putin or anything else related to Russia in it. To Alexander Lukashenko, Angela Merkel and Nelson Mandela in the study group was added Fidel Castro, expressing an attitude towards which seems to be nothing. In 2015, 60% responded to a direct question that they supported his activities, and the result of the experiment with lists was 9 pp less. This effect should be taken into account.\nAnd now about the results that came out next.\n\n\n\nBefore the war\nThe researchers returned to this topic at the end of 2020. By that time, the Crimean effect had long since passed, and the COVID effect had not yet passed, and Putin’s rating was about 65%. But the situation in the country had changed dramatically: Alexei Navalny had been poisoned shortly before, in January 2021 he would return to Russia and be arrested, and protest rallies would sweep across the country and be violently dispersed. Repression was growing, and with it the risks of supporting the opposition, albeit with participation in opinion polls. The question of the correctness of their results became acute again.\nSociologists conducted four waves of experiments: in November 2020 and in February, March and June 2021. So many were needed because the results differed greatly from the post-Crimea results. The deviation of Putin’s support in the experiments with lists from the answers to the direct question rose sharply and ranged from 9 to 23% in different waves of the polls.\nThe authors of the study conclude that “deflation” has also increased. If it was 5–9%, as it was in 2015, it would mean an even bigger drop in Putin's approval than the polls showed. Perhaps even below 50%. But the experiments showed that the “deflation” in the case of Castro and Brezhnev was about 22%. In addition to them, the scientists used in a “placebo” experiment the runner-up in the 2018 presidential election, Pavel Grudinin, whom they also considered a neutral figure for some reason. In this experiment, the “deflation” was much smaller — 12%. This can be explained by the fact that people were still afraid to honestly answer sociologists that they support Grudinin (poll results are distorted by fear?), but at the same time it shows that experiments with lists work. In fact, if people are afraid to support Grudinin even in polls, it understates “deflation,” meaning it is actually higher than 12%.\nWhy “deflation” has grown so much, the authors of the study do not explain. But adjusted for such “deflation” it turns out that Putin’s support — 40–54% depending on the wave and the list (with leaders from the past or with contemporary politicians) — was again close to that obtained in answers to a direct question — 63% in November-March and 69% in June.\nThat such an adjustment is necessary to assess real support is indirectly confirmed by measuring Navalny’s popularity. Two lists were used for these experiments: contemporary politicians, as for Putin, and — twice — public figures (Nikita Mikhalkov, Ksenia Sobchak and Grudinin). The results of two of these three experiments almost coincided with the answers to a direct question about Navalny’s support. If we forget about “deflation,” it turns out that in February-March 2021 the question about support for Navalny’s activities was not politically sensitive and people were not afraid to answer it honestly. It is hard to believe this.\n\nAfter the war started\nThe last experiment took place in June 2022 (there was no need to go to Russia for this — the experiments themselves have always been conducted by the Levada Center). Over the course of a year, Putin's support estimated in this way jumped by about the same amount as the polls showed.\nIn order to assess the “deflation” more accurately (and what if its cause is the fact that it is people on the lists), the scientists conducted another experiment with a “placebo.” The control group received a list of three innocent statements — “I can name the UN Secretary General;” “I watch TV / YouTube / online cinemas (Kinopoisk, Ivi, Okko, etc.) at least once a week” and “I have an acquaintance who has been to Cuba,” and in the study group, “I support the activities of Fidel Castro” was added to them. There were similar statements for Putin (“I usually read more than one newspaper/magazine a week;” “I can name the chairman of the Constitutional Court;” “I am satisfied with my income” plus the question about support — for the group studied).\nThe difference between the answers to the direct question about Castro's support and the results of the “placebo” experiments amounted to 14 pp in the lists with politicians and 31 pp with statements. In the case of Putin, this difference is 21 and 29 points. For both, the gap for lists with statements is larger, so it is hardly a matter of people.\nIn June 2022, when asked directly, 84% of the participants in the experiment said they supported Putin. His result in the experiment with lists of the country’s leaders is 63%. If you make an adjustment for “deflation,” you get almost the same as in the poll.\n\n\n\nWhat the authors say\nThe authors conclude that the support for Putin measured by opinion polls seems to be close to reality. They stipulate that they cannot state this unequivocally, but find their assumption of “deflation” simpler and more plausible than those based on which Putin is significantly less popular than the polls show. To do so, at the very least, one would have to find an explanation for why support for Castro or Brezhnev is also “rigged,” and also recognize that Navalny was not a sensitive figure for the respondents.\nAnother argument: even if the absolute numbers themselves are wrong, their change is about the same as in the polls — both of which show a sharp rise in support for Putin after the war began.\n\nWhat other experts say\nMargarita Zavadskaya, senior researcher at the Finnish Institute of International Relations:\nPolls using list experiments are quite popular now, because they allow you to get data without forcing people to answer a sensitive question. This technique is often used in studies of victims of violence or other crimes.\nA team of researchers led by Timothy Fry at Columbia University has long been working on this issue in Russia. The findings can be interpreted in two ways: 10-20% is added to Putin, or this difference is a technical artifact of the design, an artificial deflation of the coefficients. Placebo tests allow us to conclude that the real support is as Levada Center and others report. It would be strange that the figure of Navalny is not sensitive for respondents, but Brezhnev, Grudinin or Castro are. We do not see mass falsification either: we conduct our own polls (by phone and online), and our results generally differ slightly from the authors’ estimates. But the results of such experiments should be used very carefully, especially in authoritarian regimes — all researchers emphasize this.\nThe good news is that even if Russians are not lying and do support Putin, according to researchers from the same group, it is not about sincere love for him, but about so-called endogenous support. What is it? Autocracies with popular leaders tend to survive longer, and scholars are actively studying the factors that influence the popularity of authoritarian leaders. It may be that in non-democratic regimes, the information itself about how popular a leader is affects his or her level of support.\nTo test this, the researchers used framing experiments (they are based on the fact that perceptions of the same statement can differ depending on how it is phrased) embedded in four recent polls in Russia. Negative information about the Russian president’s popularity was found to reduce his support, while positive information had no effect. Thus, combinations of framing and list experiments suggest that Russians are leaning toward majority opinion. And it is successfully constructed by propaganda. As soon as the conviction that Putin is supported by the majority is shaken, we can expect a change of moods according to the principle of “information cascades.”\n\n\n\nGrigory Yudin, professor at the Moscow Higher School of Social and Economic Sciences (Shaninka):\nThe main problem with this text is that it makes two statements, of which only one is substantiated. The main statement is that one should be careful in using list experiments to assess the popularity of political figures, because such experiments can artificially underestimate it. And it does not depend on the country, the authors emphasize this: we are not talking about the Russian case.\nThis statement is justified in the article, but the justification is objectionable. The authors conclude that lower levels of support for any politician in the list experiment are artificial, while higher levels in the direct questioning are the real indicators. What is the basis for this assumption is unclear. Why the authors believe that the direct question gives more real values is unknown.\nLet’s look at the matter another way: if a person, when confronted with a list of questions, forgets to note that he or she supports a given politician — can we conclude that he or she actually supports him or her? Suppose you support politician X. If you are asked directly, you will say so. But if you are given a list of four names, would you forget that you sympathize with X? What kind of support is that then? In other words, we see that the two question designs produce different results, but we have no reason to conclude (as the authors do) that one of them is somehow “cleaner.” Generally speaking, any question in sociological research constructs its subject, and it is a naive illusion that the easiest way to measure something is to simply ask it head-on. Frontal questions are often the most artificial.\nThe second statement is already directly related to Russia. It reproduces a thesis that Fry and his colleagues have been making for a long time: mass polls are absolutely correct in estimating Putin's high support in Russia. Moreover, in an earlier paper, the same team even managed to show that polls underestimate this support — that is, Russians actually like Putin even more than the pollsters tell us.\nThe study uses a questionable methodology for collecting information, offers vague and suspect validity estimates, and yet concludes “genuine support for Putin,” whatever that means. Russia now has a plebiscitary regime where the question about the tsar is not perceived neutrally, but as a request for a ritualized demonstration of loyalty. Polls should not be used as plebiscites — the question “how many actually support the tsar” is meaningless (for more on this, see Grigory Yudin’s article).\nSociologist from the Public Sociology Laboratory (PSLab):\nSuch experiments are a legitimate and practiced method, everything is clearly done and clearly described, I have no doubts about the quality of the research. Post-Soviet Affairs, in which this article was published, is a prestigious journal, and there is very little chance that something of poor scientific quality could appear there. Besides, one of the authors, Timothy Fry, is a major expert on Putinism.\nThis article is part of the discussion. The authors can be argued: “Yes, people do not falsify preferences and sincerely choose Putin. But what logic guides them in doing so? Are they satisfied with Putin or, rather, are they afraid that it could be even worse?” But that does not mean that the text or method is of poor quality. The question is how to interpret this data.","blocks":[{"data":"The debate about Putin’s real popularity has always been going on, but has intensified since the war started. Putin’s rating jumped — did people really support him?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Sociologists conducting polls have to constantly justify themselves. Denis Volkov, director of the Levada Center, <a href=\"https://www.levada.ru/2023/02/10/vozmozhny-li-oprosy-v-segodnyashnej-rossii/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">listed</a> and then refuted the main arguments of critics as to why Russian polls cannot be trusted: after the war began, people — especially Putin’s opponents — began to refuse to participate in polls and to answer questions about the war much more often, and if they did answer, they usually did not answer what they “really” thought.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to Volkov, in reality, the “unreachability” of respondents has changed little since the war (in 2022 it was slightly higher than in 2019-2020, but lower than in 2021), and the number of interviews interrupted on questions about Ukraine is quite low (from two to seven), as in polls on other topics, which, with a sample of more than a thousand people, is insignificant. As for the honesty of answers, the increase in support for Putin after the start of the war is combined with changes in answers to other questions — about economic behavior and sentiment, Volkov assures.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Alexei Levinson, head of the socio-cultural research department at the Levada Center, <a href=\"https://youtu.be/QlMr53BRrwc?t=4176\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">responded</a> to another reproach — that sociologists simply cannot show results with lower ratings: “As long as the authorities are satisfied with the high ratings they receive honestly, they will tolerate us. When it stops being so, I don’t think we’ll last long.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"While the debate is going on, public opinion polls continue to record that Putin enjoys the broadest support of the population. For example, <a href=\"https://www.levada.ru/indikatory/odobrenie-organov-vlasti/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">according</a> to the Levada Center, this year Putin's activities were “generally approved” by 85–87% (the poll is conducted every month).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Scientists have come up with a way, if not to check, then to get closer to answering the question: is it true that the results of social polls are heavily distorted by the fear of giving the “wrong” answer? Their <a href=\"https://spaces-cdn.owlstown.com/blobs/0svb0fb2kofpgpro7fl9m1wujhmy\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">study</a> is called “Putin’s popularity: is it (still) real?”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The same and Putin","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"They used a method that is often used to study people’s reactions to sensitive topics — the “list experiment.” Respondents, selected according to Russia’s population structure, are randomly divided into two groups. The first, “control” group is given a list of three political figures. The second, the group under study, is given the same list plus Putin. People in each group are asked a question: how many politicians from the list do they support. The answer is not exactly who, but simply a number between zero and three or four, depending on the group.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Since no names are required, this should eliminate the “political risks” of the answer. A person in the group being surveyed names the number 1 — how do you know if it means Putin or someone else? And the answer “2” can mean both “Putin and someone else” and “some two of the other three.” The fact that the respondent does not support Putin, gives only the answer “0.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It is possible to estimate Putin’s support by the difference in the answers of the two groups. The authors conducted such an experiment in January 2015. The list included Gennady Zyuganov, Sergei Mironov and then still alive Vladimir Zhirinovsky. The average value of responses in the control group was 1.11, and in the study group (the same and Putin) — 1.92. That is, Putin’s inclusion in the list added 0.81 on average. In other words, the level of his support can be estimated at 81%. This is about 5 percentage points (pp) less than the opinion polls gave Putin at that time.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But maybe it is about modern Russian “politicians?” The authors of the study are concerned that the unpopularity of politicians in Russia may have affected the results of the experiment, but they find little evidence that this factor significantly influenced the result. Nevertheless, they set up a similar experiment in 2015, replacing the lists of quasi-opposition leaders with the leaders of the country in the XX century: Joseph Stalin, Leonid Brezhnev and Boris Yeltsin. The result is roughly the same: Putin’s rating is 79%. Less than in social polls, but still a lot.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The less, the more accurate","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"That would be too easy. Sociologists <a href=\"https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11109-013-9249-x\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">discovered</a> an interesting effect 10 years ago: adding another figure to the list reduces the result. It is not about who exactly is added, but about the fact that the list is growing. There is a peculiar deflation of the result: it is smaller the longer the list is.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"To assess this “deflation,” another experiment is conducted, which the authors of the study compare with a placebo. There is no Putin or anything else related to Russia in it. To Alexander Lukashenko, Angela Merkel and Nelson Mandela in the study group was added Fidel Castro, expressing an attitude towards which seems to be nothing. In 2015, 60% responded to a direct question that they supported his activities, and the result of the experiment with lists was 9 pp less. This effect should be taken into account.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"And now about the results that came out next.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":12710,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Maxim Shemetov / Reuters / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"People march to a rally in support of the annexation of Crimea, March 2014","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d07fa0d914c14e399d7bdc1298c3bf65-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d07fa0d914c14e399d7bdc1298c3bf65-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":792,"real_height_2x":1584},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d07fa0d914c14e399d7bdc1298c3bf65-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d07fa0d914c14e399d7bdc1298c3bf65-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":792,"real_height_2x":1584},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d07fa0d914c14e399d7bdc1298c3bf65-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d07fa0d914c14e399d7bdc1298c3bf65-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":274,"real_height_2x":548},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d07fa0d914c14e399d7bdc1298c3bf65-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d07fa0d914c14e399d7bdc1298c3bf65-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":274,"real_height_2x":548}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Before the war","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The researchers returned to this topic at the end of 2020. By that time, the Crimean effect had long since passed, and the COVID effect had not yet passed, and Putin’s rating was about 65%. But the situation in the country had changed dramatically: Alexei Navalny had been poisoned shortly before, in January 2021 he would return to Russia and be arrested, and protest rallies would sweep across the country and be violently dispersed. Repression was growing, and with it the risks of supporting the opposition, albeit with participation in opinion polls. The question of the correctness of their results became acute again.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Sociologists conducted four waves of experiments: in November 2020 and in February, March and June 2021. So many were needed because the results differed greatly from the post-Crimea results. The deviation of Putin’s support in the experiments with lists from the answers to the direct question rose sharply and ranged from 9 to 23% in different waves of the polls.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The authors of the study conclude that “deflation” has also increased. If it was 5–9%, as it was in 2015, it would mean an even bigger drop in Putin's approval than the polls showed. Perhaps even below 50%. But the experiments showed that the “deflation” in the case of Castro and Brezhnev was about 22%. In addition to them, the scientists used in a “placebo” experiment the runner-up in the 2018 presidential election, Pavel Grudinin, whom they also considered a neutral figure for some reason. In this experiment, the “deflation” was much smaller — 12%. This can be explained by the fact that people were still afraid to honestly answer sociologists that they support Grudinin (poll results are distorted by fear?), but at the same time it shows that experiments with lists work. In fact, if people are afraid to support Grudinin even in polls, it understates “deflation,” meaning it is actually higher than 12%.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Why “deflation” has grown so much, the authors of the study do not explain. But adjusted for such “deflation” it turns out that Putin’s support — 40–54% depending on the wave and the list (with leaders from the past or with contemporary politicians) — was again close to that obtained in answers to a direct question — 63% in November-March and 69% in June.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"That such an adjustment is necessary to assess real support is indirectly confirmed by measuring Navalny’s popularity. Two lists were used for these experiments: contemporary politicians, as for Putin, and — twice — public figures (Nikita Mikhalkov, Ksenia Sobchak and Grudinin). The results of two of these three experiments almost coincided with the answers to a direct question about Navalny’s support. If we forget about “deflation,” it turns out that in February-March 2021 the question about support for Navalny’s activities was not politically sensitive and people were not afraid to answer it honestly. It is hard to believe this.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After the war started","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The last experiment took place in June 2022 (there was no need to go to Russia for this — the experiments themselves have always been conducted by the Levada Center). Over the course of a year, Putin's support estimated in this way jumped by about the same amount as the polls showed.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In order to assess the “deflation” more accurately (and what if its cause is the fact that it is people on the lists), the scientists conducted another experiment with a “placebo.” The control group received a list of three innocent statements — “I can name the UN Secretary General;” “I watch TV / YouTube / online cinemas (Kinopoisk, Ivi, Okko, etc.) at least once a week” and “I have an acquaintance who has been to Cuba,” and in the study group, “I support the activities of Fidel Castro” was added to them. There were similar statements for Putin (“I usually read more than one newspaper/magazine a week;” “I can name the chairman of the Constitutional Court;” “I am satisfied with my income” plus the question about support — for the group studied).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The difference between the answers to the direct question about Castro's support and the results of the “placebo” experiments amounted to 14 pp in the lists with politicians and 31 pp with statements. In the case of Putin, this difference is 21 and 29 points. For both, the gap for lists with statements is larger, so it is hardly a matter of people.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In June 2022, when asked directly, 84% of the participants in the experiment said they supported Putin. His result in the experiment with lists of the country’s leaders is 63%. If you make an adjustment for “deflation,” you get almost the same as in the poll.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":12711,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Natalia Kolesnikova / AFP / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Putin is everywhere. Propaganda insinuates that he is super-popular, but if there are doubts about this, the mood can change","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d11f5d79d38342c1844feb790e198bc3-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d11f5d79d38342c1844feb790e198bc3-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d11f5d79d38342c1844feb790e198bc3-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d11f5d79d38342c1844feb790e198bc3-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d11f5d79d38342c1844feb790e198bc3-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d11f5d79d38342c1844feb790e198bc3-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d11f5d79d38342c1844feb790e198bc3-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d11f5d79d38342c1844feb790e198bc3-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"What the authors say","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The authors conclude that the support for Putin measured by opinion polls seems to be close to reality. They stipulate that they cannot state this unequivocally, but find their assumption of “deflation” simpler and more plausible than those based on which Putin is significantly less popular than the polls show. To do so, at the very least, one would have to find an explanation for why support for Castro or Brezhnev is also “rigged,” and also recognize that Navalny was not a sensitive figure for the respondents.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Another argument: even if the absolute numbers themselves are wrong, their change is about the same as in the polls — both of which show a sharp rise in support for Putin after the war began.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"What other experts say","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"<strong><em>Margarita Zavadskaya</em></strong><em>, senior researcher at the Finnish Institute of International Relations:</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Polls using list experiments are quite popular now, because they allow you to get data without forcing people to answer a sensitive question. This technique is often used in studies of victims of violence or other crimes.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A team of researchers led by <a href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timothy_M._Frye\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Timothy Fry</a> at Columbia University has long been working on this issue in Russia. The findings can be interpreted in two ways: 10-20% is added to Putin, or this difference is a technical artifact of the design, an artificial deflation of the coefficients. Placebo tests allow us to conclude that the real support is as Levada Center and others report. It would be strange that the figure of Navalny is not sensitive for respondents, but Brezhnev, Grudinin or Castro are. We do not see mass falsification either: we conduct our own polls (by phone and online), and our <a href=\"https://osf.io/preprints/osf/ek8wy\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">results</a> generally differ slightly from the authors’ estimates. But the results of such experiments should be used very carefully, especially in authoritarian regimes — all researchers emphasize this.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The good news is that even if Russians are not lying and do support Putin, according to researchers from the same group, it is not about sincere love for him, but about so-called endogenous support. What is it? Autocracies with popular leaders tend to survive longer, and scholars are actively studying the factors that influence the popularity of authoritarian leaders. It may be that in non-democratic regimes, the information itself about how popular a leader is affects his or her level of support.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"To test this, the researchers used framing experiments (they are based on the fact that perceptions of the same statement can differ depending on how it is phrased) embedded in four recent polls in Russia. Negative information about the Russian president’s popularity was <a href=\"https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-political-science-review/article/endogenous-popularity-how-perceptions-of-support-affect-the-popularity-of-authoritarian-regimes/7AA9363EE673DC50F46E7980DB08F936\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">found</a> to reduce his support, while positive information had no effect. Thus, combinations of framing and list experiments suggest that Russians are leaning toward majority opinion. And it is successfully constructed by propaganda. As soon as the conviction that Putin is supported by the majority is shaken, we can expect a change of moods according to the principle of “information cascades.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":12712,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Anton Vergun / Sputnik / imago / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"What Russians are guided by when supporting Putin is a separate question","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47d6d453c664f3dbc2f7f222161b0b5-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47d6d453c664f3dbc2f7f222161b0b5-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":766,"real_height_2x":1533},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47d6d453c664f3dbc2f7f222161b0b5-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47d6d453c664f3dbc2f7f222161b0b5-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":766,"real_height_2x":1533},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47d6d453c664f3dbc2f7f222161b0b5-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47d6d453c664f3dbc2f7f222161b0b5-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":265,"real_height_2x":530},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47d6d453c664f3dbc2f7f222161b0b5-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47d6d453c664f3dbc2f7f222161b0b5-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":265,"real_height_2x":530}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"<strong><em>Grigory Yudin</em></strong><em>, professor at the Moscow Higher School of Social and Economic Sciences (Shaninka):</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The main problem with this text is that it makes two statements, of which only one is substantiated. The main statement is that one should be careful in using list experiments to assess the popularity of political figures, because such experiments can artificially underestimate it. And it does not depend on the country, the authors emphasize this: we are not talking about the Russian case.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This statement is justified in the article, but the justification is objectionable. The authors conclude that lower levels of support for any politician in the list experiment are artificial, while higher levels in the direct questioning are the real indicators. What is the basis for this assumption is unclear. Why the authors believe that the direct question gives more real values is unknown.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Let’s look at the matter another way: if a person, when confronted with a list of questions, forgets to note that he or she supports a given politician — can we conclude that he or she actually supports him or her? Suppose you support politician X. If you are asked directly, you will say so. But if you are given a list of four names, would you forget that you sympathize with X? What kind of support is that then? In other words, we see that the two question designs produce different results, but we have no reason to conclude (as the authors do) that one of them is somehow “cleaner.” Generally speaking, any question in sociological research constructs its subject, and it is a naive illusion that the easiest way to measure something is to simply ask it head-on. Frontal questions are often the most artificial.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The second statement is already directly related to Russia. It reproduces a thesis that Fry and his colleagues have been making for a long time: mass polls are absolutely correct in estimating Putin's high support in Russia. Moreover, in an earlier paper, the same team even managed to show that polls underestimate this support — that is, Russians actually like Putin even more than the pollsters tell us.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The study uses a questionable methodology for collecting information, offers vague and suspect validity estimates, and yet concludes “genuine support for Putin,” whatever that means. Russia now has a plebiscitary regime where the question about the tsar is not perceived neutrally, but as a request for a ritualized demonstration of loyalty. Polls should not be used as plebiscites — the question “how many actually support the tsar” is meaningless (for more on this, see Grigory Yudin’s article).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong><em>Sociologist</em></strong><em> from the Public Sociology Laboratory (PSLab):</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Such experiments are a legitimate and practiced method, everything is clearly done and clearly described, I have no doubts about the quality of the research. Post-Soviet Affairs, in which this article was published, is a prestigious journal, and there is very little chance that something of poor scientific quality could appear there. Besides, one of the authors, Timothy Fry, is a major expert on Putinism.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This article is part of the discussion. The authors can be argued: “Yes, people do not falsify preferences and sincerely choose Putin. But what logic guides them in doing so? Are they satisfied with Putin or, rather, are they afraid that it could be even worse?” But that does not mean that the text or method is of poor quality. The question is how to interpret this data.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":5798,"header":"“No Obstacles — Just Drive Forward”","_path":"/en/opinions/2024/08/12/kursk-oblast/","lead":"A former commander of a Russian reconnaissance group explains why the Armed Forces of Ukraine broke through into the Kursk Oblast so easily","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-1920x960px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-1920x960px_2x.png","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-1272x636px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-1272x636px_2x.png","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-912x456px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-912x456px_2x.png","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-600x400px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-600x400px_2x.png","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-360x360px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/04263554d25844a4b5afc6868af221fb-360x360px_2x.png","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"A convoy of Russian army trucks damaged by AFU shelling on a highway in Sudzhansky District, Kursk Oblast, August 9, 2024. Photo: Anatoly Zhdanov / Kommersant / AP / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2024-08-12","created_at_date_time":"2024-08-12T16:02:14.529Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":9,"first_name":"Ирина","last_name":"Долинина","first_name_en":"Irina","last_name_en":"Dolinina","is_public":true,"_path":"irina-dolinina","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Журналистка «Важных историй»","lead_en":"IStories' investigative reporter","position":"Авторка","position_en":"Author","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"IStories spoke with a former reconnaissance group commander who served in the Russian army for 10 years, participated in the invasion of Ukraine, but refused to continue fighting. On the condition of anonymity, he shared his thoughts on the Armed Forces of Ukraine (AFU) breakthrough in Kursk Oblast.\n\nWarning: there is a lot of profanity in the text.\n\nParties’ preparation\n“Why did all these RVC [Russian Volunteer Corps] and the Legion [Freedom of Russia Legion] conduct their raids? To carry out additional reconnaissance [of the area]. They weren’t just walking around and posting all these videos; [PR] for the media was an afterthought. Initially, any military shit is done for military purposes. We did the same thing back in the day [since 2014]. We went in, observed the reaction — how quickly they respond to your arrival, how many forces are there, where, what, how — and then we left. Then again and again. So, eventually, [the AFU] already had a plan, gradually pulled in troops in small groups so as not to make a large movement noticeable, and then just broke through.\n\nFor more than six months, they carried out reconnaissance like this (the first RVC raid into Kursk Oblast took place in March 2024. — Ed.). They kept coming in; there were some small skirmishes, sometimes they got killed, sometimes not. But the main thing is they conducted additional reconnaissance, mapped out the area, tested the forces. And what changed on our side [on the border] in six months? Fucking nothing. And when all these raids on the Kursk direction started, the border guards only had light firearms, no heavy equipment, and the border was practically always open. But nothing changed in six months. Authorities allocated money to strengthen the border: ‘dragon’s teeth,’ trenches were supposedly dug — but mostly, the money, as usual, was fucked up. And what, the Ukrainians [are crazy], or what, not to take advantage of this, once they’ve already learned the area and it still remains weak on defense?\n\nFor those on the front line, this breakthrough is not a surprise at all. They’ve long known that something like this would start sooner or later; it was just a matter of time. As usual, all requests up the chain were met with: ‘We have everything under control; intelligence reports that nothing has been noticed.’ And this was all standard practice — before the attack, the shelling intensified. For example, a classic American tactic: they mop out as much as possible with aviation, then the troops go in. In this case, they didn’t use aviation, but intensified the shelling with drones. Here, intelligence, the Ministry of Defense, and the ‘TikTok troops’ at the border (referring to the Chechen ‘Akhmat’ battalion, which was sent to defend the border. After the AFU invasion of Kursk Oblast, its fighters forced a Russian conscript to apologize on video for saying that the Chechens were hiding behind conscripts. — Ed.) seriously fucked up.\n\n\nParties’ tactics\nThe AFU planned everything smartly, like straight out of a textbook: conduct additional reconnaissance, chart the route, and most importantly, do it quickly. They arrived in groups and just started pushing forward without securing positions. Just further and further — one swift push. Because if they were to secure positions, it would give us more time and opportunities to bring in troops to stop them. So they just push forward as fast as possible, while ours are talking shit, arguing, showing up, and filming reports. As they say in the army: ‘If you want to defeat Russia, declare war, and it will fuck itself up with inspections.’ And that’s what happened here. While they were gathering to show up, the AFU had already broken through deep inside, so it’s impossible to stop them locally. For instance, they’ve penetrated, let’s say, 15 km — meanwhile, the sabotage and reconnaissance groups (SRGs) go even further — and start digging in. And when the Russian troops finally show up, the SRG start attacking them.\n\nIn this situation, our forces didn’t just respond late — they didn’t respond [properly] at all. Especially with this favorite line that ‘everything is under control, we control everything.’ But then prisoners were captured, and they straight up say that there are only conscripts and border guards here, and they have nothing. That’s why they surrender in whole packs, because, firstly, the conscripts don’t know how to fight, and secondly, they don’t have the weapons to repel such attacks. Fine, if they [AFU soldiers] were coming without equipment or with just two tanks, you might still try to fight back. But when there are dozens of pieces of equipment, there’s nothing they can do. What are you going to do with a machine gun against a tank? So they let them all through because they simply had no way to stop them. Plus, the defensive positions weren’t prepared because the allocated money was clearly stolen. There were no obstacles — just drive forward.\n\nAnd when the Russian army finally began pulling in reserves — the fucking media were filming everything. They sent a convoy, and in [pro-war] media it was immediately: ‘Here comes the convoy, now we’ll get their asses kicked!’ And of course, the whole thing was completely obliterated by HIMARS (on the night of August 9, the AFU destroyed a convoy of the newly created 44th Corps of the Leningrad Military District near Rylsk with a HIMARS strike. Videos from the scene show dozens of corpses: experts believe that an entire battalion could have been killed in the strike. — Ed.).\n\n\nAnd the very fact that they drove in a convoy! At least on the front line, after some time and massive losses, they figured out that driving in a convoy is suicide. But those sitting here still drive in convoys and think they’re going to a parade. The AFU has drones, has rockets — what kind of fucking idiot would lead a convoy in this case, and one that’s even being filmed for the news. That’s why the guys died, without even getting there.\n\n\nWhat’s next\nMaybe this offensive is being carried out to draw troops away from Donbas, where we’ve recently ramped up the pace. Or maybe they want to capture the Kursk nuclear power plant and later trade it for Zaporizhzhia one. But in any case, the danger for the AFU is that if they push the front too far forward from the border, they could simply get encircled. So, it’s not advantageous for them to go too far — the breakthrough line is small. As soon as our forces start doing something right and pull in reserves, they can block the [AFU] approaches from Ukraine. The Russian army will encircle them, stop the flow of resources, then just tighten the ring and destroy them all.\n\nSince this is Russia, we won’t give a fuck about the civilians left there. It’s already clear that the locals have been abandoned to fend for themselves — people there are on their own. They’ll level everything with artillery and aviation: after all, what is Kursk Oblast compared to Russia?”\n\nOur source's thoughts align with comments from pro-Russian bloggers, who, after the AFU breakthrough in Kursk Oblast, resumed active criticism of the army command. For example, VChK-OGPU and Rybar Telegram channels reported that the General Staff of the Russian Armed Forces was informed about the upcoming AFU operation: in response, Valery Gerasimov accused the intelligence of panic-mongering and demanded they “not fall for enemy disinformation.” Bloggers Dva Mayora (“Two Majors”) and Zhivov Z criticized journalists who broadcasted the troop transfers almost live. “I don’t know, maybe it’s really time to issue an order from the Supreme Commander to ban the movement of convoys in the combat zone,” lamented the author of the pro-war Telegram channel Starshe Eddy and suggested beating the convoy commander brutally.\n\nThe Aida group from the Akhmat special forces noted the AFU’s tactics: “After probing the weak part of the opponent's position, a lightning-fast breakthrough occurs in a narrow area, where equipment, manpower, and artillery cover are delivered in the shortest possible time.” And the Telegram channel Na PeredoVoy (“In the Frontline”) described the active work of the Ukrainian SRG behind enemy lines: “The enemy disperses into the occupied points and forests.”","blocks":[{"data":"IStories spoke with a former reconnaissance group commander who served in the Russian army for 10 years, participated in the invasion of Ukraine, but refused to continue fighting. On the condition of anonymity, he shared his thoughts on the Armed Forces of Ukraine (AFU) breakthrough in Kursk Oblast.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>Warning: there is a lot of profanity in the text.</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Parties’ preparation","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"“Why did all these <a href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_Volunteer_Corps\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">RVC</a> [Russian Volunteer Corps] and the <a href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_Russia_Legion\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Legion</a> [Freedom of Russia Legion] conduct their raids? To carry out additional reconnaissance [of the area]. They weren’t just walking around and posting all these videos; [PR] for the media was an afterthought. Initially, any military shit is done for military purposes. We did the same thing back in the day [since 2014]. We went in, observed the reaction — how quickly they respond to your arrival, how many forces are there, where, what, how — and then we left. Then again and again. So, eventually, [the AFU] already had a plan, gradually pulled in troops in small groups so as not to make a large movement noticeable, and then just broke through.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For more than six months, they carried out reconnaissance like this <em>(the first RVC raid into Kursk Oblast took place in March 2024. — Ed.)</em>. They kept coming in; there were some small skirmishes, sometimes they got killed, sometimes not. But the main thing is they conducted additional reconnaissance, mapped out the area, tested the forces. And what changed on our side [on the border] in six months? Fucking nothing. And when all these raids on the Kursk direction started, the border guards only had light firearms, no heavy equipment, and the border was practically always open. But nothing changed in six months. Authorities allocated money to strengthen the border: ‘<a href=\"https://kursk.bezformata.com/listnews/kurskoy-oblasti-ustanavlivayut/112229005/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">dragon’s teeth</a>,’ trenches were supposedly <a href=\"https://www.amur.life/news/2022/10/23/v-kurskoy-oblasti-vykopali-okopy-i-ustanovili-blindazhi\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">dug</a> — but mostly, the money, as usual, was fucked up. And what, the Ukrainians [are crazy], or what, not to take advantage of this, once they’ve already learned the area and it still remains weak on defense?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For those on the front line, this breakthrough is not a surprise at all. They’ve long known that something like this would start sooner or later; it was just a matter of time. As usual, all requests up the chain were met with: ‘We have everything under control; intelligence reports that nothing has been noticed.’ And this was all standard practice — before the attack, the shelling intensified. For example, a classic American tactic: they mop out as much as possible with aviation, then the troops go in. In this case, they didn’t use aviation, but <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/politics/06/08/2024/66b1ba4e9a7947ef6e956b12\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">intensified</a> the shelling with drones. Here, intelligence, the Ministry of Defense, and the ‘TikTok troops’ at the border <em>(referring to the Chechen ‘Akhmat’ battalion, which was sent to defend the border. After the AFU invasion of Kursk Oblast, its fighters forced a Russian conscript to apologize on video for saying that the Chechens were hiding behind conscripts. — Ed.)</em> seriously fucked up.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Parties’ tactics","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The AFU planned everything smartly, like straight out of a textbook: conduct additional reconnaissance, chart the route, and most importantly, do it quickly. They arrived in groups and just started pushing forward without securing positions. Just further and further — one swift push. Because if they were to secure positions, it would give us more time and opportunities to bring in troops to stop them. So they just push forward as fast as possible, while ours are talking shit, arguing, showing up, and filming reports. As they say in the army: ‘If you want to defeat Russia, declare war, and it will fuck itself up with inspections.’ And that’s what happened here. While they were gathering to show up, the AFU had already broken through deep inside, so it’s impossible to stop them locally. For instance, they’ve penetrated, let’s say, 15 km — meanwhile, the sabotage and reconnaissance groups (SRGs) go even further — and start digging in. And when the Russian troops finally show up, the SRG start attacking them.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In this situation, our forces didn’t just respond late — they didn’t respond [properly] at all. Especially with this favorite line that ‘everything is under control, we control everything.’ But then prisoners were captured, and they straight up <a href=\"https://t.me/istories_media/7151\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">say</a> that there are only conscripts and border guards here, and they have nothing. That’s why they surrender in whole packs, because, firstly, the conscripts don’t know how to fight, and secondly, they don’t have the weapons to repel such attacks. Fine, if they [AFU soldiers] were coming without equipment or with just two tanks, you might still try to fight back. But when there are dozens of pieces of equipment, there’s nothing they can do. What are you going to do with a machine gun against a tank? So they let them all through because they simply had no way to stop them. Plus, the defensive positions weren’t prepared because the allocated money was clearly stolen. There were no obstacles — just drive forward.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"And when the Russian army finally began pulling in reserves — the fucking media were filming everything. They sent a convoy, and in <a href=\"https://t.me/istories_media/7206\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">[pro-war] media</a> it was immediately: ‘Here comes the convoy, now we’ll get their asses kicked!’ And of course, the whole thing was completely obliterated by HIMARS <em>(on the night of August 9, the AFU </em><a href=\"https://t.me/istories_media/7199\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>destroyed</em></a><em> a convoy of the newly created 44th Corps of the Leningrad Military District near Rylsk with a HIMARS strike. Videos from the scene show dozens of corpses: experts believe that an entire battalion could have been killed in the strike. — Ed.)</em>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":12568,"data":{"url":"https://t.me/vchkogpu/49754","initialHeight":"735px"},"category":"telegram-embed"},"type":"telegram-embed"},{"data":"And the very fact that they drove in a convoy! At least on the front line, after some time and massive losses, they figured out that driving in a convoy is suicide. But those sitting here still drive in convoys and think they’re going to a parade. The AFU has drones, has rockets — what kind of fucking idiot would lead a convoy in this case, and one that’s even being filmed for the news. That’s why the guys died, without even getting there.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"What’s next","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Maybe this offensive is being carried out to draw troops away from Donbas, where we’ve recently ramped up the pace. Or maybe they want to capture the Kursk nuclear power plant and later trade it for Zaporizhzhia one. But in any case, the danger for the AFU is that if they push the front too far forward from the border, they could simply get encircled. So, it’s not advantageous for them to go too far — the breakthrough line is small. As soon as our forces start doing something right and pull in reserves, they can block the [AFU] approaches from Ukraine. The Russian army will encircle them, stop the flow of resources, then just tighten the ring and destroy them all.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Since this is Russia, we won’t give a fuck about the civilians left there. It’s already clear that the locals have been abandoned to fend for themselves — people there are on their own. They’ll level everything with artillery and aviation: after all, what is Kursk Oblast compared to Russia?”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Our source's thoughts align with comments from pro-Russian bloggers, who, after the AFU breakthrough in Kursk Oblast, resumed active criticism of the army command. For example, <a href=\"https://t.me/vchkogpu/49705\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">VChK-OGPU</a> and <a href=\"https://t.me/rybar/62565\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Rybar</a> Telegram channels reported that the General Staff of the Russian Armed Forces was informed about the upcoming AFU operation: in response, Valery Gerasimov accused the intelligence of panic-mongering and demanded they “not fall for enemy disinformation.” Bloggers <a href=\"https://t.me/dva_majors/49243\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Dva Mayora</a> (“Two Majors”) and <a href=\"https://t.me/zhivoff/16161\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Zhivov Z</a> criticized journalists who broadcasted the troop transfers almost live. “I don’t know, maybe it’s really time to issue an order from the Supreme Commander to ban the movement of convoys in the combat zone,” <a href=\"https://t.me/vysokygovorit/16840\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">lamented</a> the author of the pro-war Telegram channel Starshe Eddy and suggested beating the convoy commander brutally.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Aida group from the Akhmat special forces <a href=\"https://t.me/moloth_war/58006\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">noted</a> the AFU’s tactics: “After probing the weak part of the opponent's position, a lightning-fast breakthrough occurs in a narrow area, where equipment, manpower, and artillery cover are delivered in the shortest possible time.” And the Telegram channel Na PeredoVoy (“In the Frontline”) described the active work of the Ukrainian SRG behind enemy lines: “The enemy disperses into the occupied points and forests.”","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":4546,"header":"What Is Inside Vladimir Putin’s Head?","_path":"/en/opinions/2024/03/14/putin/","lead":"An attempt to psychoanalyze Russian authorities by Important Stories’ editor-in-chief Roman Anin","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-1920x960px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-1920x960px_2x.png","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-1272x636px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-1272x636px_2x.png","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-912x456px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-912x456px_2x.png","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-600x400px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-600x400px_2x.png","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-360x360px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/453daf000649493cb6a1c39d57bc8a68-360x360px_2x.png","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Illustration: Krišs Salmanis","created_at_date":"2024-03-14","created_at_date_time":"2024-03-18T20:18:54.176Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":5,"first_name":"Роман","last_name":"Анин","first_name_en":"Roman","last_name_en":"Anin","is_public":true,"_path":"roman-anin","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редактор «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Редактор","position_en":"Editor","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"What is going on in Vladimir Putin’s head, and for what values are Russians dying in Ukraine? It would seem that these are completely different questions, but if we try to answer them, we will realize that, in fact, they are about the same thing.  \n\nThe war in Ukraine is not only a confrontation between two armies, but also between two ideologies. If we ask Ukrainians on the front lines what they give their lives for, most of them will answer without hesitation: for freedom. Today, this is their basic and existential value: it is not something that has been handed down from above by the authorities or propaganda, there is nothing abstract about it, its necessity has been realized by the people themselves — it is their land that has been seized, it is their cities that are being wiped off the face of the earth by Russian tanks and missiles, it is they who are being tortured for speaking their native language.  \n\nIf we were to ask Russians the same question — why are they dying in Ukraine? — then, hand on heart, many would probably say that they went to war to make money. But even those who joined the Russian army for ideological reasons — and there are many of them — would hardly be able to unanimously list the specific values for which they are fighting.\n\nUnlike the Ukrainian ideology of freedom, the ideology of the Russian world is extremely abstract. And there is a simple explanation for this: it is built on an illusion, on a myth that has nothing to do with reality.\n\nThis myth originated in the heads of elderly KGB officers who have been ruling Russia for 25 years. Let’s analyze it carefully and try to understand what it can tell us about Putin’s worldview and his attitude to reality? Let’s try to psychoanalyze the Russian authorities.\n\n\n\nThe ideology of the “Russian world”\n\nPutin formulated the final principles of the ideology of the “Russian world” last November at the session of the World Russian People’s Council.\n\nFirst, this ideology is based on the image of the enemy — the collective West: “The West does not need such a large and multinational country as Russia. <...> Our diversity and unity of cultures, traditions, languages, ethnicities simply do not fit into the logic of Western racists and colonizers, into their cruel scheme of total depersonalization, disunity, suppression and exploitation.”\n\nSecond, the concept of the Russian world is based on the idea of the exceptionalism and messianism of the Russian people, who for centuries have been opposing the corrupt West and defending their more spiritual and just values: “It is our country, the Russian world, as it has happened many times in history, that has blocked the way of those who claim world domination. <...> We are fighting now for the freedom not only of Russia, but of the whole world. <...> Russian is more than a nationality!”\n\nThe third distinctive feature of the ideology of the Russian world is its invasive character: it does not recognize state borders and denies national identity to other peoples. Both Putin and Patriarch Kirill have repeatedly asserted that Ukrainians and Belarusians are not separate ethnic groups, but parts of the “common Russian people.” Therefore, according to their logic, Russia has the right to \"protect\" the Russian-speaking population and annex the territories where they live.\n\nLet us leave aside the ethical questions to these principles and ask only logical ones:  \n\n\nwhy is the Russian world more spiritual than the West, if in reality Russia is one of the world leaders in the number of alcohol-related deaths, suicides and new HIV infections?  \nwhy does the Russian army demolish Russian-speaking cities — Mariupol, Kharkov, Odessa, Kherson — if they are inhabited by those whom it supposedly came to protect?\nWhy is it that in the “just” Russian world, Ramzan Kadyrov’s 15-year-old son beats up a defenceless Russian in front of everyone’s eyes, brags about it in public, and receives a carload of state awards, while Sasha Skochilenko, an artist from St. Petersburg, is imprisoned for seven years for putting up peaceful stickers in a store?\n\nOn the one hand, these contradictions are so obvious that it seems incredible how tens of thousands of Russians could die in Ukraine for an idea that, in terms of its reasoning, is not much different from the delusions of a patient suffering from a delusional disorder.\n\nOn the other hand, it is not surprising that this ideology has become the state ideology: Putin’s myth of the Russian world is, in fact, a mystical version of the ideology of Chekism, a system of views and beliefs of a narrow group of KGB officers who hold power in Russia.\n\n\nThe ideology of Chekism\n\nRussia is ruled by elderly Soviet Chekists — Putin, Patrushev, Bortnikov and many other of their former colleagues. To understand their worldview, one needs to know the value environment in which they grew up and how it influenced them psychologically.\n\n\nHostility\n\nPutin and his entourage have been brought up in the traditions of one of the most brutal and inhumane security services in the history of the 20th century, which killed and sent millions of its own citizens to camps. Moreover, the Chekists in power are not ashamed of these “achievements” and even find justifications for them, just as they justify today’s repressions: enemies and conspiracy all around.\n\nTheir view of the world is deeply distorted by what psychology calls hostile attribution bias. This is the human tendency to see almost any action or intention of other people (or countries) as having a hostile intent. This cognitive distortion often leads to misinterpretation of reality, conflict, and aggression.\n\nResentment\n\nThe Chekist career of Russia’s current leaders came during the KGB renaissance, when the committee was headed by their idol and celestial Yuri Andropov. It was he who created the KGB’s Fifth Directorate to combat “ideological subversion of the West” — that is, foreign agents, in modern terms. Under him, punitive psychiatry against dissidents flourished, which his loyal successors have also revived in modern Russia.\n\nChekists have always had two enemies — the West and dissidents. And while they were good at fighting the defenseless citizens of their own country, they were not so good at fighting the West: the Soviet Union lost the Cold War and collapsed. This defeat developed in Andropov’s Chekists a sentiment of resentment, humiliation, and a thirst for revenge against their enemy.\n\nMachiavellianism\n\nIn the post-Soviet period, in the very “dashing 90s,” they “enriched” their Chekist mentality with a criminal one. During those years, Putin served as vice-mayor of St. Petersburg and was responsible for privatization of state-owned enterprises, casino regulation, and foreign investment. With his help, key assets in the city — the port, oil terminal, hotels, gas stations, gambling establishments - came under the control of violent criminal groups. Moreover, Putin and other Chekists did not just help the leaders of organized crime groups, who were responsible for robberies and murders; they became their full-fledged business partners.\n\nIn 1999, Putin organized perhaps the most successful special operation of his Chekist career. He personally led a provocation against “a man who resembled Prosecutor General Skuratov,” who was caught on hidden video cameras in an apartment with sex workers.  \n\nAt the time, the Prosecutor General’s Office was investigating the Swiss company Mabetex. The firm was engaged in the reconstruction of the Kremlin and, according to European law enforcement agencies, paid bribes to the entourage and family of Boris Yeltsin, who at the time actually ruled the country while the president lay in a drunken stupor. Yeltsin’s family, frightened by the investigation, turned to the then director of the FSB for protection.\n\n“Putin is personally involved in the illegal initiation of a case against me. It was his people who fabricated the material, who brought <...> the Moscow prosecutor who opened the case at night in the Kremlin,” was how Skuratov described Putin’s role in his dismissal in 2000.\n\nIn gratitude for saving him from prosecution, the Yeltsin family appointed Putin as his successor.  \n\nWith power in their hands, the Chekists began to rule Russia according to the precepts of the organizations that had shaped their mentality — the KGB and the organized crime groups. They began to take away strategic enterprises (NTV, Yukos, etc.) by raiding, intimidating dissenters, repressing dissenters, poisoning political opponents, and organizing special operations against neighboring countries.\n\nThey also adhered to the same precepts in the selection of personnel: the key government positions were appointed first of all to loyal or compromised candidates whom they had full control over. In fact, they did not choose professionals, but recruited agents, as they had been taught. The result of such a long-term “personnel policy” was negative selection: only associates of the Chekists remained in power — those who matched them in terms of incompetence.