Fake Icing for Gingerbread House: DIY Recipe

Sean Jul 20, 2026

In the enchanting world of gingerbread house decorating, one question often arises: what's the best way to create that perfect, shimmering finish for our edible masterpieces? While royal icing is the traditional choice, it's not always convenient or easy to work with, leading many bakers to explore fake icing alternatives for their gingerbread houses. Let's delve into the fascinating realm of fake icing, its benefits, types, and applications to help you make an informed decision for your next gingerbread creation.

How to Make Fake Frosting for Ornaments
How to Make Fake Frosting for Ornaments

Fake icing, also known as tubing gel or piping gel, offers an array of advantages over royal icing. It's easier to work with, sets more quickly, and provides a broader range of colors. Moreover, it's less likely to crack or crumble under stress, making it a reliable choice for intricate gingerbread designs. Let's explore these aspects in more detail.

there are many white objects on top of the table and one is in the shape of a snake
there are many white objects on top of the table and one is in the shape of a snake

Understanding Fake Icing

Fake icing is essentially fondant combined with tylose powder to create a pipeable, edible 'icing' that hardens as it dries. It allows for greater control over design elements, withstanding the test of time better than its royal counterpart. Let's look into its composition and properties further.

How to make fake icing
How to make fake icing

Composition and Properties

Fake icing primarily comprises fondant, a sugar-based modeling paste, and tylose powder. The latter is alaid protein derived from wheat that's commonly used to stiffen fondant and create gum paste. When mixed together, they form a storable, malleable compound that can be piped into various designs and sets firmly upon drying. This makes it an ideal substitute for royal icing, particularly for those seeking more convenience and control over their gingerbread decorating.

Icing for Gingerbread Houses Sticks like Glue!
Icing for Gingerbread Houses Sticks like Glue!

Benefits over Royal Icing

One of the most significant benefits of fake icing is its versatility. Aside from being easier to pipe and set, it's also less likely to crack or break under stress, making it perfect for intricate details and delicate decorations. Furthermore, fake icing offers a broader range of colors and is more forgiving to mistakes. Given these advantages, it's no surprise that many gingerbread artists have made the switch.

However, it's essential to note that while fake icing dries quickly and hardens, it doesn't provide the same hard, glass-like finish as royal icing. If this is a desired effect, you may need to experiment with combining the two icings or use them for different parts of your design.

there is a small house made out of gingerbread and icing on the top
there is a small house made out of gingerbread and icing on the top

Types of Fake Icing

Several types of fake icing are available, each offering unique characteristics and uses. Let's explore some of the most popular options.

1. **Store-bought Fake Icing**: Commercial fake icing products are widely available and come pre-made, saving you time and effort. Brands like Wilton andudian offer a variety of colors and quality levels, making them an excellent starting point for beginners.

someone is decorating a gingerbread house with icing
someone is decorating a gingerbread house with icing

2. **Homemade Fake Icing**: For those seeking more control over their icing's composition and color, homemade fake icing is an appealing choice. By combining powdered sugar, gelatin, and tylose powder, you can create a custom formula that suits your needs. This route may require more trial and error but offers greater flexibility in the long run.

Store-bought vs. Homemade

Fake Gingerbread House Ornaments with Homemade Puff Paint
Fake Gingerbread House Ornaments with Homemade Puff Paint
someone is decorating a cake with white icing
someone is decorating a cake with white icing
Gingerbread House Icing Recipe
Gingerbread House Icing Recipe
a lit up gingerbread house sitting on top of a table next to a wicker basket
a lit up gingerbread house sitting on top of a table next to a wicker basket
life size gingerbread house
life size gingerbread house
an advertisement for the gingerbread house is shown in blue and white with words on it that read, stuurdy royal icing for gingerbread houses
an advertisement for the gingerbread house is shown in blue and white with words on it that read, stuurdy royal icing for gingerbread houses
Best Icing for Gingerbread Houses
Best Icing for Gingerbread Houses
a gingerbread house decorated with icing and pink decorations on top of a cake stand
a gingerbread house decorated with icing and pink decorations on top of a cake stand
two handmade gingerbread houses are being held by someone's hands on a marble surface
two handmade gingerbread houses are being held by someone's hands on a marble surface
two decorative gingerbread houses sitting on top of a table
two decorative gingerbread houses sitting on top of a table

The choice between store-bought and homemade fake icing largely depends on your preferences, skill level, and available time. Store-bought icings are convenient and reliable, whereas homemade versions allow for more customization and cost savings. Whichever route you choose, rest assured that both offer excellent alternatives to royal icing for your gingerbread decorating needs.

Ultimately, the perfect icing for your gingerbread house depends on your personal preferences, desired results, and the time you're willing to invest in your project. By understanding the intricacies of fake icing, you're now better equipped to make an informed decision and create the most enchanting gingerbread house this holiday season.