Peter Ideas Back to catalog
My Father The Judge: Does It Live Up to the Hype?
Nov 17, 2026 Peter

My Father Cigar Ratings

My Father The Judge is one of the brand’s most highly praised cigars, and the Grand Robusto was named Cigar Aficionado’s 2024 Cigar of the Year with 98 poin...

My Father The Judge is one of the brand’s most highly praised cigars, and the Grand Robusto was named Cigar Aficionado’s 2024 Cigar of the Year with 98 points. But does the Toro live up to the hype? We found excellent construction, effortless draw, rich wood, leather, earth, espresso, and balanced spice, but rated it 91/100. Read our honest verdict.

My Father Le Bijou 1922 Cigars

My Father The Judge: Does It Live Up to the Hype?
My Father The Judge: Does It Live Up to the Hype?

My Father Cigar Company

My Father Cigars Flor de Las Antillas Toro

MY FATHER – BLUE – My Father Cigars

My Father Le Bijou 1922
My Father Le Bijou 1922
a red ribbon with an image of a man and woman on it
a red ribbon with an image of a man and woman on it

My Father Special Edition Cigar

My Father Connecticut - Cigars International

MY FATHER – BLUE – My Father Cigars
MY FATHER – BLUE – My Father Cigars
My Father Cigars: La Promesa
My Father Cigars: La Promesa

My Father Cigars

My Father The Judge Cigar Rating

.

.

My Father Connecticut
My Father Connecticut
My Father Cigars
My Father Cigars
Ladies Bar, Whiskey Room, Cellar Design, Wine And Spirits, Whiskey
Ladies Bar, Whiskey Room, Cellar Design, Wine And Spirits, Whiskey
My Father
My Father
Ometepe
Ometepe
Total Body Workout Routine, Whiskey Room, Good Leadership Skills, Alcohol Recipes, Mixed Drinks, Whiskey, Liquor, Sake, Essen
Total Body Workout Routine, Whiskey Room, Good Leadership Skills, Alcohol Recipes, Mixed Drinks, Whiskey, Liquor, Sake, Essen
Cigarillo Flavor Options, Humidor, Malta, Whiskey, Liquor, Sake, Gentleman, Rum, Moda Masculina
Cigarillo Flavor Options, Humidor, Malta, Whiskey, Liquor, Sake, Gentleman, Rum, Moda Masculina
. Humidor, Whiskey, Liquor
. Humidor, Whiskey, Liquor
Whiskey Room, Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey, Learn Facts, Rest And Relaxation, Men's Fragrance, Whiskey
Whiskey Room, Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey, Learn Facts, Rest And Relaxation, Men's Fragrance, Whiskey
. Modern Factory, Little Havana, Personal Relationship, Science Nature, Havana, Talk To Me, Going To Work, Novelty Sign
. Modern Factory, Little Havana, Personal Relationship, Science Nature, Havana, Talk To Me, Going To Work, Novelty Sign

More shots

My Father The Judge: Does It Live Up to the Hype?
My Father The Judge: Does It Live Up to the Hype?
My Father Le Bijou 1922
My Father Le Bijou 1922
a red ribbon with an image of a man and woman on it
a red ribbon with an image of a man and woman on it
MY FATHER – BLUE – My Father Cigars
MY FATHER – BLUE – My Father Cigars
My Father Cigars: La Promesa
My Father Cigars: La Promesa
My Father Connecticut
My Father Connecticut
My Father Cigars
My Father Cigars
Ladies Bar, Whiskey Room, Cellar Design, Wine And Spirits, Whiskey
Ladies Bar, Whiskey Room, Cellar Design, Wine And Spirits, Whiskey

Related topics