Why Was The Boy Taken On Lost?

Emma Aug 14, 2026

The enigmatic season finale of "Lost" in 2007, titled "Through the Looking Glass," left fans worldwide baffled and craving answers. One of the most compelling questions raised in this episode was: why did they take the boy, a young version of Richard Alpert? This article aims to delve into possible reasons, backed by series lore and fan theories, to satiate your curiosity.

a man with his face painted orange and the caption at first i was like but then i was all
a man with his face painted orange and the caption at first i was like but then i was all

Before we dive into why they took the boy, let's briefly recap the scene. In the season 2 flashbacks, an Other, known later as Richard, whispers to young Benjamin Linus at the rocky statue. He takes the boy inland, away from his mother, Emily, and the Others' newly arrived submarine.

four different pictures with the same caption for each character in the movie, i'm vampire you're what?
four different pictures with the same caption for each character in the movie, i'm vampire you're what?

Understanding Richard Alpert's Immunity

Richard's apparent immortality and immunity to aging have been a central mystery in "Lost." As revealed in season 5, Richard's blood possesses healing properties, slowing or stopping his aging process. This immunity might explain why they took the boy.

Fr tho 😭
Fr tho 😭

In the episode "Across the Sea," we learn that the island grants immortality through its protective bubble, called the "Light." Richard's immunity might be connected to his exposure to this Light, which could be the reason he took young Benjamin.

Potential Exposure to the Light

a man in white t - shirt sitting down with his hand on the back of his shoulder
a man in white t - shirt sitting down with his hand on the back of his shoulder

One theory suggests that Richard took Benjamin to expose him to the Light. Since Benjamin's father, Charles Widmore, had been on the island before, it's plausible that their family line carries a unique genetic trait that makes them susceptible to the island's influence. Thus, Richard took Benjamin to ensure his line continued to inherit this trait.

This theory is supported by the fact that all other inhabitants of the island, besides Jacob's candidates, eventually left, either by choice or because they were killed. However, Richard remained, indicating his special connection to the island.

Protection from Potential Dangers

the lost boys characters are shown in this black and white image with stars on it
the lost boys characters are shown in this black and white image with stars on it

Another possibility is that Richard took Benjamin to protect him from the dangers lurking on the island, particularly the Smoke Monster. As we learn in season 6, the Monster can only communicate with those already on the island. By taking Benjamin inland, Richard might have been shielding him from premature contact with the Monster.

Additionally, Emily had been working with the DHARMA Initiative, a group with motivations that ultimately conflicted with the Others' interests. Richard may have taken Benjamin to safeguard him from this potential conflict and ensure he was raised outside of DHARMA's influence.

Benjamin's Destiny and the Island's Plans

dream trio :D
dream trio :D

The island often influences events to ensure a specific outcome, and its "protectiveness" is evident throughout the series. Benjamin's eventual role as one of the candidates to take on the duties of protectoryzer highlights the significance of Richard taking him as a child.

In this regard, Richard's actions can be seen as a part of the larger design of events, orchestrated by the island, to ensure that the right candidates were in place to ultimately fulfill their destinies.

108 Lost Quotes
108 Lost Quotes
father of the year 🏆🏆
father of the year 🏆🏆
the lost boys on instagram
the lost boys on instagram
many different pictures with the same caption for each person to see on their phone
many different pictures with the same caption for each person to see on their phone
the lost boys character aesthetics are in black and white, with stars above them
the lost boys character aesthetics are in black and white, with stars above them
two pictures of the same person hugging each other and one has his arm around another man's shoulder
two pictures of the same person hugging each other and one has his arm around another man's shoulder
the lost boys movie poster with two people hanging from a bridge over water and trees
the lost boys movie poster with two people hanging from a bridge over water and trees
His scary contactless blue eyes have captivated me (this was his plan)
His scary contactless blue eyes have captivated me (this was his plan)
a young boy standing in front of a mirror with his mouth open and looking at the camera
a young boy standing in front of a mirror with his mouth open and looking at the camera

Ensuring Benjamin's Role as a Candidate

One theory posits that Richard took Benjamin to ensure he grew up to become a candidate – someone who could potentially take on the role of protector of the island. By taking him away from DHARMA and his mother, Richard guaranteed that Benjamin was raised by the Others and groomed for his eventual role.

This theory is supported by the fact that all of Jacob's candidates grew up off the island, only to be drawn back to it, further implying the island's influence and design in their lives.

Benjamin's Connection to the Heart of the Island

Benjamin's eventual discovery of the Heart of the Island, the true source of its power, suggests a deep, inherent connection between him and the island. Richard might have taken him to nurture this bond and ensure Benjamin could one day protect the Heart, as he ultimately did by turning theuces back on, activating its power.

In conclusion, while "Lost" leaves much up to interpretation, the reasons behind Richard taking the boy likely tie into his immunity, the protection of Benjamin, and the ultimate fulfillment of his destiny as a candidate. These theories, woven into the rich tapestry of the series, continue to captivate fans and fuel discussions about the enigmatic events on the island.