Bath or Shower Woes? Top Solutions for Rental Property

Timothy Aug 03, 2026

When it comes to choosing between a bath and shower in a rental property, it's not just about personal preference. Both have their unique benefits and drawbacks, affecting not only your daily routine but also your rental agreement and utility bills. Let's delve into the intricacies of each to help you make an informed decision.

the bathroom is clean and ready to be used as a bathtub or shower curtain
the bathroom is clean and ready to be used as a bathtub or shower curtain

First, let's consider the practical aspects. Baths and showers each have specific advantages when it comes to space usage, water conservation, and hygiene. Understanding these can guide you towards the option that best suits your lifestyle and your rental agreement.

New lease of life: how to redecorate a rental property
New lease of life: how to redecorate a rental property

Baths: Luxury or Necessity?

Baths have been a symbol of luxury and relaxation for centuries. They offer a full-body soak, which can be therapeutic for muscle pains and stress relief. Moreover, a bath can double as a practical solution for cleaning young children or pets.

Bearsden apartment has incredible transformation in before and after pictures
Bearsden apartment has incredible transformation in before and after pictures

However, baths require significantly more water than showers. According to the U.S. Geological Survey, a full bathtub requires about 36 gallons of water, compared to the 2.5 gallons used per minute in a shower. This could lead to higher water bills and throughput equating to larger sewer fees. Additionally, not all rental properties can accommodate a bathtub, especially newer apartments prioritizing space-efficient design.

When a Bath is Worth It

Our first single family rental property renovation is finished! - The Vanderveen House
Our first single family rental property renovation is finished! - The Vanderveen House

A bath can be a worthwhile investment if you or a family member requires therapeutic soaks, or if your property has robust water and waste management systems. Also, if you plan to stay long term and can stretch your budget, a bathtub can add a touch of luxury and boost your property's resale value.

Before installing a bathtub, ensure it aligns with your rental agreement. Some landlords might have restrictions or require additional payments for modifications. Always prioritize open communication and obtain permission before proceeding with any changes.

Alternatives to Traditional Baths

a bathroom with a large mirror, sink and bathtub next to a walk in shower
a bathroom with a large mirror, sink and bathtub next to a walk in shower

If you covet a bathtub but want to conserve water, consider alternatives like walk-in bathtubs or shower-bath combinations. These offer the soaking experience while optimizing water use. However, they may not be feasible in all rental properties due to size constraints or accessibility requirements.

Moreover, regular maintenance and safety precautions are necessary for bathtubs. Slips are a common hazard, especially for the elderly or mobility-impaired. Ensure you have non-slip mats, grab rails, and adequate lighting to minimize risks.

Showers: Efficient and Versatile

Tips for Remodeling a Rental Property
Tips for Remodeling a Rental Property

Showers are increasingly popular in modern dwellings due to their space efficiency and water-saving benefits. They cater to various tastes, from rain showers to steam showers, and can be installed in enclosed spaces like wet rooms or bathtub combinations.

On average, showers use less water than baths, making them appealing for eco-conscious renters or those seeking to cut costs. However, some showerheads can dispense up to 2.5 gallons per minute, so it's crucial to choose a WaterSense-certified model for further efficiency.

Bathroom renovations that have to be seen to be believed - Queensland Homes
Bathroom renovations that have to be seen to be believed - Queensland Homes
How landlords can create the perfect rental property for tenants
How landlords can create the perfect rental property for tenants
a white bath tub sitting next to a toilet
a white bath tub sitting next to a toilet
a bathroom with a tub, shower and glass door in it's center area
a bathroom with a tub, shower and glass door in it's center area

The Benefits of Showers

Showers are quicker and more efficient for rinsing off after exercise or a long day. Additionally, they're easier to clean and maintain, requiring less elbow grease than bathtubs. Furthermore, showers accommodate wheelchairs and those with mobility issues, making them an inclusive choice.

However, be mindful of water damage and mold growth, particularly if your rental property lacks adequate ventilation. Regular cleaning and proper drainage can mitigate these risks and preserve your shower's longevity.

Showers that Stand Out

If you're eager to upgrade, consider smart showers that integrate with your home's tech system. These can provide customizeable settings, reduce water usage, and improve convenience. However, install at your peril, as some landlords might not approve of extensive modifications.

Before making any changes, consult your rental agreement and discuss any updates with your landlord. Maintaining open communication ensures you respect the property and preserve your tenancy.

Ultimately, the choice between bath or shower in a rental property depends on your personal needs and the property's features. Both options offer unique advantages, so weigh these against your budget and lifestyle to make an informed decision. After all, your bathroom should be a sanctuary reflecting your individuality and catering to your daily needs.