{"componentChunkName":"component---src-templates-category-js","path":"/en/stories/index.html","result":{"pageContext":{"pageParameters":{"isPreview":false,"isMirror":true,"delay_to_show_donate_popup_seconds":7,"about_page":false,"games_page":true,"games_page_link_in_header":false,"donate_popup_show_ru":true,"donate_popup_title_ru":"Без вас — нас не будет","donate_popup_content_ru":"Помогите нам добывать и рассказывать важные истории. Участие каждого — важно!","donate_popup_show_en":true,"donate_popup_title_en":"We can’t do it alone!","donate_popup_content_en":"Help us uncover and share the stories that matter. Every contribution makes a difference","display_regular_donors_banner":false,"showPatreonMethod":true,"useNewMaterialDonationBanner":true,"new_donations_page_design":true,"donations_popup_variants":{"ru":[{"id":"kc19b","title":"Сохраните журналистику для людей в России ","subtitle":"Читают нас прежде всего люди в России, но будущее «Важных историй» зависит от тех, кто живет за пределами страны. Поддержите нас ежемесячным донатом — сохраните независимую журналистику для ваших близких, которые остаются в России.","is_active":true,"background":"linear-gradient(10deg, #421f20 5%, #994146)"},{"id":"33tc9","title":"У пропаганды есть миллиарды из бюджета. У нас — только вы","subtitle":"Перемены возможны, если независимые от власти журналисты продолжают свою работу день за днем, год за годом. Мы рассказываем важные истории уже шесть лет. Помогите нам продолжать.","is_active":true,"background":"linear-gradient(10deg, #421f20 5%, #994146)"}],"en":[{"id":"nj1py","title":"Important stories don’t tell themselves","subtitle":"Independent journalism comes at a cost. We answer to no owners or advertisers — only to you, our readers.  Your ongoing support allows us to keep exposing the truth. Without you, we won’t be here.","is_active":true,"background":"linear-gradient(10deg, #421f20 5%, #994146)"},{"id":"xdfc1","title":"Help us outlast the Kremlin censorship","subtitle":"Censorship lose to journalism that keeps showing up, year after year. Monthly donors are what make that possible","is_active":true,"background":"linear-gradient(10deg, #421f20 5%, #994146)"},{"id":"ck121","title":"State propaganda has billions to spend. We have only you to rely on","subtitle":"Change happens when independent journalists keep showing up — day after day, year after year. Six years in, we're still showing up. Help us keep going with a monthly donation.","is_active":true,"background":"linear-gradient(10deg, #421f20 5%, #994146)"}]},"feedback_page":true,"donorsCount":0,"showAuthorsRequestAfterMaterial":true,"radioPage":true,"radioExists":{"ru":true,"en":false},"singlePlaylistPath":{"ru":"/radio/2025/12/22/razgovori-ovazhnikh/index.html"},"with_bookmarks":true,"news_feed":true,"news_feed_skeleton":false,"news_page_redesign":true,"with_topics":true,"materials_topics":false,"topics_page":true,"with_pdf_share":false,"with_native_share":false,"preferred_source_page":true,"charon_new_form":true,"preferred_source_promos":true,"charon_en_page":true},"materials":[{"id":11318,"header":"Deutsche Bank Moved Russian Billionaires to “Secrecy Jurisdictions”","_path":"/en/stories/2026/11/17/deutsche-bank-moved-russian-billionaires-to-secrecy-jurisdictions/","lead":"Ahead of global sanctions, Deutsche Bank moved wealthy Russians to its offices in Switzerland and Luxembourg","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3b61c409094f4de8adb5d0c0d783a4eb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Picture: Studio Yadi","created_at_date":"2026-11-17","created_at_date_time":"2026-11-16T13:11:52.909Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":18,"first_name":"Роман","last_name":"Катин","first_name_en":"Roman","last_name_en":"Katin","is_public":true,"_path":"r","avatar":[],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":1},{"id":11,"first_name":"Дмитрий","last_name":"Великовский","first_name_en":"Dmitry","last_name_en":"Velikovsky","is_public":true,"_path":"dmitry-velikovsky","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":189,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":189,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":2},{"id":9,"first_name":"Ирина","last_name":"Долинина","first_name_en":"Irina","last_name_en":"Dolinina","is_public":true,"_path":"irina-dolinina","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Журналистка «Важных историй»","lead_en":"IStories' investigative reporter","position":"Авторка","position_en":"Author","ordering":3}],"external_authors_list":[{"id":388,"first_name":"Khadija","last_name":"Sharife","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"Barracuda Media","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":4},{"id":389,"first_name":"Brian","last_name":"Fitzpatrick","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"IJB","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":5},{"id":391,"first_name":"Bastian","last_name":"Obermayer","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":6},{"id":390,"first_name":"Frederik","last_name":"Obermaier","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":7},{"id":392,"first_name":"Sophia ","last_name":"Baumann","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"Paper Trail Media","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":8}],"editors_list":[{"id":8,"first_name":"Алеся","last_name":"Мароховская","first_name_en":"Alesya","last_name_en":"Marokhovskaya","is_public":true,"_path":"alesya-marokhovskaya","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Главная редакторка «Важных историй»","lead_en":"Editor-in-chief","position":"Редакторка","position_en":"Editor","ordering":1}],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"In December 2021, reports of an imminent full-scale Russian invasion of Ukraine were mounting. Some large Western banks were already considering leaving the Russian market. Deutsche Bank, meanwhile, moved its Moscow headquarters into a new office in the White Square business center and declared its “commitment to the Russian market.”\nIStories and more than 200 journalists from more than 50 news outlets around the world analyzed the bank’s leaked internal documents as part of Inside Deutsche Bank, a global media investigation. The leak showed how committed the German bankers were to serving Russian billionaires.\nDeutsche Bank moved wealthy Russians to “secrecy jurisdictions,” where bank secrecy is guarded especially closely. That meant the German bank was legally unable to hand over information about these clients when the U.S. Justice Department asked for it.\nThis investigation began when two sources inside the bank gave a cache of documents to the journalists Josy Joseph of India and Khadija Sharife of South Africa. Barracuda Media, a nonprofit registered in South Africa specifically for this project, coordinated the analysis of the documents, with technical support from Germany’s Data and Research Center (DARC).\nMoving Russian clients\nAccording to the leaked files, Deutsche Bank’s clients included many well-known Russian billionaires: Roman Abramovich, Andrey Melnichenko, Alisher Usmanov, Alexei Mordashov, Oleg Deripaska, Gennady Timchenko, and others.\nAfter the 2014 annexation of Crimea, some Russian state banks and companies, along with billionaires in Vladimir Putin’s circle (Timchenko among them), came under international sanctions. The Justice Department began asking Deutsche Bank questions about its wealthy Russian clients and their businesses.\nCoincidentally, by the year after the wave of sanctions, the bank had drawn up a document titled “Russian Business Case.” The idea was to move wealthy Russians to other service hubs and “concentrate” them in three jurisdictions: Switzerland, which accounted for 60% of the bank’s total Russian client business by October 2015; Luxembourg, with 13%; and Germany, with 19%. The German option was eventually dropped.\nIn internal emails in 2017, Deutsche Bank employees discussed how ironclad bank secrecy was in Switzerland and Luxembourg. “Anything [Deutsche Bank Switzerland] learns about its client through its relationship with the client will be protected by strict Swiss banking secrecy rules,” said an email from the bank’s data protection lawyer.\nLuxembourg has similar “strict statutory banking secrecy rules.” “And you will have difficulty in getting hold of specific (Luxembourg) client agreements,” another internal email said.\nThe bank’s growing use of opaque jurisdictions to register Russian clients raised questions even there. In 2018, the first thing Luxembourg authorities brought up at a meeting with Deutsche Bank’s director for regulatory relations was “their concern related to those Russian clients”, the director wrote in an internal email.\nFor wealthy Russians, the move to Switzerland and Luxembourg came with legal advantages.\n\nBank secrecy for the “Most Sensitive Clients”\nIn November 2020, the bank prepared an internal 172-page “Russia Strategy Review.” The strategy cited an “elevated” risk of financial crime in Russia: money laundering and sanctions violations. From then on, it directed, large “Russian-linked” clients were to be placed with Deutsche Bank units in Switzerland, Luxembourg, and the United Kingdom. The bank planned to close its German hub for Russian clients soon and move the remaining clients to Zurich.\nOf 160 such Russian clients, 17 were flagged in the bank’s internal documents as appearing on the U.S. Treasury Department’s “Kremlin list.” Published by U.S. authorities in 2018, the list names key Russian billionaires and political figures and is meant to indicate who may end up under sanctions.\nAccording to the review, by 2020 those 17 people were generating 47% of Deutsche Bank’s revenue from its Russian client portfolio. Their presence on the Treasury list did not trouble the bank.\n“In the worst case,” the bank’s review said, “if the whole US Treasury Oligarch List is sanctioned (which is an extremely unlikely scenario) revenue might decrease by c. 30-35%.”\nBy 2021, various Deutsche Bank units were serving at least 46 “Most Sensitive Clients,” meaning clients with elevated reputational and sanctions risks. Virtually all of them, along with affiliated companies that were also bank clients, had been moved behind a veil of bank secrecy in “secrecy” jurisdictions by November of that year.\nThe list included people who were already under U.S. sanctions, such as Oleg Deripaska, Gennady Timchenko, and Suleiman Kerimov. A confidential internal analysis said Deripaska had “historical integrity issues” and called him “one of the more government-loyal oligarchs.”\nThe “Most Sensitive Clients” list contained a separate roster of “Critical Clients.” By November 2021, that roster included, for example, a Moscow company connected to Deripaska’s mother; the bank knew of the relationship. That same November, 11 companies linked to Kerimov were added to an “to be onboarded” list in Luxembourg. Kerimov, a billionaire senator in the Federation Council, the upper house of Russia’s parliament, had long been under U.S. sanctions.\nKerimov, Deripaska, Timchenko, and Mordashov did not respond to requests for comment. Usmanov’s representative said: “Mr Usmanov enjoys well-deserved recognition in many countries around the world as a generous philanthropist who has devoted a substantial part of his life to selflessly helping others. Any misrepresentation of that recognition would merely reflect the ignorance of those responsible.” EU sanctions on Usmanov were lifted this year, but he remains under U.S. sanctions.\nIn its response, Deutsche Bank said that concentrating Russian clients in specialized hubs such as Switzerland and Luxembourg was part of its wealth management operating model. As a result, the bank said, its “Russian clients were covered by specialist personnel … equipped with dedicated tools and control-function expertise to manage higher-risk relationships.”\nThe bank said that being named on the Treasury Department’s Kremlin list “did not in itself amount to a sanctions designation.” It added that it “applied enhanced scrutiny to higher-risk relationships, regularly reviewed its most sensitive clients and introduced limits for relevant client groups.”\n\nOnly partial answers\nThe bank’s strategy of serving clients in “secrecy” jurisdictions came under scrutiny after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, when the Justice Department asked for information about those clients.\nThe request was a headache for Deutsche Bank. Handing over incomplete information could have led to a criminal case. \nBecause most of the bank’s key Russian clients were served in “secrecy jurisdictions,” many of them ended up out of the authorities’ sight. Nearly a year before the war, for instance, the bank was discussing an expected request from the U.S. Congress concerning the assets of some oligarchs.\n“These are Russian clients, and we book Russian individuals in Lux and Switzerland, which are banking secrecy location,” a bank employee wrote to a lawyer in an internal email. The lawyer replied that in both countries the bank was allowed to share client information with foreign authorities “only in very limited cases.”\nIn 2024, the Justice Department demanded that Deutsche Bank report on how it complied with sanctions against Russia: how it monitored transactions and made sure that sanctioned individuals did not use shell companies to get around restrictions. The department also called for a list of “any Russian clients that have been sanctioned in connection with the Russian attack on Ukraine,” with details on their accounts, where those accounts were held, and their balances.\nDeutsche Bank eventually gave U.S. authorities information about its sanctioned Russian clients. But it said its response excluded companies that were less than half owned by those clients and were not themselves subject to restrictions.\n“Certain client data,” lawyers wrote to the Justice Department, “is not provided due to local banking secrecy restrictions.” An email from the bank’s head of data protection said: “It is not permitted to disclose customer data from Switzerland and Luxembourg to the DOJ (banking secrecy).” Such data “should actually not even leave the country,” he wrote.\nDeripaska, for example, was apparently among those whose full data was not passed to the Justice Department. He came under U.S. sanctions in 2018 and British sanctions in March 2022. When the bank’s internal emails mentioned his stake in the Austrian construction group Strabag, they also noted that the Justice Department did not need to be told about it for now. \n“Orderly wind-down”\nDeutsche Bank rejects “any suggestion that Deutsche Bank sought to help clients evade sanctions.” From 2019 to 2025, the bank said in its response, it invested €7 billion in its control environment and achieved “substantial improvements in governance, risk management and compliance.”\nThe bank said that “Following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, Deutsche Bank acted promptly to implement the rapidly evolving sanctions imposed by the relevant authorities.” It added that it had “fulfilled its obligations [to U.S. authorities] under the DPA [a deferred prosecution agreement]” and that the agreement was terminated more than two years ago.\nThe bank also said its Moscow office remains open, but only to “support the orderly wind-down and the management of remaining local obligations.”\n\nIn early 2026, investigators searched the bank’s headquarters in Germany. A source close to the case told the German investigative project Paper Trail Media that the search was linked to transfers the bank allegedly made on behalf of Roman Abramovich a few days before the invasion of Ukraine. The transfers involved several billion euros, the source said.\nIn March, Deutsche Bank told Germany’s central bank that it had found possible violations of EU sanctions against Russia.\nThe law firm representing Abramovich told reporters that “he denies any allegation or suggestion of wrongdoing, including any allegation of criminal conduct, corruption or impropriety.” Abramovich also rejected “unfounded speculation” about him “to the extent those internal processes [of Deutsche Bank] documented it.”\n\nThe lawyers added that neither German authorities nor Deutsche Bank had mentioned Abramovich in any public statement about the searches or indicated that any accusations were being brought against him. German authorities, they said, had confirmed to Abramovich that he is not under investigation in connection with the January 2026 search of Deutsche Bank’s premises by Germany’s Federal Criminal Police Office.\nAsked about Abramovich, Deutsche Bank said it “does not comment on potential, former or existing client relationships... Russian-linked clients were subject to the applicable onboarding, due-diligence, sanctions, beneficial-ownership and reputational-risk controls.”\n\nContributors: Sophia Stahl (Paper Trail Media), Michael Suntinger (Paper Trail Media), Anna Lauterjung (Paper Trail Media), Josy Joseph (Barracuda Media), Maria Theresa Cruz (Barracuda Media), Karina Shedrofsky (DARC), Elizabeth Bratton (Financial Times), Olaf Storbeck (Financial Times), Dan McCrum (Financial Times), Lukas Kotkamp (Follow the Money)","blocks":[{"data":"In December 2021, <a href=\"https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/ATAG/2021/698853/EPRS_ATA(2021)698853_EN.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">reports</a> of an imminent full-scale Russian <a href=\"https://ecfr.eu/article/why-russia-could-invade-ukraine-again/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">invasion</a> of Ukraine were <a href=\"https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/04/us/politics/russia-ukraine-biden.html?eafs_enabled=false\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">mounting</a>. Some large Western banks were already <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/finances/14/03/2022/622f6bcb9a79478da8f3c7be?utm_referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fyandex.ru%2F\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">considering</a> leaving the Russian market. Deutsche Bank, meanwhile, moved its Moscow headquarters into a new office in the White Square business center and <a href=\"https://country.db.com/news/detail/20211215-deutsche-bank-moves-to-white-square-in-moscow?language_id=1\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">declared</a> its “commitment to the Russian market.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories and more than 200 journalists from more than 50 news outlets around the world analyzed the bank’s leaked internal documents as part of Inside Deutsche Bank, a global media investigation. The leak showed how committed the German bankers were to serving Russian billionaires.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Deutsche Bank moved wealthy Russians to “secrecy jurisdictions,” where bank secrecy is guarded especially closely. That meant the German bank was legally unable to hand over information about these clients when the U.S. Justice Department asked for it.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>This investigation began when two sources inside the bank gave a cache of documents to the journalists Josy Joseph of India and Khadija Sharife of South Africa. Barracuda Media, a nonprofit registered in South Africa specifically for this project, coordinated the analysis of the documents, with technical support from Germany’s Data and Research Center (DARC).</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Moving Russian clients</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"According to the leaked files, Deutsche Bank’s clients included many well-known Russian billionaires: Roman Abramovich, Andrey Melnichenko, Alisher Usmanov, Alexei Mordashov, Oleg Deripaska, Gennady Timchenko, and others.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After the 2014 annexation of Crimea, some Russian state banks and companies, along with billionaires in Vladimir Putin’s circle (Timchenko among them), came under international sanctions. The Justice Department began asking Deutsche Bank questions about its wealthy Russian clients and their businesses.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Coincidentally, by the year after the wave of sanctions, the bank had drawn up a document titled “Russian Business Case.” The idea was to move wealthy Russians to other service hubs and “concentrate” them in three jurisdictions: Switzerland, which accounted for 60% of the bank’s total Russian client business by October 2015; Luxembourg, with 13%; and Germany, with 19%. The German option was eventually dropped.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In internal emails in 2017, Deutsche Bank employees discussed how ironclad bank secrecy was in Switzerland and Luxembourg. “Anything [Deutsche Bank Switzerland] learns about its client through its relationship with the client will be protected by strict Swiss banking secrecy rules,” said an email from the bank’s data protection lawyer.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Luxembourg has similar “strict statutory banking secrecy rules.” “And you will have difficulty in getting hold of specific (Luxembourg) client agreements,” another internal email said.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19829,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Shutterstock","caption":"Deutsche Bank’s building in Luxembourg","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a8e5e997ece4ce28ff63e4bb9a799b2-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a8e5e997ece4ce28ff63e4bb9a799b2-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a8e5e997ece4ce28ff63e4bb9a799b2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a8e5e997ece4ce28ff63e4bb9a799b2-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a8e5e997ece4ce28ff63e4bb9a799b2-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a8e5e997ece4ce28ff63e4bb9a799b2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a8e5e997ece4ce28ff63e4bb9a799b2-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a8e5e997ece4ce28ff63e4bb9a799b2-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a8e5e997ece4ce28ff63e4bb9a799b2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a8e5e997ece4ce28ff63e4bb9a799b2-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a8e5e997ece4ce28ff63e4bb9a799b2-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a8e5e997ece4ce28ff63e4bb9a799b2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a8e5e997ece4ce28ff63e4bb9a799b2-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a8e5e997ece4ce28ff63e4bb9a799b2-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a8e5e997ece4ce28ff63e4bb9a799b2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a8e5e997ece4ce28ff63e4bb9a799b2-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a8e5e997ece4ce28ff63e4bb9a799b2-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5a8e5e997ece4ce28ff63e4bb9a799b2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The bank’s growing use of opaque jurisdictions to register Russian clients raised questions even there. In 2018, the first thing Luxembourg authorities brought up at a meeting with Deutsche Bank’s director for regulatory relations was “their concern related to those Russian clients”, the director wrote in an internal email.<span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"After learning that the local regulator planned an on-site inspection of Deutsche Bank, the director decided to “warn” a colleague ahead of time.\"></span>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For wealthy Russians, the move to Switzerland and Luxembourg came with legal advantages.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Bank secrecy for the “</strong>Most Sensitive Clients<strong>”</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In November 2020, the bank prepared an internal 172-page “Russia Strategy Review.” The strategy cited an “elevated” risk of financial crime in Russia: money laundering and sanctions violations. From then on, it directed, large “Russian-linked” clients were to be placed with Deutsche Bank units in Switzerland, Luxembourg, and the United Kingdom. The bank planned to close its German hub for Russian clients soon and move the remaining clients to Zurich.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Of 160 such Russian clients, 17 were flagged in the bank’s internal documents as appearing on the U.S. Treasury Department’s “Kremlin list.” Published by U.S. authorities in 2018, the list names key Russian billionaires and political figures and is meant to indicate who may end up under sanctions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to the review, by 2020 those 17 people were generating 47% of Deutsche Bank’s revenue from its Russian client portfolio. Their presence on the Treasury list did not trouble the bank.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“In the worst case,” the bank’s review said, “if the whole US Treasury Oligarch List is sanctioned (which is an extremely unlikely scenario) revenue might decrease by c. 30-35%.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"By 2021, various Deutsche Bank units were serving at least 46 “Most Sensitive Clients,” meaning clients with elevated reputational and sanctions risks. Virtually all of them, along with affiliated companies that were also bank clients, had been moved behind a veil of bank secrecy in “secrecy” jurisdictions by November of that year.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The list included people who were already under U.S. sanctions, such as Oleg Deripaska, Gennady Timchenko, and Suleiman Kerimov. A confidential internal analysis said Deripaska had “historical integrity issues” and called him “one of the more government-loyal oligarchs.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19830,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Maxim Shemetov / Reuters / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"The bank’s list of “Most Sensitive Clients” included, among others, Gennady Timchenko (left) and Oleg Deripaska (right)","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e8f0f1ee37941819c25a8040a285a48-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e8f0f1ee37941819c25a8040a285a48-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e8f0f1ee37941819c25a8040a285a48-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1079,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e8f0f1ee37941819c25a8040a285a48-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e8f0f1ee37941819c25a8040a285a48-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e8f0f1ee37941819c25a8040a285a48-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1079,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e8f0f1ee37941819c25a8040a285a48-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e8f0f1ee37941819c25a8040a285a48-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e8f0f1ee37941819c25a8040a285a48-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":674,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e8f0f1ee37941819c25a8040a285a48-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e8f0f1ee37941819c25a8040a285a48-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e8f0f1ee37941819c25a8040a285a48-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":674,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e8f0f1ee37941819c25a8040a285a48-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e8f0f1ee37941819c25a8040a285a48-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e8f0f1ee37941819c25a8040a285a48-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":466},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e8f0f1ee37941819c25a8040a285a48-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e8f0f1ee37941819c25a8040a285a48-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e8f0f1ee37941819c25a8040a285a48-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":466}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The “Most Sensitive Clients” list contained a separate roster of “Critical Clients.” By November 2021, that roster included, for example, a Moscow company connected to Deripaska’s mother; the bank knew of the relationship. That same November, 11 companies linked to Kerimov were added to an “to be onboarded” list in Luxembourg. Kerimov, a billionaire senator in the Federation Council, the upper house of Russia’s parliament, had long been under U.S. sanctions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Kerimov, Deripaska, Timchenko, and Mordashov did not respond to requests for comment. Usmanov’s representative said: “Mr Usmanov enjoys well-deserved recognition in many countries around the world as a generous philanthropist who has devoted a substantial part of his life to selflessly helping others. Any misrepresentation of that recognition would merely reflect the ignorance of those responsible.” EU sanctions on Usmanov were lifted this year, but he remains under U.S. sanctions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In its response, Deutsche Bank said that concentrating Russian clients in specialized hubs such as Switzerland and Luxembourg was part of its wealth management operating model. As a result, the bank said, its “Russian clients were covered by specialist personnel … equipped with dedicated tools and control-function expertise to manage higher-risk relationships.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The bank said that being named on the Treasury Department’s Kremlin list “did not in itself amount to a sanctions designation.” It added that it “applied enhanced scrutiny to higher-risk relationships, regularly reviewed its most sensitive clients and introduced limits for relevant client groups.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Only partial answers</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The bank’s strategy of serving clients in “secrecy” jurisdictions came under scrutiny after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, when the Justice Department asked for information about those clients.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The request was a headache for Deutsche Bank. Handing over incomplete information could have led to a criminal case. <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"A deferred prosecution agreement the bank reached with U.S. authorities in January 2021 required it to “fully cooperate” with the Justice Department and to provide information about sanctioned individuals on request.\"></span>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Because most of the bank’s key Russian clients were served in “secrecy jurisdictions,” many of them ended up out of the authorities’ sight. Nearly a year before the war, for instance, the bank was discussing an expected request from the U.S. Congress concerning the assets of some oligarchs.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“These are Russian clients, and we book Russian individuals in Lux and Switzerland, which are banking secrecy location,” a bank employee wrote to a lawyer in an internal email. The lawyer replied that in both countries the bank was allowed to share client information with foreign authorities “only in very limited cases.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19831,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Jason Kleeb / Tamedia","caption":"Deutsche Bank’s office in Geneva, Switzerland (center)","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7850f6e4088f444d8904035867315d73-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7850f6e4088f444d8904035867315d73-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7850f6e4088f444d8904035867315d73-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1079,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7850f6e4088f444d8904035867315d73-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7850f6e4088f444d8904035867315d73-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7850f6e4088f444d8904035867315d73-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1079,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7850f6e4088f444d8904035867315d73-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7850f6e4088f444d8904035867315d73-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7850f6e4088f444d8904035867315d73-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":674,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7850f6e4088f444d8904035867315d73-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7850f6e4088f444d8904035867315d73-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7850f6e4088f444d8904035867315d73-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":674,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7850f6e4088f444d8904035867315d73-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7850f6e4088f444d8904035867315d73-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7850f6e4088f444d8904035867315d73-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":466},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7850f6e4088f444d8904035867315d73-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7850f6e4088f444d8904035867315d73-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7850f6e4088f444d8904035867315d73-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":466}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"In 2024, the Justice Department demanded that Deutsche Bank report on how it complied with sanctions against Russia: how it monitored transactions and made sure that sanctioned individuals did not use shell companies to get around restrictions. The department also called for a list of “any Russian clients that have been sanctioned in connection with the Russian attack on Ukraine,” with details on their accounts, where those accounts were held, and their balances.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Deutsche Bank eventually gave U.S. authorities information about its sanctioned Russian clients. But it said its response excluded companies that were less than half owned by those clients and were not themselves subject to restrictions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Certain client data,” lawyers wrote to the Justice Department, “is not provided due to local banking secrecy restrictions.” An email from the bank’s head of data protection said: “It is not permitted to disclose customer data from Switzerland and Luxembourg<strong> </strong>to the DOJ (banking secrecy).” Such data “should actually not even leave the country,” he wrote.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Deripaska, for example, was apparently among those whose full data was not passed to the Justice Department. He came under U.S. sanctions in 2018 and British sanctions in March 2022. When the bank’s internal emails mentioned his stake in the Austrian construction group Strabag, they also noted that the Justice Department did not need to be told about it for now. <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"A year earlier, Deutsche Bank had described its relationship with Strabag as “long-term and trusted.”\"></span>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>“Orderly wind-down”</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Deutsche Bank rejects “any suggestion that Deutsche Bank sought to help clients evade sanctions.” From 2019 to 2025, the bank said in its response, it invested €7 billion in its control environment and achieved “substantial improvements in governance, risk management and compliance.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The bank said that “Following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, Deutsche Bank acted promptly to implement the rapidly evolving sanctions imposed by the relevant authorities.” It added that it had “fulfilled its obligations [to U.S. authorities] under the DPA [a deferred prosecution agreement]” and that the agreement was terminated more than two years ago.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The bank also said its Moscow office remains open, but only to “support the orderly wind-down and the management of remaining local obligations.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In early 2026, investigators searched the bank’s headquarters in Germany. A source close to the case told the German investigative project Paper Trail Media that the search was linked to transfers the bank allegedly made on behalf of Roman Abramovich a few days before the invasion of Ukraine. The transfers involved several billion euros, the source said.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In March, Deutsche Bank told Germany’s central bank that it had found possible violations of EU sanctions against Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The law firm representing Abramovich told reporters that “he denies any allegation or suggestion of wrongdoing, including any allegation of criminal conduct, corruption or impropriety.” Abramovich also rejected “unfounded speculation” about him “to the extent those internal processes [of Deutsche Bank] documented it.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The lawyers added that neither German authorities nor Deutsche Bank had mentioned Abramovich in any public statement about the searches or indicated that any accusations were being brought against him. German authorities, they said, had confirmed to Abramovich that he is not under investigation in connection with the January 2026 search of Deutsche Bank’s premises by Germany’s Federal Criminal Police Office.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Asked about Abramovich, Deutsche Bank said it “does not comment on potential, former or existing client relationships... Russian-linked clients were subject to the applicable onboarding, due-diligence, sanctions, beneficial-ownership and reputational-risk controls.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>Contributors: Sophia Stahl (Paper Trail Media), Michael Suntinger (Paper Trail Media), Anna Lauterjung (Paper Trail Media), Josy Joseph (Barracuda Media), Maria Theresa Cruz (Barracuda Media), Karina Shedrofsky (DARC), Elizabeth Bratton (Financial Times), Olaf Storbeck (Financial Times), Dan McCrum (Financial Times), Lukas Kotkamp (Follow the Money)</em>","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":11317,"header":"Trump’s Companies Received Money From “Laundromat” Shell Firms, Deutsche Bank Documents Show","_path":"/en/stories/2026/11/17/trumps-companies-received-money-from-laundromat-shell-firms-deutsche-bank-documents-show/","lead":"Deutsche Bank documents link Donald Trump’s companies to Russian and Azerbaijani money-laundering schemes","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1060},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1060},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1060},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1060},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b70e0c06035b4f71be9f7c78ff12c3a5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Picture: Photo by Tierney L. Cross / Getty Images; Supplied; Financial Mail collage","created_at_date":"2026-11-17","created_at_date_time":"2026-11-16T13:06:18.893Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":18,"first_name":"Роман","last_name":"Катин","first_name_en":"Roman","last_name_en":"Katin","is_public":true,"_path":"r","avatar":[],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":1},{"id":9,"first_name":"Ирина","last_name":"Долинина","first_name_en":"Irina","last_name_en":"Dolinina","is_public":true,"_path":"irina-dolinina","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Журналистка «Важных историй»","lead_en":"IStories' investigative reporter","position":"Авторка","position_en":"Author","ordering":2},{"id":11,"first_name":"Дмитрий","last_name":"Великовский","first_name_en":"Dmitry","last_name_en":"Velikovsky","is_public":true,"_path":"dmitry-velikovsky","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":189,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":189,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":3}],"external_authors_list":[{"id":388,"first_name":"Khadija","last_name":"Sharife","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"Barracuda Media","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":4},{"id":391,"first_name":"Bastian","last_name":"Obermayer","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":5},{"id":390,"first_name":"Frederik","last_name":"Obermaier","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":6},{"id":393,"first_name":"Hakan","last_name":"Tanriverdi","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"Paper Trail Media","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":7},{"id":389,"first_name":"Brian","last_name":"Fitzpatrick","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"IJB","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":8},{"id":394,"first_name":"Jeremie","last_name":"Baruch","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"Le Monde","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":9},{"id":395,"first_name":"Karina","last_name":"Shedrofsky","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"DARC","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":10}],"editors_list":[{"id":8,"first_name":"Алеся","last_name":"Мароховская","first_name_en":"Alesya","last_name_en":"Marokhovskaya","is_public":true,"_path":"alesya-marokhovskaya","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Главная редакторка «Важных историй»","lead_en":"Editor-in-chief","position":"Редакторка","position_en":"Editor","ordering":1}],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"Starting in 2014, if not earlier, Donald Trump’s companies received money from questionable sources: shell companies that were part of the Azerbaijani and Russian laundromats. Influential officials and businessmen from Azerbaijan and Russia used these money-laundering schemes, including to bribe foreign politicians.\nBut internal Deutsche Bank documents show that the bankers appeared to be torn. Should they report the payments that Trump’s companies received from the Russian and Azerbaijani laundromats, or maintain that the bank was unaware of any ties between him and Russia? Should they tell everything to the members of Congress who were examining any evidence of Trump’s Russia connections, or withhold the full data despite an official request?\nThe financial ties between Trump’s companies and the laundromats came to light through Inside Deutsche Bank, a global media investigation that brought together IStories and more than 200 journalists from more than 50 news outlets around the world.\nThe investigation began with a major leak of documents: two sources inside the bank gave more than 15 million files to the journalists Josy Joseph of India and Khadija Sharife of South Africa. Barracuda Media, a nonprofit registered in South Africa specifically for this project, coordinated the analysis of these files, with technical support from Germany’s Data and Research Center (DARC).\n\nMoney from corruption schemes\nIn August 2014, Deutsche Bank filed a suspicious activity report (SAR) with U.S. authorities about Donald Trump’s company DT Marks Baku, the leaked files show. Trump was not yet president at the time; he was a prominent businessman with big political ambitions.\nBanks are required to file such reports when they notice questionable payments. Deutsche Bank, which acted as the correspondent bank for these transfers, wrote that “the commercial purpose of the transaction could not be confirmed” and that “the relationship of the parties [the sender and the recipient of the money] could not be determined.”\nThat is not surprising. Trump’s company received three transfers from a client of the Estonian branch of Danske Bank, Denmark’s largest lender (the client is not named in the leaked document). The branch soon made headlines around the world when news broke that it had specialized in laundering money from Russia and the Commonwealth of Independent States, a grouping of former Soviet republics.\nIn June 2015, Trump took his famous ride down the golden escalator at Trump Tower in Manhattan and formally announced his run for U.S. president. About a month and a half earlier, Deutsche Bank had noticed another suspicious payment. This time, the British shell company Faberlex paid Trump’s company THC Baku Services from its account at the same Estonian branch of Danske Bank.\nThe amount was small — a little more than $140,000.  But what matters is where it came from. Faberlex is a core company of the Azerbaijani Laundromat, a large-scale money-laundering network that became known through an investigation by the Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project (OCCRP).\nThe money that passed through this firm and through accounts at the Estonian branch of Danske Bank included corrupt payments to European lawmakers. Italian prosecutors, for example, found during a criminal investigation that Faberlex had been used to bribe Luca Volontè, a former member of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) who lobbied for Azerbaijan’s interests. In 2021, a court in Italy sentenced him to four years in prison for taking bribes from Azerbaijani politicians.\nGerman investigators found that the recipients of money sent through the Estonian branch included Eduard Lintner, a former member of Germany’s Bundestag and of PACE. In 2025, he was sentenced to nine months in prison for taking bribes while lobbying on behalf of Azerbaijan’s regime. The sentence was suspended because of his advanced age (88). Lintner passed money to another former Bundestag member, Axel Fischer, who was involved with PACE and also lobbied for Azerbaijan. Fischer was found guilty of bribery and in 2026 received a suspended sentence of one year and two months.\nIn a February 2018 suspicious activity report, Deutsche Bank listed another payment between Trump’s THC Baku Services and “an entity reportedly associated with the Russian Laundromat scheme.” That company’s name could not be found in the leaked files.\nIn all, by 2020 Donald Trump’s companies had been flagged for suspicious transactions totaling more than $3 million, according to a document from Deutsche Bank’s New York office. Among them were transactions with firms “reportedly associated with the Russian and Azerbaijan Laundromat schemes” and other questionable entities. \nThe same document said that in January 2020, the bank had once again filed a SAR on Trump’s companies DT Marks Baku and THC Baku Services. The grounds included “transactions involving entities and activity connected to the Azerbaijani money laundering scheme.” The document did not specify which persons and companies it meant.\n\n“The Azerbaijani Laundromat” and Russia\nFaberlex, which figured in the corrupt payments, was registered to a nominee owner, as were the Azerbaijani Laundromat’s other core companies, the British firms Hilux Services and Polux Management. The owner on paper was Maharram Ahmadov, an ordinary driver from Baku who does not remotely resemble an oligarch.\nAll three shell companies used an email address created on a Russian service, faberlexlp@mail.ru. The address and the Azerbaijani mobile phone number linked to it were registered to Ismail Ahmadov (presumably a relative of Maharram), IStories found. No one answered our calls to the Azerbaijani number, which was soon disconnected. No one responded to questions sent by email, either.\nTransactions by Faberlex, Hilux, and Polux linked them to yet another British shell company, Datemile Alliance, which operated from 2012 to 2016. Estonian authorities flagged it during an investigation into money laundering through the local branch of Denmark’s Danske Bank. Datemile and its counterparties connected the Azerbaijani laundering scheme to the Russian one.\n\n\nDatemile Alliance, for example, received money from Metastar Invest, another shell company from the United Kingdom. Metastar, in turn, received money from Rosoboronexport, Russia’s state-owned arms exporter. Metastar Invest was controlled by two nominee firms, which also registered a company called Armut Services. The same company was involved in moving $230 million out of Russia, an operation that came to light in the case of Sergei Magnitsky .\nOCCRP obtained transaction data during its investigation of the Azerbaijani Laundromat. The data show that over the years Metastar Invest existed, its counterparties included other strategically important companies besides Rosoboronexport. Among them were Russian metals companies (Evraz, Nizhnesergi Metalware and Metallurgical Plant, and Magnitogorsk Iron and Steel Works) and Rosselkhozbank, a state-owned agricultural lender. The bank was headed by the son of Nikolai Patrushev, one of Vladimir Putin’s closest associates and a former director of the FSB, Russia’s Federal Security Service.\nIn WikiLeaks documents, IStories also found that Metastar received money from Palmstone Holdings, a company involved in a secret shipment of aircraft parts from the U.S. to Russia.\n\n“New Order”\nWhen it became clear in 2016 that Trump would be the next U.S. president, Deutsche Bank launched an internal project called “New Order,” or Novus Ordo, the leak shows . It covered Trump himself, members of his family, his administration, and people close to him.\nTrump was a longtime client of Deutsche Bank, which lent his real estate businesses hundreds of millions of dollars. But as soon as he entered big-time politics, the bank designated Trump and people in his circle “covered clients.” Access to information about them was restricted even internally. In documents and internal correspondence, the bank sought to avoid naming Trump, using the abbreviations DT and DJT instead (his full name is Donald John Trump).\nThe secrecy, however, ran into trouble almost at once. In 2017, an employee mistakenly sent a third party a link to financial information on more than 1,500 clients, including details of three of the U.S. president’s accounts. After an internal discussion, the bank decided not to tell Trump. “Brilliant outcome,” one of the bank’s clerks wrote to his superiors.\nIn 2019, Deutsche Bank said in its documents that it was unaware of any connections between President Trump and Russia. Yet just a year later, it drew up a report on the same $3 million that Trump’s companies had received from questionable sources, including companies “associated with the Russian and Azerbaijani laundromats.”\n\nMixed feelings\nTrump was a problem client for other banks, too. Capital One, a U.S. bank that had served him for many years, dropped him in March 2021 and closed 366 of his accounts over “anti money laundering” risks.” Trump responded by suing the bank, arguing that the decision was unjustified and had been made to cater to “woke” politics. The case is still pending.\nInternal Deutsche Bank documents show that Trump was a subject of debate at the bank as well. At a meeting of its reputational risk committee in March 2016, nine months before Trump became U.S. president, a senior executive asked point-blank: Were the bank’s values and beliefs at odds with Trump’s? And how comfortable was the bank with such a client, given the obvious mismatch? Another executive replied that if the bank decided it did not want a relationship with Trump, it would have to take responsibility for that decision and think about how to communicate it to him. But the executive who had asked the questions stressed that a decision not to renew his loan could have negative consequences if he became president.\nIn April 2019, a standing committee of the U.S. House of Representatives that oversees the financial sector formally demanded data on Trump from Deutsche Bank. The demand included information about “communications on a wide range of issues, relationships with ‘covered clients’ [that is, Trump himself, his family, and his circle], the ‘Russian laundromat,’ the ‘Danish bank,’ and others.” The German bank was caught between a rock and a hard place.\n“There is an official request for information, it’s Congress, of course... Deutsche Bank’s Frankfurt headquarters will have to answer these questions to avoid severe consequences,” an employee wrote to Deutsche Bank’s legal team in internal correspondence on March 31, 2021. But she immediately added: “Sharing everything is not a solution.”\nThe request expired in January 2023, and members of Congress did not renew it. The following year, Trump won the presidency again.\nTrump did not respond to questions from reporters working on the project. The White House referred them to the Trump Organization, which did not reply.\nDeutsche Bank told Barracuda Media that it does not comment on its relationship with Trump. “Banks are legally prohibited from commenting on their discussions with supervisory authorities in the U.S. and on suspicious activity reports, including their existence or non-existence,” the bank said.","blocks":[{"data":"Starting in 2014, if not earlier, Donald Trump’s companies received money from questionable sources: shell companies that were part of the Azerbaijani and Russian laundromats. Influential officials and businessmen from Azerbaijan and Russia used these money-laundering schemes, including to bribe foreign politicians.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But internal Deutsche Bank documents show that the bankers appeared to be torn. Should they report the payments that Trump’s companies received from the Russian and Azerbaijani laundromats, or maintain that the bank was unaware of any ties between him and Russia? Should they tell everything to the members of Congress who were examining any evidence of Trump’s Russia connections, or withhold the full data despite an official request?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The financial ties between Trump’s companies and the laundromats came to light through Inside Deutsche Bank, a global media investigation that brought together IStories and more than 200 journalists from more than 50 news outlets around the world.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>The investigation began with a major leak of documents: two sources inside the bank gave more than 15 million files to the journalists Josy Joseph of India and Khadija Sharife of South Africa. Barracuda Media, a nonprofit registered in South Africa specifically for this project, coordinated the analysis of these files, with technical support from Germany’s Data and Research Center (DARC).</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Money from corruption schemes</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In August 2014, Deutsche Bank filed a suspicious activity report (SAR) with U.S. authorities about Donald Trump’s <a href=\"https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-stat/graphics/politics/trump-archive/docs/trump-fec-financial-disclosure-2015.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">company</a> DT Marks Baku, the leaked files show. Trump was not yet president at the time; he was a prominent businessman with big political ambitions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Banks are required to file such reports when they notice questionable payments. Deutsche Bank, which acted as the correspondent bank for these transfers, wrote that “the commercial purpose of the transaction could not be confirmed” and that “the relationship of the parties [the sender and the recipient of the money] could not be determined.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"That is not surprising. Trump’s company received three transfers from a client of the Estonian branch of Danske Bank, Denmark’s largest lender (the client is not named in the leaked document). The branch soon made headlines around the world when news broke that it had specialized in <a href=\"https://www.vedomosti.ru/finance/articles/2018/10/24/784536-kak-odin-bankir-vskril-aferu-v-danske-bank-na-234-milliarda\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">laundering</a> money from Russia and the Commonwealth of Independent States, a grouping of former Soviet republics.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19824,"data":{"block":"<p>“The money laundering case was clearly very serious, and what happened during those years should never have happened. We expressed our regret at the time and have consistently done so since,” Danske Bank told reporters. “The case was subject to extensive investigations by the bank and the relevant authorities, and in 2022, the matter was concluded through coordinated resolutions with the Danish and US authorities. Since then, Danske Bank has implemented fundamental changes across the bank and invested significantly in systems, capabilities and controls aimed at preventing and detecting financial crime.”</p>","header":"Danske Bank expresses regret","content":[{"insert":"“The money laundering case was clearly very serious, and what happened during those years should never have happened. We expressed our regret at the time and have consistently done so since,” Danske Bank told reporters. “The case was subject to extensive investigations by the bank and the relevant authorities, and in 2022, the matter was concluded through coordinated resolutions with the Danish and US authorities. Since then, Danske Bank has implemented fundamental changes across the bank and invested significantly in systems, capabilities and controls aimed at preventing and detecting financial crime.”\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"In June 2015, Trump <a href=\"https://www.golosameriki.com/a/four-years-of-donald-trump/5744542.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">took</a> his famous ride down the golden escalator at Trump Tower in Manhattan and formally announced his run for U.S. president. About a month and a half earlier, Deutsche Bank had noticed another suspicious payment. This time, the British shell company Faberlex paid Trump’s <a href=\"https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-stat/graphics/politics/trump-archive/docs/trump-fec-financial-disclosure-2015.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">company</a> THC Baku Services from its account at the same Estonian branch of Danske Bank.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19825,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Brendan McDermid / Reuters / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Donald Trump launches his presidential campaign at Trump Tower in New York, June 16, 2015","isNarrow":false,"creditUrl":"https://www.reuters.com/news/picture/idUSRTSWAVO/","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4c4b69db57245adb89fcd5a0f0083ff-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4c4b69db57245adb89fcd5a0f0083ff-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4c4b69db57245adb89fcd5a0f0083ff-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1364,"real_height_2x":1506},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4c4b69db57245adb89fcd5a0f0083ff-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4c4b69db57245adb89fcd5a0f0083ff-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4c4b69db57245adb89fcd5a0f0083ff-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1364,"real_height_2x":1506},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4c4b69db57245adb89fcd5a0f0083ff-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4c4b69db57245adb89fcd5a0f0083ff-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4c4b69db57245adb89fcd5a0f0083ff-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":852,"real_height_2x":1506},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4c4b69db57245adb89fcd5a0f0083ff-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4c4b69db57245adb89fcd5a0f0083ff-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4c4b69db57245adb89fcd5a0f0083ff-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":852,"real_height_2x":1506},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4c4b69db57245adb89fcd5a0f0083ff-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4c4b69db57245adb89fcd5a0f0083ff-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4c4b69db57245adb89fcd5a0f0083ff-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":295,"real_height_2x":590},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4c4b69db57245adb89fcd5a0f0083ff-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4c4b69db57245adb89fcd5a0f0083ff-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4c4b69db57245adb89fcd5a0f0083ff-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":295,"real_height_2x":590}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The amount was small — a little more than $140,000. <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"Barracuda Media reporters identified the payment after obtaining a Faberlex bank document from their source; the amount matched the figure in the Deutsche Bank leak to the cent.\"></span> But what matters is where it came from. Faberlex is a <a href=\"https://www.occrp.org/en/project/the-azerbaijani-laundromat/the-origin-of-the-money\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">core</a> company of the Azerbaijani Laundromat, a large-scale money-laundering network that became known through an <a href=\"https://www.occrp.org/ru/proekt/azerbaidzanskii-landromat\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">investigation</a> by the Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project (OCCRP).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The money that passed through this firm and through accounts at the Estonian branch of Danske Bank included corrupt payments to European lawmakers. Italian prosecutors, for example, found during a criminal investigation that Faberlex had been <a href=\"https://www.amlc.eu/the-azerbaijani-laundromat-a-new-money-laundering-machine-in-a-familiar-guise/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">used</a> to bribe Luca Volontè, a former member of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) who lobbied for Azerbaijan’s interests. In 2021, a court in Italy <a href=\"https://www.occrp.org/ru/novosti/sud-v-italii-prigovoril-eks-deputata-pase-k-tiuremnomu-sroku-za-vziatki-ot-azerbaidzanskix-politikov\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">sentenced</a> him to four years in prison for taking bribes from Azerbaijani politicians.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"German investigators found that the recipients of money sent through the Estonian branch included Eduard Lintner, a former member of Germany’s Bundestag and of PACE. In 2025, he was <a href=\"https://www.occrp.org/en/news/german-ex-mp-convicted-in-azerbaijan-bribery-scandal\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">sentenced</a> to nine months in prison for taking bribes while lobbying on behalf of Azerbaijan’s regime. The sentence was suspended because of his advanced age (88). Lintner passed money to another former Bundestag member, Axel Fischer, who was involved with PACE and also lobbied for Azerbaijan. Fischer was <a href=\"https://www.dw.com/ru/eksdeputat-bundestaga-polucil-uslovnyj-srok-za-vzatki-ot-azerbajdzana/a-75614006\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">found</a> guilty of bribery and in 2026 received a suspended sentence of one year and two months.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19826,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Collage: IStories / Images: Studio Yadi, Unsplash, Wikimedia Commons","caption":"The scheme to bribe PACE members through the Azerbaijani Laundromat","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3ff8637de14f428c966419deb459eed7-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3ff8637de14f428c966419deb459eed7-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3ff8637de14f428c966419deb459eed7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3ff8637de14f428c966419deb459eed7-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3ff8637de14f428c966419deb459eed7-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3ff8637de14f428c966419deb459eed7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3ff8637de14f428c966419deb459eed7-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3ff8637de14f428c966419deb459eed7-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3ff8637de14f428c966419deb459eed7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3ff8637de14f428c966419deb459eed7-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3ff8637de14f428c966419deb459eed7-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3ff8637de14f428c966419deb459eed7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3ff8637de14f428c966419deb459eed7-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3ff8637de14f428c966419deb459eed7-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3ff8637de14f428c966419deb459eed7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3ff8637de14f428c966419deb459eed7-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3ff8637de14f428c966419deb459eed7-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3ff8637de14f428c966419deb459eed7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"In a February 2018 suspicious activity report, Deutsche Bank listed another payment between Trump’s THC Baku Services and “an entity reportedly associated with the Russian Laundromat scheme.” That company’s name could not be found in the leaked files.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In all, by 2020 Donald Trump’s companies had been flagged for suspicious transactions totaling more than $3 million, according to a document from Deutsche Bank’s New York office. Among them were transactions with firms “reportedly associated with the Russian and Azerbaijan Laundromat schemes” and other questionable entities. <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"The document was drawn up in May 2020 by Brian Hagerty, the director of the bank’s financial crime investigations unit.\"></span>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The same document said that in January 2020, the bank had once again filed a SAR on Trump’s companies DT Marks Baku and THC Baku Services. The grounds included “transactions involving entities and activity connected to the Azerbaijani money laundering scheme.” The document did not specify which persons and companies it meant.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19827,"data":{"block":"<p>The American companies DT Marks Baku and THC Baku Services have appeared in Donald Trump’s public financial disclosures for many years. Both were connected to a failed <a href=\"https://www.azattyqasia.org/a/azerbaijan-anar-mammadov-kfc-britain-trump-hotel-baku-corruption/33029403.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">project</a> to build a luxury 33-story Trump International Hotel in Azerbaijan’s capital, Baku.</p><p>Trump’s partners in the project, which began in 2012, were relatives of Ziya Mammadov, then Azerbaijan’s transport minister. They <a href=\"https://www.occrp.org/ru/rassledovanie/v-azerbaidzanskom-ministerstve-procvetaet-semeinaia-kommerciia\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">became</a> millionaires through government contracts from his ministry. U.S. diplomatic cables and investigative reporting have repeatedly linked the Mammadov family to corruption and abuse of power. Foreign Policy <a href=\"https://foreignpolicy.com/2014/06/10/the-corleones-of-the-caspian/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">called</a> them “The Corleones of the Caspian.”</p><p>Trump publicly <a href=\"https://www.americanprogress.org/article/trumps-conflicts-interest-azerbaijan/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">disclosed</a> that he had received $2.5 million in 2015 for managing the Baku project and a little more than $300,000 in 2016. The hotel never opened. Trump’s company withdrew from the agreement in late 2016.</p><p>In 2017, the Trump Organization <a href=\"https://archive.ph/EMzKR#selection-683.364-687.214\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">told</a> The New Yorker that Trump had a “passive role” in the Azerbaijani project and had merely licensed his well-known name to a company belonging to Mammadov’s son. The leaked Deutsche Bank files do not link Mammadov to any suspicious money transfers.</p>","header":"Why Baku? What linked Trump to Azerbaijan","content":[{"insert":"The American companies DT Marks Baku and THC Baku Services have appeared in Donald Trump’s public financial disclosures for many years. Both were connected to a failed "},{"insert":"project","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.azattyqasia.org/a/azerbaijan-anar-mammadov-kfc-britain-trump-hotel-baku-corruption/33029403.html","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" to build a luxury 33-story Trump International Hotel in Azerbaijan’s capital, Baku.\nTrump’s partners in the project, which began in 2012, were relatives of Ziya Mammadov, then Azerbaijan’s transport minister. They "},{"insert":"became","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.occrp.org/ru/rassledovanie/v-azerbaidzanskom-ministerstve-procvetaet-semeinaia-kommerciia","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" millionaires through government contracts from his ministry. U.S. diplomatic cables and investigative reporting have repeatedly linked the Mammadov family to corruption and abuse of power. Foreign Policy "},{"insert":"called","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://foreignpolicy.com/2014/06/10/the-corleones-of-the-caspian/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" them “The Corleones of the Caspian.”\nTrump publicly "},{"insert":"disclosed","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.americanprogress.org/article/trumps-conflicts-interest-azerbaijan/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" that he had received $2.5 million in 2015 for managing the Baku project and a little more than $300,000 in 2016. The hotel never opened. Trump’s company withdrew from the agreement in late 2016.\nIn 2017, the Trump Organization "},{"insert":"told","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://archive.ph/EMzKR#selection-683.364-687.214","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" The New Yorker that Trump had a “passive role” in the Azerbaijani project and had merely licensed his well-known name to a company belonging to Mammadov’s son. The leaked Deutsche Bank files do not link Mammadov to any suspicious money transfers.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"<strong>“The Azerbaijani Laundromat” and Russia</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Faberlex, which figured in the corrupt payments, was registered to a nominee owner, as were the Azerbaijani Laundromat’s other core companies, the British firms Hilux Services and Polux Management. The owner on paper was Maharram Ahmadov, an ordinary <a href=\"https://www.occrp.org/en/project/the-azerbaijani-laundromat/the-origin-of-the-money\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">driver</a> from Baku who does not remotely resemble an oligarch.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"All three shell companies used an email address created on a Russian service, faberlexlp@mail.ru. The address and the Azerbaijani mobile phone number linked to it were registered to Ismail Ahmadov (presumably a relative of Maharram), IStories found. No one answered our calls to the Azerbaijani number, which was soon disconnected. No one responded to questions sent by email, either.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Transactions by Faberlex, Hilux, and Polux linked them to yet another British shell company, Datemile Alliance, which operated from 2012 to 2016. Estonian authorities <a href=\"https://www.aripaev.ee/uudised/2017/09/06/rehe-juhitud-danske-oli-offshorkade-paradiis\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">flagged</a> it during an investigation into money laundering through the local branch of Denmark’s Danske Bank. Datemile and its counterparties connected the Azerbaijani laundering scheme to the Russian one.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Datemile Alliance, for example, received money from Metastar Invest, another shell company from the United Kingdom. Metastar, in turn, received money from Rosoboronexport, Russia’s state-owned arms <a href=\"https://www.occrp.org/ru/proekt/azerbaidzanskii-landromat/ao-rosoboroneksport\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">exporter</a>. Metastar Invest was controlled by two nominee firms, which also <a href=\"https://pace.coe.int/en/files/27474/html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">registered</a> a company called Armut Services. The same company was involved in moving $230 million out of Russia, an operation that came to light in the <a href=\"https://www.svoboda.org/a/28564953.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">case</a> of Sergei Magnitsky<em> </em><span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"a lawyer for the Hermitage Capital Management fund who was killed in a Russian pretrial detention center\"></span>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"OCCRP obtained transaction data during its investigation of the Azerbaijani Laundromat. The data show that over the years Metastar Invest existed, its counterparties included other strategically important companies besides Rosoboronexport. Among them were Russian metals companies (Evraz, Nizhnesergi Metalware and Metallurgical Plant, and Magnitogorsk Iron and Steel Works) and Rosselkhozbank, a state-owned agricultural lender. The bank was headed by the son of Nikolai Patrushev, one of Vladimir Putin’s closest associates and a former director of the FSB, Russia’s Federal Security Service.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In WikiLeaks documents, IStories also found that Metastar received money from Palmstone Holdings, a company involved in a secret shipment of aircraft parts from the U.S. to Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>“New Order”</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"When it became clear in 2016 that Trump would be the next U.S. president, Deutsche Bank launched an internal project called “New Order,” or Novus Ordo, the leak shows <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"Possibly part of the motto on the Great Seal of the United States, as printed on the $1 bill\"></span>. It covered Trump himself, members of his family, his administration, and people close to him.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19828,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Charles Rex Arbogast / AP Photo","caption":"Donald Trump signs a $1 bill for a fan at a campaign rally, March 13, 2016","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e91e1ee8809849258b800931448edf71-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e91e1ee8809849258b800931448edf71-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e91e1ee8809849258b800931448edf71-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2565,"real_height_1x":1280,"real_height_2x":1710},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e91e1ee8809849258b800931448edf71-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e91e1ee8809849258b800931448edf71-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e91e1ee8809849258b800931448edf71-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2565,"real_height_1x":1280,"real_height_2x":1710},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e91e1ee8809849258b800931448edf71-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e91e1ee8809849258b800931448edf71-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e91e1ee8809849258b800931448edf71-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e91e1ee8809849258b800931448edf71-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e91e1ee8809849258b800931448edf71-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e91e1ee8809849258b800931448edf71-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e91e1ee8809849258b800931448edf71-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e91e1ee8809849258b800931448edf71-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e91e1ee8809849258b800931448edf71-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e91e1ee8809849258b800931448edf71-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e91e1ee8809849258b800931448edf71-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e91e1ee8809849258b800931448edf71-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Trump was a longtime client of Deutsche Bank, which lent his real estate businesses hundreds of millions of dollars. But as soon as he entered big-time politics, the bank designated Trump and people in his circle “covered clients.” Access to information about them was restricted even internally. In documents and internal correspondence, the bank sought to avoid naming Trump, using the abbreviations DT and DJT instead (his full name is Donald John Trump).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The secrecy, however, ran into trouble almost at once. In 2017, an employee mistakenly sent a third party a link to financial information on more than 1,500 clients, including details of three of the U.S. president’s accounts. After an internal discussion, the bank decided not to tell Trump. “Brilliant outcome,” one of the bank’s clerks wrote to his superiors.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2019, Deutsche Bank said in its documents that it was unaware of any connections between President Trump and Russia. Yet just a year later, it drew up a report on the same $3 million that Trump’s companies had received from questionable sources, including companies “associated with the Russian and Azerbaijani laundromats.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Mixed feelings</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Trump was a problem client for other banks, too. Capital One, a U.S. bank that had served him for many years, dropped him in March 2021 and closed 366 of his accounts over “anti money laundering” risks.” Trump responded by suing the bank, arguing that the decision was unjustified and had been made to cater to “woke” politics. The case is still pending.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Internal Deutsche Bank documents show that Trump was a subject of debate at the bank as well. At a meeting of its reputational risk committee in March 2016, nine months before Trump became U.S. president, a senior executive asked point-blank: Were the bank’s values and beliefs at odds with Trump’s? And how comfortable was the bank with such a client, given the obvious mismatch? Another executive replied that if the bank decided it did not want a relationship with Trump, it would have to take responsibility for that decision and think about how to communicate it to him. But the executive who had asked the questions stressed that a decision not to renew his loan could have negative consequences if he became president.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In April 2019, a standing committee of the U.S. House of Representatives that oversees the financial sector formally demanded data on Trump from Deutsche Bank. The demand included information about “communications on a wide range of issues, relationships with ‘covered clients’ <em>[that is, Trump himself, his family, and his circle]</em>, the ‘Russian laundromat,’ the ‘Danish bank,’ and others.” The German bank was caught between a rock and a hard place.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“There is an official request for information, it’s Congress, of course... Deutsche Bank’s Frankfurt headquarters will have to answer these questions to avoid severe consequences,” an employee wrote to Deutsche Bank’s legal team in internal correspondence on March 31, 2021. But she immediately added: “Sharing everything is not a solution.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The request expired in January 2023, and members of Congress did not renew it. The following year, Trump won the presidency again.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Trump did not respond to questions from reporters working on the project. The White House referred them to the Trump Organization, which did not reply.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Deutsche Bank <a href=\"http://www.inside-db.com/deutsche-bank-responds/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">told</a> Barracuda Media that it does not comment on its relationship with Trump. “Banks are legally prohibited from commenting on their discussions with supervisory authorities in the U.S. and on suspicious activity reports, including their existence or non-existence,” the bank said.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":11297,"header":"Inside Deutsche Bank: What the Largest Leak of the Bank’s Documents Revealed","_path":"/en/stories/2026/11/17/inside-deutsche-bank-what-the-largest-leak-of-the-banks-documents-revealed/","lead":"What linked Donald Trump’s companies to the laundering of Russian money, and where Russian oligarchs were kept out of sight. IStories took part in a global media investigation","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/80283e71807549aab46190776854b5da-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Illustration: Studio Yadi","created_at_date":"2026-11-17","created_at_date_time":"2026-11-16T12:49:59.449Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":18,"first_name":"Роман","last_name":"Катин","first_name_en":"Roman","last_name_en":"Katin","is_public":true,"_path":"r","avatar":[],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":1},{"id":9,"first_name":"Ирина","last_name":"Долинина","first_name_en":"Irina","last_name_en":"Dolinina","is_public":true,"_path":"irina-dolinina","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Журналистка «Важных историй»","lead_en":"IStories' investigative reporter","position":"Авторка","position_en":"Author","ordering":2},{"id":13,"first_name":"Соня","last_name":"Савина","first_name_en":"Sonya","last_name_en":"Savina","is_public":true,"_path":"sonya-savina","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Если вы хотите рассказать мне свою историю, пишите на почту sonya.savina@istories.media.","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":"Author","ordering":3}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[{"id":8,"first_name":"Алеся","last_name":"Мароховская","first_name_en":"Alesya","last_name_en":"Marokhovskaya","is_public":true,"_path":"alesya-marokhovskaya","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Главная редакторка «Важных историй»","lead_en":"Editor-in-chief","position":"Редакторка","position_en":"Editor","ordering":1}],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[{"id":11,"first_name":"Дмитрий","last_name":"Великовский","first_name_en":"Dmitry","last_name_en":"Velikovsky","is_public":true,"_path":"dmitry-velikovsky","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":189,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":189,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":1}],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"What the data leak involves\nTwo sources inside Deutsche Bank, a flagship of Europe’s financial system, gave 15 million internal documents to the journalists Josy Joseph of India and Khadija Sharife of South Africa. The files include employees’ corporate emails, reports on suspicious transactions, internal investigations, and risk assessments.\nIStories was one of the partners in Inside Deutsche Bank, a global investigation that ran for several months. It brought together more than 200 journalists from more than 50 news outlets around the world, including Der Spiegel, Le Monde, The New York Times, the Financial Times, the German investigative project Paper Trail Media, Italy’s IrpiMedia, and the Czech outlet Investigace.cz.\nBarracuda Media, a nonprofit registered in South Africa specifically for this project, coordinated the analysis of the leaked documents, with technical support from Germany’s Data and Research Center (DARC).\nThe sources believe they were acting in the public interest when they handed the bank’s documents to journalists. They also gave the files to the U.S. Justice Department and the Treasury Department’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN).\n\nWhat the files show\nThe bank’s documents revealed how Donald Trump’s companies received payments from firms linked to the Russian and Azerbaijani laundromats — large-scale schemes that laundered money for corrupt officials and politically connected businessmen. One of those firms was a shell company through which European politicians received bribes. Read the full story here.\nDeutsche Bank also moved wealthy Russians to its offices in Switzerland and Luxembourg shortly before international sanctions hit Russian billionaires, some of whom were its clients. Both countries are “secrecy jurisdictions,” where bank secrecy is guarded especially closely. That made it legally difficult for the U.S. Justice Department to obtain information from the bank about the clients it moved there. Read more about how Deutsche Bank dealt with its major Russian clients.\n\nWhy the leak matters\nDeutsche Bank has been through a series of scandals before and has paid billions of dollars in fines:\nIn 2017, U.S. and British authorities fined the bank over “mirror trades,” which made it possible to move money out of Russia under the guise of buying securities and selling them almost simultaneously.\nIn 2019, U.S. authorities fined Deutsche Bank over hiring relatives of senior Russian officials.\nIn 2020, U.S. authorities fined the bank again over its correspondent banking relationship with the Estonian branch of Danske Bank, Denmark’s largest lender. About €200 billion was laundered through that branch.\nBut that appears to have done little to change Deutsche Bank’s sense of what is acceptable, especially in its dealings with clients who have a great deal of power and money.\nIStories reporters have worked on many earlier international investigations into large-scale money-laundering schemes known as “laundromats”: “The Russian Laundromat Exposed,” “The Azerbaijani Laundromat” and “The Troika Laundromat.” All of them describe how the architects of shadow financial schemes help wealthy people, those in power, and their relatives and associates hide where their money comes from. They do this through networks of shell companies. In those companies’ accounts, legitimate money inevitably became mixed with corrupt and criminal funds.\nDeutsche Bank’s documents indicate that Donald Trump was not particular about which shadow schemes his companies’ money passed through. In that respect, he proved surprisingly similar to Russian officials and oligarchs.\n\nResponses from Trump and Deutsche Bank\nThe U.S. president did not respond to questions from reporters working on the project. The White House referred them to the Trump Organization, which did not reply. Deutsche Bank said, “We cannot comment on actual, potential or former client relationships.” It described moving Russian billionaires to its Swiss and Luxembourg offices ahead of full-scale sanctions as a mere coincidence and rejected any suggestion that it had sought to help clients evade them. The bank said it had strengthened client vetting and reputational risk controls in recent years.\n\nParticipating news outlets: Africa Uncensored (Kenya), Agência Pública (Brazil), Armando.Info (Venezuela), Berlingske (Denmark), Cenozo (Burkina Faso), CIReN (Cyprus), Concolón (Panama), Crikey (Australia), Cuestión Pública (Colombia), Daraj (Lebanon), Data Desk (United Kingdom), Dawn (Pakistan), Delfi (Estonia), Der Spiegel (Germany), Der Standard (Austria), Direkt36 (Hungary), El Armadillo (Colombia), El Clip (Latin America), elDiario.es (Spain), El Universal (Mexico), Finance Uncovered (United Kingdom), Financial Mail (South Africa), Financial Times (United Kingdom), Follow The Money (Netherlands), Foundation for Investigative Journalism (Nigeria), Gecko Project (United Kingdom), Guard Post Nigeria, Himal (Sri Lanka), IDL-Reporteros (Peru), Initium (China), Investigace.cz (Czech Republic), Investigative Journalism Bureau (Canada), IrpiMedia (Italy), IStories (Russia), Kyodo News (Japan), La Nación (Argentina), Le Monde (France), Letau.net (Ivory Coast), Malaysiakini (Malaysia), Manager Magazin (Germany), Myanmar Now (Myanmar), Netra (Bangladesh), Newslaundry (India), The New York Times (U.S.), Newstapa (KCIJ) (South Korea), No Ficción (Guatemala), Paper Trail Media (Germany), Slidstvo.Info (Ukraine), Tamedia (Switzerland), Tempo (Indonesia), The Black Sea (Turkey), The News Minute (India), The Wire (India), Tiger Eye (Ghana), Vlast (Kazakhstan), ZDF (Germany)","blocks":[{"data":"<strong>What the data leak involves</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Two sources inside Deutsche Bank, a flagship of Europe’s financial system, gave 15 million internal documents to the journalists Josy Joseph of India and Khadija Sharife of South Africa. The files include employees’ corporate emails, reports on suspicious transactions, internal investigations, and risk assessments.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories was one of the partners in Inside Deutsche Bank, a global investigation that ran for several months. It brought together more than 200 journalists from more than 50 news outlets around the world, including Der Spiegel, Le Monde, The New York Times, the Financial Times, the German investigative project Paper Trail Media, Italy’s IrpiMedia, and the Czech outlet Investigace.cz.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Barracuda Media, a nonprofit registered in South Africa specifically for this project, coordinated the analysis of the leaked documents, with technical support from Germany’s Data and Research Center (DARC).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The sources believe they were acting in the public interest when they handed the bank’s documents to journalists. They also gave the files to the U.S. Justice Department and the Treasury Department’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19805,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Ben Kuhlmann / Barracuda Media","caption":"Deutsche Bank’s headquarters in Frankfurt","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17a9ef736aa246419a58f99bdb65a503-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17a9ef736aa246419a58f99bdb65a503-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17a9ef736aa246419a58f99bdb65a503-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1280,"real_height_2x":1413},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17a9ef736aa246419a58f99bdb65a503-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17a9ef736aa246419a58f99bdb65a503-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17a9ef736aa246419a58f99bdb65a503-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1280,"real_height_2x":1413},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17a9ef736aa246419a58f99bdb65a503-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17a9ef736aa246419a58f99bdb65a503-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17a9ef736aa246419a58f99bdb65a503-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1413},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17a9ef736aa246419a58f99bdb65a503-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17a9ef736aa246419a58f99bdb65a503-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17a9ef736aa246419a58f99bdb65a503-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1413},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17a9ef736aa246419a58f99bdb65a503-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17a9ef736aa246419a58f99bdb65a503-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17a9ef736aa246419a58f99bdb65a503-original.jpg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17a9ef736aa246419a58f99bdb65a503-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17a9ef736aa246419a58f99bdb65a503-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17a9ef736aa246419a58f99bdb65a503-original.jpg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"<strong>What the files show</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The bank’s documents revealed how Donald Trump’s companies received payments from firms linked to the Russian and Azerbaijani laundromats — large-scale schemes that laundered money for corrupt officials and politically connected businessmen. One of those firms was a shell company through which European politicians received bribes. <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2026/11/17/trumps-companies-received-money-from-laundromat-shell-firms-deutsche-bank-documents-show/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Read the full story here</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Deutsche Bank also moved wealthy Russians to its offices in Switzerland and Luxembourg shortly before international sanctions hit Russian billionaires, some of whom were its clients. Both countries are “secrecy jurisdictions,” where bank secrecy is guarded especially closely. That made it legally difficult for the U.S. Justice Department to obtain information from the bank about the clients it moved there. <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2026/11/17/deutsche-bank-moved-russian-billionaires-to-secrecy-jurisdictions/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Read more about how Deutsche Bank dealt with its major Russian clients</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Why the leak matters</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Deutsche Bank has been through a series of scandals before and has paid billions of dollars in fines:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li>In 2017, U.S. and British authorities fined the bank over <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/3206462\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">“mirror trades,”</a> which made it possible to move money out of Russia under the guise of buying securities and selling them almost simultaneously.</li><li>In 2019, U.S. authorities fined Deutsche Bank over <a href=\"https://www.forbes.ru/finansy-i-investicii/382383-klassicheskaya-situaciya-deutsche-bank-oshtrafovali-za-priem-na-rabotu\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">hiring</a> relatives of senior Russian officials.</li><li>In 2020, U.S. authorities fined the bank again over <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/4407220\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">its correspondent banking relationship</a> with the Estonian branch of Danske Bank, Denmark’s largest lender. About €200 billion was laundered through that branch.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"But that appears to have done little to change Deutsche Bank’s sense of what is acceptable, especially in its dealings with clients who have a great deal of power and money.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories reporters have worked on many earlier international investigations into large-scale money-laundering schemes known as “laundromats”: “<a href=\"https://www.occrp.org/en/project/the-russian-laundromat-exposed/the-russian-laundromat-exposed\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">The Russian Laundromat Exposed</a>,” “<a href=\"https://www.occrp.org/ru/proekt/azerbaidzanskii-landromat\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">The Azerbaijani Laundromat</a>” and “<a href=\"https://meduza.io/feature/2019/03/04/koshelek-rossiyskoy-elity\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">The Troika Laundromat</a>.” All of them describe how the architects of shadow financial schemes help wealthy people, those in power, and their relatives and associates hide where their money comes from. They do this through networks of shell companies. In those companies’ accounts, legitimate money inevitably became mixed with corrupt and criminal funds.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Deutsche Bank’s documents indicate that Donald Trump was not particular about which shadow schemes his companies’ money passed through. In that respect, he proved surprisingly similar to Russian officials and oligarchs.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Responses from Trump and Deutsche Bank</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The U.S. president did not respond to questions from reporters working on the project. The White House referred them to the Trump Organization, which did not reply. Deutsche Bank <a href=\"http://www.inside-db.com/deutsche-bank-responds/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">said</a>, “We cannot comment on actual, potential or former client relationships.” It described moving Russian billionaires to its Swiss and Luxembourg offices ahead of full-scale sanctions as a mere coincidence and rejected any suggestion that it had sought to help clients evade them. The bank said it had strengthened client vetting and reputational risk controls in recent years.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19806,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"","caption":"","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4516c633149745c9974dc560dcdfeafa-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4516c633149745c9974dc560dcdfeafa-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4516c633149745c9974dc560dcdfeafa-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":1920,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1080},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4516c633149745c9974dc560dcdfeafa-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4516c633149745c9974dc560dcdfeafa-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4516c633149745c9974dc560dcdfeafa-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":1920,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1080},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4516c633149745c9974dc560dcdfeafa-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4516c633149745c9974dc560dcdfeafa-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4516c633149745c9974dc560dcdfeafa-original.png","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":1920,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1080},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4516c633149745c9974dc560dcdfeafa-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4516c633149745c9974dc560dcdfeafa-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4516c633149745c9974dc560dcdfeafa-original.png","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":1920,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1080},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4516c633149745c9974dc560dcdfeafa-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4516c633149745c9974dc560dcdfeafa-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4516c633149745c9974dc560dcdfeafa-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":466},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4516c633149745c9974dc560dcdfeafa-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4516c633149745c9974dc560dcdfeafa-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4516c633149745c9974dc560dcdfeafa-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":466}]},{"credit":"","caption":"","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50f7d670c55543ea824116328f7b453d-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50f7d670c55543ea824116328f7b453d-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50f7d670c55543ea824116328f7b453d-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":1920,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1080},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50f7d670c55543ea824116328f7b453d-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50f7d670c55543ea824116328f7b453d-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50f7d670c55543ea824116328f7b453d-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":1920,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1080},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50f7d670c55543ea824116328f7b453d-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50f7d670c55543ea824116328f7b453d-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50f7d670c55543ea824116328f7b453d-original.png","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":1920,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1080},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50f7d670c55543ea824116328f7b453d-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50f7d670c55543ea824116328f7b453d-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50f7d670c55543ea824116328f7b453d-original.png","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":1920,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1080},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50f7d670c55543ea824116328f7b453d-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50f7d670c55543ea824116328f7b453d-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50f7d670c55543ea824116328f7b453d-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":466},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50f7d670c55543ea824116328f7b453d-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50f7d670c55543ea824116328f7b453d-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/50f7d670c55543ea824116328f7b453d-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":466}]}]},"category":"two-images-embed"},"type":"two-images-embed"},{"data":"<em>Participating news outlets: Africa Uncensored (Kenya), Agência Pública (Brazil), Armando.Info (Venezuela), Berlingske (Denmark), Cenozo (Burkina Faso), CIReN (Cyprus), Concolón (Panama), Crikey (Australia), Cuestión Pública (Colombia), Daraj (Lebanon), Data Desk (United Kingdom), Dawn (Pakistan), Delfi (Estonia), Der Spiegel (Germany), Der Standard (Austria), Direkt36 (Hungary), El Armadillo (Colombia), El Clip (Latin America), elDiario.es (Spain), El Universal (Mexico), Finance Uncovered (United Kingdom), Financial Mail (South Africa), Financial Times (United Kingdom), Follow The Money (Netherlands), Foundation for Investigative Journalism (Nigeria), Gecko Project (United Kingdom), Guard Post Nigeria, Himal (Sri Lanka), IDL-Reporteros (Peru), Initium (China), Investigace.cz (Czech Republic), Investigative Journalism Bureau (Canada), IrpiMedia (Italy), IStories (Russia), Kyodo News (Japan), La Nación (Argentina), Le Monde (France), Letau.net (Ivory Coast), Malaysiakini (Malaysia), Manager Magazin (Germany), Myanmar Now (Myanmar), Netra (Bangladesh), Newslaundry (India), The New York Times (U.S.), Newstapa (KCIJ) (South Korea), No Ficción (Guatemala), Paper Trail Media (Germany), Slidstvo.Info (Ukraine), Tamedia (Switzerland), Tempo (Indonesia), The Black Sea (Turkey), The News Minute (India), The Wire (India), Tiger Eye (Ghana), Vlast (Kazakhstan), ZDF (Germany)</em>","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":11338,"header":"“You Were a Good Kid, but You Made the Wrong Choice, and That Choice Killed You”","_path":"/en/stories/2026/11/16/the-wrong-choice-that-killed-you/","lead":"How at least five orphans taken from Ukraine’s Donetsk Oblast to Russia in February 2022 ended up signing contracts with the Russian Defense Ministry and going to war","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03bb82092ac0408e820bccf06533b65b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Picture: IStories, made with AI tools","created_at_date":"2026-11-16","created_at_date_time":"2026-11-14T17:00:15.823Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":31,"first_name":"Катя","last_name":"Бонч-Осмоловская","first_name_en":"Katya","last_name_en":"Bonch-Osmolovskaya","is_public":true,"_path":"katya-bonch-osmolovskaya","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.jpeg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.jpeg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.jpeg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.jpeg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редакторка дата-отдела","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":null,"ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[{"id":240,"first_name":"Анна","last_name":"Рыжкова","first_name_en":"Anna","last_name_en":"Ryzhkova","company":"Вёрстка","company_en":"Verstka","company_link":"https://verstka.media/","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-896x504px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-original.png","real_width_1x":880,"real_width_2x":880,"real_height_1x":496,"real_height_2x":496},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-896x504px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-original.png","real_width_1x":880,"real_width_2x":880,"real_height_1x":496,"real_height_2x":496},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-688x387px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-original.png","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":880,"real_height_1x":386,"real_height_2x":496},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-688x387px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-original.png","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":880,"real_height_1x":386,"real_height_2x":496},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-416x234px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-original.png","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-416x234px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-original.png","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-336x189px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-original.png","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-336x189px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8272a7719af4413b9f9c021ff0c4a54e-original.png","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378}],"ordering":2}],"editors_list":[{"id":8,"first_name":"Алеся","last_name":"Мароховская","first_name_en":"Alesya","last_name_en":"Marokhovskaya","is_public":true,"_path":"alesya-marokhovskaya","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Главная редакторка «Важных историй»","lead_en":"Editor-in-chief","position":"Редакторка","position_en":"Editor","ordering":1}],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"In February 2022, just before Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine, hundreds of orphans from occupied Donetsk Oblast were taken to Russia. Russian authorities have repeatedly said they did this to save the children from shelling. Most of the children remained in Russian orphanages or were placed with foster families. Now, almost five years into the war, many of them have come of age and are making lives of their own in different parts of Russia.\n\nAt least five boys taken from Donetsk and Amvrosiivka have gone back to Ukraine to fight on Russia’s side, IStories and Verstka, an independent Russian news outlet, have found. They signed contracts with Russia’s Defense Ministry almost immediately after turning 18. Some have already been seriously wounded, some have received combat awards, and one has gone missing in action. Here are their stories.\n\nSome names in this story have been changed for safety reasons.\n\n“Being a soldier gives you status”\nIn late July 2022, Oleg Filatov, a father of a large family, flew to Moscow from Russia’s Far North. He was in a hurry to pick up his new foster children — teenagers Pavlo Yeremeyev (Pavel in Russian) and Yehor Lisin (Yegor in Russian) — and welcome them into his family. They had been taken from a boarding school in occupied Donetsk Oblast to Russia a few days before the full-scale war began.\n\n\n“I was counting the minutes. He had to fly into Domodedovo [Airport], get to central Moscow in 40 minutes, and pick up the children before the train left with their escort. ... We’ve never had such an extreme handover of children in our lives!” foster mother Olga Filatova wrote on social media.\n\nBefore that, the Filatovs had become guardians of two other children brought to Russia: Pavlo’s younger brother and sister. “The family is reunited now. They had been in different boarding schools and had no way to communicate. Now they’ll all be together in our family, at home. That’s what happiness is,” Filatova wrote joyfully.\n\nPavlo didn’t live with his biological brother and sister for long. Less than four months later, he moved in with another foster mother in the same town, Angelina Krivtsova.\n\nPavlo told IStories that his relationship with his first foster family didn’t work out: “At first I didn’t want to go, because I don’t like big families. But then they told me that my younger siblings — my brother and little sister — would be going there too, and abandoning them wasn’t an option. I agreed and went. I didn’t like it there at first.”\n\nA classmate who had also been taken to Russia from Donetsk Oblast suggested Pavlo join his own foster family. They asked the new foster mother for permission over a messaging app. “She agreed without a second thought. That same day, I wrote a statement renouncing the [first] foster family’s guardianship, and Filatova immediately wrote to me: ‘Don’t bother coming home anymore,’” Pavlo said. According to him, his younger brother and sister were later taken away from the Filatovs as well.\nPavlo’s new family had become guardians of four children from Donetsk Oblast. One of them, Andriy Zhelnov (Andrei in Russian), told IStories that from the age of 10 or 11 he had lived at the Amvrosiivka boarding school along with Pavlo. Zhelnov’s father stayed in Donetsk Oblast, but he was stripped of his parental rights, and the two are not in touch. Just before the full-scale war began, the orphanage’s children were taken en masse to Kursk, in Russia. According to Andriy, the children were offered a choice of several regions and foster families. He chose the Far North because “the air is fresher there and the families are pretty kind.”\n\nAfter moving to the new region, Pavlo enrolled in a local vocational college. He used his first stipend to help the military, buying medicine for mobilized soldiers.\n\nPavlo began to appear regularly in media segments and officials’ reports. In early 2024, he and his new foster family represented their region in Moscow at the “Rodnye — Lyubimye” forum, a large-scale event under the auspices of the propaganda-oriented Movement of the First. The forum opened the Year of the Family, which Vladimir Putin had declared.\n\nBy then, the father of the Krivtsov family was already fighting in Ukraine. His wife, Angelina, actively supported the war: she sewed balaclavas for soldiers, held charity fairs for those fighting in what Russia calls its “special military operation,” and sent humanitarian aid and drones to the front.\n\nIn September 2024, ahead of the second anniversary of the annexation of Ukrainian territories, Angelina Krivtsova described her family as “half Donetsk” in a celebratory social media post: “My now grown-up children have seen a lot, but now they’re home, in Russia. And knowing that makes them happy.”\n\nBy that point, some of the Ukrainian children taken in by the Krivtsov family were no longer at home. Pavlo and Andriy had signed contracts and gone off to fight for Russia. Only three months earlier, both had graduated from college. Pavlo had just turned 18, and Andriy was 19.\n\nYeremeyev told IStories he had long planned to sign a contract. “Of course, everyone tried to talk me out of it. I’d been saying for a long time, back when I was 16 or 17, that I was going to go and sign it. I have two little sisters there [in Donbas], and my mom.” (According to Pavlo, his mother was stripped of her parental rights and his father died, which is why he ended up in a children’s shelter. — Editor’s note) “Plus, [being a soldier] gives you status, prospects, a future.”\n\nAndriy Zhelnov signed his contract, he told IStories, because he “was bored.” He spent less than six months at the front — in his words, “enough to realize that there’s really nothing special there.” Asked why he came back, Andriy replied: “No leg.” He has no regrets about his decision and says he would have gone to fight even if he’d known the outcome in advance. Andriy speaks about his disability calmly, almost indifferently: “I absolutely don’t care.”\n\nZhelnov and Yeremeyev signed their contracts on the same day. They completed a monthlong basic training course in a reconnaissance company and went on their first combat mission together. “We were moving along fine; the drones didn’t notice us,” Pavlo recalled. “And at some point, out of the corner of my eye — the moon was shining that way — I saw a drone starting to get ahead of me. I stepped off the trail, and there was this little mound there. I probably passed that mine by, like, a centimeter, but he [Zhelnov] just happened to step on it. He hadn’t really seen any action yet; he’d only gotten a taste of the fighting.”\nAndriy Zhelnov had his leg amputated just below the knee. He received compensation for his injury and, in his own words, spent the money “on all sorts of nonsense.” The Russian authorities gave him housing as a child left without parental care and continue to help him as someone who fought in the war in Ukraine: he receives social benefits and vouchers for sanatorium stays. Andriy has thought about returning to the war but has not yet found a way to get to the front with such an injury. He doesn’t know what to do next.\n\nAt the time of publication, Pavlo Yeremeyev is still on the front lines. “I’ve worked my way up from an ordinary reconnaissance soldier to a drone pilot. I have two state awards — one for courage, the other for saving lives — and three ministry awards,” he said.\n\nWhen asked why he hadn’t gone to work in his field after college, Yeremeyev said it was pointless: “You know, these are the times we’re living in... Being a soldier gives you status. For example, having trained as an auto mechanic, I wouldn’t be able to join the Interior Ministry or any of the intelligence and security agencies. But right now, that wouldn’t be a problem for me at all. I didn’t give myself any other option; I had a goal, and I achieved it.”\n\nStill, he sees no sense in continuing the war. “Of course, it has to end — people aren’t made of iron. People want to be home, soldiers just like me. So many people have already died. Many mothers are left without their sons, sons without their fathers, wives without their husbands, and children without their parents. My opinion is that it’s better to end it as it is and sign a peace agreement,” Pavlo said, adding: “In any case, victory will be ours, because we have the truth on our side.”\n“Just went and signed the contract”\n“General disposition: even-tempered, positive, non-confrontational; self-esteem: adequate; calm, reserved, friendly, reasonable.”\n\nA profile with this description was uploaded to Russia’s database of orphans in October 2022. The photo shows Kyrylo P. (Kirill in Russian), a tall, brown-eyed teenager with light brown hair, available for adoption or guardianship.\n\nFour years later, the same young man posted new photos on VKontakte, a Russian social network: he stands in a trench under a camouflage net, an assault rifle slung around his neck and his call sign written in marker on the sling.\n\n“I’m on the front lines,” Kyrylo told Verstka. “When I turned 18, I waited two more months to get my college diploma, and then right away I just went and signed [the military contract]. I’m serving in an evacuation unit on the Zaporizhzhia front.”\n\nBefore going to war, Kyrylo was studying to be an auto mechanic and worked part-time at a car wash in a small town in one of the Volga regions. He ended up there in 2022, after the children of Donetsk Boarding School No. 1 were taken to Russia: first south, to a camp on the Sea of Azov, and then to orphanages across the country, wherever there was room.\n\n“When they told us we were leaving Donetsk, a TV crew came, filmed us for a while, and said we were going to Rostov-on-Don for a month. ‘You’ll live there until things calm down,’ they said. But in the end, things didn’t calm down,” Kyrylo said. He told Verstka he liked his new home better.\n“Of course, it’s better in Russia. Say, in Donetsk there was a war going on, and there was never any water — none at all. They’d turn it on once a week for two or three hours. Donetsk had just seceded from Ukraine back then, and there was nowhere to get budget money from,” he reasoned.\n\nKyrylo was placed in a boarding school because his mother was ill and couldn’t look after him. His father, he said, had fought “in the militia” — the pro-Russian separatist forces — since 2015 and was killed in 2022. His mother is no longer alive either. He has an older sister, who also moved to Russia and now lives not far from him. Kyrylo didn’t tell her about his decision to go to war.\n\nHe “had been thinking about serving since he was 16,” and when he graduated from college, he simply “went, signed, and left.” Kyrylo was wounded at the front. According to him, a drone carrying a shaped charge “hit him in the back.” He then spent two months “in and out of hospitals” and another two months on leave at home in the Volga region. Once the war ends, he would like a “quiet and peaceful life.”\n\n“Like all the guys who came back from the war [on leave], Kyrylo invited us out for drinks,” said his friend Artem, who had been at the same boarding school in Donetsk Oblast. “We went to the bathhouse and grilled kebabs. I said, ‘Bro, can I come with you too? Everything’s driving me crazy — nothing’s going right for me, basically.’ [He] tried to talk me out of it, of course. He even started swearing at me.”\n\n“You’re from Donetsk, you’re not like us”\nHearing a drone, Artem moved the phone away from his ear. “Just a second,” he said, asking the Verstka reporter to wait. “OK, it’s down. It fell without detonating. If you hit the explosive, it’ll detonate, but if you hit a blade, it might just fall.”\n\nArtem followed Kyrylo to war, and now, he said, they are holding positions about 10 kilometers apart.\n\nAsked by Verstka whether he regretted signing the contract, Artem said that “everyone regretted it.”\n\n“But who cares? Well, like, I wanted to stand up for Donetsk. Just so that all sorts of guys wouldn’t come there and take everything we have. The war will end anyway, and whether it’s soon or not, that’s not up to us to decide,” Artem reflected. “We were told to defend, and let them figure out the rest themselves. But it’s like everyone’s already fed up with it. We’re tired — very, very tired.”\n\nLike many other former students of Donetsk Oblast boarding schools, Artem didn’t know that Kyiv had been demanding the return of orphans taken to Russia from the occupied territories. He doesn’t understand what the dispute is about.\n\n“Kyiv has no right to speak,” he said. “Donetsk belongs to Russia, in theory. And Russian flags were hanging at our boarding school, too, for as long as I can remember.”\n\nArtem and Kyrylo grew up together: first they were classmates at the boarding school in Donetsk, and then, when the orphans were taken to Russia and sent to institutions across the country, they ended up in the same city.\n\n“Everything went sideways,” Artem said, recalling 2022. “The hardest part was losing my circle of friends. I’d known some of the kids for seven or eight years — since we were babies. And then — just like that — they separate us. We arrived at some new, unfamiliar place. Everyone was looking at us, like, ‘You’re from Donetsk, you’re not like us.’ Then I faced what they call bullying. We still have an accent, of course — we might say ‘sho’ [instead of the Russian ‘shto,’ for ‘what’]. Because of that, they called us — excuse my language — ‘fucking Khokhols’ [a slur for Ukrainians]. That stressed me out a lot. And technically, my passport is Russian.”\n\nArtem has no close relatives left: his grandmother, grandfather, and father have died, and his mother abandoned him in early childhood. In Russia, he completed ninth grade and enrolled in college, but tried to make money instead of studying: first as a “fetch-and-carry” farmhand, then as a tiler in private homes and as a rotational worker on a construction site in Moscow. He remembers the capital for Patriarch Ponds, where “there’s always something going on.” “We’d hang out, look at all the expensive cars we couldn’t afford, take pictures with some of them — they would even let us sit in them,” he said.\n\nWhen Artem turned 18, he was expelled from college and started looking into the conditions of service in the war. A client whose private house he was tiling unexpectedly took an interest in his future.\n\n“She said, ‘I’ll do what’s best for you. I’ll find you a decent job where they pay well.’ She bought me a train ticket to Ryazan, and I took the train there and went to sign [the contract] with the drone [forces],” Artem said.\n\nVerstka asked Artem whether he knew that recruiters act in their own financial interest. He replied that the woman “probably got her cut” for him, but that he had since lost touch with her.\n\nOnce at war, Artem was “stationed at a defensive position” (as part of a combat group holding a captured position. — Editor’s note) and learned to tell by sound which drone was coming from where. Six months into his service, he was struck by a “Baba Yaga” heavy bomber drone while in a dugout at night. At first, he lay in the hospital “like a cucumber” — meaning he couldn’t get up or move.\n“There’s just a lot to read here,” Artem said, looking over his hospital discharge summary. “The worst part was the ruptured spleen and contusions of all my internal organs. My legs stopped working, my spine went numb. There were problems with my eardrums, I temporarily lost vision in my right eye, I had second- and third-degree burns, a closed chest injury with lung contusions, some kind of tracheitis, all sorts of nonsense, basically. A severe concussion; I lost my memory for a while. What else? A brain contusion, a closed head injury — and that’s about it.”\n\nAfter rehabilitation at several hospitals, Artem returned to the front and now serves at checkpoints. During his few years in Russia, he realized he saw no future for himself in the country, neither in the region he had been moved to nor in Moscow, where “it’s all spoiled brats.” In that region, he said, he bought a one-room apartment with his military pay. “Just let them tell me, ‘It’s all over’ — I’d hop on my motorcycle and head to the boarding school in Donetsk.”\n“I simply have nothing to lose”\n“Off to the front tomorrow. Some guy told us there were 26 of them heading to the positions, but only four made it. And even those got fucked up by mortar fire.”\n“Fuck.”\n“Off to pack my stuff.”\n\nThe messages are from Dmytro Kushkovoy (Dmitry in Russian; Dima to his friends), an 18-year-old contract soldier getting ready for a “combat mission.” Like Pavlo Yeremeyev and Andriy Zhelnov, he is a former student of the Amvrosiivka boarding school, a large institution for orphans 70 kilometers from Donetsk. In February 2022, the school’s children were moved to Kursk Oblast; Dmytro stayed there and studied at a polytechnic college. After graduating, he began thinking about joining the fighting.\n\nFirst he joined chats for fighters of the Wagner mercenary group. At least three times, he asked whether he could get into Russia’s Africa Corps, which replaced Wagner in Africa, before reaching the minimum age of 22.\n\n“Please tell me how I can get to Africa at 18,” he wrote in the “White Uncles” Telegram group. Other members mocked his question: they suggested he buy a “tour package” and asked “what the fuck” a teenager wanted with “shooting games.”\n\nKushkovoy then considered joining the war, but again found no support.\n\n“I told him, ‘It’s better to just do your army service and come back.’ We all tried to talk him out of it, but it was no use. He liked the military uniform and everything related to war,” Svetlana, his ex-girlfriend, told Verstka. According to her, they met at a children’s shelter and had been together for about two years. But after he decided to go to war, they broke up for good.\n\n“The guys and I tried to talk him out of it, but he still stood his ground,” said Lesha, his friend and classmate, who grew up with him at the boarding school.\n\nThe two grew close shortly before leaving Amvrosiivka for Russia. They shared the food their relatives brought them, were roped together during “partner rock climbing,” hung out, and “looked out for each other.” In Kursk Oblast, they were assigned to the same college, which offered “government-funded support.”\n\nIn the fall of 2025, when Dima wrote to Lesha that he was already gathering documents to sign a contract, they met up and went motorbike riding all night long.\n\n“It was a funny situation,” Lesha told Verstka. “We drove to a quarry — it’s a motocross track. I told him, ‘Let me do a burnout.’ That’s when the vehicle’s standing still and the rear wheels are spinning. He handed me his motorcycle, I squeezed the front brakes, but they failed, and I landed face-first in the bushes. I’m lying there, and he comes running over to me: ‘Lekha, are you nuts?’ We’re just standing there, giggling. Two or three weeks later, I texted him: ‘How’s it going? What’s new?’ And he replies: ‘Taking it easy, serving on contract.’ So I text back: ‘Oh, you idiot...’”\n\nThey were messaging each other on November 5, 2025, ahead of the assault. Lesha sent Verstka a screenshot of their conversation.\n\n“Are you saying you regret it yourself?” Lesha asked.\n“No. I simply have nothing to lose — I don’t give a fuck. I like it here,” Dima replied.\n\nHe left for the assault and never came online again.\nAccording to his ex-girlfriend and relatives, the soldier has been listed as missing in action since November 27, 2025. His loved ones have been trying to get more detailed information from the Defense Ministry, but his status hasn’t been updated for a year.\n\n“I tried to look for him; I called the military enlistment offices both here in Donetsk and in Kursk. They said he was missing in action,” Dima’s great-aunt Olga told Verstka. “I’ve known him since he was a child. They just wouldn’t let me [become his guardian] when he had no one left, because I’m disabled and walk on crutches. His mother died of cancer, then his grandfather died, and his grandmother had died even earlier.”\n\n“Of course, there’s no exact information about his death. No one will tell me, since on paper I’m nobody to him. But through personal connections, I managed to find out that he’s on the list of those killed,” said Svetlana, Dima’s ex-girlfriend. “As far as I know, his body hasn’t been recovered — it’s near Kharkiv. We had been together for two years; it was very hard for me, but I still hope he’ll come back.”\n\nIn July 2026, Lesha put a photo that Dima had sent him shortly before the assault into a frame with a black ribbon and posted an obituary for his friend in his Telegram channel.\n\n“May you rest in peace, bro. It’s a shame you passed away at such a young age, but even though you’re not physically here with us, know that you’re in our memories and in our hearts. You were a good kid, but you made the wrong choice, and that choice killed you. ... So long, brother — may the clouds be soft beneath you; sooner or later, we’ll meet again anyway. You’re our hero; you gave your life for us.”","blocks":[{"data":"In February 2022, just before Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine, hundreds of orphans from occupied Donetsk Oblast were <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/stories/2024/04/03/khochu-damoi/index.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">taken</a> to Russia. Russian authorities have repeatedly <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/6743422\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">said</a> they did this to save the children from shelling. Most of the children <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/stories/2024/04/03/khochu-damoi/index.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">remained</a> in Russian orphanages or were placed with foster families. Now, almost five years into the war, many of them have come of age and are making lives of their own in different parts of Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At least five boys taken from Donetsk and Amvrosiivka have gone back to Ukraine to fight on Russia’s side, IStories and <a href=\"https://verstka.media/deti-siroty-vyvezennye-iz-doneczkoj-oblasti-v-rossiyu-v-fevrale-2022-goda-nachali-zaklyuchat-kontrakt\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Verstka</a>, an independent Russian news outlet, have found. They signed contracts with Russia’s Defense Ministry almost immediately after turning 18. Some have already been seriously wounded, some have received combat awards, and one has gone missing in action. Here are their stories.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>Some names in this story have been changed for safety reasons.</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>“Being a soldier gives you status”</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In late July 2022, Oleg Filatov, a father of a large family, flew to Moscow from Russia’s Far North. He was in a hurry to pick up his new foster children — teenagers Pavlo Yeremeyev (Pavel in Russian) and Yehor Lisin (Yegor in Russian) — and welcome them into his family. They had been taken from a boarding school in occupied Donetsk Oblast to Russia a few days before the full-scale war began.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19847,"data":{"url":"https://t.me/oddr_info/28704","caption":"A video documenting children being transported from a boarding school in the occupied Amvrosiivka, published by the Donetsk occupation authorities on February 19, 2022","initialHeight":"534px"},"category":"telegram-embed"},"type":"telegram-embed"},{"data":"“I was counting the minutes. He had to fly into Domodedovo [Airport], get to central Moscow in 40 minutes, and pick up the children before the train left with their escort. ... We’ve never had such an extreme handover of children in our lives!” foster mother Olga Filatova wrote on social media.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Before that, the Filatovs had become guardians of two other children brought to Russia: Pavlo’s younger brother and sister. “The family is reunited now. They had been in different boarding schools and had no way to communicate. Now they’ll all be together in our family, at home. That’s what happiness is,” Filatova wrote joyfully.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Pavlo didn’t live with his biological brother and sister for long. Less than four months later, he moved in with another foster mother in the same town, Angelina Krivtsova.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Pavlo told IStories that his relationship with his first foster family didn’t work out: “At first I didn’t want to go, because I don’t like big families. But then they told me that my younger siblings — my brother and little sister — would be going there too, and abandoning them wasn’t an option. I agreed and went. I didn’t like it there at first.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A classmate who had also been taken to Russia from Donetsk Oblast suggested Pavlo join his own foster family. They asked the new foster mother for permission over a messaging app. “She agreed without a second thought. That same day, I wrote a statement renouncing the [first] foster family’s guardianship, and Filatova immediately wrote to me: ‘Don’t bother coming home anymore,’” Pavlo said. According to him, his younger brother and sister were later taken away from the Filatovs as well.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19848,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Collage: IStories","caption":"","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84764b9a56b24badbafe5fbf38310be3-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84764b9a56b24badbafe5fbf38310be3-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84764b9a56b24badbafe5fbf38310be3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84764b9a56b24badbafe5fbf38310be3-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84764b9a56b24badbafe5fbf38310be3-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84764b9a56b24badbafe5fbf38310be3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84764b9a56b24badbafe5fbf38310be3-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84764b9a56b24badbafe5fbf38310be3-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84764b9a56b24badbafe5fbf38310be3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84764b9a56b24badbafe5fbf38310be3-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84764b9a56b24badbafe5fbf38310be3-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84764b9a56b24badbafe5fbf38310be3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84764b9a56b24badbafe5fbf38310be3-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84764b9a56b24badbafe5fbf38310be3-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84764b9a56b24badbafe5fbf38310be3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84764b9a56b24badbafe5fbf38310be3-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84764b9a56b24badbafe5fbf38310be3-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/84764b9a56b24badbafe5fbf38310be3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Pavlo’s new family had become guardians of four children from Donetsk Oblast. One of them, Andriy Zhelnov (Andrei in Russian), told IStories that from the age of 10 or 11 he had lived at the Amvrosiivka boarding school along with Pavlo. Zhelnov’s father stayed in Donetsk Oblast, but he was stripped of his parental rights, and the two are not in touch. Just before the full-scale war began, the orphanage’s children were taken en masse to Kursk, in Russia. According to Andriy, the children were offered a choice of several regions and foster families. He chose the Far North because “the air is fresher there and the families are pretty kind.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After moving to the new region, Pavlo enrolled in a local vocational college. He used his first stipend to help the military, buying medicine for mobilized soldiers.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Pavlo began to appear regularly in media segments and officials’ reports. In early 2024, he and his new foster family represented their region in Moscow at the “Rodnye — Lyubimye” forum, a large-scale <a href=\"http://government.ru/news/50647/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">event</a> under the auspices of the propaganda-oriented <a href=\"https://id.pervye.ru/projects/1767\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Movement of the First</a>. The forum opened the Year of the Family, which Vladimir Putin had declared.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"By then, the father of the Krivtsov family was already fighting in Ukraine. His wife, Angelina, actively supported the war: she sewed balaclavas for soldiers, held charity fairs for those fighting in what Russia calls its “special military operation,” and sent humanitarian aid and drones to the front.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In September 2024, ahead of the second anniversary of the annexation of Ukrainian territories, Angelina Krivtsova described her family as “half Donetsk” in a celebratory social media post: “My now grown-up children have seen a lot, but now they’re home, in Russia. And knowing that makes them happy.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"By that point, some of the Ukrainian children taken in by the Krivtsov family were no longer at home. Pavlo and Andriy had signed contracts and gone off to fight for Russia. Only three months earlier, both had graduated from college. Pavlo had just turned 18, and Andriy was 19.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Yeremeyev told IStories he had long planned to sign a contract. “Of course, everyone tried to talk me out of it. I’d been saying for a long time, back when I was 16 or 17, that I was going to go and sign it. I have two little sisters there [in Donbas], and my mom.” <em>(According to Pavlo, his mother was stripped of her parental rights and his father died, which is why he ended up in a children’s shelter. — Editor’s note)</em> “Plus, [being a soldier] gives you status, prospects, a future.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Andriy Zhelnov signed his contract, he told IStories, because he “was bored.” He spent less than six months at the front — in his words, “enough to realize that there’s really nothing special there.” Asked why he came back, Andriy replied: “No leg.” He has no regrets about his decision and says he would have gone to fight even if he’d known the outcome in advance. Andriy speaks about his disability calmly, almost indifferently: “I absolutely don’t care.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Zhelnov and Yeremeyev signed their contracts on the same day. They completed a monthlong basic training course in a reconnaissance company and went on their first combat mission together. “We were moving along fine; the drones didn’t notice us,” Pavlo recalled. “And at some point, out of the corner of my eye — the moon was shining that way — I saw a drone starting to get ahead of me. I stepped off the trail, and there was this little mound there. I probably passed that mine by, like, a centimeter, but he [Zhelnov] just happened to step on it. He hadn’t really seen any action yet; he’d only gotten a taste of the fighting.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19849,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Collage: IStories, made with AI tools","caption":"","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5f5cde00c6b4e9980b186efe4442c76-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5f5cde00c6b4e9980b186efe4442c76-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5f5cde00c6b4e9980b186efe4442c76-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5f5cde00c6b4e9980b186efe4442c76-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5f5cde00c6b4e9980b186efe4442c76-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5f5cde00c6b4e9980b186efe4442c76-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5f5cde00c6b4e9980b186efe4442c76-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5f5cde00c6b4e9980b186efe4442c76-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5f5cde00c6b4e9980b186efe4442c76-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5f5cde00c6b4e9980b186efe4442c76-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5f5cde00c6b4e9980b186efe4442c76-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5f5cde00c6b4e9980b186efe4442c76-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5f5cde00c6b4e9980b186efe4442c76-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5f5cde00c6b4e9980b186efe4442c76-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5f5cde00c6b4e9980b186efe4442c76-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5f5cde00c6b4e9980b186efe4442c76-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5f5cde00c6b4e9980b186efe4442c76-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5f5cde00c6b4e9980b186efe4442c76-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Andriy Zhelnov had his leg amputated just below the knee. He received compensation for his injury and, in his own words, spent the money “on all sorts of nonsense.” The Russian authorities gave him housing as a child left without parental care and continue to help him as someone who fought in the war in Ukraine: he receives social benefits and vouchers for sanatorium stays. Andriy has thought about returning to the war but has not yet found a way to get to the front with such an injury. He doesn’t know what to do next.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At the time of publication, Pavlo Yeremeyev is still on the front lines. “I’ve worked my way up from an ordinary reconnaissance soldier to a drone pilot. I have two state awards — one for courage, the other for saving lives — and three ministry awards,” he said.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"When asked why he hadn’t gone to work in his field after college, Yeremeyev said it was pointless: “You know, these are the times we’re living in... Being a soldier gives you status. For example, having trained as an auto mechanic, I wouldn’t be able to join the Interior Ministry or any of the intelligence and security agencies. But right now, that wouldn’t be a problem for me at all. I didn’t give myself any other option; I had a goal, and I achieved it.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Still, he sees no sense in continuing the war. “Of course, it has to end — people aren’t made of iron. People want to be home, soldiers just like me. So many people have already died. Many mothers are left without their sons, sons without their fathers, wives without their husbands, and children without their parents. My opinion is that it’s better to end it as it is and sign a peace agreement,” Pavlo said, adding: “In any case, victory will be ours, because we have the truth on our side.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>“Just went and signed the contract”</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"“General disposition: even-tempered, positive, non-confrontational; self-esteem: adequate; calm, reserved, friendly, reasonable.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A profile with this description was uploaded to Russia’s database of orphans in October 2022. The photo shows Kyrylo P. (Kirill in Russian), a tall, brown-eyed teenager with light brown hair, available for adoption or guardianship.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Four years later, the same young man posted new photos on VKontakte, a Russian social network: he stands in a trench under a camouflage net, an assault rifle slung around his neck and his call sign written in marker on the sling.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“I’m on the front lines,” Kyrylo told Verstka. “When I turned 18, I waited two more months to get my college diploma, and then right away I just went and signed [the military contract]. I’m serving in an evacuation unit on the Zaporizhzhia front.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Before going to war, Kyrylo was studying to be an auto mechanic and worked part-time at a car wash in a small town in one of the Volga regions. He ended up there in 2022, after the children of Donetsk Boarding School No. 1 were taken to Russia: first south, to a camp on the Sea of Azov, and then to orphanages across the country, wherever there was room.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“When they told us we were leaving Donetsk, a TV crew came, filmed us for a while, and said we were going to Rostov-on-Don for a month. ‘You’ll live there until things calm down,’ they said. But in the end, things didn’t calm down,” Kyrylo said. He told Verstka he liked his new home better.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19850,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Collage: IStories","caption":"","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83b394214eb6481dba038ce50d6c8ba7-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83b394214eb6481dba038ce50d6c8ba7-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83b394214eb6481dba038ce50d6c8ba7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83b394214eb6481dba038ce50d6c8ba7-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83b394214eb6481dba038ce50d6c8ba7-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83b394214eb6481dba038ce50d6c8ba7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83b394214eb6481dba038ce50d6c8ba7-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83b394214eb6481dba038ce50d6c8ba7-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83b394214eb6481dba038ce50d6c8ba7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83b394214eb6481dba038ce50d6c8ba7-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83b394214eb6481dba038ce50d6c8ba7-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83b394214eb6481dba038ce50d6c8ba7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83b394214eb6481dba038ce50d6c8ba7-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83b394214eb6481dba038ce50d6c8ba7-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83b394214eb6481dba038ce50d6c8ba7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83b394214eb6481dba038ce50d6c8ba7-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83b394214eb6481dba038ce50d6c8ba7-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83b394214eb6481dba038ce50d6c8ba7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"“Of course, it’s better in Russia. Say, in Donetsk there was a war going on, and there was never any water — none at all. They’d turn it on once a week for two or three hours. Donetsk had just seceded from Ukraine back then, and there was nowhere to get budget money from,” he reasoned.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Kyrylo was placed in a boarding school because his mother was ill and couldn’t look after him. His father, he said, had fought “in the militia” — the pro-Russian separatist forces — since 2015 and was killed in 2022. His mother is no longer alive either. He has an older sister, who also moved to Russia and now lives not far from him. Kyrylo didn’t tell her about his decision to go to war.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"He “had been thinking about serving since he was 16,” and when he graduated from college, he simply “went, signed, and left.” Kyrylo was wounded at the front. According to him, a drone carrying a shaped charge “hit him in the back.” He then spent two months “in and out of hospitals” and another two months on leave at home in the Volga region. Once the war ends, he would like a “quiet and peaceful life.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Like all the guys who came back from the war [on leave], Kyrylo invited us out for drinks,” said his friend Artem, who had been at the same boarding school in Donetsk Oblast. “We went to the bathhouse and grilled kebabs. I said, ‘Bro, can I come with you too? Everything’s driving me crazy — nothing’s going right for me, basically.’ [He] tried to talk me out of it, of course. He even started swearing at me.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>“You’re from Donetsk, you’re not like us”</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Hearing a drone, Artem moved the phone away from his ear. “Just a second,” he said, asking the Verstka reporter to wait. “OK, it’s down. It fell without detonating. If you hit the explosive, it’ll detonate, but if you hit a blade, it might just fall.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Artem followed Kyrylo to war, and now, he said, they are holding positions about 10 kilometers apart.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Asked by Verstka whether he regretted signing the contract, Artem said that “everyone regretted it.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“But who cares? Well, like, I wanted to stand up for Donetsk. Just so that all sorts of guys wouldn’t come there and take everything we have. The war will end anyway, and whether it’s soon or not, that’s not up to us to decide,” Artem reflected. “We were told to defend, and let them figure out the rest themselves. But it’s like everyone’s already fed up with it. We’re tired — very, very tired.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Like many other former students of Donetsk Oblast boarding schools, Artem didn’t know that Kyiv had been demanding the return of orphans taken to Russia from the occupied territories. He doesn’t understand what the dispute is about.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Kyiv has no right to speak,” he said. “Donetsk belongs to Russia, in theory. And Russian flags were hanging at our boarding school, too, for as long as I can remember.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Artem and Kyrylo grew up together: first they were classmates at the boarding school in Donetsk, and then, when the orphans were taken to Russia and sent to institutions across the country, they ended up in the same city.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Everything went sideways,” Artem said, recalling 2022. “The hardest part was losing my circle of friends. I’d known some of the kids for seven or eight years — since we were babies. And then — just like that — they separate us. We arrived at some new, unfamiliar place. Everyone was looking at us, like, ‘You’re from Donetsk, you’re not like us.’ Then I faced what they call bullying. We still have an accent, of course — we might say ‘sho’ [instead of the Russian ‘shto,’ for ‘what’]. Because of that, they called us — excuse my language — ‘fucking Khokhols’ [a slur for Ukrainians]. That stressed me out a lot. And technically, my passport is Russian.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Artem has no close relatives left: his grandmother, grandfather, and father have died, and his mother abandoned him in early childhood. In Russia, he completed ninth grade and enrolled in college, but tried to make money instead of studying: first as a “fetch-and-carry” farmhand, then as a tiler in private homes and as a rotational worker on a construction site in Moscow. He remembers the capital for Patriarch Ponds, where “there’s always something going on.” “We’d hang out, look at all the expensive cars we couldn’t afford, take pictures with some of them — they would even let us sit in them,” he said.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"When Artem turned 18, he was expelled from college and started looking into the conditions of service in the war. A client whose private house he was tiling unexpectedly took an interest in his future.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“She said, ‘I’ll do what’s best for you. I’ll find you a decent job where they pay well.’ She bought me a train ticket to Ryazan, and I took the train there and went to sign [the contract] with the drone [forces],” Artem said.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Verstka asked Artem whether he knew that recruiters act in their own financial interest. He replied that the woman “probably got her cut” for him, but that he had since lost touch with her.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Once at war, Artem was “stationed at a defensive position” <em>(as part of a combat group holding a captured position. — Editor’s note)</em> and learned to tell by sound which drone was coming from where. Six months into his service, he was struck by a “Baba Yaga”<span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"a heavy Ukrainian drone that drops munitions on positions\"></span> heavy bomber drone while in a dugout at night. At first, he lay in the hospital “like a cucumber” — meaning he couldn’t get up or move.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19851,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Collage: IStories","caption":"","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fd401d1eacd44cee8caded1c74a01c6f-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fd401d1eacd44cee8caded1c74a01c6f-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fd401d1eacd44cee8caded1c74a01c6f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fd401d1eacd44cee8caded1c74a01c6f-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fd401d1eacd44cee8caded1c74a01c6f-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fd401d1eacd44cee8caded1c74a01c6f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fd401d1eacd44cee8caded1c74a01c6f-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fd401d1eacd44cee8caded1c74a01c6f-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fd401d1eacd44cee8caded1c74a01c6f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fd401d1eacd44cee8caded1c74a01c6f-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fd401d1eacd44cee8caded1c74a01c6f-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fd401d1eacd44cee8caded1c74a01c6f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fd401d1eacd44cee8caded1c74a01c6f-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fd401d1eacd44cee8caded1c74a01c6f-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fd401d1eacd44cee8caded1c74a01c6f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fd401d1eacd44cee8caded1c74a01c6f-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fd401d1eacd44cee8caded1c74a01c6f-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fd401d1eacd44cee8caded1c74a01c6f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"“There’s just a lot to read here,” Artem said, looking over his hospital discharge summary. “The worst part was the ruptured spleen and contusions of all my internal organs. My legs stopped working, my spine went numb. There were problems with my eardrums, I temporarily lost vision in my right eye, I had second- and third-degree burns, a closed chest injury with lung contusions, some kind of tracheitis, all sorts of nonsense, basically. A severe concussion; I lost my memory for a while. What else? A brain contusion, a closed head injury — and that’s about it.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After rehabilitation at several hospitals, Artem returned to the front and now serves at checkpoints. During his few years in Russia, he realized he saw no future for himself in the country, neither in the region he had been moved to nor in Moscow, where “it’s all spoiled brats.” In that region, he said, he bought a one-room apartment with his military pay. “Just let them tell me, ‘It’s all over’ — I’d hop on my motorcycle and head to the boarding school in Donetsk.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>“I simply have nothing to lose”</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"“Off to the front tomorrow. Some guy told us there were 26 of them heading to the positions, but only four made it. And even those got fucked up by mortar fire.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Fuck.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Off to pack my stuff.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The messages are from Dmytro Kushkovoy (Dmitry in Russian; Dima to his friends), an 18-year-old contract soldier getting ready for a “combat mission.” Like Pavlo Yeremeyev and Andriy Zhelnov, he is a former student of the Amvrosiivka boarding school, a large institution for orphans 70 kilometers from Donetsk. In February 2022, the school’s children were moved to Kursk Oblast; Dmytro stayed there and studied at a polytechnic college. After graduating, he began thinking about joining the fighting.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"First he joined chats for fighters of the Wagner mercenary group. At least three times, he asked whether he could get into Russia’s Africa Corps, which replaced Wagner in Africa, before reaching the minimum age of 22.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Please tell me how I can get to Africa at 18,” he wrote in the “White Uncles” Telegram group. Other members mocked his question: they suggested he buy a “tour package” and asked “what the fuck” a teenager wanted with “shooting games.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Kushkovoy then considered joining the war, but again found no support.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“I told him, ‘It’s better to just do your army service and come back.’ We all tried to talk him out of it, but it was no use. He liked the military uniform and everything related to war,” Svetlana, his ex-girlfriend, told Verstka. According to her, they met at a children’s shelter and had been together for about two years. But after he decided to go to war, they broke up for good.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“The guys and I tried to talk him out of it, but he still stood his ground,” said Lesha, his friend and classmate, who grew up with him at the boarding school.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The two grew close shortly before leaving Amvrosiivka for Russia. They shared the food their relatives brought them, were roped together during “partner rock climbing,” hung out, and “looked out for each other.” In Kursk Oblast, they were assigned to the same college, which offered “government-funded support.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In the fall of 2025, when Dima wrote to Lesha that he was already gathering documents to sign a contract, they met up and went motorbike riding all night long.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“It was a funny situation,” Lesha told Verstka. “We drove to a quarry — it’s a motocross track. I told him, ‘Let me do a burnout.’ That’s when the vehicle’s standing still and the rear wheels are spinning. He handed me his motorcycle, I squeezed the front brakes, but they failed, and I landed face-first in the bushes. I’m lying there, and he comes running over to me: ‘Lekha, are you nuts?’ We’re just standing there, giggling. Two or three weeks later, I texted him: ‘How’s it going? What’s new?’ And he replies: ‘Taking it easy, serving on contract.’ So I text back: ‘Oh, you idiot...’”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"They were messaging each other on November 5, 2025, ahead of the assault. Lesha sent Verstka a screenshot of their conversation.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Are you saying you regret it yourself?” Lesha asked.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“No. I simply have nothing to lose — I don’t give a fuck. I like it here,” Dima replied.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"He left for the assault and never came online again.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19852,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Collage: IStories","caption":"","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f4a9deea58d14e3c94f2bb515f2ba921-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f4a9deea58d14e3c94f2bb515f2ba921-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f4a9deea58d14e3c94f2bb515f2ba921-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f4a9deea58d14e3c94f2bb515f2ba921-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f4a9deea58d14e3c94f2bb515f2ba921-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f4a9deea58d14e3c94f2bb515f2ba921-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f4a9deea58d14e3c94f2bb515f2ba921-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f4a9deea58d14e3c94f2bb515f2ba921-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f4a9deea58d14e3c94f2bb515f2ba921-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f4a9deea58d14e3c94f2bb515f2ba921-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f4a9deea58d14e3c94f2bb515f2ba921-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f4a9deea58d14e3c94f2bb515f2ba921-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f4a9deea58d14e3c94f2bb515f2ba921-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f4a9deea58d14e3c94f2bb515f2ba921-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f4a9deea58d14e3c94f2bb515f2ba921-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f4a9deea58d14e3c94f2bb515f2ba921-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f4a9deea58d14e3c94f2bb515f2ba921-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f4a9deea58d14e3c94f2bb515f2ba921-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"According to his ex-girlfriend and relatives, the soldier has been listed as missing in action since November 27, 2025. His loved ones have been trying to get more detailed information from the Defense Ministry, but his status hasn’t been updated for a year.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“I tried to look for him; I called the military enlistment offices both here in Donetsk and in Kursk. They said he was missing in action,” Dima’s great-aunt Olga told Verstka. “I’ve known him since he was a child. They just wouldn’t let me [become his guardian] when he had no one left, because I’m disabled and walk on crutches. His mother died of cancer, then his grandfather died, and his grandmother had died even earlier.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Of course, there’s no exact information about his death. No one will tell me, since on paper I’m nobody to him. But through personal connections, I managed to find out that he’s on the list of those killed,” said Svetlana, Dima’s ex-girlfriend. “As far as I know, his body hasn’t been recovered — it’s near Kharkiv. We had been together for two years; it was very hard for me, but I still hope he’ll come back.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In July 2026, Lesha put a photo that Dima had sent him shortly before the assault into a frame with a black ribbon and posted an obituary for his friend in his Telegram channel.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“May you rest in peace, bro. It’s a shame you passed away at such a young age, but even though you’re not physically here with us, know that you’re in our memories and in our hearts. You were a good kid, but you made the wrong choice, and that choice killed you. ... So long, brother — may the clouds be soft beneath you; sooner or later, we’ll meet again anyway. You’re our hero; you gave your life for us.”</em>","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":11117,"header":"Lima – Donbas Express. How Russia Recruits Peru Nationals to Go to War","_path":"/en/stories/2026/10/28/lima-donbas/","lead":"IStories and La Encerrona podcast retrace the route used to send people from Peru to fight in the war against Ukraine","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":266,"real_height_2x":533},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":266,"real_height_2x":533},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-original.jpg","real_width_1x":199,"real_width_2x":399,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a9b358bae4614f42ad64c64a80bc4823-original.jpg","real_width_1x":199,"real_width_2x":399,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Picture: IStories. Photo: Shutterstock","created_at_date":"2026-10-28","created_at_date_time":"2026-10-27T21:33:18.951Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":61,"first_name":"Егор","last_name":"Феоктистов","first_name_en":"Egor","last_name_en":"Feoktistov","is_public":true,"_path":"egor-feoktistov","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Автор дата-отдела «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[{"id":375,"first_name":"Эля","last_name":"Новопашенная","first_name_en":"Elya","last_name_en":"Novopashennaya","company":"","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":2}],"editors_list":[{"id":31,"first_name":"Катя","last_name":"Бонч-Осмоловская","first_name_en":"Katya","last_name_en":"Bonch-Osmolovskaya","is_public":true,"_path":"katya-bonch-osmolovskaya","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.jpeg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.jpeg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.jpeg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.jpeg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редакторка дата-отдела","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":null,"ordering":1}],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[{"id":13,"first_name":"Соня","last_name":"Савина","first_name_en":"Sonya","last_name_en":"Savina","is_public":true,"_path":"sonya-savina","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Если вы хотите рассказать мне свою историю, пишите на почту sonya.savina@istories.media.","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":"Author","ordering":1}],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"“Please, Karina, don’t tell my mum about this — I don’t want her to get even more worried. I’m just asking you to pray — just like we do — for our safe return home, because only a miracle can put an end to this war between the two countries,” wrote Jesús Chiarella, a Peruvian, to his wife shortly before he went missing in action in the war against Ukraine.\n\nIn March 2026, Jesús, along with other Peruvians, found himself at the frontlines fighting for the Russian army. According to the Peruvian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, a total of more than 450 Peruvian citizens joined the Russian Armed Forces. Before travelling to Russia, many were unaware that they would be taking part in combat operations.\n\nJesús Chiarella, like several other Peruvians, signed the military contract in the Bashkir town of Meleuz. Local authorities there pay recruiters for every new enlistee.\n\nIStories and La Encerrona, a Peruvian podcast, have retraced the route used to send people from Latin America to the war against Ukraine by a network of traffickers. Its main hub was found to be the Russian city of Ufa, where a recruitment centre specialising in foreigners is still operating.\n\nJobs in Russia\n\nArturo Rengifo, 55, learnt about the opportunity to earn money in Russia from a friend. At the time, Arturo was working as a security guard at a mining facility, but the work was unstable, meanwhile in Russia he would be offered 2,800 euros a month and 20,000 euros upon signing the contract. Arturo told his wife that the job for the “Russian government” involved nothing but “guarding containers.”\nArturo, like many Peruvians who applied for the job in Russia, had experience working in Peru’s security forces. His unit in the national police specialized in mine clearance, including the mines left from the conflict between the Peruvian authorities and the “Sendero Luminoso” Maoist group in the 1980s and 1990s.\n\nArturo and his friend were recruited by Iván Díaz, a Peruvian national nicknamed VIZIO. According to the documents shared by their relatives, Díaz was involved in the recruitment of at least seven Peruvians who ended up in the Russian Armed Forces. According to a source at La Encerrona, Iván Díaz is wanted by the Peruvian authorities.\n\nIn his tax return documentation Díaz stated that he was involved in “maintaining public order and security.” On his WhatsApp profile, however, Díaz would describe himself as a military lawyer and explicitly state being involved in recruiting Latin Americans into the Russian army. He was active on social media — Instagram, Facebook and TikTok — where he urged his followers to travel to Russia as volunteers. Some of Diaz’s videos had tens of thousands of views. All his social media accounts have now been deleted.\nArturo’s wife claims that Diaz deceived the Peruvians: “This man gave our relatives completely false information, as the contracts they signed state something entirely different.” The Peruvians were forced to sign their military contracts in Russian, a language they did not understand.\n\nRelatives of other Peruvian citizens have also complained about being deceived by the recruiters: some of those who ended up at the frontline had been promised security guards positions at military facilities without taking part in the combat, whereas some had been promised work as drone operators far from the front line, or even a job of a cook.\n\nJesús Chiarella, 45, flew to Russia with two other Peruvians just two weeks after Arturo’s departure. Before travelling to Russia, he had worked in the prison system for more than ten years. In the 2000s, Jesús served in the Peruvian army, guarding the US embassy in Iraq. In Russia, according to his wife, he was offered a similar job — an embassy guard. When his friend told him about the opportunity to earn some extra money, he agreed without a second thought.\nLima to Istanbul to Moscow\nAt least two groups of Peruvians flew to Russia from Lima. One, which included Arturo, departed on February 17; the other, which included Jesús, on March 3. The first group’s route passed through Amsterdam and Istanbul, whilst the second’s went via São Paulo, Rome and Istanbul. To ensure the future recruits passed through border control successfully, the traffickers bought them return tickets and devised a cover story, according to which Peruvians were travelling to Europe as tourists.\n\nThe group Chiarella was in was detained at São Paulo airport for two days due to not having return tickets. The agents had to buy those at short notice, and only then were the Peruvians allowed to board a flight to Rome. By the time the group reached Turkey, a detailed itinerary of their tour of the country had already been prepared to be shown to the local border officials. The tour included a visit to Hagia Sophia and a hammam in Istanbul, a helicopter flight across the Bosphorus and a romantic hot-air balloon ride in Cappadocia — all of it for the group of three men.\nIn Moscow, the volunteers from Peru no longer needed to maintain their cover story. The FSB border service at Vnukovo Airport knew in advance that the Peruvians were travelling to Russia to be selected for military service. This is evident from a request sent to the airport’s border control by Sergei Rodinko, the head of the contract recruitment centre in Ufa. The basis for entering Russia was cited as the presidential decree which lets foreigners obtain a Russian residence permit and citizenship via a simplified procedure after contracting with the Russian Armed Forces.\n\nSergei Rodinko told the IStories journalists he had never heard about any documents sent to the Vnukovo border control. A similar request from the Ufa recruitment centre — but this time to the border guards at a different airport, the Zhukovsky — has been made public in an investigation by RCN, a Colombian television company. The published request reportedly includes the names of two Peruvians and eight Colombians.\nThe same border control request from Ufa mentions the name of an ‘authorised representative for recruitment assistance’, Azamat Ashkhotov, a resident of the town of Terek in the Kabardino-Balkaria region who was due to meet the Peruvians at the airport. Another group was accompanied by yet another native of Terek, Alim Gidov. The leaked documents we were able to find contain no information about their links to the Russian army, but they indicate that Gidov had previously worked for a utility company in Terek, whilst Ashkhotov has been working as a taxi driver in recent years.\n\nWhen a family member of a Peruvian recruit asked Gidov about what had happened to their relative, he replied: “I just met them and put them on a plane! <...> The man they were going to see rang me, and [I] put them on a plane. That’s all I know, brother.”\nAlim Gidov and Azamat Ashkhotov did not respond to our questions.\n\nA tutor from Ecuador\nThe tickets to Istanbul for the group that included Jesus were booked through Euro Talent Solutions, a Colombian company which also has a registered legal entity in Poland.\n\nEuro Talent Solutions’ main area of business is helping South American nationals secure jobs in Poland and other European Union countries. On the company’s website and its social media pages, one can find such jobs as a driver in Lithuania, a warehouse assistant in Poland and a tiler in Montenegro. The agency has been operating for over two years and publishes photos of people who have found work in Europe with their help.\n\nA representative of Euro Talent Solutions, who asked to remain anonymous, confirmed that the company had worked with Ivan Díaz and, at his request, purchased tickets for 18 Peruvians. It had also booked hotels, arranged insurance and prepared its clients for their flights. However, the representative claims that the company had been “initially unaware” that the final destination on their itinerary was meant to be Russia.\nFar more than 18 people may have been sent to Russia via Diaz. According to our source, Diaz would also work with other travel agencies and send “30–40 people a month.”\n\nThe Euro Talent Solutions representative explained that at one point he realised that the company’s clients were being sent to join the Russian army from some details in a chat group discussing travel preparations. He then decided to contact the Colombian law enforcement authorities.\n\nThe main organizer of this recruitment scheme is an “Eduardo from Ecuador”, a “translator for the Russian government,” the Euro Talent Solutions representative says. Eduardo was the one who paid Iván Díaz and other intermediaries to recruit Latin Americans.\n\nAccording to the Euro Talent Solutions employee we spoke to, Eduardo soon began threatening him: “I received death threat calls from various numbers: they said I should just do my job — sell tickets, and that’s it — and that there was no need for me to say anything.” According to them, the company had terminated its collaboration with Iván Díaz and Eduardo by May 2026.\nDíaz himself told the company what he was actually doing. On one occasion, he complained about Eduardo because he had “let him down over money and commissions.” “I asked: ‘What commissions are you talking about?’ — ‘Well, to be honest, I’m working here as a recruiter for the army. I’ve got an Interpol warrant out for me at the moment,’” recounts the Euro Talent Solutions employee.\n\nAccording to Diaz, the “Russian government translator” would pay him $400 for each person recruited, as revealed by correspondence available to IStories. Euro Talent Solutions also received money from Eduardo, but not at a fixed rate — it depended on the cost of the “tour package,” which was constantly changing.\n\nIStories has identified the organizer behind the scheme used to recruit Colombians and Peruvians. His full name is Eduardo Jaime Torres Jara, he is 29 and is from Ecuador. He is now residing in Belgorod, Russia, where he graduated from Belgorod State University with an international relations degree.\nPhotos of Eduardo Torres match the image of the scheme organizer obtained by IStories. A WhatsApp account nicknamed “Interpretación y traducción Logística internacional Logística bélica (Interpreting and Translation, International Logistics, Military Logistics)” is registered to Eduardo Torres’s number. “Join the Russian army today!”, the profile description reads. A user with the same nickname was distributing instructions in the group chat Jesús Chiarella was in.\n\nImperial International Group, a Colombian company that, according to the Euro Talent Solutions representative, booked flights through his firm, also acknowledged contacts with Eduardo Torres. According to Imperial, the only person who worked with Torres was a former employee who had been dismissed for misconduct.\n\nBased on Eduardo’s messages in public Telegram groups, he began recruiting for the Russian army in June 2025. He posted his first messages in the chat groups for Latin Americans living in European countries; later, he tried to find people willing to go to war in a chat group for Africans living in Russia.\n\nAs early as May 2026, Eduardo was looking for “people living in Madrid who know the city well — for work (nothing illegal!).” He offered 1,000 euros a month for this work. It is not known how much Eduardo himself received for each person he brought to Russia. Alongside his war recruitment activity, he continued to search for language students.\n\nEduardo did not respond to IStories’ questions.\n\nMoscow to Ufa to Meleuz to Ukraine\nOn February 20, 2026, the first group, consisting of four Peruvians, landed in Ufa, the capital of a relatively remote Russian region of Bashkortostan. That same day, they underwent a medical examination and traveled by car to Meleuz, a city three hours’ drive from Ufa.\nThere, all the Peruvians were registered at the same apartment in a nine-story building and enrolled in the migration and military registries. The unusual route may be explained by how much money the recruiters were getting in Meleuz for each person sent to war: the amount of money the recruiters are paid depends on the regulations in each region.\n\nBack then, several places in the Republic of Bashkortostan were offering recruiters a reward of 400,000 rubles (about $5,000) per person, while its regional capital, Ufa, didn’t introduce the same measure until late March. In 2025 alone, 84.7 million rubles (about $1 million) from the Meleuz District budget were spent on the payments to the recruiting intermediaries. For 2026, the authorities had allocated another 64 million rubles (about $800,000) for the same purpose. \nIt is unknown who exactly received the payment for the soldiers from Peru. IStories obtained the photos of blank application forms the Peruvians had signed. It is likely that the recruiters would fill in their own details later in order to claim the bonuses for organizing the process.\nThe groups from Peru would stay in Meleuz for several days, and they received their bank cards there. Arturo Rengifo’s group returned from Meleuz to Ufa and checked into the \"Defender” center. This is a mobile recruitment center for contract soldiers which was established in 2024 at a children’s health camp called “Cheremushki.” It offers a streamlined process for all the checks and procedures needed to go to war — a “one-stop shop” check completed within 24 hours. In addition, recruits are promised a cafeteria, a checkers club, a barbershop, and a photo booth there — all designed to create “the most favorable atmosphere possible, so that this important stage in every soldier’s life proceeds with minimal stress and maximum benefit.”\nThere, the Peruvians passed medical examinations and took an intensive 16-hour Russian language course from the Center for Advanced Professional Training (TSOPP) of the Republic of Bashkortostan. The center received 12,000 rubles (about $150) for training the three foreign contract soldiers. \n\nThey were not the first foreigners at the “Defender” center. A year before they arrived in Ufa, “Gorobzor”, a local newspaper, reported on a native of Ghana who went to the center to sign a military contract as well: “I’ve been in Russia for about three years now. I have family here. <...> Russia has been good to me all the time I’ve lived here. The Russians I worked with were very kind, so it’s time for me to support Russia, too,” he said.\n\nThe Peruvian recruits did not stay long at the training center: by early March, Arturo Rengifo was already in the Rostov Oblast, in Novoshakhtinsk — a city 1,700 km from Ufa very close to the border with the Luhansk Oblast, a Russia-occupied region of Ukraine. From there, he informed his wife that he was “in a bunker, guarding weapons, and preparing to undergo training.” This was the last location known to his family. That was the point the contact with him was lost.\n\nJesús’s wife, Karina, also lost contact with her husband just as quickly. Jesús described his route in detail and told her that he had received 400,000 rubles (about $5,000) for signing the military contract. He sent his wife all the necessary documents in case he died. “Go to the Russian embassy and demand, first of all, my remains if there is no news of me within three months. Second, demand the death benefit, which you can use to buy a house or anything else you want,” he wrote to her shortly before he went missing\n\nIn mid-April, Jesús stopped responding; prior to that, his phone had been in Kozhevna, a border village in the Donetsk Oblast. As Karina learned later, her husband had been listed as missing in action since May 4, 2026. He had spent less than three weeks on the front lines.\n\nHuman traffickers\nArturo and Jesús are not the only Peruvian citizens who ended up on the front lines in the spring of 2026. According to the local Ministry of Foreign Affairs, more than 450 people joined the ranks of the Russian army, and 31 of them have been successfully evacuated from Russia. One of the lawyers representing the affected families believes the scale of recruitment is much larger, and more than 1,000 people from Peru are fighting as part of the Russian Armed Forces.\n\nIn May, the Peruvian prosecutor’s office specializing in combating human trafficking began investigating these cases. Currently, Peruvian prosecutors are conducting 21 investigations into Russia-related human trafficking cases, with another investigation related to organized crime allegations. More than 300 people are listed as victims in these cases.\nTwo alleged traffickers have already been arrested in Peru. One of them, a 54-year-old retired military officer Pocho Pinto, offered his compatriots jobs guarding a Russian military facility and promised that the recruits would not be sent to the front lines. “If they signed a contract in a language they do not understand, that constitutes grounds for a crime, namely, fraud,” said Luisa Kispé, the prosecutor.\n\nRussian authorities deny the fraudulent recruitment for the war allegations. In August, the Russian Embassy in Peru claimed that all the Peruvians who had signed the military contracts had been “informed of the terms of the document, the conditions of military service and the associated risks, as well as of the rights and obligations of the parties.”\n\nAmnesty International proposed that foreigners fraudulently recruited into the Russian army should be considered victims of human trafficking. “There is no doubt <...> that the Russian authorities have at the very least created and facilitated an enabling environment for the abusive recruitment practices — and knowingly benefited from these to boost their armed forces,” the report states.\n\nThe recruitment campaign is still on \nThe recruiting campaign is going on in Ufa. It is run by the “Central Headquarters for the Formation of Volunteer Battalions” (TSSCHFDB). It targets Latin America (Peru, Panama, Mexico, Colombia, Ecuador, Argentina), Southeast Asia (Cambodia, Myanmar, Indonesia, the Philippines), Africa (Botswana, Zimbabwe), and the CIS (Belarus, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan) nationals.\nUntil the summer of 2026, one of the websites featured an offer for intermediaries: “If the candidate pays for their own ticket, you receive $1,000. If you simply arrange for a person to participate, and we have to cover all expenses (including the ticket), your bonus is $150. It’s easy to work with us—you bring in people, and we take care of everything else.” This announcement has since been removed.\n\nIn January 2026, the headquarters also distributed a blacklist of countries whose citizens were prohibited from joining the Russian army. Several sources reported on this ban, including a British national Ben Stimson, who trains foreign mercenaries for the Russian Army, as previously noted by IStories.\n\nUntil March 2026, the organization's Telegram channel would publish photos and videos of the foreigners who had arrived in Ufa to sign contracts with the Russian Armed Forces. We were able to identify some of them using open sources.\nEdwin Díaz, a Colombian, appeared in a video released by the headquarters in late January 2026, and was taken captive a month later. Then he explained that he had come to Russia for work but was later forcibly sent to fight in the ranks of the Russian army.\n\nRelatives were searching for another Colombian, John Velez, after they lost contact with him in September 2025. In a photo taken at least a month earlier, he is standing near the airport in Ufa.\n\nSeveral photos of foreigners were taken near the “Defender” center — the same place where a group of Peruvians, including Arturo Rengifo, were living. In one of the photos, the recruits are sitting in a classroom. “Every day they study the Russian language and the history of our country, study the military disciplines, and train at sports facilities,” the organization’s Telegram channel states. The sports facilities where the foreigners exercise are also located on the premises of the “Defender” center, as confirmed by IStories.\nWhile the Central Headquarters’ Telegram channel is inactive, its TikTok account — with nearly 5,000 followers — is still attracting the attention of potential contract soldiers from Latin American countries. Although the channel is called “Central Headquarters Siberia,” it also posts photos of Latin American contract soldiers at the “Defender” center and other locations in Ufa. The most popular videos get tens of thousands of views and hundreds of comments, including from those claiming to be interested in coming to Russia.\n\nHowever, not everyone welcomes this kind of ads. “No, thanks, I’d rather stay alive,” a popular comment reads under one of the videos.","blocks":[{"data":"“Please, Karina, don’t tell my mum about this — I don’t want her to get even more worried. I’m just asking you to pray — just like we do — for our safe return home, because only a miracle can put an end to this war between the two countries,” wrote Jesús Chiarella, a Peruvian, to his wife shortly before he went missing in action in the war against Ukraine.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In March 2026, Jesús, along with other Peruvians, found himself at the frontlines fighting for the Russian army. <a href=\"https://english.elpais.com/international/2026-08-22/peruvians-trapped-in-russias-war-by-a-job-promise-theyre-taking-us-as-cannon-fodder.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">According</a> to the Peruvian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, a total of more than 450 Peruvian citizens joined the Russian Armed Forces. Before travelling to Russia, many were unaware that they would be taking part in combat operations.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Jesús Chiarella, like several other Peruvians, signed the military contract in the Bashkir town of Meleuz. Local authorities there pay recruiters for every new enlistee.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories and La Encerrona, a Peruvian <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5JhdqB5v1Fo\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">podcast</a>, have retraced the route used to send people from Latin America to the war against Ukraine by a network of traffickers. Its main hub was found to be the Russian city of Ufa, where a recruitment centre specialising in foreigners is still operating.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Jobs in Russia","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Arturo Rengifo, 55, learnt about the opportunity to earn money in Russia from a friend. At the time, Arturo was working as a security guard at a mining facility, but the work was unstable, meanwhile in Russia he would be offered 2,800 euros a month and 20,000 euros upon signing the contract. Arturo told his wife that the job for the “Russian government” involved nothing but “guarding containers.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19657,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Personal archive","caption":"Arturo Rengifo and other Peruvians on their way to Russia","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc6d62d9b994f95a40913dcc6e2d694-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc6d62d9b994f95a40913dcc6e2d694-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc6d62d9b994f95a40913dcc6e2d694-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc6d62d9b994f95a40913dcc6e2d694-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc6d62d9b994f95a40913dcc6e2d694-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc6d62d9b994f95a40913dcc6e2d694-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc6d62d9b994f95a40913dcc6e2d694-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc6d62d9b994f95a40913dcc6e2d694-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc6d62d9b994f95a40913dcc6e2d694-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc6d62d9b994f95a40913dcc6e2d694-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc6d62d9b994f95a40913dcc6e2d694-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc6d62d9b994f95a40913dcc6e2d694-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc6d62d9b994f95a40913dcc6e2d694-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc6d62d9b994f95a40913dcc6e2d694-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc6d62d9b994f95a40913dcc6e2d694-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc6d62d9b994f95a40913dcc6e2d694-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc6d62d9b994f95a40913dcc6e2d694-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc6d62d9b994f95a40913dcc6e2d694-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Arturo, like <a href=\"https://www.infobae.com/peru/2026/04/28/el-hombre-senalado-de-reclutar-y-enviar-peruanos-a-combatir-en-rusia-rompe-su-silencio-ellos-conocian-las-condiciones/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">many</a> Peruvians who applied for the job in Russia, had experience working in Peru’s security forces. His unit in the national police <a href=\"https://defentech360.com/una-jornada-con-la-division-contra-minas-de-la-policia-nacional-del-peru/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">specialized</a> in mine clearance, including the mines left from the conflict between the Peruvian authorities and the “Sendero Luminoso” Maoist group in the 1980s and 1990s.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Arturo and his friend were recruited by Iván Díaz, a Peruvian national nicknamed VIZIO. According to the documents shared by their relatives, Díaz was involved in the recruitment of at least seven Peruvians who ended up in the Russian Armed Forces. According to a source at La Encerrona, Iván Díaz is wanted by the Peruvian authorities.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In his tax return documentation Díaz stated that he was involved in “maintaining public order and security.” On his WhatsApp profile, however, Díaz would describe himself as a military lawyer and explicitly state being involved in recruiting Latin Americans into the Russian army. He was active on social media — Instagram, Facebook and TikTok — where he urged his followers to travel to Russia as volunteers. Some of Diaz’s videos had tens of thousands of views. All his social media accounts have now been deleted.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19658,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Diaz’s TikTok and WhatsApp profiles","caption":"Ivan Diaz (Vizio) didn’t have that many followers on social media, but his videos got tens of thousands of views","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/68f50c015e654ed6a997ec7ede378179-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/68f50c015e654ed6a997ec7ede378179-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/68f50c015e654ed6a997ec7ede378179-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/68f50c015e654ed6a997ec7ede378179-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/68f50c015e654ed6a997ec7ede378179-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/68f50c015e654ed6a997ec7ede378179-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/68f50c015e654ed6a997ec7ede378179-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/68f50c015e654ed6a997ec7ede378179-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/68f50c015e654ed6a997ec7ede378179-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/68f50c015e654ed6a997ec7ede378179-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/68f50c015e654ed6a997ec7ede378179-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/68f50c015e654ed6a997ec7ede378179-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/68f50c015e654ed6a997ec7ede378179-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/68f50c015e654ed6a997ec7ede378179-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/68f50c015e654ed6a997ec7ede378179-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/68f50c015e654ed6a997ec7ede378179-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/68f50c015e654ed6a997ec7ede378179-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/68f50c015e654ed6a997ec7ede378179-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Arturo’s wife claims that Diaz deceived the Peruvians: “This man gave our relatives completely false information, as the contracts they signed state something entirely different.” The Peruvians were forced to sign their military contracts in Russian, a language they did not understand.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Relatives of other Peruvian citizens have also complained about being deceived by the recruiters: some of those who ended up at the frontline had been promised security guards <a href=\"https://www.infobae.com/america/agencias/2026/08/21/prisioneros-y-estafados-el-drama-de-cientos-de-peruanos-reclutados-por-rusia-en-guerra/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">positions</a> at military facilities without taking part in the combat, whereas some had been promised work as <a href=\"https://www.yahoo.com/news/world/articles/one-peruvian-man-became-putin-040100281.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">drone operators</a> far from the front line, or even a job of a <a href=\"https://edition.cnn.com/2026/06/28/americas/russia-ukraine-peruvian-fighters-latam-intl\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">cook</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Jesús Chiarella, 45, flew to Russia with two other Peruvians just two weeks after Arturo’s departure. Before travelling to Russia, he had worked in the prison system for more than ten years. In the 2000s, Jesús served in the Peruvian army, guarding the US embassy in Iraq. In Russia, according to his wife, he was offered a similar job — an embassy guard. When his friend told him about the opportunity to earn some extra money, he agreed without a second thought.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19659,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Personal archive","caption":"Jesús Chiarella, accompanied by two Peruvians, preparing to fly to Russia","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ceaef6297ec4aaa951b2f760e43004d-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ceaef6297ec4aaa951b2f760e43004d-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ceaef6297ec4aaa951b2f760e43004d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ceaef6297ec4aaa951b2f760e43004d-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ceaef6297ec4aaa951b2f760e43004d-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ceaef6297ec4aaa951b2f760e43004d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ceaef6297ec4aaa951b2f760e43004d-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ceaef6297ec4aaa951b2f760e43004d-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ceaef6297ec4aaa951b2f760e43004d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ceaef6297ec4aaa951b2f760e43004d-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ceaef6297ec4aaa951b2f760e43004d-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ceaef6297ec4aaa951b2f760e43004d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ceaef6297ec4aaa951b2f760e43004d-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ceaef6297ec4aaa951b2f760e43004d-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ceaef6297ec4aaa951b2f760e43004d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ceaef6297ec4aaa951b2f760e43004d-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ceaef6297ec4aaa951b2f760e43004d-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ceaef6297ec4aaa951b2f760e43004d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Lima to Istanbul to Moscow","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"At least two groups of Peruvians flew to Russia from Lima. One, which included Arturo, departed on February 17; the other, which included Jesús, on March 3. The first group’s route passed through Amsterdam and Istanbul, whilst the second’s went via São Paulo, Rome and Istanbul. To ensure the future recruits passed through border control successfully, the traffickers bought them return tickets and devised a cover story, according to which Peruvians were travelling to Europe as tourists.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The group Chiarella was in was detained at São Paulo airport for two days due to not having return tickets. The agents had to buy those at short notice, and only then were the Peruvians allowed to board a flight to Rome. By the time the group reached Turkey, a detailed itinerary of their tour of the country had already been prepared to be shown to the local border officials. The tour included a visit to Hagia Sophia and a hammam in Istanbul, a helicopter flight across the Bosphorus and a romantic hot-air balloon ride in Cappadocia — all of it for the group of three men.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19661,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Personal archive","caption":"The itinerary and tickets to Istanbul prepared for the group including Chiarella ","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/14f49e5543d14faea0f59625c24b9cc3-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/14f49e5543d14faea0f59625c24b9cc3-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/14f49e5543d14faea0f59625c24b9cc3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/14f49e5543d14faea0f59625c24b9cc3-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/14f49e5543d14faea0f59625c24b9cc3-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/14f49e5543d14faea0f59625c24b9cc3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/14f49e5543d14faea0f59625c24b9cc3-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/14f49e5543d14faea0f59625c24b9cc3-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/14f49e5543d14faea0f59625c24b9cc3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/14f49e5543d14faea0f59625c24b9cc3-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/14f49e5543d14faea0f59625c24b9cc3-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/14f49e5543d14faea0f59625c24b9cc3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/14f49e5543d14faea0f59625c24b9cc3-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/14f49e5543d14faea0f59625c24b9cc3-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/14f49e5543d14faea0f59625c24b9cc3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/14f49e5543d14faea0f59625c24b9cc3-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/14f49e5543d14faea0f59625c24b9cc3-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/14f49e5543d14faea0f59625c24b9cc3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"In Moscow, the volunteers from Peru no longer needed to maintain their cover story. The FSB border service at Vnukovo Airport knew in advance that the Peruvians were travelling to Russia to be selected for military service. This is evident from a request sent to the airport’s border control by Sergei Rodinko, the head of the contract recruitment centre in Ufa. The basis for entering Russia was cited as the presidential <a href=\"http://rbc.ru/politics/05/11/2025/690b8e359a7947483435f9f8\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">decree</a> which lets foreigners obtain a Russian residence permit and citizenship via a simplified procedure after contracting with the Russian Armed Forces.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Sergei Rodinko told the IStories journalists he had never heard about any documents sent to the Vnukovo border control. A similar request from the Ufa recruitment centre — but this time to the border guards at a different airport, the Zhukovsky — has been made <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?si=ghoRmOEjciqZMWsc&amp;t=1131&amp;v=bdDRl_g3pvY&amp;feature=youtu.be\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">public </a>in an investigation by RCN, a Colombian television company. The published request reportedly includes the names of two Peruvians and eight Colombians.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19662,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Personal archive","caption":"A request from the Ufa military recruitment centre letting the Peruvians successfully pass border control at the Russian airport","isNarrow":true,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87f658780d8c4c88926c1d549d1a7297-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87f658780d8c4c88926c1d549d1a7297-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87f658780d8c4c88926c1d549d1a7297-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1438,"real_height_2x":1438},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87f658780d8c4c88926c1d549d1a7297-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87f658780d8c4c88926c1d549d1a7297-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87f658780d8c4c88926c1d549d1a7297-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1438,"real_height_2x":1438},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87f658780d8c4c88926c1d549d1a7297-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87f658780d8c4c88926c1d549d1a7297-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87f658780d8c4c88926c1d549d1a7297-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1438,"real_height_2x":1438},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87f658780d8c4c88926c1d549d1a7297-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87f658780d8c4c88926c1d549d1a7297-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87f658780d8c4c88926c1d549d1a7297-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1438,"real_height_2x":1438},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87f658780d8c4c88926c1d549d1a7297-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87f658780d8c4c88926c1d549d1a7297-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87f658780d8c4c88926c1d549d1a7297-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":552,"real_height_2x":1105},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87f658780d8c4c88926c1d549d1a7297-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87f658780d8c4c88926c1d549d1a7297-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87f658780d8c4c88926c1d549d1a7297-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":552,"real_height_2x":1105}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The same border control request from Ufa mentions the name of an ‘authorised representative for recruitment assistance’, Azamat Ashkhotov, a resident of the town of Terek in the Kabardino-Balkaria region who was due to meet the Peruvians at the airport. Another group was accompanied by yet another native of Terek, Alim Gidov. The leaked documents we were able to find contain no information about their links to the Russian army, but they indicate that Gidov had previously worked for a utility company in Terek, whilst Ashkhotov has been working as a taxi driver in recent years.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"When a family member of a Peruvian recruit asked Gidov about what had happened to their relative, he replied: “I just met them and put them on a plane! &lt;...&gt; The man they were going to see rang me, and [I] put them on a plane. That’s all I know, brother.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19663,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Personal archive","caption":"The Peruvians were met at Moscow airport to be put on a flight to Ufa","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a650546ca75b4e6fb57d641e69904c53-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a650546ca75b4e6fb57d641e69904c53-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a650546ca75b4e6fb57d641e69904c53-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a650546ca75b4e6fb57d641e69904c53-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a650546ca75b4e6fb57d641e69904c53-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a650546ca75b4e6fb57d641e69904c53-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a650546ca75b4e6fb57d641e69904c53-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a650546ca75b4e6fb57d641e69904c53-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a650546ca75b4e6fb57d641e69904c53-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a650546ca75b4e6fb57d641e69904c53-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a650546ca75b4e6fb57d641e69904c53-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a650546ca75b4e6fb57d641e69904c53-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a650546ca75b4e6fb57d641e69904c53-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a650546ca75b4e6fb57d641e69904c53-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a650546ca75b4e6fb57d641e69904c53-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a650546ca75b4e6fb57d641e69904c53-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a650546ca75b4e6fb57d641e69904c53-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a650546ca75b4e6fb57d641e69904c53-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Alim Gidov and Azamat Ashkhotov did not respond to our questions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A tutor from Ecuador","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The tickets to Istanbul for the group that included Jesus were booked through Euro Talent Solutions, a Colombian company which also has a <a href=\"https://rejestr.io/krs/1150928/euro-talent-solutions-holding\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">registered</a> legal entity in Poland.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Euro Talent Solutions’ main area of business is helping South American nationals secure jobs in Poland and other European Union countries. On the company’s <a href=\"https://www.eurotalentsolutions.com/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">website</a> and its social media pages, one can find such jobs as a driver in Lithuania, a warehouse assistant in Poland and a tiler in Montenegro. The agency has been operating for over two years and <a href=\"https://www.instagram.com/p/C_Q_ntKyrYH/?hl=en&amp;img_index=1\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">publishes</a> photos of people who have found work in Europe with their help.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A representative of Euro Talent Solutions, who asked to remain anonymous, confirmed that the company had worked with Ivan Díaz and, at his request, purchased tickets for 18 Peruvians. It had also booked hotels, arranged insurance and prepared its clients for their flights. However, the representative claims that the company had been “initially unaware” that the final destination on their itinerary was meant to be Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19664,"data":{"block":"<p>Díaz was not the only coordinator involved in this scheme. The first request to purchase tickets and organize flights came from Imperial International Group, a Colombian company, the Euro Talent Solutions employee says. Initially, the Colombian passengers were transported as ‘tourists’ via the European cities of Madrid and Paris, but, following immigration control issues, Istanbul became the main hub. Imperial International Group had allegedly claimed that the passengers would remain and work in Turkey.</p><p><br/></p><p>In total, Imperial International Group purchased 61 tickets for passengers from Colombia and El Salvador through Euro Talent Solutions. Some of those passengers were transported to the UAE and the DR Congo. Colombian media linked Imperial International to fraudulent recruitment into the Russian army: one of the victims said he had been<a href=\"https://www.semana.com/nacion/articulo/pesadilla-en-rusia-90-colombianos-estan-desaparecidos-tras-millonarias-ofertas-laborales/202616/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> promised</a> a job as a ‘human rights monitor’ in Russia, whilst another Colombian had been<a href=\"https://youtu.be/bdDRl_g3pvY?si=wBa0rVurRUQjdry-&amp;t=1062\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> lured</a> by the prospect of working as a security guard for an oil company with a “dream salary,” but he later told his wife that he had signed a contract with the Russian Armed Forces in Ufa.</p><p><br/></p><p>In response to questions from iStories and La Encerrona, Imperial International Group said it does not recruit people but selects personnel, including those “with proven military experience.” The company said it did not know the terms of the contracts and did not keep track of what happened to the candidates it had put forward.</p><p><br/></p><p>According to Imperial, the only person who had been in contact with the intermediary who sent clients to Russia was a former employee of its candidate-selection department. The company said he had been dismissed over misconduct, concealing information and negotiating on his own behalf.</p>","header":"Up to 60 more people from Colombia and El Salvador may have travelled to the war zone via the company","content":[{"insert":"Díaz was not the only coordinator involved in this scheme. The first request to purchase tickets and organize flights came from Imperial International Group, a Colombian company, the Euro Talent Solutions employee says. Initially, the Colombian passengers were transported as ‘tourists’ via the European cities of Madrid and Paris, but, following immigration control issues, Istanbul became the main hub. Imperial International Group had allegedly claimed that the passengers would remain and work in Turkey.\n\nIn total, Imperial International Group purchased 61 tickets for passengers from Colombia and El Salvador through Euro Talent Solutions. Some of those passengers were transported to the UAE and the DR Congo. Colombian media linked Imperial International to fraudulent recruitment into the Russian army: one of the victims said he had been"},{"insert":" promised","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.semana.com/nacion/articulo/pesadilla-en-rusia-90-colombianos-estan-desaparecidos-tras-millonarias-ofertas-laborales/202616/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" a job as a ‘human rights monitor’ in Russia, whilst another Colombian had been"},{"insert":" lured","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://youtu.be/bdDRl_g3pvY?si=wBa0rVurRUQjdry-&t=1062","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" by the prospect of working as a security guard for an oil company with a “dream salary,” but he later told his wife that he had signed a contract with the Russian Armed Forces in Ufa.\n\nIn response to questions from iStories and La Encerrona, Imperial International Group said it does not recruit people but selects personnel, including those “with proven military experience.” The company said it did not know the terms of the contracts and did not keep track of what happened to the candidates it had put forward.\n\nAccording to Imperial, the only person who had been in contact with the intermediary who sent clients to Russia was a former employee of its candidate-selection department. The company said he had been dismissed over misconduct, concealing information and negotiating on his own behalf.