Super Mario: Top Ratings & Reviews

Teresa Aug 02, 2026

Super Mario, Nintendo's iconic plumber, has graced our screens since 1985, evolving through countless titles and platforms. From humble beginnings on the Nintendo Entertainment System to the latest adventures on the Nintendo Switch, each game offers a unique experience, warranting its own rating. However, comparing these games isn't as straightforward as it seems, given their diverse genres - platformers, RPGs, kart racers, and more.

Super Mario Rating Scale
Super Mario Rating Scale

The most universally accepted rating system is the Metascore, which aggregates reviews from critics and users. It's a reliable indicator of a game's quality, but it doesn't capture the individual joy and nostalgia each Mario game evokes. So, let's delve into some of the most highly-rated Super Mario games, exploring what makes them stand out.

mario's face is shown in many different ways
mario's face is shown in many different ways

Super Mario Bros. (1985)

The original Super Mario Bros. introduced us to simple, yet engaging platforming. It's more than just a game; it's a staple in every gamer's diet. With its iconic level design, tight controls, and challenging boss fights, it's no surprise it garnered a Metascore of 90.

So how tall is Super Mario really?
So how tall is Super Mario really?

Despite its age, the game maintains a dedicated fanbase due to its timeless gameplay mechanics and nostalgic value. It paved the way for the entire series, making it a must-play even today.

Originality and Impact

the menu for mario's gameboy, which is being played on nintendo wii
the menu for mario's gameboy, which is being played on nintendo wii

Tallying an aggregate score of 92 on GameSpot, Super Mario Bros. shines with its innovative side-scrolling platforming, introducing power-ups like the Super Mushroom and Fire Flower for the first time.

Its impact is undeniable. It popularized the side-scrolling genre, inspired countless clones, and solidified Mario's place as a gaming icon.

Cult Following

#SUPER #MARIO #DELUX #REVIEW AND #GAMEPLAY #ANALYSE - KingInfoGamer Gaming fun #1
#SUPER #MARIO #DELUX #REVIEW AND #GAMEPLAY #ANALYSE - KingInfoGamer Gaming fun #1

Super Mario Bros.' influence persists today, spawning remakes, mods, and dedicated communities. Even the most minuscule details - like the placement of a question mark block - have been thoroughly analyzed and debated.

Its endurance is a testament to the game's quality and Nintendo's commitment to preserving their classic catalog.

Super Mario World (1990)

a close up of a nintendo mario kart character wearing a red hat with googly eyes
a close up of a nintendo mario kart character wearing a red hat with googly eyes

Super Mario World refined and improved upon its predecessor, offering a more seamless, interconnected world map and new power-ups like Cape Feather and Yoshi.

With a Metascore of 94, it's often hailed as one of the greatest platformers ever made. Its innovative design,올-the-issue

an image of a black and red object with teeth on it's face, in the shape of a barrel
an image of a black and red object with teeth on it's face, in the shape of a barrel
Mario bros character chart
Mario bros character chart
an image of mario's character expressions for the game super mario and his friends
an image of mario's character expressions for the game super mario and his friends
an angry looking cartoon character with its mouth open and teeth wide open, in black and white
an angry looking cartoon character with its mouth open and teeth wide open, in black and white
P I O L A
P I O L A
the word search page for super mario is shown in black and white with red letters
the word search page for super mario is shown in black and white with red letters
several different types of nintendo characters are shown in this image, including mario and luigi
several different types of nintendo characters are shown in this image, including mario and luigi
the super mario bros characters are shown in this chart, which shows how each character is different
the super mario bros characters are shown in this chart, which shows how each character is different
Mushrooming Laughs: 135+ Super Mario Jokes to Power Up Your Giggles
Mushrooming Laughs: 135+ Super Mario Jokes to Power Up Your Giggles

World Map and Interconnectivity

Super Mario World's World Map is a marvel of design. It allows players to choose their own path, encouraging exploration and experimentation, something rarely seen in platformers of that time.

It gave players a sense of agency and freedom, breaking away from the rigid level-to-level progression of its predecessor.

Yoshi and Power-Ups

Yoshi, Mario's beloved dinosaur companion, was introduced in this game. Besides being adorable, Yoshis serve practical purposes, like :)