Tony Hawk Underground 1 or 2: Which is Better?

Teresa Aug 02, 2026

Since their release, Tony Hawk's Underground 1 and 2 have been two of the most popular games in the legendary skating series. Both games introduced new elements, improved graphics, and a storyline for the first time in the franchise, but fans still debate: which is better, Underground 1 or 2?

two men standing next to each other with the words tony hawk's underground 2
two men standing next to each other with the words tony hawk's underground 2

The choice between these two games often comes down to personal preference, but certain aspects of each can help skaters make an informed decision.

tony hawk undeground 2
tony hawk undeground 2

Tony Hawk's Underground 1: Innovation and Classic Skating

Underground 1 (THUG 1) introduced a unique story mode, allowing players to create and customize their own skater, and interact with other characters in a fictional California setting. This broke away from the previous games' career mode and added a fresh, engaging experience.

Tony Hawk’s Underground (2003)
Tony Hawk’s Underground (2003)

THUG 1 also introduced the 'Create-A-Park' feature, which expanded the builder tools from earlier titles, offering skaters more freedom to design and build their own skate parks. This feature was a significant advancement and added incredible replayability.

Improved Graphics and Control

a person with a skateboard in his hand and a clown nose on their head
a person with a skateboard in his hand and a clown nose on their head

The game boasted improved graphics and controls compared to previous titles, with smoother ragdoll physics and a better overall gaming experience. The soundtrack, featuring tunes from artists like The White Stripes and Queens of the Stone Age, was also widely praised.

On the other hand, THUG 1 received some criticism for its linear progression and lack of pop culture references compared to its successor.

Skater Customization

Tony hawk underground 2
Tony hawk underground 2

THUG 1's skater customization was extensive, allowing players to customize their skater's appearance, choose starting skills, and personalize their truck and wheel setups. This level of personalization was unparalleled at the time.

While the customization options in THUG 1 were impressive, some players found the clothing options limiting, especially compared to those in Underground 2.

Tony Hawk's Underground 2:Expanded Story, More Customization

Tony Hawk's Underground 2 Remix
Tony Hawk's Underground 2 Remix

Underground 2 (THUG 2) built upon the success of the first installment, improving on its predecessor's formula with a more robust storyline, ambitious environments, and even more customization options.

THUG 2 further expanded the Create-A-Skater and Create-A-Park features, adding more customization options, clothing brands, and overall park-building flexibility. The story mode also evolved, featuring branching paths and multiple endings.

It hurts to say it, but I don't think we're getting a Tony Hawk's Underground remake
It hurts to say it, but I don't think we're getting a Tony Hawk's Underground remake
a man riding a skateboard up the side of a ramp in a video game
a man riding a skateboard up the side of a ramp in a video game
“Tony Hawk’s Underground 2” (2004) Ad
“Tony Hawk’s Underground 2” (2004) Ad
THPS2 Tony Hawk
THPS2 Tony Hawk
a man sitting on a couch holding a game controller
a man sitting on a couch holding a game controller
a man standing in front of a screen with an arrow pointing to the left side
a man standing in front of a screen with an arrow pointing to the left side
Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 Hidden Secret Has Been Uncovered After Over 20 Years
Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 Hidden Secret Has Been Uncovered After Over 20 Years
a man holding a game controller in front of a tv with the words busted on it
a man holding a game controller in front of a tv with the words busted on it

New Gameplay Elements and Pop Culture References

THUG 2 introduced new gameplay elements like 'Manual Globes' and 'Wall Plants,' offering fresh challenges and techniques to master. The game also featured a slew of pop culture references, celebrity skaters, and classic levels from older Tony Hawk games, appealing to both new and old fans.

However, some players criticized THUG 2 for its steeper learning curve, which might have alienated newcomers to the series.

The Downside of Success: Performance Issues

Despite the excitement surrounding its release, THUG 2 faced technological challenges. Some players reported performance issues, particularly on older consoles, which could affect the overall gaming experience.

Other players found the difficulty level in THUG 2 to be unfairly high, with certain objectives being overly challenging and frustrating.

In the end, the choice between THUG 1 and THUG 2 comes down to personal preference. THUG 1 offers a more straightforward, customization-focused experience, while THUG 2 provides a deeper story, improved controls, and more extensive customization options, albeit with some performance issues. Both are exceptional additions to the Tony Hawk series, and skaters might consider experiencing both to truly appreciate the evolution of the franchise.