The Wirecutter has become the gold standard for product recommendations, and when it comes to one of the most important purchases you will ever make, their toilet reviews are unparalleled. Choosing the right porcelain throne involves balancing factors like comfort, efficiency, and durability, and this guide breaks down the best options currently available.
How The Wirecutter Tests Toilets
Before diving into specific models, it is essential to understand the rigorous methodology behind The Wirecutter’s recommendations. Their team of experts spends weeks evaluating each product, and toilets are put through a battery of real-world tests that go beyond simple aesthetics. They meticulously measure water efficiency, flushing performance, and ease of cleaning to ensure the recommendations hold up over years of use.
The evaluation process focuses on two primary categories: elongated and round toilets. They assess the bowl shape for comfort and the trapway design for potential clogs. By simulating various usage scenarios, they identify which models deliver consistent performance without sacrificing sustainability or reliability, ensuring that every recommendation earns its place in a bathroom.

Best Overall Toilet
TOTO Drake II
The TOTO Drake II consistently claims the top spot as the best overall toilet, and for good reason. This model combines TOTO’s signature CeFiONtect glazed bowl with a powerful flush system that prevents clogs while using minimal water. The elongated bowl offers superior comfort, making it the ideal choice for most households seeking a reliable, no-frills option.
Its popularity stems from its near-perfect balance of price, performance, and durability. The Drake II is widely available, making it a practical choice for both new construction and bathroom remodels. The smooth glaze ensures that waste does not stick, simplifying maintenance and keeping the bowl fresh with less effort.
Best For Comfort
Kohler Devonshire
While the TOTO Drake II is a great all-rounder, the Kohler Devonshire stands out for those who prioritize a luxurious experience. This toilet features an elongated bowl with a higher seating position, reducing strain on the legs and back. The elongated design provides significantly more comfort than standard round models, making it a top pick for bathrooms where accessibility and ease are paramount.

The Devonshind’s pressure-assisted flushing system ensures a robust clean, handling waste without issue. Its classic styling also adds a touch of elegance to any space, proving that comfort does not have to come at the expense of aesthetics. It is a premium choice for homeowners looking to upgrade their daily routine.
Best Budget Option
Home Depot’s Hampton Bay
Not everyone wants to invest heavily in a toilet, and The Wirecutter identifies the Home Depot’s Hampton Bay line as the best budget option. These models provide the essential function of a toilet without unnecessary frills, making them accessible to renters and homeowners alike. Despite the lower price point, they do not compromise on the fundamentals of a good flush.
Installation is straightforward, and the build quality is solid enough to last for many years. For those looking to save money on a necessary fixture, the Hampton Bay series offers incredible value. It represents the sensible choice for updating a bathroom on a tight budget.

Specialty Recommendations
Beyond the standard models, specific needs might require specialized solutions. For instance, smaller bathrooms benefit from compact toilets that fit neatly into tight spaces without feeling cramped. Conversely, tankless toilets offer a sleek, modern look and eliminate the risk of unsightly tank leaks, although they are a significant investment.
For environmentally conscious consumers, dual-flush models provide the ability to conserve water with every use. These options allow users to choose between a liquid waste flush and a solid waste flush, significantly reducing water consumption over the lifetime of the fixture. Selecting the right specialty toilet ensures your bathroom is as efficient as it is comfortable.
| Category | Model | Key Feature |
|---|---|---|
| Best Overall | TOTO Drake II | Reliable Performance |
| Best for Comfort | Kohler Devonshire | Elongated Bowl |
| Best Budget | Hampton Bay | Value Oriented |





