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":{"id":19665,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"","caption":"Ivan Diaz, a coordinator sending Peruvians to Russia","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/239770680302408fa9822d6c2e816748-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/239770680302408fa9822d6c2e816748-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/239770680302408fa9822d6c2e816748-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/239770680302408fa9822d6c2e816748-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/239770680302408fa9822d6c2e816748-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/239770680302408fa9822d6c2e816748-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/239770680302408fa9822d6c2e816748-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/239770680302408fa9822d6c2e816748-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/239770680302408fa9822d6c2e816748-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/239770680302408fa9822d6c2e816748-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/239770680302408fa9822d6c2e816748-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/239770680302408fa9822d6c2e816748-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/239770680302408fa9822d6c2e816748-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/239770680302408fa9822d6c2e816748-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/239770680302408fa9822d6c2e816748-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/239770680302408fa9822d6c2e816748-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/239770680302408fa9822d6c2e816748-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/239770680302408fa9822d6c2e816748-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Far more than 18 people may have been sent to Russia via Diaz. According to our source, Diaz would also work with other travel agencies and send “30–40 people a month.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Euro Talent Solutions representative explained that at one point he realised that the company’s clients were being sent to join the Russian army from some details in a chat group discussing travel preparations. He then decided to contact the Colombian law enforcement authorities.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The main organizer of this recruitment scheme is an “Eduardo from Ecuador”, a “translator for the Russian government,” the Euro Talent Solutions representative says. Eduardo was the one who paid Iván Díaz and other intermediaries to recruit Latin Americans.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to the Euro Talent Solutions employee we spoke to, Eduardo soon began threatening him: “I received death threat calls from various numbers: they said I should just do my job — sell tickets, and that’s it — and that there was no need for me to say anything.” According to them, the company had terminated its collaboration with Iván Díaz and Eduardo by May 2026.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19666,"data":{"images":[{"caption":"Eduardo Torres, 29, an Ecuadorian national responsible for recruiting Latin Americans to the war","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5a6f6d9dd33444faf935f397370ea78-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5a6f6d9dd33444faf935f397370ea78-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5a6f6d9dd33444faf935f397370ea78-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5a6f6d9dd33444faf935f397370ea78-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5a6f6d9dd33444faf935f397370ea78-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5a6f6d9dd33444faf935f397370ea78-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5a6f6d9dd33444faf935f397370ea78-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5a6f6d9dd33444faf935f397370ea78-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5a6f6d9dd33444faf935f397370ea78-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5a6f6d9dd33444faf935f397370ea78-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5a6f6d9dd33444faf935f397370ea78-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5a6f6d9dd33444faf935f397370ea78-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5a6f6d9dd33444faf935f397370ea78-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5a6f6d9dd33444faf935f397370ea78-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5a6f6d9dd33444faf935f397370ea78-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5a6f6d9dd33444faf935f397370ea78-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5a6f6d9dd33444faf935f397370ea78-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5a6f6d9dd33444faf935f397370ea78-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Díaz himself told the company what he was actually doing. On one occasion, he complained about Eduardo because he had “let him down over money and commissions.” “I asked: ‘What commissions are you talking about?’ — ‘Well, to be honest, I’m working here as a recruiter for the army. I’ve got an Interpol warrant out for me at the moment,’” recounts the Euro Talent Solutions employee.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to Diaz, the “Russian government translator” would pay him $400 for each person recruited, as revealed by correspondence available to IStories. Euro Talent Solutions also received money from Eduardo, but not at a fixed rate — it depended on the cost of the “tour package,” which was constantly changing.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories has identified the organizer behind the scheme used to recruit Colombians and Peruvians. His full name is Eduardo Jaime Torres Jara, he is 29 and is from Ecuador. He is now residing in Belgorod, Russia, where he graduated from Belgorod State University with an international relations degree.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19667,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Social media","caption":"Eduardo Torres graduated from Belgorod State University and began working as a Spanish tutor","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/22ccd41802354f4ca354312dd05eae7d-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/22ccd41802354f4ca354312dd05eae7d-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/22ccd41802354f4ca354312dd05eae7d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/22ccd41802354f4ca354312dd05eae7d-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/22ccd41802354f4ca354312dd05eae7d-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/22ccd41802354f4ca354312dd05eae7d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/22ccd41802354f4ca354312dd05eae7d-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/22ccd41802354f4ca354312dd05eae7d-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/22ccd41802354f4ca354312dd05eae7d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/22ccd41802354f4ca354312dd05eae7d-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/22ccd41802354f4ca354312dd05eae7d-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/22ccd41802354f4ca354312dd05eae7d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/22ccd41802354f4ca354312dd05eae7d-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/22ccd41802354f4ca354312dd05eae7d-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/22ccd41802354f4ca354312dd05eae7d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/22ccd41802354f4ca354312dd05eae7d-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/22ccd41802354f4ca354312dd05eae7d-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/22ccd41802354f4ca354312dd05eae7d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Photos of Eduardo Torres match the image of the scheme organizer obtained by IStories. A WhatsApp account nicknamed “Interpretación y traducción Logística internacional Logística bélica (Interpreting and Translation, International Logistics, Military Logistics)” is registered to Eduardo Torres’s number. “Join the Russian army today!”, the profile description reads. A user with the same nickname was distributing instructions in the group chat Jesús Chiarella was in.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Imperial International Group, a Colombian company that, according to the Euro Talent Solutions representative, booked flights through his firm, also acknowledged contacts with Eduardo Torres. According to Imperial, the only person who worked with Torres was a former employee who had been dismissed for misconduct.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Based on Eduardo’s messages in public Telegram groups, he began recruiting for the Russian army in June 2025. He posted his first messages in the chat groups for Latin Americans living in European countries; later, he tried to find people willing to go to war in a chat group for Africans living in Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"As early as May 2026, Eduardo was looking for “people living in Madrid who know the city well — for work (nothing illegal!).” He offered 1,000 euros a month for this work. It is not known how much Eduardo himself received for each person he brought to Russia. Alongside his war recruitment activity, he continued to search for language students.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Eduardo did not respond to IStories’ questions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Moscow to Ufa to Meleuz to Ukraine","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"On February 20, 2026, the first group, consisting of four Peruvians, landed in Ufa, the capital of a relatively remote Russian region of Bashkortostan. That same day, they underwent a medical examination and traveled by car to Meleuz, a city three hours’ drive from Ufa.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There, all the Peruvians were registered at the same apartment in a nine-story building and enrolled in the migration and military registries. The unusual route may be explained by how much money the recruiters were getting in Meleuz for each person sent to war: the amount of money the recruiters are paid depends on the regulations in each region.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Back then, several places in the Republic of Bashkortostan were offering recruiters a reward of 400,000 rubles (about $5,000) per person, while its regional capital, Ufa, didn’t <a href=\"https://gorodufa.ru/upload/iblock/bb9/oc0a3cgmscoo0jrq04qmlrz1afq425pj.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">introduce </a>the same measure until late March. In 2025 alone, 84.7 million rubles (about $1 million) from the Meleuz District budget were <a href=\"http://finance.admmeleuz.ru/index.php?option=com_content&amp;view=article&amp;id=13692:reshenie-soveta-munitsipalnogo-rajona-meleuzovskij-rajon-respubliki-bashkortostan-ot-28-maya-2026-goda-250-ob-utverzhdenii-otcheta-ob-ispolnenii-byudzheta-munitsipalnogo-rajona-meleuzovskij-rajon-respubliki-bashkortostan-za-2025god&amp;catid=939&amp;Itemid=137\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">spent </a>on the payments to the recruiting intermediaries. For 2026, the authorities had <a href=\"http://finance.admmeleuz.ru/index.php?option=com_content&amp;view=article&amp;id=13706:aktualizirovannaya-versiya-byudzheta-munitsipalnogo-rajona-meleuzovskij-rajon-rb-na-2026-god-i-na-planovyj-period-2027-i-2028-godov-na-20-08-2026&amp;catid=941&amp;Itemid=137\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">allocated </a>another 64 million rubles (about $800,000) for the same purpose. <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"It is impossible to calculate exactly how many people there are behind these amounts: the size of the payment has changed several times. But we are talking about hundreds of contract soldiers.\"></span>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19668,"data":{"block":"<p>Starting in 2024, various regions began introducing a reward system for the army recruiters. To receive the money, they must accompany a candidate to the nearest military recruitment center. The volunteer signs an application form providing their personal information and the bank details of the person who referred them.</p><p><br/></p><p>The money is paid out from either regional budgets (covering the entire region) or municipal budgets (of a district or a city).</p><p><br/></p><p>At the time when the aforementioned Peruvian nationals were recruited, only a few regions and districts would offer bigger rewards for recruiters than the Meleuz District:</p><p><br/></p><ul><li>650,000 rubles (about $8,000) in the <a href=\"https://www.saratov.kp.ru/online/news/6808099/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Atkarsky </a>District (Saratov Oblast)</li><li>574,000 rubles (about $7,000) in the <a href=\"https://www.saratov.kp.ru/online/news/6808099/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Ryazan </a>Oblast</li><li>550,000 rubles (about $7,000) in the <a href=\"https://krasnozvezdinskoe-r64.gosweb.gosuslugi.ru/dlya-zhiteley/novosti-i-reportazhi/novosti-271_3326.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Rtishchevsky </a>District (Saratov Oblast)</li><li>520,000 rubles (about $6,5,000) in the town of <a href=\"https://oktadm.ru/official-documents/section.php?SECTION_ID=1136\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Oktyabrsky </a>(Bashkortostan)</li><li>500,000 rubles (about $6,000) in the <a href=\"https://www.garant.ru/hotlaw/yaroslavl/2068649/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Yaroslavl </a>Oblast</li></ul><p><br/></p><p>In Meleuz, the payment was set at 400,000 rubles (about $5,000), and the district ranked among the leaders in terms of the amount of the payment, at the same level with the districts of <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/8459344\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Sterlitamak </a>and <a href=\"https://rg.ru/2026/07/21/reg-pfo/v-bashkirii-zhenshchina-nezakonno-poluchila-vyplatu-za-kontraktnika.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Sterlibashevo</a>.</p><p><br/></p><p>The race for recruiter bonuses in Russia is still going on. Authorities in the Irkutsk Oblast are prepared to <a href=\"https://verstka.media/irkutskaya-oblast-ustanovila-rekordnuyu-v-rossii-vyplatu-za-privlechenie-inostranczev-na-vojnu\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">pay </a>1.5 million rubles for each foreigner recruited, while the Smolensk Oblast has <a href=\"http://publication.pravo.gov.ru/document/6700202609100003\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">introduced </a>a limited-time offer: until December 1, 2026, recruiters can receive 1.1 million rubles.</p>","header":"How the referral system for contract recruitment works in Russia","content":[{"insert":"Starting in 2024, various regions began introducing a reward system for the army recruiters. To receive the money, they must accompany a candidate to the nearest military recruitment center. The volunteer signs an application form providing their personal information and the bank details of the person who referred them.\n\nThe money is paid out from either regional budgets (covering the entire region) or municipal budgets (of a district or a city).\n\nAt the time when the aforementioned Peruvian nationals were recruited, only a few regions and districts would offer bigger rewards for recruiters than the Meleuz District:\n\n650,000 rubles (about $8,000) in the "},{"insert":"Atkarsky ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.saratov.kp.ru/online/news/6808099/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"District (Saratov Oblast)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"574,000 rubles (about $7,000) in the "},{"insert":"Ryazan ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.saratov.kp.ru/online/news/6808099/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"Oblast"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"550,000 rubles (about $7,000) in the "},{"insert":"Rtishchevsky ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://krasnozvezdinskoe-r64.gosweb.gosuslugi.ru/dlya-zhiteley/novosti-i-reportazhi/novosti-271_3326.html","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"District (Saratov Oblast)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"520,000 rubles (about $6,5,000) in the town of "},{"insert":"Oktyabrsky ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://oktadm.ru/official-documents/section.php?SECTION_ID=1136","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"(Bashkortostan)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"500,000 rubles (about $6,000) in the "},{"insert":"Yaroslavl ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.garant.ru/hotlaw/yaroslavl/2068649/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"Oblast"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"\nIn Meleuz, the payment was set at 400,000 rubles (about $5,000), and the district ranked among the leaders in terms of the amount of the payment, at the same level with the districts of "},{"insert":"Sterlitamak ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/8459344","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"and "},{"insert":"Sterlibashevo","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://rg.ru/2026/07/21/reg-pfo/v-bashkirii-zhenshchina-nezakonno-poluchila-vyplatu-za-kontraktnika.html","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":".\n\nThe race for recruiter bonuses in Russia is still going on. Authorities in the Irkutsk Oblast are prepared to "},{"insert":"pay ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://verstka.media/irkutskaya-oblast-ustanovila-rekordnuyu-v-rossii-vyplatu-za-privlechenie-inostranczev-na-vojnu","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"1.5 million rubles for each foreigner recruited, while the Smolensk Oblast has "},{"insert":"introduced ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"http://publication.pravo.gov.ru/document/6700202609100003","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"a limited-time offer: until December 1, 2026, recruiters can receive 1.1 million rubles.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"It is unknown who exactly received the payment for the soldiers from Peru. IStories obtained the photos of blank application forms the Peruvians had signed. It is likely that the recruiters would fill in their own details later in order to claim the bonuses for organizing the process.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19669,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Personal archive","caption":"The blank recruiter remuneration forms signed by the Peruvians","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/935254e676dd43ba90563a78bfd5eef3-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/935254e676dd43ba90563a78bfd5eef3-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/935254e676dd43ba90563a78bfd5eef3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1543,"real_height_2x":1543},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/935254e676dd43ba90563a78bfd5eef3-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/935254e676dd43ba90563a78bfd5eef3-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/935254e676dd43ba90563a78bfd5eef3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1543,"real_height_2x":1543},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/935254e676dd43ba90563a78bfd5eef3-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/935254e676dd43ba90563a78bfd5eef3-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/935254e676dd43ba90563a78bfd5eef3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1543,"real_height_2x":1543},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/935254e676dd43ba90563a78bfd5eef3-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/935254e676dd43ba90563a78bfd5eef3-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/935254e676dd43ba90563a78bfd5eef3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1543,"real_height_2x":1543},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/935254e676dd43ba90563a78bfd5eef3-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/935254e676dd43ba90563a78bfd5eef3-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/935254e676dd43ba90563a78bfd5eef3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":593,"real_height_2x":1186},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/935254e676dd43ba90563a78bfd5eef3-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/935254e676dd43ba90563a78bfd5eef3-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/935254e676dd43ba90563a78bfd5eef3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":593,"real_height_2x":1186}]},{"isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b4b14ac04b634d0b8c4ec336f84592f8-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b4b14ac04b634d0b8c4ec336f84592f8-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b4b14ac04b634d0b8c4ec336f84592f8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1517,"real_height_2x":1517},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b4b14ac04b634d0b8c4ec336f84592f8-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b4b14ac04b634d0b8c4ec336f84592f8-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b4b14ac04b634d0b8c4ec336f84592f8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1517,"real_height_2x":1517},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b4b14ac04b634d0b8c4ec336f84592f8-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b4b14ac04b634d0b8c4ec336f84592f8-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b4b14ac04b634d0b8c4ec336f84592f8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1517,"real_height_2x":1517},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b4b14ac04b634d0b8c4ec336f84592f8-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b4b14ac04b634d0b8c4ec336f84592f8-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b4b14ac04b634d0b8c4ec336f84592f8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1517,"real_height_2x":1517},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b4b14ac04b634d0b8c4ec336f84592f8-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b4b14ac04b634d0b8c4ec336f84592f8-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b4b14ac04b634d0b8c4ec336f84592f8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":583,"real_height_2x":1166},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b4b14ac04b634d0b8c4ec336f84592f8-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b4b14ac04b634d0b8c4ec336f84592f8-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b4b14ac04b634d0b8c4ec336f84592f8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":583,"real_height_2x":1166}]}]},"category":"two-images-embed"},"type":"two-images-embed"},{"data":"The groups from Peru would stay in Meleuz for several days, and they received their bank cards there. Arturo Rengifo’s group returned from Meleuz to Ufa and checked into the \"Defender” center. This is a mobile recruitment center for contract soldiers which was established in 2024 at a children’s health camp called “Cheremushki.” It <a href=\"https://gorobzor.ru/novosti/obschestvo/203069-esli-ne-seychas-to-kogda-kak-ustroen-centr-zaschitnik-v-ufe\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">offers </a>a streamlined process for all the checks and procedures needed to go to war — a “one-stop shop” check completed within 24 hours. In addition, recruits are promised a cafeteria, a checkers club, a barbershop, and a photo booth there — all designed to create “the most favorable atmosphere possible, so that this important stage in every soldier’s life proceeds with minimal stress and maximum benefit.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19670,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Personal archive","caption":"At the “Defender” center in Ufa, the Peruvians would pass a medical examination and took a crash course in Russian before being sent to the front lines","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8877c2d5b2f6465191798f05b81b0e01-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8877c2d5b2f6465191798f05b81b0e01-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8877c2d5b2f6465191798f05b81b0e01-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8877c2d5b2f6465191798f05b81b0e01-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8877c2d5b2f6465191798f05b81b0e01-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8877c2d5b2f6465191798f05b81b0e01-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8877c2d5b2f6465191798f05b81b0e01-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8877c2d5b2f6465191798f05b81b0e01-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8877c2d5b2f6465191798f05b81b0e01-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8877c2d5b2f6465191798f05b81b0e01-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8877c2d5b2f6465191798f05b81b0e01-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8877c2d5b2f6465191798f05b81b0e01-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8877c2d5b2f6465191798f05b81b0e01-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8877c2d5b2f6465191798f05b81b0e01-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8877c2d5b2f6465191798f05b81b0e01-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8877c2d5b2f6465191798f05b81b0e01-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8877c2d5b2f6465191798f05b81b0e01-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8877c2d5b2f6465191798f05b81b0e01-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"There, the Peruvians passed medical examinations and took an intensive 16-hour Russian language course from the <a href=\"https://copp-rb.ru/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Center </a>for Advanced Professional Training (TSOPP) of the Republic of Bashkortostan. The center received 12,000 rubles (about $150) for training the three foreign contract soldiers. <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"The center runs retraining and professional development programs upgrading of qualifications in different fields: from pedagogy and office administration to courses in welding and theatrical make-up. It also offers professional orientation programs for schoolchildren.\"></span>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"They were not the first foreigners at the “Defender” center. A year before they arrived in Ufa, “Gorobzor”, a local newspaper, <a href=\"https://gorobzor.ru/novosti/obschestvo/203069-esli-ne-seychas-to-kogda-kak-ustroen-centr-zaschitnik-v-ufe\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">reported </a>on a native of Ghana who went to the center to sign a military contract as well: “I’ve been in Russia for about three years now. I have family here. &lt;...&gt; Russia has been good to me all the time I’ve lived here. The Russians I worked with were very kind, so it’s time for me to support Russia, too,” he said.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Peruvian recruits did not stay long at the training center: by early March, Arturo Rengifo was already in the Rostov Oblast, in Novoshakhtinsk — a city 1,700 km from Ufa very close to the border with the Luhansk Oblast, a Russia-occupied region of Ukraine. From there, he informed his wife that he was “in a bunker, guarding weapons, and preparing to undergo training.” This was the last location known to his family. That was the point the contact with him was lost.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Jesús’s wife, Karina, also lost contact with her husband just as quickly. Jesús described his route in detail and told her that he had received 400,000 rubles (about $5,000) for signing the military contract. He sent his wife all the necessary documents in case he died. “Go to the Russian embassy and demand, first of all, my remains if there is no news of me within three months. Second, demand the death benefit, which you can use to buy a house or anything else you want,” he wrote to her shortly before he went missing","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In mid-April, Jesús stopped responding; prior to that, his phone had been in Kozhevna, a border village in the Donetsk Oblast. As Karina learned later, her husband had been listed as missing in action since May 4, 2026. He had spent less than three weeks on the front lines.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Human traffickers","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Arturo and Jesús are not the only Peruvian citizens who ended up on the front lines in the spring of 2026. <a href=\"https://english.elpais.com/international/2026-08-22/peruvians-trapped-in-russias-war-by-a-job-promise-theyre-taking-us-as-cannon-fodder.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">According </a>to the local Ministry of Foreign Affairs, more than 450 people joined the ranks of the Russian army, and 31 of them have been successfully evacuated from Russia. One of the lawyers representing the affected families <a href=\"https://www.infobae.com/america/agencias/2026/08/21/prisioneros-y-estafados-el-drama-de-cientos-de-peruanos-reclutados-por-rusia-en-guerra/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">believes </a>the scale of recruitment is much larger, and more than 1,000 people from Peru are fighting as part of the Russian Armed Forces.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In May, the Peruvian prosecutor’s office specializing in combating human trafficking <a href=\"https://www.gob.pe/institucion/mpfn/noticias/1386427-fiscalia-inicia-investigaciones-por-presunta-trata-de-personas-por-caso-de-peruanos-trasladados-a-rusia\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">began </a>investigating these cases. Currently, Peruvian prosecutors are <a href=\"https://caretas.pe/nacional/mas-de-300-peruanos-habrian-sido-captados-con-falsas-ofertas-laborales-para-viajar-a-rusia-fiscalia-investiga-22-casos/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">conducting </a>21 investigations into Russia-related human trafficking cases, with another investigation related to organized crime allegations. More than 300 people are listed as victims in these cases.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19671,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Paula Bayarte / EPA / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Relatives of the recruited Peruvians protest outside the Russian Embassy in Lima, Peru, on August 4, 2026","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fe31d2037ec74866a2879f2bd1a63cd3-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fe31d2037ec74866a2879f2bd1a63cd3-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fe31d2037ec74866a2879f2bd1a63cd3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":3838,"real_height_1x":1280,"real_height_2x":2560},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fe31d2037ec74866a2879f2bd1a63cd3-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fe31d2037ec74866a2879f2bd1a63cd3-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fe31d2037ec74866a2879f2bd1a63cd3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":3838,"real_height_1x":1280,"real_height_2x":2560},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fe31d2037ec74866a2879f2bd1a63cd3-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fe31d2037ec74866a2879f2bd1a63cd3-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fe31d2037ec74866a2879f2bd1a63cd3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":799,"real_height_2x":1599},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fe31d2037ec74866a2879f2bd1a63cd3-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fe31d2037ec74866a2879f2bd1a63cd3-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fe31d2037ec74866a2879f2bd1a63cd3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":799,"real_height_2x":1599},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fe31d2037ec74866a2879f2bd1a63cd3-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fe31d2037ec74866a2879f2bd1a63cd3-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fe31d2037ec74866a2879f2bd1a63cd3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fe31d2037ec74866a2879f2bd1a63cd3-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fe31d2037ec74866a2879f2bd1a63cd3-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/fe31d2037ec74866a2879f2bd1a63cd3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Two alleged traffickers have already been <a href=\"https://caretas.pe/nacional/prision-preventiva-para-investigado-por-captar-a-peruano-con-falsa-oferta-de-trabajo-y-enviarlo-a-rusia-vidal-isaac-lavado-zavala/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">arrested </a>in Peru. One of them, a 54-year-old retired military officer Pocho Pinto, <a href=\"https://larepublica.pe/sociedad/2026/10/10/dicta-14-meses-de-prision-preventiva-a-investigado-por-reclutar-peruanos-para-una-base-militar-en-rusia-779290\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">offered </a>his compatriots jobs guarding a Russian military facility and promised that the recruits would not be sent to the front lines. “If they signed a contract in a language they do not understand, that constitutes grounds for a crime, namely, fraud,” <a href=\"https://www.infobae.com/peru/2026/09/08/fiscalia-detalla-proceso-contra-sujeto-acusado-de-enviar-a-peruano-a-la-guerra-en-rusia-con-enganos/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">said </a>Luisa Kispé, the prosecutor.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russian authorities deny the fraudulent recruitment for the war allegations. In August, the Russian Embassy in Peru <a href=\"https://x.com/RusEmbPeru/status/2089100314620182765?s=20\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">claimed </a>that all the Peruvians who had signed the military contracts had been “informed of the terms of the document, the conditions of military service and the associated risks, as well as of the rights and obligations of the parties.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Amnesty International <a href=\"https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/eur46/1361/2026/en/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">proposed </a>that foreigners fraudulently recruited into the Russian army should be considered victims of human trafficking. “There is no doubt &lt;...&gt; that the Russian authorities have at the very least created and facilitated an enabling environment for the abusive recruitment practices — and knowingly benefited from these to boost their armed forces,” the report states.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The recruitment campaign is still on&nbsp;","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The recruiting campaign is going on in Ufa. It is run by the “Central Headquarters for the Formation of Volunteer Battalions” (TSSCHFDB). It targets Latin America (Peru, Panama, Mexico, Colombia, Ecuador, Argentina), Southeast Asia (Cambodia, Myanmar, Indonesia, the Philippines), Africa (Botswana, Zimbabwe), and the CIS (Belarus, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan) nationals.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19672,"data":{"block":"<p>The headquarters was <a href=\"https://xn----7sbbeqznoc1avg6byb4bo.xn--p1ai/page/istoria\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">established</a> in February 2023 in Ufa. The idea was allegedly proposed by entrepreneur Ildar Zainetdinov during a meeting with the head of Bashkortostan, Radiy Khabirov. The headquarters brought together representatives of law enforcement agencies and veterans’ organizations.</p><p><br/></p><p>The organization initially focused on recruiting Russians, and in addition to Ufa, it opened branches in Ulyanovsk, Nizhny Novgorod, Penza, Sevastopol, and Barnaul. Currently, one of its listed <a href=\"https://xn----7sbbeqznoc1avg6byb4bo.xn--p1ai/page/kontakty\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">addresses </a>is that of a contract recruitment center in Moscow: 5 Yablochkova St., Bldg. 1.</p><p><br/></p><p>The first versions of the websites created to recruit foreigners explicitly stated their <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20251204012902/https://workinrussia2025.ru/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">connection </a>to the organization. Links to these websites can be found on the headquarters&#x27; <a href=\"https://t.me/contract_bashkortostan\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Telegram channel</a>. Two other similarly named websites also belong to entities affiliated with the “Central Headquarters.”</p>","header":"What is known about the Central Headquarters for the Formation of Volunteer Battalions","content":[{"insert":"The headquarters was "},{"insert":"established","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://xn----7sbbeqznoc1avg6byb4bo.xn--p1ai/page/istoria","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" in February 2023 in Ufa. The idea was allegedly proposed by entrepreneur Ildar Zainetdinov during a meeting with the head of Bashkortostan, Radiy Khabirov. The headquarters brought together representatives of law enforcement agencies and veterans’ organizations.\n\nThe organization initially focused on recruiting Russians, and in addition to Ufa, it opened branches in Ulyanovsk, Nizhny Novgorod, Penza, Sevastopol, and Barnaul. Currently, one of its listed "},{"insert":"addresses ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://xn----7sbbeqznoc1avg6byb4bo.xn--p1ai/page/kontakty","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"is that of a contract recruitment center in Moscow: 5 Yablochkova St., Bldg. 1.\n\nThe first versions of the websites created to recruit foreigners explicitly stated their "},{"insert":"connection ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://web.archive.org/web/20251204012902/https://workinrussia2025.ru/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"to the organization. Links to these websites can be found on the headquarters' "},{"insert":"Telegram channel","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://t.me/contract_bashkortostan","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":". Two other similarly named websites also belong to entities affiliated with the “Central Headquarters.”\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"Until the summer of 2026, one of the websites <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20260726172554/https://workinrussia2025.ru/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">featured</a> an offer for intermediaries: “If the candidate pays for their own ticket, you receive $1,000. If you simply arrange for a person to participate, and we have to cover all expenses (including the ticket), your bonus is $150. It’s easy to work with us—you bring in people, and we take care of everything else.” This announcement has since been removed.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In January 2026, the headquarters also distributed a <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20260203072208/https://workinrussia2025.ru/stop2\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">blacklist</a> of countries whose citizens were prohibited from joining the Russian army. Several sources reported on this ban, including a British national Ben Stimson, who trains foreign mercenaries for the Russian Army, as previously <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/news/2026/02/23/russia-restricts-friendly-countries-mercenary-recruitment/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">noted</a> by IStories.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Until March 2026, the organization's Telegram channel would <a href=\"https://t.me/contract_bashkortostan/127\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">publish </a>photos and videos of the foreigners who had arrived in Ufa to sign contracts with the Russian Armed Forces. We were able to identify some of them using open sources.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19673,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"The headquarters’ Telegram channel","caption":"In the Telegram channel of the Central Headquarters for the Formation of Volunteer Battalions, photos of dozens of recruits from Latin America can be found","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2aa8618c7104da29f8ed26f96c4917d-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2aa8618c7104da29f8ed26f96c4917d-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2aa8618c7104da29f8ed26f96c4917d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2aa8618c7104da29f8ed26f96c4917d-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2aa8618c7104da29f8ed26f96c4917d-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2aa8618c7104da29f8ed26f96c4917d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2aa8618c7104da29f8ed26f96c4917d-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2aa8618c7104da29f8ed26f96c4917d-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2aa8618c7104da29f8ed26f96c4917d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2aa8618c7104da29f8ed26f96c4917d-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2aa8618c7104da29f8ed26f96c4917d-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2aa8618c7104da29f8ed26f96c4917d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2aa8618c7104da29f8ed26f96c4917d-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2aa8618c7104da29f8ed26f96c4917d-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2aa8618c7104da29f8ed26f96c4917d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2aa8618c7104da29f8ed26f96c4917d-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2aa8618c7104da29f8ed26f96c4917d-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2aa8618c7104da29f8ed26f96c4917d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Edwin Díaz, a Colombian, appeared in a video released by the headquarters in late January 2026, and was taken captive a month later. Then he explained that he had come to Russia for work but was later forcibly sent to fight in the ranks of the Russian army.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Relatives were searching for another Colombian, John Velez, after they lost contact with him in September 2025. In a <a href=\"https://t.me/contract_bashkortostan/10\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">photo</a> taken at least a month earlier, he is standing near the airport in Ufa.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Several photos of foreigners were taken near the “Defender” center — the same place where a group of Peruvians, including Arturo Rengifo, were living. In one of the photos, the recruits are sitting in a classroom. “Every day they study the Russian language and the history of our country, study the military disciplines, and train at sports facilities,” the organization’s Telegram channel <a href=\"https://t.me/contract_bashkortostan/30\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">states</a>. The sports facilities where the foreigners <a href=\"https://t.me/contract_bashkortostan/26\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">exercise</a> are also located on the premises of the “Defender” center, as confirmed by IStories.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19674,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"TikTok","caption":"The headquarters’ TikTok account is aimed at a Spanish-speaking audience","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/15c31cc063624607a97e2f74000d8358-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/15c31cc063624607a97e2f74000d8358-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/15c31cc063624607a97e2f74000d8358-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/15c31cc063624607a97e2f74000d8358-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/15c31cc063624607a97e2f74000d8358-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/15c31cc063624607a97e2f74000d8358-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/15c31cc063624607a97e2f74000d8358-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/15c31cc063624607a97e2f74000d8358-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/15c31cc063624607a97e2f74000d8358-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/15c31cc063624607a97e2f74000d8358-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/15c31cc063624607a97e2f74000d8358-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/15c31cc063624607a97e2f74000d8358-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/15c31cc063624607a97e2f74000d8358-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/15c31cc063624607a97e2f74000d8358-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/15c31cc063624607a97e2f74000d8358-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/15c31cc063624607a97e2f74000d8358-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/15c31cc063624607a97e2f74000d8358-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/15c31cc063624607a97e2f74000d8358-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"While the Central Headquarters’ Telegram channel is inactive, its TikTok account — with nearly 5,000 followers — is still <a href=\"https://www.tiktok.com/@rusia.ejrcito.inc\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">attracting</a> the attention of potential contract soldiers from Latin American countries. Although the channel is called “Central Headquarters Siberia,” it also <a href=\"https://www.tiktok.com/@rusia.ejrcito.inc/photo/7647717086894116116\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">posts </a>photos of Latin American contract soldiers at the “Defender” <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20261019213716/https://igenche.ru/news/novosti/2025-03-22/v-bashkirii-uvelichilos-chislo-zhelayuschih-otpravitsya-na-svo-4168496\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">center </a>and other locations in Ufa. The most popular videos get tens of thousands of views and hundreds of comments, including from those claiming to be interested in coming to Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, not everyone welcomes this kind of ads. “No, thanks, I’d rather stay alive,” a popular comment reads under one of the videos.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":10962,"header":"“Russia Has Backed Itself into a Corner”","_path":"/en/stories/2026/10/12/russia-has-backed-itself-into-a-corner/","lead":"Country’s “sovereign internet” proved vulnerable by Ukrainian attacks","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/468aa2e2922145f6a4ebf0d857afeb17-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Fire at the Yandex data center in Sasovo, Ryazan Oblast, on October 9, 2026. Picture: IStories. Photo: social media / Reuters","created_at_date":"2026-10-12","created_at_date_time":"2026-10-12T12:57:10.764Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":true,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":61,"first_name":"Егор","last_name":"Феоктистов","first_name_en":"Egor","last_name_en":"Feoktistov","is_public":true,"_path":"egor-feoktistov","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Автор дата-отдела «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":null}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[{"id":31,"first_name":"Катя","last_name":"Бонч-Осмоловская","first_name_en":"Katya","last_name_en":"Bonch-Osmolovskaya","is_public":true,"_path":"katya-bonch-osmolovskaya","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.jpeg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.jpeg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.jpeg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.jpeg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редакторка дата-отдела","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":null,"ordering":1}],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"This fall, the Russo-Ukrainian war of attrition has entered a new phase. A series of Russia’s successful attacks on Ukrainian data centers has prompted a reciprocal response: Ukrainian drones are now targeted at the data centers belonging to Russia’s digital monopolist Yandex. Among products affected are Yandex’s own services as well as those belonging to numerous other businesses that use its cloud infrastructure for hosting their platforms. Maksut Shadayev, Russia’s Minister of Digital Development, Communications, and Mass Media, called the attacks “unprecedented” and outlined plans to secure other company facilities with the help of the Ministry of Defense.\n\nRussian companies are hampered by excessive regulation: Russia’s “sovereign internet” concept prohibits storing Russian citizens’ data abroad, and the state can seize the businesses of data center owners if they fail to protect their infrastructure from drone raids. IStories examine the potential consequences of Ukraine’s new air campaign and look into Russia’s ability to manage the potential crisis for the country’s IT market.\n\nWhat happened\nOn the night of October 8, Ukrainian drones attacked the Yandex data center in Sasovo, Ryazan Oblast. The data center is located next to the workshops belonging to Sasta, a machinery manufacturer working for Russia’s defense industry, so at first there was no certainty that this attack marked the beginning of a new Ukrainian tactic. \n\nHowever, later that evening, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy described the strike as a retaliation for Russian attacks on Ukrainian data centers. The next day, October 9, drones struck a second Yandex data center situated in Kaluga Oblast. Yandex then stated that operations at the Sasovo data center had been completely halted, and part of the infrastructure in Kaluga had been disabled. On the night of October 11, drones attacked the company’s third data center in the city of Vladimir. Its operations were also halted. No employees at the facilities were injured.\nFollowing the attacks, more than 30 Yandex services became temporarily unavailable, and, following the strike on the Vladimir data center, disruptions have been reported in the company’s apps in Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan. Russians have been complaining about their Yandex Drive photos and Kinopoisk watch history disappearance, meanwhile Yandex Pay customers were unable to access their bank accounts.\n\nMillions of Russians have also felt the impact of these attacks even beyond the Yandex ecosystem: users have complained about disruptions on such websites as the Russian Railways, Cyan (a real estate database), Avito (an advertising platform), VK (a social network), Twinby (a dating website), etc. It is likely that part of their infrastructure was located in the burned-down data centers. Yandex suggested that customers migrate their data to other infrastructure providers, such as Selectel, K2Cloud, and VK Cloud.\n\nIn addition to disruptions to the day-to-day operations of its services, the Russian IT giant may face yet another serious problem. The Ryazan and Vladimir data centers house some of Russia’s most powerful supercomputers — the Chervonenskis (ranked 101st globally), the Galushkin (ranked 134th), and the Lyapunov (ranked 161st) supercomputers which Yandex used to train neural networks with billions of parameters.\n\nThe company has already taken down its supercomputers information webpage, but a copy can be found on the Web Archive. Yandex has also attempted to conceal its data centers information on the company’s own maps platform: their locations are now blurred on satellite images. At the same time, information about dozens of other Russian data centers is publicly available, and these facilities could become new targets for the Ukrainian Armed Forces' attacks.\n\nHow the data center market works in Russia\n\nThere are nearly 200 data centers operating in Russia. On March 1, 2026, the Ministry of Digital Transformation launched a non-public registry of data centers and divided them into two types: commercial data centers and those serving companies’ internal needs. The damaged Yandex facilities likely served both roles, supporting both the company’s internal services and its clients’ resources.\n\nA total of five companies — RTK-TsOD , IXcellerate, Rosatom, DataPro, and Selectel — account for two-thirds of the commercial data center market in Russia. They also own the largest data centers, alongside the companies building data centers for their own needs, such as Yandex, Sber, Megafon, MTS, VK and Wildberries.\n\nAccording to a Kommersant source in the data center market, 80 to 90% of the commercial facilities for data storage are concentrated in the European part of Russia, primarily in Moscow and St. Petersburg. Publically available data analyzed by IStories indicates that there are not many large data centers located outside these major cities.\n\nThe key facilities in Moscow, along with the manufacturing, military, energy facilities, etc., are protected by three rings of air defense, which Ukrainian drones have managed to successfully breach twice: in June 2026, when the lid of a Moscow Oil Refinery tank picturesquely flew into the air, and once again in September.\n\nYandex operates six data centers with a total capacity of over 200 MW. In addition to the three attacked ones, the company’s smaller facilities are situated in the towns of Mytishchi and Ivanteevka in the Moscow Oblast. There’s also one more data center in Vladimir, which began operations in March 2026.\n\nThe attacks struck Yandex’s busiest facilities — the Ryazan one consumes up to 34 MW of energy, the Vladimir one — up to 28 MW, and the Kaluga one — up to 13 MW, meanwhile its design capacity reaches 63 MW. All of these centers are located outside Moscow’s air defense “umbrella.”\n\nWhat else might be targeted besides Yandex\n\nData centers that support Russia’s government services may end up on the Ukrainian Armed Forces’ list of targets. Key government systems, such as Gosuslugi (the citizen services platform), Gosoblako (a cloud service for government agencies), EGRN (the real estate registry), GAS Vybory 2.0 elections platform, etc. are hosted in Rostelecom’s data centers. However, most of these are located in Moscow and are protected by the three air defense rings, so they are unlikely to be top-priority targets.\n\nOne of the most vulnerable civilian facilities for Ukrainian drones could be the Russia’s Federal Tax Service’s large data center in Dubna, Moscow Oblast. The Ukrainian army has already successfully attacked the military Satellite Communications Centre in the same town. The tax service’s backup data center is also located within the reach of a possible Ukrainian strike — in Gorodets, Nizhny Novgorod Oblast. A defense plant was successfully attacked in neighboring Dzerzhinsk in August 2026.\n\nThe ERA military technopolis in Anapa, Krasnodarsky Krai, where Russia’s Ministry of Defense tests its latest weapons prototypes, has not yet been targeted. Another data center based on a supercomputer is also located there.\n\nThe Russian Armed Forces’ key data center is located at their Moscow headquarters on Frunzenskaya Embankment and appears to be the most complex target for Ukrainian strikes. As IStories previously discovered, this is where Russia’s Unified Military Registry infrastructure is housed.\n\nThe National Defense Management Center’s supercomputer, which can be compared to Yandex supercomputers in terms of processing power, is also located there. According to Russia’s former Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu, the Russian military planned to use it to “predict the course of armed conflicts based on historical data.”\n\nWhat will happen to the data?\n\nIt is difficult to say exactly how many data centers would need to be destroyed for the internet to stop working in Russia. The main question is whether those center’s clients have backup copies of their data elsewhere, experts interviewed by IStories say.\n\nThe expert team from the Na Svyazi project notes that only multiple backups physically distant from one another and located in different countries can ensure data safety. “Take Yandex, for example — it has five data centers. If we put one [backup] file in each one, that sounds secure, right? But now that two are gone [because of the data center attacks], that’s no longer the case. If the other buildings are destroyed, the data will be destroyed too,” says a team member. According to Na Svyazi, a significant share of Russian services will be affected, and the loss of data could become critical if such attacks continue.\n\nA source familiar with the Yandex infrastructure, in his conversation with the BBC Russian Service, explained that the majority of Yandex services had been hosted in the three attacked data centers. The IT giant had been preparing for a potential shutdown of its data centers and had conducted several drills during which traffic was rerouted through other facilities.\n\n“Yandex has a strong infrastructure, and the Yandex Drive data is most likely secure,” says Leonid Yuldashev, project coordinator at eQualitie. “But there’s always some data that's stored in just one place, so a huge number of vibe coders  have already lost access to their servers. Sometimes people don’t even create backups properly — they’re either missing or a year out of date. That data will inevitably be lost.”\n\nSmall businesses that rely on cloud storage and do not keep copies of their data separately — customer databases, for example — may face the most serious consequences. “Yesterday you knew you have to produce five custom-made desks, but today everything has been destroyed, and not only do you not know the dimensions of the desks, but you also won’t be able to call the client to clarify the details, unless have your own independent backup,” the Na Svyazi team explains.\n\nIs It possible to safeguard against the attacks?\n\nRussia’s attacks on Ukrainian data centers have been persistent since mid-September. Russia has struck about ten sites in Kyiv, where more than half of the country’s data centers are concentrated. After one of the attacks, 100,000 households were left without internet access. The owners of one data center announced it completely shut down, but the customer data remained intact thanks to backups stored at facilities in the EU.\nIn February 2022, a week before the Russian invasion, Ukraine’s parliament passed a law allowing government data to be stored in foreign cloud services. In the first months of the war, petabytes of data from Ukrainian government registries were migrated to AWS (an Amazon subsidiary). PrivatBank, one of Ukraine’s largest banks, also transferred its customer data there. Some data was moved to European data centers operated by Microsoft, which allocated $400 million of aid to Ukrainian companies.\n\nThis option is not available to Russian companies due to the law requiring personal data to be stored within the country. The largest foreign cloud service providers — Amazon, Microsoft, and Google — withdrew from the Russian market in March 2022 of their own accord.\n\n“Russia has backed itself into a corner: now its data centers store information that can only be kept within the country,” says Leonid Yuldashev from eQualitie. “Because of this law, it’s not even possible to backup the information in Kazakhstan. This only multiplies the destructive power of the attacks.” \n\nYuldashev speculates that the attacks may prompt some response from the government: “They could loosen the regulations and allow Russians’ data to be stored in the Eurasian Economic Union countries . I think all the parties are currently considering this: the server and data center owners and the Ministry of Digital Development. Everyone understands that if there have been two attacks, there could potentially be 22 more.”\n\nOn the eve of Ukraine’s first strike on a Yandex data center, it was reported that the Ministry of Digital Transformation and the business community were discussing relocating Russia’s AI data centers to “friendly” countries. This was reportedly prompted by the market participants' complaints about energy shortages in Russia. \n\nMeanwhile, however, the legislation has been shifting in the opposite direction. According to the new AI law, the so-called sovereign and national AI models will be required to process and store data exclusively in data centers located within Russia, starting in March 2027. The government plans to use such sovereign AI models at “significant critical infrastructure facilities.”\n\n“Any centralization, any one-button centralized control, any single-location data storage solution is a massive vulnerability,” Na Svyazi experts explain. “What’s happening now is a consequence of ignoring the problem.”\n\nBusinesses will suffer \n\nThe authorities had shifted responsibility for protecting data centers to their owners prior to the first Ukrainian drone attacks. A decree signed by Vladimir Putin in late August allows for imposing temporary state management on critical infrastructure facilities if the owners have failed to provide adequate drone protection. Data centers are listed among such facilities.\n\nRussian data centers have begun upgrading their equipment protection systems “to meet the demands of modern challenges,” Nikita Tsaplin, the CEO of RUVDS hosting provider, noted in a conversation with Kommersant. Back in July, VSK, one of Russia’s largest insurance companies, set a requirement for the data centers to be prepared for drone attacks. According to it, a facility had to be able to withstand a collision with a drone weighing up to 350 kg.\n\nThe idea of equipping data centers with anti-drone nets is currently being discussed among hosting providers, says Leonid Yuldashev. Not everyone will be able to afford it: “I can imagine that Yandex might at least install the nets, but for a small data center in Chelyabinsk, it will be more difficult to do so. And at the same time, you wonder [about the rationality of it]: I’ll spend all this money now, then a drone crashes into the data center, and it’ll be taken away [by the state]?”\n\nThe costs of protecting the infrastructure will ultimately fall on consumers, Nikita Tsaplin says. At the same time, prices will rise most significantly for the critically important telecom, government, and financial data centers which face the highest risks.\n\nEquipment losses will also hit the data center owners, as they’ll have to purchase replacements from abroad at higher prices. The future of Yandex supercomputers remains unclear as they rely on foreign components, such as AMD EPYC processors and NVIDIA A100 graphics accelerators, the import of which has become difficult following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.\n\nStandard server equipment supplies are also declining, and due to a global memory supply shortage, their prices are rising. “All of this has become quite difficult to buy. Of course, people are buying Russian-made servers, but the problem is, they’re not actually ‘Russian-made,’” says Leonid Yuldashev. “Because of the storage crisis, it’s almost impossible to purchase equipment promptly.\"\n\nBuilding a new data center is, in itself, a costly and complex project involving significant transaction costs, Yuldashev says. It won’t be possible to quickly relocate the facilities to Russia’s Far East, beyond the range of Ukrainian drones.\n\nAlfa-Bank’s data center market review confirms this: by 2025, the rate of new facility launches had halved, and some projects already under construction had been put on hold due to the Central Bank’s high interest rates.\n\nA blow to the “sovereign Russian internet”\n\nUkraine’s choice of Yandex as a target cannot yet be explained by the fact that its data centers have been directly used in warfare — there has been no direct evidence of this. The company, however, helps the Russian army recruit new contract soldiers. In 2024, through the social advertising mechanism alone (which means it is free for the advertiser), the ads for contract military service in the Russian army were displayed more than 1 billion times on various Yandex platforms. More than 12 million of these impressions happened in Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, Belarus, Kazakhstan, and other foreign countries. In 2025, Yandex concealed the military service ad impressions statistics.\n\nThe Yandex data centers may have been targeted based on the same logic as the Wildberries and Ozon warehouses had been months earlier. If popular services — some of which hold a monopoly position in the market — become unavailable, it could hurt Russia's economy as a whole and upset Russians’ daily lives.\n\nAccording to Leonid Yuldashev, Yandex was chosen as the first target not because of its position in the cloud storage market — there are other, larger players in Russia that most Russians are completely unaware of. Attacks on Yandex primarily harm the state.\n\n“This undermines the main promise of the sovereign Russian internet,” he explains. “The authorities say they’ve blocked Telegram and YouTube, but Max  ‘works even underground,’ and RuTube  is up and running. [The government stated they] ‘have set up all the sovereign services, and everything works.’ And it turns out that if YouTube doesn’t work, but Yandex Video always does, maybe you’ll just use [Yandex]. But if both Yandex Video and YouTube fail to work, then you might start thinking, ‘Maybe I should set up a VPN [to be able to watch YouTube]?’”","blocks":[{"data":"This fall, the Russo-Ukrainian war of attrition has entered a new phase. A series of Russia’s successful attacks on Ukrainian data centers has prompted a reciprocal response: Ukrainian drones are now targeted at the data centers belonging to Russia’s digital monopolist Yandex. Among products affected are Yandex’s own services as well as those belonging to numerous other businesses that use its cloud infrastructure for hosting their platforms. Maksut Shadayev, Russia’s Minister of Digital Development, Communications, and Mass Media, <a href=\"https://tass.ru/ekonomika/28204925\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">called </a>the attacks “unprecedented” and outlined plans to secure other company facilities with the help of the Ministry of Defense.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russian companies are hampered by excessive regulation: Russia’s “sovereign internet” concept prohibits storing Russian citizens’ data abroad, and the state can seize the businesses of data center owners if they fail to protect their infrastructure from drone raids. IStories examine the potential consequences of Ukraine’s new air campaign and look into Russia’s ability to manage the potential crisis for the country’s IT market.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"What happened","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"On the night of October 8, Ukrainian drones attacked the Yandex data center in Sasovo, Ryazan Oblast. The data center is <a href=\"https://t.me/astrapress/127448\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">located </a>next to the workshops belonging to Sasta, a machinery manufacturer working for Russia’s defense industry, so at first there was no certainty that this attack marked the beginning of a new Ukrainian tactic.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, later that evening, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy <a href=\"https://newsukraine.rbc.ua/news/zelenskyy-comments-on-strike-against-yandex-1791487825.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">described </a>the strike as a retaliation for Russian attacks on Ukrainian data centers. The next day, October 9, drones struck a second Yandex data center situated in Kaluga Oblast. Yandex then <a href=\"https://x.com/yandex/status/2108482115155169544\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">stated </a>that operations at the Sasovo data center had been completely halted, and part of the infrastructure in Kaluga had been disabled. On the night of October 11, drones attacked the company’s third data center in the city of Vladimir. Its operations were also <a href=\"https://status.yandex.cloud/ru/incidents/2136\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">halted</a>. No employees at the facilities were injured.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19519,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Dnipro Osint","caption":"According to the Dnipro Osint estimates, one-third of the Sasovo data center was destroyed by fire","isNarrow":false,"creditUrl":"https://t.me/DniproOfficial/8246","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14bfb1b4cc3492bb59f0d5238500ded-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14bfb1b4cc3492bb59f0d5238500ded-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14bfb1b4cc3492bb59f0d5238500ded-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2433,"real_height_1x":1102,"real_height_2x":1397},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14bfb1b4cc3492bb59f0d5238500ded-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14bfb1b4cc3492bb59f0d5238500ded-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14bfb1b4cc3492bb59f0d5238500ded-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2433,"real_height_1x":1102,"real_height_2x":1397},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14bfb1b4cc3492bb59f0d5238500ded-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14bfb1b4cc3492bb59f0d5238500ded-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14bfb1b4cc3492bb59f0d5238500ded-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2398,"real_height_1x":688,"real_height_2x":1377},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14bfb1b4cc3492bb59f0d5238500ded-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14bfb1b4cc3492bb59f0d5238500ded-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14bfb1b4cc3492bb59f0d5238500ded-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2398,"real_height_1x":688,"real_height_2x":1377},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14bfb1b4cc3492bb59f0d5238500ded-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14bfb1b4cc3492bb59f0d5238500ded-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14bfb1b4cc3492bb59f0d5238500ded-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":237,"real_height_2x":475},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14bfb1b4cc3492bb59f0d5238500ded-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14bfb1b4cc3492bb59f0d5238500ded-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14bfb1b4cc3492bb59f0d5238500ded-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":237,"real_height_2x":475}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Following the attacks, more than 30 Yandex services <a href=\"https://status.yandex.cloud/ru/incidents/2092\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">became </a>temporarily unavailable, and, following the strike on the Vladimir data center, disruptions have been <a href=\"https://t.me/tass_agency/399760\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">reported </a>in the company’s apps in Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan. Russians have been complaining about their Yandex Drive photos and Kinopoisk watch history disappearance, meanwhile Yandex Pay customers were unable to access their bank accounts.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Millions of Russians have also <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/news/2026/10/08/polzovateli-nachali-massovo-zhalovatsya-na-sboi-rossiiskikh-servisov/index.html?_gl=1*10ijhdp*_ga*MTY5NDA0MzQ4LjE3NzEzMjA3OTk.*_ga_86829926PE*czE3OTE4ODY1NDkkbzE2NSRnMSR0MTc5MTg4Njc0OCRqMzkkbDAkaDA.\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">felt </a>the impact of these attacks even beyond the Yandex ecosystem: users have complained about disruptions on such websites as the Russian Railways, Cyan (a real estate database), Avito (an advertising platform), VK (a social network), Twinby (a dating website), etc. It is likely that part of their infrastructure was located in the burned-down data centers. Yandex <a href=\"https://status.yandex.cloud/ru/incidents/2092\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">suggested </a>that customers migrate their data to other infrastructure providers, such as Selectel, K2Cloud, and VK Cloud.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In addition to disruptions to the day-to-day operations of its services, the Russian IT giant may face yet another serious problem. The Ryazan and Vladimir data centers house some of Russia’s most powerful supercomputers — the Chervonenskis (ranked 101st <a href=\"https://top500.org/lists/top500/list/2026/06/?page=2\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">globally</a>), the Galushkin (ranked 134th), and the Lyapunov (ranked 161st) supercomputers which Yandex used to <a href=\"https://yandex.com/blog/yacompany-com/yandex-supercomputers-top-entries-from-russia-and-eastern-europe-among-world-s-most-powerful-computing-systems\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">train </a>neural networks with billions of parameters.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The company has already taken down its supercomputers information webpage, but a copy can be found on the <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20260726232218/https://yandex.ru/supercomputers\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Web Archive</a>. Yandex has also attempted to conceal its data centers information on the company’s own maps platform: their locations are now blurred on satellite images. At the same time, information about dozens of other Russian data centers is publicly available, and these facilities could become new targets for the Ukrainian Armed Forces' attacks.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"How the data center market works in Russia","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"There are nearly 200 data centers <a href=\"https://ict.moscow/analytics/sostoianie-rynka-tsod-rossii-v-2025-godu/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">operating </a>in Russia. On March 1, 2026, the Ministry of Digital Transformation <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/russia/1036293\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">launched </a>a non-public registry of data centers and divided them into two types: commercial data centers and those serving companies’ internal needs. The damaged Yandex facilities likely served both roles, supporting both the company’s internal services and its clients’ resources.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A total of five companies — RTK-TsOD <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"a subsidiary of the state-owned Rostelecom\"></span>, IXcellerate, Rosatom, DataPro, and Selectel — account for <a href=\"https://bytemag.ru/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/obzor_rynka_cod_2026.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">two-thirds</a> of the commercial data center market in Russia. They also own the largest data centers, alongside the companies building data centers for their own needs, such as Yandex, Sber, Megafon, MTS, VK and Wildberries.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19520,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/f26e4065054c4422ac82db2d08f10f84/index.html","url_mobile":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/f26e4065054c4422ac82db2d08f10f84/index.html","ratio_mobile":"7:10","ratio_desktop":"3:2"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"According to a Kommersant <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/8923600\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">source </a>in the data center market, 80 to 90% of the commercial facilities for data storage are concentrated in the European part of Russia, primarily in Moscow and St. Petersburg. Publically available data analyzed by IStories indicates that there are not many large data centers located outside these major cities.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The key facilities in Moscow, along with the manufacturing, military, energy facilities, etc., are protected by <a href=\"https://www.currenttime.tv/a/pvo-ataka-dronov-na-moskvu-18-iyunya-pochemu-ne-spravilos/33784389.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">three </a>rings of air defense, which Ukrainian drones have managed to <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/news/2026/06/18/posle-ataki-na-moskovskii-npz-v-seti-poyavilas-versiya-o-popadanii-raketi-pvo-v-rezervuar/index.html?_gl=1*sy4j91*_ga*MTY5NDA0MzQ4LjE3NzEzMjA3OTk.*_ga_86829926PE*czE3OTE4ODY1NDkkbzE2NSRnMSR0MTc5MTg4ODMxOSRqNDckbDAkaDA.\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">successfully </a>breach twice: in June 2026, when the lid of a Moscow Oil Refinery tank picturesquely <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/news/2026/06/18/posle-ataki-na-moskovskii-npz-v-seti-poyavilas-versiya-o-popadanii-raketi-pvo-v-rezervuar/index.html?_gl=1*sy4j91*_ga*MTY5NDA0MzQ4LjE3NzEzMjA3OTk.*_ga_86829926PE*czE3OTE4ODY1NDkkbzE2NSRnMSR0MTc5MTg4ODMxOSRqNDckbDAkaDA.\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">flew </a>into the air, and once again in <a href=\"https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/moscow-oil-refinery-output-halted-after-sunday-drone-attack-sources-say-2026-09-21/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">September</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Yandex operates six data centers with a total <a href=\"https://help.yandex.ru/s3static/docs/sustainability-report-2025.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">capacity </a>of over 200 MW. In addition to the three attacked ones, the company’s smaller facilities are situated in the towns of Mytishchi and Ivanteevka in the Moscow Oblast. There’s also one more data center in Vladimir, which began <a href=\"https://yandex.cloud/showcaptchafast?d=9ACF681E1493CB72B1C01241BEE30A007DCD1095F549048BD17BD0FDFCB15E2920E1756993F05A6E865122A61841FBDB3BB75F702C&amp;retpath=aHR0cHM6Ly95YW5kZXguY2xvdWQvcnUvYmxvZy9ydS1jZW50cmFsMS1lLWV4cGxvaXRhdGlvbj91dG1fcmVmZXJyZXI9aHR0cHMlM0ElMkYlMkZpc3Rvcmllcy5tZWRpYSUyRg%2C%2C_dd7ef7515c3270103d5b2301e3854d53&amp;s=92d039d6d13ba922ab87ffcc7ea85a06\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">operations </a>in March 2026.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The attacks struck Yandex’s busiest facilities — the Ryazan one <a href=\"https://www.so-ups.ru/fileadmin/files/company/future_plan/public_discussion/2025/support_mat/59_Rjazanskaja_oblast.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">consumes </a>up to 34 MW of energy, the Vladimir one — <a href=\"https://www.so-ups.ru/fileadmin/files/company/future_plan/public_discussion/2025/support_mat/07_Vladimirskaja_oblast.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">up to 28 MW</a>, and the Kaluga one — <a href=\"https://www.so-ups.ru/fileadmin/files/company/future_plan/public_discussion/2025/support_mat/17_Kaluzhskaja_oblast.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">up to 13 MW</a>, meanwhile its design capacity reaches 63 MW. All of these centers are located outside Moscow’s air defense “umbrella.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"What else might be targeted besides Yandex","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Data centers that support Russia’s government services may end up on the Ukrainian Armed Forces’ list of targets. Key government systems, such as Gosuslugi (the citizen services platform), Gosoblako (a cloud service for government agencies), EGRN (the real estate registry), GAS Vybory 2.0 elections platform, etc. are hosted in Rostelecom’s data centers. However, most of these are located in Moscow and are protected by the three air defense rings, so they are unlikely to be top-priority targets.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"One of the most vulnerable civilian facilities for Ukrainian drones could be the Russia’s Federal Tax Service’s <a href=\"https://ru-bezh.ru/gossektor/news/25/10/01/v-dubne-postroili-data-tsentr-fns-s-urovnem-zashchity-tier-4\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">large </a>data center in Dubna, Moscow Oblast. The Ukrainian army has already <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/news/2026/06/30/vsu-nachali-bit-po-rossiiskim-tsentram-kosmicheskoi-svyazi/index.html?_gl=1*8plip2*_ga*MTY5NDA0MzQ4LjE3NzEzMjA3OTk.*_ga_86829926PE*czE3OTE4ODY1NDkkbzE2NSRnMSR0MTc5MTg4ODE3NyRqMiRsMCRoMA..\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">successfully </a>attacked the military Satellite Communications Centre in the same town. The tax service’s backup data center is also <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/2871999\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">located </a>within the reach of a possible Ukrainian strike — in Gorodets, Nizhny Novgorod Oblast. A defense plant was successfully <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ua/ukr/news/rf-pislya-ataki-palae-zavod-odnogo-naybilshih-1787115106.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">attacked </a>in neighboring Dzerzhinsk in August 2026.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The ERA military technopolis in Anapa, Krasnodarsky Krai, where Russia’s Ministry of Defense tests its latest weapons prototypes, has not yet been targeted. Another data center based on a supercomputer is also <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20241202185309/https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/5886051\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">located </a>there.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Russian Armed Forces’ key data center is located at their Moscow headquarters on Frunzenskaya Embankment and appears to be the most complex target for Ukrainian strikes. As IStories previously <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/en/stories/2025/12/22/mikord/index.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">discovered</a>, this is where Russia’s Unified Military Registry infrastructure is housed.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The National Defense Management Center’s supercomputer, which can be compared to Yandex supercomputers in terms of processing power, is also located there. <a href=\"https://www.gazeta.ru/auth/sso.shtml?origin=/tags/organization/ntsuo_rf.shtml\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">According </a>to Russia’s former Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu, the Russian military planned to use it to “predict the course of armed conflicts based on historical data.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"What will happen to the data?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"It is difficult to say exactly how many data centers would need to be destroyed for the internet to stop working in Russia. The main question is whether those center’s clients have backup copies of their data elsewhere, experts interviewed by IStories say.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The expert team from the Na Svyazi project notes that only multiple backups physically distant from one another and located in different countries can ensure data safety. “Take Yandex, for example — it has five data centers. If we put one [backup] file in each one, that sounds secure, right? But now that two are gone [because of the data center attacks], that’s no longer the case. If the other buildings are destroyed, the data will be destroyed too,” says a team member. According to Na Svyazi, a significant share of Russian services will be affected, and the loss of data could become critical if such attacks continue.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A source familiar with the Yandex infrastructure, in his conversation with the BBC Russian Service, <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/articles/cwn8drkez9vpo\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">explained </a>that the majority of Yandex services had been hosted in the three attacked data centers. The IT giant had been preparing for a potential shutdown of its data centers and had conducted several drills during which traffic was rerouted through other facilities.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Yandex has a strong infrastructure, and the Yandex Drive data is most likely secure,” says Leonid Yuldashev, project coordinator at eQualitie. “But there’s always some data that's stored in just one place, so a huge number of vibe coders <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"coders who build their services relying heavily on AI\"></span> have already lost access to their servers. Sometimes people don’t even create backups properly — they’re either missing or a year out of date. That data will inevitably be lost.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Small businesses that rely on cloud storage and do not keep copies of their data separately — customer databases, for example — may face the most serious consequences. “Yesterday you knew you have to produce five custom-made desks, but today everything has been destroyed, and not only do you not know the dimensions of the desks, but you also won’t be able to call the client to clarify the details, unless have your own independent backup,” the Na Svyazi team explains.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Is It possible to safeguard against the attacks?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Russia’s attacks on Ukrainian data centers have been <a href=\"https://t.me/mod_russia/67247\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">persistent </a>since mid-September. Russia has struck about ten sites in Kyiv, where more than half of the country’s data centers are <a href=\"https://www.datacentermap.com/ukraine/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">concentrated</a>. After one of the attacks, 100,000 households were <a href=\"https://www.reuters.com/world/russias-attacks-disrupt-internet-services-100000-households-kyiv-ukrainian-2026-09-23/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">left </a>without internet access. The owners of one data center <a href=\"https://www.pravda.com.ua/eng/news/2026/10/01/8055965/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">announced </a>it completely shut down, but the customer data remained intact thanks to backups stored at facilities in the EU.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19521,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Russia’s Ministry of Defense Telegram channel","caption":"Russia’s Ministry of Defense accompanied its announcement about striking Ukrainian data centers with an “ironic” post about a “forced digital detox”","isNarrow":true,"creditUrl":"https://t.me/mod_russia/67692","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/49eb4916187042bb992d68dc25db4c82-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/49eb4916187042bb992d68dc25db4c82-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/49eb4916187042bb992d68dc25db4c82-original.png","real_width_1x":512,"real_width_2x":512,"real_height_1x":689,"real_height_2x":689},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/49eb4916187042bb992d68dc25db4c82-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/49eb4916187042bb992d68dc25db4c82-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/49eb4916187042bb992d68dc25db4c82-original.png","real_width_1x":512,"real_width_2x":512,"real_height_1x":689,"real_height_2x":689},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/49eb4916187042bb992d68dc25db4c82-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/49eb4916187042bb992d68dc25db4c82-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/49eb4916187042bb992d68dc25db4c82-original.png","real_width_1x":512,"real_width_2x":512,"real_height_1x":689,"real_height_2x":689},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/49eb4916187042bb992d68dc25db4c82-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/49eb4916187042bb992d68dc25db4c82-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/49eb4916187042bb992d68dc25db4c82-original.png","real_width_1x":512,"real_width_2x":512,"real_height_1x":689,"real_height_2x":689},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/49eb4916187042bb992d68dc25db4c82-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/49eb4916187042bb992d68dc25db4c82-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/49eb4916187042bb992d68dc25db4c82-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":512,"real_height_1x":558,"real_height_2x":689},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/49eb4916187042bb992d68dc25db4c82-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/49eb4916187042bb992d68dc25db4c82-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/49eb4916187042bb992d68dc25db4c82-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":512,"real_height_1x":558,"real_height_2x":689}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"In February 2022, a week before the Russian invasion, Ukraine’s parliament <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20261005182210/https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2075-20#Text\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">passed </a>a law allowing government data to be stored in foreign cloud services. In the first months of the war, petabytes of data from Ukrainian government registries were <a href=\"https://www.netzwoche.ch/news/2022-07-12/so-hat-die-ukraine-10-petabyte-daten-auf-aws-migriert\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">migrated </a>to AWS (an Amazon subsidiary). PrivatBank, one of Ukraine’s largest banks, also transferred its customer data there. Some data<a href=\"https://www.cbsnews.com/amp/news/microsoft-extends-aid-for-ukraines-wartime-technology-innovation/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"> was moved</a> to European data centers operated by Microsoft, which allocated $400 million of aid to Ukrainian companies.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This option is not available to Russian companies due to the law <a href=\"https://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_61801/cbf4e15b7c330f9372e876cdf2bc928bad7950ef/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">requiring </a>personal data to be stored within the country. The largest foreign cloud service providers — Amazon, Microsoft, and Google — <a href=\"https://techcrunch.com/2022/03/10/amazon-microsoft-and-google-have-suspended-cloud-sales-in-russia/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">withdrew</a> from the Russian market in March 2022 of their own accord.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Russia has backed itself into a corner: now its data centers store information that can only be kept within the country,” says Leonid Yuldashev from eQualitie. “Because of this law, it’s not even possible to backup the information in Kazakhstan. This only multiplies the destructive power of the attacks.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Yuldashev speculates that the attacks may prompt some response from the government: “They could loosen the regulations and allow Russians’ data to be stored in the Eurasian Economic Union countries <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"apart from Russia, it’s Belarus, Armenia, Kazakhstan, and Kyrgyzstan\"></span>. I think all the parties are currently considering this: the server and data center owners and the Ministry of Digital Development. Everyone understands that if there have been two attacks, there could potentially be 22 more.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"On the eve of Ukraine’s first strike on a Yandex data center, it was <a href=\"http://rbc.ru/technology_and_media/08/10/2026/6ac523999a7947776f6003e4\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">reported </a>that the Ministry of Digital Transformation and the business community were <a href=\"https://pravo.ru/news/266191/amp/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">discussing </a>relocating Russia’s AI data centers to “friendly” countries. This was reportedly prompted by the market participants' complaints about energy shortages in Russia.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Meanwhile, however, the legislation has been shifting in the opposite direction. According to the new AI law, the so-called sovereign and national AI models will be required to <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/russia/1098323\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">process </a>and store data exclusively in data centers located within Russia, starting in March 2027. The government <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/russia/1098323\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">plans </a>to use such sovereign AI models at “significant critical infrastructure facilities.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Any centralization, any one-button centralized control, any single-location data storage solution is a massive vulnerability,” Na Svyazi experts explain. “What’s happening now is a consequence of ignoring the problem.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Businesses will suffer&nbsp;","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The authorities had shifted responsibility for protecting data centers to their owners prior to the first Ukrainian drone attacks. A decree signed by Vladimir Putin in late August<a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/8923600\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"> allows for imposing </a>temporary state management on critical infrastructure facilities if the owners have failed to provide adequate drone protection. Data centers are listed among such facilities.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russian data centers have begun upgrading their equipment protection systems “to meet the demands of modern challenges,” Nikita Tsaplin, the CEO of RUVDS hosting provider, <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/8923600\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">noted </a>in a conversation with Kommersant. Back in July, VSK, one of Russia’s largest insurance companies, <a href=\"https://market.cnews.ru/news/top/2026-07-24_gigantskij_rossijskij_strahovshchik\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">set </a>a requirement for the data centers to be prepared for drone attacks. According to it, a facility had to be able to withstand a collision with a drone weighing up to 350 kg.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The idea of equipping data centers with anti-drone nets is currently being discussed among hosting providers, says Leonid Yuldashev. Not everyone will be able to afford it: “I can imagine that Yandex might at least install the nets, but for a small data center in Chelyabinsk, it will be more difficult to do so. And at the same time, you wonder [about the rationality of it]: I’ll spend all this money now, then a drone crashes into the data center, and it’ll be taken away [by the state]?”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The costs of protecting the infrastructure will ultimately fall on consumers, Nikita Tsaplin <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/8923600\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">says</a>. At the same time, prices will rise most significantly for the critically important telecom, government, and financial data centers which face the highest risks.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Equipment losses will also hit the data center owners, as they’ll have to purchase replacements from abroad at higher prices. The future of Yandex supercomputers remains unclear as they <a href=\"https://yandex.com/blog/yacompany-com/yandex-supercomputers-top-entries-from-russia-and-eastern-europe-among-world-s-most-powerful-computing-systems\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">rely </a>on foreign components, such as AMD EPYC processors and NVIDIA A100 graphics accelerators, the import of which has become <a href=\"https://www.comnews.ru/content/245257/2026-05-14/2026-w20/1008/vychislitelnyy-tupik-pochemu-rossiyskiy-ii-ostaetsya-bez-moschnostey\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">difficult </a>following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Standard server equipment supplies are also <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/7716043\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">declining</a>, and due to a global memory supply shortage, their prices are rising. “All of this has become quite difficult to buy. Of course, people are buying Russian-made servers, but the problem is, they’re not actually ‘Russian-made,’” says Leonid Yuldashev. “Because of the storage crisis, it’s almost impossible to purchase equipment promptly.\"","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Building a new data center is, in itself, a costly and complex project involving significant transaction costs, Yuldashev says. It won’t be possible to quickly relocate the facilities to Russia’s Far East, beyond the range of Ukrainian drones.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Alfa-Bank’s data center <a href=\"https://bytemag.ru/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/obzor_rynka_cod_2026.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">market review </a>confirms this: by 2025, the rate of new facility launches had halved, and some projects already under construction had been put on hold due to the Central Bank’s high interest rates.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A blow to the “sovereign Russian internet”","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Ukraine’s choice of Yandex as a target cannot yet be explained by the fact that its data centers have been directly used in warfare — there has been no direct evidence of this. The company, however, helps the Russian army recruit new contract soldiers. In 2024, through the social advertising mechanism alone (which means it is free for the advertiser), the ads for contract military service in the Russian army were <a href=\"https://verstka.media/rossiyanam-pokazali-soczialnuyu-reklamu-sluzhby-po-kontraktu-bolee-1-mlrd-raz-v-2024-godu\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">displayed </a>more than 1 billion times on various Yandex platforms. More than 12 million of these impressions happened in Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, Belarus, Kazakhstan, and other foreign countries. In 2025, Yandex <a href=\"https://verstka.media/yandex_social_advartising_news\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">concealed </a>the military service ad impressions statistics.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Yandex data centers may have been targeted based on the same <a href=\"https://t.me/robert_magyar/2623\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">logic </a>as the Wildberries and Ozon <a href=\"https://meduza.io/feature/2026/08/05/mogut-li-udary-po-wildberries-razorit-kompaniyu-i-sposobny-li-oni-privesti-k-bankovskomu-krizisu-v-rossii\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">warehouses </a>had been months earlier. If popular services — some of which hold a monopoly position in the market — become unavailable, it could hurt Russia's economy as a whole and upset Russians’ daily lives.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to Leonid Yuldashev, Yandex was chosen as the first target not because of its position in the cloud storage market — there are other, larger players in Russia that most Russians are completely unaware of. Attacks on Yandex primarily harm the state.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“This undermines the main promise of the sovereign Russian internet,” he explains. “The authorities say they’ve blocked Telegram and YouTube, but Max <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"a messaging platform promoted by the Russian government as being the most reliable one\"></span> ‘works even underground,’ and RuTube <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"a heavily censored alternative to YouTube\"></span> is up and running. [The government stated they] ‘have set up all the sovereign services, and everything works.’ And it turns out that if YouTube doesn’t work, but Yandex Video always does, maybe you’ll just use [Yandex]. But if both Yandex Video and YouTube fail to work, then you might start thinking, ‘Maybe I should set up a VPN [to be able to watch YouTube]?’”","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":10957,"header":"First Death of Plague in Russia in 50 Years ","_path":"/en/stories/2026/10/06/first-death-of-plague-in-russia-in-50-years/","lead":"The deceased woman was an employee of an anti-plague research institute. Do these institutes pose a danger, and is Russia now facing an epidemic?","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3500,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1750},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3500,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1750},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":399,"real_height_2x":799},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":399,"real_height_2x":799},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":266,"real_height_2x":533},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":266,"real_height_2x":533},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":199,"real_height_2x":399},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":199,"real_height_2x":399},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-original.jpg","real_width_1x":199,"real_width_2x":399,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/af64a155be50445f8d1e5fea8fff9893-original.jpg","real_width_1x":199,"real_width_2x":399,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"The entrance to the anti-plague institute in Irkutsk. Photo: AFP / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2026-10-06","created_at_date_time":"2026-10-12T14:30:08.842Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":89,"first_name":"Борис","last_name":"Богомильский","first_name_en":"Boris","last_name_en":"Bogomilskii","is_public":true,"_path":"boris-bogomilskii","avatar":[],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"On October 2, a 28-year-old laboratory assistant at an anti-plague research institute in the city of Irkutsk (Siberia), Daria Shipilova, died at a local hospital Shelekhov (a satellite town of Irkutsk). According to one of the explanations, she died after breaking a test tube containing the plague pathogen, and may have infected about 200 more people.\n\nThe Russian authorities deny this version and insist that there was no pathogen leak; they claim Shipilova died of pneumonia. The silence of the officials caused concern not only amongst the residents of Irkutsk, but also globally. The World Health Organisation (WHO) has been concerned about the possible spread of the plague. The organisation stated that it was “monitoring the situation.” On October 10, the WHO reported that “a key uncertainty remains the absence of a confirmed diagnosis in the deceased laboratory worker.”\n\nAs early as October 5, the possibility of a plague outbreak was discussed at the White House, according to The Washington Post. The US authorities are attempting to obtain more information about the incident, and Trump has already offered Russia assistance. It is likely that the US authorities believe Moscow is concealing the scale of the incident. Speaking to Fox News, former CIA officer Dan Hoffman even compared the incident to the Chernobyl disaster. IStories look into the scale of the situation.\n\nWhat happened in Irkutsk?\nOn September 25, Daria Shipilova, an employee of the Irkutsk Anti-Plague Institute, reportedly broke a test tube containing the pathogen responsible for pneumonic plague, according to Pavel Stepanov, a local blogger. Stepanov claims that the young woman “concealed this fact” and did not self isolate in order to avoid spreading the disease. “The number of people she had been in contact with ran into the hundreds, and you can imagine what a risk that poses,” said Stepanov.\n\n\nShortly afterwards, Shipilova started feeling unwell and was admitted to a hospital in Shelekhov. On the night of October 2, Shipilova died, and the hospital was placed under quarantine. The news quickly spread through local chat groups, and rumours of plague outbreak began to circulate. The authorities made no comment on the situation whatsoever. Against this backdrop, two further theories emerged: according to the first, the woman had been bitten by a rat; according to the second, she had contracted pneumonic plague while on a trip to Thailand. \n\nStepanov’s version, however, became the prevailing one, albeit unofficial, and soon after journalists managed to identify the infected woman.\n\nDoes the plague still exist?\nHumanity has never managed to completely eradicate the plague (unlike smallpox). The causative agent of the infection — Yersinia pestis — still exists in the wild and is carried by ground squirrels, rodents and many other animals. The infection is transmitted among animals via fleas.\n\nThe disease can only spread effectively amongst animals in certain regions of the world where certain species of small mammals and flea vectors are present. In these areas, the plague exists as natural foci.\n\nAccording to Rospotrebnadzor, Russia’s public health and consumer protection agency, the natural foci of plague are present in at least 13 regions of the country — Kalmykia, Dagestan, Ingushetia, Karachay-Cherkessia, Chechnya, Tuva, Altai, Kabardino-Balkaria, the Astrakhan, Volgograd and Rostov oblasts, and the Stavropolsky and Zabaykalsky Krai. The bacterium particularly thrives in border areas near Kazakhstan, Mongolia, China, Azerbaijan and Georgia.\n\nThere are three main forms of the plague infection: bubonic, pneumonic and septicaemic. The infection is the same, but the symptoms and fatality rates are different. Bubonic plague, which was rampant in the Middle Ages, is now considered the mildest form. While the bubonic form is caused by an infected flea’s bite, or contacting the tissues of infected animals, pneumonic plague is caused by inhaling bacteria-laden droplets (tiny particles of moisture expelled by infected animals or people). Septicaemic plague, the rarest and most dangerous form, is caused by the bacteria entering the bloodstream directly.\n\nCould there be a new epidemic?\nCases of plague infection in Russia are extremely rare. The latest officially recorded death from the plague occurred in 1979 in Kalmykia. Over the following 35 years, the disease would be scarcely mentioned. Between 2014 and 2016, Rospotrebnadzor recorded three non-fatal plague cases in Altai, where the cause was unlawful hunting of plague-infected grey ground squirrels. The most recent case was widely covered by the media: a ten-year-old boy visited his grandparents and contracted the plague whilst butchering a ground squirrel. He later recovered.\n\nIt is likely that all those three patients contracted the bubonic form, whilst the incident in Irkutsk — if it actually had to do with plague — involved the pneumonic form, which is more dangerous and can be transmitted between people via airborne droplets.\n\nIn reality, it is very difficult to contract plague this way. Transmission of the infection requires prolonged contact with the infected person. In modern Russia, there has never been a single recorded human-to-human transmission case. In the US, the latest recorded instance was in 1924.\n\nExperts believe that a single case of pneumonic plague in Irkutsk is unlikely to trigger a full-blown epidemic. According to Irina Yakutenko, a molecular biologist, we are not at risk of a new ‘Black Death,’ even if the disease were to accidentally spread into a large town or city. The necessary transmission chain — “rats to fleas to humans” — is missing for it to spread further. Furthermore, doctors are able to trace contact chains and diagnose and treat the disease quickly.\n\n“In Russia, the United States and in Europe there is no risk of a plague epidemic because the conditions to foster this risk are absent. As for the pneumonic form, the transmission chains are short because victims die before they have a chance to infect large numbers of people. For a bubonic plague epidemic, which would claim millions of people’s lives in the past, a sustained combination of poor sanitation, rats, fleas and people living together in close proximity is required,” Yakutenko told the BBC Russian Service.\n\nDo anti-plague institutes pose a danger?\nThere are at least five anti-plague institutes in Russia — in Saratov, Volgograd, Rostov, Irkutsk and Stavropol. The Stavropol Research Institute also has two branches in Sochi and Budennovsk.\n\nAccording to Stepanov, the Irkutsk Anti-Plague Institute has “deteriorated” in recent years. “Many people have left, and the expertise has weakened. It is possible that this is precisely what led to the tragedy,” he said. There is no confirmation on this information in open sources.\n\nExperts, however, note that incidents in laboratories do indeed occur, even despite strict safety protocols. This also happens in developed countries and in laboratories with the highest biosafety levels, according to Irina Yakutenko.\n\nPrecautionary measures are to be set out in the institute’s internal documents. Furthermore, more general recommendations are available on the World Health Organisation (WHO) website.\n\nStepanov claims that the laboratory assistant breached numerous instructions. According to him, Daria did not inform the research institute’s officials about the incident, most importantly. It is not known whether she had been vaccinated and briefed on what to do in an emergency, and whether she wore a protective suit.\n\n\nDaria’s colleagues were sceptical about this explanation. In an interview with a local outlet, Lyudi Baikala, they described her as a highly responsible worker.\n\n“Daria was extremely anxious about infecting anyone if the worst were to happen. This was evident from how often she sanitised her hands, even outside of work,” one of her colleagues said.\n\nFurthermore, the institute’s staff do not believe it was possible to simply break a test tube in the laboratory.\n\n“That sort of thing doesn’t happen here. But even if she had broken one — the booth and the clothing are isolated. Nothing would have happened at all,” said a source speaking to Lyudi Baikala.\n\nIn global medical history, there had been another well-known case where a researcher studying the plague died from the disease. In 2009, Malcolm Casadaban, a biologist from the University of Chicago, died from the septicaemic form of the plague. The exact route of infection was never established. However, Casadaban’s colleagues said that was not consistently wearing protective gloves, and experts suggest that the bacteria entered his bloodstream through a small wound or mucosa.\n\nHow to manage plague outbreaks?\nIn the event of a plague outbreak, the WHO issues the following recommendations to the authorities: find and stop the source of infection; protect health workers by instructing them and providing them with protective equipment and antibiotics; isolate patients with pneumonic plague and ensure the correct treatment; identify and monitor close contacts of pneumonic plague patients and do the testing; responsibly disinfect the spaces and ensure safe burial practices.\n\nThe plague is treated with antibiotics, primarily fluoroquinolones and aminoglycosides. According to Yakutenko, if diagnosed early, a course of antibiotics (10–14 days) will be sufficient to save the patient’s life. With timely treatment, the plague mortality rate is 5–10%, while in the Middle Ages the fatality rate reached 90–100 per cent.\n\nOne should not self-medicate. In the case of the pneumonic form, it is not only the medication that is important, but isolation as well. Therefore, if suspicious symptoms arise, one must first and foremost consult a doctor.\n\nFurthermore, the necessary medication may not be freely available. On October 3, Lyudi Baikala reported that plague antibiotics are hardly distributed to Irkutsk pharmacies, and where they are available, they are sold strictly on prescription in small quantities — there are at maximum five packs in stock. This is because the Irkutsk Oblast is not among the regions known to have natural foci of the plague.\n\nWhat measures have the authorities already taken?\nAccording to Lyudi Baikala’s report, on the evening of October 1, Irkutsk authorities held a meeting attended by the heads of law enforcement and administrative agencies. FSB officers were assigned to escort ambulances transporting people who had been in contact with Daria on their way to undergo examinations. On the first day alone, 90 people were placed in quarantine at a COVID-19 centre. On October 2, according to the Izvestia newspaper, there were 200 people.\n\nThe regional governor, Igor Kobzev, reported that Russia’s Chief State Sanitary Doctor, Anna Popova, was also present. According to Kobzev, everyone who had been in contact with the infected woman was under medical supervision, and so far no signs of the disease have been observed in them. However, he did not specify the cause of Daria Shipilova’s death.\n\nIt has been indirectly confirmed that the cause of death was the plague by Alexei Tsydenov, the head of the neighbouring Russian region, Buryatia. He stated that the deceased laboratory technician had not visited the Buryatia republic and that the source of the infection lay outside the region. Following this, Baikalsk (a town 145 km away from Irkutsk) authorities urged residents to refrain from travelling to Shelekhov (the town where Daria died) and its neighbouring settlements. Later, they deleted the post.\n\nThe Irkutsk Oblast authorities have not acknowledged the outbreak of plague yet. However, quarantine measures were introduced in the region: three city clinical hospitals (Nos. 1, 3 and 10), the Ivano-Matreninskaya Children’s Hospital and the city maternity hospital were placed under quarantine. On October 3, the Irkutsk Aluminium Plant in Shelekhov introduced a mask mandate for the first time since the pandemic began.\n\nThe press office of Rospotrebnadzor finally commented on the situation on October 4. The agency announced that the sanitary and epidemiological situation was stable and cited the cause of Daria Shipilova’s death as “pneumonia of unknown aetiology.” No “microorganisms linked to her professional activities” were detected in samples of her biomaterial, the agency stated.\n\nAre such measures enough?\nAs the authorities are providing little information about the measures taken and deny that Daria was infected with the plague, it is difficult to assess whether their actions have been adequate.\n\n“We do not know what happened there. If we are talking about the pneumonic form of the plague, then yes, preventive quarantine is a good measure to prevent transmission chains, even the short ones. <...> When all contacts are preventatively isolated and monitored, it is possible to cut the chains of transmission at the very start and avoid further deaths,” Yakutenko told the BBC Russian Service.","blocks":[{"data":"On October 2, a 28-year-old laboratory assistant at an anti-plague research institute in the city of Irkutsk (Siberia), Daria Shipilova, died at a local hospital Shelekhov (a satellite town of Irkutsk). According to one of the explanations, she died after breaking a test tube containing the plague pathogen, and may have infected about 200 more people.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Russian authorities deny this version and insist that there was no pathogen leak; they claim Shipilova died of pneumonia. The silence of the officials caused concern not only amongst the residents of Irkutsk, but also globally. The World Health Organisation (WHO) has been concerned about the possible spread of the plague. The organisation stated that it was “<a href=\"https://www.aa.com.tr/en/health/who-following-closely-russian-lab-workers-death-amid-suspected-pneumonic-plague/4079559\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">monitoring</a> the situation.” On October 10, the WHO <a href=\"https://www.who.int/emergencies/disease-outbreak-news/item/2026-DON620/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">reported </a>that “a key uncertainty remains the absence of a confirmed diagnosis in the deceased laboratory worker.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"As early as October 5, the possibility of a plague outbreak was discussed at the White House, according to <a href=\"https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2026/10/05/us-officials-seeking-details-reported-russian-plague-death-quarantines/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">The Washington Post</a>. The US authorities are attempting to obtain more information about the incident, and Trump has already offered Russia assistance. It is likely that the US authorities believe Moscow is concealing the scale of the incident. Speaking to Fox News, former CIA officer Dan Hoffman even compared the incident to the Chernobyl disaster. IStories look into the scale of the situation.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"What happened in Irkutsk?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"On September 25, Daria Shipilova, an employee of the Irkutsk Anti-Plague Institute, reportedly broke a test tube containing the pathogen responsible for pneumonic plague, according to Pavel Stepanov, a local <a href=\"https://t.me/stepanovnm/6836\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">blogger</a>. Stepanov claims that the young woman “concealed this fact” and did not self isolate in order to avoid spreading the disease. “The number of people she had been in contact with ran into the hundreds, and you can imagine what a risk that poses,” said Stepanov.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19522,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Lyudi Baikala; baikal-journal.ru","caption":"Daria Shipilova","isNarrow":true,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/32a1a4900d3f419dbffc79d6049d90bf-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/32a1a4900d3f419dbffc79d6049d90bf-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/32a1a4900d3f419dbffc79d6049d90bf-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":1280,"real_width_2x":1280,"real_height_1x":1280,"real_height_2x":1280},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/32a1a4900d3f419dbffc79d6049d90bf-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/32a1a4900d3f419dbffc79d6049d90bf-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/32a1a4900d3f419dbffc79d6049d90bf-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":1280,"real_width_2x":1280,"real_height_1x":1280,"real_height_2x":1280},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/32a1a4900d3f419dbffc79d6049d90bf-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/32a1a4900d3f419dbffc79d6049d90bf-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/32a1a4900d3f419dbffc79d6049d90bf-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":1280,"real_height_1x":1200,"real_height_2x":1280},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/32a1a4900d3f419dbffc79d6049d90bf-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/32a1a4900d3f419dbffc79d6049d90bf-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/32a1a4900d3f419dbffc79d6049d90bf-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":1280,"real_height_1x":1200,"real_height_2x":1280},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/32a1a4900d3f419dbffc79d6049d90bf-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/32a1a4900d3f419dbffc79d6049d90bf-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/32a1a4900d3f419dbffc79d6049d90bf-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":415,"real_height_2x":830},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/32a1a4900d3f419dbffc79d6049d90bf-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/32a1a4900d3f419dbffc79d6049d90bf-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/32a1a4900d3f419dbffc79d6049d90bf-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":415,"real_height_2x":830}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Shortly afterwards, Shipilova started feeling unwell and was admitted to a hospital in Shelekhov. On the night of October 2, Shipilova died, and the hospital was placed under quarantine. The news quickly spread through local chat groups, and rumours of plague outbreak began to circulate. The authorities made no comment on the situation whatsoever. Against this backdrop, two further theories <a href=\"https://t.me/Baikal_People/16621\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">emerged</a>: according to the first, the woman had been bitten by a rat; according to the second, she had contracted pneumonic plague while on a trip to Thailand.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Stepanov’s version, however, became the <a href=\"https://t.me/Baikal_People/16629\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">prevailing </a>one, albeit unofficial, and soon after journalists managed to identify the infected woman.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Does the plague still exist?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Humanity has never managed to completely eradicate the plague (unlike smallpox). The causative agent of the infection — Yersinia pestis — still <a href=\"https://cgon.rospotrebnadzor.ru/naseleniyu/infektsionnye-i-parazitarnye-zabolevaniya/infektsii-ot-a-do-ya/pocemu-cuma-sushhestvuet-v-nase-vremya/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">exists </a>in the wild and is carried by ground squirrels, rodents and many other animals. The infection is transmitted among animals via fleas.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The disease can only spread effectively amongst animals in certain regions of the world where certain species of small mammals and flea vectors are present. In these areas, the plague exists as natural foci.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to Rospotrebnadzor, Russia’s public health and consumer protection agency, the natural foci of plague are <a href=\"https://www.business-gazeta.ru/news/554268\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">present </a>in at least 13 regions of the country — Kalmykia, Dagestan, Ingushetia, Karachay-Cherkessia, Chechnya, Tuva, Altai, Kabardino-Balkaria, the Astrakhan, Volgograd and Rostov oblasts, and the Stavropolsky and Zabaykalsky Krai. The bacterium particularly thrives in border areas near Kazakhstan, Mongolia, China, Azerbaijan and Georgia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There are three main forms of the plague infection: bubonic, pneumonic and septicaemic. The infection is the same, but the symptoms and fatality rates are different. Bubonic plague, which was rampant in the Middle Ages, is now considered the mildest form. While the bubonic form is caused by an infected flea’s bite, or contacting the tissues of infected animals, pneumonic plague is caused by inhaling bacteria-laden droplets (tiny particles of moisture expelled by infected animals or people). Septicaemic plague, the rarest and most dangerous form, is caused by the bacteria entering the bloodstream directly.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Could there be a new epidemic?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Cases of plague infection in Russia are extremely rare. The latest officially <a href=\"https://www.kavkaz-uzel.eu/articles/242154\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">recorded </a>death from the plague occurred in 1979 in Kalmykia. Over the following 35 years, the disease would be scarcely mentioned. Between 2014 and 2016, Rospotrebnadzor <a href=\"https://28.rospotrebnadzor.ru/content/1/15322/?\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">recorded </a>three non-fatal plague cases in Altai, where the cause was unlawful hunting of plague-infected grey ground squirrels. The most recent case was widely <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/russia/518446\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">covered </a>by the media: a ten-year-old boy visited his grandparents and contracted the plague whilst butchering a ground squirrel. He later recovered.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It is likely that all those three patients contracted the bubonic form, whilst the incident in Irkutsk — if it actually had to do with plague — involved the pneumonic form, which is more dangerous and can be transmitted between people via airborne droplets.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In reality, it is very difficult to contract plague this way. Transmission of the infection <a href=\"https://www.cdc.gov/plague/causes/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">requires </a>prolonged contact with the infected person. In modern Russia, there has never been a single recorded human-to-human transmission case. In the US, the latest recorded instance was in 1924.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Experts believe that a single case of pneumonic plague in Irkutsk is unlikely to trigger a full-blown epidemic. According to Irina Yakutenko, a molecular biologist, we are not at risk of a new ‘Black Death,’ even if the disease were to accidentally spread into a large town or city. The necessary transmission chain — “rats to fleas to humans” — is missing for it to spread further. Furthermore, doctors are able to trace contact chains and diagnose and treat the disease quickly.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“In Russia, the United States and in Europe there is no risk of a plague epidemic because the conditions to foster this risk are absent. As for the pneumonic form, the transmission chains are short because victims die before they have a chance to infect large numbers of people. For a bubonic plague epidemic, which would claim millions of people’s lives in the past, a sustained combination of poor sanitation, rats, fleas and people living together in close proximity is required,” Yakutenko <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/podcasts/p076qqzl/p0pf1q03\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">told </a>the BBC Russian Service.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Do anti-plague institutes pose a danger?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"There are at least five anti-plague institutes in Russia — in <a href=\"https://www.microbe.ru/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Saratov</a>, <a href=\"https://vnipchi.rospotrebnadzor.ru/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Volgograd</a>, <a href=\"https://antiplague.ru/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Rostov</a>, <a href=\"https://irknipchi.ru/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Irkutsk </a>and <a href=\"https://snipchi.ru/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Stavropol</a>. The Stavropol Research Institute also <a href=\"https://snipchi.ru/about/struktura-instituta-2/laboratorii/index.php\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">has </a>two branches in Sochi and Budennovsk.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to Stepanov, the Irkutsk Anti-Plague Institute has “<a href=\"https://t.me/stepanovnm/6836\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">deteriorated</a>” in recent years. “Many people have left, and the expertise has weakened. It is possible that this is precisely what led to the tragedy,” he said. There is no confirmation on this information in open sources.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Experts, however, note that incidents in laboratories do indeed occur, even despite strict safety protocols. This also happens in developed countries and in laboratories with the highest biosafety levels, <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5GbyYQJjAig\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">according </a>to Irina Yakutenko.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Precautionary measures are to be set out in the institute’s internal documents. Furthermore, more general recommendations are <a href=\"https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240011311\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">available </a>on the World Health Organisation (WHO) website.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Stepanov claims that the laboratory assistant breached numerous instructions. According to him, Daria did not inform the research institute’s officials about the incident, most importantly. It is not known whether she had been vaccinated and briefed on what to do in an emergency, and whether she wore a protective suit.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19523,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Irkutsk Anti-Plague Research Institute","caption":"The institute staff at work","isNarrow":true,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/725729eb6ee6458e8c3885317bfe2adb-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/725729eb6ee6458e8c3885317bfe2adb-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/725729eb6ee6458e8c3885317bfe2adb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":998,"real_width_2x":998,"real_height_1x":666,"real_height_2x":666},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/725729eb6ee6458e8c3885317bfe2adb-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/725729eb6ee6458e8c3885317bfe2adb-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/725729eb6ee6458e8c3885317bfe2adb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":998,"real_width_2x":998,"real_height_1x":666,"real_height_2x":666},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/725729eb6ee6458e8c3885317bfe2adb-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/725729eb6ee6458e8c3885317bfe2adb-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/725729eb6ee6458e8c3885317bfe2adb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":998,"real_width_2x":998,"real_height_1x":666,"real_height_2x":666},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/725729eb6ee6458e8c3885317bfe2adb-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/725729eb6ee6458e8c3885317bfe2adb-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/725729eb6ee6458e8c3885317bfe2adb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":998,"real_width_2x":998,"real_height_1x":666,"real_height_2x":666},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/725729eb6ee6458e8c3885317bfe2adb-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/725729eb6ee6458e8c3885317bfe2adb-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/725729eb6ee6458e8c3885317bfe2adb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/725729eb6ee6458e8c3885317bfe2adb-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/725729eb6ee6458e8c3885317bfe2adb-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/725729eb6ee6458e8c3885317bfe2adb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Daria’s colleagues were <a href=\"https://baikal-journal.ru/2026/10/06/chto-pravda-chuma/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">sceptical </a>about this explanation. In an interview with a local outlet, Lyudi Baikala, they described her as a highly responsible worker.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Daria was extremely anxious about infecting anyone if the worst were to happen. This was evident from how often she sanitised her hands, even outside of work,” one of her colleagues said.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Furthermore, the institute’s staff do not believe it was possible to simply break a test tube in the laboratory.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“That sort of thing doesn’t happen here. But even if she had broken one — the booth and the clothing are isolated. Nothing would have happened at all,” said a source speaking to Lyudi Baikala.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In global medical history, there had been another well-known case where a researcher studying the plague died from the disease. In 2009, Malcolm Casadaban, a biologist from the University of Chicago, died from the septicaemic form of the plague. The exact route of infection was never established. However, Casadaban’s colleagues <a href=\"https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/researchers-death-plague-prompts-warning-flna1c9465487\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">said </a>that was not consistently wearing protective gloves, and experts suggest that the bacteria entered his bloodstream through a small wound or mucosa.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"How to manage plague outbreaks?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In the event of a plague outbreak, the WHO <a href=\"https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/plague\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">issues</a> the following recommendations to the authorities: find and stop the source of infection; protect health workers by instructing them and providing them with protective equipment and antibiotics; isolate patients with pneumonic plague and ensure the correct treatment; identify and monitor close contacts of pneumonic plague patients and do the testing; responsibly disinfect the spaces and ensure safe burial practices.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The plague is treated with antibiotics, primarily fluoroquinolones and aminoglycosides. According to Yakutenko, if diagnosed early, a course of antibiotics (10–14 days) will be sufficient to save the patient’s life. With timely treatment, the plague <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20191211003455/https://aif.ru/health/life/chumnye_varianty_chem_opasno_takoe_zabolevanie_i_na_kakie_vidy_ono_delitsya\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">mortality rate</a> is 5–10%, while in the Middle Ages the fatality rate reached 90–100 per cent.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"One should not self-medicate. In the case of the pneumonic form, it is not only the medication that is important, but <a href=\"https://iris.who.int/server/api/core/bitstreams/9a98f1fb-b2db-4c8b-8e4c-548e7dd4ed35/content\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">isolation </a>as well. Therefore, if suspicious symptoms arise, one must first and foremost consult a doctor.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Furthermore, the necessary medication may not be freely available. On October 3, Lyudi Baikala <a href=\"https://t.me/Baikal_People/16643\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">reported </a>that plague antibiotics are hardly distributed to Irkutsk pharmacies, and where they are available, they are sold strictly on prescription in small quantities — there are at maximum five packs in stock. This is because the Irkutsk Oblast is not among the regions known to have natural foci of the plague.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"What measures have the authorities already taken?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"According to Lyudi Baikala’s report, on the evening of October 1, Irkutsk authorities <a href=\"https://baikal-journal.ru/2026/10/02/pogibshaya-ot-chumy-v-shelehove-rabotala-laborantkoj-i-razbila-probirku-s-vozbuditelem-infekczii/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">held </a>a meeting attended by the heads of law enforcement and administrative agencies. FSB officers were assigned to escort ambulances transporting people who had been in contact with Daria on their way to undergo examinations. On the first day alone, 90 people were placed in quarantine at a COVID-19 centre. On October 2, according to the Izvestia newspaper, there were 200 people.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The regional governor, Igor Kobzev, <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/8991909\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">reported </a>that Russia’s Chief State Sanitary Doctor, Anna Popova, was also present. According to Kobzev, everyone who had been in contact with the infected woman was under medical supervision, and so far no signs of the disease have been observed in them. However, he did not specify the cause of Daria Shipilova’s death.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It has been indirectly confirmed that the cause of death was the plague by Alexei Tsydenov, the head of the neighbouring Russian region, Buryatia. He <a href=\"https://t.me/Baikal_People/16631\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">stated </a>that the deceased laboratory technician had not visited the Buryatia republic and that the source of the infection lay outside the region. Following this, Baikalsk (a town 145 km away from Irkutsk) authorities <a href=\"https://t.me/Baikal_People/16631\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">urged </a>residents to refrain from travelling to Shelekhov (the town where Daria died) and its neighbouring settlements. Later, they deleted the post.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Irkutsk Oblast authorities have not acknowledged the outbreak of plague yet. However, quarantine measures were introduced in the region: three city clinical hospitals (Nos. 1, 3 and 10), the Ivano-Matreninskaya Children’s Hospital and the city maternity hospital were placed under quarantine. On October 3, the Irkutsk Aluminium Plant in Shelekhov introduced a mask <a href=\"https://t.me/AFirkaz/421\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">mandate </a>for the first time since the pandemic began.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The press office of Rospotrebnadzor finally commented on the situation on October 4. The agency <a href=\"https://tass.ru/obschestvo/28180077\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">announced </a>that the sanitary and epidemiological situation was stable and cited the cause of Daria Shipilova’s death as “pneumonia of unknown aetiology.” No “microorganisms linked to her professional activities” were detected in samples of her biomaterial, the agency stated.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Are such measures enough?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"As the authorities are providing little information about the measures taken and deny that Daria was infected with the plague, it is difficult to assess whether their actions have been adequate.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“We do not know what happened there. If we are talking about the pneumonic form of the plague, then yes, preventive quarantine is a good measure to prevent transmission chains, even the short ones. &lt;...&gt; When all contacts are preventatively isolated and monitored, it is possible to cut the chains of transmission at the very start and avoid further deaths,” Yakutenko <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/podcasts/p076qqzl/p0pf1q03\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">told </a>the BBC Russian Service.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":10940,"header":"Russia is Escalating its Hybrid War against Europe, but What for? ","_path":"/en/stories/2026/10/05/russia-is-escalating-its-hybrid-war-against-europe-but-what-for/","lead":"This is what we know about the Kremlin’s methods and objectives","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":266,"real_height_2x":533},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":266,"real_height_2x":533},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":199,"real_width_2x":399,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48a0b42edf44d38814bba703c0aff5f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":199,"real_width_2x":399,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Police are combing the Leipzig Airport premises following the discovery of a Russian drone carrying explosives, August 7, 2026 / Photo: Sebastian Willnow / dpa / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2026-10-05","created_at_date_time":"2026-10-02T12:00:21.524Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":37,"first_name":"Александр","last_name":"Дмитриев","first_name_en":"Aleksandr","last_name_en":"Dmitriev","ordering":null}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"“There will be more (Russian — Ed.) hybrid threat actions in the next few months. It will be a dark winter for Europe,” Belgian defence minister Theo Franken warned on September 30. He and his European Union counterparts have already begun discussing a new protocol for responding to Russian hybrid threats. NATO officials are also calling for a revision of its defence approach in the context of hybrid warfare.\nWhat methods is Russia using to wage its hybrid warfare against Europe and why is the Kremlin doing all of this at all?\n\nDirect aggression: drones, aircraft, and beyond\nStarting in the early months of the full-scale war, Russian drones have been entering the airspace of countries neighbouring Ukraine. As early as mid-March 2022, a Romanian farmer found an ‘Orlan-10’ reconnaissance UAV, brought it home on his tractor and reported it to the police.\nSince then, Russian drones or missiles launched at Ukraine have repeatedly flown into the airspace of Romania, Moldova, Poland, Latvia and Lithuania. The Romanian armed forces alone have recorded around 80 instances of drones or their debris falling. Usually, it happens either due to the guidance system errors or because the munitions trajectories are affected by Ukrainian air defence or electronic warfare systems. Sometimes drones and missiles leave the third country’s airspace after a short while.\nIn September 2025, 19 Russian decoy Gerbera drones carrying no explosives flew into Poland all at once. Some of them were shot down by NATO aircraft; this was the first time since the start of the Russian invasion of Ukraine that the Alliance’s air force had destroyed Russian UAVs. One of the missiles fired at the drones fell onto a village house due to a guidance system malfunction, but did not explode. No one was injured.\nPrior to this, isolated incidents of drones falling in European countries were usually described as accidental, but the aerial incursion into Poland was deemed deliberate, which was stated by Polish and German authorities. The American Institute for the Study of War (ISW) suggested that Russia may have been preparing this operation for several months.\nSince the war began, the number of incidents involving Russian military aircraft at NATO’s air borders has increased. For example, in July 2026, NATO aircraft would be scrambled to intercept Russian aircraft 3.5 times more frequently than in July 2025. Interception refers to identificating the aircraft, establishing visual contact and escorting it. In most cases, NATO scrambles the jets when the Russian ones approach the Alliance’s border without a flight plan and with their transponders switched off. However, sometimes Russian aircraft do cross the air border.\nThe most notable incident occurred a year ago, when three Russian MiG-31s (the aircraft Russia uses to launch ‘Kinzhal’ missiles at Ukraine) spent 12 minutes in Estonian airspace. A few days later, European diplomats privately warned Russia that they were prepared to shoot aircraft down should such incidents recur, according to Bloomberg. On 18 March 2026, a Russian Su-30 spent approximately one minute in Estonian airspace.\n\nSabotage acts within Europe\nSince the beginning of the full-scale war, there have likely been hundreds of Russian sabotage acts within Europe. By August 2025, the International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS) had reported 66 operations linked to Russia’s hybrid war. The International Centre for Counter-Terrorism (ICCT) and GLOBSEC estimated 151 incidents linked to Russia by the first four years of the war.\nIn 2026, dozens of sabotage acts have taken place at defence enterprises and infrastructure sites across Europe. The most prominent case was the Leipzig Airport incident, when a drone carrying explosives was discovered near a Ukrainian transport aircraft carrying ammunition intended for the Ukrainian Armed Forces. US intelligence concluded that the design of the explosive device and the explosive itself were typical of those used in operations by GRU, the main intelligence directorate of the Russian general staff. Germany officially accused Russia of involvement in the attempted attack.\nIn addition to the direct acts of sabotage, Russia also launches its reconnaissance drones over Europe — not only to gather intelligence, but also to create economic and psychological pressure on Europeans, according to the IISS. The Institute estimates that between August 2024 and February 2026, Russians launched 144 drones into European airspace, sometimes using shadow fleet tankers. UAVs have been spotted both over military bases and civilian facilities such as airports. Trouw and DroneWatch, however, recorded more than 50 cases where the information following drone sighting reports was inconclusive between 9 September and 27 November 2025. IStories explained why this happens.\nFibre-optic cables on the seabed of the Baltic Sea have also become a target for sabotage attacks. From October 2023 to the end of 2025, at least 11 instances of cable breakage or damage were recorded. In April 2026, NATO ships disrupted Russian exercises in the Arctic where the Russians were testing a ‘new technology’ designed to damage deep-sea cables, sources told Reuters. The weapon was being tested by the Main Directorate of Deep-Sea Research (GUGI), which is part of the Russian Ministry of Defence.\nOther ways Russia is waging hybrid warfare\nCyberattacks. This is one of the main directions of Russia’s hybrid warfare against Europe, according to the Centre for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS). Some notable operations include a large-scale attack on energy infrastructure in Poland and an attack on a Norwegian dam which hackers were able to take control of and open its floodgates for four hours.\n\nGPS jamming. Most often, this happens because of Russian electronic warfare against Ukraine's drones. However, experts suggest this might also be an attempt to create a ‘sense of unease’ in Western countries. The Russians use both ground-based jammers (which can interfere with signals up to 450 km away from the Russian border) as well as those in space.\n\nDisinformation. The European Union has recorded thousands of instances of Russian disinformation aimed at discrediting Ukraine and Ukraine-friendly politicians as well as at praising Russia. The ‘Storm-1516’ project is described by Bloomberg as the most powerful weapon in Russia’s disinformation arsenal. The GRU is likely to be behind the project, while the content is created by the late Yevgeny Prigozhin’s ‘troll factory’ ex-employees. Often, the aim of these information campaigns is election interference. Here you can read more on how Russian propaganda’s fake news actually influences voting results.\n\nSending migrants to Europe. Russia is smuggling citizens of various Middle East and Asia countries into the EU via Belarus. In particular, tunnels from Belarus to Poland are being used for this purpose, according to The Telegraph.\nAssassination attempts. The most high-profile operations (the murders of Alexander Litvinenko and Zelimkhan Khangoshvili, and the attempted murders of Sergei Skripal and Emilian Gebrev) had been carried out before 2022. Since the full-scale invasion began, Russia has murdered Maxim Kuzminov, a Russian pilot who had defected to Ukraine. An unsuccessful plot to kill Armin Papperger, the head of Rheinmetall, a major German arms manufacturer, is another example.\n\nWhy is Russia doing all of this?\n\nThere are relatively few instances of Russian hybrid attacks in Europe able to directly influence the volume of military support for Ukraine. But those have happened — for example, the fires and explosions at factories producing weapons and ammunition. However, whilst the damage caused by a single sabotage act may not be extraordinary, it is wrong to view it in isolation from the overall military strategy, Pavel Luzin, a military analyst, says: “Every successful sabotage act builds up the damage.”\n\nUsually experts refer to broader objectives when speaking about Russian hybrid attacks.\n\nThe first objective is to intimidate Europe and force it to withdraw its support for Ukraine. The Kremlin believes that it can defeat Ukraine if Russia’s military capabilities ultimately outweigh the support Kyiv receives from Europe, the Institute for the Study of War reports. According to this logic, sabotage acts and other hybrid warfare tools are intended to force the European governments to withdraw or at least reduce their military and diplomatic support for Ukraine.\n\nRussia cannot influence the European ruling establishment directly, which is why the Kremlin is attempting to intimidate European voters, Abbas Galliamov, a political analyst, believes. The expectation is for Europeans to cast their votes for parties similar to the far-right ‘Alternative for Germany’ or the French ‘National Front.’ “[The members of these parties — Ed.] say: ‘We mustn’t upset Putin; we need to negotiate with him, or it will be bad for us, and there will be war.’ This is betting on an ostrich-like stance, where you simply want to bury your head in the sand without thinking about the future,” Galliamov explains. The situation in Ukraine is, of course, not the main issue for European voters; the problem of migration, for example, is far more pressing. But for many, the far-right parties' stance on the war may well become an additional reason to vote for them, Galliamov says.\n\nThe second objective is to test the limits of what can go unpunished. A month ago, Hanno Pevkur, the Estonian defence minister, said Russia was constantly testing the limits of Article 5 (of the North Atlantic Treaty — Ed.), trying to find the “red line.” The article Pevkur referred to states that an armed attack against one NATO member shall be considered an attack against them all, and each member will assist the party attacked. However, this does not necessarily mean military aid.\nThe problem with Article 5 is that there’s no clear criteria for its invocation. In the entire history of NATO, the article has been invoked just once — following the September 11 attack in 2001. Currently, all of Russia’s hybrid war attacks are carefully calculated so as not to provide grounds for Article 5 invocation, according to The Telegraph's sources within Western intelligence.\n“Every successful sabotage act serves as a test of the limits and of the way the target reacts, and a test of the strengths and weaknesses in the target’s defence, which can be used to plan and carry out further actions,” explains Pavel Luzin, a military analyst.\n\nSo far, NATO member states have only invoked Article 4 in response to Russia’s actions (twice). This article only provides for mandatory consultations in case one of the member states considers its ‘territorial integrity, political independence or security’ under threat. Last year, such consultations were requested by Poland (following the drone incursion) and Estonia (following the aforementioned airspace violation by Russian aircraft). The invocation of Article 4 should not be regarded as a serious step; tangible measures to counter Russian provocations would be far more effective, says Gleb Bogush, an international law expert.\n\nThe third objective is to lay the groundwork for a possible invasion. The Kremlin might not have explicitly decided that it is in its best interests to fight a conventional war with NATO, but it is “undoubtedly setting conditions to do so in the future if it so chooses,” according to ISW. The hybrid warfare attacks are aimed, amongst other things, at sowing division within NATO, as its officials acknowledge. This could affect NATO’s willingness to defend a member state in the event of a Russian invasion.\n\nFurthermore, ISW reports, the Russian military may be violating NATO’s airspace in order to gather intelligence; in particular, to understand the alliance’s air defence response patterns.","blocks":[{"data":"“There will be more (Russian — Ed.) hybrid threat actions in the next few months. It will be a dark winter for Europe,” Belgian defence minister Theo Franken <a href=\"https://www.euronews.com/2026/09/30/belgian-minister-theo-francken-warns-europe-everything-has-to-go-faster-on-defence\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">warned </a>on September 30. He and his European Union counterparts have already <a href=\"https://www.eurointegration.com.ua/rus/news/2026/09/28/7246463/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">begun </a>discussing a new protocol for responding to Russian hybrid threats. NATO officials are also <a href=\"https://www.ft.com/content/83e08169-69b5-4997-9bf0-e0622e752eda?syn-25a6b1a6=1\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">calling </a>for a revision of its defence approach in the context of hybrid warfare.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"What methods is Russia using to wage its hybrid warfare against Europe and why is the Kremlin doing all of this at all?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Direct aggression: drones, aircraft, and beyond","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Starting in the early months of the full-scale war, Russian drones have been entering the airspace of countries neighbouring Ukraine. As early as mid-March 2022, a Romanian farmer <a href=\"https://www.stirilekanald.ro/un-barbat-din-bistrita-a-gasit-o-drona-ruseasca-pe-care-a-pus-o-in-tractor-si-a-transportat-o-acasa-ce-au-descoperit-specialistii-care-au-analizat-o-20207606\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">found </a>an ‘Orlan-10’ reconnaissance UAV, brought it home on his tractor and reported it to the police.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Since then, Russian drones or missiles launched at Ukraine have repeatedly flown into the airspace of Romania, Moldova, Poland, Latvia and Lithuania. The Romanian armed forces alone have <a href=\"https://english.mapn.ro/index.php\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">recorded </a>around 80 instances of drones or their debris falling. Usually, it happens either due to the guidance system errors or because the munitions trajectories are affected by Ukrainian air defence or electronic warfare systems. Sometimes drones and missiles leave the third country’s airspace after a short while.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19469,"data":{"text":"We can’t survive without your support","title":"Help IStories","buttonText":"Donate"},"category":"donate-embed"},"type":"donate-embed"},{"data":"In September 2025, 19 Russian decoy Gerbera drones carrying no explosives flew into Poland all at once. Some of them were shot down by NATO aircraft; this was the first time since the start of the Russian invasion of Ukraine that the Alliance’s air force had destroyed Russian UAVs. One of the missiles fired at the drones fell onto a village house due to a guidance system malfunction, but did not explode. No one was injured.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Prior to this, isolated incidents of drones falling in European countries were usually described as accidental, but the aerial incursion into Poland was deemed deliberate, which was stated by <a href=\"https://x.com/sikorskiradek/status/1965808917520261138\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Polish </a>and <a href=\"https://www.politico.eu/article/germany-friedrich-merz-kremlin-nato-russia-drones-poland-defense/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">German </a>authorities. The American Institute for the Study of War (ISW) <a href=\"https://understandingwar.org/research/russia-ukraine/russian-offensive-campaign-assessment-september-10-2025/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">suggested </a>that Russia may have been preparing this operation for several months.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Since the war began, the number of incidents involving Russian military aircraft at NATO’s air borders has increased. For example, in July 2026, NATO aircraft would be <a href=\"https://understandingwar.org/research/russia-ukraine/russian-offensive-campaign-assessment-september-10-2025/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">scrambled </a>to intercept Russian aircraft 3.5 times more frequently than in July 2025. Interception refers to identificating the aircraft, establishing visual contact and escorting it. In most cases, NATO scrambles the jets when the Russian ones approach the Alliance’s border without a flight plan and with their transponders switched off. However, sometimes Russian aircraft do cross the air border.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The most notable incident occurred a year ago, when three Russian MiG-31s (the aircraft Russia uses to launch ‘Kinzhal’ missiles at Ukraine) <a href=\"https://rus.err.ee/1609806333/tri-rossijskih-istrebitelja-na-12-minut-vtorglis-v-vozdushnoe-prostranstvo-jestonii\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">spent </a>12 minutes in Estonian airspace. A few days later, European diplomats privately warned Russia that they were prepared to shoot aircraft down should such incidents recur, <a href=\"https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-09-25/europeans-privately-tell-russia-they-re-ready-to-shoot-down-jets?srnd=homepage-europe\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">according </a>to Bloomberg. On 18 March 2026, a Russian Su-30 <a href=\"https://www.vm.ee/en/news/foreign-minister-tsahkna-fighter-aircraft-russian-federation-violated-estonian-airspace\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">spent </a>approximately one minute in Estonian airspace.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Sabotage acts within Europe","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Since the beginning of the full-scale war, there have likely been hundreds of Russian sabotage acts within Europe. By August 2025, the International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS) had <a href=\"https://www.iiss.org/research-paper/2025/08/the-scale-of-russian--sabotage-operations--against-europes-critical--infrastructure/?utm_source=chatgpt.com\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">reported </a>66 operations linked to Russia’s hybrid war. The International Centre for Counter-Terrorism (ICCT) and GLOBSEC <a href=\"https://globsec.org/publication/update-russia-crime-terror-nexus-hybrid-warfare-europe?__cf_chl_rt_tk=1khsWFFlZeYUwl4SepNQzvPICJlqTWZAOifzfVK9VRU-1791556403-1.0.1.1-2k42Oz5ZDQORuIRRI_T0SBJ34DvG82j3Lr900AyB668\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">estimated</a> 151 incidents linked to Russia by the first four years of the war.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2026, dozens of sabotage acts have taken place at defence enterprises and infrastructure sites across Europe. The most prominent case was the Leipzig Airport incident, when a drone carrying explosives was discovered near a Ukrainian transport aircraft carrying ammunition intended for the Ukrainian Armed Forces. US intelligence <a href=\"https://abcnews.com/International/leipzig-airport-drone-linked-russian-military-intelligence-us/story?id=135945223\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">concluded </a>that the design of the explosive device and the explosive itself were typical of those used in operations by GRU, the main intelligence directorate of the Russian general staff. Germany officially <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/articles/c1l6v0ygl93o\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">accused </a>Russia of involvement in the attempted attack.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In addition to the direct acts of sabotage, Russia also launches its reconnaissance drones over Europe — not only to gather intelligence, but also to create economic and psychological pressure on Europeans, according to the <a href=\"https://www.iiss.org/globalassets/media-library---content--migration/images-delta/publications/research-papers/2026-new/russia-uav/ammended-file/russia_uav-campaign-over-europe.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">IISS</a>. The Institute estimates that between August 2024 and February 2026, Russians launched 144 drones into European airspace, sometimes using shadow fleet tankers. UAVs have been spotted both over military bases and civilian facilities such as airports. Trouw and DroneWatch, however, <a href=\"https://www.dronewatch.eu/61-european-drone-sightings-analysed-heres-what-we-know/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">recorded </a>more than 50 cases where the information following drone sighting reports was inconclusive between 9 September and 27 November 2025. IStories <a href=\"https://www.istories.media/stories/2025/10/10/v-yevrope-zakrivayut-aeroporti-iz-za-ugrozi-bespilotnikov-a-droni-tochno-tam-bili-i-kak-mozhno-zashchitit-aeroport/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">explained </a>why this happens.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Fibre-optic cables on the seabed of the Baltic Sea have also become a target for sabotage attacks. From October 2023 to the end of 2025, at least 11 instances of cable breakage or damage were <a href=\"https://www.internazionale.it/ultime-notizie-reuters/2026/09/10/exclusive-nato-allies-foil-russian-subsea-cable-sabotage-plot\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">recorded</a>. In April 2026, NATO ships disrupted Russian exercises in the Arctic where the Russians were testing a ‘new technology’ designed to damage deep-sea cables, <a href=\"https://www.internazionale.it/ultime-notizie-reuters/2026/09/10/exclusive-nato-allies-foil-russian-subsea-cable-sabotage-plot\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">sources </a>told Reuters. The weapon was being tested by the Main Directorate of Deep-Sea Research (GUGI), which is part of the Russian Ministry of Defence.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19472,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"AFP PHOTO / FINNISH BORDER GUARD","caption":"A Finnish border patrol vessel escorting the Eagle S tanker, which had severed five undersea cables in the Baltic Sea, March 2 2025","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2b6fa670035c4cbb94e93438cd723ebb-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2b6fa670035c4cbb94e93438cd723ebb-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2b6fa670035c4cbb94e93438cd723ebb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":1440,"real_height_2x":2880},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2b6fa670035c4cbb94e93438cd723ebb-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2b6fa670035c4cbb94e93438cd723ebb-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2b6fa670035c4cbb94e93438cd723ebb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":1440,"real_height_2x":2880},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2b6fa670035c4cbb94e93438cd723ebb-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2b6fa670035c4cbb94e93438cd723ebb-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2b6fa670035c4cbb94e93438cd723ebb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":900,"real_height_2x":1800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2b6fa670035c4cbb94e93438cd723ebb-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2b6fa670035c4cbb94e93438cd723ebb-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2b6fa670035c4cbb94e93438cd723ebb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":900,"real_height_2x":1800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2b6fa670035c4cbb94e93438cd723ebb-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2b6fa670035c4cbb94e93438cd723ebb-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2b6fa670035c4cbb94e93438cd723ebb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":311,"real_height_2x":622},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2b6fa670035c4cbb94e93438cd723ebb-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2b6fa670035c4cbb94e93438cd723ebb-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2b6fa670035c4cbb94e93438cd723ebb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":311,"real_height_2x":622}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Other ways Russia is waging hybrid warfare","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"<li><strong>Cyberattacks.</strong> This is one of the main directions of Russia’s hybrid warfare against Europe, <a href=\"https://www.csis.org/analysis/enter-europes-cyber-deterrence#h2-executive-summary\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">according </a>to the Centre for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS). Some notable operations include a large-scale <a href=\"https://www.dw.com/ru/polsa-obvinila-hakerov-iz-fsb-v-kiberatakah-na-energetiku-vo-vrema-morozov/a-75743903\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">attack </a>on energy infrastructure in Poland and an attack on a Norwegian <a href=\"https://www.abc.net.au/news/2025-08-14/norway-spy-chief-blames-russian-hackers-for-dam-sabotage/105650772\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">dam</a> which hackers were able to take control of and open its floodgates for four hours.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<li><strong>GPS jamming.</strong> Most often, this happens because of Russian electronic warfare against Ukraine's drones. However, experts <a href=\"https://theins.ru/news/270376\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">suggest </a>this might also be an attempt to create a ‘sense of unease’ in Western countries. The Russians use both ground-based jammers (which can interfere with signals up to <a href=\"https://www.internazionale.it/ultime-notizie-reuters/2026/05/26/russia-can-falsify-gps-signals-deep-into-europe-lithuania-says\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">450 </a>km away from the Russian border) as well as those in <a href=\"https://www.nytimes.com/2026/06/05/world/europe/russia-satellites-gps-interference-europe.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">space</a>.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<li><strong>Disinformation. </strong>The European Union has <a href=\"https://www.dw.com/ru/issledovanie-rossia-glavnyj-rasprostranitel-dezinformacii-v-es/a-69089063\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">recorded </a>thousands of instances of Russian disinformation aimed at discrediting Ukraine and Ukraine-friendly politicians as well as at praising Russia. The ‘Storm-1516’ project is described by <a href=\"https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2026-russia-disinformation-storm-1516-videos/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Bloomberg </a>as the most powerful weapon in Russia’s disinformation arsenal. The GRU is likely to be behind the project, while the content is created by the late Yevgeny Prigozhin’s ‘troll factory’ ex-employees. Often, the aim of these information campaigns is election interference. <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/opinions/2026/07/30/kak-feiki-vliyayut-na-vibori/index.html?_gl=1*mi4iwx*_ga*MTY5NDA0MzQ4LjE3NzEzMjA3OTk.*_ga_86829926PE*czE3OTE1NTM5NDQkbzE1MiRnMSR0MTc5MTU1NjY1NyRqMTYkbDAkaDA.\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Here </a>you can read more on how Russian propaganda’s fake news actually influences voting results.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<li><strong>Sending migrants to Europe. </strong>Russia is smuggling citizens of various Middle East and Asia countries into the EU via Belarus. In particular, tunnels from Belarus to Poland are being used for this purpose, according to <a href=\"https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2026/02/25/russia-sends-migrants-into-europe-through-secret-tunnels/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">The Telegraph</a>.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":{"id":19473,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"AP Photo / Czarek Sokolowski","caption":"Migrants on the Belarusian side of its border with Poland, 29 May 2024","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/599935bbe61a411fa3841d1cfefe4c66-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/599935bbe61a411fa3841d1cfefe4c66-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/599935bbe61a411fa3841d1cfefe4c66-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":1280,"real_height_2x":2560},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/599935bbe61a411fa3841d1cfefe4c66-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/599935bbe61a411fa3841d1cfefe4c66-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/599935bbe61a411fa3841d1cfefe4c66-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":1280,"real_height_2x":2560},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/599935bbe61a411fa3841d1cfefe4c66-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/599935bbe61a411fa3841d1cfefe4c66-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/599935bbe61a411fa3841d1cfefe4c66-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/599935bbe61a411fa3841d1cfefe4c66-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/599935bbe61a411fa3841d1cfefe4c66-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/599935bbe61a411fa3841d1cfefe4c66-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/599935bbe61a411fa3841d1cfefe4c66-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/599935bbe61a411fa3841d1cfefe4c66-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/599935bbe61a411fa3841d1cfefe4c66-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/599935bbe61a411fa3841d1cfefe4c66-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/599935bbe61a411fa3841d1cfefe4c66-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/599935bbe61a411fa3841d1cfefe4c66-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"<li><strong>Assassination attempts. </strong>The most high-profile operations (the murders of Alexander Litvinenko and Zelimkhan Khangoshvili, and the attempted murders of Sergei Skripal and Emilian Gebrev) had been carried out before 2022. Since the full-scale invasion began, Russia has murdered Maxim Kuzminov, a Russian pilot who had defected to Ukraine. An unsuccessful <a href=\"https://www.politico.eu/article/nato-official-confirms-russian-plot-kill-european-weapons-chief-armin-papperger/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">plot</a> to kill Armin Papperger, the head of Rheinmetall, a major German arms manufacturer, is another example.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"Why is Russia doing all of this?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"There are relatively few instances of Russian hybrid attacks in Europe able to directly influence the volume of military support for Ukraine. But those have happened — for example, the <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/articles/cm2rek52ypmo\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">fires and explosions</a> at factories producing weapons and ammunition. However, whilst the damage caused by a single sabotage act may not be extraordinary, it is wrong to view it in isolation from the overall military strategy, Pavel Luzin, a military analyst, says: “Every successful sabotage act builds up the damage.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Usually experts refer to broader objectives when speaking about Russian hybrid attacks.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The first objective is to intimidate Europe and force it to withdraw its support for Ukraine. The Kremlin believes that it can defeat Ukraine if Russia’s military capabilities ultimately outweigh the support Kyiv receives from Europe, the Institute for the Study of War <a href=\"https://understandingwar.org/research/defense-of-europe/the-russian-military-campaign-against-europe-current-objectives-and-efforts/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">reports</a>. According to this logic, sabotage acts and other hybrid warfare tools are intended to force the European governments to withdraw or at least reduce their military and diplomatic support for Ukraine.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russia cannot influence the European ruling establishment directly, which is why the Kremlin is attempting to intimidate European voters, Abbas Galliamov, a political analyst, believes. The expectation is for Europeans to cast their votes for parties similar to the far-right ‘Alternative for Germany’ or the French ‘National Front.’ “[The members of these parties — Ed.] say: ‘We mustn’t upset Putin; we need to negotiate with him, or it will be bad for us, and there will be war.’ This is betting on an ostrich-like stance, where you simply want to bury your head in the sand without thinking about the future,” Galliamov explains. The situation in Ukraine is, of course, not the main issue for European voters; the problem of migration, for example, is far more pressing. But for many, the far-right parties' stance on the war may well become an additional reason to vote for them, Galliamov says.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The second objective is to test the limits of what can go unpunished. A month ago, Hanno Pevkur, the Estonian defence minister, <a href=\"https://rus.err.ee/1610125186/pevkur-rossija-postojanno-proverjaet-gde-prohodit-krasnaja-linija-pjatoj-stati-nato\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">said </a>Russia was constantly testing the limits of Article 5 (of the North Atlantic Treaty — Ed.), trying to find the “red line.” The article Pevkur referred to states that an armed attack against one NATO member <a href=\"https://www.nato.int/en/what-we-do/introduction-to-nato/collective-defence-and-article-5\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">shall be considered</a> an attack against them all, and each member will assist the party attacked. However, this does not necessarily mean military aid.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19470,"data":{"author":"Pavel Luzin, a military analyst","header":"Every successful sabotage act serves as a test of the limits and of the way the target reacts"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"The problem with Article 5 is that there’s no clear criteria for its invocation. In the entire history of NATO, the article has been invoked just once — following the September 11 attack in 2001. Currently, all of Russia’s hybrid war attacks are carefully calculated so as not to provide grounds for Article 5 invocation, <a href=\"https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2026/08/23/russia-targets-weapons-factories-in-new-campaign/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">according </a>to The Telegraph's sources within Western intelligence.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Every successful sabotage act serves as a test of the limits and of the way the target reacts, and a test of the strengths and weaknesses in the target’s defence, which can be used to plan and carry out further actions,” explains Pavel Luzin, a military analyst.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"So far, NATO member states have only invoked <a href=\"https://www.nato.int/en/what-we-do/introduction-to-nato/the-consultation-process-and-article-4\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Article 4</a> in response to Russia’s actions (twice). This article only provides for mandatory consultations in case one of the member states considers its ‘territorial integrity, political independence or security’ under threat. Last year, such consultations were requested by Poland (following the drone incursion) and Estonia (following the aforementioned airspace violation by Russian aircraft). The invocation of Article 4 should not be regarded as a serious step; tangible measures to counter Russian provocations would be far more effective, says Gleb Bogush, an international law expert.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The third objective is to lay the groundwork for a possible invasion. The Kremlin might not have explicitly decided that it is in its best interests to fight a conventional war with NATO, but it is “undoubtedly setting conditions to do so in the future if it so chooses,” <a href=\"https://understandingwar.org/research/defense-of-europe/the-russian-military-campaign-against-europe-current-objectives-and-efforts/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">according </a>to ISW. The hybrid warfare attacks are aimed, amongst other things, at sowing division within NATO, as its officials <a href=\"https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2026/08/23/russia-targets-weapons-factories-in-new-campaign/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">acknowledge</a>. This could affect NATO’s willingness to defend a member state in the event of a Russian invasion.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Furthermore, ISW reports, the Russian military may be violating NATO’s airspace in order to gather intelligence; in particular, to understand the alliance’s air defence response patterns.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":10796,"header":"About 60% of Paper Votes for United Russia Might be Fabricated","_path":"/en/stories/2026/09/22/duma-elections-anomalies/","lead":"Anomalies and statistics show that 18 of 30 millions of “paper votes” for United Russia in last week’s elections might actually be fabricated, which would mean that the ruling party’s real result would be at around 35% instead of the declared 58%","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-original.png","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-original.png","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-original.png","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-original.png","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-original.png","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-original.png","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-original.png","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-original.png","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-original.png","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-original.png","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-original.png","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-original.png","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-original.png","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3cdde7133ab54978a967d0f0a9c38eb1-original.png","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Picture: IStories. Photo: Shamil Zhumatov / Reuters / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2026-09-22","created_at_date_time":"2026-09-22T13:19:02.394Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":true,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":58,"first_name":"Рина","last_name":"Николаева","first_name_en":"Rina","last_name_en":"Nikolaeva","is_public":true,"_path":"rina-nikolaeva","avatar":[],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":1},{"id":86,"first_name":"Тимур","last_name":"Хайрутдинов","first_name_en":"Timur","last_name_en":"Khairutdinov","is_public":true,"_path":"timur-khairutdinov","avatar":[],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":2}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[{"id":31,"first_name":"Катя","last_name":"Бонч-Осмоловская","first_name_en":"Katya","last_name_en":"Bonch-Osmolovskaya","is_public":true,"_path":"katya-bonch-osmolovskaya","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.jpeg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.jpeg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.jpeg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.jpeg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редакторка дата-отдела","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":null,"ordering":1}],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"According to the preliminary results from Russia’s Central Election Commission, the ruling United Russia party is winning 58% of the vote on party lists and is also winning in most single-member districts. It is about to win 355 of the 450 seats in the State Duma, which will be the largest parliamentary faction in the party’s history: in the 2021 elections, it held 324 seats. According to the Election Commission, the Communist Party of the Russian Federation (CPRF) is running second (with 14% of the vote), followed by the Liberal Democratic Party of Russia (LDPR) with their 9%, followed by New People (8%) and A Just Russia (5%). The final results will be announced on Friday, September 25.\n\nThe election was accompanied by numerous violations. Observers were denied access to polling stations, beaten, detained, and prohibited from recording videos. There were reports of ballot stuffing, voter coercion, ballot tampering, and other violations.\n\nThe authorities had created the conditions for an uncontested election from the start. A month and a half before the vote, Russia’s Supreme Court barred Yabloko, the only anti-war party, from running in the election. The authorities launched repressions against the party members. Twelve of them have been charged with criminal offenses, and eight are in custody. The party’s deputy chairman, Lev Shlosberg, was sentenced to 11 years in prison. Two Yabloko members, Konstantin Smirnov and Elena Perepelitsa, remain in pretrial detention.\n\nVoting took place on September 18–20 using the new GAS Vybory 2.0 (‘Elections 2.0’) system, which was used for federal elections for the first time. IStories had published a detailed investigation into the system and discovered that it allows for results tampering, voter rolls fraud and uploading unverified results from remote electronic voting systems.\n\nIn this article, we report on the anomalies we were able to identify in the voting results using statistical methods.\n\nUnited Russia got no more than 35% of the real vote share\nAccording to IStories calculations, instead of the claimed 58% of the vote, United Russia may actually have no more than 35%. Novaya Gazeta Europe reached a similar conclusion. Boris Ovchinnikov, an election analyst we consulted, also agrees with this assessment.\n\nWe arrived at the 35% estimate based on the voting results analyst Petr Zhizhin compiled from the Central Election Commission’s website data by the evening of September 21. At that time, 94% of the vote count had been entered into the database. The commission had not yet published the complete data for Bashkortostan with its 3 million voters, for the Leningrad and Smolensk Oblasts and the occupied territories of Ukraine (apart from Crimea).\n\nWe excluded Moscow from the analysis: approximately 80% of the votes there were cast via electronic voting, and the results were published without a breakdown by polling station. We also did not include the results of electronic voting in 32 regions. Based on this calculation, it appears that approximately 18.4 million of the 30 million paper ballots cast for United Russia — according to the data as of September 21 — may have been falsified. This means that more than 60% of the “paper” votes for the ruling party may be fabricated.\n\nThe method we used to analyze the data was first applied to Russian elections by Sergei Shpilkin, a physicist and election analyst. The method is based on the premise that the ratio of votes cast for different candidates and parties should not change depending on voter turnout. When commission members stuff the ballot boxes, they thereby increase voter turnout numbers. And since they stuff the boxes in favor of pro-government candidates, United Russia’s result would be rising alongside voter turnout.\n\nThe polling stations where the voting was fair should be forming a dense “cloud” on the chart, meanwhile the polling stations where ballot stuffing occurred are located at the top right and look like a comet’s tail. In the 2026 State Duma elections, the cluster of fraudless polling stations is located around the 35% vote share for United Russia. Most polling stations are in the “comet’s tail” zone, which indicates widespread ballot stuffing. You can read more about Sergey Shpilkin’s method in the explainer.\nWe defined the real turnout range — at which United Russia’s result does not yet correlate with the turnout numbers — at 20–29 percent. Based on the vote ratio for different candidates at this turnout level, we calculated the potential number of fraudulent ballots.\nIn fair elections, the graph showing the relationship between the number of votes and voter turnout resembles a bell curve. For example, this is what the turnout distribution looked like in the 2000 presidential election. Experts call those elections the fairest in the history of modern Russia. A different picture emerges in the 2016 State Duma elections and further on, where “peaks” appear on the right side of the graph. Those peaks are what votes rigged for the ruling party look like, as its share of the vote increases along with voter turnout.\nTurnout fabrications\nAccording to the Central Election Commission, turnout stood at 59.32 percent. This is a record for State Duma elections since 2011 (60.21 percent). “The Kremlin went too far with its another wartime election,” Mikhail Komin, a political analyst, notes. “In 2024, Putin achieved a result more typical of Latin American and Central Asian dictatorships (87% with a 77% turnout) than of his own previous term's results. Now, in the 2026 State Duma elections, the results are no less historic.” Analysts Roman Udot and Boris Ovchinnikov believe that the actual turnout was around 40%.\n\nElection commissions began falsifying turnout figures from day one, analyst Ivan Shukshin pointed out. For example, by 8:00 p.m. on September 18, an unusually high number of commissions reported a turnout of 30%. The same thing happened on the second day of voting, when the most common reported turnout figure was precisely 40% — and 85% on the third day. In normal circumstances, people across decide to go to the polls randomly and independently of each other, so the turnout distribution among law-abiding commissions should follow a simple bell curve,” Shukshin explains. “Peaks at round numbers (40%, 60%, 65%, etc) appear when the figures are fabricated.”\nVirtually all voters at unusually high turnout polling stations — those where the turnout neared 100% — voted for United Russia members. Mikhail Matveev, a State Duma candidate from CPRF who had been temporarily barred from participating in the election, drew attention to polling station 0618 in the Borsky District in Samara Oblast. The commission reported a turnout of 98.53%; according to the same data, Matveev received 14 votes, while Alexandr Zhivaykin, his opponent from United Russia, received 704 votes. The Yabloko initiative group also reported similar results favoring candidates from the ruling party in New Moscow .\n\nDuring previous elections, election commissions artificially increased turnout numbers in order to be able to falsely add votes for the ruling party's candidates. According to sources cited by Meduza, ahead of this election, officials from the presidential administration demanded that regional administrations ensure turnout numbers of more than 50 percent.\n\nOn the first day of the election, neighboring polling stations under the “Sovetskaya” Territorial Election Commission in Dagestan submitted reports showing identical voter turnout figures—another sign of vote rigging also noted by Shushkin. Similar unnatural turnout figures were also detected at election commissions in the Ivanovo and Leningrad Oblasts, in Kuzbass, in the Primorsky and Krasnodar krais and in St. Petersburg. In Kabardino-Balkaria, virtually identical turnout figures were recorded by every single polling station in the republic.\n\nAnomalous turnout and United Russia’s share in the final hours of the voting\nAccording to the official data, at some polling stations, election commissions may have added votes for United Russia right before the polls closed. For example, at two neighboring polling stations 322 and 338 in district 48 in the Kamchatka Krai, two hours before polls closed (from 6 to 8 p.m. on September 20), turnout suddenly jumped from their respective 7% and 17% to 100%, as noted by IStories. Irina Yarovaya, co-author of the law on internet surveillance, was running for the State Duma in this district. During the last two hours of voting, she identically received a record-breaking 97% of the vote at both polling stations and was re-elected to the State Duma. Yarovaya has held a seat in the State Duma for 19 years, and she now has five more years to go.\n\nIdentical results at neighboring polling stations\nAnother sign of fraud is when neighboring polling stations report virtually identical results. This may indicate that they are following a directive handed down from the authorities. In a fair election, votes at neighboring polling stations cannot be distributed identically down to hundredths of a percent. The probability of this is extremely low, but we have identified numerous regions with this anomaly.\n\nFor example, in Dagestan, the results at 11 out of 53 territorial commissions are practically identical. At 45 polling stations in Derbent, United Russia “won” with their results ranging from 93.84% to 95.03%. This is statistically impossible in a genuine voting process.\nVote manipulation\nObservers recorded commission members transferring votes for other candidates to United Russia by literally putting ballots in a different pile. “The chairperson takes a ballot with a vote for candidate No. 4, New People's Zharkova, but reads out the surname of the United Russia candidate, Romanenko. The same thing happens with the next ballot,” Daria Bagina, an observer, reports. A Yabloko observer at polling station 440 in Moscow noticed that ballots used for voting for the Yabloko candidate Viktor Kogan-Yasny, as well as for other candidates, were being placed in the United Russia pile.\n\nBut most of the vote tampering takes place without observers present. “At Moscow polling stations, they did indeed shift ballots in favor of United Russia candidates during the vote count, but this is apparently only the first level of fraud,” Boris Ovchinnikov notes. “I am certain that virtually all result reports showing a turnout of more than 75–85% (but less than 100%) were filled out with no connection to the actual count of completed ballots whatsoever. This explains the recurring vote shares across different polling stations as well as other anomalies. Where there were no actual observers present, they could have entered any numbers into the protocol and then further alter the results when entering them into the digital elections system.”\n\nVote transfer is evident in the data. It occurs at polling stations with a turnout of more than 82%. Until then, United Russia’s results are rigged through ballot stuffing: its share increases along with turnout, while the results of the other parties remain unchanged in absolute numbers. But starting at a turnout of 83%, votes for all parties except “United Russia” begin to disappear. Their results drop by more than half. At the same time, the ruling party’s results rise in a corresponding manner. This may indicate that at such polling stations, ballots for candidates from other parties are being counted as votes for United Russia.\n\nOn the graph, this pattern of votes resembles a pair of tongs. Some of the 18.4 million falsified votes may have been obtained through such vote transfers.\nAt the same time, when the turnout approaches 100%, United Russia’s share of the vote declines, while that of all other parties, on the contrary, rises. Boris Ovchinnikov explains this by the fact that there is usually no fraud at such polling stations: “A turnout of exactly 100% automatically occurs at ‘special polling stations’: in hospitals, detention centers and on ships. Anywhere where there are no permanent residents, everyone votes on a temporary voter list. Those who do not vote simply do not make it onto the list.”\n\nIn addition to United Russia, votes for A Just Russia party may also have been rigged in these elections. Election analyst Stanislav Andreychuk noted that on September 21, A Just Russia suddenly gained 60,000 votes, which allowed the party to reach the 5 percent threshold needed to enter the State Duma. “Just one phone call, a decision was made, and the numbers were rewritten right away,” Andreychuk suggests.\n\nResults abroad: emigrants against United Russia\nThe New People party received 43% of the vote and came first at polling stations abroad, according to independent exit polls conducted by the Vote Abroad project. Surveyors interviewed those voting in 22 countries and collected 15,700 responses.\n\nUnited Russia only got 5.5% of the vote. The New People party also leads according to the exit polls conducted by Vesna and Progress movements.\n\nAt the same time, according to preliminary data from the Central Election Commission, United Russia won at polling stations abroad, with 45.49% of the vote. New People came in second, getting 22.42% of the vote. A total of 212,000 Russians cast their ballots abroad.\n\nUnited Russia lost the elections in at least 40 out of 152 countries. In 39 countries, New People came first; they got their highest vote share in Slovenia, Serbia, and the Netherlands. United Russia also lost in the anti-war emigration hubs, such as Armenia, Kazakhstan, and Montenegro. Previously, Russians living in these countries would mostly vote for pro-government candidates and parties. The ruling party also lost to New People in those countries in the Middle East and Asia where thousands of Russians have also moved since 2022: the UAE, Israel, Vietnam, Thailand, and China.\nUnited Russia received its highest share of the vote abroad (79%) in the Central African Republic. Its vote share was also high in Moldova (77%), Russian-occupied South Ossetia (73%), Lebanon (70%), and Tajikistan (70%). United Russia also won in a number of Western countries: Greece (56%), Estonia (50%), Italy (40%), Switzerland (36%), and the United States (34%).\n\nUnverifiable remote voting results and the occupied territories of Ukraine\n\nAnomalies in the remote electronic voting system at the elections were detected as early as on the first day of voting. The Belgorod Territorial Election Commission closed remote voting in District No. 80 just three hours after it began, Ivan Shukshin noted. Approximately one-third of the voters who had registered for electronic voting cast their ballots in those three hours. This was later attributed to a “technical error.”\nIn addition, Petr Losev detected three simultaneous spikes in the electronic ballots generation within the remote voting system — one on the afternoon of September 18 and two on the morning of September 19. For two to three minutes, the number of ballots allegedly issued to online voters increased by 2.5 to 4 times in several regions at once.\n\nElectronic voting has long been difficult to subject to public oversight. But in the 2026 election, the blockchain data on electronic voting in Moscow was completely removed from public access. “For the first time since electronic voting began in Moscow, the ability to view or download records was disabled. In previous years, we would be able to create graphs showing how a candidate’s vote share depended on the time,” says Petr Zhizhfin, a remote voting expert. As a result, this voting method opens up numerous opportunities for manipulation. United Russia received 3.5 million electronic votes in Moscow and elsewhere, but it's not clear how many of those are genuine.\n\nVoting results in the occupied territories of Ukraine also remain completely unverifiable. There is no independent observation there, and the results are only published as overall totals not broken down by individual polling stations or election commissions.","blocks":[{"data":"According to the preliminary results from Russia’s Central Election Commission, the ruling United Russia party is <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/russia/1117424\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">winning</a> 58% of the vote on party lists and is also winning in most single-member districts. It is about to win 355 of the 450 seats in the State Duma, which will be the largest parliamentary faction in the party’s history: in the 2021 elections, it held 324 seats. According to the Election Commission, the Communist Party of the Russian Federation (CPRF) is running second (with 14% of the vote), followed by the Liberal Democratic Party of Russia (LDPR) with their 9%, followed by New People (8%) and A Just Russia (5%). The final results will be announced on Friday, September 25.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The election was accompanied by numerous violations. Observers were <a href=\"https://www.svoboda.org/a/bolee-1300-nablyudateley-ot-yabloka-i-kprf-ne-pustili-na-uchastki/33859069.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">denied </a>access to polling stations, <a href=\"https://t.me/istories_media/13641\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">beaten</a>, <a href=\"https://t.me/paperpaper_ru/72408\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">detained</a>, and prohibited from <a href=\"https://t.me/sotavisionmedia/64451\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">recording </a>videos. There were reports of ballot <a href=\"https://t.me/sikazankov/1692\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">stuffing</a>, voter <a href=\"https://t.me/ChuvashiaDream/18129\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">coercion</a>, ballot <a href=\"https://t.me/novaya_europe/67300\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">tampering</a>, and other <a href=\"https://fakegolos.com/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">violations</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The authorities had created the conditions for an uncontested election from the start. A month and a half before the vote, Russia’s Supreme Court barred Yabloko, the only anti-war <a href=\"https://www.yabloko.ru/themes/special-operation#2026\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">party</a>, from running in the election. The authorities launched <a href=\"https://www.yabloko.ru/war-against-yabloko\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">repressions </a>against the party members. Twelve of them have been charged with criminal offenses, and eight are in custody. The party’s deputy chairman, Lev Shlosberg, was sentenced to 11 years in prison. Two Yabloko members, Konstantin Smirnov and Elena Perepelitsa, remain in pretrial detention.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Voting took place on September 18–20 using the new GAS Vybory 2.0 (‘Elections 2.0’) system, which was used for federal elections for the first time. IStories had <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2026/09/17/russias-digital-elections-system-creation-and-vulnerabilities-disclosed/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">published </a>a detailed investigation into the system and discovered that it allows for results tampering, voter rolls fraud and uploading unverified results from remote electronic voting systems.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In this article, we report on the anomalies we were able to identify in the voting results using statistical methods.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"United Russia got no more than 35% of the real vote share","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"According to IStories calculations, instead of the claimed 58% of the vote, United Russia may actually have no more than 35%. Novaya Gazeta Europe <a href=\"https://novayagazeta.eu/articles/2026/09/21/rezultat-edinoi-rossii-ochishchennyi-ot-falsifikatsii-sostavliaet-okolo-34-podschitala-novaia-evropa-news\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">reached </a>a similar conclusion. Boris Ovchinnikov, an election analyst we consulted, also agrees with this assessment.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We arrived at the 35% estimate based on the voting results analyst<a href=\"https://deg.zhizhin.xyz/shpilkin.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"> Petr Zhizhin compiled </a>from the Central Election Commission’s website data by the evening of September 21. At that time, 94% of the vote count had been entered into the database. The commission had not yet published the complete data for Bashkortostan with its 3 million voters, for the Leningrad and Smolensk Oblasts and the occupied territories of Ukraine (apart from Crimea).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We excluded Moscow from the analysis: approximately 80% of the votes there were cast via electronic voting, and the results were published without a breakdown by polling station. We also did not include the results of electronic voting in 32 regions. Based on this calculation, it appears that approximately 18.4 million of the 30 million paper ballots cast for United Russia — according to the data as of September 21 — may have been falsified. This means that more than 60% of the “paper” votes for the ruling party may be fabricated.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The method we used to analyze the data was first applied to Russian elections by <a href=\"https://www.electoral.graphics/ru-ru/%D0%93%D0%BB%D0%B0%D0%B2%D0%BD%D0%B0%D1%8F/%D0%A1%D1%82%D0%B0%D1%82%D1%8C%D0%B8/%D1%81%D0%B5%D1%80%D0%B3%D0%B5%D0%B9-%D1%88%D0%BF%D0%B8%D0%BB%D1%8C%D0%BA%D0%B8%D0%BD-%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B0%D1%82%D0%B8%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B8%D1%87%D0%B5%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B8%D0%B9-%D0%B0%D0%BD%D0%B0%D0%BB%D0%B8%D0%B7-%D0%B2%D1%8B%D0%B1%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%B2\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Sergei Shpilkin</a>, a physicist and election analyst. The method is based on the premise that the ratio of votes cast for different candidates and parties should not change depending on voter turnout. When commission members stuff the ballot boxes, they thereby increase voter turnout numbers. And since they stuff the boxes in favor of pro-government candidates, United Russia’s result would be rising alongside voter turnout.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The polling stations where the voting was fair should be forming a dense “cloud” on the chart, meanwhile the polling stations where ballot stuffing occurred are located at the top right and look like a comet’s tail. In the 2026 State Duma elections, the cluster of fraudless polling stations is located around the 35% vote share for United Russia. Most polling stations are in the “comet’s tail” zone, which indicates widespread ballot stuffing. You can read more about Sergey Shpilkin’s method in the <a href=\"https://www.istories.media/reportages/2020/07/20/kolokol-pila-topor/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">explainer</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19338,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/14a7bb053e274c16807274edf18e4078/index.html","ratio_mobile":"3:4","ratio_desktop":"4:3"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"We defined the real turnout range — at which United Russia’s result does not yet correlate with the turnout numbers — at 20–29 percent. Based on the vote ratio for different candidates at this turnout level, we calculated the potential number of fraudulent ballots.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19330,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/2208859727cc4de094011210bf4d8e80/index.html","ratio_mobile":"3:4","ratio_desktop":"4:3"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"In fair elections, the graph showing the relationship between the number of votes and voter turnout resembles a bell curve. For example, this is what the turnout distribution looked like in the 2000 presidential election. Experts call those elections the fairest in the history of modern Russia. A different picture emerges in the 2016 State Duma elections and further on, where “peaks” appear on the right side of the graph. Those peaks are what votes rigged for the ruling party look like, as its share of the vote increases along with voter turnout.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19332,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/bc7d06806ca94004b8a38848d651f85e/index.html","ratio_mobile":"3:4","ratio_desktop":"4:3"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"Turnout fabrications","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"According to the Central Election Commission, turnout <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/russia/1117416\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">stood </a>at 59.32 percent. This is a record for State Duma elections since 2011 (60.21 percent). “The Kremlin went too far with its another wartime election,” Mikhail Komin, a political analyst, <a href=\"https://t.me/komintariy/182\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">notes</a>. “In 2024, Putin achieved a result more typical of Latin American and Central Asian dictatorships (87% with a 77% turnout) than of his own previous term's results. Now, in the 2026 State Duma elections, the results are no less historic.” Analysts Roman Udot and Boris Ovchinnikov <a href=\"https://tvrain.tv/news/realnaja-javka-na-vyborah-v-rossii-sostavila-okolo-40-schitajut-eksperty-576311/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">believe </a>that the actual turnout was around 40%.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Election commissions began falsifying turnout figures from day one, analyst Ivan Shukshin <a href=\"https://x.com/ishukshin/status/2101334218269733258\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">pointed </a>out. For example, by 8:00 p.m. on September 18, an unusually high number of commissions reported a turnout of 30%. The same thing <a href=\"https://x.com/ishukshin/status/2101609242830512518\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">happened </a>on the second day of voting, when the most common reported turnout figure was precisely 40% — and 85% on the third day. In normal circumstances, people across decide to go to the polls randomly and independently of each other, so the turnout distribution among law-abiding commissions should follow a simple bell curve,” Shukshin <a href=\"https://x.com/ishukshin/status/2101609242830512518\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">explains</a>. “Peaks at round numbers (40%, 60%, 65%, etc) appear when the figures are fabricated.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19333,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/bb9221386ba946c3957db976934ba7a8/index.html","ratio_mobile":"1:3","ratio_desktop":"8:9"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"Virtually all voters at unusually high turnout polling stations — those where the turnout neared 100% — voted for United Russia members. Mikhail Matveev, a State Duma candidate from CPRF who had been temporarily barred from participating in the election, <a href=\"https://t.me/matveevkomment/13324\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">drew attention</a> to polling station 0618 in the Borsky District in Samara Oblast. The commission reported a turnout of 98.53%; according to the same data, Matveev received 14 votes, while Alexandr Zhivaykin, his opponent from United Russia, received 704 votes. The Yabloko initiative group also <a href=\"https://www.threads.com/@prostor_inside/post/Ddiob6OAKeG?xmt=AQG06JBoz_4V__qvFH4M_dkFFwW0ZBfE81qbzKrpXPHfsSYA6CvCvyypf-SXpTWuiZbkwqvs&amp;slof=1\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">reported </a>similar results favoring candidates from the ruling party in New Moscow <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"parts of Moscow transferred to the city's jurisdiction in 2012\"></span>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"During previous elections, election commissions artificially increased turnout numbers in order to be able to falsely add votes for the ruling party's candidates. According to<a href=\"https://meduza.io/feature/2026/09/21/rekordy-na-vyborah-v-gosdumu-obespechili-ochen-gryazno-zato-eti-tsiferki-budut-v-papke-u-prezidenta\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"> sources </a>cited by Meduza, ahead of this election, officials from the presidential administration demanded that regional administrations ensure turnout numbers of more than 50 percent.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"On the first day of the election, neighboring polling stations under the “Sovetskaya” Territorial Election Commission in Dagestan submitted reports showing identical voter turnout figures—another sign of vote rigging also <a href=\"https://t.me/nevybory/212\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">noted</a> by Shushkin. Similar unnatural turnout figures were also detected at election commissions in the Ivanovo and Leningrad Oblasts, in Kuzbass, in the Primorsky and Krasnodar krais and in St. Petersburg. In Kabardino-Balkaria, virtually identical turnout figures were recorded by every single polling station in the republic.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Anomalous turnout and United Russia’s share in the final hours of the voting","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"According to the official data, at some polling stations, election commissions may have added votes for United Russia right before the polls closed. For example, at two neighboring polling stations 322 and 338 in district 48 in the Kamchatka Krai, two hours before polls closed (from 6 to 8 p.m. on September 20), turnout suddenly jumped from their respective 7% and 17% to 100%, as noted by IStories. Irina Yarovaya, co-author of the law on internet surveillance, was running for the State Duma in this district. During the last two hours of voting, she identically received a record-breaking 97% of the vote at both polling stations and was re-elected to the State Duma. Yarovaya has held a seat in the State Duma for 19 years, and she now has five more years to go.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Identical results at neighboring polling stations","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Another sign of fraud is when neighboring polling stations report virtually identical results. This may indicate that they are following a directive handed down from the authorities. In a fair election, votes at neighboring polling stations cannot be distributed identically down to hundredths of a percent. The probability of this is extremely low, but we have identified numerous regions with this anomaly.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For example, in Dagestan, the results at 11 out of 53 territorial commissions are practically identical. At 45 polling stations in Derbent, United Russia “won” with their results ranging from 93.84% to 95.03%. This is statistically impossible in a genuine voting process.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19334,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/806f90958b0c4cf697fb943288eac321/index.html","ratio_mobile":"3:4","ratio_desktop":"4:3"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"Vote manipulation","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Observers <a href=\"https://x.com/daria_bagina/status/2101992779916128347\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">recorded </a>commission members transferring votes for other candidates to United Russia by literally putting ballots in a different pile. “The chairperson takes a ballot with a vote for candidate No. 4, New People's Zharkova, but reads out the surname of the United Russia candidate, Romanenko. The same thing happens with the next ballot,” Daria Bagina, an observer, reports. A Yabloko observer at polling station 440 in Moscow <a href=\"https://t.me/sotaproject/118981\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">noticed </a>that ballots used for voting for the Yabloko candidate Viktor Kogan-Yasny, as well as for other candidates, were being placed in the United Russia pile.