Gen 4 Starters Ranked: The Best Pokémons From Diamond & Pearl

Anna Aug 02, 2026

Choosing a starter Pokémon in the Kanto region is no small task, as each offers a unique journey and set of challenges. In the Pokémon community, there's ongoing debate about the best Generation 4 starters, but one thing is certain: they all have their appeal. If you're planning to start a new game or embark on a Pokémon adventure, you might be wondering which starter is right for you.

the pokemon characters are all different colors and sizes
the pokemon characters are all different colors and sizes

Each generation of Pokémon games offers a trio of starters, each with its own strengths, weaknesses, and evolutions. Generation 4 includes Pokémon Diamond, Pearl, and Platinum, and their respective version-exclusive starters: Turtwig, Chimchar, and Piplup. But with so many factors to consider, such as type matchups, evolution lines, and personal playstyle, choosing the 'best' starter can be subjective. Let's dive into an in-depth ranking of Generation 4 starters, considering various aspects to help you make an informed decision.

Pokemon Starters Meme Chart
Pokemon Starters Meme Chart

Pokémon Typings and Evolution Lines

Alice, the Grass-type starter, evolves into Serperior, offering great speed and Special Attack stats, making it an excellent choice for supportive or offensive roles.

Starter Pok Mon Ranked Tristan Ettleman Medium 3 Starters Pokemon
Starter Pok Mon Ranked Tristan Ettleman Medium 3 Starters Pokemon

Beth, the Fire-type starter, evolves into Samurott, which offers a great balance of Attack and Defense stats, along with useful support moves like Aqua Jet and Swords Dance.

Type Coverage and Dynamics

an image of some pokemon characters with caption that reads, choose your favorite starter from each pokemon region
an image of some pokemon characters with caption that reads, choose your favorite starter from each pokemon region

Grass-types are strong against Water, Ground, and Rock-types but weak against Fire, Ice, Grass, and Poison-types. Serperior's high Speed and Special Attack make it an excellent sweeper, but it may struggle against powerful Special Attackers.

Fire-types are strong against Ice, Bug, Steel, and Grass-types but weak against Water, Ground, Rock, and Fire-types. Samurott's balance of Attack and Defense allows it to excel in both offensive and defensive roles, with moves like Swords Dance and Aqua Jet.

Evolution Lines and Utility

All Pokémon Starters Ranked
All Pokémon Starters Ranked

Serperior's evolution line offers good speed and evasion boosts, making it a threat in both single and double battles. However, Serperior's stats may not be as impressive as other Grass-types like Sceptile or Leavanny, and its low HP can make it fragile.

Samurott's evolution line offers a mix of offensive and defensive capabilities, with high Attack and Defense stats. Its ability, Torrent, boosts its Special Attack in the rain, making it a potent force in weather-based teams. Samurott also has access to powerful moves like Aqua Tail, Swords Dance, and Aqua Ring, providing it with solid utility.

Movepool, Abilities, and Competitive Viability

Galar starters
Galar starters

Generation 4 offered a vast movepool, allowing trainers to create diverse strategies. The availability of Held Items, abilities, and EVs further expanded these possibilities.

movepool and Abilities

See the New Trailer for Pokémon Winds and Pokémon Waves, Coming to Nintendo Switch 2
See the New Trailer for Pokémon Winds and Pokémon Waves, Coming to Nintendo Switch 2
two pokemons are hugging each other in the grass
two pokemons are hugging each other in the grass
Pokémon plante 💚
Pokémon plante 💚
many different types of pokemon characters
many different types of pokemon characters
A Definitive Ranking Of Every Starter Trio In Pokémon
A Definitive Ranking Of Every Starter Trio In Pokémon
three different images of pokemons in the water
three different images of pokemons in the water
several different types of pokemon characters
several different types of pokemon characters
three cartoon characters standing next to each other in front of a colorful background with leaves
three cartoon characters standing next to each other in front of a colorful background with leaves
the pokemon characters are playing with each other
the pokemon characters are playing with each other

Serperior has access to a wide range of moves, including Leaf Storm, Energy Ball, and Dragon Pulse, as well as the Ability Overgrow, which boosts its Power of Grass-type moves by 1.5x when its HP is below 1/3. However, its Ability cannot be changed, which might limit its adaptability.

Samurott has a diverse movepool, including powerful moves like Aqua Tail, Ice Fang, and Waterfall. Its Ability Torrent boosts its Special Attack when its HP is above 3/4, and it can be changed using the Ability Capsule, providing flexibility.

Competitive Viability

In competitive play, Serperior is often used for its high Speed and Special Attack. However, its low HP can make it vulnerable in doubles and the current metagame may not favor Grass-types.

Samurott is a strong contender in competitive play, thanks to its balanced stats, useful Abilities, and diverse movepool. Its ability to create entry hazards and set up rain teams makes it a formidable opponent. Moreover, its access to status moves like Heal Pulse and Acupressure can provide it with additional utility.

At the end of the day, the 'best' Gen 4 starter depends on your playstyle, preferences, and strategies. While this ranking provides insight into each starter's strengths, weaknesses, and evolution lines, ultimately, the best starter for you is the one you enjoy using the most. So, bring on the adventure, and may the spirit of competition inspire you to catch 'em all!