\n\nThe most appropriate term to describe such methods of governing the country is Machiavellianism. This is a state policy based on cynicism, the cult of brute force, the desire to use others for their own ends, disregard for the norms of morality and the belief that the end justifies any means.\n\nNarcissism\n\nLong years of unlimited power and permissiveness, multiplied by the efforts of their own propaganda, which for almost three decades has been creating a cult of personality of the leader (he flies a bomber, leads Siberian cranes, and threatens the “Anglo-Saxons” with a bare torso on horseback) have led Putin and his entourage to believe in their own exceptionalism, that they are the salvation of Russia, its new nobility, sent to the country by God himself. The Chekists fancied themselves Ivan the Terrible, Peter the Great and Catherine the Great.\n\nThis extreme form of narcissism is especially dangerous if a state leader suffers from it: he overestimates his own abilities, does not accept criticism, ignores advice and warnings and, as a result, makes rash and risky decisions. For example, the invasion of Ukraine.   \n\nPsychopathy\n\nMachiavellianism and narcissism, characteristic of the Chekists’ worldview, are part of the \"dark triad\" of personality, which is what modern psychology calls a combination of negative traits whose possessors pose a danger to others.  \n\nThe third pillar in this triad is psychopathy. It manifests itself in cruelty, tendency to violence, inability to empathize with other people’s grief, deceitfulness and hypocrisy.\n\nAfter two years of war with Ukraine, one can say without hesitation: Russia is ruled by real psychopaths. They give orders to demolish cities along with civilians, defiantly reward those who have committed heinous war crimes and thus encourage this practice, and threaten to nuke the planet.\n\nSadism\n\nIn recent years, some psychologists have suggested expanding the “dark triad” to a tetrad and adding another trait to Machiavellianism, narcissism and psychopathy — sadism, that is, a passion for torture, the thrill of watching other people’s suffering and pain.  \n\nLooking at the pleasure with which Yevgeny Prigozhin commented on the video of his fighter smashing a man’s head with a sledgehammer, I would say that sadism is another systemic “staple” of the ideology of the Russian world and Chekism.  \n\n\nDullness\n\nThe worldview of Putin and other ruling Chekists in Russia has another characteristic feature — a caveman-like, if we are to judge by the standards of the 21st century, dullness. They believe in the most incredible conspiracy theories, occultism and secret rites.\n\nFor example, as if it were possible to organize “a session of connection to the subconscious mind of Secretary Madeleine Albright” and read their thoughts that the U.S. wants to take away Siberia and the Far East from Russia.\n\nPutin believes that Western colonizers are exporting the genetic material of Russians to develop biological weapons. And apparently, to protect himself from attacks targeting his own biomaterial, he carries a special man with a shit suitcase everywhere he goes.\n\nAnd to rejuvenate himself, Putin, together with military officer Sergei Shoigu, takes blood baths from the cut horns of Altai red deer.\n\nTheir views on history are full of not only conspiracy theories, but also monstrous — both in their ignorance and cynicism — misconceptions, such as that it was the Poles who provoked Hitler to start World War II.\n\n\nThe ideology of Russian world and Nazism\n\nPutin’s attempts to justify Hitler are not accidental — the ideology of the Russian world is in many ways similar to that of Nazism:\n\n\nfirst, they are united by hostility towards other nations (“Anglo-Saxons” and Ukrainians, Jews and Gypsies);\nsecondly, aggressive and invasive character, which in both cases became the cause of long and bloody wars;\nthird, the idea of the exclusivity of their own nation;\nfourth, the almost sacral figure of the leader: “No Putin, no Russia”, “Hitler is Germany, Germany is Hitler.”\n\nHowever, there is a significant difference between the two. The ideology of Nazism emerged 100 years ago, and it was based on near-scientific theories popular at the time. For example, the German Nazis were inspired by the ideas of negative eugenics — the doctrine of how to combat degeneration in the human gene pool — that were widespread in the West at the time, including the United States. In other words, the very idea of racial superiority did not seem as blatant in the early 20th century as it does today.\n\nThe ideology of the Russian world emerged in the XXI century in the times of Wikipedia and ChatGPT in a country with a high level of Internet penetration. Even allies of the Russian regime laugh at its absurdity, who, trying to wash its image, have to listen to half-hour lectures about the Rurikids and Pechenegs.\n\nHowever, just a month ago, more than 16,000 Russians died for this delusion near Avdeevka, a suburb of Donetsk, equal in area to a bedroom neighborhood in Moscow, so that their spiritual leader could please the population of the country with a small victory before his fifth election.","blocks":[{"data":"What is going on in Vladimir Putin’s head, and for what values are Russians dying in Ukraine? It would seem that these are completely different questions, but if we try to answer them, we will realize that, in fact, they are about the same thing.&nbsp;&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The war in Ukraine is not only a confrontation between two armies, but also between two ideologies. If we ask Ukrainians on the front lines what they give their lives for, most of them will answer without hesitation: for freedom. Today, this is their basic and existential value: it is not something that has been handed down from above by the authorities or propaganda, there is nothing abstract about it, its necessity has been realized by the people themselves — it is their land that has been seized, it is their cities that are being wiped off the face of the earth by Russian tanks and missiles, it is they who are being <a href=\"https://www.pravda.com.ua/rus/news/2023/07/13/7411180/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">tortured</a> for speaking their native language.&nbsp;&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"If we were to ask Russians the same question — why are they dying in Ukraine? — then, hand on heart, many would probably say that they went to war to make money. But even those who joined the Russian army for ideological reasons — and there are many of them — would hardly be able to unanimously list the specific values for which they are fighting.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Unlike the Ukrainian ideology of freedom, the ideology of the Russian world is extremely abstract. And there is a simple explanation for this: it is built on an illusion, on a myth that has nothing to do with reality.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This myth originated in the heads of elderly KGB officers who have been ruling Russia for 25 years. Let’s analyze it carefully and try to understand what it can tell us about Putin’s worldview and his attitude to reality? Let’s try to psychoanalyze the Russian authorities.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":10958,"data":{"url":"https://www.youtube.com/embed/h-WzuA6HVtk","provider":"youtube","rawInput":"https://youtu.be/h-WzuA6HVtk","ratio_mobile":"16:9","ratio_desktop":"16:9"},"category":"video-embed"},"type":"video-embed"},{"data":"The ideology of the “Russian world”","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Putin <a href=\"http://kremlin.ru/events/president/news/72863\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">formulated</a> the final principles of the ideology of the “<a href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_world\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Russian world</a>” last November at the session of the World Russian People’s Council.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"First, this ideology is based on the image of the enemy — the collective West: “The West does not need such a large and multinational country as Russia. &lt;...&gt; Our diversity and unity of cultures, traditions, languages, ethnicities simply do not fit into the logic of Western racists and colonizers, into their cruel scheme of total depersonalization, disunity, suppression and exploitation.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Second, the concept of the Russian world is based on the idea of the exceptionalism and messianism of the Russian people, who for centuries have been opposing the corrupt West and defending their more spiritual and just values: “It is our country, the Russian world, as it has happened many times in history, that has blocked the way of those who claim world domination. &lt;...&gt; We are fighting now for the freedom not only of Russia, but of the whole world. &lt;...&gt; Russian is more than a nationality!”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The third distinctive feature of the ideology of the Russian world is its invasive character: it does not recognize state borders and denies national identity to other peoples. Both Putin and Patriarch Kirill have repeatedly asserted that Ukrainians and Belarusians are not separate ethnic groups, but parts of the “common Russian people.” Therefore, according to their logic, Russia has the right to \"protect\" the Russian-speaking population and annex the territories where they live.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Let us leave aside the ethical questions to these principles and ask only logical ones:&nbsp;&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li>why is the Russian world more spiritual than the West, if in reality Russia is one of the world leaders in the number of <a href=\"https://tochno.st/materials/rossiyane-chashche-vsekh-umirayut-ot-alkogolya-khotya-est-strany-gde-pyut-gorazdo-bolshe-obyasnyaem-s-chem-eto-svyazano-i-pochemu-v-etom-godu-stalo-eshche-khuzhe\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">alcohol-related deaths</a>, <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/5549246\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">suicides</a> and <a href=\"https://www.vedomosti.ru/society/news/2022/12/07/954074-rossiya-voshla-v-top-5-stran-po-vich\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">new HIV infections</a>?&nbsp;&nbsp;</li><li>why does the Russian army demolish Russian-speaking cities — Mariupol, Kharkov, Odessa, Kherson — if they are inhabited by those whom it supposedly came to protect?</li><li>Why is it that in the “just” Russian world, Ramzan Kadyrov’s 15-year-old son <a href=\"https://meduza.io/feature/2023/11/15/15-letniy-syn-ramzana-kadyrova-izbil-arestanta-v-sizo-i-poluchil-shest-ordenov-zvanie-geroya-chechni-i-otvetstvennuyu-dolzhnost-nikakogo-rassledovaniya-do-sih-por-net\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">beats up</a> a defenceless Russian in front of everyone’s eyes, brags about it in public, and receives a carload of state awards, while Sasha Skochilenko, an artist from St. Petersburg, is <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/6339183\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">imprisoned</a> for seven years for putting up peaceful stickers in a store?</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"On the one hand, these contradictions are so obvious that it seems incredible how tens of thousands of Russians could die in Ukraine for an idea that, in terms of its reasoning, is not much different from the delusions of a patient suffering from a delusional disorder.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"On the other hand, it is not surprising that this ideology has become the state ideology: Putin’s myth of the Russian world is, in fact, a mystical version of the ideology of Chekism, a system of views and beliefs of a narrow group of KGB officers who hold power in Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The ideology of Chekism","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Russia is ruled by elderly Soviet Chekists — Putin, Patrushev, Bortnikov and many other of their former colleagues. To understand their worldview, one needs to know the value environment in which they grew up and how it influenced them psychologically.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":10959,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: kremlin.ru","caption":"Federal Security Service Director Alexander Bortnikov, left, and Security Council Secretary Nikolai Patrushev before a meeting with permanent members of the Security Council of Russia, August 5, 2019.","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3fbd02d478e4fc68521d724de5a9009-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3fbd02d478e4fc68521d724de5a9009-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":740,"real_height_2x":1480},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3fbd02d478e4fc68521d724de5a9009-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3fbd02d478e4fc68521d724de5a9009-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":740,"real_height_2x":1480},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3fbd02d478e4fc68521d724de5a9009-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3fbd02d478e4fc68521d724de5a9009-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":256,"real_height_2x":512},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3fbd02d478e4fc68521d724de5a9009-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3fbd02d478e4fc68521d724de5a9009-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":256,"real_height_2x":512}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"<strong><em>Hostility</em></strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Putin and his entourage have been brought up in the traditions of one of the most brutal and inhumane security services in the history of the 20th century, which <a href=\"https://meduza.io/feature/2017/07/30/stydnye-voprosy-pro-1937-god\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">killed</a> and sent millions of its own citizens to camps. Moreover, the Chekists in power are not ashamed of these “achievements” and even <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/society/22/12/2017/5a3d6a1c9a79477b909b50f4\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">find</a> justifications for them, just as they justify today’s repressions: enemies and conspiracy all around.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Their view of the world is deeply distorted by what psychology calls <strong>hostile attribution bias</strong>. This is the human tendency to see almost any action or intention of other people (or countries) as having a hostile intent. This cognitive distortion often leads to misinterpretation of reality, conflict, and aggression.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong><em>Resentment</em></strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Chekist career of Russia’s current leaders came during the KGB renaissance, when the committee was headed by their idol and celestial Yuri Andropov. It was he who <a href=\"https://spbvedomosti.ru/news/nasledie/upravlenie-kgb-po-rabote-s-dissidentami-borba-s-ideologicheskimi-diversiyami-v-sssr/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">created</a> the KGB’s Fifth Directorate to combat “ideological subversion of the West” — that is, foreign agents, in modern terms. Under him, punitive psychiatry against dissidents <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/741690\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">flourished</a>, which his loyal successors have also <a href=\"https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2023/11/16/u-patsienta-otmechaetsia-nalichie-sverkhtsennykh-idei-o-politike\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">revived</a> in modern Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Chekists have always had two enemies — the West and dissidents. And while they were good at fighting the defenseless citizens of their own country, they were not so good at fighting the West: the Soviet Union lost the Cold War and collapsed. This defeat developed in Andropov’s Chekists a sentiment of <a href=\"https://dictionary.apa.org/resentment\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><strong>resentment</strong></a>, humiliation, and a thirst for revenge against their enemy.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong><em>Machiavellianism</em></strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In the post-Soviet period, in the very “dashing 90s,” they “enriched” their Chekist mentality with a criminal one. During those years, Putin served as vice-mayor of St. Petersburg and was <a href=\"https://www.svoboda.org/a/24203447.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">responsible</a> for privatization of state-owned enterprises, casino regulation, and foreign investment. With his help, key assets in the city — the port, oil terminal, hotels, gas stations, gambling establishments - came under the control of violent criminal groups. Moreover, Putin and other Chekists did not just help the leaders of organized crime groups, who were responsible for robberies and murders; they became their full-fledged business partners.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 1999, Putin organized perhaps the most successful special operation of his Chekist career. He personally led a provocation against “a man who resembled Prosecutor General Skuratov,” who was caught on hidden video cameras in an apartment with sex workers.&nbsp;&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At the time, the Prosecutor General’s Office was investigating the Swiss company Mabetex. The firm was engaged in the reconstruction of the Kremlin and, according to European law enforcement agencies, <a href=\"https://lenta.ru/news/1999/10/05/elzin/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">paid</a> bribes to the entourage and family of Boris Yeltsin, who at the time actually ruled the country while the president lay in a drunken stupor. Yeltsin’s family, frightened by the investigation, turned to the then director of the FSB for protection.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Putin is personally involved in the illegal initiation of a case against me. It was his people who fabricated the material, who brought &lt;...&gt; the Moscow prosecutor who opened the case at night in the Kremlin,” was how Skuratov <a href=\"https://www.svoboda.org/a/24221797.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">described</a> Putin’s role in his dismissal in 2000.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In gratitude for saving him from prosecution, the Yeltsin family appointed Putin as his successor.&nbsp;&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"With power in their hands, the Chekists began to rule Russia according to the precepts of the organizations that had shaped their mentality — the KGB and the organized crime groups. They began to take away strategic enterprises (NTV, Yukos, etc.) by raiding, intimidating dissenters, repressing dissenters, poisoning political opponents, and organizing special operations against neighboring countries.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"They also adhered to the same precepts in the selection of personnel: the key government positions were appointed first of all to loyal or compromised candidates whom they had full control over. In fact, they did not choose professionals, but recruited agents, as they had been taught. The result of such a long-term “personnel policy” was negative selection: only associates of the Chekists remained in power — those who matched them in terms of incompetence.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The most appropriate term to describe such methods of governing the country is <strong>Machiavellianism</strong>. This is a state policy based on cynicism, the cult of brute force, the desire to use others for their own ends, disregard for the norms of morality and the belief that the end justifies any means.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong><em>Narcissism</em></strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Long years of unlimited power and permissiveness, multiplied by the efforts of their own propaganda, which for almost three decades has been creating a cult of personality of the leader (he flies a bomber, leads Siberian cranes, and threatens the “Anglo-Saxons” with a bare torso on horseback) have led Putin and his entourage to believe in their own exceptionalism, that they are the <a href=\"https://www.pnp.ru/politics/volodin-vladimir-putin-spas-rossiyu-i-sdelal-ee-silnoy.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">salvation</a> of Russia, its <a href=\"https://www.svoboda.org/a/2171356.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">new nobility</a>, sent to the country by God himself. The Chekists <a href=\"https://meduza.io/feature/2023/02/23/u-nego-tri-sovetnika-ivan-groznyy-petr-velikiy-i-ekaterina-velikaya\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">fancied</a> themselves Ivan the Terrible, Peter the Great and Catherine the Great.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This extreme form of <strong>narcissism</strong> is especially dangerous if a state leader suffers from it: he overestimates his own abilities, does not accept criticism, ignores advice and warnings and, as a result, <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/opinions/2022/05/16/kak-putin-prinyal-reshenie-o-voine/index.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">makes</a> rash and risky decisions. For example, the invasion of Ukraine.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong><em>Psychopathy</em></strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Machiavellianism and narcissism, characteristic of the Chekists’ worldview, are part of the \"dark triad\" of personality, which is what modern psychology <a href=\"https://www.britannica.com/science/dark-triad\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">calls</a> a combination of negative traits whose possessors pose a danger to others.&nbsp;&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The third pillar in this triad is psychopathy. It manifests itself in cruelty, tendency to violence, inability to empathize with other people’s grief, deceitfulness and hypocrisy.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After two years of war with Ukraine, one can say without hesitation: Russia is ruled by real psychopaths. They give orders to demolish cities along with civilians, defiantly <a href=\"https://www.moscowtimes.ru/2022/04/18/putin-nagradil-za-geroizm-brigadu-stoyavshuyu-v-buche-a19648\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reward</a> those who have committed heinous war crimes and thus encourage this practice, and threaten to nuke the planet.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong><em>Sadism</em></strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In recent years, some psychologists have suggested expanding the “dark triad” to a tetrad and adding another trait to Machiavellianism, narcissism and psychopathy — <strong>sadism</strong>, that is, a passion for torture, the thrill of watching other people’s suffering and pain.&nbsp;&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Looking at the pleasure with which Yevgeny Prigozhin commented on the video of his fighter smashing a man’s head with a sledgehammer, I would say that sadism is another systemic “staple” of the ideology of the Russian world and Chekism.&nbsp;&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":10960,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Kirill Kudryavtsev / AFP / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Police disperse a demonstration in support of jailed opposition leader Alexei Navalny in Moscow on January 23, 2021","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7543a2a2811b4f748758796d63d6b55b-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7543a2a2811b4f748758796d63d6b55b-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7543a2a2811b4f748758796d63d6b55b-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7543a2a2811b4f748758796d63d6b55b-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7543a2a2811b4f748758796d63d6b55b-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7543a2a2811b4f748758796d63d6b55b-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7543a2a2811b4f748758796d63d6b55b-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7543a2a2811b4f748758796d63d6b55b-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"<strong><em>Dullness</em></strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The worldview of Putin and other ruling Chekists in Russia has another characteristic feature — a caveman-like, if we are to judge by the standards of the 21st century, dullness. They believe in the most incredible conspiracy theories, occultism and secret rites.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For example, as if it were possible to <a href=\"https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2015/06/22/64636-patrushev-i-olbrayt-kak-fraza-kremlevskih-trolley-stala-simvolom-very-kremlevskoy-elity\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">organize</a> “a session of connection to the subconscious mind of Secretary Madeleine Albright” and read their thoughts that the U.S. wants to take away Siberia and the Far East from Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Putin believes that Western colonizers are exporting the genetic material of Russians to develop biological weapons. And apparently, to protect himself from attacks targeting his own biomaterial, he carries a special man with a shit suitcase everywhere he goes.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"And to rejuvenate himself, Putin, together with military officer Sergei Shoigu, <a href=\"https://www.proekt.media/investigation/chem-boleet-putin/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">takes</a> blood baths from the cut horns of Altai red deer.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Their views on history are full of not only conspiracy theories, but also monstrous — both in their ignorance and cynicism — misconceptions, such as that it was the Poles who provoked Hitler to start World War II.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The ideology of Russian world and Nazism","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Putin’s attempts to justify Hitler are not accidental — the ideology of the Russian world is in many ways similar to that of Nazism:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li>first, they are united by hostility towards other nations (“Anglo-Saxons” and Ukrainians, Jews and Gypsies);</li><li>secondly, aggressive and invasive character, which in both cases became the cause of long and bloody wars;</li><li>third, the idea of the exclusivity of their own nation;</li><li>fourth, the almost sacral figure of the leader: “<a href=\"https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2014/10/23/no-putin-no-russia-says-kremlin-deputy-chief-of-staff-a40702\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">No Putin, no Russia</a>”, “<a href=\"https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0025913/characters/nm0381523\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Hitler is Germany, Germany is Hitler</a>.”</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"However, there is a significant difference between the two. The ideology of Nazism emerged 100 years ago, and it was based on near-scientific theories popular at the time. For example, the German Nazis were <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/blogs/2015/01/150127_blog_seva_novgorodtsev\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">inspired</a> by the ideas of negative eugenics — the doctrine of how to combat degeneration in the human gene pool — that were widespread in the West at the time, including the United States. In other words, the very idea of racial superiority did not seem as blatant in the early 20th century as it does today.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The ideology of the Russian world emerged in the XXI century in the times of Wikipedia and ChatGPT in a country with a high level of Internet penetration. Even allies of the Russian regime <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sv0JtL-oINU\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">laugh</a> at its absurdity, who, trying to wash its image, have to listen to half-hour lectures about the Rurikids and Pechenegs.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, just a month ago, more than 16,000 Russians <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/news/2024/02/19/rossiiskaya-armiya-mogla-poteryat-okolo-16-tisyach-chelovek-pri-shturme-avdeevki-provoennoe-soobshchestvo-prizivaet-rassledovat-deistviya-komandovaniya/index.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">died</a> for this delusion near Avdeevka, a suburb of Donetsk, equal in area to a bedroom neighborhood in Moscow, so that their spiritual leader could please the population of the country with a small victory before his fifth election.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":4292,"header":"The United States Could Strangle Russia. So, What is Stopping Them?","_path":"/en/opinions/2024/01/16/usa/","lead":"While the United States is more than capable of instigating a full-blown economic crisis in Russia, it’s not seen as a necessity, says Professor Oleg Itskhoki of the University of California, Los Angeles","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-1920x960px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-1920x960px_2x.png","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-1272x636px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-1272x636px_2x.png","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-912x456px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-912x456px_2x.png","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-600x400px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-600x400px_2x.png","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-360x360px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/300953030134424c983d0a0ebc7c1a79-360x360px_2x.png","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"With desire and political will, much more could have been achieved. Photo: Stephanie Scarbrough / AP / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2024-01-16","created_at_date_time":"2024-02-22T20:16:10.362Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":true,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[],"external_authors_list":[{"id":230,"first_name":"Oleg","last_name":"Itskhoki","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"professor of economics at the University of California, Los Angeles","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":1}],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"This article is based on an interview with Oleg Itskhoki\n\nOne need look no further than the steady economic growth and consistently high revenue generated from oil exports to see that, thus far, sanctions imposed against Russia have proven largely ineffective. Not only has there been no decrease in funding for the war, spending on defense and security stands at a record high, with weapons and spare parts still being readily imported into the country.\n\nHowever, with sufficient desire and political will, the United States could deal a serious blow to the Russian economy. They have not one, but three, ways of accomplishing this.\n\n\nMore oil\nDespite sanctions, income generated from oil exports constitutes a significant portion of Russia’s budget revenue and foreign currency earnings. As long as Russian oil is sold for no less than $60 per barrel, the aggressor state will continue funneling money into the war effort. However, if prices fall below this threshold, financing the war will become challenging in 2024-2025.\n\nThe United States could substantially lower the global oil price single-handedly, without resorting to sanctions. This would simply require the U.S — the world’s largest oil producer — to increase internal oil production. Currently, most of its yield is consumed domestically, with the remainder being exported internationally. How is it then that OPEC still leverages such power in the global oil market? Why doesn’t the U.S dictate its own terms? Indeed, in response to OPEC+ nations reducing production in any way, the U.S could simply accelerate its output of shale oil. In 2022, shale oil accounted for 66% of total U.S crude oil production (7.8 out of 11.9 million barrels per day). In 2023, American companies increased general production by a million barrels (to 12.9 million). \n\nThe U.S Energy Information Administration (EIA) predicts that output will increase by 300,000 barrels per day this year, and by 200,000 per day next year. Analysts make even bolder forecasts: production could increase by 500,000 barrels per day in 2024.\n\nThe fact is, American companies could be producing more oil — not 13 million barrels per day, but say, 15.\n\n\nPresident Joe Biden, despite the presiding green agenda, called for oil companies to increase production and approved a major new drilling development in Alaska. When oil prices exceeded $100 per barrel in the aftermath of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, major players like Exxon and Chevron, failed to increase extraction rates significantly, fearing a collapse in prices. However, by the end of 2022, several smaller companies and hundreds of private firms stepped up their output rate. Experts suggest that at this rate, the United States could reach 15 million barrels per day within five years.\n\nTo facilitate continued industry growth, the American administration could ensure that companies benefit from guaranteed profitability. Promising, for instance, that in the event of a collapse in global oil prices, domestic rates wouldn’t drop below $80 per barrel for an entire year. Then, the overall increase in production would be far greater than any fluctuations in oil output from Saudi Arabia. This would enable the U.S to not only lower global oil prices, reducing Russia’s revenues, but also acquire a substantial share of the world market. This is a feasible prospect.\n\n\nMore ammunition\nSimilarly, the U.S could easily resolve Ukraine’s ammunition shortage. According to a research group at the Kiel Institute, since the beginning of the war, the United States and their allies have transferred $100 billion worth of ammunition, missiles, and tanks to Ukraine. However, this isn’t enough.\n\n\nTo increase the production of necessary weaponry, the U.S government could implement the Defense Production Act (used in instances where the U.S is involved in a war, directly or indirectly), which would allow for the subsidization of armament manufacturers.\n\nThe U.S has the capacity to increase its military expenditure. In 2022, defense spending amounted to 3.1% of GDP, close to the lowest level since World War II. Even if the $106 billion President Biden requested in aid for Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan were to be added to this total, the gross amount would still only be around 3.6% of GDP. For comparison, this is significantly less than the 4.6% spent at the height of the Iraq and Afghanistan wars in 2010, not to mention the 8.9% in 1968, during the Vietnam War.\n\nWith the Defense Production Act, the U.S could increase military production rates exponentially. This hasn’t happened, which prolongs the war in Ukraine and its associated losses.\n\nAs political scientist Kirill Rogov proposes, if countries massively exceed ammunition production requirements, say tenfold, then wars can be avoided. Ironically, the ammunition then wouldn’t be necessary. Perversely however, if barely enough ammunition is produced, then actors like Putin will emerge, wanting to test the limits of the West’s resilience.\n\nA study conducted by economists at the Kellogg School of Management found that if third countries intervene in the conflict, they must do so decisively and provide absolute support. In other words, quickly bolstering Ukraine’s power and ensuring that Russia knows about it. Otherwise, this would lead to nothing more than a senseless prolongation of the conflict.\n\n\nThe terrorist label\nCircumstances suggest that now would be an appropriate and reasonable time to recognize Russia as a state sponsor of terrorism (currently there are four such nations: Iran, North Korea, Cuba, and Syria). This status imposes restrictions on aid from the U.S, a ban on the export and sale of military products, control over the export of dual-use goods, and automatic exclusion from the international financial system. Consequences would also be brought upon any government participating in arms deals with Russia, who risk the imposition of secondary sanctions. For American companies, practically any dealings with Russia would become high risk.\n\n\nFurthermore, such a status deprives a country of immunity privileges. U.S courts would therefore be at liberty to consider lawsuits brought against Russia, with any victims of the country’s terrorist activities being eligible for financial compensation, derived in part from the seizure of frozen Russian assets.\n\nThis would greatly complicate all trade with Russia, including the export of Russian goods and the import of microchips for weapons production, currently occurring despite numerous preventative sanctions. Russian international trade would be forced to resort to bartering oil in exchange for consumer goods through intermediary countries, as was the case during the Soviet era.\n\nThe U.S State Department must make the final status decision, but Anthony Blinken, the Secretary of State, appears to have removed the option from the table. This arouses disappointment in several camps — Ukraine, who has lobbied for the measure since April 2022, and several American politicians, like former Speaker of the House of Representatives, Nancy Pelosi, also vehemently expressing support. President Biden openly declared his view that labeling Russia a “terrorist state” is unnecessary. During a press conference in September 2022, he was asked whether Russia should be assigned this status, to which he replied “No”, but didn’t elaborate further.\n\n\nWhat is stopping them?\nEach method comes at a price.\n\nA rapid increase in oil production isn’t being considered for two reasons. The United States dislikes heavily intervening in market mechanisms and seeks to avoid it at any cost.\nAdditionally, the Biden administration doesn’t want to delay the green transition (the phasing out of fossil fuels in favor of renewable energy sources — RES). Furthermore, high oil prices are beneficial to the transition since consumers, keen to acquire products at a lower rate, are inclined to switch to subsidized RES. Therefore, the high oil prices generated by the actions of OPEC+, are viewed advantageously by U.S authorities.\n\nFor the Democrats, the green agenda is of greater importance than reducing Russia’s oil revenues. For those concerned by the war in Ukraine, this may seem like a misplaced priority. From the American perspective, however, the war is a far-flung regional conflict, whereas the green transition is the greatest global issue of the current decade.\n\nEconomists believe that enforcing low prices for oil producers and high prices for consumers is the optimum scenario. In other words, substantial taxes on hydrocarbon use are needed to separate producer and consumer rates. This would allow for taxes, rather than high oil prices, to become the primary driver towards the green transition. But, obviously, the concept of higher taxes on gasoline wouldn’t be particularly appealing to the general electorate. It’s difficult to imagine the U.S imposing a 300% tax on fuel or gasoline-powered cars, as is the case in certain European nations.\n\nAs for arms production, the delay boils down to not just insufficient funding, but also a lack of capacity, which the United States is doing little to resolve. Even the plan to double the production of anti-tank Javelin missiles had to be postponed from 2024 to 2026.\n\nAttempts are being made to overcome this restriction by shifting production to other countries. Proposed plans will see Poland manufacture Javelin missiles developed in the U.S, while German companies are set to produce parts for the Lockheed Martin F-35 fighter jet and a new missile system.\n\nIn summer 2022, the U.S State Department spoke out against labeling Russia a “sponsor of terrorism” out of concern for the grain deal, according to Politico. The main issue is that the United States doesn’t want 5.5 million barrels per day of Russian oil to disappear from the world market and subsequently trigger a significant increase in global oil prices. Presumably, the implementation of such an important measure is being reserved in case of a substantial escalation of Russian aggression beyond Ukraine.\n\nThe fundamental reason why none of the three aforementioned measures have been implemented is that American politicians, as well as the public, aren’t overly concerned or afraid of Putin. Perhaps they believe that he has already been sufficiently constrained and weakened by this war, which is set to continue for several more years — a factor which doesn’t seem of particular concern to the U.S.\n\nComparing the United States’ attitude towards the threat from Russia with the threat from, say, China, one witnesses a considerable disparity. The prospect of confrontation with China is seen by American society as a matter of serious concern, unlike the confrontation with Putin. This may yet prove to be a short-sighted world view.\n\nThe methods we have examined are all viable options which should have been deployed by the U.S if all this were happening during the Cold War. It’s interesting to imagine what the world would be like now if Ronald Reagan, who declared the Soviet Union an empire of evil on the eve of its collapse, were the President of the United States today? Perhaps, one of the current Republican candidates, Nikki Haley, might still show us what could have been. \n\nTranslated by Sasha Molotkova","blocks":[{"data":"<em>This article is based on an interview with Oleg Itskhoki</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"One need look no further than the steady economic growth and consistently high revenue generated from oil exports to see that, thus far, sanctions imposed against Russia have proven largely <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/opinions/2023/12/20/razocharovanie-goda-sanktsii-rossiiskuyu-ekonomiku-razrushat-ne-oni-a-voina/index.html?_gl=1*66vhdb*_ga*MTQ5MjU3MDA4NS4xNzA1MzkzODc2*_ga_86829926PE*MTcwNzMwNzMyNi4xOC4wLjE3MDczMDczMjYuMC4wLjA.\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">ineffective</a>. Not only has there been no decrease in funding for the war, spending on defense and security stands at a record high, with weapons and spare parts still being readily imported into the country.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, with sufficient desire and political will, the United States could deal a serious blow to the Russian economy. They have not one, but three, ways of accomplishing this.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"More oil","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Despite sanctions, income generated from oil exports constitutes a significant portion of Russia’s budget revenue and foreign currency earnings. As long as Russian oil is sold for <a href=\"https://minfin.gov.ru/ru/press-center/?id_4=38813-o_srednei_tsene_na_neft_marki_urals\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">no less</a> than $60 per barrel, the aggressor state will continue funneling money into the war effort. However, if prices fall below this threshold, financing the war will become challenging in 2024-2025.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The United States could substantially lower the global oil price single-handedly, without resorting to sanctions. This would simply require the U.S — the world’s largest oil producer — to increase internal oil production. Currently, most of its yield is consumed domestically, with the remainder being exported internationally. How is it then that OPEC still leverages such power in the global oil market? Why doesn’t the U.S dictate its own terms? Indeed, in response to OPEC+ nations reducing production in any way, the U.S could simply accelerate its output of shale oil. In 2022, shale oil <a href=\"https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=847&amp;t=\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">accounted</a> for 66% of total U.S crude oil production (7.8 out of 11.9 million barrels per day). In 2023, American companies <a href=\"https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/steo/report/petro_prod.php\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">increased</a> general production by a million barrels (to 12.9 million).&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The U.S Energy Information Administration (EIA) predicts that output will increase by 300,000 barrels per day this year, and by 200,000 per day next year. Analysts make even bolder <a href=\"https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/01/business/energy-environment/us-oil-production-record-climate.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">forecasts</a>: production could increase by 500,000 barrels per day in 2024.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The fact is, American companies could be producing more oil — not 13 million barrels per day, but say, 15.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":10671,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/0a7ae2a55cae45df9fceb40c180766c0/index.html","ratio_mobile":"3:4","ratio_desktop":"16:9"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"President Joe Biden, despite the presiding green agenda, called for oil companies to increase production and approved a major new drilling development in Alaska. When oil prices exceeded $100 per barrel in the aftermath of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, major players like Exxon and Chevron, <a href=\"https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/01/business/energy-environment/us-oil-production-record-climate.html?auth=login-google1tap&amp;login=google1tap\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">failed</a> to increase extraction rates significantly, fearing a collapse in prices. However, by the end of 2022, several smaller companies and hundreds of private firms stepped up their output rate. <a href=\"https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/01/business/energy-environment/us-oil-production-record-climate.html?auth=login-google1tap&amp;login=google1tap\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Experts suggest</a> that at this rate, the United States could reach 15 million barrels per day within five years.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"To facilitate continued industry growth, the American administration could ensure that companies benefit from guaranteed profitability. Promising, for instance, that in the event of a collapse in global oil prices, domestic rates wouldn’t drop below $80 per barrel for an entire year. Then, the overall increase in production would be far greater than any fluctuations in oil output from Saudi Arabia. This would enable the U.S to not only lower global oil prices, reducing Russia’s revenues, but also acquire a substantial share of the world market. This is a feasible prospect.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"More ammunition","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Similarly, the U.S could easily resolve Ukraine’s ammunition shortage. <a href=\"https://www.wsj.com/world/ukraine-goes-to-washington-with-a-new-ask-help-us-make-our-own-weapons-664c97b9\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">According to</a> a research group at the Kiel Institute, since the beginning of the war, the United States and their allies have transferred $100 billion worth of ammunition, missiles, and tanks to Ukraine. However, this isn’t enough.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":10673,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: HANNIBAL HANSCHKE / EPA / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"HIMARS have caused considerable problems for the Russian army","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/899a52bf3c0f4af3964acbbef063df16-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/899a52bf3c0f4af3964acbbef063df16-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":673,"real_height_2x":1346},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/899a52bf3c0f4af3964acbbef063df16-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/899a52bf3c0f4af3964acbbef063df16-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":673,"real_height_2x":1346},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/899a52bf3c0f4af3964acbbef063df16-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/899a52bf3c0f4af3964acbbef063df16-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":232,"real_height_2x":465},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/899a52bf3c0f4af3964acbbef063df16-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/899a52bf3c0f4af3964acbbef063df16-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":232,"real_height_2x":465}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"To increase the production of necessary weaponry, the U.S government could implement the <a href=\"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/COMPS-8323/uslm/COMPS-8323.xml\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Defense Production Act</a> (used in instances where the U.S is involved in a war, directly or indirectly), which would allow for the subsidization of armament manufacturers.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The U.S has the capacity to increase its military expenditure. In 2022, defense spending <a href=\"https://www.wsj.com/economy/the-u-s-can-afford-a-bigger-military-we-just-cant-build-it-7edd0e74\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">amounted</a> to 3.1% of GDP, close to the lowest level since World War II. Even if the $106 billion President Biden requested in aid for Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan were to be added to this total, the gross amount would still only be around 3.6% of GDP. For comparison, this is significantly less than the 4.6% spent at the height of the Iraq and Afghanistan wars in 2010, not to mention the 8.9% in 1968, during the Vietnam War.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"With the Defense Production Act, the U.S could increase military production rates exponentially. This hasn’t happened, which prolongs the war in Ukraine and its associated losses.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"As political scientist Kirill Rogov proposes, if countries massively exceed ammunition production requirements, say tenfold, then wars can be avoided. Ironically, the ammunition then wouldn’t be necessary. Perversely however, if barely enough ammunition is produced, then actors like Putin will emerge, wanting to test the limits of the West’s resilience.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A <a href=\"https://insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/why-do-long-wars-happen\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">study</a> conducted by economists at the Kellogg School of Management found that if third countries intervene in the conflict, they must do so decisively and provide absolute support. In other words, quickly bolstering Ukraine’s power and ensuring that Russia knows about it. Otherwise, this would lead to nothing more than a senseless prolongation of the conflict.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The terrorist label","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Circumstances suggest that now would be an appropriate and reasonable time to recognize Russia as a state sponsor of terrorism (currently there are <a href=\"https://www.state.gov/state-sponsors-of-terrorism/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">four</a> such nations: Iran, North Korea, Cuba, and Syria). This status <a href=\"https://www.state.gov/terrorist-designations-and-state-sponsors-of-terrorism/#eo13224\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">imposes</a> restrictions on aid from the U.S, a ban on the export and sale of military products, control over the export of dual-use goods, and automatic exclusion from the international financial system. Consequences would also be brought upon any government participating in arms deals with Russia, who risk the imposition of secondary sanctions. For American companies, practically any dealings with Russia would become <a href=\"https://www.politico.com/news/2022/07/20/pelosi-to-blinken-label-russia-as-terrorist-state-or-else-congress-will-00047076\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">high risk</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":10674,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Boris Roessler / dpa / Scanpix / LETA","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd195765dc2145929ee2400ea641f113-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd195765dc2145929ee2400ea641f113-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":819,"real_height_2x":1638},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd195765dc2145929ee2400ea641f113-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd195765dc2145929ee2400ea641f113-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":819,"real_height_2x":1638},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd195765dc2145929ee2400ea641f113-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd195765dc2145929ee2400ea641f113-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":283,"real_height_2x":566},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd195765dc2145929ee2400ea641f113-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cd195765dc2145929ee2400ea641f113-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":283,"real_height_2x":566}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Furthermore, such a status deprives a country of immunity privileges. U.S courts would therefore be at liberty to consider lawsuits brought against Russia, with any victims of the country’s terrorist activities being eligible for financial compensation, derived in part from the seizure of frozen Russian assets.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This would greatly complicate all trade with Russia, including the export of Russian goods and the import of microchips for weapons production, currently occurring despite numerous preventative sanctions. Russian international trade would be forced to resort to bartering oil in exchange for consumer goods through intermediary countries, as was the case during the Soviet era.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The U.S State Department must make the final status decision, but Anthony Blinken, the Secretary of State, appears to have removed the option from the table. This arouses disappointment in several camps — Ukraine, who has <a href=\"https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2022/04/15/zelensky-biden-russia-terrorism/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">lobbied</a> for the measure since April 2022, and several American politicians, like former Speaker of the House of Representatives, Nancy Pelosi, also vehemently expressing <a href=\"https://www.lgraham.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2022/5/graham-blumenthal-introduce-resolution-on-russian-state-sponsorship-of-terrorism\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">support</a>. President Biden openly declared his view that labeling Russia a “terrorist state” is unnecessary. During a press conference in September 2022, he was <a href=\"https://www.reuters.com/world/russia-should-not-be-branded-terrorism-sponsor-biden-says-2022-09-06/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">asked</a> whether Russia should be assigned this status, to which he replied “No”, but didn’t elaborate further.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"What is stopping them?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Each method comes at a price.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A rapid increase in oil production isn’t being considered for two reasons. The United States dislikes heavily intervening in market mechanisms and seeks to avoid it at any cost.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Additionally, the Biden administration doesn’t want to delay the green transition (the phasing out of fossil fuels in favor of renewable energy sources — RES). Furthermore, high oil prices are beneficial to the transition since consumers, keen to acquire products at a lower rate, are inclined to switch to subsidized RES. Therefore, the high oil prices generated by the actions of OPEC+, are viewed advantageously by U.S authorities.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For the Democrats, the green agenda is of greater importance than reducing Russia’s oil revenues. For those concerned by the war in Ukraine, this may seem like a misplaced priority. From the American perspective, however, the war is a far-flung regional conflict, whereas the green transition is the greatest global issue of the current decade.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Economists believe that enforcing low prices for oil producers and high prices for consumers is the optimum scenario. In other words, substantial taxes on hydrocarbon use are needed to separate producer and consumer rates. This would allow for taxes, rather than high oil prices, to become the primary driver towards the green transition. But, obviously, the concept of higher taxes on gasoline wouldn’t be particularly appealing to the general electorate. It’s difficult to imagine the U.S imposing a 300% tax on fuel or gasoline-powered cars, as is the case in certain European nations.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"As for arms production, the delay boils down to not just insufficient funding, but also a lack of capacity, which the United States is doing little to resolve. Even the plan to double the production of anti-tank Javelin missiles had to be <a href=\"https://www.wsj.com/economy/the-u-s-can-afford-a-bigger-military-we-just-cant-build-it-7edd0e74\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">postponed</a> from 2024 to 2026.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Attempts are being made to overcome this restriction by shifting production to other countries. Proposed <a href=\"https://www.wsj.com/politics/national-security/u-s-arms-makers-look-overseas-to-boost-stockpiles-1e1d6eac\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">plans</a> will see Poland manufacture Javelin missiles developed in the U.S, while German companies are set to produce parts for the Lockheed Martin F-35 fighter jet and a new missile system.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":10672,"data":{"text":"Your donation will help us continue telling the truth","title":"Support Important Stories","buttonText":"Donate"},"category":"donate-embed"},"type":"donate-embed"},{"data":"In summer 2022, the U.S State Department spoke out against labeling Russia a “sponsor of terrorism” out of concern for the grain deal, according to <a href=\"https://www.politico.com/news/2022/07/20/pelosi-to-blinken-label-russia-as-terrorist-state-or-else-congress-will-00047076\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Politico</a>. The main issue is that the United States doesn’t want 5.5 million barrels per day of Russian oil to disappear from the world market and subsequently trigger a significant increase in global oil prices. Presumably, the implementation of such an important measure is being reserved in case of a substantial escalation of Russian aggression beyond Ukraine.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The fundamental reason why none of the three aforementioned measures have been implemented is that American politicians, as well as the public, aren’t overly concerned or afraid of Putin. Perhaps they believe that he has already been sufficiently constrained and weakened by this war, which is set to continue for several more years — a factor which doesn’t seem of particular concern to the U.S.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Comparing the United States’ attitude towards the threat from Russia with the threat from, say, China, one witnesses a considerable disparity.&nbsp;The prospect of confrontation with China is seen by American society as a matter of serious concern, unlike the confrontation with Putin. This may yet prove to be a short-sighted world view.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The methods we have examined are all viable options which should have been deployed by the U.S if all this were happening during the Cold War. It’s interesting to imagine what the world would be like now if Ronald Reagan, who declared the Soviet Union an empire of evil on the eve of its collapse, were the President of the United States today? Perhaps, one of the current Republican candidates, <a href=\"https://nikkihaley.com/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Nikki Haley</a>, might still show us what could have been.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>Translated by Sasha Molotkova</em>","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":4083,"header":"The Disappointment of 2023: Sanctions. Only the War can Destroy the Russian Economy Now","_path":"/en/opinions/2023/12/20/sanctions-2023/","lead":"Emerging seemingly unscathed, Russia continues to sell oil and purchase components for weapons production, while only losing minor sums in the process. Professor Oleg Itskhoki from the University of California, Los Angeles, explains why this is the case.","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-1920x960px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-1920x960px_2x.png","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-1272x636px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-1272x636px_2x.png","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-912x456px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-912x456px_2x.png","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-600x400px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-600x400px_2x.png","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-360x360px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03914d2dea83428c8438e2635799d2fc-360x360px_2x.png","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"AFP / SCANPIX / LETA","created_at_date":"2023-12-20","created_at_date_time":"2024-02-01T14:41:58.499Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[],"external_authors_list":[{"id":230,"first_name":"Oleg","last_name":"Itskhoki","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"professor of economics at the University of California, Los Angeles","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":1}],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"This article was based on an interview with Oleg Itskhoki, with some editorial additions.\n\nWith sanctions imposed against Russia failing to achieve their intended goals, many have branded them a disappointment. Nevertheless, they did produce a result, just not one that anybody was expecting.\n\nThe objectives\nThe three main objectives were:\n\nRestrict arms production (and generate discontent among the general population by depriving them of their accustomed way of life, plus undermine the country’s long-term economic prospects). To facilitate this, the supply of many goods, equipment, and technologies (especially microchips and semiconductors), was prohibited immediately after the start of the war. The list of restricted items continues to grow.\n\nDeprive the aggressor of funds to finance the war. Following the outbreak of war, $300 billion worth of Russian international reserves were frozen. Another blow was dealt in December 2022: EU countries imposed an embargo on the purchase of Russian oil, and the G7, EU, and Australia set a price cap of $60 per barrel on Russian oil transported by sea (which affects a large portion of the oil exported outside the EU).\n\nHinder and complicate all economic interactions with the outside world. To enable this, almost all Russian banks were disconnected from the SWIFT financial messaging system.  \n\nGlass half empty\nInitially, the sanctions seemed to be working. The price of Urals oil, Russia’s flagship crude oil grade, dropped below the cap. Oil and gas revenues also decreased significantly at the start of 2023, and a large deficit emerged. Our analysis of customs data revealed that the supply of sanctioned goods from the EU fell close to zero, with imports from other countries only subsidizing the losses by a quarter. However, Russia soon found a way to circumvent the retributive measures.