Over Ice & Water Shield: When to Use Roofing Felt

Anna Aug 02, 2026

Maintaining a watertight and durable roof is paramount for protecting your home. This requires a multitude of materials working together seamlessly. One aspect that often raises questions is the relationship between roofing felt, ice and water shield, and their placement. So, the question stands, "Do you put roofing felt over ice and water shield?" Let's delve into this.". There are two schools of thought when addressing this question.

Understanding Ice and Water Shield

What is Ice and Water Shield on a Roof? (Types, Cost, and More)
What is Ice and Water Shield on a Roof? (Types, Cost, and More)

Ice and water shield, also known as self-adhesive underlayment, is a vital component of your roof's protective system. It's a thin, sticky membrane designed to protect against water intrusion in high-risk areas like eaves, valleys, and around penetrations like vents and skylights. It's applied directly to the roof deck and is particularly effective when ice dams form, preventing water from backing up under the roofing material.

ICE AND WATER SHIELD INSTALLATION TRICKS
ICE AND WATER SHIELD INSTALLATION TRICKS

Ice and water shield is often used in conjunction with other underlayments to provide an extra layer of protection, but it's the base layer against the roof deck, not the felt.

Pro: Installing Roofing Felt Over Ice and Water Shield

a man is working on the roof of a house that has been covered with tarps
a man is working on the roof of a house that has been covered with tarps

Some roofing contractors advocate for applying a layer of traditional felt over the ice and water shield. This provides a different form of protection - a light barrier against dust, debris, and excessive sun exposure. Additionally, felt can add a layer of slip resistance, improving safety during roof installation.

Moreover, felt can absorb roofing nails better than the ice and water shield, potentially reducing nail pops in the future. In snowy regions, this can also help anchor the ice and water shield, dampening the contractions and expansions that can cause tears.

Why Every Roof Needs Ice And Water Shield | Peel and Stick Underlayment
Why Every Roof Needs Ice And Water Shield | Peel and Stick Underlayment

Con: Not Installing Roofing Felt Over Ice and Water Shield

The main argument against using felt over ice and water shield is that both serve similar waterproofing purposes. The felt might not contribute significantly to the roof's overall protection and could add unnecessary cost. Since the ice and water shield can perform adequately on its own and is often warrantied accordingly, adding felt might not be necessary.

Furthermore, felt can absorb water, potentially compromising its waterproofing ability over time. In hot, sunny climates, the felt can degrade faster due to excessive heat exposure. Lastly, felt installation can add labor time, increasing the overall project cost.

a man working on the roof of a house with an ice and water barrier attached to it
a man working on the roof of a house with an ice and water barrier attached to it

Manufacturer Recommendations

Different ice and water shield manufacturers provide varying recommendations. Some recommend applying felt to protect their product, while others advise against it, stating that their product performs best on its own. It's crucial to review your specific product's instructions to ensure you're following the manufacturer's guidelines.

Always remember that proper installation is more important than additional layers. A poorly installed ice and water shield or felt can be ineffective, regardless of the additional layers you add.

Why Your Roof Needs Both Ice & Water Shield and Underlayment
Why Your Roof Needs Both Ice & Water Shield and Underlayment

In the end, deciding whether to use roofing felt over ice and water shield depends largely on your roof's specific needs, local climate, and manufacturer recommendations. It's always a good idea to consult with a reputable roofing professional for guidance tailored to your situation."

a house with cars parked in front of it and some trees on the side of the road
a house with cars parked in front of it and some trees on the side of the road
What is Ice and Water Shield on a Roof?
What is Ice and Water Shield on a Roof?
How to install ice and water shield on the roof
How to install ice and water shield on the roof
How to install ice and water shield on the roof
How to install ice and water shield on the roof
The Best Roof Underlayments
The Best Roof Underlayments
Synthetic Felt
Synthetic Felt
Valleys on your roof handle the most water flow.
Valleys on your roof handle the most water flow.
Q & A - What Felt Underlayment Should I Use? — AskARoofer
Q & A - What Felt Underlayment Should I Use? — AskARoofer