Embarking on a journey through the world of Pokémon in Pokémon SoulSilver? One of the first and indeed exciting decisions you'll make involves choosing one of the three starter Pokémon. But what if you don't want to leave any of these little creatures behind? Here's how you can catch 'em all, without worrying about that initial choice.

It's a common misconception that you're stuck with the starter you first picked. But fear not! It's entirely possible to collect all three starters - Cyndaquil, Totodile, and Chikorita. Let's dive into how you can do this.

Obtaining Your First Starter
First things first, you need to pick your starter Pokémon, as the game's initial sequence doesn't allow you to bypass this step. You'll find Professor Elm in Professor Oak's laboratory, who will ask you to choose between the three starters. Make your choice and push forward.

Once you've picked your starter, it's time to explore Johto. You'll need to participate in a couple of battles to progress the story, so get to know your starter's moveset while you're at it.
Earning the GS Ball

In route 4, you'll encounter a girl who will randomly give you a GS sphere (Ball) sometimes. This peculiar item is your key to obtaining one of the other starter Pokémon. You'll need to Talk to her at least seven times for the GS Ball to appear in your items. Be patient, it's a matter of luck!
What distinguishes the GS Ball from other Pokémon balls? When you use it, you can sometimes catch Pokémon that were previously thought impossible to catch. In your case, it stands the chance to catch Cyndaquil, Totodile, or Chikorita, depending on the starter you chose.
Catching Your Second Starter

Once you've obtained the GS Ball, head to the Burned Tower in Ecruteak City. Here, you can find a wild starter Pokémon that you can attempt to catch. If you catch this wild Pokémon, Professor Elm will give you a Level 15 version of the starter Pokémon you missed out on initially.
To optimize your chances, change your starter's moveset to ones that can counter the available starter at the Burned Tower. For instance, if you picked Totodile, Chikorita is your target, so having a move that resists or is super-effective against Chikorita will be beneficial.
Getting Your Final Starter

With two starters secured, you're just one away from a complete set. Here's how you can get the final member of Team Creation.
Once you've challenged Gym Leader Normal Falkner, you'll receive the Pokégear. Your next task is to complete the Pokégear Phone Staff's phonebook. After this, Professor Oak will inform you that he has a package for you at the Goldenrod City's Pokémon Center.







Earning Oak's Letter
Head to the Goldenrod Pokémon Center and collect Professor Oak's letter. This letter will contain a Level 15 version of the final starter Pokémon you've missed, ready to become part of your team.
That's it, folks! From here on, you'll have all three starter Pokémon in your possession without having to trade or trade back. Rock, paper, scissors may determine your initial choice, but it won't dictate the final outcome of your hand-picked team.