\nThe pace at which global oil distribution managed to adapt was particularly surprising. Europe quickly found a substitute for Russian oil: Russia now constitutes only 3% of the EU’s total oil imports (compared to 28% before the war). In the meantime, Russia redirected their exports to China (which now buys 55%, compared to just 20% a year and a half ago), India and Turkey.\nThe effectiveness of the price cap has also been called into question. Although the price of Russian oil is well below the market rate, the disparity isn’t as significant as before the cap was introduced in 2022. Crucially, Urals oil constitutes only a fraction of Russia’s total exports, with everything leaving Pacific ports and Far Eastern pipelines still operating at the global market price. We were able to establish this through analysis of customs declaration data.\nThe same is true with the import ban. Western countries have been unable to guarantee that semiconductors and other critical components used in the production of weapons will not enter Russia and be used for missile manufacturing. Microchips continue to be an accessible commodity and foreign components are frequently found in crashed Russian missiles that were manufactured following the outbreak of the war.\nBy the end of 2022, imports into Russia had evidently resumed. Economists debated when this would happen. It turned out that if exports are generating money, imports will naturally follow. When consumers are willing to overpay substantially for items, enterprising sellers will always appear, and this is highly disappointing.\nThis year, Russian economic growth will exceed expectations and the trend is set to continue in the new year. The budget deficit is shrinking, with oil and gas revenues set to meet last year’s annual targets.\nCan the glass be filled?\nIt’s unclear whether totally eliminating the supply of components critical for missile production is even possible. With buyers willing to fork out massive sums, even the trunk of a car can prove to be a bountiful method of smuggling in items like microchips. Only tightened controls could make this task more difficult and expensive.\nSanctions are only as effective as the West wants them to be. In this sense, sanctions have been majorly disappointing.\nWestern countries were terrified by the sudden surge in oil prices. Therefore, they tried to ensure that Russia was able to continue supplying 5 million barrels of oil per day to the world market, whilst not receiving the level of income they had previously enjoyed. Thus, a new type of sanction was chosen — the price cap. This was the first time it had ever been implemented, meaning the extent of its potential success was uncertain. As a result, Europe defied the advice of economists and imposed the embargo on Russian oil not in March 2022, but December. With the actual announcement of the embargo coming six months prior to its implementation, EU nations were provided with the opportunity to prepare. Russia, of course, was also able to utilize this time to their advantage.\nImproving the effectiveness of sanctions is dependent on control and, ultimately, the resources that Western nations are willing to deploy. The U.S Treasury believes that it’s important that they’re allocated correctly. It may end up being cheaper to send $60 billion and provide weapons to Ukraine every year than to impose financial sanctions and stricter export and import controls. I don’t have the data to correctly say whether the U.S Treasury is making the correct decision.\nThe United States could, for example, invest in increasing oil production as a means of reducing prices. This would slow down their “green transition” and for the U.S this holds global value, whereas the war in Ukraine is a localized conflict between two Slavic nations. From the European perspective, the considerations are somewhat different: the war is being fought in their backyard and the costs for Europe are significantly higher.\nThe sanctions’ success is reliant upon cooperation from China, India, and possibly other countries. If there’s willingness to cooperate, any country could become an ally. Given this, at least in the eyes of the United States, the problem isn’t serious enough to warrant compromise with China.\nAmerican politicians aren’t overly concerned about Putin. They understand who he is and aren’t particularly afraid of him. From their perspective, the threat from China is considerably greater. Therefore, depriving Putin of export revenues isn’t particularly high up on their list of priorities. Perhaps they think that Putin is already sufficiently constrained and weakened by this war. The fact that it may last several years also doesn’t seem particularly catastrophic for the U.S. This may prove to be a short-sighted perspective.\n\nGlass half full\nAlthough the sanctions haven’t been as effective as initially hoped, they have brought some notable successes.\nSurprisingly, smaller financial sanctions had more substantial consequences than the restrictions on oil. The current state of the ruble is largely due to the Central Bank’s inability to use dollars and euros for currency interventions. Their only alternatives are the Yuan and gold, which are largely ineffective assets for managing the currency market. Subsequently, they must resort to more repressive measures like the mandatory sale of foreign currency earnings.\nA definite success has been the European embargo on oil and oil products. If, before the war, half of Russia’s oil exports went to Europe, now it’s less than 10% (with the exemption of four countries).\nThe important thing is that Russia is losing money. Sanctions have significantly increased import costs. An optimistic assessment suggests that oil sanctions reduce their export revenues by 15%, which is an annual loss of approximately $30 billion. However, a substantial portion of these funds end up in Russian offshore structures, rather than in Russia itself. Some additional payments for transportation may also be entering these structures. Hence, the $30 billion is a generous estimate. Its inconsequential who exactly has been left out of pocket, Siluanov or Sechin (referring to Anton Siluanov, the Minister of Finance, and Igor Sechin, the CEO of Russia’s largest state-owned oil company, Rosneft — iStories). In the end, it’s a shared pocket, and the money inside can easily be moved around by order of the president.\nIf it weren’t for the sanctions, the billions of dollars that Russia loses through oil exports and overpayments for imported goods, would be spent on the war. Since the war is now the primary source of budget expenditure, the question over the effectiveness of sanctions is akin to debating whether the glass is half empty or half full.\nThe glass is gradually filling up\nGenerally, sanctions can work in two ways:\nOrchestrate a sudden financial crisis from the outset. This didn’t occur as extremely high export revenues in the first months of the war stabilized the economy. The realistic attainability of this is questionable: can a financial crisis be triggered by external actors when a state has a budget and trade surplus (exports exceed imports), a non-dollarized economy and non-dollarized loans. It seems that under such conditions a financial crisis can always be avoided. So, even if there were more sanctions at the start, the Russian economy would likely have stabilized anyway. Unfortunately, we can only speculate what might have happened if the EU had imposed the embargo on Russian gas and oil immediately.\n\nExert long-term pressure on the economy and budget. This pressure is being felt. In 2024, alternative sources of budget revenue must be found, and it’s unclear what they will be. Additional taxes, which will reduce productivity and economic growth rates, are the most obvious option.\n\nObviously, the existing sanctions are insufficient to prevent Russia from financing the war in the coming years. There will be enough money in 2024 and, most likely, in 2025, if oil prices don’t drop significantly. However, if they fall below $60 per barrel, financing the war could become challenging. Pre-Covid budgets were balanced at $45 per barrel of Urals, but now this is barely being managed at almost $80 per barrel. And the sanctions will hopefully cut the budget by 5, 10, 15 or more percent. This is set to continue for years, ultimately yielding a cumulative effect.\nHowever, in the long term, it’s the war, and not the sanctions, that is most frightening for Russia. Economically devastating, the war is currently draining 10% of the country’s GDP (that’s more than Ukraine’s entire pre-war GDP!). Even if the conflict ends and Putin remains in power, the Russian economy will remain on a war footing. It couldn’t survive otherwise, with weapons production continuing in case of an unexpected enemy retaliation.\nThis is a logical move, both militarily and economically. Stopping the 10% of GDP spending would trigger a severe crisis. The stimulation that is currently being provided by the state defense order is keeping the economy afloat and even encouraging some growth. The injection of these large sums must continue just to keep the economy at the current level, regardless of whether the war continues or not.\nThe state’s enormous military expenditure will continue for as long as Putin’s government can afford it. In other words, provided that the price of oil remains high. We may see a repeat of what happened with the Soviet Union, where falling oil prices triggered a massive crisis and transformational decline. The 10% of GDP would subsequently disappear, but before that, windfall oil revenues would vanish, and all the savings of the National Wealth Fund would be spent.\nTo assess the true magnitude of Russia’s economic losses, one mustn’t consider just specific figures, but compare them with what they might have been given the same oil prices, without the war. This would show that GDP could have risen by 5%, but it hasn’t. The other question is, would oil cost the same as it does now without the war? People often say that Putin is perpetually lucky. He’s not lucky — he’s an agent of chaos in the global economy. The chaos he creates is what leads to the rise in oil prices.\n\nTranslated by Sasha Molotkova","blocks":[{"data":"<em>This article was based on an interview with Oleg Itskhoki, with some editorial additions.</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"With sanctions imposed against Russia failing to achieve their intended goals, many have branded them a disappointment. Nevertheless, they did produce a result, just not one that anybody was expecting.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>The objectives</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The three main objectives were:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li><strong>Restrict arms production</strong> (and generate discontent among the general population by depriving them of their accustomed way of life, plus undermine the country’s long-term economic prospects). To facilitate this, the supply of many goods, equipment, and technologies (especially microchips and semiconductors), was prohibited immediately after the start of the war. The list of restricted items continues to grow.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<li><strong>Deprive the aggressor of funds to finance the war</strong>. Following the outbreak of war, $300 billion worth of Russian international reserves were <a href=\"https://www.forbes.ru/finansy/466741-evrosouz-vpervye-nazval-summu-zamorozennyh-aktivov-rossijskogo-centrobanka\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">frozen</a>. Another blow was dealt in December 2022: EU countries imposed an embargo on the purchase of Russian oil, and the G7, EU, and Australia set a price cap of $60 per barrel on Russian oil transported by sea (which affects a large portion of the oil exported outside the EU).</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<li><strong>Hinder and complicate all economic interactions with the outside world.</strong> To enable this, almost all Russian banks were disconnected from the SWIFT financial messaging system.&nbsp;&nbsp;</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":{"id":10409,"data":{"block":"<p>The purpose of the EU oil embargo was to cut Russia off from its largest consumer. It was clear that Russia would then seek to sell the oil to other countries where it could only be delivered by sea. Therefore, a price cap was imposed and subsequently enforced through an order forbidding the provision of any services related to the delivery of oil purchased from Russia above the “cap” (transportation, insurance etc.). The scheme was based upon the understanding that Russia primarily used European tankers, and the Association of British Insurers controls 95% of the maritime insurance market.</p><p><br/></p><p>The import ban covers a vast array of goods. Notably, any products which may be used to produce weaponry cannot be imported into Russia or via Russia to a third country. Furthermore, EU nations have the right to prohibit the supply of such goods to third countries if they have reason to believe that they will end up in Russia.</p><p><br/></p><p>The sanctions enforced upon most major banks and their disconnection from SWIFT constitutes a de facto ban on financial operations in dollars, euros, and the currencies of other countries implementing the sanctions. Russia now refers to these currencies as “toxic,” with most foreign trade transactions now being conducted in rubles, yuan, and the currencies of other “friendly” nations.</p>","header":"How the sanctions work","content":[{"insert":"The purpose of the EU oil embargo was to cut Russia off from its largest consumer. It was clear that Russia would then seek to sell the oil to other countries where it could only be delivered by sea. Therefore, a price cap was imposed and subsequently enforced through an order forbidding the provision of any services related to the delivery of oil purchased from Russia above the “cap” (transportation, insurance etc.). The scheme was based upon the understanding that Russia primarily used European tankers, and the Association of British Insurers controls 95% of the maritime insurance market.\n\nThe import ban covers a vast array of goods. Notably, any products which may be used to produce weaponry cannot be imported into Russia or via Russia to a third country. Furthermore, EU nations have the right to prohibit the supply of such goods to third countries if they have reason to believe that they will end up in Russia.\n\nThe sanctions enforced upon most major banks and their disconnection from SWIFT constitutes a de facto ban on financial operations in dollars, euros, and the currencies of other countries implementing the sanctions. Russia now refers to these currencies as “toxic,” with most foreign trade transactions now being conducted in rubles, yuan, and the currencies of other “friendly” nations.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Glass half empty</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Initially, the sanctions seemed to be working. The price of Urals oil, Russia’s flagship crude oil grade, <a href=\"https://istories.media/opinions/2023/05/11/sanktsii-zarabotali-a-rossiya-net/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">dropped below the cap</a>. Oil and gas revenues also decreased significantly at the start of 2023, and a large deficit emerged. Our analysis of customs data revealed that the supply of sanctioned goods from the EU fell close to zero, with imports from other countries only subsidizing the losses <a href=\"https://istories.media/opinions/2023/06/08/kak-rabotayut-sanktsii-rossiya-smogla-zamestit-lish-chetvert-poteryannogo-importa/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">by a quarter</a>. However, Russia soon found a way to circumvent the retributive measures.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The pace at which global oil distribution managed to adapt was particularly surprising. Europe quickly found a substitute for Russian oil: Russia now <a href=\"https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php?title=EU_trade_with_Russia_-_latest_developments&amp;stable=0&amp;redirect=no#Latest_developments\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">constitutes</a> only 3% of the EU’s total oil imports (compared to 28% before the war). In the meantime, Russia redirected their exports to China (which now buys 55%, compared to just 20% a year and a half ago), India and Turkey.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The effectiveness of the price cap has also been called into question. Although the price of Russian oil is well below the market rate, the disparity isn’t as significant as before the cap was introduced in 2022.&nbsp;Crucially, Urals oil constitutes only a fraction of Russia’s total exports, with everything leaving Pacific ports and Far Eastern pipelines still operating at the global market price. We were able to <a href=\"https://istories.media/opinions/2023/05/11/sanktsii-zarabotali-a-rossiya-net/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">establish</a> this through analysis of customs declaration data.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":10410,"data":{"block":"<p>To bypass Western freight carriers and insurers adhering to the cap, Russia created a shadow fleet by purchasing old tankers, often decommissioned for scrap metal. This fleet <a href=\"https://energyandcleanair.org/october-2023-monthly-analysis-on-russian-fossil-fuel-exports-and-sanctions/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">transports</a> approximately half of Russia’s oil (its capacity couldn’t accommodate it all) and doesn’t adhere to the restrictions. By last summer, Russian oil prices had <a href=\"https://meduza.io/cards/tsena-na-rossiyskuyu-neft-prevysila-potolok-kotoryy-ustanovil-dlya-nee-zapad-i-chto-teper-razve-zapadnye-strany-ee-esche-pokupayut\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">exceeded the cap</a>. India and China didn’t have time to negotiate with Russia for a lower price since their previous suppliers had already redirected their exports to the EU, <a href=\"https://youtu.be/D2j5Hk8133s?si=beFEs3B1ojtVqoit\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">explained</a> Sergey Vakulenko of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.</p><p><br/></p><p>It turned out that tankers using Western services to transport the second half of the oil could also be violating the cap by forging documents, making it <a href=\"https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2023-07-19/russia-oil-sanctions-through-the-smoke-and-mirrors?sref=87YKYqA9\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">difficult</a> to verify the true value of the transaction.</p><p><br/></p><p>In December 2023, the United States managed to impose sanctions on the Russian shadow fleet. Eight tankers were <a href=\"https://navigatingrussia.substack.com/p/dangerous-waters?utm_source=substack&amp;publication_id=783943&amp;post_id=139743088&amp;utm_medium=email&amp;utm_content=share&amp;utm_campaign=email-share&amp;action=share&amp;triggerShare=true&amp;isFreemail=true&amp;r=1ghazt\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">sanctioned</a> (seven of which belonged to the state-owned Sovcomflot) for violating the price cap.</p><p><br/></p><p>The market managed to accomplish things that the sanctions couldn’t. Since November 2023, the price of oil has been steadily declining and the value of Urals in the Port of Primorsk recently <a href=\"https://d1ubxauezca0gh.cloudfront.net/2023/12/07/rinok-pomog-sanktsiyam-padenie-mirovih-tsen-na-neft-opustilo-stoimost-urals-nizhe-potolka-a115585\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">dropped</a> below $60 per barrel. The U.S’ tightening grip has likely been a significant contributing factor.</p>","header":"How to break through the cap","content":[{"insert":"To bypass Western freight carriers and insurers adhering to the cap, Russia created a shadow fleet by purchasing old tankers, often decommissioned for scrap metal. This fleet "},{"insert":"transports","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://energyandcleanair.org/october-2023-monthly-analysis-on-russian-fossil-fuel-exports-and-sanctions/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" approximately half of Russia’s oil (its capacity couldn’t accommodate it all) and doesn’t adhere to the restrictions. By last summer, Russian oil prices had "},{"insert":"exceeded the cap","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://meduza.io/cards/tsena-na-rossiyskuyu-neft-prevysila-potolok-kotoryy-ustanovil-dlya-nee-zapad-i-chto-teper-razve-zapadnye-strany-ee-esche-pokupayut","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":". India and China didn’t have time to negotiate with Russia for a lower price since their previous suppliers had already redirected their exports to the EU, "},{"insert":"explained","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://youtu.be/D2j5Hk8133s?si=beFEs3B1ojtVqoit","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" Sergey Vakulenko of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.\n\nIt turned out that tankers using Western services to transport the second half of the oil could also be violating the cap by forging documents, making it "},{"insert":"difficult","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2023-07-19/russia-oil-sanctions-through-the-smoke-and-mirrors?sref=87YKYqA9","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" to verify the true value of the transaction.\n\nIn December 2023, the United States managed to impose sanctions on the Russian shadow fleet. Eight tankers were "},{"insert":"sanctioned","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://navigatingrussia.substack.com/p/dangerous-waters?utm_source=substack&publication_id=783943&post_id=139743088&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&utm_campaign=email-share&action=share&triggerShare=true&isFreemail=true&r=1ghazt","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" (seven of which belonged to the state-owned Sovcomflot) for violating the price cap.\n\nThe market managed to accomplish things that the sanctions couldn’t. Since November 2023, the price of oil has been steadily declining and the value of Urals in the Port of Primorsk recently "},{"insert":"dropped","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://d1ubxauezca0gh.cloudfront.net/2023/12/07/rinok-pomog-sanktsiyam-padenie-mirovih-tsen-na-neft-opustilo-stoimost-urals-nizhe-potolka-a115585","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" below $60 per barrel. The U.S’ tightening grip has likely been a significant contributing factor.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"The same is true with the import ban. Western countries have been unable to guarantee that semiconductors and other critical components used in the production of weapons will not enter Russia and be used for missile manufacturing. Microchips <a href=\"https://istories.media/stories/2023/05/19/put-kontrabandista-kak-rossiya-poluchaet-chipi-i-bespilotniki-cherez-kazakhstan/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">continue</a> to be an accessible commodity and foreign components are frequently <a href=\"https://static.rusi.org/RUSI-Silicon-Lifeline-final-updated-web_1.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">found</a> in crashed Russian missiles that were manufactured following the outbreak of the war.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"By the end of 2022, imports into Russia had evidently resumed. Economists debated when this would happen.&nbsp;It turned out that if exports are generating money, imports will naturally follow. When consumers are willing to overpay substantially for items, enterprising sellers will always appear, and this is highly disappointing.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This year, Russian economic growth will <a href=\"https://www.interfax-russia.ru/main/reshetnikov-rost-vvp-rf-v-2023-godu-ozhidaetsya-na-urovne-3\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">exceed</a> expectations and the trend is <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/business/922071\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">set to</a> continue in the new year.<a href=\"https://d.docs.live.net/9d09b6ac53b4f163/Documents/iStories%20sanctions%20dissappointment.docx#_msocom_1\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> </a>The budget deficit is <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/6394535\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">shrinking</a>, with oil and gas revenues set to <a href=\"https://minfin.gov.ru/ru/press-center/?id_4=38787-predvaritelnaya_otsenka_ispolneniya_federalnogo_byudzheta_za_yanvar-noyabr_2023_goda\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">meet</a> last year’s annual targets.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":10411,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Sputnik / imago / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Russia’s weapons production industry is booming","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f313b05612545f5925df3c6e2221735-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f313b05612545f5925df3c6e2221735-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":778,"real_height_2x":1555},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f313b05612545f5925df3c6e2221735-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f313b05612545f5925df3c6e2221735-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":778,"real_height_2x":1555},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f313b05612545f5925df3c6e2221735-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f313b05612545f5925df3c6e2221735-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":268,"real_height_2x":538},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f313b05612545f5925df3c6e2221735-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f313b05612545f5925df3c6e2221735-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":268,"real_height_2x":538}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Can the glass be filled?</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"It’s unclear whether totally eliminating the supply of components critical for missile production is even possible. With buyers willing to fork out massive sums, even the trunk of a car can prove to be a bountiful method of smuggling in items like microchips. Only tightened controls could make this task more difficult and expensive.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Sanctions are only as effective as the West wants them to be. In this sense, sanctions have been majorly disappointing.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Western countries were terrified by the sudden surge in oil prices. Therefore, they tried to ensure that Russia was able to continue supplying 5 million barrels of oil per day to the world market, whilst not receiving the level of income they had previously enjoyed. Thus, a new type of sanction was chosen — the price cap. This was the first time it had ever been implemented, meaning the extent of its potential success was uncertain. As a result, Europe defied the advice of economists and imposed the embargo on Russian oil not in March 2022, but December. With the actual announcement of the embargo coming six months prior to its implementation, EU nations were provided with the opportunity to prepare. Russia, of course, was also able to utilize this time to their advantage.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Improving the effectiveness of sanctions is dependent on control and, ultimately, the resources that Western nations are willing to deploy. The U.S Treasury believes that it’s important that they’re allocated correctly. It may end up being cheaper to send $60 billion and provide weapons to Ukraine every year than to impose financial sanctions and stricter export and import controls. I don’t have the data to correctly say whether the U.S Treasury is making the correct decision.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":10412,"data":{"author":" ","header":"If it weren’t for the sanctions, the billions of dollars that Russia loses through oil exports and overpayments for imported goods, would be spent on the war"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"The United States could, for example, invest in increasing oil production as a means of reducing prices. This would slow down their “green transition” and for the U.S this holds global value, whereas the war in Ukraine is a localized conflict between two Slavic nations. From the European perspective, the considerations are somewhat different: the war is being fought in their backyard and the costs for Europe are significantly higher.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The sanctions’ success is reliant upon cooperation from China, India, and possibly other countries. If there’s willingness to cooperate, any country could become an ally. Given this, at least in the eyes of the United States, the problem isn’t serious enough to warrant compromise with China.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"American politicians aren’t overly concerned about Putin. They understand who he is and aren’t particularly afraid of him. From their perspective, the threat from China is considerably greater. Therefore, depriving Putin of export revenues isn’t particularly high up on their list of priorities. Perhaps they think that Putin is already sufficiently constrained and weakened by this war. The fact that it may last several years also doesn’t seem particularly catastrophic for the U.S. This may prove to be a short-sighted perspective.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Glass half full</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Although the sanctions haven’t been as effective as initially hoped, they have brought some notable successes.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Surprisingly, smaller financial sanctions had more substantial consequences than the restrictions on oil. The current state of the ruble is largely due to the Central Bank’s inability to use dollars and euros for currency interventions. Their only alternatives are the Yuan and gold, which are largely ineffective assets for managing the currency market. Subsequently, they must resort to more repressive measures like the mandatory sale of foreign currency earnings.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A definite success has been the European embargo on oil and oil products. If, before the war, half of Russia’s oil exports went to Europe, now it’s <a href=\"https://energyandcleanair.org/october-2023-monthly-analysis-on-russian-fossil-fuel-exports-and-sanctions/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">less</a> than 10% (with the exemption of four countries).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The important thing is that Russia is losing money. Sanctions have significantly increased import costs. An optimistic assessment suggests that oil sanctions reduce their export revenues by 15%, which is an annual loss of approximately $30 billion. However, a substantial portion of these funds end up in Russian offshore structures, rather than in Russia itself. Some additional payments for transportation may also be entering these structures. Hence, the $30 billion is a generous estimate. Its inconsequential who exactly has been left out of pocket, Siluanov or Sechin (referring to Anton Siluanov, the Minister of Finance, and Igor Sechin, the CEO of Russia’s largest state-owned oil company, Rosneft — <em>iStories</em>). In the end, it’s a shared pocket, and the money inside can easily be moved around by order of the president.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"If it weren’t for the sanctions, the billions of dollars that Russia loses through oil exports and overpayments for imported goods, would be spent on the war. Since the war is now the primary source of budget expenditure, the question over the effectiveness of sanctions is akin to debating whether the glass is half empty or half full.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":10413,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"REUTERS / SCANPIX / LETA","caption":"In the ports of the Russian Far East, the price cap has been largely ignored from the start","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7b45e52f20884d6ba7e67506dcedf632-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7b45e52f20884d6ba7e67506dcedf632-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":775,"real_height_2x":1550},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7b45e52f20884d6ba7e67506dcedf632-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7b45e52f20884d6ba7e67506dcedf632-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":775,"real_height_2x":1550},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7b45e52f20884d6ba7e67506dcedf632-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7b45e52f20884d6ba7e67506dcedf632-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":268,"real_height_2x":536},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7b45e52f20884d6ba7e67506dcedf632-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7b45e52f20884d6ba7e67506dcedf632-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":268,"real_height_2x":536}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"<strong>The glass is gradually filling up</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Generally, sanctions can work in two ways:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li><strong>Orchestrate a sudden financial crisis from the outset.</strong> This didn’t occur as extremely high export revenues in the first months of the war stabilized the economy. The realistic attainability of this is questionable: can a financial crisis be triggered by external actors when a state has a budget and trade surplus (exports exceed imports), a non-dollarized economy and non-dollarized loans. It seems that under such conditions a financial crisis can always be avoided. So, even if there were more sanctions at the start, the Russian economy would likely have stabilized anyway. Unfortunately, we can only speculate what might have happened if the EU had imposed the embargo on Russian gas and oil immediately.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<li><strong>Exert long-term pressure on the economy and budget.</strong> This pressure is being felt. In 2024, alternative sources of budget revenue must be found, and it’s unclear what they will be. Additional taxes, which will reduce productivity and economic growth rates, are the most obvious option.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"Obviously, the existing sanctions are insufficient to prevent Russia from financing the war in the coming years. There will be enough money in 2024 and, most likely, in 2025, if oil prices don’t drop significantly. However, if they fall below $60 per barrel, financing the war could become challenging. Pre-Covid budgets were balanced at $45 per barrel of Urals, but now this is barely being managed at almost $80 per barrel. And the sanctions will hopefully cut the budget by 5, 10, 15 or more percent. This is set to continue for years, ultimately yielding a cumulative effect.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, in the long term, it’s the war, and not the sanctions, that is most frightening for Russia. Economically devastating, the war is currently draining 10% of the country’s GDP (that’s more than Ukraine’s entire pre-war GDP!). Even if the conflict ends and Putin remains in power, the Russian economy will remain on a war footing. It couldn’t survive otherwise, with weapons production continuing in case of an unexpected enemy retaliation.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This is a logical move, both militarily and economically. Stopping the 10% of GDP spending would trigger a severe crisis. The stimulation that is currently being provided by the state defense order is keeping the economy afloat and even encouraging some growth. The injection of these large sums must continue just to keep the economy at the current level, regardless of whether the war continues or not.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The state’s enormous military expenditure will continue for as long as Putin’s government can afford it. In other words, provided that the price of oil remains high. We may see a repeat of what happened with the Soviet Union, where falling oil prices triggered a massive crisis and transformational decline. The 10% of GDP would subsequently disappear, but before that, windfall oil revenues would vanish, and all the savings of the National Wealth Fund would be spent.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"To assess the true magnitude of Russia’s economic losses, one mustn’t consider just specific figures, but compare them with what they might have been given the same oil prices, without the war. This would show that GDP could have risen by 5%, but it hasn’t. The other question is, would oil cost the same as it does now without the war? People often say that Putin is perpetually lucky. He’s not lucky — he’s an agent of chaos in the global economy. The chaos he creates is what leads to the rise in oil prices.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>Translated by Sasha Molotkova</em>","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":2226,"header":"Nothing but Wagner All Around. How Putin Degraded the Russian State","_path":"/en/opinions/2023/06/27/nothing-but-wagner-all-around/","lead":"Yevgeny Prigozhin’s mutiny is the result of the actions of the president, who, in order to preserve his personal power, has long moved the country’s governance into a gray zone","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-1920x960px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-1920x960px_2x.png","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-1272x636px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-1272x636px_2x.png","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-912x456px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-912x456px_2x.png","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-600x400px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-600x400px_2x.png","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-360x360px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/07179d0f61ee4f84aec406216ed9feef-360x360px_2x.png","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"For years, Putin has been handing out the state to those who have exhibited personal loyalty to him (like Igor Sechin, right). PHOTO: REUTERS / SCANPIX / LETA","created_at_date":"2023-06-27","created_at_date_time":"2023-06-28T14:31:53.604Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[],"external_authors_list":[{"id":194,"first_name":"Ilya","last_name":"Matveev","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"University of California, Berkeley","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":null}],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"In his article “Russia at the Turn of the Millennium”, published back in December 1999, Vladimir Putin wrote: “Russia needs a strong state power and must have it.” He argued that gosudarstvennichestvo (statism) is organic for Russian history and society, and the restoration of the state is the main task for Putin himself. Since then, “strong state power,” or the “vertical of power,” has become one of the most enduring ideologies of Putin’s rule, and the term gosudarsvtennik (statist) has become a watchword by which the Kremlin elite recognizes its own.\nIt is all the more strange that in the 23rd year of Putin’s rule, the key role in the war unleashed by him was played by a private military company, its numbers peaking at 40–50 thousand people — almost a third of the entire force that invaded Ukraine on February 24, 2022. Moreover, in the end, PMC Wagner Group attempted a coup d'état; a large regional center was captured by rebel troops; armed columns marched to Moscow; several helicopters and a plane of the Ministry of Defense were shot down; at least 13 people died. The monopoly on violence, through which the state has been defined since the time of the German sociologist Max Weber, has been visibly challenged, and the notorious “vertical of power” has turned out to be as fragile as a porcelain cup. This time, the cup did not break, but was covered with cracks — the sight of Yevgeny Prigozhin chastising Deputy Minister of Defense Yevkurov, and the unhindered movement of columns through the Russian regions almost to Moscow itself, left an impression on the Russian elites; conclusions were drawn. The fragility of power is a self-fulfilling prophecy.\nIn his emergency address on June 24, which lasted only five minutes, Putin managed to bring another historical lesson, as he has generally tended to do in the recent years. This time it was about the revolution of 1917. One gets the impression that for Putin, periodic troubles are a feature of Russian history, they are inevitable, like the change of seasons, and the function of the Russian state and its leader lies in the eternal opposition to them. In reality, this is about history indeed — but only the history of the last 23 years. The fragility of the Russian state revealed by Prigozhin is the result of Putin’s own actions — he is the one who created this very state.\n\nPMC as a way to rule the country\n\nIn 2008, the Russian political sociologist Vadim Volkov published an article entitled “State Corporations: Another Institutional Experiment”. His reasoning was as follows: by the mid-2000s, rising energy prices had allowed the Russian state to accumulate significant reserves, and the question was how to spend them. Putin was aware of the task of modernizing the Russian economy, but he did not trust either private business or, importantly, the state itself to accomplish this task. As a result, state corporations were born. In essence, they are the vehicles for spending public money, protected from both market competition and government inspections and control. State corporations have been in a gray zone, which led the experts and even members of the government to debate: how, after all, to characterize the consolidation of assets within their framework — as a creeping nationalization or as a hidden privatization? Volkov himself proposed the term “personified state property”: “This property remains state property to the extent that it is controlled by the head of state.”\nIn the gray zone, protected from both market discipline and formal vertical control, the main instrument of governance is Putin’s personal relationships with the heads of state corporations — and large state companies, which in this sense do not differ from state corporations. Putin’s state is a collective of “statists”, sealed by Putin’s personal trust, and not by formal legal relations. Accordingly, the “statism” in Putin’s version is not a commitment to Weber’s ideal of a rational, meritocratic corps of bureaucrats, but rather an ideology of \"national interests\" achieved by any means necessary, with no concern for formalities. And since “national interests” is an extremely vague concept, it is not surprising that “statists” successfully replace them in everyday governance practice with private interests, engaging in personal gain in their posts.\n\n\nOccasionally, Putin’s skepticism about formal state institutions (despite his declared commitment to “statism”) broke through publicly. The story of the Rosneftegaz company, which receives dividends from Rosneft and partly from Gazprom, is quite characteristic in this regard. This mysterious company not only accumulates huge amounts of money, but also invests it in projects all over the country; who is behind the choice of objects for investment, was not explained to the population for a long time. Finally, Putin answered a direct question from Vedomosti journalist Margarita Papchenkova during his press conference in 2016: “Yes, there is such a reserve as the money of Rosneftegaz. <…> And we finance some things from there when the government forgets that there are priorities that need to be paid attention to.” This was tantamount to admitting that the “statist” Putin simply does not believe in his own state, preferring, against the backdrop of a crisis-induced budget deficit, to have a second, parallel budget, which is in the gray zone of his personal relations with Igor Sechin and, possibly, other players (Putin did not specify who “we” are). It is quite apparent that Wagner Group fits well into this management model. If there is a parallel budget, why not create a parallel army? \nResidents of the gray zone have already participated in mutinies — albeit not armed ones — against the official executive power, the government of the Russian Federation. For example, the heads of state-owned companies (Russian Railways, Rosneft, Gazprom) refused to publish their salaries, despite the request of Dmitry Medvedev, then prime minister. As a result, in 2015 the government had to revise its own decision, in effect, inscribing into law its impotence in the face of Putin’s powerful friends. State-owned companies are also known for their constant butting with the Ministry of Finance on the share of their income transferred to the budget.\nA clash with actors from the gray zone can end badly for the government. So, an attempt at preventing Rosneft from taking over the assets of another oil company, Bashneft, cost the Minister of Economic Development Alexei Ulyukaev his freedom, despite the fact that his position was fully consistent with Putin’s earlier directive to prevent further growth of state property. The arrest of Ulyukaev, which Sechin carried out with the help of FSB officers seconded to Rosneft indicated the privatization of elements of the power apparatus by a political player who used this resource to attack the federal minister (i.e., the state itself) for his own personal purposes and interests. No violent confrontation happened at that time — after all, Ulyukaev was the minister of economic development, not defense, — but typologically this situation is similar to Prigozhin’s mutiny.\n\n“Vertical of power” against the state \n\nWhy did Putin create the gray zone and allow its practices, such as the privatization of profits and the socialization of costs, to envelop the entire state apparatus? One answer is that such a system is functional. Political scientist Vladimir Gelman indicates that corruption is one of the ways to solve the agency problem (in general terms, the problem of ensuring that subordinates follow the orders of superiors). The possibility of personal gain creates an incentive to act in the interests of the principal (boss). Thus, on the whole, the “Russian system”, as the late Gleb Pavlovsky called it, is governable. It allows Putin to achieve his goals — but only within certain limits. The costs can be measured in money (plundered and lost for the state); the quality of state managers (extremely low due to the dominance of the principle “it’s who you know, not what you know”); the inability to pursue a consistent policy course (which is inevitably watered down under the influence of various private interests which Putin himself gave free rein to); and finally, cracks in the very foundation of the state system (which were revealed by the mutiny of the gray zone actor Yevgeny Prigozhin).\n\n\nPutin created this kind of state because his main task is to maintain the regime of personal power. After all, the agency problem can be solved at a much lower cost with the help of democratic accountability, which ensures the control of the population over state representatives at all levels. Under conditions of authoritarianism, this mechanism is, by definition, inaccessible, which means that only two other options remain: vertical monitoring through formal indicators (which, as Putin himself recognizes, are fulfilled only on paper) and corruption, which serves as a lubricant for the rusted state machine. Moreover, attempts at the forceful “restoration of order” within the framework of a dictatorship are dangerous in that they undermine the very foundations of Putin’s personal power, as it relies on the loyalty of his high-ranking associates. This loyalty is by no means unconditional, and attempts to replace corrupt friends with competent managers may well lead to the situation in which Putin’s friends will replace Putin himself. Hence the notorious Putin’s credo of the “stability of personnel” and his unwillingness to shuffle the deck of influential people.\nParadoxically, the strengthening of the political regime (i.e., the regime of Putin’s personal power) leads to the weakening of the state, and measures to strengthen the state can lead to the weakening and even collapse of the political regime. This dynamic has been captured by political researcher Neil Robinson, who offered to distinguish between state-building and regime-building. To a certain extent, the dictator is interested in strengthening the state: for example, restoring the functionality of law enforcement agencies allows him to more effectively deal with political opponents. In addition, a capable state increases a regime’s legitimacy in the eyes of the population — no dictatorship can rely solely on bayonets. Nevertheless, in strengthening the state, the dictator quickly hits the ceiling — a massive campaign against corruption and personnel purges without democratization lead to a decrease in governability and erosion of the political base of the dictatorship. Thus, the formation of a regime of personal power, which may initially coincide with an increase in state capacity, very quickly begins to interfere with this capacity: the preservation of the dictatorship degrades state institutions. That is why examples of successful dictatorships are vanishingly rare. Economist Dani Rodrik remarked, “For every authoritarian country that has managed to grow rapidly, there are several that have floundered. For every President Lee Kuan Yew of Singapore, there are many like President Mobutu Sese Seko of Zaire (now called the Democratic Republic of the Congo).”\n\n\nThis logic is fully applicable to Russia as well. In the early 2000s, Putin did achieve the strengthening of the state: tax revenues rose, financing of state bodies was restored, and a single legal space for the whole country was established. However, progress quickly stopped, giving way to rare local successes against the background of general stagnation, and in some places even regression. The goal of regime-building took precedence over the goal of state-building. This is how the gray zone of not quite private and not quite public organizations emerged. Until recently, Yevgeny Prigozhin was one of its residents.\n\nPutin surrounded by Prigozhins\n\nIn the case of Wagner Group, the features of the “Russian system” overlapped with the typical features of private military companies. PMCs as a whole gravitate towards the gray zone of corrupt government contracts, old boys’ networks, international adventurism and covert operations under the cover of plausible deniability. This kind of gray zone exists in democracies as well, although its significance is much less than in Russia. Thus, the subversive activities of Wagner Group in Africa are not too different from the reckless gambles of the British PMC Sandline and its founders Tim Spicer and Simon Mann. With the beginning of the Ukrainian invasion, Wagner began to perform another function, more characteristic of American PMCs: recruiting soldiers for major imperialist wars without conducting a general mobilization. Russia lacked soldiers in Ukraine in the same way that the US lacked soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan; in both cases, PMCs became the solution to the personnel issue.\n\n\nThe PMC model itself (which is contrary to the fundamental feature of modern states — the centralization and monopolization of violence) is organic to Putin’s style of governance. It is not surprising that it was the PMC that played a crucial role in the Russo-Ukrainian war. Of course, Wagner Group has unique characteristics: in no other country do PMCs cover all branches of the military, including aviation — neither do they recruit prisoners with a promise of pardon after the expiration of the contract; no other PMC is funded by corrupt state contracts, as a result of which rotten breakfasts are delivered to schools and soldiers' barracks; no other PMC owner engages in so many types of provocations at the same time — runs a troll factory, runs a network of tabloid media used for political attacks, etc. In this sense, Prigozhin and Wagner are products of Putinism, not just international trends towards the expansion of the role of PMCs.\nBut more importantly, the very political environment in which Prigozhin operated was also created by Putin. The Wagner mutiny exposed the weakness of the Russian state. Behind the monolithic facade of Putinism are clans, networks and corporations pursuing their own goals. They are quite capable of bringing the country to collapse and civil war. Even the security forces are separated not only by corporate, but also by clan-patronage lines. Suffice it to say that the Wagner mutiny was supposed to be suppressed by… Ramzan Kadyrov’s “Akhmat” battalion. One can easily imagine a situation in which Kadyrov’s troops themselves stage a mutiny, and the regular army is sent to suppress it. Suddenly it will be revealed that the regular army itself consists of regional volunteer formations, units of other PMCs that the Ministry of Defense has taken control of, etc.\nThe democratic transition in Russia which is not accompanied by the disorganization of the state similar to the 1990s will be a real miracle. And yet, only a democratic transition can ultimately lead to the emergence of a strong, capable state in Russia. Putin’s model of authoritarian state-building showed its results after 23 years: the bombing of the highway near Voronezh, the dead pilots, the Deputy Minister of Defense, listening to reproaches from a former criminal who now leads the army of criminals. “Russia needs a strong state power and must have it.”","blocks":[{"data":"In his&nbsp;<a href=\"https://www.ng.ru/politics/1999-12-30/4_millenium.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">article</a>&nbsp;“Russia at the Turn of the Millennium”, published back in December 1999, Vladimir Putin wrote: “Russia needs a strong state power and must have it.” He argued that gosudarstvennichestvo (statism) is organic for Russian history and society, and the restoration of the state is the main task for Putin himself. Since then, “strong state power,” or the “vertical of power,” has become one of the most enduring ideologies of Putin’s rule, and the term gosudarsvtennik (statist) has become a watchword by which the Kremlin elite recognizes its own.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It is all the more strange that in the 23rd year of Putin’s rule, the key role in the war unleashed by him was played by&nbsp;a private&nbsp;military company, its numbers <a href=\"https://twitter.com/DefenceHQ/status/1616323761392812033\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">peaking</a>&nbsp;at 40–50&nbsp;thousand people — almost a third of the entire force that invaded Ukraine on February 24, 2022. Moreover, in the end, PMC Wagner Group attempted a coup d'état; a large regional center was captured by rebel troops; armed columns marched to Moscow; several helicopters and a plane of the Ministry of Defense were shot down;&nbsp;at least 13 people <a href=\"https://istories.media/news/2023/06/26/vertolet-u-kirilla-bil-ne-boevoi-stali-izvestni-imena-letchikov-pogibshikh-vo-vremya-myatezha-chvk-vagner/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">died</a>. The monopoly on violence, through which the state has been defined since the time of the German sociologist Max Weber, has been visibly challenged, and the notorious “vertical of power” has turned out to be as fragile as a porcelain cup. This time, the cup did not break, but was covered with cracks — the sight of Yevgeny Prigozhin chastising Deputy Minister of Defense Yevkurov, and the unhindered movement of columns through the Russian regions almost to Moscow itself, left an impression on the Russian elites; conclusions were drawn. The fragility of power is a self-fulfilling prophecy.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In his emergency address on June 24, which lasted only five minutes, Putin managed to bring another historical lesson, as he has generally tended to do in the recent years. This time it was about the revolution of 1917. One gets the impression that for Putin, periodic troubles are a feature of Russian history, they are inevitable, like the change of seasons, and the function of the Russian state and its leader lies in the eternal opposition to them. In reality, this is about history indeed — but only the history of the last 23 years. The fragility of the Russian state revealed by Prigozhin is the result of Putin’s own actions — he is the one who created this very state.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"PMC as a way to rule the country","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In 2008, the Russian political&nbsp;<a href=\"https://eusp.org/people/volkov\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">sociologist</a>&nbsp;Vadim Volkov published an article entitled “State Corporations: Another Institutional Experiment”. His reasoning was as follows: by the mid-2000s, rising energy prices had allowed the Russian state to accumulate significant reserves, and the question was how to spend them. Putin was aware of the task of modernizing the Russian economy, but he did not trust either private business or, importantly, the state itself to accomplish this task. As a result, <a href=\"https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%93%D0%BE%D1%81%D1%83%D0%B4%D0%B0%D1%80%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B2%D0%B5%D0%BD%D0%BD%D0%B0%D1%8F_%D0%BA%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%BF%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%B0%D1%86%D0%B8%D1%8F\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">state corporations</a>&nbsp;were born. In essence, they are the vehicles for spending public money, protected from both market competition and government inspections and control. State corporations have been in a gray zone, which led the experts and even members of the government to debate: how, after all, to characterize the consolidation of assets within their framework — as a creeping nationalization or as a hidden privatization? Volkov himself proposed the term “personified state property”: “This property remains state property to the extent that it is controlled by the head of state.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In the gray zone, protected from both market discipline and formal vertical control, the main instrument of governance is Putin’s personal relationships with the heads of state corporations — and large state companies, which in this sense do not differ from state corporations. Putin’s state is a collective of “statists”, sealed by Putin’s personal trust, and not by formal legal relations. Accordingly, the “statism” in Putin’s version&nbsp;is not a commitment to Weber’s ideal of a rational, meritocratic corps of bureaucrats, but rather an ideology of \"national interests\" achieved by any means necessary, with no concern for formalities. And since “national interests” is an extremely vague concept, it is not surprising that “statists” successfully replace them in everyday governance practice with private interests, engaging in personal gain in their posts.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":8316,"data":{"author":" ","header":"In the gray zone, the main instrument of governance is Putin’s personal relationships with the heads of state corporations"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"Occasionally, Putin’s skepticism about formal state institutions (despite his declared commitment to “statism”) broke through publicly. The story of the Rosneftegaz company, which receives dividends from Rosneft and partly from Gazprom, is quite characteristic in this regard. This mysterious company not only accumulates huge amounts of money, but also invests it in projects all over the country; who is behind the choice of objects for investment, was not explained to the population for a long time. Finally, Putin&nbsp;<a href=\"http://kremlin.ru/events/president/news/53573\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">answered</a>&nbsp;a direct question from Vedomosti journalist Margarita Papchenkova during his press conference in 2016: “Yes, there is such a reserve as the money of Rosneftegaz. &lt;…&gt; And we finance some things from there when the government forgets that there are priorities that need to be paid attention to.” This was tantamount to admitting that the “statist” Putin simply does not believe in his own state, preferring, against the backdrop of a crisis-induced budget deficit, to have a second, parallel budget, which is in the gray zone of his personal relations with Igor Sechin and, possibly, other players (Putin did not specify who “we” are). It is quite apparent that Wagner Group fits well into this management model. If there is a parallel budget, why not create a parallel army?&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Residents of the gray zone have already participated in mutinies — albeit not armed ones — against the official executive power, the government of the Russian Federation. For example, the heads of state-owned companies (Russian Railways, Rosneft, Gazprom) refused to publish their salaries, despite the request of Dmitry Medvedev, then prime minister. As a result, in 2015 the government had to&nbsp;<a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/2698251\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">revise</a>&nbsp;its own decision, in effect, inscribing into law its impotence in the face of Putin’s powerful friends. State-owned companies are also <a href=\"https://www.vedomosti.ru/economics/articles/2016/10/25/662262-dohodi-rosneftegaza\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">known</a> for their constant butting with the Ministry of Finance on the share of their income transferred to the budget.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A clash with actors from the gray zone can end badly for the government. So,&nbsp;an <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/society/27/11/2017/5a1bdad69a79473b616b529f\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">attempt </a>at preventing Rosneft from taking over the assets of another oil company, Bashneft, cost the Minister of Economic Development Alexei Ulyukaev his freedom, despite the fact that his position was fully consistent with Putin’s earlier directive to prevent further growth of state property. The arrest of Ulyukaev, which Sechin carried out with the help of FSB officers seconded to Rosneft indicated the privatization of elements of the power apparatus by a political player who used this resource to attack the federal minister (i.e., the state itself) for his own personal purposes and interests. No violent confrontation happened at that time — after all, Ulyukaev was the minister of economic development, not defense, — but typologically this situation is similar to Prigozhin’s mutiny.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Vertical of power” against the state&nbsp;","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Why did Putin create the gray zone and allow its practices, such as the privatization of profits and the socialization of costs, to envelop the entire state apparatus? One answer is that such a system is functional. Political scientist Vladimir Gelman <a href=\"https://eusp.org/sites/default/files/archive/M_center/M_41_15.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">indicates</a> that corruption is one of the ways to solve the agency problem (in general terms, the problem of ensuring that subordinates follow the orders of superiors). The possibility of personal gain creates an incentive to act in the interests of the principal (boss). Thus, on the whole, the “Russian system”, as the late Gleb Pavlovsky called it, is governable. It allows Putin to achieve his goals — but only within certain limits. The costs can be measured in money (plundered and lost for the state); the quality of state managers (extremely low due to the dominance of the principle “it’s who you know, not what you know”); the inability to pursue a consistent policy course (which is inevitably watered down under the influence of various private interests which Putin himself gave free rein to); and finally, cracks in the very foundation of the state system (which were revealed by the mutiny of the gray zone actor Yevgeny Prigozhin).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":8317,"data":{"author":" ","header":"If there is a parallel budget, why not create a parallel army?"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"Putin created this kind of state because his main task is to maintain the regime of personal power. After all, the agency problem can be solved at a much lower cost with the help of democratic accountability, which ensures the control of the population over state representatives at all levels. Under conditions of authoritarianism, this mechanism is, by definition, inaccessible, which means that only two other options remain: vertical monitoring through formal indicators (which, as&nbsp;Putin himself <a href=\"https://www.hse.ru/news/3797595/82929025.