Mastering Magic: The Gathering Commander - Reddit's Best Deck Building Tips

Margaret Jul 01, 2026

Embarking on the exhilarating journey of Magic: The Gathering (MTG) Commander deck building often leads enthusiasts to the vibrant community of Reddit. This platform serves as a hub for players to share strategies, seek advice, and showcase their creations. Let's delve into the world of MTG Commander deck building on Reddit, exploring its intricacies, popular decks, and how to engage with this thriving community.

Wizards Of The Coast, Deck Builders, Card Drawing, Black And White Planeswalker, Building A Deck, Magic The Gathering, Game Art, Mtg Decks, The Gathering
Wizards Of The Coast, Deck Builders, Card Drawing, Black And White Planeswalker, Building A Deck, Magic The Gathering, Game Art, Mtg Decks, The Gathering

Reddit's MTG community is vast and diverse, with numerous subreddits dedicated to different aspects of the game. The primary subreddit for Commander is r/MTGCommander, boasting over 100,000 members. This subreddit is a treasure trove of information, featuring deck lists, strategy discussions, and regular challenges like the Commander Social and the Commander Cube.

a star wars card with a man standing in front of a fire
a star wars card with a man standing in front of a fire

Understanding Commander Format

Before diving into deck building, it's crucial to grasp the Commander format's unique rules and structure. In Commander, each player chooses a legendary creature as their commander, which serves as the deck's centerpiece and sets its color identity. The goal is to reduce your opponents' life totals to 0, typically with a starting life total of 40 instead of the standard 20.

the card for moropon, the boundless
the card for moropon, the boundless

Commander decks consist of 100 cards, with one copy of each card allowed (excluding basic lands). The only exception is your commander, which can be included multiple times. This singleton format encourages diverse and creative deck building, as you can't rely on flooding the board with copies of the same card.

Deck Construction Basics

Red Mtg Cards, Best Mtg Cards, Mtg Red Creatures, Mono Red Life Mtg Deck, Mtg Red Dragon, Red Mana Mtg, Red And White Planeswalkers, Mono Red Life Mtg, Magic The Gathering Red Mana
Red Mtg Cards, Best Mtg Cards, Mtg Red Creatures, Mono Red Life Mtg Deck, Mtg Red Dragon, Red Mana Mtg, Red And White Planeswalkers, Mono Red Life Mtg, Magic The Gathering Red Mana

Building a Commander deck begins with selecting a commander that resonates with your playstyle. Consider the commander's colors, abilities, and the overall strategy you want to employ. Once you've chosen your commander, you'll need to build a 99-card deck that supports its strategy while adhering to the format's rules.

When constructing your deck, keep the following guidelines in mind:

  • Include around 24-26 lands to ensure consistent mana production.
  • Balance your curve, aiming for a mix of low-cost and high-impact cards.
  • Consider your deck's synergy, ensuring that your cards work well together.
  • Include card draw, tutors, and removal spells to maintain a consistent game plan.
a card with an image of a cat sitting in a chair and holding a kitten
a card with an image of a cat sitting in a chair and holding a kitten

Popular Commander Archetypes

Reddit's MTG Commander community often discusses and shares popular deck archetypes. Some of the most prevalent archetypes include:

  • Voltron: Focusing on equipping and buffing your commander to deal direct damage to opponents.
  • Group Hug: Enabling and supporting your opponents' strategies while also benefiting from their actions.
  • Stax: Disrupting opponents' game plans by targeting their mana production, card draw, and board state.
  • Combo: Utilizing complex interactions between cards to achieve a specific, often game-winning, effect.
How to Build a Commander Deck in MTG – Full Guide!
How to Build a Commander Deck in MTG – Full Guide!

