Johto's Dark Side: Why It's Considered the Worst Region

Teresa Aug 02, 2026

Delving into the world of Pokémon, the Johto region, introduced in Generation II, offers a unique gaming experience but also presents certain challenges that can make it less enjoyable for some players. While it's by no means a terrible region, it has its fair share of issues that might deter newcomers or critical players. Let's explore the Johto region's worst aspects, focusing on its design, gameplay, and Pokédex completion.

F Mythical Town Names, City District Names, Japanese Town Name Generator, Territory Names, Utopian Community Names, Fantasy City District Names, Mystical Town Names, Fictional State Names, Kanto City Names
F Mythical Town Names, City District Names, Japanese Town Name Generator, Territory Names, Utopian Community Names, Fantasy City District Names, Mystical Town Names, Fictional State Names, Kanto City Names

First and foremost, Johto's design often feels cramped and disorienting compared to other regions like Kanto or Route 101 in Sinnoh. The region is a maze of small, interconnected routes and towns, making it difficult to navigate and easy to get lost, especially for new players. This labyrinthine layout can lead to frustration and wasted time, particularly when trying to find a specific location or Pokémon.

a map of the johto region with many different locations and things to see
a map of the johto region with many different locations and things to see

Navigation and Layout

Johto's routes are plagued by zigzagging paths and elongated stretches, making it challenging to predict where one might end up or find what they're looking for. This layout is in stark contrast to the more streamlined routes found in other regions, which tend to follow a more linear or grid-like pattern.

Johto Aesthetic, Pokemon Region Poster, Pokemon Johto, Pokemon Hoenn Poster, Pokemon Kanto Region Map, Pokemon Region Posters, Johto Pokemon, Sinnoh Region Poster, Johto Poster
Johto Aesthetic, Pokemon Region Poster, Pokemon Johto, Pokemon Hoenn Poster, Pokemon Kanto Region Map, Pokemon Region Posters, Johto Pokemon, Sinnoh Region Poster, Johto Poster

Moreover, Johto's dungeons and caverns are often criticized for their disappointing design. While some may enjoy the challenge, many players find them repetitive, monotonous, and lacking in the creative flair found in, for instance, Sinnoh's Diglett's Cave or the Ice_path in Unova.

Confusing Interior Design

Johto Map
Johto Map

Some indoor locations, like the Goldenrod Department Store or the Ruins of Alph, suffer from confusing layouts. While the department store might seem intuitive at first, the interconnected rooms and Paternal Bureau make it easy to get lost. Additionally, the Ruins of Alph, while visually impressive, can be frustrating due to its winding, non-Euclidean pathways.

In the case of the Ruins of Alph, the lack of a clear path or map makes maneuvering through the maze-like interior a chore. This, coupled with the pitch-black interior and the need to use Tile Rooms to progress, can lead to significant gameplay irritation.

Uninspired Routes and Locations

Pokémon
Pokémon

Some of Johto's routes and locations simply fail to capture the imagination or offer much in the way of visually interesting sights. Route 42, for example, is a long, windswept stretch of road with little more than cut grass and wild sprites to disturb the monotony. In contrast, Route 23 in Kanto offered a diverse range of Pokémon and a more distinct, varied landscape.

The outlook from certain locations, such as the Burned Tower or the outside of the Ruins of Alph, is lackluster, contributing to a sense of underwhelming design. While these aspects might not negatively impact gameplay or lore, they can detract from the overall Johto experience.

Pokédex Completion

Pokemon Season 3: The Johto Journeys
Pokemon Season 3: The Johto Journeys

Johto's Pokédex poses several challenges for players looking to complete their Pokédex. While the region introduces 100 new Pokémon that can only be found in Johto (plus 51 reuses from Kanto), filling out the Pokédex can be an uphill struggle due to poor locations, uneven species distribution, and hidden Pokémon.

Johto's Pokémon distribution leaves something to be desired. Certain species only appear in specific, often hard-to-reach areas, making them more difficult to obtain. Furthermore, the reintroduction of Kanto Pokémon that are already widely available in the first region can feel redundant, cluttering the Pokédex and making it more challenging to find the Johto and new Johto exclusive species.