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">recognizes</a>, are fulfilled only on paper) and corruption, which serves as a lubricant for the rusted state machine. Moreover, attempts at the forceful “restoration of order” within the framework of a dictatorship are dangerous in that they undermine the very foundations of Putin’s personal power, as it relies on the loyalty of his high-ranking associates. This loyalty is by no means unconditional, and attempts to replace corrupt friends with competent managers may well lead to the situation in which Putin’s friends will replace Putin himself. Hence the notorious Putin’s credo of the “stability of personnel” and his unwillingness to shuffle the deck of influential people.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Paradoxically, the strengthening of the political regime (i.e., the regime of Putin’s personal power) leads to the weakening of the state, and measures to strengthen the state can lead to the weakening and even collapse of the political regime. This dynamic has been captured by political researcher Neil Robinson, who&nbsp;<a href=\"https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Neil-Robinson-7/publication/45597193_State_regime_and_Russian_political_development/links/0046351f0f32c894a0000000/State-regime-and-Russian-political-development.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">offered</a>&nbsp;to distinguish between state-building and regime-building. To a certain extent, the dictator is interested in strengthening the state: for example, restoring the functionality of law enforcement agencies allows him to more effectively deal with political opponents. In addition, a capable state increases a regime’s legitimacy in the eyes of the population — no dictatorship can rely solely on bayonets. Nevertheless, in strengthening the state, the dictator quickly hits the ceiling — a massive campaign against corruption and personnel purges without democratization lead to a decrease in governability and erosion of the political base of the dictatorship. Thus, the formation of a regime of personal power, which may initially coincide with an increase in state capacity, very quickly begins to interfere with this capacity: the preservation of the dictatorship degrades state institutions. That is why examples of successful dictatorships are vanishingly rare. Economist Dani Rodrik <a href=\"https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/the-myth-of-authoritarian-growth?barrier=accesspaylog\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">remarked</a>, “For every authoritarian country that has managed to grow rapidly, there are several that have floundered. For every President Lee Kuan Yew of Singapore, there are many like President Mobutu Sese Seko of Zaire (now called the Democratic Republic of the Congo).”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":8318,"data":{"author":" ","header":"Attempts to replace corrupt friends with competent managers may well lead to the situation in which Putin’s friends will replace Putin himself. Hence the notorious Putin’s credo of the “stability of personnel”."},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"This logic is fully applicable to Russia as well. In the early 2000s, Putin did achieve the strengthening of the state: tax revenues rose, financing of state bodies was restored, and a single legal space for the whole country was established. However, progress quickly stopped, giving way to rare local successes against the background of general stagnation, and in some places even regression. The goal of regime-building took precedence over the goal of state-building. This is how the gray zone of not quite private and not quite public organizations emerged. Until recently, Yevgeny Prigozhin was one of its residents.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Putin surrounded by Prigozhins","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In the case of Wagner Group, the features of the “Russian system” overlapped with the typical features of private military companies. PMCs as a whole gravitate towards the gray zone of corrupt government contracts, old boys’ networks, international adventurism and covert operations under the cover of plausible deniability. This kind of gray zone exists in democracies as well, although its significance is much less than in Russia. Thus, the subversive activities of Wagner Group in Africa are not too different from the reckless gambles of the British&nbsp;<a href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sandline_International\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">PMC Sandline</a>&nbsp;and its founders Tim Spicer and Simon Mann. With the beginning of the Ukrainian invasion, Wagner began to perform another function, more characteristic of American PMCs: recruiting soldiers for major imperialist wars without conducting a general mobilization. Russia lacked soldiers in Ukraine in the same way that the US lacked soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan; in both cases, PMCs became the solution to the personnel issue.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":8319,"data":{"author":" ","header":"The democratic transition in Russia which is not accompanied by the disorganization of the state similar to the 1990s will be a real miracle"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"The PMC model itself (which is contrary to the fundamental feature of modern states — the centralization and monopolization of violence) is organic to Putin’s style of governance. It is not surprising that it was the PMC that played a crucial role in the Russo-Ukrainian war. Of course, Wagner Group has unique characteristics: in no other country do PMCs cover all branches of the military, including aviation — neither do they recruit prisoners with a promise of pardon after the expiration of the contract; no other PMC is funded by corrupt state contracts, as a result of which rotten breakfasts are delivered to schools and soldiers' barracks; no other PMC owner engages in so many types of provocations at the same time — runs a <a href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_Research_Agency\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">troll factory</a>, runs a network of tabloid media used for political attacks, etc. In this sense, Prigozhin and Wagner are products of Putinism, not just international trends towards the expansion of the role of PMCs.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But more importantly, the very political environment in which Prigozhin operated was also created by Putin. The Wagner mutiny exposed the weakness of the Russian state. Behind the monolithic facade of Putinism are clans, networks and corporations pursuing their own goals. They are quite capable of bringing the country to collapse and civil war. Even the security forces are separated not only by corporate, but also by clan-patronage lines. Suffice it to say that the Wagner mutiny was supposed to be suppressed by… Ramzan Kadyrov’s “Akhmat” battalion. One can easily imagine a situation in which Kadyrov’s troops themselves stage a mutiny, and the regular army is sent to suppress it. Suddenly it will be revealed that the regular army itself consists of regional volunteer formations, units of other PMCs that the Ministry of Defense has taken control of, etc.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The democratic transition in Russia which is not accompanied by the disorganization of the state similar to the 1990s will be a real miracle. And yet, only a democratic transition can ultimately lead to the emergence of a strong, capable state in Russia. Putin’s model of authoritarian state-building showed its results after 23&nbsp;years: the bombing of the highway near Voronezh, the dead pilots, the Deputy Minister of Defense, listening to reproaches from a former criminal who now leads the army of criminals. “Russia needs a strong state power and must have it.”","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":1504,"header":"“The War Will End When Everybody Makes an Effort for That”","_path":"/en/opinions/2023/02/07/the-war-will-end-when-everybody-makes-an-effort-for-that/","lead":"War has put some Russian citizens against a tough moral choice: if you’re against the aggressive acts of Russian authorities, may you support the Ukraine Army? “Important Stories” spoke to Russians, who send drones to the Armed Forces of Ukraine.","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-1920x960px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-1920x960px_2x.png","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-1272x636px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-1272x636px_2x.png","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-912x456px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-912x456px_2x.png","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-600x400px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-600x400px_2x.png","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-360x360px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/833b2b1bd10946d48f5f0933cd7595bd-360x360px_2x.png","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"","created_at_date":"2023-02-07","created_at_date_time":"2023-02-17T16:02:00Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":9,"first_name":"Ирина","last_name":"Долинина","first_name_en":"Irina","last_name_en":"Dolinina","is_public":true,"_path":"irina-dolinina","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Журналистка «Важных историй»","lead_en":"IStories' investigative reporter","position":"Авторка","position_en":"Author","ordering":null}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"Russian military aggression toward Ukraine caused rejection in many Russians. Some have been shielded away from the news, considering themselves powerless to do anything, others refused to participate in war, left the country, and stopped paying taxes, and the third portion of them started providing humanitarian assistance to Ukrainians. But there are also those who decided to help the Ukrainian army directly.\n\nA scientist Natalia Zotova, a software engineer Viktor Gorlov, a sociologist Gleb and one participant, whose name was changed per his request, are all members of a volunteer project called UA Drone Forces which supplies civilian drones to the Ukraine Armed Forces. They told “Important Stories” about why, in their opinion, in current circumstances, it’s unacceptable to only provide humanitarian aid to Ukraine.\n\nAbout pacifism and army assistance\n\nGleb, 30 y.o.: Most Russians, that I’m speaking to, aren’t ready to give money to Ukrainian Armed Forces. Thank God, they’re not sending money to the Russian army, at least. The weirdest thing for me personally is when people fence off with pacifism: “I’m a pacifist. I won’t give money to the army”. But in reality, it’s scary, because a man not involved in a fight between the weak and the strong, is automatically on the side of the strong. I will use a metaphor that's in use by Ukrainians. Imagine if a maniac appeared in your city, that is capturing a new pupil every day, and rapes them. And you can find this maniac and stop him. Or you can go and give the kid a cup of cocoa, wrap him up in a blanket, advise him to a therapist. New day — new pupil, you can go to them for twenty years. But that won’t stop the maniac. \n\nNatalia, 48 y.o.: The position of pacifism in a fight of good and evil, darkness and light, is unacceptable.\n\nViktor, 50 y.o.: I guess, this pacifistic attitude hides the fact that these people have a strong association with Russians, and in particular with those who are at war. Associating themselves with them, these \"pacifists\" don't want to [contribute to] their deaths.\n\nAndrey, 33 y.o.: You can treat the military differently. But people [in Ukraine] didn’t want to wage war, they didn’t attack anybody. We have a lot of contacts with Ukraine soldiers: among them are teachers, professors, and businessmen. They are regular people, who saw what Putin’s army is doing and couldn’t stay away – they went to protect their country. They are victims of aggression so we need to help them in any way possible. \n\nNatalia: For example, the first drone we bought for a doctor of philosophy. He’s still fighting. The best people in Ukraine fight and die in the army. For example, the three of us, giving you an interview, belonged to an alpinism community. And in Ukraine, the deputy head of the Federation of Mountaineering and Climbing of Ukraine has just died near Soledar. A great man, his wife is a Master of Sports in climbing. And we both saw them in the mountains. He has left four children. All of these people stood up to protect their country from invaders and we want to help them defend and withstand. \n\nAndrey: They went to war because their crazy neighbor forced them to. And because we associate ourselves with the country, where this crazy neighbor was born, grew up, and gained dictatorial power, then it’s our moral duty to help his victim. On another hand, we won’t achieve anything with Putin’s regime if Ukraine doesn’t win this war. And as democratic Russians, we want to change Russia as well.\n\nAbout the mobilized people and protests in Russia\n\nNatalia: As a Russian, I don’t accept the totalitarian regime victim narrative. As they say: If you were eaten, there are still two ways out. So, the victim narrative refuses people their own will and their own choice. Have your hands been tied up, have you been chained to the radiator? Even the mobilized — they’re going to the recruitment office on their own legs. And they’re going there with their weird thoughts: “to kill khokhols [Russian ethnic slur for Ukrainians]”, “to win” or whatever’s in their heads. And the victim's narrative is about “we’re not deciding anything, we were made, so we went”.\n\nViktor: At the same time, it’s obviously clear that there are separate cases where people were actually [forcibly] taken from work or other places. We understand that people like that exist, but what are we supposed to do? We have to stop the murdering of those who they came to kill. That is more important. If we pity those who were taken, mobilized, this war will not be stopped, there will be more victims.\n\nPersonally, I have taken part in street protests in Russia since 2008. I was at Bolotnaya Square [on 6 May 2012]. I participated in election observations and saw how they are falsified. In 2014 I left with my family because it became clear that there is no future for my children there. I didn't want my children to be subjected to all this propaganda, which is infused into a person unnoticed starting in kindergarten and school.\n\nNatalia: I went to the protests too, I was arrested by the police twice. I and my family left after Crimea was occupied [in 2014] and now we live in the United States. Since the start of the war, I've been in a tough mental state, but the activity I’m in — buying drones, it’s supporting me, giving me strength. The war will end when everybody makes an effort for that. \n\nAbout the work of the volunteer group\n\nAndrey: Initially our group was formed by two volunteers from Canada and Kyiv in April 2022: they asked to buy a drone for Kharkiv's homeland defense. We bought one, then another one. Then we got to know what drones are needed, started establishing tighter connections with Ukrainian soldiers, and worked out logistics routes.\n\nNatalia: In our group, there’re more than a half Russians, and we’re working together with Ukranians. Ukrainians’ trust in us is very valuable. There are no communication problems in our group. We have correspondence in both Russian and Ukrainian in our chat. We asked a question, how do you feel [about the fact we’re Russian], to our Ukrainian volunteers. Everyone invariably responded that we are not divided here by ethnicity, not by citizenship — Russians and Ukrainians — but by our tasks and goals, by our vision of the situation.\nAndrey: I spoke to Ukrainian soldiers personally. They all treated me kindly and with gratitude (after the full-scale war began in Ukraine, there were different attitudes towards help from Russians, part of society doesn’t accept it — Ed.note).\n\nOur Ukrainian volunteers collect requests for drones from frontline units. Then we buy drones in Europe, from where our Ukrainian volunteer takes them to Kyiv. There, drones are reprogrammed and volunteers take them to different frontline segments. After receiving the drone, Ukrainian defenders film a video and take a photo with it with our sticker visible. That way we can make sure that drones reach their destinations, exactly the one unit that requested it. We saw how useful and necessary it is – drones save lives. And we started finding friends who financially helped and started working with us on finding and buying drones. In 8 months we grew into a volunteer group and more than 40 of our drones work on the frontline.\n\nViktor: We buy civilian drones, often already used, to save money, the most common one is DJI Mavic Air 2. The biggest limitation we have is the funds. If we could buy more, we would supply more.\n\nNatalia: We have already collected more than 25 thousand euros in donations. And we get donations from completely different places: there were even transfers from Russians, who are in Russia, through other people for safety reasons. \n\nAbout the use of drones\n\nViktor: Generally the military uses drones for reconnaissance, so the soldiers could see what kind of situation they’re in, what’s going on on the opposing side, what the enemy's movements are, and what to be ready for. Or, for example, we were told there were situations, when there are no communications between the first and second line, and the enemy could slip through blocks at the first line. And the drones made it possible to see that an attack deep into the second line was being planned. So this awareness allows people to save their lives and successfully defend themselves.\n\nGleb: Apart from reconnaissance and artillery correction, drones help in finding injured after the battle, so Ukrainian soldiers could run there in time and get people out. Or you can attach some medicine to a drone and it can bring them to the injured. \n\n\nNatalia: Also drones fly up to Russian soldiers and help them surrender safely. There is an official Ukraine Ministry of Defence instruction: Russian arranges his surrender on the hotline, comes to the specified spot, and from there a drone leads him along a safe route into the rear. \n\nWe have strict accounting and control over who we deliver drones to. Our Ukrainian volunteer oversees several directions and takes requests from units situated on them. Requests are written in letters by commanders, it's quite an official thing. There’s always a waitlist, sorting according to needs: for example, somebody’s drone is out of order and it was their last one. That's the kind of equipment that lives around one-two months on the frontline. \n\nAndrey: We can’t divulge information about specific units, which we helped. But we can say that our drones participated in the Kherson liberation and the liberation of territories in the Kharkiv direction. Also, our drones are now working around Bakhmut and Donetsk. \n\nViktor: In June our drones participated in the battle of Sievierodonetsk. Five ZSU soldiers sent us a video report about getting our drone and a week later we were told that only one of the guys on that video is still alive. \n\nNatalia: It’s important to highlight that drones are not a weapon. They’re “the eyes” of soldiers. And they’re too valuable as “eyes” to strap grenades to them. But still, because of different “barriers”, I guess, psychological ones, there aren’t a lot of Russian volunteer groups that can help Ukrainians defend themselves. We know of only three such projects, one of them is our UA Drone Forces. Mostly, Russians help with humanitarian aid.","blocks":[{"data":"Russian military aggression toward Ukraine caused rejection in many Russians. Some have been shielded away from the news, considering themselves powerless to do anything, others refused to participate in war, left the country, and stopped paying taxes, and the third portion of them started providing humanitarian assistance to Ukrainians. But there are also those who decided to help the Ukrainian army directly.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A scientist Natalia Zotova, a software engineer Viktor Gorlov, a sociologist Gleb and one participant, whose name was changed per his request, are all members of a volunteer project called <a href=\"https://uadroneforces.help/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">UA Drone Forces</a> which supplies civilian drones to the Ukraine Armed Forces. They told “Important Stories” about why, in their opinion, in current circumstances, it’s unacceptable to only provide humanitarian aid to Ukraine.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"About pacifism and army assistance","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Gleb</strong>,<strong> 30 y.o.</strong>: Most Russians, that I’m speaking to, aren’t ready to give money to Ukrainian Armed Forces. Thank God, they’re not sending money to the Russian army, at least. The weirdest thing for me personally is when people fence off with pacifism: “I’m a pacifist. I won’t give money to the army”. But in reality, it’s scary, because a man not involved in a fight between the weak and the strong, is automatically on the side of the strong. I will use a metaphor that's in use by Ukrainians. Imagine if a maniac appeared in your city, that is capturing a new pupil every day, and rapes them. And you can find this maniac and stop him. Or you can go and give the kid a cup of cocoa, wrap him up in a blanket, advise him to a therapist. New day — new pupil, you can go to them for twenty years. But that won’t stop the maniac.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Natalia, 48 y.o.</strong>: The position of pacifism in a fight of good and evil, darkness and light, is unacceptable.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Viktor, 50 y.o.</strong>: I guess, this pacifistic attitude hides the fact that these people have a strong association with Russians, and in particular with those who are at war. Associating themselves with them, these \"pacifists\" don't want to [contribute to] their deaths.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Andrey, 33 y.o.</strong>: You can treat the military differently. But people [in Ukraine] didn’t want to wage war, they didn’t attack anybody. We have a lot of contacts with Ukraine soldiers: among them are teachers, professors, and businessmen. They are regular people, who saw what Putin’s army is doing and couldn’t stay away – they went to protect their country. They are victims of aggression so we need to help them in any way possible.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":7007,"data":{"author":"The volunteer of UA Drone Forces","header":"We won’t achieve anything with Putin’s regime if Ukraine doesn’t win this war. And as democratic Russians, we want to change Russia as well."},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Natalia</strong>: For example, the first drone we bought for a doctor of philosophy. He’s still fighting. The best people in Ukraine fight and die in the army. For example, the three of us, giving you an interview, belonged to an alpinism community. And in Ukraine, the deputy head of the Federation of Mountaineering and Climbing of Ukraine has just <a href=\"https://www.facebook.com/scu.org.ua/posts/pfbid02nN4vrtCrsthG7yWBgAgptuTsHSDS9tkHHDagMJjdTko6dfgwSGPXU2f9hS4JkH9Jl\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">died near Soledar</a>. A great man, his wife is a Master of Sports in climbing. And we both saw them in the mountains. He has left four children. All of these people stood up to protect their country from invaders and we want to help them defend and withstand.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Andrey</strong>: They went to war because their crazy neighbor forced them to. And because we associate ourselves with the country, where this crazy neighbor was born, grew up, and gained dictatorial power, then it’s our moral duty to help his victim. On another hand, we won’t achieve anything with Putin’s regime if Ukraine doesn’t win this war. And as democratic Russians, we want to change Russia as well.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"About the mobilized people and protests in Russia","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Natalia</strong>: As a Russian, I don’t accept the totalitarian regime victim narrative. As they say: If you were eaten, there are still two ways out. So, the victim narrative refuses people their own will and their own choice. Have your hands been tied up, have you been chained to the radiator? Even the mobilized — they’re going to the recruitment office on their own legs. And they’re going there with their weird thoughts: “to kill khokhols [Russian ethnic slur for Ukrainians]”, “to win” or whatever’s in their heads. And the victim's narrative is about “we’re not deciding anything, we were made, so we went”.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Viktor</strong>: At the same time, it’s obviously clear that there are separate cases where people were actually [forcibly] taken from work or other places. We understand that people like that exist, but what are we supposed to do? We have to stop the murdering of those who they came to kill. That is more important. If we pity those who were taken, mobilized, this war will not be stopped, there will be more victims.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Personally, I have taken part in street protests in Russia since 2008. I was at <a href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bolotnaya_Square_case\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Bolotnaya Square</a> [on 6 May 2012]. I participated in election observations and saw how they are falsified. In 2014 I left with my family because it became clear that there is no future for my children there. I didn't want my children to be subjected to all this propaganda, which is infused into a person unnoticed starting in kindergarten and school.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Natalia</strong>: I went to the protests too, I was arrested by the police twice. I and my family left after Crimea was occupied [in 2014] and now we live in the United States. Since the start of the war, I've been in a tough mental state, but the activity I’m in — buying drones, it’s supporting me, giving me strength. The war will end when everybody makes an effort for that.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"About the work of the volunteer group","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Andrey</strong>: Initially our group was formed by two volunteers from Canada and Kyiv in April 2022: they asked to buy a drone for Kharkiv's homeland defense. We bought one, then another one. Then we got to know what drones are needed, started establishing tighter connections with Ukrainian soldiers, and worked out logistics routes.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Natalia</strong>: In our group, there’re more than a half Russians, and we’re working together with Ukranians. Ukrainians’ trust in us is very valuable. There are no communication problems in our group. We have correspondence in both Russian and Ukrainian in our chat. We asked a question, how do you feel [about the fact we’re Russian], to our Ukrainian volunteers. Everyone invariably responded that we are not divided here by ethnicity, not by citizenship — Russians and Ukrainians — but by our tasks and goals, by our vision of the situation.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":7008,"data":{"images":[{"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a78b9ea88aed4917a6f1dcb978ecfe56-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a78b9ea88aed4917a6f1dcb978ecfe56-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":600,"real_height_2x":1200},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a78b9ea88aed4917a6f1dcb978ecfe56-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a78b9ea88aed4917a6f1dcb978ecfe56-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":600,"real_height_2x":1200},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a78b9ea88aed4917a6f1dcb978ecfe56-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a78b9ea88aed4917a6f1dcb978ecfe56-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":208,"real_height_2x":415},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a78b9ea88aed4917a6f1dcb978ecfe56-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a78b9ea88aed4917a6f1dcb978ecfe56-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":208,"real_height_2x":415}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Andrey</strong>: I spoke to Ukrainian soldiers personally. They all treated me kindly and with gratitude (<em>after the full-scale war began in Ukraine, there were different attitudes towards help from Russians, part of society doesn’t accept it </em>— <strong>Ed.note</strong>).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Our Ukrainian volunteers collect requests for drones from frontline units. Then we buy drones in Europe, from where our Ukrainian volunteer takes them to Kyiv. There, drones are reprogrammed and volunteers take them to different frontline segments. After receiving the drone, Ukrainian defenders film a video and take a photo with it with our sticker visible. That way we can make sure that drones reach their destinations, exactly the one unit that requested it. We saw how useful and necessary it is – drones save lives. And we started finding friends who financially helped and started working with us on finding and buying drones. In 8 months we grew into a volunteer group and more than 40 of our drones work on the frontline.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Viktor</strong>: We buy civilian drones, often already used, to save money, the most common one is DJI Mavic Air 2. The biggest limitation we have is the funds. If we could buy more, we would supply more.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Natalia</strong>: We have already collected more than 25 thousand euros in donations. And we get donations from completely different places: there were even transfers from Russians, who are in Russia, through other people for safety reasons.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"About the use of drones","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Viktor</strong>: Generally the military uses drones for reconnaissance, so the soldiers could see what kind of situation they’re in, what’s going on on the opposing side, what the enemy's movements are, and what to be ready for. Or, for example, we were told there were situations, when there are no communications between the first and second line, and the enemy could slip through blocks at the first line. And the drones made it possible to see that an attack deep into the second line was being planned. So this awareness allows people to save their lives and successfully defend themselves.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Gleb</strong>: Apart from reconnaissance and artillery correction, drones help in finding injured after the battle, so Ukrainian soldiers could run there in time and get people out. Or you can attach some medicine to a drone and it can bring them to the injured.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":7010,"data":{"text":"Your donations will help us continue to tell the truth about the war in Ukraine and more","title":"Support independent journalism!","buttonText":"Support Important Stories"},"category":"donate-embed"},"type":"donate-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Natalia</strong>: Also drones <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uv2MJtAwJUs\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">fly up</a> to Russian soldiers and help them surrender safely. There is an official Ukraine Ministry of Defence instruction: Russian arranges his surrender on the hotline, comes to the specified spot, and from there a drone leads him along a safe route into the rear.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We have strict accounting and control over who we deliver drones to. Our Ukrainian volunteer oversees several directions and takes requests from units situated on them. Requests are written in letters by commanders, it's quite an official thing. There’s always a waitlist, sorting according to needs: for example, somebody’s drone is out of order and it was their last one. That's the kind of equipment that lives around one-two months on the frontline.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Andrey</strong>: We can’t divulge information about specific units, which we helped. But we can say that our drones participated in the Kherson liberation and the liberation of territories in the Kharkiv direction. Also, our drones are now working around Bakhmut and Donetsk.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Viktor</strong>: In June our drones participated in the battle of Sievierodonetsk. Five ZSU soldiers sent us a video report about getting our drone and a week later we were told that only one of the guys on that video is still alive.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Natalia</strong>: It’s important to highlight that drones are not a weapon. They’re “the eyes” of soldiers. And they’re too valuable as “eyes” to strap grenades to them. But still, because of different “barriers”, I guess, psychological ones, there aren’t a lot of Russian volunteer groups that can help Ukrainians defend themselves. We know of only three such projects, one of them is our UA Drone Forces. Mostly, Russians help with humanitarian aid.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":1347,"header":"In Russia, a Clan War for Putin’s Throne Has Begun. Who Will Win?","_path":"/en/opinions/2023/01/09/in-russia-a-clan-war-for-putins-throne-has-begun-who-will-win/","lead":"IStories editor Roman Anin on how Russia’s Game of Thrones will end","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-1920x960px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-1920x960px_2x.png","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-1272x636px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-1272x636px_2x.png","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-912x456px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-912x456px_2x.png","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-600x400px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-600x400px_2x.png","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-360x360px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84650f3a30b54f93a56bcc69d41ad36f-360x360px_2x.png","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"PHOTO: EFREM LUKATSKY / AP / SCANPIX / LETA","created_at_date":"2023-01-09","created_at_date_time":"2023-01-19T08:02:00Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":5,"first_name":"Роман","last_name":"Анин","first_name_en":"Roman","last_name_en":"Anin","is_public":true,"_path":"roman-anin","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редактор «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Редактор","position_en":"Editor","ordering":null}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"The first G8 summit of the 21st century was held in 2000 on the Japanese island of Okinawa. Russia’s young president, Vladimir Putin, was participating in the meeting for the first time. In a group photo of the heads of government, a smiling Putin stands between U.K. Prime Minister Tony Blair and U.S. President Bill Clinton. \n\nLooking at this photo today, it’s hard to believe that Russia began the century among the world’s elite, in a club with the most developed countries on the planet. After 20 years of Putin's rule, the country has moved into another league, one featuring the likes of Iran, North Korea and Syria. \n\nRussia quite deservedly occupies its place among today’s most isolated and inhumane regimes. And it's not just because of war, but also due to 20 years of political and moral degradation.\n\nTo understand the extent of Russia’s moral decay, read the biographies of its modern-day heroes — those whom authorities have bestowed honorary orders and medals, propagandists have extolled, and teachers have set as examples for children in “patriotic” education lessons.\nNational heroes\nOne of Russia’s main heroes of the war on Ukraine is Yevgeny Prigozhin. Convicted in the past for theft, robbery, fraud, and involvement of minors in criminal activities, Prigozhin began his “career” strangling women, notoriously tearing off their gold earrings after they’d lost consciousness. Today, he’s a hero three times over: for Russia, the DNR and LNR. \nHe heads a paramilitary organization, the Wagner Group, whose forces number in the thousands, and come armed with aircraft, armored vehicles and launch rocket systems. This private army is comprised of convicts and sadists who smash the heads of prisoners with sledgehammers.\n\nPrigozhin and his sort are the heroes of Putin's time. And this, in my opinion, says much more about Russia’s future than does the depth of the decline of the country’s GDP.\nCollapse of Russian society\nMoral degradation has engulfed not just the so-called elites in Russia, but the broader public, as well. The majority of the country’s population supports the barbaric aggression against Ukraine, and these same people wonder why Putin hasn’t wiped Ukraine off the face of the earth yet.\n\nThe war has divided Russian society: parents, poisoned by propaganda, call their children traitors for refusing to support aggression against a neighboring country. Russia’s most successful and educated residents — scientists, entrepreneurs and developers — are leaving en masse. Those who oppose the war, who can’t or don’t want to leave, are paralyzed by fear, suspicion and apathy. As if Dementors have drained them of their strength and deprived them of hope.\nIt seems that Russian society is not ready for regime change. \n\nThis choice, once again, will be made for the people.\n\nThe destruction of the foundations of the state\nPutin turned 70 years old last year. We don’t know how true the many rumors about his serious illnesses are, but still few doubt that he will die relatively soon, based on life expectancy standards if nothing else. \n\nIn states with functioning institutions, the departure of a leader — whether from politics or to the next world — is an event worthy of the front pages of newspapers, but it does not determine a country’s very survival. \n\nReality is quite different in countries with broken institutions, like Russia. In eliminating all possible competitors and canceling elections, Putin has deprived Russia of guarantees for a legitimate and peaceful transfer of power. He has hung the future of the country on a very unreliable hook: his own life.\n\nIt will be difficult for Putin and his fragmented inner circle to agree on a successor, whomever they end up selecting. The war in Ukraine — or rather the military defeats there — have aggravated internal conflicts between Russia’s ruling clans to an extreme. It’s now obvious: we await a fierce struggle for the throne of an aging dictator.\n\nRussia’s “Game of Thrones” \nThe clans operating in Russia today are similar to organized crime groups. Some have their own armies, like Yevgeny Prigozhin and Viktor Zolotov, the head of the National Guard (Rosgvardiya). Others control special forces within secret services, like Nikolai Patrushev, the head of the Security Council of Russia (Sovbez). \nEach clan has its own financial resources, among them banks, state corporations and large companies. Some clans own entire regions, like Ramzan Kadyrov’s Chechnya, and they don’t obey any laws.\n\nRussia’s clans have never been united. For 20 years, they have fought with one another for resources and spheres of influence. For years, Putin has acted as a kind of arbiter in the conflicts of his inner circle, his very presence providing a precarious balance of power among the warring factions. The clans all understand: if Putin leaves office, it will disrupt the balance of power, and a war of all against all will commence. \n\nBut nothing weakens the power of a dictator more than aging and military defeat. As the end of Putin’s reign draws ever nearer — whether due to political forces or old age — the more likely the many cold wars between clans will turn hot.\nThe reasons are twofold. \n\nFor starters, the historical relations between some clans simply doesn’t leave enough room for all of them in Russia without Putin. The victory of one clan means the destruction of its rivals: they, at minimum, will have to give up their assets and influence, and maybe even their lives. \n\nSecond, Putin has deprived himself and the state of a monopoly on violence. In addition to the army and law enforcement agencies, numerous private military groups operate in Russia.\n\nFrontrunners and underdogs in the fight for the throne\nBefore placing a bet on the winner of Russia’s Game of Thrones, let's identify the underdogs. This is the easy part.\n\nWhen a dictator becomes weaker, the key factor in the struggle to succeed him is physical resources: whoever has a larger, more well-equipped army holds an advantage. This much is well understood by people close to Putin. \n\nIt explains too, in my opinion, the transformation of Dmitry Medvedev, who was once Russian liberals’ main hope for the country. Today the West considers him a clown for his ridiculous threats to the world — ”erotic fantasies,” as Prigozhin rather aptly dubbed them. Medvedev’s frivolous saber-rattling is a cowardly boy’s desperate attempt to show the class hooligans that he, too, can be bad. Maybe someone will let him join their gang.\n\nThe war on Ukraine has significantly weakened Sergey Shoigu’s once-influential clan. If, before February last year, this group claimed to be a potential successor, then after all the “gestures of goodwill” — after the world discovered the Russian army’s true nature — it no longer is. \n\nOnce one of the country’s most popular officials, Shoigu has become one of its most hated.\nThe war on Ukraine has so changed the balance of power in Russia’s snake pit such that even the favorites are worried about what lies ahead. Yuri Kovalchuk, the country’s second most influential person, until recently appeared seemingly unshakeable. Today he is at odds with Yevgeny Prigozhin, however, because he understands that in a clan war of all against all, friendship with an aging and weakening dictator no longer matters. Sadists with sledgehammers at the ready will decide.\n\nDoes this mean that Prigozhin, with his private army of thousands of killers, is the top contender to win Russia’s Game of Thrones? The situation is much more complicated in my view.\n\nClan coalitions\nHuman DNA is 99% identical to that of chimpanzees, whose entire politics revolve around alpha males.\n\nYoung and strong, the alpha male chimpanzee keeps the rest of the pack at bay, oversees the distribution of resources and severely punishes those who challenge his authority. As soon as the alpha male begins to age and show signs of weakness, however, a fierce war to replace him begins. \n\nAs primatologists have found, physical strength is an important factor in this power struggle — but it’s not decisive. Equally critical is the ability to build coalitions.\nThe reality of power in Russia’s political system today isn’t much different, as I see it. Victory in the fight to succeed the elderly alpha male will be realized not by a single clan, but by whoever can build the strongest coalition.\n\nThe outlines of one of these possible coalitions began to emerge several months after the full-scale invasion of Ukraine. We are talking about the union between Prigozhin and Kadyrov. It may also be worth adding to this alliance the clan of Zolotov, who has been well acquainted with Prigozhin since the days of “gangster Petersburg,” and who has close ties to Kadyrov. Let's call this trinity the “Coalition of the Bloodthirsty.” Its primary advantages are obvious: cruelty, determination, readiness to ignore human casualties, and of course, a huge united army.\n\n\nAnother coalition that may arise during the struggle for the throne is the alliance among those who were most influential before the start of the invasion of Ukraine: Putin’s friends and colleagues. Let's call this the “Coalition of the Cronies.” Whatever contradictions tear these Kovalchuks, Patrushevs, Tokarevs and Timchenkos apart, I think they also feel the threat posed by the “Coalition of the Bloodthirsty”. They know their flock well and understand that when Prigozhin speaks of fat cattle who can’t tear their pink asses off the sofa for the sake of war, he is referring to them as well. \n\nIf this coalition emerges, then undoubtedly its advantages will be a wealth of financial resources (these people literally own all of Russia), and control over the intelligence services. Although inferior to the “Coalition of the Bloodthirsty”’s military power, they have much greater intelligence, and intellectual potential at their disposal.\n\nA third coalition, which emerged immediately after the start of the war on Ukraine but has not yet identified its leader nor final structure, is the ”Coalition of the Patriots.” The members of this union have not yet realized themselves as a community, but the war awakened in them common values, hatreds and aspirations. The “Coalition of the Patriots” despises the Russian ruling class for its corruption and military defeats, and it rejects the “Coalition of the Bloodthirsty” for its ties to the current government, crime and Chechnya.\n\nThis coalition has huge advantages. Its interests align with those held by the vast majority of people in Russia, including the army: it is against the corruption of the current government, and supports the complete destruction of Ukraine. The “Coalition of the Patriots”, in my opinion, is a dark horse in Russia’s Game of Thrones, the success of which largely depends on who will take the reins.\nRussia at a crossroads\nRussia’s future depends on which coalition emerges victorious in the struggle for the throne. As in ancient fairy tales, there lie three paths before the country.\n\nThe path least bloody is guaranteed by the “Coalition of the Cronies”. Should it win, the victors would repress only the leaders and active members of the opposing clans. Russia’s future would be determined by the children of the leaders of this coalition. Judging by what their acquaintances tell me, these young people would rather enjoy dance parties in Monaco and the ski slopes of Courchevel, than the prospect of becoming another North Korea, with an ongoing war at the border.\n\nIf the “Coalition of the Patriots” wins, Russia will become a military dictatorship. Victory requires a firm hand at the front, and a ruthless war against traitors in the rear. How long this dictatorship would last, no one can say. North Korea has been living this way for more than 70 years.\n\nAnd if the “Coalition of the Bloodthirsty” emerges victorious, both the West and China will have to answer a very difficult question: are they ready to reckon with the fact that one of the largest nuclear arsenals in the world will be in the hands of a “holy trinity”: a strangler of women, who today heads an army of sadists with sledgehammers; an academic from Chechnya who tortures his victims and arranges extrajudicial killings; and a former presidential bodyguard.\n\nHowever this Game of Thrones ends, it’s evident already that Putin does not play a major role. The worst that can happen to a dictator has befallen him: people view him with contempt, not fear. \n\nNever ceasing to threaten the West with his missiles, they depict him in their caricatures as a monkey with a small penis hanging over a nuclear button. \n\nHe writes many hours of speeches, which his press secretary promises the whole world will be reading and analyzing for many years to come. The world keeps on spinning and does not listen, just as passers-by do not pay attention to the madman in the subway, who day in and day out threatens the end of human existence. \n\nHis unceasing efforts to be the alpha male of his pack notwithstanding, its members call him a coward who “ostentatiously fears for his life during a great and difficult war.” \nWith this stain upon him, he will end his career and life.","blocks":[{"data":"The first G8 summit of the 21st century was held in 2000 on the Japanese island of Okinawa. Russia’s young president, Vladimir Putin, was participating in the meeting for the first time. In a group photo of the heads of government, a smiling Putin stands between U.K. Prime Minister Tony Blair and U.S. President Bill Clinton.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Looking at this photo today, it’s hard to believe that Russia began the century among the world’s elite, in a club with the most developed countries on the planet. After 20 years of Putin's rule, the country has moved into another league, one featuring the likes of Iran, North Korea and Syria.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russia quite deservedly occupies its place among today’s most isolated and inhumane regimes. And it's not just because of war, but also due to 20 years of political and moral degradation.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"To understand the extent of Russia’s moral decay, read the biographies of its modern-day heroes — those whom authorities have bestowed honorary orders and medals, propagandists have extolled, and teachers have <a href=\"https://meduza.io/news/2022/10/09/shkola-v-krasnodarskom-krae-soobschila-chto-priglasila-boytsa-chvk-vagnera-na-razgovory-o-vazhnom-a-zatem-zayavila-chto-prihodil-kraeved\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">set as examples</a> for children in “patriotic” education lessons.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":6722,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: KREMLIN.RU","caption":"The G8 summit on Japan’s island of Okinawa","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c4be419a76f43b38246d0d8caede2bb-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c4be419a76f43b38246d0d8caede2bb-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":597,"real_height_2x":1194},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c4be419a76f43b38246d0d8caede2bb-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c4be419a76f43b38246d0d8caede2bb-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":597,"real_height_2x":1194},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c4be419a76f43b38246d0d8caede2bb-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c4be419a76f43b38246d0d8caede2bb-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":206,"real_height_2x":412},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c4be419a76f43b38246d0d8caede2bb-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c4be419a76f43b38246d0d8caede2bb-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":206,"real_height_2x":412}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"National heroes","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"One of Russia’s main heroes of the war on Ukraine is <a href=\"https://www.occrp.org/en/poy/2022/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Yevgeny Prigozhin</a>. Convicted in the past for theft, robbery, fraud, and involvement of minors in criminal activities, Prigozhin began his “career” <a href=\"https://meduza.io/feature/2021/06/15/za-chto-v-1981-godu-v-sssr-sudili-evgeniya-prigozhina-kotorogo-teper-ves-mir-znaet-kak-povara-putina-publikuem-tekst-sudebnogo-dokumenta\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">strangling women</a>, notoriously tearing off their gold earrings after they’d lost consciousness. Today, he’s a hero three times over: for Russia, the DNR and LNR.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"He heads a paramilitary organization, the Wagner Group, whose forces number in the thousands, and come armed with aircraft, armored vehicles and launch rocket systems. This private army is comprised of convicts and sadists who <a href=\"https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2019/11/20/82805-golovorezy-21\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">smash the heads of prisoners</a> with sledgehammers.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Prigozhin and his sort are the heroes of Putin's time. And this, in my opinion, says much more about Russia’s future than does the depth of the decline of the country’s GDP.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":6723,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: AP / SCANPIX / LETA","caption":"Yevgeny Prigozhin at the grave of a Wagner Group member","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/427d65e4a3c749aea274b871d364ed61-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/427d65e4a3c749aea274b871d364ed61-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/427d65e4a3c749aea274b871d364ed61-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/427d65e4a3c749aea274b871d364ed61-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/427d65e4a3c749aea274b871d364ed61-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/427d65e4a3c749aea274b871d364ed61-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/427d65e4a3c749aea274b871d364ed61-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/427d65e4a3c749aea274b871d364ed61-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Collapse of Russian society","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Moral degradation has engulfed not just the so-called elites in Russia, but the broader public, as well. The majority of the country’s population <a href=\"https://www.levada.ru/2022/12/02/konflikt-s-ukrainoj-noyabr-2022-goda/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">supports</a> the barbaric aggression against Ukraine, and these same people <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vcI4BJtznGU&amp;t=2s\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">wonder why</a> Putin hasn’t wiped Ukraine off the face of the earth yet.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The war <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5qmQs2LbnaE\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">has divided</a> Russian society: parents, poisoned by propaganda, call their children traitors for refusing to support aggression against a neighboring country. Russia’s most successful and educated residents — scientists, entrepreneurs and developers — are leaving en masse. Those who oppose the war, who can’t or don’t want to leave, are paralyzed by fear, suspicion and apathy. As if Dementors have drained them of their strength and deprived them of hope.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It seems that Russian society is not ready for regime change.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This choice, once again, will be made for the people.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The destruction of the foundations of the state","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Putin turned 70 years old last year. We don’t know how true the many rumors about his <a href=\"https://www.proekt.media/investigation/chem-boleet-putin/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">serious illnesses</a> are, but still few doubt that he will die relatively soon, based on life expectancy standards if nothing else.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In states with functioning institutions, the departure of a leader — whether from politics or to the next world — is an event worthy of the front pages of newspapers, but it does not determine a country’s very survival.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Reality is quite different in countries with broken institutions, like Russia. In eliminating all possible competitors and canceling elections, Putin has deprived Russia of guarantees for a legitimate and peaceful transfer of power. He has hung the future of the country on a very unreliable hook: his own life.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It will be difficult for Putin and his fragmented inner circle to agree on a successor, whomever they end up selecting. The war in Ukraine — or rather the military defeats there — have aggravated internal conflicts between Russia’s ruling clans to an extreme. It’s now obvious: we await a fierce struggle for the throne of an aging dictator.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russia’s “Game of Thrones”&nbsp;","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The clans operating in Russia today are similar to organized crime groups. Some have their own armies, like Yevgeny Prigozhin and Viktor Zolotov, the head of the National Guard (Rosgvardiya). Others control special forces within secret services, like Nikolai Patrushev, the head of the Security Council of Russia (Sovbez).&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Each clan has its own financial resources, among them banks, state corporations and large companies. Some clans own entire regions, like Ramzan Kadyrov’s Chechnya, and they don’t obey any laws.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russia’s clans have never been united. For 20 years, they have fought with one another for resources and spheres of influence. For years, Putin has acted as a kind of arbiter in the conflicts of his inner circle, his very presence providing a precarious balance of power among the warring factions. The clans all understand: if Putin leaves office, it will disrupt the balance of power, and a war of all against all will commence.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But nothing weakens the power of a dictator more than aging and military defeat. As the end of Putin’s reign draws ever nearer — whether due to political forces or old age — the more likely the many cold wars between clans will turn hot.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":6724,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"PHOTO: REUTERS / SCANPIX / LETA","caption":"Ramzan Kadyrov (in the middle) listens to a report from Andrey Mordvichev, commander of the 8th Guards Combined Arms Army","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa58d9eebe624b67b50e76513d9a4387-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa58d9eebe624b67b50e76513d9a4387-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":806,"real_height_2x":1612},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa58d9eebe624b67b50e76513d9a4387-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa58d9eebe624b67b50e76513d9a4387-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":806,"real_height_2x":1612},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa58d9eebe624b67b50e76513d9a4387-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa58d9eebe624b67b50e76513d9a4387-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":278,"real_height_2x":557},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa58d9eebe624b67b50e76513d9a4387-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fa58d9eebe624b67b50e76513d9a4387-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":278,"real_height_2x":557}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The reasons are twofold.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For starters, the historical relations between some clans simply doesn’t leave enough room for all of them in Russia without Putin. The victory of one clan means the destruction of its rivals: they, at minimum, will have to give up their assets and influence, and maybe even their lives.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Second, Putin has deprived himself and the state of a monopoly on violence. In addition to the army and law enforcement agencies, numerous private military groups operate in Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Frontrunners and underdogs in the fight for the throne","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Before placing a bet on the winner of Russia’s Game of Thrones, let's identify the underdogs. This is the easy part.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"When a dictator becomes weaker, the key factor in the struggle to succeed him is physical resources: whoever has a larger, more well-equipped army holds an advantage. This much is well understood by people close to Putin.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It explains too, in my opinion, the <a href=\"https://www.golosameriki.com/a/6649298.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">transformation</a> of Dmitry Medvedev, who was once Russian liberals’ main hope for the country. Today <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/politics/19/06/2022/62af010c9a794761171182be\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">the West considers</a> him a clown for his ridiculous threats to the world — ”erotic fantasies,” as Prigozhin rather aptly <a href=\"https://www.mk.ru/politics/2022/12/28/prigozhin-nazval-prognoz-medvedeva-eroticheskimi-fantaziyami.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">dubbed them</a>. Medvedev’s frivolous saber-rattling is a cowardly boy’s desperate attempt to show the class hooligans that he, too, can be bad. Maybe someone will let him join their gang.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The war on Ukraine has significantly weakened Sergey Shoigu’s once-influential clan. If, before February last year, this group <a href=\"https://istories.media/investigations/2022/06/14/kak-voina-raskolola-odin-iz-samikh-vliyatelnikh-politicheskikh-klanov-rossii/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">claimed</a> to be a potential successor, then after all the <a href=\"https://www.yahoo.com/video/russians-ready-another-goodwill-gesture-150400615.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">“gestures of goodwill”</a> — after the world discovered the Russian army’s true nature — it no longer is.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Once one of the country’s most popular officials, Shoigu has <a href=\"https://istories.media/opinions/2022/08/23/kto-upravlyaet-rossiiskimi-voiskami/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">become</a> one of its most hated.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":6725,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"PHOTO: SPUTNIK / REUTERS / SCANPIX / LETA","caption":"Minister of defense Sergey Shoigu","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1db50df55d0c4252a0b21b2bd7534269-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1db50df55d0c4252a0b21b2bd7534269-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":788,"real_height_2x":1576},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1db50df55d0c4252a0b21b2bd7534269-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1db50df55d0c4252a0b21b2bd7534269-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":788,"real_height_2x":1576},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1db50df55d0c4252a0b21b2bd7534269-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1db50df55d0c4252a0b21b2bd7534269-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":272,"real_height_2x":545},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1db50df55d0c4252a0b21b2bd7534269-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1db50df55d0c4252a0b21b2bd7534269-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":272,"real_height_2x":545}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The war on Ukraine has so changed the balance of power in Russia’s snake pit such that even the favorites are worried about what lies ahead. Yuri Kovalchuk, the country’s second most influential person, until recently appeared <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mPc3_5PXaUA\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">seemingly unshakeable</a>. Today he is <a href=\"https://istories.media/opinions/2022/12/28/s-kem-vrazhduet-povar-putina/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">at odds with</a> Yevgeny Prigozhin, however, because he understands that in a clan war of all against all, friendship with an aging and weakening dictator no longer matters. Sadists with sledgehammers at the ready will decide.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Does this mean that Prigozhin, with his private army of thousands of killers, is the top contender to win Russia’s Game of Thrones? The situation is much more complicated in my view.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Clan coalitions","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Human DNA is <a href=\"https://www.science.org/content/article/bonobos-join-chimps-closest-human-relatives#:~:text=Ever%20since%20researchers%20sequenced%20the,them%20our%20closest%20living%20relatives\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">99% identical</a> to that of chimpanzees, whose entire politics revolve around alpha males.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Young and strong, the alpha male chimpanzee keeps the rest of the pack at bay, oversees the distribution of resources and severely punishes those who challenge his authority. As soon as the alpha male begins to age and show signs of weakness, however, a fierce war to replace him begins.