The age-old question in the realm of roofing and waterproofing - should underlayment go over ice and water shield? - continues to puzzle contractors and homeowners alike. Let's delve into this conundrum, exploring the roles of each, their interplay, and best practices for waterproofing your roof.

Understanding these materials is the first step towards making an informed decision. Underlayment, a layer of protective material laid over the roof decking, serves as a barrier against moisture, heat, and cold. Meanwhile, ice and water shield, a self-adhesive, modified bitumen membrane, provides extra protection against water intrusion in critical areas like valleys, eaves, and around penetrations.

The Role of Ice and Water Shield
Ice and water shield is designed to protect your roof's most vulnerable points. It's not a replacement for underlayment but rather an additional layer to enhance waterproofing, especially in regions prone to ice dams, heavy rainfall, or snow melt. It typically covers a 6-inch-wide band along the eaves and rakes, and around all vents, skylights, and chimneys.

The unique features of ice and water shield - its peel-and-stick application, powerful adhesive, and overlapping design - make it perfect for quick application and ensuring no gaps are left exposed. It adheres to the roof deck and most types of underlayment, creating a watertight seal.
Lap Cement Method

One common technique for applying ice and water shield involves using lap cement – a special adhesive to secure overlapping pieces of the shield. This method ensures that overlapping edges are firmly sealed, preventing water from seeping underneath. However, using lap cement on certain types of underlayment can void its warranty, so always check the manufacturer's guidelines.
Lap cement's advantage is that it allows for repairing damaged or incomplete sections of the ice and water shield, making it a valuable tool for roofers during installation or maintenance. Nevertheless, it's not always necessary, and some manufacturers recommend applying the shield without lap cement.
When to Use Lap Cement

Using lap cement is advised when installing ice and water shield over underlayment in areas prone to heavy rain, ice dams, or snow melt. The lap cement strengthens the bond, ensuring that no water can infiltrate, even in the harshest conditions. Keep in mind that it's not a requirement for all installations, so consulting the manufacturer's recommendations is a must.
In some cases, applying lap cement during extreme cold or heat can affect its adhesion, making it less effective. Always follow the manufacturer's guidelines for application temperatures to maximize lap cement's performance.
The Debate: Underlayment Over Ice and Water Shield

Believe it or not, the order in which you apply underlayment and ice and water shield can have significant implications for your roof's waterproofing and longevity. As logic might suggest, applying underlayment over ice and water shield seems counterintuitive. Yet, this approach has its proponents and advantages.
Proponents of applying underlayment over ice and water shield argue that it provides an additional barrier, preventing water from getting to the shield. If water does breach the underlayment, it can be wicked up and away from the roof by the underlayment's unique properties, reducing the risk of leaks.







Underlayment over Ice and Water Shield
This method is beneficial in certain situations. For instance, if you're re-roofing over a roof with aging ice and water shield, applying new underlayment can extend the life of the old shield while providing additional protection. Moreover, it simplifies the application process since the ice and water shield adheres to the underlayment rather than the roof deck, saving time and labor.
However, it's essential to understand that applying underlayment over ice and water shield might not be suitable for all roofing situations, especially in areas prone to heavy rain or snow melt. The added weight of underlayment can sometimes cause the shield to bubble or wrinkle, potentially leading to leaks. Additionally, underlayment applied over ice and water shield might not be covered under the manufacturer's warranty if any water damage occurs.
The Conventional Approach: Ice and Water Shield over Underlayment
The most common and widely recommended practice is to apply ice and water shield over underlayment. This method ensures that the shield adheres directly to the roof deck, providing a secure bond and enhanced waterproofing. By placing the shield over the underlayment, any water that breaches the underlayment will still be stopped by the shield.
Moreover, applying underlayment over ice and water shield can void the shield's warranty. Most manufacturers require that their product be applied directly to the roof deck, with the underlayment placed on top. Skipping this critical step might leave you vulnerable to water damage and without the manufacturer's support.
Ultimately, whether underlayment goes over ice and water shield or vice versa depends on your specific situation and local climate. Always consult the manufacturer's guidelines and consider your regional weather patterns when deciding. A professional roofer can also provide invaluable advice tailored to your project. Don't leave waterproofing to chance - make an informed decision and enjoy peace of mind knowing your roof is equipped to handle whatever nature throws its way.