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But most of the vote tampering takes place without observers present. “At Moscow polling stations, they did indeed shift ballots in favor of United Russia candidates during the vote count, but this is apparently only the first level of fraud,” Boris Ovchinnikov notes. “I am certain that virtually all result reports showing a turnout of more than 75–85% (but less than 100%) were filled out with no connection to the actual count of completed ballots whatsoever. This explains the recurring vote shares across different polling stations as well as other anomalies. Where there were no actual observers present, they could have entered any numbers into the protocol and then further alter the results when entering them into the digital elections system.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Vote transfer is evident in the data. It occurs at polling stations with a turnout of more than 82%. Until then, United Russia’s results are rigged through ballot stuffing: its share increases along with turnout, while the results of the other parties remain unchanged in absolute numbers. But starting at a turnout of 83%, votes for all parties except “United Russia” begin to disappear. Their results drop by more than half. At the same time, the ruling party’s results rise in a corresponding manner. This may indicate that at such polling stations, ballots for candidates from other parties are being counted as votes for United Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"On the graph, this pattern of votes resembles a pair of tongs. Some of the 18.4 million falsified votes may have been obtained through such vote transfers.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19335,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/2ccf2ba22ee043c981a52e037755b0dc/index.html","ratio_mobile":"3:4","ratio_desktop":"4:3"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"At the same time, when the turnout approaches 100%, United Russia’s share of the vote declines, while that of all other parties, on the contrary, rises. Boris Ovchinnikov explains this by the fact that there is usually no fraud at such polling stations: “A turnout of exactly 100% automatically occurs at ‘special polling stations’: in hospitals, detention centers and on ships. Anywhere where there are no permanent residents, everyone votes on a temporary voter list. Those who do not vote simply do not make it onto the list.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In addition to United Russia, votes for A Just Russia party may also have been rigged in these elections. Election analyst Stanislav Andreychuk <a href=\"https://tvrain.tv/news/elektoralnyj-analitik-zajavil-o-rezkom-pojavlenii-60-tysjach-golosov-za-spravedlivuju-rossiju-576300/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">noted </a>that on September 21, A Just Russia suddenly gained 60,000 votes, which allowed the party to reach the 5 percent threshold needed to enter the State Duma. “Just one phone call, a decision was made, and the numbers were rewritten right away,” Andreychuk suggests.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Results abroad: emigrants against United Russia","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The New People party received 43% of the vote and <a href=\"https://novayagazeta.eu/articles/2026/09/21/novye-liudi-zaniali-pervoe-mesto-na-uchastkakh-za-rubezhom-po-dannym-nezavisimykh-ekzit-pollov-news\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">came </a>first at polling stations abroad, according to independent exit polls conducted by the Vote Abroad <a href=\"https://voteabroad.info/#communique-2026\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">project</a>. Surveyors interviewed those voting in 22 countries and collected 15,700 responses.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"United Russia only got 5.5% of the vote. The New People party also <a href=\"https://vesna.progressmovement.org/exitpoll\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">leads </a>according to the exit polls conducted by Vesna and Progress movements.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At the same time, according to preliminary <a href=\"http://izbirkom.ru/election/587813923/commission/d0cc2fa5-1fbc-4c3d-aa43-1e0051c7f130/results?type=6&amp;report=242\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">data </a>from the Central Election Commission, United Russia won at polling stations abroad, with 45.49% of the vote. New People came in second, getting 22.42% of the vote. A total of 212,000 Russians cast their ballots abroad.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"United Russia lost the elections in at least 40 out of 152 countries. In 39 countries, New People came first; they got their highest vote share in Slovenia, Serbia, and the Netherlands. United Russia also lost in the anti-war emigration hubs, such as Armenia, Kazakhstan, and Montenegro. Previously, Russians living in these countries would mostly <a href=\"https://istories.media/stories/2024/03/20/proshedshie-vibori-prezidenta-samie-sfalsifitsirovannie-v-istorii-rossii/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">vote </a>for pro-government candidates and parties. The ruling party also lost to New People in those countries in the Middle East and Asia where thousands of Russians have also moved since 2022: the UAE, Israel, Vietnam, Thailand, and China.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19336,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/def70ea5dee24bd3a7fb53a94fd4e76c/index.html","ratio_mobile":"3:4","ratio_desktop":"4:3"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"United Russia received its highest share of the vote abroad (79%) in the Central African Republic. Its vote share was also high in Moldova (77%), Russian-occupied South Ossetia (73%), Lebanon (70%), and Tajikistan (70%). United Russia also won in a number of Western countries: Greece (56%), Estonia (50%), Italy (40%), Switzerland (36%), and the United States (34%).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Unverifiable remote voting results and the occupied territories of Ukraine","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Anomalies in the remote electronic voting system at the elections were detected as early as on the first day of voting. The Belgorod Territorial Election Commission closed remote voting in District No. 80 just three hours after it began, Ivan Shukshin <a href=\"https://t.me/nevybory/210\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">noted</a>. Approximately one-third of the voters who had registered for electronic voting cast their ballots in those three hours. This was later attributed to a “technical error.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In addition, Petr Losev <a href=\"https://losevpeter.com/DEG\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">detected </a>three simultaneous spikes in the electronic ballots generation within the remote voting system — one on the afternoon of September 18 and two on the morning of September 19. For two to three minutes, the number of ballots allegedly issued to online voters increased by 2.5 to 4 times in several regions at once.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Electronic voting has long been difficult to subject to public oversight. But in the 2026 election, the blockchain data on electronic voting in Moscow was completely removed from public access. “For the first time since electronic voting began in Moscow, the ability to view or download records was disabled. In previous years, we would be able to create graphs showing how a candidate’s vote share depended on the time,” <a href=\"https://t.me/svobodnieslova/9652\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">says </a>Petr Zhizhfin, a remote voting expert. As a result, this voting method opens up numerous opportunities for manipulation. United Russia received 3.5 million electronic votes in Moscow and elsewhere, but it's not clear how many of those are genuine.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Voting results in the occupied territories of Ukraine also <a href=\"https://novayagazeta.eu/articles/2026/09/17/tainye-uchastki-i-zakrytyi-podschet\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">remain </a>completely unverifiable. There is no independent observation there, and the results are only published as overall totals not broken down by individual polling stations or election commissions.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":10741,"header":"Russia’s Digital Elections System Creation and Vulnerabilities Disclosed","_path":"/en/stories/2026/09/17/russias-digital-elections-system-creation-and-vulnerabilities-disclosed/","lead":"How does the internal digital system used in Russian elections operate? The vulnerabilities, the issues and the creation process of the new GAS Vybory 2.0 system have been disclosed due to a successful hacker attack on the system’s developer","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b2172f7188d14afa87ad2d099c1e6442-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Picture: IStories, AI. Photos: Reuters; Shutterstock; the leaked data and the Central Election Commission’s Telegram channel","created_at_date":"2026-09-17","created_at_date_time":"2026-09-16T20:18:53.103Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":61,"first_name":"Егор","last_name":"Феоктистов","first_name_en":"Egor","last_name_en":"Feoktistov","is_public":true,"_path":"egor-feoktistov","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Автор дата-отдела «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":1},{"id":13,"first_name":"Соня","last_name":"Савина","first_name_en":"Sonya","last_name_en":"Savina","is_public":true,"_path":"sonya-savina","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Если вы хотите рассказать мне свою историю, пишите на почту sonya.savina@istories.media.","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":"Author","ordering":2}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[{"id":31,"first_name":"Катя","last_name":"Бонч-Осмоловская","first_name_en":"Katya","last_name_en":"Bonch-Osmolovskaya","is_public":true,"_path":"katya-bonch-osmolovskaya","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.jpeg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.jpeg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.jpeg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.jpeg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редакторка дата-отдела","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":null,"ordering":1}],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[{"id":23,"first_name":"Полина","last_name":"Ужвак","first_name_en":"Polina","last_name_en":"Uzhvak","is_public":true,"_path":"polina-uzhvak","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Автор дата-отдела","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":null,"ordering":1},{"id":58,"first_name":"Рина","last_name":"Николаева","first_name_en":"Rina","last_name_en":"Nikolaeva","is_public":true,"_path":"rina-nikolaeva","avatar":[],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":2}],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"In the spring of 2026, Vladimir Putin met Russia’s Central Election Commission (TsIK) members. Among other things, Ella Pamfilova, the chair of the commission, told Putin about the GAS Vybory 2.0 (‘Elections 2.0’) digital government platform — a new version of its electronic system used for elections. For the first time, this version will be implemented at the federal level during the September 18–20 State Duma election.\n\n“We have fully transitioned to the new architecture built on domestic hardware,” — Pamfilova told Putin, — “It has no equivalent anywhere in the world in terms of data storage capacity and of the operational subsystems number. It remains autonomous from the global network belonging to the enemy; it is fully centralized. In other words, the enemy won’t be able to get to it — that’s for sure.”\n\nJust before the State Duma elections, hackers breached the infrastructure belonging to Tsifrotek, the company that developed the GAS Vybory 2.0 system. The hackers passed the obtained documents on to the IStories editorial team. We examined nearly 200 gigabytes of technical documentation, internal correspondence and the developers’ conference calls; independent technical and electoral experts assessed the archive at our request. Who created the new system, how was it made and how reliant and transparent is it?\nThe names of those involved in the development IStories spoke to are not disclosed for security reasons.\n\n“An intricate work of art.” The origins of the GAS Vybory 2.0 system\nDevelopment of the new digital system for conducting elections in Russia began in 2019. First and foremost, the Central Election Commission (TsIK) wanted to replace the old platform created back in the late 1990s. It had been updated several times, but it was still ‘morally, physically and technologically’ outdated, TsIK head Ella Pamfilova noted.\n\nThe aim was to launch the new version in 2022, but development was delayed. According to IStories calculations , this project cost the state at least 20.5 billion rubles ($250 million approx.) from 2019 to 2025. During the same period, the Electoral Commission spent 18.8 billion more on supporting the first version of the system, which was operated simultaneously with the development of the new one and was only abandoned in early 2026.\n\nThe GAS Vybory 2.0 system became one of TsIK’s most expensive expenditures. During the 5 years with no federal elections, when TsIK was not spending money on running such campaigns, the GAS Vybory 2.0 system accounted for over 40 percent of the agency’s total annual expenditure.\n\nIn autumn 2024, TsIK approved the updated system's development plan up to 2030. Oleg Kachanov, the project’s chief architect, explained that the platform would be moved to a centralized architecture with a shared database located directly at TsIK, and that it would run on Russian software exclusively. Furthermore, the new system would be integrated with other government services (such as the public services platform Gosuslugi, the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Federal Tax Service’s platforms, etc.) to ensure that voter data is updated in real time. Electoral law experts criticized this approach, arguing that it would be impossible to monitor independently.\n\nOnly one TsIK member was discontented with the new concept — Yevgeny Kolyushin, a representative of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation (KPRF). He raised questions about the lack of transparency regarding voter lists and electronic vote records, and attempted to find out how secrecy and lack of fraud would be ensured, but his concerns were ignored. The concept was adopted by a majority vote.\n\nDespite the extensive development work, the new system largely replicates the old one. This decision is understandable, says an anonymous technical expert who examined part of the developers’ archive at our request: “It is extremely difficult to rewrite a huge legacy system from scratch whilst elections are taking place continuously, so the old stack was retained for the sake of compatibility,” they note. Ella Pamfilova also spoke about this: “GAS Vybory 2.0 took all the best features from our first system,” the Election Commission chair said.\nAccording to the expert’s assessment, the developers spent most of their time trying to understand the old system, getting it up and running on new hardware and making a few tweaks, and then fixing the errors that would emerge. They describe the essence of the contractor’s work as follows: “to change things in a way that doesn’t change anything” and to migrate the system to domestically produced infrastructure.\n\nThe Election Commission is particularly proud of this shift to domestically produced systems (a part of the general “import substitution” campaign — Ed.), which was one of the project’s key principles: the commission’s chair, Ella Pamfilova, and both key development coordinators (Nikolai Bulaev, the commission’s deputy chair, and Oleg Kachanov, the chief architect of the system and deputy head of the Ministry of Digital Development) have repeatedly emphasised that the updated system exclusively runs on Russian software.\n\nThe developers of the system were sceptical about such statements. Here is how they commented on the TsIK executives’ remarks in their work chat groups:\n\n“What domestic software are we talking about? We only use foreign software in development”\n“How unpatriotic. The platform owner said it’s domestic, so that’s what it is”\n“Well, we’re no longer using Kafka [a foreign platform for data transmission and processing], it’s Кафка now. And it’s Джава instead of Java, the domestic version”\n\nInternal documents reveal that the developers also use foreign platforms (Jira and Confluence) to set and track tasks and store documentation. The team discussed plans to switch to ‘Yaga’ (a recently developed “import substituting” Russian equivalent of Jira developed by Rostelecom — Ed.) — on several occasions, but, according to the team members, “it didn’t take off, and the idea was shelved.”\n\nAt the same time, the GAS Vybory 2.0 developers must comply with the import substitution requirements set for state-owned companies. “We have to buy Russian laptops, and, since recently, keyboards, mice and monitors as well. We’re trying to purchase the highest-quality, most functional equipment possible,” they write in chat rooms. The developers bear the cost themselves. They complain that the import-substituting hardware heats up too much, whilst domestic software is not particularly reliable: “To put it mildly, this can be described as low reliability infrastructure; in other words, anything can crash at any time and at any scale.”\nIn early 2026, the GAS Vybory 2.0 was put into permanent operation. “It's the birth of a beloved child,” Nikolai Bulaev, the commission’s deputy chair, commented at the time. He also described the new system as an “intricate work of art.”\n\nTsIK was delighted with its ‘beloved child’: at the end of 2025, more than 20 people involved in its development received medals, certificates of honour and letters of thanks from the institution. “A huge, full-scale effort was made to develop a completely unique system with no global equivalents. We were navigating a ‘digital minefield’; everything was being done for the first time. The practically impossible was achieved,” Pamfilova praised the new system.\n\n“You have to work in the basement.” The system’s developers\nThe main developer of the updated system is Tsifrotek, a subsidiary of Rostelecom, Russia’s state-owned digital service provider. This is a single-project company created specifically for developing the GAS Vybory 2.0 system. Tsifrotek states that its mission is to create a “comprehensive solution for digitizing the Central Election Commission of Russia and the country’s electoral commissions at all levels” and to completely replace the old version of the platform.\nThe company is operating at a loss. According to Tsifrotek’s financial statements, losses had reached 1.7 billion rubles ($20 million approx.) by the end of 2025. The company's revenue was 426 million rubles ($5 million approx.) lower than planned, whilst the operating loss was 304 million rubles ($3,5 million approx.) higher than expected, as Alexey Gusev, the CEO of the company, explained to the staff during an internal conference call.\nTsifrotek explicitly states that the reason for the losses is its “work on a complex, years-long project of national importance — the development and maintenance of the GAS Vybory 2.0 system.” In its early years, the company was actively engaging contractors using borrowed funds, as it lacked the in-house expertise to carry out such work, but needed to meet “high reliability and security requirements.”\nThe company’s budget was also hit by fines from the state customer. In 2025 alone, the contracting authority imposed fines totalling 152 million roubles on the company (for the system maintenance, the CEO told staff whilst explaining the ‘bonus payments issues’ in the final quarter of 2025). According to him, the fines arise partly due to red tape: even if the developers meet the system maintenance requirements on time, “because of paperwork not filled in on time, the state customer has no choice but to issue fines.”\nBy 2025, Tsifrotek had already employed more than 300 people. That is also when the company began laying people off, according to its financial statements. One of our sources says this happened because the company “hadn’t calculated the budget properly”: “Firstly, there were a lot of fines following the unified voting day (in 2025, local elections in many regions of Russia were scheduled for the same day, September 14 — Ed.) Secondly, the staff had been paid generously for overtime work, even when it wasn’t actually necessary, and the budget ended up in a mess.”\n\n“At the end of 2025, they simply sacked most of the team,” ex-employees complain in their reviews. They also mention the difficult working conditions: “A very challenging place to work, with a whole lot of services operating in a complicated, confusing way. You have to work in the basement.” One of those interviewed by IStories described the atmosphere within the team as follows: “The attitude towards subordinates was offensive, they didn’t hold back much in their language or jokes, let alone valuing [employment] rights. They were always short-staffed.”\nAccording to reviews, Tsifrotek developers earn an average of around 300 thousand rubles per month ($3,500 approx.) The leaked data shows that the salaries are higher: in 2025, an ordinary developer would earn around 500 thousand rubles a month ($6,000 approx.), whilst a senior developer would earn up to 650 thousand rubles ($7,700 approx.). During the unified voting day campaigns, earnings could increase two- to threefold due to paid overtime.\n\n“For some, the monthly income reached almost a million rubles (up to $12,000), even though their salary only amounted to 300 thousand. And yet, a developer could show up and just loaf around all day,” says one person engaged in the development. In addition, staff are paid quarterly bonuses. According to the leaked documents, in certain months even ordinary developers received over a million roubles. However, since the 2025 unified voting day, the company has had bonuses issues, the staff say: they either do not pay them in full or do not pay them at all.\n“It’s just a regular IT company,” an employee tells IStories. “It’s not like everyone has to exercise every morning while listening to the Russian national anthem.” According to another employee, the company is staffed by “ordinary people” — “there’s no sign of some kind of mass Z (pro-war — Ed.) sentiment.” He describes most employees as an “amorphous, apolitical mass”: “Neither supporting [the war and the government policies in general] nor against it.” Sometimes at conference calls, he says, less-than-flattering comments about the authorities can be heard — especially upon VPNs being blocked en masse in 2025–2026 (since 2022, Russia has been blocking international social media and services, hence VPNs have been widely used to access most of them — Ed.) The team communicates on Telegram, so after the crackdown on VPNs remote developers had to “figure something out” to stay connected. It’s easier to access the Internet in the TsIK building itself: “There’s access, so at work you can chill and watch YouTube.”\n\n“The staff would sleep at work.” The development process \nTsifrotek joined the project in 2023. According to internal conference calls, the company took over the development work from the Systematica company when it was underway.\n\n“At the initial stage, no one had the source code — not Rostelecom, not the Electoral Commission, nobody. Deliveries were chaotic; it was unclear which version [of the system] was being used. The different versions were incompatible with one another. It was a real mess,” Alexander Minchenko, Tsifrotek’s then-director of development told employees at the time.\n\nIn 2025, the developers were due to carry out two system trials and then test it in a real election during the unified voting day in September. Alexey Gusev, Tsifrotek’s CEO, admitted during an internal conference call that, as of early 2025, the system was essentially not ready: “To say it’s not ready yet is an understatement.”\n\n“The quality of the system was poor. We identified around 7,000 issues, of which around 500 were critical. There wasn’t a single report that functioned properly,” Alexander Minchenko, then Head of Development at Tsifrotek, said. “How did we conduct elections in such a situation? Well, it was an extremely risky move.”\nThe team handled the 2025 unified voting day thanks to working overtime — the staff “lived at work” and “carried the unified voting day on their shoulders,” Minchenko noted during a conference call. According to him, ‘a lot of things went wrong’ during the vote, but the developers quickly fixed the bugs — so quickly that the Central Election Commission didn’t notice any problems.\n\n“The whole team simply gave it their all, pushing themselves to 1,000 per cent. I saw people sleeping whenever they could, right here in Room 110 of the data centre in the basement,” Yuri Sakun, Director of Integrated Digital Projects at Rostelecom, described the voting day.\n\nThe GAS Vybory 2.0 system features a closed network that cannot be accessed from the internet; consequently, Tsifrotek staff sometimes work within the TsIK building itself. According to one of our interviewees, all staff members are security checked by the Federal Protective Service (FSO) before being issued with a permanent pass to the TsIK. Not everyone passes the check.\n\nThe strict access regime has sometimes led to direct clashes between the developers and the FSO. “Today, FSO officers tried to detain an employee and hand them over to the police for leaving late,” one such incident was described in chat rooms in the summer of 2026. Sometimes passes are revoked without any explanation — one can only speculate about the reasons, says one of the Tsifrotek staff: for example, it can be accidentally “taking down the prod [the operating version of the system] at the wrong time,” liking a “wrong” video on YouTube, or simply somehow falling out of favour with the customer to find out later that their pass was no longer valid.\nAccording to an internal conference call at the company, work on setting up the information security department at Tsifrotek only began in 2026. “We have the department, but no staff,” the company’s then-technical director admitted at the time, adding that Tsifrotek lacked the resources and expertise to oversee the contractor responsible for the project’s security, Rostelecom’s subsidiary Solar.\n\nThe staff have had basic security training by Rostelecom, an employee told us. “But if work-related communication takes place on Telegram, that speaks volumes,” they add. In the internal chat groups employees mention one of them being hacked. They also regularly discuss suspicious files infiltrating into the code base of the system.\nThe Central Election Commission states that the upcoming State Duma elections will take place in “extremely challenging conditions,” and that the agency’s top priority is security. According to Oleg Kachanov, TsIK is successfully combating digital threats, such as DDoS attacks. This fight leads to malfunctions and obstructs work, says a person involved in the development of the system: the internal services frequently crash, and the IP addresses used by the portal’s team themselves get blocked—“this has caused several outages.” “There’s a constant struggle when it comes to security. The client plays it safe and says, ‘Let’s block it,’ but because of that, we can’t work,” the developer says.\n\nThe development progress would be demonstrated at special presentations for the customers from TsIK’s Federal Center for Informatization, the government and Ella Pamfilova personally, according to internal discussions among the developers.\n\nErrors were sometimes corrected at the last minute before demonstrations and report submissions. “We have an urgent problem <...> An error in mapping the campaign reports — the FCI is coming for the report at 9:00 a.m., and we won’t be able to provide it to them,” they wrote in the chat just 30 minutes before the deadline. The employee responsible for this replied that the cause was a misspelling of the “United Russia” party name: “They wrote ‘RUSSSIA’ with three S’s <...> But for the report, you can temporarily correct the mapping <...> Make it say ‘UNITED RUSSSIA.’”\n\nOn the customer’s (the FCI) side, the development was overseen by Rodion Shchekuteev, the deputy head of the agency, and Dmitry Gundin, head of the Department for the Collection and Processing of Information Resources at the GAS Vybory 2.0 system. New versions were personally approved by the FCI Director, Alexander Sokolchuk.\n\nIn 2023, the Tsifrotek employees discussed raising money for New Year’s gifts for several representatives of the customer: three of them, including Sokolchuk and Shchekuteev, were to receive “VIP gifts.” According to the chat logs, only 30 employees “voluntarily decided to financially contribute to the gifts” for the client’s representatives, and 2,350 rubles ($30 approx.) were raised from each of them.\n“We had systems that were completely unfinished, but we had to submit what we've done according to the contracts,” says one of the sources interviewed by IStories. According to him, they would succeed in part thanks to such gifts: “We would come and say, ‘Yes, yes, we’ll definitely get everything done, but it’s not working right now. Here’s a nice gift, by the way. Please sign here; we need to close the contract.’” Most often, they would present alcohol in large amounts: “Not exactly bribes, but gifts. All those huge trunks were X-rayed by the Federal Protective Service at the entrance.”\n\n“The systems are being refined as we speak.” Is the platform ready for its first federal election? \nAccording to one of the Tsifrotek employees interviewed by IStories, the GAS Vybory 2.0 system is almost ready and operational, but some systems were “being refined literally as we speak.” After the 2025 unified voting day, the developers had many tasks, but the client’s requirements changed frequently. The staff had to find compromises, which is why many things don’t work the way they should, our source explains. Meanwhile, the developers are “working an awful lot of overtime,” and the terms of government contracts are often not being followed — “they turn a blind eye to what needs to be documented.”\n\nThis year, for the first time, State Duma elections will be held in the Ukrainian territories occupied by Russia since 2022. Before making this decision, the Central Election Commission consulted with the Russian FSB and the Ministry of Defense.\n\nAccording to the sources interviewed by IStories,” the digital infrastructure needed to conduct elections in these territories was still not set up. “It’s total garbage, to put it mildly,” says one of the employees. “This is where it’s really possible to manipulate and alter things — it’s very difficult to verify the data coming in [from the occupied territories].”\n\nThe idea of voting in the annexed regions places an additional burden on the GAS Vybory 2.0 system — for example, in terms of communicating address data. At a call, developers discussed the way the system had to process larger address information files because of the occupied territories being included in the voting process. “If, for example, a long street is renamed, or a new region is annexed or separated — I don’t know, anything like that — the [address] file will take up over a gigabyte (at that time, the respective part of the system could only handle files smaller than 800 MB — Ed.).”\n\nConfusion over addresses in the occupied territories has led to widespread malfunctions in the subsystem used to keep track of the voter registry. In the occupied parts of Ukraine’s Donetsk, Luhansk, Zaporizhzhia, and Kherson Oblasts, there were more than 95,000 “address-related incidents,” which amounts to about 10% of all current malfunctions in the subsystem, the developers noted. Problems with addresses have also been arising in the annexed Crimea. “There are now ZERO residents on the street,” “all voters from both addresses are gone” — Crimean Sevastopol system administrators wrote in their technical support requests in 2025 and 2026.\n\nSystem tests continued until September 2026. Just a few weeks before the election, developers were still sorting through dozens of requests to fix errors, according to the internal documents. The system incorrectly calculated the percentage of election commissions that had submitted reports and produced values exceeding 100%; errors occurred while determining winners in multi-member districts and while generating the voting records.\n\nIn the region of Bashkortostan, deceased individuals have appeared on voter lists on several occasions. The most recent report on this issue was received on August 31. It is unknown whether the problem had been resolved before the election began. There were also candidate verification issues: the Bank of Russia reports would not arrive, and inaccurate tax information based on tax data would not be successfully generated.\nTo resolve some of the issues, developers changed the database manually, bypassing the standard protocols. Manual edits were performed during the testing process, but it remains unclear how such problems will be addressed during actual elections and who will be authorized to edit the result fields in the database.\n\nThis is just one of the potential vulnerabilities in the system.\n\nThe structure and vulnerabilities of the system\nDoubts about the integrity of Russian election results have existed for a long time. As far back as 2011, Sergei Shpilkin’s calculation of fabricated votes cast in favor of pro-government candidates went viral. \n\nEight years later, Moscow tested the electronic remote voting system developed by the Moscow City Hall’s IT department for the first time, and this raised more questions: observers could not verify that the electronic votes had not been tampered with at any stage, or that voters had cast their ballots in person and did it voluntarily. At the same time, Rostelecom developed another remote voting system — a federal one — for other regions. In the September 2026 State Duma elections, the federal remote voting system will be used in 32 regions.\n\nIStories examined the operation of the GAS Vybory 2.0 system, including the components involved in compiling voter rolls, interacting with the remote voting systems, and counting the votes. At our request, the documents from the Tsifrotek leak were also examined by Ivan Shukshin, an election analyst, and two technical experts who requested to remain anonymous. Together we identified the main vulnerabilities in the system the Central Election Commission could exploit to influence election results.\n\nOur analysis is based on the documents and the module code available to us. It is possible that, as of the time of publication, the system’s components may function slightly differently than it was described there.\nVulnerability #1: tampering with the results\nAfter the votes are counted at the polling station, the election commission prints and signs the final document containing the results. The voting results can then be entered into the GAS Vybory 2.0 system in two ways: automatically (by scanning a QR code or uploading a PDF file) or manually.\n\nAccording to the documentation, manually entered data is not cross-checked against the original documents. However, results uploaded to the GAS Vybory 2.0 via a QR code can also be edited manually. The system stores previous versions of the documents and the username of the user who made the changes.\n\nIt was the loose treatment of the result transferring process that made it possible to rig the results at a polling station in Saratov in 2024. At that time the old Elections system was still in use. Vladimir Putin received 300 more votes than the local commission had recorded in their voting results documents. More than two hundred unused ballots were rewritten in his favor, while the number of spoiled ballots and votes for other candidates was underreported.\n\n“Our election law states that results must be published at all polling stations; they’re always public,” explains a Tsifrotek developer interviewed by IStories. “Next, the final aggregate results must be published. Given that we now have AI, having the AI verify everything isn’t a problem at all. If someone wants to change something, it will be easy to spot.”\n\nThe results are indeed published in electronic format on the TsIK website. However, this data does not let one verify that the published results match the signed physical documents (which can also be falsified).\n\nAccording to the discussions in the Tsifrotek chat, the result calculations in the system raises doubts among the developers as well: “Colleagues, you’ve apparently been working with TsIK for a long time now — why would anyone at a polling station need to assign or manipulate [votes] when there’s the wonderful PAIP, which aggregates the data and produces the results, and no one knows how it does it?” one of the developers wrote.\n\nVulnerability #2: voter list manipulations\nIn the leak, IStories discovered the data on 111.3 million voters from the RUIP register — including their names, dates of birth, residential addresses, and the polling stations to which they are assigned. This suggests that developers — and likely the election commission staff as well — can export unencrypted personal data of Russian citizens.\n\n“Security experts were very concerned that personal data was being transmitted in plain text, with no one encrypting it,” one of the developers involved in the project told us. “There are opportunities for leaks, and there are a lot of them.”\n\nThe metadata from the voter files indicates that the data was uploaded in July 2026. The numbers of voters broken down by region largely match the Central Election Commission’s figures as of July 1 — discrepancies do not exceed 1%, except for the territories annexed in 2022 .\n\nWe compared the voter lists from the leak with the civil registry offices’ death registration data since 2022, which was provided by the Manticore project. According to our estimates, the data from the GAS Vybory 2.0 system included at least 104,000 people declared deceased in the occupied territories, including Crimea, as well as in the Kursk and Bryansk Oblasts.\n\nThe process of preparing voter lists for remote voting is one of the vulnerabilities in this subsystem. According to the documentation for the nationwide training session on using the GAS Vybory 2.0 system, system administrators at the territorial election commissions can manually enter applications for remote electronic voting into the database.\n\nWith direct access to voter rolls, system users could likely artificially inflate the number of e-voters. Such manipulation may have occurred in 2021, when several people interviewed by Meduza were surprised to discover that they had been registered for remote voting without their knowledge.\nAfter the application file is uploaded, the system checks its structure, its compliance with reference databases, and whether the voters are present in the RUIP database. However, the origin of the file is not tracked: a user with privileged access can manipulate the voter list — according to the documentation available to us, no digital signature is required to upload it.\n\nVulnerability #3: remote electronic voting\nThe remote electronic voting (DEG) system is a “black box,” and observers can only evaluate its actual operation based on official statements from the developers. Two remote electronic voting systems will be used in the 2026 elections: the federal system and the Moscow system.\n\nTsifrotek is not involved in the development of either the federal or the Moscow remote electronic voting systems. The GAS Vybory 2.0 system receives votes that have already been processed from the blockchain. However, in their documentation Tsifrotek clarifies that the term “blockchain” in this case does not correspond to its generally accepted meaning, and they cannot guarantee that the remote electronic voting system operates exactly the way it was explained to them.\nResults from the remote voting system are exported as a ZIP archive containing XML files, which must correspond to files with electronic signatures. In this case, altering the results in the XML file is supposed to trigger an error during verification. The archives containing the results are then uploaded to the GAS Vybory 2.0 system: the federal one to the MV DEG module; the Moscow one, to the MV Moscow module.\n\nAccording to the DEG MV documentation, when a result archive is imported, a verification process starts: each XML file must have a corresponding signature file. It is unknown whether this process actually works as described.\nHowever, the code for the MV Moscow component, where electronic voting results from the capital are uploaded, contains a significant vulnerability. The system locates the signature files but does not verify them, allowing files containing results to pass through even if they are not confirmed by an electronic signature. When the remote voting results reach the protocol, the system does not record the fact that the original results were not backed by an electronic signature.\n“There’s no point in talking about vulnerabilities, because this software doesn’t record votes, it processes the finalized results, and those can be altered at every step: files can be manually edited, and changes can be made in the database after they’re imported,” a technical specialist who analyzed the MV Moscow module code told IStories. In his opinion, for the system to be trustworthy, its components must be independent: “If all of this is happening within Rostelecom, will Rostelecom argue with itself about fraud?”\nIs the updated GAS Vybory 2.0 system trustworthy? Developers weigh in\nThe people who created the new version of Russia’s election platform have mixed views on whether its results can be trusted.\n\nSome sincerely believe in the project: “I have a great deal of confidence in the new system. We’re building a fair tool that lets people vote however they want,” says one of our interviewees. “As for what happens outside the system, we can only speculate. I believe the system calculates [the election results] correctly. Then we look at the results, and everyone starts shouting, ‘It’s fraud!’ For me, this isn’t fraud, but the sad truth, unfortunately: apparently, [the election results] reflect the will of the people.”\n\n“I still think that the fairer results wouldn’t affect anything. It’s just that, apparently, the number isn’t actually 80, but rather 60 [percent of those voting for ‘United Russia’],” he adds. “I did what I could to make an impact on my end. But from here on, it all depends on the people.”\n\nAnother Tsifrotek source interviewed by IStories disagrees: “You can rig or steal the votes in any system you have access to. As far as I’m concerned, the outcome is clear to everyone — we know who will win the election and who won’t.”\n\nAt the training sessions where developers tested the system, the outcome was also known in advance — the majority of seats went to the “United Russia” party.","blocks":[{"data":"In the spring of 2026, Vladimir Putin <a href=\"http://kremlin.ru/events/president/news/79455\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">met</a> Russia’s Central Election Commission (TsIK) members. Among other things, Ella Pamfilova, the chair of the commission, told Putin about the GAS Vybory 2.0 (‘Elections 2.0’) digital government platform — a new version of its electronic system used for elections. For the first time, this version will be implemented at the federal level during the September 18–20 State Duma election.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“We have fully transitioned to the new architecture built on domestic hardware,” — Pamfilova told Putin, — “It has no equivalent anywhere in the world in terms of data storage capacity and of the operational subsystems number. It remains autonomous from the global network belonging to the enemy; it is fully centralized. In other words, the enemy won’t be able to get to it — that’s for sure.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Just before the State Duma elections, hackers breached the infrastructure belonging to Tsifrotek, the company that developed the GAS Vybory 2.0 system. The hackers passed the obtained documents on to the IStories editorial team. We examined nearly 200 gigabytes of technical documentation, internal correspondence and the developers’ conference calls; independent technical and electoral experts assessed the archive at our request. Who created the new system, how was it made and how reliant and transparent is it?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19228,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/db8e18f9d43549e1acfc65278d36da1f-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/db8e18f9d43549e1acfc65278d36da1f-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/db8e18f9d43549e1acfc65278d36da1f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/db8e18f9d43549e1acfc65278d36da1f-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/db8e18f9d43549e1acfc65278d36da1f-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/db8e18f9d43549e1acfc65278d36da1f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/db8e18f9d43549e1acfc65278d36da1f-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/db8e18f9d43549e1acfc65278d36da1f-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/db8e18f9d43549e1acfc65278d36da1f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/db8e18f9d43549e1acfc65278d36da1f-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/db8e18f9d43549e1acfc65278d36da1f-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/db8e18f9d43549e1acfc65278d36da1f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/db8e18f9d43549e1acfc65278d36da1f-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/db8e18f9d43549e1acfc65278d36da1f-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/db8e18f9d43549e1acfc65278d36da1f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/db8e18f9d43549e1acfc65278d36da1f-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/db8e18f9d43549e1acfc65278d36da1f-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/db8e18f9d43549e1acfc65278d36da1f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"<em>The names of those involved in the development IStories spoke to are not disclosed for security reasons.</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“An intricate work of art.” The origins of the GAS Vybory 2.0 system","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Development of the new digital system for conducting elections in Russia <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/8380037\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">began</a> in 2019. First and foremost, the Central Election Commission (TsIK) wanted to replace the old platform <a href=\"https://ria.ru/20240823/gas_vybory-1967479545.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">created </a>back in the late 1990s. It had been updated several times, but it was still ‘morally, physically and technologically’ outdated, TsIK head Ella Pamfilova <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/4595522\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">noted</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The aim was to <a href=\"https://tass.ru/politika/9931819\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">launch </a>the new version in 2022, but development was delayed. According to IStories calculations <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"based on the federal budget data\"></span>, this project cost the state at least 20.5 billion rubles ($250 million approx.) from 2019 to 2025. During the same period, the Electoral Commission spent 18.8 billion more on supporting the first version of the system, which was operated simultaneously with the development of the new one and was only <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/8736854\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">abandoned</a> in early 2026.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The GAS Vybory 2.0 system became one of TsIK’s most expensive expenditures. During the 5 years with no federal elections, when TsIK was not spending money on running such campaigns, the GAS Vybory 2.0 system accounted for over 40 percent of the agency’s total annual expenditure.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In autumn 2024, TsIK <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/7249877\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">approved</a> the updated system's development plan up to 2030. Oleg Kachanov, the project’s chief architect, <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/7249877\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">explained</a> that the platform would be moved to a centralized architecture with a shared database located directly at TsIK, and that it would run on Russian software exclusively. Furthermore, the new system would be integrated with other government services (such as the public services platform Gosuslugi, the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Federal Tax Service’s platforms, etc.) to ensure that voter data is updated in real time. Electoral law experts <a href=\"https://theins.ru/news/291073\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">criticized</a> this approach, arguing that it would be impossible to monitor independently.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Only one TsIK member was discontented with the new concept — Yevgeny Kolyushin, a representative of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation (KPRF). He raised questions about the lack of transparency regarding voter lists and electronic vote records, and attempted to find out how secrecy and lack of fraud would be ensured, but his concerns were ignored. The concept was adopted by a majority vote.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Despite the extensive development work, the new system largely replicates the old one. This decision is understandable, says an anonymous technical expert who examined part of the developers’ archive at our request: “It is extremely difficult to rewrite a huge legacy system from scratch whilst elections are taking place continuously, so the old stack was retained for the sake of compatibility,” they note. Ella Pamfilova also spoke about this: “GAS Vybory 2.0 took all the best features from our first system,” the Election Commission <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/8553313\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">chair</a> said.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19227,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Sergey Savostyanov / TASS via ZUMA PRESS / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Ella Pamfilova speaks about the GAS Vybory 2.0 system at the International Youth Festival in Yekaterinburg on September 13, 2026","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2d817deb7fd541ffbd882b5dee08ec14-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2d817deb7fd541ffbd882b5dee08ec14-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2d817deb7fd541ffbd882b5dee08ec14-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":3839,"real_height_1x":1280,"real_height_2x":2560},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2d817deb7fd541ffbd882b5dee08ec14-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2d817deb7fd541ffbd882b5dee08ec14-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2d817deb7fd541ffbd882b5dee08ec14-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":3839,"real_height_1x":1280,"real_height_2x":2560},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2d817deb7fd541ffbd882b5dee08ec14-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2d817deb7fd541ffbd882b5dee08ec14-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2d817deb7fd541ffbd882b5dee08ec14-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2d817deb7fd541ffbd882b5dee08ec14-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2d817deb7fd541ffbd882b5dee08ec14-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2d817deb7fd541ffbd882b5dee08ec14-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2d817deb7fd541ffbd882b5dee08ec14-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2d817deb7fd541ffbd882b5dee08ec14-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2d817deb7fd541ffbd882b5dee08ec14-original.jpg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2d817deb7fd541ffbd882b5dee08ec14-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2d817deb7fd541ffbd882b5dee08ec14-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2d817deb7fd541ffbd882b5dee08ec14-original.jpg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"According to the expert’s assessment, the developers spent most of their time trying to understand the old system, getting it up and running on new hardware and making a few tweaks, and then fixing the errors that would emerge. They describe the essence of the contractor’s work as follows: “to change things in a way that doesn’t change anything” and to migrate the system to domestically produced infrastructure.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Election Commission is particularly proud of this shift to domestically produced systems (a part of the general “import substitution” campaign — Ed.), which was one of the project’s key <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/7249877\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">principles</a>: the commission’s chair, Ella Pamfilova, and both <a href=\"https://adm.digital.gov.ru/app/uploads/2025/02/postanovlenie_czik_rossii_ot_11_12_2024_n_190_1488_8.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">key development coordinators</a> (Nikolai Bulaev, the commission’s deputy chair, and Oleg Kachanov, the chief architect of the system and deputy head of the Ministry of Digital Development) have <a href=\"https://tass.ru/politika/26495415\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">repeatedly</a> <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/8553313\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">emphasised</a> that the updated system exclusively runs on Russian software.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The developers of the system were sceptical about such statements. Here is how they commented on the TsIK executives’ remarks in their work chat groups:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“What domestic software are we talking about? We only use foreign software in development”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“How unpatriotic. The platform owner said it’s domestic, so that’s what it is”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“Well, we’re no longer using Kafka [a foreign platform for data transmission and processing], it’s Кафка now. And it’s Джава instead of Java, the domestic version”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Internal documents reveal that the developers also use foreign platforms (Jira and Confluence) to set and track tasks and store documentation. The team discussed plans to switch to ‘<a href=\"https://www.cnews.ru/news/top/2023-06-09_rostelekom_i_vk_vlozhat_1\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Yaga</a>’ (a recently developed “import substituting” Russian equivalent of Jira developed by Rostelecom — Ed.) — on several occasions, but, according to the team members, “it didn’t take off, and the idea was shelved.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At the same time, the GAS Vybory 2.0 developers must comply with the import substitution <a href=\"https://kontur.ru/talk/spravka/54411-ukaz_prezidenta_ob_importozameshchenii\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">requirements</a> set for state-owned companies. “We have to buy Russian laptops, and, since recently, keyboards, mice and monitors as well. We’re trying to purchase the highest-quality, most functional equipment possible,” they write in chat rooms. The developers bear the cost themselves. They complain that the import-substituting hardware heats up too much, whilst domestic software is not particularly reliable: “To put it mildly, this can be described as low reliability infrastructure; in other words, anything can crash at any time and at any scale.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19229,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4181ed02a5524a75a58bead373edb564-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4181ed02a5524a75a58bead373edb564-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4181ed02a5524a75a58bead373edb564-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4181ed02a5524a75a58bead373edb564-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4181ed02a5524a75a58bead373edb564-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4181ed02a5524a75a58bead373edb564-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4181ed02a5524a75a58bead373edb564-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4181ed02a5524a75a58bead373edb564-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4181ed02a5524a75a58bead373edb564-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4181ed02a5524a75a58bead373edb564-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4181ed02a5524a75a58bead373edb564-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4181ed02a5524a75a58bead373edb564-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4181ed02a5524a75a58bead373edb564-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4181ed02a5524a75a58bead373edb564-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4181ed02a5524a75a58bead373edb564-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4181ed02a5524a75a58bead373edb564-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4181ed02a5524a75a58bead373edb564-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4181ed02a5524a75a58bead373edb564-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"In early 2026, the GAS Vybory 2.0 was put into permanent operation. “It's the birth of a beloved child,” Nikolai Bulaev, the commission’s deputy chair, commented at the time. He also <a href=\"https://www.vedomosti.ru/politics/articles/2024/10/10/1067724-tsik-gotovitsya-k-perehodu-na-novuyu-platformu-gas-vibori\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">described</a> the new system as an “intricate work of art.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"TsIK was delighted with its ‘beloved child’: at the end of 2025, more than 20 people involved in its development received <a href=\"http://www.cikrf.ru/vestnik/documents/decree_of_cec/57992.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">medals</a>, certificates of honour and letters of thanks from the institution. “A huge, full-scale effort was made to develop a completely unique system with no global equivalents. We were navigating a ‘digital minefield’; everything was being done for the first time. The practically impossible was achieved,” Pamfilova <a href=\"https://t.me/cikrossii/4323\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">praised</a> the new system.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“You have to work in the basement.” The system’s developers","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The main developer of the updated system is Tsifrotek, a subsidiary of Rostelecom, Russia’s state-owned digital service provider. This is a single-project company created specifically for developing the GAS Vybory 2.0 system. Tsifrotek <a href=\"https://hh.ru/employer/10434473?tab=DESCRIPTION\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">states</a> that its mission is to create a “comprehensive solution for digitizing the Central Election Commission of Russia and the country’s electoral commissions at all levels” and to completely replace the old version of the platform.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19230,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Screenshot: hh.ru","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3409bab8c93146fcbfef48f08ac8f92c-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3409bab8c93146fcbfef48f08ac8f92c-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3409bab8c93146fcbfef48f08ac8f92c-original.png","real_width_1x":1069,"real_width_2x":1069,"real_height_1x":647,"real_height_2x":647},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3409bab8c93146fcbfef48f08ac8f92c-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3409bab8c93146fcbfef48f08ac8f92c-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3409bab8c93146fcbfef48f08ac8f92c-original.png","real_width_1x":1069,"real_width_2x":1069,"real_height_1x":647,"real_height_2x":647},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3409bab8c93146fcbfef48f08ac8f92c-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3409bab8c93146fcbfef48f08ac8f92c-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3409bab8c93146fcbfef48f08ac8f92c-original.png","real_width_1x":1069,"real_width_2x":1069,"real_height_1x":647,"real_height_2x":647},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3409bab8c93146fcbfef48f08ac8f92c-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3409bab8c93146fcbfef48f08ac8f92c-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3409bab8c93146fcbfef48f08ac8f92c-original.png","real_width_1x":1069,"real_width_2x":1069,"real_height_1x":647,"real_height_2x":647},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3409bab8c93146fcbfef48f08ac8f92c-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3409bab8c93146fcbfef48f08ac8f92c-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3409bab8c93146fcbfef48f08ac8f92c-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":251,"real_height_2x":502},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3409bab8c93146fcbfef48f08ac8f92c-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3409bab8c93146fcbfef48f08ac8f92c-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3409bab8c93146fcbfef48f08ac8f92c-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":251,"real_height_2x":502}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":{"id":19222,"data":{"block":"<p>The government contracting authority of the developing and maintenance works of the GAS Vybory 2.0 system is the Federal Centre for Informatization (FCI) under the Central Election Commission of Russia, whilst Rostelecom is the <a href=\"https://www.vedomosti.ru/politics/articles/2026/01/29/1172462-lyubimoe-ditya-tsik-vvedut-v-postoyannuyu-ekspluatatsiyu-s-fevralya\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">contractor</a>. Rostelecom, in turn, engaged Tsifrotek, its subsidiary, as a subcontractor.</p><p><br/></p><p>In the public procurement databases, there are no contracts with Tsifrotek. According to the company’s financial statements, in December 2025 the main customer signed the contract with Rostelecom, and Tsifrotek planned to become the sole supplier under this contract.</p><p><br/></p><p>Internal documents indicate that Tsifrotek engaged various subcontractors for the project, including Rokitsoft (formerly ‘KROK Region’), Systematica, Step Logic, Otkrytyi Kod, Aiteko, VS Lab and others.</p>","header":"Who else was responsible for the development of the system?","content":[{"insert":"The government contracting authority of the developing and maintenance works of the GAS Vybory 2.0 system is the Federal Centre for Informatization (FCI) under the Central Election Commission of Russia, whilst Rostelecom is the "},{"insert":"contractor","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.vedomosti.ru/politics/articles/2026/01/29/1172462-lyubimoe-ditya-tsik-vvedut-v-postoyannuyu-ekspluatatsiyu-s-fevralya","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":". Rostelecom, in turn, engaged Tsifrotek, its subsidiary, as a subcontractor.\n\nIn the public procurement databases, there are no contracts with Tsifrotek. According to the company’s financial statements, in December 2025 the main customer signed the contract with Rostelecom, and Tsifrotek planned to become the sole supplier under this contract.\n\nInternal documents indicate that Tsifrotek engaged various subcontractors for the project, including Rokitsoft (formerly ‘KROK Region’), Systematica, Step Logic, Otkrytyi Kod, Aiteko, VS Lab and others.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"The company is operating at a loss. According to Tsifrotek’s financial statements, losses had reached 1.7 billion rubles ($20 million approx.) by the end of 2025. The company's revenue was 426 million rubles ($5 million approx.) lower than planned, whilst the operating loss was 304 million rubles ($3,5 million approx.) higher than expected, as Alexey Gusev, the CEO of the company, explained to the staff during an internal conference call.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19231,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data","caption":"Screenshot of a presentation accompanying the CEO of Tsifrotek’s address to staff","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/01be8cc6049f4a17adaf9e67e2def830-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/01be8cc6049f4a17adaf9e67e2def830-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/01be8cc6049f4a17adaf9e67e2def830-original.png","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2262,"real_height_1x":1066,"real_height_2x":1257},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/01be8cc6049f4a17adaf9e67e2def830-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/01be8cc6049f4a17adaf9e67e2def830-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/01be8cc6049f4a17adaf9e67e2def830-original.png","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2262,"real_height_1x":1066,"real_height_2x":1257},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/01be8cc6049f4a17adaf9e67e2def830-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/01be8cc6049f4a17adaf9e67e2def830-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/01be8cc6049f4a17adaf9e67e2def830-original.png","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2262,"real_height_1x":666,"real_height_2x":1257},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/01be8cc6049f4a17adaf9e67e2def830-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/01be8cc6049f4a17adaf9e67e2def830-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/01be8cc6049f4a17adaf9e67e2def830-original.png","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2262,"real_height_1x":666,"real_height_2x":1257},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/01be8cc6049f4a17adaf9e67e2def830-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/01be8cc6049f4a17adaf9e67e2def830-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/01be8cc6049f4a17adaf9e67e2def830-original.png","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":230,"real_height_2x":461},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/01be8cc6049f4a17adaf9e67e2def830-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/01be8cc6049f4a17adaf9e67e2def830-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/01be8cc6049f4a17adaf9e67e2def830-original.png","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":230,"real_height_2x":461}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Tsifrotek explicitly <a href=\"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/documents/b662900e2c2e4df59f8d73bb4b4c5d4b.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">states</a> that the reason for the losses is its “work on a complex, years-long project of national importance — the development and maintenance of the GAS Vybory 2.0 system.” In its early years, the company was actively engaging contractors using borrowed funds, as it lacked the in-house expertise to carry out such work, but needed to meet “high reliability and security requirements.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19233,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data","caption":"Excerpt from the notes to Tsifrotek’s financial statements for 2025","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4636db208c864303b40b5dd26b30a7f4-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4636db208c864303b40b5dd26b30a7f4-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4636db208c864303b40b5dd26b30a7f4-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2478,"real_height_1x":1482,"real_height_2x":1914},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4636db208c864303b40b5dd26b30a7f4-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4636db208c864303b40b5dd26b30a7f4-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4636db208c864303b40b5dd26b30a7f4-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2478,"real_height_1x":1482,"real_height_2x":1914},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4636db208c864303b40b5dd26b30a7f4-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4636db208c864303b40b5dd26b30a7f4-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4636db208c864303b40b5dd26b30a7f4-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":926,"real_height_2x":1853},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4636db208c864303b40b5dd26b30a7f4-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4636db208c864303b40b5dd26b30a7f4-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4636db208c864303b40b5dd26b30a7f4-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":926,"real_height_2x":1853},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4636db208c864303b40b5dd26b30a7f4-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4636db208c864303b40b5dd26b30a7f4-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4636db208c864303b40b5dd26b30a7f4-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":320,"real_height_2x":640},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4636db208c864303b40b5dd26b30a7f4-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4636db208c864303b40b5dd26b30a7f4-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4636db208c864303b40b5dd26b30a7f4-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":320,"real_height_2x":640}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The company’s budget was also hit by fines from the state customer. In 2025 alone, the contracting authority imposed fines totalling 152 million roubles on the company (for the system maintenance, the CEO told staff whilst explaining the ‘bonus payments issues’ in the final quarter of 2025). According to him, the fines arise partly due to red tape: even if the developers meet the system maintenance requirements on time, “because of paperwork not filled in on time, the state customer has no choice but to issue fines.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19234,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"","caption":"Tsifrotek brand book extracts","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ac9469d0d24f47cf8852e1b297be5294-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ac9469d0d24f47cf8852e1b297be5294-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ac9469d0d24f47cf8852e1b297be5294-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ac9469d0d24f47cf8852e1b297be5294-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ac9469d0d24f47cf8852e1b297be5294-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ac9469d0d24f47cf8852e1b297be5294-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ac9469d0d24f47cf8852e1b297be5294-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ac9469d0d24f47cf8852e1b297be5294-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ac9469d0d24f47cf8852e1b297be5294-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ac9469d0d24f47cf8852e1b297be5294-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ac9469d0d24f47cf8852e1b297be5294-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ac9469d0d24f47cf8852e1b297be5294-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ac9469d0d24f47cf8852e1b297be5294-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ac9469d0d24f47cf8852e1b297be5294-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ac9469d0d24f47cf8852e1b297be5294-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ac9469d0d24f47cf8852e1b297be5294-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ac9469d0d24f47cf8852e1b297be5294-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ac9469d0d24f47cf8852e1b297be5294-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"By 2025, Tsifrotek had already employed more than 300 people. That is also when the company <a href=\"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/documents/b662900e2c2e4df59f8d73bb4b4c5d4b.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">began </a>laying people off, according to its financial statements. One of our sources says this happened because the company “hadn’t calculated the budget properly”: “Firstly, there were a lot of fines following the unified voting day (in 2025, local elections in many regions of Russia were scheduled for the same day, September 14 — Ed.) Secondly, the staff had been paid generously for overtime work, even when it wasn’t actually necessary, and the budget ended up in a mess.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“At the end of 2025, they simply sacked most of the team,” ex-employees <a href=\"https://dreamjob.ru/employers/5038916\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">complain</a> in their reviews. They also mention the difficult working conditions: “A very challenging place to work, with a whole lot of services operating in a complicated, confusing way. You have to work in the basement.” One of those interviewed by IStories described the atmosphere within the team as follows: “The attitude towards subordinates was offensive, they didn’t hold back much in their language or jokes, let alone valuing [employment] rights. They were always short-staffed.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19235,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: dreamjob.ru screenshots","caption":"Ex-employee reviews","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/18b1b54e381a47e88a1b10489178533b-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/18b1b54e381a47e88a1b10489178533b-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/18b1b54e381a47e88a1b10489178533b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/18b1b54e381a47e88a1b10489178533b-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/18b1b54e381a47e88a1b10489178533b-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/18b1b54e381a47e88a1b10489178533b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/18b1b54e381a47e88a1b10489178533b-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/18b1b54e381a47e88a1b10489178533b-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/18b1b54e381a47e88a1b10489178533b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/18b1b54e381a47e88a1b10489178533b-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/18b1b54e381a47e88a1b10489178533b-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/18b1b54e381a47e88a1b10489178533b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/18b1b54e381a47e88a1b10489178533b-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/18b1b54e381a47e88a1b10489178533b-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/18b1b54e381a47e88a1b10489178533b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/18b1b54e381a47e88a1b10489178533b-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/18b1b54e381a47e88a1b10489178533b-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/18b1b54e381a47e88a1b10489178533b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"According to reviews, Tsifrotek developers <a href=\"https://dreamjob.ru/employers/5038916/zarplata\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">earn</a> an average of around 300 thousand rubles per month ($3,500 approx.) The leaked data shows that the salaries are higher: in 2025, an ordinary developer would earn around 500 thousand rubles a month ($6,000 approx.), whilst a senior developer would earn up to 650 thousand rubles ($7,700 approx.). During the unified voting day campaigns, earnings could increase two- to threefold due to paid overtime.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“For some, the monthly income reached almost a million rubles (up to $12,000), even though their salary only amounted to 300 thousand. And yet, a developer could show up and just loaf around all day,” says one person engaged in the development. In addition, staff are paid quarterly bonuses. According to the leaked documents, in certain months even ordinary developers received over a million roubles. However, since the 2025 unified voting day, the company has had bonuses issues, the staff say: they either do not pay them in full or do not pay them at all.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19236,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data","caption":"Tsifrotek employees at Rostelecom’s corporate competitions","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7bacaa41d6dc4d51b8e23516bf30257f-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7bacaa41d6dc4d51b8e23516bf30257f-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7bacaa41d6dc4d51b8e23516bf30257f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3000,"real_height_1x":1280,"real_height_2x":2000},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7bacaa41d6dc4d51b8e23516bf30257f-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7bacaa41d6dc4d51b8e23516bf30257f-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7bacaa41d6dc4d51b8e23516bf30257f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3000,"real_height_1x":1280,"real_height_2x":2000},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7bacaa41d6dc4d51b8e23516bf30257f-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7bacaa41d6dc4d51b8e23516bf30257f-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7bacaa41d6dc4d51b8e23516bf30257f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7bacaa41d6dc4d51b8e23516bf30257f-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7bacaa41d6dc4d51b8e23516bf30257f-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7bacaa41d6dc4d51b8e23516bf30257f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7bacaa41d6dc4d51b8e23516bf30257f-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7bacaa41d6dc4d51b8e23516bf30257f-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7bacaa41d6dc4d51b8e23516bf30257f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7bacaa41d6dc4d51b8e23516bf30257f-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7bacaa41d6dc4d51b8e23516bf30257f-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7bacaa41d6dc4d51b8e23516bf30257f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"“It’s just a regular IT company,” an employee tells IStories. “It’s not like everyone has to exercise every morning while listening to the Russian national anthem.” According to another employee, the company is staffed by “ordinary people” — “there’s no sign of some kind of mass Z (pro-war — Ed.) sentiment.” He describes most employees as an “amorphous, apolitical mass”: “Neither supporting [the war and the government policies in general] nor against it.” Sometimes at conference calls, he says, less-than-flattering comments about the authorities can be heard — especially upon VPNs being blocked en masse in 2025–2026 (since 2022, Russia has been blocking international social media and services, hence VPNs have been widely used to access most of them — Ed.) The team communicates on Telegram, so after the crackdown on VPNs remote developers had to “figure something out” to stay connected. It’s easier to access the Internet in the TsIK building itself: “There’s access, so at work you can chill and watch YouTube.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“The staff would sleep at work.” The development process&nbsp;","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Tsifrotek joined the project in 2023. According to internal conference calls, the company took over the development work from the Systematica company when it was underway.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“At the initial stage, no one had the source code — not Rostelecom, not the Electoral Commission, nobody. Deliveries were chaotic; it was unclear which version [of the system] was being used. The different versions were incompatible with one another. It was a real mess,” Alexander Minchenko, Tsifrotek’s then-director of development told employees at the time.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2025, the developers were due to carry out two system trials and then test it in a real election during the unified voting day in September. Alexey Gusev, Tsifrotek’s CEO, admitted during an internal conference call that, as of early 2025, the system was essentially not ready: “To say it’s not ready yet is an understatement.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“The quality of the system was poor. We identified around 7,000 issues, of which around 500 were critical. There wasn’t a single report that functioned properly,” Alexander Minchenko, then Head of Development at Tsifrotek, said. “How did we conduct elections in such a situation? Well, it was an extremely risky move.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19250,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data, LinkedIn","caption":"Alexey Gusev, Tsifrotek CEO, and Alexander Minchenko, Head of Development","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a8faf28b5c249f092e4587f7aec5149-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a8faf28b5c249f092e4587f7aec5149-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a8faf28b5c249f092e4587f7aec5149-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a8faf28b5c249f092e4587f7aec5149-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a8faf28b5c249f092e4587f7aec5149-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a8faf28b5c249f092e4587f7aec5149-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a8faf28b5c249f092e4587f7aec5149-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a8faf28b5c249f092e4587f7aec5149-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a8faf28b5c249f092e4587f7aec5149-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a8faf28b5c249f092e4587f7aec5149-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a8faf28b5c249f092e4587f7aec5149-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a8faf28b5c249f092e4587f7aec5149-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a8faf28b5c249f092e4587f7aec5149-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a8faf28b5c249f092e4587f7aec5149-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a8faf28b5c249f092e4587f7aec5149-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a8faf28b5c249f092e4587f7aec5149-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a8faf28b5c249f092e4587f7aec5149-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7a8faf28b5c249f092e4587f7aec5149-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The team handled the 2025 unified voting day thanks to working overtime — the staff “lived at work” and “carried the unified voting day on their shoulders,” Minchenko noted during a conference call. According to him, ‘a lot of things went wrong’ during the vote, but the developers quickly fixed the bugs — so quickly that the Central Election Commission didn’t notice any problems.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“The whole team simply gave it their all, pushing themselves to 1,000 per cent. I saw people sleeping whenever they could, right here in Room 110 of the data centre in the basement,” Yuri Sakun, Director of Integrated Digital Projects at Rostelecom, described the voting day.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The GAS Vybory 2.0 system features a closed network that cannot be accessed from the internet; consequently, Tsifrotek staff sometimes work within the TsIK building itself. According to one of our interviewees, all staff members are security checked by the Federal Protective Service (FSO) before being issued with a permanent pass to the TsIK. Not everyone passes the check.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The strict access regime has sometimes led to direct clashes between the developers and the FSO. “Today, FSO officers tried to detain an employee and hand them over to the police for leaving late,” one such incident was described in chat rooms in the summer of 2026. Sometimes passes are revoked without any explanation — one can only speculate about the reasons, says one of the Tsifrotek staff: for example, it can be accidentally “taking down the prod [the operating version of the system] at the wrong time,” liking a “wrong” video on YouTube, or simply somehow falling out of favour with the customer to find out later that their pass was no longer valid.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19237,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data","caption":"Tsifrotek staff discussing the working conditions at TsIK","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3f4884a302544fc385e27b099b35dbf2-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3f4884a302544fc385e27b099b35dbf2-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3f4884a302544fc385e27b099b35dbf2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3f4884a302544fc385e27b099b35dbf2-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3f4884a302544fc385e27b099b35dbf2-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3f4884a302544fc385e27b099b35dbf2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3f4884a302544fc385e27b099b35dbf2-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3f4884a302544fc385e27b099b35dbf2-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3f4884a302544fc385e27b099b35dbf2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3f4884a302544fc385e27b099b35dbf2-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3f4884a302544fc385e27b099b35dbf2-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3f4884a302544fc385e27b099b35dbf2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3f4884a302544fc385e27b099b35dbf2-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3f4884a302544fc385e27b099b35dbf2-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3f4884a302544fc385e27b099b35dbf2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3f4884a302544fc385e27b099b35dbf2-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3f4884a302544fc385e27b099b35dbf2-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3f4884a302544fc385e27b099b35dbf2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"According to an internal conference call at the company, work on setting up the information security department at Tsifrotek only began in 2026. “We have the department, but no staff,” the company’s then-technical director admitted at the time, adding that Tsifrotek lacked the resources and expertise to oversee the contractor responsible for the project’s security, Rostelecom’s subsidiary Solar.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The staff have had basic security training by Rostelecom, an employee told us. “But if work-related communication takes place on Telegram, that speaks volumes,” they add. In the internal chat groups employees mention one of them being hacked. They also regularly discuss suspicious files infiltrating into the code base of the system.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19247,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data ","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/389ad14829bd449498a7495f81797ade-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/389ad14829bd449498a7495f81797ade-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/389ad14829bd449498a7495f81797ade-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/389ad14829bd449498a7495f81797ade-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/389ad14829bd449498a7495f81797ade-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/389ad14829bd449498a7495f81797ade-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/389ad14829bd449498a7495f81797ade-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/389ad14829bd449498a7495f81797ade-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/389ad14829bd449498a7495f81797ade-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/389ad14829bd449498a7495f81797ade-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/389ad14829bd449498a7495f81797ade-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/389ad14829bd449498a7495f81797ade-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/389ad14829bd449498a7495f81797ade-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/389ad14829bd449498a7495f81797ade-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/389ad14829bd449498a7495f81797ade-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/389ad14829bd449498a7495f81797ade-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/389ad14829bd449498a7495f81797ade-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/389ad14829bd449498a7495f81797ade-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":{"id":19248,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data ","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7950c1baaca0482f903c9c68f0f23577-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7950c1baaca0482f903c9c68f0f23577-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7950c1baaca0482f903c9c68f0f23577-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7950c1baaca0482f903c9c68f0f23577-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7950c1baaca0482f903c9c68f0f23577-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7950c1baaca0482f903c9c68f0f23577-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7950c1baaca0482f903c9c68f0f23577-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7950c1baaca0482f903c9c68f0f23577-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7950c1baaca0482f903c9c68f0f23577-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7950c1baaca0482f903c9c68f0f23577-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7950c1baaca0482f903c9c68f0f23577-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7950c1baaca0482f903c9c68f0f23577-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7950c1baaca0482f903c9c68f0f23577-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7950c1baaca0482f903c9c68f0f23577-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7950c1baaca0482f903c9c68f0f23577-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7950c1baaca0482f903c9c68f0f23577-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7950c1baaca0482f903c9c68f0f23577-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7950c1baaca0482f903c9c68f0f23577-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The Central Election Commission <a href=\"https://nom24.ru/info/v-tsik-prizvali-otvetit-na-tsifrovye-ugrozy-uvelicheniem-mest-dlya-nablyudeniya-v-tsonakh-ekspertnyy-vzglyad\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">states</a> that the upcoming State Duma elections will take place in “extremely challenging conditions,” and that the agency’s top priority is security. According to Oleg Kachanov, TsIK is successfully combating digital threats, such as DDoS attacks. This fight leads to malfunctions and obstructs work, says a person involved in the development of the system: the internal services frequently crash, and the IP addresses used by the portal’s team themselves get blocked—“this has caused several outages.” “There’s a constant struggle when it comes to security. The client plays it safe and says, ‘Let’s block it,’ but because of that, we can’t work,” the developer says.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The development progress would be demonstrated at special presentations for the customers from TsIK’s Federal Center for Informatization, the government and Ella Pamfilova personally, according to internal discussions among the developers.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Errors were sometimes corrected at the last minute before demonstrations and report submissions. “We have an urgent problem &lt;...&gt; An error in mapping the campaign reports — the FCI is coming for the report at 9:00 a.m., and we won’t be able to provide it to them,” they wrote in the chat just 30 minutes before the deadline. The employee responsible for this replied that the cause was a misspelling of the “United Russia” party name: “They wrote ‘RUSSSIA’ with three S’s &lt;...&gt; But for the report, you can temporarily correct the mapping &lt;...&gt; Make it say ‘UNITED RUSSSIA.’”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"On the customer’s (the FCI) side, the development was overseen by Rodion Shchekuteev, the deputy head of the agency, and Dmitry Gundin, head of the Department for the Collection and Processing of Information Resources at the GAS Vybory 2.0 system. New versions were personally approved by the FCI Director, Alexander Sokolchuk.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2023, the Tsifrotek employees discussed raising money for New Year’s gifts for several representatives of the customer: three of them, including Sokolchuk and Shchekuteev, were to receive “VIP gifts.” According to the chat logs, only 30 employees “voluntarily decided to financially contribute to the gifts” for the client’s representatives, and 2,350 rubles ($30 approx.) were raised from each of them.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19240,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data ","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61645e47faeb4b4ca39a086461b0003d-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61645e47faeb4b4ca39a086461b0003d-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61645e47faeb4b4ca39a086461b0003d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61645e47faeb4b4ca39a086461b0003d-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61645e47faeb4b4ca39a086461b0003d-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61645e47faeb4b4ca39a086461b0003d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61645e47faeb4b4ca39a086461b0003d-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61645e47faeb4b4ca39a086461b0003d-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61645e47faeb4b4ca39a086461b0003d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61645e47faeb4b4ca39a086461b0003d-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61645e47faeb4b4ca39a086461b0003d-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61645e47faeb4b4ca39a086461b0003d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61645e47faeb4b4ca39a086461b0003d-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61645e47faeb4b4ca39a086461b0003d-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61645e47faeb4b4ca39a086461b0003d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61645e47faeb4b4ca39a086461b0003d-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61645e47faeb4b4ca39a086461b0003d-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61645e47faeb4b4ca39a086461b0003d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"“We had systems that were completely unfinished, but we had to submit what we've done according to the contracts,” says one of the sources interviewed by IStories. According to him, they would succeed in part thanks to such gifts: “We would come and say, ‘Yes, yes, we’ll definitely get everything done, but it’s not working right now. Here’s a nice gift, by the way. Please sign here; we need to close the contract.’” Most often, they would present alcohol in large amounts: “Not exactly bribes, but gifts. All those huge trunks were X-rayed by the Federal Protective Service at the entrance.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“The systems are being refined as we speak.” Is the platform ready for its first federal election?&nbsp;","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"According to one of the Tsifrotek employees interviewed by IStories, the GAS Vybory 2.0 system is almost ready and operational, but some systems were “being refined literally as we speak.” After the 2025 unified voting day, the developers had many tasks, but the client’s requirements changed frequently. The staff had to find compromises, which is why many things don’t work the way they should, our source explains. Meanwhile, the developers are “working an awful lot of overtime,” and the terms of government contracts are often not being followed — “they turn a blind eye to what needs to be documented.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This year, for the first time, State Duma elections will be held in the Ukrainian territories occupied by Russia since 2022. Before making this decision, the Central Election Commission consulted with the Russian FSB and the Ministry of Defense.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to the sources interviewed by IStories,” the digital infrastructure needed to conduct elections in these territories was still not set up. “It’s total garbage, to put it mildly,” says one of the employees. “This is where it’s really possible to manipulate and alter things — it’s very difficult to verify the data coming in [from the occupied territories].”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The idea of voting in the annexed regions places an additional burden on the GAS Vybory 2.0 system — for example, in terms of communicating address data. At a call, developers discussed the way the system had to process larger address information files because of the occupied territories being included in the voting process. “If, for example, a long street is renamed, or a new region is annexed or separated — I don’t know, anything like that — the [address] file will take up over a gigabyte (at that time, the respective part of the system could only handle files smaller than 800 MB — Ed.).”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Confusion over addresses in the occupied territories has led to widespread malfunctions in the subsystem used to keep track of the voter registry. In the occupied parts of Ukraine’s Donetsk, Luhansk, Zaporizhzhia, and Kherson Oblasts, there were more than 95,000 “address-related incidents,” which amounts to about 10% of all current malfunctions in the subsystem, the developers noted. Problems with addresses have also been arising in the annexed Crimea. “There are now ZERO residents on the street,” “all voters from both addresses are gone” — Crimean Sevastopol system administrators wrote in their technical support requests in 2025 and 2026.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"System tests continued until September 2026. Just a few weeks before the election, developers were still sorting through dozens of requests to fix errors, according to the internal documents. The system incorrectly calculated the percentage of election commissions that had submitted reports and produced values exceeding 100%; errors occurred while determining winners in multi-member districts and while generating the voting records.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In the region of Bashkortostan, deceased individuals have appeared on voter lists on several occasions. The most recent report on this issue was received on August 31. It is unknown whether the problem had been resolved before the election began. There were also candidate verification issues: the Bank of Russia reports would not arrive, and inaccurate tax information based on tax data would not be successfully generated.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19241,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data ","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6fd5858ed0f64f0e8a3a2eb84b671b34-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6fd5858ed0f64f0e8a3a2eb84b671b34-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6fd5858ed0f64f0e8a3a2eb84b671b34-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6fd5858ed0f64f0e8a3a2eb84b671b34-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6fd5858ed0f64f0e8a3a2eb84b671b34-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6fd5858ed0f64f0e8a3a2eb84b671b34-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6fd5858ed0f64f0e8a3a2eb84b671b34-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6fd5858ed0f64f0e8a3a2eb84b671b34-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6fd5858ed0f64f0e8a3a2eb84b671b34-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6fd5858ed0f64f0e8a3a2eb84b671b34-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6fd5858ed0f64f0e8a3a2eb84b671b34-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6fd5858ed0f64f0e8a3a2eb84b671b34-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6fd5858ed0f64f0e8a3a2eb84b671b34-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6fd5858ed0f64f0e8a3a2eb84b671b34-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6fd5858ed0f64f0e8a3a2eb84b671b34-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6fd5858ed0f64f0e8a3a2eb84b671b34-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6fd5858ed0f64f0e8a3a2eb84b671b34-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6fd5858ed0f64f0e8a3a2eb84b671b34-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"To resolve some of the issues, developers changed the database manually, bypassing the standard protocols. Manual edits were performed during the testing process, but it remains unclear how such problems will be addressed during actual elections and who will be authorized to edit the result fields in the database.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This is just one of the potential vulnerabilities in the system.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The structure and vulnerabilities of the system","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Doubts about the integrity of Russian election results have existed for a long time. As far back as 2011, Sergei Shpilkin’s calculation of fabricated votes cast in favor of pro-government candidates went <a href=\"https://meduza.io/cards/vizhu-mnogo-grafikov-o-falsifikatsii-na-vyborah-chto-oni-znachat\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">viral</a>.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Eight years later, Moscow <a href=\"https://golosinfo.org/articles/144005\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">tested</a> the electronic remote voting system developed by the Moscow City Hall’s IT department for the first time, and this raised more questions: observers could not verify that the electronic votes had not been tampered with at any stage, or that voters had cast their ballots in person and did it voluntarily. At the same time, Rostelecom developed another remote voting system — a federal one — for other regions. In the September 2026 State Duma elections, the federal remote voting system <a href=\"https://tass.ru/politika/27851431\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">will be used</a> in 32 regions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19223,"data":{"block":"<p>In 2019, the electronic remote voting system developed by the Moscow City Hall’s IT department was <a href=\"https://golosinfo.org/articles/144005\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">tested</a> for the first time during the Moscow City Duma elections. Two years later, the system was <a href=\"https://meduza.io/feature/2021/10/11/kazhdyy-raz-oschuschenie-chto-tebya-poimeli-kazhdye-vybory\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">used</a> in the State Duma elections. Blockchain technology, which the developers of the Moscow system claimed to be using, was supposed to <a href=\"https://habr.com/ru/specials/480152/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">ensure</a> trust in the system.</p><p><br/></p><p>“We’re told that blockchain is a symbol of transparency, but in reality, the collection of ballots and voter rolls go through some internal databases maintained by the [system’s] operators, which observers can never access,” says Pyotr Zhizhin, an electoral analyst. “And it’s very important that we cannot independently verify how many ballots were issued, how many were counted, how many voters are actually on the rolls, or how they were compiled.”</p><p><br/></p><p>Analysts who examined the results of the 2021 elections <a href=\"https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2021/09/30/mandaty-polzuiutsia-vbrosom\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">criticized</a> the Moscow remote voting system for the inexplicable voter behavior that <a href=\"https://electionfraud2021.acf.international/ru/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">determined</a> the distribution of seats in Moscow. More than 250,000 votes cast for opposition candidates were redirected to pro-government candidates through a revote mechanism.</p><p><br/></p><p>At the same time, Rostelecom was developing a federal system modeled after the one in Moscow. It was gradually rolled out in dozens of Russian regions outside of Moscow, and by the 2026 State Duma elections, 32 regions had been <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/8763707\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">connected</a> to the system. Rostelecom, like the Moscow City Hall, <a href=\"https://habr.com/ru/companies/rostelecom/articles/518090/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">claimed </a>that its system was reliable.</p><p><br/></p><p>According to Zhizhin, the transparency of electronic voting systems has been deteriorating since 2021, when <a href=\"https://github.com/moscow-technologies/blockchain-voting_2021\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Moscow City Hall’s IT department</a> and <a href=\"https://github.com/cikrf/deg2021\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Rostelecom </a>last published the source code. “We can see by external factors that the blockchain systems, or the databases they use, have been altered, and that the protocols have been changed,” Zhizhin explains. “Whereas [previously] in the data dumps [of results] that we use to search for anomalies, we could see a breakdown by terminals at polling stations and by digital votes, this breakdown was removed prior to the presidential election [in 2024]. Every year, the system only gets worse and becomes even more opaque.”</p>","header":"More on the concerns regarding remote voting","content":[{"insert":"In 2019, the electronic remote voting system developed by the Moscow City Hall’s IT department was "},{"insert":"tested","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://golosinfo.org/articles/144005","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" for the first time during the Moscow City Duma elections. Two years later, the system was "},{"insert":"used","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://meduza.io/feature/2021/10/11/kazhdyy-raz-oschuschenie-chto-tebya-poimeli-kazhdye-vybory","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" in the State Duma elections. Blockchain technology, which the developers of the Moscow system claimed to be using, was supposed to "},{"insert":"ensure","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://habr.com/ru/specials/480152/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" trust in the system.\n\n“We’re told that blockchain is a symbol of transparency, but in reality, the collection of ballots and voter rolls go through some internal databases maintained by the [system’s] operators, which observers can never access,” says Pyotr Zhizhin, an electoral analyst. “And it’s very important that we cannot independently verify how many ballots were issued, how many were counted, how many voters are actually on the rolls, or how they were compiled.”\n\nAnalysts who examined the results of the 2021 elections "},{"insert":"criticized","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2021/09/30/mandaty-polzuiutsia-vbrosom","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" the Moscow remote voting system for the inexplicable voter behavior that "},{"insert":"determined","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://electionfraud2021.acf.international/ru/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" the distribution of seats in Moscow. More than 250,000 votes cast for opposition candidates were redirected to pro-government candidates through a revote mechanism.\n\nAt the same time, Rostelecom was developing a federal system modeled after the one in Moscow. It was gradually rolled out in dozens of Russian regions outside of Moscow, and by the 2026 State Duma elections, 32 regions had been "},{"insert":"connected","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/8763707","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" to the system. Rostelecom, like the Moscow City Hall, "},{"insert":"claimed ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://habr.com/ru/companies/rostelecom/articles/518090/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"that its system was reliable.\n\nAccording to Zhizhin, the transparency of electronic voting systems has been deteriorating since 2021, when "},{"insert":"Moscow City Hall’s IT department","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://github.com/moscow-technologies/blockchain-voting_2021","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" and "},{"insert":"Rostelecom ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://github.com/cikrf/deg2021","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"last published the source code. “We can see by external factors that the blockchain systems, or the databases they use, have been altered, and that the protocols have been changed,” Zhizhin explains. “Whereas [previously] in the data dumps [of results] that we use to search for anomalies, we could see a breakdown by terminals at polling stations and by digital votes, this breakdown was removed prior to the presidential election [in 2024]. Every year, the system only gets worse and becomes even more opaque.”\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"IStories examined the operation of the GAS Vybory 2.0 system, including the components involved in compiling voter rolls, interacting with the remote voting systems, and counting the votes. At our request, the documents from the Tsifrotek leak were also examined by Ivan Shukshin, an election analyst, and two technical experts who requested to remain anonymous. Together we identified the main vulnerabilities in the system the Central Election Commission could exploit to influence election results.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Our analysis is based on the documents and the module code available to us. It is possible that, as of the time of publication, the system’s components may function slightly differently than it was described there.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19224,"data":{"block":"<p>The new platform consists of nearly two dozen subsystems. Here are the key ones:</p><p><br/></p><ul><li>PAIP (Election Process Automation Subsystem) — for managing election campaigns;</li></ul><p><br/></p><ul><li>RUIP (Electoral Process Participants Registry) — for compiling the voter list;</li></ul><p><br/></p><ul><li>PVV (External Interaction Subsystem) — for communicating with other government systems;</li></ul><p><br/></p><ul><li>KFPP (Political Party Financing Control) — for monitoring political parties’ bank accounts;</li></ul><p><br/></p><ul><li>MV DEG (Module for Interaction with the Remote Voting System) — for sending voter lists and ballots to the electronic remote voting system and receiving results back into the TsIK system;</li></ul><p><br/></p><ul><li>MV Moscow (Module for Interaction with the Moscow Remote Voting System) — for the same interaction, but with the Moscow remote voting system.</li></ul><p><br/></p><p>PAIP is the central component of the GAS Vybory 2.0 system, which links the other parts of the system together. Within it, the TsIK staff manage election campaign planning, define district boundaries, maintain records of the candidates and parties, and monitor their financing. Within this same system, the “Results” module processes the vote counts, which are then published on the TsIK website.</p><p><br/></p><p>The RUIP, or, <a href=\"https://tass.ru/politika/26271053\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">in the words</a> of Nikolai Bulaev, Pamfilova’s deputy and one of the project leaders, the “heart” of the system, serves as a source of up-to-date voter data. This subsystem stores the basic personal data of voting Russians: full name, birth date, residence address, passport information, and social security number (SNILS).</p><p><br/></p><p>This system also receives voter requests to be reassigned to other polling stations (via the “Mobile Voter” service) and requests to participate in remote or at-home voting processes. Before being approved, these requests must be cross-checked against the voter registry. Voter lists for all local election commissions are compiled based on data from the RUIP.</p><p><br/></p><p>The DEG Interface Module links the PAIP (the system’s core) and the remote voting complex (DEG). The developers of the new platform do not work with the DEG directly; the DEG data is fed into the vote-counting module in aggregated form. Therefore, the DEG Interface documentation does not explain exactly how vote counting is organized within the remote voting system itself.</p><p><br/></p><p>Before the election, this subsystem receives the PAIP data on election campaigns and candidates, as well as the RUIP voter lists, after which they are sent to the remote voting system. In the opposite direction, data on digital voting turnout and files containing the results are received from the DEG system. In the MV DEG, remote voting records are generated and transmitted to the “Results” module, where the final results are counted.</p><p><br/></p><p>MV Moscow is a separate module designed to connect the TsIK system with the electronic voting system developed for Moscow. It operates similarly to the module for the federal remote voting system.</p>","header":"How the GAS Vybory 2.0 system works","content":[{"insert":"The new platform consists of nearly two dozen subsystems. Here are the key ones:\n\nPAIP (Election Process Automation Subsystem) — for managing election campaigns;"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"\nRUIP (Electoral Process Participants Registry) — for compiling the voter list;"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"\nPVV (External Interaction Subsystem) — for communicating with other government systems;"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"\nKFPP (Political Party Financing Control) — for monitoring political parties’ bank accounts;"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"\nMV DEG (Module for Interaction with the Remote Voting System) — for sending voter lists and ballots to the electronic remote voting system and receiving results back into the TsIK system;"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"\nMV Moscow (Module for Interaction with the Moscow Remote Voting System) — for the same interaction, but with the Moscow remote voting system."},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"\nPAIP is the central component of the GAS Vybory 2.0 system, which links the other parts of the system together. Within it, the TsIK staff manage election campaign planning, define district boundaries, maintain records of the candidates and parties, and monitor their financing. Within this same system, the “Results” module processes the vote counts, which are then published on the TsIK website.\n\nThe RUIP, or, "},{"insert":"in the words","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://tass.ru/politika/26271053","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" of Nikolai Bulaev, Pamfilova’s deputy and one of the project leaders, the “heart” of the system, serves as a source of up-to-date voter data. This subsystem stores the basic personal data of voting Russians: full name, birth date, residence address, passport information, and social security number (SNILS).\n\nThis system also receives voter requests to be reassigned to other polling stations (via the “Mobile Voter” service) and requests to participate in remote or at-home voting processes. Before being approved, these requests must be cross-checked against the voter registry. Voter lists for all local election commissions are compiled based on data from the RUIP.\n\nThe DEG Interface Module links the PAIP (the system’s core) and the remote voting complex (DEG). The developers of the new platform do not work with the DEG directly; the DEG data is fed into the vote-counting module in aggregated form. Therefore, the DEG Interface documentation does not explain exactly how vote counting is organized within the remote voting system itself.\n\nBefore the election, this subsystem receives the PAIP data on election campaigns and candidates, as well as the RUIP voter lists, after which they are sent to the remote voting system. In the opposite direction, data on digital voting turnout and files containing the results are received from the DEG system. In the MV DEG, remote voting records are generated and transmitted to the “Results” module, where the final results are counted.\n\nMV Moscow is a separate module designed to connect the TsIK system with the electronic voting system developed for Moscow. It operates similarly to the module for the federal remote voting system.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Vulnerability #1: tampering with the results</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After the votes are counted at the polling station, the election commission prints and signs the final document containing the results. The voting results can then be entered into the GAS Vybory 2.0 system in two ways: automatically (by scanning a QR code or uploading a PDF file) or manually.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to the documentation, manually entered data is not cross-checked against the original documents. However, results uploaded to the GAS Vybory 2.0 via a QR code can also be edited manually. The system stores previous versions of the documents and the username of the user who made the changes.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It was the loose treatment of the result transferring process that made it possible to <a href=\"https://t.me/cikrf/10757\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">rig the results</a> at a polling station in Saratov in 2024. At that time the old Elections system was still in use. Vladimir Putin received 300 more votes than the local commission had recorded in their voting results documents. More than two hundred unused ballots were rewritten in his favor, while the number of spoiled ballots and votes for other candidates was underreported.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Our election law states that results must be published at all polling stations; they’re always public,” explains a Tsifrotek developer interviewed by IStories. “Next, the final aggregate results must be published. Given that we now have AI, having the AI verify everything isn’t a problem at all. If someone wants to change something, it will be easy to spot.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The results are indeed published in electronic format on the TsIK website. However, this data does not let one verify that the published results match the signed physical documents (which can also be falsified).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to the discussions in the Tsifrotek chat, the result calculations in the system raises doubts among the developers as well: “Colleagues, you’ve apparently been working with TsIK for a long time now — why would anyone at a polling station need to assign or manipulate [votes] when there’s the wonderful PAIP, which aggregates the data and produces the results, and no one knows how it does it?” one of the developers wrote.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Vulnerability #2: voter list manipulations</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In the leak, IStories discovered the data on 111.3 million voters from the RUIP register — including their names, dates of birth, residential addresses, and the polling stations to which they are assigned. This suggests that developers — and likely the election commission staff as well — can export unencrypted personal data of Russian citizens.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Security experts were very concerned that personal data was being transmitted in plain text, with no one encrypting it,” one of the developers involved in the project told us. “There are opportunities for leaks, and there are a lot of them.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The metadata from the voter files indicates that the data was uploaded in July 2026. The numbers of voters broken down by region largely match the Central Election Commission’s figures as of July 1 — discrepancies do not exceed 1%, except for the territories annexed in 2022 <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"in 9 regions, the difference is 1 to 4%, meanwhile in the Ukrainian territories occupied since 2022 (parts of Donetsk, Luhansk and Zaporizhzhia Oblasts) the leak contains 7 to 50% more voters than in the TsIK’s officially published data. In the occupied part of Kherson Oblast, there are 4% less voters, according to our calculations\"></span>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We compared the voter lists from the leak with the civil registry offices’ death registration data since 2022, which was provided by the Manticore project. According to our estimates, the data from the GAS Vybory 2.0 system included at least 104,000 people declared deceased in the occupied territories, including Crimea, as well as in the Kursk and Bryansk Oblasts.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The process of preparing voter lists for remote voting is one of the vulnerabilities in this subsystem. According to the documentation for the nationwide training session on using the GAS Vybory 2.0 system, system administrators at the territorial election commissions can manually enter applications for remote electronic voting into the database.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"With direct access to voter rolls, system users could likely artificially inflate the number of e-voters. Such manipulation may have occurred in 2021, when several people interviewed by Meduza were <a href=\"https://meduza.io/feature/2021/10/11/kazhdyy-raz-oschuschenie-chto-tebya-poimeli-kazhdye-vybory\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">surprised to discover</a> that they had been registered for remote voting without their knowledge.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19242,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data","caption":"The first step in the instructions for uploading applications to participate in electronic voting in the GAS Vybory 2.0 system","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7efea9223bf48849cc13ad32c19389c-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7efea9223bf48849cc13ad32c19389c-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7efea9223bf48849cc13ad32c19389c-original.png","real_width_1x":1174,"real_width_2x":1174,"real_height_1x":747,"real_height_2x":747},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7efea9223bf48849cc13ad32c19389c-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7efea9223bf48849cc13ad32c19389c-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7efea9223bf48849cc13ad32c19389c-original.png","real_width_1x":1174,"real_width_2x":1174,"real_height_1x":747,"real_height_2x":747},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7efea9223bf48849cc13ad32c19389c-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7efea9223bf48849cc13ad32c19389c-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7efea9223bf48849cc13ad32c19389c-original.png","real_width_1x":1174,"real_width_2x":1174,"real_height_1x":747,"real_height_2x":747},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7efea9223bf48849cc13ad32c19389c-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7efea9223bf48849cc13ad32c19389c-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7efea9223bf48849cc13ad32c19389c-original.png","real_width_1x":1174,"real_width_2x":1174,"real_height_1x":747,"real_height_2x":747},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7efea9223bf48849cc13ad32c19389c-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7efea9223bf48849cc13ad32c19389c-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7efea9223bf48849cc13ad32c19389c-original.png","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":263,"real_height_2x":527},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7efea9223bf48849cc13ad32c19389c-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7efea9223bf48849cc13ad32c19389c-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7efea9223bf48849cc13ad32c19389c-original.png","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":263,"real_height_2x":527}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":{"id":19243,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data","caption":"At the second step, a system administrator can upload a CSV file containing voter data, after which a verification against the RUIP database will automatically begin","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0433c93030424bf296110c100b60e823-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0433c93030424bf296110c100b60e823-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0433c93030424bf296110c100b60e823-original.png","real_width_1x":1159,"real_width_2x":1159,"real_height_1x":896,"real_height_2x":896},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0433c93030424bf296110c100b60e823-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0433c93030424bf296110c100b60e823-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0433c93030424bf296110c100b60e823-original.png","real_width_1x":1159,"real_width_2x":1159,"real_height_1x":896,"real_height_2x":896},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0433c93030424bf296110c100b60e823-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0433c93030424bf296110c100b60e823-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0433c93030424bf296110c100b60e823-original.png","real_width_1x":1159,"real_width_2x":1159,"real_height_1x":896,"real_height_2x":896},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0433c93030424bf296110c100b60e823-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0433c93030424bf296110c100b60e823-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0433c93030424bf296110c100b60e823-original.png","real_width_1x":1159,"real_width_2x":1159,"real_height_1x":896,"real_height_2x":896},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0433c93030424bf296110c100b60e823-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0433c93030424bf296110c100b60e823-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0433c93030424bf296110c100b60e823-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":320,"real_height_2x":641},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0433c93030424bf296110c100b60e823-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0433c93030424bf296110c100b60e823-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0433c93030424bf296110c100b60e823-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":320,"real_height_2x":641}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"After the application file is uploaded, the system checks its structure, its compliance with reference databases, and whether the voters are present in the RUIP database. However, the origin of the file is not tracked: a user with privileged access can manipulate the voter list — according to the documentation available to us, no digital signature is required to upload it.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Vulnerability #3: remote electronic voting</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The remote electronic voting (DEG) system is a “black box,” and observers can only evaluate its actual operation based on official statements from the developers. Two remote electronic voting systems will be used in the 2026 elections: the federal system and the Moscow system.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Tsifrotek is not involved in the development of either the federal or the Moscow remote electronic voting systems. The GAS Vybory 2.0 system receives votes that have already been processed from the blockchain. However, in their documentation Tsifrotek clarifies that the term “blockchain” in this case does not correspond to its generally accepted meaning, and they cannot guarantee that the remote electronic voting system operates exactly the way it was explained to them.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19244,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data","caption":"The remote voting system operation diagram from Tsifrotek’s documentation","isNarrow":true,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ef0ab9f08e5441e483cf569733306099-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ef0ab9f08e5441e483cf569733306099-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ef0ab9f08e5441e483cf569733306099-original.png","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1441,"real_height_2x":1441},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ef0ab9f08e5441e483cf569733306099-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ef0ab9f08e5441e483cf569733306099-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ef0ab9f08e5441e483cf569733306099-original.png","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1441,"real_height_2x":1441},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ef0ab9f08e5441e483cf569733306099-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ef0ab9f08e5441e483cf569733306099-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ef0ab9f08e5441e483cf569733306099-original.png","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1441,"real_height_2x":1441},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ef0ab9f08e5441e483cf569733306099-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ef0ab9f08e5441e483cf569733306099-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ef0ab9f08e5441e483cf569733306099-original.png","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1441,"real_height_2x":1441},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ef0ab9f08e5441e483cf569733306099-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ef0ab9f08e5441e483cf569733306099-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ef0ab9f08e5441e483cf569733306099-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":554,"real_height_2x":1108},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ef0ab9f08e5441e483cf569733306099-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ef0ab9f08e5441e483cf569733306099-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ef0ab9f08e5441e483cf569733306099-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":554,"real_height_2x":1108}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Results from the remote voting system are exported as a ZIP archive containing XML files, which must correspond to files with electronic signatures. In this case, altering the results in the XML file is supposed to trigger an error during verification. The archives containing the results are then uploaded to the GAS Vybory 2.0 system: the federal one to the MV DEG module; the Moscow one, to the MV Moscow module.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to the DEG MV documentation, when a result archive is imported, a verification process starts: each XML file must have a corresponding signature file. It is unknown whether this process actually works as described.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19245,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data","caption":"Diagram of the DEG system’s interaction with the GAS Vybory 2.0 platform","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17558b7d4a5c4cb9a3404affe16c6659-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17558b7d4a5c4cb9a3404affe16c6659-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17558b7d4a5c4cb9a3404affe16c6659-original.png","real_width_1x":1428,"real_width_2x":1428,"real_height_1x":794,"real_height_2x":794},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17558b7d4a5c4cb9a3404affe16c6659-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17558b7d4a5c4cb9a3404affe16c6659-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17558b7d4a5c4cb9a3404affe16c6659-original.png","real_width_1x":1428,"real_width_2x":1428,"real_height_1x":794,"real_height_2x":794},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17558b7d4a5c4cb9a3404affe16c6659-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17558b7d4a5c4cb9a3404affe16c6659-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17558b7d4a5c4cb9a3404affe16c6659-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":1428,"real_height_1x":667,"real_height_2x":794},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17558b7d4a5c4cb9a3404affe16c6659-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17558b7d4a5c4cb9a3404affe16c6659-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17558b7d4a5c4cb9a3404affe16c6659-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":1428,"real_height_1x":667,"real_height_2x":794},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17558b7d4a5c4cb9a3404affe16c6659-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17558b7d4a5c4cb9a3404affe16c6659-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17558b7d4a5c4cb9a3404affe16c6659-original.png","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":230,"real_height_2x":461},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17558b7d4a5c4cb9a3404affe16c6659-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17558b7d4a5c4cb9a3404affe16c6659-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/17558b7d4a5c4cb9a3404affe16c6659-original.png","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":230,"real_height_2x":461}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"However, the code for the MV Moscow component, where electronic voting results from the capital are uploaded, contains a significant vulnerability. The system locates the signature files but does not verify them, allowing files containing results to pass through even if they are not confirmed by an electronic signature. When the remote voting results reach the protocol, the system does not record the fact that the original results were not backed by an electronic signature.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19246,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data","caption":"The developers of the system themselves ironize the remove voting system integrity","isNarrow":true,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2dd93c9a3924d119bf102085f99f103-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2dd93c9a3924d119bf102085f99f103-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2dd93c9a3924d119bf102085f99f103-original.png","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1327,"real_height_2x":1327},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2dd93c9a3924d119bf102085f99f103-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2dd93c9a3924d119bf102085f99f103-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2dd93c9a3924d119bf102085f99f103-original.png","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1327,"real_height_2x":1327},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2dd93c9a3924d119bf102085f99f103-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2dd93c9a3924d119bf102085f99f103-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2dd93c9a3924d119bf102085f99f103-original.png","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1327,"real_height_2x":1327},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2dd93c9a3924d119bf102085f99f103-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2dd93c9a3924d119bf102085f99f103-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2dd93c9a3924d119bf102085f99f103-original.png","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1327,"real_height_2x":1327},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2dd93c9a3924d119bf102085f99f103-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2dd93c9a3924d119bf102085f99f103-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2dd93c9a3924d119bf102085f99f103-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":510,"real_height_2x":1020},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2dd93c9a3924d119bf102085f99f103-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2dd93c9a3924d119bf102085f99f103-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f2dd93c9a3924d119bf102085f99f103-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":510,"real_height_2x":1020}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"“There’s no point in talking about vulnerabilities, because this software doesn’t record votes, it processes the finalized results, and those can be altered at every step: files can be manually edited, and changes can be made in the database after they’re imported,” a technical specialist who analyzed the MV Moscow module code told IStories. In his opinion, for the system to be trustworthy, its components must be independent: “If all of this is happening within Rostelecom, will Rostelecom argue with itself about fraud?”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19225,"data":{"block":"<p>In Russia, a random draw is conducted manually to determine the order of parties on the ballot: ahead of the 2026 elections, party representatives drew lots (<a href=\"https://www.vedomosti.ru/politics/articles/2026/08/06/1219147-kak-partii-raspredelilis-v-byulletene-na-viborah\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">balls</a> or <a href=\"https://serp.mk.ru/social/2026/08/20/mosoblizbirkom-opublikoval-itogovyy-poryadok-partiy-v-byulletene-na-vyborakh.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">envelopes</a>). In the State Duma elections, “United Russia” secured the top spot on the ballot.</p><p><br/></p><p><a href=\"https://www.facebook.com/lyubarev/posts/pfbid02WSu65qVM3fyXXervuDduh8nH8GF2gfZMWq813n8efTJfgVRUXiLmrarWrnSdicmMl?locale=ru_RU\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">According </a>to Arkady Lyubarev, an election expert, the ruling party has been lucky enough to secure the first place on the ballot in one out of every three regional campaigns since 2006. Some electoral researchers believe that appearing first on the ballot gives a candidate<a href=\"https://electionlab.mit.edu/research/ballot-order-effects\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> an additional advantage</a>.</p><p><br/></p><p>This time the statistical anomaly happened as well: in 21 out of 39 cases in regional legislative elections, the ruling party was <a href=\"https://t.me/yabloko_press/3585\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">listed </a>first on the ballot. United Russia Senator Sergei Perminov attributed this phenomena to “the will of political <a href=\"https://www.vedomosti.ru/politics/articles/2026/08/13/1220772-v-er-obyasnili-volei-politicheskoi-metafiziki-pervie-mesta-partii\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">metaphysics </a>itself.”</p><p><br/></p><p>Although Ella Pamfilova publicly <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/russia/1107587\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">claims </a>that it is too early to start determining the ballot ordering through a digital draw, because, in her words, “Russians are distrustful,” this option is already built into the GAS Vybory 2.0 system. According to the documentation for PAIP (the election process automation subsystem), election commissions will be able to determine the ballot order using a computerized lottery.</p><p><br/></p><p>At the same time, in addition to this lottery, election commissions <a href=\"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/documents/19f41dd23aee4e21a7185d73669f62f3.png\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">will </a>also be <a href=\"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/documents/60041f029bc84e4f95c47d149cc8d45d.png\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">able </a>to determine the ballot order <a href=\"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/documents/eeffb5cc503b4ad19b35319821fd9226.png\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">manually</a>. The document does not specify in which cases an election commission may resort to it, and doesn’t state what purpose this functionality serves in detail. This method of allocating positions <a href=\"https://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_37119/0f580d48db85266b8d762d3c6124ba0d7157907d/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">contradicts</a> Russian legislation.</p>","header":"Ballot ordering: another system’s feature","content":[{"insert":"In Russia, a random draw is conducted manually to determine the order of parties on the ballot: ahead of the 2026 elections, party representatives drew lots ("},{"insert":"balls","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.vedomosti.ru/politics/articles/2026/08/06/1219147-kak-partii-raspredelilis-v-byulletene-na-viborah","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" or "},{"insert":"envelopes","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://serp.mk.ru/social/2026/08/20/mosoblizbirkom-opublikoval-itogovyy-poryadok-partiy-v-byulletene-na-vyborakh.html","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"). In the State Duma elections, “United Russia” secured the top spot on the ballot.\n\n"},{"insert":"According ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.facebook.com/lyubarev/posts/pfbid02WSu65qVM3fyXXervuDduh8nH8GF2gfZMWq813n8efTJfgVRUXiLmrarWrnSdicmMl?locale=ru_RU","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"to Arkady Lyubarev, an election expert, the ruling party has been lucky enough to secure the first place on the ballot in one out of every three regional campaigns since 2006. Some electoral researchers believe that appearing first on the ballot gives a candidate"},{"insert":" an additional advantage","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://electionlab.mit.edu/research/ballot-order-effects","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":".\n\nThis time the statistical anomaly happened as well: in 21 out of 39 cases in regional legislative elections, the ruling party was "},{"insert":"listed ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://t.me/yabloko_press/3585","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"first on the ballot. United Russia Senator Sergei Perminov attributed this phenomena to “the will of political "},{"insert":"metaphysics ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.vedomosti.ru/politics/articles/2026/08/13/1220772-v-er-obyasnili-volei-politicheskoi-metafiziki-pervie-mesta-partii","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"itself.”\n\nAlthough Ella Pamfilova publicly "},{"insert":"claims ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.interfax.ru/russia/1107587","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"that it is too early to start determining the ballot ordering through a digital draw, because, in her words, “Russians are distrustful,” this option is already built into the GAS Vybory 2.0 system. According to the documentation for PAIP (the election process automation subsystem), election commissions will be able to determine the ballot order using a computerized lottery.\n\nAt the same time, in addition to this lottery, election commissions "},{"insert":"will ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/documents/19f41dd23aee4e21a7185d73669f62f3.png","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"also be "},{"insert":"able ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/documents/60041f029bc84e4f95c47d149cc8d45d.png","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"to determine the ballot order "},{"insert":"manually","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/documents/eeffb5cc503b4ad19b35319821fd9226.png","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":". The document does not specify in which cases an election commission may resort to it, and doesn’t state what purpose this functionality serves in detail. This method of allocating positions "},{"insert":"contradicts","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_37119/0f580d48db85266b8d762d3c6124ba0d7157907d/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" Russian legislation.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"Is the updated GAS Vybory 2.0 system trustworthy? Developers weigh in","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The people who created the new version of Russia’s election platform have mixed views on whether its results can be trusted.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Some sincerely believe in the project: “I have a great deal of confidence in the new system. We’re building a fair tool that lets people vote however they want,” says one of our interviewees. “As for what happens outside the system, we can only speculate. I believe the system calculates [the election results] correctly. Then we look at the results, and everyone starts shouting, ‘It’s fraud!’ For me, this isn’t fraud, but the sad truth, unfortunately: apparently, [the election results] reflect the will of the people.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“I still think that the fairer results wouldn’t affect anything. It’s just that, apparently, the number isn’t actually 80, but rather 60 [percent of those voting for ‘United Russia’],” he adds. “I did what I could to make an impact on my end. But from here on, it all depends on the people.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Another Tsifrotek source interviewed by IStories disagrees: “You can rig or steal the votes in any system you have access to. As far as I’m concerned, the outcome is clear to everyone — we know who will win the election and who won’t.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At the training sessions where developers tested the system, the outcome was also known in advance — the majority of seats went to the “United Russia” party.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":10629,"header":"Unsafe Connections: the Classified Files Archive and the Philosophy Shared by an FSB Surveillance Project Ex-Developer","_path":"/en/stories/2026/09/03/unsafe-connections/","lead":"Ivan Kirsanov had been working on a surveillance system project for the Russian Federal Security Service. Then he left the country taking a copy of its internal documents archive. Why did he do it and what can we learn from the files?","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9c1c7cfce0ed4389bf3f2d204f41a5bc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Picture: IStories","created_at_date":"2026-09-03","created_at_date_time":"2026-09-02T10:48:00.408Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":23,"first_name":"Полина","last_name":"Ужвак","first_name_en":"Polina","last_name_en":"Uzhvak","is_public":true,"_path":"polina-uzhvak","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Автор дата-отдела","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":null,"ordering":1},{"id":58,"first_name":"Рина","last_name":"Николаева","first_name_en":"Rina","last_name_en":"Nikolaeva","is_public":true,"_path":"rina-nikolaeva","avatar":[],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":2}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[{"id":31,"first_name":"Катя","last_name":"Бонч-Осмоловская","first_name_en":"Katya","last_name_en":"Bonch-Osmolovskaya","is_public":true,"_path":"katya-bonch-osmolovskaya","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.jpeg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.jpeg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.jpeg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.jpeg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редакторка дата-отдела","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":null,"ordering":1}],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"“Two years earlier, I’d been attending protests, getting beaten up, and being interrogated — and now there I was, working for a company that develops software for the very same system that had subjected me to violence and repression. It’s a bit of a disconnect, but at the time I just didn’t think about it.”\n\nThis is how Ivan Kirsanov, a 24-year-old programmer, describes starting his former job at one of the companies within the Citadel holding group, the main manufacturer of the surveillance system for the FSB, Russia's Federal Security Service. Kirsanov has since quit and now works as a shepherd on a farm in France earning four euros an hour.\n\nIvan left Russia in 2025, taking with him a technical documentation archive related to SORM, a system of interception interfaces used for surveillance in Russia, produced by Citadel. IStories spoke with Ivan and examined the archive.\n\n\n\nThe traitor\nIvan grew up in the small town of Zelenodolsk, not far from Kazan, Russia. He is the youngest of three children. The Kirsanovs lived modestly: the father worked as a driver, and the mother as a cleaner at a factory.\n\n“I wouldn’t even ask them to buy me anything because I knew it was impossible. For example, I wanted a new computer because I played games and did some programming. Finally it was my sister who bought it for me, not my parents.”\n\nIvan began learning the fundamentals of programming at the age of 11. He would watch YouTube tutorials on how to write cheat codes for Minecraft, and YouTube was where he came across Alexei Navalny’s videos. Kirsanov began to “delve into the subject and take interest in politics.” In one of Navalny’s livestreams, the late politician had mentioned that Russian schoolchildren weren’t given textbooks at schools, and this, according to Ivan, “hit the nail on the head.” His school had the exact same problem.\nKirsanov then wrote a complaint to the Ministry of Education, which was forwarded to the school. The administration did not appreciate the initiative. “They started telling me that I’d let the whole school down, that I was a traitor, and that the school would face major problems and trouble because of me. My parents were asked to meet with the principal, even though I was doing well in school as I valued my reputation,” Ivan recalls. His relationship with the teachers deteriorated, but they did provide him with textbooks after all.\n\nKirsanov realized that taking action worked, so he kept doing what he saw as working. A complaint to the housing and utilities department helped restore hot water in his friend’s home, and a complaint about the summer obligatory work program at school  helped escape the obligation to shovel out basements. In ninth grade, Kirsanov and a friend attended their first protest in Kazan — the “Voters’ Strike” against Navalny being banned from the 2018 presidential election. Kirsanov’s parents did not support their son’s political activism: they threatened to take away his pocket money and cut off his internet access.\n\nAfter ninth grade, Ivan was told that his family couldn’t afford his university education. Following his parents’ advice, he enrolled in a college in his hometown to study shipbuilding, a discipline that didn’t interest him at all. In his third year in 2021, Kirsanov attended another Navalny support rally when the politician was arrested upon his return to Russia .\n\nThis time, Ivan was detained and fined. The administration of his college threatened to expel him. “You screwed me and the principal over, do you understand? I don’t need students causing problems! We just need to get rid of you,” the academic dean would scold him.\nKirsanov was not expelled from college, but the consequences of the protest did not end with that. The then student began receiving the prosecutor’s warnings on the “unacceptability of participating in unauthorized protests,” and in the fall of 2021, the Center for Combating Extremism officials visited the college. Ivan was called in for a “chat” and asked about his views on Navalny. By that point, Navalny's Anti-Corruption Foundation (FBK) had already been added to the Russian extremist and terrorist organizations list, and some protesters had received actual prison sentences.\n\n“After that interrogation, I finally realized that if I kept doing something like that, they would simply ruin my life… I was very scared. I knew I would have to keep quiet because I wanted to protect myself.”\n\nThe way out of poverty\nActing on a friend’s advice, Ivan enrolled in School 21, a Russian franchise of École 42, a French programming school. The curriculum at School 21 differed from typical Russian education. The students are taught for free, and there are no lectures or teachers — they learn the material on their own, submit their projects and grade each other’s work.\n\n“The school changed me. In college, I was surrounded by very strange people who, basically, didn’t really need anything in life. I felt very lonely; there was no one to have interesting discussions with. But at School 21, there were enthusiastic people of different professions and ages. It was as if I had stepped into some different world.”\n\nIvan devoted all his free time to programming, and six months later he landed an internship at Sber, Russia’s biggest bank. “It was just amazing for me,” the developer recalls. “At 19, I was working as a programmer at one of Russia’s top companies. At the time, I was making about 50,000 rubles ($650 approx. as of 2021) a month. That was more than both my parents would earn combined.” At first, he didn’t even spend his salary: he just saved it and “felt better.”\nThree months later, Kirsanov was offered a full-time position. His salary nearly doubled, but it was getting harder and harder to keep up: there were a lot of uncompleted college tasks, and his professors were threatening to not let him take his exams and to expel him.\n\n“My life was falling apart. If I’d been expelled from college, I would have been drafted into the army. If I’d been drafted, I would have lost my spot at ‘School 21’ and my job at Sber, which was my only way out of poverty.”\n\nIvan felt alone: his parents weren’t supportive of him, and his relationship with his girlfriend fell apart. He was diagnosed with an adjustment disorder and prescribed antidepressants. In June 2022, he finally managed to graduate. His problems with the college were over, but so was his student military service deferment. To hide from the military enlistment office, Ivan moved to Moscow.\n\nA life the way it should be lived\nKirsanov began building a “richer life” in Moscow. He rented an apartment, took up horse riding lessons, bought a motorcycle and rode it across Russia; for the first time in his life, he flew to Sochi  on vacation.\n\n“I saw the sea and realized that besides the life I’d been living — constant work, constant studying, a pretty low-income life — there’s another kind of life out there. And that’s the norm; that’s the way it should be lived by everyone.”\n\nHis friends from School 21 would find better jobs and start getting bigger paychecks. Ivan had got promoted several times, but he wouldn’t catch up with his friends. In the summer of 2023, he quit a position where he was earning three times his starting salary — which, just a year earlier, had seemed “something out of a fantasy” to him.\n\nKirsanov found a higher-paying position within three weeks. MFI-Soft, a company based in the Russian city of Nizhny Novgorod, promised shared workspaces equipped with kitchens and breakfasts provided, a company laptop, and the net salary of 200 thousand rubles ($2.200 approx. as of 2023). Neither the job responsibilities nor the company’s line of business were of decisive importance to Ivan at the time. During the interview, he was told that the job was related to the Yarovaya Law Package compliance, the infamous regulation of continuous data storage for the purposes of Russian state security and law enforcement agencies. ‎\n“At that moment, I just nodded and said, ‘Wow, that sounds great.’ But I didn’t actually care. I’d never even heard of that company.”\n\nThe FSB’s poor quality code\nThe company unknown to Ivan had been developing technical tools for the SORM surveillance system practically since Kirsanov’s birth. The enterprise had been called MERA back then. In 2003, a division dedicated to developing the SORM solutions was created within the company. That division later became a separate company, MFI-Soft.\n\n\n\nIn 2016, the Russian telecom industry was taken aback by the Yarovaya Law Package which required Russian internet providers and mobile network operators to store (and share with the FSB) massive amounts of their customers’ traffic: their correspondence, phone calls recordings, and the photo, video, and audio files they share. From the telecom companies it required spendings several times greater than their annual revenue.\n\nSix months earlier, major changes had begun in the SORM systems development market, as those were private companies responsible for the software. Anton Cherepennikov, an entrepreneur, the Virtus.pro esports club owner, and billionaire Alisher Usmanov’s business partner (Usmanov himself is a close associate of Putin) founded the Citadel group and began acquiring firms supplying equipment and software for the SORM system. The 2017 acquisition of Nizhny Novgorod-based MFI-Soft made Citadel the largest player in the SORM market . A year later, the group owned five of the seven companies whose services the Russian Ministry of Communications had recommended to the internet providers and mobile operators to be able to comply with the Yarovaya Law, accounting for up to 80% of the market.\n\n“We certainly stood out from our competitors in the SORM market—at that time, they were mainly former state scientific research institute employees or state security services officers,” Cherepennikov said in 2019.\nIvan Kirsanov had to work on improving a product of one of such companies, Nika-X, which became part of Citadel. In correspondence with his colleagues, he discussed the poor quality code written by “the developers from the FSB”. “They’re well-trained, but they lack real-world experience because they can’t work at normal commercial companies,” a senior colleague explained to Ivan. When the war had begun, the “FSB developers” had resigned. As Ivan assumed, they were “needed by the state in a related field.”\n\nIn July 2023, when Ivan was already working at MFI-Soft, all the holding company’s SORM-related subsidiaries were consolidated under the Citadel brand.\n\nFrom the user to the FSB\nIn the summer of 2023, Kirsanov joined the MFI-Soft department that handled internet traffic as a senior software engineer. The documents archive he shared with us shows in detail what happens to the internet traffic data on its way from the user to FSB employees.\n\nWe examined these documents with the help of Leonid Yuldashev, a cybersecurity expert and project coordinator at eQualitie. What can FSB officers learn about Russians’ online activities using SORM, according to the documents, and how does the system identify services and messaging apps?\n\n\n\n\nThe SORM equipment is installed within the operator’s network to intercept the complete copy of all the users’ traffic. This is a massive volume of data. To extract useful information from the raw data, the traffic must be parsed. SORM has a special component for this, called the extractor. This is what Ivan was working with.\n\nThe traffic is parsed layer by layer. One of the first stages is accounting, during which SORM links the traffic to a specific subscriber. In a mobile network, this is done via the phone number and the user’s IMSI; for the wired access, it is done via the login used for authentication with the provider. Therefore, all online activity via home Wi-Fi is linked to the person who signed the contract via the subscriber identification.\n\nNext, the extractor monitors the traffic flow and attempts to identify the nature of the connection — whether it was a message app call, a file transfer, an email, or a website access. In the documentation, this process is called “tasting.” The type of connection can be recognized by:\n\n signatures, patterns or distinctive features distinguishing one type of traffic from another;\n server name identification (SNI);\n indirect statistical characteristics.\n\nFinally, the content of the traffic is analyzed. Here, the system’s capabilities are severely limited. Modern services encrypt traffic, and, according to Kirsanov, the developers at MFI-Soft and Citadel were not tasked with decrypting it. The message text, the conversation audio, and the transferred files remain inaccessible for decryption.\nBut even encrypted traffic leaves some metadata traces. The metadata can reveal when a person logged on, which websites they visited, how much data they transmitted, how long their messenger call lasted, and when it began and ended. By analyzing metadata, one can discover one's interests, and by comparing the call start and end times of different users, one can determine who is communicating with whom. It is unclear from the documents whether the FSB engages in such traffic analysis.\n\nThe FSB officers access SORM through control consoles. This is how they filter out the information they need from all the traffic. A SORM operator can set various parameters for intercepting the traffic: the IP address, the phone number, the email address, or the server domain name. E.g., it is possible to collect all traffic identified by the system as “Telegram,” or to monitor everyone who visits the FBK website, or the “Freedom of Russia” Legion website. ‎\nTechnically, it is possible to filter traffic by a specific word mentioned. In the training presentation example, the word “blow up” appears among the filtering criteria. However, according to a former SORM developer, full-text search was rarely used — neither in the test environment nor with the real data — as it consumed a lot of resources and slowed down the performance. Moreover, there is very little unencrypted traffic data for the full-text search to process.\nThe analyzed traffic which did not reach the control panels based on the selection criteria is not lost. Statistics on all connections and the available content of messages are sent to the Yanvar data storage system, where they are stored for six months to three years, depending on the type of data according to the Yarovaya Law. During this entire period, the government security and intelligence agencies can access the stored traffic, but it is unknown whether they do so or to what extent.\n\nTelegram, Signal or Google: How well can SORM see encrypted services data?\nTo extract the valuable information from traffic more effectively, the developers use decoders: software modules designed for a specific service or app. These decoders do not decrypt the traffic, but they allow the developers to identify the services and collect more detailed metadata.\n\nSuch decoders exist for many messaging apps — for example, Telegram or WhatsApp — as well as for traffic anonymization services (Tor or various VPN services) and for certain cryptocurrencies. If no decoder has been written for a particular service, information will still be collected. But in that case, some data may be lost, and the traffic will be marked as unrecognized, Kirsanov explains.\n\nUpon reviewing the decoder documentation, we figured out how well SORM can “see” the data in some popular messaging apps.\n\nThere are decoders for Telegram, WhatsApp, IMO, Zoom, Viber, WeChat, and Discord. SORM detects the mere fact that these services are being used and collects call metadata, but it does not know what you are discussing.\n\nThere is no decoder for Signal. Based on the available documents, it is the most inaccessible service to SORM out of the entire list: it's even questionable if the system can reliably detect its use. Apparently, the system views its traffic as a standard encrypted connection without specifically identifying it as Signal.\n\nOutdated, unencrypted services such as ICQ, Mail.ru Agent, or Jabber are the most transparent to SORM. The system can even access the message content. According to cybersecurity expert Leonid Yuldashev, activists occasionally come up with the idea to revive such services and use them for secure communication. The documentation we reviewed shows the opposite.\n\nSearch queries and results on Google are invisible to SORM. However, the system knows that a user accessed the google.com domain.\n\nThere are no decoders for Google Meet and Google Drive. All of these services appear as Google traffic, which SORM identified by domain names in secure connections. The conversations, files, and search queries themselves remain inaccessible. The system can likely distinguish a Meet video call from a file upload to Drive, but only based on indirect characteristics: the domain and the type of data flow (a long two-way exchange looks different from a one-way file upload).\n\nSORM can detect some VPNs being used. There are decoders for the classic OpenVPN protocol — which most such services use — and the outdated PPTP protocol. However, modern protocols like WireGuard or VLESS are not mentioned in the documentation. The services designed to bypass Russian restrictions are currently switching to these very protocols. VLESS disguises itself as regular HTTPS, so to the system it most likely appears as some ordinary encrypted web traffic. It is unclear from the documents how WireGuard is perceived by the system.\n\nThe data on Russians’ online activities that SORM is capable of collecting is of little interest, since a significant portion of the traffic is encrypted, Yuldashev concludes. But with messaging apps blocked, users rely on VPNs, and if a VPN doesn’t work and there’s no access to messaging apps, people switch to phone calls and text messages, which are already transparent to SORM, the expert points out.\n\nMany Russian services, including Yandex and VK, also use encryption. The documents reviewed contain no information suggesting that SORM can decrypt or analyze Russian encrypted services in greater detail than foreign ones. This is also confirmed by Kirsanov as a former developer of the system. But this does not mean that communicating via such messaging apps is safe: SORM is far from being the only weapon in the security forces’ arsenal.\n\n\n\nThe tasks from FSB\nThe main SORM users are the FSB officers. From them, developers get tasks to make improvements and fix bugs in the system, yet their own security requirements prevent these bugs from being fixed promptly.\nWithout the full access to detailed error logs, the developers cannot immediately understand the cause of the problem and spend significantly more time resolving it, Kirsanov explained.\n\nThe security service was not very quick to adopt the improvements from the developers. “The FSB still has not tested them or put them into operation. They don’t have time,” one of Ivan’s colleagues described the status of the settings that had been submitted for approval a year before.\n\nNot only did the FSB give the developers tasks, but expressions of gratitude as well. In the first half of 2024, Citadel completed the system implementation in the newly-annexed regions of Kherson, Zaporizhzhia, Donetsk, and Luhansk. Those responsible for the project received a letter of appreciation from the FSB, and all Citadel employees were notified of this via corporate email, Kirsanov explained.\n\nOther government agencies do not have direct access to the system. The Ministry of Internal Affairs officers must submit reasoned requests if they want to place someone under wiretap, Andrei Zakharov shares in his book, Russian Cyberpunk.\n\nHowever, regular Citadel employees do have access to the data. Ivan recalls intercepting the internet traffic of the Tele-2 operator in Nizhny Novgorod to complete one of his tasks. “I could analyze it, or do whatever I wanted with it. Without any special authorization, I could effectively monitor real people. In reality, every developer at the company has been able to do so,” says the former SORM developer.\n\n\n“We make the world a better place.” What SORM developers think about their work\nThe authorities state that SORM’s purpose is to help solve crimes, track down criminals, and prevent terrorist attacks. Some developers see this as the end goal of their work as well.\n\n“What do you like about your work?”\n“The creative approach. We make the world a better place by using cutting-edge development and testing tools.”\n“Have you ever considered that SORM could be used for political persecution, not just to fight crime?”\n“There are people who manufacture weapons; they provide the technical means to physically eliminate both enemy forces and civilians. I can’t be held responsible for who pulls the trigger of the gun I made. I make guns. I like it.”\n\nThis is how Alexei (the name has been changed) — a current Citadel employee who spoke with IStories on condition of anonymity — describes his work. Another employee’s position might be understood from his messages in public Telegram chats.\n\n“The FSB always acts strictly in accordance with the law. <…> It is technically impossible to incorporate selection criteria into the operational and investigative system without a valid court order number. Therefore, when it comes to organizing illegal surveillance, the FSB’s technical capabilities (and the FSB itself) are absolutely no help at all.😉”\nHowever, in the video depicting the control panel in action, there is no field for a court order number to be seen. Kirsanov has also confirmed that he had never heard of such a requirement.\n\nHe, too, quickly came to embrace the same idea of his work’s mission. “At first, I went there for the money, but then I started to capture the overall spirit: we do something useful, we fight crime by writing great software which is used to catch murderers and terrorists,” the developer recalls.\n\nSix months after starting the job, Kirsanov even suggested creating a regular motivational newsletter with the information about crimes solved using SORM to an HR department colleague. She told him that this was classified information and the company didn’t have access to it.\n\nThe extent to which SORM is actually useful in criminal investigations is not publicly known. As far back as 2020, researchers from a department of criminology in Perm noted that in all the years SORM had been in operation, there had not been a single official statement regarding its use in solving prominent crimes. Back then, the researchers recommended introducing a formal report system on the efficiency of SORM by law.\n\nAfter the March 2024 terrorist attack at Crocus City Hall, when terrorists killed 147 people, it became completely clear that SORM was not performing the way it was supposed to, The Bell reported. After the attack — which SORM failed to prevent in any way —the control over the internet surveillance systems shifted from the FSB’s Scientific and Technical Service to its Second Service, which is known for persecuting the opposition and Alexei Navalny's attempted poisoning.\n\nIStories reported more on the way the FSB is attempting to achieve total surveillance over the citizens with the help of newly-introduced big fines.\n\n\n\nFrom Paris to Mariupol\nAt Citadel, Kirsanov would perform routine and not-so-exciting tasks related to product improvements, working remotely and seeing his colleagues only during conference calls, so he was unable to find friends among them. He decided to seek new experiences outside of his work and the country.\n\nIn the first year of the war, the French École 42 ended its partnership with Sber. Students could either transfer to the French branch or remain at the Russian School 21. Ivan chose the French school, was granted a French student visa, and went to Europe by bus in the fall of 2023, a month after starting work on SORM. The upcoming autumn military draft was a significant factor in his decision to leave.\nIvan would switch his IP addresses to Moscow-based ones and develop software for the Russian intelligence right from his apartment nearby Notre Dame, and at night he would walk over to the Eiffel Tower. His first emigrant experience turned out to be far from easy. “I was under constant stress because I was working illegally from abroad; I knew it could be discovered, and I would be fired. I had to take antidepressants and couldn’t sleep properly,” the developer recalls. Neither his family nor his colleagues knew he had left. A month later, he had to return as he was invited to a work conference.\n\nA few months after returning from Paris, Kirsanov set out on a new journey. This time, he headed to Mariupol, a Ukrainian city which had been heavily destroyed and then occupied by Russian troops in 2022. “I wanted to see the war. I could monitor it online, but I wanted to see it with my own eyes, to experience what it’s like to live in a state of war,” he explains, describing his choice of destination.\n\nKirsanov got scared by the sight of the ruined city and the completely destroyed Azovstal plant , along with the local residents’ accounts of how they collected rainwater for their children to drink and sheltered from the bombing in their homes. He left the occupied territories that very same day, but even after the trip, he would still avoid thinking about the war. “I understood that something terrible was happening, but I didn’t support either side. I tried not to think about it and to keep all those thoughts locked away in some separate box so I wouldn’t have to face them.”‎ ‎ ‎ \nResignation\nIn March 2024, Ivan received a letter from the European Court of Human Rights. The ECHR ruled Russia violated the European Convention on Human Rights when Ivan was detained at a January 2021 rally along with the other protesters, and he was granted a EUR 4.000 compensation. However, neither Ivan nor the other applicants received the money because by March 2024 Russia had been outside the jurisdiction of the ECHR for two years.\nNine years earlier, in December 2015, the ECHR had ruled that the SORM usage legislation in Russia was violating the European Convention on Human Rights and the right to respect for private life covered by it. Russian regulations did not provide “adequate and effective guarantees against arbitrariness and the risk of abuse which is inherent in any system of secret surveillance,” the court’s ruling stated.\n\nIvan didn’t know about the ECHR ruling on SORM; he was 13 at the time. But the ruling regarding his own detention made the developer think. “I remember I wanted to tell my friends about it, but I didn’t know how to approach it. On the one hand, I basically work within this system; on the other, a ruling like this emerges. I never told anyone,” he recalls. ‎\n\nKirsanov resigned a few months later, but the reason was the same as the one that had originally brought him to the company: he asked for a promotion and was told to wait.\n\n“They want loyal employees. They were counting on people who would work quietly for eight years and never ask for anything, never seek promotions, and just be a cog in the machine,” Kirsanov describes. An example he gives is his former colleague who had been with the company for about 10 years, earning below market the entire time. Leaked data shows that in 2025, this employee was earning just over 130 000 rubles a month ($1.500 approx as of 2025), which is a third less than the salary Kirsanov started with.\n\nMoney wasn’t the only reason for his resignation. Kirsanov described he “didn’t grow much as a programmer” during his year at the company. He recalls suggesting implementing new solutions, from AI to optimizing error handling. But the management was not enthusiastic about these ideas. “It was a company with good working conditions and up-to-date processes, but there was no innovation as such,” Ivan describes Citadel.\n\nAfter being denied a promotion, he began looking for a new job and having online interviews right from the company’s office. Management noticed this fairly quickly. He was given a choice either to quit or to stay agreeing to never seek employment elsewhere and to exclusively work at Citadel. Ivan decided to quit.\n\n“If they had promoted me back then, if they had given me the opportunity to grow professionally, most likely I would keep working there, climbing up the career ladder and doing increasingly worse things. I would sincerely believe I do the right things, just as I believed back then.”\n\nAbduction\nAfter he quit, Ivan recalls, he quickly found a new job and began gradually reconnecting with old acquaintances, following independent media, watching the oppositioners' and military analysts' blogs on YouTube and donating to human rights activists — “getting back to himself after many years,” in his words.\n\nOn the first anniversary of the murder of Navalny, Kirsanov went out to a one-person protest. He knew that being detained could lead to problems with the military registration office, as he still didn’t have a military ID {a document proving a Russian citizen’s status regarding the obligatory military service}, but he felt it was important to him not to remain silent, he says.\n\n“By early 2025, the big picture had become absolutely clear, and I realized that something horrible was happening in Russia — a war going on, the growing isolation. I began to understand that I could no longer stay there.”\n\nWhile preparing to leave, Ivan listed his car up for sale. A meeting with a potential buyer was scheduled for April 24, 2025. Instead of the prospective buyers, two men in plain clothes approached him, showed their police IDs and forced Ivan into their car. Kirsanov figured he was being abducted. He opened the car door and unsuccessfully tried to get people’s attention, then decided to tear up his passport, recalling Belarusian opposition activist Maria Kolesnikova doing the same . But that didn’t stop his captors taking him to the police station in Khoroshevo-Mnevniki .\nIvan recalls throwing himself to the ground outside the police station, screaming for help, and threatening to kill himself. The police officers clearly weren’t expecting such a reaction. They began to mock him, then tried to persuade him to enter the station and call his parents or a lawyer, but called an ambulance after the suicide threat.\n\nThe doctors took Kirsanov to a mental hospital, where, after being questioned, he was released due to his friend agreeing to take responsibility for him. Ivan didn’t know why he had been abducted, but he suspected it might be related to his involvement in political activities over the past few months. Two days after the abduction, he flew out of Russia.\n\nThe departure and a new life\nKirsanov flew to Serbia and moved to France six months later, as his studies at École 42 enabled him to obtain a French residence permit. This time, he wasn’t facing the threat of getting fired; his savings allowed him to not work, and the threat of persecution vanished. “From the very first days, I began to feel the freedom that everyone should have,” recalls the former surveillance software developer.\n\nIvan enjoyed long walks, went on short trips within France and became a volunteer with the Get Lost human rights organization. He worked on the hotline, giving instructions on how to obtain a military ID and avoid conscription, providing emotional support and referring people to counselors in the more complex cases.\nThe life of an unemployed emigrant and his attempts to legalize his status quickly ate up all his savings. Since the fall of 2025, Ivan has been living “a minimalist lifestyle”: he stays in a trailer on a farm and herds goats and picks strawberries there. In his free time — of which he now has plenty — he plays video games, reads books and rides his bike.\n\nKirsanov plans to enroll in college and enjoy a “peaceful student life” without having to combine it with working. He wants to learn the language and integrate into French society. However, first he needs to resolve his documentation issues. His student residence permit is about to expire, and the French authorities rejected his asylum application: they did not believe he faced a risk of persecution in Russia. Currently, Kirsanov is getting ready to file an appeal.\n\nMeanwhile, the Russian Ministry of Internal Affairs has issued a statement explaining that in 2025 Ivan was “voluntarily” taken to the police station to be interrogated as a witness in a criminal case in accordance with Article 119 of Russia's Criminal Code, Threat of Murder or Infliction of Grave Injury Health. The case is being handled by the St. Petersburg Center for the Security of Persons Subject to State Protection.\n\nKirsanov suspects that the case may be linked to his messages to a former Federal Penitentiary Service (FSIN) employee, Igor Potapenko, who later became St. Petersburg’s vice governor for security. Ivan had learned that Potapenko had been involved in torturing Ukrainian prisoners of war, so he sent him private messages on VK requesting a comment on the allegations — according to him, he wanted to “generate public pressure.”\n\n“I don’t see any scenarios in which I would definitely return to Russia. Some people have told me I shouldn’t tell my story without hiding my identity. But I’m not the only one; the others remain silent and don’t speak out. Yes, I had no control over how these systems would be used. I created them with good intentions. Nevertheless, I became somewhat complicit in it all. I was also scared and afraid, but I think people need to know the truth.”","blocks":[{"data":"<em>“Two years earlier, I’d been attending protests, getting beaten up, and being interrogated — and now there I was, working for a company that develops software for the very same system that had subjected me to violence and repression. It’s a bit of a disconnect, but at the time I just didn’t think about it.”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This is how Ivan Kirsanov, a 24-year-old programmer, describes starting his former job at one of the companies within the Citadel holding group, the main manufacturer of the surveillance system for the FSB, Russia's Federal Security Service. Kirsanov has since quit and now works as a shepherd on a farm in France earning four euros an hour.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Ivan left Russia in 2025, taking with him a technical documentation archive related to SORM, a system of interception interfaces used for surveillance in Russia, produced by Citadel. IStories spoke with Ivan and examined the archive.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19122,"data":{"url":"https://www.youtube.com/embed/8U3d23FPMRA","caption":"","provider":"youtube","rawInput":"https://youtu.be/8U3d23FPMRA","ratio_mobile":"16:9","ratio_desktop":"16:9"},"category":"video-embed"},"type":"video-embed"},{"data":{"id":19093,"data":{"block":"<p>Ivan Kirsanov reached out to our editorial team through Get Lost, a human rights project which helps Russians escape military service, where he had worked as a volunteer. The details of his account are backed up by the documents, letters, photos, videos, and audio recordings he provided, as well as by open source data and various leaks. It is impossible to independently verify the accuracy of everything he told us, but all the facts we were able to verify on our own have been verified with no contradictions found.</p><p><br/></p><p>Three independent technical experts evaluated the SORM files archive and the code Kirsanov had provided to the team: Leonid Yuldashev, a cybersecurity expert and project coordinator at <a href=\"https://equalitie.org/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">eQualitie</a>, Michał (Rysiek) Woźniak, an IT security expert, and another anonymous developer expert. According to their assessment, the archive appears to be authentic.</p><p><br/></p><p>Apart from Kirsanov, other SORM developers were mentioned in the archive; we verified that they indeed work for the Citadel group. One of the employees was willing to speak with us about his work.</p>","header":"Can we trust Kirsanov’s account?","content":[{"insert":"Ivan Kirsanov reached out to our editorial team through Get Lost, a human rights project which helps Russians escape military service, where he had worked as a volunteer. The details of his account are backed up by the documents, letters, photos, videos, and audio recordings he provided, as well as by open source data and various leaks. It is impossible to independently verify the accuracy of everything he told us, but all the facts we were able to verify on our own have been verified with no contradictions found.\n\nThree independent technical experts evaluated the SORM files archive and the code Kirsanov had provided to the team: Leonid Yuldashev, a cybersecurity expert and project coordinator at "},{"insert":"eQualitie","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://equalitie.org/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":", Michał (Rysiek) Woźniak, an IT security expert, and another anonymous developer expert. According to their assessment, the archive appears to be authentic.\n\nApart from Kirsanov, other SORM developers were mentioned in the archive; we verified that they indeed work for the Citadel group. One of the employees was willing to speak with us about his work.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"The traitor","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Ivan grew up in the small town of Zelenodolsk, not far from Kazan, Russia. He is the youngest of three children. The Kirsanovs lived modestly: the father worked as a driver, and the mother as a cleaner at a factory.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“I wouldn’t even ask them to buy me anything because I knew it was impossible. For example, I wanted a new computer because I played games and did some programming. Finally it was my sister who bought it for me, not my parents.”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Ivan began learning the fundamentals of programming at the age of 11. He would watch YouTube tutorials on how to write cheat codes for Minecraft, and YouTube was where he came across Alexei Navalny’s videos. Kirsanov began to “delve into the subject and take interest in politics.” In one of Navalny’s livestreams, the late politician had mentioned that Russian schoolchildren weren’t given textbooks at schools, and this, according to Ivan, “hit the nail on the head.” His school had the exact same problem.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19112,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Ivan Kirsanov’s personal archive. Screenshot: YouTube","caption":"Ivan Kirsanov as a child; Kirsanov’s YouTube channel","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e9c7b171dbdf4c35a63da1291b073a11-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e9c7b171dbdf4c35a63da1291b073a11-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e9c7b171dbdf4c35a63da1291b073a11-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e9c7b171dbdf4c35a63da1291b073a11-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e9c7b171dbdf4c35a63da1291b073a11-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e9c7b171dbdf4c35a63da1291b073a11-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e9c7b171dbdf4c35a63da1291b073a11-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e9c7b171dbdf4c35a63da1291b073a11-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e9c7b171dbdf4c35a63da1291b073a11-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e9c7b171dbdf4c35a63da1291b073a11-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e9c7b171dbdf4c35a63da1291b073a11-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e9c7b171dbdf4c35a63da1291b073a11-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e9c7b171dbdf4c35a63da1291b073a11-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e9c7b171dbdf4c35a63da1291b073a11-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e9c7b171dbdf4c35a63da1291b073a11-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e9c7b171dbdf4c35a63da1291b073a11-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e9c7b171dbdf4c35a63da1291b073a11-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e9c7b171dbdf4c35a63da1291b073a11-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Kirsanov then wrote a complaint to the Ministry of Education, which was forwarded to the school. The administration did not appreciate the initiative. “They started telling me that I’d let the whole school down, that I was a traitor, and that the school would face major problems and trouble because of me. My parents were asked to meet with the principal, even though I was doing well in school as I valued my reputation,” Ivan recalls. His relationship with the teachers deteriorated, but they did provide him with textbooks after all.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Kirsanov realized that taking action worked, so he kept doing what he saw as working. A complaint to the housing and utilities department helped restore hot water in his friend’s home, and a complaint about the summer obligatory work program at school <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"a common practice in Russia\"></span> helped escape the obligation to shovel out basements. In ninth grade, Kirsanov and a friend attended their first <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/3533312\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">protest</a> in Kazan — the “Voters’ Strike” against Navalny being banned from the 2018 presidential election. Kirsanov’s parents did not support their son’s political activism: they threatened to take away his pocket money and cut off his internet access.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After ninth grade, Ivan was told that his family couldn’t afford his university education. Following his parents’ advice, he enrolled in a college in his hometown to study shipbuilding, a discipline that didn’t interest him at all. In his third year in 2021, Kirsanov attended another Navalny support rally when the politician was arrested upon his return to Russia <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"after he had been taken to Germany to be treated for his poisoning\"></span>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This time, Ivan was detained and <a href=\"https://vahitovsky.tat.sudrf.ru/modules.php?name=sud_delo&amp;name_op=r_juid&amp;vnkod=16RS0046&amp;srv_num=1&amp;delo_id=1500001&amp;case_type=0&amp;judicial_uid=16RS0046-01-2021-001652-48\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">fined</a>. The administration of his college threatened to expel him. “You screwed me and the principal over, do you understand? I don’t need students causing problems! We just need to get rid of you,” the academic dean would scold him.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19113,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Reuters, Ivan Kirsanov’s personal archive","caption":"On January 23, 2021, Ivan was detained at a similar rally in Kazan. The next day, the court issued a verdict to fine him","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3e0c3c865f04cfd9667487a1df4f0fd-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3e0c3c865f04cfd9667487a1df4f0fd-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3e0c3c865f04cfd9667487a1df4f0fd-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3e0c3c865f04cfd9667487a1df4f0fd-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3e0c3c865f04cfd9667487a1df4f0fd-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3e0c3c865f04cfd9667487a1df4f0fd-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3e0c3c865f04cfd9667487a1df4f0fd-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3e0c3c865f04cfd9667487a1df4f0fd-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3e0c3c865f04cfd9667487a1df4f0fd-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3e0c3c865f04cfd9667487a1df4f0fd-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3e0c3c865f04cfd9667487a1df4f0fd-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3e0c3c865f04cfd9667487a1df4f0fd-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3e0c3c865f04cfd9667487a1df4f0fd-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3e0c3c865f04cfd9667487a1df4f0fd-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3e0c3c865f04cfd9667487a1df4f0fd-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3e0c3c865f04cfd9667487a1df4f0fd-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3e0c3c865f04cfd9667487a1df4f0fd-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3e0c3c865f04cfd9667487a1df4f0fd-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Kirsanov was not expelled from college, but the consequences of the protest did not end with that. The then student began receiving the prosecutor’s warnings on the “unacceptability of participating in unauthorized protests,” and in the fall of 2021, the Center for Combating Extremism officials visited the college. Ivan was called in for a “chat” and asked about his views on Navalny. By that point, Navalny's Anti-Corruption Foundation (FBK) had already been <a href=\"https://meduza.io/news/2021/08/10/fbk-vnesli-v-spisok-ekstremistov-i-terroristov\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">added</a> to the Russian extremist and terrorist organizations list, and some protesters had received actual prison <a href=\"https://www.svoboda.org/a/31203974.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">sentences</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“After that interrogation, I finally realized that if I kept doing something like that, they would simply ruin my life… I was very scared. I knew I would have to keep quiet because I wanted to protect myself.”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The way out of poverty","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Acting on a friend’s advice, Ivan enrolled in School 21, a Russian franchise of École 42, a French programming school. The curriculum at School 21 differed from typical Russian education. The students are taught for free, and there are no lectures or teachers — they learn the material on their own, submit their projects and grade each other’s work.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“The school changed me. In college, I was surrounded by very strange people who, basically, didn’t really need anything in life. I felt very lonely; there was no one to have interesting discussions with. But at School 21, there were enthusiastic people of different professions and ages. It was as if I had stepped into some different world.”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Ivan devoted all his free time to programming, and six months later he landed an internship at Sber, Russia’s biggest bank. “It was just amazing for me,” the developer recalls. “At 19, I was working as a programmer at one of Russia’s top companies. At the time, I was making about 50,000 rubles ($650 approx. as of 2021) a month. That was more than both my parents would earn combined.” At first, he didn’t even spend his salary: he just saved it and “felt better.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19114,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: School 21. Screenshot: Kirsanov’s personal archive","caption":"The School 21 campus in Kazan’s Innopolis and the welcome message in Sber’s internal chat","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a8506c9cb9e4f84be26cdea83e40b11-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a8506c9cb9e4f84be26cdea83e40b11-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a8506c9cb9e4f84be26cdea83e40b11-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a8506c9cb9e4f84be26cdea83e40b11-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a8506c9cb9e4f84be26cdea83e40b11-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a8506c9cb9e4f84be26cdea83e40b11-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a8506c9cb9e4f84be26cdea83e40b11-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a8506c9cb9e4f84be26cdea83e40b11-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a8506c9cb9e4f84be26cdea83e40b11-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a8506c9cb9e4f84be26cdea83e40b11-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a8506c9cb9e4f84be26cdea83e40b11-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a8506c9cb9e4f84be26cdea83e40b11-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a8506c9cb9e4f84be26cdea83e40b11-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a8506c9cb9e4f84be26cdea83e40b11-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a8506c9cb9e4f84be26cdea83e40b11-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a8506c9cb9e4f84be26cdea83e40b11-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a8506c9cb9e4f84be26cdea83e40b11-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a8506c9cb9e4f84be26cdea83e40b11-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Three months later, Kirsanov was offered a full-time position. His salary nearly doubled, but it was getting harder and harder to keep up: there were a lot of uncompleted college tasks, and his professors were threatening to not let him take his exams and to expel him.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“My life was falling apart. If I’d been expelled from college, I would have been drafted into the army. If I’d been drafted, I would have lost my spot at ‘School 21’ and my job at Sber, which was my only way out of poverty.”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Ivan felt alone: his parents weren’t supportive of him, and his relationship with his girlfriend fell apart. He was diagnosed with an adjustment disorder and prescribed antidepressants. In June 2022, he finally managed to graduate. His problems with the college were over, but so was his student military service deferment. To hide from the military enlistment office, Ivan moved to Moscow.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A life the way it should be lived","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Kirsanov began building a “richer life” in Moscow. He rented an apartment, took up horse riding lessons, bought a motorcycle and rode it across Russia; for the first time in his life, he flew to Sochi <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"a sea resort\"></span> on vacation.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“I saw the sea and realized that besides the life I’d been living — constant work, constant studying, a pretty low-income life — there’s another kind of life out there. And that’s the norm; that’s the way it should be lived by everyone.”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"His friends from School 21 would find better jobs and start getting bigger paychecks. Ivan had got promoted several times, but he wouldn’t catch up with his friends. In the summer of 2023, he quit a position where he was earning three times his starting salary — which, just a year earlier, had seemed “something out of a fantasy” to him.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Kirsanov found a higher-paying position within three weeks. MFI-Soft, a company based in the Russian city of Nizhny Novgorod, promised shared workspaces equipped with kitchens and breakfasts provided, a company laptop, and the net salary of 200 thousand rubles ($2.200 approx. as of 2023). Neither the job responsibilities nor the company’s line of business were of decisive importance to Ivan at the time. During the interview, he was told that the job was related to the Yarovaya Law Package compliance, the infamous regulation of continuous data storage for the purposes of Russian state security and law enforcement agencies. ‎","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“At that moment, I just nodded and said, ‘Wow, that sounds great.’ But I didn’t actually care. I’d never even heard of that company.”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The FSB’s poor quality code","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The company unknown to Ivan had been <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20250128054745/https://www.mfisoft.ru/about/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">developing </a>technical tools for the SORM surveillance system practically since Kirsanov’s birth. The enterprise had been called MERA back then. In 2003, a division dedicated to developing the SORM solutions was <a href=\"https://x-holding.ru/companies/tsitadel/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">created </a>within the company. That division later <a href=\"https://telecomtimes.ru/2021/05/corm-russia/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">became</a> a separate company, MFI-Soft.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19096,"data":{"block":"<p>It was back in the Soviet Union when the <a href=\"https://document.wikireading.ru/hlQmj8IGU6\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">development </a>of a centralized wiretapping system began. In 1996, the SORM-1 system was <a href=\"https://document.wikireading.ru/hlQmj8IGU6\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">launched</a>, aimed at intercepting telephone calls. Three years later, the FSB implemented a SORM-2 system to intercept internet traffic. Using these early versions, the FSB can only get the users’ connections information in real time. For the FSB to have access to the user’s past internet activity and phone calls data, the internet providers are obliged to have the SORM-3 system <a href=\"https://vasexperts.ru/blog/sorm/osobennosti-i-otlichiya-sorm/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">installed</a>. It is needed, among other things, to comply with the Yarovaya Law Package regulating long-term storage both of voice and internet traffic.</p><p><br/></p><p>The State Duma <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/3022832\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">passed </a>these bills in 2016 at the initiative of Irina Yarovaya, a deputy, and Viktor Ozerov, a Federation Council senator. Among other things, the law package required telecom operators and internet service providers to store their customers’ phone call records and the content of messaging app conversations — including files, audios, photos and videos — for three years and to provide this data to the security and intelligence services via SORM, all of this at the provider companies’ own expense.</p><p><br/></p><p>The bills <a href=\"https://meduza.io/news/2016/04/20/internet-industriya-vystupila-protiv-novyh-popravok-o-borbe-s-terrorizmom\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">drew </a>a <a href=\"https://ria.ru/20161229/1484925082.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">storm </a>of criticism. In 2017, the FSB <a href=\"https://meduza.io/news/2017/04/14/fsb-otsenila-zatraty-na-zakon-yarovoy-v-4-5-trilliona-rubley\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">estimated </a>that the providers&#x27; and network operators’ expenses to comply with the law package would amount to 4.5 billion rubles, which was nearly three times the combined revenue of all Russian telecom companies. As a result, the data storage period was shortened. Starting July 1, 2018, the service providers are only <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/technology_and_media/10/02/2018/5a7d8f7f9a794768f5c304e6?tb_state=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%3D&amp;&amp;utm_referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fistories.media%2F\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">required </a>to store metadata for three years (metadata includes such information about the transmission and delivery of data as who, when, and at what volume transmitted the data, as well as how long the connection lasted). The actual content of messages, files, audio and internet traffic must be stored for six months.</p>","header":"More on SORM and the Yarovaya Package","content":[{"insert":"It was back in the Soviet Union when the "},{"insert":"development ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://document.wikireading.ru/hlQmj8IGU6","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"of a centralized wiretapping system began. In 1996, the SORM-1 system was "},{"insert":"launched","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://document.wikireading.ru/hlQmj8IGU6","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":", aimed at intercepting telephone calls. Three years later, the FSB implemented a SORM-2 system to intercept internet traffic. Using these early versions, the FSB can only get the users’ connections information in real time. For the FSB to have access to the user’s past internet activity and phone calls data, the internet providers are obliged to have the SORM-3 system "},{"insert":"installed","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://vasexperts.ru/blog/sorm/osobennosti-i-otlichiya-sorm/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":". It is needed, among other things, to comply with the Yarovaya Law Package regulating long-term storage both of voice and internet traffic.\n\nThe State Duma "},{"insert":"passed ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/3022832","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"these bills in 2016 at the initiative of Irina Yarovaya, a deputy, and Viktor Ozerov, a Federation Council senator. Among other things, the law package required telecom operators and internet service providers to store their customers’ phone call records and the content of messaging app conversations — including files, audios, photos and videos — for three years and to provide this data to the security and intelligence services via SORM, all of this at the provider companies’ own expense.\n\nThe bills "},{"insert":"drew ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://meduza.io/news/2016/04/20/internet-industriya-vystupila-protiv-novyh-popravok-o-borbe-s-terrorizmom","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"a "},{"insert":"storm ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://ria.ru/20161229/1484925082.html","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"of criticism. In 2017, the FSB "},{"insert":"estimated ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://meduza.io/news/2017/04/14/fsb-otsenila-zatraty-na-zakon-yarovoy-v-4-5-trilliona-rubley","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"that the providers' and network operators’ expenses to comply with the law package would amount to 4.5 billion rubles, which was nearly three times the combined revenue of all Russian telecom companies. As a result, the data storage period was shortened. Starting July 1, 2018, the service providers are only "},{"insert":"required ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.rbc.ru/technology_and_media/10/02/2018/5a7d8f7f9a794768f5c304e6?tb_state=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%3D&&utm_referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fistories.media%2F","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"to store metadata for three years (metadata includes such information about the transmission and delivery of data as who, when, and at what volume transmitted the data, as well as how long the connection lasted). The actual content of messages, files, audio and internet traffic must be stored for six months.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"In 2016, the Russian telecom industry was <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/3022832\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">taken aback</a> by the Yarovaya Law Package which required Russian internet providers and mobile network operators to store (and share with the FSB) massive amounts of their customers’ traffic: their correspondence, phone calls recordings, and the photo, video, and audio files they share. From the telecom companies it <a href=\"https://meduza.io/news/2017/04/14/fsb-otsenila-zatraty-na-zakon-yarovoy-v-4-5-trilliona-rubley\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">required </a>spendings several times greater than their annual revenue.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Six months earlier, major changes had begun in the SORM systems development market, as those were private companies responsible for the software. Anton Cherepennikov, an entrepreneur, the Virtus.pro esports club owner, and billionaire Alisher Usmanov’s business partner (Usmanov himself is a close associate of Putin) <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/6122410\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">founded </a>the Citadel group and began acquiring firms supplying equipment and software for the SORM system. The 2017 acquisition of Nizhny Novgorod-based MFI-Soft made Citadel the largest player in the SORM market <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"a loan from Usmanov’s USM Group was used for the acquisition\"></span>. A year later, the group owned <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/technology_and_media/07/08/2019/5d49925e9a79473386b2d28d\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">five </a>of the seven companies whose services the Russian Ministry of Communications had <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/3675464\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">recommended </a>to the internet providers and mobile operators to be able to comply with the Yarovaya Law, accounting for up to 80% of the market.