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"As primatologists <a href=\"https://id.hse.ru/books/131326552.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">have found</a>, physical strength is an important factor in this power struggle — but it’s not decisive. Equally critical is the ability to build coalitions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The reality of power in Russia’s political system today isn’t much different, as I see it. Victory in the fight to succeed the elderly alpha male will be realized not by a single clan, but by whoever can build the strongest coalition.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The outlines of one of these possible coalitions began to emerge several months after the full-scale invasion of Ukraine. We are talking about the <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/features-63400922\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">union</a> between Prigozhin and Kadyrov. It may also be worth adding to this alliance the clan of Zolotov, who has been <a href=\"https://euromaidanpress.com/2022/12/02/from-decade-in-prison-to-putins-chef-who-is-wagner-ceo-evgeny-prigozhin/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">well acquainted with Prigozhin</a> since the days of “gangster Petersburg,” and who has close ties to Kadyrov. Let's call this trinity the “Coalition of the Bloodthirsty.” Its primary advantages are obvious: cruelty, determination, readiness to ignore human casualties, and of course, a huge united army.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":7015,"data":{"text":"Your donations will help us continue to tell the truth about the war in Ukraine and more","title":"Support independent journalism!","buttonText":"Support Important Stories"},"category":"donate-embed"},"type":"donate-embed"},{"data":"Another coalition that may arise during the struggle for the throne is the alliance among those who were most influential before the start of the invasion of Ukraine: Putin’s friends and colleagues. Let's call this the “Coalition of the Cronies.” Whatever contradictions tear these Kovalchuks, Patrushevs, Tokarevs and Timchenkos apart, I think they also feel the threat posed by the “Coalition of the Bloodthirsty”. They know their flock well and understand that when Prigozhin <a href=\"https://vk.com/wall-177427428_1111\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">speaks of fat cattle</a> who can’t tear their pink asses off the sofa for the sake of war, he is referring to them as well.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"If this coalition emerges, then undoubtedly its advantages will be a wealth of financial resources (these people literally own all of Russia), and control over the intelligence services. Although inferior to the “Coalition of the Bloodthirsty”’s military power, they have much greater intelligence, and intellectual potential at their disposal.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A third coalition, which emerged immediately after the start of the war on Ukraine but has not yet identified its leader nor final structure, is the ”Coalition of the Patriots.” The members of this union have not yet realized themselves as a community, but the war awakened in them common values, hatreds and aspirations. The “Coalition of the Patriots” despises the Russian ruling class for its corruption and military defeats, and it rejects the “Coalition of the Bloodthirsty” for its ties to the current government, crime and Chechnya.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This coalition has huge advantages. Its interests align with those held by the vast majority of people in Russia, including the army: it is against the corruption of the current government, and supports the complete destruction of Ukraine. The “Coalition of the Patriots”, in my opinion, is a dark horse in Russia’s Game of Thrones, the success of which largely depends on who will take the reins.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":6726,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"PHOTO: REUTERS / SCANPIX / LETA","caption":"Head of the Security Council of Russia (Sovbez) Nikolai Patrushev (left)","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e045dca217004fc39e47e8749187d083-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e045dca217004fc39e47e8749187d083-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e045dca217004fc39e47e8749187d083-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e045dca217004fc39e47e8749187d083-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e045dca217004fc39e47e8749187d083-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e045dca217004fc39e47e8749187d083-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e045dca217004fc39e47e8749187d083-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e045dca217004fc39e47e8749187d083-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Russia at a crossroads","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Russia’s future depends on which coalition emerges victorious in the struggle for the throne. As in ancient fairy tales, there lie three paths before the country.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The path least bloody is guaranteed by the “Coalition of the Cronies”. Should it win, the victors would repress only the leaders and active members of the opposing clans. Russia’s future would be determined by the children of the leaders of this coalition. Judging by what their acquaintances tell me, these young people would rather enjoy dance parties in Monaco and the ski slopes of Courchevel, than the prospect of becoming another North Korea, with an ongoing war at the border.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"If the “Coalition of the Patriots” wins, Russia will become a military dictatorship. Victory requires a firm hand at the front, and a ruthless war against traitors in the rear. How long this dictatorship would last, no one can say. North Korea has been living this way for more than 70 years.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"And if the “Coalition of the Bloodthirsty” emerges victorious, both the West and China will have to answer a very difficult question: are they ready to reckon with the fact that one of the largest nuclear arsenals in the world will be in the hands of a “holy trinity”: a strangler of women, who today heads an army of sadists with sledgehammers; an academic from Chechnya who <a href=\"https://www.svoboda.org/a/ibragim-yangulbaev-menya-pytal-lichno-kadyrov/31708446.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">tortures</a> his victims and arranges <a href=\"https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2021/03/15/ia-sluzhil-v-chechenskoi-politsii-i-ne-khotel-ubivat-liudei-18\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">extrajudicial killings</a>; and a former presidential bodyguard.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However this Game of Thrones ends, it’s evident already that Putin does not play a major role. The worst that can happen to a dictator has befallen him: people view him with contempt, not fear.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Never ceasing to threaten the West with his missiles, they <a href=\"https://twitter.com/charlie_hebdo_/status/1498704627667189762\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">depict him</a> in their caricatures as a monkey with a small penis hanging over a nuclear button.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"He writes many hours of speeches, which his press secretary <a href=\"https://www.vedomosti.ru/politics/news/2022/10/27/947679-peskov-zayavil-chto-rech-putina-na-valdae-budu-perechitivat\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">promises</a> the whole world will be reading and analyzing for many years to come. The world keeps on spinning and does not listen, just as passers-by do not pay attention to the madman in the subway, who day in and day out threatens the end of human existence.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"His unceasing efforts to be the alpha male of his pack notwithstanding, its members <a href=\"https://t.me/strelkovii/3693\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">call him</a> a coward who “ostentatiously fears for his life during a great and difficult war.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"With this stain upon him, he will end his career and life.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":1299,"header":"Why Russia Won’t Disintegrate","_path":"/en/opinions/2022/11/15/why-russia-wont-disintegrate/","lead":"In short: because regions have no independent elites, the Russian ethnic population prevalented, and the national peripheries are financially dependent on Moscow. But federalization after the regime's collapse is inevitable","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-1920x960px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-1920x960px_2x.png","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-1272x636px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-1272x636px_2x.png","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-912x456px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-912x456px_2x.png","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-600x400px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-600x400px_2x.png","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-360x360px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e8ad53ae0fe0491f8ec66d6edf9f774d-360x360px_2x.png","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Photo: Reuters / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2022-11-15","created_at_date_time":"2023-01-11T08:51:00Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":2517,"last_name":"","first_name":"Редакция","last_name_en":"","first_name_en":"Editors","ordering":null}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"Arguments about how “Russia is about to fall apart” are a fairly regular prediction among political scientists, and have been for all 30 years of the country’s existence since the fall of the Soviet Union. The war with Ukraine has drastically shortened the timeframe of these apocalyptic predictions: first, Russia could well lose the war and, second, a defeat would weaken the regime of President Vladimir Putin — and who knows if he’ll manage to hold onto power? \n\n“No Putin, no Russia,” is a phrase some representatives of the democratic opposition are ready to quote, following State Duma Chairman Vyacheslav Volodin’s lead. Those in the democratic opposition believe that the weakening of the central government will push the oblasts to govern themselves independently. IStories spoke with political scientist Alexander Kynev about why, from his point of view, nothing like this will happen.\n\nTypes of disintegration\nThe break-up of Russia is unlikely even should Putin lose his war on Ukraine. The disintegration of states isn’t accidental; the primary reasons it may happen are twofold.\nFirst, the behavior of the elites who control territory. In such a case, regions that were already actually self-sufficient would be detached. The collapse of an empire is often a collapse along the boundaries of personal unions. Take for instance a monarch of several states. He annexed the territories through dynastic alliances, treaties, etc. And then, when the very figure of the monarch disappears from this association, the empire crumbles and the territories continue to go their own way. \n\nElements of such a disintegration were also seen in Russia, when the Kingdom of Poland and the Grand Duchy of Finland (actually independent states with their own constitutions) withdrew from the collapsing Russian Empire in the 20th century. Sometimes this core, in the form of a monarchy, replaces something else. For example, in the Soviet Union, the monarch figure was, in fact, replaced by the Communist Party, which held the republics together by a parallel system of power.\n\nIn this scenario, the regions already have their own established elites, they are self-sufficient and make political decisions. Such a scenario is typical for the collapse of traditional empires in Europe and the Middle East.\n\nSecond, for social, cultural and ethnic reasons, when territories under the rule of some ethnic groups then separate and self-determine. This “national self-determination” is more a story about the end of colonialism in the 20th century. Territories and their autochthonous populations were captured, to be ruled by an external administration. As self-awareness and a sense of unity grew among the people, alongside the development of a common language, coordination and cooperation took place, an identity appeared, and the territory later got a chance for self-determination. \n\nOften such a territory did not have any prototype in the past — many colonial possessions did not have any states before the colonizers came. The basis of disintegration in these cases is namely ethnic self-determination, but it still runs along the existing administrative boundaries within the colonies. Although they are often revised, one can recall the history of two Cameroons — French and English — which then united.\n\nThe most easily separated territories are remote, whose connection with the empire is weak. Here the question of disintegration is a question of self-determination, assessments of profitability and economic connections, the ability to retain control, and more. The Spanish colonies in Latin America are an example of this, though the disintegration still took place largely along the administrative boundaries established by the Spaniards.\n\nIn any case, disintegration requires either an elite that is interested in it and controls the territory, or for populations within the larger empire to feel like distinct communities; that’s usually expressed in the proportion of ethnic or religious groups that live in this territory.\n\nIt’s difficult to imagine a secession situation when the territories don’t differ from one another; the same people live there, there’s no elite and no differences among the population.\n\nNo elites, no ethnic groups\nMost of the regions in Russia have a majority ethnic Russian population — over 80% in most. There are few ethnic republics in which titular ethnic groups are the majority: even many large ethnic regions still by-and-large have a Russian population. Buryatia, for example is 66% ethnic Russian. \n\nIn many republics there is also no single [dominant] ethnic group. In Dagestan, for example, there are more than one hundred ethnic groups, with four dominating. In other regions, a single ethnic group breaks up into sub-ethnic groups or clans, as in Yakutia. In this case, the ethnic Russians act as a lubricant that unites the territory, with the Russian language serving as a common tongue.\n\nThere is a small set of regions that have a pronounced ethnic identity. These lie mostly on the periphery: a belt along the borders in the North Caucasus and South Siberia. That’s Tyva, which was the last region to join the Soviet Union, and largely retained its identity, though it is absolutely loyal to Moscow. Regions such as Yakutia or Tatarstan are, in fact, enclaves — they are surrounded by the larger Russian state and have no external borders. We don’t know of cases from history of successful separation of enclosed regions like these.\n\nAs for the elite factor, many people remember the regional elites of the 1990s — Tatarstan President Mintimer Shaimiev, and Moscow Mayor Yury Luzhkov, to name a couple. This is a relic of a bygone era. Regional elites as an entity have disappeared over the past 20 years — the Kremlin’s regional policy was deliberately built to destroy the potential for [power centers outside of the center] to form. \n\nPower in the regions is de facto appointed by Moscow from top to bottom — there is not one power vertical, there are many. Regional administrations are not a single force; governors can’t appoint their own deputies without Moscow’s consent, for instance, and each deputy has their own Moscow boss. It is a multi-layered cake, where almost every official operates within a vertical from Moscow. They are regularly rotated, too: it’s rare for a governor to serve more than one term. Deputies change even more often. \n\nWhat team would be capable of pursuing their own policy amid these conditions, much less separating a region?\nWhen the Soviet Union collapsed, the union republics had stable elites that didn’t change for years. Under Stalin, there was a strong reshuffling of personnel — a conscious policy to mitigate threats of collapse. Khrushchev continued this policy, also often rotating regional leaders. Under Brezhnev, stabilization began in everything. Under his rule, leadership in the territories didn’t change for decades: the First Secretaries [the actual leaders of the republics that were part of the USSR] sat quietly for 15-18 years. When Gorbachev came, there was also no personnel revolution — yes, they were sent into retirement, but they were replaced mainly by other local leaders. There was one “alien” sent to the republic — Gennady Kolbin to Kazakhstan — which caused protest. He didn't stay there long.\n\nIn the late Soviet Union, there were stable elites who knew each other and controlled territory. There is none of that now. There are managers who are tied to Moscow and represent Moscow — not the regions.\n \nThere are no economic elites either, because practically all large regional property long ago became part of federal corporations. Even large medium-sized local businesses are almost non-existent; what’s left are pittances: something from trade, something from construction, local food industry, agricultural enterprises... But there is nothing close to the companies of the 1990s, which were a sort of base for regional elites. The former regional elites have become the regional managers of federal companies. Some have been there for a long time and know each other, and even have some sort of local business, but this is not the case to separate.\n\nBasically, they are represented in legislative assemblies, there are regions where they are well coordinated — such as the Novosibirsk region — but on the whole they are very dependent, weak, have no leaders, and cannot formulate a coherent policy agenda. I don't see the possibility of an entity separating from among the regions.\n\nOf course, there are still a few regions with strong elites that Moscow is afraid to touch. For example, Tatarstan.\n\nEven if there are several border regions with a predominant ethnic group and a strong local elite, they’re all subsidized [by the federal government]. For example, Chechnya.\n\nYou can look at the modern world: take France, which has retained the largest network of overseas possessions. In places like French Polynesia or New Caledonia, which you can’t even reach without refueling the plane, well, what do you have in common with France? Nevertheless, secession referendums are held regularly — they fail, people want to stay. Why? Because France supports these territories financially. Only help from Paris allows them to maintain a high standard of living. \n\nIt’s enough to go to any neighboring country to understand the difference. There is the French island of Mayotte, a former part of the Comoros, which remained with France after a referendum in the 1970s. When you swim across the strait and find yourself on the neighboring islands, you realize what a colossal difference it is. What they have is a small slice of Europe (albeit completely Islamic) and after a few tens of kilometers, absolute poverty, mountains of garbage, etc. Everyone understands that this [high standard of living] is possible only with outside help. So who needs to separate and what for?\n\nAll the talk about Russia’s collapse is more about political desires, affirmations, which have psychological and ideological underpinnings, but stray far from reality and the needs of the regions.\n\nNot a collapse, but a change of flags\nWhat is the worst-case scenario? The collapse of the state, the collapse of the federal government, insoluble conflicts between federal groups. In conditions of unrest, when there is no federal power, turmoil can begin and something could really crumble along the edges. But all things being equal, I don’t foresee such a scenario. I think that if the crystallization of regional elites starts, it won’t be now. Rather, it’ll happen after [regime] change in the federal government, when the agenda will change and new rules of the game will be determined.\nThe lion's share of the appointees, most likely, would immediately leave the regions. A certain vacuum would develop, filled with something. What that something will be, we don’t know — leaders will emerge in the process. All this would come later. And it doesn’t necessarily lead to disintegration — there would simply be a negotiation process on the powers to be held (keeping the topic of finance in mind).\n\nOne should not confuse anti-Moscow sentiments with separatist desires. If you look at local sociology, yes, there’s dissatisfaction with the bureaucracy, the establishment, and there are anti-Moscow sentiments. But there are no sentiments that could be interpreted as \"for disintegration.\" This is not the same thing — many make a semantic substitution here. \nOn the contrary, people who are in favor of disintegration are perceived in a negative light on the ground, to put it mildly. People perceive it as a value that they live in Russia. Many residents of the Far East are much more patriotic than Muscovites. For example, the movement for the retention of the Kuril Islands at Sakhalin is strong. And the people of Sakhalin in this sense are much more patriotic than the average Muscovite, who will say: ‘Come on, give these Kurils [to Japan] and don’t suffer anymore.’\n\nTheoretically, separatist desires could arise in raw-material donor regions, such as KhMAO [Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug], YNAO [Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous Okrug]. But there’s nothing like that. And there, almost all resources are federal property. Nobody will give it to them.\n\nAfter the change of power I believe federalization rather than disintegration will begin. Simply because it’s cyclical — in our country the relations between the center and the regions have always shifted on a pendulum. Now things have turned out to be too strongly relegated to the side of unification and centralization — there is a pending request for distinctiveness, for somehow identifying ourselves, to find points of self-development.\nI think that, just like 30 years ago, the movement will be largely symbolic. Where did self-determination begin in the early 1990s? Regional flags, renaming of territories, anthems, and so on. It seems to me this is the best, safe option, because the center has generally unified everything, and a departure from unification will be well received. \nLet them argue, foaming at the mouth, what to call the republics — to carry out, say, a reform of the names of the regions. In Russia we usually call them by the names of the capitals, but outside of Russia this is not always the case. I now think that one of the ways to hold the country together would be a campaign to choose geographical names for regions — for example, through referenda. It would be a colossal process that would launch social life. \n\nLet's say we make all oblasts into “krais” and let them choose their own names — for example, ‘Ladoga Krai’, ‘Yenisei Krai’, or turn Zabaykalsky Krai to Baikal Krai. Moving away from being tied to the name of the capital would be a good story about independence, identity and an attempt to say who we are generally.\n\nEverything that concerns authority — for example, the organization of federal and local police, legal proceedings, taxes — I think, will be decided separately in each region.\nThere will be a difficult story, perhaps we will have to adopt transitional laws, a new Constitution, and then in the course of discussions some concepts, points of view will be formed, they will acquire supporters, and political parties will form around this. I want to remind you that in the U.S. the first major parties appeared just around the topic of separation of powers — the John Adams’ Federalists and the Thomas Jefferson’s Democratic-Republicans. Everything will be nonlinear in our country — there cannot be a two-party system due to the diversity of the political environment. We cannot have one common opposition, there will definitely be separate left, separate right, etc.\n\nI think that a new concept will be formed in the process of negotiating, and it’ll be a good lesson — there will be a crystallization of the elites. But all this will be after a change of power, not before.\n\nThis text is a retelling of Alexander Kynev's responses from an interview with IStories.","blocks":[{"data":"Arguments about how “Russia is about to fall apart” are a fairly regular prediction among political scientists, and have been for all 30 years of the country’s existence since the fall of the Soviet Union. The war with Ukraine has drastically shortened the timeframe of these apocalyptic predictions: first, Russia could well lose the war and, second, a defeat would weaken the regime of President Vladimir Putin — and who knows if he’ll manage to hold onto power?&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“No Putin, no Russia,” is a phrase some representatives of the democratic opposition are ready to quote, following State Duma Chairman <a href=\"https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2022/03/14/lets-call-putin-fascist-autocrat-00016982\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Vyacheslav Volodin’s lead</a>. Those in the democratic opposition believe that the weakening of the central government will push the oblasts to govern themselves independently. IStories spoke with political scientist Alexander Kynev about why, from his point of view, nothing like this will happen.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Types of disintegration","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The break-up of Russia is unlikely even should Putin lose his war on Ukraine. The disintegration of states isn’t accidental; the primary reasons it may happen are twofold.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"First, the behavior of the elites who control territory. In such a case, regions that were already actually self-sufficient would be detached. The collapse of an empire is often a collapse along the boundaries of personal unions. Take for instance a monarch of several states. He annexed the territories through dynastic alliances, treaties, etc. And then, when the very figure of the monarch disappears from this association, the empire crumbles and the territories continue to go their own way.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Elements of such a disintegration were also seen in Russia, when the Kingdom of Poland and the Grand Duchy of Finland (actually independent states with their own constitutions) withdrew from the collapsing Russian Empire in the 20th century. Sometimes this core, in the form of a monarchy, replaces something else. For example, in the Soviet Union, the monarch figure was, in fact, replaced by the Communist Party, which held the republics together by a parallel system of power.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In this scenario, the regions already have their own established elites, they are self-sufficient and make political decisions. Such a scenario is typical for the collapse of traditional empires in Europe and the Middle East.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Second, for social, cultural and ethnic reasons, when territories under the rule of some ethnic groups then separate and self-determine. This “national self-determination” is more a story about the end of colonialism in the 20th century. Territories and their autochthonous populations were captured, to be ruled by an external administration. As self-awareness and a sense of unity grew among the people, alongside the development of a common language, coordination and cooperation took place, an identity appeared, and the territory later got a chance for self-determination.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Often such a territory did not have any prototype in the past — many colonial possessions did not have any states before the colonizers came. The basis of disintegration in these cases is namely ethnic self-determination, but it still runs along the existing administrative boundaries within the colonies. Although they are often revised, one can recall the history of two Cameroons — French and English — which then united.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":6639,"data":{"author":" ","header":"Disintegration requires either an elite that is interested in it and controls territory, or for the population of the territory to feel like an ethnic or religious community"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"The most easily separated territories are remote, whose connection with the empire is weak. Here the question of disintegration is a question of self-determination, assessments of profitability and&nbsp;economic connections, the ability to retain control, and more. The Spanish colonies in Latin America are an example of this, though the disintegration still took place largely along the administrative boundaries established by the Spaniards.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In any case, disintegration requires either an elite that is interested in it and controls the territory, or for populations within the larger empire to feel like distinct communities; that’s usually expressed in the proportion of ethnic or religious groups that live in this territory.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It’s difficult to imagine a secession situation when the territories don’t differ from one another; the same people live there, there’s no elite and no differences among the population.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"No elites, no ethnic groups","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Most of the regions in Russia <a href=\"https://russia.duck.consulting/maps/93\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">have a majority ethnic Russian population</a> — over 80% in most. There are few ethnic republics in which titular ethnic groups are the majority: even many large ethnic regions still by-and-large have a Russian population. <a href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buryatia\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Buryatia</a>, for example is 66% ethnic Russian.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In many republics there is also no single [dominant] ethnic group. In Dagestan, for example, there are more than one hundred ethnic groups, with four dominating. In other regions, a single ethnic group breaks up into sub-ethnic groups or clans, as in Yakutia. In this case, the ethnic Russians act as a lubricant that unites the territory, with the Russian language serving as a common tongue.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There is a small set of regions that have a pronounced ethnic identity. These lie mostly on the periphery: a belt along the borders in the North Caucasus and South Siberia. That’s Tyva, which was the last region to join the Soviet Union, and largely retained its identity, though it is absolutely loyal to Moscow. Regions such as Yakutia or Tatarstan are, in fact, enclaves — they are surrounded by the larger Russian state and have no external borders. We don’t know of cases from history of successful separation of enclosed regions like these.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"As for the elite factor, many people remember the regional elites of the 1990s — Tatarstan President <a href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mintimer_Shaimiev\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Mintimer Shaimiev</a>, and Moscow Mayor <a href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yury_Luzhkov\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Yury Luzhkov</a>, to name a couple. This is a relic of a bygone era. Regional elites as an entity have disappeared over the past 20 years — the Kremlin’s regional policy was deliberately built to destroy the potential for [power centers outside of the center] to form.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Power in the regions is de facto appointed by Moscow from top to bottom — there is not one power vertical, there are many. Regional administrations are not a single force; governors can’t appoint their own deputies without Moscow’s consent, for instance, and each deputy has their own Moscow boss. It is a multi-layered cake, where almost every official operates within a vertical from Moscow. They are regularly rotated, too: it’s rare for a governor to serve more than one term. Deputies change even more often.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"What team would be capable of pursuing their own policy amid these conditions, much less separating a region?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":6640,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: kremlin.ru","caption":"There is not one vertical of power in Russia, there are many of them: almost every regional head has their own Moscow boss","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0d239af12a804ed396aca19a2486bccc-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0d239af12a804ed396aca19a2486bccc-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":740,"real_height_2x":1480},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0d239af12a804ed396aca19a2486bccc-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0d239af12a804ed396aca19a2486bccc-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":740,"real_height_2x":1480},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0d239af12a804ed396aca19a2486bccc-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0d239af12a804ed396aca19a2486bccc-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":256,"real_height_2x":512},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0d239af12a804ed396aca19a2486bccc-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0d239af12a804ed396aca19a2486bccc-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":256,"real_height_2x":512}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"When the Soviet Union collapsed, the union republics had stable elites that didn’t change for years. Under Stalin, there was a strong reshuffling of personnel — a conscious policy to mitigate threats of collapse. Khrushchev continued this policy, also often rotating regional leaders. Under Brezhnev, stabilization began in everything. Under his rule, leadership in the territories didn’t change for decades:&nbsp;the First Secretaries [the actual leaders of the republics that were part of the USSR] sat quietly for 15-18 years. When Gorbachev came, there was also no personnel revolution — yes, they were sent into retirement, but they were replaced mainly by other local leaders. There was one “alien” sent to the republic — Gennady Kolbin to Kazakhstan — which caused protest. He didn't stay there long.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In the late Soviet Union, there were stable elites who knew each other and controlled territory. There is none of that now. There are managers who are tied to Moscow and represent Moscow — not the regions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There are no economic elites either, because practically all large regional property long ago became part of federal corporations. Even large medium-sized local businesses are almost non-existent; what’s left are pittances: something from trade, something from construction, local food industry, agricultural enterprises... But there is nothing close to the companies of the 1990s, which were a sort of base for regional elites. The former regional elites have become the regional managers of federal companies. Some have been there for a long time and know each other, and even have some sort of local business, but this is not the case to separate.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Basically, they are represented in legislative assemblies, there are regions where they are well coordinated — such as the Novosibirsk region — but on the whole they are very dependent, weak, have no leaders, and cannot formulate a coherent policy agenda. I don't see the possibility of an entity separating from among the regions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Of course, there are still a few regions with strong elites that Moscow is afraid to touch. For example, Tatarstan.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Even if there are several border regions with a predominant ethnic group and a strong local elite, they’re all subsidized [by the federal government]. For example, Chechnya.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"You can look at the modern world: take France, which has retained the largest network of overseas possessions. In places like French Polynesia or New Caledonia, which you can’t even reach without refueling the plane, well, what do you have in common with France? Nevertheless, secession referendums are held regularly — they fail, people want to stay. Why? Because France supports these territories financially. Only help from Paris allows them to maintain a high standard of living.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It’s enough to go to any neighboring country to understand the difference. There is the French island of Mayotte, a former part of the Comoros, which remained with France after a referendum in the 1970s. When you swim across the strait and find yourself on the neighboring islands, you realize what a colossal difference it is. What they have is a small slice of Europe (albeit completely Islamic) and after a few tens of kilometers, absolute poverty, mountains of garbage, etc. Everyone understands that this [high standard of living] is possible only with outside help. So who needs to separate and what for?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"All the talk about Russia’s collapse is more about political desires, affirmations, which have psychological and ideological underpinnings, but stray far from reality and the needs of the regions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Not a collapse, but a change of flags","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"What is the worst-case scenario? The collapse of the state, the collapse of the federal government, insoluble conflicts between federal groups. In conditions of unrest, when there is no federal power, turmoil can begin and something could really crumble along the edges. But all things being equal, I don’t foresee such a scenario. I think that if the crystallization of regional elites starts, it won’t be now. Rather, it’ll happen after [regime] change in the federal government, when the agenda will change and new rules of the game will be determined.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The lion's share of the appointees, most likely, would immediately leave the regions. A certain vacuum would develop, filled with something. What that something will be, we don’t know — leaders will emerge in the process. All this would come later. And it doesn’t necessarily lead to disintegration — there would simply be a negotiation process on the powers to be held (keeping the topic of finance in mind).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"One should not confuse anti-Moscow sentiments with separatist desires. If you look at local sociology, yes, there’s dissatisfaction with the bureaucracy, the establishment, and there are anti-Moscow sentiments. But there are no sentiments that could be interpreted as \"for disintegration.\" This is not the same thing — many make a semantic substitution here.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"On the contrary, people who are in favor of disintegration are perceived in a negative light on the ground, to put it mildly. People perceive it as a value that they live in Russia. Many residents of the Far East are much more patriotic than Muscovites. For example, the movement for the <a href=\"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuril_Islands_dispute\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">retention of the Kuril Islands at Sakhalin</a> is strong. And the people of Sakhalin in this sense are much more patriotic than the average Muscovite, who will say: ‘Come on, give these Kurils [to Japan] and don’t suffer anymore.’","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Theoretically, separatist desires could arise in raw-material donor regions, such as KhMAO [Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug], YNAO [Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous Okrug]. But there’s nothing like that. And there, almost all resources are federal property. Nobody will give it to them.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After the change of power I believe federalization rather than disintegration will begin. Simply because it’s cyclical — in our country the relations between the center and the regions have always shifted on a pendulum. Now things have turned out to be too strongly relegated to the side of unification and centralization — there is a pending request for distinctiveness, for somehow identifying ourselves, to find points of self-development.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":6641,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: AP / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"The arrest of Khabarovsk governor Sergei Furgal sparked months of protests. Don’t confuse anti-Moscow sentiments with separatist desires, however.","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/762353464cf3469c823be25c066fed85-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/762353464cf3469c823be25c066fed85-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":799,"real_height_2x":1598},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/762353464cf3469c823be25c066fed85-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/762353464cf3469c823be25c066fed85-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":799,"real_height_2x":1598},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/762353464cf3469c823be25c066fed85-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/762353464cf3469c823be25c066fed85-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":552},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/762353464cf3469c823be25c066fed85-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/762353464cf3469c823be25c066fed85-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":552}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"I think that, just like 30 years ago, the movement will be largely symbolic. Where did self-determination begin in the early 1990s? Regional flags, renaming of territories, anthems, and so on. It seems to me this is the best, safe option, because the center has generally unified everything, and a departure from unification will be well received.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Let them argue, foaming at the mouth, what to call the republics — to carry out, say, a reform of the names of the regions. In Russia we usually call them by the names of the capitals, but outside of Russia this is not always the case. I now think that one of the ways to hold the country together would be a campaign to choose geographical names for regions — for example, through referenda. It would be a colossal process that would launch social life.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Let's say we make all oblasts into “krais” and let them choose their own names — for example, ‘Ladoga Krai’, ‘Yenisei Krai’, or turn Zabaykalsky Krai to Baikal Krai. Moving away from being tied to the name of the capital would be a good story about independence, identity and an attempt to say who we are generally.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Everything that concerns authority — for example, the organization of federal and local police, legal proceedings, taxes — I think, will be decided separately in each region.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There will be a difficult story, perhaps we will have to adopt transitional laws, a new Constitution, and then in the course of discussions some concepts, points of view will be formed, they will acquire supporters, and political parties will form around this. I want to remind you that in the U.S. the first major parties appeared just around the topic of separation of powers — the John Adams’ Federalists and the Thomas Jefferson’s Democratic-Republicans. Everything will be nonlinear in our country — there cannot be a two-party system due to the diversity of the political environment. We cannot have one common opposition, there will definitely be separate left, separate right, etc.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"I think that a new concept will be formed in the process of negotiating, and it’ll be a good lesson — there will be a crystallization of the elites. But all this will be after a change of power, not before.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>This text is a retelling of Alexander Kynev's responses from an interview with IStories.</em>","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":622,"header":"What Would Happen If Putin's Most Cherished Dream about the War Came True?","_path":"/en/opinions/2022/06/28/what-would-happen-if-putins-most-cherished-dream-about-the-war-came-true/","lead":"Or why true patriots of Russia should want the army to leave Ukraine as soon as possible — the opinion of Roman Anin, editor-in-chief of Important Stories","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-1920x960px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-1920x960px_2x.png","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-1272x636px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-1272x636px_2x.png","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-912x456px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-912x456px_2x.png","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-600x400px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-600x400px_2x.png","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-360x360px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/be10a758413e431b8cfd200babaca129-360x360px_2x.png","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Photo: EPA / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2022-06-28","created_at_date_time":null,"updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":5,"first_name":"Роман","last_name":"Анин","first_name_en":"Roman","last_name_en":"Anin","is_public":true,"_path":"roman-anin","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редактор «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Редактор","position_en":"Editor","ordering":null}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"By the fifth month of the war, Russian public opinion about the so-called \"special military operation\" has divided roughly into three camps. On one side there is a camp of the bloodthirsty. The motto of their party is simple: \"Not a step back! Wipe the Ukrops [derogatory term for Ukrainians sometimes used in Russia] and their cities off the face of the earth! And if they resist, we'll hit them with a nuclear weapon! They will all die, and we will go to paradise.\" On the other side, there is a camp of those who oppose the war, with its well-known rhetoric: \"War is evil! Putin is a war criminal!” \n\nThe camp of doubters\nThere is no point in discussing the positions of the two opposing camps: they have nothing in common, their views of the world will never converge, and most importantly, they are a minority. It is much more important and interesting, as it seems to me, to talk about those in the middle, the camp of doubters, the people who reason like this: \"War is evil, but...\". And this \"but\" is usually followed by versatile opinions:\nin war, it is always necessary to support one's people; \nnow that Putin has started this war, we can't afford a defeat, or else Russia will be ruined.\nAt first, I thought this rhetoric was a light addition to the program of the \"bloodthirsty,\" a kind of manifesto of \"decent patriots\": it seems wrong to support the mass murder of Ukrainians, but even worse to wish the defeat of Russian army. But when I started to hear echoes of this rhetoric in the discourse of many people, including those whom I consider decent, I realized that we are talking about a much more widespread phenomenon. \nIt makes no sense to change the minds of those who think that people — whatever their nationality — should be killed. It is like trying to talk sense using references to Tolstoy into an ax-wielding maniac lunging at you. But I think it is important to look at the arguments of the doubters because to a large extent their opinions and actions determine when the war ends and what happens to Russia next. \n\nIn war, you need to support one's people\nIt is always difficult to oppose your army because such actions are usually fraught with accusations of treason. Not only in the criminal sense of the word, but also in the social sense. \"No matter where we fight, we have to support our army,\" is the way many people think, even those who would never have voted for that war in the first place.\nHowever, this argument does not stand up to criticism because history knows many examples when citizens opposed and even fought against their country's army if it waged unjust wars. I will not list them all but mention only the one with which even Russian propaganda cannot argue. It is the Red Orchestra\nThis is what the German Nazis called the Resistance movement in Germany and the countries of Europe during World War II. Among the opponents of the Nazi regime were both the most ordinary Germans — journalists, lawyers, priests — and high-ranking officers of the Wehrmacht. From school we know: German Nazis were villains, German anti-fascists, many of whom were executed for their activities, were heroes. Today no one can deny that the Germans who fought against Hitler's army made the right moral choice. Even Russian propagandists and today's supporters of the war in Ukraine think so. (You can read what they write about it here: 1, 2, 3.) \nThe Red Orchestra example reminds us once again: if your army invades a foreign country, destroys entire cities with rockets and tanks, massacres civilians, rapes women, and declares some people worthy of annihilation, there is no shame in speaking out against your army. It is a shame not to do it. \n\nIf Russia loses, it is ruined\nThis argument migrated from the propagandists' handbooks into the heads of \"decent patriots.\" For four months, the Simonyans, the Solovyovs, the Kiselyovs, and others have been scaring everybody that if Russia does not win, it will turn the planet into nuclear dust. This rhetoric is not primarily aimed at the West, but at its population, so that they will tolerate the war in awe until the authorities declare final victory, and will not for a moment wonder, \"Maybe enough is enough?\"\nThis trick works. \"The war has already gone so far that as much as I hate Putin, as much as I was originally against all this crap, now we have no other choice. If we don't win, Russia is simply ruined,\" an acquaintance of mine, whose cognitive abilities and \"decency\" I never doubted, told me. \nWell, let's agree with this argument for the time being. And let's try to imagine what will happen in the opposite case — what if Russia wins? \nLet's imagine that Putin's most desired dream came true. Kyiv has fallen, Kharkiv has fallen, Odesa has fallen, Kadyrov is dancing lezginka in front of the Ukrainian presidential administration holding Zelensky's severed head, Shoygu on a white deer hosts the victory parade, Medvedev has been pulled out of his drinking spree and appointed Gauleiter of Little Russia, Macron and Scholz are calling Putin to apologize, but they cannot reach him because he — the father of the nation, the collector of Russian lands — stands with an unperturbed face on the podium on the Maidan square and calmly, with the awareness of his rightness and the greatness of the historical moment, looks at the many kilometers long column of captive Banderites shuffling along the Khreshchatyk.\nHave you imagined it? Now let's ask ourselves a question: \"What happens next?\" No matter how we spin this question in our heads, we still end up with essentially two options: \neither the Russian army will withdraw from Ukraine, leaving behind mountains of corpses, destroyed cities, and a new puppet government represented by the \"golden loaf\" owners who fled Ukraine in 2014;\nor the occupational troops will remain in Ukraine until... \nAs for when they leave, we'll talk about it further.\n\n\nDead-end fork\nSo, Russia won. What should the army do next? Leaving Ukraine is not an option at all. We all know the ease with which Ukrainians overthrow an unwanted government. After the last Russian tank crosses the Ukraine-Russia border, Ukrainians will enthusiastically burn Gauleiter Medvedev, appointed by the occupiers, in a vat of his moonshine, which he made in the Ivanovo region at his homestead near Plyos. And then you would need to restart a \"special military operation\" to denazify Ukraine and then sacralize the burned martyr Dmitry. \nJokes aside, I'm sure no one has any doubts: Ukrainians will not live by Putin's rules unless there is a Russian army in the country. \nSo all that remains is the occupation. But this option is even worse than the first one. \nFirst, it is simply impossible: Russia does not have enough soldiers to occupy one of Europe's largest countries. The population of Ukraine is about 40 million people (well, let's subtract five million refugees). The ratio of one occupant to 40-50 locals must be kept to maintain the occupation order. Where will Russia get more than 700,000 soldiers? Even half of that, considering that the 200,000 that invaded Ukraine in February were assembled all over the country.\nSecondly, I am sure that even the most naive Russian soldier understands what awaits him in occupied Ukraine after Bucha, Irpin, Mariupol, rocket attacks on Kyiv, Kharkiv, and Kremenchuk, after all the rapes of women and murders of elderly people. \nEven now, in occupied Kherson, where locals always spoke Russian, the Russian occupiers are facing a resistance movement: cars of their appointed gauleiter are being blown up in batches. Now imagine what would happen on the streets of occupied Kyiv, occupied Odesa, or occupied Kharkiv. \nRussian soldiers will be slaughtered in alleyways at night, shot from around corners, blown up at intersections, poisoned in restaurants, and drowned in the Black Sea. And it will be done not only by former soldiers of the Ukrainian Armed Forces, it will be done by all of Ukraine — the children, wives, fathers, and brothers of those killed by the Russians. \nThird, the occupation contingent needs to be fed. A Russian \"decent patriot\" may be ready to put up with the first two mishaps — that is, that Russia needs to mobilize and send all the mobilized soldiers to maintain the occupation order in Ukraine and that dozens of coffins with soldiers with slashed throats will return to Russia every day. So if our \"decent patriot\" is ready for all that, then they should be ready to work all their life just to feed the occupation contingent. Because as long as the last Russian soldier is in Ukraine, the West will not lift the sanctions, return the seized reserves and start buying Russian oil and gas again. This means that every year there will be more and more unemployed, poor and sick people in Russia. \nSomeone may point out that the Russian army has no plans of occupying the whole of Ukraine. The territories already conquered and Donbas, which the Russian government hopes to conquer in the next few months, are enough. But assuming this is true, we are all well aware that the war will not end as long as Ukraine has an army and a president elected by the people. This means that Russia will still face the same dead-end fork.\nSo it turns out that a true patriot of Russia today — if we agree that patriotism is wanting your country to exist and flourish, rather than trying our best to fuck it up — must do everything in their power to get, first, the Russian army out of Ukraine as quickly as possible, and, second, to end the Putin regime as quickly as possible. Otherwise, if the war drags on for years, either Russia will have no army left, or its army will come home on its own. How it can end, we know well from history.","blocks":[{"data":"By the fifth month of the war, Russian public opinion about the so-called \"special military operation\" has divided roughly into three camps. On one side there is a camp of the bloodthirsty. The motto of their party is simple: \"Not a step back! Wipe the Ukrops [derogatory term for Ukrainians sometimes used in Russia] and their cities off the face of the earth! And if they resist, we'll hit them with a nuclear weapon! They will all die, and we will go to paradise.\" On the other side, there is a camp of those who oppose the war, with its well-known rhetoric: \"War is evil! Putin is a war criminal!”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The camp of doubters","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"There is no point in discussing the positions of the two opposing camps: they have nothing in common, their views of the world will never converge, and most importantly, they are a minority. It is much more important and interesting, as it seems to me, to talk about those in the middle, the camp of doubters, the people who reason like this: \"War is evil, but...\". And this \"but\" is usually followed by versatile opinions:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li>in war, it is always necessary to support one's people;&nbsp;</li><li>now that Putin has started this war, we can't afford a defeat, or else Russia will be ruined.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"At first, I thought this rhetoric was a light addition to the program of the \"bloodthirsty,\" a kind of manifesto of \"decent patriots\": it seems wrong to support the mass murder of Ukrainians, but even worse to wish the defeat of Russian army. But when I started to hear echoes of this rhetoric in the discourse of many people, including those whom I consider decent, I realized that we are talking about a much more widespread phenomenon.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It makes no sense to change the minds of those who think that people — whatever their nationality — should be killed. It is like trying to talk sense using references to Tolstoy into an ax-wielding maniac lunging at you.&nbsp;But I think it is important to look at the arguments of the doubters because to a large extent their opinions and actions determine when the war ends and what happens to Russia next.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In war, you need to support one's people","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"It is always difficult to oppose your army because such actions are usually fraught with accusations of treason. Not only in the criminal sense of the word, but also in the social sense.&nbsp;\"No matter where we fight, we have to support our army,\" is the way many people think, even those who would never have voted for that war in the first place.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, this argument does not stand up to criticism because history knows many examples when citizens opposed and even fought against their country's army if it waged unjust wars. I will not list them all but mention only the one with which even Russian propaganda cannot argue. It is the Red Orchestra","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This is what the German Nazis called the Resistance movement in Germany and the countries of Europe during World War II. Among the opponents of the Nazi regime were both the most ordinary Germans — journalists, lawyers, priests — and high-ranking officers of the Wehrmacht. From school we know: German Nazis were villains, German anti-fascists, many of whom were executed for their activities, were heroes. Today no one can deny that the Germans who fought against Hitler's army made the right moral choice. Even Russian propagandists and today's supporters of the war in Ukraine think so. (You can read what they write about it here: <a href=\"https://kprf.ru/history/soviet/208246.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">1</a>, <a href=\"https://life.ru/p/1006027\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">2</a>, <a href=\"https://www.mknews.de/social/2019/05/09/krasnaya-kapella-i-nemeckie-antifashisty.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">3</a>.)&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Red Orchestra example reminds us once again: if your army invades a foreign country, destroys entire cities with rockets and tanks, massacres civilians, rapes women, and declares some people worthy of annihilation, there is no shame in speaking out against your army. It is a shame not to do it.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"If Russia loses, it is ruined","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"This argument migrated from the propagandists' handbooks into the heads of \"decent patriots.\" For four months, the Simonyans, the Solovyovs, the Kiselyovs, and others have been scaring everybody that if Russia does not win, it will turn the planet into nuclear dust. This rhetoric is not primarily aimed at the West, but at its population, so that they will tolerate the war in awe until the authorities declare final victory, and will not for a moment wonder, \"Maybe enough is enough?\"","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This trick works. \"The war has already gone so far that as much as I hate Putin, as much as I was originally against all this crap, now we have no other choice. If we don't win, Russia is simply ruined,\" an acquaintance of mine, whose cognitive abilities and \"decency\" I never doubted, told me.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Well, let's agree with this argument for the time being. And let's try to imagine what will happen in the opposite case — what if Russia wins?&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Let's imagine that Putin's most desired dream came true. Kyiv has fallen, Kharkiv has fallen, Odesa has fallen, Kadyrov is dancing lezginka in front of the Ukrainian presidential administration holding Zelensky's severed head, Shoygu on a white deer hosts the victory parade, Medvedev has been pulled out of his drinking spree and appointed Gauleiter of Little Russia, Macron and Scholz are calling Putin to apologize, but they cannot reach him because he — the father of the nation, the collector of Russian lands — stands with an unperturbed face on the podium on the Maidan square and calmly, with the awareness of his rightness and the greatness of the historical moment, looks at the many kilometers long column of captive Banderites shuffling along the Khreshchatyk.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Have you imagined it? Now let's ask ourselves a question: \"What happens next?\" No matter how we spin this question in our heads, we still end up with essentially two options:&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li>either the Russian army will withdraw from Ukraine, leaving behind mountains of corpses, destroyed cities, and a new puppet government represented by the \"golden loaf\" owners who fled Ukraine in 2014;</li><li>or the occupational troops will remain in Ukraine until...&nbsp;</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"As for when they leave, we'll talk about it further.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":5164,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: AFP / Scanpix / LETA","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b5d31c881924dbbb793b27d07893064-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b5d31c881924dbbb793b27d07893064-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":799,"real_height_2x":1598},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b5d31c881924dbbb793b27d07893064-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b5d31c881924dbbb793b27d07893064-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":799,"real_height_2x":1598},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b5d31c881924dbbb793b27d07893064-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b5d31c881924dbbb793b27d07893064-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":552},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b5d31c881924dbbb793b27d07893064-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b5d31c881924dbbb793b27d07893064-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":552}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Dead-end fork","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"So, Russia won. What should the army do next? Leaving Ukraine is not an option at all. We all know the ease with which Ukrainians overthrow an unwanted government. After the last Russian tank crosses the Ukraine-Russia border, Ukrainians will enthusiastically burn Gauleiter Medvedev, appointed by the occupiers, in a vat of his moonshine, which he <a href=\"https://www.proekt.media/article/medvedev-samogon/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">made</a> in the Ivanovo region at his homestead near Plyos. And then you would need to restart a \"special military operation\" to denazify Ukraine and then sacralize the burned martyr Dmitry.