Worst Johto Starter: Why You Should Avoid These Pokemon

Teresa Aug 02, 2026

The debate surrounding the "worst Johto starter" often sparks lively discussions among Pokémon fans, with each trainer having their unique perspective. While each of the three Johto starters – Chikorita, Cyndaquil, and Totodile – brings its own strengths and charm to the table, some aspects invite critical evaluation.

Pokémon: Every Johto Starter Evolution, Ranked
Pokémon: Every Johto Starter Evolution, Ranked

When comparing these starters, one cannot ignore the competitive viability, type coverage, and initial stages of evolution. This article will delve into these aspects to determine which Johto starter might be considered the least competitive or advantageous, based on various factors.

Johto Starters
Johto Starters

Type Coverage and Initial Stages

The type coverage of a Pokémon determines its effectiveness in battle, as certain types have advantages over others. The Johto starters offer a mix of Grass, Fire, and Water types, providing diverse options for players.

Starter Pokémon
Starter Pokémon

However, assessing the "worst" Johto starter based on type coverage alone isn't straightforward, as each type has its merits. Grass-type moves are powerful against Water and Ground types but weak against Fire and Flying types. Conversely, Fire-type moves excel against Ice, Grass, and Bug types but lack effectiveness against Fire, Rock, and Dragon types. Water-type moves are strong against Fire and Ground types but weak against Electric and Grass types.

Chikorita: Green Urges

several different types of cartoon characters in various poses
several different types of cartoon characters in various poses

Chikorita, the Johto region's Grass-type starter, evolves into Meganium, a beautiful Grass/Poison-type Pokémon. Its typing initially seems weak due to its vulnerability to Fire and Flying-type moves. However, Grass-type moves are potent against Water and Ground-types, which are prevalent in the Johto region.

Moreover, Chikorita's early moveset includes Tackle, Defense Curl, and Growl. Nevertheless, it lacks a powerful STAB (same-type attack bonus) move until it evolves into Bayleef, learning Leech Seed at level 14. While Chikorita's type coverage might seem lackluster at first glance, it has its redemption in the mid-game.

Cyndaquil: Sparking Fire

many different types of pokemon characters
many different types of pokemon characters

Cyndaquil, the Fire-type starter from Johto, evolves into Typhlosion via its Fire-type line. This starter initially has an impressive moveset, including Tackle, Leer, and Fire Fang. With Fire Fang, Cyndaquil has a STAB move right from level 26, making it a formidable battler in the early to mid-game.

However, once Cyndaquil evolves into its final form, its type coverage remains unchanged, leaving it vulnerable to Fire and Ice-type moves. Additionally, while Typhlosion has a higher special attack than Meganium, its defensive stats are considerably lower, making it less bulky. This trade-off in stats might place Cyndaquil as a less competitive choice compared to the other two starters.

Totodile: TM Catches All

an image of different types of monsters
an image of different types of monsters

Totodile, the Water-type starter, evolves into Feraligatr. Initially, Totodile's moveset includes scratch, lightscreen, and Leer. While it can learn powerful Water-type moves like Hydro Pump and Surf, it lacks a STAB move until it evolves into Croconaw at level 16, learning Water Gun.

Totodile'schief advantage is that it can learn a diverse range of moves through TMs, such as Ice Fang (Ice-type), Crunch (Dark-type), and Earthquake (Ground-type). This flexibility makes Totodile an adaptable choice for various battle scenarios, especially in competitive battling, negating the need to consider it the "worst" Johto starter.

Friends3 Charizard Feraligatr Sceptile, Pokemon Gen 8 Starters, Charizard Sceptile Greninja, Sceptile Blaziken And Swampert Mega Evolution, Pokemon Sceptile Blaziken Swampert Wallpaper, Sceptile Omega Ruby Alpha Sapphire, Sceptile Blaziken And Sceptile, Mega Blaziken Mega Sceptile, Mega Sceptile Mega Swampert Mega Sceptile
Friends3 Charizard Feraligatr Sceptile, Pokemon Gen 8 Starters, Charizard Sceptile Greninja, Sceptile Blaziken And Swampert Mega Evolution, Pokemon Sceptile Blaziken Swampert Wallpaper, Sceptile Omega Ruby Alpha Sapphire, Sceptile Blaziken And Sceptile, Mega Blaziken Mega Sceptile, Mega Sceptile Mega Swampert Mega Sceptile
STARTER SQUAD
STARTER SQUAD
several different types of pokemon characters
several different types of pokemon characters
an old cartoon character sheet with different types of pokemons and their names on it
an old cartoon character sheet with different types of pokemons and their names on it
an advertisement for the nintendo game pokemon, featuring pikachu and other characters in front of
an advertisement for the nintendo game pokemon, featuring pikachu and other characters in front of
several different types of pokemon characters
several different types of pokemon characters
an image of some type of art work that looks like it is made out of paper
an image of some type of art work that looks like it is made out of paper
Johto Pokémon
Johto Pokémon
a close up of a cartoon character with a green leaf on his head
a close up of a cartoon character with a green leaf on his head

Evolutional Prowess and Stat Analysis

The evolutionary lines of the Johto starters also play a role in determining their competitiveness. While each evolutionary line has its merits, one aspect to consider is the evolution process's difficulty or efficiency.

Chikorita: Climb in Grace

Chikorita evolves into Bayleef at level 16 and Meganium at level 32. While the evolutionary requirements aren't particularly challenging, the slow growth in stats might place Chikorita at a disadvantage in early battles. Furthermore, Chikorita's stats focus more on defense, which might not be useful in competitive battles favoring high offense.

Despite this, Meganium's Grass/Poison typing offers unique resistances and immunities, making it a valuable addition to the team in some battles. Additionally, Meganium's high defenses and healing capabilities make it a decent support Pokémon.

Cyndaquil: Fire Burns Bright

Cyndaquil evolves into Quilava at level 14 and Typhlosion at level 36. Cyndaquil's evolution process is reasonably quick, allowing it to reach its final form relatively early in the game. Additionally, Typhlosion's typing remains unchanged throughout its evolution, ensuring a consistent typing for strategic planning.

Typhlosion boasts high offensive stats, particularly in its Special Attack and Speed. However, its defensive stats are subpar, making it a fragile Pokémon in battle. Hence, while Cyndaquil's quick evolution allows it to reach its most powerful form early, its low defensive stats might hinder its competitiveness in the late game.

Totodile: Raw Power

Totodile evolves into Croconaw at level 16 and Feraligatr at level 30. Totodile's evolutionary process is efficient, and its final form, Feraligatr, boasts impressive stats, particularly in Attack and Defense. Feraligatr's diverse movepool and balanced stat distribution make it a formidable competitive battler.

Moreover, Feraligatr's Water typing provides resistances to Electric, Fire, Ice, Steel, and other Water-type moves, along with immunities to Poison-type moves. Its high Attack stat and access to powerful moves like Earthquake and Ice Fang make it a formidable sweeper, further cementing Totodile's position as a strong contender among the Johto starters.

In the digital realm of Pokémon, each starter offers unique advantages and disadvantages, catering to different playstyles and strategies. While Cyndaquil's type coverage and low defensive stats might make it seem like the "worst" Johto starter, Totodile's adaptability, Feraligatr's competitive viability, and Chikorita's diversity in battling situations ensure that no single Pokémon can be labeled as universally the worst. Ultimately, the best starter depends on one's preferences and strategies in the vibrant and dynamic world of Pokémon battling."