As a Pokémon trainer, choosing the right starter can significantly impact your playthrough experience. Each starter has its unique strengths, weaknesses, and typing, and this tier list aims to guide you through the best choices, regardless of your playstyle.

Before diving into the tier list, remember that Pokemon's stats and abilities are just half the story. Your personal playstyle, the game's story progression, and team composition also play crucial roles in determining the best starter for you. Now, let's rank the Gen 1 to Gen 8 starters, from S to D tier, with engaging details for each tier.

S-Tier: The game-changers
S-tier starters have exceptional base stats, diverse move pools, and versatile typing. They can handle a variety of roles, from physical attackers to special sweepers, and offer immense challenge satisfaction.

Cyndaquil/Roller Form >> Typhlosion/Giga Tyranitar
Cyndaquil lines benefit from having a monstrous final evolution (Giga Tyranitar), powerful special attacks, and great defensive stats. They can serve as potent physical attackers or special sweepers, making them excellent choices for competitive battles.

Additionally, they form one of the game's strongest megas, providing a significant damage boost and gainingdn Steel/Stone typing for improved defenses. Their versatility and power earn them the top spot in our S-tier.
Totodile/Quagsire >> Feraligatr/Blissey
Totodile lines are no strangers to competitiveness, offering a tanky final evolution (Blissey) with outstanding HP and defensive stats. Their access to Reliable moves like Giga Drain and Steel typing presents unique mixed tanking opportunities, making them exceptional threats in standard battles.

Moreover, they can evolve into powerful physical attackers (Feraligatr) with high Attack and Speed stats, further increasing their adaptability. Totodile's versatility and solid stats ensure its place in the S-tier.
A-Tier: The all-rounders
A-tier starters are strong overall, boasting balanced base stats, good typing, and decent move pools. They may lack some of the versatility and power of S-tier starters but still perform admirably in various battle scenarios.

Treecko/Sceptile >> Sceptile/Shiftry
Treecko lines introduce a unique Dragon/Grass typing in their final forms (Shiftry), providing good special and physical bulk, as well as respectable speed. Sceptile's ability Overgrow also boosts its Booster Green attacks, making it a formidable special sweeper.









Furthermore, they can utilize their immense speed to outspeed opponents and devastate with their powerful Dragon/Steel moves. Their balanced attack and speed stats place them in the A-tier.
Turtwig/Garchomp >> Garchomp/Conkeldurr
Turtwig lines offer the robust physical sand-type attacker (Garchomp) with high Attack and Speed stats. They make excellent tank-killers, able to wear down the opponent's defenses and deal massive damage. Additionally, their access to Ground moves allows them to counter Electric-type Pokémon effectively.
While their final special evolution (Conkeldurr) lacks the power of Garchomp, it offers a sturdy alternative with access to powerful physical attacks. Turtwig lines' adaptability and powerful attacks secure their position in the A-tier.
B-Tier: The specialists
B-tier starters are formidable in specific roles or matchups but fall short in others. They may lack the versatility of higher tiers but still prove valuable in the right team compositions.
Piplup/Empoleon >> Empoleon/Magnezone
Piplup lines benefit from having powerful special attacks in their final forms (Empoleon or Magnezone) and a Steel typing that resists several types. They make excellent special sweepers, capable of dealing significant damage to susceptible opponents.
However, their defensive stats leave much to be desired, making them fragile in more balanced groups. Their reliance on specific matchups restricts their usage, placing them in the B-tier.
Chimchar/Infernape >> Infernape/Emboar
Chimchar lines offer two fighting-type final evolutions, Infernape and Emboar, with significant Attack and Speed stats. They possess decent physical bulk and access to powerful Fire moves, making them formidable tank-killers.
Unfortunately, their reliance on physical attacks makes them less versatile than other starters, and their defensive stats can be lackluster. Their limitations, alongside their reliance on specific matchups, land Chimchar in the B-tier.
D-Tier: The underperformers
D-tier starters struggle to maintain their relevance due to subpar stats, poor typing, or move pools that don't keep up with the competition. While they can still find success in specific circumstances, they seldom provide a significant advantage in most battle scenarios.
Squirtle/Blastoise >> Blastoise/Gyarados
Squirtle lines present a Water/Fighting final evolution (Gyarados) with decent Attack and Special Attack stats. They also possess the powerful Mega Salvo move, making them formidable in certain matchups.
However, their defensive stats are lackluster, and their typing leaves them susceptible to common rock, electric, and grass-type Pokemon. Squirtle's inability to adapt to various roles and their susceptibility to type disadvantages place them in the D-tier.
In the vast world of Pokémon, no single starter is universally perfect. Each has its unique strengths and weaknesses, and understanding their quirks is essential for creating a well-rounded and competitive team. Whether you're aiming for the Elite Four, the Battle Tower, or the Nintendo World Championships, this tier list provides valuable insights into the intricate mechanics of Pokémon battling.