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Jokes aside, I'm sure no one has any doubts: Ukrainians will not live by Putin's rules unless there is a Russian army in the country.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"So all that remains is the occupation. But this option is even worse than the first one.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"First, it is simply impossible: Russia does not have enough soldiers to occupy one of Europe's largest countries. The population of Ukraine is about 40 million people (well, let's subtract five million <a href=\"https://istories.media/reportages/2022/06/23/ne-zhdali/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">refugees</a>). The <a href=\"https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/opinions/2004/05/09/a-proven-formula-for-how-many-troops-we-need/5c6dbfc9-33f8-4648-bd07-40d244a1daa4/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">ratio</a> of one occupant to 40-50 locals must be kept to maintain the occupation order. Where will Russia get more than 700,000 soldiers? Even half of that, considering that the <a href=\"https://istories.media/investigations/2022/06/20/chto-ostalos-ot-rossiiskoi-armii-k-chetvertomu-mesyatsu-voini/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">200,000</a> that invaded Ukraine in February were assembled all over the country.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Secondly, I am sure that even the most naive Russian soldier understands what awaits him in occupied Ukraine after Bucha, Irpin, Mariupol, rocket attacks on Kyiv, Kharkiv, and Kremenchuk, after all the rapes of women and murders of elderly people.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Even now, in occupied Kherson, where locals always spoke Russian, the Russian occupiers are <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/news-61895975\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">facing</a> a resistance movement: cars of their appointed gauleiter are being <a href=\"https://incident.obozrevatel.com/crime/v-hersone-vzorvalos-avto-s-boepripasami-est-pogibshij-foto-i-video.htm\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">blown up</a> in batches. Now imagine what would happen on the streets of occupied Kyiv, occupied Odesa, or occupied Kharkiv.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russian soldiers will be slaughtered in alleyways at night, shot from around corners, blown up at intersections, poisoned in restaurants, and drowned in the Black Sea. And it will be done not only by former soldiers of the Ukrainian Armed Forces, it will be done by all of Ukraine — the children, wives, fathers, and brothers of those killed by the Russians.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Third, the occupation contingent needs to be fed. A Russian \"decent patriot\" may be ready to put up with the first two mishaps — that is, that Russia needs to mobilize and send all the mobilized soldiers to maintain the occupation order in Ukraine and that dozens of coffins with soldiers with slashed throats will return to Russia every day. So if our \"decent patriot\" is ready for all that, then they should be ready to work all their life just to feed the occupation contingent. Because as long as the last Russian soldier is in Ukraine, the West will not lift the sanctions, return the seized reserves and start buying Russian oil and gas again. This means that every year there will be more and more unemployed, poor and sick people in Russia.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Someone may point out that the Russian army has no plans of occupying the whole of Ukraine. The territories already conquered and Donbas, which the Russian government hopes to conquer in the next few months, are enough. But assuming this is true, we are all well aware that the war will not end as long as Ukraine has an army and a president elected by the people. This means that Russia will still face the same dead-end fork.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"So it turns out that a true patriot of Russia today — if we agree that patriotism is wanting your country to exist and flourish, rather than trying our best to <a href=\"https://twitter.com/roizmangbn/status/1513484355192111107\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">fuck it up</a> — must do everything in their power to get, first, the Russian army out of Ukraine as quickly as possible, and, second, to end the Putin regime as quickly as possible. Otherwise, if the war drags on for years, either Russia will have no army left, or its army will come home on its own. How it can end, we <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/institutional-39003141\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">know</a> well from history.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":602,"header":"How Russian Business Evades Western Sanctions","_path":"/en/opinions/2022/06/08/how-russian-business-evades-western-sanctions/","lead":"Bashkir orchids, technological 'cannibalism', buying up used machinery, 3D printing, and other methods","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-1920x960px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-1920x960px_2x.png","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-1272x636px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-1272x636px_2x.png","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-912x456px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-912x456px_2x.png","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-600x400px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-600x400px_2x.png","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-360x360px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65ecd183a1374996b0f1baa25ebccb23-360x360px_2x.png","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Photo: Shutterstock.com","created_at_date":"2022-06-08","created_at_date_time":null,"updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":2517,"last_name":"","first_name":"Редакция","last_name_en":"","first_name_en":"Editors","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"The new responsibility of managers in many Russian companies is to monitor Avito, Yula, and other advertisements websites to see if a device or component that is needed in production turns up. Import is a problem, as we all know. As one flower supplier says: \"After the first sanctions in 2014, we had Belarusian shrimp, and now we have Bashkir orchids.\"\nIStories decided to figure out who and how imports sanctioned goods into Russia: foreign equipment, components, and more. Online flea markets and hastily created intermediaries; parts made on 3D printers and removed from working machines (so-called 'cannibalism'); intermediaries in third countries — Russian business is trying various means to make up for the missing imports. Russia's main trading partners have stopped supplying equipment, spare parts, and other goods for most industries because of sanctions or because of convictions. The good news for business is that using certain schemes, you can import almost anything. And the bad news is that it is not possible to deliver enough goods this way. There's not enough for everyone, and prices are going up.\n\nBuying used\n\n\"We've cleaned out all the Avito,\" admits the owner of a bakery near Moscow in response to a question about how he plans to keep the equipment, which is no longer supplied to Russia, in working order. Since March, one of his firm's managers has had a new responsibility: to monitor the largest resources for the sale of used goods and equipment on a daily basis, from classified ads websites like Avito and Yula to specialized online sites for bankruptcy estate sales. \n\"We buy whatever we can find that works for us — furnaces, ovens, kneading machines, packaging and refrigeration equipment, both working and not, as 'donors' for repairs. Of course, the sellers are not fools, the prices have soared by one and a half times at best, but you have to take it to have something to work with. Everything we have is from Italy and Germany,\" says the entrepreneur.\nThe EU banned imports of equipment for bakeries and many other industries in the fifth package of sanctions on April 8, while bakeries in major Russian cities depend on imports by 80-90%, and in the regions by 50-70%, Rustam Aidiev, executive director of the National Union of Bakeries, told Kommersant.\n\nWestern companies have stopped shipping to Russia any equipment and goods that have engines and chips — just in case, so as not to fall under the secondary sanctions, because not everyone wants to understand the complex list of sanctioned products and find out what can and cannot be delivered. What can be bought now takes twice as long and costs several times as much, employees of a logistics firm said.\nThe average wear and tear of equipment in bakery production is 73%, as indicated in a report on import substitution, presented by the Moscow State University of Food Production. According to its experts, equipment in the Russian food industry is worn out by almost 60%, with a strong dependence on imports.\n\nWear and tear of equipment and dependence on imports in the Russian food industry\nSource: Presentation by Moscow State University of Food Production\n\nThere is not much hope of quickly replacing foreign equipment with Russian analogs. Firstly, complete re-equipment is expensive, and secondly, up to 80% of imported components are used in Russian-made machines, said Sergey Mayorov, chairman of the Machine-Building Cluster of the Republic of Tatarstan.\nFor large enterprises, buying used equipment is not an option (you can't buy much on \"Avito\"), and they shut down because of the lack of parts. For example, the city-forming Tikhvin Freight Car Building Plant prolonged the shutdown introduced in the middle of May for the whole month of June because of the lack of bearings produced in the USA. Smaller companies, on the other hand, are trying to get out of this as best they can.\n\"In our industry, few people have seriously invested in equipment upgrades; we still have Brother knitting machines made in the 1990s. Everyone lived according to the principle \"he who has the bad old stuff buys the new one,\" so now we are worried about the future,\" says the general director of knitwear production in the Ryazan region. He, too, has been buying up sewing and knitting machines and yarn on Avito and other resources since March.\nEven cellular operators are preparing to bring used equipment into Russia, including by purchasing base stations through resellers in friendly countries. Due to the fact that Nokia, Ericsson, and Huawei stopped supplying to Russia, there may be failures on mobile networks by the end of the summer.\n\"There is frantic demand for energy equipment right now,\" says the founder of an investment group that specializes in crisis management. With a huge profit, he sold off all the transformers, generators, turbines, and other power plant equipment that he had received over the past ten years as a reward for participating in asset sharing and bankruptcy cases: \"For example, transformers for an electric substation four years ago were worthless, but now that there are no more imports, but there is an investment program to upgrade capacity and build new substations, everyone needs them dramatically. So now it's all spread out at a 'times a hundred' price compared to what it was paid for originally.\"\n\n\n3D printing\n\nDue to difficulties with the supply of home appliances and cars, Russians rushed to fix what they had. For example, the demand for repair of household appliances for the past three months has increased by 43% compared to last year, according to \"Avito services\" analysts, who reviewed requests from 23 million users.\nThere are problems with the repair in the official services. Because of supply disruptions, there is a shortage of spare parts. Ministry of Economic Development in response to complaints from dissatisfied customers of various services has already proposed to increase the warranty repair period of machinery and automobiles from 45 to 90 days.\nIt's easier for unofficial services to keep going. 3D printers come to the rescue. \"We print plastic components, small parts like different buttons, trim pistols, levers and holders,\" the appliance repair firm's foreman recounts. The owner of the unofficial repair service for Volkswagen and Skoda cars solves the problem in the same way. A company that produces turnstiles, including state orders for large stadiums, has begun using 3D printers to print plastic parts, says its manager. How long this will be possible is a big question. A major manufacturer of 3D printers, Japan, has banned their export to Russia since May 20.\n\nReplace Britain with China\n\nMost official car dealers since the end of February sell parts, consumables, and oils only if the car is serviced by them. Prices for the goods on display in the hall are not indicated — they vary a lot, depending on which shipment the products came in. There is no significant shortage so far, but you have to wait for parts, and prices have risen dramatically.\nUnofficial service stations use analogs of parts from brands that left Russia, getting them from China and Türkiye. The quality varies and since we now have to look for new suppliers, the share of counterfeit parts is growing, the sources of IStories confess. They do not attempt to assess the growth of counterfeiting — so far these are isolated cases. \"Now it's not uncommon to have to install an analog of an analog in a car, and, of course, it's a matter of luck, but you have to take a risk if the customer wants to drive rather than wait,\" says an employee of an independent service center.\n\n\"I took a risk and put Chinese rubber on my car and I'm satisfied — excellent quality,\" says a member of the Russian Land Rover Owners Club. He is not alone: according to him, a British Land Rover running on Chinese tires is now the norm. We still have European ones, but at speculative prices — five times more expensive than a year ago, says the source.\nHowever, unofficial dealers connected with the club have figured out how to import the brand's original parts to Russia, he continues: they have worked out a delivery route through \"friendly countries\", registered a \"flawless legal entity\" in the EU, the only thing left is to find a supplier-intermediary who will agree to work according to this scheme, reselling the products purchased from Land Rover to the new entity.\nDealers are also discussing the organization of the import of \"fresh\" cars: when a car will be bought in Europe by an EU citizen who received money from a non-sanctioned country, and sent to Russia through other Europeans, or, if that does not work, re-exported through Armenia or Georgia. \"With the exchange rate of the ruble, it's a sin not to transport cars,\" admits a dealer who discusses such a scheme.\n\nDisassemble for spare parts\n\n\"And we 'cannibalize' a little bit at a time. The proportion is as follows: two American John Deere tractors (this is the world's largest manufacturer of agricultural equipment) work, and one remains idle — we disassemble it for parts. It's the same with harvesters,\" says an employee of a large Russian agricultural holding.\nTransport companies have bought up all old truck tractors in Russia in order to use them to repair European vans, employees of three logistics companies said. European trucks account for the bulk of the fleet because they are more reliable than Russian and Chinese ones. Now Russian transport companies urgently need spare parts for European-made vehicles, said Vyacheslav Trunaev, president of the Siberian Association of Automobile Carriers. According to him, to solve the problem the Association asked Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin to temporarily allow preferential imports (without customs duties and recycling fees) of European long-haul tractors not older than five years in Russia.\nPerhaps the worst situation is with aviation. \"Aeroflot will start dismantling its planes for parts by the end of the summer because of the sanctions that cut it off from acquiring foreign parts, Bloomberg wrote in May, citing experts from IBA, a company specializing in business intelligence in aviation. As employees of other airlines with fleets older than Aeroflot's told us, back in March they had allocated Boeing and Airbus for disassembly for parts.\n\nPurchase via third countries\n\nIn April, the EU banned imports of roses, rhododendrons, azaleas, and all planting material, including tubers and bulbs of plants into Russia. Before that, Europe, especially the Netherlands, accounted for 80% of the supply of seeds, bulbs, and seedlings and about half of all cut roses and tulips. In addition, the EU banned trucks registered in Belarus and Russia on its territory — they were the ones who brought all the flowers to Russia. Wholesalers immediately began to warn customers about possible supply disruptions. But a solution was found.\n\"Our partners have established subsidiaries in countries outside the EU, but I won't say where exactly, just in case,\" says the Russian online plant exchange owner. Now, according to her, supplies from Europe run smoothly.\n\nThe manager of another flower wholesaler buys plants through a partner in Serbia and receives them through Kazakhstan. \"Intermediaries from these countries are assistants to our logisticians in everything. Everything goes through them: from expensive European clothes to Japanese phones,\" he says. \"After the first sanctions in 2014, we had Belarusian shrimp, and now there are Bashkir orchids because we get phalaenopsis and other flowers through firms registered in this Russian region bordering Kazakhstan,\" explains another florist wholesaler. And, of course, there is a growing supply of flowers from other regions, like roses from Ecuador, Israel, or from Russian greenhouses, he adds. \n\nRun on old stock\n\nWithout imports, it is almost impossible to have dental treatment. In dentistry, according to the Russian Dental Association, the proportion of imported materials is at least 90%, and in prosthetics and implantology — almost 100%. Many voluntary health insurance programs and even some compulsory insurance programs prescribe the use of foreign materials.\nAfter the collapse of the ruble in February and March and sanctions-related problems with logistics, the cost of popular European and American systems for bite correction and dental materials increased by at least a third, and in most cases by half, and has not decreased since then, the doctors say. Now there is a shortage of materials. For example, the company \"3M\", which had the largest market share of composite materials for dentistry, stopped supplying back in March. The clinics are mostly running on old stock.\nThere are high-quality Russian analogs of aligners, mouth guards, and braces, but their production uses imported raw materials, said Vyacheslav Minko, chief physician and general director of the Dental Clinic \"Doctor Minko. This is a typical problem in many industries. Many clinics now offer clients Asian fillings, aligners, and implants instead of American and European: South Korea is premium, China is economy. There are good analogs of almost all European materials in China, certified in the local market, and they can be delivered to Russia in a month, says an employee of a logistics firm in Guangzhou.\n\"We also work with Russian materials, but they are closer to the premium price,\" says a private dentist from Moscow, laughing. According to him, those who wish can still get British and German materials and systems, but they will come to Russia by a roundabout route, through the UAE and Türkiye, and that will immediately add at least 40% to the price. The main problem, according to him, is the volume: foreign suppliers of dental products need to register in Russia, this process usually takes several months, and Russian companies, despite their desire, cannot increase production to meet the increased demand.\n\nReturn via partners\n\nThose who are in a real state of loss are the sellers of luxury goods: because of the sanctions, you cannot bring to Russia clothes, shoes, and bags from Europe that cost more than EUR300 (and with the premium brands that is the cost of underpants or a belt) and from the United States that cost more than USD1,000. The \"heavy luxury\" boutiques have closed their doors, deliveries have been stopped, and the Dolce & Gabbana signboard is being dismantled in Barvikha Luxury Village. Real estate consultants are already predicting that Stoleshnikov Boulevard, where most of the stores have closed, will lose its status as the most expensive shopping street in the country and are advising owners of the premises to rent them to low-cost brands or restaurateurs.\n\nConsultants believe that premium foreign brands may return through their Russian partners, as it was in the 1990s and 2000s when expensive watches were brought to Russia by Consul and clothes were brought by Jamilko, Mercury (owner of Central Universal Department Store (TsUM)) and Bosco (tenant of State Department Store (GUM)). They did it until recently but to a much smaller extent. President Vladimir Putin advises not to worry about luxury consumers: \"Those who want to bring in some luxury goods, can do it, but it will be a little more expensive for them. But these are the people who already drove Mercedes-Benz 600, and will drive, I assure you, will bring them from anywhere, from any country.\"\nIndeed, those who need already purchase \"heavy luxury\" through Georgia, Armenia, and Kazakhstan, or go shopping in the UAE. But Russian sellers of luxury brands are in no hurry to engage in parallel imports, bypassing the fashion houses. As their employees admit, they hope to resume relations with the fashion houses in the foreseeable future. So now more than half of the new brands in TsUM are Turkish (for example, Nackiyé) and Russian brands (like the new brand of the famous designer Alexander Terekhov Sashaverse or the brand of the motorcycle racer Maria Kalashnikova Bats) and even Latin American brands (for example, Colombian Kika Vargas and Brazilian Fernando Jorge). An employee of TsUM assures the plan for this expansion was conceived last year.\n\nCopy the secondary\n\nIt is not possible to replace imported software and high-tech products, especially in telecommunications. Deprivation of access to innovation leads to a setback in technical development. In the first quarter, shipments of mobile phones in Russia increased by 43% to 3.5 million units compared to the same period last year, and shipments of smartphones fell by 14% to 6.8 million, reported RBC, citing a GS Group research center report. \n\"Rostec (the State Corporation for Assistance to Development, Production and Export of Advanced Technology) proposes that the Ministry of Digital Development focus not on the fifth, but on the fourth generation of mobile telecommunications. In the approved 2020 version of the road map, it was planned to allocate RUB28.8 billion from the budget for the development of 5G. Now this money can be directed towards 4G, according to Kommersant's sources. But because of the shortage of equipment and technology, there are problems even with the deployment of such networks.\nIt will be very difficult to bring back international technology companies and software developers who have left Russia en masse — they leave not so much because of formal sanctions, but because of the image implications. And they will have to be replaced, Ruben Enikolopov, Rector of the New Economic School, admitted in an interview: \"It will not be the advanced technologies that we used to receive directly, from now on it will be a so-called 'second copy'. That is, Asian countries (which are not themselves the leaders) get the first copy from the EU and the U.S., and then we get a copy from them. So they're falling behind with some kind of lag from the leading edge, and we're going to be even twice as far behind.\"","blocks":[{"data":"The new responsibility of managers in many Russian companies is to monitor Avito, Yula, and other advertisements websites to see if a device or component that is needed in production turns up. Import is a problem, as we all know. As one flower supplier says: \"After the first sanctions in 2014, we had Belarusian shrimp, and now we have Bashkir orchids.\"","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories decided to figure out who and how imports sanctioned goods into Russia: foreign equipment, components, and more. Online flea markets and hastily created intermediaries; parts made on 3D printers and removed from working machines (so-called 'cannibalism'); intermediaries in third countries — Russian business is trying various means to make up for the missing imports. Russia's main trading partners have stopped supplying equipment, spare parts, and other goods for most industries because of sanctions or because of convictions. The good news for business is that using certain schemes, you can import almost anything. And the bad news is that it is not possible to deliver enough goods this way. There's not enough for everyone, and prices are going up.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Buying used","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"\"We've cleaned out all the Avito,\" admits the owner of a bakery near Moscow in response to a question about how he plans to keep the equipment, which is no longer supplied to Russia, in working order. Since March, one of his firm's managers has had a new responsibility: to monitor the largest resources for the sale of used goods and equipment on a daily basis, from classified ads websites like Avito and Yula to specialized online sites for bankruptcy estate sales.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"\"We buy whatever we can find that works for us — furnaces, ovens, kneading machines, packaging and refrigeration equipment, both working and not, as 'donors' for repairs. Of course, the sellers are not fools, the prices have soared by one and a half times at best, but you have to take it to have something to work with. Everything we have is from Italy and Germany,\" says the entrepreneur.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The EU banned imports of equipment for bakeries and many other industries in the fifth package of sanctions on April 8, while bakeries in major Russian cities depend on imports by 80-90%, and in the regions by 50-70%, Rustam Aidiev, executive director of the National Union of Bakeries, <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/5315204\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">told</a> Kommersant.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":5040,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Kosmogenez / Shutterstock.com","caption":"Bakeries will stand down without imported equipment. So one has to buy second-hand","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ae5186b17be4819a9acc37c9ef5fdb0-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ae5186b17be4819a9acc37c9ef5fdb0-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":900,"real_height_2x":1800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ae5186b17be4819a9acc37c9ef5fdb0-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ae5186b17be4819a9acc37c9ef5fdb0-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":900,"real_height_2x":1800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ae5186b17be4819a9acc37c9ef5fdb0-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ae5186b17be4819a9acc37c9ef5fdb0-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":311,"real_height_2x":622},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ae5186b17be4819a9acc37c9ef5fdb0-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ae5186b17be4819a9acc37c9ef5fdb0-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":311,"real_height_2x":622}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Western companies have stopped shipping to Russia any equipment and goods that have engines and chips — just in case, so as not to fall under the secondary sanctions, because not everyone wants to understand the complex list of sanctioned products and find out what can and cannot be delivered. What can be bought now takes twice as long and costs several times as much, employees of a logistics firm said.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The average wear and tear of equipment in bakery production is 73%, as <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/russia/842879\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">indicated</a> in a report on import substitution, presented by the Moscow State University of Food Production. According to its experts, equipment in the Russian food industry is worn out by almost 60%, with a strong dependence on imports.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Wear and tear of equipment and dependence on imports in the Russian food industry</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":5039,"data":{"content":[["Type of production","Wear and tear of production equipment, %","Share of imported equipment, %"],["Oil and fats","86","95"],["Meat","78","95"],["Sugar","82","92"],["Fish","74","85"],["Dairy","73","89"],["Baked goods","73","78"]]},"category":"table-embed"},"type":"table-embed"},{"data":"<em>Source: Presentation by Moscow State University of Food Production</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There is not much hope of quickly replacing foreign equipment with Russian analogs. Firstly, complete re-equipment is expensive, and secondly, up to 80% of imported components are used in Russian-made machines, said Sergey Mayorov, chairman of the Machine-Building Cluster of the Republic of Tatarstan.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For large enterprises, buying used equipment is not an option (you can't buy much on \"Avito\"), and they shut down because of the lack of parts. For example, the city-forming Tikhvin Freight Car Building Plant prolonged the shutdown introduced in the middle of May for the whole month of June because of the lack of bearings produced in the USA. Smaller companies, on the other hand, are trying to get out of this as best they can.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"\"In our industry, few people have seriously invested in equipment upgrades; we still have Brother knitting machines made in the 1990s. Everyone lived according to the principle \"he who has the bad old stuff buys the new one,\" so now we are worried about the future,\" says the general director of knitwear production in the Ryazan region. He, too, has been buying up sewing and knitting machines and yarn on Avito and other resources since March.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Even cellular operators are preparing to bring used equipment into Russia, including by purchasing base stations through resellers in friendly countries. Due to the fact that Nokia, Ericsson, and Huawei stopped supplying to Russia, there may be failures on mobile networks by the end of the summer.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"\"There is frantic demand for energy equipment right now,\" says the founder of an investment group that specializes in crisis management. With a huge profit, he sold off all the transformers, generators, turbines, and other power plant equipment that he had received over the past ten years as a reward for participating in asset sharing and bankruptcy cases: \"For example, transformers for an electric substation four years ago were worthless, but now that there are no more imports, but there is an investment program to upgrade capacity and build new substations, everyone needs them dramatically. So now it's all spread out at a 'times a hundred' price compared to what it was paid for originally.\"","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":5041,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Shutterstock.com","caption":"Used power plant equipment is selling at skyrocketing prices","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d50b3e0884484144a25a74bf70ffa0c7-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d50b3e0884484144a25a74bf70ffa0c7-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1598},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d50b3e0884484144a25a74bf70ffa0c7-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d50b3e0884484144a25a74bf70ffa0c7-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1598},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d50b3e0884484144a25a74bf70ffa0c7-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d50b3e0884484144a25a74bf70ffa0c7-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":552},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d50b3e0884484144a25a74bf70ffa0c7-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d50b3e0884484144a25a74bf70ffa0c7-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":552}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"3D printing","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Due to difficulties with the supply of home appliances and cars, Russians rushed to fix what they had. For example, the demand for repair of household appliances for the past three months has <a href=\"https://www.forbes.ru/biznes/467619-spros-na-uslugi-po-remontu-bytovoj-tehniki-vyros-na-43\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">increased</a> by 43% compared to last year, according to \"Avito services\" analysts, who reviewed requests from 23 million users.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There are problems with the repair in the official services. Because of supply disruptions, there is a shortage of spare parts. Ministry of Economic Development in response to complaints from dissatisfied customers of various services has already proposed to increase the warranty repair period of machinery and automobiles from 45 to 90 days.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It's easier for unofficial services to keep going.&nbsp;3D printers come to the rescue. \"We print plastic components, small parts like different buttons, trim pistols, levers and holders,\" the appliance repair firm's foreman recounts. The owner of the unofficial repair service for Volkswagen and Skoda cars solves the problem in the same way. A company that produces turnstiles, including state orders for large stadiums, has begun using 3D printers to print plastic parts, says its manager. How long this will be possible is a big question. A major manufacturer of 3D printers, Japan, has banned their export to Russia since May 20.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Replace Britain with China","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Most official car dealers since the end of February sell parts, consumables, and oils only if the car is serviced by them. Prices for the goods on display in the hall are not indicated — they vary a lot, depending on which shipment the products came in. There is no significant shortage so far, but you have to wait for parts, and prices have risen dramatically.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Unofficial service stations use analogs of parts from brands that left Russia, getting them from China and Türkiye. The quality varies and since we now have to look for new suppliers, the share of counterfeit parts is growing, the sources of IStories confess. They do not attempt to assess the growth of counterfeiting — so far these are isolated cases. \"Now it's not uncommon to have to install an analog of an analog in a car, and, of course, it's a matter of luck, but you have to take a risk if the customer wants to drive rather than wait,\" says an employee of an independent service center.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":5042,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: AFP / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"China and Türkiye have come to the rescue of car service centers. But even their parts are being counterfeited","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdfb6a0c85884ccf8ac3c9a36a550253-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdfb6a0c85884ccf8ac3c9a36a550253-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1599},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdfb6a0c85884ccf8ac3c9a36a550253-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdfb6a0c85884ccf8ac3c9a36a550253-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1599},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdfb6a0c85884ccf8ac3c9a36a550253-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdfb6a0c85884ccf8ac3c9a36a550253-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdfb6a0c85884ccf8ac3c9a36a550253-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdfb6a0c85884ccf8ac3c9a36a550253-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"\"I took a risk and put Chinese rubber on my car and I'm satisfied — excellent quality,\" says a member of the Russian Land Rover Owners Club. He is not alone: according to him, a British Land Rover running on Chinese tires is now the norm. We still have European ones, but at speculative prices — five times more expensive than a year ago, says the source.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, unofficial dealers connected with the club have figured out how to import the brand's original parts to Russia, he continues: they have worked out a delivery route through \"friendly countries\", registered a \"flawless legal entity\" in the EU, the only thing left is to find a supplier-intermediary who will agree to work according to this scheme, reselling the products purchased from Land Rover to the new entity.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Dealers are also discussing the organization of the import of \"fresh\" cars: when a car will be bought in Europe by an EU citizen who received money from a non-sanctioned country, and sent to Russia through other Europeans, or, if that does not work, re-exported through Armenia or Georgia. \"With the exchange rate of the ruble, it's a sin not to transport cars,\" admits a dealer who discusses such a scheme.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Disassemble for spare parts","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"\"And we 'cannibalize' a little bit at a time. The proportion is as follows: two American John Deere tractors (this is the world's largest manufacturer of agricultural equipment) work, and one remains idle — we disassemble it for parts. It's the same with harvesters,\" says an employee of a large Russian agricultural holding.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Transport companies have bought up all old truck tractors in Russia in order to use them to repair European vans, employees of three logistics companies said. European trucks account for the bulk of the fleet because they are more reliable than Russian and Chinese ones. Now Russian transport companies urgently need spare parts for European-made vehicles, said Vyacheslav Trunaev, president of the Siberian Association of Automobile Carriers. According to him, to solve the problem the Association asked Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin to temporarily allow preferential imports (without customs duties and recycling fees) of European long-haul tractors not older than five years in Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Perhaps the worst situation is with aviation. \"Aeroflot will start dismantling its planes for parts by the end of the summer because of the sanctions that cut it off from acquiring foreign parts, Bloomberg wrote in May, citing experts from IBA, a company specializing in business intelligence in aviation. As employees of other airlines with fleets older than Aeroflot's told us, back in March they had allocated Boeing and Airbus for disassembly for parts.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Purchase via third countries","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In April, the EU banned imports of roses, rhododendrons, azaleas, and all planting material, including tubers and bulbs of plants into Russia. Before that, Europe, especially the Netherlands, accounted for 80% of the supply of seeds, bulbs, and seedlings and about half of all cut roses and tulips. In addition, the EU banned trucks registered in Belarus and Russia on its territory — they were the ones who brought all the flowers to Russia. Wholesalers immediately began to warn customers about possible supply disruptions. But a solution was found.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"\"Our partners have established subsidiaries in countries outside the EU, but I won't say where exactly, just in case,\" says the Russian online plant exchange owner. Now, according to her, supplies from Europe run smoothly.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":5043,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: AP / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Kazakh roses bloom in Russia as a result of sanctions","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/05c2553e1e544a43996cad2541aa26e4-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/05c2553e1e544a43996cad2541aa26e4-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1599},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/05c2553e1e544a43996cad2541aa26e4-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/05c2553e1e544a43996cad2541aa26e4-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1599},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/05c2553e1e544a43996cad2541aa26e4-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/05c2553e1e544a43996cad2541aa26e4-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/05c2553e1e544a43996cad2541aa26e4-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/05c2553e1e544a43996cad2541aa26e4-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The manager of another flower wholesaler buys plants through a partner in Serbia and receives them through Kazakhstan. \"Intermediaries from these countries are assistants to our logisticians in everything. Everything goes through them: from expensive European clothes to Japanese phones,\" he says. \"After the first sanctions in 2014, we had Belarusian shrimp, and now there are Bashkir orchids because we get phalaenopsis and other flowers through firms registered in this Russian region bordering Kazakhstan,\" explains another florist wholesaler. And, of course, there is a growing supply of flowers from other regions, like roses from Ecuador, Israel, or from Russian greenhouses, he adds.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Run on old stock","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Without imports, it is almost impossible to have dental treatment. In dentistry, according to the Russian Dental Association, the proportion of imported materials is at least 90%, and in prosthetics and implantology — almost 100%. Many voluntary health insurance programs and even some compulsory insurance programs prescribe the use of foreign materials.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After the collapse of the ruble in February and March and sanctions-related problems with logistics, the cost of popular European and American systems for bite correction and dental materials increased by at least a third, and in most cases by half, and has not decreased since then, the doctors say. Now there is a shortage of materials. For example, the company \"3M\", which had the largest market share of composite materials for dentistry, stopped supplying back in March. The clinics are mostly running on old stock.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There are high-quality Russian analogs of aligners, mouth guards, and braces, but their production uses imported raw materials, said Vyacheslav Minko, chief physician and general director of the Dental Clinic \"Doctor Minko. This is a typical problem in many industries. Many clinics now offer clients Asian fillings, aligners, and implants instead of American and European: South Korea is premium, China is economy. There are good analogs of almost all European materials in China, certified in the local market, and they can be delivered to Russia in a month, says an employee of a logistics firm in Guangzhou.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"\"We also work with Russian materials, but they are closer to the premium price,\" says a private dentist from Moscow, laughing. According to him, those who wish can still get British and German materials and systems, but they will come to Russia by a roundabout route, through the UAE and Türkiye, and that will immediately add at least 40% to the price. The main problem, according to him, is the volume: foreign suppliers of dental products need to register in Russia, this process usually takes several months, and Russian companies, despite their desire, cannot increase production to meet the increased demand.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Return via partners","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Those who are in a real state of loss are the sellers of luxury goods: because of the sanctions, you cannot bring to Russia clothes, shoes, and bags from Europe that cost more than EUR300 (and with the premium brands that is the cost of underpants or a belt) and from the United States that cost more than USD1,000. The \"heavy luxury\" boutiques have closed their doors, deliveries have been stopped, and the Dolce &amp; Gabbana signboard is being dismantled in Barvikha Luxury Village. Real estate consultants are already predicting that Stoleshnikov Boulevard, where most of the stores have closed, will lose its status as the most expensive shopping street in the country and are advising owners of the premises to rent them to low-cost brands or restaurateurs.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":5044,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: SOPA Images / Zuma / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Fashionistas are left without luxury goods","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/41d971eb46b64df68116bad934d553f5-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/41d971eb46b64df68116bad934d553f5-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":900,"real_height_2x":1800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/41d971eb46b64df68116bad934d553f5-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/41d971eb46b64df68116bad934d553f5-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":900,"real_height_2x":1800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/41d971eb46b64df68116bad934d553f5-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/41d971eb46b64df68116bad934d553f5-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":311,"real_height_2x":622},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/41d971eb46b64df68116bad934d553f5-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/41d971eb46b64df68116bad934d553f5-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":311,"real_height_2x":622}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Consultants believe that premium foreign brands may return through their Russian partners, as it was in the 1990s and 2000s when expensive watches were brought to Russia by Consul and clothes were brought by Jamilko, Mercury (owner of Central Universal Department Store (TsUM)) and Bosco (tenant of State Department Store (GUM)). They did it until recently but to a much smaller extent. President Vladimir Putin advises not to worry about luxury consumers: \"Those who want to bring in some luxury goods, can do it, but it will be a little more expensive for them. But these are the people who already drove Mercedes-Benz 600, and will drive, I assure you, will bring them from anywhere, from any country.\"","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Indeed, those who need already purchase \"heavy luxury\" through Georgia, Armenia, and Kazakhstan, or go shopping in the UAE. But Russian sellers of luxury brands are in no hurry to engage in parallel imports, bypassing the fashion houses. As their employees admit, they hope to resume relations with the fashion houses in the foreseeable future. So now more than half of the new brands in TsUM are Turkish (for example, Nackiyé) and Russian brands (like the new brand of the famous designer Alexander Terekhov Sashaverse or the brand of the motorcycle racer Maria Kalashnikova Bats) and even Latin American brands (for example, Colombian Kika Vargas and Brazilian Fernando Jorge). An employee of TsUM assures the plan for this expansion was conceived last year.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Copy the secondary","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"It is not possible to replace imported software and high-tech products, especially in telecommunications. Deprivation of access to innovation leads to a setback in technical development. In the first quarter, shipments of mobile phones in Russia increased by 43% to 3.5 million units compared to the same period last year, and shipments of smartphones fell by 14% to 6.8 million, <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/technology_and_media/23/05/2022/6287e43c9a79477e9310bcff\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">reported RBC</a>, citing a GS Group research center report.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"\"Rostec (the State Corporation for Assistance to Development, Production and Export of Advanced Technology) proposes that the Ministry of Digital Development focus not on the fifth, but on the fourth generation of mobile telecommunications. In the approved 2020 version of the road map, it was planned to allocate RUB28.8 billion from the budget for the development of 5G. Now this money can be directed towards 4G, according to Kommersant's sources. But because of the shortage of equipment and technology, there are problems even with the deployment of such networks.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It will be very difficult to bring back international technology companies and software developers who have left Russia en masse — they leave not so much because of formal sanctions, but because of the image implications. And they will have to be replaced, Ruben Enikolopov, Rector of the New Economic School, admitted in an <a href=\"https://ria.ru/20220504/enikolopov-1786129366.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">interview</a>: \"It will not be the advanced technologies that we used to receive directly, from now on it will be a so-called 'second copy'. That is, Asian countries (which are not themselves the leaders) get the first copy from the EU and the U.S., and then we get a copy from them. So they're falling behind with some kind of lag from the leading edge, and we're going to be even twice as far behind.\"","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":580,"header":"What War Crimes Have Russian Servicemen Committed in Ukraine","_path":"/en/opinions/2022/05/26/what-war-crimes-have-russian-servicemen-committed-in-ukraine/","lead":"Analysts of the Conflict Intelligence Team recount high-profile cases that have been confirmed","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1b264bedd6664b39b3bcb929a2f7e8b1-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Photo: Reuters / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2022-05-26","created_at_date_time":null,"updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":true,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":13,"first_name":"Соня","last_name":"Савина","first_name_en":"Sonya","last_name_en":"Savina","is_public":true,"_path":"sonya-savina","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Если вы хотите рассказать мне свою историю, пишите на почту sonya.savina@istories.media.","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":"Author","ordering":null}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"In three months of the war in Ukraine, most of the accusations of war crimes were brought against the Russian side. \"The violations committed by the Russian Federation are by far larger in nature and scale [than the violations committed by Ukraine],\" the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) said in a report. Conflict Intelligence Team (CIT) analysts, who have been monitoring the actions of the Russian army in Ukraine for the past three months, agree with this assessment. Ruslan Leviev, Kirill Mikhailov, and another CIT analyst, who wished to remain anonymous, provide an exclusive comment on what actions by Russian soldiers could potentially be regarded as war crimes.\n\nTo learn how international justice works for war criminals and why the unpunished brutality of some of the Russian army's actions in Chechnya led to the massacre in Bucha, you can read this article.\nMass murders of civilians\nThe most notorious case of mass murder of civilians was the \"massacre in Bucha\". Satellite images and drone recordings clearly prove the guilt of the Russian side: they show that the corpses of civilians appeared on the streets of Bucha while the city was controlled by Russian troops. In addition, there is evidence that mass graves began to appear there at the same time. \n\nThere is also a video that clearly shows Russian military machinery with a V sign — characteristic of troops operating in the northwestern part of the Kyiv region — firing at the cyclist. We identified these vehicles as modern BMD-4M (Combat Vehicle of the Airborne), which are primarily in service with the \"Pskov paratroopers\" (the 104th and 234th regiments of the 76th Division), who suffered losses in and around Bucha in February and March of this year.\nAll this evidence, as well as a huge number of testimonies from civilians who told Western journalists about what happened, leave no doubt that the killings were committed by the Russian military, and much of the guilt lies with the paratroopers.\n\nReports of inhumane treatment of the civilian population come from almost everywhere, for example, from the Chernihiv and Sumy regions. Bucha is unique for the fact that it was the place where paratroopers stood for a long time, constantly under artillery and mortar fire and suffering losses. We assume that they suspected a spotter in everyone, were afraid of the locals, and did not even allow them to look at themselves. They could shoot civilians who just saw their positions. \n\nAnd dozens of other cases from the Kharkiv, Chernihiv, and Kyiv regions continue to surface. They are considered less revealing and do not cause such a shock, mainly because the locals had time to remove the corpses before the liberation. And while Russia is trying to deny its involvement in the crimes in Bucha alone, the Human Rights Watch report suggests that the killing of civilians is a systematic approach of many Russian servicemen in Ukraine.\n\nIndiscriminate attacks on civilian targets\nCompletely prohibited weapons, such as chemical weapons, are not used in this war, but in international norms, there are certain restrictions on any weapons. Russia has been seen violating these restrictions. The entire Russian military doctrine is based primarily on the massive, indiscriminate use of various weapons: artillery, aviation, and others. In fact, this doctrine already implies some war crimes: acting strictly on it, it is impossible not to commit them. \n\nThe Russian army knows no other way to take control of the cities. It doesn't have enough high-precision weapons to fight like NATO (when civilian casualties count in hundreds, not thousands). Accordingly, Russian generals have no intention of avoiding the damage that accompanies this strategy, they do not take into account the lives of civilians. \n\nOf the non-prohibited weapons used in ways that could lead to war crimes, Russia uses, for example, multiple rocket launchers, cluster munitions (Russia, the US, and a number of other countries have not adopted these restrictions), and incendiary munitions. Intrinsically, they have quite legitimate uses. Their main task is to defeat the enemy in open terrain, over a large area. However, the Russian army uses these weapons in residential areas. Such use could be considered a potential war crime because it is indiscriminate and prohibited by international conventions. \n\nFor example, we found that Russia bombed Chernihiv with incendiary fragmentation bombs OFZAB-500, and it is absolutely forbidden to use such bombs on city blocks where there is an accumulation of civilians. \n\nIn addition, the Izvestia newspaper openly reported on the use of 9M22S incendiary rockets to strike Ukrainian positions near Zolote. We did not see civilian objects being hit there, but there were fires in towns after such shelling, for example in Popasna, and in such a case this could also be a potential war crime.\nAnother case, in which the guilt of the Russian side is obvious, is reflected in the video from Irpin. In the video, one can spot a low flight of two Su-25s, followed immediately by an explosion in the vicinity of an apartment building. We have established that the planes came from the north — there are airfields on the territory of Belarus, where, according to satellite images, the Su-25s were based. At the time, Irpin was under Ukrainian control, and there were many civilians who had not had time to evacuate.\n\nAnother strike on the civilian population was the shelling of the station in Kramatorsk. A man was killed there and 121 others were wounded. They were awaiting evacuation. Unfortunately, the method we tried in the first days to draw conclusions from photo and video footage later proved to be inapplicable. But in this case, to check the involvement of the Russian side, we can analyze general patterns. \n\nBefore the shelling in Kramatorsk, it was in this region that Russian aircraft and missile systems struck (and are still striking) numerous railroad infrastructure, all the railroads that lead to Donbas. We are sure that the Russian generals wanted (and want) to disrupt the supply of the Ukrainian group in Donbas. And the shelling of Kramatorsk looks quite logical in line with what was happening in those days. From the general logic of what happened, we can draw a conclusion about the involvement of the Russian side. Another circumstantial evidence is that Russia has begun to deny the use of the Tochka-U missile system that was used to shell the train station. However, it is known that at least in January 2022 the complex was in use by the 47th missile brigade of the 8th Army, which is now conducting an offensive in Donbas.\n\n\nRussia responds to all such accusations by saying that the Ukrainians are bombing themselves. But the scale of destruction that we see in Mariupol, Rubizhne, and other settlements cannot be inflicted by the besieged side. For example, the Defense Ministry calls the airstrike on a maternity hospital in Mariupol, where there were women in labor, a \"staged provocation.\" However, there is a video of an Associated Press journalist who was in Mariupol at the time of the strike, and he said that he heard the sounds of planes right before the hospital was hit. The Russian side denies there was an airstrike. \nIt simply makes no sense for the Ukrainian side to engage in such provocations in the face of constant shelling, bombing, and civilian deaths.\nRape of women and children\nThe raping of Ukrainian women by the Russian military is confirmed by the reports of the international organizations Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International. We have no reason to doubt the objectivity of these organizations: they have repeatedly investigated violations of the rules of warfare by Ukraine in 2014-2015, too. We also see interviews of rape victims, and we have no doubts about their veracity. \n\nUkrainian sources are currently talking about the rape of children as well, including reports by Lyudmila Denisova, the Ukrainian Parliament Commissioner for Human Rights. We haven't seen direct evidence backed up by open data. This information still needs to be accumulated and verified for potential trials.\nAbduction of civilians \nA huge number of stories have been published in the media about people who have been \"in basements\" (this is what they call illegal detention in Donetsk People's Republic). People were captured rather randomly. Usually, it was done by ordinary soldiers who were afraid of the spotters or were looking for \"Nazis\" — they were told that there must be Nazis in Ukraine. The military has a peculiar understanding of how to identify a Nazi: if you served in the army, you are a Nazi; if you have a tattoo with the emblem of Ukraine, you are a Nazi; if you said something wrong or cursed the Russian occupiers, you are a Nazi. If the military didn't like someone, they could declare that person a Nazi, put them \"in the basement,\" and then even shoot them. We are willing to believe reports that the Russian military might shoot civilians for wearing camouflage pants typical of hunters, fishermen, and mushroom gatherers.\n\nIn the south of Ukraine (Zaporizhzhia, Kherson Oblast) we see the unfolding of the Russian repressive system, but in a harsher form: that of Chechnya or Belarus. This is confirmed by videos of Ukrainians apologizing for \"speaking ill of Russian soldiers on social networks.\" We see reports of the illegal detention of various activists and local officials who do not cooperate with the new authorities in the occupied territories. For example, on March 11, Ivan Fedorov, the mayor of Melitopol, was kidnapped by Russian soldiers and held in the Melitopol detention center for five days. Former members of the territorial defense, former participants of the antiterrorist operation (the official Ukrainian term for the first stage of the armed conflict in eastern Ukraine, which began in 2014— Ed.) also suffer. \n\nWe are receiving information from various sources that the former buildings of the Security Service of Ukraine (SBU) and the detention center are being used to illegally imprison civilians. We saw the same thing in Donbas in 2014-2015. This is how the Russian side is trying to prevent resistance to the occupation authorities.\nLooting\nThe facts of looting by the Russian army on Ukrainian territory are confirmed by data we gathered from open sources. For example, the Russian military tried to send 130 parcels with items from Ukrainian homes from Mazyr, a Belarusian city near the border with Ukraine, to Rubtsovsk, a town in the Altai region of Siberia. This was discovered after the release of CCTV footage from the SDEK offices (a Russian express delivery company) located on the border with Ukraine. We are also receiving reports from the border regions of Russia that large quantities of looted equipment and other valuables have been sent from Ukraine to various provincial towns where military units are major employers.\n\nHere, we can also mention how a Russian Yuri Zverev from the town of Klin near Moscow wrote on social media that his son-in-law brought a \"trophy\" BMW SUV \"from you know where\". Said car was \"without Ukrop [a derogatory term used in Russia for Ukrainians] numbers and documents.\" Zverev asked other users how to register such a car in Russia. He asked the administrators of the public page to post his message anonymously, but they revealed his name. After that, the online community was blocked by Roskomnadzor. \n\nOur military source described an incident in which a soldier drove a stolen car to a deployment site to sell it. He was stopped by a traffic police officer on the highway near the Russian border, who asked: \"Why don't you take the plates off? I can see you're in uniform, I understand where you're coming from and what kind of car you are driving. Take off the license plate, put the letter Z [on the car], and go in peace.\" Therefore, if we see a clearly civilian car without license plates and with the letter V or Z on it in the border regions of Russia, we are 90% sure that it was stolen by marauders. \n\nIn addition, Ukrainians themselves tracked the location of their stolen iPhones and iPads using the Find My app on their Apple devices. Smartphones and tablets were turned on in Pskov, Khimki, and Belgorod Region, where Russian troops were relocated after their withdrawal from Ukraine.\n\nLooting reached such proportions in March, in part because the Kyiv region is a fairly affluent place, and Russian soldiers come from disadvantaged regions. An analysis of the statistical data on obituaries shows that the poorer the region, the more obituaries are published there. This makes sense: the army conscripts come en masse from regions with no prospects, or from ethnic republics far from the center, where the motivation \"to make a name for yourself\" is strong. In Rubtsovsk in Soviet times there was a factory, which then closed, and people were left with two main employers — the Federal Penitentiary Service (the local colony) and the Rosgvardiya (The National Guard of the Russian Federation). And so these Rosgvardiya servicemen from a dying single-industry town went to the Kyiv region, and then sent home what they had looted there. Military salaries are low An iPad or laptop is a luxury for them.