Super Mario RPG: Remake Review Rating

Teresa Aug 02, 2026

In the vibrant world of gaming, few franchises have left as indelible a mark as Super Mario. With over 30 years of history and counting, Nintendo's iconic plumber continues to captivate across diverse platforms and genres. One standout entry, universally lauded, is 'Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars' - a gem that seamlessly merges the classic side-scrolling gameplay with robust RPG elements. As rumors abound of a potential remake, we delve into the ratings and factors that could propel this classic into the modern era.

Super Mario RPG review: Faithful remake of a daring adventure - Dexerto
Super Mario RPG review: Faithful remake of a daring adventure - Dexerto

Launched on the SNES in 1996, the original Super Mario RPG (SMRPG) was a quantum leap for the franchise. Developers Square and Nintendo blended turn-based battles, a richly narrative-driven story, and the familiar Mario universe, resulting in a game that scored high on critics' radars. A remake, thus, could potentially score just as high, bucking trends for nostalgia-driven remasters.

Super Mario RPG Hands-On Preview – A Simple Start To A Grand Adventure
Super Mario RPG Hands-On Preview – A Simple Start To A Grand Adventure

Exploring the Possibilities of a Super Mario RPG Remake

The gaming landscape has shifted dramatically since the '90s. To discern how a SMRPG remake could fare today, we examine what aspects could skyrocket its ratings.

Super Mario RPG: How to get Work Pants - Dexerto
Super Mario RPG: How to get Work Pants - Dexerto

**Graphical Overhaul and Modern Controls vs. Conservation of Original Aesthetics**

Gone but Not Forgotten - The Charm of 16-bit Graphics

Mario (Super Mario Bros. 3 NES-Style) - Mario Customs - Custom / Edited
Mario (Super Mario Bros. 3 NES-Style) - Mario Customs - Custom / Edited

Retro fashion is ripe, and the '90s aesthetic remains enduringly popular. Retaining SMRPG's original 16-bit charm, with refined sprite work and improved color palettes, could appeal to both nostalgic gamers and newcomers alike. Yet, striking a balance is key - too much 'retro' might alienate modern players, while a complete graphical overhaul could lose the soul of the original.

**-controls for the Modern Gamer - Evolution, Not Revolution**

Adapting to Evolving Controls & Mechanics

an image of mario party game characters
an image of mario party game characters

A successful Super Mario RPG remake would need to adapt to modern controllers, but simultaneously retain the intuitive control scheme that made the original so engaging. More complex combat mechanics or streamlined exploration might draw criticism, so Nintendo would need to innovate subtly, maintaining the essence of what made SMRPG great.

The Remake Factor: What Stakes are There?

Remakes and remasters have become commonplace, with varying levels of success. However, Mario titles typically transcend trends, crafting fresh experiences that respect their legacy. This leads us to ponder: what ratings could a Super Mario RPG remake achieve?

an image of mario's face and the caption that says, i really like those custom mario 64 eye textures that are used in machines
an image of mario's face and the caption that says, i really like those custom mario 64 eye textures that are used in machines

**Potential Ratings & Reviews**

Arguably, the success of 'Super Mario 3D All-Stars' provides insight. Its nostalgia-driven approach scored solidly, though not exceptionally, due to an estimation of 'lazy' remastering. However, a SMRPG remake could aim higher by offering a more substantial recreation, earning ratings in line with other high-quality reimaginings like 'Ocarina of Time 3D' or 'The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening' (2019).

the evolution of mario's head and his many other things in this info sheet
the evolution of mario's head and his many other things in this info sheet
Marcus (@Dewndeym) on X
Marcus (@Dewndeym) on X
Map Tileset - Super Mario Bros. 3 - NES
Map Tileset - Super Mario Bros. 3 - NES
Super Mario Adventures!
Super Mario Adventures!
Best skills to upgrade first for each character in Mario + Rabbids Sparks of Hope
Best skills to upgrade first for each character in Mario + Rabbids Sparks of Hope
the evolution of mario's super mario bros info sheet from the nintendo game history
the evolution of mario's super mario bros info sheet from the nintendo game history
Super Mario RPG: 9 Biggest Changes In The Remake From The Original
Super Mario RPG: 9 Biggest Changes In The Remake From The Original
#SuperMario35: A linha do tempo da franquia Super Mario
#SuperMario35: A linha do tempo da franquia Super Mario
10 Obscure Super Mario Facts in Celebration of MAR10 Day
10 Obscure Super Mario Facts in Celebration of MAR10 Day

User Inflation and Nostalgia Bias

Nintendo titles often exploit nostalgia, with ratings reflecting favorable bias. A SMRPG remake might therefore see inflated ratings from the dedicated Super Mario fanbase. But, critical reviews could benchmark the game's actual merit and potential longevity, serving as a more authentic gauge of its success.

As the gaming industry continues to grow and evolve, so too does our appreciation for the classics that laid its foundation. In a potential Super Mario RPG remake, Nintendo holds the stage to garnered high ratings by respecting its legacy while evolving for a modern audience. Here's to hoping their enchanting blend of nostalgia and innovation could lead to yet another masterpiece in the annals of gaming history.