Edmonton Ideas All articles

Freeze Sugar Cookies with Icing: Tips & Tricks

Jun 26, 2026 Edmonton
The Best Way To Freeze Cut Out Cookies
The Best Way To Freeze Cut Out Cookies

Ever wondered if you can freeze sugar cookies with icing on them to enjoy later? You're not alone. Freezing baked goods is a great way to extend their shelf life and have fresh treats on hand. But what about those beautifully decorated cookies? Let's delve into the world of frozen iced cookies.

The Best Way To Freeze Cut Out Cookies
The Best Way To Freeze Cut Out Cookies

Understanding the Freezing Process

How To Freeze Sugar Cookies - Bakin' Care Of Business
How To Freeze Sugar Cookies - Bakin' Care Of Business

Freezing is a science. It slows down bacterial growth and prevents the formation of ice crystals, keeping your cookies fresh for longer. However, it's essential to understand that freezing doesn't halt all chemical reactions. Over time, cookies can become stale, and icing can change texture.

Can You Freeze Sugar Cookies with Icing?

Freezing Sugar Cookies to Stay Fresh & Save Time
Freezing Sugar Cookies to Stay Fresh & Save Time

The short answer is yes, but with some caveats. Freezing can affect the texture and appearance of the icing. Buttercream and royal icing, two popular choices for sugar cookies, behave differently when frozen.

Buttercream Icing

homemade sugar cookies on a cooling rack with the words, how to freeze sugar cookies
homemade sugar cookies on a cooling rack with the words, how to freeze sugar cookies

Buttercream icing contains butter or margarine, which can become grainy or separate when frozen. To mitigate this, you can freeze the cookies without icing and add the buttercream once thawed. Alternatively, use a stable buttercream recipe or an icing made with shortening.

Royal Icing

Royal icing, made with meringue powder or egg whites, freezes well. However, it may become slightly more brittle and could crack if not handled carefully. To prevent this, avoid stacking frozen cookies and allow them to thaw at room temperature before handling.

Can You Freeze Decorated Sugar Cookies? How To Store Royal Icing Cookies
Can You Freeze Decorated Sugar Cookies? How To Store Royal Icing Cookies

Preparing Cookies for Freezing

To freeze sugar cookies with icing, follow these steps:

  • Bake and cool cookies completely.
  • Ice cookies as desired. If using buttercream, you may want to skip this step and ice after thawing.
  • Place cookies in a single layer on a parchment-lined baking sheet.
  • Freeze for 2-3 hours or until solid.
  • Transfer frozen cookies to an airtight container or freezer bag. Label with the date.
how to freeze decorated cookies in the shape of mermaids
how to freeze decorated cookies in the shape of mermaids

Thawing Frozen Iced Cookies

To thaw frozen iced cookies, follow these steps:

