Is Charmander the Worst Starter Pokémon?

Anna Aug 02, 2026

In the vast and vibrant world of Pokémon, the choice of a starter often shapes players' journey through the Kanto region. Among the three initial options—Bulbasaur, Squirtle, and Charmander—discerning which is the "worst" can spark debate among trainers. Let's delve into this controversial topic, balancing elemental typing, available moves, and lore, to determine if Charmander really is the starter least deserving of its slot.

a cartoon character sitting in front of a computer screen with the caption that reads, i'm really pleased because charmer was my first
a cartoon character sitting in front of a computer screen with the caption that reads, i'm really pleased because charmer was my first

Some aspiring trainers might have a preconceived notion that Charmander, with its Fire typing and fierce appearance, is the weakest of the trio. However, a thorough examination reveals that each starter has its strengths and weaknesses, making the "worst" label subjective. Let's dive into the details and first consider the elemental typing of our three protagonists.

charmander from starter squad
charmander from starter squad

Elemental Typing and Viability

Each of the three starters sports a distinct elemental typing that influences their initial and long-term viability.

sad charmander starter squad ...
sad charmander starter squad ...

Bulbasaur, a Grass and Poison-type, boasts effective neutrality against six types, including Normal and Steel. Its typing allows Bulbasaur to bypass Water-resistant opponents easily and counter a wide array of threats. However, its mediocre move pool and skewed Special/HP stat distribution might lento apparent weaknesses.

Charmander's Fire Typing

a cartoon character sitting on the ground in front of a blazing background with fire coming from it
a cartoon character sitting on the ground in front of a blazing background with fire coming from it

Charmander, on the other hand, is a Fire-type Pokémon with compelling strengths and weaknesses. Fire typed Pokémon possess excellent coverage against Grass, Bug, and Ice types—elements that several early-game opponents exploit. Moreover, Charmander's powerful Fire attacks enable it to deliver large chunks of damage. However, Fire's four weaknesses (Water, Ground, Rock, and fighting) hinder Charmander's versatility.

Despite the apparent shortfalls, Charmander's Fire typing enables it to torch many common foes, fill the role of a special sweeper, and excel in competitive play. Its powerful special moves like Flamethrower, Fire Blast, and Fire Spin ensure it is not a one-trick pony, making it an attractive choice for many trainers.

Squirtle's Water Typing

the pokemon movie poster is shown in red and yellow
the pokemon movie poster is shown in red and yellow

Squirtle, a Water-type, possesses an impressive defensive prowess and the best type coverage against eight types, including the formidable Electric and Fire. Its robust imposing presence and high Defense EVs make it an excellent tank. However, its slow speed and subpar Special and HP stat distribution might Pose challenges in certain battles.

Move Pools and Evolutions

Just as critical as typing, the diversity of a Pokémon's moveset determines its usefulness in various situations.

pokemon with magic stories of being abandoned and waiting for their trainers for a long time
pokemon with magic stories of being abandoned and waiting for their trainers for a long time

Charmander's Move Pool

Charmander offers a versatile moveset—Fire attacks such as Flamethrower, Fire Blast, and Fire Spin form its backbone, while Normal and Flying-type moves such as Heat Wave, Overheat, and Aerial Ace round out its skillset. Moreover, Charmander's evolution into Charmeleon and eventually Charizard grants it access to even more devastating attacks like Rocket Uppercut, Fire Punch, and Slash.

charmander from the starter squad series by shippiddge fanart!!
charmander from the starter squad series by shippiddge fanart!!
Pokémon: 10 Things You Didn't Know About Charmander
Pokémon: 10 Things You Didn't Know About Charmander
Squirtle Pikachu, Charmander Eyes Closed, Charmander Pokedex, Gen 1 Starter Pokemon, Fire Pokemon Cute, Cute Fire Pokemon, Cute Aesthetic Pokemon Wallpaper, Chespin Full Art, Charmander Pokemon Fanart
Squirtle Pikachu, Charmander Eyes Closed, Charmander Pokedex, Gen 1 Starter Pokemon, Fire Pokemon Cute, Cute Fire Pokemon, Cute Aesthetic Pokemon Wallpaper, Chespin Full Art, Charmander Pokemon Fanart
a cartoon character holding a fire in his hand with the caption keep it alive
a cartoon character holding a fire in his hand with the caption keep it alive
charmander starter squad
charmander starter squad
is charmander the worst starter
is charmander the worst starter
several different types of cartoon characters in various positions and sizes, all with different expressions
several different types of cartoon characters in various positions and sizes, all with different expressions
a cartoon character is in the kitchen with fire coming out of his mouth and cooking
a cartoon character is in the kitchen with fire coming out of his mouth and cooking

Charizard's Gigantamax form introduces powerful new moves like G-Max Wildfire and G-Max Flamethrower, further cementing Charmander's status as a formidable special sweeper. Although Charizard's lack of healing moves and average defensive stats might limit its endurance, Charmander's diverse moves and potential for devastating special attacks offer a compelling argument against it being the "worst" starter.

Evolution and Lore

The narrative potential and final forms of each starter also contribute to their appeal. Charmander's adorable appearance and the story of its evolution into a mighty Charizard captivate trainers worldwide. Charizard's status as one of the most iconic and recognizable Pokémon, along with its powerful Mega and Gigantamax forms, makes Charmander a popular choice.

Bulbasaur and Squirtle, too, have their charms. Venusaur and Blastoise are respected additions to any team. Still, the narrative weight and aesthetic appeal of Charizard tend to give Charmander an edge in the lore department.

In the end, the perceived disadvantage of Charmander as the "worst" starter could be a testament to the playstyle it promotes. Its high-risk, high-reward nature encourages trainers to be tactical, strategic, and adaptable. Rather than dismissing Charmander as inferior, perhaps we should celebrate the unique challenges and opportunities it presents. So, go ahead, trainers. Embrace the fire, and let your Charmander blaze its own trail through the Kanto region—after all, every starter is a journey waiting to happen.