\nDestruction of medical infrastructure\nMedical facilities in the combat zone have a special status. Separate precautions must be taken to protect such objects when conducting attacks. However, even during the war in Syria, we observed that for the Russian army these norms were not of any significance. During the Syrian war, human rights organizations provided information about the location of medical facilities, but they were still hit. Moreover, it is also believed that the strikes were carried out intentionally in order to destroy the medical infrastructure.\nIn Ukraine, the number of incidents involving damage to medical infrastructure is lower than in Syria. But we are still talking about a lot of victims of the shelling of medical institutions. By May 23, the World Health Organization (WHO) had counted more than 200 cases of damage to Ukrainian health care facilities since the start of the war. As a result, 75 people were killed and 59 injured. It should be understood that this does not mean a deliberate attack on medical institutions. But it shows indiscriminate shelling of urban neighborhoods with health care facilities, potentially constituting a war crime.\nIll-treatment of prisoners of war\nIf the treatment of prisoners of war does not meet international standards, it can be considered a war crime.\n\nWe received reports from our sources about the preparation of Russian penal colonies for Ukrainian prisoners of war even before they [the Russian authorities] started to fill them. We were told that prisoners of penitentiary facilities in Russian regions bordering Ukraine were being transferred to colonies in other regions. You could theoretically keep prisoners in the colonies but only if certain conditions are met. Prisoners of war cannot be treated like regular prisoners. They have a special status, and international organizations must have information about their state and conditions. The Red Cross must also ensure communication with relatives and the transfer of humanitarian aid to prisoners of war. But according to Deputy Prime Minister of Ukraine Iryna Vereshchuk, Russia does not allow Red Cross employees to visit Ukrainian prisoners of war. \n\nThe Ukrainian side also reported moral and psychological abuse of Ukrainian prisoners of war. For example, Ukrainian women were forced to strip naked, squat, and so on. To verify this, international organizations need access to prisoners of war. Unfortunately, we now know little about what happens to them. \n\nWe have seen reports about the alleged murder of Ukrainian prisoner of war Dan Zvonik. On April 20, the DNR people's militia published a video showing five Ukrainian prisoners of war, including Zvonik. A week later, his mother received photographs of her son's dead body. We have no reason to doubt that it is the same person on the video and in the photos, but we have no exact information on what caused his death. After this case surfaced, pro-Kremlin commentators asserted that Zvonik was wounded in combat and died as a result. The murder version is plausible, but we cannot verify this information. \nWe are not aware of any other cases of murders of Ukrainian POWs. However, there are wiretaps published by the SBU in which the Russian servicemen discuss the murder of a prisoner of war: they did not know where to keep him, so they just killed him. We have no serious reasons to question the authenticity of this record. We understand that the selection of wiretaps is biased, there may be some creative editing and phrases taken out of context. But most of the facts contained in the wiretaps are confirmed by information from other sources.\nForced Mobilization\nIn the context of war crimes, very little is said about forced mobilization (sending to a combat zone against the will. — Ed.) the territory of the Donetsk and Luhansk People's Republics It should be understood that in terms of international law, these republics are territories occupied by the Russian Federation since 2014. Under international law, an occupying power or its subordinate administrations have no right to mobilize the local population. The exception is calls for work necessary for the locals themselves, such as rebuilding infrastructure. Military mobilization in the occupied territories is a blatant violation of international law. And it is in plain sight.\n\nNow there are statements that the mobilized will finally be properly trained and prepared for the oath. And relatively recently, people were taken indiscriminately, given automatic rifles, and thrown into the offensive on Ukrainian positions for the purpose of identifying firing points of the Ukrainian army. The locals themselves call it genocide of the male population of Donbas. This is the closest thing to the very \"genocide\" that Putin spoke of in his address to the Russians on February 24.\nWhat the Ukrainian side is accused of\nWe know of two videos of Russian prisoners of war being shot. One incident occurred in the Kyiv region, south of Bucha. The geolocation of this video was confirmed by journalists of Bild and The New York Times. We consider this video credible, just like the video of shooting prisoners in the legs in the Kharkiv region. \n\nIn addition, at least two cases of Ukrainians using cluster munitions on residential areas have been confirmed. They struck with multiple rocket launchers with cluster munitions at the Russian command post, which was located in a residential area of a village in the Kharkiv region. It is also known about the shelling of the village of Solokhi in the Belgorod region with cluster munitions. We don't know if any legitimate military target was located there, but even so, the indiscriminate use of such weapons could be considered a war crime.\n\nOne civilian, a Russian, died in Solokhi. But from the Russian side, there are hundreds of times more such violations as indiscriminate shelling of territories. The scale of potential war crimes now being committed by Russian servicemen is staggering and does not compare to 2014-2015. At that time we did not observe mass murders, massive strikes on civilians, and looting at that scale. The number of attacks on civilians is ten times greater now than it was then. And while a Ukrainian court punished individual Ukrainian security forces for violations in 2014-2015, Russia has no history of punishing its military for crimes in Ukraine.","blocks":[{"data":"In three months of the war in Ukraine, most of the accusations of war crimes were brought against the Russian side. \"The violations committed by the Russian Federation are by far larger in nature and scale [than the violations committed by Ukraine],\" the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) said in a <a href=\"https://www.osce.org/files/f/documents/f/a/515868.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">report</a>. Conflict Intelligence Team (CIT) analysts, who have been monitoring the actions of the Russian army in Ukraine for the past three months, agree with this assessment. Ruslan Leviev, Kirill Mikhailov, and another CIT analyst, who wished to remain anonymous, provide an exclusive comment on what actions by Russian soldiers could potentially be regarded as war crimes.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>To learn how international justice works for war criminals and why the unpunished brutality of some of the Russian army's actions in Chechnya led to the massacre in Bucha, you can read this </em><a href=\"https://www.istories.media/opinions/2022/05/26/kak-nakazivayut-voennikh-prestupnikov/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>article</em></a><em>.</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Mass murders of civilians","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The most notorious case of mass murder of civilians was the <a href=\"https://istories.media/reportages/2022/04/05/oni-prosto-prishli-ubili-kuchu-naroda-raznesli-gorod-i-ushli/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">\"massacre in Bucha\"</a>. Satellite <a href=\"https://www.nytimes.com/2022/04/04/world/europe/bucha-ukraine-bodies.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">images</a> and <a href=\"https://edition.cnn.com/europe/live-news/russia-ukraine-war-news-04-27-22/h_a737a86115cc6fcd1c74f63e35b8f0b5\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">drone</a> recordings clearly prove the guilt of the Russian side: they show that the corpses of civilians appeared on the streets of Bucha while the city was controlled by Russian troops. In addition, there is <a href=\"https://t.me/CITeam/2456\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">evidence</a> that mass graves began to appear there at the same time.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There is also a <a href=\"https://www.nytimes.com/2022/04/05/world/europe/bucha-shooting-video.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">video</a> that clearly shows Russian military machinery with a V sign — characteristic of troops operating in the northwestern part of the Kyiv region — firing at the cyclist. We identified these vehicles as modern BMD-4M (Combat Vehicle of the Airborne), which are primarily in service with the \"Pskov paratroopers\" (the 104th and 234th regiments of the 76th Division), who suffered losses in and around Bucha in February and March of this year.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4822,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Reuters / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"People at graves that were dug during the war in the village of Staryi Krym near Mariupol, Ukraine, May 22, 2022","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/112f3ab981f3412ab9ea31eb64f3e3e9-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/112f3ab981f3412ab9ea31eb64f3e3e9-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":792,"real_height_2x":1584},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/112f3ab981f3412ab9ea31eb64f3e3e9-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/112f3ab981f3412ab9ea31eb64f3e3e9-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":792,"real_height_2x":1584},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/112f3ab981f3412ab9ea31eb64f3e3e9-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/112f3ab981f3412ab9ea31eb64f3e3e9-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":274,"real_height_2x":548},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/112f3ab981f3412ab9ea31eb64f3e3e9-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/112f3ab981f3412ab9ea31eb64f3e3e9-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":274,"real_height_2x":548}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"All this evidence, as well as a huge number of testimonies from civilians who <a href=\"https://apnews.com/article/russia-ukraine-europe-war-crimes-7791e247ce7087dddf64a2bbdcc5b888\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">told</a> Western journalists about what happened, leave no doubt that the killings were committed by the Russian military, and much of the guilt lies with the paratroopers.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Reports of inhumane treatment of the civilian population come from almost everywhere, for example, from the <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/reportages/2022/04/27/ne-tolko-bucha-vot-chto-bilo-pod-chernigovom/index.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Chernihiv</a> and Sumy regions. Bucha is unique for the fact that it was the place where paratroopers stood for a long time, constantly under artillery and mortar fire and suffering losses. We assume that they suspected a spotter in everyone, were afraid of the locals, and did not even allow them to look at themselves. They could shoot civilians who just saw their positions.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"And dozens of other cases from the Kharkiv, Chernihiv, and Kyiv regions continue to surface.&nbsp;They are considered less revealing and do not cause such a shock, mainly because the locals had time to remove the corpses before the liberation.&nbsp;And while Russia is trying to deny its involvement in the crimes in Bucha alone, the Human Rights Watch <a href=\"https://www.hrw.org/news/2022/04/03/ukraine-apparent-war-crimes-russia-controlled-areas\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">report</a> suggests that the killing of civilians is a systematic approach of many Russian servicemen in Ukraine.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4825,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/80ea75a96961405aad4c11928bf67667/visualisation-10172233/index.html","ratio_mobile":"full-width-and-height","ratio_desktop":"800:600"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":{"id":4821,"data":{"block":"<p>Human Rights Watch collected testimonies of crimes committed by Russian servicemen in 17 settlements in the Kyiv and Chernihiv regions, which were occupied by Russian troops from late February to late March.</p><p><br/></p><p>Human Rights Watch distinguishes several types of war crimes committed by the Russian military during the occupation of Ukrainian settlements: summary killings of civilians, illegal detention, detention in humiliating conditions, torture, and shooting at people unnecessarily. </p><p> </p><p>As reported by Human Rights Watch, the cases documented are only a small fraction of all war crimes. The report included only those cases that were possible to verify by talking to witnesses or victims. The actual number of crimes is much higher. </p><p> </p><p>Only in the basement of the school in the village of Yahidne, the Russian military held 350 people, including 70 children, for a month. Due to lack of air, food, lack of medicine, inability to move, 10 people died during their detention. And the UN Monitoring Mission has<a href=\"https://www.ohchr.org/ru/press-briefing-notes/2022/05/plight-civilians-ukraine\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> documented</a> 204 cases of enforced disappearance. There is one child among the kidnapped. The vast majority of disappearances, according to the UN, are caused by the actions of the Russian military and associated armed groups.</p>","header":"HOW HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH COLLECTS EVIDENCE OF WAR CRIMES","content":[{"insert":"Human Rights Watch collected testimonies of crimes committed by Russian servicemen in 17 settlements in the Kyiv and Chernihiv regions, which were occupied by Russian troops from late February to late March.\n\nHuman Rights Watch distinguishes several types of war crimes committed by the Russian military during the occupation of Ukrainian settlements: summary killings of civilians, illegal detention, detention in humiliating conditions, torture, and shooting at people unnecessarily. \n \nAs reported by Human Rights Watch, the cases documented are only a small fraction of all war crimes. The report included only those cases that were possible to verify by talking to witnesses or victims. The actual number of crimes is much higher. \n \nOnly in the basement of the school in the village of Yahidne, the Russian military held 350 people, including 70 children, for a month. Due to lack of air, food, lack of medicine, inability to move, 10 people died during their detention. And the UN Monitoring Mission has"},{"insert":" documented","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.ohchr.org/ru/press-briefing-notes/2022/05/plight-civilians-ukraine","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" 204 cases of enforced disappearance. There is one child among the kidnapped. The vast majority of disappearances, according to the UN, are caused by the actions of the Russian military and associated armed groups.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"Indiscriminate attacks on civilian targets","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Completely prohibited weapons, such as chemical weapons, are not used in this war, but in international norms, there are certain restrictions on any weapons. Russia has been seen violating these restrictions.&nbsp;The entire Russian military doctrine is based primarily on the massive, indiscriminate use of various weapons: artillery, aviation, and others. In fact, this doctrine already implies some war crimes: acting strictly on it, it is impossible not to commit them.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Russian army knows no other way to take control of the cities. It <a href=\"https://istories.media/opinions/2022/05/12/smozhet-li-rossiya-voevat-bez-zapadnogo-importa/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">doesn't have</a> enough high-precision weapons to fight like NATO (when civilian casualties count in hundreds, not thousands). Accordingly, Russian generals have no intention of avoiding the damage that accompanies this strategy, they do not take into account the lives of civilians.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Of the non-prohibited weapons used in ways that could lead to war crimes, Russia uses, for example, multiple rocket launchers, cluster munitions (Russia, the US, and a number of other countries have not adopted these restrictions), and incendiary munitions. Intrinsically, they have quite legitimate uses. Their main task is to defeat the enemy in open terrain, over a large area. However, the Russian army uses these weapons in residential areas. Such use could be considered a potential war crime because it is indiscriminate and prohibited by international conventions.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For example, we <a href=\"https://citeam-ru.medium.com/%D1%80%D0%BE%D1%81%D1%81%D0%B8%D0%B9%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B0%D1%8F-%D0%B0%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B0%D1%86%D0%B8%D1%8F-%D0%B1%D0%BE%D0%BC%D0%B1%D0%B8%D1%82-%D1%87%D0%B5%D1%80%D0%BD%D0%B8%D0%B3%D0%BE%D0%B2-%D0%B7%D0%B0%D0%B6%D0%B8%D0%B3%D0%B0%D1%82%D0%B5%D0%BB%D1%8C%D0%BD%D1%8B%D0%BC%D0%B8-%D0%B0%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B0%D0%B1%D0%BE%D0%BC%D0%B1%D0%B0%D0%BC%D0%B8-%D1%87%D1%82%D0%BE-%D0%BF%D1%80%D1%8F%D0%BC%D0%BE-%D0%B7%D0%B0%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%B5%D1%89%D0%B5%D0%BD%D0%BE-%D0%BC%D0%B5%D0%B6%D0%B4%D1%83%D0%BD%D0%B0%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%B4%D0%BD%D1%8B%D0%BC-4d1173a14494\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">found</a> that Russia bombed Chernihiv with incendiary fragmentation bombs OFZAB-500, and it is absolutely forbidden to use such bombs on city blocks where there is an accumulation of civilians.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In addition, the Izvestia newspaper openly <a href=\"https://twitter.com/RALee85/status/1527638845054930944\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reported</a> on the use of 9M22S incendiary rockets to strike Ukrainian positions near Zolote. We did not see civilian objects being hit there, but there were fires in towns after such shelling, for example in Popasna, and in such a case this could also be a potential war crime.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4823,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Fadel Senna / AFP / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Destroyed cars after shelling near the Kramatorsk train station, which was used to evacuate civilians","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0d8be8ead2c742908a27a353cf9da112-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0d8be8ead2c742908a27a353cf9da112-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1601},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0d8be8ead2c742908a27a353cf9da112-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0d8be8ead2c742908a27a353cf9da112-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1601},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0d8be8ead2c742908a27a353cf9da112-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0d8be8ead2c742908a27a353cf9da112-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":554},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0d8be8ead2c742908a27a353cf9da112-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0d8be8ead2c742908a27a353cf9da112-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":554}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Another case, in which the guilt of the Russian side is obvious, is reflected in the <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=34sjTUZjr70&amp;feature=youtu.be&amp;ab_channel=%D0%9C%D0%B5%D0%BD%D0%B0%D0%B2%D1%96%D1%82%D0%B0Online\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">video</a> from Irpin. In the video, one can spot a low flight of two Su-25s, followed immediately by an explosion in the vicinity of an apartment building. We have <a href=\"https://t.me/CITeam/2366\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">established</a> that the planes came from the north — there are airfields on the territory of Belarus, where, according to satellite images, the Su-25s were based. At the time, Irpin was under Ukrainian control, and there were many civilians who had not had time to evacuate.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Another strike on the civilian population was the <a href=\"https://t.me/CITeam/2463\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">shelling</a> of the station in Kramatorsk. A man was <a href=\"https://t.me/SBUkr/4301\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">killed</a> there and 121 others were wounded. They were awaiting evacuation. Unfortunately, the method we tried in the first days to draw conclusions from photo and video footage later proved to be inapplicable. But in this case, to check the involvement of the Russian side, we can analyze general patterns. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Before the shelling in Kramatorsk, it was in this region that Russian aircraft and missile systems struck (and are still striking) numerous railroad infrastructure, all the railroads that lead to Donbas. We are sure that the Russian generals wanted (and want) to disrupt the supply of the Ukrainian group in Donbas. And the shelling of Kramatorsk looks quite logical in line with what was happening in those days. From the general logic of what happened, we can draw a conclusion about the involvement of the Russian side. Another circumstantial evidence is that Russia has begun to deny the use of the Tochka-U missile system that was used to shell the train station. However, it is known that at least in January 2022 the complex <a href=\"https://t.me/CITeam/2463\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">was in use</a> by the 47th missile brigade of the 8th Army, which is now conducting an offensive in Donbas.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":7018,"data":{"text":"Your donations will help us continue to tell the truth about the war in Ukraine and more","title":"Support independent journalism!","buttonText":"Support Important Stories"},"category":"donate-embed"},"type":"donate-embed"},{"data":"Russia responds to all such accusations by saying that the Ukrainians are bombing themselves. But the scale of destruction that we see in Mariupol, Rubizhne, and other settlements cannot be inflicted by the besieged side. For example, the Defense Ministry <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CHp_a1KN_Y0\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">calls</a> the <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/news-60741418\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">airstrike</a> on a maternity hospital in Mariupol, where there were women in labor, a \"staged provocation.\" However, there is a <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6-NC-QOhhv4\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">video</a> of an Associated Press journalist who was in Mariupol at the time of the strike, and he said that he <a href=\"https://apnews.com/article/russia-ukraine-europe-edf7240a9d990e7e3e32f82ca351dede?fbclid=IwAR1VbtuHCXyYJ1qmjV_aSHQ6y6M8zU_1PDezgRvv9ExPhBFhScIzzOfxdCA\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">heard</a> the sounds of planes right before the hospital was hit. The Russian side denies there was an airstrike.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It simply makes no sense for the Ukrainian side to engage in such provocations in the face of constant shelling, bombing, and civilian deaths.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Rape of women and children","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The raping of Ukrainian women by the Russian military is confirmed by the <a href=\"https://www.hrw.org/ru/news/2022/04/20/ukraine-apparent-war-crimes-russia-controlled-areas\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reports</a> of the international organizations Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International. We have no reason to doubt the objectivity of these organizations: they have repeatedly investigated violations of the rules of warfare by Ukraine in 2014-2015, too. We also see <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/media-61099941\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">interviews</a> of rape victims, and we have no doubts about their veracity.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Ukrainian sources are currently talking about the rape of children as well, including <a href=\"https://t.me/denisovaombudsman/4883\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reports</a> by Lyudmila Denisova, the Ukrainian Parliament Commissioner for Human Rights. We haven't seen direct evidence backed up by open data. This information still needs to be accumulated and verified for potential trials.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Abduction of civilians&nbsp;","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"A huge number of <a href=\"https://istories.media/reportages/2022/04/27/ne-tolko-bucha-vot-chto-bilo-pod-chernigovom/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">stories</a> have been published in the media about people who have been \"in basements\" (this is what they call illegal detention in Donetsk People's Republic). People were captured rather randomly. Usually, it was done by ordinary soldiers who were afraid of the spotters or were looking for \"Nazis\" — they were told that there must be Nazis in Ukraine. The military has a peculiar understanding of how to identify a Nazi: if you served in the army, you are a Nazi; if you have a tattoo with the emblem of Ukraine, you are a Nazi; if you said something wrong or cursed the Russian occupiers, you are a Nazi. If the military didn't like someone, they could declare that person a Nazi, put them \"in the basement,\" and then even shoot them. We are willing to believe <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/news-60587829\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reports</a> that the Russian military might shoot civilians for wearing camouflage pants typical of hunters, fishermen, and mushroom gatherers.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In the south of Ukraine (Zaporizhzhia, Kherson Oblast) we see the unfolding of the Russian repressive system, but in a harsher form: that of Chechnya or Belarus. This is confirmed by <a href=\"https://meduza.io/feature/2022/05/20/v-sotssetyah-poyavilis-video-s-izvineniyami-zhiteley-okkupirovannogo-yuga-ukrainy-pered-rossiyskimi-voennymi\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">videos</a> of Ukrainians apologizing for \"speaking ill of Russian soldiers on social networks.\" We see reports of the illegal detention of various activists and local officials who do not cooperate with the new authorities in the occupied territories. For example, on March 11, Ivan Fedorov, the mayor of Melitopol, was <a href=\"https://www.currenttime.tv/a/ivan-fedorov/31758441.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">kidnapped</a> by Russian soldiers and held in the Melitopol detention center for five days. Former members of the territorial defense, former participants of the antiterrorist operation (<em>the official Ukrainian term for the first stage of the armed conflict in eastern Ukraine, which began in 2014</em>— <strong>Ed.</strong>) also <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/features-61257099\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">suffer</a>.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We are receiving information from various sources that the former buildings of the Security Service of Ukraine (SBU) and the detention center are being used to illegally imprison civilians. We saw the same thing in Donbas in 2014-2015. This is how the Russian side is trying to prevent resistance to the occupation authorities.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Looting","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The facts of looting by the Russian army on Ukrainian territory are confirmed by data we gathered from open sources. For example, the Russian military tried to send 130 parcels with items from Ukrainian homes from Mazyr, a Belarusian city near the border with Ukraine, to Rubtsovsk, a town in the Altai region of Siberia. This was discovered after the <a href=\"https://youtu.be/6vyY4rnJ7lA\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">release</a> of CCTV footage from the SDEK offices (a Russian express delivery company) located on the border with Ukraine. We are also receiving reports from the border regions of Russia that large quantities of looted equipment and other valuables have been sent from Ukraine to various provincial towns where military units are major employers.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Here, we can also mention how a Russian Yuri Zverev from the town of Klin near Moscow <a href=\"https://meduza.io/news/2022/04/24/v-tverskom-pablike-sprosili-kak-legalizovat-v-rossii-trofeynyy-vnedorozhnik-iz-ukrainy-spustya-dva-dnya-pablik-zablokirovali\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">wrote</a> on social media that his son-in-law brought a \"trophy\" BMW SUV \"from you know where\". Said car was \"without Ukrop [a derogatory term used in Russia for Ukrainians] numbers and documents.\" Zverev asked other users how to register such a car in Russia. He asked the administrators of the public page to post his message anonymously, but they revealed his name. After that, the online community was <a href=\"https://t.me/ilyashepelin/3344\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">blocked</a> by Roskomnadzor.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Our military source described an incident in which a soldier drove a stolen car to a deployment site to sell it. He was stopped by a traffic police officer on the highway near the Russian border, who asked: \"Why don't you take the plates off? I can see you're in uniform, I understand where you're coming from and what kind of car you are driving. Take off the license plate, put the letter Z [on the car], and go in peace.\" Therefore, if we see a clearly civilian car without license plates and with the letter V or Z on it in the border regions of Russia, we are 90% sure that it was stolen by marauders.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In addition, Ukrainians themselves <a href=\"https://www.instagram.com/p/CcWLKGxtgFK/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">tracked</a> the location of their stolen iPhones and iPads using the Find My app on their Apple devices. Smartphones and tablets were turned on in Pskov, Khimki, and Belgorod Region, where Russian troops were relocated after their withdrawal from Ukraine.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Looting reached such proportions in March, in part because the Kyiv region is a fairly affluent place, and Russian soldiers come from disadvantaged regions. An <a href=\"https://istories.media/investigations/2022/05/04/yunie-bednie-mertvie/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">analysis</a> of the statistical data on obituaries shows that the poorer the region, the more obituaries are published there. This makes sense: the army conscripts come en masse from regions with no prospects, or from ethnic republics far from the center, where the motivation \"to make a name for yourself\" is strong. In Rubtsovsk in Soviet times there was a factory, which then closed, and people were left with two main employers — the Federal Penitentiary Service (the local colony) and the Rosgvardiya (The National Guard of the Russian Federation). And so these Rosgvardiya servicemen from a dying single-industry town went to the Kyiv region, and then sent home what they had looted there. Military salaries are low An iPad or laptop is a luxury for them.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Destruction of medical infrastructure","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Medical facilities in the combat zone have a special status. Separate precautions must be taken to protect such objects when conducting attacks. However, even during the war in Syria, we observed that for the Russian army these norms were not of any significance. During the Syrian war, human rights organizations provided information about the location of medical facilities, but they were still hit. Moreover, it is also believed that the strikes were carried out intentionally in order to destroy the medical infrastructure.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4824,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Mstyslav Chernov / AP / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"One of the women in labor, Marianna Vyshemirskaya, near the maternity hospital that was damaged by shelling in Mariupol on March 9, 2022","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e75e95a9cb54f1c95ec5665194a64aa-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e75e95a9cb54f1c95ec5665194a64aa-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":802,"real_height_2x":1603},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e75e95a9cb54f1c95ec5665194a64aa-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e75e95a9cb54f1c95ec5665194a64aa-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":802,"real_height_2x":1603},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e75e95a9cb54f1c95ec5665194a64aa-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e75e95a9cb54f1c95ec5665194a64aa-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":277,"real_height_2x":554},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e75e95a9cb54f1c95ec5665194a64aa-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e75e95a9cb54f1c95ec5665194a64aa-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":277,"real_height_2x":554}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"In Ukraine, the number of incidents involving damage to medical infrastructure is lower than in Syria. But we are still talking about a lot of victims of the shelling of medical institutions. By May 23, the World Health Organization (WHO) had <a href=\"https://twitter.com/WHOUkraine/status/1528637932235636740\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">counted</a> more than 200 cases of damage to Ukrainian health care facilities since the start of the war. As a result, 75 people were killed and 59 injured. It should be understood that this does not mean a deliberate attack on medical institutions. But it shows indiscriminate shelling of urban neighborhoods with health care facilities, potentially constituting a war crime.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Ill-treatment of prisoners of war","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"If the treatment of prisoners of war does not meet international standards, it can be considered a war crime.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We received reports from our sources about the preparation of Russian penal colonies for Ukrainian prisoners of war even before they [the Russian authorities] started to fill them. We were told that prisoners of penitentiary facilities in Russian regions bordering Ukraine were being transferred to colonies in other regions. You could theoretically keep prisoners in the colonies but only if certain conditions are met. Prisoners of war cannot be treated like regular prisoners. They have a special status, and international organizations must have information about their state and conditions. The Red Cross must also ensure communication with relatives and the transfer of humanitarian aid to prisoners of war. But <a href=\"https://tsn.ua/exclusive/vereschuk-rozpovila-pro-kilkist-polonenih-ukrayinciv-u-rosiyan-i-chomu-ne-mozhna-chekati-na-obmin-azh-do-peremogi-2013550.html?fbclid=IwAR2U1l2wUWGupZUjtq-upzWWNfTUkQkkWU3Ymqqa2078LFsLSiUbrm7P3OA\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">according to Deputy Prime Minister of Ukraine</a> Iryna Vereshchuk, Russia does not allow Red Cross employees to visit Ukrainian prisoners of war.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Ukrainian side also <a href=\"https://theins.ru/news/250201\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reported</a> moral and psychological abuse of Ukrainian prisoners of war. For example, Ukrainian women were forced to strip naked, squat, and so on. To verify this, international organizations need access to prisoners of war. Unfortunately, we now know little about what happens to them.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We have seen <a href=\"https://edition.cnn.com/videos/world/2022/05/02/ukrainian-war-prisoner-death-dnt-rivers-newday-intl-ldn-vpx.cnn\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reports</a> about the alleged murder of Ukrainian prisoner of war Dan Zvonik. On April 20, the DNR people's militia published a <a href=\"https://t.me/opersvodki/3608\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">video</a> showing five Ukrainian prisoners of war, including Zvonik. A week later, his mother received photographs of her son's dead body. We have no reason to doubt that it is the same person on the video and in the photos, but we have no exact information on what caused his death. After this case surfaced, pro-Kremlin commentators asserted that Zvonik was wounded in combat and died as a result. The murder version is plausible, but we cannot verify this information.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We are not aware of any other cases of murders of Ukrainian POWs. However, there are wiretaps <a href=\"https://t.me/uniannet/56629\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">published</a> by the SBU in which the Russian servicemen discuss the murder of a prisoner of war: they did not know where to keep him, so they just killed him. We have no serious reasons to question the authenticity of this record. We understand that the selection of wiretaps is biased, there may be some creative editing and phrases taken out of context. But most of the facts contained in the wiretaps are confirmed by information from other sources.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Forced Mobilization","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In the context of war crimes, very little is said about <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/features-61480788\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">forced mobilization</a> (<em>sending to a combat zone against the will.</em> — <strong>Ed.</strong>) the territory of the Donetsk and Luhansk People's Republics It should be understood that in terms of international law, these republics are territories occupied by the Russian Federation since 2014. Under international law, an occupying power or its subordinate administrations have no right to mobilize the local population. The exception is calls for work necessary for the locals themselves, such as rebuilding infrastructure. Military mobilization in the occupied territories is a blatant violation of international law. And it is in plain sight.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Now there are <a href=\"https://www.ostro.org/general/society/news/636295/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">statements</a> that the mobilized will finally be properly trained and prepared for the oath. And relatively recently, people were taken indiscriminately, given automatic rifles, and thrown into the offensive on Ukrainian positions for the purpose of identifying firing points of the Ukrainian army. The locals themselves <a href=\"https://kanaldom.tv/prinuditelnaya-evakuacziya-i-mobilizacziya-v-ordlo-bylo-podgotovkoj-k-vtorzheniyu-rf-v-ukrainu-lisyanskij/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">call</a> it genocide of the male population of Donbas. This is the closest thing to the very \"genocide\" that Putin spoke of in his <a href=\"https://paperpaper.ru/putin-obyavil-o-nachale-voennoj-operac/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">address</a> to the Russians on February 24.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"What the Ukrainian side is accused of","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"We know of two videos of Russian prisoners of war being shot. One<a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/news-61031035\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> incident</a> occurred in the Kyiv region, south of Bucha. The geolocation of this video was <a href=\"https://www.nytimes.com/live/2022/04/06/world/ukraine-russia-war-news#russia-pows-ukraine-executed\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">confirmed</a> by journalists of Bild and The New York Times. We consider this video credible, just like the <a href=\"https://meduza.io/news/2022/03/27/opublikovano-video-gde-predpolozhitelno-ukrainskie-soldaty-strelyayut-po-nogam-plennym-rossiyanam-bastrykin-velel-nachat-proverku\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">video</a> of shooting prisoners in the legs in the Kharkiv region.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In addition, at least two cases of Ukrainians using cluster munitions on residential areas have been confirmed. They <a href=\"https://www.nytimes.com/2022/04/18/world/europe/ukraine-forces-cluster-munitions.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">struck</a> with multiple rocket launchers with cluster munitions at the Russian command post, which was located in a residential area of a village in the Kharkiv region. It is also known about the <a href=\"https://t.me/milinfolive/83567\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">shelling</a> of the village of Solokhi in the Belgorod region with cluster munitions. We don't know if any legitimate military target was located there, but even so, the indiscriminate use of such weapons could be considered a war crime.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"One civilian, a Russian, died in Solokhi. But from the Russian side, there are hundreds of times more such violations as indiscriminate shelling of territories. The scale of potential war crimes now being committed by Russian servicemen is staggering and does not compare to 2014-2015. At that time we did not observe mass murders, massive strikes on civilians, and looting at that scale. The number of attacks on civilians is ten times greater now than it was then. And while a Ukrainian court punished individual Ukrainian security forces for violations in 2014-2015, Russia has no history of punishing its military for crimes in Ukraine.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":577,"header":"The First Grain War","_path":"/en/opinions/2022/05/25/the-first-grain-war/","lead":"Is it true that Russia threatens the whole world with famine?","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-1920x960px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-1920x960px_2x.png","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-1272x636px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-1272x636px_2x.png","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-912x456px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-912x456px_2x.png","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-600x400px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-600x400px_2x.png","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-360x360px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03ce94bd5a374479b5deab3de7cd0d8f-360x360px_2x.png","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"ФОТО: VALENTYN OGIRENKO / REUTERS / SCANPIX / LETA","created_at_date":"2022-05-25","created_at_date_time":null,"updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":58,"first_name":"Рина","last_name":"Николаева","first_name_en":"Rina","last_name_en":"Nikolaeva","is_public":true,"_path":"rina-nikolaeva","avatar":[],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres said Russia's invasion of Ukraine and blockade of Black Sea ports threaten the world with food shortages that could last for years. One of the world's leading business publications, The Economist, published an issue with a frightening cover — it depicts ears of wheat with skulls instead of grains, and the headline reads: \"The coming food catastrophe. War is tipping a fragile world towards mass hunger.\"\nHow justified are these fears? An expert on the food market Andrei Dmitrievsky answers this question (the expert speaks under a pseudonym, because \"Important Stories\" is designated an \"undesirable organization\" in Russia).\nThere was famine before, but because of the war, the number of starving people will increase\nHunger was there before the war and it didn't go anywhere. Over the past five years, the number of starving people in the world has been growing. The main reason is the increase in food prices. In total, the UN estimates that in 2021 193 million people were starving around the world. According to the estimates of the UN agencies, FAO and WFP, due to the war in Ukraine, the increase in the number of starving people this year will be 20 to 50 million people. \nWe believed that prices had peaked and would not rise anymore, there were good prospects for the new world harvest. But on February 24 the war began, and we saw a new jump in prices. World grain prices have already risen by more than 50% since the beginning of the year. And this, of course, is the most important story right now — that there is a war going on, that Ukraine cannot ship grain from its blocked ports. The main Ukrainian ports and oil terminals are Odesa and Mykolaiv, the southwest of the country. Ukraine is one of the main suppliers of wheat and corn and the largest supplier of vegetable oil to the world market. \nSupplies from Ukraine are ongoing, but almost entirely by land — this is a very modest volume. At best, they can now export a million to a million and a half tons of grain per month, while in peacetime they could export six to seven million. Last year, Ukraine had a record harvest, stocks are available, but they cannot be exported because of the war. \nWar is a very important, but not the only reason for the rise in food prices. Weather conditions have deteriorated noticeably. South America was unlucky: the drought affected first Argentina's and then Brazil's crops. The situation with winter wheat in the United States is unprecedentedly serious. It has never been in such a bad state in the entire history of observations. Plus, the prospects for a new harvest in Europe, primarily in France, the number one wheat producer and exporter in the European Union, have deteriorated last month. There is also not enough moisture, and the prognosis is very bad at the moment. \nThe West accuses Russia of a \"grain war\", but it has not yet begun \nEuropean politicians are now talking a lot about the fact that the Kremlin has unleashed a \"grain war\": firstly, it has blocked Ukrainian ports, and secondly, it can limit the export of Russian wheat to the world market. But the fact is that the Kremlin has not yet unleashed this war. \nUkrainian ports are blocked, but I don't think it was a goal in itself. There is a war going on, these are its consequences. Right now, it's hard to expect the ports to be unlocked. The war becomes protracted, it is a war of survival. For Ukraine, agriculture is a very important component of the economy, about 10% of GDP.\nTo truly start a global food world war, the Kremlin will need to limit Russian exports. This, in my opinion, is a completely nuclear scenario. Russia is the largest supplier of wheat to the world market. The world volume of wheat trade is 200 million tons, of which Russia accounts for 40 million. If that one-fifth drops out of the world balance, the price increase will not be half, but multi-fold worldwide. And the hunger that there is now will seem just a light warm-up. \nIf Russia restricts grain exports, it won't hit Western countries directly because they don't buy much Russian grain. Basically, the blow will be on poor countries. And the poorer the country, the stronger the consequences of rising prices will be for it. In the US, on average, households spend 10% of their income on food, in Europe — 10–15 %. In countries where food costs account for 60–70% of income, rising food prices are a matter of physical survival.\nNow the regions where they are consistently undernourished are primarily sub-Saharan Africa: The Central African Republic, Congo, Ethiopia, and Sudan. In Asia — Yemen, Afghanistan. The situation will be very difficult if Russia really unleashes a \"grain war\". I don't know how many millions of refugees will try to break into more well-fed countries from the Middle East, from Africa. This is something unprecedented, there has never been anything like it in the world.\nHigh prices benefit the Russian budget, but not Russian farmers \nIn recent years, Russia has been actively introducing various restrictions on exports. There are two types of them: a quota (it is impossible to export more than the established amount) and very strict export duty. All these restrictions remain in effect. And the Russian budget is the beneficiary of today's high grain prices, because the higher the price of grain on the world market, the more duties agricultural producers pay to the budget. \nFees, according to officials, were introduced to combat food inflation — rising food prices. But these measures were not effective. The fact is that the growth of wholesale prices for grains and oilseeds has little effect on food inflation. The main factors that determine the dynamics of retail prices — those that the consumer sees on the shelf in the store — are completely different. Those factors include the general inflation in the country, logistics, rent, wages, and the ruble exchange rate. All of these factors are far more important overall to food inflation than the cost of wheat. \nRussia, unfortunately, went down what we call the \"Argentine way\" a few years ago. Of the notable food exporters in the world, Argentina is the only one with permanent severe restrictions from the government. They do it for fiscal reasons: the duties are used to replenish the budget. And it is also done under the slogan that the domestic consumer must be protected (from rising prices). Moreover, in Russia, export restrictions have been in effect for several years, and in Argentina — for several decades. The result of these restrictions is as follows: food inflation in Argentina is about 50% per year.\nThe restriction of exports is a huge blow to Russian agriculture, to Russian farmers. Now farmers lose about 30% of revenue because of these restrictions. Not profits, but revenues! A huge percentage, no one in the world has this. \nThe growth of Russian agriculture was based on cooperation with the rest of the world: Russia exported products and bought equipment and technology. All these successes that Russia has become the number one wheat exporter in the world are not due to state support, but because there was normal access to the world market. Now there is no such access. That is, they will export grain, but at the same time, they will earn significantly less.\nAt the same time, the cost of food is growing all over the world. But American and European farmers can offset the costs by selling their grain or soybeans at a high price. Russian farmers are faced with the fact that they have an increase in ruble prime cost year-on-year — 20-30% and the prices at which they can sell their products are artificially lowered. And in Russia, grain prices are going down. That is, the cost of grain has increased, and the price at which it can be sold on the market has decreased. This means that in a few years there will be zero growth in Russian crop production, and even more likely, there will be a fall. \nRussian farmers need the whole world — as a buyer and as a supplier\nIn Russia, we are expecting a record harvest of grain and wheat. But this is due solely to the wonderful weather. The area under crops has already begun to shrink. In the case of winter crops' sowing — what was sown in Russia last autumn —, there was a decent reduction, by 5%, by about a million hectares. And it will continue in the coming years. It's just that the weather is so good that this year it has completely compensated for this factor. This is the number one consequence of government policy. \nConsequence number two is that we are waiting for the archaization of production, a decrease in intensity. Farmers will try to economize, apply less fertilizer, avoid updating equipment, and use fewer plant protection products, which will lead to a decrease in yields and an increase in the risks of crop failure in case of adverse weather. If you start scaling back here and here, then — bang! You have bad weather, and there can be a serious crop failure out of the blue.\nIt is important how long the war will last and how the main suppliers of material and technical resources will behave. These are mostly global international companies, and they have partially suspended operations in Russia. And 2022 is going to be a normal year for us because all the plant protection products, seeds, and so on are brought in well in advance. But in 2023 there will be problems. It is unclear whether foreign companies will supply material and technical resources. \nAnd Russia's successes are based primarily on cooperation with the world. And cooperation is not only about the fact that we can sell grain and oilseeds. It is about the fact is that we can safely import what Russian agriculture needs. These are seeds, plant protection products, fertilizers, equipment, animal feed additives, and the parent flock, which is needed to maintain reproduction. Of course, being North Korea, we can't dream of any agrarian success, because to succeed, we need the rest of the world, both as a buyer and as a supplier. \nWhat's Next for Food Prices\nA good scenario is that in the coming months there will be a truce, and deliveries from Odesa and Mykolaiv will resume. Then we will see prices fall. If there is stabilization, Ukraine will be able to harvest the crop and will be able to sow. \nA bad scenario — the war continues to drag on until at least 2023, damage is caused to the terminals in Odesa and Mykolaiv. It is unclear how to harvest the Ukrainian crop. It is unclear who will gather it, and how it will be sold. Then we will see a decent increase in prices from the current record levels. \nAnd the third scenario, the most dramatic, is that hostilities continue, Ukraine does not export anything, plus Russia imposes restrictions on exports. Not necessarily tough, just to scare the market. That's when it's going to be a real grain war.","blocks":[{"data":"UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres said Russia's invasion of Ukraine and blockade of Black Sea ports <a href=\"https://news.un.org/ru/story/2022/05/1424192\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">threaten</a> the world with food shortages that could last for years. One of the world's leading business publications, The Economist, published an <a href=\"https://www.economist.com/leaders/2022/05/19/the-coming-food-catastrophe\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">issue</a> with a frightening cover — it depicts ears of wheat with skulls instead of grains, and the headline reads: \"The coming food catastrophe. War is tipping a fragile world towards mass hunger.\"","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"How justified are these fears? An expert on the food market Andrei Dmitrievsky answers this question (the expert speaks under a pseudonym, because \"Important Stories\" is <a href=\"https://istories.media/opinions/2022/03/09/vazhnie-istorii-priznali-nezhelatelnoi-organizatsiei-chto-dalshe/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">designated</a> an \"undesirable organization\" in Russia).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There was famine before, but because of the war, the number of starving people will increase","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Hunger was there before the war and it didn't go anywhere. Over the past five years, the number of starving people in the world has been growing. The main reason is the <a href=\"https://www.fao.org/worldfoodsituation/foodpricesindex/ru/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">increase in food prices</a>. In total, the UN estimates that in 2021 193 million people were <a href=\"https://www.wfp.org/publications/global-report-food-crises-2022\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">starving</a> around the world. According to the estimates of the UN agencies, FAO and WFP, due to the war in Ukraine, the increase in the number of starving people this year will be <a href=\"https://www.fao.org/newsroom/detail/un-security-council-meeting-agriculture-is-key-to-lasting-peace-and-security-fao-says/ru\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">20</a> to <a href=\"https://reliefweb.int/report/world/projected-increase-acute-food-insecurity-due-war-ukraine\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">50 million</a> people.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4801,"data":{"block":"<p>According to the international food insecurity classification <a href=\"https://fews.net/sectors-topics/approach/integrated-phase-classification\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Integrated Phase Classification (IPC)</a>, which is used by the UN, there are five phases of food insecurity.</p><p>1. Households are able to meet essential food and non-food needs.</p><p>2. Households can afford basic food, but hardly can afford some essential non-food expenditures.</p><p>3. Households have food consumption gaps that are reflected by high or above-usual acute malnutrition.</p><p>4. Have large food consumption gaps which are reflected in very high acute malnutrition and excess mortality. </p><p>5. Extreme lack of food when starvation, death, destitution, and extremely critical acute malnutrition levels are evident.</p><p>People living in conditions of the third, fourth and fifth phases of food insecurity are considered starving.</p>","header":"Who the UN considers to be starving","content":[{"insert":"According to the international food insecurity classification "},{"insert":"Integrated Phase Classification (IPC)","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://fews.net/sectors-topics/approach/integrated-phase-classification","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":", which is used by the UN, there are five phases of food insecurity.\n1. Households are able to meet essential food and non-food needs.\n2. Households can afford basic food, but hardly can afford some essential non-food expenditures.\n3. Households have food consumption gaps that are reflected by high or above-usual acute malnutrition.\n4. Have large food consumption gaps which are reflected in very high acute malnutrition and excess mortality. \n5. Extreme lack of food when starvation, death, destitution, and extremely critical acute malnutrition levels are evident.\nPeople living in conditions of the third, fourth and fifth phases of food insecurity are considered starving.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":{"id":4803,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/8bd89f72231847e7a1481195cd10dc7e/","ratio_mobile":"3:5","ratio_desktop":"4:3","fallback_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/70fde145fe1046cf81081dc8804748c5-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/70fde145fe1046cf81081dc8804748c5-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":870,"real_height_2x":1740},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/70fde145fe1046cf81081dc8804748c5-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/70fde145fe1046cf81081dc8804748c5-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":870,"real_height_2x":1740},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/70fde145fe1046cf81081dc8804748c5-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/70fde145fe1046cf81081dc8804748c5-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":300,"real_height_2x":602},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/70fde145fe1046cf81081dc8804748c5-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/70fde145fe1046cf81081dc8804748c5-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":300,"real_height_2x":602}]},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"We believed that prices had peaked and would not rise anymore, there were good prospects for the new world harvest. But on February 24 the war began, and we saw a new jump in prices. World grain prices have already risen by more than 50% since the beginning of the year. And this, of course, is the most important story right now — that there is a war going on, that Ukraine cannot ship grain from its blocked ports. The main Ukrainian ports and oil terminals are Odesa and Mykolaiv, the southwest of the country. Ukraine is one of the main suppliers of wheat and corn and the largest supplier of vegetable oil to the world market.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Supplies from Ukraine are ongoing, but almost entirely by land — this is a very modest volume. At best, they can now export a million to a million and a half tons of grain per month, while in peacetime they could export six to seven million. Last year, Ukraine had a record harvest, stocks are available, but they cannot be exported because of the war.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4804,"data":{"text":"live in countries that have undergone or are undergoing a military conflict","header":"of starving people","number":"80 %"},"category":"text-with-number-embed"},"type":"text-with-number-embed"},{"data":"War is a very important, but not the only reason for the rise in food prices. Weather conditions have deteriorated noticeably. South America was unlucky: the drought affected first Argentina's and then Brazil's crops. The situation with winter wheat in the United States is unprecedentedly serious. It has never been in such a bad state in the entire history of observations. Plus, the prospects for a new harvest in Europe, primarily in France, the number one wheat producer and exporter in the European Union, have deteriorated last month. There is also not enough moisture, and the prognosis is very bad at the moment.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The West accuses Russia of a \"grain war\", but it has not yet begun&nbsp;","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"European politicians are now talking a lot about the fact that the Kremlin has unleashed a \"grain war\": firstly, it has blocked Ukrainian ports, and secondly, it can limit the export of Russian wheat to the world market. But the fact is that the Kremlin has not yet unleashed this war.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Ukrainian ports are blocked, but I don't think it was a goal in itself. There is a war going on, these are its consequences. Right now, it's hard to expect the ports to be unlocked. The war becomes protracted, it is a war of survival. For Ukraine, agriculture is a very important component of the economy, about 10% of GDP.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4805,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Maxar Technologies / Reuters / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"The Russian military has not only blocked grain stocks at Ukrainian ports but also, according to media reports, is stealing from the supplies. CNN published a satellite image of a Russian vessel, which, according to the authors of the investigation, was transporting grain stolen in Ukraine from Crimea to Syria. CNN journalists identified the vessel as the bulk carrier ship, the Matros Pozynich. According to CNN, it is one of three Russian vessels involved in the trade of grain that was stolen from Ukraine.","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dcab508fc42c49d7a899cd6196582af0-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dcab508fc42c49d7a899cd6196582af0-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":674,"real_height_2x":1348},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dcab508fc42c49d7a899cd6196582af0-1200xautopx_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dcab508fc42c49d7a899cd6196582af0-1200xautopx_2x.jpeg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":674,"real_height_2x":1348},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dcab508fc42c49d7a899cd6196582af0-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dcab508fc42c49d7a899cd6196582af0-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":466},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dcab508fc42c49d7a899cd6196582af0-415xautopx_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dcab508fc42c49d7a899cd6196582af0-415xautopx_2x.jpeg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":466}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"To truly start a global food world war, the Kremlin will need to limit Russian exports. This, in my opinion, is a completely nuclear scenario. Russia is the largest supplier of wheat to the world market. The world volume of wheat trade is 200 million tons, of which Russia accounts for 40 million. If that one-fifth drops out of the world balance, the price increase will not be half, but multi-fold worldwide. And the hunger that there is now will seem just a light warm-up.