Starter shingles, also known as course shingles, have long been a contentious topic in the roofing industry. Despite their name, they're not necessarily the starter of every roof project, sparking the question: do you really need to use starter shingles? Let's delve into this roofing conundrum, exploring its historical significance, its role in modern roofing, and whether it's a must-have or more of a 'nice-to-have'.

Starter shingles were introduced in the 1950s to tackle the issue of wind uplift, where strong winds could lift up the edge shingles and compromise the roof's integrity. The design of starter shingles, with their tab at one end and a flat base, allowed them to interlock with the main shingles and provide a robust first course. However, the necessity of starter shingles has been a topic of debate ever since.

Understanding the Role of Starter Shingles in TraditionalRoofing
The primary purpose of starter shingles is to create a secure first layer of protection against wind uplift. They are designed to be imperfect, with one end cut off to create an interlocking tab, allowing the first row of shingles to cling securely to the roof deck.

This primary function is backed by the historical practice and the approvals of major roofing manufacturers. For instance, GAF, one of the largest roofing manufacturers in North America, recommends using their CertainTeed starter shingles to ensure the roof's edge is securely sealed and protected.
Providing a Solid Foundation for the Roof

Starter shingles add an extra layer of security to the roof's edge, particularly for roofs situated in areas prone to high winds. By preventing the edge shingles from being blown off, they help ensure the longevity of the roof, reducing the likelihood of costly repairs or premature replacement.
Moreover, starter shingles help maintain the aesthetic appeal of the roof. Without them, the first row of shingles would be cut to fit, resulting in a less uniform, less attractive appearance. The consistent tab of starter shingles provides a neat and uniform first row, enhancing the overall look of the roof.
Creating a Better Seal Against Weather Elements

Starter shingles are designed to create a tight seal against the roof deck. This seal acts as a barrier against wind-driven rain, snow, and ice, preventing them from infiltrating the roof structure. By keeping these elements out, the starter shingles help prolong the life of the roof and protect the underlying structure from water damage.
The National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA) also recommends using starter shingles, emphasizing their role in providing a weather-tight seal at the roof's edge. While they may seem like a small, insignificant detail, their impact on the roof's overall performance and longevity is profound.
The Modern Debate: Are Starter Shingles Still Necessary?

With the advancement of roofing technology and materials, some roofers argue that starter shingles are no longer essential. The modern shingles, they posit, are sturdy enough to withstand wind uplift, and various sealing techniques can achieve a tight roof edge without starter shingles.
Moreover, some manufacturers have innovated their shingles to incorporate the functions of starter shingles. For instance, CertainTeed's "Starter" shingles are designed to use full shingles at the roof's edge, which can be applied as if they were starter shingles, potentially eliminating the need for separate starter shingles.








The Argument for Eliminating Starter Shingles
Some roofers argue that using full-width shingles at the roof's edge can create a stronger, more uniform seal than starter shingles. This approach also reduces waste, as there are no leftover starter shingles. Moreover, it can save time and labor, as the need to install specialized starter shingles is eliminated.
However, this approach is not without its detractors. Some roofing experts warn that using full-width shingles at the edge can compromise the roof's ability to withstand wind uplift. Although this is a minority opinion, it highlights the continued debate surrounding the use of starter shingles.
The Argument for Continued Use of Starter Shingles
Proponents of starter shingles argue that they remain the best way to create a secure, weather-tight seal at the roof's edge. They maintain that the interlocking tab design, along with the reduced height of starter shingles, provides superior protection against wind uplift and weather infiltration.
Furthermore, many roofing warranties still require the use of starter shingles. Failing to use them could void the warranty, leading to costly repairs or replacements if something goes wrong with the roof. Therefore, roofers may continue to use starter shingles to ensure they are covered by manufacturer warranties.
In the end, the necessity of starter shingles seems to depend on various factors, including the specific roof design, the quality of materials used, the locality's weather patterns, and the roofing contractor's preference and experience. While some modern roofing methods may render starter shingles unnecessary, the traditional practice of using them remains a tried-and-true approach to creating a secure, weather-resistant roof.
Ultimately, the decision to use starter shingles should be guided by professional advice and careful consideration of the specific roofing situation. After all, a well-informed, well-planned roofing project is a roofing project well done.