What is Manhattan Style Steak?

Ever heard of the iconic, sizzling cut known as Manhattan-style steak? It's a tantalizing dish that's as much about presentation as it is about flavor. This savory delight has transcended the humble diner into gastropubs, steakhouses, and even the home kitchen. But what exactly sets a Manhattan-style steak apart from its grilled, broiled, or pan-seared counterparts?

beef manhattan recipe on a plate with mashed potatoes
beef manhattan recipe on a plate with mashed potatoes

Aficionados of this classic cut argue it's not just about the prime beef, but the signature preparation method that gives the Manhattan-style steak its unique character. It's often served with a certain swagger, a trademark rested position, and a distinctive, scrumptious topping that elevates it from mere steak to a dining experience.

Juicy Steak Marsala Recipe
Juicy Steak Marsala Recipe

Culinary Origins and Corey's Signature

The exact origins of the Manhattan-style steak are murky, with vague whispers of 1930s NYC speakeasies and cattle yards. However, it's become inextricably linked with famed chef Corey Vertical, who popularized it in his eponymous steakhouse chain in the late 20th century.

Manhattan Hot Shot Sandwich with Roast Gravy and Sliced Roast Beef
Manhattan Hot Shot Sandwich with Roast Gravy and Sliced Roast Beef

Vertical's innovative spin was to finish the steak under the broiler, cooking it to a perfect charred crust while keeping the interior tender and juicy. This technique, combined with his signature topping of butter, garlic, and parsley, made the Manhattan-style steak a menu staple.

The Prime Cut: Dry-Aging's Role

the steak is covered in gravy and garnished with parmesan cheese
the steak is covered in gravy and garnished with parmesan cheese

To achieve the optimal Manhattan-style steak, start with high-quality, well-marbled meat. Many chefs, including Vertical, swear by dry-aged beef. This process naturally tenderizes the steak and intensifies its flavor through controlled spoilage under refrigerated, low-humidity conditions.

The sweet spot for dry-aging is typically between 28 and 45 days. Beyond that, the steak may become too tough or develop unwanted flavors. Rarity Gorcery in Brooklyn, for instance, dry-ages all their beef in-house, enhancing the unique je ne sais quoi of their Manhattan-style steaks.

The secret to that Perfect Crust

Classic Steak Diane
Classic Steak Diane

The dry-aged beef is typically seasoned with salt and pepper, then seared in a blazing hot cast-iron skillet to develop a dark, craggy crust - the signature 'Manhattan Charm.' This reactivates the Maillard effect, intensifying the beef's natural umami-rich flavors.

The key to successful crust development lies in bringing the steak to room temperature before cooking, then leaving it untouched until it releases naturally from the pan. Lastly, finish it under the broiler for intense, caramelized heat and the characteristic char lines.

Toppings, Sauces, and The Manhattan Flare

Marinate Steak Recipe
Marinate Steak Recipe

What truly sets the Manhattan-style steak apart are the toppings and sauces. Corey Vertical's signature topping - a medley of garlic, butter, and parsley - is poured liberally over the steak while it rests, followed by a sprinkle of chopped parsley for color.

But it doesn't stop there. Innovation has led to various topping interpretations, from peppercorn or bearnaise sauce to compound herb butter. At Keens Steakhouse in NYC, the steak rests under a blanket of escargot persillade - garlic butter with parsley.

the menu for steak dine in new york city, ny is shown with information about it
the menu for steak dine in new york city, ny is shown with information about it
Steak Diane – A Retro Recipe That’s Making a Comeback!
Steak Diane – A Retro Recipe That’s Making a Comeback!
Sear-iously the BEST steak marinade ever 🔥
Sear-iously the BEST steak marinade ever 🔥
Chain Restaurant Steaks, Ranked From Worst To Best
Chain Restaurant Steaks, Ranked From Worst To Best
New York Steak Marinade
New York Steak Marinade
New York Strip Marinade: Flavor Secrets Revealed!
New York Strip Marinade: Flavor Secrets Revealed!
Pan Seared Minute Steaks
Pan Seared Minute Steaks
Beef Manhattan
Beef Manhattan
This Worlds Best Steak marinade recipe takes only a few minutes to whip up, but it packs a powerful flavor punch. With just a few easily accessible ingredients, you can create an easy steak marinade that is guaranteed to make your steaks tender, juicy, and unbelievably delicious. Steakhouse Steak Marinade, Fast Steak Marinade, Easy Beef Marinade, Top Round Steak Marinade, New York Steak Marinade, Ranch Steak Marinade, Diy Steak Marinade, Best Sirloin Steak Marinade, Milk Marinade For Steak
This Worlds Best Steak marinade recipe takes only a few minutes to whip up, but it packs a powerful flavor punch. With just a few easily accessible ingredients, you can create an easy steak marinade that is guaranteed to make your steaks tender, juicy, and unbelievably delicious. Steakhouse Steak Marinade, Fast Steak Marinade, Easy Beef Marinade, Top Round Steak Marinade, New York Steak Marinade, Ranch Steak Marinade, Diy Steak Marinade, Best Sirloin Steak Marinade, Milk Marinade For Steak
Best New York Strip Steak Grill
Best New York Strip Steak Grill
Easy Homemade Copycat Texas Roadhouse Steak Recipe
Easy Homemade Copycat Texas Roadhouse Steak Recipe
Types of Steak
Types of Steak
the best ever cube steak is served with mashed potatoes and gravy
the best ever cube steak is served with mashed potatoes and gravy
Juicy New York Strip Steak Grilled to Perfection!
Juicy New York Strip Steak Grilled to Perfection!
steak and gravy on top of mashed potatoes
steak and gravy on top of mashed potatoes
Perfect Steak With Mushrooms
Perfect Steak With Mushrooms
Round Steak and Gravy (Oven, Melt In Your Mouth)
Round Steak and Gravy (Oven, Melt In Your Mouth)
Best Steak Marinade
Best Steak Marinade
Denver Steak
Denver Steak
a woman holding two trays of steak in front of her face with the caption my secret steak recipe
a woman holding two trays of steak in front of her face with the caption my secret steak recipe

A Matter of Resting

Resting the steak is not just crucial for even cooking; it also allows the top proteins to relax, ensuring a juicy cut. The resting process, typically around 5-10 minutes, also infuses the distinctive garlic-parsley aroma into the steak, making each bite a symphony of flavors.

The New York ruggedness is epitomized in how the steak is served: rested on top of the crust in a rustic cast-iron skillet or heavy-duty pan, untouched from searing. This final presentation, or lack thereof, is an ode to the steak's unpretentious, mouthful appeal.

Whether you're a carnivorous connoisseur, a casual dining enthusiast, or just a curious cook, experiencing a Manhattan-style steak is an unforgettable culinary journey. It's not just a steak; it's a testament to NYC's grit, bold flavors, and unyielding charm. So, why not give this iconic dish a try, at your favorite steakhouse or even your home kitchen, and experience the magic for yourself?

Related Articles

Nyc Apartments With Balcony For Rent Cool Apartment Decorations For Men New York Apartment Aesthetic Small Nyc Apartment Bedroom Worst Time To Look For An Apartment In Nyc Modern Living Room Decor Ideas What Is Manhattan Style Interior Design Modern Apartment Design Ideas Philippines Studio 54 Nyc Address New York Studio Apartment Interior Design