how to freeze cookie dough on a baking sheet with the words, how to freeze cookie dough
how to freeze cookie dough on a baking sheet with the words, how to freeze cookie dough
How to Store Frosted Sugar Cookies - Counter, Refrigerator or Freezer
How to Store Frosted Sugar Cookies - Counter, Refrigerator or Freezer
33K views · 2.9K reactions | Freezing Christmas Cookies🎄🍪 Freezing decorated cookies has changed my holiday baking game! I can decorate more cookies, they taste amazing, and they stay soft. Plus, it saves me so much time during the hectic holiday season.  ✨NEVER freeze cookies before they dry. Make sure royal icing has completely dried before freezing! Do an experiment on one or two cookies before going all out on this hack! And remember, LEAVE THE LID ON overnight!!! Cookies must be brought back to room temperature before opening or you risk exposing cookies to condensation! 🫶🎄 Cutters @cameliacutters  Heat Sealer by Metronic (Amazon) Bags by MoloTAR (Amazon) Ribbons by Guifier (Amazon)  Elastic Bands by Bebeepoo (Amazon)  #instahack #cookiedecoratingvideo #royalicingcookies #christmascookies | Oh Baby Bakery | Facebook
33K views · 2.9K reactions | Freezing Christmas Cookies🎄🍪 Freezing decorated cookies has changed my holiday baking game! I can decorate more cookies, they taste amazing, and they stay soft. Plus, it saves me so much time during the hectic holiday season. ✨NEVER freeze cookies before they dry. Make sure royal icing has completely dried before freezing! Do an experiment on one or two cookies before going all out on this hack! And remember, LEAVE THE LID ON overnight!!! Cookies must be brought back to room temperature before opening or you risk exposing cookies to condensation! 🫶🎄 Cutters @cameliacutters Heat Sealer by Metronic (Amazon) Bags by MoloTAR (Amazon) Ribbons by Guifier (Amazon)  Elastic Bands by Bebeepoo (Amazon) #instahack #cookiedecoratingvideo #royalicingcookies #christmascookies | Oh Baby Bakery | Facebook
Yes, you CAN freeze decorated cookies...Works for Me Wednesday
Yes, you CAN freeze decorated cookies...Works for Me Wednesday
some cookies are on a cooling rack with the words how long can you store your sugar cookies decorated or plain?
some cookies are on a cooling rack with the words how long can you store your sugar cookies decorated or plain?
a woman is standing in front of some decorated cookies on a table with the words freezing decorated cookies
a woman is standing in front of some decorated cookies on a table with the words freezing decorated cookies
How to Freeze Decorated Cookies
How to Freeze Decorated Cookies
Learn How To Flood Cookies with Royal Icing! 4 Different Ways! - Your Baking Bestie
Learn How To Flood Cookies with Royal Icing! 4 Different Ways! - Your Baking Bestie
How to Freeze Sugar Cookies - Prep, Containers, Temperature and Thawing
How to Freeze Sugar Cookies - Prep, Containers, Temperature and Thawing
how to freeze cookie dough with the words, how to freeze cookie dough on it
how to freeze cookie dough with the words, how to freeze cookie dough on it
Complete Guide to Freezing Cookies
Complete Guide to Freezing Cookies
Yes, you CAN freeze decorated cookies...Works for Me Wednesday
Yes, you CAN freeze decorated cookies...Works for Me Wednesday
Can I Freeze Royal Icing?
Can I Freeze Royal Icing?
Easy Sugar Cookie Icing {that hardens!} - Belly Full
Easy Sugar Cookie Icing {that hardens!} - Belly Full
The Sugar Cookie Icing That Hardens Perfectly Every Time
The Sugar Cookie Icing That Hardens Perfectly Every Time
How to Make Sugar Cookies - Cooking With Karli
How to Make Sugar Cookies - Cooking With Karli
how to make sugar cookies with buttercream
how to make sugar cookies with buttercream
9 Mistakes Almost Everyone Makes With Royal Icing
9 Mistakes Almost Everyone Makes With Royal Icing
How to Freeze Cookie Dough (Video)
How to Freeze Cookie Dough (Video)
how to freeze baked cookies beginner - friendly guide for freezing cookies for later
how to freeze baked cookies beginner - friendly guide for freezing cookies for later
  • Remove cookies from the freezer.
  • Place on a wire rack or plate at room temperature.
  • Allow to thaw for 1-2 hours or until completely thawed.
  • If using buttercream, ice cookies once thawed.

Storing Frozen Cookies

Proper storage is key to maintaining the quality of your frozen cookies. Use airtight containers or freezer bags to prevent freezer burn. Label containers with the date to ensure you're enjoying the freshest cookies.

How Long Do Frozen Iced Cookies Last?

Frozen iced cookies can last up to 3 months in the freezer. However, their quality may degrade over time. For best results, enjoy them within the first month.

Freezing sugar cookies with icing is possible, but it requires some careful consideration. By understanding the behavior of different icings and following proper freezing and thawing techniques, you can enjoy your beautifully decorated cookies even months later.