Saferest Mattress Protector: Best Choice at Bed Bath & Beyond

Frances Aug 03, 2026

Are you looking to enhance your sleep experience with an added layer of protection? Bed Bath & Beyond offers a range of mattress protectors designed to keep your bedding clean and comfortable. But how do you choose the safest mattress protector for your needs? Let's delve into the top options at Bed Bath & Beyond, highlighting their unique features and benefits.

Depop Unisex Home accessory
Depop Unisex Home accessory

First, consider the materials used. From waterproof and water-resistant to hypoallergenic and breathable, there's a protector suited to every preference. Here, we'll explore two primary types: waterproof protectors and allergen-proof protectors, diving into their advantages and drawbacks.

an image of a woman and her child in bed with the cover pulled up to protect them from mosquito bites
an image of a woman and her child in bed with the cover pulled up to protect them from mosquito bites

Waterproof Mattress Protectors

Waterproof protectors are ideal for those with young children or pets, offering peace of mind against spills, accidents, and messes. They typically feature a plastic or vinyl backing to prevent liquids from seeping through to your mattress.

a bed with white sheets and pillows on top of it, next to a night stand
a bed with white sheets and pillows on top of it, next to a night stand

However, it's crucial to note that while waterproof, these protectors may not be breathable, potentially leading to a warmer sleep surface. Also, they might emit a plastic-like odor initially.

Noiseless Waterproof Mattress Pads

Full Cool Touch Waterproof Mattress Pad - Threshold™: Hypoallergenic Protector, Fits 18" Depth, Moisture-Wicking
Full Cool Touch Waterproof Mattress Pad - Threshold™: Hypoallergenic Protector, Fits 18" Depth, Moisture-Wicking

The PET Waterproof Mattress Pad from Bed Bath & Beyond is a standout choice, known for its noise-free construction. Its thin, flexible vinyl backing reduces crinkling noises, ensuring a quiet sleep environment.

Moreover, its soft cotton top layer offers comfortable sleeping. This protector also features an elastic band at the bottom to keep it securely in place during sleep.

Breathable Waterproof Mattress Protectors

a person is pulling up the side of a mattress
a person is pulling up the side of a mattress

If breathability is a concern, consider protectors with advanced fabric technology, like the Lightweight Waterproof Mattress Protector. This protector uses a membrane underneath the fabric to block liquids while allowing air and heat to pass through, keeping your mattress fresh and dry.

Additionally, it's machine-washable, making clean-up easy, and its smooth, soft surface ensures a comfortable night's sleep.

Allergen-Proof Mattress Protectors

Mattress Protector Benefits You'll Wish You Knew Sooner
Mattress Protector Benefits You'll Wish You Knew Sooner

For those with allergies or sensitivities, allergen-proof protectors provide a barrier against dust mites, bed bugs, and other allergens. These protectors typically use fabric barriers to keep your mattress clean and free of irritants.

However, they may not be as effective against liquids and may not fit as snugly as their waterproof counterparts. They also might contribute to a slightly warmer sleep surface due to their typically tight weave.

Full Rayon from Bamboo Polyester Mattress Protector 100% Waterproof Deep Pocket Protector
Full Rayon from Bamboo Polyester Mattress Protector 100% Waterproof Deep Pocket Protector
Organic Cotton Sateen Mattress/Box Spring Protector - 12 in.
Organic Cotton Sateen Mattress/Box Spring Protector - 12 in.
Waterproof Mattress Protector Test! Must-Have Bedding for Spills & Accidents
Waterproof Mattress Protector Test! Must-Have Bedding for Spills & Accidents
The Best Mattress Protectors, Mattress Pads & Pillow Protectors for Airbnb Hosts
The Best Mattress Protectors, Mattress Pads & Pillow Protectors for Airbnb Hosts
Pure Cotton Mattress Protector
Pure Cotton Mattress Protector
BEDLORE® (Pack of 2) Waterproof Noiseless Mattress Protector, Hypoallergenic Quilted Washable Mattress Cover, Breathable Mattress Pad With 6-18'' Deep 75.0 H x 39.0 W in  Polyester
BEDLORE® (Pack of 2) Waterproof Noiseless Mattress Protector, Hypoallergenic Quilted Washable Mattress Cover, Breathable Mattress Pad With 6-18'' Deep 75.0 H x 39.0 W in Polyester
Nestl Waterproof King Mattress Protector, Premium Cooling Mattress Pad, Mattress Cover Fits Mattresses Up to 21 inches, White
Nestl Waterproof King Mattress Protector, Premium Cooling Mattress Pad, Mattress Cover Fits Mattresses Up to 21 inches, White

Hypoallergenic Mattress Protectors

The AllerEase Hypoallergenic Mattress Protector is a top choice for those with allergies. It features AllerEase fabrics, which use a microfilament technology to create a barrier against allergens without sacrificing breathability or comfort.

This protector is also machine-washable and fits standard mattress depths, making it a convenient choice for many.

zippered Mattress Encasements

Mattress encasements like the AllerEase zippered Mattress Encasement offer total encapsulation, providing a thorough barrier against allergens and dust mites. They typically fit tightly to your mattress and feature a thick, padded cover for comfort.

However, they may require more effort to put on and remove, and their zipper closure might create noise during sleep.

Ultimately, the best mattress protector for you depends on your specific needs and preferences. Whether you're looking to prevent spills, allergens, or both, Bed Bath & Beyond has a range of quality protectors to ensure a safe, comfortable sleep. So why wait? Upgrade your mattress with a protector today and enjoy peace of mind every night.