Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander Cost: Full Price Comparison 2024
When evaluating SUV ownership, the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander stand out as top contenders—especially when comparing their total cost of ownership. The Honda Pilot typically starts around $33,000, offering a more accessible entry point for budget-conscious buyers, while the Toyota Highlander begins closer to $38,000, reflecting its premium reputation and advanced features. Beyond the sticker price, long-term expenses such as maintenance, fuel efficiency, and insurance significantly influence the true cost. The Pilot delivers strong gas mileage—up to 28 mpg combined—with reliable reliability and lower average repair costs. The Highlander excels in ride comfort and available tech, including a user-friendly infotainment system and optional safety features, but often comes with higher maintenance fees and slightly stronger fuel consumption. Ownership costs also vary by location and driving habits, but many owners find the Pilot’s balance of affordability and durability makes it the smarter value choice, especially for families prioritizing efficiency. Ultimately, the decision hinges on balancing upfront cost, desired features, and long-term ownership expenses to match your lifestyle needs.
The Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander each present compelling advantages, but cost-conscious buyers should weigh total ownership expenses beyond base prices. While the Pilot offers a more economical total package, the Highlander’s premium interior and brand loyalty appeal to those seeking enhanced comfort and technology. To maximize savings, reviewing current dealer incentives, financing rates, and regional pricing can further tip the scales toward the better value. Careful comparison ensures a smart investment that fits both budget and driving expectations.
Choose wisely—your next SUV should match your needs without breaking the bank.
2026 Toyota Highlander vs 2026 Honda Pilot - which is better for you? Find out with Edmunds' head-to-head car comparison tool. Compare prices, options, features and specs, expert and consumer. To help you decide between the Toyota Highlander and Honda Pilot, we cover what sets them apart in areas like pricing and safety.
Easily compare the 2026 Toyota Highlander vs. 2026 Honda Pilot to see how they stack up in pricing, performance, and more. Compare the 2025 Honda Pilot and 2025 Toyota Highlander and choose the best midsize 3.
Find out how the 2025 Toyota Highlander compares to the Honda Pilot. Our comparison shows which SUV has the best performance, seating, entertainment and more. Not sure if the Toyota Highlander or Honda Pilot is the right car for you? Not an issue.
Use Carfax's comparison below to compare reviews, configurations, price and more. Comparing the 2025 Toyota Highlander and 2025 Honda Pilot? We highlight 3 key differences buyers need to know before signing on the dotted line. Pricing When comparing SUVs like the Toyota Highlander and the Honda Pilot, it is important to look at price, fuel economy, cargo and seating capacity, and standard features.
Starting with price, the Toyota Highlander is more expensive with a starting MSRP or TSRP of $47,065 and the similarly equipped Honda Pilot starts at $41,695. Compare the Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander. See specs, third-row space, cargo capacity, towing, and pricing to find the best 3.
The 2025 Honda Pilot has a starting MSRP of $40,200 for the base Sport trim, while the Toyota Highlander begins at $39,520 for the LE model. The top-of-the-line Honda Pilot Black Edition trim is priced at $54,580, while the Highlander's top trim, the Platinum, is priced at $51,925.