Starter Shingles vs Roll: A Comprehensive Comparison

Teresa Aug 02, 2026

When it comes to roofing materials, two popular choices often cross homeowners' minds: starter shingles and rolled roofing. Both have their unique advantages, and selecting the right one depends on your specific needs, budget, and the roofing project at hand. Let's delve into the details of each, helping you make an informed decision.

Rolled Roofing vs Roof Shingles vs Tiles - Pros and Cons (with PHOTOS)
Rolled Roofing vs Roof Shingles vs Tiles - Pros and Cons (with PHOTOS)

Roofing material selection influences aesthetics, functionality, and duration. It's not just about appearance; it's also about protection and lifespan. So, let's dive into the key aspects of starter shingles vs. rolled roofing to help you choose the best fit.

the differences between shingles and metal roofing materials infographical graphic by truehandroofing com
the differences between shingles and metal roofing materials infographical graphic by truehandroofing com

Starter Shingles

Starter shingles are designed for your roof's initial course, providing a crucial first line of defense against the elements. They are often cut with a specifically designed notching tool to create a tight seal and facilitate installation.

How to Use 3-Tab Shingles for Starter Strip | Shingles | Roofing | Roof
How to Use 3-Tab Shingles for Starter Strip | Shingles | Roofing | Roof

Starter shingles are typically strip or architectural shingles, offering a wide range of colors and styles to match your overall roofing plan. They are made from asphalt or fiberglass, with fiberglass ones being more durable and resistant to damage.

Advantages of Starter Shingles

How to Install Starter Strip | Shingle Roof Install Guide
How to Install Starter Strip | Shingle Roof Install Guide

1. Enhanced Protection: Starter shingles offer superior protection against wind, rain, and ice dams. They are designed to adhere to each other prominently, creating a strong, sealed barrier.

2. Improved Aesthetics: Alongside their protective function, starter shingles lend a neat, uniform look to your roof. They help achieve a cohesive, professional appearance overall.

Disadvantages of Starter Shingles

Comparing Rolled Roofing, Shingles, and Tiles
Comparing Rolled Roofing, Shingles, and Tiles

1. Labor-Intensive: Installing starter shingles requires more time and effort than rolling out a continuous sheet. This can translate to higher labor costs.

2. More Expensive: While prices vary greatly based on materials and location, starter shingles can be pricier than rolled roofing due to their need for specialized installation.

Rolled Roofing

Decorative Shingles
Decorative Shingles

Rolled roofing, also known as rolled roofing membrane or Built-Up Roofing (BUR), is composed of multiple plies of reinforced bitumen sheets. It's commonly found in low-slope and flat roofs, providing a durable, cost-effective covering.

Rolled roofing comes in rolls, usually 36" or 24" wide and ranging from 50 to 200 square feet per roll. It's typically installed in a continuous sheet, reducing installation time and labor costs.

Installing Asphalt Shingles over an Existing Shingle Roof - Fine Homebuilding
Installing Asphalt Shingles over an Existing Shingle Roof - Fine Homebuilding
Four Ways to Shingle a Valley - Fine Homebuilding
Four Ways to Shingle a Valley - Fine Homebuilding
Architectural Shingles vs. 3-Tab Shingles – Pros and Cons
Architectural Shingles vs. 3-Tab Shingles – Pros and Cons
How Big is a Square of Shingles? (3 Diagrams Included)
How Big is a Square of Shingles? (3 Diagrams Included)
The Purpose of Starter Shingles - Their Use & Function - IKO
The Purpose of Starter Shingles - Their Use & Function - IKO
Prep a Wood-Shingle Roof for Reroofing - Fine Homebuilding
Prep a Wood-Shingle Roof for Reroofing - Fine Homebuilding
Guide to Shingle-Installation Patterns
Guide to Shingle-Installation Patterns
Roofing Materials List: The Main Parts of a Roof
Roofing Materials List: The Main Parts of a Roof
the different types of lines and shapes that can be used to make an ornament
the different types of lines and shapes that can be used to make an ornament

Advantages of Rolled Roofing

1. Inexpensive: Rolled roofing is usually less expensive than starter shingles due to its simplified installation process and material costs.

2. Easy Installation: As rolled roofing comes in continuous sheets, it's faster to install than starter shingles, reducing labor costs. It adheres directly to the roof deck, creating a seamless surface.

Disadvantages of Rolled Roofing

1. Limited Aesthetics: While functional, rolled roofing has a less appealing look compared to shingles. It's typically black, although some manufacturers offer other colors and patterns.

2. Limited Suitability: Rolled roofing is best suited for low-slope or flat roofs. For steeper pitches, starter shingles may be a more suitable choice.

In the end, selecting between starter shingles and rolled roofing comes down to your specific roofing needs, budget, and the aesthetic you're aiming for. For optimal results, always consult with a professional roofer to ensure you're making the best decision for your home.