Starter Strip vs Ice and Water Shield: Benefits & Drawbacks

Anna Aug 02, 2026

When it comes to protecting your roof and building envelope from water intrusion, the choice between a starter strip and an ice and water shield is a crucial one. Both are designed to safeguard your home, but they cater to different needs and climate zones. Here's a comprehensive comparison to help you understand each product better.

Ice & Water Shield Calculator
Ice & Water Shield Calculator

But first, let's demystify these terms. A starter strip is a granular, self-adhesive underlayment used at the eaves of a roof to prevent water backup. It creates a barrier against water flowing back underneath the shingles. On the other hand, an ice and water shield is a self-adhesive membrane designed to protect against ice dams and water backup, typically used on the entire roof or in problematic areas.

Cooling Towels Bulk, Portable Cooling Packs, Cooling Head Wrap, Extreme Cooling Version Neck Fan, Summer Cooling Accessory, Cooling Scarf For Summer, Wrap-around Cooling Neck Fan, Cooler Shock Reusable Ice Packs, Activcool Cooling Towel
Cooling Towels Bulk, Portable Cooling Packs, Cooling Head Wrap, Extreme Cooling Version Neck Fan, Summer Cooling Accessory, Cooling Scarf For Summer, Wrap-around Cooling Neck Fan, Cooler Shock Reusable Ice Packs, Activcool Cooling Towel

Understanding Starter Strips

Starter strips are essential for preventing water from entering your home through the roof's most vulnerable points - the eaves and rakes. They are typically used along the eaves, covering the first three feet of the roofing felt, creating a seal where ice and snow melt can flow off the roof without seeping underneath the shingles.

an ice - like object is floating in the air
an ice - like object is floating in the air

Starter strips are less expensive and easier to install than ice and water shields. They are suitable for climates with low to moderate snowfall and minimal ice buildup. However, they are not designed to protect the entire roof or handle significant water backup, making them less effective in colder, snowier regions.

Advantages of Using Starter Strips

Hammer of Skadi by Stuart Immonen Thunder Hammer Art, Crystal Hammer Fantasy, Ice Hammer Fantasy, Hammer Of Thunderbolts, Comic Style Thor Hammer, Thor Summoning Hammer, Storm Thor Hammer, Fantasy Sledge Hammer, Mjolnir Original Artwork
Hammer of Skadi by Stuart Immonen Thunder Hammer Art, Crystal Hammer Fantasy, Ice Hammer Fantasy, Hammer Of Thunderbolts, Comic Style Thor Hammer, Thor Summoning Hammer, Storm Thor Hammer, Fantasy Sledge Hammer, Mjolnir Original Artwork

Starter strips are a cost-effective solution that provides basic water protection. They are easy to install, lightweight, and can help reduce the risk of ice dams at the eaves. They are also more breathable than other underlayment options, allowing your roof to "breathe" and reducing the likelihood of moisture buildup.

Moreover, starter strips comply with most building codes and are recommended by many roofing manufacturers. They are widely available and can be used with various roofing materials, including asphalt, wood, and metal.

Limitations of Starter Strips

RV Skirting Kit: Cut Heating Costs, No Drill
RV Skirting Kit: Cut Heating Costs, No Drill

While starter strips do their job at the eaves, they are not designed to protect the rest of the roof. In climates with heavy snowfall or dramatic temperature fluctuations, ice dams can form further up the roof, causing water to back up and potentially infiltrate the home. Starter strips do not provide enough protection in these situations.

Another limitation is that starter strips are not always self-adhesive, requiring additional application steps. They may also require additional protection at roof valleys and vertical 墙 surfaces, adding to the overall job cost.

Ice and Water Shields

an ice shelf is shown with water, ice and other things labeled in the diagram
an ice shelf is shown with water, ice and other things labeled in the diagram

Ice and water shields are designed to provide a more robust defense against water intrusion. They are self-adhesive, peel-and-stick membranes that can be applied to the entire roof or in problematic areas. This makes them an excellent choice for climates with heavy snowfall, dramatic temperature swings, or flat and low-slope roofs.

