Why 'Eighth Grade' Got an R Rating

Frances Aug 03, 2026

The shocking revelation that-rated film "Eighth Grade" was rated R, instead of the expected PG-13, raised questions and eyebrows among parents, critics, and moviegoers alike. The MPA's decision to assign an R rating, primarily due to explicit content, begged the question: why was a coming-of-age story set in middle school given an R rating?

Eighth Grade (2018)
Eighth Grade (2018)

Bo Burnham's indie gem, which won the Sundance Film Festival's Grand Jury Prize and was praised for its raw and insightful portrayal of adolescent life, is centered around 13-year-old Kayla Day, played by Elsie Fisher. The film's graphic language, soft nudity, and intense parties were enough to trigger an R rating, but critics and audiences argued that the film's content was a realistic and necessary portrayal of eighth-grade life, making the rating seem disproportionate.

8th graders can see R-rated 'Eighth Grade' free this week
8th graders can see R-rated 'Eighth Grade' free this week

The MPA's Stance on the R Rating

The Motion Picture Association (MPA), which evaluates and assigns ratings to films, is known for its stringent rules. Their R rating warns that a film may contain sustained fino violent content, sex, nudity, and/or language that the MPA deems too intense for under 17s. "Eighth Grade" was evaluated based on these same criteria.

eighth grade poster
eighth grade poster

The MPA's official statement regarding the film's rating read: "For strong language throughout, some sexuality, and drug material." This aligns with the explicit content found in the film, highlighting the stark contrast between the film's subject matter and the sanitized version of adolescence often depicted in movies intended for younger audiences.

Language in "Eighth Grade"

Eighth grade minimalist poster
Eighth grade minimalist poster

Burnham's script is filled with raw, honest dialogue that reflects the explicit language often found in middle-school environments. kayla, the protagonist, is bullied, lonely, and anxious, which often manifests in profanity-laced outbursts. Yet, critics and parents alike argue that the film's language is authentic and-needed to fully explore the character's emotional struggles.

For instance, when analyzing the film for Common Sense Media, criticлна Kovalik noted: "Despite the frequent language, the film's world feels real... it's true to life, and the characters are never reduced to clichés." Thus, the film's R-rating due to language might be contentious, but it's also an integral part of its storytelling.

Sexual Content and Parties in "Eighth Grade"

an old tv with the words free movies and shows on it
an old tv with the words free movies and shows on it

The film's R-rating also stems from its portrayal of adolescent sexual exploration. Kayla experiments with online dating and identities, and there are hints of sexual encounters among her peers. Additionally, the movie doesn't shy away from portraying intense middle-school parties, complete with underage drinking and drug use.

While these scenes might be uncomfortable for some viewers, they're rooted in reality. Burnham, himself an eighth-grader when he started writing the script, sought to depict a genuine middle-school experience. He told The Hollywood Reporter, "I wanted to show the raw, honest moments... the beautiful, awkward, confusing and, yes, explicit moments."

Parents, Critics, and audience reactions to the R-Rating

the best teen movies to watch list is shown in this hand - drawn notepad
the best teen movies to watch list is shown in this hand - drawn notepad

While some parents and critics were surprised and somewhat dismayed by the R-rating, many praised "Eighth Grade" for its bravery and authenticity. Although the rating makes the film inaccessible for many younger teens, it has sparked conversations about the need for more realistic depictions of adolescence in cinema.

Critic Richard Roeper, after initially expressing concern about the R-rating, changed his tune after watching the film. He wrote in The Chicago Sun-Times: "It's not 'enaise delusional to suggest that 'Eighth Grade' might have been better served with a PG-13 rating... but it would have come at a cost of softening Burnham's resolutely honest and brave portrait of adolescence."

Films To Watch At A Sleepover, Movies For Teenagers, Teenage Netflix Movies List, List Of Teen Movies, Movies Teens Should Watch, Movies To Watch For Teen, Sleepover Movies For Teens, Teenage Movies To Watch, Teenage Movies List
Films To Watch At A Sleepover, Movies For Teenagers, Teenage Netflix Movies List, List Of Teen Movies, Movies Teens Should Watch, Movies To Watch For Teen, Sleepover Movies For Teens, Teenage Movies To Watch, Teenage Movies List
two women standing next to each other with the words iconic girly movies on them
two women standing next to each other with the words iconic girly movies on them
a girl with glasses is smiling for the camera and has an ad on her face
a girl with glasses is smiling for the camera and has an ad on her face
Eighth Grade(2018)USA__My Rating:8.4__Director:Bo Burnham
Eighth Grade(2018)USA__My Rating:8.4__Director:Bo Burnham
Eighth Grade, 2018
Eighth Grade, 2018
the poster for eighth grade written and directed by bo burnham, with an image of a woman's face
the poster for eighth grade written and directed by bo burnham, with an image of a woman's face
Why that disturbing #MeToo moment in 'Eighth Grade' has everyone talking
Why that disturbing #MeToo moment in 'Eighth Grade' has everyone talking
shows to watch based on your mood 🖤🧡❤️🩵🩷🤍 #Netflix #fyp #trending #viral
shows to watch based on your mood 🖤🧡❤️🩵🩷🤍 #Netflix #fyp #trending #viral

Too Much Reality for a PG-13 Rating?

Some argue that "Eighth Grade" walks a fine line - it's undeniably a coming-of-age story ripped from the headlines of 2018, but it's also steeped in a raw, honest language and experiences that push the boundaries of what's generally considered appropriate for a PG-13 film.

Burnham himself, in an interview with Vulture, seemed resigned to the controversial rating. "I Iikened the but Dante in 'Inferno' - I said, 'If I have to go through the nine circles of Hell to make this movie, I will.'" He also noted that the R-rating, while restrictive, might also serve as a defiant badge of honor.

The Impact on Younger Audience and Upside of the R-Rating

The R-rating does limit the film's audience, but it also grants "Eighth Grade" a kind of taboo allure, simultaneously provoking curiosity and conversation. Moreover, despite the stringent age restriction, many younger teens have been drawn to the film, not put off by the rating.

In a review for Vox, critic Aja Romano noted, "The R-rating has become a badge of honor and a selling point... 'Eighth Grade' has been wholly embraced by teen girls and women, who appreciate its nuanced, realistic portrait of an age group usually stereotyped or ignored by Hollywood."

Indeed, the R-rating, while divisive, has spurred not just conversation but also understanding and appreciation for Burnham's unflinching portrayal of adolescence. Far from killing "Eighth Grade," the controversial rating has sparked dialogue and intrigue around the film, drawing in audiences who might otherwise have been put off by a sanitized version of middle-school life.

As "Eighth Grade" continues to find audiences and spark discussions, it's clear that its R-rating, while restrictive, serves as a testament to the film's unflinching honesty and commitment to truth-telling. So, why was "Eighth Grade" rated R? Because it dared to portray adolescence with all its messy, explicit, and, yes, R-rated reality.