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4806,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/df3839105bcd4511b23f3732270c719f/","ratio_mobile":"3:5","ratio_desktop":"4:3","fallback_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/59d142032e1f4364b0c0d20c09f0f537-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/59d142032e1f4364b0c0d20c09f0f537-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":727,"real_height_2x":1454},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/59d142032e1f4364b0c0d20c09f0f537-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/59d142032e1f4364b0c0d20c09f0f537-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":727,"real_height_2x":1454},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/59d142032e1f4364b0c0d20c09f0f537-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/59d142032e1f4364b0c0d20c09f0f537-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":252,"real_height_2x":503},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/59d142032e1f4364b0c0d20c09f0f537-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/59d142032e1f4364b0c0d20c09f0f537-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":252,"real_height_2x":503}]},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"If Russia restricts grain exports, it won't hit Western countries directly because they don't buy much Russian grain. Basically, the blow will be on poor countries. And the poorer the country, the stronger the consequences of rising prices will be for it. In the US, on average, households spend 10% of their income on food, in Europe — 10–15 %. In countries where food costs account for 60–70% of income, rising food prices are a matter of physical survival.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4807,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/91986488069a42ddabff20e1d4f01ac3/","ratio_mobile":"1:2","ratio_desktop":"8:7","fallback_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a762f9a5730451fb320a04603041aed-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a762f9a5730451fb320a04603041aed-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":955,"real_height_2x":1910},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a762f9a5730451fb320a04603041aed-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a762f9a5730451fb320a04603041aed-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":955,"real_height_2x":1910},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a762f9a5730451fb320a04603041aed-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a762f9a5730451fb320a04603041aed-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":330,"real_height_2x":660},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a762f9a5730451fb320a04603041aed-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a762f9a5730451fb320a04603041aed-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":330,"real_height_2x":660}]},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"Now the regions where they are consistently undernourished are primarily sub-Saharan Africa: The Central African Republic, Congo, Ethiopia, and Sudan. In Asia — Yemen, Afghanistan. The situation will be very difficult if Russia really unleashes a \"grain war\". I don't know how many millions of refugees will try to break into more well-fed countries from the Middle East, from Africa. This is something unprecedented, there has never been anything like it in the world.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4808,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/541e3cb514dc4a4294c5ae117ae88732/","ratio_mobile":"1:1","ratio_desktop":"80:35","fallback_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0dbfde23023349989a125e0fe8d7799e-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0dbfde23023349989a125e0fe8d7799e-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":500,"real_height_2x":999},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0dbfde23023349989a125e0fe8d7799e-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0dbfde23023349989a125e0fe8d7799e-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":500,"real_height_2x":999},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0dbfde23023349989a125e0fe8d7799e-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0dbfde23023349989a125e0fe8d7799e-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":172,"real_height_2x":346},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0dbfde23023349989a125e0fe8d7799e-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0dbfde23023349989a125e0fe8d7799e-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":172,"real_height_2x":346}]},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"High prices benefit the Russian budget, but not Russian farmers&nbsp;","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In recent years, Russia has been actively introducing various restrictions on exports. There are two types of them: a quota (it is impossible to export more than the established amount) and very strict export duty. All these restrictions remain in effect. And the Russian budget is the beneficiary of today's high grain prices, because the higher the price of grain on the world market, the more duties agricultural producers pay to the budget.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4811,"data":{"text":"And get new reports and videos about real Russia directly to your inbox","title":"Please subscribe to the Istories newsletter"},"category":"mailing-embed"},"type":"mailing-embed"},{"data":"Fees, according to officials, were introduced to combat food inflation — rising food prices. But these measures were not effective. The fact is that the growth of wholesale prices for grains and oilseeds has little effect on food inflation. The main factors that determine the dynamics of retail prices — those that the consumer sees on the shelf in the store — are completely different. Those factors include the general inflation in the country, logistics, rent, wages, and the ruble exchange rate. All of these factors are far more important overall to food inflation than the cost of wheat.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russia, unfortunately, went down what we call the \"Argentine way\" a few years ago. Of the notable food exporters in the world, Argentina is the only one with permanent severe restrictions from the government. They do it for fiscal reasons: the duties are used to replenish the budget. And it is also done under the slogan that the domestic consumer must be protected (from rising prices). Moreover, in Russia, export restrictions have been in effect for several years, and in Argentina — for several decades. The result of these restrictions is as follows: food inflation in Argentina is about 50% per year.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4809,"data":{"text":"— that much Russian grain exporters pay pay to the budget in the form of duties; such duties have not been introduced anywhere else in the world","header":" of the revenues","number":"30%"},"category":"text-with-number-embed"},"type":"text-with-number-embed"},{"data":"The restriction of exports is a huge blow to Russian agriculture, to Russian farmers. Now farmers lose about 30% of revenue because of these restrictions. Not profits, but revenues! A huge percentage, no one in the world has this.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The growth of Russian agriculture was based on cooperation with the rest of the world: Russia exported products and bought equipment and technology. All these successes that Russia has become the number one wheat exporter in the world are not due to state support, but because there was normal access to the world market. Now there is no such access. That is, they will export grain, but at the same time, they will earn significantly less.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At the same time, the cost of food is growing all over the world. But American and European farmers can offset the costs by selling their grain or soybeans at a high price. Russian farmers are faced with the fact that they have an increase in ruble prime cost year-on-year — 20-30% and the prices at which they can sell their products are artificially lowered. And in Russia, grain prices are going down. That is, the cost of grain has increased, and the price at which it can be sold on the market has decreased. This means that in a few years there will be zero growth in Russian crop production, and even more likely, there will be a fall.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russian farmers need the whole world — as a buyer and as a supplier","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In Russia, we are expecting a record harvest of grain and wheat. But this is due solely to the wonderful weather. The area under crops has already begun to shrink. In the case of winter crops' sowing — what was sown in Russia last autumn —, there was a decent reduction, by 5%, by about a million hectares. And it will continue in the coming years. It's just that the weather is so good that this year it has completely compensated for this factor. This is the number one consequence of government policy.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4802,"data":{"text":"Food market expert","author":"Andrei Dmitrievsky","header":"Russia's successes are based on cooperation with the world. And cooperation is not only about the fact that we can sell grain and oilseeds. It is about the fact is that we can safely import what Russian agriculture needs. Being North Korea, we can't dream of any agrarian success, because to succeed, we need the rest of the world, both as a buyer and as a supplier. "},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"Consequence number two is that we are waiting for the archaization of production, a decrease in intensity. Farmers will try to economize, apply less fertilizer, avoid updating equipment, and use fewer plant protection products, which will lead to a decrease in yields and an increase in the risks of crop failure in case of adverse weather. If you start scaling back here and here, then — bang! You have bad weather, and there can be a serious crop failure out of the blue.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It is important how long the war will last and how the main suppliers of material and technical resources will behave. These are mostly global international companies, and they have partially suspended operations in Russia. And 2022 is going to be a normal year for us because all the plant protection products, seeds, and so on are brought in well in advance. But in 2023 there will be problems. It is unclear whether foreign companies will supply material and technical resources.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"And Russia's successes are based primarily on cooperation with the world. And cooperation is not only about the fact that we can sell grain and oilseeds. It is about the fact is that we can safely import what Russian agriculture needs. These are seeds, plant protection products, fertilizers, equipment, animal feed additives, and the parent flock, which is needed to maintain reproduction. Of course, being North Korea, we can't dream of any agrarian success, because to succeed, we need the rest of the world, both as a buyer and as a supplier.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4810,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/7bcc9023f83440ff900de050c088b60a/","ratio_mobile":"1:2","ratio_desktop":"8:7","fallback_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/034fe7fec349414d9ea1c728876a3cc7-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/034fe7fec349414d9ea1c728876a3cc7-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":922,"real_height_2x":1846},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/034fe7fec349414d9ea1c728876a3cc7-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/034fe7fec349414d9ea1c728876a3cc7-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":922,"real_height_2x":1846},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/034fe7fec349414d9ea1c728876a3cc7-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/034fe7fec349414d9ea1c728876a3cc7-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":319,"real_height_2x":638},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/034fe7fec349414d9ea1c728876a3cc7-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/034fe7fec349414d9ea1c728876a3cc7-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":319,"real_height_2x":638}]},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"What's Next for Food Prices","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"A good scenario is that in the coming months there will be a truce, and deliveries from Odesa and Mykolaiv will resume. Then we will see prices fall. If there is stabilization, Ukraine will be able to harvest the crop and will be able to sow.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A bad scenario — the war continues to drag on until at least 2023, damage is caused to the terminals in Odesa and Mykolaiv. It is unclear how to harvest the Ukrainian crop. It is unclear who will gather it, and how it will be sold. Then we will see a decent increase in prices from the current record levels.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"And the third scenario, the most dramatic, is that hostilities continue, Ukraine does not export anything, plus Russia imposes restrictions on exports. Not necessarily tough, just to scare the market. That's when it's going to be a real grain war.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":569,"header":"The War Does Not Justify Its Goals","_path":"/en/opinions/2022/05/23/the-war-does-not-justify-its-goals/","lead":"What Vladimir Putin wanted when he started the war against Ukraine, and what actually happened","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-1920x960px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-1920x960px_2x.png","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-1272x636px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-1272x636px_2x.png","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-912x456px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-912x456px_2x.png","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-600x400px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-600x400px_2x.png","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-360x360px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/deebb271ec3d48a39ec20cbca14acd73-360x360px_2x.png","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Photo: Reuters / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2022-05-23","created_at_date_time":null,"updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":true,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"opinions","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":18,"first_name":"Роман","last_name":"Катин","first_name_en":"Roman","last_name_en":"Katin","is_public":true,"_path":"r","avatar":[],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":null},{"id":8,"first_name":"Алеся","last_name":"Мароховская","first_name_en":"Alesya","last_name_en":"Marokhovskaya","is_public":true,"_path":"alesya-marokhovskaya","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Главная редакторка «Важных историй»","lead_en":"Editor-in-chief","position":"Редакторка","position_en":"Editor","ordering":null}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"May 24 marks three months since Vladimir Putin unleashed a war against Ukraine. This war was a crime from the very beginning. But now it is clear that it also turned out to be meaningless. Putin called a military invasion of Ukraine the only possible way to ensure the security of Russia. Judging by the statements of the president and other Russian officials, the “special military operation” was supposed to protect the inhabitants of the Donetsk People's Republic (DNR) and Luhansk People's Republic (LNR), save our people, stop the advance of the NATO military bloc to the Russian borders and put an end to the “reckless course towards complete US domination.” The authorities also hoped to rally Russian society around the head of state. What came of it?\n\nIStories found that during the war, the death rate of young males in the Russian regions increased significantly. And in just three months of the \"special military operation\" as many civilians died as in the previous 8 years of confrontation between the DNR and LNR with Ukraine. Meanwhile, the problems that Vladimir Putin wanted to solve with military force have only gotten worse. NATO has not stopped expanding – new members are rushing to join the alliance. Russia's influence in the world and its ability to compete with the US and other countries have decreased. And Russian society has split: bewilderment about the “special operation” is expressed even by employees of the Russian special services who are always loyal to the president.\n\nOur people are not saved\n\nIn his February 24 address, Vladimir Putin insisted that a military invasion of Ukraine was necessary to \"defend Russia, our people.\" In fact, this war, like any other, leads to an increase in mortality: thousands of military personnel and civilians die. And the long-term consequences are that Russia in the future will face a record birth crisis in the entire latest history.  \n\nSince the beginning of the war in Ukraine, according to the UN, 3,811 civilians have been killed, including 255 children, and another 4,278 civilians have been injured. The real numbers are much higher, because the information comes with a delay, and some messages are waiting for confirmation. “Most of the civilian casualties recorded were caused by the use of explosive weapons with a wide impact area, including shelling from heavy artillery and multiple launch rocket systems, and missile and air strikes,” the UN report says.\nIt is difficult to estimate exactly how many Russian soldiers died during the war, mostly young males. The Russian side has not reported on the dead for two months. The last time the Russian General Staff reported 1,351 dead. At the same time, the UK claims there are 15,000 dead Russian soldiers. And according to the Ukrainian side on May 20, Russia lost more than 28.5 thousand troops. IStories independently verifies all public reports of the dead in order to maintain its list of losses. At the moment, it has 2,622 names.\n\nEven from these fragmentary data, it follows that the war increased the death rate of young males in Russia by 20% compared to peacetime. In the regions that sent the most military personnel to participate in the \"special operation\", the mortality rate of young men has increased significantly since February of this year. In Dagestan, North Ossetia, and Buryatia, the increase in mortality ranged from 100 to 140%.\nA few days before the start of the war, the authorities of the DNR and LNR announced a full troop mobilization. And they limited the exit of the male population from controlled territories. They do not disclose the losses among the men called up for service (the DNR Ombudsman spoke about 1201 dead employees of law enforcement agencies since the beginning of 2022). But in percentage terms, they are hardly much less than the losses of contract soldiers who were sent to fight from the Russian regions.\n\nFor 3 months of the Russian \"special operation\" to save the DNR, LNR, about the same number of civilians died as in all 8 years of military clashes between the Ukrainian army and the armed forces of these republics — more than 3 thousand people. It should be taken into account that the figure of losses for 8 years (3404 people by the end of 2021) includes more than 2 thousand civilians who died in the midst of the conflict — in 2014-2015. Later on, civilians died less often: in 2021, according to the UN, 21 civilians were killed by random shells, unexploded ordnance and mines.\n\nIf the “genocide”, as Vladimir Putin called it, continued for 8 years in the East of Ukraine, then what can be said about the “special operation” that led to the same losses among the civilian population in just three months?\n\nNATO expansion was not stopped\n\n“The NATO alliance <...> is steadily expanding, the military machine is moving and coming close to our borders. <...> The military development of the territories adjacent to our borders, if we allow it, will continue for decades to come, and perhaps forever. And it will create a constantly growing, absolutely unacceptable threat for Russia. <...> Further expansion of NATO and the military development of the territory of Ukraine that has begun is unacceptable for us,” that is how Vladimir Putin explained the causes of the war in his address to the Russians on February 24.\n\nBut the war unleashed by Russia against Ukraine did not remove NATO from Russia's borders and did not limit the expansion of the alliance. \nThree sources of IStories — former and current senior intelligence officers — believe that Russia's open military incursion into Ukraine has ensured NATO a comfortable, stable existence for decades to come. They recall that quite recently this bloc was shattered by internal contradictions: Turkey took the liberty of purchasing Russian weapons. The interests of some NATO members in the Middle East did not coincide with those of the United States. There were no indisputable arguments for accepting new members into the alliance. The meaning of NATO's existence was blurred. Former US President Donald Trump even threatened to withdraw the US from the alliance. And the increase in defense spending caused discussions and opposition from politicians.\n\nWith their \"special operation\" the Russian authorities breathed new life into NATO and fully justified the ever-increasing defense spending.\n\nNow the \"military development\" of territories near the Russian borders will only accelerate. And Russia's border with the countries of the alliance will be doubled. At the time of the beginning of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, five countries of the alliance bordered the Russian Federation — Latvia, Lithuania, Norway, Poland and Estonia (the United States borders Russia only by sea). Ukraine got the opportunity to join NATO in 2008, but this process was frozen for 14 years. The old members of NATO did not want to spend money on the new poor members and shoulder their worries. \n\nNow prosperous Finland wants to join NATO. Its border with Russia exceeds 1,200 kilometers. And also Sweden has shown the same intentions (it doesn't have a common border with Russia, only exclusive economic zones border). On May 18, in Brussels, the Secretary General of the alliance received membership applications from the ambassadors of Finland and Sweden. Both countries have reconsidered the risks to national security and in today's conditions see only one way to ensure it — to become members of NATO.\nIn May, Switzerland announced plans to lean closer to the alliance. The country has maintained military and political neutrality enshrined in the constitution since 1815. The Swiss Ministry of Defense is preparing a report on possible options for strengthening security, including through cooperation with NATO. \n\nUS dominance has not ended\n\n“Our special military operation is designed to put an end to <...> the reckless course towards complete US domination,” Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov said.\nSources of IStories from the Russian intelligence services doubt that the “special operation” undermined US dominance. By engaging in a military gamble, Russia severely limited its ability to compete with other countries.\n\nAmerican economic influence in Europe has only grown. Urgent US requests to limit the EU's reliance on Russian energy resources, such as abandoning the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline and buying American liquefied natural gas, no longer seem too radical. Germany resisted this pressure to the last and called the gas pipeline an exclusively economic project, not related to politics. But after the start of Russia's \"special military operation\" in Ukraine, Nord Stream 2, in which investments exceeded 10 billion euros, simply died. Initially, the opponents of the project were the USA, Poland, Ukraine and the Baltic countries.\n\nIn 2021, the United States became the main supplier of liquefied gas to Europe. And in 2022, according to analysts, the US may become the largest supplier of liquefied natural gas in the world. Now the US is promising the Europeans to replace gas supplies from Russia, although this is expensive and difficult to do given the large volumes of pipeline gas. But nothing is impossible. Now Russia's former main European partner, Germany, intends to almost completely eliminate the need for Russian gas in 2024.\nWhat is Russia losing? Gas and oil bring our country up to half of the budget revenues and account for more than half of all exports. Russia sells to Europe 70% of its gas and 60% of its oil and oil products. In just three months of the war, the European Union paid Russia more than 50 billion euros for oil and gas. \n\nEurope is trying to agree on an embargo on Russian oil: to stop importing it within six months. And to stop import of oil products within a year. In addition, in April the European Union imposed a ban on the purchase of Russian coal. This is very beneficial for American coal companies. Their future supplies to Europe are expected to grow significantly and they have not seen such an increase since 2018.\n\nAllies fail to save Russia\n\nForeign Minister Sergey Lavrov is confident that Russia is supported by the majority of countries. “They are, by and large, the majority. But the pressure they are under is not only unprecedented, I could never imagine such a thing,” said Lavrov expressing his surprise. The minister said that the US is trying to put pressure on China, India, Egypt, Turkey, and other countries because of their cooperation with Russia. \n\nDue to the rupture of ties with the West, Russia just hoped to turn to Asia — primarily to China and India, in order to supply raw materials there and receive goods, services, and technologies. But in order to remain among the leaders in the supply of energy resources, it is necessary to increase their production. And, for example, traditional Russian oil fields are gradually being exhausted. The development of new often hard-to-reach fields and the production of hard-to-recover oil require technologies that Western companies possess.\n\nThe war in Ukraine resulted in the largest international oil and oilfield services companies with modern oil exploration and production technologies leaving the Russian market. And Russia did not have its own. Rosnedra (Russian Federal Subsoil Resources Management Agency) had to state that it would not be possible to develop offshore fields without these technologies. And Russia's current allies are unlikely to help in this.\nChina does not impose sanctions against Russia, has increased its consumption of Russian oil, and even voted against an anti-Russian resolution on Ukraine at a special session of the UN Human Rights Council. But China does not dispute the measures already taken against Russia. In order not to fall under secondary sanctions, the Bank of China and ICBC (China's largest lending institutions) stopped issuing letters of credit to Chinese companies for the purchase of Russian raw materials. Immediately after the start of the “special military operation”, Chinese oil refineries began buying Russian oil at a significant discount. Negotiations are underway on gas, but even in this situation, the Chinese demand a 10% discount. In addition, some Chinese IT companies have stopped deliveries to Russia. Chinese shippers predictably stopped the transit of goods through Russia to Europe. China also refused to supply Russian airlines with spare parts for aircraft.\n\nAs for India, hopes for it are weak, although it has not imposed direct sanctions against Russia either. In April, the media learned that the Indian state corporation refused to purchase Russian oil after the US' calls not to increase the consumption of Russian energy resources. Even earlier, India stopped transactions for the purchase of Russian helicopters, formally not linking this to sanctions. And the Indian state bank issued a letter stating that it would strictly comply with the restrictions set by European and American sanctions against Russia and its structures.\n\nSociety is not united\n\n“Competition in who is more patriotic is hardly necessary, especially at such a moment when we all need to be united <...> around our country, around our president,” said Putin’s press secretary Dmitry Peskov reflecting on patriotism.\n\nSince the beginning of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, numerous polls (Russian Public Opinion Research Center (VTsIOM), Public Opinion Foundation (FOM), Russian field, the research project \"Do Russians Want War?\", Extremescan) show that the majority of Russians support the \"special military operation\". However, all these surveys are criticized by sociologists, since it is difficult to study public opinion in wartime, especially in countries with autocratic regimes. When answering questions, people may hide their position and try to give the “correct” answer in order to avoid reprisals. According to sociologist Maxim Alyukov, people may perceive polls as a tool of the government and that may result in their fear to answer the questions.\n\nDespite massive state propaganda and the destruction of any independent media, the Russian authorities feel threatened by those who disagree with the war. A week after the invasion of Ukraine, a law was passed punishing the dissemination of \"inaccurate information\" about the actions of the Russian military (anything is considered such information, from value judgments to individual words). This law introduces a punishment of up to 15 years in prison. The State Duma also passed a law according to which one can be imprisoned for up to three years for calls for sanctions against Russia. \nRussian media are forbidden to call what is happening in Ukraine a war and an invasion. Instead, they are required to use the wording “special military operation”. Media outlets that refused to comply with these demands were blocked. In the first week of the war alone, the authorities liquidated or blocked almost all independent media. On March 5, the Ministry of Justice added the Latvian foundation IStories Fonds, the founder of IStories, to the list of “undesirable organizations”. \n\nPublic-sector employees, people who are directly dependent on state organizations and officials, take part in the authorities' campaigns in support of military operations. The authorities organize publicly funded concerts “For the Motherland!” (\"Zа Родину!\") and other public events. At the same time, anti-war protests in Russia are led by people of all professions and ages, despite the risks of being fined, arrested or even subjected to criminal charges. According to OVD-Info (independent Russian human rights media project aimed at combating political persecution), on April 14, it was known about 15,428 arrests at anti-war actions and 1,938 administrative cases for \"discreditation of the army.\" \nThere is no single positive assessment of the \"special operation\" even in the environment most loyal to the president — in the Russian special services. Sources of IStories in this sphere believe that Vladimir Putin lost his nerve, and the military actions against Ukraine were the result of the head of state being misinformed. \n\nThe current consequences of the “special operation” contradict the national interests of Russia to such an extent that even a fresh conspiracy theory has appeared among the employees of the Russian special services. It goes like this: having unleashed a war with Ukraine, the president succumbed to a provocation from the United States and, instead of resorting to a calm and consistent increase in political and economic influence, he snapped and turned back to zero all his achievements of the past twenty years. In the presidential environment and even in the Federal Security Service (FSB), the culprits are traditionally called \"Western agents of influence\".\n\nA former Russian intelligence officer who does not support this theory, assessing the \"special operation\", quotes one of the French figures of the Napoleonic era: \"This is worse than a crime, this is a mistake.\"","blocks":[{"data":"May 24 marks three months since Vladimir Putin unleashed a war against Ukraine. This war was a crime from the very beginning. But now it is clear that it also turned out to be meaningless. Putin called a military invasion of Ukraine the only possible way to ensure the security of Russia. Judging by the statements of the president and other Russian officials, the “special military operation” was supposed to protect the inhabitants of the Donetsk People's Republic (DNR) and Luhansk People's Republic (LNR), save our people, stop the advance of the NATO military bloc to the Russian borders and put an end to the “reckless course towards complete US domination.” The authorities also hoped to rally Russian society around the head of state. What came of it?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories found that during the war, the death rate of young males in the Russian regions increased significantly. And in just three months of the \"special military operation\" as many civilians died as in the previous 8 years of confrontation between the DNR and LNR with Ukraine. Meanwhile, the problems that Vladimir Putin wanted to solve with military force have only gotten worse. NATO has not stopped expanding – new members are rushing to join the alliance. Russia's influence in the world and its ability to compete with the US and other countries have decreased. And Russian society has split: bewilderment about the “special operation” is expressed even by employees of the Russian special services who are always loyal to the president.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Our people are not saved","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In his February 24 address, Vladimir Putin insisted that a military invasion of Ukraine was necessary to \"defend Russia, our people.\" In fact, this war, like any other, leads to an increase in mortality: thousands of military personnel and civilians die. And the long-term consequences are that Russia in the future <a href=\"https://istories.media/investigations/2022/05/04/yunie-bednie-mertvie/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">will face</a> a record birth crisis in the entire latest history.&nbsp;&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Since the beginning of the war in Ukraine, <a href=\"https://istories.media/reportages/2022/05/16/voina-v-tsifrakh/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">according to the UN</a>, 3,811 civilians have been <a href=\"https://www.ohchr.org/en/news/2022/05/ukraine-civilian-casualty-update-20-may-2022\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">killed</a>, including 255 children, and another 4,278 civilians have been injured. The real numbers are much higher, because the information comes with a delay, and some messages are waiting for confirmation. “Most of the civilian casualties recorded were caused by the use of explosive weapons with a wide impact area, including shelling from heavy artillery and multiple launch rocket systems, and missile and air strikes,” the UN report says.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4763,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Yevgeny Maloletka / AP / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Ukrainian emergency workers and volunteers carry an injured pregnant woman out of a shelled maternity hospital in Mariupol on March 9, 2022. The baby was stillborn. Half an hour after the labor the mother also died.","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5084a94f4201421ea88da10fd8ba7a0b-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5084a94f4201421ea88da10fd8ba7a0b-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5084a94f4201421ea88da10fd8ba7a0b-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5084a94f4201421ea88da10fd8ba7a0b-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5084a94f4201421ea88da10fd8ba7a0b-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5084a94f4201421ea88da10fd8ba7a0b-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5084a94f4201421ea88da10fd8ba7a0b-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5084a94f4201421ea88da10fd8ba7a0b-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"It is difficult to estimate exactly how many Russian soldiers died during the war, mostly young males. The Russian side has not reported on the dead for two months. The last time the Russian General Staff <a href=\"https://t.me/rian_ru/155675\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reported</a> 1,351 dead. At the same time, the UK <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/news-61196727\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">claims</a> there are 15,000 dead Russian soldiers. And <a href=\"https://www.facebook.com/GeneralStaff.ua/posts/320940553552363?__cft__%5b0%5d=AZVB3C0mCfmXXkDI5bcU_nwKlAisDJCOVV6cTVnfdenSUcD-aJstTJfvJr4SkQlCOQxEA7zx3InaECfPGRKwX2VSKR0r-VvBJ1kPymRcVZfcUgdcb0rwTZDnY06HfWjl0_jMuEkyON7TA7cj50yy83vW&amp;__tn__=%2CO%2CP-R\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">according to the Ukrainian side</a> on May 20, Russia lost more than 28.5 thousand troops. IStories independently verifies all public reports of the dead in order to maintain its <a href=\"https://istories.media/reportages/2022/05/16/voina-v-tsifrakh/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">list</a> of losses. At the moment, it has 2,622 names.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Even from these fragmentary data, it follows that the war increased the death rate of young males in Russia by 20% compared to peacetime. In the regions that sent the most military personnel to participate in the \"special operation\", the mortality rate of young men has increased significantly since February of this year. In Dagestan, North Ossetia, and Buryatia, the increase in mortality ranged from 100 to 140%.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4762,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/0db6646594f149fe95eb032711ff23de/visualisation-10102793/index.html","text":"The number of deaths in peacetime is the average number of deaths of men aged 18 to 35 years for the period 2018-2020, divided by 365 and multiplied by the number of days of war. The number of deaths of young men aged 18-35 in the war is the number of confirmed deaths in the region, multiplied by 0.8, since 80% of the soldiers killed in action were under 35.","ratio_mobile":"300:600","ratio_desktop":"815:800"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"A few days before the start of the war, the authorities of the DNR and LNR <a href=\"https://www.1tv.ru/news/2022-02-19/421381-v_dnr_i_lnr_ob_yavili_vseobschuyu_mobilizatsiyu_iz_za_usileniya_obstrelov_so_storony_ukrainskih_silovikov\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">announced</a> a full troop mobilization. And they <a href=\"https://www.fontanka.ru/2022/02/18/70454657/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">limited the exit</a> of the male population from controlled territories. They do not disclose the losses among the men called up for service (the DNR Ombudsman <a href=\"https://anna-news.info/vlasti-dnr-otchitalis-o-poteryah-pri-provedenii-spetsialnoj-voennoj-operatsii/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">spoke</a> about 1201 dead employees of law enforcement agencies since the beginning of 2022). But in percentage terms, they are hardly much less than the losses of contract soldiers who were sent to fight from the Russian regions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For 3 months of the Russian \"special operation\" to save the DNR, LNR, about the same number of civilians died as in all 8 years of military clashes between the Ukrainian army and the armed forces of these republics — more than 3 thousand people. It should be taken into account that the figure of losses for 8 years (3404 people by the end of 2021) includes more than 2 thousand civilians who died in the midst of the conflict — in 2014-2015. Later on, civilians died less often: in 2021, <a href=\"https://ukraine.un.org/sites/default/files/2022-02/Conflict-related%20civilian%20casualties%20as%20of%2031%20December%202021%20%28rev%2027%20January%202022%29%20corr%20EN_0.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">according to the UN</a>, 21 civilians were killed by random shells, unexploded ordnance and mines.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"If the “genocide”, as Vladimir Putin called it, continued for 8 years in the East of Ukraine, then what can be said about the “special operation” that led to the same losses among the civilian population in just three months?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"NATO expansion was not stopped","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"“The NATO alliance &lt;...&gt; is steadily expanding, the military machine is moving and coming close to our borders. &lt;...&gt; The military development of the territories adjacent to our borders, if we allow it, will continue for decades to come, and perhaps forever. And it will create a constantly growing, absolutely unacceptable threat for Russia. &lt;...&gt; Further expansion of NATO and the military development of the territory of Ukraine that has begun is unacceptable for us,” that is how Vladimir Putin explained the causes of the war in his <a href=\"https://paperpaper.ru/putin-obyavil-o-nachale-voennoj-operac/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">address</a> to the Russians on February 24.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But the war unleashed by Russia against Ukraine did not remove NATO from Russia's borders and did not limit the expansion of the alliance.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Three sources of IStories — former and current senior intelligence officers — believe that Russia's open military incursion into Ukraine has ensured NATO a comfortable, stable existence for decades to come. They recall that quite recently this bloc was shattered by internal contradictions: Turkey took the liberty of <a href=\"https://tass.ru/mezhdunarodnaya-panorama/6665204\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">purchasing</a> Russian weapons. The interests of some NATO members in the Middle East did not coincide with those of the United States. There were no indisputable arguments for accepting new members into the alliance. The meaning of NATO's existence was blurred. Former US President Donald Trump even <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/politics/04/09/2020/5f5203609a79476f08ca5176\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">threatened to</a> withdraw the US from the alliance. And the increase in defense spending caused <a href=\"https://www.dw.com/ru/%D0%BF%D0%BE%D1%87%D0%B5%D0%BC%D1%83-%D0%B3%D0%B5%D1%80%D0%BC%D0%B0%D0%BD%D0%B8%D1%8F-%D0%BD%D0%B5-%D0%B2%D1%8B%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BB%D1%8F%D0%B5%D1%82-%D0%BD%D0%B0-%D0%BE%D0%B1%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%BD%D1%83-2-%D1%81%D0%B2%D0%BE%D0%B5%D0%B3%D0%BE-%D0%B2%D0%B2%D0%BF/a-44649632\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">discussions</a> and <a href=\"https://ria.ru/20180703/1523892138.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">opposition</a> from politicians.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"With their \"special operation\" the Russian authorities breathed new life into NATO and fully justified the ever-increasing defense spending.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Now the \"military development\" of territories near the Russian borders will only accelerate. And Russia's border with the countries of the alliance will be doubled. At the time of the beginning of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, five countries of the alliance bordered the Russian Federation — Latvia, Lithuania, Norway, Poland and Estonia (the United States borders Russia only by sea). Ukraine got the opportunity to join NATO in 2008, but this process was frozen for 14 years. The old members of NATO did not want to spend money on the new poor members and shoulder their worries.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Now prosperous Finland wants to join NATO. Its border with Russia exceeds 1,200 kilometers. And also Sweden has shown the same intentions (it doesn't have a common border with Russia, only exclusive economic zones border). On May 18, in Brussels, the Secretary General of the alliance received membership applications from the ambassadors of Finland and Sweden. Both countries have reconsidered the risks to national security and in today's conditions see only one way to ensure it — <a href=\"https://meduza.io/news/2022/05/15/shvetsiya-i-finlyandiya-ofitsialno-ob-yavili-chto-podadut-zayavki-na-vstuplenie-v-nato\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">to become</a> members of NATO.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4764,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Jonathan Nackstrand / AFP / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Swedish soldiers camouflage their armored personnel carriers during a field exercise near Visby on the Swedish island of Gotland, May 17, 2022.","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/df5e8f1734de49cba1651ccffdc5d330-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/df5e8f1734de49cba1651ccffdc5d330-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/df5e8f1734de49cba1651ccffdc5d330-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/df5e8f1734de49cba1651ccffdc5d330-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/df5e8f1734de49cba1651ccffdc5d330-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/df5e8f1734de49cba1651ccffdc5d330-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/df5e8f1734de49cba1651ccffdc5d330-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/df5e8f1734de49cba1651ccffdc5d330-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"In May, Switzerland announced plans to lean closer to the alliance. The country has maintained military and political neutrality enshrined in the constitution since 1815. The Swiss Ministry of Defense is preparing a report on possible options for strengthening security, including through cooperation with NATO.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"US dominance has not ended","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"“Our special military operation is designed to put an end to &lt;...&gt; the reckless course towards complete US domination,” Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov <a href=\"https://www.vesti.ru/article/2702139\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">said</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Sources of IStories from the Russian intelligence services doubt that the “special operation” undermined US dominance. By engaging in a military gamble, Russia severely limited its ability to compete with other countries.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"American economic influence in Europe has only grown. Urgent US requests to limit the EU's reliance on Russian energy resources, such as abandoning the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline and buying American liquefied natural gas, no longer seem too radical. Germany <a href=\"https://tass.ru/ekonomika/9529507?utm_source=yandex.ru&amp;utm_medium=organic&amp;utm_campaign=yandex.ru&amp;utm_referrer=yandex.ru\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">resisted</a> this pressure to the last and called the gas pipeline an exclusively economic project, not related to politics. But after the start of Russia's \"special military operation\" in Ukraine, Nord Stream 2, in which investments exceeded 10 billion euros, simply died. Initially, the opponents of the project <a href=\"https://aif.ru/money/economy/zagnali_v_trubu_kto_v_evrope_podderzhivaet_severnyy_potok-2_a_kto_protiv\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">were</a> the USA, Poland, Ukraine and the Baltic countries.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2021, the United States became <a href=\"https://1prime.ru/gas/20210517/833683654.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">the main</a> supplier of liquefied gas to Europe. And in 2022, according to analysts, the US <a href=\"https://tass.ru/ekonomika/13808689?utm_source=yandex.ru&amp;utm_medium=organic&amp;utm_campaign=yandex.ru&amp;utm_referrer=yandex.ru\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">may</a> become the largest supplier of liquefied natural gas in the world. Now the US is promising the Europeans <a href=\"https://www.forbes.ru/biznes/460353-ssa-poobesali-obespecit-evrope-postavki-gaza-na-zamenu-importa-iz-rossii\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">to replace</a> gas supplies from Russia, although this is expensive and difficult to do given the large volumes of pipeline gas. But nothing is impossible. Now Russia's former main European partner, Germany, <a href=\"https://www.bfm.ru/news/496107\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">intends to</a> almost completely eliminate the need for Russian gas in 2024.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"What is Russia losing? Gas and oil bring our country up to half of the budget revenues and account for more than half of all exports. Russia <a href=\"https://www.iea.org/reports/russian-supplies-to-global-energy-markets\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">sells</a> to Europe 70% of its gas and 60% of its oil and oil products. In just three months of the war, the European Union <a href=\"https://crea.shinyapps.io/russia_counter/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">paid</a> Russia more than 50 billion euros for oil and gas.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Europe is trying to <a href=\"https://thebell.io/alekperov-zayavil-o-negativnykh-posledstviyakh-embargo-na-neft-dlya-es-i-rossii\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">agree on</a> an embargo on Russian oil: to stop importing it within six months. And to stop import of oil products within a year. In addition, in April the European Union <a href=\"https://www.forbes.ru/biznes/461941-es-otkazyvaetsa-ot-rossijskogo-ugla-nuzno-li-strane-pereorientirovat-sa-na-aziu\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">imposed</a> a ban on the purchase of Russian coal. This is very beneficial for American coal companies. Their future supplies to Europe are expected to <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/5304900\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">grow</a> significantly and they have not seen such an increase since 2018.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Allies fail to save Russia","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov is confident that Russia is supported by the majority of countries. “They are, by and large, the majority. But the pressure they are under is not only unprecedented, I could never imagine such a thing,” said Lavrov expressing his surprise. The minister said that the US is trying to put pressure on China, India, Egypt, Turkey, and other countries because of their cooperation with Russia.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Due to the rupture of ties with the West, Russia just hoped to turn to Asia — primarily to China and India, in order to supply raw materials there and receive goods, services, and technologies. But in order to remain among the leaders in the supply of energy resources, it is necessary to increase their production. And, for example, traditional Russian oil fields are gradually <a href=\"https://ria.ru/20210921/zapasy-1751002337.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">being exhausted</a>. The development of new often hard-to-reach fields and the production of hard-to-recover oil require technologies that Western companies possess.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The war in Ukraine resulted in the largest international oil and oilfield services companies with modern oil exploration and production technologies <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/business/830174\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">leaving</a> the Russian market. And Russia did not have its own. Rosnedra (Russian Federal Subsoil Resources Management Agency) had to <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/russia/840980\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">state</a> that it would not be possible to develop offshore fields without these technologies. And Russia's current allies are unlikely to help in this.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4765,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: AFP / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Members of the Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) in the Kremlin in Moscow on May 16, 2022.","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d84ddff2de04abf97004e27cdcd900c-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d84ddff2de04abf97004e27cdcd900c-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d84ddff2de04abf97004e27cdcd900c-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d84ddff2de04abf97004e27cdcd900c-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d84ddff2de04abf97004e27cdcd900c-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d84ddff2de04abf97004e27cdcd900c-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d84ddff2de04abf97004e27cdcd900c-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d84ddff2de04abf97004e27cdcd900c-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"China does not impose sanctions against Russia, <a href=\"https://lenta.ru/news/2022/05/20/more/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">has increased its</a> consumption of Russian oil, and even <a href=\"https://tass.ru/mezhdunarodnaya-panorama/14611009?utm_source=yandex.ru&amp;utm_medium=organic&amp;utm_campaign=yandex.ru&amp;utm_referrer=yandex.ru\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">voted</a> against an anti-Russian resolution on Ukraine at a special session of the UN Human Rights Council. But China does not dispute the measures already taken against Russia. In order not to fall under secondary sanctions, the Bank of China and ICBC (China's largest lending institutions) <a href=\"https://www.finanz.ru/novosti/birzhevyye-tovary/kitayskie-banki-prisoedinilis-k-sankciyam-protiv-rossii-1031233100\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">stopped</a> issuing letters of credit to Chinese companies for the purchase of Russian raw materials. Immediately after the start of the “special military operation”, Chinese oil refineries began buying Russian oil at a significant <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/business/839296\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">discount</a>. Negotiations are underway on gas, but even in this situation, the Chinese <a href=\"https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-04-04/china-gas-buyers-seek-cheap-russian-fuel-shunned-by-the-world\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">demand</a> a 10% discount. In addition, some Chinese IT companies have <a href=\"https://ria.ru/20220507/it-1787334809.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">stopped</a> deliveries to Russia. Chinese shippers predictably <a href=\"https://www.vedomosti.ru/business/articles/2022/03/02/911782-kitai-ostanavlivaet-tranzit\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">stopped</a> the transit of goods through Russia to Europe. China also <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/politics/10/03/2022/6229bede9a79474e88ac5634\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">refused</a> to supply Russian airlines with spare parts for aircraft.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"As for India, hopes for it are weak, although it has not imposed direct sanctions against Russia either. In April, the media learned that the Indian state corporation <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/business/13/04/2022/625611249a794780a5252529\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">refused</a> to purchase Russian oil after the US' calls not to increase the consumption of Russian energy resources. Even earlier, India stopped transactions for the purchase of Russian <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/politics/17/04/2022/625b71d39a794731b2e72f92\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">helicopters</a>, formally not linking this to sanctions. And the Indian state bank issued a letter stating that it would strictly <a href=\"https://tass.ru/ekonomika/13909975?utm_source=yandex.ru&amp;utm_medium=organic&amp;utm_campaign=yandex.ru&amp;utm_referrer=yandex.ru\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">comply</a> with the restrictions set by European and American sanctions against Russia and its structures.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Society is not united","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"“Competition in who is more patriotic is hardly necessary, especially at such a moment when we all need to be united &lt;...&gt; around our country, around our president,” said Putin’s press secretary Dmitry Peskov <a href=\"https://tass.ru/politika/14272525\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reflecting</a> on patriotism.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Since the beginning of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, numerous polls (Russian Public Opinion Research Center (<a href=\"https://wciom.ru/analytical-reviews/analiticheskii-obzor/specialnaja-voennaja-operacija-monitoring\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">VTsIOM</a>), Public Opinion Foundation (<a href=\"https://media.fom.ru/fom-bd/d82022.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">FOM</a>), <a href=\"https://russianfield.com/metavernis\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Russian field</a>, the research project <a href=\"https://www.dorussianswantwar.com/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">\"Do Russians Want War?\"</a>, <a href=\"https://extremescan.eu/russian-citizens-on-the-special-military-operation-in-ukraine-independent-opinion-poll/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Extremescan</a>) show that the majority of Russians support the \"special military operation\". However, all these surveys are <a href=\"https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/author/maksim-aliukov/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">criticized</a> by sociologists, since it is difficult to study public opinion in wartime, especially in countries with autocratic regimes. When answering questions, people may hide their position and try to give the “correct” answer in order to avoid reprisals. <a href=\"https://www.opendemocracy.net/ru/oprosy-obschestvennogo-mneniya-kak-politicheskoe-oruzhie-alyukov/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">According to sociologist Maxim Alyukov</a>, people may perceive polls as a tool of the government and that may result in their fear to answer the questions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Despite massive state propaganda and the destruction of any independent media, the Russian authorities feel threatened by those who disagree with the war. A week after the invasion of Ukraine, a law was <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/news-60615902\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">passed</a> punishing the dissemination of \"inaccurate information\" about the actions of the Russian military (anything is considered such information, from value judgments to individual words).&nbsp;This law introduces a punishment of up to 15 years in prison. The State Duma also <a href=\"http://duma.gov.ru/news/53620/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">passed</a> a law according to which one can be imprisoned for up to three years for calls for sanctions against Russia.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":4766,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Sipa / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"More than 2,500 people were detained in 49 Russian cities during anti-war protests on March 6, 2022.","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/483285a4167640d0afdba894bf915bae-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/483285a4167640d0afdba894bf915bae-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/483285a4167640d0afdba894bf915bae-1200xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/483285a4167640d0afdba894bf915bae-1200xautopx_2x.png","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/483285a4167640d0afdba894bf915bae-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/483285a4167640d0afdba894bf915bae-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/483285a4167640d0afdba894bf915bae-415xautopx_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/483285a4167640d0afdba894bf915bae-415xautopx_2x.png","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Russian media are forbidden to call what is happening in Ukraine a war and an invasion. Instead, they are required to use the wording “special military operation”. Media outlets that refused to comply with these demands were blocked. In the first week of the war alone, the authorities liquidated or blocked almost all independent media. On March 5, the Ministry of Justice added the Latvian foundation IStories Fonds, the founder of IStories, to the list of “undesirable organizations”.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Public-sector employees, people who are directly dependent on state organizations and officials, take part in the authorities' campaigns in support of military operations. The authorities organize <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/features-61401033\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">publicly</a> funded concerts “For the Motherland!” (\"Zа Родину!\") and other public events. At the same time, anti-war protests in Russia <a href=\"https://istories.media/reportages/2022/04/25/vi-chto-duri-vi-pochemu-protiv-rodini/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">are</a> led by people of all professions and ages, despite the risks of being fined, arrested or even subjected to criminal charges. According to <a href=\"https://istories.media/reportages/2022/05/16/voina-v-tsifrakh/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">OVD-Info</a> (independent Russian human rights media project aimed at combating political persecution), on April 14, it was known about 15,428 arrests at anti-war actions and 1,938 administrative cases for \"discreditation of the army.\"&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There is no single positive assessment of the \"special operation\" even in the environment most loyal to the president — in the Russian special services. Sources of IStories in this sphere believe that Vladimir Putin lost his nerve, and the military actions against Ukraine were <a href=\"https://istories.media/opinions/2022/05/16/kak-putin-prinyal-reshenie-o-voine/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">the result</a> of the head of state being misinformed.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The current consequences of the “special operation” contradict the national interests of Russia to such an extent that even a fresh conspiracy theory has appeared among the employees of the Russian special services. It goes like this: having unleashed a war with Ukraine, the president succumbed to a provocation from the United States and, instead of resorting to a calm and consistent increase in political and economic influence, he snapped and turned back to zero all his achievements of the past twenty years. In the presidential environment and even in the Federal Security Service (FSB), the culprits are traditionally called \"Western agents of influence\".","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A former Russian intelligence officer who does not support this theory, assessing the \"special operation\", quotes one of the French figures of the Napoleonic era: \"This is worse than a crime, this is a mistake.\"","type":"p","className":""}]}],"more":true,"limit":30,"category":"opinions","locale":"en"}},"staticQueryHashes":["764694655"],"slicesMap":{}}