Engaging with the MTG Commander Reddit Community

Participating in the MTG Commander Reddit community offers numerous benefits, from refining your deck-building skills to discovering new strategies and cards. To make the most of this resource, consider the following tips:

Beginner's MTG Guide
Beginner's MTG Guide
Magic The Gathering Anime, Mtg Anime Art, Black Lotus Mtg Card, Mtg Anime, Black Lotus Mtg Value, Anime Art Mtg Cards, Mtg Black, Magic The Gathering Anime Cards, Esper Mtg
Magic The Gathering Anime, Mtg Anime Art, Black Lotus Mtg Card, Mtg Anime, Black Lotus Mtg Value, Anime Art Mtg Cards, Mtg Black, Magic The Gathering Anime Cards, Esper Mtg
MacCready, Lamplight Mayor
MacCready, Lamplight Mayor
Malenia, Blade of Miquella
Malenia, Blade of Miquella
Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate (CLB) Card Gallery
Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate (CLB) Card Gallery
a hand holding up a card with an image of a cat demon on it's back
a hand holding up a card with an image of a cat demon on it's back
a card with an image of snow artifact
a card with an image of snow artifact
a card with an image of a woman holding a bow
a card with an image of a woman holding a bow
a hand holding up a card with an image of a man in armor on it
a hand holding up a card with an image of a man in armor on it
Mtg Edgar Markov Proxy, Mtg Decks, Dark Deck, Mtg Cards, Avacyn Angel Of Hope Proxy, Avacyn Cards, Mtg Commander Deck Ideas, Mtg Art, Nerd Life
Mtg Edgar Markov Proxy, Mtg Decks, Dark Deck, Mtg Cards, Avacyn Angel Of Hope Proxy, Avacyn Cards, Mtg Commander Deck Ideas, Mtg Art, Nerd Life
Estrella's Command
Estrella's Command
a card with a tower on it that says, command tower land add one man of any color in your commander's colet identity
a card with a tower on it that says, command tower land add one man of any color in your commander's colet identity
Magic The Gathering Planeswalker, Mono Black Commander Mtg, Mtg Proxy Commander Card Ideas, Mtg Custom Commanders, Mtg Planeswalkers, Shapeshifter Mtg, Amonkhet Magic The Gathering, Magic The Gathering Nope, Garruk Mtg
Magic The Gathering Planeswalker, Mono Black Commander Mtg, Mtg Proxy Commander Card Ideas, Mtg Custom Commanders, Mtg Planeswalkers, Shapeshifter Mtg, Amonkhet Magic The Gathering, Magic The Gathering Nope, Garruk Mtg
commandtowerhouse
commandtowerhouse
the great fairy fountain card is shown
the great fairy fountain card is shown
Best Decks to Build on a Budget w/ The Commander’s Quarters I The Command Zone 293 I Magic MTG
Best Decks to Build on a Budget w/ The Commander’s Quarters I The Command Zone 293 I Magic MTG
an image of the game's main menu
an image of the game's main menu
an image of a woman with purple hair
an image of a woman with purple hair
kyler
kyler

1. Be respectful and constructive: When offering feedback or discussing decks, maintain a positive and helpful attitude. Remember that everyone is at a different skill level and has unique preferences.

2. Share your creations: Post your Commander decks and explain your thought process behind them. The community loves seeing new and innovative ideas.

3. Participate in challenges and events: Engage in regular challenges and events, such as the Commander Social or the Commander Cube. These activities foster a sense of community and provide opportunities to test your decks against diverse opponents.

Reddit Subreddits for MTG Commander

In addition to the main r/MTGCommander subreddit, several other subreddits cater to specific aspects of Commander:

  • r/EDH: A smaller subreddit focused on Elder Dragon Highlander (EDH), an older name for the Commander format.
  • r/MTGDeckbuilding: A subreddit dedicated to discussing and sharing deck-building strategies for various MTG formats, including Commander.
  • r/MTGLegacy: While focused on the Legacy format, this subreddit occasionally discusses Commander strategies and deck-building principles.

Embracing the MTG Commander community on Reddit opens doors to endless learning, creativity, and camaraderie. By engaging with fellow players, sharing your decks, and participating in challenges, you'll not only improve your Commander skills but also contribute to the vibrant and welcoming environment that makes Reddit an exceptional resource for MTG enthusiasts.