In the quest for the perfect potato salad, many of us have turned to store-bought options for convenience and variety. With numerous brands and flavors available, choosing the best can be a daunting task. We've taken the liberty to taste test and rank the top store-bought potato salads of 2017, ensuring you make an informed decision at the grocery store.
Our Top Picks for Best Store-Bought Potato Salad in 2017
1. Heinz Potato Salad
Heinz, a household name in condiments, also delivers a crowd-pleasing potato salad. Their classic recipe features tender potatoes, crisp celery, and onions in a creamy dressing that's not too heavy. The balance of flavors makes it a versatile side dish that pairs well with various meals. It's also widely available, making it a convenient choice.
2. O Organics Potato Salad
For those seeking an organic option, O Organics' potato salad is a standout. Made with USDA-certified organic ingredients, it offers a clean taste without compromising flavor. The salad features a tangy, mustard-based dressing that sets it apart from other store-bought options. It's also free from artificial flavors and preservatives, making it a healthier choice.

3. Marie's Cole Slaw Potato Salad
Marie's Cole Slaw Potato Salad is a unique blend of two classic sides. The combination of creamy potato salad and crunchy coleslaw creates a textural contrast that's surprisingly delightful. The dressing is tangy and sweet, with a hint of vinegar that cuts through the richness of the potatoes. It's a great option if you're looking to try something different.
4. Fresh Thyme Market Potato Salad
Fresh Thyme Market's potato salad is a step up from the typical deli case offering. Made with high-quality ingredients, including free-range eggs and organic celery, it has a fresher taste than many store-bought options. The dressing is creamy and tangy, with a hint of Dijon mustard that adds depth of flavor. It's a premium product that's worth seeking out.
What to Consider When Buying Store-Bought Potato Salad
When selecting a store-bought potato salad, there are several factors to consider:

- Ingredients: Check the ingredient list for any allergens or ingredients you want to avoid. Some salads may contain high-fructose corn syrup, artificial flavors, or other additives.
- Calories and Fat: Potato salad can be high in calories and fat, so consider your dietary needs when making a selection.
- Texture: Some people prefer their potato salad creamy, while others like it chunky. Consider your preference when choosing a salad.
- Flavor: Potato salads come in a variety of flavors, from classic to tangy to sweet. Choose a flavor profile that suits your taste.
- Price: Store-bought potato salads vary in price, so consider your budget when making a selection.
How We Tested and Ranked the Best Store-Bought Potato Salads
To determine the best store-bought potato salads of 2017, we tasted and ranked each option based on the following criteria:
| Criteria | Weight |
|---|---|
| Taste | 40% |
| Texture | 30% |
| Ingredients | 20% |
| Value | 10% |
We tasted each potato salad blind, focusing on the balance of flavors, creaminess of the dressing, and overall enjoyment. We also considered the ingredient list, looking for salads made with high-quality, natural ingredients. Finally, we factored in the price, ensuring that our top picks offered good value for money.
Whether you're looking for a classic potato salad or something with a unique twist, our top picks offer the best store-bought options of 2017. So, the next time you're at the grocery store, you can confidently choose a potato salad that's sure to please.