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19115,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Yulia Ostroukhova / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0","caption":"Anton Cherepennikov","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2762c8ad866342efb3877f55f5a4dcaa-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2762c8ad866342efb3877f55f5a4dcaa-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2762c8ad866342efb3877f55f5a4dcaa-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2762c8ad866342efb3877f55f5a4dcaa-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2762c8ad866342efb3877f55f5a4dcaa-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2762c8ad866342efb3877f55f5a4dcaa-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2762c8ad866342efb3877f55f5a4dcaa-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2762c8ad866342efb3877f55f5a4dcaa-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2762c8ad866342efb3877f55f5a4dcaa-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2762c8ad866342efb3877f55f5a4dcaa-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2762c8ad866342efb3877f55f5a4dcaa-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2762c8ad866342efb3877f55f5a4dcaa-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2762c8ad866342efb3877f55f5a4dcaa-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2762c8ad866342efb3877f55f5a4dcaa-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2762c8ad866342efb3877f55f5a4dcaa-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2762c8ad866342efb3877f55f5a4dcaa-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2762c8ad866342efb3877f55f5a4dcaa-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2762c8ad866342efb3877f55f5a4dcaa-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":{"id":19097,"data":{"block":"<p>In addition to the billionaire Usmanov, who had <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YyVcgr1Rzxw\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">helped </a>Anton Cherepennikov, the FSB leadership itself benefits directly from SORM as well. According to our <a href=\"https://istories.media/stories/2023/03/27/on-otkrival-dveri-mnogikh-kabinetov-na-lubyanke/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">information</a>, in 2017, Valery Bitaev, the FSB First Deputy Director Sergei Korolev’s associate, acquired a 23% stake in the Citadel group. Andrei Zakharov, an investigative journalist, <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YyVcgr1Rzxw\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">discovered </a>that Boris Korolev, the general’s son, also became one of the beneficiaries of the business. In 2018, Citadel purchased a 51% stake in his IT startup, Bastion.</p><p><br/></p><p>In addition, the 30-year-old Boris Korolev <a href=\"https://meduza.io/feature/2026/03/16/na-blokirovkah-telegram-i-whatsapp-zarabatyvayut-general-fsb-i-ego-syn-vyyasnil-rassledovatel-andrey-zaharov\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">serves </a>as a deputy director of X Holding, the parent holding company that owns Citadel, other SORM equipment suppliers as well as the companies supplying TSPU (‘technical means for countering threats” — the equipment that operators and providers are required to install to let authorities block certain websites and services).</p><p><br/></p><p>In 2023, Anton Cherepennikov, the 40-year-old X Holding owner, <a href=\"https://istories.media/news/2023/07/22/umer-glava-krupneishego-v-rossii-postavshchika-oborudovaniya-dlya-slezhki-tsitadel-40-letnii-anton-cherepennikov-yego-telo-nashli-v-ofise/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">died</a>. It presumably happened during a xenon therapy <a href=\"https://ko.ru/articles/vdokh-smerti-kak-ksenonoterapiya-prevratilas-v-opasnoe-modnoe-razvlechenie/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">session </a>— a <a href=\"https://ko.ru/articles/vdokh-smerti-kak-ksenonoterapiya-prevratilas-v-opasnoe-modnoe-razvlechenie/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">process </a>of breathing in a mixture of oxygen and xenon, which supposedly has a relaxing effect. After Cherepennikov’s death, the shares of the holding were <a href=\"https://x-holding.ru/news/holding/prinyata-model-upravleniya-i-razvitiya-iks/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">redistributed </a>among the managing partners and the co-founders of the member companies. The holding company <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/quote/news/article/6a049d749a7947da875d9327\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">concealed </a>its financial statements, making it impossible to reliably identify the current owners. Among the <a href=\"https://meduza.io/feature/2026/03/16/na-blokirovkah-telegram-i-whatsapp-zarabatyvayut-general-fsb-i-ego-syn-vyyasnil-rassledovatel-andrey-zaharov\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">likely beneficiaries</a> are Valery Bitaev, Korolev Sr.’s close associate, and Korolev Jr., who owned a 20% stake in Garda, a company within the holding, prior to Cherepennikov’s death. Boris Korolev’s stake in X Holding is “ultimately his father’s asset as well,” Zakharov believes.</p>","header":"How an FSB general’s family profits from SORM","content":[{"insert":"In addition to the billionaire Usmanov, who had "},{"insert":"helped ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YyVcgr1Rzxw","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"Anton Cherepennikov, the FSB leadership itself benefits directly from SORM as well. According to our "},{"insert":"information","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://istories.media/stories/2023/03/27/on-otkrival-dveri-mnogikh-kabinetov-na-lubyanke/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":", in 2017, Valery Bitaev, the FSB First Deputy Director Sergei Korolev’s associate, acquired a 23% stake in the Citadel group. Andrei Zakharov, an investigative journalist, "},{"insert":"discovered ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YyVcgr1Rzxw","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"that Boris Korolev, the general’s son, also became one of the beneficiaries of the business. In 2018, Citadel purchased a 51% stake in his IT startup, Bastion.\n\nIn addition, the 30-year-old Boris Korolev "},{"insert":"serves ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://meduza.io/feature/2026/03/16/na-blokirovkah-telegram-i-whatsapp-zarabatyvayut-general-fsb-i-ego-syn-vyyasnil-rassledovatel-andrey-zaharov","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"as a deputy director of X Holding, the parent holding company that owns Citadel, other SORM equipment suppliers as well as the companies supplying TSPU (‘technical means for countering threats” — the equipment that operators and providers are required to install to let authorities block certain websites and services).\n\nIn 2023, Anton Cherepennikov, the 40-year-old X Holding owner, "},{"insert":"died","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://istories.media/news/2023/07/22/umer-glava-krupneishego-v-rossii-postavshchika-oborudovaniya-dlya-slezhki-tsitadel-40-letnii-anton-cherepennikov-yego-telo-nashli-v-ofise/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":". It presumably happened during a xenon therapy "},{"insert":"session ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://ko.ru/articles/vdokh-smerti-kak-ksenonoterapiya-prevratilas-v-opasnoe-modnoe-razvlechenie/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"— a "},{"insert":"process ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://ko.ru/articles/vdokh-smerti-kak-ksenonoterapiya-prevratilas-v-opasnoe-modnoe-razvlechenie/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"of breathing in a mixture of oxygen and xenon, which supposedly has a relaxing effect. After Cherepennikov’s death, the shares of the holding were "},{"insert":"redistributed ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://x-holding.ru/news/holding/prinyata-model-upravleniya-i-razvitiya-iks/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"among the managing partners and the co-founders of the member companies. The holding company "},{"insert":"concealed ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.rbc.ru/quote/news/article/6a049d749a7947da875d9327","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"its financial statements, making it impossible to reliably identify the current owners. Among the "},{"insert":"likely beneficiaries","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://meduza.io/feature/2026/03/16/na-blokirovkah-telegram-i-whatsapp-zarabatyvayut-general-fsb-i-ego-syn-vyyasnil-rassledovatel-andrey-zaharov","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" are Valery Bitaev, Korolev Sr.’s close associate, and Korolev Jr., who owned a 20% stake in Garda, a company within the holding, prior to Cherepennikov’s death. Boris Korolev’s stake in X Holding is “ultimately his father’s asset as well,” Zakharov believes.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"“We certainly stood out from our competitors in the SORM market—at that time, they were mainly former state scientific research institute employees or state security services officers,” Cherepennikov <a href=\"https://www.cybersport.ru/tags/other/anton-cherepennikov-rasskazal-chem-zanimaetsya-posle-kibersporta\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">said </a>in 2019.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Ivan Kirsanov had to work on improving a product of one of such companies, Nika-X, which became part of Citadel. In correspondence with his colleagues, he discussed the poor quality code written by “the developers from the FSB”. “They’re well-trained, but they lack real-world experience because they can’t work at normal commercial companies,” a senior colleague explained to Ivan. When the war had begun, the “FSB developers” had resigned. As Ivan assumed, they were “needed by the state in a related field.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In July 2023, when Ivan was already working at MFI-Soft, all the holding company’s SORM-related subsidiaries were <a href=\"https://x-holding.ru/companies/tsitadel/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">consolidated </a>under the Citadel brand.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"From the user to the FSB","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In the summer of 2023, Kirsanov joined the MFI-Soft department that handled internet traffic as a senior software engineer. The documents archive he shared with us shows in detail what happens to the internet traffic data on its way from the user to FSB employees.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We examined these documents with the help of Leonid Yuldashev, a cybersecurity expert and project coordinator at <a href=\"https://equalitie.org/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">eQualitie</a>. What can FSB officers learn about Russians’ online activities using SORM, according to the documents, and how does the system identify services and messaging apps?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19098,"data":{"block":"<p>The archive provided by Kirsanov contains technical documentation for the traffic extractor (more details on this component will be provided below), parts of its source code, the system logs — records of the program&#x27;s operation — as well as the intercepted traffic information, and the system&#x27;s screenshots and video recordings. The files are from between 2021 and 2024.</p><p><br/></p><p>All the documents come from a single vendor, MFI-Soft, part of the Citadel group. The files show the capabilities of the traffic monitoring system and its structure, but they do not cover the full range of SORM devices.</p>","header":"The documents we examined","content":[{"insert":"The archive provided by Kirsanov contains technical documentation for the traffic extractor (more details on this component will be provided below), parts of its source code, the system logs — records of the program's operation — as well as the intercepted traffic information, and the system's screenshots and video recordings. The files are from between 2021 and 2024.\n\nAll the documents come from a single vendor, MFI-Soft, part of the Citadel group. The files show the capabilities of the traffic monitoring system and its structure, but they do not cover the full range of SORM devices.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"The SORM equipment is installed within the operator’s network to intercept the complete copy of all the users’ traffic. This is a massive volume of data. To extract useful information from the raw data, the traffic must be parsed. SORM has a special component for this, called the extractor. This is what Ivan was working with.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The traffic is parsed layer by layer. One of the first stages is accounting, during which SORM links the traffic to a specific subscriber. In a mobile network, this is done via the phone number and the user’s IMSI; for the wired access, it is done via the login used for authentication with the provider. Therefore, all online activity via home Wi-Fi is linked to the person who signed the contract via the subscriber identification.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Next, the extractor monitors the traffic flow and attempts to identify the nature of the connection — whether it was a message app call, a file transfer, an email, or a website access. In the documentation, this process is called “tasting.” The type of connection can be recognized by:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li>&nbsp;signatures, patterns or distinctive features distinguishing one type of traffic from another;</li><li>&nbsp;server name identification (SNI);</li><li>&nbsp;indirect statistical characteristics.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"Finally, the content of the traffic is analyzed. Here, the system’s capabilities are severely limited. Modern services encrypt traffic, and, according to Kirsanov, the developers at MFI-Soft and Citadel were not tasked with decrypting it. The message text, the conversation audio, and the transferred files remain inaccessible for decryption.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19111,"data":{"text":"","title":"Support IStories","buttonText":"Donate"},"category":"donate-embed"},"type":"donate-embed"},{"data":"But even encrypted traffic leaves some metadata traces. The metadata can reveal when a person logged on, which websites they visited, how much data they transmitted, how long their messenger call lasted, and when it began and ended. By analyzing metadata, one can discover one's interests, and by comparing the call start and end times of different users, one can determine who is communicating with whom. It is unclear from the documents whether the FSB engages in such traffic analysis.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The FSB officers access SORM through control consoles. This is how they filter out the information they need from all the traffic. A SORM operator can set various parameters for intercepting the traffic: the IP address, the phone number, the email address, or the server domain name. E.g., it is possible to collect all traffic identified by the system as “Telegram,” or to monitor everyone who visits the FBK website, or the “Freedom of Russia” Legion website. ‎","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19105,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the SORM documents archive","caption":"Screenshot from a tutorial video on using control panels. The drop-down list shows the criteria by which data can be filtered","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b6780a6a4fc4c04a4f62ea010e3bc56-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b6780a6a4fc4c04a4f62ea010e3bc56-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b6780a6a4fc4c04a4f62ea010e3bc56-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1184,"real_height_2x":1307},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b6780a6a4fc4c04a4f62ea010e3bc56-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b6780a6a4fc4c04a4f62ea010e3bc56-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b6780a6a4fc4c04a4f62ea010e3bc56-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1184,"real_height_2x":1307},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b6780a6a4fc4c04a4f62ea010e3bc56-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b6780a6a4fc4c04a4f62ea010e3bc56-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b6780a6a4fc4c04a4f62ea010e3bc56-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":740,"real_height_2x":1307},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b6780a6a4fc4c04a4f62ea010e3bc56-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b6780a6a4fc4c04a4f62ea010e3bc56-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b6780a6a4fc4c04a4f62ea010e3bc56-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":740,"real_height_2x":1307},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b6780a6a4fc4c04a4f62ea010e3bc56-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b6780a6a4fc4c04a4f62ea010e3bc56-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b6780a6a4fc4c04a4f62ea010e3bc56-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":256,"real_height_2x":512},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b6780a6a4fc4c04a4f62ea010e3bc56-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b6780a6a4fc4c04a4f62ea010e3bc56-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b6780a6a4fc4c04a4f62ea010e3bc56-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":256,"real_height_2x":512}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Technically, it is possible to filter traffic by a specific word mentioned. In the training presentation example, the word “blow up” appears among the filtering criteria. However, according to a former SORM developer, full-text search was rarely used — neither in the test environment nor with the real data — as it consumed a lot of resources and slowed down the performance. Moreover, there is very little unencrypted traffic data for the full-text search to process.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19106,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the SORM documents archive","caption":"Extractor operation training presentation. The example involving full-text search was not used","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f18f19b3ef4743f987643e5cf44a3142-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f18f19b3ef4743f987643e5cf44a3142-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f18f19b3ef4743f987643e5cf44a3142-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1078,"real_height_2x":1190},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f18f19b3ef4743f987643e5cf44a3142-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f18f19b3ef4743f987643e5cf44a3142-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f18f19b3ef4743f987643e5cf44a3142-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1078,"real_height_2x":1190},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f18f19b3ef4743f987643e5cf44a3142-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f18f19b3ef4743f987643e5cf44a3142-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f18f19b3ef4743f987643e5cf44a3142-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":674,"real_height_2x":1190},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f18f19b3ef4743f987643e5cf44a3142-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f18f19b3ef4743f987643e5cf44a3142-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f18f19b3ef4743f987643e5cf44a3142-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":674,"real_height_2x":1190},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f18f19b3ef4743f987643e5cf44a3142-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f18f19b3ef4743f987643e5cf44a3142-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f18f19b3ef4743f987643e5cf44a3142-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":466},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f18f19b3ef4743f987643e5cf44a3142-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f18f19b3ef4743f987643e5cf44a3142-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f18f19b3ef4743f987643e5cf44a3142-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":466}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The analyzed traffic which did not reach the control panels based on the selection criteria is not lost. Statistics on all connections and the available content of messages are sent to the Yanvar data storage system, where they are stored for six months to three years, depending on the type of data according to the Yarovaya Law. During this entire period, the government security and intelligence agencies can access the stored traffic, but it is unknown whether they do so or to what extent.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19107,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the SORM documents archive","caption":"The Yanvar database","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b96b0446e3a3432c902768e701c28064-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b96b0446e3a3432c902768e701c28064-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b96b0446e3a3432c902768e701c28064-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1019,"real_height_2x":1126},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b96b0446e3a3432c902768e701c28064-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b96b0446e3a3432c902768e701c28064-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b96b0446e3a3432c902768e701c28064-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1019,"real_height_2x":1126},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b96b0446e3a3432c902768e701c28064-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b96b0446e3a3432c902768e701c28064-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b96b0446e3a3432c902768e701c28064-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":637,"real_height_2x":1126},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b96b0446e3a3432c902768e701c28064-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b96b0446e3a3432c902768e701c28064-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b96b0446e3a3432c902768e701c28064-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":637,"real_height_2x":1126},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b96b0446e3a3432c902768e701c28064-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b96b0446e3a3432c902768e701c28064-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b96b0446e3a3432c902768e701c28064-original.jpg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":220,"real_height_2x":441},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b96b0446e3a3432c902768e701c28064-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b96b0446e3a3432c902768e701c28064-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b96b0446e3a3432c902768e701c28064-original.jpg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":220,"real_height_2x":441}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Telegram, Signal or Google: How well can SORM see encrypted services data?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"To extract the valuable information from traffic more effectively, the developers use decoders: software modules designed for a specific service or app. These decoders do not decrypt the traffic, but they allow the developers to identify the services and collect more detailed metadata.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Such decoders exist for many messaging apps — for example, Telegram or WhatsApp — as well as for traffic anonymization services (Tor or various VPN services) and for certain cryptocurrencies. If no decoder has been written for a particular service, information will still be collected. But in that case, some data may be lost, and the traffic will be marked as unrecognized, Kirsanov explains.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Upon reviewing the decoder documentation, we figured out how well SORM can “see” the data in some popular messaging apps.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li>There are decoders for Telegram, WhatsApp, IMO, Zoom, Viber, WeChat, and Discord. SORM detects the mere fact that these services are being used and collects call metadata, but it does not know what you are discussing.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<li>There is no decoder for Signal. Based on the available documents, it is the most inaccessible service to SORM out of the entire list: it's even questionable if the system can reliably detect its use. Apparently, the system views its traffic as a standard encrypted connection without specifically identifying it as Signal.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<li>Outdated, unencrypted services such as ICQ, Mail.ru Agent, or Jabber are the most transparent to SORM. The system can even access the message content. According to cybersecurity expert Leonid Yuldashev, activists occasionally come up with the idea to revive such services and use them for secure communication. The documentation we reviewed shows the opposite.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<li>Search queries and results on Google are invisible to SORM. However, the system knows that a user accessed the google.com domain.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<li>There are no decoders for Google Meet and Google Drive. All of these services appear as Google traffic, which SORM identified by domain names in secure connections. The conversations, files, and search queries themselves remain inaccessible. The system can likely distinguish a Meet video call from a file upload to Drive, but only based on indirect characteristics: the domain and the type of data flow (a long two-way exchange looks different from a one-way file upload).</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<li>SORM can detect some VPNs being used. There are decoders for the classic OpenVPN protocol — which most such services use — and the outdated PPTP protocol. However, modern protocols like WireGuard or VLESS are not mentioned in the documentation. The services designed to bypass Russian restrictions are currently switching to these very protocols. VLESS disguises itself as regular HTTPS, so to the system it most likely appears as some ordinary encrypted web traffic. It is unclear from the documents how WireGuard is perceived by the system.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"The data on Russians’ online activities that SORM is capable of collecting is of little interest, since a significant portion of the traffic is encrypted, Yuldashev concludes. But with messaging apps blocked, users rely on VPNs, and if a VPN doesn’t work and there’s no access to messaging apps, people switch to phone calls and text messages, which are already transparent to SORM, the expert points out.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Many Russian services, including Yandex and VK, also use encryption. The documents reviewed contain no information suggesting that SORM can decrypt or analyze Russian encrypted services in greater detail than foreign ones. This is also confirmed by Kirsanov as a former developer of the system. But this does not mean that communicating via such messaging apps is safe: SORM is far from being the only weapon in the security forces’ arsenal.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19099,"data":{"block":"<p>One piece of evidence is the comments on the Investigative Committee’s VK page, which Andrei Zakharov <a href=\"https://t.me/zakharovchannel/1978\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">pointed </a>out. When responding to comments from anonymous users, an Investigative Committee representative addresses them by their first and patronymic names. It is clear that for the security and intelligence agencies there is no confidential correspondence or anonymity on VK. “FSB agents can essentially access any VK account without a password and simply monitor the user’s activity,” a source close to the security services <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=88t3AenN1oc&amp;t=1049s\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">told </a>Zakharov.</p><p><br/></p><p>Timofey Dubrovskikh, a cybersecurity expert, advises assuming that law enforcement agencies have access to all data on all Russian services and messaging apps. “From the state agencies perspective, this is much more convenient than conducting surveillance in a centralized manner. Instead of working on the code themselves, building their own technical department and creating SORM-4 to intercept encryption certificates and crack them, it’s easier to go to the IT companies and intimidate them by any means necessary, so that Yandex, for example, would<a href=\"https://meduza.io/feature/2023/08/08/sovsem-skoro-fsb-poluchit-kruglosutochnyy-dostup-k-dannym-servisa-yandeksa-po-zakazu-taksi-kak-vyyasnila-meduza-v-tom-chisle-k-poezdkam-za-predelami-rossii\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> hand over </a>the data themselves,” Dubrovskikh believes.</p>","header":"Why it is unsafe to communicate on Russian platforms","content":[{"insert":"One piece of evidence is the comments on the Investigative Committee’s VK page, which Andrei Zakharov "},{"insert":"pointed ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://t.me/zakharovchannel/1978","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"out. When responding to comments from anonymous users, an Investigative Committee representative addresses them by their first and patronymic names. It is clear that for the security and intelligence agencies there is no confidential correspondence or anonymity on VK. “FSB agents can essentially access any VK account without a password and simply monitor the user’s activity,” a source close to the security services "},{"insert":"told ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=88t3AenN1oc&t=1049s","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"Zakharov.\n\nTimofey Dubrovskikh, a cybersecurity expert, advises assuming that law enforcement agencies have access to all data on all Russian services and messaging apps. “From the state agencies perspective, this is much more convenient than conducting surveillance in a centralized manner. Instead of working on the code themselves, building their own technical department and creating SORM-4 to intercept encryption certificates and crack them, it’s easier to go to the IT companies and intimidate them by any means necessary, so that Yandex, for example, would"},{"insert":" hand over ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://meduza.io/feature/2023/08/08/sovsem-skoro-fsb-poluchit-kruglosutochnyy-dostup-k-dannym-servisa-yandeksa-po-zakazu-taksi-kak-vyyasnila-meduza-v-tom-chisle-k-poezdkam-za-predelami-rossii","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"the data themselves,” Dubrovskikh believes.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"The tasks from FSB","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The main SORM users are the FSB officers. From them, developers get tasks to make improvements and fix bugs in the system, yet their own security requirements prevent these bugs from being fixed promptly.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19108,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the SORM documents archive","caption":"An example of a task from the FSB: Developers are asked how to set up the control panel so that the phone model could be identified during a regular mobile network call, rather than just the audio and general statistics","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b616a0fe7a5a429e9b3f67fdbc0258d8-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b616a0fe7a5a429e9b3f67fdbc0258d8-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b616a0fe7a5a429e9b3f67fdbc0258d8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b616a0fe7a5a429e9b3f67fdbc0258d8-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b616a0fe7a5a429e9b3f67fdbc0258d8-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b616a0fe7a5a429e9b3f67fdbc0258d8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b616a0fe7a5a429e9b3f67fdbc0258d8-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b616a0fe7a5a429e9b3f67fdbc0258d8-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b616a0fe7a5a429e9b3f67fdbc0258d8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b616a0fe7a5a429e9b3f67fdbc0258d8-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b616a0fe7a5a429e9b3f67fdbc0258d8-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b616a0fe7a5a429e9b3f67fdbc0258d8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b616a0fe7a5a429e9b3f67fdbc0258d8-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b616a0fe7a5a429e9b3f67fdbc0258d8-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b616a0fe7a5a429e9b3f67fdbc0258d8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b616a0fe7a5a429e9b3f67fdbc0258d8-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b616a0fe7a5a429e9b3f67fdbc0258d8-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b616a0fe7a5a429e9b3f67fdbc0258d8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Without the full access to detailed error logs, the developers cannot immediately understand the cause of the problem and spend significantly more time resolving it, Kirsanov explained.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The security service was not very quick to adopt the improvements from the developers. “The FSB still has not tested them or put them into operation. They don’t have time,” one of Ivan’s colleagues described the status of the settings that had been submitted for approval a year before.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Not only did the FSB give the developers tasks, but expressions of gratitude as well. In the first half of 2024, Citadel completed the system implementation in the newly-annexed regions of Kherson, Zaporizhzhia, Donetsk, and Luhansk. Those responsible for the project received a letter of appreciation from the FSB, and all Citadel employees were notified of this via corporate email, Kirsanov explained.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Other government agencies do not have direct access to the system. The Ministry of Internal Affairs officers must submit reasoned requests if they want to place someone under wiretap, Andrei Zakharov <a href=\"https://thebell.io/chernyy-yashchik-kak-fsb-poluchaet-dostup-k-zvonkam-i-perepiske-rossiyan\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">shares </a>in his book, Russian Cyberpunk.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, regular Citadel employees do have access to the data. Ivan recalls intercepting the internet traffic of the Tele-2 operator in Nizhny Novgorod to complete one of his tasks. “I could analyze it, or do whatever I wanted with it. Without any special authorization, I could effectively monitor real people. In reality, every developer at the company has been able to do so,” says the former SORM developer.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“We make the world a better place.” What SORM developers think about their work","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The authorities <a href=\"https://duma.gov.ru/news/56767/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">state </a>that SORM’s purpose is to help solve crimes, track down criminals, and prevent terrorist attacks. Some developers see this as the end goal of their work as well.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong><em>“What do you like about your work?”</em></strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“The creative approach. We make the world a better place by using cutting-edge development and testing tools.”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong><em>“Have you ever considered that SORM could be used for political persecution, not just to fight crime?”</em></strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“There are people who manufacture weapons; they provide the technical means to physically eliminate both enemy forces and civilians. I can’t be held responsible for who pulls the trigger of the gun I made. I make guns. I like it.”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This is how Alexei (the name has been changed) — a current Citadel employee who spoke with IStories on condition of anonymity — describes his work. Another employee’s position might be understood from his messages in public Telegram chats.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“The FSB always acts strictly in accordance with the law. &lt;…&gt; It is technically impossible to incorporate selection criteria into the operational and investigative system without a valid court order number. Therefore, when it comes to organizing illegal surveillance, the FSB’s technical capabilities (and the FSB itself) are absolutely no help at all.</em>😉<em>”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19109,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Telegram chat screenshots","caption":"A Citadel employee is reassuring his chatmates that the FSB always acts strictly within the law","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b8e6217f7f64bd6b1a3a3f7a13cd16b-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b8e6217f7f64bd6b1a3a3f7a13cd16b-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b8e6217f7f64bd6b1a3a3f7a13cd16b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b8e6217f7f64bd6b1a3a3f7a13cd16b-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b8e6217f7f64bd6b1a3a3f7a13cd16b-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b8e6217f7f64bd6b1a3a3f7a13cd16b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b8e6217f7f64bd6b1a3a3f7a13cd16b-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b8e6217f7f64bd6b1a3a3f7a13cd16b-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b8e6217f7f64bd6b1a3a3f7a13cd16b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b8e6217f7f64bd6b1a3a3f7a13cd16b-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b8e6217f7f64bd6b1a3a3f7a13cd16b-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b8e6217f7f64bd6b1a3a3f7a13cd16b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b8e6217f7f64bd6b1a3a3f7a13cd16b-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b8e6217f7f64bd6b1a3a3f7a13cd16b-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b8e6217f7f64bd6b1a3a3f7a13cd16b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b8e6217f7f64bd6b1a3a3f7a13cd16b-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b8e6217f7f64bd6b1a3a3f7a13cd16b-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6b8e6217f7f64bd6b1a3a3f7a13cd16b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"However, in the video depicting the control panel in action, there is no field for a court order number to be seen. Kirsanov has also confirmed that he had never heard of such a requirement.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"He, too, quickly came to embrace the same idea of his work’s mission. “At first, I went there for the money, but then I started to capture the overall spirit: we do something useful, we fight crime by writing great software which is used to catch murderers and terrorists,” the developer recalls.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Six months after starting the job, Kirsanov even suggested creating a regular motivational newsletter with the information about crimes solved using SORM to an HR department colleague. She told him that this was classified information and the company didn’t have access to it.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The extent to which SORM is actually useful in criminal investigations is not publicly known. As far back as 2020, researchers from a department of criminology in Perm <a href=\"https://thebell.io/chernyy-yashchik-kak-fsb-poluchaet-dostup-k-zvonkam-i-perepiske-rossiyan\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">noted </a>that in all the years SORM had been in operation, there had not been a single official statement regarding its use in solving prominent crimes. Back then, the researchers recommended <a href=\"https://elibrary.ru/item.asp?id=44507534\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">introducing </a>a formal report system on the efficiency of SORM by law.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After the March 2024 terrorist attack at Crocus City Hall, when terrorists killed 147 people, it became completely clear that SORM was not performing the way it was supposed to, The Bell <a href=\"https://thebell.io/sekret-yarovoy-kak-vtoraya-sluzhba-fsb-zakhvatila-kontrol-nad-runetom\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">reported</a>. After the attack — which SORM failed to prevent in any way —the control over the internet surveillance systems shifted from the FSB’s Scientific and Technical Service to its Second Service, which is known for persecuting the opposition and Alexei Navalny's attempted <a href=\"https://dossier.center/aan/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">poisoning</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories reported <a href=\"https://www.istories.media/stories/2026/09/02/kak-fsb-presleduet-operatorov-svyazi-iz-za-otsutstviya-sistemi-slezhki-sorm/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">more </a>on the way the FSB is attempting to achieve total surveillance over the citizens with the help of newly-introduced big fines.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19123,"data":{"block":"<p>Several <a href=\"https://theins.ru/news/112869\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">cases </a>in which SORM was used to wiretap opposition politicians and independent journalists are publicly known. One of the most prominent cases involved Alexei Navalny’s phone conversations being eavesdropped on in 2010. The emotional <a href=\"https://rg.ru/2013/07/25/nav.html?tb_state=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&amp;utm_referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fthebell.io%2F\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">extracts </a>of those conversations were used against him in court during the Kirovles case.</p><p><br/></p><p>In 2024, the Golovinsky Court in Moscow tried two Venezuelans in absentia and sentenced them to six years in prison for organizing an anti-war SMS campaign targeting Russians’ cell phones, which constitutes a crime according to Russia&#x27;s war censorship laws. The intelligence agencies used SORM to uncover this “crime case”. All of the abovementioned cases involved regular cellphone communication, not internet traffic data.</p>","header":"What we know about SORM being used in criminal investigations","content":[{"insert":"Several "},{"insert":"cases ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://theins.ru/news/112869","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"in which SORM was used to wiretap opposition politicians and independent journalists are publicly known. One of the most prominent cases involved Alexei Navalny’s phone conversations being eavesdropped on in 2010. The emotional "},{"insert":"extracts ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://rg.ru/2013/07/25/nav.html?tb_state=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&utm_referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fthebell.io%2F","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"of those conversations were used against him in court during the Kirovles case.\n\nIn 2024, the Golovinsky Court in Moscow tried two Venezuelans in absentia and sentenced them to six years in prison for organizing an anti-war SMS campaign targeting Russians’ cell phones, which constitutes a crime according to Russia's war censorship laws. The intelligence agencies used SORM to uncover this “crime case”. All of the abovementioned cases involved regular cellphone communication, not internet traffic data.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"From Paris to Mariupol","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"At Citadel, Kirsanov would perform routine and not-so-exciting tasks related to product improvements, working remotely and seeing his colleagues only during conference calls, so he was unable to find friends among them. He decided to seek new experiences outside of his work and the country.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In the first year of the war, the French École 42 ended its partnership with Sber. Students could either transfer to the French branch or remain at the Russian School 21. Ivan chose the French school, was granted a French student visa, and went to Europe by bus in the fall of 2023, a month after starting work on SORM. The upcoming autumn military draft was a significant factor in his decision to leave.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19116,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Kirsanov’s personal archive","caption":"Ivan Kirsanov working remotely for Citadel while in Paris in the summer of 2023","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6cabc42d32c14ce68529d37a099c20b0-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6cabc42d32c14ce68529d37a099c20b0-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6cabc42d32c14ce68529d37a099c20b0-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6cabc42d32c14ce68529d37a099c20b0-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6cabc42d32c14ce68529d37a099c20b0-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6cabc42d32c14ce68529d37a099c20b0-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6cabc42d32c14ce68529d37a099c20b0-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6cabc42d32c14ce68529d37a099c20b0-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6cabc42d32c14ce68529d37a099c20b0-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6cabc42d32c14ce68529d37a099c20b0-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6cabc42d32c14ce68529d37a099c20b0-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6cabc42d32c14ce68529d37a099c20b0-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6cabc42d32c14ce68529d37a099c20b0-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6cabc42d32c14ce68529d37a099c20b0-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6cabc42d32c14ce68529d37a099c20b0-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6cabc42d32c14ce68529d37a099c20b0-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6cabc42d32c14ce68529d37a099c20b0-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6cabc42d32c14ce68529d37a099c20b0-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Ivan would switch his IP addresses to Moscow-based ones and develop software for the Russian intelligence right from his apartment nearby Notre Dame, and at night he would walk over to the Eiffel Tower. His first emigrant experience turned out to be far from easy. “I was under constant stress because I was working illegally from abroad; I knew it could be discovered, and I would be fired. I had to take antidepressants and couldn’t sleep properly,” the developer recalls. Neither his family nor his colleagues knew he had left. A month later, he had to return as he was invited to a work conference.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A few months after returning from Paris, Kirsanov set out on a new journey. This time, he headed to Mariupol, a Ukrainian city which had been heavily destroyed and then occupied by Russian troops in 2022. “I wanted to see the war. I could monitor it online, but I wanted to see it with my own eyes, to experience what it’s like to live in a state of war,” he explains, describing his choice of destination.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Kirsanov got scared by the sight of the ruined city and the completely destroyed Azovstal plant <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"which had been the final pocket of resistance in the city before it was occupied completely\"></span>, along with the local residents’ accounts of how they collected rainwater for their children to drink and sheltered from the bombing in their homes. He left the occupied territories that very same day, but even after the trip, he would still avoid thinking about the war. “I understood that something terrible was happening, but I didn’t support either side. I tried not to think about it and to keep all those thoughts locked away in some separate box so I wouldn’t have to face them.”‎ ‎ ‎&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19117,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Screenshots: Kirsanov’s personal archive","caption":"Ivan’s trip to the occupied Mariupol","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86760059079e41ba85567d24e7b3e2c2-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86760059079e41ba85567d24e7b3e2c2-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86760059079e41ba85567d24e7b3e2c2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86760059079e41ba85567d24e7b3e2c2-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86760059079e41ba85567d24e7b3e2c2-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86760059079e41ba85567d24e7b3e2c2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86760059079e41ba85567d24e7b3e2c2-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86760059079e41ba85567d24e7b3e2c2-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86760059079e41ba85567d24e7b3e2c2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86760059079e41ba85567d24e7b3e2c2-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86760059079e41ba85567d24e7b3e2c2-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86760059079e41ba85567d24e7b3e2c2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86760059079e41ba85567d24e7b3e2c2-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86760059079e41ba85567d24e7b3e2c2-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86760059079e41ba85567d24e7b3e2c2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86760059079e41ba85567d24e7b3e2c2-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86760059079e41ba85567d24e7b3e2c2-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86760059079e41ba85567d24e7b3e2c2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Resignation","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In March 2024, Ivan received a letter from the European Court of Human Rights. The ECHR ruled Russia violated the European Convention on Human Rights when Ivan was detained at a January 2021 rally along with the other protesters, and he was <a href=\"https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng#%7B%22itemid%22:[%22001-231620%22]%7D\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">granted </a>a EUR 4.000 compensation. However, neither Ivan nor the other applicants received the money because by March 2024 Russia had been <a href=\"https://meduza.io/cards/rossiyane-skoro-ne-smogut-zhalovatsya-v-espch-kuda-teper-obraschatsya-tem-chi-prava-narusheny\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">outside </a>the jurisdiction of the ECHR for two years.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Nine years earlier, in December 2015, the ECHR had ruled that the SORM usage legislation in Russia was violating the European Convention on Human Rights and the right to respect for private life covered by it. Russian regulations did not provide “adequate and effective guarantees against arbitrariness and the risk of abuse which is inherent in any system of secret surveillance,” the court’s ruling <a href=\"https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng#%7B%22itemid%22:[%22001-159324%22]%7D\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">stated</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Ivan didn’t know about the ECHR ruling on SORM; he was 13 at the time. But the ruling regarding his own detention made the developer think. “I remember I wanted to tell my friends about it, but I didn’t know how to approach it. On the one hand, I basically work within this system; on the other, a ruling like this emerges. I never told anyone,” he recalls. ‎","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Kirsanov resigned a few months later, but the reason was the same as the one that had originally brought him to the company: he asked for a promotion and was told to wait.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“They want loyal employees. They were counting on people who would work quietly for eight years and never ask for anything, never seek promotions, and just be a cog in the machine,” Kirsanov describes. An example he gives is his former colleague who had been with the company for about 10 years, earning below market the entire time. Leaked data shows that in 2025, this employee was earning just over 130 000 rubles a month ($1.500 approx as of 2025), which is a third less than the salary Kirsanov started with.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Money wasn’t the only reason for his resignation. Kirsanov described he “didn’t grow much as a programmer” during his year at the company. He recalls suggesting implementing new solutions, from AI to optimizing error handling. But the management was not enthusiastic about these ideas. “It was a company with good working conditions and up-to-date processes, but there was no innovation as such,” Ivan describes Citadel.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After being denied a promotion, he began looking for a new job and having online interviews right from the company’s office. Management noticed this fairly quickly. He was given a choice either to quit or to stay agreeing to never seek employment elsewhere and to exclusively work at Citadel. Ivan decided to quit.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“If they had promoted me back then, if they had given me the opportunity to grow professionally, most likely I would keep working there, climbing up the career ladder and doing increasingly worse things. I would sincerely believe I do the right things, just as I believed back then.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Abduction","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"After he quit, Ivan recalls, he quickly found a new job and began gradually reconnecting with old acquaintances, following independent media, watching the oppositioners' and military analysts' blogs on YouTube and donating to human rights activists — “getting back to himself after many years,” in his words.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"On the first anniversary of the murder of Navalny, Kirsanov went out to a one-person protest. He knew that being detained could lead to problems with the military registration office, as he still didn’t have a military ID {a document proving a Russian citizen’s status regarding the obligatory military service}, but he felt it was important to him not to remain silent, he says.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“By early 2025, the big picture had become absolutely clear, and I realized that something horrible was happening in Russia — a war going on, the growing isolation. I began to understand that I could no longer stay there.”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"While preparing to leave, Ivan listed his car up for sale. A meeting with a potential buyer was scheduled for April 24, 2025. Instead of the prospective buyers, two men in plain clothes approached him, showed their police IDs and forced Ivan into their car. Kirsanov figured he was being abducted. He opened the car door and unsuccessfully tried to get people’s attention, then decided to tear up his passport, recalling Belarusian opposition activist Maria Kolesnikova doing the same <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"she did it not to be forcedly taken out of the country, but in Kirsanov’s case, it wouldn’t have affected the officers in any way\"></span>. But that didn’t stop his captors taking him to the police station in Khoroshevo-Mnevniki <span class=\"factcheck\" data-explanation=\"a district in Moscow\"></span>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19118,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Yandex Maps. Screenshots: Kirsanov’s personal archive","caption":"The corner of Demyan Bedny and Marshal Tukhachevsky Streets, where plainclothes officers detained Ivan; the Khoroshevo-Mnevniki police station where he was taken; the scratches left from the incident","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8d4469868b4745c1a1e229fd076dc1c7-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8d4469868b4745c1a1e229fd076dc1c7-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8d4469868b4745c1a1e229fd076dc1c7-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8d4469868b4745c1a1e229fd076dc1c7-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8d4469868b4745c1a1e229fd076dc1c7-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8d4469868b4745c1a1e229fd076dc1c7-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8d4469868b4745c1a1e229fd076dc1c7-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8d4469868b4745c1a1e229fd076dc1c7-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8d4469868b4745c1a1e229fd076dc1c7-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8d4469868b4745c1a1e229fd076dc1c7-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8d4469868b4745c1a1e229fd076dc1c7-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8d4469868b4745c1a1e229fd076dc1c7-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8d4469868b4745c1a1e229fd076dc1c7-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8d4469868b4745c1a1e229fd076dc1c7-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8d4469868b4745c1a1e229fd076dc1c7-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8d4469868b4745c1a1e229fd076dc1c7-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8d4469868b4745c1a1e229fd076dc1c7-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8d4469868b4745c1a1e229fd076dc1c7-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Ivan recalls throwing himself to the ground outside the police station, screaming for help, and threatening to kill himself. The police officers clearly weren’t expecting such a reaction. They began to mock him, then tried to persuade him to enter the station and call his parents or a lawyer, but called an ambulance after the suicide threat.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The doctors took Kirsanov to a mental hospital, where, after being questioned, he was released due to his friend agreeing to take responsibility for him. Ivan didn’t know why he had been abducted, but he suspected it might be related to his involvement in political activities over the past few months. Two days after the abduction, he flew out of Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The departure and a new life","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Kirsanov flew to Serbia and moved to France six months later, as his studies at École 42 enabled him to obtain a French residence permit. This time, he wasn’t facing the threat of getting fired; his savings allowed him to not work, and the threat of persecution vanished. “From the very first days, I began to feel the freedom that everyone should have,” recalls the former surveillance software developer.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Ivan enjoyed long walks, went on short trips within France and became a volunteer with the Get Lost human rights organization. He worked on the hotline, giving instructions on how to obtain a military ID and avoid conscription, providing emotional support and referring people to counselors in the more complex cases.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":19120,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: IStories","caption":"After Moscow’s high salaries, Ivan now lives “a minimalist lifestyle”","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/761d734fe1384dcbaf893e2f1ac0e7f6-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/761d734fe1384dcbaf893e2f1ac0e7f6-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/761d734fe1384dcbaf893e2f1ac0e7f6-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/761d734fe1384dcbaf893e2f1ac0e7f6-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/761d734fe1384dcbaf893e2f1ac0e7f6-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/761d734fe1384dcbaf893e2f1ac0e7f6-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/761d734fe1384dcbaf893e2f1ac0e7f6-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/761d734fe1384dcbaf893e2f1ac0e7f6-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/761d734fe1384dcbaf893e2f1ac0e7f6-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/761d734fe1384dcbaf893e2f1ac0e7f6-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/761d734fe1384dcbaf893e2f1ac0e7f6-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/761d734fe1384dcbaf893e2f1ac0e7f6-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/761d734fe1384dcbaf893e2f1ac0e7f6-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/761d734fe1384dcbaf893e2f1ac0e7f6-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/761d734fe1384dcbaf893e2f1ac0e7f6-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/761d734fe1384dcbaf893e2f1ac0e7f6-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/761d734fe1384dcbaf893e2f1ac0e7f6-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/761d734fe1384dcbaf893e2f1ac0e7f6-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":{"id":19121,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: IStories","caption":"Kirsanov in France in 2026","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d722921ec83b493ca616a8bf1a5e8a0e-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d722921ec83b493ca616a8bf1a5e8a0e-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d722921ec83b493ca616a8bf1a5e8a0e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d722921ec83b493ca616a8bf1a5e8a0e-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d722921ec83b493ca616a8bf1a5e8a0e-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d722921ec83b493ca616a8bf1a5e8a0e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d722921ec83b493ca616a8bf1a5e8a0e-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d722921ec83b493ca616a8bf1a5e8a0e-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d722921ec83b493ca616a8bf1a5e8a0e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d722921ec83b493ca616a8bf1a5e8a0e-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d722921ec83b493ca616a8bf1a5e8a0e-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d722921ec83b493ca616a8bf1a5e8a0e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d722921ec83b493ca616a8bf1a5e8a0e-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d722921ec83b493ca616a8bf1a5e8a0e-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d722921ec83b493ca616a8bf1a5e8a0e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d722921ec83b493ca616a8bf1a5e8a0e-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d722921ec83b493ca616a8bf1a5e8a0e-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d722921ec83b493ca616a8bf1a5e8a0e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The life of an unemployed emigrant and his attempts to legalize his status quickly ate up all his savings. Since the fall of 2025, Ivan has been living “a minimalist lifestyle”: he stays in a trailer on a farm and herds goats and picks strawberries there. In his free time — of which he now has plenty — he plays video games, reads books and rides his bike.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Kirsanov plans to enroll in college and enjoy a “peaceful student life” without having to combine it with working. He wants to learn the language and integrate into French society. However, first he needs to resolve his documentation issues. His student residence permit is about to expire, and the French authorities rejected his asylum application: they did not believe he faced a risk of persecution in Russia. Currently, Kirsanov is getting ready to file an appeal.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Meanwhile, the Russian Ministry of Internal Affairs has issued a statement explaining that in 2025 Ivan was “voluntarily” taken to the police station to be interrogated as a witness in a criminal case in accordance with Article 119 of Russia's Criminal Code, Threat of Murder or Infliction of Grave Injury Health. The case is being handled by the St. Petersburg Center for the Security of Persons Subject to State Protection.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Kirsanov suspects that the case may be linked to his messages to a former Federal Penitentiary Service (FSIN) employee, Igor Potapenko, who later <a href=\"https://tass.ru/politika/22339283\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">became </a>St. Petersburg’s vice governor for security. Ivan had learned that Potapenko had been involved in <a href=\"https://www.svoboda.org/a/wsj-fsin-posle-nachala-voyny-poruchili-pytatj-ukrainskih-plennyh/33309379.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">torturing </a>Ukrainian prisoners of war, so he sent him private messages on VK requesting a comment on the allegations — according to him, he wanted to “generate public pressure.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“I don’t see any scenarios in which I would definitely return to Russia. Some people have told me I shouldn’t tell my story without hiding my identity. But I’m not the only one; the others remain silent and don’t speak out. Yes, I had no control over how these systems would be used. I created them with good intentions. Nevertheless, I became somewhat complicit in it all. I was also scared and afraid, but I think people need to know the truth.”</em>","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":10452,"header":"What Happened to Russian Conscripts in Kursk in 2024 — and Afterwards","_path":"/en/stories/2026/08/27/kursk-2024/","lead":"In August 2024, two and a half years after the Russian full-scale invasion of Ukraine had begun, the Armed Forces of Ukraine started their incursion operation in Russian Kursk Oblast. Among those guarding the Russian border, most were young conscripts of varying levels of training. IStories and Verstka researched how the conscripts had been drawn into hostilities and how the war affected the survivors","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/20b7c5b01b5d4a4fac14bebc12d024c0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Cover: IStories. Photos: Kyrylo Chubotin / SIPA / Scanpix / LETA; the conscripts’ social media pages","created_at_date":"2026-08-27","created_at_date_time":"2026-08-05T16:50:38.567Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":true,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":61,"first_name":"Егор","last_name":"Феоктистов","first_name_en":"Egor","last_name_en":"Feoktistov","is_public":true,"_path":"egor-feoktistov","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Автор дата-отдела «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[{"id":366,"first_name":"Екатерина","last_name":"Красоткина","first_name_en":"Ekaterina","last_name_en":"Krasotkina","company":"«Вёрстка»","company_en":"Verstka","company_link":"https://verstka.media/","avatar":[],"ordering":2}],"editors_list":[{"id":31,"first_name":"Катя","last_name":"Бонч-Осмоловская","first_name_en":"Katya","last_name_en":"Bonch-Osmolovskaya","is_public":true,"_path":"katya-bonch-osmolovskaya","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.jpeg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.jpeg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.jpeg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.jpeg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редакторка дата-отдела","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":null,"ordering":1}],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"On the night of August 5-6, 2024, the Russian soldiers stationed near the Russian-Ukrainian border in Kursk Oblast heard military vehicles moving. They reported the suspicious activity across the border to their headquarters, and in the morning, they got an order to send two men on a reconnaissance mission to a neighboring platoon stationed closer to the border. Maxim and his comrade — both conscripts — volunteered.\n\nWhen they almost reached their destination, they saw two vehicles in the forest belt: \"We thought those were two ‘UAZ Hunters’ and headed over there, [thinking our platoon was there].” We heard an unintelligible shout from there, and then shooting started.\n\n“After that, everything was like slow motion,” Maxim recalls. “My fellow soldier turned toward me, and I saw three bullets hit him in the head. I just fell onto the asphalt, looked at my comrade’s body, and realized there was no way to help him. The first thought that crossed my mind was that this was a dream, that it wasn’t real. And then I came to my senses when they started shooting at me.”\n\n*****\nMaxim’s fellow soldier is just one of dozens of young conscripts who died as a result of the Ukrainian incursion campaign into Kursk Oblast. IStories and Verstka have counted at least 77 conscripts who died in the region’s border zone in 2024. As of this publication, over 30 more remain missing. It is likely that over time they will also be officially recognized as dead. According to our data, in 2026, Russian authorities have been still registering the deaths of conscripts who went missing two years ago.\nIStories and Verstka have spoken with surviving conscripts and relatives of those who served on the border, analyzed open sources, and reconstructed the course of events in the Kursk Oblast in August and September 2024.\nHow the conscripts ended up at the border\n\nStarting in late March 2024, the conscripts drafted in the autumn began arriving at the border in the Kursk Oblast. At some locations, they replaced the demobee conscripts — those approaching the termination of their service. “We learned from them that there’s nothing much going on there, but you’re sitting at point zero, at the ‘ribbon’ [front line], so you see the enemy, and they see you,” Nikita Litvinyuk recounted after being taken captive by the Ukrainian Armed Forces (UAF). “You stay still and so do they.”\n\nAt a military unit in Klintsy, Bryansk Oblast (where the 488th Regiment is stationed), the soldiers were assured that they would be stationed behind the border guards and contract soldiers. “To be honest, I was happy because I knew it would be a bit more relaxed than at the unit,” said a captured conscript. “At the unit, they push us hard: marching, drills, all that stuff. But everyone says it’s calm at the border — nothing too demanding, you just sit around, go on guard duty, and that’s it.”\nSome of the people involved in the events in Kursk had other motivations: for example, Ruslan told us that he deliberately volunteered to be sent to the border, and at first, his commanders were reluctant to send him there. “There’s nothing to do at the unit, and nothing interesting there,” Ruslan explains. “I wanted to join the army and really understand what it’s all about.” When asked about the risks of serving at the border, he replied: “I wasn’t particularly worried. I had thought [the Ukrainian forces] might advance, but not the way it actually happened.”\n\nSome of the conscripts did not tell their relatives that they were serving right at the border. “It turns out they only found out in September, when I returned [from captivity],” Andrei told IStories. “All that time, I’d been saying that I wasn’t there, that I was 40 kilometers away.”\n\nSometimes the conscripts’ commanders went along with this cover story. “My mom would call them and ask where I was. They’d say 'he is fine, he is in the unit', even though I was at the border. So they were lying, so it turns out,” said one of the captured soldiers. Some relatives tried to keep conscripts from being sent to the border. “They sent letters to the prosecutor’s office and to every possible authority,” Eduard Shulz told. “But [the commanders] sent us anyway. They said there weren’t enough people, enough mobilized soldiers and contract soldiers.”\n\nThe training level of the conscripts varied significantly. According to one of our interviewees, at the training unit they had been trained intensively for four months, were taught to utilize various types of weapons, and were trained to identify drones by sound. Another conscript recalls that even instructors from the Russian Army's elite Special Operations Forces were brought in to help with the training. At the same time, there were conscripts stationed at the border who, by their own account, had only fired a few bullets at a basic training course.\n\nThe conscripts' daily routine at the border was almost identical. They served at strongpoints — well-fortified underground facilities with a network of tunnels and observation posts. The soldiers would dig trenches and build dugouts, and they regularly went on guard duty.\n\nContract soldiers and mobilized troops — reservists drafted due to the war — also served alongside them, but in much smaller numbers. According to our interviewees, conscripts made up the majority at many positions, accounting for 50 to 85 percent of the personnel.\n\nThe beginning\n\nBorder guards and conscripts at the “Sudzha” checkpoint were the first to notice the first signs of the preparations for the incursion. On the Russian Airborne Forces Day, August 2, there had been more FPV drones in the sky, Georgy Ivankov recounted. The drones disrupted the communications and then dropped anti-tank mines onto the conscripts’ position; Ivankov suffered a concussion. From that moment on, both the conscripts and the border guards would take shelter in a dugout: “By August 4, no one would be getting out anymore, and we stayed in the basement until August 6, not going out anywhere.”\nSimilar events had been unfolding further north, at Russian troop positions near Sverdlikovo. “For three days and three nights, FPVs [drones], ‘Baba Yagas’ [the Russian nickname for Ukrainian heavy drones capable of carrying cargo and dropping mines], as well as artillery, had been firing at us before the upcoming assault,” Alexander Kuzmenkov, the commander of the conscripts, later described. Another stronghold near Sverdlikovo came under tank fire; at least seven border guards were wounded in a battle on August 4.\nAt neighboring positions, the Ukrainian preparations were also observed. “We had a ‘Mavic’ drone in our platoon. We’d fly it out on reconnaissance missions,” Ivan Badanin recalled. “We’d already seen that the Ukrainian Army soldiers were preparing an advance, because we saw military vehicles passing by. We reported all the data and coordinates, but the commander wasn’t interested. He said everything was fine — they were just going about their business over there.” Although the commanders didn’t mention the impending offensive, by the evening of August 5, the conscripts realized that “it was going to be a very intense night.”\nOn the night of August 5–6, Ukrainian artillery launched massive shelling on Russian positions along a large stretch of the border. As morning approached, the Ukrainian Armed Forces struck the headquarters of the 17th and 18th battalions of the 488th Regiment.\n“At 4:27 a.m., a rocket strike hit our headquarters,” Denis Glushko recalled. “The headquarters collapsed; everyone was concussed.” According to another captured conscript, four people were burned alive. After the strike on the headquarters, the commander of the 17th Battalion and the other officers “quietly left the scene, just drove away.” The command of the 18th Battalion did the same, conscript Anton Safonov recounted. A staff officer later told the soldiers that there would be no evacuation: “Nobody gives a shit about us; zero fucks given.”\n\nNikolaevo-Daryino\n\nNikolaevo-Daryino is a border village five kilometers west of Sverdlikovo, where by August 6, dozens of conscripts had already been under daily shelling for several days.\n\nAround 1:00 a.m. on August 6, the conscripts defending two strongholds near Nikolaevo-Daryino heard military vehicles moving near the very border. Then came a barrage from all types of weapons: mortars, “Grad” multiple-launch rocket systems, FPV drones, and UAVs carrying mines. By the morning, when everything had quieted down, the Ukrainian military vehicles had already passed the Russians’ border positions.\n\nMaxim and his late fellow soldier were unknowingly walking toward them. According to the conscript, it was there that he “saw death up close for the first time.” Once the shock had worn off, Maxim turned back and found himself in a wheat field: “It seemed to me that if I stood up in the middle of the field and ran, they wouldn’t notice me. I was just starting to get to my feet when several bullets whizzed past my head again. In the end, they set the wheat field on fire with a drone. I kept crawling; the field was quite large — almost a kilometer. As I was reaching the edge of the field, the fire was already a meter away from me. There was a gully, so there I stood up and started firing roughly in the direction of the forest belt from which they’d been shooting at us. I put my rifle on safe and tumbled down that gully.”\n\nMaxim ran back to his position and reported his fellow soldier's death to the commander. “He was in a state of shock himself,” recalls the conscript. “He kept asking if he’d misheard me, then started contacting the headquarters. He said, ‘Fucking hell, I’ve already suffered casualties.’ And the headquarters commander was like, ‘Calm the fuck down! Pull your shit together, you bitch.’ And the connection cut out. Then the headquarters commander gave us the order to launch an assault — and there were only seven of us.” Maxim convinced everyone that heading toward the border was dangerous, so he stayed at the strongpoint with his fellow servicemen.\n\nOn the third line, in the village of Nizhny Klin, there was stationed a medical platoon. It was mostly made up of conscripts. As one of them told IStories, the nighttime artillery barrage did not affect them, but around 7 a.m., the soldiers heard gunfire and put on their gear. “There were no specific orders, so we had to improvise. The commanders weren’t prepared for such situations either,” our interviewee recalls. The conscripts and the platoon command abandoned their positions and took cover in the forest.\n\nThe 30th Artillery Brigade's position was located 10 km from the border, in Novoivanovka. Following the Ukrainian advance, nine conscript artillerymen would be listed as missing in action; five of them were later declared dead. Their official date of death is August 6, 2024. It is likely that their position became a priority target and immediately came under fire from the Ukrainian Army.\n\nFirst POWs\nFirst reports on conscripts being captured appeared on the evening of August 6. Drone footage shows several people walking along a road with their hands tied behind their backs. Danil Kolesnikov was among them: Ukrainian blogger Dmytro Karpenko later posted a video featuring the conscript.\nKolesnikov had been stationed at the “Cross” position just 100 meters from the border. By the moment of the offensive, the conscripts and the border guards had been sheltering in the basement for four days due to constant shelling.\nWhen a tank began firing at a concrete building above the basement early in the morning of August 6, the soldiers in the shelter decided to abandon their position. But they did not have time to: grenades rained down into the basement, and the entrances were consumed by fire. Nine men surrendered, and several border guards were killed in the firefight. The road to Sudzha, which had been covered by the “Cross” strongpoint, was now left open to the advancing Ukrainian troops.\n\nThe Sudzha border crossing point\n\nOne of the most heavily fortified strongholds was the Sudzha international road border crossing: several buildings that in peaceful times had been used by the border service to inspect the vehicles crossing the border.\n\nAccording to one of the captured soldiers, only the conscripts, along with their commander, were stationed on the front line, right at the border. They did not receive the order to retreat from the border toward the Sudzha crossing point until the evening of August 6. Вy then, the shelling had lasted all day, and more than 50 people had gathered at the crossing point — conscripts from the “Oleshnya-2” position in a neighboring village had arrived there that same evening. It was ordered not to surrender the point, and the soldiers were denied evacuation.\nThe next morning, Ukrainian forces launched an assault on the checkpoint. “The first wave was more or less over, then came the second. That was it — nothing was left of the facility except for a concrete room,” one of the soldiers recalled. He said the conscripts were loading magazines for the border guards, who were firing back at the advancing Ukrainian troops.\n\n“We were sitting in some small room in the very center,” another conscript recounted. “There was essentially nothing left around us. And the tank firing at our left and then at our right. We knew that if it hit us directly just once or twice, it would be a mass grave right there.”\n\n“Someone said, ‘Count the shells — the tank can’t keep firing endlessly,’” recalled a captured soldier. “So I counted them.” The shelling continued for about an hour; the fifteenth shell hit the room where the wounded were lying, and they were trapped under the rubble. After the sixteenth shell, the surviving officers decided to surrender, and, on the evening of August 7, several dozen people were taken captive, according to videos published on Ukrainian media.\nSverdlikovo\n\nJust seven kilometers to the north, the Sputnik stronghold — which was also mostly filled with conscripts — ended up surrounded quickly. The UAF were not attempting an assault. “They were just shelling us to keep us from sticking out,” the conscripts’ commander, Major Bykov, told. “The company commander contacted us, and I asked if he knew anything. He said, ‘There's no communication with the higher [command], none at all.’”\n\nAfter several days of shelling and negotiations with the Ukrainian forces, Bykov convinced his comrades to abandon their position without a fight. According to him, a total of 29 people (including 23 conscripts) from Sputnik surrendered.\nThe next day, August 10, the Ukrainian Armed Forces launched an assault on the second stronghold, Styk (“Junction”), near Sverdlikovo. Until then, a group of conscripts had been stationed there in relatively calm conditions, reinforced by mortar crews who had retreated from near Daryino. According to IStories estimates, at least four conscripts may have been killed during the Styk assault on August 10.\n\nSome of the survivors, following orders from the senior staff officer, managed to withdraw to the third strongpoint, “Moscow.” There, Captain Kuzmenkov’s troops held their ground until August 14. After several assaults, he also resolved to surrender: “When there are no other options left, the choice is to sacrifice the men or try to save their lives. Maybe at my own expense. But I think their mothers will be grateful.”\n\nOleshnya\n\nAccording to our estimates, the heaviest losses — at least 15 people killed or missing — were suffered by conscripts holding positions near the village of Oleshnya.\n\nSimilar to other locations, the shelling there began as early as August 2–3. “At night, they started bombing everyone; we couldn’t do anything at all — we just sat there. Then they started shelling us with artillery, it seemed,” recounted a conscript from the Oleshnya-2 stronghold. “A radio message came through saying they’d taken over all of Oleshnya-1 and were heading our way.” The commander ordered the conscripts to withdraw to the Sudzha crossing point, where they faced the major offensive there.\n\nAt least four conscripts were killed near Oleshnya on the second day — August 7. Mikhail Zelensky and two other soldiers managed to escape from their position and reach a command post further back from the front lines. However, Ukrainian troops had already taken up positions there. Zelensky and his comrades hid in a wooded area and did not leave it.\n\nMagomed was one of the conscripts stationed at Oleshnya and killed during the operation. According to his relative, Magomed’s position was attacked on August 6. The command ordered the soldiers not to leave the strongpoint and promised to send in reinforcements, but no one except a zampolit — political commissar, an officer responsible for indoctrination and morale issues — arrived at the position. Later, in a conversation with Magomed’s family, the officer claimed that he had to abandon the conscript and two other soldiers at the strongpoint in order to save a group of 22 conscripts. According to the conscripts who broke out of the encirclement, Magomed and his comrades managed to retreat to Gogolevka, where they were killed by a grenade explosion in a dugout.\n\nAnother captured conscript shared a similar story about the zampolit who had arrived at the border. They and the border guards split into four groups and headed for Gogolevka. On the morning of August 7, Ukrainian troops attempted to capture one of the groups. In the firefight, the conscript said, nine people were killed, and only three survived.\n\nOn the run\n\nSmall groups of conscripts with some border guards and a handful of officers among them went on to hide in the forests for weeks and would be captured by the Ukrainian military almost daily until the end of August.\n\nAndrey from the Vologda Oblast told IStories that he spent about six days in the forest with other soldiers. The conscripts would drink swamp water and eat grass, nettles, and rowan branches. “Nettles actually taste the best,” says Andrei. “Rowan branches have a soft tip at the end. You can chew on that, too.” Some conscripts were luckier, if near the forests where they hid there were sunflower or soybean fields.\n\nSergey Yershov and another soldier split from their medical platoon in Nizhny Klin and spent more than 50 days in the woods. In late September, they made their way to Russian troops, after which the conscripts were sent to a hospital. The medical platoon where Yershov served had surrendered on August 12. One of his fellow soldiers told IStories that he had returned to Russia via a prisoner exchange as early as August 24.\n\nOn the eastern flank, where the 252nd Motorized Rifle Regiment was holding the line near the villages of Plyokhovo and Borki, the Ukrainian troops broke through the border as well, but were unable to advance further. The retreating conscripts wandered through the forests and swamps for several days, being hit by artillery fire and drones, one of them, Alexander, told us.\n\nFinally, on August 14, they made it to Borki, where a local resident sheltered them: “He was quite an interesting character. As far as I could tell, he hadn’t left because he was on a drinking bender. He brought us whatever food he had at home, and some water to drink. Getting water was really hard: all we had was water from the outdoor shower, and also from a bathtub that had been filled.”\n\nBy that time, Ukrainian troops had already taken over the village. Alexander and his sergeant kept an eye on the vehicles passing by the house, noting down the coordinates on a piece of paper and texting them to their command: “They would strike those pickup trucks with drones, and those houses the Ukrainians stationed in as well.”\n\nA few days later, the water in the tub was gone, so the soldiers removed the water heater and took apart the pipes to drain the remaining water from there. Meanwhile, the homeowner was cruising around the village on a scooter looking for alcohol. “This is a guy who doesn’t care what’s going on around him; all he wants is to find some moonshine,” Alexander says. “The Ukrainian soldiers had to warn him: ‘Don’t ride here. It’s mined; don’t go there.’”\n\nThe soldiers took turns on duty, and spent the rest of their time reading the books in the house. By the time active fighting reached Borki, there was hardly a single building left intact in the village.\n\n“They started searching the houses, just in case someone had slipped through,” the conscript recalls. “I was in the annex at the time [on duty], with no ballistic vest and no helmet. I mean, what was the point?? We were in the middle of nowhere with God knows how many of them around. I just put my rifle on the ground and sat down. They opened the door, and there I was, just sitting. They were very surprised and said, ‘Don’t make any sudden moves; everything will be fine.’ And then they started searching the whole house.”\n\nThe Ukrainian soldiers told Alexander and the other captives that one of the conscripts had shot himself: “We had a conversation [with the soldier who shot himself] about how you mustn’t [surrender],” says Alexander.\n\nThe captured Russians were given food and cigarettes. “When [the Ukrainian soldiers] realized that we were conscripts and that we’d been stuck here for about a month, they were surprised and said, ‘Wow, you guys are tough,’” Alexander recalls.\n\nVeseloye\n\nIn mid-September, the Ukrainian Armed Forces broke through the border in Kursk Oblast once again, this time about 30 km west of the existing front line. Despite the fact that the incursion had been going on for over a month, recent Russian conscripts from Airborne Forces units were still stationed at the border positions. Later, those of them taken captive explained that, officially, they were located at a training ground in Pskov Oblast, not in the combat zone.\n\nA new Ukrainian offensive in another sector of Kursk Oblast was faced by Russian conscripts from the 234th Airborne Assault Regiment, the 217th Parachute Regiment, and the 1140th Artillery Regiment.\n\nIn the first days of the Ukrainian breakthrough in the Glushkovsky District, at least eight Airborne Forces conscripts were killed. Some of them were likely stationed at a rural school building in Veseloye, 3.5 km from the border, according to their relatives' posts on social media.\n\nAccording to the “Russian Spring’s War Reporters” Telegram channel, the school building was destroyed by a U.S. precision-guided air bomb. The UAF unit Khorne Group published a video of the strike. Our estimates indicate that the total losses among conscripts in this area of the front may have exceeded 20 people since August 2024.\n\nCapture, exchange, and demobilization\n\nAndrey, a conscript from Vologda Oblast, recounts that he was taken captive after several days in the woods. “They brought me to some house. There, some Ukrainian women started bandaging my wounds again. The whole time, they kept saying that I had come onto their land, that I was killing their children, killing their husbands, that ‘you’re all so bad, but we’re still helping you — although we could have abandoned you,’ Andrei recounts their conversation. “I told them I was defending my country. I didn’t set foot on your land. I was on my own.”\n\nConscripts who were taken prisoner were called in for interrogations, another interviewee told us. “Some would be called in and tell everything — absolutely everything: the positions, the roles, — he says. — Sure, they were threatened and beaten, but there were no bruises, the specialists know how to beat people with no bruises. But I was lucky. I once wandered into the SBU [State Security of Ukraine] office by accident. They decided to interrogate me, and when they found out where I worked [as a train attendant], they asked, ‘Do you know anything about Metro-2?’ [the secret tunnels under Moscow intended for the country’s leadership]. I said, ‘Well, I just know stuff from books,’ — and that seemed funny to me. They said, ‘Why are you laughing? Face down on the floor, or we’ll beat you up right here!’” However, they didn’t do anything, and the conscript was released.\n\nSeveral conscripts we managed to speak with describe the conditions in captivity as satisfactory. “The food wasn’t anything special — it was just what the other prisoners there ate. There were Ukrainians in the same prison as well,” says Alexander.\n\n“They did feed us, but the food was not tasty at all,” Yevgeny recalls. “The tastiest thing we had there was bread. Since it’s warm there and trees grow, we would pick apples — we made a stick to reach the trees through the bars.”\n\n“At one point, I was afraid [I would be tortured],” recalls Andrei. “The guys in the cell next to me said they would try to make them speak Ukrainian. They’d say something to me in Ukrainian as well, and I was supposed to answer, but I didn’t understand it and played dumb. I thought something [some kind of punishment] would follow. When I realized that they don't punish you, don’t even do anything of the kind, I understood that I was in a normal prison. Everything settled down for me, so I totally stopped being afraid.”\n\nTwo weeks after the incursion into Kursk Oblast began, on August 24, the first POW exchange took place, and 115 conscripts returned to Russia. They were seated on a bus and sent to the Belarus border. According to our interviewees, no one knew their destination until the very last moment: the prisoners thought they were being taken to some sort of a special settlement.\n\nAfter returning to Russia, the wounded soldiers were sent to a hospital, but one of the men we spoke to refused to go there. “The guys I thought had died turned out to have been taken captives; they were exchanged along with me. I couldn’t bear to be separated from them for even a week,” Andrey explains. “Lying above me was my buddy, whom I thought had died, but he survived. To my left lay another buddy who had survived. I was so happy that they were alive, I didn’t need any hospital.”\n\nAfter “investigative procedures” and a medical examination in Moscow, the soldiers who did not require hospitalization were reassigned to military units. There, they served out the remainder of their terms (six to eight weeks) and were then discharged, the conscripts who returned from captivity told us.\n\nAccording to one of them, some of the conscripts who went through the exchange were then sent back to the border in Bryansk Oblast. They spent more than a month there.\n\nThe aftermath\n\nThe prisoner exchanges went on into 2025. In April, Mikhail Zelensky and the conscripts captured in the Glushkovo area came back to Russia. “I Want to Live” — a Ukrainian government project established for the Russian soldiers to willingly surrender into captivity — informed the IStories and Verstka that about 500 conscripts have been exchanged. Two years after the Kursk Oblast operation, none of the Russian conscripts remained in captivity.\n\nOn April 26, 2025, Chief of the General Staff Valery Gerasimov reported to Vladimir Putin about the “crushing defeat suffered by Ukrainian armed formations” in Kursk Oblast. The search for the bodies of the fallen conscripts and their extraction only became possible after Russian troops reached the border again.\n\nThe mother of a soldier who is still considered missing in action told us that her son’s body was never found at the position near Sverdlikovo. “I periodically call Rostov-on-Don [where the bodies are identified at the Center for Reception, Registration, and Transfer of the Deceased]. There’s been no DNA match,” she says. “[They say that] it’s impossible to carry out a recovery there — drones are flying, and the area hasn’t been cleared of mines.”\n\nConscripts listed as missing in action were being officially declared deceased one by one throughout 2025. The last known case of a status change occurred in May 2026 — nearly two years after the soldier’s death.\n\nIn total, at least 77 conscripts were killed in the first months of fighting in Kursk Oblast. According to IStories and Verstka's estimates, about 30 more people are still considered missing in action.\n\nLife after the war\n\nAlexander says that before his mandatory military service, he was seriously planning to sign a military contract [to go to war against Ukraine voluntarily], as he was “really eager” to. “But my mother is a very anxious person, and we agreed that I would serve my mandatory service first, and then, if I hadn’t changed my mind, I could sign a contract,” Alexander explains. “When I came back after all of that, of course, I thought about it for a long time; the officers were encouraging me to sign. For better or for worse, but I changed my mind.”\n\n“The effects of the concussion haven’t gone away even though it’s been two years,” Mikhail tells us. “Emotionally, all [feelings] are gone. All that’s left is aggression. Maybe a little joy sometimes. It only takes a split second to set me off — and that’s it, I explode. It’s very hard to control all of this.”\n\nAccording to Mikhail, his hearing was severely damaged. “I always wear an earbud — at least one — with music playing constantly,” he says. “There’s a very loud ringing [in my ears], and it won’t go away.” Mikhail has not received any government assistance, so he is currently paying for his treatment out of his own pocket.\n\nThe mother of one of these conscripts also told us that some of them have not received any support from the government. “His concussion was so severe that he was almost unconscious when he was taken prisoner,” says Ekaterina. “When he came home from the army, he practically refused to talk to me. He would just lie in bed, turned away. We spent a year struggling to get him recognized as a combat veteran because there were no documents on him. The documents were restored, and he underwent treatment, but his condition wasn’t recognized as a combat-related injury. He now suffers from constant high blood pressure, headaches and insomnia. I’m currently paying for all his treatment out of my own pocket.”\n\nSome conscripts face similar difficulties in receiving the payments they’re entitled to for the injuries and participation in the “counterterrorism operation zone” (the CTO in Kursk Oblast was declared on August 10). “Until I went to the prosecutor’s office, they didn’t want to pay me the regional [injury compensation],” says Andrey.\n\n“I didn’t receive my combat veteran status until December of 2025,” says Timur. “I haven’t received any payments for the days I spent in the CTO zone. I’m still working through these issues with lawyers.”\n\n“It was specifically the 18th Battalion [of the 488th Regiment] that didn’t get a single ruble,\" Egor explains. “The guys who served in other units received decent payments. They paid the demobilized soldiers from our unit — who had already left long ago by August — but they didn’t pay us. We’re basically not counting on it anymore.”\n\nAccording to other conscripts, they “weren’t wronged financially” — with the money from the government, some were able to buy a car or a plot of land to build a house. Andrey used the compensation he received to buy an apartment in his hometown and started a business with a fellow soldier. “If it weren’t for [the journalists’ questions], I wouldn’t even have remembered about the army time,” he says. “I used to go crazy at night. New Year’s Eve, fireworks — that’s it; I’d hide in some basement listening to them. Well, yeah, my mind goes into overdrive at night sometimes. Things just get scary in my head. You wake up covered in sweat.”\n\nAndrey calls his experience serving in the army “a school of life.” “I come home, look at my uniform, and remember: it turns out I really was there. I became physically fit there, maybe more experienced, and started looking at things with a more mature perspective,” Andrey reflects. “You remember a lot of good things. We get together with our fellow soldiers and have fun — and everything’s great. We remember our jokes. Then we remember those who can no longer be here to hear those jokes. As the saying goes, we started by toasting to their health and ended by toasting to their rest in peace. Overall, it’s good that I’m here, on my own two feet, with both arms intact — everything’s fine, and I’ve got my head on my shoulders. Fate is such a thing: what if I hadn’t been in the army? Or, let’s say, what if things had turned out just a little differently? I probably wouldn’t be standing here. That’s just how things turn out, and sometimes it’s strange.”","blocks":[{"data":"On the night of August 5-6, 2024, the Russian soldiers stationed near the Russian-Ukrainian border in Kursk Oblast heard military vehicles moving. They reported the suspicious activity across the border to their headquarters, and in the morning, they got an order to send two men on a reconnaissance mission to a neighboring platoon stationed closer to the border. Maxim and his comrade — both conscripts — volunteered.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"When they almost reached their destination, they saw two vehicles in the forest belt: \"We thought those were two ‘UAZ Hunters’ and headed over there, [thinking our platoon was there].” We heard an unintelligible shout from there, and then shooting started.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“After that, everything was like slow motion,” Maxim recalls. “My fellow soldier turned toward me, and I saw three bullets hit him in the head. I just fell onto the asphalt, looked at my comrade’s body, and realized there was no way to help him. The first thought that crossed my mind was that this was a dream, that it wasn’t real. And then I came to my senses when they started shooting at me.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>*****</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Maxim’s fellow soldier is just one of dozens of young conscripts who died as a result of the Ukrainian incursion campaign into Kursk Oblast. IStories and <a href=\"https://verstka.media/srochniki-na-vojne\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Verstka</a> have counted at least 77 conscripts who died in the region’s border zone in 2024. As of this publication, over 30 more remain missing. It is likely that over time they will also be officially recognized as dead. According to our data, in 2026, Russian authorities have been still registering the deaths of conscripts who went missing two years ago.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18868,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/b5ba2671e1b2472181a30adaefbf8252/index.html","url_mobile":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/b5ba2671e1b2472181a30adaefbf8252/index.html","ratio_mobile":"9:16","ratio_desktop":"full-height"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"IStories and Verstka have spoken with surviving conscripts and relatives of those who served on the border, analyzed open sources, and reconstructed the course of events in the Kursk Oblast in August and September 2024.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18869,"data":{"block":"<p>We spoke with eight conscripts who were stationed at the border when the incursion into the Kursk Oblast began, as well as with five other servicemen&#x27;s relatives. The names of all interviewees have been changed for security reasons.</p><p><br/></p><p>To get the full picture, we also studied Ukrainian bloggers&#x27; interviews with Russians taken captive in the Kursk region. There are over 50 of such interviews. </p><p><br/></p><p>Interviews with prisoners of war cannot be viewed as an absolutely reliable source of information: by some lawyers, they might even be interpreted as acts of “public curiosity” according to the <a href=\"https://www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/geneva-convention-relative-treatment-prisoners-war\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Geneva Convention</a>. Besides, some of the interviews might have been given involuntarily (although Ukrainian bloggers emphasize that POWs can always refuse to be interviewed). We cross-checked the facts stated by the captured soldiers when it was possible. However, both their statements and the accounts of our interviewees may contain inaccuracies and distortions that are difficult to check independently.</p><p><br/></p><p>To calculate the number of conscripts killed and missing, we used social media posts. We confirmed deaths using official data and public obituaries. The deaths and disappearances of some servicemen were also confirmed to us by eyewitnesses. Conscripts for whom there has been no news since the reports of their disappearance in 2024 are classified as missing in action.</p>","header":"Sources used in the research","content":[{"insert":"We spoke with eight conscripts who were stationed at the border when the incursion into the Kursk Oblast began, as well as with five other servicemen's relatives. The names of all interviewees have been changed for security reasons.\n\nTo get the full picture, we also studied Ukrainian bloggers' interviews with Russians taken captive in the Kursk region. There are over 50 of such interviews. \n\nInterviews with prisoners of war cannot be viewed as an absolutely reliable source of information: by some lawyers, they might even be interpreted as acts of “public curiosity” according to the "},{"insert":"Geneva Convention","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/geneva-convention-relative-treatment-prisoners-war","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":". Besides, some of the interviews might have been given involuntarily (although Ukrainian bloggers emphasize that POWs can always refuse to be interviewed). We cross-checked the facts stated by the captured soldiers when it was possible. However, both their statements and the accounts of our interviewees may contain inaccuracies and distortions that are difficult to check independently.\n\nTo calculate the number of conscripts killed and missing, we used social media posts. We confirmed deaths using official data and public obituaries. The deaths and disappearances of some servicemen were also confirmed to us by eyewitnesses. Conscripts for whom there has been no news since the reports of their disappearance in 2024 are classified as missing in action.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":{"id":19478,"data":{"url":"https://www.youtube.com/embed/0mOICS0eTN8","caption":"","provider":"youtube","rawInput":"https://youtu.be/0mOICS0eTN8","ratio_mobile":"16:9","ratio_desktop":"16:9"},"category":"video-embed"},"type":"video-embed"},{"data":"How the conscripts ended up at the border","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Starting in late March 2024, the conscripts drafted in the autumn began arriving at the border in the Kursk Oblast. At some locations, they replaced the demobee conscripts — those approaching the termination of their service. “We learned from them that there’s nothing much going on there, but you’re sitting at point zero, at the ‘ribbon’ [front line], so you see the enemy, and they see you,” Nikita Litvinyuk <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4IeEgHIru0M&amp;t=181s\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">recounted</a> after being taken captive by the Ukrainian Armed Forces (UAF). “You stay still and so do they.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At a military unit in Klintsy, Bryansk Oblast (where the 488th Regiment is stationed), the soldiers were assured that they would be stationed behind the border guards and contract soldiers. “To be honest, I was happy because I knew it would be a bit more relaxed than at the unit,” <a href=\"http://youtube.com/watch?si=6gJjgTxxLSBZLzCy&amp;t=165&amp;v=SmPqEtiaIfg&amp;feature=youtu.be\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">said</a> a captured conscript. “At the unit, they push us hard: marching, drills, all that stuff. But everyone says it’s calm at the border — nothing too demanding, you just sit around, go on guard duty, and that’s it.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18870,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the conscripts’ social media pages","caption":"The conscripts would serve in the strongpoints at the ‘point zero’","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e20c6426629e4458bc6aefd05f284ff1-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e20c6426629e4458bc6aefd05f284ff1-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e20c6426629e4458bc6aefd05f284ff1-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e20c6426629e4458bc6aefd05f284ff1-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e20c6426629e4458bc6aefd05f284ff1-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e20c6426629e4458bc6aefd05f284ff1-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e20c6426629e4458bc6aefd05f284ff1-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e20c6426629e4458bc6aefd05f284ff1-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e20c6426629e4458bc6aefd05f284ff1-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e20c6426629e4458bc6aefd05f284ff1-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e20c6426629e4458bc6aefd05f284ff1-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e20c6426629e4458bc6aefd05f284ff1-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e20c6426629e4458bc6aefd05f284ff1-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e20c6426629e4458bc6aefd05f284ff1-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e20c6426629e4458bc6aefd05f284ff1-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e20c6426629e4458bc6aefd05f284ff1-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e20c6426629e4458bc6aefd05f284ff1-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e20c6426629e4458bc6aefd05f284ff1-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Some of the people involved in the events in Kursk had other motivations: for example, Ruslan told us that he deliberately volunteered to be sent to the border, and at first, his commanders were reluctant to send him there. “There’s nothing to do at the unit, and nothing interesting there,” Ruslan explains. “I wanted to join the army and really understand what it’s all about.” When asked about the risks of serving at the border, he replied: “I wasn’t particularly worried. I had thought [the Ukrainian forces] might advance, but not the way it actually happened.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Some of the conscripts did not tell their relatives that they were serving right at the border. “It turns out they only found out in September, when I returned [from captivity],” Andrei told IStories. “All that time, I’d been saying that I wasn’t there, that I was 40 kilometers away.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Sometimes the conscripts’ commanders went along with this cover story. “My mom would call them and ask where I was. They’d say 'he is fine, he is in the unit', even though I was at the border. So they were lying, so it turns out,” <a href=\"https://youtu.be/eDU89zetvZs?si=-0K1sCz-0E-fRSwU&amp;t=109\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">said</a> one of the captured soldiers. Some relatives tried to keep conscripts from being sent to the border. “They sent letters to the prosecutor’s office and to every possible authority,” Eduard Shulz <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xyvMXdH5mDk&amp;t=104s\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">told</a>. “But [the commanders] sent us anyway. They said there weren’t enough people, enough mobilized soldiers and contract soldiers.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The training level of the conscripts varied significantly. According to one of our interviewees, at the training unit they had been trained intensively for four months, were taught to utilize various types of weapons, and were trained to identify drones by sound. Another conscript recalls that even instructors from the Russian Army's elite Special Operations Forces were brought in to help with the training. At the same time, there were conscripts stationed at the border who, by their own account, had only fired a few bullets at a basic training course.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The conscripts' daily routine at the border was almost identical. They served at <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZHXX6Blxx80\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">strongpoints </a>— well-fortified underground facilities with a network of tunnels and observation posts. The soldiers would dig trenches and build dugouts, and they regularly went on guard duty.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Contract soldiers and mobilized troops — reservists drafted due to the war — also served alongside them, but in much smaller numbers. According to our interviewees, conscripts made up the majority at many positions, accounting for 50 to 85 percent of the personnel.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The beginning","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":{"id":18871,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/96e834ca9b56490ab33adc7795ad7b07/index.html","url_mobile":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/96e834ca9b56490ab33adc7795ad7b07/index.html","ratio_mobile":"full-width-and-height-scroll","ratio_desktop":"full-width-and-height-scroll"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed","platform":"web"},{"data":"Border guards and conscripts at the “Sudzha” checkpoint were the first to notice the first signs of the preparations for the incursion. On the Russian Airborne Forces Day, August 2, there had been more FPV drones in the sky, Georgy Ivankov <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Id3tdUahAIA&amp;t=1354s\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">recounted</a>. The drones disrupted the communications and then dropped anti-tank mines onto the conscripts’ position; Ivankov suffered a concussion. From that moment on, both the conscripts and the border guards would take shelter in a dugout: “By August 4, no one would be getting out anymore, and we stayed in the basement until August 6, not going out anywhere.”","type":"p","platform":"app","className":""},{"data":"Similar events had been unfolding further north, at Russian troop positions near Sverdlikovo. “For three days and three nights, FPVs [drones], ‘Baba Yagas’ [the Russian nickname for Ukrainian heavy drones capable of carrying cargo and dropping mines], as well as artillery, had been firing at us before the upcoming assault,” Alexander Kuzmenkov, the commander of the conscripts, later <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AOQoe3UAG0k&amp;t=414s\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">described</a>. Another stronghold near Sverdlikovo came under tank fire; at least seven border guards were wounded in a battle on August 4.","type":"p","platform":"app","className":""},{"data":"At neighboring positions, the Ukrainian preparations were also observed. “We had a ‘Mavic’ drone in our platoon. We’d fly it out on reconnaissance missions,” Ivan Badanin <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uvJKvsU-3Kw&amp;t=201s\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">recalled</a>. “We’d already seen that the Ukrainian Army soldiers were preparing an advance, because we saw military vehicles passing by. We reported all the data and coordinates, but the commander wasn’t interested. He said everything was fine — they were just going about their business over there.” Although the commanders didn’t mention the impending offensive, by the evening of August 5, the conscripts <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w8dSHrK8a9w&amp;t=662s\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">realized </a>that “it was going to be a very intense night.”","type":"p","platform":"app","className":""},{"data":"On the night of August 5–6, Ukrainian artillery launched massive shelling on Russian positions along a large stretch of the border. As morning approached, the Ukrainian Armed Forces struck the headquarters of the 17th and 18th battalions of the 488th Regiment.","type":"p","platform":"app","className":""},{"data":"“At 4:27 a.m., a rocket strike hit our headquarters,” Denis Glushko <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w8dSHrK8a9w&amp;t=464s\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">recalled</a>. “The headquarters collapsed; everyone was concussed.” According to <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WBD_6zCzf68&amp;t=1067s\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">another </a>captured conscript, four people were burned alive. After the strike on the headquarters, the commander of the 17th Battalion and the other officers “quietly left the scene, just drove away.” The command of the 18th Battalion <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6l90sKKpTfE&amp;t=34s\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">did the same</a>, conscript Anton Safonov recounted. A staff officer later told the soldiers that there would be no evacuation: “Nobody gives a shit about us; zero fucks given.”","type":"p","platform":"app","className":""},{"data":"Nikolaevo-Daryino","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Nikolaevo-Daryino is a border village five kilometers west of Sverdlikovo, where by August 6, dozens of conscripts had already been under daily shelling for several days.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Around 1:00 a.m. on August 6, the conscripts defending two strongholds near Nikolaevo-Daryino <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uvJKvsU-3Kw&amp;t=306s\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">heard</a> military vehicles moving near the very border. Then came a barrage from all types of weapons: mortars, “Grad” multiple-launch rocket systems, FPV drones, and UAVs carrying mines. By the morning, when everything had quieted down, the Ukrainian military vehicles had already passed the Russians’ border positions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Maxim and his late fellow soldier were unknowingly walking toward them. According to the conscript, it was there that he “saw death up close for the first time.” Once the shock had worn off, Maxim turned back and found himself in a wheat field: “It seemed to me that if I stood up in the middle of the field and ran, they wouldn’t notice me. I was just starting to get to my feet when several bullets whizzed past my head again. In the end, they set the wheat field on fire with a drone. I kept crawling; the field was quite large — almost a kilometer. As I was reaching the edge of the field, the fire was already a meter away from me. There was a gully, so there I stood up and started firing roughly in the direction of the forest belt from which they’d been shooting at us. I put my rifle on safe and tumbled down that gully.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Maxim ran back to his position and reported his fellow soldier's death to the commander. “He was in a state of shock himself,” recalls the conscript. “He kept asking if he’d misheard me, then started contacting the headquarters. He said, ‘Fucking hell, I’ve already suffered casualties.’ And the headquarters commander was like, ‘Calm the fuck down! Pull your shit together, you bitch.’ And the connection cut out. Then the headquarters commander gave us the order to launch an assault — and there were only seven of us.” Maxim convinced everyone that heading toward the border was dangerous, so he stayed at the strongpoint with his fellow servicemen.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"On the third line, in the village of Nizhny Klin, there was stationed a medical platoon. It was mostly made up of conscripts. As one of them told IStories, the nighttime artillery barrage did not affect them, but around 7 a.m., the soldiers heard gunfire and put on their gear. “There were no specific orders, so we had to improvise. The commanders weren’t prepared for such situations either,” our interviewee recalls. The conscripts and the platoon command abandoned their positions and took cover in the forest.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The 30th Artillery Brigade's position was located 10 km from the border, in Novoivanovka. Following the Ukrainian advance, nine conscript artillerymen would be listed as missing in action; five of them were later declared dead. Their official date of death is August 6, 2024. It is likely that their position became a priority target and immediately came under fire from the Ukrainian Army.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"First POWs","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":{"id":18879,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/a12b932bc9724851a00baeb74b4ba451/index.html","url_mobile":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/a12b932bc9724851a00baeb74b4ba451/index.html","ratio_mobile":"full-width-and-height-scroll","ratio_desktop":"full-width-and-height-scroll"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed","platform":"web"},{"data":"First reports on conscripts being captured <a href=\"https://t.me/istories_media/7151\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">appeared</a> on the evening of August 6. Drone footage shows several people walking along a road with their hands tied behind their backs. Danil Kolesnikov was among them: Ukrainian blogger Dmytro Karpenko later <a href=\"http://youtube.com/watch?si=5c2k-jSDHiXf77-D&amp;v=p13osihrfzs&amp;feature=youtu.be\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">posted </a>a video featuring the conscript.","type":"p","platform":"app","className":""},{"data":{"id":18877,"data":{"author":"Social media","caption":"Conscripts from the \"Cross\" position were among the first to be captured   ","videosList":[{"url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/videos/df46721ce90f4c1bac30a17a15218831.mp4","content_type":"video/mp4"},{"url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/videos/df46721ce90f4c1bac30a17a15218831.webm","content_type":"video/webm"}],"hasControls":false},"category":"gif-embed"},"type":"gif-embed","platform":"app"},{"data":"Kolesnikov had been stationed at the “Cross” position just 100 meters from the border. By the moment of the offensive, the conscripts and the border guards had been sheltering in the basement for four days due to constant shelling.","type":"p","platform":"app","className":""},{"data":"When a tank began firing at a concrete building above the basement early in the morning of August 6, the soldiers in the shelter decided to abandon their position. But they did not have time to: grenades rained down into the basement, and the entrances were consumed by fire. Nine men surrendered, and several border guards were killed in the firefight. The road to Sudzha, which had been covered by the “Cross” strongpoint, was now left open to the advancing Ukrainian troops.","type":"p","platform":"app","className":""},{"data":"The Sudzha border crossing point","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"One of the most heavily fortified strongholds was the Sudzha international road border crossing: several buildings that in peaceful times had been used by the border service to inspect the vehicles crossing the border.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to one of the captured soldiers, only the conscripts, along with their commander, were <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AMOwO679bQw&amp;t=1239s\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">stationed</a> on the front line, right at the border. They did not receive the order to retreat from the border toward the Sudzha crossing point until the evening of August 6. Вy then, the shelling had lasted all day, and more than 50 people had gathered at the crossing point — conscripts from the “Oleshnya-2” position in a neighboring village had arrived there that same evening. It was ordered not to surrender the point, and the soldiers were denied evacuation.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18873,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Yandex.Maps","caption":"Sudzha road border crossing point before the hostilities","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e153fe742a794251a225da0a79dbd6ad-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e153fe742a794251a225da0a79dbd6ad-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e153fe742a794251a225da0a79dbd6ad-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1278,"real_width_2x":1280,"real_height_1x":858,"real_height_2x":859},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e153fe742a794251a225da0a79dbd6ad-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e153fe742a794251a225da0a79dbd6ad-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e153fe742a794251a225da0a79dbd6ad-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1278,"real_width_2x":1280,"real_height_1x":858,"real_height_2x":859},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e153fe742a794251a225da0a79dbd6ad-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e153fe742a794251a225da0a79dbd6ad-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e153fe742a794251a225da0a79dbd6ad-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":1278,"real_height_1x":805,"real_height_2x":858},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e153fe742a794251a225da0a79dbd6ad-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e153fe742a794251a225da0a79dbd6ad-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e153fe742a794251a225da0a79dbd6ad-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":1278,"real_height_1x":805,"real_height_2x":858},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e153fe742a794251a225da0a79dbd6ad-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e153fe742a794251a225da0a79dbd6ad-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e153fe742a794251a225da0a79dbd6ad-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":278,"real_height_2x":557},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e153fe742a794251a225da0a79dbd6ad-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e153fe742a794251a225da0a79dbd6ad-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e153fe742a794251a225da0a79dbd6ad-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":278,"real_height_2x":557}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The next morning, Ukrainian forces launched an assault on the checkpoint. “The first wave was more or less over, then came the second. That was it — nothing was left of the facility except for a concrete room,” one of the soldiers <a href=\"http://youtube.com/watch?si=w67XXIfhzF9UJpom&amp;t=1473&amp;v=OxQfd7icuG4&amp;feature=youtu.be\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">recalled</a>. He said the conscripts were loading magazines for the border guards, who were firing back at the advancing Ukrainian troops.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“We were sitting in some small room in the very center,” another conscript <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?si=ov_OTXanBHqm1_vm&amp;t=1458&amp;v=GotPEklWKXQ&amp;feature=youtu.be\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">recounted</a>. “There was essentially nothing left around us. And the tank firing at our left and then at our right. We knew that if it hit us directly just once or twice, it would be a mass grave right there.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Someone said, ‘Count the shells — the tank can’t keep firing endlessly,’” <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?si=8KTRRelyxJE-SZCa&amp;t=1454&amp;v=zCSTruN5L3I&amp;feature=youtu.be\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">recalled</a> a captured soldier. “So I counted them.” The shelling continued for about an hour; the fifteenth shell hit the room where the wounded were lying, and they were trapped under the rubble. After the sixteenth shell, the surviving officers decided to surrender, and, on the evening of August 7, several dozen people were taken captive, according to <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?si=qBRr-pGtjlUdAAFk&amp;v=DU95pUaONPM&amp;feature=youtu.be\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">videos</a> published on Ukrainian media.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18874,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Ukraine’s Nakhtigal UAV unit video screenshot","caption":"Dozens of Russian soldiers being captured at the Sudzha checkpoint","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/25ddb45ff79d4bd9bc5ccaede15ceefb-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/25ddb45ff79d4bd9bc5ccaede15ceefb-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/25ddb45ff79d4bd9bc5ccaede15ceefb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1914,"real_width_2x":1914,"real_height_1x":1079,"real_height_2x":1079},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/25ddb45ff79d4bd9bc5ccaede15ceefb-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/25ddb45ff79d4bd9bc5ccaede15ceefb-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/25ddb45ff79d4bd9bc5ccaede15ceefb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1914,"real_width_2x":1914,"real_height_1x":1079,"real_height_2x":1079},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/25ddb45ff79d4bd9bc5ccaede15ceefb-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/25ddb45ff79d4bd9bc5ccaede15ceefb-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/25ddb45ff79d4bd9bc5ccaede15ceefb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":1914,"real_height_1x":676,"real_height_2x":1079},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/25ddb45ff79d4bd9bc5ccaede15ceefb-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/25ddb45ff79d4bd9bc5ccaede15ceefb-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/25ddb45ff79d4bd9bc5ccaede15ceefb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":1914,"real_height_1x":676,"real_height_2x":1079},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/25ddb45ff79d4bd9bc5ccaede15ceefb-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/25ddb45ff79d4bd9bc5ccaede15ceefb-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/25ddb45ff79d4bd9bc5ccaede15ceefb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/25ddb45ff79d4bd9bc5ccaede15ceefb-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/25ddb45ff79d4bd9bc5ccaede15ceefb-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/25ddb45ff79d4bd9bc5ccaede15ceefb-original.jpg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]},{"isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5d294379a221470d8f76e1e93637b805-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5d294379a221470d8f76e1e93637b805-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5d294379a221470d8f76e1e93637b805-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1914,"real_width_2x":1914,"real_height_1x":1079,"real_height_2x":1079},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5d294379a221470d8f76e1e93637b805-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5d294379a221470d8f76e1e93637b805-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5d294379a221470d8f76e1e93637b805-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1914,"real_width_2x":1914,"real_height_1x":1079,"real_height_2x":1079},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5d294379a221470d8f76e1e93637b805-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5d294379a221470d8f76e1e93637b805-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5d294379a221470d8f76e1e93637b805-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":1914,"real_height_1x":676,"real_height_2x":1079},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5d294379a221470d8f76e1e93637b805-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5d294379a221470d8f76e1e93637b805-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5d294379a221470d8f76e1e93637b805-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":1914,"real_height_1x":676,"real_height_2x":1079},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5d294379a221470d8f76e1e93637b805-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5d294379a221470d8f76e1e93637b805-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5d294379a221470d8f76e1e93637b805-original.jpg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5d294379a221470d8f76e1e93637b805-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5d294379a221470d8f76e1e93637b805-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5d294379a221470d8f76e1e93637b805-original.jpg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"two-images-embed"},"type":"two-images-embed"},{"data":"Sverdlikovo","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Just seven kilometers to the north, the Sputnik stronghold — which was also mostly filled with conscripts — ended up surrounded quickly. The UAF were not attempting an assault. “They were just shelling us to keep us from sticking out,” the conscripts’ commander, Major Bykov, <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EPkA5lkdpzI&amp;t=704s\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">told</a>. “The company commander contacted us, and I asked if he knew anything. He said, ‘There's no communication with the higher [command], none at all.’”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After several days of shelling and negotiations with the Ukrainian forces, Bykov convinced his comrades to abandon their position without a fight. According to him, a total of 29 people (including 23 conscripts) from Sputnik surrendered.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18875,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"DeepState","caption":"Footage showing the capture of conscripts under the command of Major Bykov","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0d7a05243294581b8116e6a5da868b1-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0d7a05243294581b8116e6a5da868b1-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0d7a05243294581b8116e6a5da868b1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0d7a05243294581b8116e6a5da868b1-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0d7a05243294581b8116e6a5da868b1-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0d7a05243294581b8116e6a5da868b1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0d7a05243294581b8116e6a5da868b1-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0d7a05243294581b8116e6a5da868b1-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0d7a05243294581b8116e6a5da868b1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0d7a05243294581b8116e6a5da868b1-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0d7a05243294581b8116e6a5da868b1-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0d7a05243294581b8116e6a5da868b1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0d7a05243294581b8116e6a5da868b1-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0d7a05243294581b8116e6a5da868b1-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0d7a05243294581b8116e6a5da868b1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0d7a05243294581b8116e6a5da868b1-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0d7a05243294581b8116e6a5da868b1-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0d7a05243294581b8116e6a5da868b1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The next day, August 10, the Ukrainian Armed Forces launched an assault on the second stronghold, Styk (“Junction”), near Sverdlikovo. Until then, a group of conscripts had been stationed there in relatively calm conditions, reinforced by mortar crews who had retreated from near Daryino. According to IStories estimates, at least four conscripts may have been killed during the Styk assault on August 10.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Some of the survivors, following orders from the senior staff officer, managed to withdraw to the third strongpoint, “Moscow.” There, Captain Kuzmenkov’s troops held their ground until August 14. After several assaults, he also resolved to <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AOQoe3UAG0k&amp;t=706s\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">surrender</a>: “When there are no other options left, the choice is to sacrifice the men or try to save their lives. Maybe at my own expense. But I think their mothers will be grateful.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Oleshnya","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"According to our estimates, the heaviest losses — at least 15 people killed or missing — were suffered by conscripts holding positions near the village of Oleshnya.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Similar to other locations, the shelling there began as early as August 2–3. “At night, they started bombing everyone; we couldn’t do anything at all — we just sat there. Then they started shelling us with artillery, it seemed,” recounted a conscript from the Oleshnya-2 stronghold. “A radio message came through saying they’d taken over all of Oleshnya-1 and were heading our way.” The commander ordered the conscripts to withdraw to the Sudzha crossing point, where they faced the major offensive there.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At least four conscripts were killed near Oleshnya on the second day — August 7. Mikhail Zelensky and two other soldiers managed to escape from their position and reach a command post further back from the front lines. However, Ukrainian troops had already taken up positions there. Zelensky and his comrades hid in a wooded area and did not leave it.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Magomed was one of the conscripts stationed at Oleshnya and killed during the operation. According to his relative, Magomed’s position was attacked on August 6. The command ordered the soldiers not to leave the strongpoint and promised to send in reinforcements, but no one except a zampolit — political commissar, an officer responsible for indoctrination and morale issues — arrived at the position. Later, in a conversation with Magomed’s family, the officer claimed that he had to abandon the conscript and two other soldiers at the strongpoint in order to save a group of 22 conscripts. According to the conscripts who broke out of the encirclement, Magomed and his comrades managed to retreat to Gogolevka, where they were killed by a grenade explosion in a dugout.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Another captured conscript <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?si=mQ728kWZOfFEkBaH&amp;t=788&amp;v=7CllELzRaLI&amp;feature=youtu.be\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">shared</a> a similar story about the zampolit who had arrived at the border. They and the border guards split into four groups and headed for Gogolevka. On the morning of August 7, Ukrainian troops attempted to capture one of the groups. In the firefight, the conscript said, nine people were killed, and only three survived.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"On the run","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Small groups of conscripts with some border guards and a handful of officers among them went on to hide in the forests for weeks and would be captured by the Ukrainian military almost daily until the end of August.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Andrey from the Vologda Oblast told IStories that he spent about six days in the forest with other soldiers. The conscripts would drink swamp water and eat grass, nettles, and rowan branches. “Nettles actually taste the best,” says Andrei. “Rowan branches have a soft tip at the end. You can chew on that, too.” Some conscripts were luckier, if near the forests where they hid there were sunflower or soybean fields.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Sergey Yershov and another soldier split from their medical platoon in Nizhny Klin and <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20260604142426/https://tsargrad.tv/articles/mat-ne-poverila-pust-skazhet-kodovoe-slovo-ranenyj-srochnik-50-dnej-shel-iz-pod-kurska_1154298\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">spent </a>more than 50 days in the woods. In late September, they made their way to Russian troops, after which the conscripts were sent to a hospital. The medical platoon where Yershov served had surrendered on August 12. One of his fellow soldiers told IStories that he had returned to Russia via a <a href=\"https://t.me/istories_media/7368\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">prisoner exchange</a> as early as August 24.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"On the eastern flank, where the 252nd Motorized Rifle Regiment was holding the line near the villages of Plyokhovo and Borki, the Ukrainian troops broke through the border as well, but were unable to advance further. The retreating conscripts wandered through the forests and swamps for several days, being hit by artillery fire and drones, one of them, Alexander, told us.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Finally, on August 14, they made it to Borki, where a local resident sheltered them: “He was quite an interesting character. As far as I could tell, he hadn’t left because he was on a drinking bender. He brought us whatever food he had at home, and some water to drink. Getting water was really hard: all we had was water from the outdoor shower, and also from a bathtub that had been filled.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"By that time, Ukrainian troops had already taken over the village. Alexander and his sergeant kept an eye on the vehicles passing by the house, noting down the coordinates on a piece of paper and texting them to their command: “They would strike those pickup trucks with drones, and those houses the Ukrainians stationed in as well.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A few days later, the water in the tub was gone, so the soldiers removed the water heater and took apart the pipes to drain the remaining water from there. Meanwhile, the homeowner was cruising around the village on a scooter looking for alcohol. “This is a guy who doesn’t care what’s going on around him; all he wants is to find some moonshine,” Alexander says. “The Ukrainian soldiers had to warn him: ‘Don’t ride here. It’s mined; don’t go there.’”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The soldiers took turns on duty, and spent the rest of their time reading the books in the house. By the time active fighting reached Borki, there was hardly a single building left intact in the village.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“They started searching the houses, just in case someone had slipped through,” the conscript recalls. “I was in the annex at the time [on duty], with no ballistic vest and no helmet. I mean, what was the point?? We were in the middle of nowhere with God knows how many of them around. I just put my rifle on the ground and sat down. They opened the door, and there I was, just sitting. They were very surprised and said, ‘Don’t make any sudden moves; everything will be fine.’ And then they started searching the whole house.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Ukrainian soldiers told Alexander and the other captives that one of the conscripts had shot himself: “We had a conversation [with the soldier who shot himself] about how you mustn’t [surrender],” says Alexander.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The captured Russians were given food and cigarettes. “When [the Ukrainian soldiers] realized that we were conscripts and that we’d been stuck here for about a month, they were surprised and said, ‘Wow, you guys are tough,’” Alexander recalls.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Veseloye","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In mid-September, the Ukrainian Armed Forces <a href=\"https://t.me/istories_media/7558\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">broke through</a> the border in Kursk Oblast once again, this time about 30 km west of the existing front line. Despite the fact that the incursion had been going on for over a month, recent Russian conscripts from Airborne Forces units were still stationed at the border positions. Later, those of them taken captive <a href=\"http://youtube.com/watch?si=9TG-JQKQuT2WdHGP&amp;t=433&amp;v=xFQzDBMgNnw&amp;feature=youtu.be\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">explained</a> that, officially, they were located at a training ground in Pskov Oblast, not in the combat zone.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A new Ukrainian offensive in another sector of Kursk Oblast was faced by Russian conscripts from the 234th Airborne Assault Regiment, the 217th Parachute Regiment, and the 1140th Artillery Regiment.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In the first days of the Ukrainian breakthrough in the Glushkovsky District, at least eight Airborne Forces conscripts were killed. Some of them were likely stationed at a rural school building in Veseloye, 3.5 km from the border, according to their relatives' posts on social media.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<a href=\"https://t.me/RVvoenkor/77017\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">According </a>to the “Russian Spring’s War Reporters” Telegram channel, the school building was destroyed by a U.S. precision-guided air bomb. The UAF unit Khorne Group <a href=\"https://t.me/khornegroup/2707\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">published</a> a video of the strike. Our estimates indicate that the total losses among conscripts in this area of the front may have exceeded 20 people since August 2024.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18876,"data":{"author":"Khorne Group","caption":"The Veseloye school building strike","videosList":[{"url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/videos/ac0089accf444a729fd759aeed36fef9.mp4","content_type":"video/mp4"},{"url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/videos/ac0089accf444a729fd759aeed36fef9.webm","content_type":"video/webm"}],"hasControls":false},"category":"gif-embed"},"type":"gif-embed"},{"data":"Capture, exchange, and demobilization","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Andrey, a conscript from Vologda Oblast, recounts that he was taken captive after several days in the woods. “They brought me to some house. There, some Ukrainian women started bandaging my wounds again. The whole time, they kept saying that I had come onto their land, that I was killing their children, killing their husbands, that ‘you’re all so bad, but we’re still helping you — although we could have abandoned you,’ Andrei recounts their conversation. “I told them I was defending my country. I didn’t set foot on your land. I was on my own.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Conscripts who were taken prisoner were called in for interrogations, another interviewee told us. “Some would be called in and tell everything — absolutely everything: the positions, the roles, — he says. — Sure, they were threatened and beaten, but there were no bruises, the specialists know how to beat people with no bruises. But I was lucky. I once wandered into the SBU [State Security of Ukraine] office by accident. They decided to interrogate me, and when they found out where I worked [as a train attendant], they asked, ‘Do you know anything about Metro-2?’ [the secret tunnels under Moscow intended for the country’s leadership]. I said, ‘Well, I just know stuff from books,’ — and that seemed funny to me. They said, ‘Why are you laughing? Face down on the floor, or we’ll beat you up right here!’” However, they didn’t do anything, and the conscript was released.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Several conscripts we managed to speak with describe the conditions in captivity as satisfactory. “The food wasn’t anything special — it was just what the other prisoners there ate. There were Ukrainians in the same prison as well,” says Alexander.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“They did feed us, but the food was not tasty at all,” Yevgeny recalls. “The tastiest thing we had there was bread. Since it’s warm there and trees grow, we would pick apples — we made a stick to reach the trees through the bars.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“At one point, I was afraid [I would be tortured],” recalls Andrei. “The guys in the cell next to me said they would try to make them speak Ukrainian. They’d say something to me in Ukrainian as well, and I was supposed to answer, but I didn’t understand it and played dumb. I thought something [some kind of punishment] would follow. When I realized that they don't punish you, don’t even do anything of the kind, I understood that I was in a normal prison. Everything settled down for me, so I totally stopped being afraid.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Two weeks after the incursion into Kursk Oblast began, on August 24, the first POW exchange <a href=\"https://t.me/istories_media/7368\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">took place</a>, and 115 conscripts returned to Russia. They were seated on a bus and sent to the Belarus border. According to our interviewees, no one knew their destination until the very last moment: the prisoners thought they were being taken to some sort of a special settlement.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After returning to Russia, the wounded soldiers were sent to a hospital, but one of the men we spoke to refused to go there. “The guys I thought had died turned out to have been taken captives; they were exchanged along with me. I couldn’t bear to be separated from them for even a week,” Andrey explains. “Lying above me was my buddy, whom I thought had died, but he survived. To my left lay another buddy who had survived. I was so happy that they were alive, I didn’t need any hospital.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After “investigative procedures” and a medical examination in Moscow, the soldiers who did not require hospitalization were reassigned to military units. There, they served out the remainder of their terms (six to eight weeks) and were then discharged, the conscripts who returned from captivity told us.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to one of them, some of the conscripts who went through the exchange were then sent back to the border in Bryansk Oblast. They spent more than a month there.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The aftermath","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The prisoner exchanges went on into 2025. In April, Mikhail Zelensky and the conscripts captured in the Glushkovo area <a href=\"https://t.me/dvizhenie_nashvyhod/1244\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">came back </a>to Russia. “I Want to Live” — a Ukrainian government project established for the Russian soldiers to willingly surrender into captivity — informed the IStories and Verstka that about 500 conscripts have been exchanged. Two years after the Kursk Oblast operation, none of the Russian conscripts remained in captivity.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"On April 26, 2025, Chief of the General Staff Valery Gerasimov <a href=\"https://t.me/mod_russia/51801\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">reported </a>to Vladimir Putin about the “crushing defeat suffered by Ukrainian armed formations” in Kursk Oblast. The search for the bodies of the fallen conscripts and their extraction only became possible after Russian troops reached the border again.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The mother of a soldier who is still considered missing in action told us that her son’s body was never found at the position near Sverdlikovo. “I periodically call Rostov-on-Don [where the bodies are identified at the Center for Reception, Registration, and Transfer of the Deceased]. There’s been no DNA match,” she says. “[They say that] it’s impossible to carry out a recovery there — drones are flying, and the area hasn’t been cleared of mines.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Conscripts listed as missing in action were being officially declared deceased one by one throughout 2025. The last known case of a status change occurred in May 2026 — nearly two years after the soldier’s death.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In total, at least 77 conscripts were killed in the first months of fighting in Kursk Oblast. According to IStories and Verstka's estimates, about 30 more people are still considered missing in action.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Life after the war","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Alexander says that before his mandatory military service, he was seriously planning to sign a military contract [to go to war against Ukraine voluntarily], as he was “really eager” to. “But my mother is a very anxious person, and we agreed that I would serve my mandatory service first, and then, if I hadn’t changed my mind, I could sign a contract,” Alexander explains. “When I came back after all of that, of course, I thought about it for a long time; the officers were encouraging me to sign. For better or for worse, but I changed my mind.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“The effects of the concussion haven’t gone away even though it’s been two years,” Mikhail tells us. “Emotionally, all [feelings] are gone. All that’s left is aggression. Maybe a little joy sometimes. It only takes a split second to set me off — and that’s it, I explode. It’s very hard to control all of this.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to Mikhail, his hearing was severely damaged. “I always wear an earbud — at least one — with music playing constantly,” he says. “There’s a very loud ringing [in my ears], and it won’t go away.” Mikhail has not received any government assistance, so he is currently paying for his treatment out of his own pocket.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The mother of one of these conscripts also told us that some of them have not received any support from the government. “His concussion was so severe that he was almost unconscious when he was taken prisoner,” says Ekaterina. “When he came home from the army, he practically refused to talk to me. He would just lie in bed, turned away. We spent a year struggling to get him recognized as a combat veteran because there were no documents on him. The documents were restored, and he underwent treatment, but his condition wasn’t recognized as a combat-related injury. He now suffers from constant high blood pressure, headaches and insomnia. I’m currently paying for all his treatment out of my own pocket.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Some conscripts face similar difficulties in receiving the payments they’re entitled to for the injuries and participation in the “counterterrorism operation zone” (the CTO in Kursk Oblast was <a href=\"https://t.me/gubernator_46/7389\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">declared </a>on August 10). “Until I went to the prosecutor’s office, they didn’t want to pay me the regional [injury compensation],” says Andrey.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“I didn’t receive my combat veteran status until December of 2025,” says Timur. “I haven’t received any payments for the days I spent in the CTO zone. I’m still working through these issues with lawyers.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“It was specifically the 18th Battalion [of the 488th Regiment] that didn’t get a single ruble,\" Egor explains. “The guys who served in other units received decent payments. They paid the demobilized soldiers from our unit — who had already left long ago by August — but they didn’t pay us. We’re basically not counting on it anymore.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to other conscripts, they “weren’t wronged financially” — with the money from the government, some were able to buy a car or a plot of land to build a house. Andrey used the compensation he received to buy an apartment in his hometown and started a business with a fellow soldier. “If it weren’t for [the journalists’ questions], I wouldn’t even have remembered about the army time,” he says. “I used to go crazy at night. New Year’s Eve, fireworks — that’s it; I’d hide in some basement listening to them. Well, yeah, my mind goes into overdrive at night sometimes. Things just get scary in my head. You wake up covered in sweat.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Andrey calls his experience serving in the army “a school of life.” “I come home, look at my uniform, and remember: it turns out I really was there. I became physically fit there, maybe more experienced, and started looking at things with a more mature perspective,” Andrey reflects. “You remember a lot of good things. We get together with our fellow soldiers and have fun — and everything’s great. We remember our jokes. Then we remember those who can no longer be here to hear those jokes. As the saying goes, we started by toasting to their health and ended by toasting to their rest in peace. Overall, it’s good that I’m here, on my own two feet, with both arms intact — everything’s fine, and I’ve got my head on my shoulders. Fate is such a thing: what if I hadn’t been in the army? Or, let’s say, what if things had turned out just a little differently? I probably wouldn’t be standing here. That’s just how things turn out, and sometimes it’s strange.”","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":10302,"header":"The Alleged Mastermind of a $2 Billion U.S. Telemedicine Scam Is Enjoying the Luxury Life in Russia","_path":"/en/stories/2026/07/29/american-fraudsters-luxury-life-in-russia/","lead":"Brian Sutton, accused of masterminding one of the largest fraud schemes to ever be unraveled in the United States, is living freely in Russia. Among his acquisitions there is a fleet of luxury cars, an elite villa near Moscow, and a stake in an MMA club tied to a member of the Russian parliament","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e671850de05401fa8dae1ef5ecf6659-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Cover: James O'Brien / OCCRP","created_at_date":"2026-07-29","created_at_date_time":"2026-07-28T14:04:09.636Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":18,"first_name":"Роман","last_name":"Катин","first_name_en":"Roman","last_name_en":"Katin","is_public":true,"_path":"r","avatar":[],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[{"id":365,"first_name":"Зак","last_name":"Копплин","first_name_en":"Zack","last_name_en":"Kopplin","company":"OCCRP","company_en":"OCCRP","company_link":"https://www.occrp.org/en","avatar":[],"ordering":2}],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[{"id":11,"first_name":"Дмитрий","last_name":"Великовский","first_name_en":"Dmitry","last_name_en":"Velikovsky","is_public":true,"_path":"dmitry-velikovsky","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":189,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":189,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":1}],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"This translation was provided by OCCRP\n\nBetween 2015 and 2022, a criminal group used dozens of pharmacies across the United States to bill medical insurance companies a staggering $2 billion for fraudulent prescriptions. The group collected over $758 million, laundering vast sums through offshore accounts before distributing the profits among themselves or reinvesting them in their operation. Fifteen people were sentenced in California for their roles in the scheme and seven pleaded guilty in federal court, with some later receiving ten-year prison sentences.\n\nBut the man prosecutors identify as the group’s ringleader, 34-year-old Los Angeles-born Brian Sutton, has not been tried. The U.S. Attorney's Office in Brooklyn describes the indicted Sutton as “at large,” and a felony case against him in California remains active.\n\nIStories tracked him down in Russia. In a country under the cloud of war and dictatorship, he is living a life of unabashed luxury. His assets there include nearly two dozen Mercedes Benz cars and several other luxury vehicles, a villa in an exclusive area near Moscow (and another owned by a family member), several businesses, and even a stake in an MMA club tied to a member of Russian parliament whose family is considered close to Chechen strongman leader Ramzan Kadyrov.\n\n“The American justice system will be unable to reach Sutton in Russia,” says Ilya Shumanov, the former director of the local chapter of Transparency International. “There is no extradition treaty between the U.S. and Russia, and cooperation between law enforcement agencies remains exclusively in the area of ​​counterterrorism … The chance of his extradition to the United States is zero.” “The choice of Russia as a safe haven for international criminals is understandable and is nothing particularly new,” Shumanov noted, citing the case of Rinaldo Nazzaro, the founder of a neo-Nazi paramilitary group who relocated to Russia in the late 2010s. \n\nSutton and members of his family did not respond to requests for comment. The U.S. Department of Justice, the Santa Clara County District Attorney’s Office, and the Russian Interior Ministry also did not reply.\n\n“Mutant pharmacies”\nSutton’s name, and the operation he allegedly led, first came to light in California in 2015, when a CBS news employee noticed that his medical insurance company had paid a shocking $44,000 for a one-month supply of a nutritional supplement.\nThe Los Angeles pharmacy that filled the prescription and submitted the claim was owned by Sutton’s family, as CBS Evening News reported that June. When confronted there by a producer, Sutton ignored questions and shut the door.\nEventually, the authorities caught on. A 2020 California felony complaint alleged that the group owned five Los Angeles-area pharmacies. It described them as “mutant pharmacies” because they functioned as “mills for fulfilling fraudulent prescriptions for pain creams and durable medical equipment.”\n“Many of the pharmacies were not stocked like normal pharmacies,” the complaint read. “The purchase of over-the-counter drugs was so rare that at one location the employees were unable to work the cash register.”\nTo feed these mills, prosecutors alleged, the conspirators ran an aggressive call center that harassed ordinary citizens with dozens of unsolicited calls, deceiving them into believing they were speaking with their own doctors or insurers. They then used the information they obtained to issue high-cost prescriptions, bombarding unwitting victims with shipments of unwanted medical gear and pain creams they had never requested. Fifteen co-conspirators eventually pleaded guilty, admitting to running a massive statewide scam and defrauding insurance companies of about $40 million. \n\nA later federal case, prosecuted in Brooklyn, New York, covered what prosecutors described as a wider-ranging and more ambitious iteration of the scheme, tallying the much larger amount of nearly $2 billion in fraudulent medical bills, of which over $758 million was paid out.\n\nThe sophisticated operation involved calling patients to offer prescription medications at little to no cost, recruiting doctors to review nonexistent telemedicine visits, and billing insurance companies for drugs that in some cases were not even delivered. The conspirators bought many dozens of pharmacies across the country, expanding into states like New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Texas, and Alabama. To avoid U.S. law enforcement, they set up call centers overseas, including in Russia.\n\nSeven people ultimately pleaded guilty and were convicted for their roles in the operation. But not Sutton, who was out of reach of authorities.\n\nA luxury life in Russia\nThe U.S. Department of Justice describes the group behind the telemedicine fraud as a “Moscow-based criminal organization.” Indeed, Russian land records and leaked databases show that Sutton and his family were establishing themselves in the country by 2019.\nThat year, leaked data from the Russian road police shows, Sutton bought and registered a Range Rover and a Rolls Royce Wraith in Russia, the first luxury cars of what would ultimately become an impressive fleet. According to a list of Sutton’s assets obtained by reporters, his collection ultimately included six BMWs, two more Rolls Royces, and 23 Mercedes-Benz vehicles produced over a 36-year span.\nAlso in 2019, a 64-year–old relative, David Sutton — presumably Brian’s father — purchased a luxurious villa near the Russian capital, according to land registry records. Nearly 600 square meters in size, the home includes a large private formal garden and a guest house on the property.\n\nIt is part of Barvikha 21, an “elite guarded cottage settlement” whose homes were built “in the style of American architect Frank Lloyd Wright.” Located in the elite Rublevka area to the west of Moscow, and adjoining a 20-hectare forested recreation area, the development is just five kilometers from Putin’s infamous residence at Novo Ogarevo.\nOver the next few years, three members of the Sutton family — Brian, David, and a woman named Mila Sutton — listed the address as their residence, according to a leaked database. (Both David and Mila Sutton were also indicted for the medical insurance fraud scheme in California, but neither appears ever to have been arrested or tried. Neither responded to requests for comment.)\nBut Brian Sutton had ambitions for a larger footprint in Barvikha 21. In 2025, he bought another villa in the same development, combining its territory with an adjacent plot he acquired on which the existing villa had been demolished. His property there now stretches over more than 6,500 square meters, nearly the size of a regulation football field.\nMeanwhile, the Russian commercial register shows, Sutton had founded a call center called Well Connect in Moscow in 2019. Though its website is now defunct, the company’s page in the Russian social network Vkontakte is still available.\n“We do marketing in the sphere of medicine,” it reads, “moving diagnostic methods and the treatment of clients in a better direction.” According to leaks of Russian tax information, Sutton earned 125 million rubles ($1.6 million) from the company in 2020–2021.\nBrian Sutton also tried his hand in the Russian coal-trading business. In 2019, he founded Coal Trade, a Moscow company that, according to its website, included among its partners some of the largest Russian steel manufacturing and mining groups, such as Evraz and its coal business, Raspadskaya. Sutton retained his 90 percent stake in Coal Trade until late 2022, after which it was acquired by a firm whose ultimate owners are unknown. The Evraz plants and Raspadskaya were sanctioned by the United States in 2024.\nThe available financial data shows that Coal Trade made a profit of about $4.4 million in 2021 and $1.6 million in 2022, but its business started collapsing after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine that year.\nIn November 2022, Sutton acquired Relaxzon, a small fitness and spa center in the village of Gorchakovo on the outskirts of Moscow.\n\nUnited Russia Fighters\nThe full story of Brian Sutton’s relationship with Russia is unknown. According to leaked records, David Sutton is listed as being born in the Soviet Union, while Brian was born in Los Angeles and holds U.S. citizenship. Both men received Israeli citizenship in 2017. Brian also got a Russian passport in 2022.\nBeyond that, Brian Sutton seems to have a connection to Chechnya, a republic ruled with an iron fist by strongman leader Ramzan Kadyrov that is barely reachable even for Russian federal law enforcement.\nSutton’s first known listed place of residence in Russia, according to a police database, was an address in Argun, a town not far from the Chechen capital of Grozny. Several subsequent entries also associate a Grozny address with him, while identifying another address in Moscow as his residence.\nCorporate records show that in June 2022 he acquired a 10-percent stake in United Russian Fighters (URF), an MMA club and fighting team tied to Bekkhan Agayev, a member of the Russian Parliament with the ruling United Russia party.\nOn its Instagram account, the team describes Agayev as one of its “founders,” calling him “a true patriot of Russia who makes a significant contribution to our country’s development every day.” The account also notes that he continues to support the team. \n(Agayev does not have a personal stake in the company behind URF, since members of parliament are prohibited from conducting business. A 40 percent share is owned by his son Deni.)\nAs previously reported by IStories, URF is active in providing support for the Russian military in its war on Ukraine.\nAgayev, who has been sanctioned by the United States since 2022, comes from a family that is considered close to Ramzan Kadyrov, the strongman head of Chechnya.\nKadyrov recorded a personal birthday greeting for Agayev’s father, Vakha, for his 60th birthday in 2013, calling him a “dear brother,” and also awarded him the title of “Honorary Citizen of the Republic.” That same year, a street was named after him in the Chechen town of Urus-Martan. Vakha Agayev, who died of COVID in 2020, ran a business that traded in Chechen oil.\nBekkhan Agayev did not respond to questions about the nature of his relationship with Sutton. His son also did not reply.\nBut Shumanov, the former Transparency International director, said that in the context of modern Russia, protecting one’s property rights or “avoiding pressure from security forces” was “virtually impossible.”\n“There’s a high probability that the property and assets that Sutton acquired in Russia will [eventually] go to his influential Russian friends,” Shumanov added. “If he decides to leave Russia, I would venture to guess that many surprises await him. The FBI has a long list of cases of arresting individuals on the U.S. wanted list in other countries.”","blocks":[{"data":"<em>This translation was provided by </em><a href=\"https://www.occrp.org/en/investigation/the-alleged-mastermind-of-a-2-billion-us-telemedicine-scam-is-enjoying-the-luxury-life-in-russia\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"><em>OCCRP</em></a>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Between 2015 and 2022, a criminal group used dozens of pharmacies across the United States to <a href=\"https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/three-members-international-criminal-organization-sentenced-lengthy-sentences-2-billion\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">bill</a> medical insurance companies a staggering $2 billion for fraudulent prescriptions. The group collected over $758 million, laundering vast sums through offshore accounts before distributing the profits among themselves or reinvesting them in their operation. Fifteen people were <a href=\"https://da.santaclaracounty.gov/news/news-release/40-million-medical-insurance-scammers-sentenced\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">sentenced</a> in California for their roles in the scheme and seven pleaded guilty in federal court, with some later receiving ten-year prison sentences.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But the man prosecutors identify as the group’s <a href=\"https://www.justice.gov/usao-edny/pr/seven-members-moscow-based-criminal-organization-plead-guilty-over-17-billion\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">ringleader</a>, 34-year-old Los Angeles-born Brian Sutton, has not been tried. The U.S. Attorney's Office in Brooklyn describes the indicted Sutton as “at large,” and a felony case against him in California remains active.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories tracked him down in Russia. In a country under the cloud of war and dictatorship, he is living a life of unabashed luxury. His assets there include nearly two dozen Mercedes Benz cars and several other luxury vehicles, a villa in an exclusive area near Moscow (and another owned by a family member), several businesses, and even a stake in an MMA club tied to a member of Russian parliament whose family is considered close to Chechen strongman leader Ramzan Kadyrov.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“The American justice system will be unable to reach Sutton in Russia,” says Ilya Shumanov, the former director of the local chapter of Transparency International. “There is no extradition treaty between the U.S. and Russia, and cooperation between law enforcement agencies remains exclusively in the area of ​​counterterrorism … The chance of his extradition to the United States is zero.” “The choice of Russia as a safe haven for international criminals is understandable and is nothing particularly new,” Shumanov noted, citing the case of Rinaldo Nazzaro, the founder of a neo-Nazi paramilitary group who relocated to Russia in the late 2010s. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Sutton and members of his family did not respond to requests for comment. The U.S. Department of Justice, the Santa Clara County District Attorney’s Office, and the Russian Interior Ministry also did not reply.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Mutant pharmacies”","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Sutton’s name, and the operation he allegedly led, first came to light in California in 2015, when a CBS news employee noticed that his medical insurance company had paid a shocking $44,000 for a one-month supply of a nutritional supplement.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Los Angeles pharmacy that filled the prescription and submitted the claim was owned by Sutton’s family, as CBS Evening News <a href=\"https://www.cbsnews.com/news/prescription-resveratrol-supplement-expensive-investigation/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">reported</a> that June. When confronted there by a producer, Sutton ignored questions and shut the door.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Eventually, the authorities caught on. A 2020 California felony complaint alleged that the group owned five Los Angeles-area pharmacies. It described them as “mutant pharmacies” because they functioned as “mills for fulfilling fraudulent prescriptions for pain creams and durable medical equipment.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Many of the pharmacies were not stocked like normal pharmacies,” the complaint read. “The purchase of over-the-counter drugs was so rare that at one location the employees were unable to work the cash register.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18816,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Superior Court of California, County of Santa Clara","caption":"Defendants Brian Sutton and David Sutton in a California court document","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e0c04aeca0864154acde6ec3bee4aed7-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e0c04aeca0864154acde6ec3bee4aed7-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e0c04aeca0864154acde6ec3bee4aed7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e0c04aeca0864154acde6ec3bee4aed7-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e0c04aeca0864154acde6ec3bee4aed7-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e0c04aeca0864154acde6ec3bee4aed7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e0c04aeca0864154acde6ec3bee4aed7-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e0c04aeca0864154acde6ec3bee4aed7-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e0c04aeca0864154acde6ec3bee4aed7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e0c04aeca0864154acde6ec3bee4aed7-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e0c04aeca0864154acde6ec3bee4aed7-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e0c04aeca0864154acde6ec3bee4aed7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e0c04aeca0864154acde6ec3bee4aed7-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e0c04aeca0864154acde6ec3bee4aed7-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e0c04aeca0864154acde6ec3bee4aed7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e0c04aeca0864154acde6ec3bee4aed7-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e0c04aeca0864154acde6ec3bee4aed7-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e0c04aeca0864154acde6ec3bee4aed7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"To feed these mills, prosecutors alleged, the conspirators ran an aggressive call center that harassed ordinary citizens with dozens of unsolicited calls, deceiving them into believing they were speaking with their own doctors or insurers. They then used the information they obtained to issue high-cost prescriptions, bombarding unwitting victims with shipments of unwanted medical gear and pain creams they had never requested. Fifteen co-conspirators eventually pleaded guilty, admitting to running a massive statewide scam and defrauding insurance companies of about $40 million. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A later federal case, prosecuted in Brooklyn, New York, covered what prosecutors described as a wider-ranging and more ambitious iteration of the scheme, tallying the much larger amount of nearly $2 billion in fraudulent medical bills, of which over $758 million was paid out.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The sophisticated operation involved calling patients to offer prescription medications at little to no cost, recruiting doctors to review nonexistent telemedicine visits, and billing insurance companies for drugs that in some cases were not even delivered. The conspirators bought many dozens of pharmacies across the country, expanding into states like New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Texas, and Alabama. To avoid U.S. law enforcement, they set up call centers overseas, including in Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Seven people ultimately pleaded guilty and were convicted for their roles in the operation. But not Sutton, who was out of reach of authorities.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A luxury life in Russia","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The U.S. Department of Justice describes the group behind the telemedicine fraud as a “Moscow-based criminal organization.” Indeed, Russian land records and leaked databases show that Sutton and his family were establishing themselves in the country by 2019.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"That year, leaked data from the Russian road police shows, Sutton bought and registered a Range Rover and a Rolls Royce Wraith in Russia, the first luxury cars of what would ultimately become an impressive fleet. According to a list of Sutton’s assets obtained by reporters, his collection ultimately included six BMWs, two more Rolls Royces, and 23 Mercedes-Benz vehicles produced over a 36-year span.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Also in 2019, a 64-year–old relative, David Sutton — presumably Brian’s father — purchased a luxurious villa near the Russian capital, according to land registry records. Nearly 600 square meters in size, the home includes a large private formal garden and a guest house on the property.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18812,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"«Портал недвижимости»; Google Earth","caption":"David Sutton’s villa in Barvikha-21","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42d4aa419ef1443783611fd3d10eb806-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42d4aa419ef1443783611fd3d10eb806-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42d4aa419ef1443783611fd3d10eb806-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42d4aa419ef1443783611fd3d10eb806-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42d4aa419ef1443783611fd3d10eb806-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42d4aa419ef1443783611fd3d10eb806-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42d4aa419ef1443783611fd3d10eb806-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42d4aa419ef1443783611fd3d10eb806-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42d4aa419ef1443783611fd3d10eb806-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42d4aa419ef1443783611fd3d10eb806-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42d4aa419ef1443783611fd3d10eb806-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42d4aa419ef1443783611fd3d10eb806-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42d4aa419ef1443783611fd3d10eb806-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42d4aa419ef1443783611fd3d10eb806-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42d4aa419ef1443783611fd3d10eb806-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42d4aa419ef1443783611fd3d10eb806-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42d4aa419ef1443783611fd3d10eb806-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/42d4aa419ef1443783611fd3d10eb806-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"It is part of <a href=\"https://barvikha-21.ru/#about\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Barvikha 21</a>, an “elite guarded cottage settlement” whose homes were built “in the style of American architect Frank Lloyd Wright.” Located in the elite Rublevka area to the west of Moscow, and adjoining a 20-hectare forested recreation area, the development is just five kilometers from Putin’s infamous residence at Novo Ogarevo.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Over the next few years, three members of the Sutton family — Brian, David, and a woman named Mila Sutton&nbsp;— listed the address as their residence, according to a leaked database. (Both David and Mila Sutton were also indicted for the medical insurance fraud scheme in California, but neither appears ever to have been arrested or tried. Neither responded to requests for comment.)","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But Brian Sutton had ambitions for a larger footprint in Barvikha 21. In 2025, he bought another villa in the same development, combining its territory with an adjacent plot he acquired on which the existing villa had been demolished. His property there now stretches over more than 6,500 square meters, nearly the size of a regulation football field.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Meanwhile, the Russian commercial register shows, Sutton had founded a call center called Well Connect in Moscow in 2019. Though its website is now defunct, the <a href=\"https://vk.com/well_connect\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">company’s page</a> in the Russian social network Vkontakte is still available.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18813,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Well Connect Vkontakte page","caption":"Brian Sutton’s Well Connect call center office in Moscow","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eaa9835686764b02960b9dbde666ab4c-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eaa9835686764b02960b9dbde666ab4c-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eaa9835686764b02960b9dbde666ab4c-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eaa9835686764b02960b9dbde666ab4c-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eaa9835686764b02960b9dbde666ab4c-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eaa9835686764b02960b9dbde666ab4c-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eaa9835686764b02960b9dbde666ab4c-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eaa9835686764b02960b9dbde666ab4c-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eaa9835686764b02960b9dbde666ab4c-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eaa9835686764b02960b9dbde666ab4c-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eaa9835686764b02960b9dbde666ab4c-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eaa9835686764b02960b9dbde666ab4c-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eaa9835686764b02960b9dbde666ab4c-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eaa9835686764b02960b9dbde666ab4c-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eaa9835686764b02960b9dbde666ab4c-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eaa9835686764b02960b9dbde666ab4c-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eaa9835686764b02960b9dbde666ab4c-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eaa9835686764b02960b9dbde666ab4c-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"“We do marketing in the sphere of medicine,” it reads, “moving diagnostic methods and the treatment of clients in a better direction.” According to leaks of Russian tax information, Sutton earned 125 million rubles ($1.6 million) from the company in 2020–2021.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Brian Sutton also tried his hand in the Russian coal-trading business. In 2019, he founded Coal Trade, a Moscow company that, according to its <a href=\"https://coal-trade.ru/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">website</a>, included among its partners some of the largest Russian steel manufacturing and mining groups, such as Evraz and its coal business, Raspadskaya. Sutton retained his 90 percent stake in Coal Trade until late 2022, after which it was acquired by a firm whose ultimate owners are unknown. The Evraz plants and Raspadskaya were sanctioned by the United States in 2024.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The available financial data shows that Coal Trade made a profit of about $4.4 million in 2021 and $1.6 million in 2022, but its business started collapsing after Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine that year.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In November 2022, Sutton acquired Relaxzon, a small <a href=\"https://relaxzon.ru/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">fitness and spa center</a> in the village of Gorchakovo on the outskirts of Moscow.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"United Russia Fighters","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The full story of Brian Sutton’s relationship with Russia is unknown. According to leaked records, David Sutton is listed as being born in the Soviet Union, while Brian was born in Los Angeles and holds U.S. citizenship. Both men received Israeli citizenship in 2017. Brian also got a Russian passport in 2022.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Beyond that, Brian Sutton seems to have a connection to Chechnya, a republic ruled with an iron fist by strongman leader Ramzan Kadyrov that is <a href=\"https://www.csmonitor.com/World/Europe/2015/0423/Pro-Russia-Chechen-leader-threatens-to-kill-Russian-cops-on-his-turf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">barely reachable</a> even for Russian federal law enforcement.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Sutton’s first known listed place of residence in Russia, according to a police database, was an address in Argun, a town not far from the Chechen capital of Grozny. Several subsequent entries also associate a Grozny address with him, while identifying another address in Moscow as his residence.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Corporate records show that in June 2022 he acquired a 10-percent stake in United Russian Fighters (URF), an MMA club and fighting team tied to Bekkhan Agayev, a member of the Russian Parliament with the ruling United Russia party.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18814,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"United Russia","caption":"Bekkhan Agayev, a member of the Russian State Duma","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc624bfe83c45e9bf6fe72cc0b783a8-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc624bfe83c45e9bf6fe72cc0b783a8-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc624bfe83c45e9bf6fe72cc0b783a8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc624bfe83c45e9bf6fe72cc0b783a8-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc624bfe83c45e9bf6fe72cc0b783a8-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc624bfe83c45e9bf6fe72cc0b783a8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc624bfe83c45e9bf6fe72cc0b783a8-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc624bfe83c45e9bf6fe72cc0b783a8-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc624bfe83c45e9bf6fe72cc0b783a8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc624bfe83c45e9bf6fe72cc0b783a8-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc624bfe83c45e9bf6fe72cc0b783a8-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc624bfe83c45e9bf6fe72cc0b783a8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc624bfe83c45e9bf6fe72cc0b783a8-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc624bfe83c45e9bf6fe72cc0b783a8-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc624bfe83c45e9bf6fe72cc0b783a8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc624bfe83c45e9bf6fe72cc0b783a8-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc624bfe83c45e9bf6fe72cc0b783a8-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8cc624bfe83c45e9bf6fe72cc0b783a8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"On its <a href=\"https://www.instagram.com/p/DTZ21D8jdsK/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Instagram account</a>, the team describes Agayev as one of its “founders,” calling him “a true patriot of Russia who makes a significant contribution to our country’s development every day.” The account also notes that he continues to support the team.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"(Agayev does not have a personal stake in the company behind URF, since members of parliament are prohibited from conducting business. A 40 percent share is owned by his son Deni.)","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"As <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2026/06/24/agayevs/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">previously reported by IStories</a>, URF is active in providing support for the Russian military in its war on Ukraine.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Agayev, who has been sanctioned by the United States since 2022, comes from a family that is considered close to Ramzan Kadyrov, the strongman head of Chechnya.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Kadyrov recorded a personal birthday greeting for Agayev’s father, Vakha, for his 60th birthday in 2013, calling him a “dear brother,” and also <a href=\"https://checheninfo.ru/16845-chechenskiy-biznesmen-stal-stal-pochetnym-grazhdaninom-chr.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">awarded</a> him the title of “Honorary Citizen of the Republic.” That same year, a street was named after him in the Chechen town of Urus-Martan. Vakha Agayev, who died of COVID in 2020, ran a business that traded in Chechen oil.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Bekkhan Agayev did not respond to questions about the nature of his relationship with Sutton.&nbsp;His son also did not reply.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But Shumanov, the former Transparency International director, said that in the context of modern Russia, protecting one’s property rights or “avoiding pressure from security forces” was “virtually impossible.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“There’s a high probability that the property and assets that Sutton acquired in Russia will [eventually] go to his influential Russian friends,” Shumanov added. “If he decides to leave Russia, I would venture to guess that many surprises await him. The FBI has a long list of cases of arresting individuals on the U.S. wanted list in other countries.”","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":10188,"header":"AI at the (Federal Security) Service","_path":"/en/stories/2026/07/15/ai-at-the-federal-security-service/","lead":"The Russian state security service — FSB — has been trying to implement AI in its anti-opposition operations for at least two years. IStories investigated how the development of the Pauk (“Spider”) system went — and why it was stopped (at least for now)","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93cbdc7f88af4fa99513a17b23f488b5-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"","created_at_date":"2026-07-15","created_at_date_time":"2026-07-14T13:43:29.917Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":true,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":61,"first_name":"Егор","last_name":"Феоктистов","first_name_en":"Egor","last_name_en":"Feoktistov","is_public":true,"_path":"egor-feoktistov","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Автор дата-отдела «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":null}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[{"id":31,"first_name":"Катя","last_name":"Бонч-Осмоловская","first_name_en":"Katya","last_name_en":"Bonch-Osmolovskaya","is_public":true,"_path":"katya-bonch-osmolovskaya","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.jpeg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.jpeg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.jpeg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.jpeg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редакторка дата-отдела","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":null,"ordering":1}],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[{"id":5,"first_name":"Роман","last_name":"Анин","first_name_en":"Roman","last_name_en":"Anin","is_public":true,"_path":"roman-anin","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редактор «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Редактор","position_en":"Editor","ordering":1},{"id":13,"first_name":"Соня","last_name":"Савина","first_name_en":"Sonya","last_name_en":"Savina","is_public":true,"_path":"sonya-savina","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Если вы хотите рассказать мне свою историю, пишите на почту sonya.savina@istories.media.","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":"Author","ordering":2}],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"The FSB’s Second Service, or The Service for Defense of the Constitutional Order and Combating Terrorism, which is combating internet access for Russians and thereby harming Russia’s IT sector, began integrating AI into its routine work at least two years ago. This challenging task was entrusted to Mikord, a company based in Kazan (Russia’s Tatarstan republic capital — Ed.)\n\nIn December 2025, an anonymous hacker group breached Mikord’s infrastructure and obtained the documents on its other then-upcoming project, a digital military registry. The group passed the documents to Get Lost, an organization helping Russians evade conscription, who shared the data with IStories. Due to this leak, we have been able to publish investigations on the military registry work, as well as on other classified systems of the Russian Ministry of Defense.\n\nWe have also learned how, over a year and a half, Mikord worked on the Pauk (“Spider”) project commissioned to them by the FSB’s Second Service. The FSB was supposed to use Pauk to combine information from the media and FSB’s own databases to create a neural network assistant for intelligence officers.\n\nWho commissioned the project\n\nIn the spring of 2024, a little-known Kazan-based company called Mikord was commissioned to create a new service for the FSB. Around the same time, the company was unexpectedly entrusted with the development of a military registry — one of the Russian Ministry of Defense’s largest projects which would consolidate dozens of data sources on millions of Russians in a single location.\nAs previously reported by IStories, Mikord’s success at the federal level may be linked to Nikolai Nikiforov, a Tatarstan native and former Minister of Communications of Russia. The families of Nikiforov and the Mikord founder Alexander Nikolaev had been in business together for a long time.\n\nThe contract for the Pauk system development listed Military Unit 43753 (the FSB’s Center for Information Protection and Special Communications) as main customer and the Kvant Research Institute as the contractor. In turn, Kvant contracted Mikord to carry out the work. \nIn the documents, this project is referred to as the “Portal for Analytics and Usage of Contents,” or, shortly, Pauk (“Spider”). A “spider,” or a crawler, is a term used for bots that scan webpages and automatically collect information from them.\n\nIt is likely that the Second Service of the FSB was intended to be Pauk’s end user, even though it did not commission the work formally. The Service staff were to participate in the key stages of the new service’s development and implementation, and the work schedule had to be coordinated with the Second Service as well. The ZKSibST abbreviation (short for “Defense of the Constitutional Order and Combating Terrorism” in Russian) used in the titles of project documents and the news content Mikord received to be used in the system at the development stage also suggest the Second Service’s involvement. \nHow the FSB intended to use the AI system\n\nPauk was supposed to automate the operations of a situation center presumably created within the FSB’s Second Service. As seen in the project documentation, the center’s shift staff monitor Russian and foreign media news on a daily basis. Every day they compile a news digest which is then sent to FSB leadership.\n\nThe web crawler was supposed to automatically collect all the news stories of interest to the FSB. These stories would then be published on an internal news portal, where the officer on duty could select which stories to include in the daily digest.\n\nThe compiled digests would be stored within Pauk’s closed (i.e. not connected to the Internet) network, where they could be viewed by the staff on duty as well as other FSB employees. Users would be able to search the reports for the information about specific people or events. Via an LLM and a chatbot interface, the users from FSB would also be able to work with “various closed sources information.” This required Pauk to receive information from certain “third-party data banks” and “data from text sources,” i.e. reports, scans, and the FSB’s own records.\nThe documentation does not reveal which specific classified sources the security service intended to use. According to an IStories source familiar with the FSB’s operations, the agency already has a similar data source — the Central Operational Database (COD). It can be accessed by the FSB headquarters staff. Rumors, reports, and criminal cases information are stored in this database. \n\nAdditionally, a separate database containing information on Russian citizens has been created within the Second Service, Alexander Fedotov, a former FSB officer, previously told The Insider in an interview. This database contains activists' and protesters' personal data: their names, photos, and phone numbers.\n\nThe envisioned AI assistant could significantly simplify the security officers’ work concerning large volumes of unstructured information and an operational database on activists. \n\nThe project documentation also listed the types of data that the AI assistant’s response to a “persons of interest” query might contain: their full name, date of birth, region, phone number, license plate number, and car brand. It is possible that the FSB has begun considering the use of AI in its routine operational work.\n\nThe Mikord documents contain correspondence between the project manager and an FSB supervisor, identified by the “A.G.” initials. In response to one of the developers’ questions, the FSB representative stated that the system would serve “30 main department users,” but its user load could eventually grow up to 400 people.\n\nHow the FSB tracks the media\n\nThe FSB project supervisors provided the Mikord team with a set of real news digests compiled by the Second Service from January 2024 to June 2025. The developers analyzed them to narrow down the websites and Telegram channels source list for Pauk to the most popular ones. \n \nMikord used the June 2024 digests set to test an LLM in order to figure out how the chatbot would respond to a security service officer's potential questions. IStories examined the documents metadata and discovered that Ilya Oputin, a programmer at Ozon (a major Russian online marketplace — Ed.) who is believed to have graduated from the FSB Academy, might have worked on them. Oputin did not respond to the journalists’ questions. \nEach digest is divided into two sections: Russian and international news. Several documents contain the following introductory paragraph: “As a result of monitoring online media on April 10, 2024, the following significant incidents and events were identified as those of interest in terms of defending the constitutional order and combating terrorism.” \n\nWe have compiled the news into a unified calendar: there, you can view a specific day report, find a random news item, or search one by keyword. The calendar is available in the Russian version of the text.\n\nIt is unknown what criteria the FSB used to select the news items. In the same digest, a news item titled “Parliament Proposes Designating the Ukrainian Armed Forces, the Security Service of Ukraine, and the Defense Intelligence of Ukraine as Terrorists” may appear alongside a note about a Khabarovsk Krai village headman video appealing to Vladimir Putin. \n\nMany of the news items in the digests are copying the FSB’s own press releases and statements, such as the news titled “The FSB Reports an Ivanovo Resident Detained For Financing the Ukrainian Armed Forces” or “FSB Chief Speaks About Kyiv Recruiting Migrants to Commit Crimes in Russia.” \n\nWe analyzed nearly 5,000 news items from FSB reports and grouped them into themed categories. Many of them are consistent with the Second Service’s traditional activities: combating Islamists, spying on the opposition and carrying out political assassinations. From these same digests, we learned that the service closely monitors news about pressure on migrants in Russia, strikes and protests abroad, and ethnic conflicts in Europe. A detailed analysis of the FSB’s Second Service news digests can be found here (in Russian).\n\nIndependent outlets have become some of the key sources of information about what's going on in Russia for the Second Service. According to our calculations, in the first six months of 2025, three of them — Activatica, RusNews, and Govorit NeMoskva — were among the five top cited media outlets in the FSB digests. \n\nActivatica — an outlet covering civic activism and repressions in Russia — tops this ranking by a wide margin. In the first six months of 2025, 244 of their news stories appeared in the FSB digests. Activatica was the source of one in every six news items in the Second Service’s reports. \n\nSometimes the digests are almost completely shaped by Activatica’s news items. The June 26 2024 report contained three Activatica stories: the protests against rising utility rates in Ufa; Moscow’s Mitino residents’ video appeal to Putin asking him not to build a packaging plant; daily protests in Arkhangelsk Oblast’s Yarensk, where residents opposed the decision to move the emergency medical services station 200 km from the village.\n\nOverall, between January 2024 and June 2025, more than 550 articles from the uncensored outlets (mostly those operating in exile due to the official persecution on behalf of the government, e.g. being designated as “foreign agents” — Ed.) appeared in the FSB’s news digests — that’s more than 10% of all the news items included. Among others, the officers cited such outlets as OVD-Info, 7x7, Sirena and Meduza.\nIndependent media outlets’ reports about the FSB itself are also of interest to the security service. For example, a Meduza article about Sergei Dubov, a Second Service employee, made its way into a digest for the FSB high-ranking officials that very same day. \n\nOverall, in a year and a half the FSB’s Second Service monitored more than a thousand information sources: Russian federal and regional media websites, independent media outlets in exile, anonymous Telegram channels, VK news communities and YouTube channels. \n\nIt is impossible to manually monitor such a wide range of sources on a daily basis. There are several references in the digests indicating that the Second Service is already using a solution similar to Pauk (made by a Russian company called Kribrum) to search and filter news. Kribrum is a service for monitoring media and social networks launched 15 years ago by Igor Ashmanov and Natalia Kaspersky. \n\nAshmanov, a member of Russia’s Human Rights Council, constantly comes up with some new restrictive proposals. For example, he has proposed establishing a military censorship body in Russia as well as creating a “toxic content” registry. At a 2015 Kribrum presentation Ashmanov shared that the system analyzed 19 thousand media outlets and classified them into “liberal,” “neutral,” or “patriotic” ones.\n\nIt is likely that the Second Service had planned to replace the third-party solution with its own one. According to an IStories source close to the FSB, the Service’s units can create such solutions for their own use if they secure the necessary budget. Media monitoring, in particular, had previously been handled by the Department of Operational Information — a unit of the FSB’s Fifth Service responsible for intelligence in CIS countries (Commonwealth of Independent States, a regional organisation of post-soviet states — Ed.). \n\nWhat the prototype looks like\n\nThe Mikord document archive reveals a detailed description of how Pauk was supposed to work. In addition, IStories have found the design layouts of the project, which have been shared publicly and, at the time of publication, are still available to anyone interested. Using the data, we’ve recreated a clickable Pauk prototype: follow the link to try out the role of an FSB Second Service official. \n\nWhile working on the confidential FSB service, Mikord used foreign technologies and products. For example, the latest Pauk interfaces were stored in Figma, an American service. A US-made framework, LlamaIndex, was to be used for processing news reports and other classified documents. \nThe Llama 2 LLM by Meta (it’s worth noting that the company is designated as an “extremist organization” in Russia — Ed.) was supposed to respond to the security service officials’ requests. The dialogue sessions between the FSB officers and the AI assistant were to be stored in a MongoDB database (meanwhile its developers had declared they support Ukraine and had ceased operations in Russia).\n\nThe work was supposed to look like this: an FSB officer on duty supervises the list of sources whose news items get into the Pauk feed. At the same stage the user can edit the news items, rate them on a one-to-five scale, and comment. Selected news items make it into the daily digest for the higher-ranking officials.\nEach news item is assigned a category and a list of tags, keywords, and personalities mentioned. FSB officers can use these to search. \n\nThe Second Service officer on duty can also set up Telegram notifications for incidents of interest. The technical document provides a scenario for using such notifications: “for example, all news stories mentioning ‘a demonstration near the embassy’ or ‘a fight between migrants in Kazan.’” \n\nIt is likely that the FSB had intended to use this tool to quickly respond to certain events in Russia among other things. “There was also an idea that if a selected news item contains words like ‘URGENT,’ ‘FLASH,’ and so on, we could choose to use it as an alert notification criteria,” — the FSB project supervisor identified as A.G. told a Mikord staff member. Another comment from the supervisor suggests that the news notifications were to be sent via a Telegram bot the officers were supposed to subscribe to.\n\nOnly the approved news items would enter the Pauk's closed environment where an FSB officer could compile a daily or monthly digest in a built-in editing tool. In addition, the same service was supposed to incorporate a CRM system to assign and track monitoring tasks. The FSB high officials would be able to order a report on a topic of interest directly within the Pauk system.\n\n***\n\nAccording to the plan, the first phase of Pauk’s development was to be completed by the autumn of 2025. That’s roughly when, after nearly a year and a half of work, a manager commented in Mikord's task tracker that the development of the project was suspended. “Goodbye, project…,” another employee replied. \n\nA source familiar with the development process told IStories that Mikord simply couldn’t deliver on this government contract. The company was not able to launch the service on time, which is why the work was shut down. \n\nThe Mikord team likely lacked both the development experience and the necessary expertise to work with language models, an IT specialist interviewed by IStories suggested upon reviewing the project documentation, Mikord’s task tracker entries and other data.","blocks":[{"data":"The FSB’s Second Service, or The Service for Defense of the Constitutional Order and Combating Terrorism, which is <a href=\"https://thebell.io/teper-oni-vse-reshayut-u-runeta-poyavilsya-novyy-kurator--sluzhba-fsb-otvechavshaya-za-otravlenie-navalnogo\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">combating</a> internet access for Russians and thereby harming Russia’s IT sector, began integrating AI into its routine work at least two years ago. This challenging task was entrusted to Mikord, a company based in Kazan (Russia’s Tatarstan republic capital — Ed.)","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>In December 2025, an anonymous hacker group breached Mikord’s infrastructure and obtained the documents on its other then-upcoming project, a digital military registry. The group passed the documents to Get Lost, an organization helping Russians evade conscription, who shared the data with IStories. Due to this leak, we have been able to publish investigations on the </em><a href=\"https://www.istories.media/en/stories/2025/12/22/mikord/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"><em>military registry</em></a><em> work, as well as on </em><a href=\"https://www.istories.media/stories/2026/02/02/pod-grifom-voennaya-taina/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"><em>other classified systems</em></a><em> of the Russian Ministry of Defense.</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We have also learned how, over a year and a half, Mikord worked on the Pauk (“Spider”) project commissioned to them by the FSB’s Second Service. The FSB was supposed to use Pauk to combine information from the media and FSB’s own databases to create a neural network assistant for intelligence officers.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Who commissioned the project","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In the spring of 2024, a little-known Kazan-based company called Mikord was commissioned to create a new service for the FSB. Around the same time, the company was unexpectedly entrusted with the development of a <a href=\"https://www.istories.media/en/stories/2025/12/22/mikord/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">military registry</a> — one of the Russian Ministry of Defense’s largest projects which would consolidate dozens of data sources on millions of Russians in a single location.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18705,"data":{"block":"<p>The Second Service is the main FSB unit responsible for suppressing opposition. Officers from this unit were <a href=\"https://theins.ru/politika/249691\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">involved</a> in the poisonings of Alexei Navalny and Vladimir Kara-Murza, and they had been tailing Boris Nemtsov before he was assassinated. The Second Service also persecuted those who <a href=\"https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2019/08/02/81476-delo-212\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">participated </a>in the 2019 protests in Moscow and Eduard Limonov’s National Bolshevik Party <a href=\"https://fsb.dossier.center/2s/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">activists</a>.</p><p><br/></p><p>The Second Service is also responsible for the North-Caucasus region of Russia, where it deals, among other issues, with Chechnya and Islamic extremism. This is where Igor Girkin (Strelkov) had <a href=\"https://theins.ru/confession/285905\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">worked</a> before he became the leader of the so-called “Donetsk People’s Republic” armed forces. Senior officers of the Second Service <a href=\"https://t.me/DBRgovua/3915\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">helped</a> Viktor Yanukovych, the then Ukrainian President, suppress the 2014 Euromaidan protests. They also <a href=\"https://theins.ru/confession/285905\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">supervised </a>Russia&#x27;s annexation of Crimea.