Pokémon: The 5 Best Things About Johto (& 5 That Needed Improvement)
Pokémon: The 5 Best Things About Johto (& 5 That Needed Improvement)
10 Best Animated Pokémon Johto Journeys Episodes, Ranked
10 Best Animated Pokémon Johto Journeys Episodes, Ranked
Johto Map
Johto Map
Pokéarth - Johto - National Park - Generation II
Pokéarth - Johto - National Park - Generation II
three cartoon characters standing next to each other
three cartoon characters standing next to each other
an image of a video game scene in the dark
an image of a video game scene in the dark
Pokémon: Every Johto Starter Evolution, Ranked
Pokémon: Every Johto Starter Evolution, Ranked
a tall tower sitting next to a lush green forest under a blue sky with clouds
a tall tower sitting next to a lush green forest under a blue sky with clouds
an illustrated map of a city with mountains and lakes
an illustrated map of a city with mountains and lakes

Presence of Kanto Reuses

Having half of the Pokédex filled with reuses from the Kanto region can feel like a step backward, especially when many of these Pokémon can be caught earlier in the game. This results in a bloated Pokédex, making it more difficult to locate and obtain the new Johto-exclusive species and ಹೆಚ್ಚाय/forms.

The auxiliary Pokédex in HeartGold and SoulSilver, introduced to keep track of these Kanto reuses, is a poor solution to this problem, as it still requires players to catch and register these Pokémon to access the National Pokédex in the post-game.

Hidden Pokémon and Unpredictable Spawning

Johto also suffers from an abundance of hidden or rare-pawn Pokémon that can be hard to track down. Critical Hit and Held Item Pokémon are some examples, hidden in very specific dens or caves, or requiring the use of the Poké Radar for a chance to encounter them.

Moreover, the semi-random nature of Pokémon spawning can make it difficult to predict which species will appear where and when. This can lead to time-wasting and frustration when trying to fill out the Pokédex, particularly if players are looking for specific Pokémon that spawn infrequently or in obscure locations.

Gameplay Mechanics

Finally, Johto's gameplay mechanics can also pose challenges to both new and experienced players. The reliance on HMs (Hidden Machines) and breedable Pokémon, the lack of Flying-type advantages, and the two-route system can all contribute to a more challenging, if not always enjoyable, experience.

Johto's HMs are numerous and mandatory, requiring players to teach and use moves like Cut, Strength, and Fly frequently throughout the game. This can be time-consuming and frustrating, particularly when breeding Pokémon to remove these HMs before using them in battle.

Dependencies on Hidden Machines and Breeding

The abundance of HMs makes it necessary to breed certain Pokémon to remove these moves, as many of them cannot be taught or removed via TMs. This added step in gameplay can be a deterrent for new players and an annoyance for experienced ones, given the time and resources required for breeding.

Johto also lacks a significant advantage for Flying-types, a staple of the franchise. In most regions, Flying-types can traverse land quickly and easily, but Johto has no such advantage. This can make it more difficult for players to plan their route and progress through the region efficiently.

The Two-Route Conundrum

Finally, the two-route system in Johto allows the player to choose one of two starting routes, Route 29 or Route 30. While this might seem like a minor point, the choice made early on can significantly impact the player's experience, as certain Pokémon are exclusive to each route. This can lead to missed opportunities and a need to either replay the game or trade with another player to access these exclusive species.

While this system does encourage trade, it can also create unnecessary challenges and frustration for those looking to fill out their Pokédex or breed specific Pokémon. Furthermore, the choice made early on can also affect the available movepools of certain Pokémon, further compounding the challenge presented by Johto's gameplay mechanics.

The Johto region, while offering a unique and engaging experience, is not without its flaws. Its cramped and confusing design, the challenges posed by Pokédex completion, and the sometimes-painful gameplay mechanics can make it an unappealing choice for some players. However, with a bit of preparation and understanding, these challenges can be overcome, and Johto's unique charm can shine through. As with any region, the best way to overcome its worst aspects is to dive in headfirst, learn its secrets, and conquer its challenges. So grab your Pokédex and a sturdy pair of walking shoes – the road to the Elite Four awaits!