Why The Most Hated Water Starters

Teresa Aug 02, 2026

When discussing the water starters in the Pokémon franchise, one name often rises to the top of discussions: Magikarp. Known for its seemingly useless nature, it's often categorized as the "most hated" water starter due to its overwhelming lack of utility in battles. But why does this innocuous fish bear the brunt of so much disdain?

an animal character is shown in the screen above it's name, wavelo
an animal character is shown in the screen above it's name, wavelo

Magikarp's reputation is somewhat justified when you consider its early-stage王stay usefulness in battles. It has extremely low base stats, poor moveset, and a pathetic 20 HP, making it a sitting duck in battles. Furthermore, it learns new moves at a painfully slow rate, adding to the frustration of training it. These factors make Magikarp a polarizing figure among Pokémon trainers, often sparking heated debates about its worth.

an image of a very cute looking cartoon character with big eyes and large ears,
an image of a very cute looking cartoon character with big eyes and large ears,

The Evolution Conundrum

One of the primary reasons Magikarp is the most hated water starter is its evolutionary line. Most Pokémon have straightforward evolutions, often improving or changing their typing to create a useful addition to a team. However, Magikarp's evolution into Gyarados is somewhat deceptive. You see, Magikarp doesn't evolve until it has accumulated 400 experience points, which can take an excessive amount of time and patience. This delay in evolution further amplifies the negativity towards Magikarp.

some cartoon characters are lined up in a line
some cartoon characters are lined up in a line

Moreover, Gyarados itself doesn't immediately restore faith in Magikarp's lineage. While it's a powerful Pokémon with impressive stats, its unique Water/Flying typing and its high Special Attack makes it a Liability in water-based teams, which usually favor Physical attackers. Its moveset, while powerful, isn't diverse enough to make it a match for every opponent.

Magikarp's Role in Competitive Play

the pokemon characters are all different sizes and colors
the pokemon characters are all different sizes and colors

In competitive battling, Magikarp's role is limited due to its lack of battle-ready stats. Its only feasible role is to absorb Water-type moves, thanks to its Water/Flying typing. This strategy, however, is not recommended due to the risk of it fainting before it can even land an attack, or evolving into Gyarados mid-battle, which can disrupt team strategies.

Additionally, its ability to increase its power level when its HP is low (defined by the ability Swift Swim) is counteracted by its low HP stat, making it a risky play. Its other ability, Oblivious, doesn't provide any significant advantage in competitive play.

Magikarp in the Meta

Wartortle!! (Starter Squad)
Wartortle!! (Starter Squad)

Magikarp's controversial status has carried over into the meta of Pokémon games, with many trainers intentionally trying to avoid using it. Its poor battle record and the effort required to train it has fostered a culture of avoidance in competitive play, making it the most hated water starter. Even in solo play, many players opt for other water types for their teams, leading to Magikarp's further isolation within the meta.

In contrast, other water starters like Squirtle, Blastoise, and Empoleon have enjoyed non-stop popularity due to their usability, diverse move pools, and powerful evolutions. This further cements Magikarp's status as the 'outcast' of the water starters, reinforcing community sentiments about its usefulness.

The Power of the Underated

an image of some cartoon characters in different colors and sizes, with the same character on each
an image of some cartoon characters in different colors and sizes, with the same character on each

Despite Magikarp's overwhelmingly negative press, it's worth noting that it's not entirely useless. Its ability to dodge critical hits with its liquidated form can save it from otherwise fatal attacks, and its potential to evolve into Gyarados at the perfect moment has led to some surprising upsets in battles. These 'glitchy' moments, while rare, have given rise to a small but dedicated fanbase that sees value in Magikarp.

Magikarp has also inspired various cultural memes and references, often highlighting its 'uselessness' in a comic way. These memes have brought light to its unique plight in the Pokémon franchise, sparking debates and offering a level of comic relief in an otherwise serious competitive scene.

Starter Pokémon's 'Feminine' Evolution Is Bothering Some Fans - Kotaku
Starter Pokémon's 'Feminine' Evolution Is Bothering Some Fans - Kotaku
Pokemon-variations
Pokemon-variations
the pokemon characters are all different colors and sizes
the pokemon characters are all different colors and sizes
some type of artwork that looks like pokemons
some type of artwork that looks like pokemons
Best Non-Toxic Water Filters
Best Non-Toxic Water Filters
a collage of water bottles with the words, when the water tastes weird >
a collage of water bottles with the words, when the water tastes weird >
an image of a cartoon character floating in the water with blue and purple colors on it
an image of a cartoon character floating in the water with blue and purple colors on it
an image of a cartoon character in front of a computer screen with pink and blue colors
an image of a cartoon character in front of a computer screen with pink and blue colors
a blue and yellow cartoon character running in the water
a blue and yellow cartoon character running in the water

The Future of Magikarp

While Magikarp's status as the most hated water starter doesn't seem likely to change anytime soon, there's always room for Game Freak to potentially rebalance the fish Pokémon in future games. A move rebalance, better stats, or a unique ability could breathe new life into Magikarp, transforming it from a joke into a formidable competitor. For now, however, Magikarp wears its 'worst starter' crown with a certain amount of pride, or at least, blissful ignorance.

In the end, Magikarp serves as a testament to the power of perseverance in Pokémon. Despite its flaws and limitations, it keeps swimming, eventually evolving into one of the most powerful dragons in the Pokémon universe. So, perhaps it's not the most hated water starter after all - maybe it's just the most misunderstood.