</p><p><br/></p><p>The same service oversees the education and culture spheres in Russia. For example, it <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/investigations/2022/04/08/ranshe-nikomu-v-golovu-ne-prikhodilo-schitat-obrazovanie-ugrozoi-bezopasnosti/index.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">approves</a> university professors appointments and keeps an eye on <a href=\"https://qvclklblvbiismop.8qaj3npj5q1y.monster/feature/2024/04/08/meduza-poluchila-dostup-k-pochte-sotrudnika-fsb-kotoryy-uzhe-10-let-boretsya-s-nezavisimoy-rossiyskoy-kulturoy-ot-serebrennikova-do-berkovich\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">theaters </a>and <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/news/2026/02/06/nurlanu-saburovu-zapretili-vezd-v-rossiyu-po-initsiative-vtoroi-sluzhbi-fsb-viyasnili-vazhnie-istorii/index.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">stand-up</a> comedians.</p>","header":"What the FSB’s Second Service is known for","content":[{"insert":"The Second Service is the main FSB unit responsible for suppressing opposition. Officers from this unit were "},{"insert":"involved","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://theins.ru/politika/249691","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" in the poisonings of Alexei Navalny and Vladimir Kara-Murza, and they had been tailing Boris Nemtsov before he was assassinated. The Second Service also persecuted those who "},{"insert":"participated ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2019/08/02/81476-delo-212","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"in the 2019 protests in Moscow and Eduard Limonov’s National Bolshevik Party "},{"insert":"activists","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://fsb.dossier.center/2s/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":".\n\nThe Second Service is also responsible for the North-Caucasus region of Russia, where it deals, among other issues, with Chechnya and Islamic extremism. This is where Igor Girkin (Strelkov) had "},{"insert":"worked","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://theins.ru/confession/285905","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" before he became the leader of the so-called “Donetsk People’s Republic” armed forces. Senior officers of the Second Service "},{"insert":"helped","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://t.me/DBRgovua/3915","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" Viktor Yanukovych, the then Ukrainian President, suppress the 2014 Euromaidan protests. They also "},{"insert":"supervised ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://theins.ru/confession/285905","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"Russia's annexation of Crimea.\n\nThe same service oversees the education and culture spheres in Russia. For example, it "},{"insert":"approves","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/investigations/2022/04/08/ranshe-nikomu-v-golovu-ne-prikhodilo-schitat-obrazovanie-ugrozoi-bezopasnosti/index.html","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" university professors appointments and keeps an eye on "},{"insert":"theaters ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://qvclklblvbiismop.8qaj3npj5q1y.monster/feature/2024/04/08/meduza-poluchila-dostup-k-pochte-sotrudnika-fsb-kotoryy-uzhe-10-let-boretsya-s-nezavisimoy-rossiyskoy-kulturoy-ot-serebrennikova-do-berkovich","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"and "},{"insert":"stand-up","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/news/2026/02/06/nurlanu-saburovu-zapretili-vezd-v-rossiyu-po-initsiative-vtoroi-sluzhbi-fsb-viyasnili-vazhnie-istorii/index.html","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" comedians.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"As<a href=\"https://www.istories.media/en/stories/2025/12/22/mikord/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"> previously reported</a> by IStories, Mikord’s success at the federal level may be linked to Nikolai Nikiforov, a Tatarstan native and former Minister of Communications of Russia. The families of Nikiforov and the Mikord founder Alexander Nikolaev had been in business together for a long time.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The contract for the Pauk system development listed Military Unit 43753 (the FSB’s Center for Information Protection and Special Communications) as main customer and the Kvant Research Institute as the contractor. In turn, Kvant contracted Mikord to carry out the work. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18706,"data":{"block":"<p>The Kvant Research Institute was established in the late 1970s and <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20110706210342/http://www.rdi-kvant.ru/about.php\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">specialized </a>in developing the first supercomputers to solve cryptographic problems for the Soviet Union’s special services. In the 1990s, the institute began collaborating with the FSB — they opened a satellite branch of the Institute of Cryptography, Communications, and Informatics Department of the FSB Academy at Kvant.</p><p><br/></p><p>In 2007, the institute <a href=\"https://normativ.kontur.ru/document?moduleId=1&amp;documentId=130280\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">came under the jurisdiction</a> of the FSB. In 2015, it was <a href=\"https://www.forbes.ru/tekhnologii/internet-i-svyaz/293423-shpionskii-sled-u-italyanskoi-kibergruppy-okazalis-rossiiskie-go\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">revealed </a>that the institute had been paying for a license to use the Remote Control System <a href=\"https://citizenlab.ca/research/hacking-team-targeting-ethiopian-journalists/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">spyware </a>(RCS, a program developed by an Italian company HackingTeam) for several years. Once deployed on a target device, RCS gained access to its files, microphones, cameras, messages and passwords. HackingTeam’s Russian clients <a href=\"https://www.forbes.ru/news/293525-rossiiskii-zakazchik-hacking-team-podtverdil-priobretenie-shpionskogo-po\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">confirmed</a> that they had purchased their malware, but claimed they only did it for the purpose of learning and “enhancing their expertise.”</p><p><br/></p><p>On the Kvant website, the company has <a href=\"https://archive.ph/LTdvK\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">listed </a>its 2010s achievements as &quot;a voice command recognition system for the FEDOR space robot&quot; and &quot;machine learning and artificial intelligence research&quot; projects.</p><p><br/></p><p>Some of those research project details <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20181220091717/https://www.d1g1r3v.net/madskillz/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">became public</a> after a hacker group called Digital Revolution <a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/features-46621322\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">breached </a>Kvant’s servers. We now know that in 2017, the institute looked into using machine learning models to analyze public opinion online. The authors of the research paper proposed monitoring Instagram, VK and other social media posts to identify protest sentiments and combat the so-called “disinformation campaigns.”</p><p><br/></p><p>After the cyberattack, the institute continued to develop its AI-based tools. Among its latest creations are <a href=\"https://archive.ph/9DuhW\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">facial recognition</a> tools, <a href=\"https://archive.ph/jJBRq\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">software </a>allowing to restore text in low-resolution images, and a <a href=\"https://archive.ph/zXdHr\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">program</a> for online content popularity estimations. </p><p><br/></p><p>An equally important direction of Kvant’s work is cybersecurity: <a href=\"https://archive.ph/Q1tOk\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">protection </a>against power grid eavesdropping, open sources cyberthreats <a href=\"https://archive.ph/BugYs\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">detection </a>and software backdoors tracking.</p>","header":"What we know about Kvant","content":[{"insert":"The Kvant Research Institute was established in the late 1970s and "},{"insert":"specialized ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://web.archive.org/web/20110706210342/http://www.rdi-kvant.ru/about.php","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"in developing the first supercomputers to solve cryptographic problems for the Soviet Union’s special services. In the 1990s, the institute began collaborating with the FSB — they opened a satellite branch of the Institute of Cryptography, Communications, and Informatics Department of the FSB Academy at Kvant.\n\nIn 2007, the institute "},{"insert":"came under the jurisdiction","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://normativ.kontur.ru/document?moduleId=1&documentId=130280","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" of the FSB. In 2015, it was "},{"insert":"revealed ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.forbes.ru/tekhnologii/internet-i-svyaz/293423-shpionskii-sled-u-italyanskoi-kibergruppy-okazalis-rossiiskie-go","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"that the institute had been paying for a license to use the Remote Control System "},{"insert":"spyware ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://citizenlab.ca/research/hacking-team-targeting-ethiopian-journalists/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"(RCS, a program developed by an Italian company HackingTeam) for several years. Once deployed on a target device, RCS gained access to its files, microphones, cameras, messages and passwords. HackingTeam’s Russian clients "},{"insert":"confirmed","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.forbes.ru/news/293525-rossiiskii-zakazchik-hacking-team-podtverdil-priobretenie-shpionskogo-po","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" that they had purchased their malware, but claimed they only did it for the purpose of learning and “enhancing their expertise.”\n\nOn the Kvant website, the company has "},{"insert":"listed ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://archive.ph/LTdvK","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"its 2010s achievements as \"a voice command recognition system for the FEDOR space robot\" and \"machine learning and artificial intelligence research\" projects.\n\nSome of those research project details "},{"insert":"became public","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://web.archive.org/web/20181220091717/https://www.d1g1r3v.net/madskillz/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" after a hacker group called Digital Revolution "},{"insert":"breached ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.bbc.com/russian/features-46621322","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"Kvant’s servers. We now know that in 2017, the institute looked into using machine learning models to analyze public opinion online. The authors of the research paper proposed monitoring Instagram, VK and other social media posts to identify protest sentiments and combat the so-called “disinformation campaigns.”\n\nAfter the cyberattack, the institute continued to develop its AI-based tools. Among its latest creations are "},{"insert":"facial recognition","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://archive.ph/9DuhW","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" tools, "},{"insert":"software ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://archive.ph/jJBRq","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"allowing to restore text in low-resolution images, and a "},{"insert":"program","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://archive.ph/zXdHr","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" for online content popularity estimations. \n\nAn equally important direction of Kvant’s work is cybersecurity: "},{"insert":"protection ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://archive.ph/Q1tOk","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"against power grid eavesdropping, open sources cyberthreats "},{"insert":"detection ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://archive.ph/BugYs","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"and software backdoors tracking.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"In the documents, this project is referred to as the “Portal for Analytics and Usage of Contents,” or, shortly, Pauk (“Spider”). A “spider,” or a crawler, is a term used for bots that scan webpages and automatically collect information from them.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It is likely that the Second Service of the FSB was intended to be Pauk’s end user, even though it did not commission the work formally. The Service staff were to participate in the key stages of the new service’s development and implementation, and the work schedule had to be coordinated with the Second Service as well. The ZKSibST abbreviation (short for “Defense of the Constitutional Order and Combating Terrorism” in Russian) used in the titles of project <a href=\"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/documents/36514ec57dc54f9e9063cc32eed22ea0.png\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">documents</a> and the news content Mikord received to be used in the system at the development stage also suggest the Second Service’s involvement. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18707,"data":{"block":"<p>The development contract between Kvant and the main customer, military unit 43753, was signed on May 30, 2025, as part of the state defense order. Mikord was supposed to carry out the work in two phases and complete it in October 2026. </p><p><br/></p><p>The tests of the system were to be conducted at the address of the “operating organization”: 12 Vernadsky Prospekt, Building 4, Moscow. This is the address of the Priboi facility where the FSB’s Second Service (military unit 36391) is <a href=\"https://theins.ru/confession/285905\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">located</a>. References to the service appear several times in the work schedule described in the contract. </p><p><br/></p><p>For example, “logged actions list, data format, file types for log files and data import and export as well as data transfer format” had to be coordinated with both the Center for Information Protection and Special Communications (military unit 43753) and the Second Service (military unit 36391). </p><p><br/></p><p>Representatives from both those FSB military units were also required to participate in the software installation at the facility, as well as in the set-up and adjustment work. </p><p><br/></p><p>The Second Service is listed as the sole body possessing a number of formal approvals authorizing the Pauk use. Ultimately, the work schedule itself had to be approved by a representative of the Second Service — N. N. Belyaev, the deputy commander of military unit 36391.</p>","header":"The connection between the FSB’s Second Service and the Pauk development","content":[{"insert":"The development contract between Kvant and the main customer, military unit 43753, was signed on May 30, 2025, as part of the state defense order. Mikord was supposed to carry out the work in two phases and complete it in October 2026. \n\nThe tests of the system were to be conducted at the address of the “operating organization”: 12 Vernadsky Prospekt, Building 4, Moscow. This is the address of the Priboi facility where the FSB’s Second Service (military unit 36391) is "},{"insert":"located","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://theins.ru/confession/285905","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":". References to the service appear several times in the work schedule described in the contract. \n\nFor example, “logged actions list, data format, file types for log files and data import and export as well as data transfer format” had to be coordinated with both the Center for Information Protection and Special Communications (military unit 43753) and the Second Service (military unit 36391). \n\nRepresentatives from both those FSB military units were also required to participate in the software installation at the facility, as well as in the set-up and adjustment work. \n\nThe Second Service is listed as the sole body possessing a number of formal approvals authorizing the Pauk use. Ultimately, the work schedule itself had to be approved by a representative of the Second Service — N. N. Belyaev, the deputy commander of military unit 36391.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"How the FSB intended to use the AI system","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Pauk was supposed to automate the operations of a situation center presumably created within the FSB’s Second Service. As seen in the project documentation, the center’s shift staff monitor Russian and foreign media news on a daily basis. Every day they compile a news digest which is then sent to FSB leadership.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The web crawler was supposed to automatically collect all the news stories of interest to the FSB. These stories would then be published on an internal news portal, where the officer on duty could select which stories to include in the daily digest.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The compiled digests would be stored within Pauk’s closed (i.e. not connected to the Internet) network, where they could be viewed by the staff on duty as well as other FSB employees. Users would be able to search the reports for the information about specific people or events. Via an LLM and a chatbot interface, the users from FSB would also be able to work with “various closed sources information.” This required Pauk to receive information from certain “third-party data banks” and “data from text sources,” i.e. reports, scans, and the FSB’s own records.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18715,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data","caption":"Pauk’s architecture design","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b0c064c5bb184ed9b1faaa460824937d-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b0c064c5bb184ed9b1faaa460824937d-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b0c064c5bb184ed9b1faaa460824937d-original.png","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1230,"real_height_2x":1358},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b0c064c5bb184ed9b1faaa460824937d-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b0c064c5bb184ed9b1faaa460824937d-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b0c064c5bb184ed9b1faaa460824937d-original.png","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1230,"real_height_2x":1358},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b0c064c5bb184ed9b1faaa460824937d-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b0c064c5bb184ed9b1faaa460824937d-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b0c064c5bb184ed9b1faaa460824937d-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":769,"real_height_2x":1358},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b0c064c5bb184ed9b1faaa460824937d-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b0c064c5bb184ed9b1faaa460824937d-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b0c064c5bb184ed9b1faaa460824937d-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":769,"real_height_2x":1358},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b0c064c5bb184ed9b1faaa460824937d-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b0c064c5bb184ed9b1faaa460824937d-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b0c064c5bb184ed9b1faaa460824937d-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":266,"real_height_2x":532},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b0c064c5bb184ed9b1faaa460824937d-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b0c064c5bb184ed9b1faaa460824937d-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b0c064c5bb184ed9b1faaa460824937d-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":266,"real_height_2x":532}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The documentation does not reveal which specific classified sources the security service intended to use. According to an IStories source familiar with the FSB’s operations, the agency already has a similar data source — the Central Operational Database (COD). It can be accessed by the FSB headquarters staff. Rumors, reports, and criminal cases information are stored in this database.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Additionally, a separate database containing information on Russian citizens has been created within the Second Service, Alexander Fedotov, a former FSB officer, previously told The Insider in an <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?si=mMg_-b4xNymxlOCS&amp;v=V7RiD7TLjqI&amp;feature=youtu.be\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">interview</a>. This database contains activists' and protesters' personal data: their names, photos, and phone numbers.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The envisioned AI assistant could significantly simplify the security officers’ work concerning large volumes of unstructured information and an operational database on activists.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The project documentation also listed the types of data that the AI assistant’s response to a “persons of interest” query might contain: their full name, date of birth, region, phone number, license plate number, and car brand. It is possible that the FSB has begun considering the use of AI in its routine operational work.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Mikord documents contain correspondence between the project manager and an FSB supervisor, identified by the “A.G.” initials. In response to one of the developers’ questions, the FSB representative stated that the system would serve “30 main department users,” but its user load could eventually grow up to 400 people.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"How the FSB tracks the media","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The FSB project supervisors provided the Mikord team with a set of real news digests compiled by the Second Service from January 2024 to June 2025. The developers analyzed them to narrow down the websites and Telegram channels source list for Pauk to the most popular ones.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Mikord used the June 2024 digests set to test an LLM in order to figure out how the chatbot would respond to a security service officer's potential questions. IStories examined the documents metadata and discovered that Ilya Oputin, a programmer at Ozon (a major Russian online marketplace — Ed.) who is believed to have graduated from the FSB Academy, might have worked on them. Oputin did not respond to the journalists’ questions. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18709,"data":{"block":"<p>The metadata contains all the June digests’ author&#x27;s name: Ilya Alexandrovich Oputin. IStories examined the available data leaks and found only one person with the exact same full name. That person turned out to be Ilya Oputin, an Ozon marketplace developer.</p><p><br/></p><p>One of Oputin’s most recent registered addresses was 10k2, Vernadsky Prospekt in Moscow, a house <a href=\"https://wikimapia.org/19511020/ru/%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%BE%D1%81%D0%BF-%D0%92%D0%B5%D1%80%D0%BD%D0%B0%D0%B4%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B3%D0%BE-10-%D0%BA%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%BF%D1%83%D1%81-2#/photo/2309052\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">built </a>for the FSO (Russian Federal Security Service) needs. It is just a few minutes’ walk from the aforementioned Priboi Research Institute where the Second Service of the FSB is located.</p><p><br/></p><p>According to the leaks, for nearly five years (October 2013 to July 2018), Oputin was officially registered as a resident at 1&#x2F;3, Bolshaya Lubyanka Street in Moscow. The National Coordination Center for Computer Incidents (NCCCI), an FSB unit created to prevent critical infrastructure hacker attacks, is <a href=\"https://agentura.ru/profile/federalnaja-sluzhba-bezopasnosti-rossii-fsb/nacionalnyj-koordinacionnyj-centr-po-kompjuternym-incidentam-nkcki/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">located </a>at this address.</p><p><br/></p><p>For a year after that, Oputin lived in the Moscow region with Andrei Babaev, who had been registered at the Bolshaya Lubyanka address during the same period as Oputin.</p><p><br/></p><p>Oputin and Babaev both used another address — 70 Michurinsky Prospekt, Moscow — for various marketplace purchases. The FSB Academy is located at this address, which is where, according to leaked information, they both studied from 2008 to 2013 (five years is the standard training period at the Academy, which is enough for, e.g., <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20260209235720/http://academy.fsb.ru/info/institut-kriptografii-svyazi-i-informatiki/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">completing </a>a degree program at its Institute of Cryptography, Communications, and Informatics).</p><p><br/></p><p>Just like Oputin, Babaev began his career in IT and landed a job at Yandex. His name <a href=\"https://roskomsvoboda.org/en/post/nejroseti-auryi-pod-kontrolem-fsb/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">appears </a>in a 2020 Roskomsvoboda project article titled “Aura Neural Networks Under FSB Control.” The article referred to the Aura social network launched by Yandex, a Russian digital giant, which had been included in the registry of information distributors and therefore legally required to disclose its users&#x27; correspondence to the security services. </p><p><br/></p><p>The article, however, doesn’t refer to Babaev, a 1.5% Aura shareholder, as an ex-FSB official. Meanwhile, just two years before the Aura launch he had listed military unit 78705, which is <a href=\"https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2012/12/03/52619-ofitser-s-bolshoy-dorogi\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">considered </a>part of the FSB, as his place of work. By August 2020, the social media platform had already been <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/russia/721846\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">shut down</a>.</p>","header":"What is known about the Pauk digests authors","content":[{"insert":"The metadata contains all the June digests’ author's name: Ilya Alexandrovich Oputin. IStories examined the available data leaks and found only one person with the exact same full name. That person turned out to be Ilya Oputin, an Ozon marketplace developer.\n\nOne of Oputin’s most recent registered addresses was 10k2, Vernadsky Prospekt in Moscow, a house "},{"insert":"built ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://wikimapia.org/19511020/ru/%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%BE%D1%81%D0%BF-%D0%92%D0%B5%D1%80%D0%BD%D0%B0%D0%B4%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B3%D0%BE-10-%D0%BA%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%BF%D1%83%D1%81-2#/photo/2309052","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"for the FSO (Russian Federal Security Service) needs. It is just a few minutes’ walk from the aforementioned Priboi Research Institute where the Second Service of the FSB is located.\n\nAccording to the leaks, for nearly five years (October 2013 to July 2018), Oputin was officially registered as a resident at 1/3, Bolshaya Lubyanka Street in Moscow. The National Coordination Center for Computer Incidents (NCCCI), an FSB unit created to prevent critical infrastructure hacker attacks, is "},{"insert":"located ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://agentura.ru/profile/federalnaja-sluzhba-bezopasnosti-rossii-fsb/nacionalnyj-koordinacionnyj-centr-po-kompjuternym-incidentam-nkcki/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"at this address.\n\nFor a year after that, Oputin lived in the Moscow region with Andrei Babaev, who had been registered at the Bolshaya Lubyanka address during the same period as Oputin.\n\nOputin and Babaev both used another address — 70 Michurinsky Prospekt, Moscow — for various marketplace purchases. The FSB Academy is located at this address, which is where, according to leaked information, they both studied from 2008 to 2013 (five years is the standard training period at the Academy, which is enough for, e.g., "},{"insert":"completing ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://web.archive.org/web/20260209235720/http://academy.fsb.ru/info/institut-kriptografii-svyazi-i-informatiki/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"a degree program at its Institute of Cryptography, Communications, and Informatics).\n\nJust like Oputin, Babaev began his career in IT and landed a job at Yandex. His name "},{"insert":"appears ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://roskomsvoboda.org/en/post/nejroseti-auryi-pod-kontrolem-fsb/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"in a 2020 Roskomsvoboda project article titled “Aura Neural Networks Under FSB Control.” The article referred to the Aura social network launched by Yandex, a Russian digital giant, which had been included in the registry of information distributors and therefore legally required to disclose its users' correspondence to the security services. \n\nThe article, however, doesn’t refer to Babaev, a 1.5% Aura shareholder, as an ex-FSB official. Meanwhile, just two years before the Aura launch he had listed military unit 78705, which is "},{"insert":"considered ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2012/12/03/52619-ofitser-s-bolshoy-dorogi","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"part of the FSB, as his place of work. By August 2020, the social media platform had already been "},{"insert":"shut down","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.interfax.ru/russia/721846","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":".\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"Each digest is divided into two sections: Russian and international news. Several documents contain the following introductory paragraph: “As a result of monitoring online media on April 10, 2024, the following significant incidents and events were identified as those of interest in terms of defending the constitutional order and combating terrorism.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We have compiled the news into a unified calendar: there, you can view a specific day report, find a random news item, or search one by keyword. The calendar is available in <a href=\"https://istories.media/stories/2026/07/15/neiroseti-v-plenu-u-fsb/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">the Russian version</a> of the text.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It is unknown what criteria the FSB used to select the news items. In the same digest, a news item <a href=\"https://tsargrad.tv/news/priznat-vsu-sbu-i-gur-terroristami-komissija-parlamenta-rossii-dala-rekomendaciju-genprokurature-i-fsb_1016573\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">titled </a>“Parliament Proposes Designating the Ukrainian Armed Forces, the Security Service of Ukraine, and the Defense Intelligence of Ukraine as Terrorists” may appear alongside a note about a Khabarovsk Krai village headman video <a href=\"https://activatica.org/content/531b5f3f-34a1-4702-9c23-1b0b6630acf0/glava-poselka-v-habarovskom-krae-obratilsya-k-putinu\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">appealing </a>to Vladimir Putin.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Many of the news items in the digests are copying the FSB’s own press releases and statements, such as the news titled “The FSB Reports an Ivanovo Resident Detained For Financing the Ukrainian Armed Forces” or “FSB Chief Speaks About Kyiv Recruiting Migrants to Commit Crimes in Russia.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/stories/2026/07/15/za-kakimi-temami-sledit-vtoraya-sluzhba-fsb/index.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">analyzed</a> nearly 5,000 news items from FSB reports and grouped them into themed categories. Many of them are consistent with the Second Service’s traditional activities: combating Islamists, spying on the opposition and carrying out political assassinations. From these same digests, we learned that the service closely monitors news about pressure on migrants in Russia, strikes and protests abroad, and ethnic conflicts in Europe. A detailed analysis of the FSB’s Second Service news digests can be found <a href=\"https://www.istories.media/stories/2026/07/15/za-kakimi-temami-sledit-vtoraya-sluzhba-fsb/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">here</a> (in Russian).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Independent outlets have become some of the key sources of information about what's going on in Russia for the Second Service. According to our calculations, in the first six months of 2025, three of them — Activatica, RusNews, and Govorit NeMoskva — were among the five top cited media outlets in the FSB digests.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Activatica — an outlet covering civic activism and repressions in Russia — tops this ranking by a wide margin. In the first six months of 2025, 244 of their news stories appeared in the FSB digests. Activatica was the source of one in every six news items in the Second Service’s reports. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Sometimes the digests are almost completely shaped by Activatica’s news items. The June 26 2024 report contained three Activatica stories: the <a href=\"https://activatica.org/content/271b0085-861c-4f91-b1af-b8ddbd29bb2a/ufimcy-vyshli-na-akcii-protiv-povysheniya-tarifov-zhkh\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">protests </a>against rising utility rates in Ufa; Moscow’s Mitino residents’ video <a href=\"https://activatica.org/content/4bc332d8-3d3c-4d4a-bf2b-f1a524c5a07d/v-mitino-trebuyut-otmenit-stroitelstvo-zavodov-upakovki\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">appeal </a>to Putin asking him not to build a packaging plant; daily <a href=\"https://activatica.org/content/83c2983a-a189-4bda-b381-cd8212dcadb6/v-sele-yarensk-zhiteli-kazhdyj-den-vyhodyat-za-skoruyu-pomosh\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">protests </a>in Arkhangelsk Oblast’s Yarensk, where residents opposed the decision to move the emergency medical services station 200 km from the village.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Overall, between January 2024 and June 2025, more than 550 articles from the uncensored outlets (mostly those operating in exile due to the official persecution on behalf of the government, e.g. being designated as “foreign agents” — Ed.) appeared in the FSB’s news digests — that’s more than 10% of all the news items included. Among others, the officers cited such outlets as OVD-Info, 7x7, Sirena and Meduza.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18714,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/8f948419fe2a4d72b96a1289c6a52ba8/index.html","url_mobile":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/8f948419fe2a4d72b96a1289c6a52ba8/index.html","ratio_mobile":"3:4","ratio_desktop":"4:3"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"Independent media outlets’ reports about the FSB itself are also of interest to the security service. For example, a Meduza <a href=\"https://meduza.io/feature/2024/04/08/meduza-poluchila-dostup-k-pochte-sotrudnika-fsb-kotoryy-uzhe-10-let-boretsya-s-nezavisimoy-rossiyskoy-kulturoy-ot-serebrennikova-do-berkovich\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">article </a>about Sergei Dubov, a Second Service employee, made its way into a digest for the FSB high-ranking officials that very same day.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Overall, in a year and a half the FSB’s Second Service monitored more than a thousand information sources: Russian federal and regional media websites, independent media outlets in exile, anonymous Telegram channels, VK news communities and YouTube channels.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It is impossible to manually monitor such a wide range of sources on a daily basis. There are several references in the digests indicating that the Second Service is already using a solution similar to Pauk (made by a Russian company called Kribrum) to search and filter news. Kribrum is a service for monitoring media and social networks <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/2256259\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">launched </a>15 years ago by Igor Ashmanov and Natalia Kaspersky.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Ashmanov, a member of Russia’s Human Rights Council, constantly comes up with some new restrictive proposals. For example, he has proposed establishing a military <a href=\"https://tass.ru/obschestvo/16158269\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">censorship </a>body in Russia as well as creating a “toxic content” <a href=\"https://meduza.io/news/2022/01/29/putin-podderzhal-ideyu-sozdaniya-reestra-toksichnogo-kontenta-v-internete\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">registry</a>. At a 2015 Kribrum presentation Ashmanov <a href=\"https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2015/04/24/63969-esli-u-vas-paranoyya-8212-eto-ne-znachit-chto-za-vami-ne-sledyat\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">shared</a> that the system analyzed 19 thousand media outlets and classified them into “liberal,” “neutral,” or “patriotic” ones.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It is likely that the Second Service had planned to replace the third-party solution with its own one. According to an IStories source close to the FSB, the Service’s units can create such solutions for their own use if they secure the necessary budget. Media monitoring, in particular, had previously been handled by the Department of Operational Information — a unit of the FSB’s Fifth Service responsible for intelligence in CIS countries (Commonwealth of Independent States, a regional organisation of post-soviet states — Ed.).&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"What the prototype looks like","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The Mikord document archive reveals a detailed description of how Pauk was supposed to work. In addition, IStories have found the design layouts of the project, which have been shared publicly and, at the time of publication, are still <a href=\"https://www.figma.com/design/WtanNB0i8u50Q0YCpp6sSc/%D0%9D%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%BE%D1%81%D1%82%D0%BD%D0%B0%D1%8F-%D0%BB%D0%B5%D0%BD%D1%82%D0%B0?t=ZJXR7jdfYkCkU7DZ-0\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">available</a> to anyone interested. Using the data, we’ve recreated a clickable Pauk prototype: follow <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/stories/2026/07/15/kak-viglyadit-rabochee-mesto-spetssluzhbista/index.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">the link</a> to try out the role of an FSB Second Service official.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"While working on the confidential FSB service, Mikord used foreign technologies and products. For example, the latest Pauk interfaces were stored in Figma, an American service. A US-made framework, LlamaIndex, was to be used for processing news reports and other classified documents. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18716,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data","caption":"The AI assistant workflow overview","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83927413ab0646899ffc661aa9356055-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83927413ab0646899ffc661aa9356055-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83927413ab0646899ffc661aa9356055-original.png","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1278,"real_height_2x":1411},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83927413ab0646899ffc661aa9356055-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83927413ab0646899ffc661aa9356055-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83927413ab0646899ffc661aa9356055-original.png","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1278,"real_height_2x":1411},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83927413ab0646899ffc661aa9356055-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83927413ab0646899ffc661aa9356055-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83927413ab0646899ffc661aa9356055-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":799,"real_height_2x":1411},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83927413ab0646899ffc661aa9356055-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83927413ab0646899ffc661aa9356055-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83927413ab0646899ffc661aa9356055-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":799,"real_height_2x":1411},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83927413ab0646899ffc661aa9356055-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83927413ab0646899ffc661aa9356055-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83927413ab0646899ffc661aa9356055-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":552},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83927413ab0646899ffc661aa9356055-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83927413ab0646899ffc661aa9356055-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83927413ab0646899ffc661aa9356055-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":552}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The Llama 2 LLM by Meta (it’s worth noting that the company is designated as an “extremist organization” in Russia — Ed.) was supposed to respond to the security service officials’ requests. The dialogue sessions between the FSB officers and the AI assistant were to be stored in a MongoDB database (meanwhile its developers had <a href=\"https://www.mongodb.com/company/blog/news/mongodb-assistance-ukraine-shut-down-work-russia\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">declared</a> they support Ukraine and had ceased operations in Russia).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The work was supposed to look like this: an FSB officer on duty supervises the list of sources whose news items get into the Pauk feed. At the same stage the user can edit the news items, rate them on a one-to-five scale, and comment. Selected news items make it into the daily digest for the higher-ranking officials.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18717,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Source: the leaked data","caption":"Pauk interface reference as seen by the customer. An FSB officer leaves a comment: ‘Take note for future action’","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eda2597f9d6540d3adb44c5a239d0548-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eda2597f9d6540d3adb44c5a239d0548-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eda2597f9d6540d3adb44c5a239d0548-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eda2597f9d6540d3adb44c5a239d0548-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eda2597f9d6540d3adb44c5a239d0548-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eda2597f9d6540d3adb44c5a239d0548-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eda2597f9d6540d3adb44c5a239d0548-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eda2597f9d6540d3adb44c5a239d0548-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eda2597f9d6540d3adb44c5a239d0548-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eda2597f9d6540d3adb44c5a239d0548-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eda2597f9d6540d3adb44c5a239d0548-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eda2597f9d6540d3adb44c5a239d0548-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eda2597f9d6540d3adb44c5a239d0548-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eda2597f9d6540d3adb44c5a239d0548-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eda2597f9d6540d3adb44c5a239d0548-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eda2597f9d6540d3adb44c5a239d0548-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eda2597f9d6540d3adb44c5a239d0548-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/eda2597f9d6540d3adb44c5a239d0548-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Each news item is assigned a category and a list of tags, keywords, and personalities mentioned. FSB officers can use these to search.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Second Service officer on duty can also set up Telegram notifications for incidents of interest. The technical document provides a scenario for using such notifications: “for example, all news stories mentioning ‘a demonstration near the embassy’ or ‘a fight between migrants in Kazan.’”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It is likely that the FSB had intended to use this tool to quickly respond to certain events in Russia among other things. “There was also an idea that if a selected news item contains words like ‘URGENT,’ ‘FLASH,’ and so on, we could choose to use it as an alert notification criteria,” — the FSB project supervisor identified as A.G. told a Mikord staff member. Another comment from the supervisor suggests that the news notifications were to be sent via a Telegram bot the officers were supposed to subscribe to.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Only the approved news items would enter the Pauk's closed environment where an FSB officer could compile a daily or monthly digest in a built-in editing tool. In addition, the same service was supposed to incorporate a CRM system to assign and track monitoring tasks. The FSB high officials would be able to order a report on a topic of interest directly within the Pauk system.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>***</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to the plan, the first phase of Pauk’s development was to be completed by the autumn of 2025. That’s roughly when, after nearly a year and a half of work, a manager commented in Mikord's task tracker that the development of the project was suspended. “Goodbye, project…,” another employee replied.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A source familiar with the development process told IStories that Mikord simply couldn’t deliver on this government contract. The company was not able to launch the service on time, which is why the work was shut down.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Mikord team likely lacked both the development experience and the necessary expertise to work with language models, an IT specialist interviewed by IStories suggested upon reviewing the project documentation, Mikord’s task tracker entries and other data.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":10034,"header":"One Powerful Family, Different Sides of the War","_path":"/en/stories/2026/06/24/agayevs/","lead":"A Russian Duma deputy’s family supports Russian militaries in the war against Ukraine while investing millions of euros in Luxembourg and Germany","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2760,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1380},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2760,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1380},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-original.png","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-original.png","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-original.png","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-original.png","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-original.png","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-original.png","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-original.png","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-original.png","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-original.png","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-original.png","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-original.png","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-original.png","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-original.png","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/afbc056885d64521875b8b713ce1a7dd-original.png","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Left to right: Bekkhan Agayev, Ramzan Kadyrov, Vakha Agayev. Picture: IStories. Photos: United Russia official website, Kadyrov’s VKontakte page","created_at_date":"2026-06-24","created_at_date_time":"2026-06-16T23:11:36.169Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":18,"first_name":"Роман","last_name":"Катин","first_name_en":"Roman","last_name_en":"Katin","is_public":true,"_path":"r","avatar":[],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[{"id":358,"first_name":"Манон","last_name":"Ромейн","first_name_en":"Manon","last_name_en":"Romain","company":"Le Monde","company_en":"Le Monde","company_link":"https://www.lemonde.fr/","avatar":[],"ordering":1}],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"The war has divided the family of Bekkhan Agayev, a United Russia State Duma deputy close to Ramzan Kadyrov (the head of Chechen Republic — Ed.). The fight club Agayev founded supports the Russian ArBat battalion fighting against Ukraine, meanwhile the deputy’s younger brother, Batyr Agayev, has become a Belgian citizen. The investment funds associated with him have invested approximately €100 million in European real estate.\n\nIStories discovered this thanks to our participation in the OpenLux project, which allows the journalists access data on the ownership of Luxembourg-registered companies and funds. Le Monde and Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project (OCCRP) are partners in the project.\n\nKadyrov’s “dear brother”\n\nRamzan Kadyrov referred to Bekkhan and Batyr’s father, Vakha Agayev, the patriarch of the family, as “dear brother.” There is a video honoring Agayev on Kadyrov’s VKontakte page: on Agayev’s 60th birthday in 2013, Kadyrov awarded him the title of “Honorary Citizen of the Chechen Republic.” They are shown discussing something at a large table set with appetizers against a backdrop of golden furniture. In 2013, a street in the city of Urus-Martan was named in honor of the “dear brother” even though he was still alive back then.\n\nVakha Agayev built the family business empire, the Yug-Nefteprodukt, a Chechen oil trading company. With his children, Bekkhan and Batyr, Vakha also owned stakes in the largest oil refineries of southern Russia — the Tuapse and Krasnodar ones.\nThere is no doubt that the business has been a family enterprise: the Agayevs took turns owning Yug-Nefteprodukt. Vakha Agayev founded the company in 1998. He and his youngest son, Batyr, would successively control it through one German company (Interinol) and two offshore entities, Rutley Company SA and Okling Group SA, based in the British Virgin Islands, as revealed in the offshore leak documents obtained by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ).\n\nStarting in 2009, the family members have owned Yug-Nefteprodukt directly. Initially, it was owned by the younger son, Batyr Agayev (as both the father and the elder son were members of the State Duma at the time, which would not allow them to run the business — Ed.). From 2018 to 2021, the elder son Bekkhan was in charge. Vakha died of COVID-19 in 2020, and the following year Bekkhan returned to the Russian parliament, where he still holds a seat. Now it was time for the next generation of the Agayev family to take the reins, and Yug-Nefteprodukt was transferred to Bekkhan’s son, Ruslan.\n\nThe Agayevs business in Europe has also been a family affair. Interinol, a German oil and petroleum trader, is still owned by Batyr Agayev. Vakha Agayev was listed as managing director, and Bekkhan served as an authorized representative until 2015 (while still being a Russian Duma deputy).\n\nIn 2024, Interinol changed its name to Agom and switched to asset management, but this is still the company the Agayevs utilized to hold stakes in the Tuapse and Krasnodar oil refineries (as well as the offshore companies).\n\nThe Agayev family have invested their oil money in real estate — not only in Russia but, as it turned out, in Europe as well.\n\nBatyr Agayev’s Luxembourg-based Everest\n\nThe Luxembourg registry records show that Batyr Agayev, the younger brother of the deputy Bekkhan, has become a Belgian citizen and splits his time between Berlin and Monaco. Batyr Agayev owns a 56.16% stake in a Luxembourg-based real estate investment fund Everest One, established in 2019. According to the fund’s website, it focuses on real estate investments (primary commercial and office real estate in Germany, but also on hotels, healthcare facilities and housing). Its assets amounted to €65 million in 2022.\n\nThe fund is managed by Mimco Group, founded by Swiss national Bernd von Manteuffel and Luxembourg national Christophe Nadal. The former has been dealing with European real estate for over 35 years, while the latter, according to the website, boasts 20 years of experience. The group currently manages assets of over €2 billion worth.\nBatyr Agayev also holds a 43.5% stake in the Luxembourg-based Mimco Real Estate Holding. According to the 2022 data, the company invested about €35 million in German Mimco Real Estate Holding Se & Co Kg, which is intended for real estate investments, as indicated in the company’s financial report.\n\nA fight club and the Wild Donbass Division\n\n“Bekkhan Agayev is one of the founders of the URF [United Russian Fighters] team. <...> He is a true patriot of Russia who makes a significant contribution to our country’s development every day. <...> We are sincerely proud that he supports our team, motivates our athletes, and helps the community,” the URF mixed martial arts club posted on their Instagram page.\n\nAccording to a company register, Bekkhan Agayev’s son Dany owns 40% of the United Russian Fighters club. Half of the URF is owned by its vice-president, Roland (Rocky) Kavali. Among those representing the club is, for example, the well-known Russian fighter Alexander Emelianenko.\n\nURF and its associates assist Russian military forces in the war against Ukraine. “We’ve gathered a large shipment of humanitarian aid, which will be sent today to the ArBat, (“Armenian Batallion” — Ed.) within the Pyatnashka, [a military unit also known as] the Wild Donbass Division, from our team and our founders,” the club reported on its Instagram page in 2024. \nRoland Kavali, the Agayevs’ partner at United Russian Fighters and the club’s vice-president, as well as Vagab Vagabov, one of the fighters, were longtime friends of the late ArBat founder Armen Sargsyan, the battalion commander has mentioned in an interview. He thanked them for their support. Kavali contributes “a great deal to the battalion,” the commander explained: “He’s built us a gym where Vagab Vagabov trains the guys, gets them ready, and keeps them in shape.”\n\nIn January 2024, Vagabov told Match TV that he had signed a military contract to serve in the ArBat battalion. However, he is not fighting on the front lines, but rather 2–3 km away. “I’ve taken on the soldiers’ physical and firearms training,” Vagabov said in a Sport-Express interview.\n\nNeither the Agayevs, nor Kavali, nor the Mimco founders Manteuffel and Nadal have responded to our questions.","blocks":[{"data":"The war has divided the family of Bekkhan Agayev, a United Russia State Duma deputy close to Ramzan Kadyrov (the head of Chechen Republic — Ed.). The fight club Agayev founded supports the Russian ArBat battalion fighting against Ukraine, meanwhile the deputy’s younger brother, Batyr Agayev, has become a Belgian citizen. The investment funds associated with him have invested approximately €100 million in European real estate.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories discovered this thanks to our participation in the <a href=\"https://www.occrp.org/en/project/openlux\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">OpenLux</a> project, which allows the journalists access data on the ownership of Luxembourg-registered companies and funds. <a href=\"https://www.lemonde.fr/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Le Monde</a> and Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project (<a href=\"https://www.occrp.org/en\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">OCCRP</a>) are partners in the project.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Kadyrov’s “dear brother”","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Ramzan Kadyrov referred to Bekkhan and Batyr’s father, Vakha Agayev, the patriarch of the family, as “dear brother.” There is a <a href=\"https://vkvideo.ru/video279938622_456241571?t=19s\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">video</a> honoring Agayev on Kadyrov’s VKontakte page: on Agayev’s 60th birthday in 2013, Kadyrov awarded him the title of “Honorary Citizen of the Chechen Republic.” They are shown discussing something at a large table set with appetizers against a backdrop of golden furniture. In 2013, a street in the city of Urus-Martan was <a href=\"https://urusmartan.bezformata.com/listnews/sin-svoego-otechestva/10210586/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">named </a>in honor of the “dear brother” even though he was still alive back then.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Vakha Agayev built the family business empire, the Yug-Nefteprodukt, a Chechen oil trading company. With his children, Bekkhan and Batyr, Vakha also owned stakes in the largest oil refineries of southern Russia — the Tuapse and Krasnodar ones.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18569,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Ramzan Kadyrov’s VKontakte page","caption":"Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrov and Vakha Agayev at a banquet","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9ed29206bef44f3481c9eabe22497f8b-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9ed29206bef44f3481c9eabe22497f8b-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9ed29206bef44f3481c9eabe22497f8b-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":3024,"real_height_1x":1266,"real_height_2x":1995},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9ed29206bef44f3481c9eabe22497f8b-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9ed29206bef44f3481c9eabe22497f8b-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9ed29206bef44f3481c9eabe22497f8b-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":3024,"real_height_1x":1266,"real_height_2x":1995},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9ed29206bef44f3481c9eabe22497f8b-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9ed29206bef44f3481c9eabe22497f8b-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9ed29206bef44f3481c9eabe22497f8b-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":791,"real_height_2x":1583},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9ed29206bef44f3481c9eabe22497f8b-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9ed29206bef44f3481c9eabe22497f8b-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9ed29206bef44f3481c9eabe22497f8b-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":791,"real_height_2x":1583},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9ed29206bef44f3481c9eabe22497f8b-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9ed29206bef44f3481c9eabe22497f8b-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9ed29206bef44f3481c9eabe22497f8b-original.png","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":273,"real_height_2x":547},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9ed29206bef44f3481c9eabe22497f8b-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9ed29206bef44f3481c9eabe22497f8b-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9ed29206bef44f3481c9eabe22497f8b-original.png","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":273,"real_height_2x":547}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"There is no doubt that the business has been a family enterprise: the Agayevs took turns owning Yug-Nefteprodukt. Vakha Agayev <a href=\"https://nepotism.proekt.media/cards/rel/agaev-vakha-abuevich\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">founded</a> the company in 1998. He and his youngest son, Batyr, would successively control it through one German company (Interinol) and two offshore entities, Rutley Company SA and Okling Group SA, based in the British Virgin Islands, as revealed in the offshore leak documents obtained by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Starting in 2009, the family members have owned Yug-Nefteprodukt directly. Initially, it was owned by the younger son, Batyr Agayev (as both the father and the elder son were members of the State Duma at the time, which would not allow them to run the business — Ed.). From 2018 to 2021, the elder son Bekkhan was in charge. Vakha died of COVID-19 in 2020, and the following year Bekkhan returned to the Russian parliament, where he still holds a seat. Now it was time for the next generation of the Agayev family to take the reins, and Yug-Nefteprodukt was transferred to Bekkhan’s son, Ruslan.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Agayevs business in Europe has also been a family affair. Interinol, a German oil and petroleum trader, is <a href=\"https://theins.ru/korrupciya/247973\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">still owned</a> by Batyr Agayev. Vakha Agayev <a href=\"https://www.companyhouse.de/Bekkhan-Agaew\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">was listed</a> as managing director, and Bekkhan served as an authorized representative until 2015 (while still being a Russian Duma deputy).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2024, Interinol <a href=\"https://www.northdata.de/AGOM%20GmbH,%20Berlin/Amtsgericht%20Charlottenburg%20(Berlin)%20HRB%2076203%20B\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">changed </a>its name to Agom and switched to asset management, but this is still the company the Agayevs utilized to hold stakes in the Tuapse and Krasnodar oil refineries (as well as the offshore companies).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Agayev family have invested their oil money in real estate — not only in Russia but, as it turned out, in Europe as well.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18494,"data":{"items":[{"text":[{"insert":"The Tuapse Oil Refinery, in which the Agayevs owned a stake, used to be one of the "},{"insert":"main","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://belchemoil.by/news/international/top-10-krupnejshih-npz-v-rossii-moshhnost-modernizaciya-i-glubina-pererabotki","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" oil refineries in southern Russia (prior to its stoppage due to a Ukrainian drone attack in 2026 — Ed.). And the Agayevs’ Yug-Nefteprodukt was one of the largest suppliers of crude oil to this refinery. In 2004, the company "},{"insert":"supplied","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.lawtek.ru/news/10738/rosneft_zaklyuchila_dogovor_s_tuapsinskim_npz_na_pererabotku_v_tekushchem_godu_4_08_mln_t_nefti","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" more than 30% of all the crude oil to be processed at the refinery (meanwhile Rosneft, the state-owned company that controlled the refinery at the time, supplied 40%). Until 2004, the Agayevs’ offshore companies (the aforementioned Rutley Company and Okling Group) owned 20.32% of the Tuapse Oil Refinery. Later these shares were "},{"insert":"purchased","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/559989","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" by Rosneft.\n\nStarting in the 2000s, the Agayevs, through the same offshore firms and the German Interinol, have owned a 41.2% share of another key southern Russia oil refinement facility, the Krasnodar Oil Refinery — Krasnodarekoneft (KNPZ-KEN). Bekkhan Agayev was on board until 2021. According to the documents from the ICIJ offshore leak, Mikhail Gutseriev’s (a Russian billionaire and Russneft founder — Ed.) offshores, Basca United SA and Ratger Company SA, co-owned the refinery. In 2021, KNPZ-KEN merged with Afipsky Refinery belonging to Gutseriev.\n"}],"image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cfed8c2d2e2b4c0092b985f36af35ecd-1060x596px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cfed8c2d2e2b4c0092b985f36af35ecd-1060x596px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1060,"for_height":596,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cfed8c2d2e2b4c0092b985f36af35ecd-original.png","real_width_1x":1060,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":596,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cfed8c2d2e2b4c0092b985f36af35ecd-1060x596px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cfed8c2d2e2b4c0092b985f36af35ecd-1060x596px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1060,"for_height":596,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cfed8c2d2e2b4c0092b985f36af35ecd-original.png","real_width_1x":1060,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":596,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cfed8c2d2e2b4c0092b985f36af35ecd-720x405px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cfed8c2d2e2b4c0092b985f36af35ecd-720x405px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":720,"for_height":405,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cfed8c2d2e2b4c0092b985f36af35ecd-original.png","real_width_1x":720,"real_width_2x":1440,"real_height_1x":404,"real_height_2x":810},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cfed8c2d2e2b4c0092b985f36af35ecd-720x405px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cfed8c2d2e2b4c0092b985f36af35ecd-720x405px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":720,"for_height":405,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cfed8c2d2e2b4c0092b985f36af35ecd-original.png","real_width_1x":720,"real_width_2x":1440,"real_height_1x":404,"real_height_2x":810},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cfed8c2d2e2b4c0092b985f36af35ecd-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cfed8c2d2e2b4c0092b985f36af35ecd-416x234px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cfed8c2d2e2b4c0092b985f36af35ecd-original.png","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cfed8c2d2e2b4c0092b985f36af35ecd-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cfed8c2d2e2b4c0092b985f36af35ecd-416x234px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cfed8c2d2e2b4c0092b985f36af35ecd-original.png","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468}],"credit":[{"insert":"The oil refineries associated with Agayevs","attributes":{"bold":true}},{"insert":"\n"}],"textBlock":"<p>The Tuapse Oil Refinery, in which the Agayevs owned a stake, used to be one of the <a href=\"https://belchemoil.by/news/international/top-10-krupnejshih-npz-v-rossii-moshhnost-modernizaciya-i-glubina-pererabotki\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">main</a> oil refineries in southern Russia (prior to its stoppage due to a Ukrainian drone attack in 2026 — Ed.). And the Agayevs’ Yug-Nefteprodukt was one of the largest suppliers of crude oil to this refinery. In 2004, the company <a href=\"https://www.lawtek.ru/news/10738/rosneft_zaklyuchila_dogovor_s_tuapsinskim_npz_na_pererabotku_v_tekushchem_godu_4_08_mln_t_nefti\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">supplied</a> more than 30% of all the crude oil to be processed at the refinery (meanwhile Rosneft, the state-owned company that controlled the refinery at the time, supplied 40%). Until 2004, the Agayevs’ offshore companies (the aforementioned Rutley Company and Okling Group) owned 20.32% of the Tuapse Oil Refinery. Later these shares were <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/559989\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">purchased</a> by Rosneft.</p><p><br/></p><p>Starting in the 2000s, the Agayevs, through the same offshore firms and the German Interinol, have owned a 41.2% share of another key southern Russia oil refinement facility, the Krasnodar Oil Refinery — Krasnodarekoneft (KNPZ-KEN). Bekkhan Agayev was on board until 2021. According to the documents from the ICIJ offshore leak, Mikhail Gutseriev’s (a Russian billionaire and Russneft founder — Ed.) offshores, Basca United SA and Ratger Company SA, co-owned the refinery. In 2021, KNPZ-KEN merged with Afipsky Refinery belonging to Gutseriev.</p>","creditBlock":"<p><strong>The oil refineries associated with Agayevs</strong></p>"},{"text":[{"insert":"The billionaire Mikhail Gutseriev is also close to the Kadyrov family. In 2025, Ramzan Kadyrov awarded the billionaire the title of Honorary Citizen of Chechnya. On his Telegram channel, he "},{"insert":"stated","attributes":{"link":{"link":"http://rbc.ru/politics/02/06/2025/683d914b9a79478b74d99bf3","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" that Gutseriev and Chechnya’s first president Akhmad Kadyrov (Ramzan’s father), shared “warm, personal, and trusting relations.”\n\nBekkhan Agayev used to be Gutseriev's "},{"insert":"advisor ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/5953701","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"at Russneft. According to the ICIJ offshore leak, his brother, Batyr Agayev, has owned Eso Trading, a petroleum products trading company registered in the British Virgin Islands. The company was "},{"insert":"supplied ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.volza.com/company-profile/eso-trading-ltd-from-resources-of-cjsc-kompaniya-adamas-40860475/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"with petroleum products by the Agayevs’ Yug-Nefteprodukt and was part of complex export schemes involving Gutseriev’s Russneft in the early 2000s. These schemes drew the attention of Russian tax authorities at the time, leading to legal "},{"insert":"proceedings ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.garant.ru/products/ipo/prime/doc/5225779/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"in arbitration courts. Eso Trading would export petroleum products processed from Russneft crude oil at the Afipsky Refinery to France, Spain, and Portugal. The crude oil and petroleum products passed through a chain of companies eligible for VAT refunds. The tax authorities objected to this, suspecting that the scheme was making no economic sense, which made it seem suspicious.\n"}],"image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ae1b0c17601e4e1e965bf558bb7a04b9-1060x596px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ae1b0c17601e4e1e965bf558bb7a04b9-1060x596px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1060,"for_height":596,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ae1b0c17601e4e1e965bf558bb7a04b9-original.png","real_width_1x":1060,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":596,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ae1b0c17601e4e1e965bf558bb7a04b9-1060x596px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ae1b0c17601e4e1e965bf558bb7a04b9-1060x596px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1060,"for_height":596,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ae1b0c17601e4e1e965bf558bb7a04b9-original.png","real_width_1x":1060,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":596,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ae1b0c17601e4e1e965bf558bb7a04b9-720x405px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ae1b0c17601e4e1e965bf558bb7a04b9-720x405px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":720,"for_height":405,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ae1b0c17601e4e1e965bf558bb7a04b9-original.png","real_width_1x":720,"real_width_2x":1440,"real_height_1x":404,"real_height_2x":810},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ae1b0c17601e4e1e965bf558bb7a04b9-720x405px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ae1b0c17601e4e1e965bf558bb7a04b9-720x405px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":720,"for_height":405,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ae1b0c17601e4e1e965bf558bb7a04b9-original.png","real_width_1x":720,"real_width_2x":1440,"real_height_1x":404,"real_height_2x":810},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ae1b0c17601e4e1e965bf558bb7a04b9-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ae1b0c17601e4e1e965bf558bb7a04b9-416x234px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ae1b0c17601e4e1e965bf558bb7a04b9-original.png","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ae1b0c17601e4e1e965bf558bb7a04b9-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ae1b0c17601e4e1e965bf558bb7a04b9-416x234px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ae1b0c17601e4e1e965bf558bb7a04b9-original.png","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468}],"credit":[{"insert":"Connections to Mikhail Gutseriev","attributes":{"bold":true}},{"insert":"\n"}],"textBlock":"<p>The billionaire Mikhail Gutseriev is also close to the Kadyrov family. In 2025, Ramzan Kadyrov awarded the billionaire the title of Honorary Citizen of Chechnya. On his Telegram channel, he <a href=\"http://rbc.ru/politics/02/06/2025/683d914b9a79478b74d99bf3\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">stated</a> that Gutseriev and Chechnya’s first president Akhmad Kadyrov (Ramzan’s father), shared “warm, personal, and trusting relations.”</p><p><br/></p><p>Bekkhan Agayev used to be Gutseriev&#x27;s <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/5953701\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">advisor </a>at Russneft. According to the ICIJ offshore leak, his brother, Batyr Agayev, has owned Eso Trading, a petroleum products trading company registered in the British Virgin Islands. The company was <a href=\"https://www.volza.com/company-profile/eso-trading-ltd-from-resources-of-cjsc-kompaniya-adamas-40860475/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">supplied </a>with petroleum products by the Agayevs’ Yug-Nefteprodukt and was part of complex export schemes involving Gutseriev’s Russneft in the early 2000s. These schemes drew the attention of Russian tax authorities at the time, leading to legal <a href=\"https://www.garant.ru/products/ipo/prime/doc/5225779/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">proceedings </a>in arbitration courts. Eso Trading would export petroleum products processed from Russneft crude oil at the Afipsky Refinery to France, Spain, and Portugal. The crude oil and petroleum products passed through a chain of companies eligible for VAT refunds. The tax authorities objected to this, suspecting that the scheme was making no economic sense, which made it seem suspicious.</p>","creditBlock":"<p><strong>Connections to Mikhail Gutseriev</strong></p>"},{"text":[{"insert":"In 2006, Yug-Nefteprodukt affiliates "},{"insert":"purchased ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/710981","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"Capital Tower, a 16-story business center on Brestskaya Street in Moscow. At the time, the deal was estimated to be worth $70–75 million. The business center was registered under a Cypriot company, Boundhill Trading, which belonged to Vakha and Batyr Agayev through three offshore companies (Prime Business Inc, Rutley Company SA, and Northern Starinvest SA), as revealed in the ICIJ offshore leak.\n"}],"image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/19bd6a340f2e42bc9e06f93977ba64f6-1060x596px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/19bd6a340f2e42bc9e06f93977ba64f6-1060x596px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1060,"for_height":596,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/19bd6a340f2e42bc9e06f93977ba64f6-original.png","real_width_1x":1060,"real_width_2x":1980,"real_height_1x":596,"real_height_2x":1114},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/19bd6a340f2e42bc9e06f93977ba64f6-1060x596px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/19bd6a340f2e42bc9e06f93977ba64f6-1060x596px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1060,"for_height":596,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/19bd6a340f2e42bc9e06f93977ba64f6-original.png","real_width_1x":1060,"real_width_2x":1980,"real_height_1x":596,"real_height_2x":1114},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/19bd6a340f2e42bc9e06f93977ba64f6-720x405px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/19bd6a340f2e42bc9e06f93977ba64f6-720x405px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":720,"for_height":405,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/19bd6a340f2e42bc9e06f93977ba64f6-original.png","real_width_1x":720,"real_width_2x":1440,"real_height_1x":405,"real_height_2x":810},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/19bd6a340f2e42bc9e06f93977ba64f6-720x405px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/19bd6a340f2e42bc9e06f93977ba64f6-720x405px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":720,"for_height":405,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/19bd6a340f2e42bc9e06f93977ba64f6-original.png","real_width_1x":720,"real_width_2x":1440,"real_height_1x":405,"real_height_2x":810},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/19bd6a340f2e42bc9e06f93977ba64f6-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/19bd6a340f2e42bc9e06f93977ba64f6-416x234px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/19bd6a340f2e42bc9e06f93977ba64f6-original.png","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/19bd6a340f2e42bc9e06f93977ba64f6-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/19bd6a340f2e42bc9e06f93977ba64f6-416x234px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/19bd6a340f2e42bc9e06f93977ba64f6-original.png","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468}],"credit":[{"insert":"Capital Tower Business Center","attributes":{"bold":true}},{"insert":"\n"}],"textBlock":"<p>In 2006, Yug-Nefteprodukt affiliates <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/710981\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">purchased </a>Capital Tower, a 16-story business center on Brestskaya Street in Moscow. At the time, the deal was estimated to be worth $70–75 million. The business center was registered under a Cypriot company, Boundhill Trading, which belonged to Vakha and Batyr Agayev through three offshore companies (Prime Business Inc, Rutley Company SA, and Northern Starinvest SA), as revealed in the ICIJ offshore leak.</p>","creditBlock":"<p><strong>Capital Tower Business Center</strong></p>"},{"text":[{"insert":"In 2019, Yug-Nefteprodukt "},{"insert":"acquired ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/4040205","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"a 25% stake in Red7, a premium-class residential complex project on Sakharov Avenue in the very centre of Moscow, just 2.5 km from the Kremlin. “The Garden Ring isn’t simply welcoming a new building in the spirit of modern London or Hong Kong. A prototype of the Moscow of tomorrow is being created here,” the project’s website ambitiously "},{"insert":"declares","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://red-7.ru/architecture/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":". The complex was completed in 2024.\n\nAs of 2025, its developer, the Osnova Group — one of the top 10 largest developers in the capital — was 10% owned by AG-Invest, which is Yug-Nefteprodukt’s new company name.\n"}],"image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0ceb300601034b14ac191d1803643d12-1060x596px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0ceb300601034b14ac191d1803643d12-1060x596px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1060,"for_height":596,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0ceb300601034b14ac191d1803643d12-original.png","real_width_1x":1060,"real_width_2x":2073,"real_height_1x":596,"real_height_2x":1164},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0ceb300601034b14ac191d1803643d12-1060x596px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0ceb300601034b14ac191d1803643d12-1060x596px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1060,"for_height":596,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0ceb300601034b14ac191d1803643d12-original.png","real_width_1x":1060,"real_width_2x":2073,"real_height_1x":596,"real_height_2x":1164},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0ceb300601034b14ac191d1803643d12-720x405px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0ceb300601034b14ac191d1803643d12-720x405px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":720,"for_height":405,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0ceb300601034b14ac191d1803643d12-original.png","real_width_1x":720,"real_width_2x":1440,"real_height_1x":405,"real_height_2x":810},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0ceb300601034b14ac191d1803643d12-720x405px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0ceb300601034b14ac191d1803643d12-720x405px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":720,"for_height":405,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0ceb300601034b14ac191d1803643d12-original.png","real_width_1x":720,"real_width_2x":1440,"real_height_1x":405,"real_height_2x":810},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0ceb300601034b14ac191d1803643d12-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0ceb300601034b14ac191d1803643d12-416x234px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0ceb300601034b14ac191d1803643d12-original.png","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0ceb300601034b14ac191d1803643d12-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0ceb300601034b14ac191d1803643d12-416x234px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0ceb300601034b14ac191d1803643d12-original.png","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468}],"credit":[{"insert":"Red7 Residential Complex","attributes":{"bold":true}},{"insert":"\n"}],"textBlock":"<p>In 2019, Yug-Nefteprodukt <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/4040205\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">acquired </a>a 25% stake in Red7, a premium-class residential complex project on Sakharov Avenue in the very centre of Moscow, just 2.5 km from the Kremlin. “The Garden Ring isn’t simply welcoming a new building in the spirit of modern London or Hong Kong. A prototype of the Moscow of tomorrow is being created here,” the project’s website ambitiously <a href=\"https://red-7.ru/architecture/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">declares</a>. The complex was completed in 2024.</p><p><br/></p><p>As of 2025, its developer, the Osnova Group — one of the top 10 largest developers in the capital — was 10% owned by AG-Invest, which is Yug-Nefteprodukt’s new company name.</p>","creditBlock":"<p><strong>Red7 Residential Complex</strong></p>"}],"header":"Assets and connections"},"category":"images-with-text-embed"},"type":"images-with-text-embed"},{"data":"Batyr Agayev’s Luxembourg-based Everest","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The Luxembourg registry records show that Batyr Agayev, the younger brother of the deputy Bekkhan, has become a Belgian citizen and splits his time between Berlin and Monaco. Batyr Agayev owns a 56.16% stake in a Luxembourg-based real estate investment fund Everest One, established in 2019. According to the fund’s <a href=\"https://www.mimcocapital.com/en/investement-solution/everest-one/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">website</a>, it focuses on real estate investments (primary commercial and office real estate in Germany, but also on hotels, healthcare facilities and housing). Its assets amounted to €65 million in 2022.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The fund is managed by Mimco Group, founded by Swiss national Bernd von Manteuffel and Luxembourg national Christophe Nadal. The former has been dealing with European real estate for over 35 years, while the latter, according to the website, boasts 20 years of experience. The group currently manages assets of over €2 billion worth.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18498,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Mimco website","caption":"Everest One fund was launched by Mimco in 2019","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdf1a0f98d2d4f1ab48869866a90c384-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdf1a0f98d2d4f1ab48869866a90c384-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdf1a0f98d2d4f1ab48869866a90c384-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":3241,"real_height_1x":1057,"real_height_2x":1785},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdf1a0f98d2d4f1ab48869866a90c384-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdf1a0f98d2d4f1ab48869866a90c384-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdf1a0f98d2d4f1ab48869866a90c384-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":3241,"real_height_1x":1057,"real_height_2x":1785},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdf1a0f98d2d4f1ab48869866a90c384-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdf1a0f98d2d4f1ab48869866a90c384-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdf1a0f98d2d4f1ab48869866a90c384-original.png","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2398,"real_height_1x":660,"real_height_2x":1321},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdf1a0f98d2d4f1ab48869866a90c384-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdf1a0f98d2d4f1ab48869866a90c384-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdf1a0f98d2d4f1ab48869866a90c384-original.png","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2398,"real_height_1x":660,"real_height_2x":1321},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdf1a0f98d2d4f1ab48869866a90c384-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdf1a0f98d2d4f1ab48869866a90c384-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdf1a0f98d2d4f1ab48869866a90c384-original.png","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":227,"real_height_2x":457},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdf1a0f98d2d4f1ab48869866a90c384-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdf1a0f98d2d4f1ab48869866a90c384-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bdf1a0f98d2d4f1ab48869866a90c384-original.png","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":227,"real_height_2x":457}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Batyr Agayev also holds a 43.5% stake in the Luxembourg-based Mimco Real Estate Holding. According to the 2022 data, the company invested about €35 million in German Mimco Real Estate Holding Se &amp; Co Kg, which is intended for real estate investments, as indicated in the company’s financial report.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A fight club and the Wild Donbass Division","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"“Bekkhan Agayev is one of the founders of the URF [United Russian Fighters] team. &lt;...&gt; He is a true patriot of Russia who makes a significant contribution to our country’s development every day. &lt;...&gt; We are sincerely proud that he supports our team, motivates our athletes, and helps the community,” the URF mixed martial arts club <a href=\"https://www.instagram.com/p/DTZ21D8jdsK/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">posted</a> on their Instagram page.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to a company register, Bekkhan Agayev’s son Dany owns 40% of the United Russian Fighters club. Half of the URF is owned by its vice-president, Roland (Rocky) Kavali. Among those representing the club is, for example, the well-known Russian fighter Alexander Emelianenko.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"URF and its associates assist Russian military forces in the war against Ukraine. “We’ve gathered a large shipment of humanitarian aid, which will be sent today to the ArBat, (“Armenian Batallion” — Ed.) within the Pyatnashka, [a military unit also known as] the Wild Donbass Division, from our team and our founders,” the club <a href=\"https://www.instagram.com/reel/C-4iPdXOqsM/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">reported</a> on its Instagram page in 2024.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18499,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"United Russian Fighters club Instagram","caption":"Vagab Vagabov, a fighter, and the United Russian Fighters club on helping the ArBat battalion","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e25a77855fae4f68a899d6a84c577a3c-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e25a77855fae4f68a899d6a84c577a3c-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e25a77855fae4f68a899d6a84c577a3c-original.png","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2804,"real_height_1x":1003,"real_height_2x":1466},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e25a77855fae4f68a899d6a84c577a3c-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e25a77855fae4f68a899d6a84c577a3c-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e25a77855fae4f68a899d6a84c577a3c-original.png","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2804,"real_height_1x":1003,"real_height_2x":1466},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e25a77855fae4f68a899d6a84c577a3c-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e25a77855fae4f68a899d6a84c577a3c-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e25a77855fae4f68a899d6a84c577a3c-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2398,"real_height_1x":627,"real_height_2x":1254},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e25a77855fae4f68a899d6a84c577a3c-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e25a77855fae4f68a899d6a84c577a3c-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e25a77855fae4f68a899d6a84c577a3c-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2398,"real_height_1x":627,"real_height_2x":1254},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e25a77855fae4f68a899d6a84c577a3c-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e25a77855fae4f68a899d6a84c577a3c-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e25a77855fae4f68a899d6a84c577a3c-original.png","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":216,"real_height_2x":433},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e25a77855fae4f68a899d6a84c577a3c-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e25a77855fae4f68a899d6a84c577a3c-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e25a77855fae4f68a899d6a84c577a3c-original.png","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":216,"real_height_2x":433}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Roland Kavali, the Agayevs’ partner at United Russian Fighters and the club’s vice-president, as well as Vagab Vagabov, one of the fighters, were longtime friends of the late ArBat founder Armen Sargsyan, the battalion commander has <a href=\"https://gorlovka-pravda.com/novosti-gorlovki/ob-yetnicheskom-sostave-nashego-podrazdelenija-o-druzhbe-s-rolandom-kavali-i-bratjami-vagabovymi-30199.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">mentioned</a> in an interview. He thanked them for their support. Kavali contributes “a great deal to the battalion,” the commander explained: “He’s built us a gym where Vagab Vagabov trains the guys, gets them ready, and keeps them in shape.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In January 2024, Vagabov <a href=\"https://matchtv.ru/boxing/matchtvnews_NI2011431_Bojec_MMA_Vagab_Vagabov__o_sluzhbe_v_zone_SVO_Podpisal_kontrakt_s_Dikoj_divizijej_Donbassa_batalon_Arbat\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">told</a> Match TV that he had signed a military contract to serve in the ArBat battalion. However, he is not fighting on the front lines, but rather 2–3 km away. “I’ve taken on the soldiers’ physical and firearms training,” Vagabov <a href=\"https://www.sport-express.ru/martial/mma/amc-fight-nights/news/chempion-amc-fight-nights-vagabov-rasskazal-o-sluzhbe-v-zone-svo-2174447/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">said</a> in a Sport-Express interview.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Neither the Agayevs, nor Kavali, nor the Mimco founders Manteuffel and Nadal have responded to our questions.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":9991,"header":"Putin and the Bomb: History of Russian Nuclear Blackmail","_path":"/en/stories/2026/06/19/history-of-russian-nuclear-blackmail/","lead":"IStories unfold the Russian president’s path from discussing “getting rid of extensive weapons” back in 2000 to being ready to “employ all available means” in 2022 — and the way the West learned to deal with the threats and keep helping Ukraine","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-original.png","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-original.png","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-original.png","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-original.png","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-original.png","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-original.png","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-original.png","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-original.png","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-original.png","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-original.png","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-original.png","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-original.png","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-original.png","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f5d16838942d4778ad6a9b94ff65c3a5-original.png","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Photo: kremlin.ru","created_at_date":"2026-06-19","created_at_date_time":"2026-06-18T18:04:41.219Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":2517,"last_name":"","first_name":"Редакция","last_name_en":"","first_name_en":"Editors","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"“The plan was crystal clear: [Russia] would have cut through Ukraine like a knife through butter, reaching the border of Poland and the Baltic states, and then it would have pulled out its nuclear arsenal and repeated what he [Vladimir Putin] himself had said: ‘Yes, I understand that you are stronger than me in conventional terms. But here’s the thing: <...> I either annex the city of Narva, which is actually Russian [Narva is situated in Estonia - Ed.], or, if you resist, I’ll destroy a European city or an American military contingent,” — political analyst Andrei Piontkovsky described Putin’s plans had there been a swift victory over Ukraine.\n\nAll the leading Russian propagandists have threatened the West with a nuclear strike — this comes as no surprise anymore. For example, back in 2014 Dmitry Kiselyov [a famous Russian TV propagandist — Ed.] said that Russia could turn the U.S. into radioactive ash. And Margarita Simonyan [RT editor in chief — Ed.] said in 2025: “There are no guarantees other than a nuclear bomb.” \n\nVladimir Solovyov [another well-known TV propagandist — Ed.] has, on various occasions, threatened Ukraine, Europe, and the U.S. with nuclear weapons and even suggested setting off a nuclear explosion in space: “I don’t understand why, for example, Elon Musk’s satellites aren’t a legitimate target for us. One nuclear explosion in space, I believe, would solve this problem quite effectively.” There are also other examples.\n\nBut the propagandists won’t be the ones making the decision. It is Putin who has moved from discussing “getting rid of extensive weapons” to being ready to “employ all available means.” We describe his transformation in his own words.\n\nPutin’s statements\nHereinafter, we use the Kremlin’s official translation.\n\nMarch 2000. “We seek to make our world safer, to clean it of the stockpiles of weapons, of excessive weapons. <...> We should preserve and strengthen the Russian nuclear weapons capability. But this is not to say that we will increase its size, it is already excessive in some ways. We are talking about enhancing the security of the country and strengthening the nuclear “shield” of the Russian Federation.”\n\nMay 2002. “It’s more worthwhile perhaps to eliminate a certain part of nuclear potentials. <...> Any man who has at least once in his career dealt with arms, had arms in his hands, at least to hunt or a rifle or whatever, he knows that it's much better, much safer to have it in storage disarmed, disassembled perhaps, rather than to have it in your arms and charged with bullets in it and with your finger on the trigger at the same time.”\n\nDecember 2014. “I think [sometimes — Ed.] that maybe it would be best if our bear just sat still. Maybe he should stop chasing pigs and boars around the taiga but start picking berries and eating honey. Maybe then he will be left alone. But no, he won’t be! Because someone will always try to chain him up. As soon as he’s chained they will tear out his teeth and claws. In this analogy, I am referring to the power of nuclear deterrence. As soon as — God forbid — it happens and they no longer need the bear, the taiga will be taken over.”\n\nMarch 2015. In a film produced to commemorate the first anniversary of the 2014 annexation of Crimea, Putin answered whether Russian nuclear forces had been placed on alert during the crisis: “We were ready to do it. I talked with [the Western counterparts — Ed.] colleagues and told them that this [Crimean peninsula — Ed.] is our historic territory, Russian people live there, they are in danger, we cannot leave them <...> ‘Where are you? Thousands of kilometers away. And we’re here. This is our land. What are you going to fight for here? You don’t know? We do. And we’re ready.’”\nMarch 2018. “If someone decides to destroy Russia, then we have a legal right to respond. Yes, for humanity it will be a global catastrophe, for the world it will be a global catastrophe. But still, as a citizen of Russia and the head of the Russian state, then I want to ask myself the question: ‘Why do we need such a world if there is no Russia there?’”\n\nOctober 2018. “We cannot be the initiators of such a catastrophe because we have no provision for a pre-emptive strike. Yes, it looks like we are sitting on our hands and waiting until someone uses nuclear weapons against us. Well, yes, this is what it is. But then any aggressor should know that retaliation is inevitable and they will be annihilated. And we as the victims of an aggression, we as martyrs would go to paradise [Heaven — Ed.] while they will simply perish because they won’t even have time to repent their sins.”\n\nFebruary 2022. “No matter who tries to stand in our way or all the more so create threats for our country and our people, they must know that Russia will respond immediately, and the consequences will be such as you have never seen in your entire history. No matter how the events unfold, we are ready. All the necessary decisions in this regard have been taken.”\n\nSeptember 2022. “To defend Russia and our people, we will certainly make use of all weapon systems available to us. This is not a bluff. The citizens of Russia can rest assured that the territorial integrity of our Motherland, our independence and freedom will be defended — I repeat — by all the systems available to us. Those who are using nuclear blackmail against us should know that the wind rose can turn around.”\nDecember 2022. “Concerning the threat of nuclear war. <...> The threat is growing, to be honest. Regarding Russia never using [nuclear weapons] first under any circumstances. Well, if it does not use them first, then it will not be the second to use them either, because in the case of a nuclear strike at our territory, our capabilities will be significantly limited.”\n\nJune 2024. “Somehow, the West believes that Russia will never use nuclear weapons. However, our nuclear doctrine clearly states that if somebody’s actions threaten our sovereignty and territorial integrity, we reserve the right to employ all available means in response.”\n\nNuclear doctrine transformation\nAs Vladimir Putin’s rhetoric on nuclear weapons has grown more heated, Russia’s nuclear doctrine has also transformed.\n\nThe first doctrine (2000) was approved by Putin immediately after he won the 2000 presidential election. The document was published (which hadn’t happened in Soviet and Russian history) on April 21. In the document, the Russian Federation reserved the right to use nuclear weapons “in response to the use of nuclear and other types of weapons of mass destruction against it and (or) its allies, as well as in response to large-scale aggression utilizing conventional weapons in situations critical to the national security of the Russian Federation” (English translation can be found here).\n\nThe second doctrine (2010) clarified the criteria for when nuclear weapons could be used by Russia. In the document, the circumstances allowing a nuclear strike were not described as “situations critical to the national security of the Russian Federation” anymore, but instead a situation “when the very existence of the state is under threat” (source: Carnegie Endowment English translation). \n\nThe third doctrine (2020). Essentially, we could consider the 2020 “Basic Principles of State Policy of the Russian Federation on Nuclear Deterrence” decree a new nuclear doctrine. The criteria for nuclear weapons usage had not changed, but the four conditions determining whether it can be used were described for the first time:\n\n“arrival of reliable data on a launch of ballistic missiles attacking the territory of the Russian Federation and/or its allies”; \n“use of nuclear weapons or other types of weapons of mass destruction by an adversary against the Russian Federation and/or its allies”; \n“attack by adversary against critical governmental or military sites of the Russian Federation, disruption of which would undermine nuclear forces response actions”; \n“aggression against the Russian Federation with the use of conventional weapons when the very existence of the state is in jeopardy.” (source: official English translation)\n\nFor the first time, Russia has listed the risks “that can evolve into military threats to the Russian Federation and that are intended to be neutralized by the implementation of nuclear deterrence.” These include, among others, buildup by a potential adversary of forces groupings that possess nuclear weapons delivery means in the territories contiguous to the Russian Federation and its allies; deployment of missile defence systems, medium- and shorter-range missiles and strike unmanned aerial vehicles; deployment of nuclear weapons and their delivery means in the territories of non-nuclear weapon states.\n\nThe fourth doctrine (2024). The current nuclear doctrine (in English) was approved on November 19, 2024. Compared to the 2020 version, several changes have been made, including the provision specifying the circumstances under which Russia reserves the right to use nuclear weapons. Whereas previously an enemy attack using conventional weapons had to pose a threat to the very existence of the state, the doctrine now refers to a critical threat to the sovereignty and (or) territorial integrity of the state: furthermore, the doctrine now covers attacks not only on Russia but also on Belarus, where Russia has deployed nuclear weapons (“as participants in the Union State” — Ed.)\n\nAnother condition for the usage of nuclear weapons added to the four mentioned above is “receipt of reliable data on the massive launch of air and space attack means” (aircraft, missiles, unmanned aerial vehicles, etc) and their crossing of the state border of Russia. \n\nThe list of military risks that can potentially evolve into threats has also been expanded. In light of the Ukrainian military’s promises to isolate Crimea, this point seems to be the most relevant right now: “actions by a potential adversary aimed at isolating a part of the territory of the Russian Federation, including blocking access to vital transport communication.”\n\nAre Russian nuclear threats a bluff or not?\n\nFrom a rational point of view, using nuclear weapons in the war against Ukraine makes little sense. IStories have described why (here and here). In short, there are now no large concentrations of troops or equipment on the frontlines due to the usage of drones, so a tactical nuclear strike would not achieve any military objectives. An attempt to alter the course of the war with a strategic nuclear strike to shock the enemy and force them to surrender could result in the simultaneous death of tens of thousands (or even hundreds of thousands) of civilians. Russia probably won’t take such a step. But even a tactical nuclear weapons use would turn pretty much the entire world against Russia.\nNeither Ukraine nor its Western allies have ever crossed the line beyond which Russia would seriously consider using nuclear weapons, says Maxim Starchak, Fellow at the Centre for International and Defence Policy of the Queen’s University (Canada): “Throughout this war, the parties have firsthand seen the limits of nuclear deterrence. Russia likely believed that its nuclear capabilities would deter the West in providing Ukraine with certain types of weapons. But that didn’t work out. On the one hand, the West has taken the nuclear factor into account in its actions. This affected the timing of delivery and the types of weapons supplied. On the other hand, it turned out that by gradually supplying the required weapons the West is not moving toward a nuclear conflict with Russia.”\n\nRather than exposing Russia’s bluff, the goal of Ukraine’s allies is to ensure that the nuclear weapons usage framework (the one that Russia established itself) keeps working, explains Pavel Podvig, the head of the “Russian Strategic Nuclear Forces” research project. Back in 2022, not only the Western countries, but also China, India, and the Global South countries expressed their sharp opposition to the use of nuclear weapons. In particular, the G20 2022 summit declaration stated that the use or threat of use of nuclear weapons is unacceptable.\n\nUkraine’s allies must continue intensifying the pressure on Russia, which means emphasizing that nuclear threats and the use of nuclear weapons are unacceptable, and that no one is posing a threat to Russia’s sovereignty and territorial integrity, Podvig believes. According to him, this pressure allows the West to ramp up the arms shipments and enables Ukraine to intensify the strikes against Russian territory: “The idea is to establish a framework and operate within its limits. And I see no reason why this would not keep working. If nuclear weapons are completely removed from this equation, the support for Ukraine could be even more intensive. The aid to Ukraine and the arms delivery have been successful for as long as the nuclear weapons have been removed from this framework.”","blocks":[{"data":"“The plan was crystal clear: [Russia] would have cut through Ukraine like a knife through butter, reaching the border of Poland and the Baltic states, and then it would have pulled out its nuclear arsenal and repeated what he [Vladimir Putin] himself <a href=\"https://france.mid.ru/ru/presse/vladimir_putin_i_emmanuel_makron/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">had said</a>: ‘Yes, I understand that you are stronger than me in conventional terms. But here’s the thing: &lt;...&gt; I either annex the city of Narva, which is actually Russian [Narva is situated in Estonia - Ed.], or, if you resist, I’ll destroy a European city or an American military contingent,” — political analyst Andrei Piontkovsky <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7BxZtT4Agw4\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">described </a>Putin’s plans had there been a swift victory over Ukraine.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"All the leading Russian propagandists have threatened the West with a nuclear strike — this comes as no surprise anymore. For example, back in 2014 Dmitry Kiselyov [a famous Russian TV propagandist — Ed.] said that Russia<a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-31557254\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"> could turn</a> the U.S. into radioactive ash. And Margarita Simonyan [RT editor in chief — Ed.] said <a href=\"https://t.me/margaritasimonyan/15272\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">in 2025</a>: “There are no guarantees other than a nuclear bomb.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Vladimir Solovyov [another well-known TV propagandist — Ed.] has, on various occasions, threatened Ukraine, Europe, and the U.S. with nuclear weapons and even suggested setting off a nuclear explosion in space: “I don’t understand why, for example, Elon Musk’s satellites aren’t a legitimate target for us. One <a href=\"https://t.me/Crimeanwind/93255\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">nuclear explosion</a> in space, I believe, would solve this problem quite effectively.” There are also <a href=\"https://profile.ru/politics/primenenie-yadernogo-oruzhiya-mozhet-uberech-chelovechestvo-ot-globalnoj-katastrofy-1338893/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">other</a> <a href=\"https://profile.ru/abroad/pora-podumat-o-demonstracionnom-yadernom-vzryve-1520096/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">examples</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But the propagandists won’t be the ones making the decision. It is Putin who has moved from discussing “getting rid of extensive weapons” to being ready to “employ all available means.” We describe his transformation in his own words.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Putin’s statements","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"<em>Hereinafter, we use the Kremlin’s official translation.</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<a href=\"http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/transcripts/21306\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">March 2000</a>. “We seek to make our world safer, to clean it of the stockpiles of weapons, of excessive weapons. &lt;...&gt; We should preserve and strengthen the Russian nuclear weapons capability. But this is not to say that we will increase its size, it is already excessive in some ways. We are talking about enhancing the security of the country and strengthening the nuclear “shield” of the Russian Federation.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<a href=\"http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/transcripts/21606\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">May 2002</a>. “It’s more worthwhile perhaps to eliminate a certain part of nuclear potentials. &lt;...&gt;&nbsp;Any man who has at least once in his career dealt with arms, had arms in his hands, at least to hunt or a rifle or whatever, he knows that it's much better, much safer to have it in storage disarmed, disassembled perhaps, rather than to have it in your arms and charged with bullets in it and with your finger on the trigger at the same time.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<a href=\"http://kremlin.ru/events/president/news/47250\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">December 2014</a>. “I think [sometimes — Ed.] that maybe it would be best if our bear just sat still. Maybe he should stop chasing pigs and boars around the taiga but start picking berries and eating honey. Maybe then he will be left alone. But no, he won’t be! Because someone will always try to chain him up. As soon as he’s chained they will tear out his teeth and claws. In this analogy, I am referring to the power of nuclear deterrence. As soon as — God forbid — it happens and they no longer need the bear, the taiga will be taken over.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<a href=\"https://edition.cnn.com/2015/03/16/europe/russia-putin-crimea-nuclear\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">March 2015</a>. In a <a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PGGNXIQXlcU\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">film</a> produced to commemorate the first anniversary of the 2014 annexation of Crimea, Putin answered whether Russian nuclear forces had been placed on alert during the crisis: “We were ready to do it. I talked with [the Western counterparts — Ed.] colleagues and told them that this [Crimean peninsula — Ed.] is our historic territory, Russian people live there, they are in danger, we cannot leave them &lt;...&gt; ‘Where are you? Thousands of kilometers away. And we’re here. This is our land. What are you going to fight for here? You don’t know? We do. And we’re ready.’”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18521,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: kremlin.ru","caption":"Putin on the day of annexation of Crimea, March 18, 2014","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/478bee378a614868b0f1d6fe45bce4c3-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/478bee378a614868b0f1d6fe45bce4c3-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/478bee378a614868b0f1d6fe45bce4c3-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":1098,"real_width_2x":1098,"real_height_1x":677,"real_height_2x":677},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/478bee378a614868b0f1d6fe45bce4c3-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/478bee378a614868b0f1d6fe45bce4c3-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/478bee378a614868b0f1d6fe45bce4c3-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":1098,"real_width_2x":1098,"real_height_1x":677,"real_height_2x":677},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/478bee378a614868b0f1d6fe45bce4c3-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/478bee378a614868b0f1d6fe45bce4c3-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/478bee378a614868b0f1d6fe45bce4c3-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":1098,"real_width_2x":1098,"real_height_1x":677,"real_height_2x":677},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/478bee378a614868b0f1d6fe45bce4c3-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/478bee378a614868b0f1d6fe45bce4c3-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/478bee378a614868b0f1d6fe45bce4c3-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":1098,"real_width_2x":1098,"real_height_1x":677,"real_height_2x":677},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/478bee378a614868b0f1d6fe45bce4c3-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/478bee378a614868b0f1d6fe45bce4c3-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/478bee378a614868b0f1d6fe45bce4c3-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":254,"real_height_2x":511},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/478bee378a614868b0f1d6fe45bce4c3-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/478bee378a614868b0f1d6fe45bce4c3-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/478bee378a614868b0f1d6fe45bce4c3-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":254,"real_height_2x":511}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"<a href=\"https://www.businessinsider.com/putin-said-2018-would-use-nuclear-weapons-if-russia-attacked-2022-4\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">March 2018</a>. “If someone decides to destroy Russia, then we have a legal right to respond. Yes, for humanity it will be a global catastrophe, for the world it will be a global catastrophe. But still, as a citizen of Russia and the head of the Russian state, then I want to ask myself the question: ‘Why do we need such a world if there is no Russia there?’”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<a href=\"http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/58848\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">October 2018</a>. “We cannot be the initiators of such a catastrophe because we have no provision for a pre-emptive strike. Yes, it looks like we are sitting on our hands and waiting until someone uses nuclear weapons against us. Well, yes, this is what it is. But then any aggressor should know that retaliation is inevitable and they will be annihilated. And we as the victims of an aggression, we as martyrs would go to paradise [Heaven — Ed.] while they will simply perish because they won’t even have time to repent their sins.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<a href=\"http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/67843\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">February 2022</a>. “No matter who tries to stand in our way or all the more so create threats for our country and our people, they must know that Russia will respond immediately, and the consequences will be such as you have never seen in your entire history. No matter how the events unfold, we are ready. All the necessary decisions in this regard have been taken.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<a href=\"http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/69390\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">September 2022.</a> “To defend Russia and our people, we will certainly make use of all weapon systems available to us. This is not a bluff. The citizens of Russia can rest assured that the territorial integrity of our Motherland, our independence and freedom will be defended — I repeat — by all the systems available to us. Those who are using nuclear blackmail against us should know that the wind rose can turn around.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18519,"data":{"url":"https://t.me/smotri_media/23679","initialHeight":"477px"},"category":"telegram-embed"},"type":"telegram-embed"},{"data":"<a href=\"http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/70046\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">December 2022</a>. “Concerning the threat of nuclear war. &lt;...&gt; The threat is growing, to be honest. Regarding Russia never using [nuclear weapons] first under any circumstances. Well, if it does not use them first, then it will not be the second to use them either, because in the case of a nuclear strike at our territory, our capabilities will be significantly limited.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<a href=\"http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/74223\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">June 2024</a>. “Somehow, the West believes that Russia will never use nuclear weapons. However, our nuclear doctrine clearly states that if somebody’s actions threaten our sovereignty and territorial integrity, we reserve the right to employ all available means in response.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Nuclear doctrine transformation","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"As Vladimir Putin’s rhetoric on nuclear weapons has grown more heated, Russia’s nuclear doctrine has also transformed.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>The first doctrine (2000)</strong> was approved by Putin immediately after he won the 2000 presidential election. The document was <a href=\"http://special.kremlin.ru/acts/bank/15386/page/2\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">published </a>(which hadn’t happened in Soviet and Russian history) on April 21. In the document, the Russian Federation reserved the right to use nuclear weapons “in response to the use of nuclear and other types of weapons of mass destruction against it and (or) its allies, as well as in response to large-scale aggression utilizing conventional weapons in situations critical to the national security of the Russian Federation” (English translation can be found <a href=\"https://www.armscontrol.org/act/2000-05/russias-military-doctrine\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">here</a>).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>The second doctrine (2010)</strong> clarified the criteria for when nuclear weapons could be used by Russia. <a href=\"http://kremlin.ru/supplement/461\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">In the document</a>, the circumstances allowing a nuclear strike were not described as “situations critical to the national security of the Russian Federation” anymore, but instead a situation “when the very existence of the state is under threat” (source: Carnegie Endowment <a href=\"https://carnegieendowment.org/files/2010russia_military_doctrine.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">English</a> translation).&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>The third doctrine (2020).</strong> Essentially, we could consider the 2020 “Basic Principles of State Policy of the Russian Federation on Nuclear Deterrence” <a href=\"http://publication.pravo.gov.ru/Document/View/0001202006020040?rangeSize=1&amp;index=1\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">decree</a> a new nuclear doctrine. The criteria for nuclear weapons usage had not changed, but the four conditions determining whether it can be used were described for the first time:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“arrival of reliable data on a launch of ballistic missiles attacking the territory of the Russian Federation and/or its allies”;&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“use of nuclear weapons or other types of weapons of mass destruction by an adversary against the Russian Federation and/or its allies”;&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“attack by adversary against critical governmental or military sites of the Russian Federation, disruption of which would undermine nuclear forces response actions”;&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“aggression against the Russian Federation with the use of conventional weapons when the very existence of the state is in jeopardy.” (source: official <a href=\"https://archive.mid.ru/en/web/guest/foreign_policy/international_safety/disarmament/-/asset_publisher/rp0fiUBmANaH/content/id/4152094\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">English </a>translation)","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For the first time, Russia has listed the risks “that can evolve into military threats to the Russian Federation and that are intended to be neutralized by the implementation of nuclear deterrence.” These include, among others, buildup by a potential adversary of forces groupings that possess nuclear weapons delivery means in the territories contiguous to the Russian Federation and its allies; deployment of missile defence systems, medium- and shorter-range missiles and strike unmanned aerial vehicles; deployment of nuclear weapons and their delivery means in the territories of non-nuclear weapon states.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>The fourth doctrine (2024).</strong> The <a href=\"http://static.kremlin.ru/media/events/files/ru/KrzVeeTCkT05CCvgIoY03xuvIdkVslkx.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">current </a>nuclear doctrine (<a href=\"https://www.mid.ru/en/foreign_policy/international_safety/1434131/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">in English</a>) was approved on November 19, 2024. Compared to the 2020 version, several changes have been made, including the provision specifying the circumstances under which Russia reserves the right to use nuclear weapons. Whereas previously an enemy attack using conventional weapons had to pose a threat to the very existence of the state, the doctrine now refers to a critical threat to the sovereignty and (or) territorial integrity of the state: furthermore, the doctrine now covers attacks not only on Russia but also on Belarus, where Russia has deployed nuclear weapons (“as participants in the Union State” — Ed.)","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Another condition for the usage of nuclear weapons added to the four mentioned above is “receipt of reliable data on the massive launch of air and space attack means” (aircraft, missiles, unmanned aerial vehicles, etc) and their crossing of the state border of Russia.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The list of military risks that can potentially evolve into threats has also been expanded. In light of the Ukrainian military’s <a href=\"https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/ukraines-drone-commander-wants-cut-crimea-off-russia-2026-06-11/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">promises </a>to isolate Crimea, this point seems to be the most relevant right now: “actions by a potential adversary aimed at isolating a part of the territory of the Russian Federation, including blocking access to vital transport communication.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Are Russian nuclear threats a bluff or not?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"From a rational point of view, using nuclear weapons in the war against Ukraine makes little sense. IStories have described why (<a href=\"https://www.istories.media/en/stories/2024/11/28/nuclear-reasons/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">here</a> and <a href=\"https://www.istories.media/en/stories/2024/09/20/nuclear-escalation/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">here</a>). In short, there are now no large concentrations of troops or equipment on the frontlines due to the usage of drones, so a tactical nuclear strike would not achieve any military objectives. An attempt to alter the course of the war with a strategic nuclear strike to shock the enemy and force them to surrender could result in the simultaneous death of tens of thousands (or even hundreds of thousands) of civilians. Russia probably won’t take such a step. But even a tactical nuclear weapons use would turn pretty much the entire world against Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18517,"data":{"text":"nuclear security expert","author":"Pavel Podvig","header":"The aid for Ukraine and the arms delivery have been successful for as long as the nuclear weapons have been removed from this framework"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"Neither Ukraine nor its Western allies have ever crossed the line beyond which Russia would seriously consider using nuclear weapons, says Maxim Starchak, Fellow at the Centre for International and Defence Policy of the Queen’s University (Canada): “Throughout this war, the parties have firsthand seen the limits of nuclear deterrence. Russia likely believed that its nuclear capabilities would deter the West in providing Ukraine with certain types of weapons. But that didn’t work out. On the one hand, the West has taken the nuclear factor into account in its actions. This affected the timing of delivery and the types of weapons supplied. On the other hand, it turned out that by gradually supplying the required weapons the West is not moving toward a nuclear conflict with Russia.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Rather than exposing Russia’s bluff, the goal of Ukraine’s allies is to ensure that the nuclear weapons usage framework (the one that Russia established itself) keeps working, explains Pavel Podvig, the head of the <a href=\"https://russianforces.org/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">“Russian Strategic Nuclear Forces”</a> research project. Back in 2022, not only the Western countries, but also China, India, and the Global South countries expressed their sharp opposition to the use of nuclear weapons. In particular, the G20 2022 summit <a href=\"https://www.consilium.europa.eu/media/60201/2022-11-16-g20-declaration-data.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">declaration </a>stated that the use or threat of use of nuclear weapons is unacceptable.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Ukraine’s allies must continue intensifying the pressure on Russia, which means emphasizing that nuclear threats and the use of nuclear weapons are unacceptable, and that no one is posing a threat to Russia’s sovereignty and territorial integrity, Podvig believes. According to him, this pressure allows the West to ramp up the arms shipments and enables Ukraine to intensify the strikes against Russian territory: “The idea is to establish a framework and operate within its limits. And I see no reason why this would not keep working. If nuclear weapons are completely removed from this equation, the support for Ukraine could be even more intensive. The aid to Ukraine and the arms delivery have been successful for as long as the nuclear weapons have been removed from this framework.”","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":9760,"header":"The Mapping of Power: Russia’s “Game of Thrones”","_path":"/en/stories/2026/05/29/russias-game-of-thrones/","lead":"The consequences of the war against Ukraine are causing frustration and tension even among Russia’s elite: the power structures created by Vladimir Putin, which consist of various clans, are beginning to falter","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2404,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1202},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2404,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1202},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2404,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1202},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2404,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1202},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/023b3d9f9d704f1cb334adbed7baabfe-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Illustrations: Correctiv, IStories, using AI","created_at_date":"2026-05-29","created_at_date_time":"2026-05-28T00:45:01.769Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":5,"first_name":"Роман","last_name":"Анин","first_name_en":"Roman","last_name_en":"Anin","is_public":true,"_path":"roman-anin","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редактор «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Редактор","position_en":"Editor","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"Every month, the Russian army loses more than 35,000 soldiers while achieving almost no significant advances on the battlefield. At the same time, Ukraine’s drone strikes deep inside Russian territory are becoming increasingly effective and damaging. The Economist recently described the situation as a possible turning point in the war. Sir Lawrence Freedman, one of Britain’s best-known military experts, told the magazine that the current moment increasingly resembles a strategic turning point in the war.\nRussia’s economy is slowing down sharply. Regional budget deficits are growing, businesses are struggling under extremely high interest rates, and inflation continues to push prices upward. Disruptions of mobile communications and internet shutdowns across many Russian regions have added to public frustration, creating growing social discontent that the Kremlin can no longer easily dismiss.\nInside the Russian elite, tensions are also rising. According to an intelligence report recently published by IStories, Financial Times, and CNN, senior Russian security officials are increasingly blaming one another for failures in Ukraine. \nAhead of the Victory Day parade on Red Square, Vladimir Putin asked Donald Trump to persuade Volodymyr Zelenskyy not to strike Moscow during the celebrations. A leader who wants everyone to believe he is winning the war does not ask his enemies for a temporary pause so he can safely watch a parade of a heavily depleted army.\nVladimir Putin has fallen into a trap of his own making — a system built not on democratic institutions, but on informal rules and competing clans organized around money, security structures, political influence, and personal loyalty to the Czar. For decades, Putin acted as the ultimate arbiter between these groups, balancing their interests. But as the pressure of war grows and Putin’s authority weakens, the balance inside the elite is beginning to break down.\nDifferent factions are now quietly preparing for an uncertain future — strengthening their control over financial resources, security agencies, and even private military forces. To understand where Russia may be heading in the coming years, it is necessary to understand the key clans that dominate the Russian system today — and the struggle that may begin once the current balance of power finally starts to collapse. \nTo understand the trajectory of the Russian state in the coming years, it is essential to map the primary actors who will likely participate in the inevitable Russian “Game of Thrones.”\nIStories and CORRECTIV have built profiles of the most influential Russian clans, their leaders, and the assets they control. The project focuses mainly on groups that possess not only formal political authority but also real physical power through control over security services, armed structures, or other coercive institutions.\nFor that reason, the profile does not include figures often described by the media as “technocrats” — such as Russian Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin, Central Bank chief Elvira Nabiullina, Finance Minister Anton Siluanov, and others. Although they occupy senior government positions, they do not appear to possess the kind of direct coercive power that could play a decisive role in a future struggle for power in Russia.\nThis profile covers some of the best-known and most powerful Russian clans and groups, but it is not a complete list of all potential actors in Russia’s potential “Game of Thrones.”\n\nThe Bodyguards\n\nViktor Zolotov (72 years old) met Vladimir Putin in the early 90s by a stroke of luck. According to the former head of the Security Service of Russia’s first president, Alexander Korzhakov, he hired Zolotov out of desperation — there were no people.\nTherefore, when the then-mayor of St. Petersburg asked Yeltsin to provide him with protection against St. Petersburg gangsters in the early 90s, Korzhakov decided to get rid of Zolotov and sent him to guard Sobchak.\nIn St. Petersburg, Zolotov met Putin and soon became responsible for his protection and that of his family members. When Putin became president, he appointed Zolotov as head of the Presidential Security Service.\nFor many years, Zolotov remained in the shadow of his boss. However, after mass protests against election fraud broke out in Russia in 2011, which Putin perceived as a conspiracy by Western intelligence agencies with part of the Russian — primarily liberal — elite, he decided to promote his bodyguards to leadership positions in law enforcement and other government agencies.\nPutin appointed Zolotov as head of the Interior Ministry’s Internal Troops, which in 2016 were renamed Rosgvardia and removed from the MVD into an independent paramilitary structure with 350,000 personnel.\nIn this post, Zolotov is essentially tasked with the same mission he has performed for the last 35 years — guarding Putin and his power. For these purposes, in 2023, following the failed mutiny of Yevgeny Prigozhin, Putin issued a decree transferring heavy equipment to Rosgvardia. Now, in the event of internal unrest, Putin’s bodyguard will be able to use heavy tanks against the Russian people.\nThere is no doubt Zolotov will decide to do so: as one of the leaders of the Russian criminal world told me, in St. Petersburg criminal circles, Zolotov had the nickname “The Pierced” (Probitiy) — for his cruelty and unquestioning loyalty to the Tsar.\nAlexey Dyumin (53 years old) comes from a military family. In 1995, he joined the Main Guard Directorate (predecessor of the FSO), where he dealt with communications; in 1999, he joined the Presidential Security Service. \nSince then, for 15 years, Dyumin served in Putin’s security detail, never leaving his side day or night, preventing him from drowning in the ocean, and guarding him from bears in the taiga. Initially, Dyumin owed his promotion to Viktor Zolotov: “Viktor Vasilyevich Zolotov is a person who did a lot for my destiny, taught me sense and wisdom… and I understood immediately that he is a very strong, spirited commander behind whom one can go to the end. And then there was an introduction to Vladimir Vladimirovich… and off we went!” Dyumin recalled. However, Dyumin subsequently became one of Putin’s main favorites and one of the most likely successors to the presidency. \nIn 2014, as part of the campaign to promote bodyguards to the highest echelons of power, Putin appointed Dyumin as deputy head of the GRU and commander of the Special Operations Forces (SSO), which played a key role in the occupation of Crimea. According to a source acquainted with Dyumin, he received the Hero of Russia star for this operation. \nIn 2016, Putin appointed Dyumin as governor of the Tula Oblast, which he led for the next eight years. As soon as the Russian president’s favorite became governor, everyone began to help him: from the Ministry of Defense, which began building bridges in the Tula Oblast, to the Moscow government, which renovated the embankment in Tula. State companies and private businesses joined in. \nIn 2024, Putin returned his favorite to Moscow and appointed him as his assistant overseeing the defense-industrial complex, as well as the Secretary of the State Council. This once insignificant advisory body received constitutional status in 2020 during major amendments. According to many experts, Putin gave the body constitutional status to be able to lead it in the future and hand over power to a successor while retaining the ability to control their decisions.\nDmitry Mironov (56 years old) is a descendant of military officers whose career became a classic example of a “personal bodyguard” ascending to the heights of state power. Since the early 90s, Mironov served in state security (FSO), where he for many years held the position of Vladimir Putin’s adjutant. The degree of closeness to the president is evidenced by the fact that in narrow circles, Putin reportedly affectionately calls him “sonny.” \nMironov’s public career began in 2014 when Putin appointed him head of the GUEBiPK of the Ministry of Internal Affairs. Already in 2016, similar to Alexey Dyumin, Mironov was sent for “testing” in a region — he headed the complex and protest-prone Yaroslavl Oblast. As governor, he enjoyed exclusive access to the president. \nIn 2021, Putin returned Mironov to Moscow, appointing him as his assistant. Today, he holds one of the most non-public but strategically important positions — chairman of the commission on personnel policy in law enforcement agencies. Through Mironov’s hands pass the dossiers of all the country’s key siloviki, making the former adjutant the “chief HR officer” of the regime. \nLike other members of the “bodyguards” clan, Mironov also oversees mobilization resources, heading the Council for Cossack Affairs and supporting Cossack units in the war with Ukraine.\n\nAlexey Rubezhnoy (53 years old) is a career officer of the “Alpha” special unit who replaced Dmitry Kochnev as head of the Presidential Security Service (SBP) in June 2016. Rubezhnoy focused on creating powerful economic influence, using the SBP as a tool for lobbying and control over strategic assets. \nRubezhnoy heads the Supreme Supervisory Board of the Russian Boxing Federation, led by Umar Kremlev (Lutfulloev) — a businessman with a criminal past. Rubezhnoy and Kremlev are relatives; they are married to sisters. Through Rubezhnoy’s patronage, Kremlev gained access to personal communication with the president. Their partnership allowed them to take control of multi-billion dollar markets: from monopolizing the betting business to managing the country’s largest lottery operator. After the full-scale invasion in 2022, Rubezhnoy became one of the main beneficiaries of the process of deprivatization and “nationalization” of private property. \nIt was Rubezhnoy who lobbied Putin for the decree transferring the assets of Russia’s largest car dealer, Rolf, to the temporary management of Rosimushchestvo; the new owner effectively became Rubezhnoy’s protégé, Kremlev.\nDmitry Kochnev (61 years old), director of the Federal Protective Service (FSO), is one of the most secretive and least-known silovik within Vladimir Putin’s inner circle. In 2021, Kochnev was promoted to General of the Army — Russia’s highest military rank (excluding Marshal) — underscoring a status that places him on equal footing with Sergei Shoigu, Alexander Bortnikov, and Viktor Zolotov.\nKochnev began his career in state security during the Soviet era, joining the KGB’s 9th Directorate in 1984, which was responsible for protecting the country’s top leadership. Following the collapse of the Soviet Union, he continued his rise through the structures of the Federal Protective Service.\nIn the early 2000s, Kochnev entered Vladimir Putin’s orbit, gradually becoming one of the most trusted officers in the president’s personal security detail. He oversaw the operational work of the Presidential Security Service (SBP) and was responsible for organizing the protection of top officials and strategic facilities.\nIn 2016, Putin appointed Kochnev as director of the FSO. While the agency is formally responsible for guarding high-ranking officials, the Kremlin, government communications, and strategic sites, it has long since transformed into an independent center of influence with vast financial, technical, and operational capabilities.\nFollowing the invasion of Ukraine, the FSO’s role expanded significantly: thanks to constant access to Putin and information on top officials, Kochnev and his agency wield immense influence.\n\nAlexander Kurenkov (53 years old) is a career intelligence officer whose biography exactly repeats the path of “adjutants” who became state ministers. From 2002, he began service in the FSO, and from 2015, he became Vladimir Putin’s adjutant. \nIn 2021, Kurenkov was transferred to Rosgvardia to Viktor Zolotov, where he became deputy director. However, in May 2022, Putin appointed him head of the MCHS. Putin characterized him as a “hard worker” (sluzhaka) in the best sense of the word, capable of bringing strict order to the structure. \nIn June 2025, Kurenkov was promoted to Colonel General. Under his leadership, the MCHS is integrating into the military agenda, actively restoring the civil defense system and shelters, for which over 150 billion rubles is planned.\n\nThe Consiglieri\n\nYuri Kovalchuk (74 years old) is called the “personal banker” and chief ideologue of the president, responsible for forming the media agenda and strategic planning. Kovalchuk is the informal curator of Russia’s internal policy. \nThrough the National Media Group (NMG), led by Putin’s mistress Alina Kabaeva, Kovalchuk controls the country’s largest media resources: Channel One, Fifth Channel, REN TV, and Izvestia. \nThe economic foundation of the clan consists of Bank Rossiya and the SOGAZ insurance group. \nYuri Kovalchuk’s role reached a new level after 2020: according to many sources, it was he who spent the most time with Putin in isolation during the pandemic, sharing his views on “restoring historical justice” and confrontation with the West. \nThrough Sergey Kiriyenko, they control the presidential administration, and through Mikhail Kovalchuk (Yuri’s brother), they control fundamental science and the budgets of the Kurchatov Institute. \nIn 2024, the clan’s influence was secured by the appointment of Yuri’s son, Boris Kovalchuk, as head of the Accounts Chamber.\n\nMikhail Kovalchuk (79 years old) is the elder brother of Yuri Kovalchuk and the chief ideologue of Russia’s scientific and technological development. \nSince 2005, he has led the NRC Kurchatov Institute, which has turned into a “scientific empire,” absorbing dozens of the country’s leading research institutes. \nKovalchuk serves as Putin’s guide to the world of “science of the future” and global threats. He is the author of theories about the creation of “nature-like technologies” and “biological dangers” coming from the West. \nAfter 2022, Mikhail Kovalchuk became a key figure in ensuring “technological mobilization,” promoting the idea of the complete isolation of Russian science from Western institutions.\nSergey Kiriyenko (62 years old) is the curator of the Putin regime’s internal policy, serving as First Deputy Head of the Presidential Administration since 2016. His alliance with the Kovalchuk clan is strategic: Kiriyenko provides administrative resources and personnel selection, while the Kovalchuks provide financial and media support. \nHis influence is built on total control over meanings and personnel. He is the ideologue of the “Leaders of Russia” system. In the digital environment, the clan is anchored through Sergey’s son — Vladimir Kiriyenko, who headed the VK holding. This turned the country’s largest social network into an instrument of state control and propaganda. After 2022, Kiriyenko became a key “civilian” face of the war, overseeing the creation of a new ideological layer in society.\n\nBoris Kovalchuk (48 years old) is the son of Yuri Kovalchuk, embodying the process of transferring power and assets to the “heirs” of the president’s inner circle. From 2009 to 2024, he led the Inter RAO holding — one of the country’s largest energy companies. In 2024, he was appointed head of the Accounts Chamber of the RF. \nThis appointment turned him into the country’s chief “auditor,” giving the Kovalchuk clan an unprecedented lever of control over the entire vertical of power, allowing them to oversee the financial discipline of potential competitors.\n\nAlexander Beglov (69 years old) is considered a direct appointee of Yuri Kovalchuk, ensuring the clan’s interests in their “base” region. As governor of St. Petersburg, Beglov acts as an operator of large infrastructure and investment projects in which Bank Rossiya and Kovalchuk-linked contractors are interested. \nIn 2024, having been re-elected for a new term, Beglov maintained full administrative control over the country’s second most important city for the Kovalchuk clan.\n\nAlexander Gutsan (65 years old) is a trusted person of the Kovalchuk clan in the law enforcement vertical. In September 2025, Gutsan’s political weight reached its peak: he was appointed Prosecutor General of the Russian Federation. This appointment allowed the Kovalchuk clan to gain control over the main supervisory body in the country. \nIn league with Boris Kovalchuk (head of the Accounts Chamber), the family now has the ability to not only audit financial expenditures but also immediately initiate criminal and administrative prosecution of any officials or businessmen. Gutsan plays the role of a key tool in the legalization of property redistribution.\n\n \nThe KGB Colleagues\n\nSergey Chemezov (73 years old) is one of the most influential people in Putin’s circle, whose connection with the president dates back to the mid-80s in Dresden (GDR). \nSince 2007, Chemezov has led the state corporation Rostec. Under his control are hundreds of enterprises of the military-industrial complex. \nAfter 2022, Chemezov’s role as the main arms producer for the Russian army became critical. He actively participates in the process of “creeping nationalization”: assets of private owners who fail to cope with state defense orders or are recognized as “disloyal” are systematically transferred to the management of Rostec.\n\nNikolay Tokarev (75 years old) is a member of the “Dresden group.” Tokarev traditionally belongs to Sergey Chemezov’s orbit of influence. \nUnder his leadership, Transneft turned into a key tool of the Kremlin’s energy diplomacy, managing the world’s largest oil pipeline system. \nAfter 2022, Tokarev’s role became critical in the context of reorienting oil flows from the West to the East. In the clan hierarchy, Tokarev acts as the “guardian of the pipe” — the regime’s key financial artery.\n\nDenis Manturov (57 years old) is the key conductor of Sergey Chemezov’s interests in the government. Chemezov publicly called Manturov a “reliable friend.” \nIn May 2024, he received the status of First Deputy Prime Minister, making him the chief curator of the entire real sector of the economy and the military-industrial complex. \nFor the successful supply of the front in 2026, Putin awarded Manturov the title of Hero of the Russian Federation. Manturov plays the role of a strategic operator who legalizes Rostec’s expansion and puts civilian industry on “military tracks.”\n\nSergey Kulikov (50 years old) is one of the most trusted young technocrats in Sergey Chemezov’s system. In December 2020, Kulikov replaced Anatoly Chubais as head of Rosnano. \nHis appointment marked the final transition of the innovation sector under the control of the Rostec group and the siloviki. \nIn the context of the war, Rosnano was reoriented toward the needs of the VPK, particularly for creating new materials and microelectronics for the front.\n\nThe Oilmen\n\nIgor Sechin (65 years old) is known in the media as “Darth Vader” for his tough management style. Since 2004, Sechin has headed Rosneft, turning it into the world’s largest oil company through a series of aggressive takeovers. He became the main ideologue of state capitalism. \nPower support for Sechin is provided by the so-called “Sechin’s Spetsnaz” — the 6th service of the FSB’s Internal Security Directorate, which he helped form for the Yukos case. \nFormer head of the “Six,” Ivan Tkachev, now heads the Department of Military Counterintelligence of the FSB (DVKR), which gives Sechin unprecedented levers of influence over the army leadership.\n\nGennady Timchenko (73 years old) is a heavyweight of the Putin elite. According to official statements by the US Treasury, Vladimir Putin personally had investments in Gunvor, which made Timchenko the actual manager of the president’s personal oil income. \nAfter 2022, Timchenko’s role became critical for the regime’s survival under the oil embargo. His structures and former managers switched to managing the “shadow fleet” — numerous tankers with opaque ownership. \nTimchenko acts as the architect of parallel export corridors.\n\nLieutenant General Ivan Tkachev (55 years old) led the 6th service of the FSB’s Internal Security Directorate, created with Sechin’s direct participation to purge the political and economic field of opponents. The “Six” gained a reputation as an “Oprichnina.”\nAfter UMB, Tkachev headed Department “K” of the FSB, and then moved to the post of head of the Department of Military Counterintelligence (DVKR) of the FSB.\nDuring full-scale war, the DVKR exercises direct oversight of the Ministry of Defense and monitors the distribution of giant defense budgets.\n\nEduard Khudaynatov (65 years old) is a key business partner of Igor Sechin, performing the role of “trusted person” for managing private assets. \nIn 2013, he formally left Rosneft to create his own private holding — the Independent Oil and Gas Company (NNC). \nNNC became a unique tool in the architecture of Sechin’s clan, systematically buying up oil fields and refineries that are then integrated into general logistics chains with Rosneft. \nNNC is effectively a “private branch” of the state oil monopoly.\n\nAlexander Novak (54 years old) is a key technocrat in the management system of the Russian fuel and energy complex. Despite his “technocrat” status, Novak is deeply integrated into Igor Sechin’s orbit of interests. \nSince 2015, he has been a member of the Board of Directors of Rosneft. \nIn May 2024, Putin re-confirmed him as Vice Prime Minister. Novak plays the role of Sechin’s “state interface,” legalizing Rosneft’s initiatives through government decrees and international agreements.\n\nThe Rotors\n\nArkady Rotenberg (74 years old) is a childhood friend of Putin. He built a giant construction empire specialized in the most ambitious state projects, the main symbol being the Crimean Bridge. \nRotenberg operates through private structures that depend entirely on budget funding. \nAfter 2022, Arkady Rotenberg and his clan members became key beneficiaries of property redistribution and nationalization. \nAccording to the Financial Times, Rotenberg-linked company “Roskhim” has already acquired at least three Russian companies after they were nationalized. In 2020, Putin awarded him the title of Hero of Labour of the RF.\n\nIgor Rotenberg (52 years old) is the eldest son of Arkady Rotenberg. \nHis main asset is a stake in RT-Invest Transport Systems, the operator of the Platon system, which collects fees from heavy trucks on federal highways. This project is a classic example of public-private partnership in the interest of a narrow circle of people. \nIgor Rotenberg also controls Gazprom Burenie, Gazprom’s largest contractor. He manages “digital rent,” providing the family’s long-term financial stability.\n\nBoris Rotenberg (68 years old) is the younger brother of Arkady. \nBoris was traditionally responsible for the financial block and the management of the family’s personal assets. \nHe also acts as the main curator of sports projects, which are an important channel for informal communication with Putin. \nAfter 2022, SMP Bank was integrated into Promsvyazbank (PSB), allowing family assets to be integrated into the system for servicing state defense orders.\n\nOleg Belozerov (56 years old) has headed RZD since 2015. His career is inextricably linked with St. Petersburg and the interests of the Rotenberg brothers. \nUnder his leadership, RZD became the main customer for Rotenberg construction holdings, including projects for the expansion of the Eastern Polygon (BAM and Transsib). \nBelozerov ensures the smooth operation of military transport logistics.\n\nThe Military\n\nAndrey Belousov (66 years old) was appointed Minister of Defense in May 2024. \nHe is the main architect of the concept of “Military Keynesianism,” whereby huge military spending should become the engine for the entire Russian economy. \nBelousov’s main task is to conduct a “total audit” and eradicate corruption schemes. He does not claim the role of commander but fully controls financial flows. \nHe is an ideal tool for Putin to control the security block.\nValery Gerasimov (70 years old) has been Chief of the General Staff since 2012. \nHe is one of three people in the country with access to the “nuclear briefcase.” \nSince January 2023, Gerasimov has personally led the Joint Group of Forces in the conflict with Ukraine. \nHe remains the key link between the political leadership and the fighting army.\n\nAdmiral Igor Kostyukov (65 years old) has led military intelligence since 2018. \nUnder his leadership, the GRU turned into Russia’s main instrument for sabotage abroad. \nIn 2024–2026, the GRU became the main operator of “hybrid war,” including cyberattacks and sabotage at logistics hubs supplying aid to Ukraine. \nIn January 2026, he led the Russian delegation at talks in Abu Dhabi, highlighting his status as an influential political player.\n\nThe Chekists\n\nAlexander Bortnikov (74 years old) has headed the FSB since May 2008. \nHe acts as the main “guardian of the regime,” responsible for internal stability and fighting dissent. \nAfter 2022, his influence became existential for the Kremlin. \nDespite facing criticism for misjudging the situation in Ukraine at the onset of the invasion, Bortnikov retained his post and was reappointed as the service’s director in May 2024. His main task is to ensure total political sterility within the country.\nHowever, according to sources of IStories, Bortnikov is losing influence due to his health and spends more time in sanatoriums than at work.\n\nSergey Korolev (63 years old) is the “Gray Cardinal” of the Lubyanka. \nDespite a reputation for being close to leaders of the criminal world (helping Gennady Petrov and the hitman Aslan Gagiev), such connections are interpreted as “operational work” in the Putin regime. \nToday, Korolev is the First Deputy Director of the FSB and effectively manages the day-to-day activities of the service due to Bortnikov’s health.\n\nGeneral Alexey Sedov (71 years old) has led the 2nd service since 2006, which human rights activists call the “political Gestapo.”\nThis service oversees the fight against “extremism” and “internal threats,” which in practice translates to the persecution of opposition leaders, journalists, and activists.\nThe 2nd service of the FSB is responsible for the physical and legal elimination of political opponents: its employees were behind the poisoning of Alexei Navalny. \nSedov has the right of direct reports to Putin. \nIn 2026, Sedov remains the key architect of total political control.\n\nNikolai Patrushev (74 years old) served as Secretary of the Security Council for 16 years (2008–2024), transforming the body into a “shadow government” that shaped an aggressive foreign policy and an anti-Western vision for the country’s development.\nHis positions were shaken after the Yevgeny Prigozhin mutiny. \nIn May 2024, he was moved to the more modest post of assistant to the president overseeing shipbuilding. \nNevertheless, he retains significant influence within the state security system through a network of his appointees, including Alexey Sedov.\n\nThe Orthodox\n\nKonstantin Malofeev (51 years old) is known as the “Orthodox oligarch.” He was at the origin of the 2014 events in Donbas and Crimea. \nAfter 2022, his significance grew due to the financing of numerous private armed units and volunteer battalions. Possessing his own mini-army, Malofeev could become a “jack-in-the-box” in the 2026 struggle for succession.\n\nIgor Shchegolev (60 years old), the Presidential Envoy to the Central Federal District and former Minister of Communications, is a former intelligence officer of the KGB’s First Chief Directorate (PGU) who served under TASS cover. Shchegolev’s ties to Putin date back to 1999; he served as an advisor when Putin headed the government and ran the presidential protocol department in 2002.\nIn 2008, Shchegolev was appointed Minister of Communications. Between 2009 and 2010, a fund managed by his longtime friend, Konstantin Malofeev, acquired roughly a 10% stake in Rostelecom, Russia’s largest state-controlled telecommunications company. Malofeev later sold this stake back to Rostelecom in 2013 for more than 30 billion rubles. Russian media suspected that Malofeev may have been acting in Shchegolev’s interests.\n\nGeorgy Shevkunov (Tikhon) (67 years old) is widely known as Vladimir Putin’s “confessor” and ranks among the most powerful figures within the Russian Orthodox Church. He grew close to Putin in the late 1990s when the latter headed the FSB. Putin reportedly visited the priest on his own initiative; Tikhon was then the abbot of the Sretensky Monastery, located just a couple of kilometers from the FSB headquarters on Lubyanka. \nShevkunov is a long-standing ideologue of Russia's confrontation with the West and a key pro-war propagandist who has exerted immense effort to shape state policy. \nSources acquainted with Malofeev and Shchegolev note that both are deeply connected to Tikhon. Despite the Metropolitan’s strained relations with the official church leadership, he is frequently tipped as a potential contender for the post of Russian Patriarch.\n\nTranslation: CORRECTIV, IStories","blocks":[{"data":"Every month, the Russian army loses more than 35,000 soldiers while achieving almost no significant advances on the battlefield. At the same time, Ukraine’s drone strikes deep inside Russian territory are becoming increasingly effective and damaging. The Economist recently described the situation as a possible turning point in the war. Sir Lawrence Freedman, one of Britain’s best-known military experts, told the magazine that the current moment increasingly resembles a strategic turning point in the war.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russia’s economy is slowing down sharply. Regional budget deficits are growing, businesses are struggling under extremely high interest rates, and inflation continues to push prices upward. Disruptions of mobile communications and internet shutdowns across many Russian regions have added to public frustration, creating growing social discontent that the Kremlin can no longer easily dismiss.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Inside the Russian elite, tensions are also rising. According to an intelligence report recently <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2026/05/04/vladimir-putin-fear/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">published</a> by IStories, Financial Times, and CNN, senior Russian security officials are increasingly blaming one another for failures in Ukraine.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Ahead of the Victory Day parade on Red Square, Vladimir Putin asked Donald Trump to persuade Volodymyr Zelenskyy not to strike Moscow during the celebrations. A leader who wants everyone to&nbsp;believe he is winning the war does not ask his enemies for a temporary pause so he can safely watch a parade of a heavily depleted army.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Vladimir Putin has fallen into a trap of his own making — a system built not on democratic institutions, but on informal rules and competing clans organized around money, security structures, political influence, and personal loyalty to the Czar. For decades, Putin acted as the ultimate arbiter between these groups, balancing their interests. But as the pressure of war grows and Putin’s authority weakens, the balance inside the elite is beginning to break down.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Different factions are now quietly preparing for an uncertain future — strengthening their control over financial resources, security agencies, and even private military forces. To understand where Russia may be heading in the coming years, it is necessary to understand the key clans that dominate the Russian system today — and the struggle that may begin once the current balance of power finally starts to collapse.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"To understand the trajectory of the Russian state in the coming years, it is essential to map the primary actors who will likely participate in the inevitable Russian “Game of Thrones.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories and CORRECTIV have built profiles of the most influential Russian clans, their leaders, and the assets they control. The project focuses mainly on groups that possess not only formal political authority but also real physical power through control over security services, armed structures, or other coercive institutions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For that reason, the profile does not include figures often described by the media as “technocrats” — such as Russian Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin, Central Bank chief Elvira Nabiullina, Finance Minister Anton Siluanov, and others. Although they occupy senior government positions, they do not appear to possess the kind of direct coercive power that could play a decisive role in a future struggle for power in Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This profile covers some of the best-known and most powerful Russian clans and groups, but it is not a complete list of all potential actors in Russia’s potential “Game of Thrones.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Bodyguards","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":{"id":18351,"data":{"images":[{"isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc13b94b498440bcab3166dce86e4e68-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc13b94b498440bcab3166dce86e4e68-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc13b94b498440bcab3166dce86e4e68-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1917,"real_width_2x":2781,"real_height_1x":828,"real_height_2x":1201},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc13b94b498440bcab3166dce86e4e68-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc13b94b498440bcab3166dce86e4e68-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc13b94b498440bcab3166dce86e4e68-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1917,"real_width_2x":2781,"real_height_1x":828,"real_height_2x":1201},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc13b94b498440bcab3166dce86e4e68-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc13b94b498440bcab3166dce86e4e68-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc13b94b498440bcab3166dce86e4e68-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":518,"real_height_2x":1036},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc13b94b498440bcab3166dce86e4e68-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc13b94b498440bcab3166dce86e4e68-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc13b94b498440bcab3166dce86e4e68-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":518,"real_height_2x":1036},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc13b94b498440bcab3166dce86e4e68-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc13b94b498440bcab3166dce86e4e68-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc13b94b498440bcab3166dce86e4e68-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":179,"real_height_2x":358},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc13b94b498440bcab3166dce86e4e68-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc13b94b498440bcab3166dce86e4e68-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc13b94b498440bcab3166dce86e4e68-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":179,"real_height_2x":358}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":{"id":18367,"data":{"text":"Rosgvardia (National Guard)","author":"Viktor Zolotov","category":"The Bodyguards","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8e4751941f96442798c4baf9caa4ce38-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8e4751941f96442798c4baf9caa4ce38-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8e4751941f96442798c4baf9caa4ce38-original.png","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":721,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8e4751941f96442798c4baf9caa4ce38-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8e4751941f96442798c4baf9caa4ce38-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8e4751941f96442798c4baf9caa4ce38-original.png","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":721,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Viktor Zolotov</strong> (72 years old) met Vladimir Putin in the early 90s by a stroke of luck. According to the former head of the Security Service of Russia’s first president, Alexander Korzhakov, he hired Zolotov out of desperation — there were no people.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Therefore, when the then-mayor of St. Petersburg asked Yeltsin to provide him with protection against St. Petersburg gangsters in the early 90s, Korzhakov decided to get rid of Zolotov and sent him to guard Sobchak.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In St. Petersburg, Zolotov met Putin and soon became responsible for his protection and that of his family members. When Putin became president, he appointed Zolotov as head of the Presidential Security Service.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For many years, Zolotov remained in the shadow of his boss. However, after mass protests against election fraud broke out in Russia in 2011, which Putin perceived as a conspiracy by Western intelligence agencies with part of the Russian — primarily liberal — elite, he decided to promote his bodyguards to leadership positions in law enforcement and other government agencies.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Putin appointed Zolotov as head of the Interior Ministry’s Internal Troops, which in 2016 were renamed Rosgvardia and removed from the MVD into an independent paramilitary structure with 350,000 personnel.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In this post, Zolotov is essentially tasked with the same mission he has performed for the last 35 years — guarding Putin and his power. For these purposes, in 2023, following the failed mutiny of Yevgeny Prigozhin, Putin issued a decree transferring heavy equipment to Rosgvardia. Now, in the event of internal unrest, Putin’s bodyguard will be able to use heavy tanks against the Russian people.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There is no doubt Zolotov will decide to do so: as one of the leaders of the Russian criminal world told me, in St. Petersburg criminal circles, Zolotov had the nickname “The Pierced” (Probitiy) — for his cruelty and unquestioning loyalty to the Tsar.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18301,"data":{"text":"State Council","author":"Alexey Dyumin ","category":"The Bodyguards","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/caf84cbfd2f74b3e8e0a9db30666b51f-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/caf84cbfd2f74b3e8e0a9db30666b51f-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/caf84cbfd2f74b3e8e0a9db30666b51f-original.webp","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/caf84cbfd2f74b3e8e0a9db30666b51f-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/caf84cbfd2f74b3e8e0a9db30666b51f-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/caf84cbfd2f74b3e8e0a9db30666b51f-original.webp","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Alexey Dyumin</strong> (53 years old) comes from a military family. In 1995, he joined the Main Guard Directorate (predecessor of the FSO), where he dealt with communications; in 1999, he joined the Presidential Security Service. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Since then, for 15 years, Dyumin served in Putin’s security detail, never leaving his side day or night, preventing him from drowning in the ocean, and guarding him from bears in the taiga.&nbsp;Initially, Dyumin owed his promotion to Viktor Zolotov: “Viktor Vasilyevich Zolotov is a person who did a lot for my destiny, taught me sense and wisdom… and I understood immediately that he is a very strong, spirited commander behind whom one can go to the end. And then there was an introduction to Vladimir Vladimirovich… and off we went!” Dyumin recalled.&nbsp;However, Dyumin subsequently became one of Putin’s main favorites and one of the most likely successors to the presidency.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2014, as part of the campaign to promote bodyguards to the highest echelons of power, Putin appointed Dyumin as deputy head of the GRU and commander of the Special Operations Forces (SSO), which played a key role in the occupation of Crimea.&nbsp;According to a source acquainted with Dyumin, he received the Hero of Russia star for this operation. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2016, Putin appointed Dyumin as governor of the Tula Oblast, which he led for the next eight years.&nbsp;As soon as the Russian president’s favorite became governor, everyone began to help him: from the Ministry of Defense, which began building bridges in the Tula Oblast, to the Moscow government, which renovated the embankment in Tula.&nbsp;State companies and private businesses joined in. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2024, Putin returned his favorite to Moscow and appointed him as his assistant overseeing the defense-industrial complex, as well as the Secretary of the State Council. This once insignificant advisory body received constitutional status in 2020 during major amendments.&nbsp;According to many experts, Putin gave the body constitutional status to be able to lead it in the future and hand over power to a successor while retaining the ability to control their decisions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18302,"data":{"text":"Presidential Administration / Personnel Policy Commission","author":"Dmitry Mironov","category":"The Bodyguards","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a89408aef63f49eca33cf9dbe96dc30c-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a89408aef63f49eca33cf9dbe96dc30c-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a89408aef63f49eca33cf9dbe96dc30c-original.webp","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a89408aef63f49eca33cf9dbe96dc30c-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a89408aef63f49eca33cf9dbe96dc30c-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a89408aef63f49eca33cf9dbe96dc30c-original.webp","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Dmitry Mironov</strong> (56 years old) is a descendant of military officers whose career became a classic example of a “personal bodyguard” ascending to the heights of state power.&nbsp;Since the early 90s, Mironov served in state security (FSO), where he for many years held the position of Vladimir Putin’s adjutant. The degree of closeness to the president is evidenced by the fact that in narrow circles, Putin reportedly affectionately <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2024/07/09/putins-sonny/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">calls him “sonny.”</a>&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Mironov’s public career began in 2014 when Putin appointed him head of the GUEBiPK of the Ministry of Internal Affairs. Already in 2016, similar to Alexey Dyumin, Mironov was sent for “testing” in a region — he headed the complex and protest-prone Yaroslavl Oblast. As governor, he enjoyed exclusive access to the president.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2021, Putin returned Mironov to Moscow, appointing him as his assistant. Today, he holds one of the most non-public but strategically important positions — chairman of the commission on personnel policy in law enforcement agencies. Through Mironov’s hands pass the dossiers of all the country’s key siloviki, making the former adjutant the “chief HR officer” of the regime.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Like other members of the “bodyguards” clan, Mironov also oversees mobilization resources, heading the Council for Cossack Affairs and supporting Cossack units in the war with Ukraine.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18303,"data":{"text":"Presidential Security Service (SBP)","author":"Alexey Rubezhnoy ","category":"The Bodyguards","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ee50cb89ffb4d44bd5a80f283b262c1-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ee50cb89ffb4d44bd5a80f283b262c1-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ee50cb89ffb4d44bd5a80f283b262c1-original.webp","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ee50cb89ffb4d44bd5a80f283b262c1-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ee50cb89ffb4d44bd5a80f283b262c1-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6ee50cb89ffb4d44bd5a80f283b262c1-original.webp","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Alexey Rubezhnoy</strong> (53 years old) is a career officer of the “Alpha” special unit who replaced Dmitry Kochnev as head of the Presidential Security Service (SBP) in June 2016.&nbsp;Rubezhnoy focused on creating powerful economic influence, using the SBP as a tool for lobbying and control over strategic assets. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Rubezhnoy heads the Supreme Supervisory Board of the Russian Boxing Federation, led by Umar Kremlev (Lutfulloev) — a businessman with a criminal past.&nbsp;Rubezhnoy and Kremlev are relatives; they are married to sisters. Through Rubezhnoy’s patronage, Kremlev gained access to personal communication with the president. Their partnership allowed them to take control of multi-billion dollar markets: from monopolizing the betting business to managing the country’s largest lottery operator.&nbsp;After the full-scale invasion in 2022, Rubezhnoy became one of the main beneficiaries of the process of deprivatization and “nationalization” of private property.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It was Rubezhnoy who lobbied Putin for the decree transferring the assets of Russia’s largest car dealer, Rolf, to the temporary management of Rosimushchestvo; the new owner effectively became Rubezhnoy’s protégé, Kremlev.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18307,"data":{"text":"Federal Protective Service (FSO)","author":"Dmitry Kochnev","category":"The Bodyguards","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/906c1641bfb34c798f9d2a2f039cbf18-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/906c1641bfb34c798f9d2a2f039cbf18-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/906c1641bfb34c798f9d2a2f039cbf18-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/906c1641bfb34c798f9d2a2f039cbf18-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/906c1641bfb34c798f9d2a2f039cbf18-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/906c1641bfb34c798f9d2a2f039cbf18-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Dmitry Kochnev</strong> (61 years old), director of the Federal Protective Service (FSO), is one of the most secretive and least-known silovik within Vladimir Putin’s inner circle. In 2021, Kochnev was promoted to General of the Army — Russia’s highest military rank (excluding Marshal) — underscoring a status that places him on equal footing with Sergei Shoigu, Alexander Bortnikov, and Viktor Zolotov.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Kochnev began his career in state security during the Soviet era, joining the KGB’s 9th Directorate in 1984, which was responsible for protecting the country’s top leadership. Following the collapse of the Soviet Union, he continued his rise through the structures of the Federal Protective Service.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In the early 2000s, Kochnev entered Vladimir Putin’s orbit, gradually becoming one of the most trusted officers in the president’s personal security detail. He oversaw the operational work of the Presidential Security Service (SBP) and was responsible for organizing the protection of top officials and strategic facilities.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2016, Putin appointed Kochnev as director of the FSO. While the agency is formally responsible for guarding high-ranking officials, the Kremlin, government communications, and strategic sites, it has long since transformed into an independent center of influence with vast financial, technical, and operational capabilities.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Following the invasion of Ukraine, the FSO’s role expanded significantly: thanks to constant access to Putin and information on top officials, Kochnev and his agency wield immense influence.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18308,"data":{"text":"Ministry of Emergency Situations (MCHS)","author":"Alexander Kurenkov ","category":"The Bodyguards","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d8eaec4e17e2467d968fd5f948d80c58-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d8eaec4e17e2467d968fd5f948d80c58-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d8eaec4e17e2467d968fd5f948d80c58-original.webp","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d8eaec4e17e2467d968fd5f948d80c58-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d8eaec4e17e2467d968fd5f948d80c58-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d8eaec4e17e2467d968fd5f948d80c58-original.webp","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Alexander Kurenkov</strong> (53 years old) is a career intelligence officer whose biography exactly repeats the path of “adjutants” who became state ministers.&nbsp;From 2002, he began service in the FSO, and from 2015, he became Vladimir Putin’s adjutant. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2021, Kurenkov was transferred to Rosgvardia to Viktor Zolotov, where he became deputy director.&nbsp;However, in May 2022, Putin appointed him head of the MCHS. Putin characterized him as a “hard worker” (sluzhaka) in the best sense of the word, capable of bringing strict order to the structure.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In June 2025, Kurenkov was promoted to Colonel General. Under his leadership, the MCHS is integrating into the military agenda, actively restoring the civil defense system and shelters, for which over 150 billion rubles is planned.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Consiglieri","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":{"id":18352,"data":{"images":[{"isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c3725a41e5184d71ba060717dd002fa6-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c3725a41e5184d71ba060717dd002fa6-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c3725a41e5184d71ba060717dd002fa6-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1917,"real_width_2x":2781,"real_height_1x":828,"real_height_2x":1201},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c3725a41e5184d71ba060717dd002fa6-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c3725a41e5184d71ba060717dd002fa6-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c3725a41e5184d71ba060717dd002fa6-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1917,"real_width_2x":2781,"real_height_1x":828,"real_height_2x":1201},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c3725a41e5184d71ba060717dd002fa6-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c3725a41e5184d71ba060717dd002fa6-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c3725a41e5184d71ba060717dd002fa6-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":518,"real_height_2x":1036},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c3725a41e5184d71ba060717dd002fa6-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c3725a41e5184d71ba060717dd002fa6-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c3725a41e5184d71ba060717dd002fa6-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":518,"real_height_2x":1036},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c3725a41e5184d71ba060717dd002fa6-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c3725a41e5184d71ba060717dd002fa6-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c3725a41e5184d71ba060717dd002fa6-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":179,"real_height_2x":358},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c3725a41e5184d71ba060717dd002fa6-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c3725a41e5184d71ba060717dd002fa6-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c3725a41e5184d71ba060717dd002fa6-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":179,"real_height_2x":358}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":{"id":18309,"data":{"text":"Bank Rossiya, National Media Group (NMG), SOGAZ","author":"Yuri Kovalchuk","category":"The Consiglieri","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cc0ba95dce35436fa773ecda419c0fd6-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cc0ba95dce35436fa773ecda419c0fd6-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cc0ba95dce35436fa773ecda419c0fd6-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cc0ba95dce35436fa773ecda419c0fd6-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cc0ba95dce35436fa773ecda419c0fd6-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cc0ba95dce35436fa773ecda419c0fd6-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Yuri Kovalchuk</strong> (74 years old) is called the “personal banker” and chief ideologue of the president, responsible for forming the media agenda and strategic planning. Kovalchuk is the informal curator of Russia’s internal policy.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Through the National Media Group (NMG), led by Putin’s mistress Alina Kabaeva, Kovalchuk controls the country’s largest media resources: Channel One, Fifth Channel, REN TV, and Izvestia.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The economic foundation of the clan consists of Bank Rossiya and the SOGAZ insurance group.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Yuri Kovalchuk’s role reached a new level after 2020: according to many sources, it was he who spent the most time with Putin in isolation during the pandemic, sharing his views on “restoring historical justice” and confrontation with the West.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Through Sergey Kiriyenko, they control the presidential administration, and through Mikhail Kovalchuk (Yuri’s brother), they control fundamental science and the budgets of the Kurchatov Institute.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2024, the clan’s influence was secured by the appointment of Yuri’s son, Boris Kovalchuk, as head of the Accounts Chamber.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18315,"data":{"text":"Kurchatov Institute, Presidential Council for Science and Education","author":"Mikhail Kovalchuk ","category":"The Consiglieri","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a1cc52f9753b483f9334c3bf3c2b139d-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a1cc52f9753b483f9334c3bf3c2b139d-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a1cc52f9753b483f9334c3bf3c2b139d-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a1cc52f9753b483f9334c3bf3c2b139d-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a1cc52f9753b483f9334c3bf3c2b139d-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a1cc52f9753b483f9334c3bf3c2b139d-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Mikhail Kovalchuk</strong> (79 years old) is the elder brother of Yuri Kovalchuk and the chief ideologue of Russia’s scientific and technological development.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Since 2005, he has led the NRC Kurchatov Institute, which has turned into a “scientific empire,” absorbing dozens of the country’s leading research institutes.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Kovalchuk serves as Putin’s guide to the world of “science of the future” and global threats. He is the author of theories about the creation of “nature-like technologies” and “biological dangers” coming from the West.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After 2022, Mikhail Kovalchuk became a key figure in ensuring “technological mobilization,” promoting the idea of the complete isolation of Russian science from Western institutions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18311,"data":{"text":"Presidential Administration (Internal Policy), Rosatom, VK","author":"Sergey Kiriyenko ","category":"The Consiglieri","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0b28c97ac24a4f5288985e8500e183c4-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0b28c97ac24a4f5288985e8500e183c4-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0b28c97ac24a4f5288985e8500e183c4-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0b28c97ac24a4f5288985e8500e183c4-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0b28c97ac24a4f5288985e8500e183c4-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0b28c97ac24a4f5288985e8500e183c4-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Sergey Kiriyenko</strong> (62 years old) is the curator of the Putin regime’s internal policy, serving as First Deputy Head of the Presidential Administration since 2016.&nbsp;His alliance with the Kovalchuk clan is strategic: Kiriyenko provides administrative resources and personnel selection, while the Kovalchuks provide financial and media support. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"His influence is built on total control over meanings and personnel. He is the ideologue of the “Leaders of Russia” system.&nbsp;In the digital environment, the clan is anchored through Sergey’s son — Vladimir Kiriyenko, who headed the VK holding. This turned the country’s largest social network into an instrument of state control and propaganda.&nbsp;After 2022, Kiriyenko became a key “civilian” face of the war, overseeing the creation of a new ideological layer in society.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18312,"data":{"text":"Accounts Chamber of the RF / Energy","author":"Boris Kovalchuk ","category":"The Consiglieri","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a54ab193bef840da848956e019ed4454-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a54ab193bef840da848956e019ed4454-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a54ab193bef840da848956e019ed4454-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a54ab193bef840da848956e019ed4454-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a54ab193bef840da848956e019ed4454-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a54ab193bef840da848956e019ed4454-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Boris Kovalchuk</strong> (48 years old) is the son of Yuri Kovalchuk, embodying the process of transferring power and assets to the “heirs” of the president’s inner circle.&nbsp;From 2009 to 2024, he led the Inter RAO holding — one of the country’s largest energy companies.&nbsp;In 2024, he was appointed head of the Accounts Chamber of the RF. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This appointment turned him into the country’s chief “auditor,” giving the Kovalchuk clan an unprecedented lever of control over the entire vertical of power, allowing them to oversee the financial discipline of potential competitors.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18314,"data":{"text":"Government of St. Petersburg","author":"Alexander Beglov","category":"The Consiglieri","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4401d119f104bb4ad0f374418a5e0c6-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4401d119f104bb4ad0f374418a5e0c6-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4401d119f104bb4ad0f374418a5e0c6-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4401d119f104bb4ad0f374418a5e0c6-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4401d119f104bb4ad0f374418a5e0c6-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e4401d119f104bb4ad0f374418a5e0c6-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Alexander Beglov</strong> (69 years old) is considered a direct appointee of Yuri Kovalchuk, ensuring the clan’s interests in their “base” region.&nbsp;As governor of St. Petersburg, Beglov acts as an operator of large infrastructure and investment projects in which Bank Rossiya and Kovalchuk-linked contractors are interested.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2024, having been re-elected for a new term, Beglov maintained full administrative control over the country’s second most important city for the Kovalchuk clan.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18316,"data":{"text":"Prosecutor General’s Office","author":"Alexander Gutsan ","category":"The Consiglieri","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/609f67b1dbc34f87aecdfdbc16a32ef2-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/609f67b1dbc34f87aecdfdbc16a32ef2-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/609f67b1dbc34f87aecdfdbc16a32ef2-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/609f67b1dbc34f87aecdfdbc16a32ef2-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/609f67b1dbc34f87aecdfdbc16a32ef2-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/609f67b1dbc34f87aecdfdbc16a32ef2-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Alexander Gutsan</strong> (65 years old) is a trusted person of the Kovalchuk clan in the law enforcement vertical.&nbsp;In September 2025, Gutsan’s political weight reached its peak: he was appointed Prosecutor General of the Russian Federation. This appointment allowed the Kovalchuk clan to gain control over the main supervisory body in the country.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In league with Boris Kovalchuk (head of the Accounts Chamber), the family now has the ability to not only audit financial expenditures but also immediately initiate criminal and administrative prosecution of any officials or businessmen.&nbsp;Gutsan plays the role of a key tool in the legalization of property redistribution.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":" ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The KGB Colleagues","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":{"id":18353,"data":{"images":[{"isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/109f0004746f43f1a51e516eedeef7a4-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/109f0004746f43f1a51e516eedeef7a4-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/109f0004746f43f1a51e516eedeef7a4-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1917,"real_width_2x":2781,"real_height_1x":828,"real_height_2x":1201},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/109f0004746f43f1a51e516eedeef7a4-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/109f0004746f43f1a51e516eedeef7a4-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/109f0004746f43f1a51e516eedeef7a4-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1917,"real_width_2x":2781,"real_height_1x":828,"real_height_2x":1201},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/109f0004746f43f1a51e516eedeef7a4-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/109f0004746f43f1a51e516eedeef7a4-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/109f0004746f43f1a51e516eedeef7a4-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":518,"real_height_2x":1036},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/109f0004746f43f1a51e516eedeef7a4-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/109f0004746f43f1a51e516eedeef7a4-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/109f0004746f43f1a51e516eedeef7a4-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":518,"real_height_2x":1036},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/109f0004746f43f1a51e516eedeef7a4-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/109f0004746f43f1a51e516eedeef7a4-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/109f0004746f43f1a51e516eedeef7a4-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":179,"real_height_2x":358},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/109f0004746f43f1a51e516eedeef7a4-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/109f0004746f43f1a51e516eedeef7a4-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/109f0004746f43f1a51e516eedeef7a4-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":179,"real_height_2x":358}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":{"id":18322,"data":{"text":"Rostec","author":"Sergey Chemezov ","category":"The KGB Colleagues","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/38af51ffc038478187173466f64794d1-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/38af51ffc038478187173466f64794d1-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/38af51ffc038478187173466f64794d1-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/38af51ffc038478187173466f64794d1-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/38af51ffc038478187173466f64794d1-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/38af51ffc038478187173466f64794d1-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Sergey Chemezov</strong> (73 years old) is one of the most influential people in Putin’s circle, whose connection with the president dates back to the mid-80s in Dresden (GDR).&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Since 2007, Chemezov has led the state corporation Rostec. Under his control are hundreds of enterprises of the military-industrial complex.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After 2022, Chemezov’s role as the main arms producer for the Russian army became critical.&nbsp;He actively participates in the process of “creeping nationalization”: assets of private owners who fail to cope with state defense orders or are recognized as “disloyal” are systematically transferred to the management of Rostec.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18318,"data":{"text":"Transneft","author":"Nikolay Tokarev","category":"The KGB Colleagues","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c024754cff9b4d9e99e1885ee44310af-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c024754cff9b4d9e99e1885ee44310af-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c024754cff9b4d9e99e1885ee44310af-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c024754cff9b4d9e99e1885ee44310af-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c024754cff9b4d9e99e1885ee44310af-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c024754cff9b4d9e99e1885ee44310af-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Nikolay Tokarev</strong> (75 years old) is a member of the “Dresden group.” Tokarev traditionally belongs to Sergey Chemezov’s orbit of influence.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Under his leadership, Transneft turned into a key tool of the Kremlin’s energy diplomacy, managing the world’s largest oil pipeline system.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After 2022, Tokarev’s role became critical in the context of reorienting oil flows from the West to the East. In the clan hierarchy, Tokarev acts as the “guardian of the pipe” — the regime’s key financial artery.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18319,"data":{"text":"Government","author":"Denis Manturov","category":"The KGB Colleagues","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d8807664c5d4cf5805f4eb9807f78a6-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d8807664c5d4cf5805f4eb9807f78a6-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d8807664c5d4cf5805f4eb9807f78a6-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d8807664c5d4cf5805f4eb9807f78a6-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d8807664c5d4cf5805f4eb9807f78a6-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6d8807664c5d4cf5805f4eb9807f78a6-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Denis Manturov</strong> (57 years old) is the key conductor of Sergey Chemezov’s interests in the government. Chemezov publicly called Manturov a “reliable friend.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In May 2024, he received the status of First Deputy Prime Minister, making him the chief curator of the entire real sector of the economy and the military-industrial complex.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For the successful supply of the front in 2026, Putin awarded Manturov the title of Hero of the Russian Federation.&nbsp;Manturov plays the role of a strategic operator who legalizes Rostec’s expansion and puts civilian industry on “military tracks.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18321,"data":{"text":"Rosnano, Military-Industrial Commission (VPK)","author":"Sergey Kulikov","category":"The KGB Colleagues","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7b55aa8917dd4894aa4f81ca2645f953-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7b55aa8917dd4894aa4f81ca2645f953-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7b55aa8917dd4894aa4f81ca2645f953-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7b55aa8917dd4894aa4f81ca2645f953-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7b55aa8917dd4894aa4f81ca2645f953-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7b55aa8917dd4894aa4f81ca2645f953-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Sergey Kulikov</strong> (50 years old) is one of the most trusted young technocrats in Sergey Chemezov’s system.&nbsp;In December 2020, Kulikov replaced Anatoly Chubais as head of Rosnano. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"His appointment marked the final transition of the innovation sector under the control of the Rostec group and the siloviki.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In the context of the war, Rosnano was reoriented toward the needs of the VPK, particularly for creating new materials and microelectronics for the front.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Oilmen","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":{"id":18354,"data":{"images":[{"isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8e9f1d8f56e4223860e624942309f4f-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8e9f1d8f56e4223860e624942309f4f-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8e9f1d8f56e4223860e624942309f4f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2625,"real_height_1x":829,"real_height_2x":1134},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8e9f1d8f56e4223860e624942309f4f-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8e9f1d8f56e4223860e624942309f4f-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8e9f1d8f56e4223860e624942309f4f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2625,"real_height_1x":829,"real_height_2x":1134},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8e9f1d8f56e4223860e624942309f4f-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8e9f1d8f56e4223860e624942309f4f-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8e9f1d8f56e4223860e624942309f4f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2398,"real_height_1x":518,"real_height_2x":1036},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8e9f1d8f56e4223860e624942309f4f-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8e9f1d8f56e4223860e624942309f4f-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8e9f1d8f56e4223860e624942309f4f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2398,"real_height_1x":518,"real_height_2x":1036},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8e9f1d8f56e4223860e624942309f4f-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8e9f1d8f56e4223860e624942309f4f-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8e9f1d8f56e4223860e624942309f4f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":179,"real_height_2x":358},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8e9f1d8f56e4223860e624942309f4f-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8e9f1d8f56e4223860e624942309f4f-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8e9f1d8f56e4223860e624942309f4f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":179,"real_height_2x":358}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":{"id":18326,"data":{"text":"Rosneft","author":"Igor Sechin","category":"The Oilmen","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/73ee0283c9744e7da49f6f7b7e74ae7e-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/73ee0283c9744e7da49f6f7b7e74ae7e-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/73ee0283c9744e7da49f6f7b7e74ae7e-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/73ee0283c9744e7da49f6f7b7e74ae7e-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/73ee0283c9744e7da49f6f7b7e74ae7e-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/73ee0283c9744e7da49f6f7b7e74ae7e-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Igor Sechin</strong> (65 years old) is known in the media as “Darth Vader” for his tough management style.&nbsp;Since 2004, Sechin has headed Rosneft, turning it into the world’s largest oil company through a series of aggressive takeovers. He became the main ideologue of state capitalism.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Power support for Sechin is provided by the so-called “Sechin’s Spetsnaz” — the 6th service of the FSB’s Internal Security Directorate, which he helped form for the Yukos case.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Former head of the “Six,” Ivan Tkachev, now heads the Department of Military Counterintelligence of the FSB (DVKR), which gives Sechin unprecedented levers of influence over the army leadership.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18327,"data":{"text":"Novatek, Sibur, ex-Gunvor","author":"Gennady Timchenko","category":"The Oilmen","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14728148f66488e914f6ff2b0dca3ec-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14728148f66488e914f6ff2b0dca3ec-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14728148f66488e914f6ff2b0dca3ec-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14728148f66488e914f6ff2b0dca3ec-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14728148f66488e914f6ff2b0dca3ec-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b14728148f66488e914f6ff2b0dca3ec-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Gennady Timchenko</strong> (73 years old) is a heavyweight of the Putin elite.&nbsp;According to official statements by the US Treasury, Vladimir Putin personally had investments in Gunvor, which made Timchenko the actual manager of the president’s personal oil income.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After 2022, Timchenko’s role became critical for the regime’s survival under the oil embargo. His structures and former managers switched to managing the “shadow fleet” — numerous tankers with opaque ownership.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Timchenko acts as the architect of parallel export corridors.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18328,"data":{"text":"Department of Military Counterintelligence (DVKR) of the FSB","author":"Ivan Tkachev ","category":"The Oilmen","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0887a1afb4748a0b02a0b21bcad6222-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0887a1afb4748a0b02a0b21bcad6222-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0887a1afb4748a0b02a0b21bcad6222-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0887a1afb4748a0b02a0b21bcad6222-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0887a1afb4748a0b02a0b21bcad6222-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0887a1afb4748a0b02a0b21bcad6222-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Lieutenant General Ivan Tkachev</strong> (55 years old) led the 6th service of the FSB’s Internal Security Directorate, created with Sechin’s direct participation to purge the political and economic field of opponents. The “Six” gained a reputation as an “Oprichnina.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After UMB, Tkachev headed Department “K” of the FSB, and then moved to the post of head of the Department of Military Counterintelligence (DVKR) of the FSB.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"During full-scale war, the DVKR exercises direct oversight of the Ministry of Defense and monitors the distribution of giant defense budgets.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18330,"data":{"text":"Independent Oil and Gas Company (NNC)","author":"Eduard Khudaynatov ","category":"The Oilmen","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c066e90120d743f3a8ffcc42a7d857d2-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c066e90120d743f3a8ffcc42a7d857d2-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c066e90120d743f3a8ffcc42a7d857d2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c066e90120d743f3a8ffcc42a7d857d2-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c066e90120d743f3a8ffcc42a7d857d2-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c066e90120d743f3a8ffcc42a7d857d2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Eduard Khudaynatov</strong> (65 years old) is a key business partner of Igor Sechin, performing the role of “trusted person” for managing private assets.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2013, he formally left Rosneft to create his own private holding — the Independent Oil and Gas Company (NNC).&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"NNC became a unique tool in the architecture of Sechin’s clan, systematically buying up oil fields and refineries that are then integrated into general logistics chains with Rosneft. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"NNC is effectively a “private branch” of the state oil monopoly.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18332,"data":{"text":"Government of the RF","author":"Alexander Novak ","category":"The Oilmen","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/045bde816932447e829946371deed5a2-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/045bde816932447e829946371deed5a2-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/045bde816932447e829946371deed5a2-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/045bde816932447e829946371deed5a2-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/045bde816932447e829946371deed5a2-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/045bde816932447e829946371deed5a2-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Alexander Novak</strong> (54 years old) is a key technocrat in the management system of the Russian fuel and energy complex. Despite his “technocrat” status, Novak is deeply integrated into Igor Sechin’s orbit of interests. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Since 2015, he has been a member of the Board of Directors of Rosneft. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In May 2024, Putin re-confirmed him as Vice Prime Minister. Novak plays the role of Sechin’s “state interface,” legalizing Rosneft’s initiatives through government decrees and international agreements.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Rotors","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":{"id":18355,"data":{"images":[{"isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d24e14248ee498f8a7e42dee98583d1-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d24e14248ee498f8a7e42dee98583d1-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d24e14248ee498f8a7e42dee98583d1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1917,"real_width_2x":2781,"real_height_1x":828,"real_height_2x":1201},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d24e14248ee498f8a7e42dee98583d1-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d24e14248ee498f8a7e42dee98583d1-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d24e14248ee498f8a7e42dee98583d1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1917,"real_width_2x":2781,"real_height_1x":828,"real_height_2x":1201},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d24e14248ee498f8a7e42dee98583d1-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d24e14248ee498f8a7e42dee98583d1-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d24e14248ee498f8a7e42dee98583d1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":518,"real_height_2x":1036},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d24e14248ee498f8a7e42dee98583d1-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d24e14248ee498f8a7e42dee98583d1-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d24e14248ee498f8a7e42dee98583d1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":518,"real_height_2x":1036},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d24e14248ee498f8a7e42dee98583d1-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d24e14248ee498f8a7e42dee98583d1-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d24e14248ee498f8a7e42dee98583d1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":179,"real_height_2x":358},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d24e14248ee498f8a7e42dee98583d1-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d24e14248ee498f8a7e42dee98583d1-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d24e14248ee498f8a7e42dee98583d1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":179,"real_height_2x":358}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":{"id":18333,"data":{"text":"Mostotrest, SMP Bank, Sheremetyevo, Domodedovo","author":"Arkady Rotenberg","category":"The Rotors","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc60fa0e30f241fbb3137a15928b0a25-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc60fa0e30f241fbb3137a15928b0a25-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc60fa0e30f241fbb3137a15928b0a25-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc60fa0e30f241fbb3137a15928b0a25-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc60fa0e30f241fbb3137a15928b0a25-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc60fa0e30f241fbb3137a15928b0a25-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Arkady Rotenberg</strong> (74 years old) is a childhood friend of Putin.