When it comes to the world of Pokémon, the appeal of the first Pokémon a player starts with in a game is often unique and subjective. In Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl, the choice of starter Pokémon can significantly influence your gaming experience. Among the three initial choices—Piplup, Turtwig, and Chimchar—the general consensus among players often deems one as the worst. But why is that?

Engaging with the starter Pokémon discussion in Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl brings a mix of nostalgia, strategy, and preference into the debate. Each starter has its own strengths, weaknesses, and unique gameplay experience, which makes the "worst" choice a matter of perspective. Let's dive into the reasons why some players might consider one starter inferior.

The First Starter: Piplup
Piplup, the penguin-like starter mainly bolstering Ice and Water typing, is often a fan favorite. Its design is cute and appealing, but for many, Empoleon—its final evolution—doesn't quite resonate in terms of stats and type effectiveness. This might make it seem like an unfavorable choice.

However, gravely discounting Piplup as the worst starter might be a hasty judgment. Empoleon, despite its demise after the fourth generation, is still a formidable Water-Ice Pokémon, with a balanced stat line and an excellent typing synergy. Moreover, the decreased use of popular Fire and Grass types in later gyms and Elite Four battles opens up opportunities for Piplup to shine.
Piplup's Gameplay Pros

Piplup's Water typing grants it STAB (Same Type Attack Bonus) for many moves throughout its evolution line. Its Ice typing also provides a powerful STAB with moves like Blizzard and Ice Punch. Additionally, Piplup and its evolutions are immune to Steel and Poison types, which are abundant in the fourth generation's game.
Moreover, Piplup has decent Speed and good Special Attack stats, allowing it to spam damaging moves while avoiding many opponents' hits. Its Ice typing also gives it numerous advantages over opposing Grass types throughout the game, including the notable Elite Four member, Gardenia.
Piplup's GameplayCons

Despite its advantages, Piplup still suffers from some significant drawbacks. Empoleon's relatively low HP can make it fragile in battle, and its surfact typing weakness to Electric, Grass, and Rock types can be exploited.
The availability of other efficient Water and Ice types in the generation may also make Piplup seem less appealing. Pokémon like Gyarados, Feraligatr, and Mamoswine are powerful alternatives that can supplant Piplup's niche, making it feel less unique.
The Second Starter: Turtwig

Turtwig, the diminutive tortoise with a powerful offense, evolves into the formidable Garchomp, a Dragon and Ground type powerhouse. However, compared to the other starters, Turtwig's initial stages are significantly underwhelming, causing some players to avoid it.
However, those who stick with Turtwig are rewarded handsomely with Garchomp's devastating power and versatility. Alongside an underwhelming early-game, Turtwig's vulnerabilities to Electric types can deter many players from choosing it. Yet, this potential "worst starter" might just unmask its indomitable power in the late-game.









Turtwig's Gameplay Pros
Turtwig and its evolutions boast impressive Attack and Defense stats, making them excellent physical sweepers. Garchomp's Dragon and Ground typing provides STAB moves, striking a balance between offense and resilience. Moreover, Garchomp's high Speed allows it to outspeed many opponents and deliver devastating hits.
Garchomp's vast movepool and access to powerful moves like Earthquake, Outrage, and Swords Dance makes it an indispensable asset in battles. Its Ground typing Immunity to Electric attacks also mitigates one of its few weaknesses, ensuring its longevity in competitive battles.
Turtwig's Gameplay Cons
Turtwig's initial stages—Turtwig and Grotle—have underwhelming stats and paltry move pools. They struggle to keep up with other starters and initial choices throughout the game. Additionally, Garchomp's ground typing makes it weak to Ice, Water, and Grass attacks, potentially limiting its availability in competitive battles.
The late-game reward of Garchomp might not be compelling enough for some players to persist through Turtwig's early-game frailties. This might make Turtwig seem like the worst starter option for impatient or casual players.
The Third Starter: Chimchar
Chimchar, the little monkey with a trailing flame, evolves into Infernape, a Fire-Fighting Pokémon with an impressive stat line and move diversity. However, for many players, the perceived "middle of the road" weaknesses and somewhat unimpressive typing make Chimchar an unflattering choice.
Moreover, Chimchar's Fire typing has fallen out of grace in competitive battles following the fourth generation, further cementing an unpromising outlook. Nevertheless, a closer look might reveal that Chimchar isn't as lackluster as it seems.
Chimchar's Gameplay Pros
Infernape's balanced offensive and defensive typing allows it to be a formidable sweeper against many late-game opponents. Its Fire typing offers immunity to Grass and Ice types, which are common in the fourth generation. Additionally, Infernape's high Special Attack and Speed make it an excellent special sweeper, outpacing many opponents.
Its typing also grants it synergy with a diverse range of moves, including STAB moves for both Fire and Fighting types. Moreover, Infernape's high Attack stat allows it to use moves like Close Combat and Flare Blitz, reinforcing its position as a powerful sweeper.
Chimchar's Gameplay Cons
Chimchar's Fire typing grants it a formidable STAB move, but it also makes it weak to Water, Ground, and Rock types. Although Chimchar's final evolutions gain immunity to Poison attacks, the early-game typing leaves it highly susceptible to moves that counter Fire types.
The middle-of-the-road typing of Infernape might seem underwhelming for some players. Infernape's low Special Defense can also make it fragile against powerful special attacks, which might deter some players from choosing Chimchar as their starter.
Ultimately, determining the worst starter Pokémon in Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl is a matter of subjective preference and patience. While Piplup, Turtwig, and Chimchar all have their weaknesses and strengths, their appeal lies in how players can exploit and mitigate those aspects. In the end, the "worst starter" is the one you choose, as each path leads to a unique and engaging experience in the world of Pokémon.