Substitute Guitar Picks: Uncommon & Creative Alternatives

Sean Jul 20, 2026

When it comes to guitar playing, the right picks can make a significant difference in your sound and performance. While traditional triangular plastic picks are commonly used, there's a plethora of alternatives out there, each offering its unique set of advantages. Let's dive into a comprehensive guide on the various things you can use as a guitar pick, their pros, and cons.

What Can I Use As A Guitar Pick? (Alternatives That Actually Work)
What Can I Use As A Guitar Pick? (Alternatives That Actually Work)

First, it's essential to understand that guitar picks aren't one-size-fits-all. The ideal pick varies depending on your playing style, the genre of music, and your personal preference. So, let's explore the diverse world of guitar picks.

custom diy guitar picks!
custom diy guitar picks!

Alternative Materials

One of the primary ways guitarists vary their picks is by opting for different materials.

Guitar pick
Guitar pick

Traditional plastic picks are durable and offer a wide range of thicknesses, but they can feel pretty generic. Let's delve into some alternative materials:

Tortoiseshell

DIY guitar pick
DIY guitar pick

Tortoiseshell picks are made from the shells of certain species of intimate tortoises. They produce a rich, warm tone and are preferred by many Blues and Jazz guitarists. However, they're less durable than plastic picks and are now banned in most countries due to their derivation from endangered species.

An eco-friendly alternative is celluloid, which mimics the look and feel of tortoiseshell but is produced from plant-based materials.

Metal

I NEVER find them
I NEVER find them

Metal picks are typically made from stainless steel, copper, or brass. They produce a bright, attacking tone and are often used in genres like heavy metal and rock. They're very durable but can feel uncomfortable for prolonged use due to their weight and lack of grip.

Some metal picks, like those made from aluminum, are lighter and more comfortable but may lack the tonal sparkle of heavier metals.

Non-Traditional Shapes and Sizes

six guitar picks with different designs on them, all in different colors and shapes are shown
six guitar picks with different designs on them, all in different colors and shapes are shown

Besides materials, the shape and size of your pick can also significantly impact your sound and playing comfort.

Let's explore some non-traditional shapes and sizes that cater to different playing styles:

how to make guitar picks with pictures and instructions on how to cut them from plastic
how to make guitar picks with pictures and instructions on how to cut them from plastic
two key chains with charms attached to them on a white surface, one has a guitar pick and the other has a charm
two key chains with charms attached to them on a white surface, one has a guitar pick and the other has a charm
Custom Guitar picks
Custom Guitar picks
two guitar picks sitting on top of a laptop keyboard
two guitar picks sitting on top of a laptop keyboard
Cute Expression Guitar Picks For Acoustic Guitar Electric Guitar Bass Ukelele(1Mm/5Pack)
Cute Expression Guitar Picks For Acoustic Guitar Electric Guitar Bass Ukelele(1Mm/5Pack)
guitar pick necklace made with wire
guitar pick necklace made with wire
PickYourPicks2014 - Etsy UK
PickYourPicks2014 - Etsy UK
Guitar picks
Guitar picks
can tab guitar🎸
can tab guitar🎸
I feel like they sound bad maybe that js me tho
I feel like they sound bad maybe that js me tho

Jazz Picks

Jazz picks, also known as thumb picks, are small, often escudo-shaped, and are worn on the thumb for increased control and definition. They're popular among fingerstyle guitarists and those who prefer a more intimate, delicate sound.

Jazz picks come in various materials, including plastic, metal, and even stone. Some even feature built-in finger picks for simultaneous thumb and finger playing.

Thumb Picks

Thumb picks are larger, worn on the thumb, and often used in conjunction with finger placement. They're popular among bluegrass and country guitarists for their ability to deliver a strong, clear attack.

Thumb picks come in a variety of materials and designs, with some featuring sharp tips for greater string separation and attack.

Incorporating alternative picks into your playing can provide fresh tonal options and unique challenges that can help you grow as a musician. Don't be afraid to experiment with different materials, shapes, and sizes to find what works best for you. Who knows, you might just discover your new favorite sound!