&nbsp;He built a giant construction empire specialized in the most ambitious state projects, the main symbol being the Crimean Bridge. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Rotenberg operates through private structures that depend entirely on budget funding.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After 2022, Arkady Rotenberg and his clan members became key beneficiaries of property redistribution and nationalization. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to the <em>Financial Times</em>, Rotenberg-linked company “Roskhim” has already acquired at least three Russian companies after they were nationalized.&nbsp;In 2020, Putin awarded him the title of Hero of Labour of the RF.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18334,"data":{"text":"Platon System, Gazprom Burenie","author":"Igor Rotenberg","category":"The Rotors","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0df0241e70e940ae8f8dc755848d4306-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0df0241e70e940ae8f8dc755848d4306-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0df0241e70e940ae8f8dc755848d4306-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0df0241e70e940ae8f8dc755848d4306-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0df0241e70e940ae8f8dc755848d4306-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0df0241e70e940ae8f8dc755848d4306-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Igor Rotenberg</strong> (52 years old) is the eldest son of Arkady Rotenberg.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"His main asset is a stake in RT-Invest Transport Systems, the operator of the Platon system, which collects fees from heavy trucks on federal highways. This project is a classic example of public-private partnership in the interest of a narrow circle of people.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Igor Rotenberg also controls Gazprom Burenie, Gazprom’s largest contractor. He manages “digital rent,” providing the family’s long-term financial stability.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18335,"data":{"text":"SMP Bank","author":"Boris Rotenberg","category":"The Rotors","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2405a744688b433486fbe64c183a781a-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2405a744688b433486fbe64c183a781a-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2405a744688b433486fbe64c183a781a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2405a744688b433486fbe64c183a781a-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2405a744688b433486fbe64c183a781a-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2405a744688b433486fbe64c183a781a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Boris Rotenberg</strong> (68 years old) is the younger brother of Arkady. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Boris was traditionally responsible for the financial block and the management of the family’s personal assets.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"He also acts as the main curator of sports projects, which are an important channel for informal communication with Putin.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After 2022, SMP Bank was integrated into Promsvyazbank (PSB), allowing family assets to be integrated into the system for servicing state defense orders.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18336,"data":{"text":"Russian Railways (RZD)","author":"Oleg Belozerov","category":"The Rotors","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a620b6d6f5d3484d9fe963f282cbb680-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a620b6d6f5d3484d9fe963f282cbb680-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a620b6d6f5d3484d9fe963f282cbb680-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a620b6d6f5d3484d9fe963f282cbb680-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a620b6d6f5d3484d9fe963f282cbb680-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a620b6d6f5d3484d9fe963f282cbb680-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Oleg Belozerov</strong> (56 years old) has headed RZD since 2015. His career is inextricably linked with St. Petersburg and the interests of the Rotenberg brothers.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Under his leadership, RZD became the main customer for Rotenberg construction holdings, including projects for the expansion of the Eastern Polygon (BAM and Transsib).&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Belozerov ensures the smooth operation of military transport logistics.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Military","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":{"id":18346,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83cb1b5b04d4450e874f247e8c96cb5a-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83cb1b5b04d4450e874f247e8c96cb5a-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83cb1b5b04d4450e874f247e8c96cb5a-original.png","real_width_1x":1917,"real_width_2x":2626,"real_height_1x":828,"real_height_2x":1134},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83cb1b5b04d4450e874f247e8c96cb5a-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83cb1b5b04d4450e874f247e8c96cb5a-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83cb1b5b04d4450e874f247e8c96cb5a-original.png","real_width_1x":1917,"real_width_2x":2626,"real_height_1x":828,"real_height_2x":1134},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83cb1b5b04d4450e874f247e8c96cb5a-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83cb1b5b04d4450e874f247e8c96cb5a-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83cb1b5b04d4450e874f247e8c96cb5a-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":518,"real_height_2x":1036},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83cb1b5b04d4450e874f247e8c96cb5a-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83cb1b5b04d4450e874f247e8c96cb5a-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83cb1b5b04d4450e874f247e8c96cb5a-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":518,"real_height_2x":1036},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83cb1b5b04d4450e874f247e8c96cb5a-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83cb1b5b04d4450e874f247e8c96cb5a-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83cb1b5b04d4450e874f247e8c96cb5a-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":179,"real_height_2x":358},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83cb1b5b04d4450e874f247e8c96cb5a-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83cb1b5b04d4450e874f247e8c96cb5a-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/83cb1b5b04d4450e874f247e8c96cb5a-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":179,"real_height_2x":358}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":{"id":18374,"data":{"text":"Ministry of Defense of the RF","author":"Andrey Belousov","category":"The Military","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1da44613754b4dd1b6dc438b438d63bf-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1da44613754b4dd1b6dc438b438d63bf-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1da44613754b4dd1b6dc438b438d63bf-original.png","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1da44613754b4dd1b6dc438b438d63bf-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1da44613754b4dd1b6dc438b438d63bf-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1da44613754b4dd1b6dc438b438d63bf-original.png","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Andrey Belousov</strong> (66 years old) was appointed Minister of Defense in May 2024. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"He is the main architect of the concept of “Military Keynesianism,” whereby huge military spending should become the engine for the entire Russian economy.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Belousov’s main task is to conduct a “total audit” and eradicate corruption schemes. He does not claim the role of commander but fully controls financial flows.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"He is an ideal tool for Putin to control the security block.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18337,"data":{"text":"General Staff","author":"Valery Gerasimov","category":"The Military","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8702f8ebc2d4133b8131d99a62499f2-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8702f8ebc2d4133b8131d99a62499f2-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8702f8ebc2d4133b8131d99a62499f2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8702f8ebc2d4133b8131d99a62499f2-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8702f8ebc2d4133b8131d99a62499f2-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f8702f8ebc2d4133b8131d99a62499f2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Valery Gerasimov</strong> (70 years old) has been Chief of the General Staff since 2012. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"He is one of three people in the country with access to the “nuclear briefcase.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Since January 2023, Gerasimov has personally led the Joint Group of Forces in the conflict with Ukraine.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"He remains the key link between the political leadership and the fighting army.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18338,"data":{"text":"GRU","author":"Igor Kostyukov","category":"The Military","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f41a3c668f8a41c7a6d65945b6e6fab7-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f41a3c668f8a41c7a6d65945b6e6fab7-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f41a3c668f8a41c7a6d65945b6e6fab7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f41a3c668f8a41c7a6d65945b6e6fab7-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f41a3c668f8a41c7a6d65945b6e6fab7-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f41a3c668f8a41c7a6d65945b6e6fab7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Admiral Igor Kostyukov</strong> (65 years old) has led military intelligence since 2018. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Under his leadership, the GRU turned into Russia’s main instrument for sabotage abroad.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2024–2026, the GRU became the main operator of “hybrid war,” including cyberattacks and sabotage at logistics hubs supplying aid to Ukraine.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In January 2026, he led the Russian delegation at talks in Abu Dhabi, highlighting his status as an influential political player.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Chekists","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":{"id":18356,"data":{"images":[{"isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4da7cb42ed254e7299fe0e62f17c8642-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4da7cb42ed254e7299fe0e62f17c8642-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4da7cb42ed254e7299fe0e62f17c8642-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2625,"real_height_1x":829,"real_height_2x":1134},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4da7cb42ed254e7299fe0e62f17c8642-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4da7cb42ed254e7299fe0e62f17c8642-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4da7cb42ed254e7299fe0e62f17c8642-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2625,"real_height_1x":829,"real_height_2x":1134},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4da7cb42ed254e7299fe0e62f17c8642-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4da7cb42ed254e7299fe0e62f17c8642-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4da7cb42ed254e7299fe0e62f17c8642-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2398,"real_height_1x":518,"real_height_2x":1036},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4da7cb42ed254e7299fe0e62f17c8642-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4da7cb42ed254e7299fe0e62f17c8642-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4da7cb42ed254e7299fe0e62f17c8642-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2398,"real_height_1x":518,"real_height_2x":1036},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4da7cb42ed254e7299fe0e62f17c8642-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4da7cb42ed254e7299fe0e62f17c8642-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4da7cb42ed254e7299fe0e62f17c8642-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":179,"real_height_2x":358},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4da7cb42ed254e7299fe0e62f17c8642-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4da7cb42ed254e7299fe0e62f17c8642-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/4da7cb42ed254e7299fe0e62f17c8642-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":179,"real_height_2x":358}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":{"id":18339,"data":{"text":"FSB","author":"Alexander Bortnikov","category":"The Chekists","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2ddb693a557b4f4c815724f7d7483266-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2ddb693a557b4f4c815724f7d7483266-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2ddb693a557b4f4c815724f7d7483266-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2ddb693a557b4f4c815724f7d7483266-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2ddb693a557b4f4c815724f7d7483266-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/2ddb693a557b4f4c815724f7d7483266-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Alexander Bortnikov</strong> (74 years old) has headed the FSB since May 2008. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"He acts as the main “guardian of the regime,” responsible for internal stability and fighting dissent.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After 2022, his influence became existential for the Kremlin. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Despite facing criticism for misjudging the situation in Ukraine at the onset of the invasion, Bortnikov retained his post and was reappointed as the service’s director in May 2024. His main task is to ensure total political sterility within the country.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, according to sources of <em>IStories</em>, Bortnikov is losing influence due to his health and spends more time in sanatoriums than at work.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18371,"data":{"text":"FSB","author":"Sergey Korolev","category":"The Chekists","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/082d2eb66a7945568eed36988c6dc158-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/082d2eb66a7945568eed36988c6dc158-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/082d2eb66a7945568eed36988c6dc158-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/082d2eb66a7945568eed36988c6dc158-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/082d2eb66a7945568eed36988c6dc158-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/082d2eb66a7945568eed36988c6dc158-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Sergey Korolev</strong> (63 years old) is the “Gray Cardinal” of the Lubyanka.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Despite a reputation for being close to leaders of the criminal world (helping Gennady Petrov and the hitman Aslan Gagiev), such connections are interpreted as “operational work” in the Putin regime.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Today, Korolev is the First Deputy Director of the FSB and effectively manages the day-to-day activities of the service due to Bortnikov’s health.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18341,"data":{"text":"Service for the Protection of the Constitutional Order and Combatting Terrorism (2nd service of the FSB)","author":"Alexey Sedov","category":"The Chekists","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9a0effd54e4341febbd1663430461d70-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9a0effd54e4341febbd1663430461d70-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9a0effd54e4341febbd1663430461d70-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9a0effd54e4341febbd1663430461d70-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9a0effd54e4341febbd1663430461d70-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9a0effd54e4341febbd1663430461d70-original.webp","real_width_1x":359,"real_width_2x":719,"real_height_1x":359,"real_height_2x":719}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>General Alexey Sedov</strong> (71 years old) has led the 2nd service since 2006, which human rights activists call the “political Gestapo.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This service oversees the fight against “extremism” and “internal threats,” which in practice translates to the persecution of opposition leaders, journalists, and activists.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The 2nd service of the FSB is responsible for the physical and legal elimination of political opponents:&nbsp;its employees were behind the poisoning of Alexei Navalny. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Sedov has the right of direct reports to Putin.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2026, Sedov remains the key architect of total political control.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18342,"data":{"text":"Assistant to the President","author":"Nikolai Patrushev","category":"The Chekists","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5ba6d85ba0c249ad9a4e35a26ac2ff7d-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5ba6d85ba0c249ad9a4e35a26ac2ff7d-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5ba6d85ba0c249ad9a4e35a26ac2ff7d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5ba6d85ba0c249ad9a4e35a26ac2ff7d-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5ba6d85ba0c249ad9a4e35a26ac2ff7d-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5ba6d85ba0c249ad9a4e35a26ac2ff7d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Nikolai Patrushev</strong> (74 years old) served as Secretary of the Security Council for 16 years (2008–2024), transforming the body into a “shadow government” that shaped an aggressive foreign policy and an anti-Western vision for the country’s development.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"His positions were shaken after <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/opinions/2023/06/27/nothing-but-wagner-all-around/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">the Yevgeny Prigozhin mutiny</a>.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In May 2024, he was moved to the more modest post of assistant to the president overseeing shipbuilding.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Nevertheless, he retains significant influence within the state security system through a network of his appointees, including Alexey Sedov.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Orthodox","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":{"id":18357,"data":{"images":[{"isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bb4f32bd64cc4f1aa519d41645a19386-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bb4f32bd64cc4f1aa519d41645a19386-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bb4f32bd64cc4f1aa519d41645a19386-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1917,"real_width_2x":2781,"real_height_1x":828,"real_height_2x":1201},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bb4f32bd64cc4f1aa519d41645a19386-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bb4f32bd64cc4f1aa519d41645a19386-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bb4f32bd64cc4f1aa519d41645a19386-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1917,"real_width_2x":2781,"real_height_1x":828,"real_height_2x":1201},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bb4f32bd64cc4f1aa519d41645a19386-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bb4f32bd64cc4f1aa519d41645a19386-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bb4f32bd64cc4f1aa519d41645a19386-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":518,"real_height_2x":1036},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bb4f32bd64cc4f1aa519d41645a19386-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bb4f32bd64cc4f1aa519d41645a19386-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bb4f32bd64cc4f1aa519d41645a19386-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":518,"real_height_2x":1036},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bb4f32bd64cc4f1aa519d41645a19386-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bb4f32bd64cc4f1aa519d41645a19386-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bb4f32bd64cc4f1aa519d41645a19386-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":179,"real_height_2x":358},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bb4f32bd64cc4f1aa519d41645a19386-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bb4f32bd64cc4f1aa519d41645a19386-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bb4f32bd64cc4f1aa519d41645a19386-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":179,"real_height_2x":358}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":{"id":18343,"data":{"text":"Tsargrad Media, private armed units","author":"Konstantin Malofeev","category":"The Orthodox","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3813b9ffb6546908492f68120452a75-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3813b9ffb6546908492f68120452a75-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3813b9ffb6546908492f68120452a75-original.webp","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3813b9ffb6546908492f68120452a75-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3813b9ffb6546908492f68120452a75-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d3813b9ffb6546908492f68120452a75-original.webp","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Konstantin Malofeev</strong> (51 years old) is known as the “Orthodox oligarch.” He was at the origin of the 2014 events in Donbas and Crimea.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After 2022, his significance grew due to the financing of numerous private armed units and volunteer battalions.&nbsp;Possessing his own mini-army, Malofeev could become a “jack-in-the-box” in the 2026 struggle for succession.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18344,"data":{"text":"Presidential Envoy to the Central Federal District","author":"Igor Shchegolev","category":"The Orthodox","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f20c753a34d24d28b4068dcfca8b440e-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f20c753a34d24d28b4068dcfca8b440e-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f20c753a34d24d28b4068dcfca8b440e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f20c753a34d24d28b4068dcfca8b440e-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f20c753a34d24d28b4068dcfca8b440e-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f20c753a34d24d28b4068dcfca8b440e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Igor Shchegolev</strong> (60 years old), the Presidential Envoy to the Central Federal District and former Minister of Communications, is a former intelligence officer of the KGB’s First Chief Directorate (PGU) who served under TASS cover. Shchegolev’s ties to Putin date back to 1999; he served as an advisor when Putin headed the government and ran the presidential protocol department in 2002.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2008, Shchegolev was appointed Minister of Communications. Between 2009 and 2010, a fund managed by his longtime friend, Konstantin Malofeev, acquired roughly a 10% stake in Rostelecom, Russia’s largest state-controlled telecommunications company. Malofeev later sold this stake back to Rostelecom in 2013 for more than 30 billion rubles. Russian media suspected that Malofeev may have been acting in Shchegolev’s interests.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18345,"data":{"text":"Crimean Diocese / Russian Orthodox Church","author":"Georgy Shevkunov (Tikhon)","category":"The Orthodox","imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/419d20c06e1e45d9886a7e8e5b03d923-autox360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/419d20c06e1e45d9886a7e8e5b03d923-autox360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/419d20c06e1e45d9886a7e8e5b03d923-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/419d20c06e1e45d9886a7e8e5b03d923-autox360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/419d20c06e1e45d9886a7e8e5b03d923-autox360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":"auto","for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/419d20c06e1e45d9886a7e8e5b03d923-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}]},"category":"text-with-photo-embed"},"type":"text-with-photo-embed"},{"data":"<strong>Georgy Shevkunov (Tikhon)</strong> (67 years old) is widely known as Vladimir Putin’s “confessor” and ranks among the most powerful figures within the Russian Orthodox Church. He grew close to Putin in the late 1990s when the latter headed the FSB. Putin reportedly visited the priest on his own initiative; Tikhon was then the abbot of the Sretensky Monastery, located just a couple of kilometers from the FSB headquarters on Lubyanka. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Shevkunov is a long-standing ideologue of Russia's confrontation with the West and a key pro-war propagandist who has exerted immense effort to shape state policy. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Sources acquainted with Malofeev and Shchegolev note that both are deeply connected to Tikhon. Despite the Metropolitan’s strained relations with the official church leadership, he is frequently tipped as a potential contender for the post of Russian Patriarch.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>Translation: </em><a href=\"https://correctiv.org/aktuelles/2026/05/19/the-mapping-of-power-russias-game-of-thrones/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"><em>CORRECTIV</em></a><em>, IStories</em>","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":9713,"header":"Never-ending Prison","_path":"/en/stories/2026/05/20/never-ending-prison/","lead":"After being released from prisons in Russia, Ukrainian citizens are indefinitely kept in practical captivity. IStories managed to talk to them","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f0f823537c5442cabdde87178fdf9f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Cover: IStories","created_at_date":"2026-05-20","created_at_date_time":"2026-05-19T15:30:35.947Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":23,"first_name":"Полина","last_name":"Ужвак","first_name_en":"Polina","last_name_en":"Uzhvak","is_public":true,"_path":"polina-uzhvak","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Автор дата-отдела","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":null,"ordering":1},{"id":58,"first_name":"Рина","last_name":"Николаева","first_name_en":"Rina","last_name_en":"Nikolaeva","is_public":true,"_path":"rina-nikolaeva","avatar":[],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":2}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[{"id":31,"first_name":"Катя","last_name":"Бонч-Осмоловская","first_name_en":"Katya","last_name_en":"Bonch-Osmolovskaya","is_public":true,"_path":"katya-bonch-osmolovskaya","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.jpeg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.jpeg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.jpeg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.jpeg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редакторка дата-отдела","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":null,"ordering":1}],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[{"id":3,"name":"Репрессии","slug":"repressii","image":[],"image_credit":"","description":[],"show_description_block":false,"ordering":0}],"body_preview":"About a thousand Ukrainian citizens who have served their sentences for criminal offenses in Russian prisons and were supposed to be released, ended up in detention centers for foreigners and even jail-type centers designed for offenders. The detention terms are constantly being extended for these Ukrainians. Men are pressured to sign military contracts and go to war against Ukraine. They are kept in prison-like conditions, without proper medical care and with no possibility to return home. IStories journalists have spoken to Ukrainians kept in Russian detention centers.\n\nThe names of the individuals have been changed at their request for security reasons.\n\n“The defendant may be deported after the military operation is completed.” Why Russia detains ex-prisoner Ukrainian citizens\nOlha's prison term ended in January 2026, but instead of being released, she was sent to a temporary detention center for foreign nationals in one of the regions of Central Russia. Olha came to Russia as a teenager and graduated from high school and college there, but kept her Ukrainian citizenship. On the verge of her release from prison, the Federal Penitentiary Service (FSIN) decided that her stay in Russia was “undesirable,” and the Ministry of Internal Affairs ruled to deport her. \n\nDeporting foreign nationals after their prison sentences is a common practice which had also been used in pre-war Russia, says Oleksii Ladukhin, a lawyer at Every Human Being. After the full-scale invasion began, direct deportations to Ukraine were halted. Because of this, Ukrainian citizens are spending months and years in detention centers. \n\nIStories has obtained a court ruling extending the detention of a Ukrainian citizen in one of such centers. Here is how Russian court justifies indefinitely detaining people in such conditions: “The circumstances preventing the deportation of the administrative defendant are temporary in nature; once the special military operation (an official euphemism used in Russia to describe the Russo-Ukrainian war — Ed.) is completed, the administrative defendant may be deported to their country of citizenship.” This essentially translates to indefinite detention.\n\nAccording to Ladukhin, before the war deportations used to take about two weeks; everything would depend on whether the person being deported had their valid documents and on the level of cooperation with the receiving country authorities. “Courts did not routinely and massively extend detention periods like they do now, because it was possible to file a complaint with the European Court of Human Rights over such practices,” says the lawyer. “In 2022, the situation changed dramatically. Neither we nor our colleagues from other organizations have had a single case where a court would reject a Ministry of Internal Affairs request to extend the detention of a Ukrainian citizen.”\n\nRussia is using the Ukrainians subject to deportation as bargaining chips. In May 2025, during a large-scale “1,000 for 1,000” prisoners of war exchange, 120 civilians returned to Ukraine. But among them there wasn't a single person of those abducted from the occupied territories. Instead, Russia sent back those Ukrainian citizens it was supposed to deport anyway: those who had served their sentences in Russian penal colonies and prisoners from Ukraine's Kherson oblast who had been taken to Russia in 2022.\nIn a conversation with IStories, Mykhailo Savva, a Ukrainian Center for Civil Liberties expert, described this practice as “blatant fraud on the part of Russia.”\n\nNot less than 1,000 Ukrainians are stuck in detention centers for foreign nationals across Russia, but the exact number is unknown, says Hanna Skrypka, a lawyer with the Protection for Prisoners of Ukraine NGO. The detainees are kept in various Russian regions, and in many cases there is no way of communication for them. The detainees IStories were able to speak with say that in the Sakharovo detention center (in Moscow Oblast — Ed.) alone there are about 300 to 400 detained Ukrainians. There are about 70 of them kept in the village of Voronino in Smolensk Oblast. As more people are released from penal colonies, the number of detainees is growing. \n\nOlha has been kept in the center for more than four months. According to her, some of the people there have had their detention term extended up to seven times. “No one is giving us any information. It’s agonizing. The people are burned out and desperate. We’re treated like subhumans. They say deportation is impossible and that I’ll be stuck here until the end of the ‘special military operation.’ It sends shivers down my spine,” she says. Oleksii Ladukhin says one of the people who reached out to him spent more than three years at the foreigners detention center.\n“I’ll die here without treatment”. The detention conditions\n\nThe centers where the Ukrainians are kept are designed for short-term detention only. The conditions there are no better than in penal colonies — and sometimes even worse. The food supply and the access to personal hygiene and medical care are highly problematic issues there. \n\nIn one of the regions of the North Caucasus, there are no vacant places in the foreign nationals detention center, so the Ukrainians awaiting deportation have been sent to a jail-type facility (а “detention center for people under administrative arrest” — Ed.). “It’s a regular jail with the bare minimum of amenities. No outdoor time, no medical facilities — nothing at all. No beds, just bunks. A cell for four people. Unsafe and unsanitary conditions. No soap, no toothbrushes, no hygiene products. No doctors. The food supply is terrible. They installed a shower in April; before that, we had to wash ourselves in a basin,” describes Mykola, one of the detainees.\nAccording to Mykola, he had a blood pressure spike in winter; an ambulance was called, and the nurse administered his shot carelessly, which caused an abscess. The man had to be taken to the surgery room by ambulance again. He was soon discharged, even though the wound had not yet healed (the photos are at the disposal of the editorial staff). “They said that they wouldn’t give me any medication because I have no state health insurance. I offered to buy the medicines with my own money, but they kicked me out of the ward anyway. The wound is still bleeding,” the man says. The inmates at the facility are not provided with medical care although some of them suffer health issues including stomach ulcers, gastritis, and hypertension.\n\nAnother person IStories spoke with, Yaroslav, describes similar conditions at another detention center in one of Russia’s central regions. Yaroslav was released from a Russian prison in 2025 and has been held at the detention center for five months now; his cellmates have been there for over a year. The center is overcrowded.\n\n“No one knows what to do with us; there is no more space,” says Yaroslav. “The police bring in new people. They are sent away. ‘Take them wherever you want,’ they say.” \n\nThere are six Ukrainians in Yaroslav’s cell. Just one shower for 30 people. The inmates are only allowed to be outside (in a small courtyard with high walls and a metal grate overhead) for an hour a day and are allowed to use the phone for just an hour a day, too. “We’re just stuck in here, locked up” Yaroslav continues. – “We're asking them to maybe let us shovel snow in the winter, just to move around and stretch our legs.’ But no, they tell us we have no right to work.”\nYaroslav is HIV-positive and needs to take medication every day, but the police won't provide it: “I’m fighting [to be deported to Ukraine] because I feel trapped. Without treatment I’ll die here.” \n\n“Locked up for no reason and waiting for hell knows what.” How indefinite detention works\n\nOnce in three months, the Ukrainians are taken to a court that extends their detention at the request of the Ministry of Internal Affairs. “We have a lawyer; he explains it all [why detention cannot be extended indefinitely] clearly, the judge agrees with him, leaves, comes back, and still orders the detention to be extended for another three months,” Serhii, one of our interviewees, describes the typical procedure. \n\nOleksii Ladukhin explains that appeals do nothing to speed up the deportation process: “According to the Russian prosecutor’s office and the superior courts, if the number of possible detention extensions is not specified in the legislation, there's no limit. And so there are no violations.” \n\nBack in 2025, Serhii was to be deported to Ukraine via Georgia, but Georgian border guards did not let him pass because his passport had expired. The Russian Ministry of Internal Affairs left him in a jail-type detention center in one of the North Caucasus regions, as there were no spots available at the local detention center. He has been there for a whole year since his release from prison. \n\nIn his case, the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the courts are at least trying to follow the formalities. Some detainees are even less lucky. Andriy, another Ukrainian currently kept at a foreigners detention center, told IStories that the order to place him there had expired back in August 2025: \"I appealed to the administration, explaining that I have been kept here unlawfully. For me to stay here, there should be a court order with a specific term. They don’t understand. I have filed a lawsuit with the court. No response. Another lawsuit with the prosecutor’s office. No response. I called them. A prosecutor came here in the fall of 2025 and said they would look into it. They’re still looking into it.” \nThe European Court of Human Rights has ruled that keeping people in detention centers for foreign citizens long-term constitutes a violation of Article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which prohibits unlawful confinement, Oleksii Ladukhin explains. “Detention is permissible when they are actually carrying out the deportation, when the authorities are taking active and good-faith steps to implement it: transferring documents, coordinating the location and time of deportation and conducting negotiations. If the process has stalled, a person cannot be detained indefinitely. This is a severe violation of their rights,” he says. \n\n“It’s very hard: being locked up for no reason and waiting for hell knows what,” Serhii confides. “My family in Ukraine is having problems; I don’t know if I’ll ever see them again. It’s very difficult mentally. The prison walls are suffocating, and the whole situation is overwhelming.\n\n“When they are fed up, they’ll sign up as cannon fodder.” War recruitment at the detention centers\n\nAll of our interviewees note that the former prisoners — and primarily those who had lived in the now-occupied territories of Ukraine before coming to Russia — are being recruited to fight against their own country. “We’re hearing that the general idea is 'let's keep them locked up, and when they are fed up, they’ll sign up for the ‘special military operation’ as cannon fodder,” says Yaroslav, who has been kept at the detention center for six months since his official release. \n\nAt a detention center in one of the regions in Central Russia there are people who have been expecting deportation for over a year and a half, two Ukrainians told IStories. According to them, the only way to get out that was offered to those detainees was to sign a military contract with the Ministry of Defense and go to war against Ukraine. \nAndriy, our interviewee kept in the Caucasian jail-type detention center, confirms: “There are instructions from above to offer [the military contracts]. Right now, the guys are just losing their minds from the hopelessness and from no way out in sight, and they’re even ready to sign the contracts. But in the jail-type detention center, they aren’t even given that opportunity. In [another region], people have been taken away to fight in the ‘special military operation’; a couple of people left when I was there\". \n\nNot all the Ukrainians interviewed by IStories want to return home. Many men are sure that upon their return they will be forcibly mobilized without being allowed to see their families. Those who do not want to return to Ukraine are either trying to seek asylum in Russia, are applying for Russian passports, or looking for opportunities to leave via a third country at a family invitation or for work, but all they get is detention extensions.\n\n“He wasn’t even ill before, but now he’s disabled.” Fate of those stranded at the Russian-Georgian border\nMen who do not want to return to Ukraine are citing the consequences of the August 2025 mass return, when Ukraine organized the evacuation of its citizens who had been stranded in a basement on the Russian-Georgian border through Moldova. \nA few days later, reports emerged that those who had returned were sent to TCRs (territorial recruitment centers, a Ukrainian name for military enlistment offices — Ed.) after a three-day quarantine. Those deemed fit for service were mobilized. Hanna Skrypka (Protection for Prisoners of Ukraine) confirmed IStories that 40 of the 65 returnees had been mobilized.  \n\nProtection for Prisoners of Ukraine published an open letter calling on the Ministry of Defense and the Security Service of Ukraine, as well as other Ukrainian government agencies, to consider changing the return procedures. For example, they requested to allow people to see their families and receive medical and psychological assistance upon returning. According to Skrypka, they have not received any reaction to this letter. \n\nCurrently, 19 of those who refused to return to Ukraine in August 2025 are remaining in the border gray zone. They are still living in a windowless basement and are entirely dependent on charities that occasionally bring them food and humanitarian aid.\n“It’s a concrete room with no ventilation. We can’t predict when the next food supply will arrive, so we constantly have to save food. There have been times when we spent a whole week with no food,” says Oleksii, a Ukrainian citizen who has been living in the basement for nearly a year. \n\nThe Georgian Red Cross branch told the Ukrainians that the aid program for them had ended. The branch’s deputy secretary-general, Kakha Mamuladze, confirmed IStories that the program had been shut down back in December because international donors had stopped funding it. The Tbilisi Volunteers organization, which supports Ukrainians in Georgia, cannot operate fully due to Georgia’s newly introduced “foreign agents” law and is forced to find workarounds to continue helping those stranded at the border, said Maria, its head.\n\nThe most serious problem is the lack of medical care. One man became disabled while stuck at the border. He had an eye infection, and his fellow basement dwellers tried to call an ambulance. They had reached out to the Ukrainian consulate, but no help arrived for several weeks. “By the time we managed to get him to the hospital, all that the doctors could do was remove his eye. He wasn’t even ill before, but now he’s disabled. What kind of medical care is this? We don’t even have painkillers for headaches and toothaches, not to mention those of us who need a more serious treatment or medications,” Oleksii says. \nAmong those in the basement there are people with hepatitis and HIV. They need daily treatment, but it’s very difficult to access. “Antiretroviral therapy medication isn’t available over the counter, and the Georgian HIV care center can’t give medications out to unregistered and untested patients. But they can’t get tested at the border. We’ve managed to find a way to deliver the medications several times and we hope we’ll be able to do it again soon,” says Maria from Tbilisi Volunteers. \n\nIn November 2025, Andriy Bilyk, a representative of the Ukrainian Embassy in Georgia, visited the Ukrainians remaining in the basement. He explained that technically the consulate could issue the new passports for them, but this would require approval from the Ukrainian Ministry of Justice as well as the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Security Service of Ukraine (a recording of the meeting is at IStories’ disposal). A month later, the embassy sent the approval document to the basement, but by that moment the Security Service of Ukraine had not issued passports to any of those citizens.\n\nPavlo has remained in the basement for almost a year. He says he is already losing hope of ever getting his passport and leaving. “They constantly throw something at us to keep us from bothering them. Two or three weeks go by, and we start calling and writing to them again. I wonder if I’ve got 50 kilos of weight left. I feel terrible. There’s no air here; we’re just suffocating. The only thing left to do is to shoot myself — I don’t know what other way out there is.” \n\nIStories have sent inquiries to the Russian Ministry of Internal Affairs, the Office of the Human Rights Commissioner of Russia, and the Presidential Council on Human Rights asking what steps the Russian authorities are taking to end the indefinite detention of Ukrainian citizens. We have not received any responses from these entities. The Office of the Ukrainian Parliament Commissioner for Human Rights and the Ukrainian Embassy in Georgia also have not responded to our inquiries as of the moment of publication.","blocks":[{"data":"About a thousand Ukrainian citizens who have served their sentences for criminal offenses in Russian prisons and were supposed to be released, ended up in detention centers for foreigners and even jail-type centers designed for offenders. The detention terms are constantly being extended for these Ukrainians. Men are pressured to sign military contracts and go to war against Ukraine. They are kept in prison-like conditions, without proper medical care and with no possibility to return home. IStories journalists have spoken to Ukrainians kept in Russian detention centers.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>The names of the individuals have been changed at their request for security reasons.</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“The defendant may be deported after the military operation is completed.” Why Russia detains ex-prisoner Ukrainian citizens","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Olha's prison term ended in January 2026, but instead of being released, she was sent to a temporary detention center for foreign nationals in one of the regions of Central Russia. Olha came to Russia as a teenager and graduated from high school and college there, but kept her Ukrainian citizenship. On the verge of her release from prison, the Federal Penitentiary Service (FSIN) decided that her stay in Russia was “undesirable,” and the Ministry of Internal Affairs ruled to deport her.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Deporting foreign nationals after their prison sentences is a common practice which had also been used in pre-war Russia, says Oleksii Ladukhin, a lawyer at Every Human Being. After the full-scale invasion began, direct deportations to Ukraine were halted. Because of this, Ukrainian citizens are spending months and years in detention centers.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories has obtained a court ruling extending the detention of a Ukrainian citizen in one of such centers. Here is how Russian court justifies indefinitely detaining people in such conditions: “The circumstances preventing the deportation of the administrative defendant are temporary in nature; once the special military operation (an official euphemism used in Russia to describe the Russo-Ukrainian war — Ed.) is completed, the administrative defendant may be deported to their country of citizenship.” This essentially translates to indefinite detention.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to Ladukhin, before the war deportations used to take about two weeks; everything would depend on whether the person being deported had their valid documents and on the level of cooperation with the receiving country authorities. “Courts did not routinely and massively extend detention periods like they do now, because it was possible to file a complaint with the European Court of Human Rights over such practices,” says the lawyer. “In 2022, the situation changed dramatically. Neither we nor our colleagues from other organizations have had a single case where a court would reject a Ministry of Internal Affairs request to extend the detention of a Ukrainian citizen.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russia is using the Ukrainians subject to deportation as bargaining chips. In May 2025, during a large-scale “1,000 for 1,000” prisoners of war exchange, 120 civilians returned to Ukraine. But among them there wasn't a single person of those abducted from the occupied territories. Instead, Russia sent back those Ukrainian citizens it was supposed to deport anyway: those who had served their sentences in Russian penal colonies and prisoners from Ukraine's Kherson oblast who had been taken to Russia in 2022.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18233,"data":{"text":"a Ukrainian citizen detained in Russia after her release from prison ","author":"Olha","header":"No one is giving us any information. It’s agonizing. The people are burned out and desperate. We’re treated like subhumans. They say deportation is impossible and that I’ll be stuck here until the end of the “special military operation.” It sends shivers down my spine"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"In a conversation with IStories, Mykhailo Savva, a Ukrainian Center for Civil Liberties expert, described this practice as “blatant fraud on the part of Russia.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Not less than 1,000 Ukrainians are stuck in detention centers for foreign nationals across Russia, but the exact number is unknown, says Hanna Skrypka, a lawyer with the Protection for Prisoners of Ukraine NGO. The detainees are kept in various Russian regions, and in many cases there is no way of communication for them. The detainees IStories were able to speak with say that in the Sakharovo detention center (in Moscow Oblast — Ed.) alone there are about 300 to 400 detained Ukrainians. There are about 70 of them kept in the village of Voronino in Smolensk Oblast. As more people are released from penal colonies, the number of detainees is growing.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Olha has been kept in the center for more than four months. According to her, some of the people there have had their detention term extended up to seven times. “No one is giving us any information. It’s agonizing. The people are burned out and desperate. We’re treated like subhumans. They say deportation is impossible and that I’ll be stuck here until the end of the ‘special military operation.’ It sends shivers down my spine,” she says. Oleksii Ladukhin says one of the people who reached out to him spent more than three years at the foreigners detention center.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18236,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"","caption":"A courtyard for outdoor recreation at one of the temporary detention centers for foreign nationals in Central Russia","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7296c9ebc1941538e68e2fdafadd15f-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7296c9ebc1941538e68e2fdafadd15f-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7296c9ebc1941538e68e2fdafadd15f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2117,"real_height_1x":893,"real_height_2x":986},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7296c9ebc1941538e68e2fdafadd15f-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7296c9ebc1941538e68e2fdafadd15f-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7296c9ebc1941538e68e2fdafadd15f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2117,"real_height_1x":893,"real_height_2x":986},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7296c9ebc1941538e68e2fdafadd15f-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7296c9ebc1941538e68e2fdafadd15f-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7296c9ebc1941538e68e2fdafadd15f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2117,"real_height_1x":558,"real_height_2x":986},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7296c9ebc1941538e68e2fdafadd15f-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7296c9ebc1941538e68e2fdafadd15f-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7296c9ebc1941538e68e2fdafadd15f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2117,"real_height_1x":558,"real_height_2x":986},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7296c9ebc1941538e68e2fdafadd15f-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7296c9ebc1941538e68e2fdafadd15f-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7296c9ebc1941538e68e2fdafadd15f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":193,"real_height_2x":386},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7296c9ebc1941538e68e2fdafadd15f-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7296c9ebc1941538e68e2fdafadd15f-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e7296c9ebc1941538e68e2fdafadd15f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":193,"real_height_2x":386}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"“I’ll die here without treatment”. The detention conditions","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The centers where the Ukrainians are kept are designed for short-term detention only. The conditions there are no better than in penal colonies — and sometimes even worse. The food supply and the access to personal hygiene and medical care are highly problematic issues there.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In one of the regions of the North Caucasus, there are no vacant places in the foreign nationals detention center, so the Ukrainians awaiting deportation have been sent to a jail-type facility (а “detention center for people under administrative arrest” — Ed.). “It’s a regular jail with the bare minimum of amenities. No outdoor time, no medical facilities — nothing at all. No beds, just bunks. A cell for four people. Unsafe and unsanitary conditions. No soap, no toothbrushes, no hygiene products. No doctors. The food supply is terrible. They installed a shower in April; before that, we had to wash ourselves in a basin,” describes Mykola, one of the detainees.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18237,"data":{"images":[{"caption":"Detention conditions at one of the centers (North Caucasus)","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61b619ed01c747feb9ee3be849808e94-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61b619ed01c747feb9ee3be849808e94-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61b619ed01c747feb9ee3be849808e94-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61b619ed01c747feb9ee3be849808e94-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61b619ed01c747feb9ee3be849808e94-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61b619ed01c747feb9ee3be849808e94-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61b619ed01c747feb9ee3be849808e94-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61b619ed01c747feb9ee3be849808e94-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61b619ed01c747feb9ee3be849808e94-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61b619ed01c747feb9ee3be849808e94-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61b619ed01c747feb9ee3be849808e94-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61b619ed01c747feb9ee3be849808e94-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61b619ed01c747feb9ee3be849808e94-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61b619ed01c747feb9ee3be849808e94-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61b619ed01c747feb9ee3be849808e94-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61b619ed01c747feb9ee3be849808e94-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61b619ed01c747feb9ee3be849808e94-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61b619ed01c747feb9ee3be849808e94-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"According to Mykola, he had a blood pressure spike in winter; an ambulance was called, and the nurse administered his shot carelessly, which caused an abscess. The man had to be taken to the surgery room by ambulance again. He was soon discharged, even though the wound had not yet healed (the photos are at the disposal of the editorial staff). “They said that they wouldn’t give me any medication because I have no state health insurance. I offered to buy the medicines with my own money, but they kicked me out of the ward anyway. The wound is still bleeding,” the man says. The inmates at the facility are not provided with medical care although some of them suffer health issues including stomach ulcers, gastritis, and hypertension.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Another person IStories spoke with, Yaroslav, describes similar conditions at another detention center in one of Russia’s central regions. Yaroslav was released from a Russian prison in 2025 and has been held at the detention center for five months now; his cellmates have been there for over a year. The center is overcrowded.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“No one knows what to do with us; there is no more space,” says Yaroslav. “The police bring in new people. They are sent away. ‘Take them wherever you want,’ they say.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There are six Ukrainians in Yaroslav’s cell. Just one shower for 30 people. The inmates are only allowed to be outside (in a small courtyard with high walls and a metal grate overhead) for an hour a day and are allowed to use the phone for just an hour a day, too. “We’re just stuck in here, locked up” Yaroslav continues. – “We're asking them to maybe let us shovel snow in the winter, just to move around and stretch our legs.’ But no, they tell us we have no right to work.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18238,"data":{"images":[{"caption":"Detention conditions at one of the centers (Central Russia)","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5613579eb32f45c2b1d6c604e3ab35b4-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5613579eb32f45c2b1d6c604e3ab35b4-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5613579eb32f45c2b1d6c604e3ab35b4-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5613579eb32f45c2b1d6c604e3ab35b4-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5613579eb32f45c2b1d6c604e3ab35b4-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5613579eb32f45c2b1d6c604e3ab35b4-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5613579eb32f45c2b1d6c604e3ab35b4-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5613579eb32f45c2b1d6c604e3ab35b4-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5613579eb32f45c2b1d6c604e3ab35b4-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5613579eb32f45c2b1d6c604e3ab35b4-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5613579eb32f45c2b1d6c604e3ab35b4-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5613579eb32f45c2b1d6c604e3ab35b4-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5613579eb32f45c2b1d6c604e3ab35b4-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5613579eb32f45c2b1d6c604e3ab35b4-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5613579eb32f45c2b1d6c604e3ab35b4-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5613579eb32f45c2b1d6c604e3ab35b4-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5613579eb32f45c2b1d6c604e3ab35b4-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5613579eb32f45c2b1d6c604e3ab35b4-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Yaroslav is HIV-positive and needs to take medication every day, but the police won't provide it: “I’m fighting [to be deported to Ukraine] because I feel trapped. Without treatment I’ll die here.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Locked up for no reason and waiting for hell knows what.” How indefinite detention works","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Once in three months, the Ukrainians are taken to a court that extends their detention at the request of the Ministry of Internal Affairs. “We have a lawyer; he explains it all [why detention cannot be extended indefinitely] clearly, the judge agrees with him, leaves, comes back, and still orders the detention to be extended for another three months,” Serhii, one of our interviewees, describes the typical procedure.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Oleksii Ladukhin explains that appeals do nothing to speed up the deportation process: “According to the Russian prosecutor’s office and the superior courts, if the number of possible detention extensions is not specified in the legislation, there's no limit. And so there are no violations.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Back in 2025, Serhii was to be deported to Ukraine via Georgia, but Georgian border guards did not let him pass because his passport had expired. The Russian Ministry of Internal Affairs left him in a jail-type detention center in one of the North Caucasus regions, as there were no spots available at the local detention center. He has been there for a whole year since his release from prison.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In his case, the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the courts are at least trying to follow the formalities. Some detainees are even less lucky. Andriy, another Ukrainian currently kept at a foreigners detention center, told IStories that the order to place him there had expired back in August 2025: \"I appealed to the administration, explaining that I have been kept here unlawfully. For me to stay here, there should be a court order with a specific term. They don’t understand. I have filed a lawsuit with the court. No response. Another lawsuit with the prosecutor’s office. No response. I called them. A prosecutor came here in the fall of 2025 and said they would look into it. They’re still looking into it.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18239,"data":{"images":[{"caption":"In response to the appeals, the Russian Ministry of Internal Affairs cites the impossibility of enforcing deportation orders","isNarrow":true,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ba2e46cb380e4de6ad53afdfad4d34c8-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ba2e46cb380e4de6ad53afdfad4d34c8-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ba2e46cb380e4de6ad53afdfad4d34c8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":810,"real_width_2x":810,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1080},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ba2e46cb380e4de6ad53afdfad4d34c8-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ba2e46cb380e4de6ad53afdfad4d34c8-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ba2e46cb380e4de6ad53afdfad4d34c8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":810,"real_width_2x":810,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1080},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ba2e46cb380e4de6ad53afdfad4d34c8-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ba2e46cb380e4de6ad53afdfad4d34c8-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ba2e46cb380e4de6ad53afdfad4d34c8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":810,"real_width_2x":810,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1080},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ba2e46cb380e4de6ad53afdfad4d34c8-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ba2e46cb380e4de6ad53afdfad4d34c8-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ba2e46cb380e4de6ad53afdfad4d34c8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":810,"real_width_2x":810,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1080},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ba2e46cb380e4de6ad53afdfad4d34c8-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ba2e46cb380e4de6ad53afdfad4d34c8-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ba2e46cb380e4de6ad53afdfad4d34c8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":809,"real_height_1x":553,"real_height_2x":1079},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ba2e46cb380e4de6ad53afdfad4d34c8-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ba2e46cb380e4de6ad53afdfad4d34c8-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ba2e46cb380e4de6ad53afdfad4d34c8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":809,"real_height_1x":553,"real_height_2x":1079}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The European Court of Human Rights has ruled that keeping people in detention centers for foreign citizens long-term constitutes a violation of<a href=\"https://www.echr.coe.int/documents/d/echr/convention_eng\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"> Article 5</a> of the European Convention on Human Rights, which prohibits unlawful confinement, Oleksii Ladukhin explains. “Detention is permissible when they are actually carrying out the deportation, when the authorities are taking active and good-faith steps to implement it: transferring documents, coordinating the location and time of deportation and conducting negotiations. If the process has stalled, a person cannot be detained indefinitely. This is a severe violation of their rights,” he says.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“It’s very hard: being locked up for no reason and waiting for hell knows what,” Serhii confides. “My family in Ukraine is having problems; I don’t know if I’ll ever see them again. It’s very difficult mentally. The prison walls are suffocating, and the whole situation is overwhelming.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“When they are fed up, they’ll sign up as cannon fodder.” War recruitment at the detention centers","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"All of our interviewees note that the former prisoners — and primarily those who had lived in the now-occupied territories of Ukraine before coming to Russia — are being recruited to fight against their own country. “We’re hearing that the general idea is 'let's keep them locked up, and when they are fed up, they’ll sign up for the ‘special military operation’ as cannon fodder,” says Yaroslav, who has been kept at the detention center for six months since his official release.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At a detention center in one of the regions in Central Russia there are people who have been expecting deportation for over a year and a half, two Ukrainians told IStories. According to them, the only way to get out that was offered to those detainees was to sign a military contract with the Ministry of Defense and go to war against Ukraine.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18234,"data":{"text":"Ex-prisoner Ukrainian citizen","author":"Andriy","header":"The guys are just losing their minds from the hopelessness and from no way out in sight, and they’re even ready to sign the military contracts."},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"Andriy, our interviewee kept in the Caucasian jail-type detention center, confirms: “There are instructions from above to offer [the military contracts]. Right now, the guys are just losing their minds from the hopelessness and from no way out in sight, and they’re even ready to sign the contracts. But in the jail-type detention center, they aren’t even given that opportunity. In [another region], people have been taken away to fight in the ‘special military operation’; a couple of people left when I was there\".&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Not all the Ukrainians interviewed by IStories want to return home. Many men are sure that upon their return they will be forcibly mobilized without being allowed to see their families. Those who do not want to return to Ukraine are either trying to seek asylum in Russia, are applying for Russian passports, or looking for opportunities to leave via a third country at a family invitation or for work, but all they get is detention extensions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“He wasn’t even ill before, but now he’s disabled.” Fate of those stranded at the Russian-Georgian border","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Men who do not want to return to Ukraine are citing the consequences of the August 2025 mass return, when Ukraine <a href=\"https://istories.media/news/2025/08/22/ukraine-udalos-vernut-65-grazhdan-zastryavshikh-na-verkhnem-larse-posle-deportatsii-iz-rossii/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">organized </a>the evacuation of its citizens who had been stranded in a basement on the Russian-Georgian border through Moldova.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18232,"data":{"block":"<p>Russian authorities <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2025/05/23/deportation-from-the-occupation/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">have been using</a> the Verkhniy Lars–Daryali border crossing to deport Ukrainians since at least 2023. They use it to deport those who have served their sentences in Russia and have been released, as well as those occupied regions <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2025/05/23/deportation-from-the-occupation/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">residents</a> who, for whatever reason, happen to be seen as “undesirable.” </p><p><br/></p><p>Initially, Georgia would <a href=\"https://novayagazeta.eu/articles/2025/07/17/desiatki-ukraintsev-vydvorennykh-iz-rossii-popali-v-lovushku-na-granitse-s-gruziei\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">let</a> some of the deported Ukrainians in, but later the authorities started to only allow them to transit through to Moldova. Moreover, in July 2025, Moldova stopped admitting deportees with no valid passports.</p><p><br/></p><p>As a result, about a hundred people were stranded in a basement at the border between Russia and Georgia. To draw attention to their cause, they started <a href=\"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/news/2025/07/21/chto-vazhno-znat-segodnya-vechernii-daidzhest-vazhnikh-istorii/index.html?_gl=1*13cuqt*_ga*MTY5NDA0MzQ4LjE3NzEzMjA3OTk.*_ga_86829926PE*czE3NzkzNTczNzgkbzQ4JGcxJHQxNzc5MzU3NDYwJGozOCRsMCRoMA..\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">protesting</a> and went on a hunger <a href=\"https://novayagazeta.eu/articles/2025/08/06/zastriavshie-v-bufernoi-zone-gruzii-ukraintsy-peredali-tamozhennoi-sluzhbe-zaiavlenie-o-nachale-golodovki-news\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">strike</a>. </p><p><br/></p><p>Ultimately, Ukraine was able to arrange evacuation for most of the people. 65 Ukrainians returned home, while another 22 refused to.</p>","header":"The summer of 2025 humanitarian crisis at the Russian-Georgian border","content":[{"insert":"Russian authorities "},{"insert":"have been using","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://istories.media/en/stories/2025/05/23/deportation-from-the-occupation/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" the Verkhniy Lars–Daryali border crossing to deport Ukrainians since at least 2023. They use it to deport those who have served their sentences in Russia and have been released, as well as those occupied regions "},{"insert":"residents","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://istories.media/en/stories/2025/05/23/deportation-from-the-occupation/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" who, for whatever reason, happen to be seen as “undesirable.” \n\nInitially, Georgia would "},{"insert":"let","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://novayagazeta.eu/articles/2025/07/17/desiatki-ukraintsev-vydvorennykh-iz-rossii-popali-v-lovushku-na-granitse-s-gruziei","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" some of the deported Ukrainians in, but later the authorities started to only allow them to transit through to Moldova. Moreover, in July 2025, Moldova stopped admitting deportees with no valid passports.\n\nAs a result, about a hundred people were stranded in a basement at the border between Russia and Georgia. To draw attention to their cause, they started "},{"insert":"protesting","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://storage.googleapis.com/istories/news/2025/07/21/chto-vazhno-znat-segodnya-vechernii-daidzhest-vazhnikh-istorii/index.html?_gl=1*13cuqt*_ga*MTY5NDA0MzQ4LjE3NzEzMjA3OTk.*_ga_86829926PE*czE3NzkzNTczNzgkbzQ4JGcxJHQxNzc5MzU3NDYwJGozOCRsMCRoMA..","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" and went on a hunger "},{"insert":"strike","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://novayagazeta.eu/articles/2025/08/06/zastriavshie-v-bufernoi-zone-gruzii-ukraintsy-peredali-tamozhennoi-sluzhbe-zaiavlenie-o-nachale-golodovki-news","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":". \n\nUltimately, Ukraine was able to arrange evacuation for most of the people. 65 Ukrainians returned home, while another 22 refused to.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"A few days later, reports <a href=\"https://www.ekhokavkaza.com/a/ukrayintsi-hruziya-deportatsiya-mobilizatsiya/33514356.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">emerged</a> that those who had returned were sent to TCRs (territorial recruitment centers, a Ukrainian name for military enlistment offices — Ed.) after a three-day quarantine. Those deemed fit for service were mobilized. Hanna Skrypka (Protection for Prisoners of Ukraine) confirmed IStories that 40 of the 65 returnees had been mobilized.&nbsp;&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Protection for Prisoners of Ukraine published an open <a href=\"https://www.facebook.com/ngoauu/posts/pfbid02kWQWbML5fJYYrnMHUVxPoP7c2XLDMa6NdGcLxrEQNeTxoDE5KuAcGYN5UUe5nnywl\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">letter</a> calling on the Ministry of Defense and the Security Service of Ukraine, as well as other Ukrainian government agencies, to consider changing the return procedures. For example, they requested to allow people to see their families and receive medical and psychological assistance upon returning. According to Skrypka, they have not received any reaction to this letter.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Currently, 19 of those who refused to return to Ukraine in August 2025 are remaining in the border gray zone. They are still living in a windowless basement and are entirely dependent on charities that occasionally bring them food and humanitarian aid.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18240,"data":{"images":[{"caption":"The conditions in the basement at the Russian-Georgian border ","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cda3cb54d1494ccbbe6c137cd69dc57d-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cda3cb54d1494ccbbe6c137cd69dc57d-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cda3cb54d1494ccbbe6c137cd69dc57d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cda3cb54d1494ccbbe6c137cd69dc57d-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cda3cb54d1494ccbbe6c137cd69dc57d-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cda3cb54d1494ccbbe6c137cd69dc57d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cda3cb54d1494ccbbe6c137cd69dc57d-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cda3cb54d1494ccbbe6c137cd69dc57d-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cda3cb54d1494ccbbe6c137cd69dc57d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cda3cb54d1494ccbbe6c137cd69dc57d-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cda3cb54d1494ccbbe6c137cd69dc57d-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cda3cb54d1494ccbbe6c137cd69dc57d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cda3cb54d1494ccbbe6c137cd69dc57d-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cda3cb54d1494ccbbe6c137cd69dc57d-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cda3cb54d1494ccbbe6c137cd69dc57d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cda3cb54d1494ccbbe6c137cd69dc57d-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cda3cb54d1494ccbbe6c137cd69dc57d-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cda3cb54d1494ccbbe6c137cd69dc57d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"“It’s a concrete room with no ventilation. We can’t predict when the next food supply will arrive, so we constantly have to save food. There have been times when we spent a whole week with no food,” says Oleksii, a Ukrainian citizen who has been living in the basement for nearly a year.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Georgian Red Cross branch told the Ukrainians that the aid program for them had ended. The branch’s deputy secretary-general, Kakha Mamuladze, confirmed IStories that the program had been shut down back in December because international donors had stopped funding it. The Tbilisi Volunteers organization, which supports Ukrainians in Georgia, cannot operate fully due to Georgia’s newly introduced “foreign agents” law and is forced to find workarounds to continue helping those stranded at the border, said Maria, its head.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The most serious problem is the lack of medical care. One man became disabled while stuck at the border. He had an eye infection, and his fellow basement dwellers tried to call an ambulance. They had reached out to the Ukrainian consulate, but no help arrived for several weeks. “By the time we managed to get him to the hospital, all that the doctors could do was remove his eye. He wasn’t even ill before, but now he’s disabled. What kind of medical care is this? We don’t even have painkillers for headaches and toothaches, not to mention those of us who need a more serious treatment or medications,” Oleksii says.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18241,"data":{"images":[{"caption":"The man who lost his eye while remaining at the border","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47145373c15452798190464db8e20ca-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47145373c15452798190464db8e20ca-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47145373c15452798190464db8e20ca-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47145373c15452798190464db8e20ca-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47145373c15452798190464db8e20ca-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47145373c15452798190464db8e20ca-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47145373c15452798190464db8e20ca-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47145373c15452798190464db8e20ca-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47145373c15452798190464db8e20ca-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47145373c15452798190464db8e20ca-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47145373c15452798190464db8e20ca-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47145373c15452798190464db8e20ca-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47145373c15452798190464db8e20ca-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47145373c15452798190464db8e20ca-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47145373c15452798190464db8e20ca-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47145373c15452798190464db8e20ca-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47145373c15452798190464db8e20ca-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e47145373c15452798190464db8e20ca-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Among those in the basement there are people with hepatitis and HIV. They need daily treatment, but it’s very difficult to access. “Antiretroviral therapy medication isn’t available over the counter, and the Georgian HIV care center can’t give medications out to unregistered and untested patients. But they can’t get tested at the border. We’ve managed to find a way to deliver the medications several times and we hope we’ll be able to do it again soon,” says Maria from Tbilisi Volunteers.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In November 2025, Andriy Bilyk, a representative of the Ukrainian Embassy in Georgia, visited the Ukrainians remaining in the basement. He explained that technically the consulate could issue the new passports for them, but this would require approval from the Ukrainian Ministry of Justice as well as the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Security Service of Ukraine (a recording of the meeting is at IStories’ disposal). A month later, the embassy sent the approval document to the basement, but by that moment the Security Service of Ukraine had not issued passports to any of those citizens.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Pavlo has remained in the basement for almost a year. He says he is already losing hope of ever getting his passport and leaving. “They constantly throw something at us to keep us from bothering them. Two or three weeks go by, and we start calling and writing to them again. I wonder if I’ve got 50 kilos of weight left. I feel terrible. There’s no air here; we’re just suffocating. The only thing left to do is to shoot myself — I don’t know what other way out there is.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>IStories have sent inquiries to the Russian Ministry of Internal Affairs, the Office of the Human Rights Commissioner of Russia, and the Presidential Council on Human Rights asking what steps the Russian authorities are taking to end the indefinite detention of Ukrainian citizens. We have not received any responses from these entities. The Office of the Ukrainian Parliament Commissioner for Human Rights and the Ukrainian Embassy in Georgia also have not responded to our inquiries as of the moment of publication. </em>","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":9685,"header":"Independent Review Confirms Critical Telegram Vulnerability Previously Exposed by IStories","_path":"/en/stories/2026/05/18/independent-review-confirms-critical-telegram-vulnerability/","lead":"The privacy of hundreds of millions of users is at risk, experts say","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-original.png","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-original.png","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-original.png","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-original.png","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-original.png","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-original.png","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-original.png","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-original.png","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-original.png","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-original.png","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-original.png","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-original.png","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-original.png","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/45443855f81b409e9bf45930f0da8e43-original.png","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Illustration: Elizaveta Dobrovinskaya","created_at_date":"2026-05-18","created_at_date_time":"2026-05-17T15:47:04.017Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":5,"first_name":"Роман","last_name":"Анин","first_name_en":"Roman","last_name_en":"Anin","is_public":true,"_path":"roman-anin","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редактор «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Редактор","position_en":"Editor","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"IStories has obtained an expert report from Symbolic Software, a firm specializing in cybersecurity analysis and technical audits of applications for tech giants such as Zoom, Mozilla, Coinbase, and many others.\n\nSymbolic Software reviewed the claims from last year’s IStories report regarding Telegram’s ties to the FSB, concluding that the vulnerability we detailed in 2025 poses a genuine threat to the privacy of all the app’s users, including those communicating in secret chats.\n\n“We evaluate claims from public reporting about these vulnerabilities, finding the core technical assertions <...> to be accurate and reproducible. <...> The implications extend beyond theoretical concerns. <...> This is particularly significant given Telegrams adoption by journalists, activists, and other high-risk users,” the expert review states (the full Symbolic Software report can be read here).\n\nThe anatomy of the vulnerability\nWhile working on last year’s investigation, IStories conducted an experiment: we asked people in various countries to send messages to each other via Telegram and record the network traffic using specialized software.\n\nWe then shared the results with cybersecurity experts, who discovered that during data transmission, the app sends an unencrypted header containing a unique device identifier: auth_key_id. Armed with this identifier, anyone with access to Telegram’s traffic can track users, analyze their online activity, and map their communication networks.\n\nSymbolic Software experts reached the same conclusion: \n\n“Our analysis confirms the core technical findings: Telegram clients <...> transmit messages over unencrypted TCP connections, exposing the auth_key_id in cleartext (or trivially obfuscated form) to any network intermediary. The auth_key_id functions as a persistent device identifier that remains constant across sessions, IP address changes, network switches, and geographic locations. This creates a technical capability for device tracking by any entity with passive network access, including Internet Service Provider (ISP)s, network administrators, government surveillance programs, and other adversaries positioned along the communication path.”\n\n“All of these adversaries,” the review continues, “can collect auth_key_id values through entirely passive observation.  No man-in-the-middle attack is required, no certificate compromise is necessary, and no active protocol manipulation is needed. Simple packet capture and trivial deobfuscation suffice to extract persistent device identifiers from Telegram traffic. \n\nThe persistence of auth_key_id values across sessions, network changes, and extended time periods enables long-term tracking of individual devices. An adversary who collects auth_key_id values from network traffic can build a comprehensive database associating specific auth_key_id values with observed network locations, timestamps, traffic patterns, and — when the user’s identity is known through other means — specific individuals.\nSuch a database could enable queries like: ‘Where has the device associated with auth_key_id X been observed over the past six months?’ or ‘Which auth_key_id values were present at network location Y during time period Z?’ The ability to track devices across IP address changes means that even users who employ dynamic IP addressing, regularly switch networks, or use mobile connections remain trackable through their persistent auth_key_id,” the experts emphasize.\n\nThe FSB connection and the origin of the report\nThis expert review is particularly valuable not only because it was conducted by an independent firm with a solid reputation in cybersecurity, but also because its initiator was apparently none other than Vladimir Vedeneev — one of the key figures in last year’s IStories investigation. In 2025, we revealed that Vedeneev had served for several years as Telegram’s chief financial officer, held power of attorney to sign documents on behalf of the company and Pavel Durov, and, moreover, maintains nearly the entirety of the app’s network infrastructure across multiple countries.\n\nWe also learned that Vedeneev’s former Russian company (he transferred ownership to a relative in 2024) services FSB operational and investigative systems used to surveil Russian citizens under a classified government contract. Most importantly, according to Vedeneev himself, he is assigned a dedicated FSB handler — a senior security service officer with whom Vedeneev has long cooperated and shared information: “I am overseen by a FSB guy, related to SORM (the System for Operative Investigative Activities, the technical specification for the targeted surveillance of telephone and Internet communications in Russia. — Ed.). He’s apparently trying to get promoted, so he tells everyone: ‘Access to Vladimir is only through me.’ He calls me and says: ‘Listen, Volodya, basically, you’ve got to somehow talk to them, to all of them [other FSB officers], and so on.’ \n\nThey [the FSB officers] say: ‘So, we need this IP address at this time. Who is it?’ We understand that we can’t not answer, right? We quickly answer them. We have authorized emails from which they send requests. We quickly answer them. We say: ‘It’s Ivanov Ivan Ivanovich, apartment number 7, blah-blah-blah.’ They’re like: ‘All right, okay,’” Vedeneev told IStories in an interview. \n\nFollowing the publication of the investigation, Vedeneev filed a lawsuit in Switzerland, where he resides, against the story’s lead author and IStories founder, Roman Anin. In the lawsuit, Vedeneev does not dispute the investigation’s claims; instead, he demands the removal of the interview in which he admits to cooperating with the FSB. \n\nWhile reviewing the materials of the Swiss case, we discovered this very same technical review by Symbolic Software, which Vedeneev had apparently attached in hopes that the experts would refute the article’s technical findings. Instead, they confirmed them.\n\nGlobal reach and the scale of the risk\n“From a surveillance infrastructure perspective, ‘global’ reach depends on the extent of the adversary's network access. <...> Achieving truly global surveillance would require infrastructure access across multiple geographic regions and network paths,” the Symbolic Software review states.\n\nVladimir Vedeneev possesses exactly this level of access. For instance, here is what he said in an interview with IStories: “Telegram doesn’t have access to the data centers in Singapore or Miami: they’ve never been there. Four data centers have already been built. We (Vedeneev’s company GNM, which services Telegram’s network infrastructure. — Ed.) are present in all four. <...> At this point, I provide all communication channels. Not someone else — me! If I really wanted to, of course, I could capture this traffic.” \n\nVedeneev’s admission, coupled with the experts’ conclusions, indicates that a significant portion of Telegram’s traffic essentially flows through a single individual, and:\nthis traffic contains unencrypted device identifiers that allow user tracking;\nthis individual has an FSB handler with whom he has long cooperated and shared information.\n\nIn last year’s interview with IStories, Vladimir Vedeneev denied the vulnerability we described, claiming he only provides his FSB handler with information regarding Russian internet users from Russian companies, but not from Telegram. Whether this is true or not is a matter of faith.\nThe Symbolic Software expert notes that the vulnerability did not stem from a technical failing, but rather is the result of “a fundamental abdication of Telegram’s responsibility to protect user privacy through appropriate cryptographic measures. <...>  The proper solution is <...> for Telegram to eliminate the vulnerability entirely through mandatory use of transport-layer encryption — a standard practice adopted by virtually every other major messaging platform. The technical implementation is straightforward, the performance impact negligible, and the privacy benefits substantial. Until Telegram implements proper TLS encryption, it continues to expose its users to unnecessary privacy risks,” the expert concludes.\n\nThe Symbolic Software review does not claim that malicious actors with access to Telegram traffic and device identifiers can decrypt messages. However, cybersecurity experts interviewed by IStories consider such a risk to be entirely possible.\n\nThe issue is that the auth_key_id identifier — which Telegram transmits openly over the network for some reason — is used to locate the specific user's key in the database, which the app then uses to decrypt messages on its servers. Thus, if someone like Vladimir Vedeneev or another passive traffic observer were to gain access to this database, it means they could potentially decrypt messages.\n\nTelegram’s response\nTelegram representative Remi Vaughn (whose actual existence remains unverified: there are no photos or other mentions of him online) sent the following response to the IStories editorial office: “Regarding the unpublished article, we reject its conclusions for the reasons outlined on this page.\n\nThe auth_key_id parameter changes regularly and does not reveal user information, message contents, recipients, or private data. Any observer able to see it would already have access to more reliable network-level signals for tracking. Telegram owns its infrastructure, which is configured, managed and controlled exclusively by Telegram’s internal engineering teams. GNM is a respected global infrastructure provider, and neither GNM nor its owner Mr. Vedeneev is connected to the FSB. \n\nSince 2021, neither GNM nor any other company affiliated with Mr. Vedeneev has provided services in the Telegram data center that stores information of Russian and European citizens. This fact alone makes the entire FSB–Vedeneev conspiracy theory inconsistent with reality.”","blocks":[{"data":"IStories has obtained an expert report from Symbolic Software, a firm specializing in cybersecurity analysis and technical audits of applications for tech giants such as Zoom, Mozilla, Coinbase, and many others.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Symbolic Software reviewed the claims from last year’s IStories <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/stories/2025/06/10/telegram-fsb/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">report</a> regarding Telegram’s ties to the FSB, concluding that the vulnerability we detailed in 2025 poses a genuine threat to the privacy of all the app’s users, including those communicating in secret chats.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“We evaluate claims from public reporting about these vulnerabilities, finding the core technical assertions &lt;...&gt; to be accurate and reproducible. &lt;...&gt; The implications extend beyond theoretical concerns. &lt;...&gt; This is particularly significant given Telegrams adoption by journalists, activists, and other high-risk users,” the expert review states (the full Symbolic Software report can be read <a href=\"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/documents/d92f02fe94f64906887d290489e26d14.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">here</a>).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The anatomy of the vulnerability","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"While working on last year’s investigation, IStories conducted an experiment: we asked people in various countries to send messages to each other via Telegram and record the network traffic using specialized software.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We then shared the results with cybersecurity experts, who discovered that during data transmission, the app sends an unencrypted header containing a unique device identifier: auth_key_id. Armed with this identifier, anyone with access to Telegram’s traffic can track users, analyze their online activity, and map their communication networks.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Symbolic Software experts reached the same conclusion: ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Our analysis confirms the core technical findings: Telegram clients &lt;...&gt; transmit messages over unencrypted TCP connections, exposing the auth_key_id in cleartext (or trivially obfuscated form) to any network intermediary. The auth_key_id functions as a persistent device identifier that remains constant across sessions, IP address changes, network switches, and geographic locations. This creates a technical capability for device tracking by any entity with passive network access, including Internet Service Provider (ISP)s, network administrators, government surveillance programs, and other adversaries positioned along the communication path.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“All of these adversaries,” the review continues, “can collect auth_key_id values through entirely passive observation.  No man-in-the-middle attack is required, no certificate compromise is necessary, and no active protocol manipulation is needed. Simple packet capture and trivial deobfuscation suffice to extract persistent device identifiers from Telegram traffic. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The persistence of auth_key_id values across sessions, network changes, and extended time periods enables long-term tracking of individual devices. An adversary who collects auth_key_id values from network traffic can build a comprehensive database associating specific auth_key_id values with observed network locations, timestamps, traffic patterns, and — when the user’s identity is known through other means — specific individuals.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18224,"data":{"text":"","author":"","header":"They [the FSB officers] say: “So, we need this IP address at this time. Who is it?” We quickly answer them "},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"Such a database could enable queries like: ‘Where has the device associated with auth_key_id X been observed over the past six months?’ or ‘Which auth_key_id values were present at network location Y during time period Z?’ The ability to track devices across IP address changes means that even users who employ dynamic IP addressing, regularly switch networks, or use mobile connections remain trackable through their persistent auth_key_id,” the experts emphasize.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The FSB connection and the origin of the report","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"This expert review is particularly valuable not only because it was conducted by an independent firm with a solid reputation in cybersecurity, but also because its initiator was apparently none other than Vladimir Vedeneev — one of the key figures in last year’s IStories investigation. In 2025, we revealed that Vedeneev had served for several years as Telegram’s chief financial officer, held power of attorney to sign documents on behalf of the company and Pavel Durov, and, moreover, maintains nearly the entirety of the app’s network infrastructure across multiple countries.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We also learned that Vedeneev’s former Russian company (he transferred ownership to a relative in 2024) services FSB operational and investigative systems used to surveil Russian citizens under a classified government contract. Most importantly, according to Vedeneev himself, he is assigned a dedicated FSB handler — a senior security service officer with whom Vedeneev has long cooperated and shared information: “I am overseen by a FSB guy, related to SORM <em>(the System for Operative Investigative Activities, the technical specification for the targeted surveillance of telephone and Internet communications in Russia. —&nbsp;Ed.).</em> He’s apparently trying to get promoted, so he tells everyone: ‘Access to Vladimir is only through me.’ He calls me and says: ‘Listen, Volodya, basically, you’ve got to somehow talk to them, to all of them [other FSB officers], and so on.’ ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"They [the FSB officers] say: ‘So, we need this IP address at this time. Who is it?’ We understand that we can’t not answer, right? We quickly answer them. We have authorized emails from which they send requests. We quickly answer them. We say: ‘It’s Ivanov Ivan Ivanovich, apartment number 7, blah-blah-blah.’ They’re like: ‘All right, okay,’” Vedeneev told IStories in an interview. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Following the publication of the investigation, Vedeneev filed a lawsuit in Switzerland, where he resides, against the story’s lead author and IStories founder, Roman Anin. In the lawsuit, Vedeneev does not dispute the investigation’s claims; instead, he demands the removal of the interview in which he admits to cooperating with the FSB. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"While reviewing the materials of the Swiss case, we discovered this very same technical review by Symbolic Software, which Vedeneev had apparently attached in hopes that the experts would refute the article’s technical findings. Instead, they confirmed them.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Global reach and the scale of the risk","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"“From a surveillance infrastructure perspective, ‘global’ reach depends on the extent of the adversary's network access. &lt;...&gt; Achieving truly global surveillance would require infrastructure access across multiple geographic regions and network paths,” the Symbolic Software review states.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Vladimir Vedeneev possesses exactly this level of access. For instance, here is what he said in an interview with IStories: “Telegram doesn’t have access to the data centers in Singapore or Miami: they’ve never been there. Four data centers have already been built. We <em>(Vedeneev’s company GNM, which services Telegram’s network infrastructure. — Ed.)</em> are present in all four. &lt;...&gt; At this point, I provide all communication channels. Not someone else — me! If I really wanted to, of course, I could capture this traffic.” ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Vedeneev’s admission, coupled with the experts’ conclusions, indicates that a significant portion of Telegram’s traffic essentially flows through a single individual, and:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li>this traffic contains unencrypted device identifiers that allow user tracking;</li><li>this individual has an FSB handler with whom he has long cooperated and shared information.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"In last year’s interview with IStories, Vladimir Vedeneev denied the vulnerability we described, claiming he only provides his FSB handler with information regarding Russian internet users from Russian companies, but not from Telegram. Whether this is true or not is a matter of faith.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18225,"data":{"text":"","author":"","header":"If I really wanted to, of course, I could capture this traffic"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"The Symbolic Software expert notes that the vulnerability did not stem from a technical failing, but rather is the result of “a fundamental abdication of Telegram’s responsibility to protect user privacy through appropriate cryptographic measures. &lt;...&gt;  The proper solution is &lt;...&gt; for Telegram to eliminate the vulnerability entirely through mandatory use of transport-layer encryption — a standard practice adopted by virtually every other major messaging platform. The technical implementation is straightforward, the performance impact negligible, and the privacy benefits substantial. Until Telegram implements proper TLS encryption, it continues to expose its users to unnecessary privacy risks,” the expert concludes.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Symbolic Software review does not claim that malicious actors with access to Telegram traffic and device identifiers can decrypt messages. However, cybersecurity experts interviewed by IStories consider such a risk to be entirely possible.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The issue is that the auth_key_id identifier — which Telegram transmits openly over the network for some reason — is used to locate the specific user's key in the database, which the app then uses to decrypt messages on its servers. Thus, if someone like Vladimir Vedeneev or another passive traffic observer were to gain access to this database, it means they could potentially decrypt messages.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Telegram’s response","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Telegram representative Remi Vaughn (whose actual existence remains unverified: there are no photos or other mentions of him online) sent the following response to the IStories editorial office: “Regarding the unpublished article, we reject its conclusions for the reasons outlined on <a href=\"https://telegra.ph/Telegram-GNM-auth-key-id-05-04?utm_source=chatgpt.com\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">this page</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The auth_key_id parameter changes regularly and does not reveal user information, message contents, recipients, or private data. Any observer able to see it would already have access to more reliable network-level signals for tracking. Telegram owns its infrastructure, which is configured, managed and controlled exclusively by Telegram’s internal engineering teams. GNM is a respected global infrastructure provider, and neither GNM nor its owner Mr. Vedeneev is connected to the FSB. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Since 2021, neither GNM nor any other company affiliated with Mr. Vedeneev has provided services in the Telegram data center that stores information of Russian and European citizens. This fact alone makes the entire FSB–Vedeneev conspiracy theory inconsistent with reality.”","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":9609,"header":"He Burned Himself Alive to Protest Russia’s War in Ukraine. The State Tried to Erase Him","_path":"/en/stories/2026/05/06/okunev/","lead":"Russian programmer Alexander Okunev set himself on fire on the third anniversary of the full-scale invasion. No one heard","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/03e0da8aa85242d99edf541a3897682a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Illustration: IStories. Background photo: Lutz Schneider / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 3.0","created_at_date":"2026-05-06","created_at_date_time":"2026-05-05T09:47:56.241Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":35,"first_name":"Мария","last_name":"Жолобова","first_name_en":"Maria","last_name_en":"Zholobova","is_public":true,"_path":"maria-zholobova","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-896x504px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-896x504px_2x.png","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-688x387px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-688x387px_2x.png","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-416x234px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-416x234px_2x.png","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-336x189px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-336x189px_2x.png","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Редакторка","position_en":null,"ordering":1},{"id":87,"first_name":"Филипп","last_name":"Горенштейн","first_name_en":"Filipp","last_name_en":"Gorenshtein","is_public":true,"_path":"filipp-gorenshtein","avatar":[],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":2}],"external_authors_list":[{"id":317,"first_name":"Holger","last_name":"Roonemaa","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"Delfi Estonia","company_en":null,"company_link":"https://rus.delfi.ee/","avatar":[],"ordering":3},{"id":353,"first_name":"Индре","last_name":"Макарайтите","first_name_en":"Indrė","last_name_en":"Makaraitytė","company":"LRT","company_en":"LRT","company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":4},{"id":318,"first_name":"Ilya","last_name":"Ber","first_name_en":null,"last_name_en":null,"company":"Delfi Estonia","company_en":null,"company_link":"https://rus.delfi.ee/","avatar":[],"ordering":5}],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"Information about the self-immolation of a resident of Kaliningrad born in 1988 in protest against the war was first published in an open report of the Estonian Foreign Intelligence Service. The authors of the report did not disclose the name of the deceased. We managed to find out the details of the incident together with Delfi Estonia and Lithuanian broadcaster LRT. We reconstructed what happened based on Russian Investigative Committee documents, conversations with Okunev's relatives and colleagues, and European security sources. \n\nFive CCTV cameras are installed in front of the 1200 Guardsmen Memorial in Kaliningrad, the USSR's first monument to soldiers killed in the Great Patriotic War, 1941-1945. In the center of the memorial is the Eternal Flame. From time to time, various incidents occur near the memorial, which are then widely reported in the local news, and their perpetrators become the subjects of criminal cases. Since last year, for the \"desecration of war memorials,\" a sentence of up to five years in prison has been provided. \n\nThus, in February this year, a drunken Kaliningrad resident wanted to light a cigarette from the fire and warmed his feet over the flames. In January 2026, a couple of residents stole a basket of flowers from the monument. In September 2025, another couple had sex at the memorial. \n\nSix months before that, around 5 am on February 24, 2025, 37-year-old Kaliningrad resident Alexander Okunev burned himself alive at the memorial to 1200 Guardsmen in protest against the war — and no one found out about it. \n\"He was sitting in a corner, not where all the people were\"\n\nIn the 2010s, Kaliningrad earned the title of the protest capital of Russia, and a series of large-scale rallies even led to the replacement of Governor Georgy Boos. \n\nHowever, since the start of the full-scale war in Ukraine, the city has not exhibited any notable protest activity. In the first days of the invasion, a wave of anti-war actions swept through Kaliningrad. At one point, the city became a leader in the number of protocols issued for \"discrediting\" the army. But almost immediately, protests died down as they did throughout the country. Igor Luzin, a Kaliningrad activist and former employee of Navalny's local headquarters, explains that the \"political field\" in Kaliningrad has been cleaned up just like the rest of Russia. \n\nAlexander Okunev was not an activist. He avoided talking politics at work (he was a sysadmin at a firm selling retail equipment), did not argue about the full-scale war with his family, and apparently was not active on social media. Okunev had almost no friends, had no girlfriend, and lived alone. \n\nHe practically did not talk to his colleagues, could ignore even his superiors: he could keep silent in response to a greeting or not answer the questions. At corporate parties, New Year's Eve, for example, he tried not to leave his office. \n\n\"Was sitting there in a corner, not where all the people ... Somehow always in himself, lived his own life,\" recalls his former colleague. \"Closed. Strange.\" However, there were no complaints about his work: \"His programmer's brains were cool\". His colleague believes that Alexander could have made a good career, \"but it feels like he didn't care much about money\". When Okunev decided to quit (about six months before the incident), everyone was upset. \n\n\"We asked him, have you found another job? No. Are you going somewhere? Maybe. No one had any idea what or why he left,\" says his former colleague. Acquaintances call Okunev \"kind, responsive, fair\": \"He always helped everyone\". He was fond of origami, and when one of his colleagues had a birthday, he could secretly put \"some flowers\" on their table. Regarding his hobbies, people close to him say that he liked to watch movies and ride a bicycle. \n\nAfter the dismissal, Okunev really did not find another job. \"Sat at home, practically did not communicate with anyone,\" heard his ex-colleague. \nCleanup\n\nHaving decided on such a desperate protest act as self-immolation, Alexander Okunev did not seem to be trying to attract attention. Maybe he was afraid that someone could stop him. But he obviously chose the date (the anniversary of the Russian full-scale invasion of Ukraine) and the place (the main war memorial in the city) for a reason. Perhaps the time too: the Russian missile struck Kyiv on February 24, 2022, began just about five in the morning. \n\nOkunev's charred corpse, despite the numerous cameras at the memorial, was discovered by a random passerby only at around 6:40 am. The snow appears to have been spray-painted with the words \"No to War\". Employees of the investigative department for the Leninsky district of Kaliningrad went to the scene. In the report of the events of the night, Okunev's self-immolation is mentioned along with reports of two other corpses and a ninth-grade girl who had left home.\n\nThe incident was reported to the head of the city administration, Elena Dyatlova. She immediately took everything under her control, the European intelligence officer knows. She was assisted by Evgeny Maslov, head of the local service for the protection of cultural heritage. The main thing for them was to quickly get rid of the body and the words on the snow — the officials were worried mostly that journalists would know what happened. The Minister of Culture and Tourism of the Kaliningrad Oblast, Andrey Yermak, was especially worried that the self-immolation took place near the monument of the Great Patriotic War — too symbolic. \n\nEverything was settled by 9:15 am. Traces of the incident were removed, and authorities were relieved to report to the local governor and other local officials that no one had seen anything, the source of IStories Media said. \n\nInformation about the self-immolation of an unnamed Kaliningrad resident first went public only along with a report by Estonian intelligence in the winter of 2026: \"On the third anniversary of Russia's full-scale war, at five o'clock in the morning on February 24, 2025, a man born in 1988 wrote 'No to War' in the snow near the monument to a Russian soldier in Kaliningrad and set himself on fire in protest.\" \n\nNone of the Kaliningrad media ever reported the news. There were no local or propaganda Telegram channels or other social media posts about Okunev. The Alexanders' family did not spread the word about the incident either. \"What's the point of somehow publicizing and telling all this? What for?\" one of them told reporters.\n\"There is another way\"\n\nAn acquaintance of Okunev says that on the eve of his suicide, he behaved \"absolutely normally.\" There was no hint of what he was going to do, and \"what happened came as a shock to everyone.\" Okunev's relatives speak of some \"expert examinations\" conducted as part of the investigation, which found that \"there was no outside influence\" on Aexander. The family was questioned by the local Investigative Committee; the police came to Okunev's former colleagues for a \"characterization,\" but came away with \"Worked well, did not communicate with anyone.\"\n\nA close friend of Okunev recounted to IStories Media the content of his suicide note: \"He wrote that there is another way. Apparently, he meant a world with peace. And he didn't want to live in the world we have, so he made this decision... But we are all aware that world peace is a utopia.\"\n\nThe note also shows that Okunev understood that \"most likely, it will not be in the news anywhere, it will not be widely covered anywhere,\" the source tells IStories Media.\n\nElena Maslova, head of the Kaliningrad administration, and Evgeny Maslov, head of the cultural heritage protection service, have not responded to journalists' requests. \n\nCulture Minister Andrei Yermak replied that he was not familiar with the results of the investigation of this \"accident\", so he would not comment on anything. He expressed confidence that law enforcement agencies \"will comment on the situation as soon as the investigation is finalized.\" \n\n\"These people are afraid not of the people, but of their superiors\"\n\nIn January 1969, the self-immolation of Jan Palach, a philosophy student at Charles University, brought tens of thousands of people onto the streets and became a symbol of resistance to the Soviet occupation in Czechoslovakia. The self-immolation of street vendor Mohammed Bouazizi provoked mass protests in Tunisia, which eventually led to the resignation of the country's president. \n\nIn Russia, the self-immolations of journalist Irina Slavina and Udmurt scientist Albert Razin did not lead to any notable collective action. Could Okunev's suicide have provoked some protest if people had learned about it?\n\nSociologist Margarita Zavadskaya thinks not. \"Self-immolation is a powerful symbolic act,\" she says, \"but public outrage alone is not enough to trigger large-scale collective action under conditions of severe repression and limited access to information.\" \n\nSo why did the Russian authorities try so hard to conceal information about what happened? To prevent \"protest contagion\" and imitation, she explains. Moreover, such an anti-war suicide contradicts the government's theory of a universal public consensus on war. And local officials would look incapable of maintaining control in the eyes of their superiors. \n\nPolitical scientist Ekaterina Shulman also does not believe that fear of further protests was behind the Kaliningrad authorities' actions. \"Local authorities are not afraid of the people, not of protests. They are afraid of their superiors,\" she says, \"they were afraid to hear: 'You oversaw, allowed a scandal, there are media publications, what do you eat your bread for?'\"\n\n\"Authoritarian regimes are afraid of symbolic sparks. They understand that a single act of protest may not cause an immediate mass movement, but can become a moral symbol around which scattered anxiety and discontent begin to crystallize,\" says Lithuanian political scientist Nerijus Malukiavicius. \"That is why such regimes seek to 'clean up' the scene, silence history, and discredit the victim.\"","blocks":[{"data":"<em>Information about the self-immolation of a resident of Kaliningrad born in 1988 in protest against the war was first published in an open report of the Estonian Foreign Intelligence Service. The authors of the report did not disclose the name of the deceased. We managed to find out the details of the incident together with Delfi Estonia and Lithuanian broadcaster LRT. We reconstructed what happened based on Russian Investigative Committee documents, conversations with Okunev's relatives and colleagues, and European security sources. </em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Five CCTV cameras are installed in front of the 1200 Guardsmen Memorial in Kaliningrad, the USSR's first monument to soldiers killed in the Great Patriotic War, 1941-1945. In the center of the memorial is the Eternal Flame. From time to time, various incidents occur near the memorial, which are then widely reported in the local news, and their perpetrators become the subjects of criminal cases. Since last year, for the \"desecration of war memorials,\" a sentence of up to five years in prison has been provided. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Thus, in February this year, a drunken Kaliningrad resident wanted to light a cigarette from the fire and warmed his feet over the flames. In January 2026, a couple of residents stole a basket of flowers from the monument. In September 2025, another couple had sex at the memorial. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Six months before that, around 5 am on February 24, 2025, 37-year-old Kaliningrad resident Alexander Okunev burned himself alive at the memorial to 1200 Guardsmen in protest against the war — and no one found out about it. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18156,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photos: The Government of the Kaliningrad Oblast","caption":"The day before Okunev’s self-immolation, Defender of the Fatherland Day was celebrated at the Memorial to the 1,200 Guardsmen","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/08e4682e70634cd29b52652aea07e335-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/08e4682e70634cd29b52652aea07e335-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/08e4682e70634cd29b52652aea07e335-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/08e4682e70634cd29b52652aea07e335-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/08e4682e70634cd29b52652aea07e335-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/08e4682e70634cd29b52652aea07e335-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/08e4682e70634cd29b52652aea07e335-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/08e4682e70634cd29b52652aea07e335-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/08e4682e70634cd29b52652aea07e335-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/08e4682e70634cd29b52652aea07e335-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/08e4682e70634cd29b52652aea07e335-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/08e4682e70634cd29b52652aea07e335-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/08e4682e70634cd29b52652aea07e335-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/08e4682e70634cd29b52652aea07e335-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/08e4682e70634cd29b52652aea07e335-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/08e4682e70634cd29b52652aea07e335-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/08e4682e70634cd29b52652aea07e335-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/08e4682e70634cd29b52652aea07e335-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"\"He was sitting in a corner, not where all the people were\"","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In the 2010s, Kaliningrad earned the title of the protest capital of Russia, and a series of large-scale rallies even <a href=\"https://namednibook.ru/protesty-v-kaliningrade-otstavka-boo.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">led to the replacement</a> of Governor Georgy Boos. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, since the start of the full-scale war in Ukraine, the city has not exhibited any notable protest activity. In the first days of the invasion, a wave of anti-war actions swept through Kaliningrad. At one point, the city became a leader in the number of protocols issued for \"discrediting\" the army. But almost immediately, protests died down as they did throughout the country. Igor Luzin, a Kaliningrad activist and former employee of Navalny's local headquarters, explains that the \"political field\" in Kaliningrad has been cleaned up just like the rest of Russia. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Alexander Okunev was not an activist. He avoided talking politics at work (he was a sysadmin at a firm selling retail equipment), did not argue about the full-scale war with his family, and apparently was not active on social media. Okunev had almost no friends, had no girlfriend, and lived alone. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"He practically did not talk to his colleagues, could ignore even his superiors: he could keep silent in response to a greeting or not answer the questions. At corporate parties, New Year's Eve, for example, he tried not to leave his office. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"\"Was sitting there in a corner, not where all the people ... Somehow always in himself, lived his own life,\" recalls his former colleague. \"Closed. Strange.\" However, there were no complaints about his work: \"His programmer's brains were cool\". His colleague believes that Alexander could have made a good career, \"but it feels like he didn't care much about money\". When Okunev decided to quit (about six months before the incident), everyone was upset. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"\"We asked him, have you found another job? No. Are you going somewhere? Maybe. No one had any idea what or why he left,\" says his former colleague. Acquaintances call Okunev \"kind, responsive, fair\": \"He always helped everyone\". He was fond of origami, and when one of his colleagues had a birthday, he could secretly put \"some flowers\" on their table. Regarding his hobbies, people close to him say that he liked to watch movies and ride a bicycle. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After the dismissal, Okunev really did not find another job. \"Sat at home, practically did not communicate with anyone,\" heard his ex-colleague. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18157,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photos: social media","caption":"Alexander Okunev and his family","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c4245ab7728342b29b863e15f62ad9a2-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c4245ab7728342b29b863e15f62ad9a2-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c4245ab7728342b29b863e15f62ad9a2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c4245ab7728342b29b863e15f62ad9a2-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c4245ab7728342b29b863e15f62ad9a2-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c4245ab7728342b29b863e15f62ad9a2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c4245ab7728342b29b863e15f62ad9a2-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c4245ab7728342b29b863e15f62ad9a2-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c4245ab7728342b29b863e15f62ad9a2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c4245ab7728342b29b863e15f62ad9a2-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c4245ab7728342b29b863e15f62ad9a2-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c4245ab7728342b29b863e15f62ad9a2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c4245ab7728342b29b863e15f62ad9a2-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c4245ab7728342b29b863e15f62ad9a2-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c4245ab7728342b29b863e15f62ad9a2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c4245ab7728342b29b863e15f62ad9a2-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c4245ab7728342b29b863e15f62ad9a2-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c4245ab7728342b29b863e15f62ad9a2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Cleanup","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Having decided on such a desperate protest act as self-immolation, Alexander Okunev did not seem to be trying to attract attention. Maybe he was afraid that someone could stop him. But he obviously chose the date (the anniversary of the Russian full-scale invasion of Ukraine) and the place (the main war memorial in the city) for a reason. Perhaps the time too: the Russian missile struck Kyiv on February 24, 2022, began just about five in the morning. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Okunev's charred corpse, despite the numerous cameras at the memorial, was discovered by a random passerby only at around 6:40 am. The snow appears to have been spray-painted with the words \"No to War\". Employees of the investigative department for the Leninsky district of Kaliningrad went to the scene. In the report of the events of the night, Okunev's self-immolation is mentioned along with reports of two other corpses and a ninth-grade girl who had left home.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The incident was reported to the head of the city administration, <strong>Elena Dyatlova</strong>. She immediately took everything under her control, the European intelligence officer knows. She was assisted by <strong>Evgeny Maslov</strong>, head of the local service for the protection of cultural heritage. The main thing for them was to quickly get rid of the body and the words on the snow — <strong>the officials were worried mostly that journalists would know what happened</strong>. The Minister of Culture and Tourism of the Kaliningrad Oblast, Andrey Yermak, was especially worried that the self-immolation took place near the monument of the Great Patriotic War — too symbolic. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Everything was settled by 9:15 am. Traces of the incident were removed, and authorities were relieved to report to the local governor and other local officials that no one had seen anything, the source of IStories Media said. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Information about the self-immolation of an unnamed Kaliningrad resident first went public only along with a <a href=\"https://raport.valisluureamet.ee/2026/en/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">report</a> by Estonian intelligence in the winter of 2026: \"On the third anniversary of Russia's full-scale war, at five o'clock in the morning on February 24, 2025, a man born in 1988 wrote 'No to War' in the snow near the monument to a Russian soldier in Kaliningrad and set himself on fire in protest.\" ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"None of the Kaliningrad media ever reported the news. There were no local or propaganda Telegram channels or other social media posts about Okunev. The Alexanders' family did not spread the word about the incident either. \"What's the point of somehow publicizing and telling all this? What for?\" one of them told reporters.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18159,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photos: The Government of the Kaliningrad Oblast","caption":"The issue was handled by several officials, the source said","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f88f6f08b68498bb2b2cd18069b2e8b-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f88f6f08b68498bb2b2cd18069b2e8b-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f88f6f08b68498bb2b2cd18069b2e8b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f88f6f08b68498bb2b2cd18069b2e8b-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f88f6f08b68498bb2b2cd18069b2e8b-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f88f6f08b68498bb2b2cd18069b2e8b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f88f6f08b68498bb2b2cd18069b2e8b-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f88f6f08b68498bb2b2cd18069b2e8b-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f88f6f08b68498bb2b2cd18069b2e8b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f88f6f08b68498bb2b2cd18069b2e8b-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f88f6f08b68498bb2b2cd18069b2e8b-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f88f6f08b68498bb2b2cd18069b2e8b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f88f6f08b68498bb2b2cd18069b2e8b-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f88f6f08b68498bb2b2cd18069b2e8b-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f88f6f08b68498bb2b2cd18069b2e8b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f88f6f08b68498bb2b2cd18069b2e8b-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f88f6f08b68498bb2b2cd18069b2e8b-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8f88f6f08b68498bb2b2cd18069b2e8b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"\"There is another way\"","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"An acquaintance of Okunev says that on the eve of his suicide, he behaved \"absolutely normally.\" There was no hint of what he was going to do, and \"what happened came as a shock to everyone.\" Okunev's relatives speak of some \"expert examinations\" conducted as part of the investigation, which found that \"there was no outside influence\" on Aexander. The family was questioned by the local Investigative Committee; the police came to Okunev's former colleagues for a \"characterization,\" but came away with \"Worked well, did not communicate with anyone.\"","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A close friend of Okunev recounted to IStories Media the content of his suicide note: \"He wrote that there is another way. Apparently, he meant a world with peace. And he didn't want to live in the world we have, so he made this decision... But we are all aware that world peace is a utopia.\"","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The note also shows that Okunev understood that \"most likely, it will not be in the news anywhere, it will not be widely covered anywhere,\" the source tells IStories Media.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Elena Maslova, head of the Kaliningrad administration, and Evgeny Maslov, head of the cultural heritage protection service, have not responded to journalists' requests. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Culture Minister Andrei Yermak replied that he was not familiar with the results of the investigation of this \"accident\", so he would not comment on anything. He expressed confidence that law enforcement agencies \"will comment on the situation as soon as the investigation is finalized.\" ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"\"These people are afraid not of the people, but of their superiors\"","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In January 1969, the self-immolation of Jan Palach, a philosophy student at Charles University, brought tens of thousands of people onto the streets and became a symbol of resistance to the Soviet occupation in Czechoslovakia. The self-immolation of street vendor Mohammed Bouazizi provoked mass protests in Tunisia, which eventually led to the resignation of the country's president. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In Russia, the self-immolations of journalist Irina Slavina and Udmurt scientist Albert Razin did not lead to any notable collective action. Could Okunev's suicide have provoked some protest if people had learned about it?","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Sociologist Margarita Zavadskaya thinks not. \"Self-immolation is a powerful symbolic act,\" she says, \"but public outrage alone is not enough to trigger large-scale collective action under conditions of severe repression and limited access to information.\" ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"So why did the Russian authorities try so hard to conceal information about what happened? To prevent \"protest contagion\" and imitation, she explains. Moreover, such an anti-war suicide contradicts the government's theory of a universal public consensus on war. And local officials would look incapable of maintaining control in the eyes of their superiors. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Political scientist Ekaterina Shulman also does not believe that fear of further protests was behind the Kaliningrad authorities' actions. \"Local authorities are not afraid of the people, not of protests. They are afraid of their superiors,\" she says, \"they were afraid to hear: 'You oversaw, allowed a scandal, there are media publications, what do you eat your bread for?'\"","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"\"Authoritarian regimes are afraid of symbolic sparks. They understand that a single act of protest may not cause an immediate mass movement, but can become a moral symbol around which scattered anxiety and discontent begin to crystallize,\" says Lithuanian political scientist Nerijus Malukiavicius. \"That is why such regimes seek to 'clean up' the scene, silence history, and discredit the victim.\"","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":9591,"header":"Vladimir Putin Fears an Assassination Attempt and a Coup, an EU Intelligence Agency Says","_path":"/en/stories/2026/05/04/vladimir-putin-fear/","lead":"Tensions among security services are rising, and security measures around the Russian president are strengthening","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-400x267px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-400x267px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-400x267px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-400x267px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":400,"for_height":267,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":400,"real_width_2x":800,"real_height_1x":267,"real_height_2x":534},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-300x200px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-300x200px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-300x200px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-300x200px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":300,"for_height":200,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":300,"real_width_2x":600,"real_height_1x":200,"real_height_2x":400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-200x133px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-200x133px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-200x133px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-200x133px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":200,"for_height":133,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/65caaaad2e1f4c4c8f01b93a3f6899a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":200,"real_width_2x":400,"real_height_1x":133,"real_height_2x":266}],"entry_image_credit":"Illustration: IStories. Images used: Ivan Sekretarev / AP Photo; Ramil Sitdikov / Reuters","created_at_date":"2026-05-04","created_at_date_time":"2026-05-03T15:17:13.336Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":5,"first_name":"Роман","last_name":"Анин","first_name_en":"Roman","last_name_en":"Anin","is_public":true,"_path":"roman-anin","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редактор «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Редактор","position_en":"Editor","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"IStories has obtained a report by an intelligence service of a European Union country on the real situation in the Kremlin and the condition of Vladimir Putin. The document was provided to us by a source close to the agency that compiled the report. The editorial team is publishing the text of this report because:\n\nit is of significant public interest;\nsome of the information it contains has been independently verified;\nthe source who provided the document holds an official position in the government of a European country and risks their reputation and career if the document is a deliberate disinformation campaign;\n\nHere is the text of the document.\n\n“The Kremlin on high alert\n\nSince the beginning of March 2026, the Kremlin and Vladimir Putin have been concerned about a leak of sensitive information and, at the same time, about the risk of a plot or coup attempt against the Russian president. In particular, he fears the use of drones for a possible assassination attempt by members of the Russian political elite.\n\nStrengthening security measures around the Russian president\n\nIn response, the Federal Protective Service (FSO), whose primary mission is to ensure the physical protection of the highest officials of the Russian state, has significantly tightened security measures around Vladimir Putin:\n\nVisitors to the Presidential Administration undergo two levels of screening, including a full body search by FSO officers.\nThe FSO has significantly reduced the list of locations regularly visited by the president; neither he nor his family visit their usual residences in the Moscow region and Valdai anymore.\nSince the beginning of the war in Ukraine, Putin has often taken refuge in renovated bunkers, particularly in the Krasnodar region, where he may work for weeks, while Russian media continue public communication using pre-recorded footage.\nNo visits to military infrastructure have been organized this year, in contrast to frequent trips in 2025.\nCommunication networks in certain districts of Moscow are periodically shut down.\nFSO officers conduct large-scale checks using canine units and are also deployed along the Moscow River, ready to respond to possible drone attacks.\nThe FSO now controls and approves any informational or media publication involving the president, relying on a secret presidential decree (apparently referring to announcements of Putin’s trips and participation in various events — Ed.)\nPersonnel working near Putin are now prohibited from using mobile phones; they must use devices without internet access.\nThese employees are also banned from using public transportation and move exclusively using FSO transport; surveillance systems have been installed in the homes of cooks, photographers, and bodyguards.\n\nSergei Shoigu considered a potential destabilizing actor\n\nSergei Shoigu, former Minister of Defense and Secretary of the Security Council of the Russian Federation since May 2024, who retains significant influence within the military command, is associated with the risk of a coup attempt.\n\nThe arrest of his former first deputy, Ruslan Tsalikov, on March 5, 2026, is seen as a violation of informal guarantees of safety for elites, weakening Shoigu’s position and increasing the likelihood that he himself may face criminal prosecution.\n\nRising tensions among security structures\n\nThe issue of the physical security of senior Russian Armed Forces officers has led to increased tensions among representatives of Russia’s security agencies.\nAfter the killing of Lieutenant General Fanil Sarvarov in Moscow on December 22, 2025, Chief of the General Staff Valery Gerasimov proposed that Vladimir Putin convene a meeting of the permanent members of the Security Council to discuss the situation. However, Putin chose to hold a smaller meeting on December 25, 2025, the day after another attack on Russian security officials at the same location as the killing of Sarvarov.\n\nDuring the meeting, representatives of the security agencies, the so-called “siloviki,” blamed one another for shortcomings in the security system revealed by Ukrainian attacks. Emphasizing that these attacks cause fear and disorganization within the ranks of the Russian Armed Forces, Valery Gerasimov sharply criticized his colleagues from the intelligence services for failing to anticipate them. The Chief of the General Staff also complained about a lack of personnel for the physical protection of officers in rear areas and drew the president’s attention to this issue.\n\nThe Director of the Federal Security Service, Alexander Bortnikov, in turn, defended himself by stressing the impossibility of systematically preventing such attacks. He criticized the Ministry of Defense for lacking a specialized unit responsible for the physical protection of top officials — similar to those in other security agencies.\n\nThe head of the National Guard, Viktor Zolotov, in turn, noted that the resources at his disposal cannot be allocated to protect officers of the Ministry of Defense. He also addressed operational security recommendations to Gerasimov for Ministry of Defense officers, which provoked the Chief of the General Staff’s anger.\n\nAt the end of this tense meeting, Vladimir Putin called for calm, proposing to change the format of the discussion. He instructed participants to submit their proposals for resolving the issues discussed within a week.\n\nExpansion of security measures for ten senior Russian generals\n\nAfter the meeting, Vladimir Putin met with Federal Protective Service Director Dmitry Kochnev, whose primary task is to ensure the physical security of top state officials. It was decided to amend the internal regulations of the FSO by expanding the list of individuals under its enhanced protection.\n\nPreviously, such protection applied only to Valery Gerasimov. Now it has been extended to ten senior generals, including three deputy chiefs of the General Staff. Vladimir Putin’s decision, made at the request of the General Staff, demonstrates the political weight of Valery Gerasimov, who succeeded in this “arbitration,” while other security agencies have so far failed to expand the FSO’s mandate in their interests.\n\nList of generals placed under FSO protection:\n\nColonel General Nikolai Bogdanovsky, First Deputy Chief of the General Staff;\nColonel General Sergey Istrakov, Deputy Chief of the General Staff;\nColonel General Alexey Kim, Deputy Chief of the General Staff;\nColonel General Sergey Rudskoy, Head of the Main Operational Directorate of the General Staff;\nColonel General Viktor Poznikhir, First Deputy Head of the Main Operational Directorate of the General Staff;\nLieutenant General Stanislav Gadzhimagomedov, Head of the National Defense Management Center (NDMC RF);\nAdmiral Igor Kostyukov, Head of the Main Intelligence Directorate (GRU);\nColonel General Vladimir Zarudnitsky, Head of the Military Academy of the General Staff;\nColonel General Alexander Chaiko;\nColonel General Mikhail Mizintsev.”\n\nWhat is independently confirmed\nSome of the information in this report is confirmed by independent sources. For example, that the large-scale internet shutdowns in Moscow are carried out by the FSO rather than the FSB, as reported by some media outlets, had been told to IStories a month earlier by a former FSB officer. However, we did not publish this at the time because we could not find a second source to confirm it. Now the same claim appears in the European intelligence report.\n\nSeveral sources of IStories also confirm the increased fear of Putin over a plot or coup attempt. This is evidenced not only by heightened security measures around the Kremlin and other locations visited by the Russian president, but also by some indirect signs.\n\nFor example, a current FSB officer told IStories that it has become much more difficult for his unit to obtain authorization for wiretapping in non-political criminal cases because “all equipment has been redirected to monitor the government and other state bodies.”\n\nThe extreme level of Putin’s fear of an assassination attempt or conspiracy is also indirectly indicated by the fact that this year not a single deputy of the State Duma received an invitation to the Victory Day parade on Red Square.\n\nWhy this report is one of the most important recent stories about Russia — read in an opinion by IStories founder Roman Anin.","blocks":[{"data":"IStories has obtained a report by an intelligence service of a European Union country on the real situation in the Kremlin and the condition of Vladimir Putin. The document was provided to us by a source close to the agency that compiled the report. The editorial team is publishing the text of this report because:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li>it is of significant public interest;</li><li>some of the information it contains has been independently verified;</li><li>the source who provided the document holds an official position in the government of a European country and risks their reputation and career if the document is a deliberate disinformation campaign;</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"Here is the text of the document.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“<strong>The Kremlin on high alert</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Since the beginning of March 2026, the Kremlin and Vladimir Putin have been concerned about a leak of sensitive information and, at the same time, about the risk of a plot or coup attempt against the Russian president. In particular, he fears the use of drones for a possible assassination attempt by members of the Russian political elite.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Strengthening security measures around the Russian president</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In response, the Federal Protective Service (FSO), whose primary mission is to ensure the physical protection of the highest officials of the Russian state, has significantly tightened security measures around Vladimir Putin:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li>Visitors to the Presidential Administration undergo two levels of screening, including a full body search by FSO officers.</li><li>The FSO has significantly reduced the list of locations regularly visited by the president; neither he nor his family visit their usual residences in the Moscow region and Valdai anymore.</li><li>Since the beginning of the war in Ukraine, Putin has often taken refuge in renovated bunkers, particularly in the Krasnodar region, where he may work for weeks, while Russian media continue public communication using pre-recorded footage.</li><li>No visits to military infrastructure have been organized this year, in contrast to frequent trips in 2025.</li><li>Communication networks in certain districts of Moscow are periodically shut down.</li><li>FSO officers conduct large-scale checks using canine units and are also deployed along the Moscow River, ready to respond to possible drone attacks.</li><li>The FSO now controls and approves any informational or media publication involving the president, relying on a secret presidential decree <em>(apparently referring to announcements of Putin’s trips and participation in various events — Ed.)</em></li><li>Personnel working near Putin are now prohibited from using mobile phones; they must use devices without internet access.</li><li>These employees are also banned from using public transportation and move exclusively using FSO transport; surveillance systems have been installed in the homes of cooks, photographers, and bodyguards.</li><li><br></li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Sergei Shoigu considered a potential destabilizing actor</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Sergei Shoigu, former Minister of Defense and Secretary of the Security Council of the Russian Federation since May 2024, who retains significant influence within the military command, is associated with the risk of a coup attempt.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The arrest of his former first deputy, Ruslan Tsalikov, on March 5, 2026, is seen as a violation of informal guarantees of safety for elites, weakening Shoigu’s position and increasing the likelihood that he himself may face criminal prosecution.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Rising tensions among security structures</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The issue of the physical security of senior Russian Armed Forces officers has led to increased tensions among representatives of Russia’s security agencies.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18141,"data":{"text":"We can’t survive without your support","title":"Help us keep telling important stories","buttonText":"Donate"},"category":"donate-embed"},"type":"donate-embed"},{"data":"After the killing of Lieutenant General Fanil Sarvarov in Moscow on December 22, 2025, Chief of the General Staff Valery Gerasimov proposed that Vladimir Putin convene a meeting of the permanent members of the Security Council to discuss the situation. However, Putin chose to hold a smaller meeting on December 25, 2025, the day after another attack on Russian security officials at the same location as the killing of Sarvarov.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"During the meeting, representatives of the security agencies, the so-called “siloviki,” blamed one another for shortcomings in the security system revealed by Ukrainian attacks. Emphasizing that these attacks cause fear and disorganization within the ranks of the Russian Armed Forces, Valery Gerasimov sharply criticized his colleagues from the intelligence services for failing to anticipate them. The Chief of the General Staff also complained about a lack of personnel for the physical protection of officers in rear areas and drew the president’s attention to this issue.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Director of the Federal Security Service, Alexander Bortnikov, in turn, defended himself by stressing the impossibility of systematically preventing such attacks. He criticized the Ministry of Defense for lacking a specialized unit responsible for the physical protection of top officials — similar to those in other security agencies.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The head of the National Guard, Viktor Zolotov, in turn, noted that the resources at his disposal cannot be allocated to protect officers of the Ministry of Defense. He also addressed operational security recommendations to Gerasimov for Ministry of Defense officers, which provoked the Chief of the General Staff’s anger.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At the end of this tense meeting, Vladimir Putin called for calm, proposing to change the format of the discussion. He instructed participants to submit their proposals for resolving the issues discussed within a week.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Expansion of security measures for ten senior Russian generals</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"After the meeting, Vladimir Putin met with Federal Protective Service Director Dmitry Kochnev, whose primary task is to ensure the physical security of top state officials. It was decided to amend the internal regulations of the FSO by expanding the list of individuals under its enhanced protection.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Previously, such protection applied only to Valery Gerasimov. Now it has been extended to ten senior generals, including three deputy chiefs of the General Staff. Vladimir Putin’s decision, made at the request of the General Staff, demonstrates the political weight of Valery Gerasimov, who succeeded in this “arbitration,” while other security agencies have so far failed to expand the FSO’s mandate in their interests.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"List of generals placed under FSO protection:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li>Colonel General Nikolai Bogdanovsky, First Deputy Chief of the General Staff;</li><li>Colonel General Sergey Istrakov, Deputy Chief of the General Staff;</li><li>Colonel General Alexey Kim, Deputy Chief of the General Staff;</li><li>Colonel General Sergey Rudskoy, Head of the Main Operational Directorate of the General Staff;</li><li>Colonel General Viktor Poznikhir, First Deputy Head of the Main Operational Directorate of the General Staff;</li><li>Lieutenant General Stanislav Gadzhimagomedov, Head of the National Defense Management Center (NDMC RF);</li><li>Admiral Igor Kostyukov, Head of the Main Intelligence Directorate (GRU);</li><li>Colonel General Vladimir Zarudnitsky, Head of the Military Academy of the General Staff;</li><li>Colonel General Alexander Chaiko;</li><li>Colonel General Mikhail Mizintsev.”</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"<strong>What is independently confirmed</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Some of the information in this report is confirmed by independent sources. For example, that the large-scale internet shutdowns in Moscow are carried out by the FSO rather than the FSB, as reported by some media outlets, had been told to IStories a month earlier by a former FSB officer. However, we did not publish this at the time because we could not find a second source to confirm it. Now the same claim appears in the European intelligence report.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Several sources of IStories also confirm the increased fear of Putin over a plot or coup attempt. This is evidenced not only by heightened security measures around the Kremlin and other locations visited by the Russian president, but also by some indirect signs.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For example, a current FSB officer told IStories that it has become much more difficult for his unit to obtain authorization for wiretapping in non-political criminal cases because “all equipment has been redirected to monitor the government and other state bodies.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The extreme level of Putin’s fear of an assassination attempt or conspiracy is also indirectly indicated by the fact that this year not a single deputy of the State Duma received an invitation to the Victory Day parade on Red Square.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Why this report is one of the most important recent stories about Russia — <a href=\"https://istories.media/en/opinions/2026/05/04/russia-has-two-paths-left/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">read in an opinion</a> by IStories founder Roman Anin.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":9532,"header":"Might Belarus Join Russia in the War?","_path":"/en/stories/2026/04/22/might-belarus-join-russia-in-the-war/","lead":"Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has stated Russia is once again attempting to drag Belarus into the war. Is it possible? How could it look and how would it affect Ukraine?","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-original.png","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-original.png","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-original.png","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-original.png","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-original.png","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-original.png","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-original.png","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff2b77030bc4996aaf4c034df54cb1d-original.png","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Ukraine and Belarus leaders in 2019. Today, Zelenskyy warns Lukashenko against joining the war referring to Nicolás Maduro’s destiny. Photo: Press office of the President of Ukraine","created_at_date":"2026-04-22","created_at_date_time":"2026-04-21T20:08:53.872Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":2517,"last_name":"","first_name":"Редакция","last_name_en":"","first_name_en":"Editors","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"“According to intelligence, the construction of roads toward Ukrainian territory and the development of artillery positions are underway in the Belarusian border areas. We believe that Russia may once again attempt to drag Belarus into its war,” Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy stated last week.\nZelenskyy did not specify what exactly could be the goal of this process, but there are two main scenarios:\n\nEither the Belarusian army itself joins Russia in the aggression and invades Ukraine;\nOr, just like it was in 2022, Belarus provides the Russian army with a foothold for invading Ukraine from the north.\n\nIStories have requested experts to comment on how probable each scenario is. \n\nMilitary construction at the borderlands and its relevance\nSoon after Zelenskyy’s statement, eRadar, a Ukrainian war analytics Telegram channel, published some of the satellite images taken in March in the border regions of Belarus. As reported by the channel, the pictures show a new border post, a military town, a training ground, a dam and an embankment to move military vehicles being built there. “It seems Belarus has indeed been tasked by Russia to keep our forces on alert ahead of their spring-summer offensive in the east and south,” Andriy Kovalenko, head of Ukraine’s Center for Countering Disinformation, commented.\nHowever, there has been no observed buildup of Belarusian or Russian troops near the border, Andriy Demchenko, Ukraine’s State Border Guard Service spokesperson, said on Monday. “As part of their information campaign, they (the Belarusians — Ed.) previously announced the creation of a Southern Operational Command — specifically along the border with Ukraine. The positions, training grounds, and access roads might be established within this framework,” Demchenko explained.\nConflict Intelligence Team (CIT) (an OSINT project specialized in investigations into the activities of Russian Armed Forces — Ed.) suggests that the construction works are routine military activity and do not indicate preparations for a ground invasion of Ukraine. A source within CIT asked to remain anonymous comments, “we are not seeing artillery positions being set up or military vehicles concentrated.”\nIn recent years, Belarus has had little direct involvement in hostilities against Ukraine. The most recent known case involves repeaters used to control attack drones located on Belarusian territory.\nIn late December, Zelenskyy reported that antennas had been installed in Belarus near the Ukrainian border, some of them on the roofs of apartment buildings, which Russians were using to control drones attacking western regions of Ukraine. Two months later, Ukrainian Defense Minister Mykhailo Fedorov reported that a mesh network used to control the attacking UAVs in the north of Ukraine has been destroyed. Fedorov’s advisor, Serhii Beskrestnov, explained that there had been several locations in Belarus from which the drones would receive a signal they then retransmitted and amplified to one another (this is what constitutes a mesh network). The Ukrainian military did not specify how the Belarusian repeaters were destroyed. Since then, there have been no reports of their use.\nOtherwise, Belarus’s military assistance to Russia can be described as less direct: it is wounded Russian soldiers' treatment and rehabilitation, military equipment parts production, combat helicopter maintenance, weapon parts supply chains that allow Russians circumvent the sanctions, etc.\n\nMay the Belarusian army join the fight itself?\n“We estimate the prospect of the Belarusian Armed Forces joining the war as highly improbable,” the CIT expert says. He mentioned several reasons.\nBelarusian army capabilities. According to Belarusian dictator Alexander Lukashenko, there are currently 70,000 active-duty soldiers. The total is around 100,000 if the Internal Troops of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and certain other units are included. However, analysts’ estimates are more modest. According to the Global Military project, there are about 45,000 troops in the Belarusian army, while Latvian intelligence puts the figure at approximately 50,000. Taking civilian staff into account, the 70,000 figure cited by Lukashenko is quite realistic. At the same time, Russia has about 700,000 personnel “in the special military operation zone,” as Vladimir Putin claimed in December.\nThe combat readiness of the Belarusian army is also questionable. “It’s important to understand that the number of truly combat-ready units is measured in the thousands,” explains the CIT analyst. According to him, without a mobilization — which CIT considers impossible to happen — the Belarusian army will be unable to influence the course of hostilities in any way.\nLukashenko says that “in the event of war” and mobilization, he could expand the army to 500,000 troops. The opposition United Transitional Cabinet of Belarus believes that the army could be expanded to 140,000–200,000 troops at best through mobilization, and that number would include the Internal Troops of the Ministry of Internal Affairs. “Half a million, it seems to me, is just a mantra used for self-reassurance, or perhaps for intimidating neighbors,” says Vadzim Kabanchuk, representative of the defence committee within the Belarusian opposition. Besides, it would have to be figured out how to equip, accommodate, and train such a large number of recruits.\nIn terms of weapons and military equipment, Belarus has little to offer the Russian army. Most of its arsenal was inherited from the Soviet Union. During the war, these stocks may have been depleted: there is evidence of mothballed equipment having been transferred from Belarus to the Russia-occupied territories of Ukraine. At the start of the war, the Belarusian prime minister acknowledged that in Russia there was demand for weapons from Belarus.\nThe main achievement of the Belarusian defense industry since the end of the Soviet era is considered to be the Polonez multiple-launch rocket system, capable of hitting targets at a distance of up to 300 km. However the Belarusian army has few Polonez systems (estimated at six units as of 2022). Secondly, the Russian army possesses some significantly more powerful and longer-range weapons, such as the Iskander systems.\nUkraine’s preparedness. “If we were to go to war against Ukraine today, it would be pointless. Their border with Belarus is so heavily fortified that it’s impossible to approach it,” Belarus President Lukashenko said two years ago. According to Lukashenko, the Ukrainian Armed Forces have about 120,000 troops stationed along the Belarus border. However, the Belarusian Border Committee estimates the number of Ukrainian troops at the border as only 15,000.\nUkrainians, understandably, do not disclose the number of their troops at the border, but regularly report on new fortifications being built along the border.\nAnother significant factor is Ukraine’s ability to monitor troop and equipment movements. If the Belarusian army does begin to redeploy its units to the border, the Ukrainian Armed Forces will have the opportunity to send their own units there in advance and set up a \"drone wall” Ukrainians used in 2026 to successfully slow down the Russian army’s advance.\nBelarusian people oppose taking part in the war. The army likely does as well. Recent polls (in October and November) show that the majority of Belarusians don’t support the Russian invasion of Ukraine. At the same time, a significant proportion (34–39%) chose not to answer the question. As for ending the war, more than 60% of respondents support an immediate ceasefire and negotiations.\nThe military isn’t eager to go to war either, according to the Belarusian opposition estimates. “The soldiers themselves lack the motivation — they need to be explained why they should invade and occupy a foreign country. There is no political ideology for that,” activist Ilya Dobrotvor, says. “In 2022, when the full-scale war began, it was the hesitation within the Belarusian army that effectively prevented Lukashenko from issuing an order for them to enter [Ukrainian territory] alongside the Russians,” Vadzim Kabanchuk from the United Transitional Cabinet says.\n“Overall, Lukashenko is well aware that dragging Belarus into the war against Ukraine — let alone the hostilities on Belarus territory — would practically be a death sentence for him. Because there is public consensus on the idea he himself has been selling the idea to Belarusians in recent years : ‘I have ensured you peace, you are not fighting,’” Artsiom Brukhan, speaker of the Belarusian opposition Coordination Council, says.\n\nIs Russia going to attack Ukraine from Belarus?\nIf Russians decide to attack Ukraine from Belarus using their own army like they did in 2022, they won't be able to expect to break through to the outskirts of Kyiv again. In 2026, the plausible objectives of another invasion from Belarus could be to stretch the front line and draw Ukrainian forces away from other sectors.\nHowever, the Russian army currently significantly lacks the required resources, says the anonymous CIT analyst. “Such an operation would require at least several combined-arms armies. But then they would have to be withdrawn from the current front line, seriously weakening certain sectors,” the expert says. As of now, CIT has not detected Russian units being deployed to Belarus.\nThe State Border Service of Ukraine believes that Russia currently has no forces in Belarus that would be capable of carrying out a second invasion. \nHowever, Ukrainians do not rule out Russian provocations aimed at distracting Ukrainian forces units from other parts of the front. CIT believes that the Russian Armed Forces are already attempting to stretch the front by creating a “buffer zone” in the Sumy and Kharkiv regions. So far it has not been very successful, says the CIT expert: the Ukrainian Armed Forces withdrawing from border villages block the Russians’ advance deeper into the country. Moreover, the Ukrainians manage to do this without deploying reinforcements — mainly by the forces of territorial defense brigades.\n\nWhy is the threat from Belarus discussed now?\nZelensky has pointed out Russia’s attempts to make Belarus a bigger threat many times throughout the war. Here are the reasons why the President might be mentioning this possibility now, according to Anton Naumluck, a Russian journalist who had worked in Ukraine for many years and founded the Graty magazine.\n“We cannot dismiss the possibility of Ukrainian intelligence learning that the Belarusian government is actually planning to take a bigger part in the war,” Naumluck says. “No matter what’s being said about Belarusians opposing the war, Lukashenko might simply decide that the people will tolerate any decision.”\nOn the other hand, the journalist thinks, “if the Office of the President of Ukraine is already thinking about the future electoral campaign, the threat of a new invasion might make people come to terms with such internal problems as forced mobilization or corruption.”\nAnother plausible explanation for speaking about the possible threat is Zelenskyy’s team “trying to strengthen the dialogue with the Belarusian opposition [Sviatlana Tsikhanouskaya and her Office],” Naumluck says.","blocks":[{"data":"“According to intelligence, the construction of roads toward Ukrainian territory and the development of artillery positions are underway in the Belarusian border areas. We believe that Russia may once again attempt to drag Belarus into its war,” Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy <a href=\"https://x.com/ZelenskyyUa/status/2045177152379781261\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">stated</a> last week.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Zelenskyy did not specify what exactly could be the goal of this process, but there are two main scenarios:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<li>Either the Belarusian army itself joins Russia in the aggression and invades Ukraine;</li><li>Or, just like it was in 2022, Belarus provides the Russian army with a foothold for invading Ukraine from the north.</li>","type":"ul","className":""},{"data":"IStories have requested experts to comment on how probable each scenario is.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Military construction at the borderlands and its relevance","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Soon after Zelenskyy’s statement, eRadar, a Ukrainian war analytics Telegram channel, <a href=\"https://t.me/eRadarrua/88551\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">published </a>some of the satellite images taken in March in the border regions of Belarus. As reported by the channel, the pictures show a new border post, a military town, a training ground, a dam and an embankment to move military vehicles being built there. “It seems Belarus has indeed been tasked by Russia to keep our forces on alert ahead of their spring-summer offensive in the east and south,” Andriy Kovalenko, head of Ukraine’s Center for Countering Disinformation, <a href=\"https://t.me/akovalenko1989/10642\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">commented</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, there has been no observed buildup of Belarusian or Russian troops near the border, Andriy Demchenko, Ukraine’s State Border Guard Service spokesperson, <a href=\"https://www.ukrinform.ua/rubric-ato/4114505-u-bilorusi-nemae-peremisenna-tehniki-abo-pidtagnenna-vijsk-do-kordonu-demcenko.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">said </a>on Monday. “As part of their information campaign, they (the Belarusians — Ed.) previously <a href=\"https://belta.by/president/view/v-belorusskoj-armii-planirujut-sozdat-juzhnoe-operativnoe-komandovanie-504280-2022/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">announced </a>the creation of a Southern Operational Command — specifically along the border with Ukraine. The positions, training grounds, and access roads might be established within this framework,” Demchenko explained.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Conflict Intelligence Team (CIT) (an OSINT project specialized in investigations into the activities of Russian Armed Forces — Ed.) suggests that the construction works are routine military activity and do not indicate preparations for a ground invasion of Ukraine. A source within CIT asked to remain anonymous comments, “we are not seeing artillery positions being set up or military vehicles concentrated.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In recent years, Belarus has had little direct involvement in hostilities against Ukraine. The most recent known case involves repeaters used to control attack drones located on Belarusian territory.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18089,"data":{"text":"We can’t survive without your support","title":"Help us keep telling important stories","buttonText":"Donate"},"category":"donate-embed"},"type":"donate-embed"},{"data":"In late December, Zelenskyy <a href=\"https://t.me/V_Zelenskiy_official/17448\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reported </a>that antennas had been installed in Belarus near the Ukrainian border, some of them on the roofs of apartment buildings, which Russians were using to control drones attacking western regions of Ukraine. Two months later, Ukrainian Defense Minister Mykhailo Fedorov <a href=\"https://www.pravda.com.ua/rus/news/2026/02/27/8023062/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reported </a>that a mesh network used to control the attacking UAVs in the north of Ukraine has been destroyed. Fedorov’s advisor, Serhii Beskrestnov, <a href=\"https://t.me/serhii_flash/7002\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">explained </a>that there had been several locations in Belarus from which the drones would receive a signal they then retransmitted and amplified to one another (this is what constitutes a mesh network). The Ukrainian military did not specify how the Belarusian repeaters were destroyed. Since then, there have been no reports of their use.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Otherwise, Belarus’s military assistance to Russia can be described as less direct: it is wounded Russian soldiers' <a href=\"https://investigatebel.org/ru/investigations/sekretnye-pacienty-rossii-v-belarusi\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">treatment </a>and <a href=\"https://investigatebel.org/ru/investigations/belarus-sanatoriums-russian-war-veterans\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">rehabilitation</a>, military equipment parts <a href=\"https://militarnyi.com/uk/news/bilorus-z-2024-roku-postachae-rosii-shasi-mzkt-dlya-novoi-versii-pantsir/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">production</a>, combat helicopter <a href=\"https://news.obozrevatel.com/abroad/v-belarusi-remontiruyut-rossijskie-vertoletyi-mi-8-i-mi-17-obnarodovanyi-dokazatelstva.htm\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">maintenance</a>, weapon parts <a href=\"https://investigatebel.org/ru/investigations/zapadnye-mikroshemy-v-rossii-cherez-belarus\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">supply chains</a> that allow Russians circumvent the sanctions, etc.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"May the Belarusian army join the fight itself?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"“We estimate the prospect of the Belarusian Armed Forces joining the war as highly improbable,” the CIT expert says. He mentioned several reasons.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Belarusian army capabilities. </strong><a href=\"https://belta.by/president/view/lukashenko-belarus-v-sluchae-vojny-mozhet-narastit-chislennost-vojsk-do-polumilliona-773113-2026/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">According </a>to Belarusian dictator Alexander Lukashenko, there are currently 70,000 active-duty soldiers. The total is around 100,000 if the Internal Troops of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and certain other units are included. However, analysts’ estimates are more modest. According to the Global Military project, there are about <a href=\"https://www.globalmilitary.net/countries/blr/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">45,000</a> troops in the Belarusian army, while Latvian intelligence puts the figure at <a href=\"https://news.inbox.lv/1502rvc-how-dangerous-is-the-belarusian-army-conclusions-of-latvian-intelligence?language=ru&amp;persist_language=1\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">approximately 50,000.</a> Taking civilian staff into account, the 70,000 figure cited by Lukashenko is quite realistic. At the same time, Russia has about 700,000 personnel “in the special military operation zone,” as Vladimir Putin <a href=\"https://www.interfax.ru/russia/1064213\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">claimed </a>in December.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The combat readiness of the Belarusian army is also questionable. “It’s important to understand that the number of truly combat-ready units is measured in the thousands,” explains the CIT analyst. According to him, without a mobilization — which CIT considers impossible to happen — the Belarusian army will be unable to influence the course of hostilities in any way.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18088,"data":{"url":"https://t.me/Crimeanwind/44809","caption":"Alexander Lukashenko visiting a Belarusian Ministry of Defense training center, October 2023","initialHeight":"787px"},"category":"telegram-embed"},"type":"telegram-embed"},{"data":"Lukashenko <a href=\"https://belta.by/president/view/lukashenko-belarus-v-sluchae-vojny-mozhet-narastit-chislennost-vojsk-do-polumilliona-773113-2026/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">says </a>that “in the event of war” and mobilization, he could expand the army to 500,000 troops. The opposition United Transitional Cabinet of Belarus believes that the army could be expanded to 140,000–200,000 troops at best through mobilization, and that number would include the Internal Troops of the Ministry of Internal Affairs. “Half a million, it seems to me, is just a mantra used for self-reassurance, or perhaps for intimidating neighbors,” <a href=\"https://ru.belsat.eu/92424694/kabanchuk-o-zayavleniyah-lukashenko\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">says </a>Vadzim Kabanchuk, representative of the defence committee within the Belarusian opposition. Besides, it would have to be figured out how to equip, accommodate, and train such a large number of recruits.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In terms of weapons and military equipment, Belarus has little to offer the Russian army. Most of its arsenal was inherited from the Soviet Union. During the war, these stocks may have been depleted: there is <a href=\"https://www.dw.com/ru/voennye-rf-i-tanki-na-belorusskoj-zeleznoj-doroge-cto-izvestno/a-63512203\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">evidence </a>of mothballed equipment having been transferred from Belarus to the Russia-occupied territories of Ukraine. At the start of the war, the Belarusian prime minister <a href=\"https://www.svaboda.org/a/31866688.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">acknowledged </a>that in Russia there was demand for weapons from Belarus.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The main achievement of the Belarusian defense industry since the end of the Soviet era is <a href=\"https://www.iiss.org/online-analysis/online-analysis/2022/07/the-credibility-and-implications-of-russias-missile-and-nuclear-proposal-to-belarus/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">considered </a>to be the Polonez multiple-launch rocket system, capable of hitting targets at a distance of up to 300 km. However the Belarusian army has few Polonez systems (estimated at <a href=\"https://www.iiss.org/online-analysis/online-analysis/2022/07/the-credibility-and-implications-of-russias-missile-and-nuclear-proposal-to-belarus/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">six units</a> as of 2022). Secondly, the Russian army possesses some significantly more powerful and longer-range weapons, such as the Iskander systems.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Ukraine’s preparedness.</strong> “If we were to go to war against Ukraine today, it would be pointless. Their border with Belarus is so heavily fortified that it’s impossible to approach it,” Belarus President Lukashenko <a href=\"https://t.me/zarubinreporter/2383\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">said </a>two years ago. According to Lukashenko, the Ukrainian Armed Forces have about 120,000 troops stationed along the Belarus border. However, the Belarusian Border Committee <a href=\"https://tass.ru/mezhdunarodnaya-panorama/22992759\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">estimates </a>the number of Ukrainian troops at the border as only 15,000.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Ukrainians, understandably, do not disclose the number of their troops at the border, but <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ua/ukr/news/ukrayina-posilyue-bezpeku-kordonu-zokrema-1736350579.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">regularly </a><a href=\"https://www.pravda.com.ua/rus/news/2026/04/20/8030938/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">report </a>on new fortifications being built along the border.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Another significant factor is Ukraine’s ability to monitor troop and equipment movements. If the Belarusian army does begin to redeploy its units to the border, the Ukrainian Armed Forces will have the opportunity to send their own units there in advance and set up a \"drone wall” Ukrainians used in 2026 to successfully <a href=\"https://understandingwar.org/research/russia-ukraine/russian-offensive-campaign-assessment-april-4-2026/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">slow down</a> the Russian army’s advance.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Belarusian people oppose taking part in the war. The army likely does as well. </strong>Recent polls (in <a href=\"https://isans.org/ru/sociological-research/rezultaty-5-volny-monitoringovogo-issledovaniya-obshhestvennogo-mneniya-isans.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">October</a> and <a href=\"https://drive.google.com/file/d/1K9gZOl9R_TA14pjXtn3JLHm0J_yGRmv2/view\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">November</a>) show that the majority of Belarusians don’t support the Russian invasion of Ukraine. At the same time, a significant proportion (34–39%) chose not to answer the question. As for ending the war, more than 60% of respondents support an immediate ceasefire and negotiations.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The military isn’t eager to go to war either, according to the Belarusian opposition estimates. “The soldiers themselves lack the motivation — they need to be explained why they should invade and occupy a foreign country. There is no political ideology for that,” activist Ilya Dobrotvor, <a href=\"https://24tv.ua/geopolitics/ru/belarus-gotovitsja-k-vojne-chto-stoit-za-zajavlenijami-lukashenko_n3042918\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">says</a>. “In 2022, when the full-scale war began, it was the hesitation within the Belarusian army that effectively prevented Lukashenko from issuing an order for them to enter [Ukrainian territory] alongside the Russians,” Vadzim Kabanchuk from the United Transitional Cabinet <a href=\"https://ru.belsat.eu/92424694/kabanchuk-o-zayavleniyah-lukashenko\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">says</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18091,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Belarusian Ministry of Defense Instagram","caption":"Belarusian military personnel removing snow after a heavy snowfall","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a402ae81b194f529db5afa4c30e4d9e-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a402ae81b194f529db5afa4c30e4d9e-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a402ae81b194f529db5afa4c30e4d9e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1070,"real_width_2x":1070,"real_height_1x":768,"real_height_2x":768},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a402ae81b194f529db5afa4c30e4d9e-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a402ae81b194f529db5afa4c30e4d9e-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a402ae81b194f529db5afa4c30e4d9e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1070,"real_width_2x":1070,"real_height_1x":768,"real_height_2x":768},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a402ae81b194f529db5afa4c30e4d9e-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a402ae81b194f529db5afa4c30e4d9e-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a402ae81b194f529db5afa4c30e4d9e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1070,"real_width_2x":1070,"real_height_1x":768,"real_height_2x":768},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a402ae81b194f529db5afa4c30e4d9e-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a402ae81b194f529db5afa4c30e4d9e-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a402ae81b194f529db5afa4c30e4d9e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1070,"real_width_2x":1070,"real_height_1x":768,"real_height_2x":768},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a402ae81b194f529db5afa4c30e4d9e-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a402ae81b194f529db5afa4c30e4d9e-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a402ae81b194f529db5afa4c30e4d9e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":297,"real_height_2x":595},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a402ae81b194f529db5afa4c30e4d9e-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a402ae81b194f529db5afa4c30e4d9e-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a402ae81b194f529db5afa4c30e4d9e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":297,"real_height_2x":595}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"“Overall, Lukashenko is well aware that dragging Belarus into the war against Ukraine — let alone the hostilities on Belarus territory — would practically be a death sentence for him. Because there is public consensus on the idea he himself has been selling the idea to Belarusians in recent years : ‘I have ensured you peace, you are not fighting,’” Artsiom Brukhan, speaker of the Belarusian opposition Coordination Council, <a href=\"https://uatv.ua/eto-budet-krah-dlya-vlasti-lukashenko-eksperty-o-vozmozhnom-vstuplenii-belorusskoj-armii-v-vojnu-protiv-ukrainy/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">says</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Is Russia going to attack Ukraine from Belarus?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"If Russians decide to attack Ukraine from Belarus using their own army like they did in 2022, they won't be able to expect to break through to the outskirts of Kyiv again. In 2026, the plausible objectives of another invasion from Belarus could be to stretch the front line and draw Ukrainian forces away from other sectors.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, the Russian army currently significantly lacks the required resources, says the anonymous CIT analyst. “Such an operation would require at least several combined-arms armies. But then they would have to be withdrawn from the current front line, seriously weakening certain sectors,” the expert says. As of now, CIT has not detected Russian units being deployed to Belarus.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The State Border Service of Ukraine <a href=\"https://www.ukrinform.ua/rubric-ato/4114505-u-bilorusi-nemae-peremisenna-tehniki-abo-pidtagnenna-vijsk-do-kordonu-demcenko.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">believes </a>that Russia currently has no forces in Belarus that would be capable of carrying out a second invasion.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, Ukrainians do not rule out Russian provocations aimed at distracting Ukrainian forces units from other parts of the front. CIT believes that the Russian Armed Forces are already attempting to stretch the front by creating a “buffer zone” in the Sumy and Kharkiv regions. So far it has not been very successful, says the CIT expert: the Ukrainian Armed Forces withdrawing from border villages block the Russians’ advance deeper into the country. Moreover, the Ukrainians manage to do this without deploying reinforcements — mainly by the forces of territorial defense brigades.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Why is the threat from Belarus discussed now?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Zelensky has pointed out Russia’s attempts to make Belarus a bigger threat&nbsp;<a href=\"https://www.pravda.com.ua/rus/news/2023/01/11/7384389/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">many</a> <a href=\"https://www.unian.ua/war/bilorus-u-viyni-proti-ukrajini-putin-zbirayetsya-vtyagnuti-shche-odnu-krajinu-u-konflikt-12907047.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">times</a> <a href=\"https://www.ukrinform.ua/rubric-ato/4088778-zelenskij-e-riziki-vtaguvanna-bilorusi-u-vijnu.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">throughout</a> the war. Here are the reasons why the President might be mentioning this possibility now, according to Anton Naumluck, a Russian journalist who had worked in Ukraine for many years and founded the Graty magazine.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“We cannot dismiss the possibility of Ukrainian intelligence learning that the Belarusian government is actually planning to take a bigger part in the war,” Naumluck says. “No matter what’s being said about Belarusians opposing the war, Lukashenko might simply decide that the people will tolerate any decision.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"On the other hand, the journalist thinks, “if the Office of the President of Ukraine is already thinking about the future electoral campaign, the threat of a new invasion might make people come to terms with such internal problems as forced mobilization or corruption.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Another plausible explanation for speaking about the possible threat is Zelenskyy’s team “trying to strengthen the dialogue with the Belarusian opposition [Sviatlana Tsikhanouskaya and her Office],” Naumluck says.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":9484,"header":"New Reforms Will Leave Some Areas of Russia without Internet, Internet Providers Warn","_path":"/en/stories/2026/04/14/new-reforms-will-leave-some-areas-of-russia-without-internet/","lead":"Essentially, only the state-run internet will remain in the whole country","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-original.png","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-original.png","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-original.png","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-original.png","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-original.png","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-original.png","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-original.png","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0394610d973b4b06a178eeafc082afef-original.png","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Illustration: IStories; photo: SeventyFour Images / Alamy","created_at_date":"2026-04-14","created_at_date_time":"2026-04-15T14:57:41.741Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":60,"first_name":"Анастасия","last_name":"Мереняшева","first_name_en":"Anastasiya","last_name_en":"Merenyasheva","is_public":true,"_path":"anastasiya-merenyasheva","avatar":[],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":1}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"The Association of Small Telecom Operators of the Regions of Russia (AMOR) has sent a letter to Vladimir Putin, Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin, and Prosecutor General Alexander Gutsan demanding that they abandon the Internet service provider market reform recently proposed by the Russian Ministry of Digital Development. A copy of the letter is at the disposal of IStories, and its authenticity has been confirmed by market sources.\nThe association members requested a legal, prosecutorial, and antitrust examination of the initiatives as well as postponing their adoption and investigating the Ministry of Digital Development’s activities to ensure the anti-corruption legislation compliance.\n\nThe initiatives\nLast week, it was reported that the Ministry of Digital Development is discussing toughening the licensing rules for Russian Internet providers. Essentially, this will result in a total elimination of small and medium-sized providers. As a result, only the state-controlled telecom companies will remain on the market.\nThe ministry wants to introduce three new types of licenses, with a cost ranging from 1 to 50 million rubles (from $13,000 to $665,000 approx.), which will not be issued to individual entrepreneurs.\nThe Ministry of Digital Development also wants to start revoking the providers’ licenses for repeated “major violations” and to introduce a 10-year ban on licensing the beneficiaries of the offending companies.\nIn addition, a minimum amount requirement for the providers' authorized capital will be established, ranging from 5 to 100 million rubles (depending on the type of license).\nThe Ministry of Digital Development stated that the proposals “have been received positively by the industry.” According to officials, their goal is to ensure that only the “reliable operators” remain as well as \"to guarantee effective compliance with the law\".\nEarlier, the digital development minister Maksut Shadayev had claimed regional Internet providers were failing to comply with the obligatory installation of the TPSU tools (traffic filtering tools used by Roskomnadzor, Russia’s executive body responsible for censoring media, telecommunications, and internet content — Ed.) and the SORM system (interception interfaces used for surveillance — Ed.).\nAs part of this reform, the Ministry of Digital Development also plans to lift the moratorium on telcos inspections, which was set to last until 2030, RBC Russia reported. The sources explained that the moratorium is making it hard for authorities to verify whether the companies have installed the SORM system.\n\nThe companies reaction\nThe AMOR association has demanded that the Ministry of Digital Development be tasked with developing alternative mechanisms for modernizing the telecommunications sector which “would enable the government to achieve its objectives without destroying small and regional telecom businesses,” and has requested that its representatives be included in the process.\nNot only will the reforms hinder the operations of small and regional telecom businesses, but will make them impossible, AMOR claims.\n\nConsequences: from unemployment to price growth\nAccording to the AMOR letter, the total number of employees of all the Russian telecom companies whose annual revenue amounts to 50 million rubles ($665,000 approx) and below is 15,200 people. The companies generating 50 to 500 million rubles ($665,000 and $7 million approx.) in revenue employ 21,800 people in the country. Therefore, tens of thousands of telecom industry employees might suddenly find themselves out of work.\n\n\nOther consequences will include Internet cost growth. It is difficult to say precisely how much the prices will change, the telco sources interviewed by IStories say.\n“I think the costs could change dramatically, even outrageously, since there won’t be any competition even in the long run,” says one of the Moscow oblast providers' owners.\nIn addition, the Ministry of Digital Development’s proposal could potentially leave some people without Internet at all, because major players haven’t entered some areas due to unprofitability, AMOR points out.\n“The regional and municipal providers will suffer the most, especially those operating in the private housing areas and places where the requirements tied to the coverage rate of apartment buildings are basically impossible to meet,” the statement says.\nThis will cause the providers who have historically ensured Internet access in remote villages, hard-to-reach areas, and rural communities to quit , the association asserts. \n“The simultaneous layoff of tens of thousands of workers, the price growth and declining service quality will inevitably lead to increased social tension at the time when stability is the absolute priority for the state,” AMOR notes.\nIn addition, the reforms will negatively impact equipment suppliers and manufacturers, television service providers and broadcasters as well as software developers for billing, video surveillance and intercom systems, and so on. \n“Less independent providers means less customers, deployments and growth opportunities for the entire ecosystem. This means less orders, investments, and jobs far beyond the telecommunications industry. Additionally, it will lower the demand for Russian hardware and software,” the letter reads.\nAn AMOR source interviewed by IStories considers there is no ground for claiming that the independent providers are ignoring the requirements regarding the SORM and TSPU systems.\nHe notes that the FSB (Russian Federal Security Service — Ed.) frequently imposes massive fines on the non-compliant providers, including the numerous subsidiaries of major providers. A Leningrad oblast provider owner IStories have spoken to also confirms that the regulations are strict.\n“It’s practically impossible to avoid setting the TSPU, and doing so would be very risky. They monitor it very closely and have everything they need to verify our compliance,” he asserts. \n\nThe state Internet\nAMOR states that the reforms are being pursued in the interests of the five biggest internet providers in the country (Rostelecom, VimpelCom, ER-Telecom, MTS, and MegaFon). These changes essentially create an oligopoly, when the whole industry is completely controlled by just a few companies.\n\n\n“We believe that the motivation behind this reform does not reflect the interests of the industry or the country as a whole, but rather serves the interests of a very limited circle of large commercial entities,” the statement reads.\nThe Leningrad oblast provider owner agrees.\n“None of the companies had ever doubted that the consolidation would happen. It’s just a matter of time and approach – whether they’ll buy us or just take the business. My view is that they’ll buy the medium-sized ones and simply press the small ones. We live in a capitalist system, where the big ones feed on the small ones. The only question is how civilized is our capitalism,” he says.\nAccording to his predictions, the complete takeover of the small and medium providers will occur within three years, as the big players won’t be able to secure the services for all the clients at once. \n\nThe consequences for Russian cybersecurity\nThe provider owners IStories have spoken to have admitted that telecom consolidation has taken place in many countries around the world a long time ago. However, they say that the unique situation in Russia makes the country’s entire network more resilient to cyberattacks and external threats.\nAccording to them, the larger the number of independent providers, data transmission routes, and network control centers in Russia is, the easier it is to cope with the consequences of any crash, error, or attack, and the lower the importance of each single point of failure is to the system.\n“The decentralized architecture of the Russian Internet segment is its fundamental advantage from a security standpoint. [...] Concentrating infrastructure management in the hands of five providers will sharply increase our vulnerability to DDoS attacks and targeted cyberattacks by unfriendly countries (Russia officially maintains a so-called \"Unfriendly countries\" list — Ed.). For a country with a vast territory and widely distributed infrastructure, decentralization is a factor of resilience, not a development obstacle,” the AMOR statement reads.","blocks":[{"data":"The Association of Small Telecom Operators of the Regions of Russia (AMOR) has sent a letter to Vladimir Putin, Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin, and Prosecutor General Alexander Gutsan demanding that they abandon the Internet service provider market reform recently proposed by the Russian Ministry of Digital Development. A copy of the letter is at the disposal of IStories, and its authenticity has been confirmed by market sources.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The association members requested a legal, prosecutorial, and antitrust examination of the initiatives as well as postponing their adoption and investigating the Ministry of Digital Development’s activities to ensure the anti-corruption legislation compliance.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The initiatives","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Last week, it <a href=\"https://iz.ru/export/google/amp/2070651\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">was reported</a> that the Ministry of Digital Development is discussing toughening the licensing rules for Russian Internet providers. Essentially, this will result in a total elimination of small and medium-sized providers. As a result, only the state-controlled telecom companies will remain on the market.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The ministry wants to introduce three new types of licenses, with a cost ranging from 1 to 50 million rubles (from $13,000 to $665,000 approx.), which will not be issued to individual entrepreneurs.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Ministry of Digital Development also wants to start revoking the providers’ licenses for repeated “major violations” and to introduce a 10-year ban on licensing the beneficiaries of the offending companies.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In addition, a minimum amount requirement for the providers' authorized capital will be established, ranging from 5 to 100 million rubles (depending on the type of license).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Ministry of Digital Development stated that the proposals “have been received positively by the industry.” According to officials, their goal is to ensure that only the “reliable operators” remain as well as \"to guarantee effective compliance with the law\".","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Earlier, the digital development minister Maksut Shadayev had <a href=\"https://www.cableman.ru/content/maksut-shadaev-malye-operatory-svyazi-zachastuyu-ne-vypolnyayut-trebovaniya-regulyatorov\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">claimed</a> regional Internet providers were failing to comply with the obligatory installation of the TPSU tools (traffic filtering tools used by Roskomnadzor, Russia’s executive body responsible for censoring media, telecommunications, and internet content — Ed.) and the SORM system (interception interfaces used for surveillance — Ed.).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"As part of this reform, the Ministry of Digital Development also <a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/technology_and_media/03/04/2026/69ce38e79a794729dc0e6ba6\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">plans to lift</a> the moratorium on telcos inspections, which was set to last until 2030, RBC Russia reported. The sources explained that the moratorium is making it hard for authorities to verify whether the companies have installed the SORM system.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The companies reaction","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The AMOR association has demanded that the Ministry of Digital Development be tasked with developing alternative mechanisms for modernizing the telecommunications sector which “would enable the government to achieve its objectives without destroying small and regional telecom businesses,” and has requested that its representatives be included in the process.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Not only will the reforms hinder the operations of small and regional telecom businesses, but will make them impossible, AMOR claims.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Consequences: from unemployment to price growth","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"According to the AMOR letter, the total number of employees of all the Russian telecom companies whose annual revenue amounts to&nbsp;50 million rubles ($665,000 approx) and below is 15,200 people. The companies generating 50 to 500 million rubles ($665,000 and $7 million approx.) in revenue employ 21,800 people in the country. Therefore, <strong>tens of thousands of telecom industry employees might suddenly find themselves out of work.</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18057,"data":{"header":"Reforms might also lead to Russian hardware and software declining in demand"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"Other consequences will include<strong> Internet cost growth.</strong> It is difficult to say precisely how much the prices will change, the telco sources interviewed by IStories say.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“I think the <strong>costs could change dramatically,</strong> even outrageously, since there won’t be any competition even in the long run,” says one of the Moscow oblast providers' owners.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In addition, the Ministry of Digital Development’s proposal could potentially <strong>leave some people without Internet at all</strong>, because major players haven’t entered some areas due to unprofitability, AMOR points out.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“The regional and municipal providers will suffer the most, especially those operating in the private housing areas and places where the requirements tied to the coverage rate of apartment buildings are basically impossible to meet,” the statement says.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This will cause the providers who have historically ensured Internet access in remote villages, hard-to-reach areas, and rural communities to quit , the association asserts.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“The simultaneous layoff of tens of thousands of workers, the price growth and declining service quality will inevitably lead to increased social tension at the time when stability is the absolute priority for the state,” AMOR notes.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In addition, the reforms will negatively impact equipment suppliers and manufacturers, television service providers and broadcasters as well as software developers for billing, video surveillance and intercom systems, and so on.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Less independent providers means less customers, deployments and growth opportunities for the entire ecosystem. This means less orders, investments, and jobs far beyond the telecommunications industry. Additionally, it will lower the demand for Russian hardware and software,” the letter reads.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"An AMOR source interviewed by IStories considers there is no ground for claiming that the independent providers are ignoring the requirements regarding the SORM and TSPU systems.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"He notes that the FSB (Russian Federal Security Service — Ed.) frequently imposes massive fines on the non-compliant providers, including the numerous subsidiaries of major providers. A Leningrad oblast provider owner IStories have spoken to also confirms that the regulations are strict.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“It’s practically impossible to avoid setting the TSPU, and doing so would be very risky. They monitor it very closely and have everything they need to verify our compliance,” he asserts.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The state Internet","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"AMOR states that the reforms are being pursued in the interests of the five biggest internet providers in the country (Rostelecom, VimpelCom, ER-Telecom, MTS, and MegaFon). These changes essentially create an oligopoly, when the whole industry is completely controlled by just a few companies.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":18058,"data":{"header":"Concentrating the infrastructure management in the hands of five providers will sharply increase the DDoS attacks vulnerability "},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"“We believe that the motivation behind this reform does not reflect the interests of the industry or the country as a whole, but rather serves the interests of a very limited circle of large commercial entities,” the statement reads.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Leningrad oblast provider owner agrees.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“None of the companies had ever doubted that the consolidation would happen. It’s just a matter of time and approach – whether they’ll buy us or just take the business. My view is that they’ll buy the medium-sized ones and simply press the small ones. We live in a capitalist system, where the big ones feed on the small ones. The only question is how civilized is our capitalism,” he says.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to his predictions, the complete takeover of the small and medium providers will occur within three years, as the big players won’t be able to secure the services for all the clients at once.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The consequences for Russian cybersecurity","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The provider owners IStories have spoken to have admitted that telecom consolidation has taken place in many countries around the world a long time ago. However, they say that the unique situation in Russia makes the country’s entire network more resilient to cyberattacks and external threats.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to them, the larger the number of independent providers, data transmission routes, and network control centers in Russia is, the easier it is to cope with the consequences of any crash, error, or attack, and the lower the importance of each single point of failure is to the system.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“The decentralized architecture of the Russian Internet segment is its fundamental advantage from a security standpoint. [...] Concentrating infrastructure management in the hands of five providers will sharply increase our vulnerability to DDoS attacks and targeted cyberattacks by unfriendly countries (Russia officially maintains a so-called \"Unfriendly countries\" list — Ed.). For a country with a vast territory and widely distributed infrastructure, decentralization is a factor of resilience, not a development obstacle,” the AMOR statement reads.