Ice and water shields create a watertight barrier, protecting your home from ice dams, wind-driven rain, and any other water that might attempt to intrude. They are typically reinforced with a scrim or mesh backing, giving them enhanced tear resistance and making them easier to install.

Diffusion Demonstration
Diffusion Demonstration
Tech Today by Mark S. Graham 2014-11-01
Tech Today by Mark S. Graham 2014-11-01
143K views · 772 reactions | Quick ways to stay Warm! 🌨️ Easy, last minute tips for weathering freezing storms. Emergency ways to keep warm with things you already have at home. #snowstorm #freezing #coldweather #energyefficiency #storm | Jeff & Lauren | Facebook
143K views · 772 reactions | Quick ways to stay Warm! 🌨️ Easy, last minute tips for weathering freezing storms. Emergency ways to keep warm with things you already have at home. #snowstorm #freezing #coldweather #energyefficiency #storm | Jeff & Lauren | Facebook
Summer Skirmish - Shield Wall demo
Summer Skirmish - Shield Wall demo
DIY Cooling Face Mist for Instant Refresh! Mix rose water + aloe vera gel + ice cubes, spray on your face, and feel the heat disappear! 🌬️❄️   #tipsandtricks #trick #bringhacks #aitips #tips #lifehack #BringHacks #tricks #hacks #LifeHacks #tip #summertips #lifehacks Ice Recipe For Face, Benefits Of Dipping Face In Ice Water, Frozen Aloe Vera For Face, Aloe Ice Cubes For Face, Diy Ice Cubes For Face, Aloe Vera Ice Cubes Skincare, How To Use Ice Cubes On Face, How To Make Rice Water Face Mist, How To Use Aloe Vera Ice Cubes On Face
DIY Cooling Face Mist for Instant Refresh! Mix rose water + aloe vera gel + ice cubes, spray on your face, and feel the heat disappear! 🌬️❄️ #tipsandtricks #trick #bringhacks #aitips #tips #lifehack #BringHacks #tricks #hacks #LifeHacks #tip #summertips #lifehacks Ice Recipe For Face, Benefits Of Dipping Face In Ice Water, Frozen Aloe Vera For Face, Aloe Ice Cubes For Face, Diy Ice Cubes For Face, Aloe Vera Ice Cubes Skincare, How To Use Ice Cubes On Face, How To Make Rice Water Face Mist, How To Use Aloe Vera Ice Cubes On Face
an ice dam with water coming out of it and the words what cause ice dam?
an ice dam with water coming out of it and the words what cause ice dam?
a snowflake is shown in the center of a circular object with icicles on it
a snowflake is shown in the center of a circular object with icicles on it
two different types of ice cubes with text describing how they are made and what to use
two different types of ice cubes with text describing how they are made and what to use
Ice Floor
Ice Floor

Benefits of Using Ice and Water Shields

Ice and water shields provide comprehensive protection, covering vulnerable areas like valleys, dormers, and skylights. They can be a cost-effective solution in the long run, as they reduce the risk of costly water damage repairs. They are also self-adhesive, making installation easier and faster, especially on large or complex roofs.

Moreover, ice and water shields offer superior protection against ice dams, even in the harshest winter conditions. They are recommended by many roofing manufacturers and can be used with various roofing materials, including slate, tile, and metal.

Considerations with Ice and Water Shields

Although ice and water shields offer superior protection, they come at a higher cost than starter strips. They are also more challenging to install on steep pitches, as theMemans' self-adhesive nature can make applying them more complex on vertical surfaces.

Additionally, ice and water shields are not breathable, which can potentially trap moisture under the membrane if not installed correctly. Proper ventilation and installation are crucial to prevent any potential moisture buildup.

In conclusion, the choice between a starter strip and an ice and water shield depends on your specific needs and regional climate. Both products play a critical role in protecting your home, and understanding their strengths and Limitations will help you make an informed decision. It's always a good idea to consult with a roofing professional to determine the best protection for your home.