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":9430,"header":"US Citizen Went to Army Recruitment Offices in Both Moscow and Kyiv","_path":"/en/stories/2026/04/06/us-citizen-went-to-army-recruitment-offices-in-both-moscow-and-kyiv/","lead":"Mathew Dubron wrote a book on the two opposing sides volunteers’ perspectives on war and told IStories about what he saw in both countries","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-1920x960px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-1920x960px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-1272x636px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-1272x636px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-912x456px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-912x456px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-600x400px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-600x400px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-360x360px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-360x360px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/572d6bec08404e7f87f38874a119cb6b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Picture: IStories, using AI. Photo: SOPA Images via ZUMA Press Wire / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2026-04-06","created_at_date_time":"2026-04-03T18:18:41.328Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":13,"first_name":"Соня","last_name":"Савина","first_name_en":"Sonya","last_name_en":"Savina","is_public":true,"_path":"sonya-savina","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a0e1983f65dd43929246814147e02504-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Если вы хотите рассказать мне свою историю, пишите на почту sonya.savina@istories.media.","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":"Author","ordering":1},{"id":61,"first_name":"Егор","last_name":"Феоктистов","first_name_en":"Egor","last_name_en":"Feoktistov","is_public":true,"_path":"egor-feoktistov","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Автор дата-отдела «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":2}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[{"id":31,"first_name":"Катя","last_name":"Бонч-Осмоловская","first_name_en":"Katya","last_name_en":"Bonch-Osmolovskaya","is_public":true,"_path":"katya-bonch-osmolovskaya","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.jpeg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.jpeg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.jpeg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.jpeg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редакторка дата-отдела","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":null,"ordering":1}],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"Mathew Kyle Dubron, a US citizen, is one of the individuals whose name IStories found on the list of foreigners who went through Moscow’s recruitment center for contract military service. He told IStories he went through one in Ukraine as well, though he never actually joined either army. According to him, he was gathering information for his fiction book, “The Volunteers. A Story of the Russo-Ukraine War: Based on true stories from both sides” published in Autumn 2025. The book follows the stories of two characters: a Russian soldier who went to war to earn money, and an American who enlisted in the Ukrainian army. \n\nDubron is a former military who served in the US and in Israel. He described the differences he saw between the recruiting process in Russia and Ukraine — and between the two countries at war in general.\n\n— As a citizen of the US, why did you choose the Russian invasion of Ukraine as the subject matter of the book? \n\n— First, I studied history. I do think that it is the most historically important thing to happen in the 21st century. I believe it destroys the world order that was established post 1946-1947, with the UN agreeing that we don't invade countries and we solve our problems through mediation or legal means. I do understand that people have broken that, but we've generally kept to that. And I think that the breaking of that is an extremely historical event, and I wanted to write about that as a historian. \nNumber two, I would say that I was in a unique position because I did serve in the Israeli military, and in the Israel military, we have a lot of Ukrainians and a lot of Russians. So I actually did know people who were on both sides. And that's where the idea of the book came in, just telling what the normal person goes through. Yes. Don't get me wrong. I'm not defending the criminal soldiers that they (the Russians — Ed.) have, but I am saying that there are normal people who are forced to be there and it sucks. And the Ukrainians, on their side, you have normal people who just want to go home. And I can sympathize with that level of soldiering as a soldier.\nI tried to approach writing a modern book in a historical context, and then I realized that the tragedy and suffering that is going on would not be told well in a non-fiction book. I realized that I wanted to tell a more personalized story about the war and be able to relate it more to Americans.\n\n— How did you collect the information to write the part of the book telling the russian soldier story?\n— 2022 was when I came up with the idea for the book and research. But what I wanted when I wrote the book — and I said that it's based on true stories — I didn't want to just be some idiot who just made up stories, or watched a YouTube video and said, “Okay, cool. I know exactly what's going on here guys”. No. I wanted to go there.\nBecause I have two passports and because I have friends from both sides, I was able to go in with an Israeli passport into Russia, use the American one to get around in case that gets flagged or in trouble, and then get out with an Israel passport. \nI already had the title, “the Volunteers”. The important part is volunteering, so I went to the recruitment center to look around. So, I went for a day. \n— What did you see in the Moscow recruitment center?\nIt's almost like an assembly line, and my book talks about it. You go in, you sit down, you talk. You get asked one question — “why do you want to be here?” Uh, money. Oh, okay. Cool. Goodbye. Next. \nIf you replaced everything there with AI, nothing would change. They don't care. There's four or five guys sitting there, and there's a line up the door of people. \nUnfortunately, when you're an American there, everyone asks you what you think. So I had to keep it very, very pro-Russian. I don't want to end up like many Americans who've been arrested, including two or three former American Marines, anything like that. I always give the party line answer.\nTheir physical (checkup — Ed.) is… I didn't even realize I took a physical. I just talked to somebody and walked out.\nThey don't really check skills and things like this. The Americans or the Ukrainians will be like, oh, you're a programmer. OK, we can put you somewhere and use your skill sets. Whereas from what I saw, it seemed like they (Russians — Ed.) really didn't care at all. They just were like: oh, a person, cool.\n[When it turned out it was time to sign the contract] I just said, “Oh, I didn't know it would be today. I want to go see the beauty of Russia. See you later. I'll come back”. And they were cool with that. They have so many people there. It's not even a concern for them.\n\nMe being an American, they would never stop me from leaving. I just knew that. I don't think they'd cause an international incident this week. So I'll be OK.\n\nI stayed for a little bit longer to arrange the interview. I really wanted to interview someone who was on the front. So my friend, who I met through my Israeli contacts, was able to set up the meeting with someone who was there (Dubron opted not to reveal the interviewee's name — Ed.)\n\nAlso I was able to arrange the interview with a person who lost a very close family member. And so I was able to ask them, why did they join? Were they some person who wants the Russian Empire back? Are they a person who is patriotic? Are they a person who was avoiding criminal (responsibility — Ed.)? And then they said, money. And that's where the character of my book came, with the money (as a motivation — Ed.)\n\n— Why did you decide to go to the recruitment center if you had no intention to fight? \nI wanted to get something so that I could say “this is true”. I didn't want to just say that, I wanted to use some primary sources, going back to my historical training. I wanted to either be my primary source or talk to someone who was there. \n\nAnd the gentleman who I talked to, who was on the front, did not join through a recruiting center. He was a member of one of the, I would say PMCs, and then he ended up in the army when they switched over. \n— What surprised you the most in the Russian recruiting center? \nI was very surprised to see that it was a one stop shop. You just walk in and then that day they were leaving. I don't know if they do background checks. This is crazy! \nI served in the IDF. There is rubber stamping that happens where it's like, “Yeah, he's good, we swear”. But it's at least even then they go through the pretense. \n\nEven in what the Russians call elite units, which is VDV and the Morskaya Pekhota, they don't get that much training. From a direct source from someone who was there, their training was four to six weeks. (Russian BBC Service has also reported that the paratrooper training during the war has been taking just a couple of weeks — meanwhile before the war it would take 6 to 12 months to do the just basic training — Ed.).\n\nIn an elite unit in Israel you'd be training for 8 to 12 months before you're even allowed to take the training wheels off and go for a walk, whereas in the American military the fastest pipeline for a special operations soldier is still a year. \nBut it may have changed again, it's been two years. But in 2024, they were doing a counter-offensive, so it must have been pretty manpower-heavy comparatively.\n\n— Why do some foreigners — Americans included — decide to go to war on Russia’s side? \n— That's, actually — I wouldn't say “common — but it's a thing. Number one is Russian women, most likely, is where they go. Guys like girls, and that's a story as old as time. \nNumber two, I would say, in their case, it would be... I can't speak for everyone else, but I would say veterans would probably feel a little betrayed after the collapse of Afghanistan and things like that. And they probably feel betrayed that certain social ideologies were being pushed in the US military.\nAnd Russia claims to be this bastion of strong Christian nation, but what they portray themselves as and what they really are is a different world. And they're sending their guys to go die on the front when they have a huge demographic crisis. But I would say that this right-wing Christian nation ideology attracts a lot of, I would say, very disenfranchised Americans and Westerners. \nAnd I would say, people still, especially in the West, associate Russia with communism, being the successor state of the Soviet Union. So, it could attract the left-wing, too. \n\n— In your book, another part of the story is that of an American fighting for Ukraine. How did you collect the information for this part?\n— After a month in Russia, I went back to the United States. I — again through contacts — arranged meetings in Ukraine. I went to Lviv and Kyiv. \nI went to the recruiting place in Kyiv in the old city hall. They gave me the number for the International Legion over regular brigades, as I am an American. \n\nWhat I noticed in Ukraine is that they care a lot more about skills. The difference is I saw the Ukrainians taking their time a little more with recruits. When I was there, they were talking to them, which is something that I know is shocking compared to the Russian side of the house, but they wanted to know a little bit more about you. Maybe, I can't say for certain, to place you where you may be the best for the Ukrainian military.\nI would also say that the Ukrainian (recruiting office — Ed.) was a lot more upbeat. The Russian office looked like it was quite possibly the most depressing place I've ever been, and that includes a morgue. Everyone there was kind of in a bad mood.\n\n— What else is different about the recruiting process in the two countries?\n From what I saw: (in Ukraine — Ed.) the people who joined got to choose. If you join and want to go to the 12th assault brigade or something like that, “Okay, cool. We're gonna send you there”. Oh, 95th air mobile. “Okay, cool”. \nI also feel that the Ukrainian one takes more time. It took four to six weeks for the Americans I interviewed, and they were actually angry about it. I met an American who came over and was ready to go fight for Ukraine. He walks in. They're like, “we'll call you”. And he never got a call for six weeks. He said he almost lost all his money.\nUkraine most likely wants to make sure the volunteer is not wanted by Interpol or something like this. (The official website of the International Legion for the Defence of Ukraine states that an application is reviewed by the Legion and the corresponding unit for 4 to 6 weeks — Ed.)\n\n— How would you describe the mood in the two countries? \nThey were very different.\n\nThe mood in Moscow was very serious (as of the beginning of 2024 — Ed.). There's propaganda posters everywhere for what they call a special military operation. They never use the term (war — Ed.), ever. I find it hilarious that you'll be talking to someone there and you'll like, “war”, and they'll be like, no, “call it whatever you want”. What do you want to call it, dude? It's a war. \n\nIn Kyiv, people were still friendly. I accidentally walked into someone's home instead of a cafe and was like, I'm so sorry, I'm walking out. And they're like, “No no no, stay for tea!”.\n\nAnd I would say that the narratives portrayed in the West on both sides are incorrect, from what I saw.\n\nThere was this narrative that “Ukraine is breaking”, but I didn't see that in 2024. I saw a very determined group of people. And that's impressive. The narrative also is that “Russia is breaking” and I don't see that either. In Russia, I just see people who are tired. And I'd say they are also tired in Kyiv, but there's hope. In Russia, it's just tiredness. I would say that's the big difference. \n\n— What's the motivation difference between the volunteers fighting for Russia and Ukraine you wrote about in the book?\nRussians’ motivations are generally money. And unfortunately, from the start of the war, I think the true believers (among the volunteers — Ed.) on both sides are mostly gone — unfortunately, because they have fought bravely. Ukrainians are still getting high quality foreign volunteers, but the foreign volunteers don't come for money on the Ukrainian side. They come for their friends already there. They come because they want to help. They come because they're professionals and they say, “I believe in this. This is a true fight where I get to help”. And that's what I wrote about. \n\nBut I wasn't trying to make the Russians characters. I wasn't trying to make Ukrainian characters. I was trying to make them as real as possible. \n\nThe American was there for ideals. When people died, it was a little more hurtful, that kind of impact. The Russian was forced there for money. \n\nBut you have to remember they are people. The second you start degrading your enemy as a caricature, or the second you start degrading your enemy as just evil, without understanding, you're not going to do well.\n\nI think telling it from a humanistic perspective is able to, again, give that quality to the average Ukrainian soldier. If you keep saying, oh, these Russian soldiers suck, I think that takes away from some of the Ukrainian soldiers who've been fighting these guys for four years. When the Russians make gains, what does that say about you guys? That's really not fair. That's wrong. So you need to say, OK, yes, your average soldier quality goes to Ukraine. But the Russians still have combat-capable, decent units that are pushing, and actually sometimes getting repulsed (by Ukrainians — Ed.), which is beyond impressive for someone who's been fighting. \nI'm not trying to say anything other than war is hell, it sucks that people are there. It's just all of it is a tragedy on a level that is incomprehensible.\n\nMy family is a military family and I would say the majority of them are pretty anti-war overall. Going to wars, you have to brainwash 18 year old kids. “Go have fun”. But that's because you're drilled in your head. \n\nYou can have guys who fought in a lot of elite units: Israel, America, Ukraine. And they did all the “cool things”, and they come back, and you ask them — “was it worth not seeing your family?” — and they will almost always say “no.”","blocks":[{"data":"Mathew Kyle Dubron, a US citizen, is one of the individuals whose name IStories <a href=\"https://www.istories.media/en/stories/2025/04/23/mercenaries/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">found</a> on the list of foreigners who went through Moscow’s recruitment center for contract military service. He told IStories he went through one in Ukraine as well, though he never actually joined either army. According to him, he was gathering information for his fiction book, “The Volunteers. A Story of the Russo-Ukraine War: Based on true stories from both sides” published in Autumn 2025. The book follows the stories of two characters: a Russian soldier who went to war to earn money, and an American who enlisted in the Ukrainian army.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Dubron is a former military who served in the US and in Israel. He described the differences he saw between the recruiting process in Russia and Ukraine — and between the two countries at war in general.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17986,"data":{"block":"<p>We found Dubron’s name in the EMIAS Moscow healthcare system data leak in spring 2025, when we discovered that the registration addresses of nearly 1,500 foreigners matched the address of a recruitment center in Moscow. One of those people was Dubron.</p><p><br/></p><p>IStories confirmed that several hundred people listed in the leak and registered in the center subsequently participated in the war against Ukraine. However, after the medical examination and even <a href=\"https://novayagazeta.eu/articles/2024/08/07/iz-za-nekhvatki-zhivoi-sily-na-fronte-rossiia-raskinula-verbovochnye-seti-v-samykh-nishchikh-regionakh-planety\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">during the training</a>, some might have opted out of participating in the war. Several people were able to leave Russia shortly after visiting the recruitment center, according to the data leaked from the FSB Border Service database.</p><p><br/></p><p>According to the EMIAS leak, Dubron visited a recruitment center on February 15, 2024. He claims he did not sign a contract with the Russian Armed Forces and did not participate in the war. According to Dubron, he entered Russia in February 2024, stayed in the country for about a month, and returned to the U.S. in March. Dubron shared bank statements confirming his expenditures in the U.S. dated May 2024. The FSB border service leak contains no information about this period.</p><p><br/></p><p>From open sources we learned that Dubron went to an American military college and served in the U.S. in the 82nd Airborne Division. According to Dubron, he had also served in the Israeli army, which we haven&#x27;t been able to additionally verify independently. </p><p><br/></p><p>IStories also discovered that Dubron visited Russia at least six times between 2021 and 2023. According to him, he traveled there to visit his friends. We do not have additional independent evidence of the trips to Ukraine Dubron describes he had taken.</p><p><br/></p><p>We are not publishing a photo of Dubron at his request.</p>","header":"What we know about Mathew Dubron","content":[{"insert":"We found Dubron’s name in the EMIAS Moscow healthcare system data leak in spring 2025, when we discovered that the registration addresses of nearly 1,500 foreigners matched the address of a recruitment center in Moscow. One of those people was Dubron.\n\nIStories confirmed that several hundred people listed in the leak and registered in the center subsequently participated in the war against Ukraine. However, after the medical examination and even "},{"insert":"during the training","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://novayagazeta.eu/articles/2024/08/07/iz-za-nekhvatki-zhivoi-sily-na-fronte-rossiia-raskinula-verbovochnye-seti-v-samykh-nishchikh-regionakh-planety","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":", some might have opted out of participating in the war. Several people were able to leave Russia shortly after visiting the recruitment center, according to the data leaked from the FSB Border Service database.\n\nAccording to the EMIAS leak, Dubron visited a recruitment center on February 15, 2024. He claims he did not sign a contract with the Russian Armed Forces and did not participate in the war. According to Dubron, he entered Russia in February 2024, stayed in the country for about a month, and returned to the U.S. in March. Dubron shared bank statements confirming his expenditures in the U.S. dated May 2024. The FSB border service leak contains no information about this period.\n\nFrom open sources we learned that Dubron went to an American military college and served in the U.S. in the 82nd Airborne Division. According to Dubron, he had also served in the Israeli army, which we haven't been able to additionally verify independently. \n\nIStories also discovered that Dubron visited Russia at least six times between 2021 and 2023. According to him, he traveled there to visit his friends. We do not have additional independent evidence of the trips to Ukraine Dubron describes he had taken.\n\nWe are not publishing a photo of Dubron at his request.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"<strong>— As a citizen of the US, why did you choose the Russian invasion of Ukraine as the subject matter of the book?&nbsp;</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— First, I studied history. I do think that it is the most historically important thing to happen in the 21st century. I believe it destroys the world order that was established post 1946-1947, with the UN agreeing that we don't invade countries and we solve our problems through mediation or legal means. I do understand that people have broken that, but we've generally kept to that. And I think that the breaking of that is an extremely historical event, and I wanted to write about that as a historian.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Number two, I would say that I was in a unique position because I did serve in the Israeli military, and in the Israel military, we have a lot of Ukrainians and a lot of Russians. So I actually did know people who were on both sides. And that's where the idea of the book came in, just telling what the normal person goes through. Yes. Don't get me wrong. I'm not defending the criminal soldiers that they (the Russians — Ed.) have, but I am saying that there are normal people who are forced to be there and it sucks. And the Ukrainians, on their side, you have normal people who just want to go home. And I can sympathize with that level of soldiering as a soldier.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"I tried to approach writing a modern book in a historical context, and then I realized that the tragedy and suffering that is going on would not be told well in a non-fiction book. I realized that I wanted to tell a more personalized story about the war and be able to relate it more to Americans.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17987,"data":{"images":[{"caption":"Mathew Dubron’s book cover. It was published in 2025","isNarrow":true,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3912e5fe4ff748e789f179db960d37b4-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3912e5fe4ff748e789f179db960d37b4-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3912e5fe4ff748e789f179db960d37b4-original.jpg","real_width_1x":798,"real_width_2x":798,"real_height_1x":1199,"real_height_2x":1199},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3912e5fe4ff748e789f179db960d37b4-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3912e5fe4ff748e789f179db960d37b4-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3912e5fe4ff748e789f179db960d37b4-original.jpg","real_width_1x":798,"real_width_2x":798,"real_height_1x":1199,"real_height_2x":1199},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3912e5fe4ff748e789f179db960d37b4-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3912e5fe4ff748e789f179db960d37b4-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3912e5fe4ff748e789f179db960d37b4-original.jpg","real_width_1x":798,"real_width_2x":798,"real_height_1x":1199,"real_height_2x":1199},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3912e5fe4ff748e789f179db960d37b4-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3912e5fe4ff748e789f179db960d37b4-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3912e5fe4ff748e789f179db960d37b4-original.jpg","real_width_1x":798,"real_width_2x":798,"real_height_1x":1199,"real_height_2x":1199},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3912e5fe4ff748e789f179db960d37b4-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3912e5fe4ff748e789f179db960d37b4-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3912e5fe4ff748e789f179db960d37b4-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":798,"real_height_1x":623,"real_height_2x":1199},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3912e5fe4ff748e789f179db960d37b4-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3912e5fe4ff748e789f179db960d37b4-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3912e5fe4ff748e789f179db960d37b4-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":798,"real_height_1x":623,"real_height_2x":1199}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"<strong>— How did you collect the information to write the part of the book telling the russian soldier story?</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— 2022 was when I came up with the idea for the book and research. But what I wanted when I wrote the book — and I said that it's based on true stories — I didn't want to just be some idiot who just made up stories, or watched a YouTube video and said, “Okay, cool. I know exactly what's going on here guys”. No. I wanted to go there.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Because I have two passports and because I have friends from both sides, I was able to go in with an Israeli passport into Russia, use the American one to get around in case that gets flagged or in trouble, and then get out with an Israel passport.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"I already had the title, “the Volunteers”. The important part is volunteering, so I went to the recruitment center to look around. So, I went for a day.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>— What did you see in the Moscow recruitment center?</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It's almost like an assembly line, and my book talks about it. You go in, you sit down, you talk. You get asked one question — “why do you want to be here?” Uh, money. Oh, okay. Cool. Goodbye. Next.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"If you replaced everything there with AI, nothing would change. They don't care. There's four or five guys sitting there, and there's a line up the door of people.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Unfortunately, when you're an American there, everyone asks you what you think. So I had to keep it very, very pro-Russian. I don't want to end up like many Americans who've been arrested, <a href=\"https://ru.themoscowtimes.com/2020/07/31/rossiiskii-sud-prigovoril-bivshego-morpeha-ssha-k-9-godam-kolonii-za-napadenie-na-politseiskih-a351\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">including </a>two or three former American <a href=\"https://meduza.io/feature/2019/01/01/kto-takoy-pol-uilan-amerikanets-zaderzhannyy-v-moskve-po-podozreniyu-v-shpionazhe\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Marines</a>, anything like that. I always give the party line answer.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Their physical (checkup — Ed.) is… I didn't even realize I took a physical. I just talked to somebody and walked out.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"They don't really check skills and things like this. The Americans or the Ukrainians will be like, oh, you're a programmer. OK, we can put you somewhere and use your skill sets. Whereas from what I saw, it seemed like they (Russians — Ed.) really didn't care at all. They just were like: oh, a person, cool.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"[When it turned out it was time to sign the contract] I just said, “Oh, I didn't know it would be today. I want to go see the beauty of Russia. See you later. I'll come back”. And they were cool with that. They have so many people there. It's not even a concern for them.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Me being an American, they would never stop me from leaving. I just knew that. I don't think they'd cause an international incident this week. So I'll be OK.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"I stayed for a little bit longer to arrange the interview. I really wanted to interview someone who was on the front. So my friend, who I met through my Israeli contacts, was able to set up the meeting with someone who was there <em>(Dubron opted not to reveal the interviewee's name — Ed.)</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Also I was able to arrange the interview with a person who lost a very close family member. And so I was able to ask them, why did they join? Were they some person who wants the Russian Empire back? Are they a person who is patriotic? Are they a person who was avoiding criminal (responsibility — Ed.)? And then they said, money. And that's where the character of my book came, with the money (as a motivation — Ed.)","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>— Why did you decide to go to the recruitment center if you had no intention to fight?&nbsp;</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"I wanted to get something so that I could say “this is true”. I didn't want to just say that, I wanted to use some primary sources, going back to my historical training. I wanted to either be my primary source or talk to someone who was there.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"And the gentleman who I talked to, who was on the front, did not join through a recruiting center. He was a member of one of the, I would say PMCs, and then he ended up in the army when they switched over.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>— What surprised you the most in the Russian recruiting center?&nbsp;</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"I was very surprised to see that it was a one stop shop. You just walk in and then that day they were leaving. I don't know if they do background checks. This is crazy!&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17988,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Sputnik via IMAGO / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Uniform distribution at a Moscow recruiting center","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f6381568b8e645ad9afc556d685a17f9-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f6381568b8e645ad9afc556d685a17f9-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f6381568b8e645ad9afc556d685a17f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":3839,"real_height_1x":1280,"real_height_2x":2560},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f6381568b8e645ad9afc556d685a17f9-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f6381568b8e645ad9afc556d685a17f9-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f6381568b8e645ad9afc556d685a17f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":3839,"real_height_1x":1280,"real_height_2x":2560},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f6381568b8e645ad9afc556d685a17f9-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f6381568b8e645ad9afc556d685a17f9-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f6381568b8e645ad9afc556d685a17f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f6381568b8e645ad9afc556d685a17f9-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f6381568b8e645ad9afc556d685a17f9-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f6381568b8e645ad9afc556d685a17f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f6381568b8e645ad9afc556d685a17f9-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f6381568b8e645ad9afc556d685a17f9-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f6381568b8e645ad9afc556d685a17f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f6381568b8e645ad9afc556d685a17f9-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f6381568b8e645ad9afc556d685a17f9-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/f6381568b8e645ad9afc556d685a17f9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"I served in the IDF. There is rubber stamping that happens where it's like, “Yeah, he's good, we swear”. But it's at least even then they go through the pretense.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Even in what the Russians call elite units, which is VDV and the Morskaya Pekhota, they don't get that much training. From a direct source from someone who was there, their training was four to six weeks. <em>(Russian BBC Service </em><a href=\"https://www.bbc.com/russian/articles/cy9le4r4403o\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>has also reported</em></a><em> that the paratrooper training during the war has been taking just a couple of weeks — meanwhile before the war it would take 6 to 12 months to do the just basic training — </em><strong><em>Ed.</em></strong><em>)</em>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In an elite unit in Israel you'd be training for 8 to 12 months before you're even allowed to take the training wheels off and go for a walk, whereas in the American military the fastest pipeline for a special operations soldier is still a year.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But it may have changed again, it's been two years. But in 2024, they were doing a counter-offensive, so it must have been pretty manpower-heavy comparatively.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>— Why do some foreigners — Americans included — decide to go to war on Russia’s side?&nbsp;</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— That's, actually — I wouldn't say “common — but it's a thing. Number one is Russian women, most likely, is where they go. Guys like girls, and that's a story as old as time.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Number two, I would say, in their case, it would be... I can't speak for everyone else, but I would say veterans would probably feel a little betrayed after the collapse of Afghanistan and things like that. And they probably feel betrayed that certain social ideologies were being pushed in the US military.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"And Russia claims to be this bastion of strong Christian nation, but what they portray themselves as and what they really are is a different world. And they're sending their guys to go die on the front when they have a huge <a href=\"https://meduza.io/feature/2025/09/24/v-rossii-snova-kak-i-v-90-e-demograficheskiy-krizis-chem-on-otlichaetsya-ot-predyduschego-i-pochemu-na-etot-raz-kuda-opasnee\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">demographic crisis</a>. But I would say that this right-wing Christian nation ideology attracts a lot of, I would say, very disenfranchised Americans and Westerners.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"And I would say, people still, especially in the West, associate Russia with communism, being the successor state of the Soviet Union. So, it could attract the left-wing, too.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>— In your book, another part of the story is that of an American fighting for Ukraine. How did you collect the information for this part?</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— After a month in Russia, I went back to the United States. I — again through contacts — arranged meetings in Ukraine. I went to Lviv and Kyiv.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"I went to the recruiting place in Kyiv in the old city hall. They gave me the number for the International Legion over regular brigades, as I am an American.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"What I noticed in Ukraine is that they care a lot more about skills. The difference is I saw the Ukrainians taking their time a little more with recruits. When I was there, they were talking to them, which is something that I know is shocking compared to the Russian side of the house, but they wanted to know a little bit more about you. Maybe, I can't say for certain, to place you where you may be the best for the Ukrainian military.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17989,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Mykola Miakshykov / Ukrinform / ABACAPRESS.COM / Scanpix / LETA","caption":"Ukrainian Army Recruitment Center in Dnipro","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e0203ec03fa4c4083a3355ce850974d-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e0203ec03fa4c4083a3355ce850974d-1920xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e0203ec03fa4c4083a3355ce850974d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":1280,"real_height_2x":2560},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e0203ec03fa4c4083a3355ce850974d-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e0203ec03fa4c4083a3355ce850974d-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e0203ec03fa4c4083a3355ce850974d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":1280,"real_height_2x":2560},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e0203ec03fa4c4083a3355ce850974d-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e0203ec03fa4c4083a3355ce850974d-1200xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e0203ec03fa4c4083a3355ce850974d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e0203ec03fa4c4083a3355ce850974d-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e0203ec03fa4c4083a3355ce850974d-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e0203ec03fa4c4083a3355ce850974d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":800,"real_height_2x":1600},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e0203ec03fa4c4083a3355ce850974d-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e0203ec03fa4c4083a3355ce850974d-415xautopx_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e0203ec03fa4c4083a3355ce850974d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e0203ec03fa4c4083a3355ce850974d-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e0203ec03fa4c4083a3355ce850974d-415xautopx_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e0203ec03fa4c4083a3355ce850974d-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"I would also say that the Ukrainian (recruiting office — Ed.) was a lot more upbeat. The Russian office looked like it was quite possibly the most depressing place I've ever been, and that includes a morgue. Everyone there was kind of in a bad mood.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>— What else is different about the recruiting process in the two countries?</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>&nbsp;</strong>From what I saw: (in Ukraine — Ed.) the people who joined got to choose. If you join and want to go to the 12th assault brigade or something like that, “Okay, cool. We're gonna send you there”. Oh, 95th air mobile. “Okay, cool”.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"I also feel that the Ukrainian one takes more time. It took four to six weeks for the Americans I interviewed, and they were actually angry about it. I met an American who came over and was ready to go fight for Ukraine. He walks in. They're like, “we'll call you”. And he never got a call for six weeks. He said he almost lost all his money.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Ukraine most likely wants to make sure the volunteer is not wanted by Interpol or something like this. (The official website of the International Legion for the Defence of Ukraine <a href=\"https://ildu.mil.gov.ua/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">states</a> that an application is reviewed by the Legion and the corresponding unit for 4 to 6 weeks — Ed.)","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>— How would you describe the mood in the two countries?&nbsp;</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"They were very different.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The mood in Moscow was very serious (as of the beginning of 2024 — Ed.).<strong> </strong>There's propaganda posters everywhere for what they call a special military operation. They never use the term (war — Ed.), ever. I find it hilarious that you'll be talking to someone there and you'll like, “war”, and they'll be like, no, “call it whatever you want”. What do you want to call it, dude? It's a war.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In Kyiv, people were still friendly. I accidentally walked into someone's home instead of a cafe and was like, I'm so sorry, I'm walking out. And they're like, “No no no, stay for tea!”.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"And I would say that the narratives portrayed in the West on both sides are incorrect, from what I saw.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There was this narrative that “Ukraine is breaking”, but I didn't see that in 2024. I saw a very determined group of people. And that's impressive. The narrative also is that “Russia is breaking” and I don't see that <a href=\"http://either.in\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">either.</a> In Russia, I just see people who are tired. And I'd say they are also tired in Kyiv, but there's hope. In Russia, it's just tiredness. I would say that's the big difference.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>— What's the motivation difference between the volunteers fighting for Russia and Ukraine you wrote about in the book?</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russians’ motivations are generally money. And unfortunately, from the start of the war, I think the true believers (among the volunteers — Ed.) on both sides are mostly gone — unfortunately, because they have fought bravely. Ukrainians are still getting high quality foreign volunteers, but the foreign volunteers don't come for money on the Ukrainian side. They come for their friends already there. They come because they want to help. They come because they're professionals and they say, “I believe in this. This is a true fight where I get to help”. And that's what I wrote about.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But I wasn't trying to make the Russians characters. I wasn't trying to make Ukrainian characters. I was trying to make them as real as possible.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The American was there for ideals. When people died, it was a little more hurtful, that kind of impact. The Russian was forced there for money.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But you have to remember they are people. The second you start degrading your enemy as a caricature, or the second you start degrading your enemy as just evil, without understanding, you're not going to do well.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"I think telling it from a humanistic perspective is able to, again, give that quality to the average Ukrainian soldier. If you keep saying, oh, these Russian soldiers suck, I think that takes away from some of the Ukrainian soldiers who've been fighting these guys for four years. When the Russians make gains, what does that say about you guys? That's really not fair. That's wrong. So you need to say, OK, yes, your average soldier quality goes to Ukraine. But the Russians still have combat-capable, decent units that are pushing, and actually sometimes getting repulsed (by Ukrainians — Ed.), which is beyond impressive for someone who's been fighting.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"I'm not trying to say anything other than war is hell, it sucks that people are there. It's just all of it is a tragedy on a level that is incomprehensible.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"My family is a military family and I would say the majority of them are pretty anti-war overall. Going to wars, you have to brainwash 18 year old kids. “Go have fun”. But that's because you're drilled in your head.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"You can have guys who fought in a lot of elite units: Israel, America, Ukraine. And they did all the “cool things”, and they come back, and you ask them — “was it worth not seeing your family?” — and they will almost always say “no.”","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":9334,"header":"From Irish Alumina to Russian Rockets","_path":"/en/stories/2026/03/24/from-irish-alumina-to-russian-rockets/","lead":"Leaked transaction data reveals how a major refinery in Ireland owned by Russian oligarch Oleg Deripaska feeds into the aluminum supply chain of Russia’s weapons manufacturers. An investigation by IStories, OCCRP, The Irish Times, and partners","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6c670b55a20e48e2b9698c6804468438-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Illustration: IStories. Photo: AP Photo, Google Maps","created_at_date":"2026-03-24","created_at_date_time":"2026-03-23T10:12:01.908Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[],"external_authors_list":[{"id":348,"first_name":"Мария","last_name":"Савицкая","first_name_en":"Maria","last_name_en":"Savitskaya","company":"","company_en":null,"company_link":null,"avatar":[],"ordering":1},{"id":349,"first_name":"Эли","last_name":"Московиц","first_name_en":"Eli","last_name_en":"Moskowitz","company":"OCCRP","company_en":"OCCRP","company_link":"https://www.occrp.org/","avatar":[],"ordering":2},{"id":251,"first_name":"Миша","last_name":"Гагарин","first_name_en":"Misha","last_name_en":"Gagarin","company":"OCCRP","company_en":"OCCRP","company_link":"https://www.occrp.org/","avatar":[],"ordering":3},{"id":350,"first_name":"Ингрид","last_name":"Геркама","first_name_en":"Ingrid","last_name_en":"Gercama","company":"OCCRP","company_en":"OCCRP","company_link":"https://www.occrp.org/","avatar":[],"ordering":4},{"id":351,"first_name":"Конор","last_name":"Галлахер","first_name_en":"Conor","last_name_en":"Gallagher","company":"The Irish Times","company_en":"The Irish Times","company_link":"https://www.irishtimes.com/","avatar":[],"ordering":5}],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"This translation was provided by OCCRP.\n\nAlong a rugged, wind-swept shore in western Ireland stands Aughinish Alumina, the hulking industrial complex that is Europe's largest alumina refinery.\n\nInside the sprawling plant, heat and pressure are harnessed to transform bauxite — a reddish rock mined oceans away — into alumina, the main raw material needed to produce aluminum.\nStrong and resistant to corrosion, aluminum is vital for manufacturing military hardware like missiles, drones, and aircraft. That’s one reason why the European Commission has called on member states to stockpile alumina as a defense against hostile powers.\n\nYet rather than remaining in the European Union, the majority of the Aughinish factory’s exports are shipped to Russia’s largest aluminum smelters. Those smelters, in turn, feed into a supply chain of sanctioned defense contractors whose weapons have killed thousands of civilians in Ukraine, a new investigation by OCCRP and partners has found.   \nReporters could not track the final destination of a specific batch of Aughinish’s alumina, as the powdery substance is typically mixed together with alumina from other sources in the smelting process. \n\nHowever, customs and trade data show that since 2023, more than half the Ireland-based refinery’s alumina exports have gone to smelters in Russia owned by the plant’s Russian parent company, United Company Rusal.\n\nAfter processing the alumina into aluminum, the smelters have sold more than $650 million worth of the metal to a Moscow-based trader, Aluminium Sales Company (ASK), which supplies aluminum to clients that include dozens of EU-sanctioned Russian weapons manufacturers, according to leaked transaction data. (The data does not detail the volume of aluminum sold.)\nWeapons made by these firms have leveled entire city blocks in Mariupol, struck a children’s hospital in Kyiv, and blown open an apartment building in western Ukraine, according to EU sanctions listings, Ukraine’s military intelligence, and the London-based Royal United Services Institute (RUSI). \n\nAughinish Alumina’s exports to Russia — which have increased since the full-scale invasion of Ukraine — are entirely legal under EU trade rules. That is because despite the bloc’s recognition of alumina’s importance, no restrictions have been placed on the product’s export to Russia.\n\n“A strategic asset”\nAughinish Alumina’s Russian parent company, Rusal, is one of the world’s largest aluminum producers, with mines, refineries, and smelters across the globe. In Russia, it is the primary supplier of aluminum for the defense, transport, construction and electrical industries. \n\nAfter Russia’s 2022 invasion of Ukraine, the EU sanctioned Rusal’s founder and former top shareholder Oleg Deripaska, a billionaire and close ally of Russian President Vladimir Putin, for his alleged involvement in companies working with the Russian defense sector. (Deripaska did not respond to reporters’ request for comment, but has mounted failed legal challenges to U.S., EU, and Australian sanctions against him.)\nRusal, however, remained untouched, sparking a debate in the Irish parliament about the company’s plant in County Limerick, which produces around a third of the EU’s alumina. \n“We appear to be protecting the Aughinish Alumina plant from sanctions,” then-MP Thomas Pringle said in April 2022. “That is hypocritical of us. If we need to protect that plant, the Government should be considering taking it over straight away and…take it out of the hands of the oligarchs.” \n\nThe country’s then minister of state, Patrick O’Donovan, responded by saying that the plant “is not connected…to any sort of Russian empire,” and that it was a major employer and supplier of alumina to European industries.\n\nRusal itself had actually been briefly sanctioned back in 2018 by the U.S. for its connection to Deripaska. The move sent shockwaves through the global aluminum industry and led to a surge in aluminum prices. Not long after, the U.S. agreed to delist the company after Deripaska reduced his shares in Rusal’s parent company to a minority stake. \n\n\nFrom Guinea to Siberia\nTo trace Russia’s aluminum supply chain, reporters started at the source. Trade data shows the bauxite refined by the Aughinish factory comes from the West African country Guinea, where Rusal owns three mines. It also comes from a Rusal-owned mine in the Brazilian Amazon whose largest shareholder is the mining and commodity trading giant Glencore. (When reached for comment Glencore, which owns a 10% stake in Rusal’s parent company, said it was “unable to comment on Aughinish’s commercial decisions.”)\n\nAfter arriving by bulk carrier to Irish shores, the bauxite is transformed with heat, pressure, and caustic soda into alumina at the Aughinish facility. Since the 2022 invasion — after which one of Rusal’s Ukraine-based refineries was nationalized — Aughinish has become an increasingly important alumina supplier for the Russian conglomerate.\n\nTrade data shows that starting in 2023, the Ireland-based plant has shipped the majority of its alumina exports to Rusal smelters in Russia. The bulk has gone to two smelters in particular: the Krasnoyarsk and Sayanogorsk facilities in Siberia.\nIn 2024, for instance, Aughinish sent around half of all its refined alumina produced that year — worth around $400 million — to Krasnoyarsk and Sayanogorsk, accounting for nearly 40% of the alumina imported by the smelters. That year, the two smelters produced over a third of Rusal’s entire aluminum output, according to annual reports.\n\nBut that’s where the public paper trail ends, with Rusal making no public mention of supplying Russian arms manufacturers. Leaked transaction data, however, allowed reporters to follow the aluminum’s path.\n\nFrom Russian smelters to Ukraine’s frontlines\nThe leaked transaction data obtained by reporters shows ASK paid Rusal’s trading arm more than $640 million for aluminum from the company’s smelters between the start of the full-scale invasion in February 2022 to April 2025.\n\n(While the data does not show the exact volumes ASK sourced from each smelter, it shows the trader also paid service fees to specific smelters for loading and unloading aluminum, some 40 percent of which went to Krasnoyarsk and Sayanogorsk.)\n\nThroughout the same time period ASK, in turn, made approximately a third of its revenue — some $337 million — selling aluminum for the purpose of Russian defense contracts.\n\nReporters were unable to trace alumina from Aughinish to a specific product. However, ASK’s 2024 customer list included more than 40 EU-sanctioned companies — many owned by the Russian defense conglomerate Rostec — which produce weapons including anti-aircraft missiles, rocket systems, and long-range bombers, according to sanctions listings. \n\nEighteen of these companies have built arms directly used in deadly attacks in Ukraine, said Andriy Yusov, an official from the Main Directorate of Intelligence of the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, which analyzes the debris of Russian weaponry found on Ukraine's battlefields. \n\nOne of the trader’s biggest customers is Kamaz, a manufacturer of heavy-duty vehicles used by Russia’s armed forces in Ukraine, according to its EU sanctions listing. In 2024, Kamaz paid ASK $16 million for aluminum, the data shows. \n\nAnother top ASK client is the U.S.- and EU-sanctioned Votkinsk Machine Building Plant, which bought $101,200 worth of aluminum from ASK in 2024.\n\nAccording to EU authorities and Ukraine's military intelligence agency, the Votkinsk plant manufactures a range of armaments, including long-range missiles and the short-range Iskander ballistic missile — a weapon that reportedly killed 31 civilians in an attack in the northeastern city of Sumy in April 2025. \n\nKamaz, Votkinsk, and eleven other sanctioned arms manufacturers that buy aluminum from ASK did not respond to requests to comment.\n\nExport control issues\nThe EU banned imports of aluminum produced in Russia in February 2025 in an effort to sever an income stream that could be used to fund Moscow’s war. But it has not prohibited the export of alumina to Russia, despite calls from the Latvian government which argued that a ban would “weaken [Russia’s] war machine.” \n\nSupplies of EU-produced alumina to Russia “could undermine NATO’s stated goals of supporting Ukraine and deterring Russia,” Oleksandr V. Danylyuk, a former Ukraine defense official who is now a fellow at the think-tank RUSI, says.\n\nPavlo Shkurenko, a Sanctions Research Fellow at Kyiv School of Economics Institute, also warns that Europe’s “entanglement” with Russia’s metallurgical sector carries serious risks for the continent.\n\nIt enables “not only direct daily attacks on Ukrainian civilians, but also potential confrontation with Europe itself, as the development of Russian military industry suggests.”\nWhen reached for comment, Aughinish told OCCRP that it operates “in strict compliance with all applicable European Union laws, including sanctions, export control measures and trade regulations.” The company said it had implemented “robust sanctions compliance and due diligence framework covering its entire supply chain,” though it did not respond to specific questions about whether its products might be used to build Russian weapons. \n\nThe firm emphasized that alumina and aluminum are basic commodities serving “broad general purpose societal needs…vital for countless civilian industries.” \n\nIreland’s Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade stressed that alumina is “not a sanctioned good” and “therefore its export to other countries, including Russia, is not restricted.”\nA lack of data makes it “difficult to ascertain where Russia is sourcing its tools and weapons from,” a spokesperson said, adding that “Ireland remains unequivocal in its continuing support for Ukraine in light of Russia’s unjustified invasion.” \n\nThe Russian Ministry of Defense, ASK, and Rusal and its parent company EN+ Group did not respond to reporters’ request for comment. \n\nKhadija Sharife, Alina Tsogoeva (OCCRP), Kaur Maran (Eesti Ekspress), Simon Goodley (The Guardian), Maksym Dudchenko (KibOrg), and Lars Bové (De Tijd) contributed reporting.","blocks":[{"data":"<em>This translation was provided by </em><a href=\"https://www.occrp.org/en/investigation/inside-the-aluminum-supply-chain-linking-irish-industry-to-russian-rockets\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>OCCRP</em></a><em>.</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Along a rugged, wind-swept shore in western Ireland stands Aughinish Alumina, the hulking industrial complex that is Europe's largest alumina refinery.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Inside the sprawling plant, heat and pressure are harnessed to transform bauxite — a reddish rock mined oceans away — into alumina, the main raw material needed to produce aluminum.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Strong and resistant to corrosion, aluminum is vital for manufacturing military hardware like missiles, drones, and aircraft. That’s one reason why the European Commission has called on member states to stockpile alumina as a defense against hostile powers.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Yet rather than remaining in the European Union, the majority of the Aughinish factory’s exports are shipped to Russia’s largest aluminum smelters. Those smelters, in turn, feed into a supply chain of sanctioned defense contractors whose weapons have killed thousands of civilians in Ukraine, a new investigation by OCCRP and partners has found.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17914,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: Alan Betson / The Irish Times","caption":"View of the Aughinish Alumina refinery in Country Limerick, Ireland","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9d7359bd9b3946b4a5619c17578e6a01-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9d7359bd9b3946b4a5619c17578e6a01-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9d7359bd9b3946b4a5619c17578e6a01-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1079,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9d7359bd9b3946b4a5619c17578e6a01-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9d7359bd9b3946b4a5619c17578e6a01-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9d7359bd9b3946b4a5619c17578e6a01-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1079,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9d7359bd9b3946b4a5619c17578e6a01-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9d7359bd9b3946b4a5619c17578e6a01-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9d7359bd9b3946b4a5619c17578e6a01-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":674,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9d7359bd9b3946b4a5619c17578e6a01-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9d7359bd9b3946b4a5619c17578e6a01-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9d7359bd9b3946b4a5619c17578e6a01-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":674,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9d7359bd9b3946b4a5619c17578e6a01-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9d7359bd9b3946b4a5619c17578e6a01-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9d7359bd9b3946b4a5619c17578e6a01-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":466},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9d7359bd9b3946b4a5619c17578e6a01-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9d7359bd9b3946b4a5619c17578e6a01-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9d7359bd9b3946b4a5619c17578e6a01-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":466}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Reporters could not track the final destination of a specific batch of Aughinish’s alumina, as the powdery substance is typically mixed together with alumina from other sources in the smelting process.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, customs and trade data show that since 2023, more than half the Ireland-based refinery’s alumina exports have gone to smelters in Russia owned by the plant’s Russian parent company, United Company Rusal.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After processing the alumina into aluminum, the smelters have sold more than $650 million worth of the metal to a Moscow-based trader, Aluminium Sales Company (ASK), which supplies aluminum to clients that include dozens of EU-sanctioned Russian weapons manufacturers, according to leaked transaction data. (The data does not detail the volume of aluminum sold.)","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Weapons made by these firms have leveled entire city blocks in Mariupol, struck a children’s hospital in Kyiv, and blown open an apartment building in western Ukraine, according to EU sanctions listings, Ukraine’s military intelligence, and the London-based Royal United Services Institute (RUSI).&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Aughinish Alumina’s exports to Russia — which have increased since the full-scale invasion of Ukraine — are entirely legal under EU trade rules. That is because despite the bloc’s recognition of alumina’s importance, no restrictions have been placed on the product’s export to Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“A strategic asset”","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Aughinish Alumina’s Russian parent company, Rusal, is one of the world’s largest aluminum producers, with mines, refineries, and smelters across the globe. In Russia, it is the primary supplier of aluminum for the defense, transport, construction and electrical industries.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After Russia’s 2022 invasion of Ukraine, the EU sanctioned Rusal’s founder and former top shareholder Oleg Deripaska, a billionaire and close ally of Russian President Vladimir Putin, for his alleged involvement in companies working with the Russian defense sector. (Deripaska did not respond to reporters’ request for comment, but has mounted failed legal challenges to <a href=\"https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/russian-oligarch-deripaska-loses-us-court-battle-lift-sanctions-2022-03-29/?utm_source=chatgpt.com\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">U.S.</a>, <a href=\"https://infocuria.curia.europa.eu/tabs/document?source=document&amp;text=&amp;docid=293803&amp;pageIndex=0&amp;doclang=FR&amp;mode=req&amp;dir=&amp;occ=first&amp;part=1&amp;cid=1489261\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">EU</a>, and <a href=\"https://www.judgments.fedcourt.gov.au/judgments/Judgments/fca/single/2024/2024fca0062\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Australian</a> sanctions against him.)","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17918,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: REUTERS / Sergei Karpukhin","caption":"Oleg Deripaska","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ceec42aa1c6943008a905ea63b17a3e5-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ceec42aa1c6943008a905ea63b17a3e5-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ceec42aa1c6943008a905ea63b17a3e5-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ceec42aa1c6943008a905ea63b17a3e5-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ceec42aa1c6943008a905ea63b17a3e5-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ceec42aa1c6943008a905ea63b17a3e5-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3840,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ceec42aa1c6943008a905ea63b17a3e5-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ceec42aa1c6943008a905ea63b17a3e5-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ceec42aa1c6943008a905ea63b17a3e5-original.png","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":600,"real_height_2x":1200},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ceec42aa1c6943008a905ea63b17a3e5-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ceec42aa1c6943008a905ea63b17a3e5-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ceec42aa1c6943008a905ea63b17a3e5-original.png","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":600,"real_height_2x":1200},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ceec42aa1c6943008a905ea63b17a3e5-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ceec42aa1c6943008a905ea63b17a3e5-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ceec42aa1c6943008a905ea63b17a3e5-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":207,"real_height_2x":415},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ceec42aa1c6943008a905ea63b17a3e5-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ceec42aa1c6943008a905ea63b17a3e5-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ceec42aa1c6943008a905ea63b17a3e5-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":207,"real_height_2x":415}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Rusal, however, remained untouched, sparking a debate in the Irish parliament about the company’s plant in County Limerick, which produces around a third of the EU’s alumina.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“We appear to be protecting the Aughinish Alumina plant from sanctions,” then-MP Thomas Pringle said in April 2022. “That is hypocritical of us. If we need to protect that plant, the Government should be considering taking it over straight away and…take it out of the hands of the oligarchs.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The country’s then minister of state, Patrick O’Donovan, responded by <a href=\"https://data.oireachtas.ie/ie/oireachtas/debateRecord/dail/2022-04-06/debate/mul@/main.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">saying</a> that the plant “is not connected…to any sort of Russian empire,” and that it was a major employer and supplier of alumina to European industries.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Rusal itself had actually been briefly sanctioned back in 2018 by the U.S. for its connection to Deripaska. The move sent shockwaves through the global aluminum industry and led to a surge in aluminum prices. Not long after, the U.S. agreed to delist the company after Deripaska reduced his shares in Rusal’s parent company to a minority stake.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"From Guinea to Siberia","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"To trace Russia’s aluminum supply chain, reporters started at the source. Trade data shows the bauxite refined by the Aughinish factory comes from the West African country Guinea, where Rusal owns three mines. It also comes from a Rusal-owned mine in the Brazilian Amazon whose largest shareholder is the mining and commodity trading giant Glencore. (When reached for comment Glencore, which owns a 10% stake in Rusal’s parent company, said it was “unable to comment on Aughinish’s commercial decisions.”)","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After arriving by bulk carrier to Irish shores, the bauxite is transformed with heat, pressure, and caustic soda into alumina at the Aughinish facility.&nbsp;Since the 2022 invasion — after which one of Rusal’s Ukraine-based refineries was nationalized —&nbsp;Aughinish has become an increasingly important alumina supplier for the Russian conglomerate.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Trade data shows that starting in 2023, the Ireland-based plant has shipped the majority of its alumina exports to Rusal smelters in Russia. The bulk has gone to two smelters in particular: the Krasnoyarsk and Sayanogorsk facilities in Siberia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17915,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: REUTERS","caption":"Rusal’s Sayanogorsk facility","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0f141eaa6c6441a912a4d163b1b58d9-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0f141eaa6c6441a912a4d163b1b58d9-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0f141eaa6c6441a912a4d163b1b58d9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1079,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0f141eaa6c6441a912a4d163b1b58d9-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0f141eaa6c6441a912a4d163b1b58d9-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0f141eaa6c6441a912a4d163b1b58d9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1079,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0f141eaa6c6441a912a4d163b1b58d9-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0f141eaa6c6441a912a4d163b1b58d9-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0f141eaa6c6441a912a4d163b1b58d9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":674,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0f141eaa6c6441a912a4d163b1b58d9-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0f141eaa6c6441a912a4d163b1b58d9-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0f141eaa6c6441a912a4d163b1b58d9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":674,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0f141eaa6c6441a912a4d163b1b58d9-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0f141eaa6c6441a912a4d163b1b58d9-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0f141eaa6c6441a912a4d163b1b58d9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":466},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0f141eaa6c6441a912a4d163b1b58d9-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0f141eaa6c6441a912a4d163b1b58d9-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/c0f141eaa6c6441a912a4d163b1b58d9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":466}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"In 2024, for instance, Aughinish sent around half of all its refined alumina produced that year — worth around $400 million — to Krasnoyarsk and Sayanogorsk, accounting for nearly 40% of the alumina imported by the smelters.&nbsp;That year, the two smelters produced over a third of Rusal’s entire aluminum output, according to annual reports.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"But that’s where the public paper trail ends, with Rusal making no public mention of supplying Russian arms manufacturers.&nbsp;Leaked transaction data, however, allowed reporters to follow the aluminum’s path.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"From Russian smelters to Ukraine’s frontlines","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The leaked transaction data obtained by reporters shows ASK paid Rusal’s trading arm more than $640 million for aluminum from the company’s smelters between the start of the full-scale invasion in February 2022 to April 2025.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"(While the data does not show the exact volumes ASK sourced from each smelter, it shows the trader also paid service fees to specific smelters for loading and unloading aluminum, some 40 percent of which went to Krasnoyarsk and Sayanogorsk.)","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Throughout the same time period ASK, in turn, made approximately a third of its revenue — some $337 million — selling aluminum for the purpose of Russian defense contracts.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Reporters were unable to trace alumina from Aughinish to a specific product. However, ASK’s 2024 customer list included more than 40 EU-sanctioned companies — many owned by the Russian defense conglomerate Rostec — which produce weapons including anti-aircraft missiles, rocket systems, and long-range bombers, according to sanctions listings.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Eighteen of these companies have built arms directly used in deadly attacks in Ukraine, said Andriy Yusov, an official from the Main Directorate of Intelligence of the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, which analyzes the debris of Russian weaponry found on Ukraine's battlefields.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"One of the trader’s biggest customers is Kamaz, a manufacturer of heavy-duty vehicles used by Russia’s armed forces in Ukraine, according to its EU sanctions listing. In 2024, Kamaz paid ASK $16 million for aluminum, the data shows.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Another top ASK client is the U.S.- and EU-sanctioned Votkinsk Machine Building Plant, which bought $101,200 worth of aluminum from ASK in 2024.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to EU authorities and Ukraine's military intelligence agency, the Votkinsk plant manufactures a range of armaments, including long-range missiles and the short-range Iskander ballistic missile — a weapon that reportedly killed 31 civilians in an attack in the northeastern city of Sumy in April 2025.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Kamaz, Votkinsk, and eleven other sanctioned arms manufacturers that buy aluminum from ASK did not respond to requests to comment.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Export control issues","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"The EU banned imports of aluminum produced in Russia in February 2025 in an effort to sever an income stream that could be used to fund Moscow’s war. But it has not prohibited the export of alumina to Russia, despite calls from the Latvian government which argued that a ban would “weaken [Russia’s] war machine.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Supplies of EU-produced alumina to Russia “could undermine NATO’s stated goals of supporting Ukraine and deterring Russia,” Oleksandr V. Danylyuk, a former Ukraine defense official who is now a fellow at the think-tank RUSI, says.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Pavlo Shkurenko, a Sanctions Research Fellow at Kyiv School of Economics Institute, also warns that Europe’s “entanglement” with Russia’s metallurgical sector carries serious risks for the continent.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It enables “not only direct daily attacks on Ukrainian civilians, but also potential confrontation with Europe itself, as the development of Russian military industry suggests.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17917,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Visualization: James O’Brien / OCCRP","caption":"Route of a bulk carrier from the Aughinish facility in Ireland to the port of Ust-Luga, Russia","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ab0de1b940164a2fb5e42a30b81866b7-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ab0de1b940164a2fb5e42a30b81866b7-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ab0de1b940164a2fb5e42a30b81866b7-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2130,"real_height_1x":1012,"real_height_2x":1123},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ab0de1b940164a2fb5e42a30b81866b7-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ab0de1b940164a2fb5e42a30b81866b7-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ab0de1b940164a2fb5e42a30b81866b7-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2130,"real_height_1x":1012,"real_height_2x":1123},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ab0de1b940164a2fb5e42a30b81866b7-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ab0de1b940164a2fb5e42a30b81866b7-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ab0de1b940164a2fb5e42a30b81866b7-original.png","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2130,"real_height_1x":632,"real_height_2x":1123},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ab0de1b940164a2fb5e42a30b81866b7-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ab0de1b940164a2fb5e42a30b81866b7-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ab0de1b940164a2fb5e42a30b81866b7-original.png","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2130,"real_height_1x":632,"real_height_2x":1123},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ab0de1b940164a2fb5e42a30b81866b7-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ab0de1b940164a2fb5e42a30b81866b7-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ab0de1b940164a2fb5e42a30b81866b7-original.png","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":217,"real_height_2x":437},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ab0de1b940164a2fb5e42a30b81866b7-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ab0de1b940164a2fb5e42a30b81866b7-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ab0de1b940164a2fb5e42a30b81866b7-original.png","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":217,"real_height_2x":437}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"When reached for comment, Aughinish told OCCRP that it operates “in strict compliance with all applicable European Union laws, including sanctions, export control measures and trade regulations.” The company said it had implemented “robust sanctions compliance and due diligence framework covering its entire supply chain,” though it did not respond to specific questions about whether its products might be used to build Russian weapons.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The firm emphasized that alumina and aluminum are basic commodities serving “broad general purpose societal needs…vital for countless civilian industries.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Ireland’s Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade stressed that alumina is “not a sanctioned good” and “therefore its export to other countries, including Russia, is not restricted.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A lack of data makes it “difficult to ascertain where Russia is sourcing its tools and weapons from,” a spokesperson said, adding that “Ireland remains unequivocal in its continuing support for Ukraine in light of Russia’s unjustified invasion.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Russian Ministry of Defense, ASK, and Rusal and its parent company EN+ Group did not respond to reporters’ request for comment.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>Khadija Sharife, Alina Tsogoeva (OCCRP), Kaur Maran (Eesti Ekspress), Simon Goodley (The Guardian), Maksym Dudchenko (KibOrg), and Lars Bové (De Tijd) contributed reporting.</em>","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":9325,"header":"How the Daughter of a Russian Intelligence Officer Became a Recruiter for Epstein’s Trafficking Network","_path":"/en/stories/2026/03/21/lana/","lead":"IStories tells the story of Lana Pozhidaeva — an MGIMO graduate, model, and daughter of career intelligence officers — who for many years was involved in Jeffrey Epstein’s network and recruited women for him from the former Soviet Union","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/007b72c6535c4d03b0ce5cb667ad5016-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Illustration: IStories, created using AI. Photo: Elder Ordonez / INSTARimages / Scanpix / LETA","created_at_date":"2026-03-21","created_at_date_time":"2026-03-21T19:23:08.638Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":43,"first_name":"Никита","last_name":"Кондратьев","first_name_en":"Nikita","last_name_en":"Kondratyev","is_public":true,"_path":"nikita-kondratyev","avatar":[],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":1},{"id":61,"first_name":"Егор","last_name":"Феоктистов","first_name_en":"Egor","last_name_en":"Feoktistov","is_public":true,"_path":"egor-feoktistov","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Автор дата-отдела «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":2}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[{"id":5,"first_name":"Роман","last_name":"Анин","first_name_en":"Roman","last_name_en":"Anin","is_public":true,"_path":"roman-anin","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1435d3e9c5384ab4902bab6b024b8c38-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редактор «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Редактор","position_en":"Editor","ordering":1}],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"Lana Pozhidaeva’s biography stands in sharp contrast to the typical stories of young women from poor families in post-Soviet countries who became victims of the influential American financier Jeffrey Epstein. According to the official account, Epstein died by suicide in a New York jail cell after U.S. authorities charged him with sexual exploitation of minors and human trafficking.\n\nPozhidaeva was born and raised in Moscow in a well-off family. From an early age, Svetlana — her full name — played tennis, but ultimately chose a career in finance: she graduated from MGIMO with honors, learned English, French, Italian, and Spanish, interned at the Russian Foreign Ministry and at Lukoil, studied in France, and immediately after graduation began working as an analyst at Credit Europe Bank, later moving on to Russian investment firms.\n\nHowever, in 2008, Pozhidaeva abruptly changed career paths and tried modeling: at age 24, she submitted photos to a Maxim magazine competition and unexpectedly reached the finals, she told journalists in 2018.\n\n“My parents said: you’re crazy. When someone tells me I’m crazy, I take it as a compliment, because the worst thing for me is being told I’m boring or ordinary,” Pozhidaeva explained.\n\nThe MGIMO graduate signed her first modeling contract with the Milan-based agency Elite Models and then moved to Europe. At the same time, in the United States she was represented by MC2 Model Management, an agency founded with Epstein’s money by Jean-Luc Brunel, a close associate of the financier. Brunel was widely considered a key supplier of underage girls to Epstein’s network and was himself accused of raping minors. After Epstein’s death in 2019, Brunel was arrested in France and in 2022 was found dead in his prison cell.\nPozhidaeva’s introduction to Epstein took place in 2008: documents published by the U.S. Department of Justice include an email from Epstein’s assistant sending him Lana’s phone numbers and asking him to call the Russian model. From then on, Pozhidaeva became closely acquainted not only with Epstein but also with other influential figures in the United States. By at least 2010, she had begun helping the financier — accused of pedophilia — recruit young women in former Soviet countries.\n\nAfter the U.S. Department of Justice released millions of documents from the Epstein case, Pozhidaeva drew attention from leading global media outlets. A week ago, she spoke publicly to reporters from The Wall Street Journal, saying she had been manipulated and abused by Epstein and that she recruited young women for his network against her will. She denied any ties to Russian authorities.\n\nHowever, in that interview Pozhidaeva left out many details about her cooperation with Epstein, as well as aspects of her biography, which begins in Moscow’s notorious House on the Embankment — a building where many prominent Bolsheviks and security officials once lived before being sent to labor camps or executed.\nImportant Stories uncovered previously unreported details about Pozhidaeva’s life and explains how a woman from a family of Russian intelligence officers built a career within the sex-network of a powerful American financier.\nHouse on the Embankment\nPozhidaeva was born and raised in Moscow in a Stalin-era apartment building near Begovaya, but part of her family has lived for generations in the House on the Embankment. The apartment there was allocated to her maternal grandfather, Colonel Marcel Platonov, a well-known Soviet military surgeon and gynecologist. Platonov worked in Kremlin and General Staff clinics and became one of the leading gynecologists of the Soviet Ministry of Defense.\n\nSvetlana’s parents — Yuri and Irina — graduated from the Military Institute of Foreign Languages in Moscow, colloquially known as a “spy school.”\nGraduates of the institute often went on to serve in the KGB’s First Chief Directorate (foreign intelligence) or in the military attaché corps, a source who served alongside interpreters from the institute in conflict zones told Important Stories. The institute was also one of the few military schools that admitted women.\n\nAmong its well-known graduates are arms trafficker Viktor Bout and Yuri Drozdov, head of the KGB’s illegal intelligence network from 1979 to 1991 and deputy head of the First Chief Directorate, who in 1962 organized the exchange of Soviet spy Rudolf Abel for U.S. pilot Francis Gary Powers.\n\nPozhidaeva’s father, Yuri Pozhidaev, trained as a Persian-language military interpreter and in 1978, on the eve of the Soviet invasion, was sent to Afghanistan as part of the military advisory corps. During the war, he remained in Kabul working within the office of the chief military adviser (a structure tied to the General Staff). Little is known about his later career except his rank — lieutenant colonel. It appears that both of Lana’s parents left service in the late 1990s.\n\nAs Pozhidaeva’s relationship with Epstein grew closer and her role in his network became more significant, she began introducing her relatives to her boss and his influential associates.\nHer father and the FSB\nIn the spring of 2015, Pozhidaeva’s brother Sergey traveled to the United States. She tried to place him in companies linked to Epstein and to Sultan Ahmed bin Sulayem, the former head of the global logistics giant DP World, who was dismissed earlier this year following reports about his ties to Epstein.\nIn December 2015, Pozhidaeva’s parents also traveled to the U.S., as confirmed by both correspondence and Russian border-crossing records. Ahead of their visit, Epstein transferred more than $237,000 from his offshore Butterfly Trust to Lana’s account “for the family.” The parents stayed with her in New York and later moved to Epstein’s Florida residence.\n\nAfter visiting the mansion, Lana’s mother wrote to Epstein:\n“My son asked me: \"How's the house\"? I said that it's like \"Great Getsby\"; \"No,- he said,- it's not Great Getsby , it's Great Jeffry!\" So, for our family you are a Great man!’”\n\nA few days later, Lana told Epstein that she had introduced her parents to her then-boyfriend Pen King:\n“Dad shared some stories from his FSB part, Pen loved it.”\nAfter the family became close to Epstein, Yuri Pozhidaev’s career in Russia advanced rapidly. In December 2017, the retired lieutenant colonel began working at Technopromexport (part of the Rostec holding, the main producer of the Russian arms) and frequently traveled to Tehran, where the company was building energy infrastructure.\n\nIn 2018, while continuing to receive a salary from Technopromexport, he became deputy head of security in the Iranian division of Russian Railways International, which was building the “North–South” transport corridor linking Russia, Iran, and India — a major international government project involving billions of rubles in investment.\nMoreover, in 2020, while still formally employed by Russian Railways, Pozhidaev became deputy general director for security at Caspian Services, the main contractor for Russia’s Ministry of Transport on the same corridor project. He remained in that role at least until early 2026.\n\nThe types of positions Yuri Pozhidaev held in state corporations are typically reserved for security service officers — often so-called “seconded personnel” (APS) from the FSB. Orders assigning such officers to companies, banks, and ministries are signed by the FSB director; the officers receive formal positions related to security but remain in active service and report back to the agency.\n\nInvestigative journalists from the Explainer project found that in 2022 Yuri Pozhidaev sent three letters to the address at 20/2 Bolshaya Lubyanka — home to the Moscow regional FSB pension department.\nA family of recruiters\nCorrespondence between Epstein and Pozhidaeva differs from his communication with other models from the former Soviet Union: in his emails, Epstein does not flirt with Lana, and she, unlike many others, does not appear to harbor romantic illusions about their relationship.\n\nAt the beginning of their relationship in 2009, Epstein helped Lana with visa issues and invited her to events at the United Nations and the World Economic Forum in Davos alongside Maria Drokova, a former commissar of the pro-Kremlin youth movement Nashi who later worked as Epstein’s PR agent. But within a year, Pozhidaeva began sourcing young women for Epstein from post-Soviet countries, traveling to Kyiv and Moscow and introducing her friends to him.\n\nIn several emails, Epstein expressed dissatisfaction that the women she found appeared older than he preferred. In one case, Pozhidaeva offered to arrange a meeting with a 17-year-old girl (we are not publishing the link to that file because the U.S. Department of Justice did not redact the victim’s identifying details).\n\nBefore sending women to Epstein’s island, Lana arranged for some of them to take lessons in foot massage so they “would know how to do it.”\n\nStarting in 2016, Pozhidaeva began recruiting under the alias “Julia Santos” — the name of a character from the popular American soap opera All My Children, played by Santa Barbara star Sydney Penny, a cultural reference familiar to a child growing up in 1990s Moscow.\n\nInvestigators were able to link the alias to Pozhidaeva by cross-referencing emails from “Santos” mentioning meetings with her parents, visits from her brother, or references to her boyfriend, and matching those details with travel records and emails sent under her real name.\n\nWe found messages indicating 18 women whom Pozhidaeva, under the name Julia Santos, recruited for sex parties or meetings with Epstein. The vast majority were from Russia and Ukraine. In one case, the woman was from Odesa and had been a victim of child pornography as a teenager. In another, Epstein instructed that a trafficking victim not be allowed to keep food in the refrigerator because she “needed to lose six kilos” to spend time with him.\nIn May 2017, Pozhidaeva sent Epstein a photograph from a party in Barbados: a Ukrainian woman is seen standing next to “A” — likely British Prince Andrew, who in 2025 was stripped of all titles due to his ties to Epstein.\n\n“I have heard super druggy,” Pozhidaeva wrote of her.\n\nAfter her parents met Epstein, they also began offering women for his network. For example, Lana’s mother attempted to “offer” a woman from Ukraine who, in her words, was “in a really bad situation.” Her father, Lieutenant Colonel Pozhidaev, sent Epstein photos of young women without comment (in both cases, victims’ names were not redacted in DOJ documents).\nFeminism funded by a sex offender\n“I feel ashamed and think about those other women all the time. That’s the hardest part of all of this — I was too consumed by my own abuse to see beyond it. I had to appear happy, to keep smiling, while privately I was battling eating disorders, depression, and insomnia,” Lana said in her interview with The Wall Street Journal.\n\nHer work was well paid: Epstein wrote that at the beginning she earned about $30,000 per year after taxes — roughly the median salary in New York at the time. From at least 2017, DOJ materials show payments to Pozhidaeva of $8,333 per month through Epstein’s Enhanced Education foundation, set up as automatic transfers.\nOver the years, Lana accumulated enough money to purchase two small apartments in central Moscow.\n\nShe now claims she was a victim like the underage girls, arguing that Epstein controlled her immigration status, housing, and finances. She says she could not leave because large payments were structured as loans. Important Stories found no confirmation of this in the available files.\n\nEpstein also supported her business ventures. He donated more than $50,000 to the Education Advance foundation she co-founded in 2017 with her boyfriend, New York venture investor Pendleton King Jr. Investigative journalists later found that the funds went to a Buddhist organization at MIT. The ultimate purpose of the project remains unclear.\nAnother initiative she launched with Epstein’s support was WE Talks — a platform modeled on TED Talks, aimed at bringing together ambitious women. The name stood for “Women Empowerment.”\n\nThe project was registered at Epstein’s address, funded by him, and Lana discussed its operations with him directly.\n\nIts co-director was Viktoria Drokova, sister of Maria Drokova. Maria herself also participated.\n\nIn correspondence, Lana described how they were brainstorming ways to reshape Epstein’s public image:\n“We are brainstorming with Masha how we can turn the discussion around and ask why money should not be taken for a good cause just because sth had happened 10+ years ago and that you had funded great projects and probably saved many lives. Hope this can be good.”\n\nIn 2019, Pozhidaeva and the Drokova sisters began holding WE Talks events in Moscow, but Epstein’s death disrupted their plans.\n\nPozhidaeva also claimed she feared retaliation if she tried to leave Epstein — not for herself, but for her family in Russia. She suggested Epstein could pressure her parents through connections in Russian leadership, including Sergey Belyakov, an FSB officer and former deputy minister of economic development.\nBelyakov was indeed a long-time contact of Epstein in Russia. According to the Dossier Center, Epstein advised him on economic issues and helped bring high-profile guests to the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum, while Belyakov introduced Epstein to senior officials in Russia’s Finance Ministry and Central Bank.\n\nAccording to Novaya Gazeta Europe, Belyakov helped Epstein obtain a Russian visa in 2011 via an FSB veterans’ organization. Epstein wrote that he planned to visit Moscow, but there is no evidence he did.\n\nPozhidaeva herself helped facilitate contacts between Epstein and Russian officials, including preparations for meetings with Finance Ministry and Central Bank representatives. In 2014, Belyakov wrote a recommendation letter supporting her U.S. visa extension.\n“Snow White” and America’s power elite\nOver ten years working for Epstein, Pozhidaeva gained access to some of the most powerful people in the U.S. and globally.\n\nIn 2010, paparazzi photographed her leaving Epstein’s Manhattan mansion on a day when Prince Andrew was present. She later identified herself in photos with Bill Gates and Norwegian diplomat Terje Rød-Larsen, who also stepped down from positions after his ties to Epstein became public.\nTheir interactions appear to have been professional, including helping organize visits and meetings.\n\nHowever, her name also appears in correspondence linked to sexual encounters involving prominent individuals.\n\nIn one email exchange, Epstein requested a Snow White costume for a party.\n“Brett Rattner is going to film a big movie Snow White, I would love to take photos of you in a snow white costume. You can get it from the costume store,” he wrote.\n\nAfterward, Barclays CEO Jes Staley wrote:\n“That was fun. Say hi to Snow White.”\n\nPozhidaeva a few hours later reported:\n“the snow white was f..ed twice as soon as she put her costume.”\nIn the early 2010s, Pozhidaeva had a relationship with Joshua Fink, son of BlackRock founder Larry Fink — one of the most powerful figures in global finance. \nIn 2012, Epstein introduced her to Elon Musk and attempted to arrange meetings in Paris, promising Musk “a lot of fun” with her.\nHe also tried to match her with Saudi businessman Mohammed Abdul Latif Jameel, though unsuccessfully. However, Pozhidaeva later claimed she had a sexual relationship with his son, Hassan Jameel.\nAfter Epstein\nSix months after Epstein’s death, Pozhidaeva changed her identity. Now 42, she goes by Sofia Platt and has changed her name in her Russian passport.\nShe continues to work from the United States. In San Francisco, she co-founded Bridge Funding Global, a fundraising platform focused on women entrepreneurs, and contributes to business publications such as Forbes.\n\nMelinda French Gates spoke at the opening of one of her events.\n\nPozhidaeva says she also mentors children in foster care and invests in private credit. She describes her past work as consulting for social enterprises.\nShe has largely withdrawn from public view and now identifies herself as a “victim of human trafficking.”\n\nOn her website, she states:\n“I have already told my story. In order to preserve my mental well-being and the integrity of this process, I will not accept further media requests or give interviews.”\n\nShe says she is currently undergoing recovery through a mental health program in the U.S. Virgin Islands — where Epstein’s island is located.\n\nImportant Stories attempted to contact Pozhidaeva-Platt and her family. Her attorney, Kyle Stroup, responded:\n“Ms. Pozhidaeva declines to provide any further comment or information at this time and is not looking to engage in further interviews. Accordingly, we respectfully request that you cease contacting her or her family.”","blocks":[{"data":"Lana Pozhidaeva’s biography stands in sharp contrast to the typical stories of young women from poor families in post-Soviet countries who became victims of the influential American financier Jeffrey Epstein. According to the official account, Epstein died by suicide in a New York jail cell after U.S. authorities charged him with sexual exploitation of minors and human trafficking.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Pozhidaeva was born and raised in Moscow in a well-off family. From an early age, Svetlana — her full name —<a href=\"https://www.thevoicemag.ru/lifestyle/stil-zhizni/lana-pozhidaevav-odin-moment-ya-reshila-nachat-vse-s-nulya-i-pereehat-v-evropu/?utm_source=google.com&amp;utm_medium=organic&amp;utm_campaign=google.com&amp;utm_referrer=google.com\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> played tennis</a>, but ultimately chose a career in finance: she graduated from MGIMO with honors, learned English, French, Italian, and Spanish,<a href=\"https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%2011/EFTA02408860.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> interned</a> at the Russian Foreign Ministry and at Lukoil, studied in France, and immediately after graduation began working as an analyst at Credit Europe Bank, later moving on to Russian investment firms.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, in 2008, Pozhidaeva abruptly changed career paths and tried modeling: at age 24, she submitted photos to a Maxim magazine competition and unexpectedly reached the finals, she<a href=\"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sNxUrdoTpG8\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> told</a> journalists in 2018.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“My parents said: you’re crazy. When someone tells me I’m crazy, I take it as a compliment, because the worst thing for me is being told I’m boring or ordinary,”</em> Pozhidaeva explained.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The MGIMO graduate signed her first modeling contract with the Milan-based agency Elite Models and then moved to Europe. At the same time, in the United States she was represented by MC2 Model Management, an agency founded with Epstein’s money by Jean-Luc Brunel, a close associate of the financier. Brunel was widely considered a key supplier of underage girls to Epstein’s network and was himself accused of raping minors. After Epstein’s death in 2019, Brunel was arrested in France and in 2022 was found dead in his prison cell.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17901,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Screenshots: fashionmodeldirectory.com, justice.gov","caption":"By the time the MGIMO graduate joined Brunel’s agency, his ties to Epstein were already well known","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6301f19c20d847e3863d6699b491c0cc-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6301f19c20d847e3863d6699b491c0cc-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6301f19c20d847e3863d6699b491c0cc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6301f19c20d847e3863d6699b491c0cc-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6301f19c20d847e3863d6699b491c0cc-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6301f19c20d847e3863d6699b491c0cc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6301f19c20d847e3863d6699b491c0cc-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6301f19c20d847e3863d6699b491c0cc-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6301f19c20d847e3863d6699b491c0cc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6301f19c20d847e3863d6699b491c0cc-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6301f19c20d847e3863d6699b491c0cc-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6301f19c20d847e3863d6699b491c0cc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6301f19c20d847e3863d6699b491c0cc-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6301f19c20d847e3863d6699b491c0cc-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6301f19c20d847e3863d6699b491c0cc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6301f19c20d847e3863d6699b491c0cc-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6301f19c20d847e3863d6699b491c0cc-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6301f19c20d847e3863d6699b491c0cc-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Pozhidaeva’s introduction to Epstein took place in 2008: documents published by the U.S. Department of Justice include an email from Epstein’s assistant sending him Lana’s phone numbers and asking him to call the Russian model. From then on, Pozhidaeva became closely acquainted not only with Epstein but also with other influential figures in the United States. By at least 2010, she had begun helping the financier — accused of pedophilia — recruit young women in former Soviet countries.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After the U.S. Department of Justice released millions of documents from the Epstein case, Pozhidaeva drew attention from leading global media outlets. A week ago, she spoke publicly to reporters from <em>The Wall Street Journal</em>, saying she had been manipulated and abused by Epstein and that she recruited young women for his network against her will. She denied any ties to Russian authorities.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, in that interview Pozhidaeva left out many details about her cooperation with Epstein, as well as aspects of her biography, which begins in Moscow’s notorious House on the Embankment — a building where many prominent Bolsheviks and security officials once lived before being sent to labor camps or executed.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>Important Stories</em> uncovered previously unreported details about Pozhidaeva’s life and explains how a woman from a family of Russian intelligence officers built a career within the sex-network of a powerful American financier.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>House on the Embankment</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Pozhidaeva was born and raised in Moscow in a Stalin-era apartment building near Begovaya, but part of her family has lived for generations in the House on the Embankment. The apartment there was allocated to her maternal grandfather, Colonel Marcel Platonov, a well-known Soviet military surgeon and gynecologist. Platonov worked in Kremlin and General Staff clinics and became one of the leading gynecologists of the Soviet Ministry of Defense.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Svetlana’s parents — Yuri and Irina — graduated from the Military Institute of Foreign Languages in Moscow, colloquially known as a “spy school.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17902,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"social","caption":"Yuri and Irina Pozhidaev at a reunion of graduates from the Military Institute of Foreign Languages and the Military Red Banner Institute of the USSR Ministry of Defense","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd227f59f9c546ffbfe54235310464a6-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd227f59f9c546ffbfe54235310464a6-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd227f59f9c546ffbfe54235310464a6-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd227f59f9c546ffbfe54235310464a6-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd227f59f9c546ffbfe54235310464a6-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd227f59f9c546ffbfe54235310464a6-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd227f59f9c546ffbfe54235310464a6-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd227f59f9c546ffbfe54235310464a6-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd227f59f9c546ffbfe54235310464a6-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd227f59f9c546ffbfe54235310464a6-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd227f59f9c546ffbfe54235310464a6-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd227f59f9c546ffbfe54235310464a6-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd227f59f9c546ffbfe54235310464a6-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd227f59f9c546ffbfe54235310464a6-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd227f59f9c546ffbfe54235310464a6-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd227f59f9c546ffbfe54235310464a6-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd227f59f9c546ffbfe54235310464a6-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd227f59f9c546ffbfe54235310464a6-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Graduates of the institute often went on to serve in the KGB’s First Chief Directorate (foreign intelligence) or in the military attaché corps, a source who served alongside interpreters from the institute in conflict zones told <em>Important Stories</em>. The institute was also one of the few military schools that admitted women.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Among its well-known graduates are arms trafficker Viktor Bout and Yuri Drozdov, head of the KGB’s illegal intelligence network from 1979 to 1991 and deputy head of the First Chief Directorate, who in 1962 organized the exchange of Soviet spy Rudolf Abel for U.S. pilot Francis Gary Powers.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Pozhidaeva’s father, Yuri Pozhidaev, trained as a Persian-language military interpreter and in 1978, on the eve of the Soviet invasion, was sent to Afghanistan as part of the military advisory corps. During the war, he remained in Kabul working within the office of the chief military adviser (a structure tied to the General Staff). Little is known about his later career except his rank — lieutenant colonel. It appears that both of Lana’s parents left service in the late 1990s.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"As Pozhidaeva’s relationship with Epstein grew closer and her role in his network became more significant, she began introducing her relatives to her boss and his influential associates.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Her father and the FSB</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In the spring of 2015, Pozhidaeva’s brother Sergey traveled to the United States. She tried to place him in companies linked to Epstein and to Sultan Ahmed bin Sulayem, the former head of the global logistics giant DP World, who was dismissed earlier this year following reports about his ties to Epstein.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In December 2015, Pozhidaeva’s parents also traveled to the U.S., as confirmed by both correspondence and Russian border-crossing records. Ahead of their visit, Epstein transferred more than $237,000 from his offshore Butterfly Trust to Lana’s account “for the family.” The parents stayed with her in New York and later moved to Epstein’s Florida residence.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After visiting the mansion, Lana’s mother wrote to Epstein:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“My son asked me: \"How's the house\"? I said that it's like \"Great Getsby\"; \"No,- he said,- it's not Great Getsby , it's Great Jeffry!\" So, for our family you are a Great man!’”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A few days later, Lana told Epstein that she had introduced her parents to her then-boyfriend Pen King:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“Dad shared some stories from his FSB part, Pen loved it.”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17903,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Social media, justice.gov","caption":"From left to right: Lana with her brother Sergei in New York; Lana with her father; Lana, Yuri, Irina, and Sergei Pozhidaev at the table","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a001373857b45e5b8a4116394dcb0b2-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a001373857b45e5b8a4116394dcb0b2-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a001373857b45e5b8a4116394dcb0b2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a001373857b45e5b8a4116394dcb0b2-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a001373857b45e5b8a4116394dcb0b2-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a001373857b45e5b8a4116394dcb0b2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a001373857b45e5b8a4116394dcb0b2-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a001373857b45e5b8a4116394dcb0b2-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a001373857b45e5b8a4116394dcb0b2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a001373857b45e5b8a4116394dcb0b2-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a001373857b45e5b8a4116394dcb0b2-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a001373857b45e5b8a4116394dcb0b2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a001373857b45e5b8a4116394dcb0b2-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a001373857b45e5b8a4116394dcb0b2-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a001373857b45e5b8a4116394dcb0b2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a001373857b45e5b8a4116394dcb0b2-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a001373857b45e5b8a4116394dcb0b2-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/8a001373857b45e5b8a4116394dcb0b2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"After the family became close to Epstein, Yuri Pozhidaev’s career in Russia advanced rapidly. In December 2017, the retired lieutenant colonel began working at Technopromexport (part of the Rostec holding, the main producer of the Russian arms) and frequently traveled to Tehran, where the company was building energy infrastructure.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2018, while continuing to receive a salary from Technopromexport, he became deputy head of security in the Iranian division of Russian Railways International, which was building the “North–South” transport corridor linking Russia, Iran, and India — a<a href=\"https://www.tatar-inform.ru/news/xusnullin-investicii-v-mtk-sever-yug-ocenivayutsya-v-280-mlrd-rublei-do-2030-goda-5906394\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> major international government project</a> involving billions of rubles in investment.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Moreover, in 2020, while still formally employed by Russian Railways, Pozhidaev became deputy general director for security at Caspian Services,<a href=\"https://www.rbc.ru/business/29/10/2025/6900cc729a794738494fb5db\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> the main contractor</a> for Russia’s Ministry of Transport on the same corridor project. He remained in that role at least until early 2026.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The types of positions Yuri Pozhidaev held in state corporations are typically reserved for security service officers — often so-called “seconded personnel” (APS) from the FSB. Orders assigning such officers to companies, banks, and ministries are signed by the FSB director; the officers receive formal positions related to security but remain in active service and report back to the agency.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Investigative journalists from the Explainer project<a href=\"https://explainer.one/materials/iz-doma-na-naberezhnoj-na-ostrov-epshtejna-1\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> found</a> that in 2022 Yuri Pozhidaev sent three letters to the address at 20/2 Bolshaya Lubyanka — home to the Moscow regional FSB pension department.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>A family of recruiters</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Correspondence between Epstein and Pozhidaeva differs from his communication with other models from the former Soviet Union: in his emails, Epstein does not flirt with Lana, and she, unlike many others, does not appear to harbor romantic illusions about their relationship.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At the beginning of their relationship in 2009, Epstein<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/EFTA02415963?view=inbox\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> helped</a> Lana with visa issues and invited her to events at the United Nations and<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/EFTA02276670?view=inbox\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> the World Economic Forum in Davos</a> alongside<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/vol00009-efta01028026-pdf?view=inbox\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> Maria Drokova</a>, a former commissar of the pro-Kremlin youth movement Nashi who later worked as Epstein’s PR agent. But within a year, Pozhidaeva began sourcing young women for Epstein from post-Soviet countries, traveling to<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/vol00009-efta00752504-pdf?view=inbox\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> Kyiv and Moscow</a> and<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/EFTA02168814?view=inbox\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> introducing</a> her friends to him.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In several emails, Epstein expressed dissatisfaction that the women she found appeared older than he preferred. In one case, Pozhidaeva offered to arrange a meeting with a 17-year-old girl (we are not publishing the link to that file because the U.S. Department of Justice did not redact the victim’s identifying details).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Before sending women to Epstein’s island, Lana arranged for some of them to take<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/EFTA02483372\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> lessons in foot massage</a> so they “would know how to do it.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Starting in 2016, Pozhidaeva began recruiting under the alias “Julia Santos” — the name of a character from the popular American soap opera <em>All My Children</em>, played by <em>Santa Barbara</em> star Sydney Penny, a cultural reference familiar to a child growing up in 1990s Moscow.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Investigators were able to link the alias to Pozhidaeva by cross-referencing emails from “Santos”<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/EFTA02367488\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> mentioning</a> meetings with her parents,<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/EFTA02389229?view=inbox\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> visits</a> from her brother, or references to her<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/EFTA02346367?view=inbox\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> boyfriend</a>, and matching those details with travel records and emails sent under her real name.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"We found messages indicating 18 women whom Pozhidaeva, under the name Julia Santos, recruited for sex parties or meetings with Epstein. The vast majority were from Russia and Ukraine. In one case, the woman was from Odesa and<a href=\"https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%2011/EFTA02622513.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> had been a victim of child pornography</a> as a teenager. In another, Epstein<a href=\"https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA00964428.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> instructed</a> that a trafficking victim not be allowed to keep food in the refrigerator because she “needed to lose six kilos” to spend time with him.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17905,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"justice.gov","caption":"Pozhidaeva organized photo shoots on Epstein’s island with victims of sex trafficking","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e274105636c04ff5aa7843c841313325-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e274105636c04ff5aa7843c841313325-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e274105636c04ff5aa7843c841313325-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e274105636c04ff5aa7843c841313325-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e274105636c04ff5aa7843c841313325-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e274105636c04ff5aa7843c841313325-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e274105636c04ff5aa7843c841313325-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e274105636c04ff5aa7843c841313325-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e274105636c04ff5aa7843c841313325-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e274105636c04ff5aa7843c841313325-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e274105636c04ff5aa7843c841313325-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e274105636c04ff5aa7843c841313325-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e274105636c04ff5aa7843c841313325-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e274105636c04ff5aa7843c841313325-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e274105636c04ff5aa7843c841313325-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e274105636c04ff5aa7843c841313325-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e274105636c04ff5aa7843c841313325-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e274105636c04ff5aa7843c841313325-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"In May 2017, Pozhidaeva sent Epstein a photograph from a party in Barbados: a Ukrainian woman is seen standing next to “A” — likely British Prince Andrew, who in 2025 was stripped of all titles due to his ties to Epstein.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“I have heard super druggy,”</em> Pozhidaeva<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/vol00009-efta00664521-pdf?view=inbox\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> wrote</a> of her.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After her parents met Epstein, they also began offering women for his network. For example, Lana’s mother attempted to “offer” a woman from Ukraine who, in her words, was “in a really bad situation.” Her father, Lieutenant Colonel Pozhidaev, sent Epstein photos of young women without comment<em> (in both cases, victims’ names were not redacted in DOJ documents).</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Feminism funded by a sex offender</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"“I feel ashamed and think about those other women all the time. That’s the hardest part of all of this — I was too consumed by my own abuse to see beyond it. I had to appear happy, to keep smiling, while privately I was battling eating disorders, depression, and insomnia,” Lana<a href=\"https://www.wsj.com/us-news/epstein-victim-svetlana-pozhidaeva-22f2ebf6\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> said</a> in her interview with <em>The Wall Street Journal</em>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Her work was well paid: Epstein<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/EFTA02398837?view=inbox\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> wrote</a> that at the beginning she earned about $30,000 per year after taxes — roughly the median salary in New York at the time. From at least 2017, DOJ materials show payments to Pozhidaeva of $8,333 per month through Epstein’s Enhanced Education foundation, set up as<a href=\"https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%2011/EFTA02633246.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> automatic transfers</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Over the years, Lana accumulated enough money to purchase two small apartments in central Moscow.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"She now claims she was a victim like the underage girls, arguing that Epstein controlled her immigration status, housing, and finances. She says she could not leave because large payments were structured as loans. <em>Important Stories</em> found no confirmation of this in the available files.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Epstein also supported her business ventures. He<a href=\"https://littlesis.org/person/379708-Lana_Pozhidaeva\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> donated</a> more than $50,000 to the Education Advance foundation she co-founded in 2017 with her boyfriend, New York venture investor Pendleton King Jr. Investigative journalists later<a href=\"https://www.thedailybeast.com/billionaire-pedophile-jeffrey-epstein-funded-womens-empowerment-entrepreneur-lana-pozhidaeva/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> found</a> that the funds went to a Buddhist organization at MIT. The ultimate purpose of the project remains unclear.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17906,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"justice.gov, Daily Beast","caption":"","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e0cabb6689845d6a59838967bb0f7f8-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e0cabb6689845d6a59838967bb0f7f8-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e0cabb6689845d6a59838967bb0f7f8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e0cabb6689845d6a59838967bb0f7f8-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e0cabb6689845d6a59838967bb0f7f8-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e0cabb6689845d6a59838967bb0f7f8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e0cabb6689845d6a59838967bb0f7f8-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e0cabb6689845d6a59838967bb0f7f8-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e0cabb6689845d6a59838967bb0f7f8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e0cabb6689845d6a59838967bb0f7f8-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e0cabb6689845d6a59838967bb0f7f8-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e0cabb6689845d6a59838967bb0f7f8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e0cabb6689845d6a59838967bb0f7f8-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e0cabb6689845d6a59838967bb0f7f8-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e0cabb6689845d6a59838967bb0f7f8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e0cabb6689845d6a59838967bb0f7f8-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e0cabb6689845d6a59838967bb0f7f8-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6e0cabb6689845d6a59838967bb0f7f8-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Another initiative she launched with Epstein’s support was<a href=\"https://www.bizprofile.net/ny/new-york/we-talks-enterprises-llc\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> WE Talks</a> — a platform modeled on TED Talks, aimed at bringing together ambitious women. The name stood for “Women Empowerment.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The project was registered at Epstein’s address,<a href=\"https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA00811860.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> funded</a> by him, and Lana<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/vol00009-efta01041363-pdf?view=inbox\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> discussed</a> its operations with him directly.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Its co-director was<a href=\"https://www.linkedin.com/in/victoria-drokova-69703967/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> Viktoria Drokova</a>, sister of Maria Drokova. Maria herself also participated.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In correspondence, Lana described how they were brainstorming ways to reshape Epstein’s public image:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“We are brainstorming with Masha how we can turn the discussion around and ask why money should not be taken for a good cause just because sth had happened 10+ years ago and that you had funded great projects and probably saved many lives. Hope this can be good.”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2019, Pozhidaeva and the Drokova sisters<a href=\"https://www.thevoicemag.ru/lifestyle/stil-zhizni/lana-pozhidaevav-odin-moment-ya-reshila-nachat-vse-s-nulya-i-pereehat-v-evropu/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> began</a> holding WE Talks events in Moscow, but Epstein’s death disrupted their plans.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Pozhidaeva also claimed she feared retaliation if she tried to leave Epstein — not for herself, but for her family in Russia. She suggested Epstein could pressure her parents through connections in Russian leadership, including Sergey Belyakov, an FSB officer and former deputy minister of economic development.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17908,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"justice.gov, Wikimedia Commons","caption":"Pozhidaeva and FSB officer Belyakov communicated outside the St. Petersburg Forum as well","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61e45b5d80304c66ae8051a4dbbee8b9-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61e45b5d80304c66ae8051a4dbbee8b9-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61e45b5d80304c66ae8051a4dbbee8b9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61e45b5d80304c66ae8051a4dbbee8b9-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61e45b5d80304c66ae8051a4dbbee8b9-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61e45b5d80304c66ae8051a4dbbee8b9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61e45b5d80304c66ae8051a4dbbee8b9-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61e45b5d80304c66ae8051a4dbbee8b9-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61e45b5d80304c66ae8051a4dbbee8b9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61e45b5d80304c66ae8051a4dbbee8b9-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61e45b5d80304c66ae8051a4dbbee8b9-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61e45b5d80304c66ae8051a4dbbee8b9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61e45b5d80304c66ae8051a4dbbee8b9-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61e45b5d80304c66ae8051a4dbbee8b9-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61e45b5d80304c66ae8051a4dbbee8b9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61e45b5d80304c66ae8051a4dbbee8b9-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61e45b5d80304c66ae8051a4dbbee8b9-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/61e45b5d80304c66ae8051a4dbbee8b9-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Belyakov was indeed a long-time contact of Epstein in Russia.<a href=\"https://dossier.center/jeffreyepsteinrusconnect/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> According to </a><a href=\"https://dossier.center/jeffreyepsteinrusconnect/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>the Dossier Center</em></a>, Epstein advised him on economic issues and helped bring high-profile guests to the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum, while Belyakov introduced Epstein to senior officials in Russia’s Finance Ministry and Central Bank.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<a href=\"https://novayagazeta.eu/articles/2026/02/04/epshtein-poluchil-rossiiskuiu-vizu-po-priglasheniiu-veteranov-fsb-news\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">According to </a><a href=\"https://novayagazeta.eu/articles/2026/02/04/epshtein-poluchil-rossiiskuiu-vizu-po-priglasheniiu-veteranov-fsb-news\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>Novaya Gazeta Europe</em></a>, Belyakov helped Epstein obtain a Russian visa in 2011 via an FSB veterans’ organization. Epstein<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/vol00009-efta00752504-pdf?view=inbox\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> wrote</a> that he planned to visit Moscow, but there is no evidence he did.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Pozhidaeva herself<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/EFTA02586572?view=inbox\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> helped facilitate</a> contacts between Epstein and Russian officials, including preparations for meetings with Finance Ministry and Central Bank representatives. In 2014, Belyakov<a href=\"https://dossier.center/jeffreyepsteinrusconnect/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> wrote</a> a recommendation letter supporting her U.S. visa extension.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>“Snow White” and America’s power elite</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Over ten years working for Epstein, Pozhidaeva gained access to some of the most powerful people in the U.S. and globally.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2010, paparazzi<a href=\"https://www.nzherald.co.nz/lifestyle/was-russian-model-linked-to-sex-trafficker-jeffrey-epstein-at-the-manhattan-apartment-with-prince-andrew/YKZTVFM7K2MC2BXLPIJYRLSGCE/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> photographed</a> her leaving Epstein’s Manhattan mansion on a day when Prince Andrew was present. She later identified herself in photos with Bill Gates and Norwegian diplomat Terje Rød-Larsen, who also stepped down from positions after his ties to Epstein became public.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17909,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Daily Mail via pressreader.com, justice.gov","caption":"Pozhidaeva is not well known, but her name often comes up in high-profile scandals","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f99f112c6d44ff4bea50996d5ace0b0-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f99f112c6d44ff4bea50996d5ace0b0-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f99f112c6d44ff4bea50996d5ace0b0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f99f112c6d44ff4bea50996d5ace0b0-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f99f112c6d44ff4bea50996d5ace0b0-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f99f112c6d44ff4bea50996d5ace0b0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f99f112c6d44ff4bea50996d5ace0b0-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f99f112c6d44ff4bea50996d5ace0b0-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f99f112c6d44ff4bea50996d5ace0b0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f99f112c6d44ff4bea50996d5ace0b0-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f99f112c6d44ff4bea50996d5ace0b0-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f99f112c6d44ff4bea50996d5ace0b0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f99f112c6d44ff4bea50996d5ace0b0-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f99f112c6d44ff4bea50996d5ace0b0-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f99f112c6d44ff4bea50996d5ace0b0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f99f112c6d44ff4bea50996d5ace0b0-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f99f112c6d44ff4bea50996d5ace0b0-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9f99f112c6d44ff4bea50996d5ace0b0-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Their interactions appear to have been professional, including<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/EFTA02111976?view=inbox\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> helping</a> organize visits and meetings.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, her name also appears in correspondence linked to sexual encounters involving prominent individuals.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In one email exchange, Epstein<a href=\"https://www.businessinsider.com/epstein-files-reveal-new-snow-white-emails-2026-2\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> requested</a> a Snow White costume for a party.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“Brett Rattner is going to film a big movie Snow White, I would love to take photos of you in a snow white costume. You can get it from the costume store,”</em> he wrote.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Afterward, Barclays CEO Jes Staley<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/EFTA01300650?view=inbox\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> wrote</a>:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“That was fun. Say hi to Snow White.”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Pozhidaeva a few hours later<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/EFTA02410216?view=inbox\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> reported</a>:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“the snow white was f..ed twice as soon as she put her costume.”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17910,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"justice.gov","caption":"After Pozhidaeva told Epstein about the party with “Snow White,” he received photos of that very girl","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86dbb4e47e184d53b2cf185579dbd8b2-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86dbb4e47e184d53b2cf185579dbd8b2-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86dbb4e47e184d53b2cf185579dbd8b2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86dbb4e47e184d53b2cf185579dbd8b2-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86dbb4e47e184d53b2cf185579dbd8b2-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86dbb4e47e184d53b2cf185579dbd8b2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86dbb4e47e184d53b2cf185579dbd8b2-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86dbb4e47e184d53b2cf185579dbd8b2-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86dbb4e47e184d53b2cf185579dbd8b2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86dbb4e47e184d53b2cf185579dbd8b2-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86dbb4e47e184d53b2cf185579dbd8b2-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86dbb4e47e184d53b2cf185579dbd8b2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86dbb4e47e184d53b2cf185579dbd8b2-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86dbb4e47e184d53b2cf185579dbd8b2-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86dbb4e47e184d53b2cf185579dbd8b2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86dbb4e47e184d53b2cf185579dbd8b2-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86dbb4e47e184d53b2cf185579dbd8b2-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/86dbb4e47e184d53b2cf185579dbd8b2-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"In the early 2010s, Pozhidaeva had a relationship with<a href=\"https://www.gettyimages.de/detail/nachrichtenfoto/joshua-fink-and-svetlana-pozhivaeva-attend-the-19th-nachrichtenfoto/131767256\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> Joshua Fink</a>, son of BlackRock founder Larry Fink — one of the most powerful figures in global finance.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In 2012, Epstein<a href=\"https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%209/EFTA00661909.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> introduced</a> her to Elon Musk and attempted to<a href=\"https://www.justice.gov/epstein/files/DataSet%2010/EFTA01895036.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> arrange</a> meetings in Paris, promising Musk “a lot of fun” with her.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"He also<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/EFTA02431658?view=inbox\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> tried</a> to match her with Saudi businessman Mohammed Abdul Latif Jameel, though unsuccessfully. However, Pozhidaeva later<a href=\"https://jmail.world/thread/EFTA02565917?view=inbox\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> claimed</a> she had a sexual relationship with his son, Hassan Jameel.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17911,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Social media, justice.gov, Wikimedia Commons","caption":"In the photo, dressed in evening wear, are Lana Pozhidaeva and her then-boyfriend, Joshua Fink, the son of BlackRock’s CEO","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3c460af4371849e3b3d8c163a6a69d48-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3c460af4371849e3b3d8c163a6a69d48-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3c460af4371849e3b3d8c163a6a69d48-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3c460af4371849e3b3d8c163a6a69d48-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3c460af4371849e3b3d8c163a6a69d48-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3c460af4371849e3b3d8c163a6a69d48-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3c460af4371849e3b3d8c163a6a69d48-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3c460af4371849e3b3d8c163a6a69d48-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3c460af4371849e3b3d8c163a6a69d48-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3c460af4371849e3b3d8c163a6a69d48-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3c460af4371849e3b3d8c163a6a69d48-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3c460af4371849e3b3d8c163a6a69d48-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":675,"real_height_2x":1192},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3c460af4371849e3b3d8c163a6a69d48-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3c460af4371849e3b3d8c163a6a69d48-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3c460af4371849e3b3d8c163a6a69d48-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3c460af4371849e3b3d8c163a6a69d48-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3c460af4371849e3b3d8c163a6a69d48-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3c460af4371849e3b3d8c163a6a69d48-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":467}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"<strong>After Epstein</strong>","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Six months after Epstein’s death, Pozhidaeva changed her identity. Now 42, she goes by Sofia Platt and has changed her name in her Russian passport.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"She continues to work from the United States. In San Francisco, she co-founded<a href=\"https://bridgefundingglobal.com/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> Bridge Funding Global</a>, a fundraising platform focused on women entrepreneurs, and contributes to business publications such as<a href=\"https://www.forbes.com/sites/ellevate/2021/02/04/women-founders-and-funders-are-outperforming-so-why-is-gender-inequality-growing-and-what-do-we-do-about-it/?sh=3d82d9fe357e\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> </a><a href=\"https://www.forbes.com/sites/ellevate/2021/02/04/women-founders-and-funders-are-outperforming-so-why-is-gender-inequality-growing-and-what-do-we-do-about-it/?sh=3d82d9fe357e\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>Forbes</em></a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Melinda French Gates<a href=\"https://www.forbes.com/sites/evaepker/2023/06/27/10-trillion-and-counting-three-best-practices-for-female-gps-looking-to-capitalize-on-the-growing-power-of-female-lps/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> spoke</a> at the opening of one of her events.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Pozhidaeva says she also mentors children in foster care and invests in private credit. She describes her past work as consulting for social enterprises.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"She has largely withdrawn from public view and now identifies herself as a “victim of human trafficking.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"On her website, she states:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“I have already told my story. In order to preserve my mental well-being and the integrity of this process, I will not accept further media requests or give interviews.”</em>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"She says she is currently undergoing recovery through a mental health program in the U.S. Virgin Islands — where Epstein’s island is located.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>Important Stories</em> attempted to contact Pozhidaeva-Platt and her family. Her attorney, Kyle Stroup, responded:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>“Ms. Pozhidaeva declines to provide any further comment or information at this time and is not looking to engage in further interviews. Accordingly, we respectfully request that you cease contacting her or her family.”</em>","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":9292,"header":"The Russian War Snuff Videos Industry: “Welcome to the Real Murders Channel”","_path":"/en/stories/2026/03/17/the-russian-war-snuff-videos-industry-welcome-to-the-real-murders-channel/","lead":"Who makes money off videos of brutal war executions published on Telegram channels","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2592,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1296},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2592,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1296},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ff35b013d1446abaf5411d72acc1f99-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Illustration: Mila Grabowsky / Important Stories","created_at_date":"2026-03-17","created_at_date_time":"2026-03-16T14:04:45.166Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":9,"first_name":"Ирина","last_name":"Долинина","first_name_en":"Irina","last_name_en":"Dolinina","is_public":true,"_path":"irina-dolinina","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Журналистка «Важных историй»","lead_en":"IStories' investigative reporter","position":"Авторка","position_en":"Author","ordering":1},{"id":63,"first_name":"Александр","last_name":"Атасунцев","first_name_en":"Aleksandr","last_name_en":"Atasuntsev","is_public":true,"_path":"aleksandr-atasuntsev","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1600,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":900},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1600,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":900},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9221d0c3f56540c987baccd79213070b-original.jpeg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Автор отдела расследований","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":2}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[{"id":35,"first_name":"Мария","last_name":"Жолобова","first_name_en":"Maria","last_name_en":"Zholobova","is_public":true,"_path":"maria-zholobova","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-896x504px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-896x504px_2x.png","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-688x387px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-688x387px_2x.png","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-416x234px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-416x234px_2x.png","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-336x189px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-336x189px_2x.png","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Редакторка","position_en":null,"ordering":1},{"id":8,"first_name":"Алеся","last_name":"Мароховская","first_name_en":"Alesya","last_name_en":"Marokhovskaya","is_public":true,"_path":"alesya-marokhovskaya","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/12285015ded6416c9ce475e3a939d7f7-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Главная редакторка «Важных историй»","lead_en":"Editor-in-chief","position":"Редакторка","position_en":"Editor","ordering":2}],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[{"id":11,"first_name":"Дмитрий","last_name":"Великовский","first_name_en":"Dmitry","last_name_en":"Velikovsky","is_public":true,"_path":"dmitry-velikovsky","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":189,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/078f94d54df44f239737af7e8b861959-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":189,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":1}],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"In 2022, a new trend emerged in the Russian segment of Telegram messenger: public channels exclusively publishing incredibly graphic, violent videos of the war in Ukraine, including combat killings, executions of war prisoners, and desecration of the bodies of the deceased. In four years of the war, such channels have gained hundreds of thousands of subscribers and became successful businesses. The owners of the channels try to carefully hide themselves behind anonymous accounts. However, IStories managed to find out how the Telegram military snuff videos market works and who is making money from it.\n\nWarning: This text contains descriptions of murder and violence as well as profanity and ethnic slurs.\n\nA drone-filmed video shows a battle underway, and a soldier is taking an enemy captive. The captive has a yellow armband on his sleeve, worn by the Armed Forces of Ukraine; he has raised his hands and is not resisting. Off-camera, presumedly Russian soldiers are commenting on the footage in real time. “FInish him off,” a voice can be heard on the radio. “Don’t talk to him, just fucking kill him,” says another one. The video freezes for a few seconds; the commenters are confused. The next thing we see is the captive’s body falling. “Fuck it, that’s awesome,” the soldiers cheer. \n\nThis video was posted on the “Video *** 18+” Telegram channel (here and further on, we hide the exact names of these channels not to give them publicity — Ed.) on January 2, 2026. “Our stormtrooper beats up a pig and captures it in hand-to-hand combat, then decides it’s useless and kills it,” the video caption reads. \n\nThe channel has almost 40 thousand subscribers. The main content is the so-called snuff: videos of Ukrainian soldiers being killed, corpses torn to pieces or burned, bodies desecrated, all titled with offensive captions such as “the pigs who tried to surrender being shot.” Sometimes the channel author even specifies the “key moments” timecodes. “For The Hague,” he comments sarcastically.\n\n“Video *** 18+” is an anonymous channel, but IStories managed to find the founder, Vladimir Grebennikov, 36, a refractory worker at the Volgograd Aluminum Plant. In his free time, he goes fishing with his father, an Afghan War vet. On his social media page, the father often recalls his service and posts the war photos, including the dead Soviet soldiers’ bodies. \n\nAt night, Grebennikov participates in amateur car races. His social media avatar is Russia’s imperial flag with “We are Russians — God is with us” slogan written on it. On Telegram, the name “Vova” is accompanied by a Russian national flag icon.\nRefractory workers in Volgograd are paid less than 80,000 rubles (approx. USD 1,000) per month. Most likely, Grebennikov earned more by selling ads on the channel. “Video *** 18+” publishes about 30 advertising posts per week, mostly promoting other channels, or sometimes counterfeit cigarettes shops and online casinos. According to IStories' estimate based on pricing in this kind of market, the channel might be bringing its owner about 200,000 rubles (approx. USD 2,500) per month.\n\nGrebennikov tells IStories he “has been interested in the topic of war” his entire life. “I watch these videos myself,” he said. “And I decided: if I watch them, why not create a channel and start posting them? So I started doing this, and then somehow they ended up at the top of Google and Yandex (Russian search engine – Ed.) search results. Then people started following the channel. That’s basically it. I was never going to become a blogger or anything like that.” \n\nGrebennikov himself hasn’t fought and does not want to: “To be a soldier, a contract soldier, to go to war, you have to be brave, at least. I’m not.”\n\nBy early 2026, he had sold his channel because he had “burned out during all that time.” When asked how much he had managed to earn from the channel, Grebennikov refused to answer. \nWhat are snuff videos, and where are they coming from?\n\nBefore the Russo-Ukrainian war, no other conflict in history had been documented in such detail with photos and videos. Cameras are placed on hundreds of thousands of drones, which have become an indispensable warfare tool. Russian soldiers wear cameras on their helmets to record “the evidence of their heroism and the elimination of targets,” a former soldier told IStories on an anonymous basis. And, of course, soldiers also have cameras on their phones. \n\nThe military immediately saw the potential of such footage. For example, the “Arkhangel Spetsnaza” (translated as “Special Forces Archangel” — Ed.) Telegram channel has been providing detailed operation coverage since the beginning of the invasion, starting with the Hostomel Airport air assault on February 24. As IStories found out, the channel was created by Yevgeny Zhulidov, an officer of the 45th Airborne Troops Special Purpose Brigade. He now has over 1.1 million subscribers and might earn up to 3.8 million rubles (approx. USD 48,000) a month from advertising, based on the rates provided by his advertising manager, multiplied by the number of such posts. \n\nThere are also channels posting nothing but snuff content: photos and videos of murders, mutilated bodies, and desecration of corpses. Execution exclusives are popular, especially when filmed from a first-person perspective. A typical ad looks like this: “GoPro recordings of khokhols (derogatory slur meaning Ukrainians — Ed.) shot in the head, the wounded finished off, and whole groups killed: here you’ll find everything others don't dare to show on their channels.” \nIStories examined more than 50 war snuff Telegram channels. Most of them are run by civilians, not military personnel. For example, Grebennikov, an aluminum plant worker, has never been to the front himself, but would find the videos and the photos online: “Sometimes I indicated the source, sometimes I didn’t.” From time to time, Grebennikov would post messages of gratitude to the subscribers, posing as a member of the military. The credulous subscribers responded by wishing “our guys” good luck. \n\nAccording to a former Russian military officer interviewed by IStories, the footage of incidents that the soldiers send to the command posts often leaks from there. “Even if the video is highly classified, there will always be someone who will leak it for money or hype.”\n\nSuch videos and photos subsequently become war crimes evidence. The UN Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine (HRMMU) has confirmed cases of executions of Ukrainian military personnel via this evidence. According to the latest report by the UN Human Rights Office, there have been no fewer than 96 executions of Ukrainian soldiers confirmed since 2022. The HRMMU told IStories they also keep an eye on the Russian snuff channels.\nIn just one of the channels, IStories found 51 videos of mass shootings and beheadings in the “Executions” section. In the “Executions (photos)” section, there are 53 more photos of corpses. Some of them have their hands tied. \nSometimes the admins try to squeeze maximum profit out of such videos and ask subscribers for “donations.”\n\n“Guys. Does anyone want to donate 1.000 rubles to our fighter for executing a khokhol?” a snuff channel admin wrote in a chat on December 3, 2025. “We have the footage,” another administrator wrote a few hours later. “We’ll post it on the channel soon.” The same day, a video titled “Awesome exclusive finishing off a foreign mercenary” was posted. The video shows a wounded soldier lying on the ground is executed with a gunshot to the head.\n\n“We also thank our subscriber for financially supporting the soldier who finished this idiot off!” the video description reads. “Hear me out, executions are fucking awesome,” commented the admin in the chat.\n\nOn December 7, 2025, the same admin called on the subscribers to help with the content search: “The simplest and most effective way is to write to the soldiers and ask them to provide the footage [...] If a soldier asks for money in return, let us know.”\n\nHow teenagers monetize snuff\n\n“Happy New Year, everyone. There were many sad events and things in 2022, but any disappointment is overshadowed by the pleasant fact that about 100,000 combat pigs (and thousands of civilians😁) have been killed. And in 2023, with God’s help, we'll kill at least as many more,” another Telegram channel, “*** slaughter”, the admin addressed his subscribers at the end of 2022. \nThis channel has been around for more than three years. It is the largest war snuff content channel IStories has been able to find, with over 100,000 subscribers.\n\nSince its launch, “*** slaughter” has published more than 15,000 photos and 20,000 videos. The channel publishes footage — both exclusive and taken from somewhere else — showing dead Ukrainian soldiers and moments of them being killed. Ads are also posted almost every day: military service campaign ads, online casinos, and AI bots for undressing girls in photos.\n\nIStories found out that the channel has been monetized by teenagers. Their contact details have been listed for advertising inquiries right in the channel description next to the “18+” label.\n\nDenis Bogolyubov is now 19 years old. He comes from the village of Korkatovo in the Republic of Mari El, with a population of about 500 people. In the neighboring village school, there are two memorial plaques to local residents who went to war and died, and Denis’ uncle is one of them. \n\nDenis was involved in advertising the “*** slaughter” channel during, at the very least, the summer and fall of 2023, when he was 16 years old. In addition to the snuff channel, Denis collaborated with educational and entertainment Telegram communities. “In more than two years of active work on Telegram, I have gained extensive experience in budget management and the implementation of successful cases,” Bogolyubov writes on his personal channel. Denis charges “15% to 25%, depending on the subject” for advertising services “with his trusted people” and more than 11,000 rubles for “consulting.” \n\nBogolyubov did not respond to IStories’ inquiries.\n\nThe second teenage advertising manager had not even turned 16 when he started working for the “*** slaughter” channel in 2023. Artem Prigodin is from the village of Konosha in the Arkhangelsk Oblast. In 2023 and 2024, Artem appeared as the administrator or advertising manager of two other trash channels called “not for the faint-hearted” and “18+ strictly.” His advertising career has been interrupted by compulsory military service at the Russian border. \n\nArtem Prigodin confirmed to us that he worked for “*** slaughter” in 2023–2024, but then “had a beef with the owner and quit.” According to Prigodin, he did not meet the channel owner in person and “only saw him via camera.” He claims the owner is not a member of the military. After completing his compulsory military service, Prigodin has no intention of remaining in the army on a contract basis: “It’s a one-way ticket. You sign the contract, and tomorrow you’re cannon fodder.”\nIStories weren’t able to identify the “*** slaughter” channel owner.\n\n“Are we supposed to be ashamed to post and watch?”\n\nAs IStories found out, not only do teens manage the ads in snuff channels, but they also create and actively run their own violent footage communities. We know at least two channels like this. \n\nOne of them, called “***’s Funny Corpses,” was created in 2022 and blocked in 2025 after gaining just over 8,000 subscribers. The owner recreated the channel, and 800 people subscribed to it. \n\nIn the last few weeks alone, the channel has published a photo of a decapitated Ukrainian soldier whose head is impaled on a stick; a video of a Russian soldier urinating on a corpse; and a photo of a body with its hands tied and its skull crushed. The administrators made their own sticker pack from such photos of killed Ukrainian soldiers. \n\nIStories discovered that the founder of this channel is Artem Filippov, 18, from Kaluga. He calls himself the “Kaluga serial killer” and, according to his photos on social media, embraces neo-Nazi views. \nFilippov created the channel when he was just 15 years old. Among the other admins, we found four more teenagers who are now no older than 15 (their names are known to the newsroom, but we are not naming them since they are underage — Ed.). Their Telegram accounts are registered using the phone numbers of their older relatives. One of the teenagers, a 14-year-old eighth grader from Abakan, uses photos of Russian soldiers as userpics. “Mines, explosions, bloody smoke, we’ll wash away the enemy with blood, with our battle plan!” his account description reads. Information obtained from data leaks shows that, in seventh grade, he had applied to join Yunarmiya. This Russian youth organisation aims to prepare kids for future military service.\n\nIn a conversation with IStories, Artem Filippov confirmed that he founded the channel while still at school. “This channel was created in response to similar Ukrainian channels. It’s called information warfare,” Filippov claims. “I was just on the internet, arguing with some guy from Ukraine, I don’t remember the topic. He started showing me photos of our fallen soldiers, and I decided to find a channel with dead Ukrainians. At that time, there were practically none. So I decided to create my own channel.” \n\nFilippov came up with the “Funny Corpses” channel name himself: “I was just so angry that we didn’t have this kind of content, while the Ukrainians had a lot of it. That’s why I deliberately chose such a loud, provocative name.” According to Filippov, younger people are the channel’s main audience. \n\nImmediately after the conversation with IStories, Filippov announced on a backup channel that the main channel had allegedly been “blocked again,” but he would not recreate it.\nVladimir Grebennikov, the “Video *** 18+” snuff channel founder, also blames Ukrainians for provoking him to create hateful captions for his videos and photos. “I think it all started with the Ukrainians,” Grebennikov says. “Initially, there were no such [misanthropic] captions, but now 95% of them are like that.”\n\nHe noticed school kids were showing particular interest in his violent content. Nevertheless, he claims he would block minors if he identified them.\n\nGrebennikov sees no moral contradiction in posting and sharing the violent content among mass audiences:\n\n“What’s wrong with it? It’s our life, people are fighting there and dying, someone’s sisters, brothers, husbands, and so on. Do you think people shouldn’t know how it feels to them and how they died or whatever? Many people live here and don’t know that there is a war going on, figuratively speaking, they don’t give a shit, while someone else has been living in trenches for several years and so on. Do you think we shouldn’t be interested in this? Are we supposed to be ashamed to post and watch?”\n\nHow much the owners earn thanks to snuff content \n\nThere are two main ways for snuff channel owners to make money: advertisement posts and collecting donations from subscribers.\n\nAds are present on almost all snuff channels studied by IStories: it could be online casinos, tech stores, counterfeit cigarettes stores, or the military service campaign ads. Snuff channels also often promote one another.\n\nAccording to one of the administrators, the cost of an ad post depends on the reach, not on the number of subscribers. In the snuff content “market,” a thousand views cost 300–350 rubles (approx. USD 4). This indicator is known as CPM (cost per mille). Administrators of other channels estimate it more modestly: at 160 (approx. USD 2) or even just 70 (approx. USD 1) rubles per thousand views.\n\nIStories discovered a 4-snuff-channel network that, at such rates, has a total audience of 115,000 subscribers and averages 12,000 views per post, earning about 200,000 rubles per month.\n\nThis network was administered by Robert Khaibullin, 24, from Magnitogorsk. Here is how he advertised one of the channels: “If you are weak-nerved, don’t enter. If you have a stable psyche, welcome to the real murders channel.” According to the information found in data leaks, Khaibullin has never been employed. His only official income comes from sports betting and stock trading. Khaibullin told IStories he was only responsible for advertising on these channels and “didn’t even know what the content was.” “At the moment, I have completely left this field,” Khaibullin added. \nAdvertising in large communities is handled by special managers, with the same people often working for several ones. One of the manager’s contact details were listed in more than ten different channels, including the largest one, “*** slaughter.”\nMost likely, this manager is Nikita Semenov, 23, from the Oryol Oblast. The phone number he registered the account with belongs to his girlfriend, but Semenov has used it when applying for loans, IStories found out. Until 2021, Semenov had worked as a handyman in the Oryol Oblast, then moved to Moscow, where he worked in a warehouse and had a side job as a taxi driver. Semenov did not respond to our request for comment.\n\nThe “*** slaughter” channel, with its 112,000 subscribers and nearly 30,000 views per post, publishes one ad per day on average and might be earning up to 260,000 rubles per month (approx. USD 3,250). When we contacted its owner, posing as potential ad buyers, he agreed to give us a “starter discount” and place an ad for a new military-themed Telegram channel for just 2,000 rubles (approx. USD 25). Even at this price, the channel can generate over 50,000 rubles (approx. USD 620) per month in revenue.\n\nApart from ads paid for directly by clients, automatically appearing in-app ads are also shown across channels. But channel creators don't get any money from these ads if they are in Russia.\n\nThe channels’ owners also earn decent money from collecting donations from subscribers. \n\nThe “*** 21+” channel, with about 100,000 subscribers, posts videos of Ukrainians being murdered paired with reports on the money collected. “Thank you so much, friends, for your financial support 🙂 From the bottom of our hearts 👍,” the admins write, listing the amounts transferred to their cards. Judging by their posts, the channel has managed to collect almost 400,000 rubles (approx. USD 5,000) in three and a half years, with more than 800 people having contributed.\nFemale admins: Matryoshka, Goddess, and Snaky Girlboss\n\n“Friends, do you like the violent footage we publish?”, the subscribers were asked in a poll published on several war snuff channels. Out of hundreds of answers, “Yes” and “We need the videos to be more violent” were the most popular options.\n\nMany channels have their own chats and allow users to comment. In some of the channel chats, there are over 1,000 participants, with the largest one numbering almost 10,000 people. People chat all day and night: the participants either mock the Ukrainians or engage in heated discussions about the war, throwing insults at each other (as sometimes Ukraine supporters might join in the conversations). \n\nThe chat admins do not restrict or moderate the constant stream of hateful comments; instead, they encourage it. \nWe have identified more than 30 chat admins from various snuff channels. Although almost 90% of subscribers are male (according to TGStat data — Ed.), there are quite a few women among the admins.\n\nThe “*** SMO Snuff” (the “Special Military Operation” euphemism is the official term for the war in Russia — Ed.) channel's chat has a particularly high number of female admins: half of them are women. The channel itself boasts more than 50,000 subscribers, and the chat has just over a thousand members. The most active ones are the admins nicknamed “Masyanya” (Ekaterina Chrikyan, 36, from the Nizhny Novgorod Oblast), “The Angry Beastess” (Diana Loginova, 34, originally from Moldova), “Miss Sudarynya” (Ekaterina Selina, 40, from the Rostov Oblast), “Snaky Girlboss” (Natalya Abramova, 43, from the Novosibirsk Oblast), and “Goddess” (Natalya Alekhina, 39, from the Krasnodar Krai). \n\nThey mainly discuss personal topics (such as one of the women’s troubled relationship) rather than the channel's snuff content. Sometimes, another female admin, nicknamed “Matryoshka,” would pop into the chat to share updates on her combatant husband.\nThe “Goddess” confirmed to us she moderates the chat, but she doesn’t know why she was put in charge: “Probably because I’ve been around for a while. I’ve been observing [the chat] for a long time.” “Masyanya” told IStories that the channel owner, whom she is familiar with, promoted her to chat admin “behind her back.” “I’m a frequent participant, that’s all,” she explains. “My brother is in the SMO zone.” “Miss Sudarynya” said she joined the group “just like everyone else,” and then hung up, saying, “How do I know you’re not a khokhol?” “The Angry Beastess” was out of reach. \n\nWhy people are watching and talking about snuff videos\n\nAn interest in the theme of death is inherent to human nature, but it intensifies during certain historical periods, according to a criminal psychology expert interviewed by IStories on condition of anonymity. “During the periods of civil unrest, wars, and revolutions, people’s violence sensitivity threshold can shift,” the expert says.\n\nHowever, the culture of mass consumption of snuff content is not a universal characteristic of human nature, Kirill Titaev, a sociologist and researcher in law enforcement and crime, points out in an interview with the “Stories and Facts” outlet. “Undoubtedly, various forms of violent content have accompanied humanity since ancient times. But it would be fundamentally wrong to try to link this exact phenomenon to the gladiatorial fighting culture or the Middle Ages' public executions,” the sociologist says. “It would imply that humans in general have some psychological predisposition to enjoy this kind of content and to seek it. But we know of many societies of other countries and eras where there is no snuff content available at all.” \nAccording to Titaev, for the mass consumption of snuff to take root in society, it must first be socially approved. “To take off, watching this would have to be culturally legitimized, because not only is one ready to watch it, but also to discuss it,” the sociologist explains. The second factor is the physical distancing from what is happening on the screen. “Typically, the murder act — with all its associated smells, sounds, and other physical sensations — is not experienced directly by the content consumer,” Titaev adds. \n\nMass violent video consumption can be dangerous for society, according to the criminal psychology expert. “It doesn’t mean that people who become desensitized to violence will repeat it, but they will have fewer restraints,” he says.\n\nRussian legislation on snuff videos\n\nThere are enough regulations in Russia to allow for the prosecution of snuff channel owners. For example, it’s the set of laws banning trash streams, signed by Russia's president in 2024. These laws ban the content that “is offensive to human dignity and public morality,” “contains depictions of activities that appear to be illegal, including violent ones, and is distributed with the intention of pranks, profit, or other low motives.” Exposing children to such content is prohibited distinctly. For such violations, the Administrative Code imposes heavy fines and confiscation of equipment used to create such videos.\n\nThere is a separate law on “inciting hatred or hostility,” which covers the derogatory captions that accompany the photos and videos. For example, in 2025, a Ulan-Ude resident was fined for using the word “khokhly” in his community chat. The court deemed her actions “aimed at humiliating human dignity based on nationality while committed publicly via the internet.”\n\n“Under the ‘On Information’ law, social media page owners are required to independently monitor, promptly respond to, and remove the banned content, but few actually do so. Everyone has already gotten used to Roskomnadzor’s (Russian digital censoring body — Ed.) strict policies and bans,” says Sarkis Darbinyan, a cyberlaw attorney.\n\nThe Telegram app itself claims that it has taken down over 9 million groups and channels in 2026 alone. In 2025, the number was 44 million. However, the platform does not specify what exactly the kind of content banned was, except for terrorist groups and child pornography. Of all the snuff channels we examined, there was only one channel that would be blocked by Telegram, Artem Filippov’s “***’s Funny Corpses” channel. Darbinian believes that Telegram’s policy regarding similar content “echoes its founder’s (Pavel Durov — Ed.) libertarian approach”: “Durov has always stated that he is only willing to counter terrorism, which he has consistently done. It seems that if he weren’t required to, he wouldn’t remove anything at all.”\nAuthorities should intervene and seek out the distributors and producers of snuff content, Kirill Titaev believes. “This is a classic task for investigative and law enforcement units, which are supposed to identify the creators and the intermediaries. A person who films a homicide scene is clearly an accomplice in the homicide; moreover, it is supposed to mean aggravating circumstances and quite substantial prison terms,” he says. \n\nThe Criminal Code was also amended by the legislative package banning “trash streams” in 2024. Posting violent videos depicting murders is now considered to be an aggravating circumstance and a qualifying element in ten Criminal Code articles, including murder, intentional bodily harm infliction, assault, and torture.\n\nState Duma Chairman Vyacheslav Volodin had described the importance of banning the “trash streams” to his Telegram channel audience, naming them “online broadcasts during which unlawful acts are committed, demonstrating cruelty, sadism, and abuse of people and animals, usually to make money and increase one’s audience.” \n\n“The state should not persecute these platforms [Telegram, etc.], but rather be grateful to them. They enable investigators to identify specific individuals and hold them accountable under criminal law,” Titaev adds. “But the problem is, the people who should be doing this work are busy persecuting the very journalists who are doing their work instead.”","blocks":[{"data":"In 2022, a new trend emerged in the Russian segment of Telegram messenger: public channels exclusively publishing incredibly graphic, violent videos of the war in Ukraine, including combat killings, executions of war prisoners, and desecration of the bodies of the deceased. In four years of the war, such channels have gained hundreds of thousands of subscribers and became successful businesses. The owners of the channels try to carefully hide themselves behind anonymous accounts. However, IStories managed to find out how the Telegram military snuff videos market works and who is making money from it.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong><em>Warning: This text contains descriptions of murder and violence as well as profanity and ethnic slurs.</em></strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"A drone-filmed video shows a battle underway, and a soldier is taking an enemy captive. The captive has a yellow armband on his sleeve, worn by the Armed Forces of Ukraine; he has raised his hands and is not resisting. Off-camera, presumedly Russian soldiers are commenting on the footage in real time. “FInish him off,” a voice can be heard on the radio. “Don’t talk to him, just fucking kill him,” says another one. The video freezes for a few seconds; the commenters are confused. The next thing we see is the captive’s body falling. “Fuck it, that’s awesome,” the soldiers cheer.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This video was posted on the “Video *** 18+” Telegram channel (here and further on, we hide the exact names of these channels not to give them publicity — Ed.) on January 2, 2026. “Our stormtrooper beats up a pig and captures it in hand-to-hand combat, then decides it’s useless and kills it,” the video caption reads.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The channel has almost 40 thousand subscribers. The main content is the so-called snuff: videos of Ukrainian soldiers being killed, corpses torn to pieces or burned, bodies desecrated, all titled with offensive captions such as “the pigs who tried to surrender being shot.” Sometimes the channel author even specifies the “key moments” timecodes. “For The Hague,” he comments sarcastically.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Video *** 18+” is an anonymous channel, but IStories managed to find the founder, Vladimir Grebennikov, 36, a refractory worker at the Volgograd Aluminum Plant. In his free time, he goes fishing with his father, an Afghan War vet. On his social media page, the father often recalls his service and posts the war photos, including the dead Soviet soldiers’ bodies.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At night, Grebennikov participates in amateur car races. His social media avatar is Russia’s imperial flag with “We are Russians — God is with us” slogan written on it. On Telegram, the name “Vova” is accompanied by a Russian national flag icon.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17847,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Pictures: Vladimir Grebennikov's social media / Important Stories","caption":"In his free time, Vladimir Grebennikov goes fishing with his father and participates in amateur car races","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3009f6048843418b89d04c6e02dd6a93-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3009f6048843418b89d04c6e02dd6a93-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3009f6048843418b89d04c6e02dd6a93-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3009f6048843418b89d04c6e02dd6a93-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3009f6048843418b89d04c6e02dd6a93-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3009f6048843418b89d04c6e02dd6a93-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3009f6048843418b89d04c6e02dd6a93-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3009f6048843418b89d04c6e02dd6a93-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3009f6048843418b89d04c6e02dd6a93-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3009f6048843418b89d04c6e02dd6a93-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3009f6048843418b89d04c6e02dd6a93-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3009f6048843418b89d04c6e02dd6a93-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3009f6048843418b89d04c6e02dd6a93-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3009f6048843418b89d04c6e02dd6a93-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3009f6048843418b89d04c6e02dd6a93-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3009f6048843418b89d04c6e02dd6a93-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3009f6048843418b89d04c6e02dd6a93-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3009f6048843418b89d04c6e02dd6a93-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Refractory workers in Volgograd are <a href=\"https://volgograd.hh.ru/vacancy/127654725?utm_campaign=dm-aggregators-main_b2c-rf_paid_cpc_applicant_feed&amp;utm_medium=ppc&amp;utm_source=jobfilter.ru\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">paid </a>less than 80,000 rubles (approx. USD 1,000) per month. Most likely, Grebennikov earned more by selling ads on the channel. “Video *** 18+” publishes about 30 advertising posts per week, mostly promoting other channels, or sometimes counterfeit cigarettes shops and online casinos. According to IStories' estimate based on pricing in this kind of market, the channel might be bringing its owner about 200,000 rubles (approx. USD 2,500) per month.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Grebennikov tells IStories he “has been interested in the topic of war” his entire life. “I watch these videos myself,” he said. “And I decided: if I watch them, why not create a channel and start posting them? So I started doing this, and then somehow they ended up at the top of Google and Yandex (Russian search engine – Ed.) search results. Then people started following the channel. That’s basically it. I was never going to become a blogger or anything like that.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Grebennikov himself hasn’t fought and does not want to: “To be a soldier, a contract soldier, to go to war, you have to be brave, at least. I’m not.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"By early 2026, he had sold his channel because he had “burned out during all that time.” When asked how much he had managed to earn from the channel, Grebennikov refused to answer.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17831,"data":{"block":"<p>Now the channel description lists the new owners’ accounts instead of Grebennikov’s one: it’s Timur Nikityuk, 20, from the occupied Luhansk Oblast (he received a Russian passport in 2023); Andrei Savenkov from Belgorod, and a person nicknamed “That Very Donnie”, a channel buyer, according to his account description. We were not able to establish their identity.</p><p><br/></p><p>Grebennikov still moderates the channel chat. One of the other admins is Sergey Loginov, 25, who lives in the Moscow Oblast and works in e-commerce. On social media, he uses a portrait of one of Hitler’s closest associates, Rudolf Hess, instead of his own photo. Some of his contacts named him “Wehrmacht” in their phone contact lists.</p><p><br/></p><p>Nikituk, Savenkov, and Loginov did not respond to our inquiries.</p>","header":"The new owners","content":[{"insert":"Now the channel description lists the new owners’ accounts instead of Grebennikov’s one: it’s Timur Nikityuk, 20, from the occupied Luhansk Oblast (he received a Russian passport in 2023); Andrei Savenkov from Belgorod, and a person nicknamed “That Very Donnie”, a channel buyer, according to his account description. We were not able to establish their identity.\n\nGrebennikov still moderates the channel chat. One of the other admins is Sergey Loginov, 25, who lives in the Moscow Oblast and works in e-commerce. On social media, he uses a portrait of one of Hitler’s closest associates, Rudolf Hess, instead of his own photo. Some of his contacts named him “Wehrmacht” in their phone contact lists.\n\nNikituk, Savenkov, and Loginov did not respond to our inquiries.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"What are snuff videos, and where are they coming from?","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Before the Russo-Ukrainian war, no other conflict in history had been documented in such detail with photos and videos. Cameras are placed on hundreds of thousands of drones, which have become an indispensable warfare tool. Russian soldiers wear cameras on their helmets to record “the evidence of their heroism and the elimination of targets,” a former soldier told IStories on an anonymous basis. And, of course, soldiers also have cameras on their phones.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The military immediately saw the potential of such footage. For example, the “Arkhangel Spetsnaza” (translated as “Special Forces Archangel” — Ed.) Telegram channel has been providing detailed operation coverage since the beginning of the invasion, starting with the Hostomel Airport air assault on February 24. As <a href=\"https://www.istories.media/en/news/2024/09/24/special-forces-archangel/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">IStories found out,</a> the channel was created by Yevgeny Zhulidov, an officer of the 45th Airborne Troops Special Purpose Brigade. He now has over 1.1 million subscribers and might earn up to 3.8 million rubles (approx. USD 48,000) a month from advertising, based on the rates provided by his advertising manager, multiplied by the number of such posts.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There are also channels posting nothing but snuff content: photos and videos of murders, mutilated bodies, and desecration of corpses. Execution exclusives are popular, especially when filmed from a first-person perspective. A typical ad looks like this: “GoPro recordings of khokhols (derogatory slur meaning Ukrainians — Ed.) shot in the head, the wounded finished off, and whole groups killed: here you’ll find everything others don't dare to show on their channels.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17848,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Illustration: Mila Grabowski / Important Stories","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87a059cb4d524deeb28de146cfd96c00-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87a059cb4d524deeb28de146cfd96c00-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87a059cb4d524deeb28de146cfd96c00-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":768,"real_height_2x":848},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87a059cb4d524deeb28de146cfd96c00-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87a059cb4d524deeb28de146cfd96c00-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87a059cb4d524deeb28de146cfd96c00-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":768,"real_height_2x":848},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87a059cb4d524deeb28de146cfd96c00-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87a059cb4d524deeb28de146cfd96c00-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87a059cb4d524deeb28de146cfd96c00-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":480,"real_height_2x":848},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87a059cb4d524deeb28de146cfd96c00-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87a059cb4d524deeb28de146cfd96c00-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87a059cb4d524deeb28de146cfd96c00-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":480,"real_height_2x":848},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87a059cb4d524deeb28de146cfd96c00-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87a059cb4d524deeb28de146cfd96c00-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87a059cb4d524deeb28de146cfd96c00-original.jpg","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":166,"real_height_2x":332},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87a059cb4d524deeb28de146cfd96c00-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87a059cb4d524deeb28de146cfd96c00-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/87a059cb4d524deeb28de146cfd96c00-original.jpg","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":166,"real_height_2x":332}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"IStories examined more than 50 war snuff Telegram channels. Most of them are run by civilians, not military personnel. For example, Grebennikov, an aluminum plant worker, has never been to the front himself, but would find the videos and the photos online: “Sometimes I indicated the source, sometimes I didn’t.” From time to time, Grebennikov would post messages of gratitude to the subscribers, posing as a member of the military. The credulous subscribers responded by wishing “our guys” good luck.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to a former Russian military officer interviewed by IStories, the footage of incidents that the soldiers send to the command posts often leaks from there. “Even if the video is highly classified, there will always be someone who will leak it for money or hype.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Such videos and photos subsequently become war crimes evidence. The UN Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine (HRMMU) <a href=\"https://ukraine.ohchr.org/en/Alarming-Rise-in-Executions-of-Captured-Ukrainian-Military-Personnel\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">has confirmed</a> cases of executions of Ukrainian military personnel via this evidence. According to the <a href=\"https://ukraine.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/2025-12/2025-12-09%20OHCHR%2043rd%20periodic%20report%20on%20Ukraine%20ENG.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">latest report </a>by the UN Human Rights Office, there have been no fewer than 96 executions of Ukrainian soldiers confirmed since 2022. The HRMMU told IStories they also keep an eye on the Russian snuff channels.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17861,"data":{"url":"https://www.youtube.com/embed/QZ2MalBKYsw","text":"Watch Istories' film about the military snuff videos market","caption":"","provider":"youtube","rawInput":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QZ2MalBKYsw","ratio_mobile":"16:9","ratio_desktop":"16:9"},"category":"video-embed"},"type":"video-embed"},{"data":"In just one of the channels, IStories found 51 videos of mass shootings and beheadings in the “Executions” section. In the “Executions (photos)” section, there are 53 more photos of corpses. Some of them have their hands tied.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17828,"data":{"block":"<p><em>Warning: descriptions of murder and violence, profanity.</em></p><p><br/></p><p>Two Ukrainian soldiers lying on the ground, in the snow, one of them smoking. The Russian filming the video on his phone is interrogating him, but is not satisfied with the answers. With his free hand, he points his machine gun at the back of the Ukrainian&#x27;s head — “Are you bullshitting me?” — and shoots him several times. </p><p><br/></p><p>The second Ukrainian is nearby, in a mess of blood and snow. He is not moving. “Where are the rest?” the person filming asks. The camera shakes: apparently, he kicks the second Ukrainian. Another Russian puts his rifle to the wounded man’s head. “Finish him off,” says the person filming. The second Ukrainian is also killed.</p><p><br/></p><p>***</p><p><br/></p><p>The frame shows several corpses of Ukrainian soldiers. At least one of them has his hands tied behind his back. A severed pig’s head is lying next to the corpses. “Glory to whom? Glory to Russia, you fucks. Lie down and rest, damn it”, a man who is presumably a Russian soldier says. “The Hague, check this out!”, the caption reads.</p><p><br/></p><p>***</p><p><br/></p><p>The Russians capture two Ukrainians. One of them is younger and wounded. The second is an elderly man. A Russian soldier uses a radio to ask someone what to do with the captives: “A fucking wounded one and an old one. Shall we just kill them both?”, he asks. Without waiting for orders, another soldier shoots the wounded Ukrainian. Then the second one is executed. </p><p><br/></p><p>The video went viral on snuff channels in June 2025. The identities of those involved in the shooting <a href=\"https://evocation.info/ivan-shalagin/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">have been de-anonymized</a>. The one negotiating over the radio is Ivan Shalagin, commander of the assault group of the 14th Special Purpose Brigade. He refused to answer our questions.</p><p><br/></p><p>***</p><p><br/></p><p>Last summer, “Warhronika”, a popular Telegram channel, shared a series of reports on the capture of Krasnohorivka made by war correspondent Andrei Filatov; even Russia Today <a href=\"https://russian.rt.com/ussr/news/1527025-cikl-reportazhei-krasnogorovka?utm_source=chatgpt.com\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">announced the launch</a> of the project. In the fourth episode of the report, posted in November 2025, the creators <a href=\"https://t.me/Warhronika/10468\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">showed </a>Russian soldiers shoot an apparently unarmed Ukrainian soldier in the back of the head. The snuff channels took notice of this video. It was reposted by “Hardcore *** 18+” channel with added timecodes and a caption: “Execution. Finishing off that same faggot.”</p>","header":"Typical war snuff content description","content":[{"insert":"Warning: descriptions of murder and violence, profanity.","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":"\n\nTwo Ukrainian soldiers lying on the ground, in the snow, one of them smoking. The Russian filming the video on his phone is interrogating him, but is not satisfied with the answers. With his free hand, he points his machine gun at the back of the Ukrainian's head — “Are you bullshitting me?” — and shoots him several times. \n\nThe second Ukrainian is nearby, in a mess of blood and snow. He is not moving. “Where are the rest?” the person filming asks. The camera shakes: apparently, he kicks the second Ukrainian. Another Russian puts his rifle to the wounded man’s head. “Finish him off,” says the person filming. The second Ukrainian is also killed.\n\n***\n\nThe frame shows several corpses of Ukrainian soldiers. At least one of them has his hands tied behind his back. A severed pig’s head is lying next to the corpses. “Glory to whom? Glory to Russia, you fucks. Lie down and rest, damn it”, a man who is presumably a Russian soldier says. “The Hague, check this out!”, the caption reads.\n\n***\n\nThe Russians capture two Ukrainians. One of them is younger and wounded. The second is an elderly man. A Russian soldier uses a radio to ask someone what to do with the captives: “A fucking wounded one and an old one. Shall we just kill them both?”, he asks. Without waiting for orders, another soldier shoots the wounded Ukrainian. Then the second one is executed. \n\nThe video went viral on snuff channels in June 2025. The identities of those involved in the shooting "},{"insert":"have been de-anonymized","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://evocation.info/ivan-shalagin/","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":". The one negotiating over the radio is Ivan Shalagin, commander of the assault group of the 14th Special Purpose Brigade. He refused to answer our questions.\n\n***\n\nLast summer, “Warhronika”, a popular Telegram channel, shared a series of reports on the capture of Krasnohorivka made by war correspondent Andrei Filatov; even Russia Today "},{"insert":"announced the launch","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://russian.rt.com/ussr/news/1527025-cikl-reportazhei-krasnogorovka?utm_source=chatgpt.com","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" of the project. In the fourth episode of the report, posted in November 2025, the creators "},{"insert":"showed ","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://t.me/Warhronika/10468","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":"Russian soldiers shoot an apparently unarmed Ukrainian soldier in the back of the head. The snuff channels took notice of this video. It was reposted by “Hardcore *** 18+” channel with added timecodes and a caption: “Execution. Finishing off that same faggot.”\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"Sometimes the admins try to squeeze maximum profit out of such videos and ask subscribers for “donations.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Guys. Does anyone want to donate 1.000 rubles to our fighter for executing a khokhol?” a snuff channel admin wrote in a chat on December 3, 2025. “We have the footage,” another administrator wrote a few hours later. “We’ll post it on the channel soon.” The same day, a video titled “Awesome exclusive finishing off a foreign mercenary” was posted. The video shows a wounded soldier lying on the ground is executed with a gunshot to the head.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“We also thank our subscriber for financially supporting the soldier who finished this idiot off!” the video description reads. “Hear me out, executions are fucking awesome,” commented the admin in the chat.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"On December 7, 2025, the same admin called on the subscribers to help with the content search: “The simplest and most effective way is to write to the soldiers and ask them to provide the footage [...] If a soldier asks for money in return, let us know.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"How teenagers monetize snuff","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"“Happy New Year, everyone. There were many sad events and things in 2022, but any disappointment is overshadowed by the pleasant fact that about 100,000 combat pigs (and thousands of civilians😁) have been killed. And in 2023, with God’s help, we'll kill at least as many more,” another Telegram channel, “*** slaughter”, the admin addressed his subscribers at the end of 2022.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17849,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Illustration: Mila Grabowski / Important Stories","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc0d9a03361f4ed0a4780a9ea25e5170-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc0d9a03361f4ed0a4780a9ea25e5170-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc0d9a03361f4ed0a4780a9ea25e5170-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":768,"real_height_2x":848},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc0d9a03361f4ed0a4780a9ea25e5170-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc0d9a03361f4ed0a4780a9ea25e5170-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc0d9a03361f4ed0a4780a9ea25e5170-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":768,"real_height_2x":848},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc0d9a03361f4ed0a4780a9ea25e5170-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc0d9a03361f4ed0a4780a9ea25e5170-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc0d9a03361f4ed0a4780a9ea25e5170-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":480,"real_height_2x":848},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc0d9a03361f4ed0a4780a9ea25e5170-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc0d9a03361f4ed0a4780a9ea25e5170-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc0d9a03361f4ed0a4780a9ea25e5170-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":480,"real_height_2x":848},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc0d9a03361f4ed0a4780a9ea25e5170-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc0d9a03361f4ed0a4780a9ea25e5170-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc0d9a03361f4ed0a4780a9ea25e5170-original.jpg","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":166,"real_height_2x":332},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc0d9a03361f4ed0a4780a9ea25e5170-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc0d9a03361f4ed0a4780a9ea25e5170-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dc0d9a03361f4ed0a4780a9ea25e5170-original.jpg","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":166,"real_height_2x":332}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"This channel has been around for more than three years. It is the largest war snuff content channel IStories has been able to find, with over 100,000 subscribers.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Since its launch, “*** slaughter” has published more than 15,000 photos and 20,000 videos. The channel publishes footage — both exclusive and taken from somewhere else — showing dead Ukrainian soldiers and moments of them being killed. Ads are also posted almost every day: military service campaign ads, online casinos, and AI bots for undressing girls in photos.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories found out that the channel has been monetized by teenagers. Their contact details have been listed for advertising inquiries right in the channel description next to the “18+” label.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Denis Bogolyubov is now 19 years old. He comes from the village of Korkatovo in the Republic of Mari El, with a population of about 500 people. In the neighboring village school, there are two memorial plaques to local residents who went to war and died, and Denis’ uncle is one of them.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Denis was involved in advertising the “*** slaughter” channel during, at the very least, the summer and fall of 2023, when he was 16 years old. In addition to the snuff channel, Denis collaborated with educational and entertainment Telegram communities. “In more than two years of active work on Telegram, I have gained extensive experience in budget management and the implementation of successful cases,” Bogolyubov writes on his personal channel. Denis charges “15% to 25%, depending on the subject” for advertising services “with his trusted people” and more than 11,000 rubles for “consulting.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Bogolyubov did not respond to IStories’ inquiries.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The second teenage advertising manager had not even turned 16 when he started working for the “*** slaughter” channel in 2023. Artem Prigodin is from the village of Konosha in the Arkhangelsk Oblast. In 2023 and 2024, Artem appeared as the administrator or advertising manager of two other trash channels called “not for the faint-hearted” and “18+ strictly.” His advertising career has been interrupted by compulsory military service at the Russian border.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Artem Prigodin confirmed to us that he worked for “*** slaughter” in 2023–2024, but then “had a beef with the owner and quit.” According to Prigodin, he did not meet the channel owner in person and “only saw him via camera.” He claims the owner is not a member of the military. After completing his compulsory military service, Prigodin has no intention of remaining in the army on a contract basis: “It’s a one-way ticket. You sign the contract, and tomorrow you’re cannon fodder.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17850,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Pictures: social media / Important Stories","caption":"From left: Denis Bogolyubov, “*** slaughter” channel owner's profile picture, Artem Prigodin","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0f4b4acdcb224461a8bcf3d0a3cb9c61-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0f4b4acdcb224461a8bcf3d0a3cb9c61-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0f4b4acdcb224461a8bcf3d0a3cb9c61-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0f4b4acdcb224461a8bcf3d0a3cb9c61-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0f4b4acdcb224461a8bcf3d0a3cb9c61-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0f4b4acdcb224461a8bcf3d0a3cb9c61-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0f4b4acdcb224461a8bcf3d0a3cb9c61-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0f4b4acdcb224461a8bcf3d0a3cb9c61-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0f4b4acdcb224461a8bcf3d0a3cb9c61-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0f4b4acdcb224461a8bcf3d0a3cb9c61-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0f4b4acdcb224461a8bcf3d0a3cb9c61-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0f4b4acdcb224461a8bcf3d0a3cb9c61-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0f4b4acdcb224461a8bcf3d0a3cb9c61-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0f4b4acdcb224461a8bcf3d0a3cb9c61-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0f4b4acdcb224461a8bcf3d0a3cb9c61-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0f4b4acdcb224461a8bcf3d0a3cb9c61-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0f4b4acdcb224461a8bcf3d0a3cb9c61-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/0f4b4acdcb224461a8bcf3d0a3cb9c61-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"IStories weren’t able to identify the “*** slaughter” channel owner.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Are we supposed to be ashamed to post and watch?”","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"As IStories found out, not only do teens manage the ads in snuff channels, but they also create and actively run their own violent footage communities. We know at least two channels like this.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"One of them, called “***’s Funny Corpses,” was created in 2022 and blocked in 2025 after gaining just over 8,000 subscribers. The owner recreated the channel, and 800 people subscribed to it.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In the last few weeks alone, the channel has published a photo of a decapitated Ukrainian soldier whose head is impaled on a stick; a video of a Russian soldier urinating on a corpse; and a photo of a body with its hands tied and its skull crushed. The administrators made their own sticker pack from such photos of killed Ukrainian soldiers.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories discovered that the founder of this channel is Artem Filippov, 18, from Kaluga. He calls himself the “Kaluga serial killer” and, according to his photos on social media, embraces neo-Nazi views.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17851,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Pictures: Artem Filippov's social media / Important Stories","caption":"Philippov shows off the Russian neo-nazi gestures, poses with a flag of the Russian Empire and uses a Russian analog of the Swastika, the Kolovrat","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/575ed4ae9a704969b0b513a0870992ca-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/575ed4ae9a704969b0b513a0870992ca-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/575ed4ae9a704969b0b513a0870992ca-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/575ed4ae9a704969b0b513a0870992ca-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/575ed4ae9a704969b0b513a0870992ca-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/575ed4ae9a704969b0b513a0870992ca-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/575ed4ae9a704969b0b513a0870992ca-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/575ed4ae9a704969b0b513a0870992ca-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/575ed4ae9a704969b0b513a0870992ca-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/575ed4ae9a704969b0b513a0870992ca-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/575ed4ae9a704969b0b513a0870992ca-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/575ed4ae9a704969b0b513a0870992ca-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/575ed4ae9a704969b0b513a0870992ca-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/575ed4ae9a704969b0b513a0870992ca-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/575ed4ae9a704969b0b513a0870992ca-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/575ed4ae9a704969b0b513a0870992ca-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/575ed4ae9a704969b0b513a0870992ca-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/575ed4ae9a704969b0b513a0870992ca-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Filippov created the channel when he was just 15 years old. Among the other admins, we found four more teenagers who are now no older than 15 (their names are known to the newsroom, but we are not naming them since they are underage — Ed.). Their Telegram accounts are registered using the phone numbers of their older relatives. One of the teenagers, a 14-year-old eighth grader from Abakan, uses photos of Russian soldiers as userpics. “Mines, explosions, bloody smoke, we’ll wash away the enemy with blood, with our battle plan!” his account description reads. Information obtained from data leaks shows that, in seventh grade, he had applied to join Yunarmiya. This Russian youth organisation aims to prepare kids for future military service.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In a conversation with IStories, Artem Filippov confirmed that he founded the channel while still at school. “This channel was created in response to similar Ukrainian channels. It’s called information warfare,” Filippov claims. “I was just on the internet, arguing with some guy from Ukraine, I don’t remember the topic. He started showing me photos of our fallen soldiers, and I decided to find a channel with dead Ukrainians. At that time, there were practically none. So I decided to create my own channel.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Filippov came up with the “Funny Corpses” channel name himself: “I was just so angry that we didn’t have this kind of content, while the Ukrainians had a lot of it. That’s why I deliberately chose such a loud, provocative name.” According to Filippov, younger people are the channel’s main audience.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Immediately after the conversation with IStories, Filippov announced on a backup channel that the main channel had allegedly been “blocked again,” but he would not recreate it.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17829,"data":{"block":"<p>In the “***’s Funny Corpses” channel chat, the administrator of another (4,000 subscribers) war snuff community has been mentioned many times. Stepan Koptev from the Yaroslavl region is now 18 years old, and he has served as the main administrator of the latter channel (at least in 2023 and 2024), when he was 16–17 years old, IStories found out. </p><p> </p><p>Koptev confirmed to us that he founded the channel when he was 15 but has since sold it. “I created it to sell and earn a little.” “People were buying such stuff back then,” Koptev explained his choice of content policy.</p>","header":"Another “teenager channel”","content":[{"insert":"In the “***’s Funny Corpses” channel chat, the administrator of another (4,000 subscribers) war snuff community has been mentioned many times. Stepan Koptev from the Yaroslavl region is now 18 years old, and he has served as the main administrator of the latter channel (at least in 2023 and 2024), when he was 16–17 years old, IStories found out. \n \nKoptev confirmed to us that he founded the channel when he was 15 but has since sold it. “I created it to sell and earn a little.” “People were buying such stuff back then,” Koptev explained his choice of content policy.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"Vladimir Grebennikov, the “Video *** 18+” snuff channel founder, also blames Ukrainians for provoking him to create hateful captions for his videos and photos. “I think it all started with the Ukrainians,” Grebennikov says. “Initially, there were no such [misanthropic] captions, but now 95% of them are like that.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"He noticed school kids were showing particular interest in his violent content. Nevertheless, he claims he would block minors if he identified them.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Grebennikov sees no moral contradiction in posting and sharing the violent content among mass audiences:","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“What’s wrong with it? It’s our life, people are fighting there and dying, someone’s sisters, brothers, husbands, and so on. Do you think people shouldn’t know how it feels to them and how they died or whatever? Many people live here and don’t know that there is a war going on, figuratively speaking, they don’t give a shit, while someone else has been living in trenches for several years and so on. Do you think we shouldn’t be interested in this? Are we supposed to be ashamed to post and watch?”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"How much the owners earn thanks to snuff content&nbsp;","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"There are two main ways for snuff channel owners to make money: advertisement posts and collecting donations from subscribers.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Ads are present on almost all snuff channels studied by IStories: it could be online casinos, tech stores, counterfeit cigarettes stores, or the military service campaign ads. Snuff channels also often promote one another.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"According to one of the administrators, the cost of an ad post depends on the reach, not on the number of subscribers. In the snuff content “market,” a thousand views cost 300–350 rubles (approx. USD 4). This indicator is known as CPM (cost per mille). Administrators of other channels estimate it more modestly: at 160 (approx. USD 2) or even just 70 (approx. USD 1) rubles per thousand views.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories discovered a 4-snuff-channel network that, at such rates, has a total audience of 115,000 subscribers and averages 12,000 views per post, earning about 200,000 rubles per month.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This network was administered by Robert Khaibullin, 24, from Magnitogorsk. Here is how he advertised one of the channels: “If you are weak-nerved, don’t enter. If you have a stable psyche, welcome to the real murders channel.” According to the information found in data leaks, Khaibullin has never been employed. His only official income comes from sports betting and stock trading. Khaibullin told IStories he was only responsible for advertising on these channels and “didn’t even know what the content was.” “At the moment, I have completely left this field,” Khaibullin added.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17830,"data":{"block":"<p>In one of the channels, Haibullin was listed as an administrator alongside Matvey Ozarchuk, 23, who runs a violent content channels network for more than 2.6 million people. It includes several military snuff channels, but the most popular ones are “trash videos” (such as car accidents) compilations from around the world. </p><p><br/></p><p>Ozarchuk was also born in Magnitogorsk and still lives there. He befriends Khaibullin on social media. His only official job was a month at the Magnitogorsk municipal funeral service. Supposedly (according to his nicknames on other people’s contact lists), Ozarchuk used to sell Christmas trees. Like Khaibullin, his declared revenue came from betting and stock market trading.</p><p><br/></p><p>Ozarchuk did not respond to our inquiries. </p>","header":"Snuff unrelated to war is also popular","content":[{"insert":"In one of the channels, Haibullin was listed as an administrator alongside Matvey Ozarchuk, 23, who runs a violent content channels network for more than 2.6 million people. It includes several military snuff channels, but the most popular ones are “trash videos” (such as car accidents) compilations from around the world. \n\nOzarchuk was also born in Magnitogorsk and still lives there. He befriends Khaibullin on social media. His only official job was a month at the Magnitogorsk municipal funeral service. Supposedly (according to his nicknames on other people’s contact lists), Ozarchuk used to sell Christmas trees. Like Khaibullin, his declared revenue came from betting and stock market trading.\n\nOzarchuk did not respond to our inquiries. \n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"Advertising in large communities is handled by special managers, with the same people often working for several ones. One of the manager’s contact details were listed in more than ten different channels, including the largest one, “*** slaughter.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17852,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Pictures: Nikita Semenov's social media / Important Stories","caption":"Nikita Semenov, snuff channels' advertising manager, and excerpts from his correspondence with iStories journalist who posed as a potential client","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/60cef469b5e547c1bd02698df8178153-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/60cef469b5e547c1bd02698df8178153-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/60cef469b5e547c1bd02698df8178153-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/60cef469b5e547c1bd02698df8178153-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/60cef469b5e547c1bd02698df8178153-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/60cef469b5e547c1bd02698df8178153-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/60cef469b5e547c1bd02698df8178153-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/60cef469b5e547c1bd02698df8178153-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/60cef469b5e547c1bd02698df8178153-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/60cef469b5e547c1bd02698df8178153-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/60cef469b5e547c1bd02698df8178153-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/60cef469b5e547c1bd02698df8178153-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/60cef469b5e547c1bd02698df8178153-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/60cef469b5e547c1bd02698df8178153-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/60cef469b5e547c1bd02698df8178153-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/60cef469b5e547c1bd02698df8178153-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/60cef469b5e547c1bd02698df8178153-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/60cef469b5e547c1bd02698df8178153-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Most likely, this manager is Nikita Semenov, 23, from the Oryol Oblast. The phone number he registered the account with belongs to his girlfriend, but Semenov has used it when applying for loans, IStories found out. Until 2021, Semenov had worked as a handyman in the Oryol Oblast, then moved to Moscow, where he worked in a warehouse and had a side job as a taxi driver. Semenov did not respond to our request for comment.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The “*** slaughter” channel, with its 112,000 subscribers and nearly 30,000 views per post, publishes one ad per day on average and might be earning up to 260,000 rubles per month (approx. USD 3,250). When we contacted its owner, posing as potential ad buyers, he agreed to give us a “starter discount” and place an ad for a new military-themed Telegram channel for just 2,000 rubles (approx. USD 25). Even at this price, the channel can generate over 50,000 rubles (approx. USD 620) per month in revenue.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Apart from ads paid for directly by clients, automatically appearing in-app ads are also shown across channels. But channel creators don't get any money from these ads if they are in Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The channels’ owners also earn decent money from collecting donations from subscribers.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The “*** 21+” channel, with about 100,000 subscribers, posts videos of Ukrainians being murdered paired with reports on the money collected. “Thank you so much, friends, for your financial support 🙂 From the bottom of our hearts 👍,” the admins write, listing the amounts transferred to their cards. Judging by their posts, the channel has managed to collect almost 400,000 rubles (approx. USD 5,000) in three and a half years, with more than 800 people having contributed.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17853,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Illustration: Mila Grabowsky / Important Stories","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/90ac926e3a9d4646a8ef79c421c4a649-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/90ac926e3a9d4646a8ef79c421c4a649-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/90ac926e3a9d4646a8ef79c421c4a649-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":768,"real_height_2x":848},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/90ac926e3a9d4646a8ef79c421c4a649-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/90ac926e3a9d4646a8ef79c421c4a649-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/90ac926e3a9d4646a8ef79c421c4a649-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":768,"real_height_2x":848},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/90ac926e3a9d4646a8ef79c421c4a649-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/90ac926e3a9d4646a8ef79c421c4a649-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/90ac926e3a9d4646a8ef79c421c4a649-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":480,"real_height_2x":848},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/90ac926e3a9d4646a8ef79c421c4a649-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/90ac926e3a9d4646a8ef79c421c4a649-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/90ac926e3a9d4646a8ef79c421c4a649-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2120,"real_height_1x":480,"real_height_2x":848},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/90ac926e3a9d4646a8ef79c421c4a649-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/90ac926e3a9d4646a8ef79c421c4a649-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/90ac926e3a9d4646a8ef79c421c4a649-original.jpg","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":166,"real_height_2x":332},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/90ac926e3a9d4646a8ef79c421c4a649-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/90ac926e3a9d4646a8ef79c421c4a649-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/90ac926e3a9d4646a8ef79c421c4a649-original.jpg","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":166,"real_height_2x":332}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Female admins: Matryoshka, Goddess, and Snaky Girlboss","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"“Friends, do you like the violent footage we publish?”, the subscribers were asked in a poll published on several war snuff channels. Out of hundreds of answers, “Yes” and “We need the videos to be more violent” were the most popular options.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Many channels have their own chats and allow users to comment. In some of the channel chats, there are over 1,000 participants, with the largest one numbering almost 10,000 people. People chat all day and night: the participants either mock the Ukrainians or engage in heated discussions about the war, throwing insults at each other (as sometimes Ukraine supporters might join in the conversations).&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The chat admins do not restrict or moderate the constant stream of hateful comments; instead, they encourage it.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17856,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Pictures: social media / Important Stories","caption":"Snuff channels' chat rules examples","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1aa1a0451c1349c1a7e9224f25c02daf-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1aa1a0451c1349c1a7e9224f25c02daf-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1aa1a0451c1349c1a7e9224f25c02daf-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1aa1a0451c1349c1a7e9224f25c02daf-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1aa1a0451c1349c1a7e9224f25c02daf-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1aa1a0451c1349c1a7e9224f25c02daf-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1aa1a0451c1349c1a7e9224f25c02daf-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1aa1a0451c1349c1a7e9224f25c02daf-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1aa1a0451c1349c1a7e9224f25c02daf-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1aa1a0451c1349c1a7e9224f25c02daf-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1aa1a0451c1349c1a7e9224f25c02daf-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1aa1a0451c1349c1a7e9224f25c02daf-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1aa1a0451c1349c1a7e9224f25c02daf-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1aa1a0451c1349c1a7e9224f25c02daf-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1aa1a0451c1349c1a7e9224f25c02daf-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1aa1a0451c1349c1a7e9224f25c02daf-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1aa1a0451c1349c1a7e9224f25c02daf-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1aa1a0451c1349c1a7e9224f25c02daf-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"We have identified more than 30 chat admins from various snuff channels. Although almost 90% of subscribers are male (according to TGStat data — Ed.), there are quite a few women among the admins.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The “*** SMO Snuff” (the “Special Military Operation” euphemism is the official term for the war in Russia —&nbsp;Ed.) channel's chat has a particularly high number of female admins: half of them are women. The channel itself boasts more than 50,000 subscribers, and the chat has just over a thousand members. The most active ones are the admins nicknamed “Masyanya” (Ekaterina Chrikyan, 36, from the Nizhny Novgorod Oblast), “The Angry Beastess” (Diana Loginova, 34, originally from Moldova), “Miss Sudarynya” (Ekaterina Selina, 40, from the Rostov Oblast), “Snaky Girlboss” (Natalya Abramova, 43, from the Novosibirsk Oblast), and “Goddess” (Natalya Alekhina, 39, from the Krasnodar Krai).&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"They mainly discuss personal topics (such as one of the women’s troubled relationship) rather than the channel's snuff content. Sometimes, another female admin, nicknamed “Matryoshka,” would pop into the chat to share updates on her combatant husband.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17858,"data":{"images":[{"isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/722d99ed6af044708b513b0eac2064be-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/722d99ed6af044708b513b0eac2064be-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/722d99ed6af044708b513b0eac2064be-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1467,"real_height_2x":1467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/722d99ed6af044708b513b0eac2064be-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/722d99ed6af044708b513b0eac2064be-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/722d99ed6af044708b513b0eac2064be-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1467,"real_height_2x":1467},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/722d99ed6af044708b513b0eac2064be-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/722d99ed6af044708b513b0eac2064be-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/722d99ed6af044708b513b0eac2064be-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1467,"real_height_2x":1467},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/722d99ed6af044708b513b0eac2064be-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/722d99ed6af044708b513b0eac2064be-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/722d99ed6af044708b513b0eac2064be-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1079,"real_width_2x":1079,"real_height_1x":1467,"real_height_2x":1467},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/722d99ed6af044708b513b0eac2064be-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/722d99ed6af044708b513b0eac2064be-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/722d99ed6af044708b513b0eac2064be-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":564,"real_height_2x":1128},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/722d99ed6af044708b513b0eac2064be-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/722d99ed6af044708b513b0eac2064be-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/722d99ed6af044708b513b0eac2064be-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":564,"real_height_2x":1128}]},{"credit":"Pictures: social media / Important Stories","caption":"Following the Russian aerial attack that injured at least 22 people, including two children, in Kyiv on December 27, 2025, a user joined the chat on the “*** SMO Snuff” channel and asked the participants questions in Ukrainian","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/608a7580d1594573bb7d060cd5819d2b-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/608a7580d1594573bb7d060cd5819d2b-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/608a7580d1594573bb7d060cd5819d2b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1039,"real_width_2x":1039,"real_height_1x":977,"real_height_2x":977},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/608a7580d1594573bb7d060cd5819d2b-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/608a7580d1594573bb7d060cd5819d2b-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/608a7580d1594573bb7d060cd5819d2b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1039,"real_width_2x":1039,"real_height_1x":977,"real_height_2x":977},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/608a7580d1594573bb7d060cd5819d2b-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/608a7580d1594573bb7d060cd5819d2b-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/608a7580d1594573bb7d060cd5819d2b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1039,"real_width_2x":1039,"real_height_1x":977,"real_height_2x":977},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/608a7580d1594573bb7d060cd5819d2b-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/608a7580d1594573bb7d060cd5819d2b-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/608a7580d1594573bb7d060cd5819d2b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1039,"real_width_2x":1039,"real_height_1x":977,"real_height_2x":977},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/608a7580d1594573bb7d060cd5819d2b-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/608a7580d1594573bb7d060cd5819d2b-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/608a7580d1594573bb7d060cd5819d2b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":389,"real_height_2x":779},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/608a7580d1594573bb7d060cd5819d2b-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/608a7580d1594573bb7d060cd5819d2b-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/608a7580d1594573bb7d060cd5819d2b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":389,"real_height_2x":779}]}]},"category":"two-images-embed"},"type":"two-images-embed"},{"data":"The “Goddess” confirmed to us she moderates the chat, but she doesn’t know why she was put in charge: “Probably because I’ve been around for a while. I’ve been observing [the chat] for a long time.” “Masyanya” told IStories that the channel owner, whom she is familiar with, promoted her to chat admin “behind her back.” “I’m a frequent participant, that’s all,” she explains. “My brother is in the SMO zone.” “Miss Sudarynya” said she joined the group “just like everyone else,” and then hung up, saying, “How do I know you’re not a khokhol?” “The Angry Beastess” was out of reach.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Why people are watching and talking about snuff videos","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"An interest in the theme of death is inherent to human nature, but it intensifies during certain historical periods, according to a criminal psychology expert interviewed by IStories on condition of anonymity. “During the periods of civil unrest, wars, and revolutions, people’s violence sensitivity threshold can shift,” the expert says.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, the culture of mass consumption of snuff content is not a universal characteristic of human nature, Kirill Titaev, a sociologist and researcher in law enforcement and crime, points out in an <a href=\"https://i-f.media/materials/2026/03/16/chto-mi-znaem-o-potreblenii-snaff-kontenta/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">interview</a> with the “Stories and Facts” outlet. “Undoubtedly, various forms of violent content have accompanied humanity since ancient times. But it would be fundamentally wrong to try to link this exact phenomenon to the gladiatorial fighting culture or the Middle Ages' public executions,” the sociologist says. “It would imply that humans in general have some psychological predisposition to enjoy this kind of content and to seek it. But we know of many societies of other countries and eras where there is no snuff content available at all.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17860,"data":{"text":"Help important stories be heard","title":"Censorship thrives on silence","buttonText":"Turn the sound on"},"category":"donate-embed"},"type":"donate-embed"},{"data":"According to Titaev, for the mass consumption of snuff to take root in society, it must first be socially approved. “To take off, watching this would have to be culturally legitimized, because not only is one ready to watch it, but also to discuss it,” the sociologist explains. The second factor is the physical distancing from what is happening on the screen. “Typically, the murder act — with all its associated smells, sounds, and other physical sensations — is not experienced directly by the content consumer,” Titaev adds.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Mass violent video consumption can be dangerous for society, according to the criminal psychology expert. “It doesn’t mean that people who become desensitized to violence will repeat it, but they will have fewer restraints,” he says.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russian legislation on snuff videos","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"There are enough regulations in Russia to allow for the prosecution of snuff channel owners. For example, it’s the <a href=\"https://www.garant.ru/hotlaw/federal/1746687/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">set of laws</a> banning trash streams, signed by Russia's president in 2024. These laws ban the content that “is offensive to human dignity and public morality,” “contains depictions of activities that appear to be illegal, including violent ones, and is distributed with the intention of pranks, profit, or other low motives.” Exposing children to such content is <a href=\"https://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_108808/9083b03e61777d3fe172fb3ef707a10e10688262/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">prohibited </a>distinctly. For such <a href=\"https://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_482412/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">violations</a>, the Administrative Code imposes heavy fines and confiscation of equipment used to create such videos.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There is a separate law on “inciting hatred or hostility,” which covers the derogatory captions that accompany the photos and videos. For example, in 2025, a Ulan-Ude resident was fined for using the word “khokhly” in his community chat. The court <a href=\"https://verstka.media/rossijskij-sud-priznal-razzhiganiem-nenavisti-k-ukrainczam-frazy-so-slovom-hohly\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">deemed </a>her actions “aimed at humiliating human dignity based on nationality while committed publicly via the internet.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Under the ‘On Information’ law, social media page owners are required to independently monitor, promptly respond to, and remove the banned content, but few actually do so. Everyone has already gotten used to Roskomnadzor’s (Russian digital censoring body — Ed.) strict policies and bans,” says Sarkis Darbinyan, a cyberlaw attorney.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Telegram app itself claims that it <a href=\"https://telegram.org/moderation\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">has taken down</a> over 9 million groups and channels in 2026 alone. In 2025, the number was 44 million. However, the platform does not specify what exactly the kind of content banned was, except for terrorist groups and child pornography. Of all the snuff channels we examined, there was only one channel that would be blocked by Telegram, Artem Filippov’s “***’s Funny Corpses” channel. Darbinian believes that Telegram’s policy regarding similar content “echoes its founder’s (Pavel Durov — Ed.) libertarian approach”: “Durov has always stated that he is only willing to counter terrorism, which he has consistently done. It seems that if he weren’t required to, he wouldn’t remove anything at all.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17859,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Illustration: Mila Grabowsky / Important Stories","caption":"","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b36461f2afbc45fb898296d8bc1b5c87-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b36461f2afbc45fb898296d8bc1b5c87-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b36461f2afbc45fb898296d8bc1b5c87-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2117,"real_height_1x":893,"real_height_2x":986},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b36461f2afbc45fb898296d8bc1b5c87-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b36461f2afbc45fb898296d8bc1b5c87-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b36461f2afbc45fb898296d8bc1b5c87-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2117,"real_height_1x":893,"real_height_2x":986},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b36461f2afbc45fb898296d8bc1b5c87-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b36461f2afbc45fb898296d8bc1b5c87-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b36461f2afbc45fb898296d8bc1b5c87-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2117,"real_height_1x":558,"real_height_2x":986},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b36461f2afbc45fb898296d8bc1b5c87-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b36461f2afbc45fb898296d8bc1b5c87-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b36461f2afbc45fb898296d8bc1b5c87-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2117,"real_height_1x":558,"real_height_2x":986},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b36461f2afbc45fb898296d8bc1b5c87-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b36461f2afbc45fb898296d8bc1b5c87-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b36461f2afbc45fb898296d8bc1b5c87-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":193,"real_height_2x":386},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b36461f2afbc45fb898296d8bc1b5c87-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b36461f2afbc45fb898296d8bc1b5c87-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/b36461f2afbc45fb898296d8bc1b5c87-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":193,"real_height_2x":386}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Authorities should intervene and seek out the distributors and producers of snuff content, Kirill Titaev believes. “This is a classic task for investigative and law enforcement units, which are supposed to identify the creators and the intermediaries. A person who films a homicide scene is clearly an accomplice in the homicide; moreover, it is supposed to mean aggravating circumstances and quite substantial prison terms,” he says.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Criminal Code<a href=\"https://www.garant.ru/hotlaw/federal/1746687/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> was also amended </a>by the legislative package banning “trash streams” in 2024. Posting violent videos depicting murders is now considered to be an aggravating circumstance and a qualifying element in ten Criminal Code articles, including murder, intentional bodily harm infliction, assault, and torture.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"State Duma Chairman Vyacheslav Volodin <a href=\"https://t.me/vv_volodin/743\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">had described</a> the importance of banning the “trash streams” to his Telegram channel audience, naming them “online broadcasts during which unlawful acts are committed, demonstrating cruelty, sadism, and abuse of people and animals, usually to make money and increase one’s audience.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“The state should not persecute these platforms [Telegram, etc.], but rather be grateful to them. They enable investigators to identify specific individuals and hold them accountable under criminal law,” Titaev adds. “But the problem is, the people who should be doing this work are busy persecuting the very journalists who are doing their work instead.”","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":9291,"header":"Inside the Pipeline: How North Korea Armed Russia","_path":"/en/stories/2026/03/16/how-north-korea-armed-russia/","lead":"Russia has received more than 8 million artillery rounds from the DPRK. An investigation by IStories and the Open Source Centre","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/6af21c99644b4cae89a2d4b4db76c14a-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Illustration: IStories","created_at_date":"2026-03-16","created_at_date_time":"2026-03-16T10:01:02.099Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":true,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":61,"first_name":"Егор","last_name":"Феоктистов","first_name_en":"Egor","last_name_en":"Feoktistov","is_public":true,"_path":"egor-feoktistov","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/9e523d40f309453baf3c3f1f506aaf7e-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Автор дата-отдела «Важных историй»","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":null}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[{"id":31,"first_name":"Катя","last_name":"Бонч-Осмоловская","first_name_en":"Katya","last_name_en":"Bonch-Osmolovskaya","is_public":true,"_path":"katya-bonch-osmolovskaya","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-896x504px_2x.jpeg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-688x387px_2x.jpeg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-416x234px_2x.jpeg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpeg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_1x.jpeg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1a8c02b72db84f2781be3243be755f17-336x189px_2x.jpeg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Редакторка дата-отдела","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":null,"ordering":1}],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":{"id":24,"header":"How Russia Imports Foreign Components and Machinery","_path":"/en/cases/2025/02/18/how-russia-imports-foreign-components-and-machinery/","color":"#BF9F99"},"topics":[],"body_preview":"On the morning of June 18, 2023, the cargo ship Angara dropped anchor near the Russky Bridge, the towering span connecting its namesake island to Vladivostok. Having departed Novorossiysk six months earlier, it was the vessel’s first call at a Russian port since the start of its long voyage.\n\nSixteen sailors boarded the ship, having arrived in the Primorsky Krai from every corner of Russia just the day before. This new crew was destined to be pioneers. Nearly two months later, the Angara would deliver the first containers of North Korean artillery shells to Russia. Three other bulk carriers — the Lady R, the Maia-1, and the Maria — later joined the transport operations.\n\nIStories has obtained movement data for all Russian vessels involved in transporting munitions from the DPRK. Together with researchers from the Open Source Centre, we have determined that over the course of two and a half years, Moscow has received more than eight million shells from Pyongyang.\n\nOur investigation also relied on the manifests of the sailors who participated in the arms transfers. We discovered that they left a trail of evidence across social media, posting photos and details of the operations even as official documentation meticulously obscured the cargo's trail.\n\nRussia’s only ally\n\nIn the summer of 2023, Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu traveled to the DPRK on an official visit. While there, he toured an arms exhibition and delivered a personal message from Vladimir Putin to Kim Jong Un.\n\nObservers speculated whether the Russian and North Korean leaders would reach an agreement on munitions supplies and technology transfers. A month after Shoigu's visit, the White House announced that the parties had made significant progress in their negotiations.\n\n“Any arms deal between the DPRK and Russia would directly violate a number of U.N. Security Council resolutions,” warned John Kirby, a spokesperson for the U.S. National Security Council. As it turned out, the Angara had returned from its maiden North Korean voyage just the day before Kirby’s warning — and set sail on its second trip only 24 hours later.\n\nBy the time Ukraine’s Main Directorate of Intelligence (GUR) reported on the arms shipments in September, the Angara had already established a steady operational rhythm. Every Monday or Tuesday, the vessel cleared customs in Vladivostok before proceeding to the Dunay military port — a former Soviet submarine base. There, containers of weaponry were offloaded onto a rail spur for transport to stockpiles in western Russia.\n\nAccording to Ukrainian intelligence, starting in August 2023, the DPRK began supplying Russia with 122-mm and 152-mm shells for Soviet-era artillery, rockets for Grad multiple launch rocket systems (MLRS), and tank ammunition. In October 2023, the United States tracked the movement of containers from the Dunay port to an ammunition depot near Tikhoretsk in the Krasnodar Krai — a facility that researchers from the British Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) noted had been prepared in advance for North Korean shipments.\n\nSoon, North Korean weaponry began appearing on the front lines. Analysts from the Open Source Centre (OSC) identified numerous images of Pyongyang-sourced shells and rockets shared on social media by Russian servicemen.\n\nBy early 2025, North Korean munitions had become vital for the Russian military effort, accounting for 75% to 100% of all daily artillery fire, according to reports from Russian artillerymen obtained by Reuters. \"Without help from the DPRK, the Russian army shelling of Ukrainian defensive positions would have been cut in half,\" GUR stated at the time.\n\nVoyage to “Busan”\n\nIn the spring of 2025, analysts from the Open Source Centre (OSC) published a study based on satellite imagery of the Russian ports of Dunay and Vostochny, along with the North Korean port of Rajin. Their findings identified 64 voyages made by the four vessels — the Angara, the Lady R, the Maia-1, and the Maria. The OSC estimated that these shipments carried between 4.2 million and 5.8 million artillery shells and MLRS rockets.\n\nThe British analysts acknowledged, however, that these figures were conservative and contained significant gaps. The harsh weather of the Far East offers few clear days for reliable satellite surveillance of these maritime hubs.\n\nIStories has bridged these intelligence gaps. We gained access to comprehensive movement logs for all vessels involved in the North Korean arms pipeline, identified individual crew members, and gathered firsthand evidence of their participation in operations that breached U.N. sanctions.\n\nWorking in tandem with the Open Source Centre, we have calculated that over a 2.5-year period, these four Russian ships conducted at least 112 voyages to North Korea. These shipments likely delivered between 8 million and 11 million pieces of ammunition to the Russian military.\n\nThe documents obtained by IStories list the vessels' stated destinations and general cargo information, but their actual arrival points and the true contents of the containers were deliberately concealed.\n\nThe South Korean port of Busan served as the primary “official” destination for the Angara, the Lady R, the Maia-1, and the Maria. According to the data set analyzed by IStories, these ships purportedly completed over 100 voyages to Busan since 2023.\n\nRussian border guards helped maintain this fiction. If a ship’s documentation listed South Korea as its destination, the FSB Border Service database recorded the same information, as shown by border-crossing records for the crews of the Angara and the Maria. However, as the Open Source Centre points out, South Korean port registries contain no record of these vessels ever docking there.\n\nThe deception was occasionally undermined by the crews themselves. In February 2024, a sailor on the Maia-1 posted a video to social media with the caption “Let’s go home” and a geotag for “Busan, South Korea.” In reality, the vessel was near the North Korean port of Rajin at the time of filming; its true coordinates were visible on a navigation screen caught in the frame.\nTo mask its movements, the Angara utilized not only Busan but also the Chinese port of Qingdao. According to official logs, the vessel visited Qingdao at least twice, though it was likely in the DPRK instead: during one of these voyages, the Angara was spotted in Rajin, and the transit time for these trips would have been insufficient to reach the more distant Qingdao.\n\nThroughout the North Korean munitions transport operations, the Angara concealed its location — its Automatic Identification System (AIS) was deactivated, and its true destination was masked in the paperwork. There was a single exception: from July 22 to August 10, 2023, the ship continuously transmitted its actual coordinates during a round trip to Tianjin, China. The Angara only disabled its AIS after arriving at the port of Korsakov on Sakhalin Island.\nIStories has established that upon the vessel’s arrival in Korsakov, Alexander Borovik, a courier for Spetssvyaz (the Main Center for Special Communications), boarded the ship. This state enterprise is tasked with transporting secret and hazardous materials, weaponry, munitions, and other “defense-industrial products.” Borovik was listed in the documents as the cargo escort. He spent several days on board, disembarking in Nakhodka and flying to Moscow shortly thereafter; leaked travel records show that Spetssvyaz booked his flight.\n\nBorovik has served as a courier for the state enterprise since at least 2009. His flight history includes travel on aircraft belonging to Roscosmos and a cargo carrier that the U.S. Treasury Department has linked to Rosoboronexport, Russia’s state arms exporter.\nThis voyage of the Angara was an anomaly. The movements of the other Russian vessels involved in the arms pipeline are masked. However, the documents obtained by IStories allow us to trace every voyage made by the Angara, the Lady R, the Maia-1, and the Maria to the DPRK and back.\n\nThe North Korean arms supply operation began in earnest in early September 2023, when the Angara arrived at the Dunay port directly from Rajin. This vessel accounts for one-third of all recorded voyages; the Maria handled a similar share, with the remaining trips split between the Lady R and the Maia-1.\n\nFollowing December 2023, shipments through Dunay ceased, and all munitions containers were diverted to Vostochny Port, the largest facility on Russia’s Pacific coast.\nOn average, the DPRK supplied Russia with approximately 350,000 pieces of ammunition per month — a volume requiring five separate voyages. For context, this monthly supply is enough to sustain the Russian military’s offensive operations for roughly 30 days.\n\nLoose feeds sink ships\nIStories has identified 145 sailors in the records who served on the North Korean voyages. We verified the identities of more than 100 of them and tracked down their social media accounts.\n\nWhile most crew members had backgrounds in traditional commercial shipping, the ranks also included recent maritime college graduates. For some of these young sailors, transporting weaponry from the DPRK marked their very first international assignment.\nTo lead the initial Angara shipments, the operation’s planners appointed a seasoned master: 52-year-old Andrey Grinko. By that time, Grinko had spent more than five years executing Ministry of Defense contracts that demanded the highest levels of secrecy.\n\nSince 2017, Grinko has made at least eight voyages to Syria aboard the Pizhma, Sparta II, and Ursa Major — vessels tasked with supplying Russian forces. In late 2024, the Ursa Major sank off the coast of Spain. According to the Spanish investigation, the ship was transporting nuclear reactor components intended for a North Korean submarine.\n\nOn the Angara, Grinko was joined by two other sailors with experience on Ministry of Defense cargo ships: Enver Dudov and Vyacheslav Konovalov. These men had previously participated in transporting stolen Ukrainian grain from Sevastopol to Tartus, Syria, aboard the Matros Koshka and the Mikhail Nenashev. Five more sailors from MoD supply vessels and two individuals linked to illegal grain exports would later join the North Korean runs.\n\nIStories reached out to the participants of the North Korean arms operations. Only one sailor from the Angara confirmed his involvement. He stated that the crew received their instructions from the vessel’s operator, MG-Flot, and noted that \"mobile phones had to be surrendered for signature upon crossing the border.\"\n\nAnother sailor, when asked about the DPRK voyages, replied that he could not disclose any information because he had “signed a contract.” Other crew members either ignored inquiries regarding North Korea or failed to respond to requests for comment entirely.\n\nIt appears, however, that the requirement to \"surrender mobile phones\" was frequently ignored. Crew members published more than 60 photos and videos from their North Korean voyages online. Both veteran captains and recent graduates were eager to document their journeys on social media. For instance, Angara crew member Mikhail Lavrentyev captured what is perhaps the most picturesque shot of the Dunay military port to date. \nIn some instances, the same container-laden vessel was caught on camera by two different sailors in close succession. This occurred, for example, aboard the Lady R in February 2024.\nAdditionally, we identified a video believed to have been filmed in Rajin Bay — located seven kilometers from the North Korean port of Rajin, the primary loading site for the Russian ships. A crew member from the Maria uploaded the footage to social media on December 13, 2024.\n\nOfficial records show that just one day earlier, on December 12, the vessel had departed Vladivostok, purportedly bound for Busan. Yet, by December 14, it was already heading back toward Russia, its deck stacked with containers.\n\n“Vessel conditions leave much to be desired”\n\nTwo companies, MG-Flot and Sovfracht, are responsible for the North Korean supply line. According to records, these firms own the vessels and manage all aspects of their commercial operations. \n\nSovfracht owns the Maria and the Lady R, while MG-Flot owns the Angara and the Maia-1. Several sailors spoke to IStories about their experience working for MG-Flot.\n\n“The condition of the ships, like the rest of the Russian fleet, leaves much to be desired — they are old vessels, roughly 30 years old, give or take,” shared one Angara crew member. “The pay is alright — higher than at other Russian companies — and the food is decent.”\n\nAnother sailor from the same ship offered a bleaker assessment: “Once the ships were transferred to MG-Flot’s management, supplies and spare parts stopped arriving. The company’s attitude toward provisions is poor.” He added that fuel was provided only at the “bare minimum,” and eventually, the company began refueling the Angara using fuel taken from other vessels.\n\nFurther evidence of the poor technical condition of the vessels used in the supply line can be found in legal records. In August 2023, shortly before its first voyage to the DPRK, the Maia-1 failed to fulfill a commercial contract due to its condition, according to an arbitration court ruling.\n\nThe vessel had been chartered for the Arctic LNG 2 project, carrying road slabs and paving stones in its hold. During the voyage, fuel oil leaked from a fuel tank into the cargo area due to corrosion, damaging the goods. A court ordered the owner of the Maia-1, Auto Ferry Cargo Terminal (Avtoparomny Gruzovoy Terminal LLC), to cover losses totaling 58 million rubles. However, by the summer of 2025, the cargo sender lowered its demands and re-engaged the vessel for further transport as a way to settle the debt.\n\nIn this ruling, the court identified the owner of the Maia-1 as a company that had previously managed to stay off sanctions lists. The same company appears in another document as the legal successor to MG-Flot in a separate legal dispute.\n\nWhile ownership data for Avtoparomny Gruzovoy Terminal is largely obscured, records show that in 2021, businessman Dzhamaldin Pashaev acquired a 50% stake in the firm. Pashaev is also the sole owner of MG-Flot, a fact revealed in a separate criminal bribery case. In 2024, the United States sanctioned Pashaev for importing components from Iran to support Russian drone production at the Alabuga plant.\n\nIStories also identified two shipping agencies that facilitated the port calls for the Maria, the Lady R, the Angara, and the Maia-1 as they delivered North Korean armaments. Sovfracht-Vostok (in which the sanctioned company Sovfracht holds a 24% stake) acted as the initial agent. All munitions deliveries through September 2023 involved this firm, which served as the intermediary between the vessel operators and port authorities, pilots, and other contractors.\n\nThe agency role later shifted to a company called DV Shipping. Financial documents show that this firm received tens of millions of rubles from Sovfracht, Sovfracht-Vostok, and Avtoparomny Gruzovoy Terminal. DV Shipping covered the costs for pilotage, water bunkering, diesel quality analysis, and port dues on at least one occasion for each of the four vessels: the Maria, the Lady R, the Angara, and the Maia-1.\nSailors working for MG-Flot told IStories that the North Korean runs paid above-average wages and were never delayed. The company made official payments — a rarity in an industry where, as one Maia-1 crew member put it, “elsewhere they pay less, or it's all under the table.”\n\nThe sailor described his time on the vessel as “satisfactory.” He added: “There were difficulties when I was there, but everything was paid. Don't forget what MG-Flot does and what is happening. We have the 'Special Military Operation' going on — a sort of war with the West — but our people are very weak; they're the 'Pepsi Generation.' If you want money, you work. If you don't like it, go somewhere else; no one is holding you back.”\n\nBy January 2026, the company’s financial stability was called into question. MG-Flot testified in court that it would be unable to pay salaries or settle accounts with contractors if the tax authorities enforced VAT collection. “MG-Flot is under sanctions from the U.S., E.U., and U.K. During the Special Military Operation, three of the company’s vessels sustained damage and one was sunk, forcing the company to incur additional expenses for their restoration,” a company representative explained.\n\nWhat happened next\n\nIn November 2025, Ukraine’s GUR stated that ammunition shipments from the DPRK to Russia had plummeted by more than half. According to Ukrainian intelligence, North Korean stockpiles have been depleted to such an extent that Russia is now receiving obsolete, nearly unusable hardware. Every second shell is being sent to Russian factories for refurbishment to bring it up to operational standards.\n\nIStories has found that the fleet involved in these shipments has also been halved, leaving only the Angara and the Lady R. The Angara’s most recent voyage to the DPRK occurred in January 2026, while the Lady R likely set off for a new consignment of shells in March 2026, just before this report’s publication.\n\nShipments began to dwindle as early as the autumn of 2024, when the average frequency of voyages dropped from five to three per month. Since the beginning of 2026, IStories and OSC have detected only a single delivery from the DPRK.\n\nNK Pro, a project that monitors satellite imagery of North Korean ports, reached a similar conclusion. Their analysts suggested that the cargo flow might have been diverted to the rail link between Russia and North Korea.\n\nHowever, analysts from the Open Source Centre believe other factors could also explain the decline. On one hand, Russia has exponentially scaled up its domestic ammunition production. According to Estonian intelligence estimates, Russian output grew from 1 million shells in 2022 to 7 million in 2025. Consequently, the Russian military may be becoming less reliant on imported munitions.\n\nOn the other hand, the exhaustion of the DPRK’s own stockpiles — the explanation favored by Ukrainian officials — remains a distinct possibility. North Korean manufacturing capacity may simply be insufficient to sustain Russia’s high rate of consumption. Tellingly, in December 2025, Kim Jong Un ordered the construction of new military facilities to ramp up the production of missiles and shells.","blocks":[{"data":"On the morning of June 18, 2023, the cargo ship Angara dropped anchor near the Russky Bridge, the towering span connecting its namesake island to Vladivostok. Having departed Novorossiysk six months earlier, it was the vessel’s first call at a Russian port since the start of its long voyage.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Sixteen sailors boarded the ship, having arrived in the Primorsky Krai from every corner of Russia just the day before. This new crew was destined to be pioneers. Nearly two months later, the Angara would deliver the first containers of North Korean artillery shells to Russia. Three other bulk carriers — the Lady R, the Maia-1, and the Maria — later joined the transport operations.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories has obtained movement data for all Russian vessels involved in transporting munitions from the DPRK. Together with <a href=\"https://www.opensourcecentre.org/research/on-the-bridge\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">researchers from the Open Source Centre</a>, we have determined that over the course of two and a half years, Moscow has received more than eight million shells from Pyongyang.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Our investigation also relied on the manifests of the sailors who participated in the arms transfers. We discovered that they left a trail of evidence across social media, posting photos and details of the operations even as official documentation meticulously obscured the cargo's trail.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russia’s only ally","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In the summer of 2023, Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu <a href=\"https://tass.ru/politika/18372903\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">traveled</a> to the DPRK on an official visit. While there, he toured an arms exhibition and delivered a personal message from Vladimir Putin to Kim Jong Un.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Observers <a href=\"https://novayagazeta.eu/amp/articles/2023/07/28/vziat-kima-za-tri-dnia\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">speculated</a> whether the Russian and North Korean leaders would reach an agreement on munitions supplies and technology transfers. A month after Shoigu's visit, the White House <a href=\"https://www.politico.com/news/2023/08/30/north-korea-russia-meet-over-arms-deal-00113471\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">announced</a> that the parties had made significant progress in their negotiations.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Any arms deal between the DPRK and Russia would directly violate a number of U.N. Security Council resolutions,” warned John Kirby, a spokesperson for the U.S. National Security Council. As it turned out, the Angara had returned from its maiden North Korean voyage just the day before Kirby’s warning — and set sail on its second trip only 24 hours later.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"By the time Ukraine’s Main Directorate of Intelligence (GUR) <a href=\"https://gur.gov.ua/content/ahresor-uzhe-pivtora-misiatsia-otrymuie-snariady-z-pivnichnoi-korei-kyrylo-budanov.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reported</a> on the arms shipments in September, the Angara had already established a steady operational rhythm. Every Monday or Tuesday, the vessel cleared customs in Vladivostok before proceeding to the Dunay military port — a <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20250219072926/https://www.cia.gov/readingroom/docs/CIA-RDP78T05929A000900020013-6.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">former</a> Soviet submarine base. There, containers of weaponry were offloaded onto a <a href=\"https://www.rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/commentary/report-orient-express-north-koreas-clandestine-supply-route-russia\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">rail spur</a> for transport to stockpiles in western Russia.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17810,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/6c69147a84654660b73847052f7a7c2c/index.html","url_mobile":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/6c69147a84654660b73847052f7a7c2c/index.html","ratio_mobile":"3:4","ratio_desktop":"1:1"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"According to Ukrainian intelligence, starting in August 2023, the DPRK <a href=\"https://nv.ua/ukr/world/geopolitics/pivnichna-koreya-prodaye-zbroyu-rosiji-budanov-nazvav-vidi-zbroji-ta-skilki-ce-trivaye-novini-ukrajini-50353326.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">began</a> supplying Russia with 122-mm and 152-mm shells for Soviet-era artillery, rockets for Grad multiple launch rocket systems (MLRS), and tank ammunition. In October 2023, the United States <a href=\"https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2023/10/13/north-korea-russia-weapons-ukraine/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">tracked</a> the movement of containers from the Dunay port to an ammunition depot near Tikhoretsk in the Krasnodar Krai — a facility that researchers from the British Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) <a href=\"https://www.rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/commentary/report-orient-express-north-koreas-clandestine-supply-route-russia\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">noted</a> had been prepared in advance for North Korean shipments.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Soon, North Korean weaponry <a href=\"https://x.com/PolymarketIntel/status/1715421360644600064?s=20\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">began</a> appearing on the front lines. Analysts from the Open Source Centre (OSC) <a href=\"https://stories.opensourcecentre.org/brothers-in-arms/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">identified</a> numerous images of Pyongyang-sourced shells and rockets shared on social media by Russian servicemen.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"By early 2025, North Korean munitions had become vital for the Russian military effort, accounting for 75% to 100% of all daily artillery fire, according to reports from Russian artillerymen <a href=\"https://www.reuters.com/graphics/UKRAINE-CRISIS/NORTHKOREA-RUSSIA/lgvdxqjwbvo/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">obtained</a> by Reuters. \"Without help from the DPRK, the Russian army shelling of Ukrainian defensive positions would have been cut in half,\" GUR stated at the time.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Voyage to “Busan”","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In the spring of 2025, analysts from the Open Source Centre (OSC) <a href=\"https://static.opensourcecentre.org/assets/osc_brothers_in_arms.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">published</a> a study based on satellite imagery of the Russian ports of Dunay and Vostochny, along with the North Korean port of Rajin. Their findings identified 64 voyages made by the four vessels — the Angara, the Lady R, the Maia-1, and the Maria. The OSC estimated that these shipments carried between 4.2 million and 5.8 million artillery shells and MLRS rockets.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The British analysts acknowledged, however, that these figures were conservative and contained significant gaps. The harsh weather of the Far East offers few clear days for reliable satellite surveillance of these maritime hubs.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories has bridged these intelligence gaps. We gained access to comprehensive movement logs for all vessels involved in the North Korean arms pipeline, identified individual crew members, and gathered firsthand evidence of their participation in operations that breached U.N. <a href=\"https://main.un.org/securitycouncil/en/sanctions/1718\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">sanctions</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Working in tandem with the Open Source Centre, we have calculated that over a 2.5-year period, these four Russian ships conducted at least 112 voyages to North Korea. These shipments likely delivered between 8 million and 11 million pieces of ammunition to the Russian military.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17811,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/c93b8cdfe6f349b58706183da162bbc4/index.html","url_mobile":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/c93b8cdfe6f349b58706183da162bbc4/index.html","ratio_mobile":"1:1","ratio_desktop":"800:600"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":{"id":17812,"data":{"block":"<p>We adopted the munitions calculation methodology developed by Open Source Centre (OSC) analysts. Using this approach in April 2025, a joint analysis by OSC and Reuters <a href=\"https://static.opensourcecentre.org/assets/osc_brothers_in_arms.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">estimated</a> that the DPRK had supplied at least 15,800 containers of ammunition.</p><p><br/></p><p><strong>Satellite analysis:</strong> For 41 voyages, OSC analyzed imagery of the vessels during offloading at the Russian ports of Vostochny and Dunay. In 23 other cases, only imagery from the North Korean port of Rajin was available; in these instances, analysts counted how many containers were loaded onto the ships versus those left on the pier.</p><p><br/></p><p><strong>3D modeling:</strong> To verify these counts, OSC created 3D models of each vessel, determining that each ship could carry between 200 and 500 munitions-laden containers. The modeling accounted not only for vessel capacity but also for the precise dimensions of the containers and the ammunition crates inside them.</p><p><br/></p><p><strong>Load composition:</strong> A key assumption involved the composition of the North Korean shipments. Based on estimates provided by Ukrainian sources to Reuters, the breakdown was as follows: 60% of the crates contained 122-mm howitzer shells, 25% contained 152-mm shells, and the remaining 15% were 122-mm MLRS rockets.</p><p><br/></p><p><strong>Packaging configurations:</strong> OSC also factored in that 122-mm artillery rounds were shipped in two configurations: crates holding either one or two shells, distributed roughly equally.. </p><p><br/></p><p>IStories significantly expanded the list of known shipments, identifying an additional 32 deliveries — accounting for approximately 30% of all munitions-related voyages. OSC estimated the volume of these newly identified shipments based on the average container counts from previously verified cases.</p><p><br/></p><p>Consequently, between September 2023 and January 2026, the Russian military received at least 29,488 containers of DPRK weaponry. According to OSC’s assessment, this is equivalent to between 8 million and 11 million artillery shells and rockets.</p>","header":"Methodology: How the totals were calculated","content":[{"insert":"We adopted the munitions calculation methodology developed by Open Source Centre (OSC) analysts. Using this approach in April 2025, a joint analysis by OSC and Reuters "},{"insert":"estimated","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://static.opensourcecentre.org/assets/osc_brothers_in_arms.pdf","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" that the DPRK had supplied at least 15,800 containers of ammunition.\n\n"},{"insert":"Satellite analysis:","attributes":{"bold":true}},{"insert":" For 41 voyages, OSC analyzed imagery of the vessels during offloading at the Russian ports of Vostochny and Dunay. In 23 other cases, only imagery from the North Korean port of Rajin was available; in these instances, analysts counted how many containers were loaded onto the ships versus those left on the pier.\n\n"},{"insert":"3D modeling:","attributes":{"bold":true}},{"insert":" To verify these counts, OSC created 3D models of each vessel, determining that each ship could carry between 200 and 500 munitions-laden containers. The modeling accounted not only for vessel capacity but also for the precise dimensions of the containers and the ammunition crates inside them.\n\n"},{"insert":"Load composition:","attributes":{"bold":true}},{"insert":" A key assumption involved the composition of the North Korean shipments. Based on estimates provided by Ukrainian sources to Reuters, the breakdown was as follows: 60% of the crates contained 122-mm howitzer shells, 25% contained 152-mm shells, and the remaining 15% were 122-mm MLRS rockets.\n\n"},{"insert":"Packaging configurations:","attributes":{"bold":true}},{"insert":" OSC also factored in that 122-mm artillery rounds were shipped in two configurations: crates holding either one or two shells, distributed roughly equally.. \n\nIStories significantly expanded the list of known shipments, identifying an additional 32 deliveries — accounting for approximately 30% of all munitions-related voyages. OSC estimated the volume of these newly identified shipments based on the average container counts from previously verified cases.\n\nConsequently, between September 2023 and January 2026, the Russian military received at least 29,488 containers of DPRK weaponry. According to OSC’s assessment, this is equivalent to between 8 million and 11 million artillery shells and rockets.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"The documents obtained by IStories list the vessels' stated destinations and general cargo information, but their actual arrival points and the true contents of the containers were deliberately concealed.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The South Korean port of Busan served as the primary “official” destination for the Angara, the Lady R, the Maia-1, and the Maria. According to the data set analyzed by IStories, these ships purportedly completed over 100 voyages to Busan since 2023.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Russian border guards helped maintain this fiction. If a ship’s documentation listed South Korea as its destination, the FSB Border Service database recorded the same information, as shown by border-crossing records for the crews of the Angara and the Maria. However, as the Open Source Centre points out, South Korean port registries contain no record of these vessels ever docking there.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The deception was occasionally undermined by the crews themselves. In February 2024, a sailor on the Maia-1 posted a video to social media with the caption “Let’s go home” and a geotag for “Busan, South Korea.” In reality, the vessel was near the North Korean port of Rajin at the time of filming; its true coordinates were visible on a navigation screen caught in the frame.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17813,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Social media, Google Earth","caption":"The navigation screen captured the filming location off the coast of the DPRK, near the Russian border","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bcab5ead2535407d8bf424e5997ab20b-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bcab5ead2535407d8bf424e5997ab20b-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bcab5ead2535407d8bf424e5997ab20b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1221,"real_height_2x":1348},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bcab5ead2535407d8bf424e5997ab20b-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bcab5ead2535407d8bf424e5997ab20b-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bcab5ead2535407d8bf424e5997ab20b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1221,"real_height_2x":1348},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bcab5ead2535407d8bf424e5997ab20b-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bcab5ead2535407d8bf424e5997ab20b-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bcab5ead2535407d8bf424e5997ab20b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":763,"real_height_2x":1348},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bcab5ead2535407d8bf424e5997ab20b-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bcab5ead2535407d8bf424e5997ab20b-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bcab5ead2535407d8bf424e5997ab20b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":763,"real_height_2x":1348},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bcab5ead2535407d8bf424e5997ab20b-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bcab5ead2535407d8bf424e5997ab20b-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bcab5ead2535407d8bf424e5997ab20b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":264,"real_height_2x":528},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bcab5ead2535407d8bf424e5997ab20b-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bcab5ead2535407d8bf424e5997ab20b-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/bcab5ead2535407d8bf424e5997ab20b-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":264,"real_height_2x":528}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"To mask its movements, the Angara utilized not only Busan but also the Chinese port of Qingdao. According to official logs, the vessel visited Qingdao at least twice, though it was likely in the DPRK instead: during one of these voyages, the Angara was <a href=\"https://stories.opensourcecentre.org/brothers-in-arms/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">spotted</a> in Rajin, and the transit time for these trips would have been <a href=\"https://docs.un.org/en/S/2024/215\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">insufficient</a> to reach the more distant Qingdao.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Throughout the North Korean munitions transport operations, the Angara concealed its location — its Automatic Identification System (AIS) was deactivated, and its true destination was masked in the paperwork. There was a single exception: from July 22 to August 10, 2023, the ship continuously transmitted its actual coordinates during a round trip to Tianjin, China. The Angara only disabled its AIS after arriving at the port of Korsakov on Sakhalin Island.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17814,"data":{"block":"<p>The vessel departed Vladivostok on July 22, 2023, and headed for Tianjin, IStories has established. By the morning of August 6, it had returned to the Russian port of Korsakov, according to the Angara’s own documentation and a U.N. Security Council <a href=\"https://docs.un.org/en/S/2024/215\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">report</a> citing AIS data. While the crew visited the port of Korsakov, they officially cleared the border only on August 14 in Nakhodka, per FSB Border Service records.</p><p><br/></p><p>At that time, the ship’s hold likely contained 50.69 tons of explosive missiles. The Dossier Center was the first to <a href=\"https://t.me/dossiercenter/300\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">report</a> such a shipment, citing the Angara’s documents, though journalists did not specify the exact timing of the delivery.</p><p><br/></p><p>Later, U.N. investigators identified the same cargo — missiles weighing exactly 50.69 tons — on board the Angara during its stay in Korsakov. They also established that the vessel was subsequently offloaded at the Dunay military port between August 15 and 21. A satellite image from August 18 confirmed that the Angara was moored there during that window.</p><p><br/></p><p>It remains unknown exactly where the missiles were loaded onto the Angara. According to IStories data, the vessel moved between Korsakov, Nakhodka, and Dunay with this cargo on board. Crucially, the ship did not dock in either Korsakov or Nakhodka; the actual offloading took place exclusively at the military port.</p>","header":"Inside the Angara’s Hold: What we know about the cargo","content":[{"insert":"The vessel departed Vladivostok on July 22, 2023, and headed for Tianjin, IStories has established. By the morning of August 6, it had returned to the Russian port of Korsakov, according to the Angara’s own documentation and a U.N. Security Council "},{"insert":"report","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://docs.un.org/en/S/2024/215","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" citing AIS data. While the crew visited the port of Korsakov, they officially cleared the border only on August 14 in Nakhodka, per FSB Border Service records.\n\nAt that time, the ship’s hold likely contained 50.69 tons of explosive missiles. The Dossier Center was the first to "},{"insert":"report","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://t.me/dossiercenter/300","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" such a shipment, citing the Angara’s documents, though journalists did not specify the exact timing of the delivery.\n\nLater, U.N. investigators identified the same cargo — missiles weighing exactly 50.69 tons — on board the Angara during its stay in Korsakov. They also established that the vessel was subsequently offloaded at the Dunay military port between August 15 and 21. A satellite image from August 18 confirmed that the Angara was moored there during that window.\n\nIt remains unknown exactly where the missiles were loaded onto the Angara. According to IStories data, the vessel moved between Korsakov, Nakhodka, and Dunay with this cargo on board. Crucially, the ship did not dock in either Korsakov or Nakhodka; the actual offloading took place exclusively at the military port.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"IStories has established that upon the vessel’s arrival in Korsakov, Alexander Borovik, a courier for Spetssvyaz (the Main Center for Special Communications), boarded the ship. This state enterprise is <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20251116022558/https://www.cccb.ru/about/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">tasked</a> with transporting secret and hazardous materials, weaponry, munitions, and other “defense-industrial products.” Borovik was listed in the documents as the cargo escort. He spent several days on board, disembarking in Nakhodka and flying to Moscow shortly thereafter; leaked travel records show that Spetssvyaz booked his flight.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Borovik has served as a courier for the state enterprise since at least 2009. His flight history includes travel on aircraft belonging to Roscosmos and a cargo carrier that the U.S. Treasury Department has linked to Rosoboronexport, Russia’s state arms exporter.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17815,"data":{"block":"<p>In 2007, Borovik became a co-founder of the branch of Boevoe Bratstvo (Combat Brotherhood) in Orekhovo-Zuyevo, a city in the Moscow Oblast. This prominent veteran organization was <a href=\"https://web.archive.org/web/20260215195806/https://bbratstvo.com/ob-organizatsii/istoricheskaya-spravka\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">established</a> by retired members of the Russian military, intelligence services, special forces, and law enforcement.</p><p><br/></p><p>Leaked records first link Borovik to Spetssvyaz in 2009. His subsequent movements can be traced through the FSB Border Service database.</p><p><br/></p><p>In January 2021, Borovik traveled from Saint Petersburg to the Algerian port of Oran aboard the vessel Johann Mahmastal. According to documents obtained by IStories, the ship was carrying several tons of missiles. Borovik returned to Russia by air three months later.</p><p><br/></p><p>In April 2022, he embarked on the Maia-1 from Novorossiysk. While the vessel successfully completed one voyage to India, it was detained in an Indian port that July due to outstanding debts to an Estonian company. At the time, the ship was carrying munitions intended for the Indian military, <a href=\"https://maritime-executive.com/article/india-detains-russian-ship-carrying-munitions-for-unpaid-fuel-bill\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">according</a> to The Maritime Executive.</p><p><br/></p><p>Beginning in 2022, Borovik frequently departed Russia on private business jets and transport aircraft. His destinations included Iraq (January 2022), Chad and Togo (June 2022), and Turkey (September 2022).</p><p><br/></p><p>The FSB database provides not only dates and destinations but also aircraft tail numbers. In October 2022, Borovik flew to Uganda on a Roscosmos <a href=\"https://www.jetphotos.com/registration/RA-64045\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">aircraft</a>, followed by a December trip on a <a href=\"https://www.jetphotos.com/registration/RA-76846\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">plane</a> belonging to the cargo carrier Aviacon Zitotrans.</p><p><br/></p><p>According to the U.S. Treasury Department, Aviacon Zitotrans has <a href=\"https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/jy1220\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">delivered</a> military equipment — including rockets, warheads, and helicopter parts — to Venezuela and Africa. U.S. authorities also alleged that the firm assisted Rosoboronexport in coordinating overseas arms shipments through Turkish intermediaries.</p><p><br/></p><p>On several international flights, Borovik was accompanied by fellow Spetssvyaz couriers. For instance, Konstantin Barulin joined him on the trip to Togo, while Dmitry Burgaz accompanied him to Iraq. In a sharp contrast to their covert military assignments, these same individuals were <a href=\"http://www.rcoi.mcko.ru/resources/upload/RichFilemanager/documents/2020-2021/dostavka_em/11/graf_dost_11_04-06-21.xlsx\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">tasked</a> in 2021 with delivering Unified State Exam (EGE) materials for Russian language tests to Moscow schools.</p>","header":"Who is Alexander Borovik?","content":[{"insert":"In 2007, Borovik became a co-founder of the branch of Boevoe Bratstvo (Combat Brotherhood) in Orekhovo-Zuyevo, a city in the Moscow Oblast. This prominent veteran organization was "},{"insert":"established","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://web.archive.org/web/20260215195806/https://bbratstvo.com/ob-organizatsii/istoricheskaya-spravka","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" by retired members of the Russian military, intelligence services, special forces, and law enforcement.\n\nLeaked records first link Borovik to Spetssvyaz in 2009. His subsequent movements can be traced through the FSB Border Service database.\n\nIn January 2021, Borovik traveled from Saint Petersburg to the Algerian port of Oran aboard the vessel Johann Mahmastal. According to documents obtained by IStories, the ship was carrying several tons of missiles. Borovik returned to Russia by air three months later.\n\nIn April 2022, he embarked on the Maia-1 from Novorossiysk. While the vessel successfully completed one voyage to India, it was detained in an Indian port that July due to outstanding debts to an Estonian company. At the time, the ship was carrying munitions intended for the Indian military, "},{"insert":"according","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://maritime-executive.com/article/india-detains-russian-ship-carrying-munitions-for-unpaid-fuel-bill","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" to The Maritime Executive.\n\nBeginning in 2022, Borovik frequently departed Russia on private business jets and transport aircraft. His destinations included Iraq (January 2022), Chad and Togo (June 2022), and Turkey (September 2022).\n\nThe FSB database provides not only dates and destinations but also aircraft tail numbers. In October 2022, Borovik flew to Uganda on a Roscosmos "},{"insert":"aircraft","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.jetphotos.com/registration/RA-64045","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":", followed by a December trip on a "},{"insert":"plane","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.jetphotos.com/registration/RA-76846","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" belonging to the cargo carrier Aviacon Zitotrans.\n\nAccording to the U.S. Treasury Department, Aviacon Zitotrans has "},{"insert":"delivered","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/jy1220","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" military equipment — including rockets, warheads, and helicopter parts — to Venezuela and Africa. U.S. authorities also alleged that the firm assisted Rosoboronexport in coordinating overseas arms shipments through Turkish intermediaries.\n\nOn several international flights, Borovik was accompanied by fellow Spetssvyaz couriers. For instance, Konstantin Barulin joined him on the trip to Togo, while Dmitry Burgaz accompanied him to Iraq. In a sharp contrast to their covert military assignments, these same individuals were "},{"insert":"tasked","attributes":{"link":{"link":"http://www.rcoi.mcko.ru/resources/upload/RichFilemanager/documents/2020-2021/dostavka_em/11/graf_dost_11_04-06-21.xlsx","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" in 2021 with delivering Unified State Exam (EGE) materials for Russian language tests to Moscow schools.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"This voyage of the Angara was an anomaly. The movements of the other Russian vessels involved in the arms pipeline are masked. However, the documents obtained by IStories allow us to trace every voyage made by the Angara, the Lady R, the Maia-1, and the Maria to the DPRK and back.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The North Korean arms supply operation began in earnest in early September 2023, when the Angara arrived at the Dunay port directly from Rajin. This vessel accounts for one-third of all recorded voyages; the Maria handled a similar share, with the remaining trips split between the Lady R and the Maia-1.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Following December 2023, shipments through Dunay ceased, and all munitions containers were diverted to Vostochny Port, the <a href=\"https://www.morport.com/rus/news/gruzooborot-morskih-portov-rossii-za-2025-god\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">largest</a> facility on Russia’s Pacific coast.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17816,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"","caption":"","isNarrow":true,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d225351522e743e5b17b226da5b20915-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d225351522e743e5b17b226da5b20915-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d225351522e743e5b17b226da5b20915-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2522,"real_height_1x":2477,"real_height_2x":3254},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d225351522e743e5b17b226da5b20915-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d225351522e743e5b17b226da5b20915-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d225351522e743e5b17b226da5b20915-original.png","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2522,"real_height_1x":2477,"real_height_2x":3254},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d225351522e743e5b17b226da5b20915-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d225351522e743e5b17b226da5b20915-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d225351522e743e5b17b226da5b20915-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":1548,"real_height_2x":3096},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d225351522e743e5b17b226da5b20915-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d225351522e743e5b17b226da5b20915-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d225351522e743e5b17b226da5b20915-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":1548,"real_height_2x":3096},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d225351522e743e5b17b226da5b20915-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d225351522e743e5b17b226da5b20915-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d225351522e743e5b17b226da5b20915-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":535,"real_height_2x":1070},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d225351522e743e5b17b226da5b20915-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d225351522e743e5b17b226da5b20915-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/d225351522e743e5b17b226da5b20915-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":535,"real_height_2x":1070}]},{"credit":"Social media","caption":"Crew members from the Maria and Lady R documented their visits to Vostochny Port","isNarrow":true,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/031032504b094b7a91fdb317e8ba080d-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/031032504b094b7a91fdb317e8ba080d-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/031032504b094b7a91fdb317e8ba080d-original.png","real_width_1x":1080,"real_width_2x":1080,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1080},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/031032504b094b7a91fdb317e8ba080d-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/031032504b094b7a91fdb317e8ba080d-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/031032504b094b7a91fdb317e8ba080d-original.png","real_width_1x":1080,"real_width_2x":1080,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1080},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/031032504b094b7a91fdb317e8ba080d-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/031032504b094b7a91fdb317e8ba080d-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/031032504b094b7a91fdb317e8ba080d-original.png","real_width_1x":1080,"real_width_2x":1080,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1080},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/031032504b094b7a91fdb317e8ba080d-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/031032504b094b7a91fdb317e8ba080d-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/031032504b094b7a91fdb317e8ba080d-original.png","real_width_1x":1080,"real_width_2x":1080,"real_height_1x":1080,"real_height_2x":1080},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/031032504b094b7a91fdb317e8ba080d-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/031032504b094b7a91fdb317e8ba080d-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/031032504b094b7a91fdb317e8ba080d-original.png","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":415,"real_height_2x":830},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/031032504b094b7a91fdb317e8ba080d-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/031032504b094b7a91fdb317e8ba080d-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/031032504b094b7a91fdb317e8ba080d-original.png","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":415,"real_height_2x":830}]}]},"category":"two-images-embed"},"type":"two-images-embed"},{"data":"On average, the DPRK supplied Russia with approximately 350,000 pieces of ammunition per month — a volume requiring five separate voyages. For context, this monthly supply is <a href=\"https://edition.cnn.com/2024/03/10/politics/russia-artillery-shell-production-us-europe-ukraine\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">enough to sustain</a> the Russian military’s offensive operations for roughly 30 days.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Loose feeds sink ships","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":{"id":17817,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Social media","caption":"Denis Zagorodnenko, Chief Officer of the Lady R, photographed the vessel’s container stowage plan","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d9d67f780ae4c7c864609a02c85466a-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d9d67f780ae4c7c864609a02c85466a-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d9d67f780ae4c7c864609a02c85466a-original.png","real_width_1x":1440,"real_width_2x":1440,"real_height_1x":1440,"real_height_2x":1440},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d9d67f780ae4c7c864609a02c85466a-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d9d67f780ae4c7c864609a02c85466a-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d9d67f780ae4c7c864609a02c85466a-original.png","real_width_1x":1440,"real_width_2x":1440,"real_height_1x":1440,"real_height_2x":1440},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d9d67f780ae4c7c864609a02c85466a-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d9d67f780ae4c7c864609a02c85466a-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d9d67f780ae4c7c864609a02c85466a-original.png","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":1440,"real_height_1x":1200,"real_height_2x":1440},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d9d67f780ae4c7c864609a02c85466a-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d9d67f780ae4c7c864609a02c85466a-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d9d67f780ae4c7c864609a02c85466a-original.png","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":1440,"real_height_1x":1200,"real_height_2x":1440},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d9d67f780ae4c7c864609a02c85466a-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d9d67f780ae4c7c864609a02c85466a-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d9d67f780ae4c7c864609a02c85466a-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":414,"real_height_2x":829},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d9d67f780ae4c7c864609a02c85466a-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d9d67f780ae4c7c864609a02c85466a-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1d9d67f780ae4c7c864609a02c85466a-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":414,"real_height_2x":829}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"IStories has identified 145 sailors in the records who served on the North Korean voyages. We verified the identities of more than 100 of them and tracked down their social media accounts.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"While most crew members had backgrounds in traditional commercial shipping, the ranks also included recent maritime college graduates. For some of these young sailors, transporting weaponry from the DPRK marked their very first international assignment.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17818,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/13d158d77f1e41f88b76c2b2670b80b8/index.html","url_mobile":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/13d158d77f1e41f88b76c2b2670b80b8/index.html","ratio_mobile":"2:3","ratio_desktop":"800:720"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"To lead the initial Angara shipments, the operation’s planners appointed a seasoned master: 52-year-old Andrey Grinko. By that time, Grinko had spent more than five years executing Ministry of Defense contracts that demanded the highest levels of secrecy.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Since 2017, Grinko has made at least eight voyages to Syria aboard the Pizhma, Sparta II, and Ursa Major — vessels tasked with supplying Russian forces. In late 2024, the Ursa Major <a href=\"https://www.istories.media/news/2025/12/29/zatonuvshii-v-proshlom-godu-u-beregov-ispanii-rossiiskii-sukhogruz-vez-detali-atomnogo-reaktora-dlya-kndr-la-verdad/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">sank</a> off the coast of Spain. According to the Spanish investigation, the ship was transporting nuclear reactor components intended for a North Korean submarine.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"On the Angara, Grinko was joined by two other sailors with experience on Ministry of Defense cargo ships: Enver Dudov and Vyacheslav Konovalov. These men had previously participated in <a href=\"https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/exclusive-kyiv-asks-turkey-probe-three-more-russian-ships-it-alleges-transported-2022-07-05/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">transporting</a> stolen Ukrainian grain from Sevastopol to Tartus, Syria, aboard the Matros Koshka and the Mikhail Nenashev. Five more sailors from MoD supply vessels and two individuals linked to illegal grain exports would later join the North Korean runs.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories reached out to the participants of the North Korean arms operations. Only one sailor from the Angara confirmed his involvement. He stated that the crew received their instructions from the vessel’s operator, MG-Flot, and noted that \"mobile phones had to be surrendered for signature upon crossing the border.\"","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Another sailor, when asked about the DPRK voyages, replied that he could not disclose any information because he had “signed a contract.” Other crew members either ignored inquiries regarding North Korea or failed to respond to requests for comment entirely.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"It appears, however, that the requirement to \"surrender mobile phones\" was frequently ignored. Crew members published more than 60 photos and videos from their North Korean voyages online. Both veteran captains and recent graduates were eager to document their journeys on social media. For instance, Angara crew member Mikhail Lavrentyev captured what is perhaps the most picturesque shot of the Dunay military port to date. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17819,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Social media","caption":"A photograph of the port of Dunay, taken by Mikhail Lavrentyev — then a sailor and later the captain of the Angara. The image is estimated to have been captured in September 2023","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54851fca20504583a8bf188554dbba2e-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54851fca20504583a8bf188554dbba2e-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54851fca20504583a8bf188554dbba2e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2560,"real_height_1x":1440,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54851fca20504583a8bf188554dbba2e-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54851fca20504583a8bf188554dbba2e-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54851fca20504583a8bf188554dbba2e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2560,"real_height_1x":1440,"real_height_2x":1920},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54851fca20504583a8bf188554dbba2e-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54851fca20504583a8bf188554dbba2e-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54851fca20504583a8bf188554dbba2e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":900,"real_height_2x":1800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54851fca20504583a8bf188554dbba2e-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54851fca20504583a8bf188554dbba2e-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54851fca20504583a8bf188554dbba2e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":900,"real_height_2x":1800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54851fca20504583a8bf188554dbba2e-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54851fca20504583a8bf188554dbba2e-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54851fca20504583a8bf188554dbba2e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":311,"real_height_2x":622},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54851fca20504583a8bf188554dbba2e-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54851fca20504583a8bf188554dbba2e-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/54851fca20504583a8bf188554dbba2e-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":311,"real_height_2x":622}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"In some instances, the same container-laden vessel was caught on camera by two different sailors in close succession. This occurred, for example, aboard the Lady R in February 2024.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17821,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Social media","caption":"Images of the Lady R with cargo: munitions from the DPRK were transported in containers identical to these","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/452dbe2ed8924f0c86ad71fb2966dd1c-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/452dbe2ed8924f0c86ad71fb2966dd1c-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/452dbe2ed8924f0c86ad71fb2966dd1c-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3240,"real_height_1x":1920,"real_height_2x":3240},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/452dbe2ed8924f0c86ad71fb2966dd1c-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/452dbe2ed8924f0c86ad71fb2966dd1c-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/452dbe2ed8924f0c86ad71fb2966dd1c-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3240,"real_height_1x":1920,"real_height_2x":3240},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/452dbe2ed8924f0c86ad71fb2966dd1c-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/452dbe2ed8924f0c86ad71fb2966dd1c-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/452dbe2ed8924f0c86ad71fb2966dd1c-original.png","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":1200,"real_height_2x":2400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/452dbe2ed8924f0c86ad71fb2966dd1c-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/452dbe2ed8924f0c86ad71fb2966dd1c-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/452dbe2ed8924f0c86ad71fb2966dd1c-original.png","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":1200,"real_height_2x":2400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/452dbe2ed8924f0c86ad71fb2966dd1c-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/452dbe2ed8924f0c86ad71fb2966dd1c-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/452dbe2ed8924f0c86ad71fb2966dd1c-original.png","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":415,"real_height_2x":830},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/452dbe2ed8924f0c86ad71fb2966dd1c-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/452dbe2ed8924f0c86ad71fb2966dd1c-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/452dbe2ed8924f0c86ad71fb2966dd1c-original.png","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":415,"real_height_2x":830}]},{"isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ecedc744666455296de7b9aa881d753-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ecedc744666455296de7b9aa881d753-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ecedc744666455296de7b9aa881d753-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3240,"real_height_1x":1920,"real_height_2x":3240},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ecedc744666455296de7b9aa881d753-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ecedc744666455296de7b9aa881d753-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ecedc744666455296de7b9aa881d753-original.png","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":3240,"real_height_1x":1920,"real_height_2x":3240},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ecedc744666455296de7b9aa881d753-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ecedc744666455296de7b9aa881d753-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ecedc744666455296de7b9aa881d753-original.png","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":1200,"real_height_2x":2400},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ecedc744666455296de7b9aa881d753-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ecedc744666455296de7b9aa881d753-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ecedc744666455296de7b9aa881d753-original.png","real_width_1x":1200,"real_width_2x":2400,"real_height_1x":1200,"real_height_2x":2400},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ecedc744666455296de7b9aa881d753-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ecedc744666455296de7b9aa881d753-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ecedc744666455296de7b9aa881d753-original.png","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":415,"real_height_2x":830},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ecedc744666455296de7b9aa881d753-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ecedc744666455296de7b9aa881d753-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/7ecedc744666455296de7b9aa881d753-original.png","real_width_1x":415,"real_width_2x":830,"real_height_1x":415,"real_height_2x":830}]}],"compare":true},"category":"two-images-embed"},"type":"two-images-embed"},{"data":"Additionally, we identified a video believed to have been filmed in Rajin Bay — located seven kilometers from the North Korean port of Rajin, the primary loading site for the Russian ships. A crew member from the Maria uploaded the footage to social media on December 13, 2024.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Official records show that just one day earlier, on December 12, the vessel had departed Vladivostok, purportedly bound for Busan. Yet, by December 14, it was already heading back toward Russia, its deck stacked with containers.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17827,"data":{"author":"Social media","caption":"Footage from a Maria crew member, presumably filmed near the port of Rajin. Date of recording: December 13, 2024","isVertical":true,"videosList":[{"url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/videos/43412f87a9954003ac6504940c436744.mp4","content_type":"video/mp4"},{"url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/videos/43412f87a9954003ac6504940c436744.webm","content_type":"video/webm"}],"hasControls":false},"category":"gif-embed"},"type":"gif-embed"},{"data":{"id":17823,"data":{"block":"<p>The video shows a sailor filming the sunrise on the horizon; at one point, the island of Taechodo enters the frame before the camera pans back toward the sun. The caption reads: “And it’s like this every morning, I don’t even know.”</p><p><br/></p><p>The sun’s elevation above the horizon and its position relative to the island match data <a href=\"https://www.suncalc.org/#/42.159,130.2427,12/2024.12.13/09:03/1/3\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">provided</a> by SunCalc for a location near Taechodo at that specific time. Furthermore, a 3D model of the island <a href=\"https://peakvisor.com/panorama.html?lat=42.16840641122704&amp;lng=130.23941323538315&amp;alt=1&amp;yaw=122.55&amp;pitch=1.95&amp;hfov=50.54\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">generated</a> via PeakVisor (a mountain visualization tool) aligns perfectly with the silhouette seen in the sailor’s video.</p>","header":"Video breakdown","content":[{"insert":"The video shows a sailor filming the sunrise on the horizon; at one point, the island of Taechodo enters the frame before the camera pans back toward the sun. The caption reads: “And it’s like this every morning, I don’t even know.”\n\nThe sun’s elevation above the horizon and its position relative to the island match data "},{"insert":"provided","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.suncalc.org/#/42.159,130.2427,12/2024.12.13/09:03/1/3","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" by SunCalc for a location near Taechodo at that specific time. Furthermore, a 3D model of the island "},{"insert":"generated","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://peakvisor.com/panorama.html?lat=42.16840641122704&lng=130.23941323538315&alt=1&yaw=122.55&pitch=1.95&hfov=50.54","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" via PeakVisor (a mountain visualization tool) aligns perfectly with the silhouette seen in the sailor’s video.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"“Vessel conditions leave much to be desired”","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"Two companies, MG-Flot and Sovfracht, are responsible for the North Korean supply line. According to records, these firms own the vessels and manage all aspects of their commercial operations. ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Sovfracht owns the Maria and the Lady R, while MG-Flot owns the Angara and the Maia-1. Several sailors spoke to IStories about their experience working for MG-Flot.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“The condition of the ships, like the rest of the Russian fleet, leaves much to be desired — they are old vessels, roughly 30 years old, give or take,” shared one Angara crew member. “The pay is alright — higher than at other Russian companies — and the food is decent.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Another sailor from the same ship offered a bleaker assessment: “Once the ships were transferred to MG-Flot’s management, supplies and spare parts stopped arriving. The company’s attitude toward provisions is poor.” He added that fuel was provided only at the “bare minimum,” and eventually, the company began refueling the Angara using fuel taken from other vessels.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Further evidence of the poor technical condition of the vessels used in the supply line can be found in legal records. In August 2023, shortly before its first voyage to the DPRK, the Maia-1 failed to fulfill a commercial contract due to its condition, according to an arbitration court ruling.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The vessel had been chartered for the Arctic LNG 2 project, carrying road slabs and paving stones in its hold. During the voyage, fuel oil leaked from a fuel tank into the cargo area due to corrosion, damaging the goods. A court <a href=\"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Document/Pdf/33c4a795-2d4c-4c58-a99b-f86b36b2ac2e/2d92d8ca-d38f-44e6-917d-51434156485e/A40-201466-2024_20250205_Reshenija_i_postanovlenija.pdf?isAddStamp=True\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">ordered</a> the owner of the Maia-1, Auto Ferry Cargo Terminal (Avtoparomny Gruzovoy Terminal LLC), to cover losses totaling 58 million rubles. However, by the summer of 2025, the cargo sender <a href=\"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Document/Pdf/33c4a795-2d4c-4c58-a99b-f86b36b2ac2e/a3455e10-8965-4074-9c50-fe8f6fd08585/A40-201466-2024_20250619_Postanovlenie_apelljacionnoj_instancii.pdf?isAddStamp=True\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">lowered</a> its demands and re-engaged the vessel for further transport as a way to settle the debt.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In this ruling, the court identified the owner of the Maia-1 as a company that had previously managed to stay off sanctions lists. The same company <a href=\"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Document/Pdf/db44f54b-9717-48af-b585-00ee32afe6d8/8be605ca-e25f-45ce-b017-3be3e83deb1c/A15-10930-2024_20250523_Reshenija_i_postanovlenija.pdf?isAddStamp=True\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">appears</a> in another document as the legal successor to MG-Flot in a separate legal dispute.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"While ownership data for Avtoparomny Gruzovoy Terminal is largely obscured, records <a href=\"https://archive.ph/esLK4\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">show</a> that in 2021, businessman Dzhamaldin Pashaev acquired a 50% stake in the firm. Pashaev is also the sole owner of MG-Flot, a fact <a href=\"https://archive.ph/jt34I\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">revealed</a> in a separate criminal bribery case. In 2024, the United States <a href=\"https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/jy2570\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">sanctioned</a> Pashaev for importing components from Iran to support Russian drone production at the Alabuga plant.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories also identified two shipping agencies that facilitated the port calls for the Maria, the Lady R, the Angara, and the Maia-1 as they delivered North Korean armaments. Sovfracht-Vostok (in which the sanctioned company Sovfracht holds a 24% stake) acted as the initial agent. All munitions deliveries through September 2023 involved this firm, which served as the intermediary between the vessel operators and port authorities, pilots, and other contractors.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The agency role later shifted to a company called DV Shipping. Financial documents show that this firm received tens of millions of rubles from Sovfracht, Sovfracht-Vostok, and Avtoparomny Gruzovoy Terminal. DV Shipping covered the costs for pilotage, water bunkering, diesel quality analysis, and port dues on at least one occasion for each of the four vessels: the Maria, the Lady R, the Angara, and the Maia-1.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17824,"data":{"url":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/9719a3c7a7d54da8adf3703ebc0e5226/index.html","url_mobile":"https://static.istories.media/iframes/9719a3c7a7d54da8adf3703ebc0e5226/index.html","ratio_mobile":"full-height","ratio_desktop":"full-width-and-height"},"category":"visualization-embed"},"type":"visualization-embed"},{"data":"Sailors working for MG-Flot told IStories that the North Korean runs paid above-average wages and were never delayed. The company made official payments — a rarity in an industry where, as one Maia-1 crew member put it, “elsewhere they pay less, or it's all under the table.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The sailor described his time on the vessel as “satisfactory.” He added: “There were difficulties when I was there, but everything was paid. Don't forget what MG-Flot does and what is happening. We have the 'Special Military Operation' going on — a sort of war with the West — but our people are very weak; they're the 'Pepsi Generation.' If you want money, you work. If you don't like it, go somewhere else; no one is holding you back.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"By January 2026, the company’s financial stability was called into question. MG-Flot <a href=\"https://kad.arbitr.ru/Document/Pdf/2e5cd017-c57b-407a-8735-d2a87037785d/8f41620d-9fc4-4feb-8375-27cc4637e2de/A15-185-2026_20260127_Opredelenie.pdf?isAddStamp=True\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">testified</a> in court that it would be unable to pay salaries or settle accounts with contractors if the tax authorities enforced VAT collection. “MG-Flot is under sanctions from the U.S., E.U., and U.K. During the Special Military Operation, three of the company’s vessels sustained damage and one was sunk, forcing the company to incur additional expenses for their restoration,” a company representative explained.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"What happened next","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In November 2025, Ukraine’s GUR <a href=\"https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/russia-plans-make-up-120000-glide-bombs-this-year-ukrainian-intelligence-says-2025-11-14/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">stated</a> that ammunition shipments from the DPRK to Russia had plummeted by more than half. According to Ukrainian intelligence, North Korean stockpiles have been depleted to such an extent that Russia is now receiving obsolete, nearly unusable hardware. Every second shell is being sent to Russian factories for refurbishment to bring it up to operational standards.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"IStories has found that the fleet involved in these shipments has also been halved, leaving only the Angara and the Lady R. The Angara’s most recent voyage to the DPRK occurred in January 2026, while the Lady R likely set off for a new consignment of shells in March 2026, just before this report’s publication.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17826,"data":{"author":"Social media","caption":"The Maia-1 at the entrance to the English Channel in December 2024 — filmed after several months of transporting North Korean armaments","isVertical":true,"videosList":[{"url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/videos/c7200d1c36f04227aaf3140c03c7339f.mp4","content_type":"video/mp4"},{"url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/videos/c7200d1c36f04227aaf3140c03c7339f.webm","content_type":"video/webm"}],"hasControls":false},"category":"gif-embed"},"type":"gif-embed"},{"data":{"id":17825,"data":{"block":"<p>The Maia-1 completed its final delivery of North Korean munitions containers in March 2024. By late October of that year, it embarked on a return voyage carrying industrial equipment. IStories tracked the vessel’s path and discovered that this North Korea-bound cargo had been <a href=\"https://www.marinetraffic.com/en/photos/of/ships/shipid:362332/shipname:MAIA%201#6264561\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">photographed</a> as early as that summer, though the exact nature of the shipment remains unknown.</p><p><br/></p><p>After settling its court-ordered debts, the Maia-1 likely resumed fulfilling Ministry of Defense contracts. In late 2025, the vessel visited the Algerian port of Oran, a key hub for Russian arms exports. As of mid-March 2026, the Maia-1 is en route back to the Russian Far East.</p><p><br/></p><p>In July 2025, another vessel, the Maria, was withdrawn from the regular Russia – DPRK route. According to AIS data, in late February 2026, it docked at the <a href=\"https://j.map.baidu.com/66/---J\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Jinhai Shipyard</a> in the Chinese port of Zhoushan. The Maria spent approximately one week at the shipyard before departing in early March and disabling its AIS.</p>","header":"The Maia-1 and the Maria: Where are they now?","content":[{"insert":"The Maia-1 completed its final delivery of North Korean munitions containers in March 2024. By late October of that year, it embarked on a return voyage carrying industrial equipment. IStories tracked the vessel’s path and discovered that this North Korea-bound cargo had been "},{"insert":"photographed","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://www.marinetraffic.com/en/photos/of/ships/shipid:362332/shipname:MAIA%201#6264561","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" as early as that summer, though the exact nature of the shipment remains unknown.\n\nAfter settling its court-ordered debts, the Maia-1 likely resumed fulfilling Ministry of Defense contracts. In late 2025, the vessel visited the Algerian port of Oran, a key hub for Russian arms exports. As of mid-March 2026, the Maia-1 is en route back to the Russian Far East.\n\nIn July 2025, another vessel, the Maria, was withdrawn from the regular Russia – DPRK route. According to AIS data, in late February 2026, it docked at the "},{"insert":"Jinhai Shipyard","attributes":{"link":{"link":"https://j.map.baidu.com/66/---J","type":"usual"}}},{"insert":" in the Chinese port of Zhoushan. The Maria spent approximately one week at the shipyard before departing in early March and disabling its AIS.\n"}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"Shipments began to dwindle as early as the autumn of 2024, when the average frequency of voyages dropped from five to three per month. Since the beginning of 2026, IStories and OSC have detected only a single delivery from the DPRK.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"NK Pro, a project that monitors satellite imagery of North Korean ports, <a href=\"https://www.nknews.org/2026/03/north-korea-has-sent-5k-containers-of-munitions-to-russia-since-august-seoul/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reached</a> a similar conclusion. Their analysts suggested that the cargo flow might have been diverted to the rail link between Russia and North Korea.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"However, analysts from the Open Source Centre believe other factors could also explain the decline. On one hand, Russia has exponentially scaled up its domestic ammunition production. According to Estonian intelligence <a href=\"https://www.valisluureamet.ee/doc/raport/2026-en.pdf\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">estimates</a>, Russian output grew from 1 million shells in 2022 to 7 million in 2025. Consequently, the Russian military may be becoming less reliant on imported munitions.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"On the other hand, the exhaustion of the DPRK’s own stockpiles — the explanation favored by Ukrainian officials — remains a distinct possibility. North Korean manufacturing capacity may simply be insufficient to sustain Russia’s high rate of consumption. Tellingly, in December 2025, Kim Jong Un <a href=\"https://www.euronews.com/2025/12/26/kim-jong-un-orders-north-korea-to-boost-missile-production-in-2026\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">ordered</a> the construction of new military facilities to ramp up the production of missiles and shells.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":9235,"header":"Students Recruited to War in Universities and Colleges All Over Russia","_path":"/en/stories/2026/03/03/students-recruited-to-war-in-universities-and-colleges-all-over-russia/","lead":"What we know about the student recruitment campaign and how to avoid it ","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-original.jpg","real_width_1x":600,"real_width_2x":1200,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/56927377a4f34571a0508a3484cfaa22-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"War contract campaign at MIREA University. Photo provided by a student","created_at_date":"2026-03-03","created_at_date_time":"2026-03-03T15:48:28.976Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":true,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":23,"first_name":"Полина","last_name":"Ужвак","first_name_en":"Polina","last_name_en":"Uzhvak","is_public":true,"_path":"polina-uzhvak","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-896x504px_2x.jpg","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-688x387px_2x.jpg","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-416x234px_2x.jpg","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a2c3a2eaa4af438c94e0f73b51cc6e26-336x189px_2x.jpg","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Автор дата-отдела","lead_en":"","position":"Автор","position_en":null,"ordering":1},{"id":75,"first_name":"Лена","last_name":"Лемясова","first_name_en":"Lena","last_name_en":"Lemyasova","is_public":true,"_path":"lena-lemyasova","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-896x504px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-original.png","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1086,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":610},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-896x504px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-original.png","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1086,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":610},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-688x387px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-original.png","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1086,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":610},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-688x387px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-original.png","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1086,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":610},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-416x234px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-original.png","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-416x234px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-original.png","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-336x189px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-original.png","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":189,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-336x189px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/dd3b56c7f0e04e7dafa98f2be5b13c06-original.png","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":189,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Журналистка «Важных историй»","lead_en":"IStories' reporter","position":"Автор","position_en":"Author","ordering":2}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[{"id":34,"first_name":"Ольга","last_name":"Чуракова","first_name_en":"Olga","last_name_en":"Churakova","is_public":true,"_path":"churakova","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-896x504px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":938,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":526},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-896x504px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":938,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":526},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-688x387px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":938,"real_height_1x":386,"real_height_2x":526},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-688x387px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":938,"real_height_1x":386,"real_height_2x":526},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-416x234px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-416x234px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-336x189px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-336x189px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1247bb5fb58b415c86e20aee75c472f7-original.png","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":190,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Авторка отдела расследований","lead_en":"","position":"Авторка","position_en":null,"ordering":1}],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"Since December 2025, a coercive campaign has been underway in Russian universities and colleges to make students enlist in the military. Initially, the aggressive recruiting targeted young men who were falling behind in their studies. By the end of February, however, they started offering anyone (even girls) to join the war.\n\nCurrently, at least 83 universities and 24 colleges in 36 regions of Russia and annexed Crimea have joined the recruiting campaign in one form or another. The data has been provided to IStories by Timur Tukhvatullin, an education rights defender, and the Get Lost project. The Echo project also compiled a similar list.\nThe campaign spanned the entire country, from Kaliningrad (The Immanuel Kant Baltic Federal University) to Vladivostok (The Far Eastern Federal University). Some universities have been given target quotas for the number of students to be sent to war. E.g., in February, Far Eastern Federal University planned to send more than 30 students to the military, and at Plekhanov University of Economics, the group leaders in one of the faculties were instructed to recruit two students per month. At Tomsk State University of Architecture and Building, they set up a special office to ensure that the military quotas were met.\nOutright pressure isn't used at the moment and so far remains to be something of an exception: the only notable case involved the headmistress of the Novosibirsk Transport Technologies College who accused students of “cowardice” for their unwillingness to give their lives “for the fatherland.”\n\nAt the Russian Technological University (MIREA), the students in their final years falling behind have been sent one by one to the recruiters’ office. The recruiters tried to persuade them that signing a contract was their only chance to avoid being expelled from the university, one of the students told IStories. The university administration did not notify the students about the options to resit the failed exams, and threatened to expel those who refused to sign the military contract. After the media coverage, the university informed students about the opportunities to resit the exams, but would still call the students urging them to join the military.\n\nSometimes teachers and professors also get pressured by the administration. “One of my coworkers got mad and told the bosses, ‘You know what the goal is. You know we’ll be to blame if any of them signs the contract. We're basically the ones sending them into this crap [i.e. the war — Ed.].’ The administration responded that we had no choice because we work in a state institution and the order ‘came from above.’ They said, ‘If this doesn’t align with your moral principles, quit your job,’” a teacher at one of Moscow’s colleges told IStories.    \n\nAll the recruitment is done according to the Ministry of Defense’s guidelines: they offer students to sign a one-year contract to serve in the new unmanned aerial vehicle forces, take a sabbatical and serve as a UAV pilot away from the front lines, receiving millions in pay and then quickly returning to school with an opportunity to get state-funded education instead of having to pay for it.\nLegally, none of these promises (except for the payments) are backed up by anything; on paper, the conditions look like a typical “cannon fodder” assault infantry ones (the tactics of using huge numbers of untrained soldiers during the assaults in the hope of exhausting Ukrainian ammunition has become widely used by Russian commanders during the war).\n\nSpeaking to IStories, many students emphasize that practically no one at their universities and colleges believes in what is said in the propaganda leaflets. Nevertheless, some educational institutions are already reporting the first students have enlisted to fight. The Kutafin Moscow State Law Academy “has sent the first students to serve in the UAV forces,” wrote Viktor Blazheev, the university's rector and Vladimir Putin's confidant. “I can see the great prospects and the great career growth,” said a Nizhnekamsk polytechnic college student when explaining his decision to sign a contract. A student at the Volzhsky branch of the Moscow Power Engineering Institute said that his decision to “take a year off from school, help the Motherland defeat the enemy and return to his place at the university in a year” was supported by both his parents and his girlfriend. Among the students who decided to go to war are two brothers from a college in Volzhsky.\n\nStudents told IStories how they manage to passively resist the coercion, and lawyers shared advice on how to defend one's right to complete the education and avoid military service if the school administration attempts to make one fail their exams to get them enlisted.\n\n“Documenting the coercion is vital.” Why the student military contracts are a scam and how to legally resist pressure\n\nIn February, several regional educational institutions' websites posted the standard UAV forces contract appendix. These documents reveal how the actual conditions of service will differ from what agitators, recruiters, and school administrators say.\n\nLawyers from the Movement of Conscientious Objectors (stoparmy.org) examined the wording of the contract appendix and concluded that signing a contract while at school does not formally protect anyone from being forcibly transferred to the assault infantry.\n\nE.g., the promise to make a student contract last for just one year goes against Vladimir Putin’s September 21, 2022 mobilization decree, which is still in effect. It means the contract won't expire until Putin's decree is declared invalid.\nAt the same time, it cannot be ruled out that in the future, the Ministry of Defense and the Ministry of Education could come to an agreement and actually design a special program for students, Sergey Krivenko, the Citizen. Army. Law human rights group head tells IStories.\n\n“Very often they start an illegal scheme and then find a way to legalize it after a while. This was the case with the year-round conscription. For a long time, they had been calling people to the conscription commissions before the conscription began, which we considered a violation, but now it has all been legalized. But for now, signing a contract remains a one-way ticket. The presidential decree is in force, and one cannot resign while it is,” the lawyer says.\n\nThe “guarantee” that the student will serve in unmanned forces, far away from the front line, are also invalidated by the wording of the contract appendix. The Movement of Conscientious Objectors lawyers point out that the Ministry of Defense reserves the right to transfer a new contractor to another branch or category of troops if the person is not suitable for the position of UAV pilot. In other words, it's the commanders who will determine the ex-student’s combat role, and it's not done before the contract is signed, but after, when it the contract is already impossible to terminate.\n\nIn addition, neither the appendix nor the existing law guarantees students they will study for free after the service. There's also no legislation to guarantee the admission to a state-funded master's or postgraduate program without competition for those students.\n\nTimur Tukhvatullin, an education rights defender\n\n— Some students are not given the opportunity to resit exams and are told that the alternative to signing a contract is expulsion. \n\nNot allowing students to resit exams is a legal violation. According to the law, students must be given two attempts to resit the exam. The first re-examination would happen with the professor who had administered the initial exam or test. The second re-examination is with a commission consisting of several teachers. Only if the student fails the commission resit can they be expelled.\n\nAnd it should be a proper resit, where they don’t try to fail you and don’t stray from the topic. If there are violations during the resit, it is possible to appeal, which must be done on the same day.\n\nIf they do not allow you to resit the exam, you should contact Rosobrnadzor [Russian federal agency tasked with the supervision and control of national education and science — Ed.] and the prosecutor’s office. If they do not help, go to court. This is enough of a reason to initiate administrative proceedings for obstruction of education, and in some cases, it may be a criminal offense of abuse of official authority.\n\nDocumenting the coercion is vital: it can be done by using a voice recorder or taking chat messages screenshots.\n\nAt present, we are not aware of any cases where a university has expelled a student illegally. It is important to remember that if you have had two resits and they were unsuccessful, you can be expelled by law. But even in this case you shouldn’t sign the contract.\n\n“Intimidating students by saying the military is inevitable.” The students’ experience\n\nAlexander (all names have been changed — Ed.), The Bauman Moscow State Technical University\n\n— They said there would be a meeting for the failing students. I understood that they would be trying to persuade us to sign contracts. About a hundred people from every class year were gathered.\n\nThe meeting was led by the recruitment office staff. One of them started intimidating the students by saying that military service is inevitable, that everyone would have to serve, and even called on the girls to join. Four people were interested in the contract and were sent to the recruitment office.\n\nI doubt that the contract will actually last for just one year. I believe promising people a fortune for a year of service is just a way to lure them in.\n\nMy classmates and I don't discuss this [the war — Ed.], we just joke about it in a dark way. The idea to send young students to the “Special Military Operation” (a euphemism introduced by the Russian government to legally describe the Russo-Ukrainian war - Ed.) is terrible. I don’t see any active and open support for the “Special Military Operation” among my peers or at the institute in general. I’m not feeling worried about these meetings, but I absolutely do not like these plans. Then people wonder why the population is declining.\n\nRuslan, The Likhachev Moscow Technological College\n\n— All final-year students were called to an urgent mandatory meeting in the assembly hall. Half of the people didn't show up anyway.\n\nNo one believed these promises; everyone understood what was going on. There are people whose relatives in the armed forces were supposed to be discharged two years ago, but their contracts are automatically extended every year. No one believes in this venture. \n\nAt the end, they asked us to sign papers stating whether we were going to continue our studies, work in our field, or enlist in the military. The director’s deputy said that our country doesn’t need people just roaming around aimlessly, and that there are only two options: either fight or study.\n\nThey set up a room in a separate office where you can fly a drone on a simulator. They offered a three-day training course at some police college. They said that no one would be put on any lists there, that it was just like a game of paintball and drone training.\n\nThe next day, they gathered us again. They promised to tell us about the internship, but in the end, they invited us to work in some elite unit. They handed out pieces of paper with the information on the “special type of government service” and “work in the center of Moscow without participating in military operations or being sent anywhere.” Several people approached the recruiter to ask something, but I don’t know if they signed up or not.\n\nStepan, Russian Technological University (MIREA)\n\n— We were supposed to have exam resits. The teacher first sent us the information, then said it had been canceled. The order came “from above”: don’t allow [resits] to take place. They said, “We’re not waiting for you, we won’t give you the permission to resit, so do whatever you want.”\n\nThey called and told us to come to the academic department. The deputy principal told us to go to room 212 and find out what our option was. There was a poster about contract military service hanging in front of the door, which made me nervous.\n\nThere were camouflage nets in the room and a laptop showing drone videos of people being blown up. A man sitting there didn’t introduce himself. He had no rank insignia and wore civilian clothes. I hadn’t seen him at the university before.  \nHe wrote down my details and said that I had no chance of retaking my exams and that I could either sign a contract with the Ministry of Defense and go to operate drones, or I would be sent to serve in the army. With the contract, I would get paid and be honored as a “hero.” He tried to convince me that the contract would last just a year. But I know that they don’t let anyone go easily. \n\nA lot of guys at the university are really worried. There are some guys who spend most of their time at their computers, they don’t socialize much, and the first, the academic department manages to pressure them a lot, then those from room 212. None of my friends have signed anything, but in general, it's such a sensitive topic that no one talks about it. \n\nAfter the fuss in the news, they allowed resits again, but people are still summoned to that room.\n\nIgor, The Far Eastern Federal University \n\n— There really is a quota requirement [of 32 people per month]. But, thank God, there is no pressure to sign these contracts.\n\nThey don’t threaten us with the university expulsion, but they have shortened the period for the resits. Now the deadline is March 12, whereas it used to be a week or a week and a half later.\nThe mood is silent. Many students don’t like it and everyone understands how absurd it is, but no one will say so directly, as you understand. I haven't seen any active “Special Military Operation” supporters at the university and I doubt they even exist.\n\nLooking at the quota numbers, it becomes clear that even the rector’s office does not expect crowds of students to sign contracts.\n\nStudents generally understand that they could be sent to the front lines, and that they will not actually be allowed to terminate their contracts after a year.\n\nSveta, The Ural State Academy of Visual Arts and Architecture\n\n— Our university exclusively has creative majors, and the overwhelming majority of students are women. One boy I know makes no secret of the fact that he will do whatever it takes to avoid being drafted into the army, let alone going to war.\n\nTwo years ago, a similar campaign was held, but it was conducted more discreetly: they would send out invitations to a “mandatory event” with no further details. \n\nMy classmate, who fell for it the first time, said that they talked to them like this: “It’s okay that you might be tired of studying. Your first priority should be to stand on your own two feet. We are offering you the opportunity to earn money and get a change of scenery. You can return to your studies at any time, having served your duty to the Motherland.”\n\nMy classmate said that at the end, two or three guys would approach the recruiters with their questions. At the time, in 2024, no one was talking about the UAVs; they simply offered students to make money doing some “easy work.” \n\nThis time, the senior students understood why they were being gathered, and some of them boycotted the meeting. In another group, some got interested. They described the prospects like this: “It’s just a year, and they give you three million rubles (approx. USD 40 thousand) right away, you can do whatever you want with it.” \n\nWith fewer options after getting a bachelor's degree, some people are really starting to think about taking this step. The lecturers say there won’t be any government-funded options to get a master’s degree. The number of programs is shrinking: our department has lost more than five master's programs. The ones that remain don't give you access to a job in the industry.\n\nThose paying for their education who had hoped to get a state-funded master's degree are looking very lost. This includes my classmate, who was counting on getting a master's degree to keep his student deferment of military service.\n\nIf we were to characterize all students at the university in general terms, over the past year it has become more apparent who disagrees with the statements and requests made to students by the dean's office. Anyone who takes even the slightest militaristic stance receives mostly negative reactions. No one downloads the MAX app (a state-controlled messenger to replace the more popular Telegram and WhatsApp which are to be banned — Ed.), and the administration has not yet taken on the task of “re-educating” us.","blocks":[{"data":"Since December 2025, a coercive campaign has been underway in Russian universities and colleges to make students enlist in the military. Initially, the aggressive recruiting targeted young men who were falling behind in their studies. By the end of February, however, they started offering anyone (even girls) to join the war.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Currently, at least 83 universities and 24 colleges in 36 regions of Russia and annexed Crimea have joined the recruiting campaign in one form or another. The data has been provided to IStories by Timur Tukhvatullin, an education rights defender, and the Get Lost project. The Echo project also <a href=\"https://echofm.online/stories/studentov-verbuyut-na-vojnu-kak-minimum-v-70-uchebnyh-zavedeniyah-iz-24-regionov-vklyuchaya-anneksirovannyj-krym-vyyasnilo-eho\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">compiled </a>a similar list.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17702,"data":{"block":"<p><em>In three cases, we were asked not to name the educational institutions</em></p><p><br/></p><ul><li>A.A. Leonov College of Space Engineering and Technology (Moscow Oblast)</li><li>A.A. Leonov University of Technology (Moscow Oblast)</li><li>Anapa Industrial Technical School</li><li>Astrakhan State University (Znamensk Branch)</li><li>Baltic State Technical University (Voenmeh) (Saint Petersburg)</li><li>Bauman Moscow State Technical University</li><li>Belgorod State Technological University</li><li>Cheboksary College of Economics and Technology</li><li>Chita State Academy of Medicine</li><li>Don State Technical University (Rostov-on-Don)</li><li>Far Eastern Federal University (Vladivostok)</li><li>Financial University under the Government of the Russian Federation (Vladikavkaz Branch)</li><li>Gorno-Altaysk State University</li><li>Higher School of Economics University (Moscow)</li><li>Immanuel Kant Baltic Federal University (Kaliningrad)</li><li>Institute of Food Technology and Design (Nizhny Novgorod)</li><li>Kazan Federal University</li><li>Kazan National Research Technological University</li><li>Kazan State Agrarian University</li><li>Kazan State University of Architecture and Civil Engineering</li><li>Krasnodar Mechanical Engineering and Service College</li><li>Kuban State University (Krasnodar)</li><li>Kutafin Moscow State Law University</li><li>Likhachev Moscow Technological College</li><li>Lipetsk State Pedagogical University</li><li>M.F. Panov College of Modern Technologies (Moscow)</li><li>Maykop State Technological University</li><li>Medical College No. 2 (Moscow)</li><li>Meleuz Multidisciplinary Professional College (Bashkortostan)</li><li>Moscow Aviation Institute</li><li>Moscow City University</li><li>Moscow Industrial College</li><li>Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology</li><li>Moscow Power Engineering Institute University (Volzhsky Branch)</li><li>Moscow State Linguistic University</li><li>N.N. Godovikov Polytechnic College (Moscow)</li><li>National Research University of Electronic Technology (MIET)</li><li>Nizhnekamsk Polytechnic College</li><li>Nizhnevartovsk State University</li><li>Nizhny Novgorod State University of Architecture and Civil Engineering</li><li>Novosibirsk Architecture and Construction College</li><li>Novosibirsk Law Institute</li><li>Novosibirsk Printing and Information Technology College</li><li>Novosibirsk State Pedagogical University</li><li>Novosibirsk State University</li><li>Novosibirsk State University of Architecture and Civil Engineering</li><li>Novosibirsk Transport Technologies College</li><li>Orel State University (Karachev Branch)</li><li>Orenburg College of Economics and Informatics</li><li>Orsk Institute of Humanities and Technology</li><li>Peoples&#x27; Friendship University of Russia (RUDN)</li><li>Petrovsky College</li><li>Plekhanov Russian University of Economics</li><li>Pushkin Leningrad State University</li><li><em>Requested not to name the educational institution</em></li><li><em>Requested not to name the educational institution</em></li><li><em>Requested not to name the educational institution</em></li><li>Revda Multidisciplinary Technical College</li><li>Russian Biotechnology University (Moscow)</li><li>Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration</li><li>Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration (Smolensk Branch)</li><li>Russian State University of Justice (Simferopol Branch, Crimea)</li><li>Russian Technological University (MIREA)</li><li>Russian University of Transport (MIIT)</li><li>Saint Petersburg Electrotechnical University (LETI)</li><li>Saint Petersburg National Research University of Information Technologies, Mechanics and Optics (ITMO)</li><li>Saint Petersburg Polytechnic University</li><li>Saint Petersburg State Institute of Culture</li><li>Saint Petersburg State Marine Technical University</li><li>Saint Petersburg State University</li><li>Saint Petersburg State University</li><li>Saint Petersburg State University of Aerospace Instrumentation</li><li>Saint Petersburg State University of Architecture and Civil Engineering</li><li>Saint Petersburg State University of Civil Aviation</li><li>Saint Petersburg State University of Economics</li><li>Saint Petersburg State University of Industrial Technologies and Design</li><li>Samara National Research University</li><li>Saratov State Academy of Law</li><li>Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University</li><li>Siberian Federal University (Krasnoyarsk)</li><li>Sochi State University</li><li>Southern Federal University (Rostov-on-Don)</li><li>Southwestern State University (Kursk)</li><li>St. Petersburg State Transport University</li><li>State University of Maritime and Inland Shipping (Saint Petersburg)</li><li>Technological College No. 34 (Moscow)</li><li>The Bonch-Bruevich Saint Petersburg State University of Telecommunications</li><li>The College of the Kazan Innovative University</li><li>The College of the Volga Institute of Economics, Pedagogy, and Law</li><li>The College of the Volgograd State University</li><li>The Kirov Saint Petersburg State Forestry University</li><li>Tomsk State University of Architecture and Building</li><li>Transbaikal State University (Chita)</li><li>Tsaritsyno College (Moscow)</li><li>Tver State Medical University</li><li>Ufa University of Science and Technology</li><li>Ulyanovsk College of Culture and Arts</li><li>Ulyanovsk Institute of Civil Aviation</li><li>Ulyanovsk State Pedagogical University</li><li>Ural Federal University (Yekaterinburg)</li><li>Ural State Academy of Visual Arts and Architecture (Yekaterinburg)</li><li>Ural State Law University (Yekaterinburg)</li><li>Volgograd State Institute of Arts and Culture</li><li>Volgograd State Medical University</li><li>Volgograd State University</li><li>Volgograd State University (Volzhsky Branch)</li><li>Voronezh State University</li></ul>","header":"Where does student recruitment campaign take place?","content":[{"insert":"In three cases, we were asked not to name the educational institutions","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":"\n\nA.A. Leonov College of Space Engineering and Technology (Moscow Oblast)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"A.A. Leonov University of Technology (Moscow Oblast)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Anapa Industrial Technical School"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Astrakhan State University (Znamensk Branch)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Baltic State Technical University (Voenmeh) (Saint Petersburg)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Bauman Moscow State Technical University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Belgorod State Technological University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Cheboksary College of Economics and Technology"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Chita State Academy of Medicine"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Don State Technical University (Rostov-on-Don)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Far Eastern Federal University (Vladivostok)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Financial University under the Government of the Russian Federation (Vladikavkaz Branch)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Gorno-Altaysk State University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Higher School of Economics University (Moscow)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Immanuel Kant Baltic Federal University (Kaliningrad)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Institute of Food Technology and Design (Nizhny Novgorod)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Kazan Federal University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Kazan National Research Technological University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Kazan State Agrarian University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Kazan State University of Architecture and Civil Engineering"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Krasnodar Mechanical Engineering and Service College"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Kuban State University (Krasnodar)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Kutafin Moscow State Law University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Likhachev Moscow Technological College"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Lipetsk State Pedagogical University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"M.F. Panov College of Modern Technologies (Moscow)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Maykop State Technological University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Medical College No. 2 (Moscow)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Meleuz Multidisciplinary Professional College (Bashkortostan)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Moscow Aviation Institute"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Moscow City University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Moscow Industrial College"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Moscow Power Engineering Institute University (Volzhsky Branch)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Moscow State Linguistic University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"N.N. Godovikov Polytechnic College (Moscow)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"National Research University of Electronic Technology (MIET)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Nizhnekamsk Polytechnic College"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Nizhnevartovsk State University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Nizhny Novgorod State University of Architecture and Civil Engineering"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Novosibirsk Architecture and Construction College"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Novosibirsk Law Institute"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Novosibirsk Printing and Information Technology College"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Novosibirsk State Pedagogical University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Novosibirsk State University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Novosibirsk State University of Architecture and Civil Engineering"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Novosibirsk Transport Technologies College"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Orel State University (Karachev Branch)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Orenburg College of Economics and Informatics"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Orsk Institute of Humanities and Technology"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Peoples' Friendship University of Russia (RUDN)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Petrovsky College"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Plekhanov Russian University of Economics"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Pushkin Leningrad State University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Requested not to name the educational institution","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Requested not to name the educational institution","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Requested not to name the educational institution","attributes":{"italic":true}},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Revda Multidisciplinary Technical College"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Russian Biotechnology University (Moscow)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration (Smolensk Branch)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Russian State University of Justice (Simferopol Branch, Crimea)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Russian Technological University (MIREA)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Russian University of Transport (MIIT)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Saint Petersburg Electrotechnical University (LETI)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Saint Petersburg National Research University of Information Technologies, Mechanics and Optics (ITMO)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Saint Petersburg Polytechnic University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Saint Petersburg State Institute of Culture"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Saint Petersburg State Marine Technical University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Saint Petersburg State University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Saint Petersburg State University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Saint Petersburg State University of Aerospace Instrumentation"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Saint Petersburg State University of Architecture and Civil Engineering"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Saint Petersburg State University of Civil Aviation"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Saint Petersburg State University of Economics"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Saint Petersburg State University of Industrial Technologies and Design"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Samara National Research University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Saratov State Academy of Law"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Siberian Federal University (Krasnoyarsk)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Sochi State University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Southern Federal University (Rostov-on-Don)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Southwestern State University (Kursk)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"St. Petersburg State Transport University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"State University of Maritime and Inland Shipping (Saint Petersburg)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Technological College No. 34 (Moscow)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"The Bonch-Bruevich Saint Petersburg State University of Telecommunications"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"The College of the Kazan Innovative University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"The College of the Volga Institute of Economics, Pedagogy, and Law"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"The College of the Volgograd State University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"The Kirov Saint Petersburg State Forestry University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Tomsk State University of Architecture and Building"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Transbaikal State University (Chita)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Tsaritsyno College (Moscow)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Tver State Medical University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Ufa University of Science and Technology"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Ulyanovsk College of Culture and Arts"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Ulyanovsk Institute of Civil Aviation"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Ulyanovsk State Pedagogical University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Ural Federal University (Yekaterinburg)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Ural State Academy of Visual Arts and Architecture (Yekaterinburg)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Ural State Law University (Yekaterinburg)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Volgograd State Institute of Arts and Culture"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Volgograd State Medical University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Volgograd State University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Volgograd State University (Volzhsky Branch)"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}},{"insert":"Voronezh State University"},{"insert":"\n","attributes":{"list":"bullet"}}]},"category":"drop-down-embed"},"type":"drop-down-embed"},{"data":"The campaign spanned the entire country, from Kaliningrad (The <a href=\"https://kantiana.ru/news/upravlyay-dronami-sluzhi-rodine/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Immanuel Kant Baltic Federal University</a>) to Vladivostok (The <a href=\"https://vladivostok1.ru/text/gorod/2026/02/27/76285106/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">Far Eastern Federal University</a>). Some universities have been given<a href=\"https://t.me/istories_media/11467\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"> target quotas</a> for the number of students to be sent to war. E.g., in February, Far Eastern Federal University planned to send more than 30 students to the military, and at Plekhanov University of Economics, the group leaders in one of the faculties were instructed to recruit two students per month. At Tomsk State University of Architecture and Building, they set up a <a href=\"https://tsuab.ru/article/sluzhba-po-kontraktu-v-voyskakh-bespilotnykh-sistem?lang=ru\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">special office</a> to ensure that the military quotas were met.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Outright pressure isn't used at the moment and so far remains to be something of an exception: the only notable <a href=\"https://www.reddit.com/r/UkrainianConflict/comments/1r92a63/novosibirsk_transport_college_director_maria/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">case </a>involved the headmistress of the Novosibirsk Transport Technologies College who accused students of “cowardice” for their unwillingness to give their lives “for the fatherland.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At the Russian Technological University (MIREA), the students in their final years falling behind have been sent one by one to the recruiters’ office. The recruiters tried to persuade them that signing a contract was their only chance to avoid being expelled from the university, one of the students told IStories. The university administration did not notify the students about the options to resit the failed exams,&nbsp;and threatened to expel those who refused to sign the military contract. After the media coverage, the university informed students about the opportunities to resit the exams, but would still call the students urging them to join the military.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Sometimes teachers and professors also get pressured by the administration. “One of my coworkers got mad and told the bosses, ‘You know what the goal is. You know we’ll be to blame if any of them signs the contract. We're basically the ones sending them into this crap [i.e. the war — Ed.].’ The administration responded that we had no choice because we work in a state institution and the order ‘came from above.’ They said, ‘If this doesn’t align with your moral principles, quit your job,’” a teacher at one of Moscow’s colleges <a href=\"https://www.istories.media/stories/2026/02/26/mi-budem-vinovati-yesli-kto-to-iz-nikh-podpishet-kontrakt/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">told IStories</a>.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"All the recruitment is done according to the Ministry of Defense’s <a href=\"https://vk.com/wall-216938057_1013\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">guidelines</a>: they offer students to sign a one-year contract to serve in the new unmanned aerial vehicle forces, take a sabbatical and serve as a UAV pilot away from the front lines, receiving millions in pay and then quickly returning to school with an opportunity to get state-funded education instead of having to pay for it.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17706,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo provided by a student","caption":"An interview invitation to the President’s Main Directorate of Special Programs (formerly the 15th KGB service; responsible for mobilization activities and government bunkers), distributed to students at Likhachev College","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ccb5d600959b4b60827df674e5b5f615-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ccb5d600959b4b60827df674e5b5f615-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ccb5d600959b4b60827df674e5b5f615-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ccb5d600959b4b60827df674e5b5f615-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ccb5d600959b4b60827df674e5b5f615-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ccb5d600959b4b60827df674e5b5f615-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1279,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ccb5d600959b4b60827df674e5b5f615-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ccb5d600959b4b60827df674e5b5f615-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ccb5d600959b4b60827df674e5b5f615-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ccb5d600959b4b60827df674e5b5f615-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ccb5d600959b4b60827df674e5b5f615-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ccb5d600959b4b60827df674e5b5f615-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":798,"real_height_2x":1412},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ccb5d600959b4b60827df674e5b5f615-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ccb5d600959b4b60827df674e5b5f615-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ccb5d600959b4b60827df674e5b5f615-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ccb5d600959b4b60827df674e5b5f615-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ccb5d600959b4b60827df674e5b5f615-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/ccb5d600959b4b60827df674e5b5f615-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":276,"real_height_2x":553}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Legally, none of these promises (except for the payments) are backed up by anything; on paper, the conditions look like a typical “cannon fodder” assault infantry ones (the tactics of using huge numbers of untrained soldiers during the assaults in the hope of exhausting Ukrainian ammunition has become widely used by Russian commanders during the war).","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Speaking to IStories, many students emphasize that practically no one at their universities and colleges believes in what is said in the propaganda leaflets. Nevertheless, some educational institutions are already reporting the first students have enlisted to fight. The Kutafin Moscow State Law Academy “has sent the first students to serve in the UAV forces,” wrote Viktor Blazheev, the university's rector and Vladimir Putin's confidant. “I can see the great prospects and the great career growth,” said a Nizhnekamsk polytechnic college student when <a href=\"https://www.tatar-inform.ru/news/vizu-bolsie-perspektivy-student-iz-niznekamska-otpravitsya-sluzit-v-voiska-bpla-6018151?yclid=mm26cwo3oi226409194\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">explaining his decision</a> to sign a contract. A <a href=\"https://admvol.ru/ovolzhsky/news/20165/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">student at the Volzhsky branch</a> of the Moscow Power Engineering Institute said that his decision to “take a year off from school, help the Motherland defeat the enemy and return to his place at the university in a year” was supported by both his parents and his girlfriend. Among the students who decided to go to war are <a href=\"https://vk.com/admvol_34?w=wall-172765992_46943\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">two brothers</a> from a college in Volzhsky.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Students told IStories how they manage to passively resist the coercion, and lawyers shared advice on how to defend one's right to complete the education and avoid military service if the school administration attempts to make one fail their exams to get them enlisted.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Documenting the coercion is vital.” Why the student military contracts are a scam and how to legally resist pressure","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"In February, several regional educational institutions' websites posted the <a href=\"https://t.me/istories_media/11473?single\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">standard UAV forces contract appendix</a>. These documents reveal how the actual conditions of service will differ from what agitators, recruiters, and school administrators say.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Lawyers from the Movement of Conscientious Objectors (stoparmy.org) examined the wording of the contract appendix and concluded that signing a contract while at school does not formally protect anyone from being forcibly transferred to the assault infantry.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"E.g., the promise to make a student contract last for just one year goes against Vladimir Putin’s September 21, 2022 mobilization decree, which is still in effect. It means the contract won't expire until Putin's decree is declared invalid.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17703,"data":{"text":"an education rights defender","author":"Timur Tukhvatullin","header":"Not allowing students to resit exams is a legal violation"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"At the same time, it cannot be ruled out that in the future, the Ministry of Defense and the Ministry of Education could come to an agreement and actually design a special program for students, Sergey Krivenko, the Citizen. Army. Law human rights group head tells IStories.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Very often they start an illegal scheme and then find a way to legalize it after a while. This was the case with the year-round conscription. For a long time, they had been calling people to the conscription commissions before the conscription began, which we considered a violation, but now it has all been legalized. But for now, signing a contract remains a one-way ticket. The presidential decree is in force, and one cannot resign while it is,” the lawyer says.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The “guarantee” that the student will serve in unmanned forces, far away from the front line, are also invalidated by the wording of the contract appendix. The Movement of Conscientious Objectors lawyers point out that the Ministry of Defense reserves the right to transfer a new contractor to another branch or category of troops if the person is not suitable for the position of UAV pilot. In other words, it's the commanders who will determine the ex-student’s combat role, and it's not done before the contract is signed, but after, when it the contract is already impossible to terminate.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In addition, neither the appendix nor the existing law guarantees students they will study for free after the service. There's also no legislation to guarantee the admission to a state-funded master's or postgraduate program without competition for those students.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Timur Tukhvatullin, an education rights defender</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— Some students are not given the opportunity to resit exams and are told that the alternative to signing a contract is expulsion.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Not allowing students to resit exams is a legal violation. According to the law, students must be given two attempts to resit the exam. The first re-examination would happen with the professor who had administered the initial exam or test. The second re-examination is with a commission consisting of several teachers. Only if the student fails the commission resit can they be expelled.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"And it should be a proper resit, where they don’t try to fail you and don’t stray from the topic. If there are violations during the resit, it is possible to appeal, which must be done on the same day.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"If they do not allow you to resit the exam, you should contact Rosobrnadzor [Russian federal agency tasked with the supervision and control of national education and science —&nbsp;Ed.] and the prosecutor’s office. If they do not help, go to court. This is enough of a reason to initiate administrative proceedings for obstruction of education, and in some cases, it may be a criminal offense of abuse of official authority.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Documenting the coercion is vital: it can be done by using a voice recorder or taking chat messages screenshots.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At present, we are not aware of any cases where a university has expelled a student illegally. It is important to remember that if you have had two resits and they were unsuccessful, you can be expelled by law. But even in this case you shouldn’t sign the contract.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Intimidating students by saying the military is inevitable.” The students’ experience","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Alexander (all names have been changed — Ed.), The Bauman Moscow State Technical University</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— They said there would be a meeting for the failing students. I understood that they would be trying to persuade us to sign contracts. About a hundred people from every class year were gathered.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The meeting was led by the recruitment office staff. One of them started intimidating the students by saying that military service is inevitable, that everyone would have to serve, and even called on the girls to join. Four people were interested in the contract and were sent to the recruitment office.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"I doubt that the contract will actually last for just one year. I believe promising people a fortune for a year of service is just a way to lure them in.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"My classmates and I don't discuss this [the war — Ed.], we just joke about it in a dark way. The idea to send young students to the “Special Military Operation” (a euphemism introduced by the Russian government to legally describe the Russo-Ukrainian war - Ed.) is terrible. I don’t see any active and open support for the “Special Military Operation” among my peers or at the institute in general. I’m not feeling worried about these meetings, but I absolutely do not like these plans. Then people wonder why the population is declining.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Ruslan, The Likhachev Moscow Technological College</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— All final-year students were called to an urgent mandatory meeting in the assembly hall. Half of the people didn't show up anyway.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"No one believed these promises; everyone understood what was going on. There are people whose relatives in the armed forces were supposed to be discharged two years ago, but their contracts are automatically extended every year. No one believes in this venture.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At the end, they asked us to sign papers stating whether we were going to continue our studies, work in our field, or enlist in the military. The director’s deputy said that our country doesn’t need people just roaming around aimlessly, and that there are only two options: either fight or study.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"They set up a room in a separate office where you can fly a drone on a simulator. They offered a three-day training course at some police college. They said that no one would be put on any lists there, that it was just like a game of paintball and drone training.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The next day, they gathered us again. They promised to tell us about the internship, but in the end, they invited us to work in some elite unit. They handed out pieces of paper with the information on the “special type of government service” and “work in the center of Moscow without participating in military operations or being sent anywhere.” Several people approached the recruiter to ask something, but I don’t know if they signed up or not.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Stepan, Russian Technological University (MIREA)</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— We were supposed to have exam resits. The teacher first sent us the information, then said it had been canceled. The order came “from above”: don’t allow [resits] to take place. They said, “We’re not waiting for you, we won’t give you the permission to resit, so do whatever you want.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"They called and told us to come to the academic department. The deputy principal told us to go to room 212 and find out what our option was. There was a poster about contract military service hanging in front of the door, which made me nervous.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"There were camouflage nets in the room and a laptop showing drone videos of people being blown up. A man sitting there didn’t introduce himself. He had no rank insignia and wore civilian clothes. I hadn’t seen him at the university before. &nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17707,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo provided by a student","caption":"Military contract ad at MIREA","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48d8e46ab454f7ab5aeef1d41febf44-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48d8e46ab454f7ab5aeef1d41febf44-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48d8e46ab454f7ab5aeef1d41febf44-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1079,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48d8e46ab454f7ab5aeef1d41febf44-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48d8e46ab454f7ab5aeef1d41febf44-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48d8e46ab454f7ab5aeef1d41febf44-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":1079,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48d8e46ab454f7ab5aeef1d41febf44-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48d8e46ab454f7ab5aeef1d41febf44-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48d8e46ab454f7ab5aeef1d41febf44-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":674,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48d8e46ab454f7ab5aeef1d41febf44-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48d8e46ab454f7ab5aeef1d41febf44-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48d8e46ab454f7ab5aeef1d41febf44-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2118,"real_height_1x":674,"real_height_2x":1191},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48d8e46ab454f7ab5aeef1d41febf44-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48d8e46ab454f7ab5aeef1d41febf44-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48d8e46ab454f7ab5aeef1d41febf44-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":466},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48d8e46ab454f7ab5aeef1d41febf44-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48d8e46ab454f7ab5aeef1d41febf44-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e48d8e46ab454f7ab5aeef1d41febf44-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":828,"real_height_1x":233,"real_height_2x":466}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"He wrote down my details and said that I had no chance of retaking my exams and that I could either sign a contract with the Ministry of Defense and go to operate drones, or I would be sent to serve in the army. With the contract, I would get paid and be honored as a “hero.” He tried to convince me that the contract would last just a year. But I know that they don’t let anyone go easily.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"A lot of guys at the university are really worried. There are some guys who spend most of their time at their computers, they don’t socialize much, and the first, the academic department manages to pressure them a lot, then those from room 212. None of my friends have signed anything, but in general, it's such a sensitive topic that no one talks about it.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"After the fuss in the news, they allowed resits again, but people are still summoned to that room.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Igor, The Far Eastern Federal University&nbsp;</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— There really is a quota requirement [of 32 people per month]. But, thank God, there is no pressure to sign these contracts.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"They don’t threaten us with the university expulsion, but they have shortened the period for the resits. Now the deadline is March 12, whereas it used to be a week or a week and a half later.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17704,"data":{"author":"This is how agitators summon students for war","header":"It’s okay that you might be tired of studying"},"category":"quotation-embed"},"type":"quotation-embed"},{"data":"The mood is silent. Many students don’t like it and everyone understands how absurd it is, but no one will say so directly, as you understand. I haven't seen any active “Special Military Operation” supporters at the university and I doubt they even exist.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Looking at the quota numbers, it becomes clear that even the rector’s office does not expect crowds of students to sign contracts.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Students generally understand that they could be sent to the front lines, and that they will not actually be allowed to terminate their contracts after a year.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<strong>Sveta, The Ural State Academy of Visual Arts and Architecture</strong>","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"— Our university exclusively has creative majors, and the overwhelming majority of students are women. One boy I know makes no secret of the fact that he will do whatever it takes to avoid being drafted into the army, let alone going to war.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Two years ago, a similar campaign was held, but it was conducted more discreetly: they would send out invitations to a “mandatory event” with no further details.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"My classmate, who fell for it the first time, said that they talked to them like this: “It’s okay that you might be tired of studying. Your first priority should be to stand on your own two feet. We are offering you the opportunity to earn money and get a change of scenery. You can return to your studies at any time, having served your duty to the Motherland.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"My classmate said that at the end, two or three guys would approach the recruiters with their questions. At the time, in 2024, no one was talking about the UAVs; they simply offered students to make money doing some “easy work.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This time, the senior students understood why they were being gathered, and some of them boycotted the meeting. In another group, some got interested. They described the prospects like this: “It’s just a year, and they give you three million rubles (approx. USD 40 thousand) right away, you can do whatever you want with it.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"With fewer options after getting a bachelor's degree, some people are really starting to think about taking this step. The lecturers say there won’t be any government-funded options to get a master’s degree. The number of programs is shrinking: our department has lost more than five master's programs. The ones that remain don't give you access to a job in the industry.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Those paying for their education who had hoped to get a state-funded master's degree are looking very lost. This includes my classmate, who was counting on getting a master's degree to keep his student deferment of military service.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"If we were to characterize all students at the university in general terms, over the past year it has become more apparent who disagrees with the statements and requests made to students by the dean's office. Anyone who takes even the slightest militaristic stance receives mostly negative reactions. No one downloads the MAX app (a state-controlled messenger to replace the more popular Telegram and WhatsApp which are to be banned — Ed.), and the administration has not yet taken on the task of “re-educating” us.","type":"p","className":""}]},{"id":9135,"header":"“The Central African Republic Supports Trump”","_path":"/en/stories/2026/02/14/wagner-africa-latam/","lead":"A new leak unveils the scale of Wagner Group’s ex-staffers’ work in Africa and Latin America as well as Russian intelligence connections","entry_image":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-1920x960px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-1920x960px_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-1920x960px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-1920x960px_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":960,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1920,"real_width_2x":2784,"real_height_1x":960,"real_height_2x":1392},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-1272x636px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-1272x636px_2x.webp","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-1272x636px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-1272x636px_2x.jpg","for_width":1272,"for_height":636,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1272,"real_width_2x":2544,"real_height_1x":636,"real_height_2x":1272},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-912x456px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-912x456px_2x.webp","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-912x456px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-912x456px_2x.jpg","for_width":912,"for_height":456,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":912,"real_width_2x":1824,"real_height_1x":456,"real_height_2x":912},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-600x400px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-600x400px_2x.webp","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":598,"real_width_2x":1197,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-600x400px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-600x400px_2x.jpg","for_width":600,"for_height":400,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":598,"real_width_2x":1197,"real_height_1x":400,"real_height_2x":800},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-360x360px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-360x360px_2x.webp","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-360x360px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-360x360px_2x.jpg","for_width":360,"for_height":360,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/e330949c36df40abaeef0762b89e012f-original.jpg","real_width_1x":360,"real_width_2x":720,"real_height_1x":360,"real_height_2x":720}],"entry_image_credit":"Monument to Russian mercenaries in Bangui, the capital of the Central African Republic. Photo: Sam Mednick / AP Photo","created_at_date":"2026-02-14","created_at_date_time":"2026-02-13T11:55:24.156Z","updated_at_date":null,"updated_at_date_time":null,"is_exclusive":false,"is_urgent":false,"spec_project":null,"has_visualization_without_fallback":false,"has_additional_facts":false,"category":"stories","locale":"en","authors_list":[{"id":9,"first_name":"Ирина","last_name":"Долинина","first_name_en":"Irina","last_name_en":"Dolinina","is_public":true,"_path":"irina-dolinina","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-896x504px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":896,"for_height":504,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-688x387px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":688,"for_height":387,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":387,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-416x234px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":416,"for_height":234,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_2x.webp","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-336x189px_2x.jpg","crop_zone":null,"for_width":336,"for_height":189,"original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/1ce8f6c2725d44ee82748f09aa73e8a1-original.jpg","real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"Журналистка «Важных историй»","lead_en":"IStories' investigative reporter","position":"Авторка","position_en":"Author","ordering":null}],"external_authors_list":[],"editors_list":[{"id":35,"first_name":"Мария","last_name":"Жолобова","first_name_en":"Maria","last_name_en":"Zholobova","is_public":true,"_path":"maria-zholobova","avatar":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-896x504px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-896x504px_2x.webp","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-896x504px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-896x504px_2x.png","for_width":896,"for_height":504,"real_width_1x":896,"real_width_2x":1792,"real_height_1x":504,"real_height_2x":1008},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-688x387px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-688x387px_2x.webp","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-688x387px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-688x387px_2x.png","for_width":688,"for_height":387,"real_width_1x":688,"real_width_2x":1376,"real_height_1x":388,"real_height_2x":774},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-416x234px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-416x234px_2x.webp","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-416x234px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-416x234px_2x.png","for_width":416,"for_height":234,"real_width_1x":416,"real_width_2x":832,"real_height_1x":234,"real_height_2x":468},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-336x189px_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-336x189px_2x.webp","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378},{"format":"png","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-336x189px_1x.png","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/a4d6e59fc3174f31b1ef5e5d65093192-336x189px_2x.png","for_width":336,"for_height":189,"real_width_1x":336,"real_width_2x":672,"real_height_1x":188,"real_height_2x":378}],"lead":"","lead_en":"","position":"Редакторка","position_en":null,"ordering":1}],"external_editors_list":[],"participants_list":[],"external_participants_list":[],"case":null,"topics":[],"body_preview":"In February 2024, a convoy of fifty motorcyclists held a rally in Bangui (the capital of the Central African Republic), which ended with a protest outside the US embassy. The protesters carried signs reading “The Central African Republic Supports Trump,” “We stand with Morocco,” “We stand with Algeria,” and “We stand with all of Africa.”\n\n“Our rally is meant to show support for the former US leader Donald Trump's candidacy. He didn’t meddle in African affairs during his presidency. Trump is the one who will lead the US forward. We also support the sovereignty of all African states,\" one of the participants said.\n\nThis event, which was widely covered in the media and on social networks, had been planned by an organization made up of ex-employees of the late Yevgeny Prigozhin, founder of the Wagner mercenary group. This information has been revealed in a more than 1,400 pages’ archive an anonymous source shared with The Continent, a pan-African media outlet. Among the documents there are lists of employees, invoices, airline tickets, and other evidence of the Russians’ propaganda and media activities abroad. \n\nThe archive mainly covers the operations of the Company (as its employees refer to it) in the timeframe of January to October 2024. The documents contain information on the affairs in more than twenty African countries and several Latin American countries. IStories, The Continent, Forbidden Stories and the Dossier Center outlets, as well as the All Eyes On Wagner and openDemocracy projects, have confirmed the authenticity of the documents and found out what Yevgeny Prigozhin’s former employees have been working on after his death. \n\nThe Company’s operations and their costs\nAccording to the documents obtained, the organization’s expenses for just 10 months amounted to almost 660 million rubles (roughly $8.6 million). E.g., in February 2024, the pro-Trump rally organization in the Central African Republic, as well as several other similar events, cost around $57,000 (or more than 5 million rubles). The events included a “US Activities in the CAR Investigation Committee Round Table Meeting” and an anti-American influence flash mob. Part of the funds was spent on paying various African media outlets for the rally coverage (for each article, the Company would pay between $220 and $800). According to the documents, securing the media coverage is seen as an important part of the company's work, amounting to more than $300,000 of costs per month.\nThe Company has promoted its narratives in the African media under the guise of African sovereignty support. The document titled “Confederation of Independence” states that in the work with African countries the Company would exploit discontent with the former colonial powers, primarily France and Great Britain. The ultimate goal of the work is articulated in the document as follows: “The Company is working on a plan to reshape Africa by creating a belt of regimes friendly to the Russian Federation in the states above the equator, from Guinea-Conakry to Somalia.” \n\nFor example, in Namibia, in an attempt to strengthen the position of the ruling party's candidate in the presidential election, the Company distributed a fake letter containing information on how the British government was allegedly financing the opposition. Later, in the internal reports, the Company employees bragged that the fake piece of news had been seen by 1.7 million people on social media and forced the British ambassador to Namibia to make a statement refuting the aforementioned claim on national television.\n\nAt least as of 2024, the Company paid particular attention to promoting the Russian-style “foreign agents” regulation. One report states that the political strategists recommended the authorities in Burkina Faso arrest the so-called “foreign agents” and shut down the French broadcasters. According to the documents, the Company has also widely promoted anti-Ukraine narratives, claiming, for example, that Ukraine “supported terrorism in Africa.” \nThe Company has also been involved in \"pushing out the ‘unfriendly’ countries’ corporations” from the natural resource industry in Africa. The documents claim that it was the Company's employees who developed a draft of a new Mining Code that was later adopted by the Malian government, which ultimately led to a major conflict with a Canadian mining company. Meanwhile Mali's cooperation with Russia in gold mining continued to grow stronger.\n\nBesides Africa, Prigozhin’s ex-associates got actively involved in Latin American affairs, according to the documents. For example, employees of the Company attempted to stabilize the regime of Bolivian President Luis Arce after a coup attempt in June 2024. The archive also contains evidence that some Argentinian media outlets had been paid for various publications.\n\nThe Company’s employees and the Russian foreign intelligence connection\nAccording to the documents and information obtained by Forbidden Stories from their sources, at least 60 Russians have worked for the Company in Africa and Latin America. Some of them were the late Prigozhin’s ex-staffers, e.g., Sergei Mashkevich and Sergei Klyukin. \n\nMashkevich ranked high in Prigozhin’s hierarchy and stayed the head of his African back office until 2022 at least. Sergei Klyukin worked for Prigozhin in Sudan, according to the Dossier Center: he was one of the leaders of the operational headquarters in Khartoum.\n\nAnother notable name mentioned in the documents is Maxim Shugaley, who had worked for Prigozhin as a political strategist. Among other things, he was involved in the election campaign of Mahamat Deby, the president of Chad. Shugaley promoted the narrative that Deby’s rival, Succes Masra, was allegedly supported by the US. \n\nShugaley is best known for his arrest in Libya in 2019 on charges of attempted interference in the country’s presidential election. He spent a year and a half under arrest and was released after Prigozhin intervened. In September 2024, Shugaley was detained in the Chadian capital of N'Djamena but was soon released. \n\nApart from the people working for the Company, the documents repeatedly mention the SVR. From the context, it is clear that this abbreviation refers to the Russian Foreign Intelligence Service. Forbidden Stories’ sources in European intelligence agencies have also confirmed to journalists that Russia's Foreign Intelligence Service “took the Company under its wing” at the end of 2023.\n\nIn the draft document on the “strategies for further work” in Africa, its authors repeatedly mention that the Company would be provided with the “assistance from the SVR”, for example, in “introducing the Russian influence agents” into the leadership of the UN mission in the Central African Republic, as well as in providing the information on France and the US plans on military and political presence in the Sahel. It is also mentioned that the SVR would ensure that “the Russian Ministry of Defense would not stand in the way of the Wagner PMC specialists” in the Central African Republic and Libya.\nEarlier, the All Eyes On Wagner project and Radio Liberty reported that Vitaly Perfilev, Prigozhin's ex-mercenary in the CAR who was in charge of collaborating with the local police, had been replaced by Denis Pavlov, an employee of the SVR. One of the sources for All Eyes On Wagner believes that another person connected with the SVR is Bagrat Shinkuba, who was seen at a Malian Ministry of Foreign Affairs' meeting with a Russian delegation on August 31, 2023, and introduced as the “chargé d'affaires of the Russian Federation in Mali.”\n\nNone of the individuals mentioned, nor the Russian Foreign Intelligence Service, have responded to inquiries from the journalists.\n\nEarlier, IStories, Forbidden Stories and our colleagues reported on how a former Wagner staffer exposed Russian propaganda activities in the Central African Republic.","blocks":[{"data":"In February 2024, a convoy of fifty motorcyclists held a rally in Bangui (the capital of the Central African Republic), which ended with a protest outside the US embassy. The protesters carried signs reading “The Central African Republic Supports Trump,” “We stand with Morocco,” “We stand with Algeria,” and “We stand with all of Africa.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"“Our rally is meant to show support for the former US leader Donald Trump's candidacy. He didn’t meddle in African affairs during his presidency. Trump is the one who will lead the US forward. We also support the sovereignty of all African states,\" one of the participants <a href=\"https://lepotentielcentrafricain.com/rca-une-caravane-a-bangui-pour-soutenir-lancien-president-donald-trump/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">said</a>.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"This event, which was widely covered in the media and on social networks, had been planned by an organization made up of ex-employees of the late Yevgeny Prigozhin, founder of the Wagner mercenary group. This information has been revealed in a more than 1,400 pages’ archive an anonymous source shared with The Continent, a pan-African media outlet. Among the documents there are lists of employees, invoices, airline tickets, and other evidence of the Russians’ propaganda and media activities abroad.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The archive mainly covers the operations of the Company (as its employees refer to it) in the timeframe of January to October 2024. The documents contain information on the affairs in more than twenty African countries and several Latin American countries. IStories, The Continent, Forbidden Stories and the Dossier Center outlets, as well as the All Eyes On Wagner and openDemocracy projects, have confirmed the authenticity of the documents and found out what Yevgeny Prigozhin’s former employees have been working on after his death.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"The Company’s operations and their costs","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"According to the documents obtained, the organization’s expenses for just 10 months amounted to almost 660 million rubles (roughly $8.6 million). E.g., in February 2024, the pro-Trump rally organization in the Central African Republic, as well as several other similar events, cost around $57,000 (or more than 5 million rubles). The events included a “US Activities in the CAR Investigation Committee Round Table Meeting” and an anti-American influence flash mob. Part of the funds was spent on paying various African media outlets for the rally coverage (for each article, the Company would pay between $220 and $800). According to the documents, securing the media coverage is seen as an important part of the company's work, amounting to more than $300,000 of costs per month.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17553,"data":{"images":[{"caption":"Some of the publications “the Company” paid for","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e363a6475b249f6bfe687e166901a5c-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e363a6475b249f6bfe687e166901a5c-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e363a6475b249f6bfe687e166901a5c-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2117,"real_height_1x":893,"real_height_2x":986},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e363a6475b249f6bfe687e166901a5c-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e363a6475b249f6bfe687e166901a5c-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e363a6475b249f6bfe687e166901a5c-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2117,"real_height_1x":893,"real_height_2x":986},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e363a6475b249f6bfe687e166901a5c-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e363a6475b249f6bfe687e166901a5c-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e363a6475b249f6bfe687e166901a5c-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2117,"real_height_1x":558,"real_height_2x":986},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e363a6475b249f6bfe687e166901a5c-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e363a6475b249f6bfe687e166901a5c-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e363a6475b249f6bfe687e166901a5c-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2117,"real_height_1x":558,"real_height_2x":986},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e363a6475b249f6bfe687e166901a5c-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e363a6475b249f6bfe687e166901a5c-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e363a6475b249f6bfe687e166901a5c-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":193,"real_height_2x":386},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e363a6475b249f6bfe687e166901a5c-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e363a6475b249f6bfe687e166901a5c-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/3e363a6475b249f6bfe687e166901a5c-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":193,"real_height_2x":386}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The Company has promoted its narratives in the African media under the guise of African sovereignty support. The document titled “Confederation of Independence” states that in the work with African countries the Company would exploit discontent with the former colonial powers, primarily France and Great Britain. The ultimate goal of the work is articulated in the document as follows: “The Company is working on a plan to reshape Africa by creating a belt of regimes friendly to the Russian Federation in the states above the equator, from Guinea-Conakry to Somalia.”&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"For example, in Namibia, in an attempt to strengthen the position of the ruling party's candidate in the presidential election, the Company distributed a fake letter containing information on how the British government was allegedly financing the opposition. Later, in the internal reports, the Company employees bragged that the fake piece of news had been seen by 1.7 million people on social media and forced the British ambassador to Namibia to make a statement refuting the aforementioned claim on national television.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"At least as of 2024, the Company paid particular attention to promoting the Russian-style “foreign agents” regulation. One report states that the political strategists recommended the authorities in Burkina Faso arrest the so-called “foreign agents” and shut down the French broadcasters. According to the documents, the Company has also widely promoted anti-Ukraine narratives, claiming, for example, that Ukraine “supported terrorism in Africa.” ","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17554,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"Photo: AFP","caption":"Niger’s military junta (which came to power with the help of the Wagner Group) supporter seen with flags of Mali, Burkina Faso, Algeria, Niger, and Russia, August 26, 2023","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/28b8577819574be7b0d0268586c1d363-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/28b8577819574be7b0d0268586c1d363-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/28b8577819574be7b0d0268586c1d363-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":3391,"real_height_1x":1303,"real_height_2x":2302},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/28b8577819574be7b0d0268586c1d363-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/28b8577819574be7b0d0268586c1d363-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/28b8577819574be7b0d0268586c1d363-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1919,"real_width_2x":3391,"real_height_1x":1303,"real_height_2x":2302},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/28b8577819574be7b0d0268586c1d363-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/28b8577819574be7b0d0268586c1d363-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/28b8577819574be7b0d0268586c1d363-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":814,"real_height_2x":1629},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/28b8577819574be7b0d0268586c1d363-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/28b8577819574be7b0d0268586c1d363-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/28b8577819574be7b0d0268586c1d363-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":2399,"real_height_1x":814,"real_height_2x":1629},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/28b8577819574be7b0d0268586c1d363-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/28b8577819574be7b0d0268586c1d363-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/28b8577819574be7b0d0268586c1d363-original.jpg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":281,"real_height_2x":563},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/28b8577819574be7b0d0268586c1d363-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/28b8577819574be7b0d0268586c1d363-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/28b8577819574be7b0d0268586c1d363-original.jpg","real_width_1x":413,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":281,"real_height_2x":563}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"The Company has also been involved in \"pushing out the ‘unfriendly’ countries’ corporations” from the natural resource industry in Africa. The documents claim that it was the Company's employees who developed a draft of a new Mining Code that was later adopted by the Malian government, which ultimately <a href=\"https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/7957377\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">led </a>to a major conflict with a Canadian mining company. Meanwhile Mali's cooperation with Russia in gold mining <a href=\"https://afrinz.ru/2025/05/mali-sozdast-zavod-po-pererabotke-zolota-v-partnerstve-s-rossiej/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">continued </a>to grow stronger.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Besides Africa, Prigozhin’s ex-associates got actively involved in Latin American affairs, according to the documents. For example, employees of the Company attempted to stabilize the regime of Bolivian President Luis Arce after a coup attempt in June 2024. The archive also contains evidence that some Argentinian media outlets had been paid for various publications.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17557,"data":{"images":[{"caption":"The Company’s internal documents obtained by journalists","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93630e6a760b4d62a631106e454971e2-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93630e6a760b4d62a631106e454971e2-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93630e6a760b4d62a631106e454971e2-original.png","real_width_1x":1239,"real_width_2x":1239,"real_height_1x":1752,"real_height_2x":1752},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93630e6a760b4d62a631106e454971e2-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93630e6a760b4d62a631106e454971e2-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93630e6a760b4d62a631106e454971e2-original.png","real_width_1x":1239,"real_width_2x":1239,"real_height_1x":1752,"real_height_2x":1752},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93630e6a760b4d62a631106e454971e2-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93630e6a760b4d62a631106e454971e2-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93630e6a760b4d62a631106e454971e2-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":1239,"real_height_1x":1696,"real_height_2x":1752},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93630e6a760b4d62a631106e454971e2-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93630e6a760b4d62a631106e454971e2-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93630e6a760b4d62a631106e454971e2-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":1239,"real_height_1x":1696,"real_height_2x":1752},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93630e6a760b4d62a631106e454971e2-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93630e6a760b4d62a631106e454971e2-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93630e6a760b4d62a631106e454971e2-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":586,"real_height_2x":1173},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93630e6a760b4d62a631106e454971e2-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93630e6a760b4d62a631106e454971e2-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/93630e6a760b4d62a631106e454971e2-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":586,"real_height_2x":1173}]},{"isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5392a241b29e4a1b9b89e255cc8e1a9b-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5392a241b29e4a1b9b89e255cc8e1a9b-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5392a241b29e4a1b9b89e255cc8e1a9b-original.png","real_width_1x":1239,"real_width_2x":1239,"real_height_1x":1752,"real_height_2x":1752},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5392a241b29e4a1b9b89e255cc8e1a9b-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5392a241b29e4a1b9b89e255cc8e1a9b-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5392a241b29e4a1b9b89e255cc8e1a9b-original.png","real_width_1x":1239,"real_width_2x":1239,"real_height_1x":1752,"real_height_2x":1752},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5392a241b29e4a1b9b89e255cc8e1a9b-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5392a241b29e4a1b9b89e255cc8e1a9b-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5392a241b29e4a1b9b89e255cc8e1a9b-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":1239,"real_height_1x":1696,"real_height_2x":1752},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5392a241b29e4a1b9b89e255cc8e1a9b-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5392a241b29e4a1b9b89e255cc8e1a9b-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5392a241b29e4a1b9b89e255cc8e1a9b-original.png","real_width_1x":1199,"real_width_2x":1239,"real_height_1x":1696,"real_height_2x":1752},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5392a241b29e4a1b9b89e255cc8e1a9b-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5392a241b29e4a1b9b89e255cc8e1a9b-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5392a241b29e4a1b9b89e255cc8e1a9b-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":586,"real_height_2x":1173},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5392a241b29e4a1b9b89e255cc8e1a9b-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5392a241b29e4a1b9b89e255cc8e1a9b-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/5392a241b29e4a1b9b89e255cc8e1a9b-original.png","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":586,"real_height_2x":1173}]}]},"category":"two-images-embed"},"type":"two-images-embed"},{"data":"The Company’s employees and the Russian foreign intelligence connection","type":"h2","className":""},{"data":"According to the documents and information obtained by Forbidden Stories from their sources, at least 60 Russians have worked for the Company in Africa and Latin America. Some of them were the late Prigozhin’s ex-staffers, e.g., Sergei Mashkevich and Sergei Klyukin.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Mashkevich <a href=\"https://www.istories.media/en/stories/2024/11/21/russian-propaganda-work-in-central-african-republic/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">ranked </a>high in Prigozhin’s hierarchy and stayed the head of his African back office until 2022 at least. Sergei Klyukin worked for Prigozhin in Sudan, <a href=\"https://dossier.center/radio-africa/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">according </a>to the Dossier Center: he was one of the leaders of the operational headquarters in Khartoum.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Another notable name mentioned in the documents is Maxim Shugaley, who had worked for Prigozhin as a political strategist. Among other things, he was involved in the election campaign of Mahamat Deby, the president of Chad. Shugaley promoted the narrative that Deby’s rival, Succes Masra, was allegedly supported by the US.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Shugaley is best known for his <a href=\"https://www.proekt.media/article/shugaley-zaderzhan-v-livii/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">arrest </a>in Libya in 2019 on charges of attempted interference in the country’s presidential election. He spent a year and a half under arrest and was released after Prigozhin intervened. In September 2024, Shugaley was <a href=\"https://www.currenttime.tv/a/vlasti-chada-osvobodili-maksima-shugaleya/33204780.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">detained </a>in the Chadian capital of N'Djamena but was soon released.&nbsp;","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"Apart from the people working for the Company, the documents repeatedly mention the SVR. From the context, it is clear that this abbreviation refers to the Russian Foreign Intelligence Service. Forbidden Stories’ sources in European intelligence agencies have also confirmed to journalists that Russia's Foreign Intelligence Service “took the Company under its wing” at the end of 2023.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"In the draft document on the “strategies for further work” in Africa, its authors repeatedly mention that the Company would be provided with the “assistance from the SVR”, for example, in “introducing the Russian influence agents” into the leadership of the UN mission in the Central African Republic, as well as in providing the information on France and the US plans on military and political presence in the Sahel. It is also mentioned that the SVR would ensure that “the Russian Ministry of Defense would not stand in the way of the Wagner PMC specialists” in the Central African Republic and Libya.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":{"id":17555,"data":{"images":[{"credit":"From the Company’s internal documents","caption":"Instances of the SVR’s role in the Company's activities being mentioned","isNarrow":false,"imagesList":[{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cf581b0d9e424ca4a8bdf009fde545a3-1920xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cf581b0d9e424ca4a8bdf009fde545a3-1920xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cf581b0d9e424ca4a8bdf009fde545a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2117,"real_height_1x":893,"real_height_2x":986},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cf581b0d9e424ca4a8bdf009fde545a3-1920xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cf581b0d9e424ca4a8bdf009fde545a3-1920xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1920,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cf581b0d9e424ca4a8bdf009fde545a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1918,"real_width_2x":2117,"real_height_1x":893,"real_height_2x":986},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cf581b0d9e424ca4a8bdf009fde545a3-1200xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cf581b0d9e424ca4a8bdf009fde545a3-1200xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cf581b0d9e424ca4a8bdf009fde545a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2117,"real_height_1x":558,"real_height_2x":986},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cf581b0d9e424ca4a8bdf009fde545a3-1200xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cf581b0d9e424ca4a8bdf009fde545a3-1200xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":1200,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cf581b0d9e424ca4a8bdf009fde545a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":1198,"real_width_2x":2117,"real_height_1x":558,"real_height_2x":986},{"format":"webp","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cf581b0d9e424ca4a8bdf009fde545a3-415xautopx_1x.webp","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cf581b0d9e424ca4a8bdf009fde545a3-415xautopx_2x.webp","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cf581b0d9e424ca4a8bdf009fde545a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":193,"real_height_2x":386},{"format":"jpg","url_1x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cf581b0d9e424ca4a8bdf009fde545a3-415xautopx_1x.jpg","url_2x":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cf581b0d9e424ca4a8bdf009fde545a3-415xautopx_2x.jpg","for_width":415,"for_height":"auto","original_url":"https://static.istories.media/uploaded/images/cf581b0d9e424ca4a8bdf009fde545a3-original.jpg","real_width_1x":414,"real_width_2x":829,"real_height_1x":193,"real_height_2x":386}]}]},"category":"image-embed"},"type":"image-embed"},{"data":"Earlier, the All Eyes On Wagner project and Radio Liberty <a href=\"https://www.svoboda.org/a/novichok-iz-bryusselya-kto-menyaet-lyudey-prigozhina-v-afrike/32719761.html\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">reported </a>that Vitaly Perfilev, Prigozhin's ex-mercenary in the CAR who was in charge of collaborating with the local police, had been replaced by Denis Pavlov, an employee of the SVR. One of the sources for All Eyes On Wagner believes that another person connected with the SVR is Bagrat Shinkuba, who was seen at a Malian Ministry of Foreign Affairs' meeting with a Russian delegation on August 31, 2023, and <a href=\"https://x.com/malimaeci/status/1697306366879186967?s=46&amp;t=cZCdKRLLFJfmbAN6SyYp9Q\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\">introduced </a>as the “chargé d'affaires of the Russian Federation in Mali.”","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"None of the individuals mentioned, nor the Russian Foreign Intelligence Service, have responded to inquiries from the journalists.","type":"p","className":""},{"data":"<em>Earlier, IStories, Forbidden Stories and our colleagues </em><a href=\"https://www.istories.media/en/stories/2024/11/21/russian-propaganda-work-in-central-african-republic/\" data-type=\"usual\" target=\"_blank\"><em>reported </em></a><em>on how a former Wagner staffer exposed Russian propaganda activities in the Central African Republic.</em>","type":"p","className":""}]}],"more":true,"limit":30,"category":"stories","locale":"en"}},"staticQueryHashes":["764694655"],"slicesMap":{}}